We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–109 of 229. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 35 of 1968 ›

Before the debate was adjourned I was discussing with some Members across the House statements about four-seat constituencies. We had Deputy Treacy who was very critical of the four-seat constituencies here in Dublin. There was a Labour Convention in Ennis last Sunday and the members there instructed their delegates to have an amendment moved here in the House that the constituency would be made a four-seater. They cannot be shouting for four-seaters in one place and not have them in another. It seems that the Opposition generally seem to shout "gerrymandering" without looking at the position one way or another. Many of them have not yet spoken; those who have are contradicting each other.

I would like to refer to my own county of Cork. At column 1266 of the Official Report of 27th November, 1968, Deputy Treacy said:

"A large portion of North Cork has been detached and is now being added to Mid-Cork. This proposal, too, is quite unnecessary and is designed solely on a selfish political basis to try and weaken Fine Gael and Labour in these two constituencies."

On the very same day, 27th November, 1968, at column 1276 we have Deputy Barrett, a Fine Gael Deputy from Cork saying:

"On the last occasion the constituencies were carved up—and plainly in a spirit of gerrymandering which had no regard whatsoever for a portion of the constituency which, whilst it was then in the county, always looked upon itself as part of Cork City constituency—the Minister and his Party proceeded to carve up the areas of Blackrock and Douglas in such a way that an area of the city, within a quarter of a mile of the City Hall, was shifted into a constituency which sprawled itself away down through County Cork and on to the borders of County Kerry."

You have Deputy Treacy stating that there is no need to change the constituency and Deputy Barrett stating there was no need to have Blackrock and Douglas added to the Mid-Cork constituency. Deputy Barrett was speaking about 1961. They are contradicting each other. When one comes to Blackrock and Douglas in 1961 it is well to remember that they were part of County Cork and that they were electing members to the Cork County Council. They were not in the city then. However, since then they have been taken into Cork city and they are now electing members of the corporation. It is only right that Blackrock and Douglas should form part of Cork city constituency or constituencies as the case may be.

We have the usual remarks here from people like Deputy Barrett who always bring it up one way or another about "sprawling itself away down to the borders of County Kerry". One would think that we people who live on the borders of County Kerry have a malignant disease and should be avoided.

Deputy Barrett also states at column 1277 of the Official Report of 27th November, 1968:

"They are fully aware that the Minister and his Party will have the most cynical disregard for their rights if their rights clash with the interests of the Fianna Fáil Party, because the reason Blackrock and Douglas were pushed out of Mid-Cork was because they were very notably Fine Gael in their sympathies and that disturbed the balance of Fianna Fáil's power in Cork City".

I would like to refer Deputy Barrett back to the general election of 1965. when Fine Gael had a candidate in the field from the Blackrock/Douglas area. In that election the quota was 8,000 odd and over 40,000 voters cast their votes. The Fine Gael candidate from that area polled 789 votes. This is the area which is supposed to be predominantly Fine Gael. Our candidates in the same area got close on 3,000 first preference votes. This is an inaccuracy which I would like to be put on record. Again, we were speaking about statements being accurate and I would like to go back to column 1276 of 27th November, 1968. Deputy Barrett said as regards the people of Blackrock and Douglas:

"If they wanted to find a TD they had to hie themselves off to the country, the nearest TD being at Bandon or in Macroom."

I think it is very unbecoming of Deputy Barrett or anybody else to cast a slur on a Deputy who lives close to me and is my good friend, Mrs. Eileen Desmond. It is bad form that she should be deliberately omitted. After all, she was elected as a Member of the Dáil in the general election of 1965. She headed the poll at that time. It is very strange that we have here a man who is regarded as a leading Fine Gael personality in a city of 120,000 population and that he does not know a Labour Deputy who resides within seven or eight miles of his home. He would probably go astray there. If he is in any difficulty I will be glad to show him around the area.

This morning we heard Deputy Burton and Deputy Collins, who spoke about mid-Cork. Deputy Collins was bemoaning the fact that the Béara peninsula was going in with County Kerry and was being halved. Everybody knew that County Kerry in itself had not enough population to maintain six Deputies and that, if they are to maintain six Deputies, population would have to be added from some other area. Senator FitzGerald said:

I would suggest adding the districts of Knocknagree, Cullen, Doonasheen, Derragh, Caherbarnagh and Coomlogan.

That was a different part of Cork but, on Senator FitzGerald's suggestion, we would actually have a parish halved. The Minister would be accused of gerrymandering if he did that in order to get three seats in South Kerry. It was obvious they were going to say he was gerrymandering for one reason or another.

As regards the area of mid-Cork I think it is properly described as a truly rural area. I am very glad it is a truly rural area. I hope I will be able to represent those people after the next general election. It is strange that when I went to West and South West Cork many people welcomed me though many of them were of a different political viewpoint. They stressed the importance of having their Deputy living in the constituency. They were not used to it because of the Fine Gael Deputy who had represented them for years. I should like to emphasise that it is only right that when a TD is elected he should live within his area as much as possible.

Deputy Seán Collins announced to all and sundry that he would be reelected in the next general election, that we in Fianna Fáil would not put him out. The only danger there lies within his own Party: there are a few young colts there fretting at the reins and he may have a problem keeping them down. However, that is his business, not ours.

From what Deputy James Tully said it appears that the Labour Party would like to see general elections occur on Sundays. I thoroughly disagree. Irish people generally, regardless of their religious persuasion, have always held that Sunday should be a free day, away from work or any political activity as regards polling, et cetera. Long may it remain that way. There was talk by the Opposition to the effect that it is the plain people of Ireland who will decide the next general election and that it was they who defeated the referendum—the ordinary man and woman. Do we not all know that Fine Gael represent the upper class, the conservative element, in the urban areas and that they have their eyes set on the 400 acre farms in the rural areas? Do we not also know that when there was a Coalition Government Labour, strange to say, came in and backed Fine Gael and that the ordinary man and woman got very little by way of social service improvement from the Labour Party who rowed in with the conservative Party?

I should like to say a few words in conclusion about Deputy Fitzpatrick's suggestion that this Bill should be known as a "Bolander." Deputy Boland is the Minister whose duty it was to introduce this Bill. He brought it in, he was qualified to bring it in. This Minister has true Republican blood in his veins—those who came before him were of that outlook. All I can say is that I wish him many years of success in a Fianna Fáil Cabinet. The Opposition have said it may not be long before there is a general election. The day may not be far away but we will meet them and beat them.

Comment on this

It is not my intention to speak for long. I should like to refer to a few remarks by Deputy Meaney. He referred to the people whom we in Fine Gael represent, and at one stage he said we are associated with people who own 400 acres of land or more. The constituency I have represented to date is probably the biggest in the country and I doubt if there is one individual in it who owns 400 acres.

Comment on this

Are you not the Party of the 400 acre farmers?

Comment on this

I doubt if the Deputy knows either the policy of Fianna Fáil or of Fine Gael so there is no point in arguing with him. If the Deputy went to Cork and spoke there as he did here today and if every person in the constituency heard him he would not be long here.

Comment on this

Are you not the Party of the 400 acre farmers? You cannot deny it.

Comment on this

It does not mean much to the man in the street whether he votes in a three-seat, a four-seat or a five-seat constituency. Only those who are well versed in politics know the difference between the three-seat, the four-seat and the five-seat constituency and there cannot be a complaint about how these constituencies have been drafted as far as the Minister's Party are concerned. The Minister for Local Government did an effective job, probably the most effective ever done, in the division of constituencies. I will refer firstly to what he did to my neighbouring county, Mayo. Traditionally, there were North Mayo and South Mayo and, as we all know, there have been two Fianna Fáil Ministers returned from South Mayo with two Fine Gael representatives also. Due to the fall in population in Mayo, it was not entitled any longer to four seats in each constituency. If they were reduced to three seats, there was a danger that one of the sitting Ministers would lose his seat. So what did they do? They drew a stroke from north to south of the county and ensured that the Minister for Justice was on one side of it and the Minister for Health on the other.

Geographically speaking, this is unfair. North Mayo should have been left as it was and given three seats and South Mayo should have been left as it was and given the same number of seats. If that had been done, however, one member of the Fianna Fáil Party, now a Cabinet Minister, would no longer be elected. The same occurred in Donegal which also had been split from east to west. Now it is being split from north to south.

In Dublin, the majority of the constituencies are four-seaters. In any of these constituencies, less than 50 per cent of the vote will ensure two out of four seats. If you had 60 per cent of the poll you could get three out of the four seats. As I have said, with 40 per cent of the votes you would be guaranteed two seats. Fianna Fáil's general idea in Dublin, where their popularity is probably at its lowest ever, is to get two seats, to give one to Labour and one to Fine Gael. I am sure the Minister had this idea in mind when he drew up the boundaries. He has told us that some of them are not finalised and I am sure that if Fianna Fáil cumainn point out to him that it would be more advantageous to have this bit out and that bit in he will agree.

In reference to the west again, 150,957 people have emigrated from that region during the last 40 years, 46,000 having gone during the last ten years. I would go into the counties in detail but I feel sure the Minister for Local Government knows exactly the number of people who have left each county. Galway has lost 7,213; Roscommon 7,400; Mayo 18,000; Leitrim 7,000 and Sligo 6,000. If those people could find a living in their own country I am sure they would have stayed but their emigration is due to the fact that we have had a Fianna Fáil Government in office for so long who have done very little for these people. That is the reason we have lost seats now.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I must point out to the Deputy that emigration is not within the scope of this Bill.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Leas-Cheann Comhairle's viewpoint but I was merely pointing out that the number of people who have left the west of Ireland would constitute approximately two more seats here in the Dáil and the reason we have lost two seats is, in all probability, because we have had a Fianna Fáil Government for so long.

The constituency which I hope to represent in future will now be known as North-East Galway. I must say I am sorry that the part of South Galway that formed part of East Galway has been taken away from me but I am sure that the people in that area who supported me in the past will support the Fine Gael Deputy for that area now and prospective Fine Gael candidates as well.

I would like also to welcome the people of West Roscommon into North-East Galway. It seems that the Minister for Education was not altogether happy with the people around the Cloonfad and Athleague districts because he no longer saw fit to keep them in that area. Of course, this takes trouble off his hands because these districts are within the Suck basin and for a long time past he has been promising them drainage. He has got that off his hands now and it will be the responsibility of those who represent North-East Galway in the future.

This is an example of what the Minister for Local Government would have done if PR had been abolished. It seems to me that the Minister had a commission or his own organisation working on this for a long time because these boundaries were drawn very quickly indeed. I was surprised at the very efficient manner in which the Minister introduced this Bill and the fact that he introduced it so quickly after the referendum. I am sure that, if PR had been abolished, he would have introduced another Bill setting out the single-seat constituencies. I dread to think what that would have been like considering the job he has done on those three-, four- and five-seaters— three-seaters where he has a chance of winning two and four-seaters where in all probability he will only get one.

I forecast that, as good as the job is that has been done by the Minister to gerrymander constituencies and to ensure maximum Fianna Fáil representation, this will backfire on the people who drew it up in the same way as their efforts to abolish PR backfired. I have no doubt it will backfire at the next general election. It might have been possible in the past to pull the wool over people's eyes but the people today are more awake than they ever were in the past. I know that at the next general election they will give you the answer they gave in the referendum and which you hope they will not give you.

Comment on this

I would like to add my few points to this debate and to say that we are going through a constitutional exercise which has been described as vindictive gerrymandering and getting our own back on the people. The attacks that have been made by the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party have been heard before. No matter what way the constituencies are revised, in the last analysis it is the people who will decide who will go and who will stay. We have no fears in relation to that particular problem. We will face up to our responsibilities now, just as we will in the future. It is about time the Opposition speakers, both Labour and Fine Gael, grew up and realised that it is the people who will decide; that the composition of this House cannot be decided in the House but only outside it. It is only people who are afraid of the decision of the electorate who are terrorised in the manner in which the Fine Gael and Labour Deputies seem to be terrorised here. When "the chips are down", the Irish people are an intelligent people. They have displayed this intelligence in elections over a long number of years. When it comes to deciding whether they should remain in employment or not, then they will decide whom to vote for—and they can only vote for one Party, Fianna Fáil.

I listened to the Fine Gael Deputy for Cavan describing the Minister's Bill in a certain type of way. I would say in relation to this particular Deputy that he is "Fitzpandering" to the weak-kneed politicians, trying to terrorise those unfortunate men into a situation where they will believe they will lose their seats as a result of the revision. There is no doubt drones must be frightened and terrorised. The lost years of inactivity must be staring them in the face. Now that the situation has caught up with them, I can understand that they should have this great feeling of fear they have displayed here during the course of this debate.

The Fine Gael Party should change their name to the Political Legal Adoption Society of Ireland and adopt the Labour Party. It would seem this is what they are trying to do. During the referendum campaign they were concerned about the future of the Labour Party. Now they are concerned about the future of the Deputies of the Labour Party. I am not so sure this particular "adoption society" is not endeavouring to get into its ranks the super socialists we hear so much from in the Labour Benches as they have done in the past with a number of other political organisations that came into the House. The efforts of Deputy Donegan and many others to attract the socialists over to the Fine Gael benches may succeed at some stage. At the moment both Parties are just putting up a front. The people do not know what is going on behind the scenes, that the "backroom boys" of both Parties are conniving and supporting one another in their campaign of terror and character assassination here in the House—the campaign that was carried on so forcibly during the referendum. Efforts have been made by many of the speakers here to carry this out. I want to sound a warning at this stage to the Front Bench of both Labour and Fine Gael. The next time I hear comments such as have been made in relation to honourable men on this side of the House I will read out, paragraph by paragraph, what these men stood for and their misdeeds, and they will go out of this House very sorry men. That is what is coming to those people who attacked honest men in the malicious manner they did in the not too distant past.

The area I am about to represent is one on which I will stake my claim. Ballyfermot is coming into my area and I welcome it with open arms. Some of the finest people in the country come from Ballyfermot and Inchicore. I do not shrink with terror like some others at a new place coming into my area. This is a very fine area and I gladly accept it. People who have done their work honestly have nothing to be afraid of. It is only the TDs who did not do their jobs well in the past and who now find their past is catching up with them who have something to be afraid of. They relied on the historical situation in the country and they are now having to meet the possibility of having a revised area. It is quite obvious from the terror we have seen in the eyes of the Opposition that those unfortunate men may well have a political breakdown as well as a mental breakdown before the next general election.

It is easy to pick those people out. You can pick out the happy ones and the unhappy ones and you can also pick out the drones. There are many of them in this House and they now have to do something at last. We heard very few complaints from this side of the House because, as I said before, we are quite sure that the people of this nation, when called on, will put their marks on the ballot paper and will do so in a responsible manner. In the Ballyfermot area I am going to represent I want to sound a note of warning for the socialist Santa Claus who is going to get his long beard singed in the very near future. We have heard his complaints on this Bill and on other Bills and I want to warn him that he will be answered quite definitely in the future. I am quite sure this Bill will go through in the very capable hands of a very capable Minister and I am quite sure the people will get value for their money from their representatives who will be elected by them.

I listened with some interest to Deputy Donnellan, a man with great imagination. He spoke about the four-seat constituencies and said that one would only need to get about 40 per cent of the votes to get two seats. We gave you the option of one seat for 51 per cent. Now you are claiming that we can get two seats with 40 per cent. You cannot have it both ways. We are prepared to face a situation in which you would have to get 51 per cent for one seat.

Comment on this

The Deputy is confusing the issue.

Comment on this

I am not. The Deputy claims that the seats in Dublin are gerrymandered to give us two seats for 40 per cent.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy tell me why there were not four-seaters down the country?

Comment on this

The Deputy said that we only require 40 per cent to get two seats but under the system which was rejected by the people we required 50 per cent in each area to get one seat but now you say we only want 40 per cent to get two seats.

Comment on this

The Deputy is confusing the issue now.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not like to interrupt this dialogue but Deputy Donnellan spoke and Deputy Dowling is in possession.

Comment on this

The number of four-seaters in the country in 1961 was 12 and now it is only 14 so it is not a big difference. It is only 12 as against 14. If that was the system which was to obtain surely we would have all four-seaters but there is only an increase of two. However, I do not want to detain the House very long. I welcome the Bill and I am sure it will give satisfaction to the majority of the people.

I note, as a Dublin Deputy, the population explosion in the city has meant that we need further representatives. We cannot be held responsible either individually or collectively in this Party for that explosion as it is something which happens in a progressive city. As a result, there is bound to be this increase in representatives. We hope this trend will continue. No doubt people have been attracted to the city because of employment opportunities or other factors.

Comment on this

Or the fact that they would be represented by Deputy Dowling perhaps.

Comment on this

That may be so. I trust when efforts are made to ensure that the population will be diverted to other sectors that it will not be opposed and that no cry will go up, such as we heard in recent times, when an effort was made to bring about development of industrial estates which would bring prosperity to particular areas. With the development of the industrial estate in Galway and the industrial estate at Shannon I hope there is not sabotage in the future as Shannon was sabotaged in the past.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

What about the chassis business?

Comment on this

That is something which the people of Dublin and especially Inchicore will never forgive them for. They will not forgive the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party for that. The ghosts of the Labour Party are sitting in the front benches. There is not a Member present. That shows their interest in the Bill. They are like terrified men prowling the constituencies scratching out envelopes to send cards to their constituents. Some of them appeared in my new area from the socialist Santa Claus. He would want to dig much deeper into the bag next year or there will be nothing left. That is the Ballyfermot area which I have already mentioned. I took a small trip through the area the other day and noticed the desperate conditions in it. I will have to work hard next year or maybe the next two or three years to put this area on its feet. Nevertheless, I tackle it with great pride and on the understanding that the people there are good and honest people.

Comment on this

I have no doubt the Deputy will make a change in it in a short time.

Comment on this

There is no doubt about it. I have already made suggestions in my brief appearance there and the Deputy will notice by the number of questions in the future that I will be seeking amenities for this large area which has very few services. While I am here I shall make every effort to obtain nothing but the best for the very fine people there. I now want to refer to the other area in my constituency, Inchicore, where the sabotage took place not so long ago in relation to the chassis works designed to employ 3,000 people.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should not continue to discuss this matter as it is not relevant to the Bill under discussion.

Comment on this

Had this taken place, there would be 3,000 more people in the area and I might not have had to take so many people in from outside. I am prepared to make that sacrifice in the interests of the community, to serve these people, although far removed from me. I regret that the industrial workers who should have been employed in Inchicore are not there now but I will do my part to rectify this situation and to see, if possible, that there will be quite a substantial number of people there by the end of my time as a representative for the area. I have already asked the Minister, in relation to this area, to speed up the services that would create more employment there and, therefore, swell still further the population of this prosperous and ever-expanding area.

There was mention made today of the Senator's alternative. At least, one thing can be said about the Senator: he gave this matter some consideration. It would seem from the comments of the rest of the Fine Gael Party that they neither heeded him nor gave him any assistance. The suggestions made by many Fine Gael speakers certainly did not coincide with the suggestion made by the Senator. Nevertheless, the Senator did give consideration to the matter and was prepared to put the facts on paper.

Once again, I want to compliment the Minister on the difficult job he has done. As Deputy Burke said earlier today, it is impossible to please everybody. The people who are most noticeably displeased are the drones and those who after years of inactivity are horrified that they may lose the little bit of leather that they sit on in this House, as I have no doubt they will when they go before the people in the very near future. The people are always conscious of the fact that while Fianna Fáil are in office they will be in employment.

Comment on this

It was not my intention to intervene in this debate. I am quite satisfied with the area which I have got. I believe that any Deputy who has done his work properly for the people should not be afraid to enter the contest in any constituency that he is given. The last speaker mentioned Deputies who did not do their job. In this connection I can see a few of the heads opposite falling. The Fianna Fáil Deputies in the west of Ireland did nothing to try to arrest the tidal wave of emigration which has been going on in the west for at least a quarter of a century. A great deal has been said by Deputies on the opposite side of the House about the loss of Deputies which is about to take place in the west. It may be that we will lose two or three Deputies in the west of Ireland but let us look at the reason for this. The reason is not what happened in the referendum. The reason is the neglect by the Fianna Fáil administration down the years which allowed 44,000 people from the province of Connacht to emigrate in the past ten years.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy but I would remind him that an economic debate would so widen the scope that the debate could not be contained within what is appropriate to the Bill.

Comment on this

I was dealing with the reason why the people in the west voted "No" to the tolerance proposal.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair could not allow the discussion on the referendum to recommence at this stage.

Comment on this

With due respect, I think this is pertinent to the discussion, that we would not lose two Deputies in the west of Ireland had that emigration been arrested. There would be 44,000 extra people in the west, which would give us at least two more Deputies. There appeared to be a ring of dissatisfaction in the voices of those who spoke of our losing two or three Deputies. That loss does not surprise me, having regard to the neglect of the west that has taken place over the years.

I regret very much the demise of Leitrim as a political entity in our national Parliament. I cannot understand why the name of Leitrim will no longer appear on the political scene. I see no reason why the constituency comprising the area I represent should not be called Sligo-Leitrim or why the constituency comprising part of Leitrim and Donegal should not be called Donegal-Leitrim or why the constituency comprising part of Leitrim and Roscommon should not be called Roscommon-Leitrim. It is noticeable that the constituency comprising part of Clare and Galway is to be called Clare-Galway. It is not very clear to me whether that is due to political figures having associations with Clare. If that is the reason, may I suggest that we had great national heroes in Leitrim also and, if that is the case, it would constitute an insult to Leitrim that gave us the great Seán MacDiarmada? I have had close associations with Leitrim all my life. For 25 years, before I became a Member of this House, when part of Leitrim was in my constituency, I worked there as a young man and I found the people of Leitrim to be the kindest and most generous that I have ever met. Leitrim got the rawest deal of any county. The people of Leitrim withstood the evictions of the notorious Lord Leitrim. The people there now are the descendants of those who were driven into the hillsides and had to live amid rocks and rushes. It is the memory of these people that has been insulted by the deletion of the name of Leitrim from the political map.

The question has been asked from the opposite side of the House, what was the alternative, what was the cure? When the proposal to change the constituencies was first mooted I forecast to many people in this House what would happen and the reasons why it would happen. The reasons were very plain to me. The entire rot in the division of the constituencies in the west of Ireland set in in Donegal. There were two three-seat constituencies in Donegal. In each constituency there were two Fianna Fáil Deputies and one Fine Gael Deputy. If Donegal were made a five-seater the Government were bound to lose a Deputy; they could not get four out of five, and it might have been a Minister who would have gone. I do not say that if we were in power we would not do the same, but I am pointing out that this is where all the trouble started.

If Donegal became a five-seater, there were a few thousand left who could have been pushed into Sligo-Leitrim. Sligo-Leitrim had exactly enough for four seats: Sligo, about 50,000, and Leitrim, about 30,000. As I said, Donegal had to retain these two three-seaters and this had to be done at the expense of mutilating Leitrim. Once that happened no other change could have been made except to put central Leitrim in with Sligo and the south in with Roscommon.

I should like to refer again to Leitrim disappearing off the map in the context of the Taoiseach's visit to Drumshanbo during the referendum campaign, when he bewailed the plight of County Leitrim, which, of course, is the most depressed county in Ireland. At the same time, he had in his pocket an £8 million contract for an industry in this country, and we know where he put it, in his own city of Cork. If he was in earnest, why did he not put that industry in Leitrim, whose condition he bemoaned so much? That industry would have arrested emigration and possibly emigrants would return to build up the population so that we could have an extra Deputy there.

If this Bill passes and if I am returned again, I should like to welcome the new area of Leitrim in with Sligo, that is Ballinamore and south of it, and I can assure them of my best attention in solving any of their little problems if and when asked to do so.

Comment on this

Anybody looking at this action by the Minister for Local Government does not have to go too far under the surface to see that this has been a deliberate, last-minute subterfuge adopted by the Minister in his disappointment and in trying to recover from what the people told him in no uncertain manner on 16th October last. He now finds himself like the drowning man who will grasp at any straw passing by on the surface of the tide in order to save himself and to ease his conscience in respect of what he tried to perpetrate through the referendum.

The people are not fools, and in his desperation he now comes along and as he himself and members of his own Cabinet have said, they will now start on the butchering operation. What he means or who he means to butcher, whether it is the land of Ireland or the people of Ireland, is a matter for conjecture. My view is that by this hasty action the Minister is seeking refuge and succour and trying to safeguard himself and the dying Party he represents.

Does the Minister think this will be an injection that will bring back again the Party which he represents on to the republican road we had not heard of for a long time until the representative from Donegal mentioned it some days ago and was publicly rebuked by his own Leader for the statement he made, in the presence of no less than two ambassadors to this country who were listening in the Distinguished Visitors' Gallery? If the Minister thinks that he can now introduce Kathleen Ní hUallacháin and break the shackles that have bound us to a foreign foe, that he can wave the republican flag which was buried and buried long ago by his Party, he has another guess coming.

In this last-minute effort to retrieve himself and his Party he is only going further into the mire and he will sink down and drag the Party with him in this exercise. Anybody with only half an eye on political affairs in the country today knows in his heart and soul that this effort by the Minister has not got anything like the support he thought he should get from within his own Party. We know that members of his own Party made him change his mind with regard to the butchering operation which he wanted to carry out and of which he is well capable.

I want to talk for a moment about my own constituency. We had a surplus in East Limerick and it was generally known and spoken of by the intelligentsia of the Minister's Party how the butchering was going to operate in Limerick. However, having assessed the position, his own members in desperation, and knowing exactly what would happen, made a last-minute effort and got him to change his mind and leave a particular electoral area and take over another to safeguard their own interest. That is common property. It applied in East Limerick. A similar situation existed in West Limerick. His own Deputies knew it and they fled like scalded cats to try to change his mind regarding the butchering operation he had in mind there. West Limerick was short of the quota undoubtedly; so was North Kerry and it was his intention to take some of West Limerick and land it into North Kerry across the river. The pressure groups got busy and the Minister had to pull down his flag and tack his sails and turn from North Kerry to South Kerry.

Now we come to the slaughter of the "Holy Innocents" in the Banner county of Clare who have stood by the Party for so long in their stupidity and we find that all that was needed in Clare to make a fourth seat was 3,000 votes. They knew they could only get two elected in Clare, the Minister for Labour, God help us, and some old throwback that they would bring in for good measure and so it was no advantage to the Party to bring in 3,000 people into Clare and make it a four-seat constituency. Somebody else would benefit but not themselves in the Minister's view. So he divided Clare from the Atlantic Ocean to the Shannon, took 15,000 votes from it and threw them into Galway to make a threeseater of this famous constituency of Clare-Galway to suit himself and his Party. He divided Clare from Lisdoonvarna across to Killaloe knowing very well that the Minister for Labour was snugly tucked in between Ennis and West Clare.

Then what would he do? Last Monday he had received advice from members of his own Party through the urban council of Ennis and Clare County Council that a protest was signed by members of his own Party dissociating themselves from his action in this butchering operation. That was passed at the Ennis Urban Council and the members of his Party who signed it were brought to a special meeting called and held in Ennis on Monday. The local Deputy was sent down to castigate the members of his own Party who signed the protest. They were hauled before the council meeting and chastisement was administered to them. They had to come into the council chamber and talk their way out of it as best they could and make excuses for their action in signing the protest.

This is what has happened as a result of the Minister's action and he cannot deny it. It is something we shall talk about as we did prior to the 16th October, something I hope the Minister will take cognisance of, if he can retain the memory of what the people of Clare and Limerick say about his action. The Clare constituency is now butchered in such a way that one mile from Ennis the people no longer vote for a Clare man. That is part of ClareGalway. But the Minister went further afield into County Roscommon and took a piece out of Roscommon to make up the constituency of Clare-Galway. If that is not butchering brought to the nth degree I am no mathematician. The people of Clare know why this was done and nobody better than the Minister for Labour but the people of Clare will give their answer in no uncertain terms.

Is there any justice, honesty or fair play in this action? The honest-minded Fianna Fáil supporter who thinks back to the 16th October will reflect again because they have all seen the double dealing which the Minister has brought to his task since he took over his Department. We in the Labour Party are not afraid to face the people at any time. We are always honest with them and we have taken the honest, longterm view on these matters. Whatever way the Minister tries to butcher—his own words — constituencies — whether he means the land or the people, I do not know; eventually it is the people— he will get the answer he deserves.

There are much greater issues to be resolved; there are bigger things in the destiny of the nation that we cannot have discussed. We cannot let the people of Ireland into the knowledge of what is taking place or what should be discussed but we are rushing into this as we rushed headlong into the referendum operation and there is no doubt in my mind about the outcome of this operation by the Minister for Local Government. Let us not leave this today without impressing on him that the result of his action will boomerang with the same velocity as did the result of the referendum on 16th of October.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

Since the start of this discussion on the Electoral (Amendment) Bill I have been amazed at the inconsistency of the Opposition Benches. Indeed, one could say that the Opposition have been using cajolery and humbug to confuse and cloud up the issue. This will not pay any dividend. Their insincerity is obvious and it is plain to see that they have no regard whatsoever for the intelligence of the Irish people.

A Fine Gael spokesman, Deputy T. J. Fitzpatrick, when opening the discussion on this Bill on behalf of his Party certainly put up a very good show. He did his best despite the fact that he had very little to go on. He was, of course, very critical at the start of his speech that the Bill was not recommended by the Minister. This is not the first time this has happened. I believe that it happened in 1959 and also in 1961. He made what can now be expected of Fine Gael, a sly attack on the character of the Minister for Local Government because the same Minister who is now introducing this Bill was with us as Minister for Local Government when the referendum proposals were introduced.

These remarks and the approach of Deputy Fitzpatrick have well and truly been answered by speakers from this side of the House. Deputy Fitzpatrick is to be complimented on his valiant efforts to introduce the commission into this discussion because he got his point on record despite all the efforts of the Chair. He went on to accuse us of gerrymandering under this new Bill but I should like to refresh the mind of Deputy Fitzpatrick and all those who think like him that the same thing was said of us and would have been said of us if the straight vote had been accepted and if PR had been abolished. The main cry of the Opposition during the referendum campaign was that we would have wholesale gerrymandering and I suppose they are now trying the same approach under the present system, the system of PR.

This is a repetition also of their approach to the Electoral Bill of 1961. We know that the 1959 revision was virtually an agreed revision; boundaries were to be breached and there was to be fair representation for rural Ireland and the west. I understand that this approach was specifically endorsed by the then Leader of Fine Gael. Soon after the passing of the Bill, however, legal proceedings were instigated by the then Fine Gael Senator, Dr. John O'Donovan, acting through Fine Gael lawyers, to have this measure declared unconstitutional precisely because of its approach to rural representation.

We all know that the court held the 1959 Act to be unconstitutional and Dr. O'Donovan and his friends were, therefore, quite pleased with their work and, as a result, a revision of the constituencies had to take place in 1961. However, in 1961 the Bill was bitterly assailed by Fine Gael and their allies simply because the county boundaries were to be broken but when the opportunity was given to the people of doing away with the necessity of breaking county boundaries and of having single-seat constituencies, the Opposition raced up and down the country and made sure that the issues of the referendum were clouded from the people and, as a result, the Government's efforts in regard to these electoral reforms were not successful.

Part of the opposition to the 1961 Bill was based on the view that the Government should have moved an amendment to the Constitution but when the Government adopted this advice after the publication of the 1966 census they were assailed by the Opposition. The Opposition are on record as having jeered at the Government for trying to maintain county boundaries—boundaries that, I might add, were laid down as far back as the time of King John. They argued that the west of Ireland was overrepresented. When, as a result of the decision of the people, the Government introduced a new Bill which necessarily reduces representation in the west and breaches many county boundaries, there is an outcry from the same people who only a few months ago travelled up and down the country opposing the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill which sought to preserve county boundaries and to give fair rural representation.

In an answer to a Parliamentary question put by me to the Minister for Local Government on 26th November, it can be seen that TDs in certain parts of the country will need to get as many as 13,220 votes while in Dublin North West, 10,520 votes would suffice. We can also see that 10,850 votes in South County Dublin will do the same work as 12,350 votes in North East Donegal or 13,240 votes in South West Donegal. When the opportunity of having fair representation for the west and for rural Ireland was given to the people it was not accepted although we all pay lip service to the fact that rural Ireland should be fairly represented, all, that is, excepting one Deputy of the Labour Party, Deputy Seán Dunne who is on record as maintaining that rural Ireland is overrepresented. Even under the present Bill he wants to cut rural representation down further.

These are some of the inconsistencies that have come to the surface during this discussion and there are others. As regards the Constituency Commission, such a proposal was put forward by the Government in 1959 as part of the proposed amendment of the Constitution put to the people at the time. Both Opposition Parties criticised it, particularly the provision that the decision of the commission would be altered by only a two-thirds majority of the Dáil. They held that this gave too much power to the commission, that the commission would be too strong altogether.

In the 1968 Bill the Government changed the form of the commission to meet these objections, in particular by providing for amendment of the commission's findings by a simple majority of the Dáil. The Opposition then attacked this because it gave too little power to the commission. I do not think it would be any harm to place on record that the very same Senator who moved an Opposition amendment in 1959 to change a two-thirds majority of the Dáil to a simple majority, moved an amendment in 1968 to change a simple majority to a two-thirds majority. Fine Gael, having opposed the Government's proposal to amend the Constitution to provide for a Constituency Commission, are now pressing for it although they must know that it is not possible without an amendment of the Constitution. The Constitution as it stands, very clearly gives to the Oireachtas itself the duty of revision of the constituencies. Any measure which sought to transfer that power elsewhere would be unconstitutional.

One could go on citing inconsistencies. The Opposition and members of the Labour Party, in particular a prime mover, called for an early general election. They know well that under the Constitution an election cannot be held until a revision of the constituencies is carried out. Yet they are carrying out a filibuster against this Bill. We had Deputy Treacy attacking the Government for their "indecent haste" in introducing the Bill. It must be conceded, however, that there are a number of constant factors underlying the Opposition approach. The most prominent of these facts is their unconcealed contempt for the intelligence of the people. In this they are very much mistaken. It is because of this attitude that they are almost permanently in opposition. A second factor is their contempt for the will of the people. They opposed the Constitution in 1937 and they opposed in particular those provisions which gave the people direct control over the organs of Government. They opposed the decision that the people be given an opportunity to amend the Constitution in a Bill this year and they are now advocating proposals which conflict with the people's decision.

We have many charges of gerrymandering, charges that this Bill was given to us as a result of the work of a large Party and that the Bill is introduced for the primary purpose of making sure that our Party, Fianna Fáil, will have enough seats after the next general election to form a Government. I do not think that I should go into the general election campaign or the formation of a Government on this basis. As a result of the next general election, which will be held between now and April, 1970, the people will make up their minds whether they want Fianna Fáil to remain on as their Government. If they do not want them, the decision will be theirs as to what sort of Government they will have.

This is not the time nor the place to go into this and I only mention it in passing. We have Opposition Deputies saying that county boundaries are being pushed here, there and everywhere. I honestly believe that I would be the best person to draw up this Bill, if I were to do it to satisfy myself. I believe every Deputy in this House would draw up a different Bill if he had to do it to satisfy himself. I believe there are few people who are completely and wholly satisfied with the revision of the constituencies. It would be completely, utterly and totally impossible to please everyone. I am not pleased with the advantage I get in my constituency in West Limerick. If gerrymandering were the interest there, I should like to explain that this is largely a strong Fine Gael area which was given to West Limerick. This is known to the local people. I see Deputy Clinton smiling there. He probably thought I was about to trip myself up. This area is 60 or 70 miles away from my own area of Abbeyfeale. It is as far away as the town of Roscrea is from Dublin. If that is gerrymandering, it is a nice one. If I were working in my own interest I would like to see West Kerry pushed into it. I have nothing behind me and what I have been given is 60 to 70 miles away.

I had to laugh here today when I heard Deputy M. Dockrell, a prominent member of Fine Gael, saying that he would have a job to get across the Liffey if he were to get part of another constituency. If he considers it a job to cross the Liffey I should like to see him in a rural area trying to travel 70 miles odd and after that getting up on the Galtee Mountains to visit constituents. I wish Deputy Dockrell every success and I hope he will not suffer any stress in getting across the River Liffey.

We had a lot of talk about the breaking of county boundaries by Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick (Cavan) and other speakers. According to Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick, over the last few weeks, county boundaries should not be interfered with or broken. I believe Deputy Fitzpatrick, as well as Deputies from the Labour Party, are anything but worried about the breaking of county boundaries. County boundaries are not sacred things and should be broken if necessary. We had another inconsistency in the Opposition Parties saying that the county boundaries should not be broken. They are contradicting themselves. We had Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick saying on 28th May, 1968, and I quote from volume No. 235, column 145:

The Minister seems to think that county boundaries are sacred and that the counties and constituencies should coincide identically.

He goes on to say:

I do not think there is anything sacred about county boundaries. For example, for years back, we have had county managers managing two counties. We have had joint county managers in a number of counties. Practically every police district in this State consists of two counties joined together.

He says that a hospital now caters for three to four counties and that, therefore, there is nothing sacred about county boundaries.

If you listened to Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick, as I did last week, you would think that he has now forgotten what he said. It is only fair, right and proper that he should be well and truly reminded of this. In volume 235 column No. 518 of the same date he says:

I find it difficult to believe that people have all that dislike to moving from one county to another.

He said this after I had spoken at the time and made the case that we should not have to shift from one county to another unless it was vitally necessary. Indeed, Deputy Fitzpatrick and other members of his Party were not alone in that. We have had members of the Labour Party saying the same thing.

Earlier today a member of our Party said it was on record that the Labour Party were not in favour of county boundaries and this member of my Party was severely "sat on" by Deputy Tully. I avail of this opportunity to quote from the Official Report, volume 233, column 1517, where Deputy Michael O'Leary of the Labour Party is reported as saying:

The Taoiseach, originally, and later, the Minister for Local Government, mentioned the great problems involved in changing county boundaries. Who introduced counties into this country? Is this the national Parliament of this country? As far as I know, counties are relics of feudalism. We owe loyalty to this country rather than to any county. We owe loyalties to cities such as Dublin, Belfast and Cork, and to the rural areas: we should not shed tears for county boundaries which were introduced, in the first place, by an English administration.

When this was mentioned earlier today it was denied by Deputy James Tully that a member of the Labour Party would say such a thing but here is the proof that it was said by a member of the Labour Party. When it was mentioned to Deputy James Tully, he said, in effect: "Do not mind Deputy O'Leary: he is only a city TD." Deputy James Tully, for his own personal reasons, may have classified Deputy Michael O'Leary as "only a city TD". Deputy O'Leary is a representative of part of the city of Dublin and, furthermore, he is a Corkman and it is not so very long ago since he came to live in Dublin.

Comment on this

You do not merely disregard county boundaries. You have wiped Leitrim off the electoral map. There is a difference between breaching boundaries and wiping a county from the electoral map.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

Deputy Treacy is on record as saying he is quite satisfied with his constituency even though county boundaries are broken there and part of his constituency is made up of an area in County Waterford. He said he headed the poll——

Comment on this

It is no thanks to the Fianna Fáil administration who carved up my constituency at that time in the hope that they would do me damage.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

I did not anticipate interruptions from Deputy Treacy——

Comment on this

It is no thanks to the Fianna Fáil administration that I headed the poll there.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

Deputy Kyne of Waterford is a member of the Labour Party and he was in the same position——

Comment on this

The attempt to gerrymander boomeranged there.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

Please. Keep quiet. I have never interrupted Deputy Treacy and I hope I never shall.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins will do his best to give a completely different impression——

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

The truth is hard. The truth always hurts you because you are one of the people who were classified in one of my opening sentences——

Comment on this

You are talking a lot of twaddle.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

I am not talking out of turn. Tomorrow, when I would be expecting interruptions from the Deputy, I would say it. You have never denied that you were quite satisfied with your constituency.

Comment on this

It backfired on you.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

You cannot have it both ways. That is what is wrong with fellows like you. We shall not allow you to have it both ways. You are a pack of opportunists. You want it one way one day and a different way the next day. You will have to take it the same way the whole time. If you want county boundaries then stick to that: if you do not want county boundaries then forget the matter.

Comment on this

Tell us about Leitrim now.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

I will tell you something now that another member of your Party said a few minutes ago. Deputy Coughlan spoke of the revision of East and West Limerick and had a cock and bull story to tell. He said that great efforts were made to keep one little townland from being transferred into West Limerick. Deputy Coughlan must not be very familiar with the rural part of his constituency. It is plain to see, since the introduction of the Electoral Bill, that the area given to West Limerick from East Limerick was in a bottleneck and that five parishes were there. Even with an imagination as large as that of Deputy Treacy, one could not say——

Comment on this

I suppose it was done to help Deputy Coughlan?

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

The day I would want help from you would be a long way off. If I wanted help, I would not go to Deputy Treacy.

Comment on this

I am sure your desire was to help Deputy Coughlan in this instance.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

I am sure I can get a lot of help from Deputy Fahey. Would Deputy Treacy and his colleagues please keep quiet and let me make my speech? I listened to the speech by Deputy P.J. Hogan of South Tipperary who is a respected surgeon and gentleman. He dissected the Bill. I have great respect for his medical dissections but I regret that I have not the same respect for his dissections of constituencies.

Comment on this

No doubt you have great respect for Dr. Kevin Boland.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

Deputy P.J. Hogan, who is a fine surgeon, had the shakes in his hand when he was using the scalpel on the constituencies.

Comment on this

He is not a good butcher.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

He cannot be regarded as a good surgeon where the creation of constituencies is concerned because the figures he gave were so glaringly out. When I checked them, they were not out by ten or fifty per cent nor by 100 per cent; in some cases, they were out by thousands per cent. Admittedly, he said he was not an expert at such figures and we let it go with him. He should be informed. His worthy colleague from South Tipperary, Deputy Fahey, cleared the air for him in no uncertain manner.

Deputy Coughlan alleged that East Limerick was fashioned in order to keep out a particular town. It was not named because the Deputy knew that what he said was completely untrue. It is typical of his approach to the debate. I have no doubt that the Minister for Local Government will deal with what he had to say as it deserves to be dealt with and as he was dealt with a couple of weeks ago when the Minister had the same type of job to do.

Deputy Coughlan also told us that there was gerrymandering in West Limerick and that we were afraid that part of West Limerick would be pushed into North Kerry. It is a pity Deputy Coughlan did not enlarge on that statement because I should love to take it up and to give him the information which he is so sadly lacking. It is typical of the half lies, half charges, half truths which they are all adept at putting across. I have no doubt but that, when this measure goes through and when people have had time to digest it properly, it will be seen that we made the best use of the material available to us, in the interests of the nation. There are no steam-rolling tactics. Nobody can say with any degree of honesty that we as a Party are trying to push through this measure as fast as possible. Up to now, we are offering speaker for speaker. I honestly think there are more speakers from the Opposition benches so far but I think there is very little in it, if anything. Maybe the edge might be somewhat with the Opposition.

One would be inclined to think that, with all the cries we are getting for a general election—cries which we know not to be genuine—there would be some co-operation in putting this measure through the House. Despite those cries which we hear, I am inclined to believe that something of a filibuster is going on. I believe every effort is being made to keep this debate open.

Comment on this

Look at the crowded House here.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

It might not be crowded but it is certainly plain to be seen by anybody who sits here long enough that there is no shortage of speakers. One does not have to have a crowd, I think, to have a filibuster. If we had nice timing and a nice placing of speakers we could certainly have that. Again, there is something else that strikes me. There has been all the outcry about gerrymandering and about what will happen, but Deputy Tom Fitzpatrick (Cavan) has told us that there is no fear whatever as far as Fine Gael are concerned. In volume 237 of the Official Report, at column 1243, Deputy Fitzpatrick gave us a definition of the word “gerrymander” taken from the Imperial Dictionary of the English Language, New Edition, Volume II:

To arrange the political divisions of a State so that, in an election, one Party may obtain an advantage over its opponent even though the latter may possess a majority of votes in the State.

If Opposition Deputies are not afraid that we will get a majority of the votes then the so-called gerrymander will not succeed. Indeed, Deputy Fitzpatrick is on record as saying that the Minister will not succeed in his objects. If that be the argument, then Deputy Fitzpatrick, speaking for the Fine Gael Party, and Deputy Treacy, speaking for the Labour Party, are talking a great deal of rubbish.

Comment on this

I should like, first of all, to join with Deputy Collins, who has just sat down, in congratulating Deputy Tom Fitzpatrick on the able manner in which he dealt with this Bill and on the very clear way in which he pointed out the motives behind the Bill and its many defects and deficiencies. It is not often that we get compliments and congratulations from the other side of the House, but it is nice to hear them when they are paid.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

That is not fair. It is not true.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins also talked about filibustering. There is no doubt about it, if his speech was anything at all it was a first-class example of filibustering. I do not intend to say a great deal on this Bill. I certainly will not be accused of filibustering because, quite frankly, I do not think this Bill is worth debating. I believe the Minister has finally and definitely made up his mind that, no matter what arguments are put forward and no matter how convincing the evidence, he will not change a single line in the Bill.

This Bill is the outcome of many weeks and months of haggling within the Minister's own Party. It is a wellknown fact that the horse dealing was so intense that, in some cases, all the Fianna Fáil members of county councils had to come up here to try to settle the arguments. All the time the basic motive was how could they get the maximum number of Fianna Fáil TDs returned to this House. If any further evidence were needed of the arrogance towards, the disregard for and even contempt of the people, this Bill certainly provides it. The Government have wasted the best part of the last 12 months and an enormous amount of money in trying to provide themselves with the necessary machinery for gerrymandering on a large scale, but the people gave them their answer. When certain proposals were put before the people in the referendum they met with a crushing defeat. This is now a further effort at gerrymandering. It is a last ditch attempt to use the situation in which they are obliged to revise constituencies in order to gerrymander the country and ensure that the maximum possible number of Fianna Fáil TDs are elected. "The best laid schemes ... gang aft agley" and I have no doubt that the people will respond, when the opportunity offers, in the very same way as they did when the referendum proposals were before them.

Deputy Collins referred at length to the question of breaching boundaries. It is well known that the Minister for Local Government went all over the country, thumping his breast piously and solemnly because of the grievous sin it would be if natural boundaries had to be crossed or infringed in any way. He was denied what he was looking for in the referendum and he now comes back here with a job to be done. Had he tried to cut up the country and breach the greatest possible number of boundaries—natural, county and otherwise—he could not have done it better than he has done it in this Bill. He has separated no less than 17 pieces of nine counties, although it has been clearly shown, and it has not been denied by any member of the Fianna Fáil Party so far, that revision could have been done by altering only six pieces of six counties, and this without the expertise and the advice available to the Minister in his own Department.

I am not sufficiently familiar with the greater part of the country to criticise in detail, but there are a couple of areas with which I am familiar. I am certainly familiar with my own constituency of County Dublin. It is quite obvious to me what the intention is in County Dublin. There is little regard to natural boundaries. I am sorry the Minister is not here because I intend to spell out for him in some detail what has been done. Ballyfermot has been put in with the city. Now that is something with which I agree. It always belonged there, but it is no harm to point out that the Minister recognised that he himself had lost the support of the people of Ballyfermot; he recognised that very definitely on the day of the referendum. He recognised it previously in the Presidential Election. He used to have the support of the people of Ballyfermot but the people in Ballyfermot have wakened up to the fact that absolutely nothing has been done for them over the years and that theirs was a most neglected area. The Minister decided it was better to get that load off his back. He did not want any repetition of that humiliation in the coming general election.

The next motive uppermost in his mind was to get rid of me. He told me twice across the floor of the House that he would settle me. Possibly he may have succeeded, but I am quite happy to leave that to the verdict of the people. He divided my county council area exactly in two so that no matter which area I chose to stand in I would find myself with half the votes I normally get as a result of the work I have done over the years in my council area, where I have headed the poll on three different occasions in the local elections. I am confident that when this comes before the people they will give me the support they have always given me in the past.

His next motive was that he wanted to get away from Deputy P.J. Burke. Deputy Burke has always been a great embarrassment to the Minister. He has been an embarrassment because he has headed the poll consistently. He is a hard worker and the people know it in his constituency. They have recognised that over the years. The Minister thought it was as well to get away from him. I understand that the latest rumour at Fianna Fáil meetings is that the Minister is trying to get Deputy Burke to stand with him in South County Dublin. Could anything be a greater laugh?

That was not the end of his motives. His further motive was to ensure that Deputy Foley would be kept in this House. Deputy Foley is a favourite with the Minister and consequently he chopped up the constituency in such a way that two seats would be almost assured for Fianna Fáil in North County Dublin. I would not be as certain as the Minister is that those are two safe seats, because I believe the people have made up their minds. We have had a landslide recently, and it would not take a landslide to ensure that Fianna Fáil are not able to retain two seats in North County Dublin. However, that is the intention behind it.

I would ask the people to have a look at the shape of the new constituencies, to have a look at the shape of Dún Laoghaire/Rathdown, to have a look at the shape of South County Dublin, to have a look at the area that is now described as North County Dublin. Believe it or not Kimmage, Manor Estates and Greenhills are in North County Dublin which goes over to KCR Garage. Talk about natural boundaries. There were numerous natural boundaries which could have been followed but they were ignored. They were ignored for certain purposes, and I have enumerated some of the purposes. One was to eliminate a councillor of their own who was likely to be a rival and who is not a favourite, Councillor Walsh, and by splitting his council vote they ensured that he was killed off. When you live in a constituency and are intimate with what is happening in it you know the moves behind the scene.

The Minister was bound to be an expert in his own area. Why did he not take the Naas road as a boundary? Everyone knows it is a natural boundary. Why not take the road to the west or the Navan road? Those are natural boundaries. Why not take the Navan road and make North County Dublin a three seater and give South County Dublin four seats?

Comment on this

The population comes into it.

Comment on this

If he took the Navan road he would have the population for a three seater on the north side and a four seater on the south side. He has gone out of his way to change the boundaries. South County Dublin now crosses the Bray Road at one point. Is the Bray Road a natural boundary? Why chop in and out like that?

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Cosgrave had that fixed up?

Comment on this

If Deputy Cosgrave succeeded he succeeded in getting something sensible done. I am not sure he has succeeded. I would ask anyone with time to spare to have a look at the way they have cut in on the map. Look at Walkinstown, Greenhills and Manor Estates. See the shape of the map and ask what regard was had for natural boundaries. It is the greatest laugh and the greatest nonsense to say that any heed was paid to the natural boundaries. This is simply and solely a revenge Bill, a Bill to show the people that they have not succeeded in changing the Government's efforts to gerrymander the country and keep themselves in office for the next 20 years. This is a further blatant effort to do that.

I want to say a word now about County Meath. I said I know something about County Meath. Here Deputy Farrelly was uppermost in the Minister's mind. Deputy Farrelly lives at the furthest end of County Meath and, of course, the effort here is to get rid of him by putting his own home area in Monaghan. This is very important—the area where he is known best and where his vote is strongest. There has been a Fine Gael seat in Meath since the foundation of the State and a Fine Gael seat will remain in Meath no matter what effort the Minister makes. I think he can only succeed in giving us an extra seat in Monaghan and an extra seat in Cavan. As I said before: "The best laid schemes—". That is what the Minister deserves.

Knowing our own areas no one can understand why the country has been carved up in this way except that it was done for petty purposes and to show the people that they were wrong. It was obvious that Deputy G. Collins was not prepared to accept the verdict of the people. He says he believes they were completely wrong in the referendum and that this is a further opportunity for them to rectify their serious error in not enabling Fianna Fáil to provide themselves with machinery to gerrymander the country.

There is no point in speaking at length on this Bill because the Minister has finally and definitely made up his mind. There will be no change, and no argument will have any effect. We are being accused of delaying the prospect of getting this to the country. I will not be accused of delaying the prospect of getting it to the country because, so far as I am concerned, the sooner it goes to the country the better. I am confident that the people have made up their minds that Fianna Fáil are too long in office and that the most important thing at present is to change the Government. The country is being governed from the outside because of the pressures that have built up. The people have their minds made up and they will change the Government and, no matter what gerrymandering machinery they try to provide themselves with, they are gone. This change is inevitable and the Government may as well take it in their stride. Many of them are convinced that this will be useless.

Deputy Collins said that speakers in this debate had no regard for the intelligence of the Irish people. What regard had the Government Party for the intelligence of the Irish people when they put before them the proposal in the referendum? They had the same regard as they had for their intelligence in the proposal they are putting before them now in this Electoral Bill. I know that a job had to be done. The constituencies had to be revised. I spoke during the course of the referendum and indicated that this was vitally necessary because of the fact that in 1961 when the constituencies were being revised the position was that in County Dublin it took 9 per cent more population to elect a Deputy than it did in South Mayo, but in 1966 when the census came out this 9 per cent had grown to 72 per cent because of developments that had taken place in County Dublin. I say that the revision is essential and must be done. It provided the Minister with an opportunity to do a proper job. I do not know how anybody trying to rationalise the situation could come in from the Naas Road on the Long Mile and not take the small corporation area on the right hand side into County Dublin.

You meet the corporation area first and then the county and then the city. If we were doing anything rational, surely this should have been included in the plan? It is not included in the plan. Every natural and normal boundary in the country has been ignored. The Minister may say that he had to go by townlands? He may say this is the by townlands? He may say this is the only way we have because we must go according to population on the register. Townlands can go through the middle of fields. We have a position now here under this new arrangement in which people who voted all their lives in Newcastle, and who went to school in Newcastle and are beside Newcastle, will be obliged to vote in Lucan, because of this north-south boundary according to townlands.

Comment on this

Does that not apply where you have any new boundary?

Comment on this

Not at all. Why not try to work this out?

Comment on this

They are complaining here about cutting up parishes.

Comment on this

I personally would have no difficulty in meeting the requirements of the Constitution and sticking to boundaries which everybody knows and on which people are walking and travelling every day.

Comment on this

You would have four in South County Dublin and three in North County Dublin?

Comment on this

You could do it that way and use the Navan Road as a boundary. I say that the River Liffey is not a natural boundary because it goes into the fields. People do not travel on the Liffey unless they are in boats and very few are in boats. I think that the normal thing is to use main roads.

Comment on this

Then you could divide a village.

Comment on this

You could. There is no crime about that. Here you have a situation which you have always had between city and county, where the right-hand side of the road was in the county and the left-hand side in the city. This is something the people know well. It is very easily divided but there are very few people who know the exact boundaries of townlands.

Comment on this

It is the only way we do know it.

Comment on this

I submit there are very few people in the country who know the exact townland boundaries. People know the roads very well. This is the way this effort should be made. This is the only way you could have a rational break-up. It might present a little bit of difficulty here and there because of population and of the collection of the census. It is the only sensible way to do it. Anybody who would tell me there were no motives behind the way the Dublin County constituency, Dún Laoghaire-Rath-down and the city constituencies were broken up could not be believed. I would say it is quite a laugh. If it is an attack on the people's intelligence this is it. One has only to look at the map and see the way the job is done with the line going in and out to fulfil certain purposes and to separate certain personalities. I have spelled it out in fair detail and I do not propose to do anything more. I am not fully familiar with the situation so I cannot indicate in detail the motives that have moved the Minister in the various other parts of the country but I know what was behind his movements in Dublin. I can tell him that there is serious resentment on the part of many of the people in what is now described as North County Dublin because no stretch of imagination could put them into North County Dublin. It would take a mind like the Minister's to conceive it. I know the people will give them their answer in the next election.

Comment on this

In the first paragraph of the explanatory memorandum to this Bill it is stated that the purpose of the Bill is to revise Dáil constituencies in the light of the 1966 census. We all know that there is another purpose and that is to revise Dáil constituencies with a view to securing the greatest possible advantage for the Fianna Fáil Party. That has been repeated very often in this House. Most of the general arguments on the Bill have been repeated at this stage. As Deputy Clinton and other speakers have said, it seems frustrating and futile to deal with the arguments on this Bill. Unlike my Labour colleague, Deputy Coughlan, who referred to this measure as a hasty one, I believe that this measure was framed long before we went out on the referendum campaign. This measure was framed before the referendum. Perhaps, some little alterations were made in it by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party by leaving in townlands, but generally, I have every reason to believe that this measure was framed before the referendum was held on the 16th October. This was the fall back.

When the Minister talked about the consequences of the defeat for the Government on the 16th October he knew very well what he was talking about and what the next step would be. The only consideration that appears evident in the measure and in the alterations that have been made is that the constituency boundaries throughout the 26 Counties appear to be arranged having regard to the desirability of decreasing and eliminating as many Opposition Deputies as was possible. That was the purpose. Another purpose was to avoid so far as possible competition between Government members or Government Ministers. I think my colleague, when speaking here earlier this evening, made that point pretty clear. He spoke about Mid-Cork and said it was essentially a rural constituency and that he will be able to represent it. That is why Mid-Cork has been so framed—so that a Fianna Fáil man can represent it. But, if you will pardon me, that is not what is important. What is important in the framing of constituencies is that the needs of the people are met, not the needs of individual Fianna Fáil Members.

Deputy Meaney made the point I am trying to make on this Bill. It was framed long before we fought the referendum campaign and Deputy Meaney said he had toured the area which will form part of his new constituency. He did not say when, but we all know it was during the referendum campaign to collect "Yes" votes for the proposed changes and, ironically, in the area which is now added to his Mid-Cork constituency. He was also concerned that another Cork man, Deputy Barrett, when speaking last week, overlooked the fact that I lived only seven miles from Cork city. Deputy Barrett had been making the point that the people of two Cork suburbs, Douglas and Blackrock, had to travel to Bandon or Macroom, if they required to see a Deputy. I am sure Deputy Barrett did not intend to reflect on me.

The point I wish to make is that members of the Government Party did not overlook my presence when reframing the constituencies in County Cork, because quite a lot of the area in which there was Labour support was syphoned off and put into West Cork. Two considerations influenced the Government when reframing County Cork and any of us could have foreseen that. First, North-East Cork carries five seats, of which the Government Party have secured two. The referendum result made it abundantly clear that the Government would not secure in the immediate future, if ever again, more than two seats in that constituency, so the obvious thing to do was to reduce the number of seats and arrange the constituency so that they could secure two out of four seats.

If one is concerned with Party rather than with the good of the people whom it is intended to represent, this makes sense. There was also Government concern because there has been a growing swing to Labour in Cork as, indeed, in all our cities, and the way to combat that was to divide Cork city. Great play has been made of the fact that it is important to retain Cork as a completely urban area and this prompts me to ask why not apply that principle to Dublin, vis-à-vis County Dublin, to Limerick city and to other such areas? If it is logical to treat Cork in this way, does the same logic not apply to other cities? However, a similar decision has not been taken in respect of the other cities.

We have abundant evidence in County Cork that what was in mind was to make it as difficult as possible for Labour Members, and for Opposition Members generally, to secure reelection. Also in mind was the need to eliminate as far as possible competition between Government Members and to create competition between Opposition Deputies. No consideration was given to the matter of convenience —convenience of representation or the convenience of the people.

Surely some consideration might have been given to the idea of having constituencies based on existing health areas. In County Cork we have north, south and west health areas, but we have a situation as a result of this unfair, unjust alteration of constituencies, in which in Mid-Cork we represent three different health areas, in East Cork we represent two health areas and in South-West Cork we represent the same number. This makes representation difficult and it makes it difficult for the people. The only purpose it serves is to ensure that the maximum benefit will be derived by the Government Party. This is rampant in the entire proposals for the 26 Counties—one finds that the same picture obtains throughout.

That is why I agree with others who have said that it is futile to speak at length on this measure. It was framed for this purpose, it will be carried and put through the House despite anything we can say. That is what matters in the minds of the present Government. Two nights before the voting took place on the referendum, the Taoiseach appeared on television. He said he was horrified at the suggestion that gerrymandering could take place under the single seat system and he challenged the Leaders of the other two Parties to do any better than the Government had done in the reframing of constituencies. I do not think the situation has changed since—there is the difference between multi-seat and single seat constituencies—and I now challenge the Taoiseach to leave to a Committee of the House the job of reframing constituency boundaries. Of course, that challenge will not be met because, when the House had the chance of acceding to a request to set up a commission, the Taoiseach and his Party voted against the proposal.

As I have said, there is no point in continuing to speak on this. I realise I may not refer to questions which are not included in the Bill but perhaps I might be allowed to speak on something which I think should be in the Bill. I refer to postal votes for emigrants. This is not a novel idea. A great deal of concern is being expressed for rural Ireland. It was expressed by the Minister during the referendum campaign, it was expressed in his introductory statement and in Government speeches on this Bill. We have made provision for votes for Army personnel serving overseas. We should decide that our emigrants, particularly temporary emigrants, as we hope most of them will be, should be entitled to vote in elections while they are away from home.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy but within the framework of this Bill we deal with the constituencies only. The Deputy will appreciate that it is not an ordinary electoral Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy got it in. It was a very good performance.

Comment on this

I have nothing to add except to say that this is not a Bill based on the 1966 Census. It is a Bill designed to make the best of a bad job after the colossal defeat experienced by the Government in the recent referendum. This is a last desperate attempt by the Government to hold on to power, but I can assure them that when the next election comes along the people will decide that the Government who are capable of rushing a measure of this sort through the House will be defeated just as they were in the recent referendum—by a colossal margin.

Comment on this

I rise to make a few very brief remarks. Maybe I can attribute the fact that I wish to make these remarks to the contribution of Deputy Mrs. Desmond, at least the latter part of it. She was referring to the idea of the constituencies being drawn up by a commission, to the Taoiseach's offer on television during the referendum campaign. She did not appear to state very clearly that he was making the offer to accept any type of commission in the setting up of single-seat constituencies. The idea of having single-seat constituencies has, of course, been rejected and we are to continue under PR. It came to my mind that throughout the referendum campaign the Opposition speakers time and again emphasised the point that the PR system that operated in this country suited the country, that it was an Irish PR system, that it was a system particular to this country, something which had been accepted by the Irish people, something which was understood by them.

Comment on this

The system we have we know.

Comment on this

Yes, that was more or less the line you were taking. If, however, we were to have an independent commission set up to draw up the constituencies under PR you would have a much different position because the Constitution only states that constituencies must have at least three seats. There is nothing in the Constitution to stop an independent commission from recommending to this House that we should have one constituency with 144 seats. There would not have been any necessity for them to pay any heed to what we were told was the Irish system of PR. We could have ended up with recommendations which would have been abhorred not alone by Members of this House but by the vast majority of the people. We could have ended up with a completely different electoral system, something we did not want at all. I just want to point out the many strange decisions which it would be possible to make by giving an independent commission power to draw up constituencies under PR. They could not have done this to any great degree under a single seat system.

During the referendum campaign charges of gerrymandering were being made. I was very much in favour of the single-seat constituency idea and of the straight vote because it would be the only proper way to operate single seats. We were being told— because it was good propaganda I suppose at the time to drag this into it—that we were seeking power with which we could gerrymander the constituencies. As we know the proposals in the referendum were defeated. The people who were making the charges that if they were passed there would be gerrymandering are still making the charge that there is gerrymandering. I suggest they just cannot have it both ways. The Irish people are intelligent and it is very foolish of political representatives to underestimate the intelligence of the people. I feel that it is a deliberate insult to the intelligence of the Irish people to suggest to them not to vote for something because it would give power to gerrymander and then when they do not vote for it, to still come in and make charges that gerrymandering is being carried out. It is not logical and I suggest to them that they are wasting their time with those allegations.

Nobody expects the Fine Gael or Labour Party to come into the House and tell the Minister for Local Government that they agree with his proposals for the drawing up of the constituencies in their entirety. He did not wish it upon himself to have to draw up new constituencies. He has to do this because of the position under the Constitution. Everybody understands this. The revision was thrust upon him and he had to do the job. It is not reasonable to expect that the Opposition Parties would agree with him, but to continue to make charges of gerrymandering just does not make sense to me because no matter what proposals he brought in they would still be opposing them.

There are 144 Members in the House. Slightly over half of them are on the Government side of the House and very few of the Government Members are satisfied with these proposals either because nearly every Member of the House has had his original constituency, in which he was elected, interfered with. They had to be changed to meet the new requirements. Even in my own constituency in the west of Ireland which was a three-seat constituency and still is a three-seat constituency under the new proposals we have had a change, a small change. I am not happy about it, but I have to accept it.

We have lost a portion of the West Galway Constituency and, when one has worked as well as one can for people in an area and then finds that they will not be in a position to vote for him at the next election, naturally one is rather sad about it and feels slightly upset. But that is political life and I am afraid it is something we will have to put up with. I hope that the people whom I represented in the Liscannane electoral district will be happy in their new constituency. However, that is only a very small change. Some of the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil side of the House will find themselves in completely new areas and to a large extent will find themselves in a very difficult position as regards going to new people asking them to vote for them. This affects both sides and all Parties and it just is not good enough for members of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party to say that they are the only people who have cause to be upset. In the corridors of this House the Fine Gael and Labour Members know from speaking privately to Fianna Fáil TDs that very many of them are upset and unhappy about the new situation—not, indeed, that they fear it but it is natural to be upset about having to stand in a different area from the one in which one has probably stood for many years and where one has come to know a large section of the electorate and has worked with them and lived with them. For a large proportion of those people it will be quite a change.

Therefore, I appeal for a little bit of fair play from Fine Gael and Labour. It seems to me that the great desire on their part is to throw as much mud as they can, to say as many things, horrible things, as they can possibly think of. There is a tremendous amount of rumour-mongering emanating from the Opposition Benches and every time that it is challenged there is no evidence produced to substantiate the allegations being made. I congratulate and compliment Deputy Cosgrave on the appeal which he has made——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is this relevant?

Comment on this

——to his own members to stop this kind of carry-on. I wish to associate myself with the remarks of Deputy Cosgrave. He was speaking to his own people and I only hope they will listen to him on this occasion because they did not listen to him when he asked them to vote for the Government proposals in the referendum.

Comment on this

That was enlightened advice from Deputy Molloy. Having listened to some of the debate on the Electoral (Amendment) Bill, it surprised me to hear Deputy Molloy turn away from the purpose of the debate this afternoon to give advice to the members of the Fine Gael Party. I do not think the members of the Fine Gael Party need any advice from Deputy Molloy or any other Deputy as to how they should behave.

I have just one or two things to say on this Bill and I do not think there is any Deputy in this House who should have more to say about it than I have. I am not going to say very much this evening as I will have more to say on it during the later Stages. I happen to be a Deputy who has had two-thirds of the electoral area he represents on the county council taken away from him and one-third of the adjoining electoral area also taken away. All those areas are within 12 to 14 miles from me. Actually, the parish in which I live has been divided. One portion has been put into Cavan and the other into Monaghan.

Of course, when one thinks about Monaghan it immediately brings to mind the purpose of the whole act. We have now in the constituency of Monaghan an eminent Minister of the Fianna Fáil Party. He has gone around most of the constituencies in this country during his lifetime. From 1938 to 1948 he was a Deputy for Athlone-Longford and from 1948 to 1961 he was a Deputy for Longford-Westmeath. From 1961 until the present day he has been a Deputy for Monaghan. Cavan and Monaghan could have been made a five-seat constituency. That was in the ordinary scheme of things but with this eminent Minister going around from one constituency to another he could not be left in that invidious position so they had to give him a portion of county Meath so that he could arrive back in Dáil Éireann after the next general election as a representative for Monaghan.

Comment on this

He might go back to Longford.

Comment on this

He might do so or go to Longford-Westmeath as it was. As I said earlier, I am one of the victims of what the Minister and the Fianna Fáil Party are doing. I am proud to have represented the people of County Meath since 1961. It is the royal County. We have been kicked around in changes of constituencies since the late 1930s. We were thrown at one stage into Meath-Westmeath. We had a sojourn there for a while and then we were taken back into County Meath and remained as one unit during the 1940s until 1959-60 when the last redrafting of constituencies came around.

In 1960 they proceeded to dole out portion of County Meath to Kildare and that is the way it has remained until the present day. Now, as I said before, to help this particular gentleman who is now a representative from Monaghan they had to take two portions of County Meath and they extended the constituency of Meath up to the Bog of Allen. I do not think anybody who heard the speeches made by members of the Fianna Fáil Government during the referendum to the effect that if you wanted your TD you did not want to have to travel long distances to see him can agree that if the Minister for Local Government wanted to find the TD from Navan or within five miles of Ardee that he should have to go to the Bog of Allen to find him. I do not think this is right and I do not believe the Minister for Local Government thinks it is right.

Comment on this

We agree on that at any rate. It is your fault not mine.

Comment on this

This has been done in the hope that they would keep a Fine Gael representative from County Meath out of Leinster House. Since the foundation of the State there have been Fine Gael representatives in County Meath and I have no doubt that when the next election comes around and the chips are down the people of County Meath will return a Fine Gael Deputy to this House despite what Fianna Fáil may think they have been doing to try to disfranchise the people who support Fine Gael.

In the 1960 rearrangement the Deputy for Fine Gael in County Meath was the late Captain Giles, God rest him. At that time, in order to see if they could take away Fine Gael support from the county they took his portion of the constituency away. He was not in very good health at that time and he decided not to go forward again. I stood for election and was elected. It is a very strange thing and looks very strange to me and the people in County Meath that I represent that they have followed me to the north of County Meath and have taken away the area I live in. I shall have more to say on this during the later Stages of the Bill but when the chips are down the people of County Meath will thwart the efforts of the Fianna Fáil Party who are trying to deny Fine Gael their true representation in County Meath.

Comment on this

I believe that this Bill is a vindictive act, a vindictive Bill brought in by a vindictive Minister against the people who dared express their opinions in a massive vote against the Government recently in the referendum. The Government stand condemned and discredited. Because they know that have lost the support of the majority of the people they are trying in this Bill to hold on to the reins of office.

We have in this Bill a form of gerrymandering equal to, if not worse than, that which the Unionists have perpetrated on the people of Derry. We have heard Fianna Fáil speak about their aspirations for a long number of years. We have heard them tell us they would get back the Six Counties. For a long number of years we had 26 Counties but now one county in the west, lovely Leitrim, is being wiped completely off the map. The Government try to blame the Opposition Deputies. The Minister has done so day after day and said across to the people on this side of the House: "You and you alone are responsible for this." I want to say that the people are responsible for what is happening.

I heard Deputy Molloy speak a few moments ago about the intelligence of the people. The people are certainly intelligent because over 600,000 of them have shown how intelligent they were recently when they showed they were not prepared to allow the Government to rivet themselves in power by the first proposition that was put to them. Because that was defeated by an intelligent electorate, they now come with this proposition to the House. If marks were to be given for gerrymandering, the Government would get 100 per cent. Deputy Briscoe may smile. Consider how the constituencies are framed, the manner in which the Government have crossed county borders where and when it suited them.

Senator FitzGerald pointed out in the daily national newspapers that if a body of people wanted to arrange the constituencies in a fair and honest way, cherishing all the children of the nation equally—a sentiment to which Fianna Fáil give so much lip service —they could have done it by crossing only six county borders and disturbing approximately 35,000 to 36,000 of the population. Here we have a proposal to cross 13 borders and to disturb well over 100,000 people.

Comment on this

Like all your figures, unsubstantiated.

Comment on this

The Deputy is the last one who should speak about it. If, for example, the Government wanted to cherish all the children of the nation equally, if they wanted to be fair to the minority, they could have left Cavan and Monaghan as a five-seat constituency and could have left Donegal as a five-seat constituency but the grass roots came out and said, "If you do, the Protestant Association will get a seat in each area and we cannot trust them to walk into the division lobby with Fianna Fáil". They did not want that. When you talk about cherishing all the children of the nation equally, they should have given those people their God-given right. They are the people who speak so much about the rights of the minority. The minorities should remember that. It is well known that people from Donegal, Monaghan and Cavan came up and asked them not to leave Donegal as a five-seat constituency, that the protestant Association would get a man in there and that they could not trust him, that they did not know what way he would vote. The same happened as regards Monaghan. It is obvious from the map that it would be quite easy to leave Cavan and Monaghan as a five-seat constituency. It had the right number of people for a five-seat constituency. A smaller number of Donegal people could be moved into Limerick— I mean Leitrim—and if that were done Leitrim would still be on the map. The Minister need not smile because I said "Limerick" instead of Leitrim. When I mentioned Limerick I might not have been so far out. You brought portion of the constituency——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must address the Chair.

Comment on this

Through the Chair, to the Minister.

Comment on this

The Chair was smiling also.

Comment on this

Portion of Clare has been added to Galway and to make up that constituency they have brought in portion of Roscommon. So that it would not be stretching the imagination too far to suggest that the Minister could quite easily have done what I, through a slip of the tongue, suggested. Their plan was quite simple. Where Fianna Fáil think that they are reasonably strong and could get 45 or 46 per cent of the votes, they have made the constituencies three-seaters, hoping that by doing so they may get two out of every three seats.

In the recent referendum they got the highest percentage of the votes they received in the entire country in Connacht and Ulster—45.2 per cent. It may be no harm to remind them that that represents a drop from the 54.8 per cent that they got in the same area in the 1959 referendum. Their desire now is quite simple. They think that in those areas in Connacht and Ulster they will get two out of three seats in the three-seat constituencies.

Now let us come to Dublin where in the recent referendum the Government got only 30.6 per cent of the votes. They are hoping that through some miracle they may get two out of the four seats. The people of Ireland have found them out as they have shown by their intelligent vote in the recent referendum. It is well known that the Government are flying against the wishes of the people as expressed by the massive number of votes cast against their proposals in the referendum. The people showed that they want to retain proportional representation. If the Government were to concede the wishes of the people, there should be five, six or even seven-seat constituencies. The Government believe that by having the larger constituencies they would lose heavily. Despite what the Government have done in this Bill they will be defeated because the Irish people have found them out and know them for what they are.

The Minister and many other Members of the Fianna Fáil Party were shedding crocodile tears because the west was to lose four seats which were to be added to the representation of the city of Dublin. As one who comes from rural Ireland it is my opinion that it is people, not mountains, hills or rivers, who are entitled to seats. If the west loses four seats, who is responsible for that? The responsibility and the blame rests on the shoulders of the people on the far side of the House and the Government now in power. Representation is based on the population of a particular constituency on a particular day in 1966.

Through Fianna Fáil's bad government, as a result of their neglect of the west and of rural Ireland, they have driven from the west over 150,957 persons, with the result that in Connacht there were 150,000 fewer persons on the register in 1966 as compared with 1956. That is the reason why there will be four fewer Deputies in the west under this Bill. It is because of the mismanagement of the Minister for Local Government and the Government of which he is a member. When the Minister sheds crocodile tears about crossing boundaries who but himself is to blame? The Minister often comes in here and talks about the dreadful year that 1956 was. We hear this regularly from the Fianna Fáil Party. In County Galway, since 1956——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I must interrupt the Deputy to point out that he cannot embark on what might be regarded as an economic debate on this Bill. We are confined, within the terms of the Bill, to what is in the Bill—the rearrangement of constituencies.

Comment on this

I have not very much to say on the Bill but I do want to say that the Bill is deliberately framed to suit the members of Fianna Fáil. No matter what they may say in this House it is a well-known fact that there were two or three Party meetings held and that the squabbling went on in the Party Rooms at the meeting.

Comment on this

That is another deliberate untruth.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe may shake his head, but it is a well-known fact that over a month ago the Minister had the Bill prepared, that there was a proposition, which was carried, at the Fianna Fáil Party meeting, that Deputy Boland's Bill would be put before the Fianna Fáil Party meeting for consideration. The Bill was put before the Fianna Fáil Party for consideration, and therefore you have the constituencies——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it in order for Deputy L'Estrange to make allegations which are absolutely untrue and cannot be substantiated? I know these allegations are not true, and I think there must be some sort of restriction.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair cannot control allegations of this kind which are in the nature of political charges.

Comment on this

What I have said is quite true. I made a similar allegation before when the referendum was being discussed. We were told the decision was unanimous at a Fianna Fáil meeting. I stated here it was not. It has since been admitted by Fianna Fáil Ministers that it was not, and it was admitted by Deputy Lionel Booth, who proposed an amendment in this House, despite the fact that the Minister for Local Government said here it was a unanimous decision of the Party without anybody dissenting from it.

This Bill is designed so that the maximum number of Fianna Fáil Deputies can be returned to this House and so that the Fianna Fáil Party can try to rivet itself in power despite the wishes of the people. The Bill was deliberately framed to put out of this House at least three or four of our Deputies. For example, in the constituency of Roscommon they came within one mile of where Deputy Joan Burke is living, taking away 45 or 46 of her best polling booths. Something similar has happened in the constituencies of Deputy P.J. Reynolds and Deputy Philip Burton. We know what has happened in County Meath, the constituency of Deputy Denis Farrelly: they took part of Meath and put it into Cavan; they took another part of the constituency where he is living and put it into Monaghan, and at the other end they added part of the constituency of Kildare to Meath. As regards my own constituency of Longford-Westmeath, we welcome back the part which was taken from us by the Government in 1960, but we deprecate what they have done in dividing the town of Athlone and transferring 4,000 of the population there, more than 2,000 votes, to bolster up the position of the Minister for Education, Deputy Brian Lenihan.

The Government's gerrymandering tactics will misfire and will boomerang on them. An intelligent electorate has found them out, and while they suffered a massive defeat amounting to more than 234,000 votes in the referendum, it is nothing to what they will suffer in the next general election, come when it may. We are ready and all we want Fianna Fáil to do is name the day. Despite the fact that their Ministers have gerrymandered the constituencies to suit their own purposes, the Irish people love fairplay and justice. They hate injustice and will certainly teach Deputy Boland, the Minister for Local Government, and his Government a lesson when the next election comes.

Comment on this

Listening to Deputy L'Estrange one would imagine that nobody suffered through this rearrangement but the Fine Gael people. It is unfortunate that Deputy L'Estrange and his Party did not support the section of the referendum that would have maintained the existing constituency boundaries. They were completely against this and the result is the situation in which we find ourselves today.

I think I have the greatest grievance of any of the Deputies in this House inasmuch as, taking the area from one end of my constituency to the other, I have a distance of 113 miles to travel, that is, going from Ballydavid on the Dingle Peninsula down to Dursey Island in West Cork. This is equal to the distance from Dingle to Clonmel or from Killorglin, my own town, to Roscrea. This is an intolerable position in which to find oneself. No matter what Deputies on the far side say, we have plenty of grievances on this side of the House. I would, even at this stage, appeal to the Minister to ease this burden that has been imposed on us. Certain sections of my constituency have been taken from me, and if the Minister were trying to gerrymander at all, there are plenty of good territories in the north-east part of South Kerry that could have been dealt with, but the Minister did not do that. Speaking from my own knowledge I can say that our voting potential in South Kerry is no less than it was before the constituency was rearranged.

Something should be done in the future to see that people get the service to which they are entitled. We have already very extended lines in Kerry, and it is difficult to get to the people even once a year. I try to visit all areas at least once and that is not sufficient if a Deputy is to deal with the many problems that arise in his constituency. At some future date all Parties in the House should get together and try to alter this impossible situation which has been brought about as a result of a High Court decision. I am referring to my own constituency, but I am sure there are many others, particularly in the western areas, that are in the same position. The people are entitled to a far better service than we can give them. Some of the people in those western areas are not very well able to put their cases in writing and have to depend on others to do it. I have to get to towns and villages and the various crossroads at least every two months in order to meet the people who are looking for my assistance, and it is an impossible strain for a Deputy to give the service that is needed.

If the Opposition Deputies are honest in their approach to the referendum result, they must face up to the problems that have been created. The proposal was put before the people to adjust the constituencies or at least to bring the tolerance into effect. This is a position which should have been made clear. It is an aftermath of the whole thing that now remains and makes things very difficult. People require greater service today than when I first came to the Dáil which is not many years ago. They seem to demand more; they follow Deputies around to get necessary advice. They are leaning more and more on Deputies. I hope at some future date, not too far away, something will be done to have the constituencies once more adjusted. It should be possible to reach some agreement with all sides of the House to have this brought about. Otherwise, the people cannot get the services they require. We find we have a further 15 miles added to the length of our constituency. This should never have happened. That is the position now and it certainly gives us plenty of work and headaches for the future.

Comment on this

I suppose everything that could be said by both sides has been said on this Bill. Deputy Connor was very frank when he said that not everybody in Fianna Fáil was satisfied with the Bill. The Fianna Fáil people who attempted to apologise for the Bill and give reasons why it was introduced have had their say. People on this side of the House have accused them of ulterior motives but the fact remains, as Deputy Connor said, that this measure has changed constituency boundaries to the detriment of Deputies on either side. In my own constituency of Mayo the gerrymander, as I shall call it, has meant that my end of the constituency has been so changed that I shall have more difficulty in being elected than I had previously. From the Fianna Fáil point of view that may be very sound because I believe Fianna Fáil, and the Minister for Local Government in particular, so designed the two constituencies in Mayo as to ensure as far as possible that they would gain two seats out of three in each constituency.

The Minister carried out this division with that in mind. I am sure he had the advice of his two Ministers in the constituency and I know that from the Fianna Fáil point of view he probably felt it would be better to have the Miniters divided there. They were in the same constituency, the one I have the honour to represent. The Minister for Local Government did not do that in the interests of Fine Gael and possibly could not be expected to do it, but the way in which it was done ensures that another Deputy elected with me has been given more votes than he needs with the intention, of course, of lowering the Fine Gael vote in the other constituency. In fact, it is done to ensure that while a Deputy of my Party in one constituency would have a quota and a half a Deputy in another constituency, deprived of that halfquota might not be elected.

Perhaps that is good practical politics. Some Fianna Fáil speakers have said that if Fine Gael had accepted the referendum measure this would not have occurred. I opposed the measure even though I come from the west and I was accused by Fianna Fáil speakers on every platform of neglecting the west by so doing. It was said that by taking the action I took and making the speeches I made I was depriving the west of representation in Dáil Éireann to which they were entitled. I wanted representation for the west— there is no Deputy of any Party who does not want it—but I feared that the Bill was misleading, fraudulent and dangerous. My reason for saying that is that the Bill enabled any Government that might be in power—perhaps Fianna Fáil had no intention of using the powers they gained through the Bill—to arrange constituencies in such a way that one-sixth above or below the designated number of 20,000 would enable them to put an individual candidate into a seat. That is a power I would not like to give to my own Party or any other.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The issues in regard to the referendum have been disposed of and we cannot go back on the referendum.

Comment on this

I do not want to go outside the rules of order and I bow to the ruling of the Chair, but the referendum and everything connected with it is relevant to this Bill because the Bill is a result of the referendum and the action taken by the people. The fact that the people took certain action and decided not to accept the referendum proposals is responsible for the Bill being before the House, and I would ask for the tolerance of the Chair——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair does not wish to have the discussion widened but does not mind a passing reference to the referendum without elaborating on the issues.

Comment on this

I shall bow to that ruling. The people gave the decision and it is no use now for any Deputy on any side to attempt to deny that the people took such action. They took it in a manner that possibly nobody on any side of the House could have believed possible. They made the decisions so clear by their massive vote against the referendum proposals that never again, I think, in the history of the State will such proposals be put before them.

The Government, and possibly the Minister for Local Government, were proved wrong in this. It has been said that this was "Boland's madness" rather than a decision of the Fianna Fáil Government but whether it was "Boland's madness" that was responsible for this referendum or not, the fact remains that the people spoke out loud and clear. The other night the Minister for External Affairs said it was because the Parties opposite had posed the questions in an untruthful way. He did not say it that way but the implication was that the reason why the majority of the electorate rejected the Bill was that we used propaganda that was not true and which was apparently designed to scare the people. Surely that was a naïve statement from the Minister for External Affairs? Surely he does not believe that our people are so naïve as to accept an argument of that kind? Surely the Fianna Fáil propaganda machine is greater and far more efficient than he would give it credit for? Surely he did not believe that the electorate would accept that kind of argument and that they could be scared and stampeded into taking an action against their beliefs because the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party had decided to use certain propaganda in order to beguile?

I wonder if this man really believes that this is so but whether he believes it or not, this Bill is before us now as a direct result of what the people did in the polling booths. I do not know why the Minister should have taken the action he did or why he should have put the proposals before the people knowing that, in 1959, the people had rejected this idea and, at the same time as they rejected it, they elected one of the greatest figures in the political life of this country as President of Ireland. That illustrious gentleman had come out in favour of a change in the electoral system and yet the people elected him to office but rejected his proposal. Surely any sane man in Fianna Fáil should have seen the red light and should have known that the people would reject both proposals in the referendum of 1968?

Comment on this
Lionel Booth Acting Chairman (Mr. Booth) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is straying from the terms of the Bill before the House. Discussion of the referendum has already been ruled out of order.

Comment on this