Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 110–229 of 229. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 35 of 1968 ›
I listened to the Minister for External Affairs straying very much the other night. However, I will accept your ruling. If a rule is made for Deputies, it should apply also to Ministers. However, I am not going to argue that point and I bow to the ruling of the Chair. There were many other methods of devising constituency boundaries than the one adopted by the Minister for Local Government.
It has been clearly shown in this House by Deputy Patrick Hogan of Fine Gael that there were methods of devising constituency boundaries to give us exactly the same number of Deputies and that, instead of moving 101,000 people from the constituencies where they hitherto had voted, the same result could have been achieved by moving 35,000 people. Senator Garret FitzGerald writing in the Irish Independent, also explained, and had maps to prove it, that this should have been done in a certain way. The charge against the Minister of drawing up constituency boundary lines in order to ensure, in so far as is possible, that Fianna Fáil people would be elected, is well substantiated and the House must realise that this is true.
Many Deputies, including Deputy Connor who is not satisfied with the changes in his constituency, believe that the people they have represented for a considerable period of time will feel a sense of loss. All of us in constituencies that have been carved or dismembered will feel the same sense of loss. Deputy Boland, apparently, did not ask some of his Fianna Fáil people or some of his Fianna Fáil Deputies for their opinions. He just decided arbitrarily to carve the constituencies in a certain way and to let the Deputies and the electors take the consequences.
There would be no need for this Bill if Fianna Fáil had adopted the suggestion that Deputy Connor mentioned a few minutes ago—a conference with the other Parties in the Dáil to try to divide the constituencies in such a way that boundaries, in so far as is possible, would follow county lines and traditional lines and that fair representation was given in relation to rural areas and also, of course, to the urban areas. A means of doing that could have been devised with the consent of all Parties in the Dáil and if Deputy Boland's madness had not driven him to put the proposals before the people he could have introduced an amendment to the Constitution that would have enabled him to disregard the High Court judge's decision of 1961.
Certainly this House could decide to pass a Bill through Dáil Éireanna Bill that would be designed to give fair representation to the west of Ireland and to rural areas without being unfair to the urban areas and to the cities. That was within the competence of Dáil Éireann and if that were not achieved, and if a tolerance Bill, independent of changes in the electoral system, had been proposed in this House, the House would certainly have passed it.
The Minister for Local Government must be taken to task for not doing that and Fianna Fáil may long be sorry for not having advised their Minister. The men at the Party meetings could have said: "We know the rural areas need greater representation; we know that the urban areas are growing and growing and as they grow the danger exists that representation for the west and for all the other rural areas will fall more out of balance." Certainly, the Government could have devised a Bill that would have been passed through the Dáil in order to ensure that such representation was given. However, they did not do that and there is no doubt that the charges made against them of doing it in order to attain more power are true. They did it to ensure that men who had grown stale in power would remain in power for a longer period without having to fight for their constituencies.
The people, as I said, rejected the idea but certainly there must be people in Fianna Fáil now who are sorry that they did not attempt to bring this idea before the Minister and before the Government. They may be very sorry as time goes on because I believe that at the next election the people will remember that the Fianna Fáil Government played politics when there was an economic situation building up in this country that could become dangerous, which has been shown by the mini-Budget as something on which the Government should take drastic and immediate action. It was a matter of fiddling while Rome burned. It was a matter of fiddling with a referendum when the economic situation was deteriorating from day to day. I do not talk about a tug-of-war in the Fianna Fáil Party. That has nothing to do with the House and nothing to do with the country but I do say this. They will stand before the bar of judgement at the next election and the people will decide whether the Party that fiddled while the economic situation was deteriorating are entitled to come back as the Government in the future.
The people will vote massively against the Fianna Fáil Party at the next election and it will be their just due because any Party, Sir, that so miscalculated public opinion in this country, any Party that was so far off the pulse of public opinion, certainly does not deserve the support of the electorate and are not competent to rule the country in the interests of all the people.
Comment on this
The Deputy is straying back to the referendum again.
Comment on this
I thank you, Sir. Possibly you are being lenient with me or possibly I am not as familiar with the rules of procedure as others but I crave your indulgence in this case.
Comment on this
The Minister for External Affairs the other night spoke about members of the Fine Gael Party, the Leader of Fine Gael and almost a majority of Fine Gael being in favour of the single seat. Others said that at the Fine Gael Party meeting there definitely was a very narrow margin between the people who wanted to hold PR and those who wanted the single seat. I want to deny that with all the vehemence I can because I was present at the Party meeting and I can assure the House that the majority for retaining PR was a very strong one. That is a certainty. The Minister smiles. Possibly he thinks that does not matter. Perhaps it does not matter but I just mention it to refute the allegations made across the House. It is wrong. Whether it was right or wrong does not matter now because the people have spoken. Perhaps, we could quote what the illustrious man in the Park said about it years ago and, perhaps, we could quote what Deputy James Dillon said about it years ago but this has no bearing on the situation now. The people will say to themselves that the Fianna Fáil Party had support for a long time and that they are not capable of doing a job in the way in which they should do it. I think the electorate will be massively against them at the next election because of the mistakes they made.
Comment on this
Like most other people, I appreciate the onerous task facing the Minister for Local Government. No county has suffered as badly as my constituency in the re-arrangement of the constituencies. In County Clare we have a situation in which some 14,000 of the population have been taken out of the county and put in with Galway, forming a new constituency. This is probably one of the most historic constituencies in Ireland and Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and all political Parties deplore what has happened here but at least we appreciate that something like this was inevitable in view of the result of the vote on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill.
In Clare a few weeks ago, before the referendum, Opposition members of the county council called a special meeting to advise people to vote against the Third Amendment and the other day— last Monday—another special meeting was called to protest against the rearrangements of the constituencies. Anyway, the people appreciate that something like this was inevitable. At least it can be said that transferring 14,000 people out of the county is better than the transfer of a small number, such as 6,000 or 7,000. In this 14,000 of the population there are close on 10,000 voters who are on the electoral list and this gives an opportunity to the people of this area to enter in the next election a Clare man as one of their TDs.
I am sure they will see it this way and they will go about doing that when the time comes. We appreciate that the Minister when coming to Clare did not depart from the pattern which he followed for the rest of Ireland, that is, creating three-seat constituencies which, at least, are smaller and more manageable than some of the four-seaters now in existence. It means that a TD has far less ground to cover in order to look after the interests of his constituents. Perhaps, three seats will do better in the future. It is hard for people to knuckle down to this and be any way joyous about it. The first reaction of everyone was that of disappointment. As I have said, we appreciate that we are no worse off than a county like Leitrim. This gives us an opportunity to elect a Clare man and be represented by a Clare man in that part of the constituency.
We have a growing population in County Clare and after the next census, perhaps, we will have the required population to enable us to revert to the four-seat constituency we had. We look forward to the day when we will have all the electors in the county again united as one constituency, that is, the constituency of Clare.
Comment on this
I think the Government have wasted a lot of time and taxpayers' money during the past 12 months. It might have been necessary to revise the constituencies but it is quite clear that the real purpose of the Bill is to preserve the interests of the Government. Were it not for the mass emigration from the west we could have, at least, four to six more seats. This is entirely due to the mismanagement of the Government in not providing jobs for the people. In my constituency alone they have taken from me 48 polling booths, giving to Clare-Galway 1,975 of a population and 7,938 from Roscommon to East Galway—a total of 9,913. The Minister should leave County Roscommon unmolested. It has a population of 56,228 and, with 4,424 from Athlone West Urban, we have 60,652 of a population. This would give us a three-seat constituency and a little to spare. Of course, it is quite obvious why we got the Athlone West Urban: it is to consolidate the position of the Minister for Education, Deputy Brian Lenihan. I might add that, in taking away all along the Suck there was taken with it also the drainage of the Suck which was one of the Minister's main problems in the constituency and which had been promised to the constituents in the 1964 by-election. This is not a revision: it is a butchering of the areas.
Comment on this
I shall deal with the individual constituencies only to the absolute minimum. I should like to speak about constituencies in general rather than about constituencies in particular. I may be able to do this as a Dublin Deputy better than people from rural Ireland where certain county boundaries had to be breached. The last speaker has claimed that the main purpose of this Bill is to protect the interest of the Government. I say that this cannot be shown to be true to any extent in the city or county of Dublin, including Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown.
In the last general election, in the constituencies as they now exist, Fianna Fáil won two seats out of three in Dublin South East; three seats out of five in Dublin South West; Central; three seats out of five in Dublin County; one seat out of three in Dublin North West; two seats out of four in Dublin North Central and failed, after a very long count, by a margin of a total of four votes, to secure the majority of seats in Dublin North East.
My objection to this Bill, if I have any, is that, from the time I entered politics in 1956 and when we first succeeded in securing three seats in Dublin South West in 1957 we felt we had achieved something because it was the first time since the establishment of that constituency that Fianna Fáil secured a majority of the seats. In the subsequent by-election we lost the additional seat by a little over 50 votes and we did not regain it in the next general election but we did regain it in the last one—and comfortably, if I may say so. I believe the main reason the Fianna Fáil voluntary organisation was able to bring about this situation in Dublin was that most of the constituencies had an odd number of seats and where you have one Deputy out of three or two Deputies out of five, then everybody with the slightest interest in Fianna Fáil will come out to try to help to achieve a majority of the seats. When you have an even number of seats, there is apt to be complacency—and I mean this on all sides, including the Fianna Fáil Party. A lot of them will say: "Four seats: Fianna Fáil will probably get two out of four." If you add the figures I have given for Dublin it will be seen, by simple mathematics, that Fianna Fáil will not only be able to hold its present position in Dublin city, but will probably end up maybe a seat less—that is, if these straightforward mathematics work out. This does not always happen. We know you cannot have straightforward mathematics. As a Fine Gael speaker will say, the Government Party was guilty of gross miscalculation in putting the referendum issue to the people but I would point out that for a whole week before the end of that campaign, nobody in the Fine Gael Party would offer better than even money and, therefore, they also were guilty of miscalculation on that particular issue.
I have no doubt at all that even the young people coming up today have been told by their fathers and mothers of the time of the recession of 1956 and 1957 when their fathers lost their employment. That was the time when people who had been in jobs for 18, 20 and 30 years found themselves out on the dole. We found families breaking up. We had no housing shortage, certainly, because we had nobody to take the houses, and there was not the price of a bag of cement in the coffers when Fianna Fáil came back. Fianna Fáil offers job security.
Comment on this
We had to restore their jobs for them after their experience of two disastrous Coalition Government here. One has only to drive around the outskirts of Dublin now to see the factories and alongside them the houses erected for the people whereas the Coalition Government could not get people for the houses which were lying empty.
Comment on this
We have factories alongside the houses. We are expanding urban Dublin so fast that I think everybody is now aware of the grave traffic crisis in Dublin city—because this is Fianna Fáil policy. In Dublin, Fianna Fáil policy will be accepted by the people so long as they know they have a pay packet on every Friday night and that their job is secure; so long as they know they will get reasonable rises in their wages and reasonable increases in their living standards as time goes on. This is what Fianna Fáil have been giving and now offer.
With regard to the measures that had to be taken recently, in good anticipation of the world situation, the ordinary worker in Dublin is secure in his employment and is better off now than he was in 1957.
Comment on this
Would Deputy Lemass relate his remarks to the measure which is before the House?
Comment on this
If we had a situation whereby we had three-seat and five-seat constituencies in Dublin I promise the Minister for Local Government and the Taoiseach that the people will give them a majority of the seats in the Dáil in Dublin.
Comment on this
You will find out whether or not they are different.
Comment on this
Will the Chair allow me to answer that remark? In three and five-seat constituencies in Dublin, we elected only one councillor but three TDs in the following general election. This happened after the second last local election.
Comment on this
Job security has nothing to do with the county council. Certain international problems have adequately been dealt with by the Government. I imagine this Bill has been considered on more than one occasion by the Government before it was eventually produced. I do not believe the Government will lightly amend the recommendations put before the House. Unfortunately, I have not all the reports with me that I would like to have now because I found that the speeches were shorter this evening than usual, which is a good thing: sometimes we should have a rule here, as they have in the local authorities, about ten-minute and 15-minute speeches. Deputy Dockrell opened the debate this morning and concluded it last week. He referred to old Dublin and to the fact that the constituency he represented for so long had been changed beyond recognition and that all south Dublin, where the Dockrell name and family have been established for so long, had been reduced in size. He recollected how this constituency used to extend almost from the Pigeon House right up to the county boundary. He asked that the constituency be extended. I support that request. I would prefer to see the constituency a five-seat constituency, as it was before, and my own constituency made, if necessary, into a three-seat constituency.
I should like to refer now to Deputy Briscoe, as reported in tonight's Evening Herald, page 8; he said:
A lot of the debate was sheer hypocrisy and the charge of gerrymandering did not stand up to examination. He believed that three-seat constituencies were better because they would make it possible for people to have closer contact with their TDs.
I support this general view of Deputy Briscoe. At the moment it would appear that Deputy Briscoe and myself are likely to contest the same constituency. I would prefer to see this constituency either reduced to three seats or increased to five seats because in a four-seat constituency I believe the ordinary run of the people will not show the great enthusiasm I have seen them showing over the years. From what I read of Deputy Maurice Dockrell's speech last week and Deputy Briscoe's tonight, I think I am in line with both of them and I would ask the Minister to examine this question of the even number seat constituencies, particularly in South Dublin. I cannot speak so well for North Dublin because we are sometimes described as provinces apart. As the Bill stands, it is more than likely I will seek to represent Dublin South Central. I shall be sorry to lose the people of Drimnagh who gave me such very valuable support in the last general election, but I will be very glad to get back the people in Rathfarnham whom I represented when I was first elected.
I understand that it has been suggested to Deputy Maurice Dockrell that he should leave the old South Central constituency and contest Dublin South-West. I should like to warn him that I suspect this suggestion has come from Deputy Richie Ryan, who is anxious to protect himself and anxious to prevent my very good friend from Fine Gael, the former Deputy Jim O'Keeffe, and Councillor Maurice O'Connell from securing election to this House. He is afraid he may be asked to contest that area which elected him in third place in the second last local authority election. I should like to remind Deputy Richie Ryan that he barely took the last seat in what is now Dublin South-Central, the area he has intimated he intends to contest in future elections.
I should like to go on record that I believe the people of Dublin will stand firmly behind Fianna Fáil in a general election.
Comment on this
I believe that we should give them an opportunity of electing a clear majority of fianna Fáil TDs in Dublin city because that is the only way they will know they will have a job to go to next week, and that that job will be secure; that is the only way they will know that there will be jobs for their children, when they grow up, and free education for them while they are children. I am certain the people of Dublin will stand behind Fianna Fáil and give them a majority of the seats, if this Bill gives them the opportunity of doing so.
Comment on this
One almost feels there is a threat in what Deputy Lemass has just said: if the people are not prepared to accept Fianna Fáil they will be out of their jobs in the morning.
Comment on this
As far as the people are concerned, it would be better if the Deputy went to the moon.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass is the son of another Deputy in this House who was going to lead the people into a land flowing with milk and honey, with 100,000 more jobs.
Comment on this
Let the Deputy contain himself for a moment. Does he disagree with the figures issued by the Department, figures which prove beyond all doubt that there are 1,000 fewer people in employment today than there were this time last year?
Comment on this
It arises in so far as there are over 1,000 fewer people employed here today and they will not have votes because they are over in Coventry.
Comment on this
That is so but, with respect, before you came in, we had to listen to Deputy Lemass talking about the factories and the pay packets and the number of people who are in employment but who would be out of employment in certain eventualities. There was a threat of unemployment. I am just wondering are the Taca men wagging their fingers at the people. I represent a constituency that has not been affected by this proposed revision but, if it suited Fianna Fáil, they would have carved up my constituency too. It suits them as it is because it is a three-seat constituency. That is why Fianna Fáil did not get moving in that particular area. I would be adopting an attitude of "I'm all right, Jack" if I were not to comment, however briefly, on this revision. We had a Deputy from Clare a few moments ago describing the historic county of Clare. I do not know what he meant. Maybe I have an idea. The historic county of Clare was being cut up. He tried to suppress his feelings but, of course, he had been brainwashed, as a great many members of the Party are when they come in here, and he must toe the line like all the rest.
Comment on this
My brains are better than that. It could not be done by Fianna Fáil, and neither would I be brow-beaten by them. I have been in this House for 14½ years in spite of Fianna Fáil. This Bill is a monument to Fianna Fáil, to the great "Fianna Failure." They were to save the west. The population of the west has now been depleted and the people are "gone west". If we had issued a postal ballot paper to the men from the west who are in Coventry and Birmingham and spread all over the world due to Fianna Fáil failure, or "Fianna Failure" as they are known, Fianna Fáil would have got the greatest mauling they ever got in their lifetime from those people.
The Minister seems to be licking his wounds after the great mauling he got in the referendum. As I see it, this is a savage attack by the Minister on the people for not having accepted Fianna Fáil policy. With this carving up I can see the Minister in no other role than that of Jack the Ripper. He gets his knife out and stabs here and there to get his own back on the people. Fianna Fáil seem to be very complacent. They seem to think the people are fools, but they forget there is a voters' list. They may fool the old people, but they will not fool the youth. In the future they are likely to get the mauling they deserve.
Deputy Lemass said a few minutes ago that while he agreed with the Bill he had some reservations. He said he would like the Minister to do this and look at that. Can they not do their dirty washing in their Party room without letting it overflow in here? It shows that there is no unanimity in the Party. Let us hope that when it comes to casting his vote for or against this Bill he will take the right side.
I said I would be brief. Fianna Fáil are on the way down, and they are going faster than they think. The Taca men are deserting them like rats deserting a sinking ship.
Comment on this
That has absolutely nothing to do with the Bill. We are discussing the revision of the constituencies.
Comment on this
There is a lot of poison out and it is not rat poison. I see them deserting all over the country. Those are the votes that will desert Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
When it comes to the day of reckoning what the Parliamentary Secretary is saying will be on the record and he may have his nose rubbed in it. Early on at the referendum count there was a lovely aroma of cigars.
Comment on this
In the evening you could not smell even a Woodbine. The Taca men had deserted when they saw how the count was going. The Minister is back. As I said he is licking his wounds. This patchwork quilt Bill is a monument to "Fianna Failure". The people had to leave the west due to a lack of employment which Deputy Lemass said was available. His father said he would provide 100,000 new jobs. The jobs are in England. If those men had a postal vote we know the reply Fianna Fáil would have got from them.
Comment on this
——hardly mentioned the Bill before the House tonight. Any electoral Bill is bound to be criticised by the Opposition and by some of the Government Party, because to get a perfect Bill the Minister's name would have to be Solomon and not Boland. I think this is a fair effort to give us an electoral pattern so that the people's voice will be heard in a truly representative way.
It is galling to hear Deputies speaking of gerrymandering. It is impossible to gerrymander in a country like ours. We have not got a ghetto pattern. This is not Little Rock or Derry. We have not got all the Fianna Fáil supporters living in one area and the Fine Gael and Labour supporters living in others. All our skins are white. I am not boasting when I say that but just making the point.
During the referendum debate it was pointed out by Opposition speakers that you cannot gerrymander under the PR system which they wanted to keep. The Minister had a difficult task. He has not pleased everyone but what he has done shows that we are truly a democracy. In the space of a few months the electoral system has been reviewed by the people and by the Oireachtas. This shows the desire of the Government Party to ensure that one basic rule of democracy, that is, a person's right to vote, will be preserved. The people have spoken on the system they want, and we will now try to make the best of it. It has been said that many areas were butchered or charged to suit the Minister or someone else. That is quite absurd. You cannot do that in a society like ours. I can speak for the city only. In the city there is not a Fianna Fáil area, a Labour area or a Fine Gael area.
Comment on this
There are places in which at one time there was a Fine Gael majority and others in which there was a Fianna Fáil majority.
Comment on this
I will not interrupt the Deputy's pipe dream. He can go on saying that. If he says it often enough he will believe it is true, but the election will bring him back to earth with a great shock.
I have one fault to find with this Bill. I am speaking now not as a politician but purely as a native of this city. I wish the Minister had kept to the old ward boundaries as far as possible. The wards system in this city dates back for many hundreds of years. We claim that in the time of Grattan's Parliament those wards were there. The whole structure of society has changed since then but the fundamentals have not changed. The people of this city when exercising their franchise want to do so in their local areas so far as possible.
If you mention the wards—the Royal Exchange wards, the Mansion House ward, Pembroke East and Pembroke West—you might say that the very names are redolent of the old regime. Maybe they are, but at the same time they are the basis of our electoral system in the city. We should by all means preserve these wards. It will not always be possible for the Minister to do so. I know he tries hard, but perhaps he could try harder to keep these wards intact because the city, like the rural part of the country, has certain traditions. You have a class of people who hold certain broad political views which they like to express. The city goes back to the Norman invasion. These city people have a wonderful sense of independence. Deputy Dockrell of Fine Gael has praised the spirit of the people and I do the same. Throughout the history of the country they have fought for this independence and they have not been broken down by the enemy. Despite the cutting off of the wards they will come forward and vote as they think best, always expressing their consideration for the country as a whole and for the city in particular.
I do not think there is any attempt to gerrymander. We know it is not true. It is impossible to gerrymander the constituencies. If certain Deputies on the Opposition side are hit, let them remember some of us on this side will also be hit. It is something which is very hard to avoid. To suggest gerrymandering is to damage the national image because it is not true that it has been done. I do not think it can be done. During the remaining Stages the Bill should be examined again. I would be all in favour of being fair to any Opposition Deputy who could prove conclusively that he is, in fact, being unduly injured by the new changes. If we are going to preserve democracy in this country in face of the attacks made on it, not only here but also in Europe generally, not only must an electoral Bill be fair but the changes must appear to the people to be fair. We can only do this by having a Bill brought in here after careful consideration and put to the House saying: "This is our honest effort to make the best of the changes which we must make". I am quite convinced that the Minister has made an honest and genuine effort not to please the Fianna Fáil Party, the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party Deputies but to give the best possible set-up in the electoral areas so that the people can express their will in a very democratic way and give us a good Parliament.
Comment on this
I am trying not to be partisan. I am thinking not only of my own Party or myself in this matter, but I am trying to think of the Oireachtas. Somebody said that corruption does harm to governments. It harms the country as a whole. We see it happening in Europe, which is not very far away. We are lucky in so far as we have had in the periods since the State was founded a democratic Government. At times this was a very good Fianna Fáil Government and at times we had another Government, but to suggest gerrymandering is to damage this image. Some people would believe it. It is our duty here to give the people an opportunity to elect a representative Parliament. I believe in the integrity and the intelligence of the people doing this. The issues should not be clouded by unfounded suggestions that the Minister has done something wrong. No matter what Minister sat where the present Minister sits tonight somebody would criticise him because they were hurt by the proposals in the Bill or because they did not get the areas they wanted. They say that the people get the Government they deserve, and I suppose that an area gets the Deputy it deserves. Unless there are people who will examine the claims of every person putting himself forward for election— and people do this—they will not be sure of getting the best people to form the best Government. I have no doubt that the Fianna Fáil Party will occupy these benches after the next election but I do not think that even this is the most important thing. The most important thing is that the people should have chosen the Government whom they think is best fitted to serve. Until we get away from those charges of gerrymandering and corruption we will not improve the image of this House. It would be very easy to make countercharges to the Opposition charges about Taca. I should love to meet a Taca man.
Comment on this
I am not discussing Taca. Most Opposition Deputies feel that unless Taca is mentioned there is something wrong with the debate.
Comment on this
In conclusion, I would like to make an earnest appeal to the Opposition to judge this Bill on its merits and to leave aside extraneous issues. There is plenty of time during the sessions here to debate the issues which we have heard discussed, like those of unemployment, emigration, and Taca. There is an obligation on the Government to bring in this Bill.
One point Deputy Coogan made was that the Fianna Fáil Party had to wash their dirty linen here. There is a duty on the Minister and on the Cabinet to bring in this Bill here. We in the Fianna Fáil Party make our views known when we are trying to be honest and criticise where criticism is necessary, and then we are accused of falling out. We are united behind our Leader, Deputy Jack Lynch, and in regard to this Bill, the people will show their confidence in the Party and will return them in the new electoral areas which Deputy Boland, the Minister for Local Government, has given to us in a fair and honest attempt to meet the situation which confronts him.
Comment on this
A Cheann Comhairle, so far as my own constituency of Limerick East is concerned, I have not heard any complaints whatever about the Bill. The change there is very slight and is an obvious one. Nobody could talk of gerrymandering. It is a small corner of east Limerick which jutted into west Limerick that has been taken out and put into west Limerick. There is no complaint there. The same thing applies to the majority of counties. A couple of counties have had to be divided up in a way that one would prefer to have avoided, in particular Leitrim, but my mind goes back to the beginning of the referendum campaign, when the Minister for Finance went down to a public meeting in Leitrim and told the people assembled there that if the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill were not passed Leitrim probably would have to be divided by three, that it would not form a constituency of its own, that it would have to go in with others. He strongly advised the people of Leitrim, therefore, that if they wanted to avoid that situation they might support the Government's proposals in the referendum. The same advice was given in other counties and cities which were threatened with being divided up. That advice was not followed and, as a result, a certain amount of dividing up has had to go on. It has been carried out in much the same way as the Government forecast it would have to be carried out.
What strikes me as being utterly hypocritical is that the Fine Gael and Labour Parties come in here whining and complaining about the Minister for Local Government butchering the constituencies when the real people to blame are the Fine Gael and Labour Parties because, during a period of months they went up and down and around and about this country persuading the electorate to vote "No" on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. They told the people there was no harm in the breaching of county boundaries, that it was better to do that than to accept the Bill.
They got what they asked for and, having got that, having forced the Minister for Local Government into the position of having to divide counties— he had first of all told the people that they would be faced with this—Fine Gael and Labour come back and complain and whine because the Minister has to do it. They are the people who are to blame, and it is complete hypocrisy on their part that they should attack the Minister and accuse him of all sorts of low tactics and of vindictiveness. The Minister has carried out what he told the people before the referendum he would have to carry out if the proposals in the referendum were not accepted. These proposals were not accepted because of the opposition put up to them by Fine Gael and Labour. Therefore, it is obvious that Fine Gael and Labour must take the blame for the unfortunate situation that now threatens Leitrim, Clare and other areas where people are being cut off from the main body of the people in their own counties.
We in Fianna Fáil have nothing to be ashamed of in this Bill. The Minister had an unpleasant duty to perform and he did it with the absolute minimum of butchering and carving up. If he had wanted to be vindictive, there is nothing to stop him carving up every county and forming constituencies bearing no relation to county boundaries. He did it to the minimum extent possible and any fairminded person will agree that he did it without fear or favour.
Though some Fine Gael Members and Labour Members may not be suited by it, an equal number of Fianna Fáil Members are not suited by it. Deputy L'Estrange tonight repeatedly made the allegation that this Bill was discussed at Fianna Fáil Party meetings before it was finally decided. Deputy Briscoe pointed out that that was not so. It was not discussed before it was published. The first and only time it was discussed at a Fianna Fáil Party meeting was after the Bill had been circulated to Deputies.
It is perhaps typical of the hypocritical Fine Gael approach that, having caused this situation, they now turn around and say Fianna Fáil are trying to use it to their own advantage. This situation was caused by Fine Gael and Labour, not by the Minister for Local Government who is now being accused of so many low tactics. The Minister has done a difficult job very well and, apart from this hypocritical whining from Fine Gael and Labour Deputies, no serious fault has been found with the Bill among the general public.
Comment on this
First, let me say I want to pay a special tribute to the Minister for the manner in which he has carried out the difficult task of dividing up the constituencies, particularly for the manner in which he has tried to preserve county boundaries. In all the Minister's speeches, here and throughout the country during the referendum campaign, at all times he tried to explain to the people that he wished to preserve county boundaries. What amazes me is the weeping and whining of the Opposition, having received exactly what they asked for during the referendum. Here in the House they cry bitter tears because the Bill is before them. They say it involves gerrymandering.
I have no doubt Members of the Opposition are peeved by the division of some constituencies. They fear that in that division they may be isolated, whereas they would like to see themselves in a position where their only opposition would be perhaps a local councillor or some unknown outsider. The reason they are peeved is that they may have to face a Fianna Fáil Deputy or they may find themselves facing each other.
In regard to my own constituency of County Dublin I am peeved in many ways, particularly because I lose an area which was very good to me —Tallaght, Rathfarnham, Dundrum, Bohernabreena, Newcastle, Saggart and other districts. Deputy P.J. Burke has lost a similar area. Though we are peeved, we realise at the same time that this was necessary. The referendum was held, the people did not accept the proposals put to them, and therefore a division of constituencies had to take place.
The situation in County Dublin has caused annoyance to Opposition Deputies, particularly to Deputy Clinton. I know the reason why. It is because Deputy Clinton will now be in a constituency to be contested by the Minister for Local Government. It is a constituency in which Deputy Clinton has not done any work, relatively speaking. He has never tried to help the people there as Fianna Fáil Deputies have done. Deputy Clinton made specific references to me, to Deputy Burke and to the Minister. He said the Minister is aggrieved, that he wants to get rid of Deputy Burke because at all times Deputy Burke has topped the poll. Deputy Clinton can say things like that but there is no truth in them. The Minister has always worked solely for the good of the people whom he has represented as a member of Fianna Fáil. He is not particularly worried whether he tops the poll or not. It might be well to remind Deputy Clinton, who is so measly minded as to make reference to people in their absence—I have on two occasions been listening to the debate in the Whip's Office when Deputy Clinton made reference to me and I say this in his absence but his colleagues will probably convey it to him—that Deputy Clinton was the last man elected in the five-seat constituency of County Dublin at the last election. Deputy Clinton was elected without reaching the quota and he was an elected representative before the last election. I came into the field completely unknown to the people and I was elected prior to Deputy Clinton, and I reached the quota. Deputy Clinton should bear this in mind when he says that the Minister is trying to safeguard me. I challenge Deputy Clinton here and now to come out and to defend his seat in North County Dublin with me and we will see how he gets on. I know well he would not do it. I know well the work on which he is engaged is for a small sector of the community who are arrogant at all times against the Fianna Fáil Party and who have displayed it in many ways not alone by marches and other political demonstrations. Deputy Clinton has been assisting these people but he will see that this is not a true reflection of the people of County Dublin.
I want to say that in County Dublin in general the Minister did what I would term a reasonably good job. As I have said, I am aggrieved at losing areas which were particularly good to me at the last election but I am convinced that the Fianna Fáil Members have worked sufficiently hard to ensure their own re-election. I am sure the people of County Dublin received good enough representation from the Fianna Fáil Party and the Government to ensure that the Fianna Fáil Members are returned to office. I cannot speak for the Opposition Members because seldom was the Fine Gael Member ever seen doing anything constructive in the area. As for the Labour Member he has concentrated on the area of Ballyfermot but this concentration seems to be wilting away because Fianna Fáil has a Deputy who has worked hard in the area, who has got down to business and who is now changing the erroneous ideas given to the people of Ballyfermot by the Labour Deputy.
I compliment the Minister on the manner in which he divided the constituencies. I compliment him on the manner in which he received allegations made by the Opposition Deputies and I have no doubt that he in his reply will deal with those people.
Comment on this
Prior to the referendum we had a number of articles appearing in certain daily newspapers, articles written by a Fine Gael Senator, and in regard to Leitrim the suggestion was that Donegal should be a five-seat constituency and an area of Donegal put into Leitrim. This was supposed to solve the problems which might arise in relation to any forthcoming legislation on the revision of the constituencies.
During the referendum campaign in Donegal this suggestion was backed up by, above all people, a Donegal Deputy, also of the Fine Gael Party. He said that any thinking voter in Donegal would vote against the referendum proposal and would agree with the sensible suggestion that Donegal should be a five-seat constituency and that the balance of 8,000 or 9,000 Donegal people could be put in with County Leitrim. This is on the record of this House because he repeated it here.
Now, if there is such an outcry by Fine Gael and by Labour against the crossing of county boundaries, why is it that they see nothing wrong with this suggestion by a Fine Gael economist who is used to dealing in figures, whose business it is to deal in figures —and facts I hope, too—and a Fine Gael Deputy? But the Minister, who is tied to a 20,000 figure of population per Deputy, is criticised. It has been called gerrymandering but the suggestion put forward in respect of Leitrim and Donegal by two prominent Fine Gael people has not been branded as gerrymandering. It is very difficult to understand the mentality of people who, on the one hand, advocate a situation like this themselves and who, when somebody else does the very same thing, describe it as gerrymandering. We in Donegal would object as violently to having some Donegal people going into a Leitrim constituency as Leitrim is now objecting to having their people go into a Donegal constituency. It is as simple as that.
The other problem which has arisen for Leitrim is that they find themselves as a Sligo-Leitrim constituency. You must remember that there is more than one two-county constituency in the Schedule of this Bill. You have Sligo-Leitrim, South West Donegal-Leitrim, Roscommon-Leitrim and Clare-Gal-way. There are many others. All of these problems arise because the Minister was tied within certain limits, but the problem admittedly becomes more acute in a county with a population of over 50,000 people. The county has just enough population for two Deputies. Therefore, had there been a constituency of Leitrim it would have not alone taken in that part of Donegal suggested by Fine Gael, but parts of other counties as well. So that there, again, there would be wholesale breaches of county boundaries. As far as Donegal beis concerned—I speak of Donegal because I know the situation there—one must start at Malin Head. In order to get the required number one cannot go anywhere else. I think the Minister—I did not discuss this with him before the Bill was circulated—has done a reasonable job here. Here you have a county which has kept the setup which it had apart from the taking in of a certain portion of the Leitrim constituency. If all the Members of this House were in the Minister's position and were asked to do the same job and 143 blueprints were superimposed on one another it certainly would be a jigsaw puzzle.
If we were given a pencil to do as we wished I do not believe that there are two Deputies in this House who would come up with the same blueprint. Accordingly, when a person comes up with a blueprint for all of us it is only logical to assume that all of us can disagree on it. It would be impossible to provide one which would satisfy all Deputies and all Parties and this one does not do so. Before we saw it we did not expect it would.
Comment on this
Deputy Noel Lemass spoke loudly in praise of the Fianna Fáil policy in recent years which has resulted in the fact that Dublin now gains an increased representation. Under the proposals in this Bill the number of Deputies in Dublin will be increased by four. He attributed this increase to the success of the Fianna Fáil economic policy in recent years but Deputy Noel Lemass very cleverly avoided any reference to another aspect of this Bill.
The explanatory memorandum circulated with the Bill says: "The purpose of this Bill is to revise Dáil constituencies in the light of the 1966 Census returns". Deputy Noel Lemass dealt with one aspect of this. However, there is another aspect of it which to my mind shows the most significant and the most tragic effect of the Bill. After 40 years of native Government we have now a situation in which the west of Ireland is losing three Dáil representatives. When one looks at the census returns for 1966 one finds that in the Province of Connaught between the years 1926 and 1966, a period of 40 years, the population of Connaught fell by 150,957. Between the years 1956 and 1966 the population of the Province of Connaught fell by 44,271 people. The fact that the Bill is necessary to reduce the number of Deputies in the west of Ireland by three is a terrible indictment of the economic policies pursued by the Government, particularly the disastrous policies enshrined in the First and Second Programmes for Economic Expansion.
Comment on this
The decline in the west has gone so far now that County Leitrim has been written off the political map. It has been gerrymandered and butchered into three different sections. The Minister stated, and many Fianna Fáil spokesmen reiterated this during the referendum campaign, that it was desirable as far as possible to avoid having to breach county boundaries. Therefore, there is no reason why it was not possible to avoid doing this in the Bill.
As far as I am aware it was possible to make Donegal a five-seat constituency. Deputy Barrett from Clare mentioned that 14,000 people from Clare were going into the Clare-Galway constituency. He said this was a good thing because it would enable those 14,000 people to elect a Clare man to represent them in Dáil Éireann. I think I know the area it is proposed to transfer to Galway and if I know those 14,000 people I believe they would prefer to elect a Clare man to represent the constituency of Clare. It would have been much more desirable—and I am sure those 14,000 people would have preferred it—to have a Deputy returned for the constituency of Clare rather than for the constituency of Clare-Galway.
Fianna Fáil spokesmen say, and harp on this, that because Fine Gael and Labour succeeded to a remarkable degree in defending proportional representation during the recent referendum, we are now responsible for this measure. This Bill, as I have pointed out, and I think this is the most significant thing about it, is necessary because of the fact—I am sure the people of Ireland are now well aware of it—that Fianna Fáil failed to a remarkable degree to implement a realistic policy to retain the people in rural Ireland. In addition to that, faced with the fact that Fine Gael and Labour succeeded in retaining the system of proportional representation, the Government and particularly the Minister for Local Government, were then faced with having to revise the constituencies.
There is no doubt whatsoever that this Bill has been very cleverly designed with a view to ensuring as far as possible that the present Fianna Fáil Deputies would in so far as the Government can ensure it be returned after the next election. There is no justification whatsoever for the new constituency in Cork which stretches from Charleville right down to the coast. It is a long, narrow constituency, 90 miles long and there is no justification whatsoever for that division.
Comment on this
As my colleague, Deputy O'Malley from Limerick, said, there is only a very minor adjustment between east and west Limerick. I suppose I am one of the Deputies who are least affected in so far as our political fortune is concerned. The revision of the constituencies does not affect me at all and, therefore, I am trying to give as objective a view as possible on this whole thing.
The position then in regard to the west of Ireland, as many of my colleagues from the west who have spoken have said, is that they have lost three seats. I do not know whether one can go so far as to say, as some of my colleagues have said, but there are certainly grounds for saying, that this Bill is revenge on the people for having voted so overwhelmingly in the recent referendum for the retention of the system of proportional representation. As a Deputy who has been keenly interested for a long number of years in the welfare of the people of rural Ireland, as one who had the privilege of serving under the great apostle of rural Ireland, the late Canon Hayes, in the organisation he founded, Muintir na Tíre, I deplore the fact that we have now reached the stage where one western county is being wiped off the political map. I am confident that the people in the west of Ireland, when they will get the opportunity at the next general election, will vote in a very striking manner, just as they did in the referendum. They will express their opinion of the failure of Fianna Fáil to implement a proper economic policy and their votes will reflect their resentment of this attempt to gerrymander and butcher the western province.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the Opposition Parties are trying to defend an impossible position. The sole purpose of the recent referendum and the putting before the people of the Third Amendment was to avoid bringing this measure before the House. It was to avoid having to deprive the western seaboard of Deputies and transferring them to Dublin. We find the very Deputies who so confused the issue that the people who were most affected voted as they advised, that is, "No", coming into the House and trying to blame Fianna Fáil for doing what is absolutely necessary under the judgment of Mr. Justice Budd given in 1961. The Minister has no alternative. The Government have no alternative. They must carve up the constituencies. There is no tolerance that is worth while. The Minister is hamstrung.
It is colossal nerve for people to come in here and shed crocodile tears for a position for which they are mainly responsible. They themselves are responsible mainly for the position in which we find ourselves today. It is a sad position. It will be sadder still in future when there will be fewer Deputies representing the west. The last speaker spoke about the depopulation of the west. I am a southerner. In every country in the world people are leaving the land, leaving agriculture, for cities and industrial employment—I suppose on account of the better conditions there and because the people are now better educated.
We had here a Deputy from Cork city who has spent the last six or seven years in public and in private and in this House bemoaning the fact that three districts—Ballyclough, Blackrock and Douglas—were taken from his constituency and put into the city of Cork and for that reason he is no longer heading the poll and that it has been to the great detriment and handicap of his Party. Now that they are being given back to him and the city is united again, he came into the House last week and, although he could not criticise the fact that they were given back, he made slighting references as to what the Minister was going to do and what he had up his sleeve when putting these portions back into the city of Cork. Is it possible to please them? Of course, it is not. That is one of the benefits of being in Opposition. You can have it both ways. You can tell the people to vote "No" and then you can cry crocodile tears because the consequence of voting "No" is to deprive them of their representatives in Dáil Éireann. I agree with the Deputy who said that it would be impossible to get two men even of the same Party to draw up constituencies that would suit everybody. In fact, if Solomon himself were to return he could hardly please every Deputy in drawing up constituencies.
I think the Minister has done a fair job. Nothing has been pinpointed against him in regard to what he has done. Personally, although far away from the county, I am sorry that Leitrim has gone as a political entity but we know where the blame is and it is not on the Fianna Fáil side. I am perfectly certain of that. I am sorry because I am afraid, if this is to continue, we will see other counties going off the political map in the future, all because the people will never get another chance of voting for the proposition contained in the Third Amendment.
Comment on this
It should be placed on the record that the reason for this measure having to be brought before the House, the Minister and the Government having nothing to do with it, is the judgment given in 1961 which the Third Amendment put before the people was designed to change and in respect of which they were confused by the Opposition Parties and advised to reject. If there is anything wrong with this measure, it is due entirely to the result of the referendum and the advice given to the people by the Opposition Parties.
Comment on this
I just want to say a few words—as my late colleague in this Party used to say—a few words for Clare—the new Clare/Galway constituency. While I have no objection to trying to work with the people of Clare—I regard myself as half Clare as the Hogans came from Clare—I feel that the people of Clare have no desire to be in with Galway. I know from the few contacts I have that they are very aggrieved to think that a Fianna Fáil Minister would do this to the most Fianna Fáil Minister county in the country. They feel they have been badly treated. The word I hear most often used is the "partition" of Clare. "Partition" is a dirty word in this country. That is how they feel. They feel that badly in Clare that this is the term they use for it.
I was given to understand when the Minister for Local Government was speaking about the redistribution of the constituencies prior to the referendum that the whole idea was to make constituencies, where possible, compact and not to breach county boundaries. If elected in the next general election, I will find myself representing part of three counties— Roscommon, Galway and Clare. It seems to me, in spite of what the previous speaker said, that the Minister is trying to penalise us in the west for defeating the proposition put forward in the referendum because he has breached every county boundary that he could possibly breach.
The only explanation I could imagine for the swipe at Roscommon was that possibly it would help Deputy Millar but he has changed his mind and I do not think he intends to avail of the little bonus he got in that end of the constituency.
I can see that amalgamation of Clare and Galway should help the Fianna Fáil people in the Galway end of the constituency. I do not agree with the Deputy from Clare who says that Clare will elect a Fianna Fáil Deputy on their own. I think this is impossible. I am sure they would like to because I think Clare people like to vote for Clare people. That is why I feel that I will get a vote in Clare. I think it was done purely to protect the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Carty. It certainly will not do anything to boost the Government in that area. The people feel they have been terribly let down.
I do not know why we must play musical chairs in the constituencies. When I was first elected to the House some 11 years ago I stood for South Galway. In those days Galway had three three-seat constituencies. In those early days, Fianna Fáil held six seats and the Opposition had three. Then we had a change of constituencies and East Galway was a five-seater and West Galway was a three-seater. Then the Government slipped and it became obvious that, if we were to retain a five-seater in East Galway or if we went down to a four-seater, the Government would then drop another seat. It could be argued that I might have lost a seat. Certainly I might, but it looked more likely that it would be a Fianna Fáil seat that would go. Obviously, there was hasty consultation by way of shoring up the slipping Fianna Fáil votes, so they turned it back into a three-seater. The Government have not been very smart, and I think that out of the nine seats for Galway they will lose one if not two extra seats.
I was rather amused when the last speaker, Deputy Healy, blamed the Deputies on the Opposition side of the House for the depopulation of the west. It must be admitted that the people are leaving the west because they do not find it economic to live there any longer. Surely we are not to blame for the economic state of the country? The Government, and solely the Government, are to blame for the flight from the land. It is interesting to note that since 1956 the population of Galway has gone down by 7,213 and I am afraid that in the next ten years there will be a similar drop unless we have a change of Government very quickly.
I agree with the large number of speakers here who said that the gerrymandering and the butchering—to use the words of the Minister for Industry and Commerce Deputy Colley, on television—has been done purely as a sort of revenge. I remember the Minister, Deputy Colley, on the night of the referendum stating that: "The people will be sorry when we come to the butchering of constituencies", and it looks as if the vendetta is being carried through to the bitter end. While we welcome the people of Clare into the new Galway constituency, I have sympathy for them in that this has been perpetrated on them, because it looks as if they only got enough to make their presence felt but not enough to give them a Deputy. However, I am sure that those of us in the Galway constituency who are elected will look after their interests as best we can.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom comhgháirdeachas a dhéanamh leis an Aire as ucht an Bhille seo a chur ós ár gcomhair. Níl mórán le rá agam ina thaobh, agus ní chuirfidh mé moill rómhór ar an Teach leis na smaointí atá le nochtadh agam.
I should like to compliment the last speaker, Deputy Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins. It is grand to hear the women of the country, especially those in this House, saying their piece. We have accusations levelled at us from time to time in regard to the equality of women. If we had more women elected to Dáil Éireann we might be able to disabuse the minds of people who feel we are against women in politics. We are all in favour of women in this House, regardless of political allegiance.
Deputy Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins says that Fianna Fáil have gerrymandered the constituency of Clare. Surely the answer to this is that historically Clare has always been a Fianna Fáil constituency and will, indeed, always be a Fianna Fáil constituency? At the moment it is represented for Fianna Fáil by the Minister for Labour, Deputy Dr. Hillery, Deputy Seán Ó Ceallaigh and Deputy Barrett. If possible, we would have left it intact instead of having to split it up into the constituencies of Clare and Clare-Galway. As I say, Clare has a history of voting for Fianna Fáil. It elected the President of Ireland, in the first instance, and from that time it has returned Fianna Fáil members with considerable majorities. If Fianna Fáil wanted to gerrymander surely in this instance the wise thing would have been to leave that constituency intact. Unfortunately, or fortunately as the case may be, this Bill had to be introduced and the constituencies had to be revised.
I do not intend to indulge in self-interest in this debate, but there is one matter in the Bill which worries me in relation to the constituency I represent, the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. First of all, may I say that a considerable part of what I would consider to be my support has been taken away from me? The townlands of Dundrum, Mount Merrion, Goatstown, Clonskea, Milltown—indeed, Milltown, where I hold a monthly clinic—all these have been taken away from the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. I should like to take this opportunity of thanking the people for the considerable support they have given Fianna Fáil over the years in those areas. I am sorry I will not be their representative in the next election. Of course, I hope I will succeed again in the revised constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown, but I would urge the people in those areas to support the Fianna Fáil candidates who will be on offer at the next general election. I know very well the people who will be elected there for Fianna Fáil, whoever they may be, will give as good service as they have been getting to date. That does not sound very humble, but it is a personal point of view, as all opinions are personal.
In relation to the division of the constituency, the map in the Library which is available to Deputies shows a line going from Leopardstown Racecourse right up to Ballybrack, and then suddenly shooting down again to take in Shankill and Rathmichael. I would ask the Minister to straighten out that line from Leopardstown Racecourse to Shankill. This is the complete answer. It gives a coherence to the constituency. It makes it physically practicable to get around and I think the Deputies in the constituency, those representing Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, would like this line to be straightened out. There is undoubtedly a bend in it which, in my opinion, is unnecessary. The Minister could take a part of Rathmichael and a part of Shankill out of this constituency to solve the problem of balancing the population. I can foresee no difficulty for the Minister in that respect, and I would urge him to have another look at the map which is available to Deputies in the Dáil Library. Indeed, for historical reasons he might revise the map itself because in many ways it would appear to be out of date, in the sense that it does not deal particularly with new areas in the constituency, but I have no doubt that in time the map will be brought up to date.
One matter which seems to have dogged this debate is the element of self-interest introduced by the Opposition Parties as to how representation of the constituencies will affect them personally; in other words this Bill has been reduced by the Opposition to a personal level. This is, I think, a matter of some importance. No Deputy worth his salt would have any fear about putting his name before the people in any given area. Party politics are moving away from the arena of personalities into the area of Party policies. Policies rather than personalities are what the people want today and they will follow the policy of a Party they consider good. Discussing this Bill in terms of self-interest is very wrong. Any candidate offering himself to the people should be prepared to take what is coming to him whether he be elected or defeated.
The debate has been one long litany of self-interest in the case of the Opposition Party and I should like to remind them that it is the people who decide these issues and that coming here to shed crocodile tears merely indicates their own little area of self-interest. "Shall I or shall I not be elected the next time?"— that is apparently the question they are discussing. Can anybody in the House, particularly from city or suburban constituencies, say with certainty where his votes come from? Can he go along a street in suburbia and say: "That is Deputy Andrews' side of the street; that is Deputy Cosgrave's side; that is Deputy Booth's street and that is Deputy Dockrell's"? Alternatively, can he go along and say that houses numbers 1 to 10 are Andrews' street——
Comment on this
I am sure that when I am dead and buried the people of Dún Laoghaire will erect some sort of monument to me and, if not, perhaps they will consider calling a street after me. Can one say with certainty that No. 1 is Andrews', No. 2 Cosgrave's, No. 3 Andrews', No. 4 Dockrell's and No. 5 Booth's? One cannot do that any more. City and suburban people and, I have no doubt, rural people are becoming far more sophisticated than those who voted traditionally for a Party out of loyalty to that Party. The new generation is more concerned with policies than with personalities. We are moving into an arena of sophistication in politics. With the coverage given to politics by RTE, the newspapers and various journals people are becoming far more aware and this is a very good thing. Communication has been lax over the years but now, with more modern media, people know and understand issues which are put clearly before them. In saying this I do not intend in any way to denigrate those people who have voted from the establishment of the State up to five, six or seven years ago. They had their own views and their own ways of formulating their opinions but people nowadays are becoming more aware.
I have here some rather interesting statistics. There have been four revisions of constituencies before this: this will be the fifth. There was a revision of constituencies before the election on the 9th June, 1927. The second revision was before the election of the 1st July, 1937, the third in 1948 and the fourth before the election of the 4th October, 1961. I am not in a position to announce to the House when the next general election will be but it will be held after the fifth revision of the constituencies. The number of TDs defeated in the election of the 9th June, 1927 was 43. The number who did not contest the election was 30. The number of TDs defeated in the election of the 1st July, 1937 was 31 and the number who did not offer themselves for election was 16. After the fourth revision of the constituencies in the election of the 4th October, 1961 the number defeated was 11 and the number of TDs who did not contest the election was 15. The average turnover of Deputies in 16 general elections only four of which followed revision of constituencies, was 33.
Comment on this
I should like to check that again. There were four revisions of constituencies and I am grateful to the Deputy for reminding me but it was not in 1947; it was in 1948. That was the third time the constituencies were revised. The number of TDs defeated was 20 and the number who did not contest the election was nine.
We are now coming to the fifth revision of the constituencies. The first revision was on the 27th August, 1923; the second on the 1st July, 1937; the third on the 4th February, 1948 and the fourth on the 4th October, 1961. This is a matter that concerns all of us but we should look at it more from the point of view of how we can serve the people rather than how they can serve us.
A certain amount of abuse has been levelled at the Minister and for the record, I want to say that from my own experience as a Deputy and as a party worker in Fianna Fáil in my townland of Dundrum for the past 16 or 17 years, the Minister for Local Government has consistently received bad press or bad publicity. This has been uninformed and unreasonable. For my part as a backbench Deputy of the Party I can say that the Minister, Deputy Boland, is a man who is available to backbench Deputies and I have no doubt available to all Deputies in the House. One has just to mention a problem to him in relation to a residents' association anxious to meet the Minister for Local Government and give him a day's notice and you can come in and line up behind a large queue of people waiting to see him. He is an extremely hard-working and dedicated Minister and a man of integrity. It comes ill from certain Deputies to level at him the type of abuse that has been forthcoming from them.
Personally, I want to thank the Minister for what he has done for the constituency I represent. He is going into the new constituency of South County Dublin and I have no doubt he will receive the same support as I received there. I wish him the very best of luck in these areas of Milltown, parts of Dundrum, Goatstown, Mount Merrion and Clonskeagh.
Comment on this
I believe that the Minister in his approach to the redistribution of constituencies tried to achieve what he had failed to achieve in the recent referendum. He set out, in so far as it was in his power to do so, to nullify the wishes of the people which were so clearly expressed in the referendum.
The people gave their verdict in no uncertain manner and even the most ardent Fianna Fáil Members of this House stated that they were glad that there had been a very clear-cut decision and that there was no ambiguity about the result. The people had spoken and spoken clearly and loudly to the effect that they wished to retain the PR system of election. The Taoiseach himself said that the lesson of the referendum would not be lost.
I am sure everybody knows—and it has long been agreed by all Members of this House—that PR worked at its best in larger constituencies; the larger the constituency, the better PR is seen to work. The Government should realise even at this late hour how foolish and stupid they are in trying to alter the system. They should accept the lesson they have learned and agree to abide by the wishes of the people. The wish of the people is that PR be retained but the Minister, in the revision of the constituencies, has adopted the opposite attitude.
In the explanatory memorandum we see that in 1961 there were 17 three-seat constituencies and, under the new Bill, the Minister proposes to have no fewer than 26 such constituencies. In other words, he has created more small constituencies and this is in direct contrast with what the people expressed in the referendum. We had 12 four-seat constituencies in 1961 but, under the new Bill, there will be 14 and, of course, as regards five-seat constituencies in which PR works very effectively, the Minister is reducing these from nine to two under the new system.
However, the Minister was careful to pick and choose the different areas in which he will make three-seat and four-seat constituencies. All along the western coast, from Donegal to Kerry where he knows that as yet Labour have not been very strong and the issue has mainly been between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, the Minister is hoping, with a small majority in these three-seat areas, to get two out of three. That is the sole purpose of having three-seat constituencies in that area.
In Dublin, where Fianna Fáil know that in a three-seat constituency it is practically a foregone conclusion that the three seats would divide 1-1-1 — Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour —they are hoping that they will be able to get two out of four in the four-seat areas. Two out of four is much better for them than one out of three. In the five-seat constituencies in Dublin, Fianna Fáil hope only to get two out of five; they could not hope to get three out of five, hence, the Minister is reducing those five-seat areas and making them four-seat ones.
Prior to the last local elections when the Minister revised the local authority areas, it was accepted here by all Parties, Fianna Fáil as well as Fine Gael and Labour, that the decision to divide North Dublin and South Dublin by the Liffey was a very wise one. Part of the No. 9 local authority area embraced part of the north side of the Liffey but then the Minister decided that this would no longer be the case. Members of all Parties seemed satisfied that the north and south sides were clearly divided by the Liffey. In this Bill, however, the Minister is re-introducing that. He is now creating a constituency of Dublin Central.
Comment on this
The Minister has played around with Dublin North East and has part of Baldoyle into the county.
Comment on this
There was no reason why the Minister could not have taken a little from the county and have 14 seats on the north side and 13 on the south side.
Comment on this
The Minister could have given or taken a little. Three four-seat areas and a two-seater are 14 seats. He could very easily have made two five-seaters and a four-seater but this did not suit his purpose.
Comment on this
The part of Dublin Central that is north of the Liffey would give enough for two seats.
Comment on this
This could not be done unless another seat were taken and put into part of the county.
Comment on this
The Minister could have made three four's and a three or he could have made three five's. However, this would not suit Fianna Fáil. With a very slight adjustment in Dublin where there are 13 seats on one side and 14 on the other, the Minister could, with a very slight adjustment and with Baldoyle given to the county——
Comment on this
The Minister had to separate the two Ministers, Deputy Haughey and Deputy Colley. It would not do to have one heading the poll, beating the other.
Comment on this
I shall not go into any details as regards County Dublin but it does seem that part of Kimmage Manor is now in County Dublin.
Comment on this
I do not know but surely the Minister could have devised something better in County Dublin. I do not know if there is any truth in the rumour that he created North County Dublin and South County Dublin because he did not want to be in the constituency with Deputy P. J. Burke. That rumour has been going around that the Minister wanted Deputy Burke out of the constituency. However, a more daring example of the way constituencies were carved solely and entirely for the purpose of suiting Fianna Fáil is Mayo. The county of Mayo has practically the same population still, but instead of having a North and South Mayo now we will have an east and west side. Was there any advantage in changing to east and west rather than north and south? The only answer to that is that Fianna Fáil did not want to have two Ministers in the one constituency and this was a way of dividing it.
Of course, the county of Leitrim has been completely carved up. Part of it has gone to Donegal, some of it to Roscommon and some to Sligo. It no longer exists at all. The Minister took the part around Athlone and purposely put it into Roscommon in the hope that it would suit the Fianna Fáil Minister in Roscommon.
Despite the fact that Leitrim no longer exists as a political entity on the map, we see that the Taoiseach was in undue haste, within a fortnight of the death of Senator Miss Pearse, in appointing a Senator to that area. He did not wait a month before he appointed a Senator, and I do not know what was the need for this great haste.
Comment on this
I only wanted to point out that we have two vacancies in the Dáil and there is no haste in filling them.
Comment on this
It may not be relevant, but it is a very live topic at the moment with people outside. The people are wide awake. They were not fooled by the propaganda of Fianna Fáil in the referendum and the people will clearly see through this attempt by the Minister to overrule and override the decision which they gave so clearly in the referendum.
Comment on this
Whenever the Government think fit to go to the country the people will again give them their answer. We on this side of the House are not afraid to face the next election. We look forward to it. We know that the people will give the Fianna Fáil Government the answer they so richly deserve. The Government failed in the referendum, as I have said, and even if they try by might and main to do everything they can in this Bill to gerrymander the constituencies to safeguard themselves they are now on the run and, please God, when they go to the country the people will give them their answer good and proper.
Comment on this
I will be brief on this. Before the debate comes to a conclusion I should like to say a few words in so far as the revision of the constituencies is concerned. At the outset I would say that, looking at this revision from a personal point of view, I should be pleased indeed with it. I represent the constituency of Mid-Cork and I also represent Bandon/Macroom electoral area in the Cork County Council. Up to now in the old constituency the area I represent in the local authority was almost detached from the constituency I represent in Dáil Éireann and the Minister has included in that constituency now the area where I live and the town of Macroom. I agree with the Minister only on this point. This town has been changed in every revision that has come about and it should always be included in the constituency of Cork. This town is always regarded as the capital of Mid-Cork.
In so far as I am concerned, I am mature enough and have experience enough to look beyond my own door and beyond the boundaries of the constituency of Mid-Cork. The proposed new constituency, if it is not altered in this constituency revision, is almost 90 miles in length. I believe the Minister had complete disregard for distance. In the new constituency there are four outgoing Opposition Deputies. There are two Labour Deputies— Deputies McAuliffe and Mrs. Desmond —and two Fine Gael Deputies—Deputies Burton and I. This was set up for the purpose of trying to select a constituency where the two Labour Deputies would be opposed to each other and the two Fine Gael Deputies. In so far as that constituency is concerned, with regard to the two Fine Gael Deputies at least after the next election we will return two Fine Gael TDs in that constituency.
I will not deal with the gerrymandering in the city of Dublin as I do not know enough about that but as far as Cork county is concerned—I am sure Deputy Crowley will agree with me—and particularly the constituency of Mid-Cork, you have an area in Mid-Cork where Kinsale is almost in the centre of the county and you have Kinsale town in the new constituency of West Cork and Pearson's Bridge at the entrance to Bantry which is near the west of Cork. This does not make sense. You have the constituency extending from Newtownshandrom and Charleville right across to Crosshaven. In the old constituency I represent there are two different housing areas, the southern Cork housing area and the northern housing area as well. I felt the people I represent were at a disadvantage. People who came to me in connection with problems would be dealt with by the Northern Housing Committee of which I was not a member. The only way I can make representations on their behalf is by letter or telephone. If I am returned to the Dáil in the new constituency, which is divided between three housing areas and three health authorities as well, I can see a difficulty.
The last speaker said that the recently-held referendum showed in no uncertain terms that the people wanted to hold on to the system of PR. I will not refer to the referendum beyond saying that the people figured that the PR system had served them well and that it was a most democratic system. If we are honest—and surely the Minister for Local Government is honest?—we must agree that it is an established fact that if proportional representation is to be used effectively it can be used to greatest effect in five- or six-seat constituencies rather than in a three-seat constituency.
Particularly along the western seaboard, all the constituencies there are three-seat constituencies. The Minister for Local Government is hoping, I suppose, that, with 51 per cent of the vote cast in those three-seat constituencies, Fianna Fáil can gain two out of the three seats. The referendum proved that the political tide has turned against the Government. Their hope now is that gerrymandering of constituencies will modify the trend. I know perfectly well that this will not be so and that the people, having in no uncertain way given their answer in the referendum, will certainly give them their answer again whether there are three-seat, four-seat or five-seat constituencies.
There are many counties such as County Leitrim that have been completely mutilated. I admit that it is probably a difficult job to divide the constituencies and that, no matter what way they are divided, somebody is likely to complain but I cannot see any reason why a county like Leitrim should be divided between three counties. Look at the constituency of Galway-Clare, where a part of Clare had to go into Galway. The Minister for Local Government will be known as the great exterminator of county and constituency boundaries.
Let me come back again to the constituency of mid-Cork. In the recent referendum. I had in my possession from the Fianna Fáil director of elections in that constituency, a printed pamphlet signed by Deputy Tom Meaney, Director of Elections in the northern area of Millstreet, Knocknagree and Boherbue. Leaflets were handed out to the effect that, if the people in that area voted "No" then that area would go into Kerry in the revision of constituencies. I refer to this because that very Deputy, when he spoke here this evening on this very Bill, stated that the Fine Gael Party were threatening and spreading false propaganda in the referendum in order to intimidate and force people into voting "No." The people have voted "No" and have held on to the system of proportional representation.
Comment on this
Yes. The Minister for Local Government has now decided that, because they voted in such an overwhelming majority to retain the system of proportional representation, he will set up three-seat constituencies as far as he is able to do so in order that the people will not be able to use effectively the system of proportional representation. Deputy Andrews, a while ago——
Comment on this
They are interested in self preservation and, as far as we are concerned here on this side of the House, we know perfectly well that, whatever constituencies there may be when the next general election comes, the people will give their answer to Fianna Fáil as they did in the recent referendum.
Comment on this
No Party since the foundation of the State ever sustained such a humiliating defeat.
Comment on this
When the Minister comes to reply to this debate, it will be most interesting to hear his reply to the charge by Deputy T. J. Fitzpatrick of Cavan that it is quite illogical, even dishonourable, for a person in his position, who did all that one man could do to overthrow the system of proportional representation, to come now into this House with an Electoral (Amendment) Bill which purports to reorganise the operation of the system. Deputy Fitzpatrick points out most significantly that the Minister breached the normal and sensible convention of this House that a Minister, when introducing a Bill, recommends the Bill to the House. It is quite clear that, having been thwarted by a substantial majority in the referendum, the Minister is now doing what he can—indeed, it is not very much but it is enough to warrant a protest—to make the system of proportional representation inoperable.
In the course of the many interesting television presentations—"Seven Days" and other programmes— during the referendum campaign, the programme which gave us the history of proportional representation established very significantly that those who propounded the system visualised large constituencies because the system of proportional representation comes into play to full effect in large constituencies.
Indeed, it is very interesting to recall something which many Members of the Oireachtas may overlook. In the early days of this State, when we were filled with enthusiasm for proportional representation as the fairest system, large constituencies were the rule rather than the exception. In the election for the Seanad fought on the universal franchise in the 1920's, the whole country was a single constituency. It might not have been very practicable and it did not work, it is true, but, nevertheless, the fact that this development took place establishes that those concerned with proportional representation at the time were anxious to operate it in large constituencies. Indeed, for many years, up to the first Fianna Fáil gerrymander in the 1930's, we had constituencies of seven members and nine members in Dublin city—the whole of North Dublin as one constituency and the whole of South Dublin as another. Now, we have a reduction in the number of five-member constituencies from nine to two and we have an increase of nine in the number of threemember constituencies, in the hope that Fianna Fáil will obtain two out of three seats, thwarting, as I have said, the principle of proportional representation.
As a Dublin Deputy, I resent very much the line taken by the Minister and the Tánaiste in endeavouring to promote friction and ill-will between the west of Ireland and Dublin city in the allegations made in the course of this debate. If the population of the west has declined from the point of view of the principle of one man one vote, which the Government did their best to overthrow, that is not the fault of my constituents in Dublin NorthEast or the fault of any other voters in Dublin.