Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968 — Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–164 of 495. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 35 of 1968 ›
When suggesting changes in the boundaries of a particular constituency under consideration Members will be allowed to deal with changes in other constituencies with which the constituency under consideration forms a group. This would be in accordance with the normal rules of debate and, consequently, would not need to be dealt with by a special Order of the House. I understand it is proposed to postpone sections 3, 4 and 5 until consideration of the Schedule has been completed.
Comment on this
Could the Minister do anything about this problem, possibly in this Bill or, if not, in some future Bill, where there are polling districts crossing? The result of these proposals before the House is that people living in certain areas could be voting several miles away in the heart of another constituency. This is a peculiar situation that has arisen because of the way in which the boundary map is drawn up. Could the Minister try to have constituencies or electoral areas straightened out in some way so that this will not keep on recurring?
Comment on this
It is referred to but it is not provided for. It still continues.
Comment on this
We shall discuss it when we come to section 7.
Comment on this
The Minister says this is dealt with here.
Comment on this
Section 7 provides that where a polling district is split between two or more constituencies suitable polling arrangements will be made for the voters concerned either by joining a part or parts of the divided district with an adjoining district or districts or by constituting each divided part as a separate polling district. The provision is necessary because of the time taken in the ordinary course for going through the ordinary procedure for making a polling scheme. Subsection (2) provides that any such arrangement is temporary and will have effect only until new polling schemes are made. Any such arrangement will be subject to the sanction of the Minister as are polling schemes, and will come into effect only following the dissolution of the Dáil following the passing of this Bill. Under the 1961 Act, these temporary arrangements fell to be made by the returning officers because, at that time, the returning officer was, in nearly all cases, the registration officer. The registration authority is now the county or county borough council. It is considered more appropriate that the temporary arrangements in regard to polling districts should be made as provided in subsection (3), by the appropriate officer of the registration authority, that is, the county secretary or the city manager, following consultation with the returning officer. Does that cover what the Deputy has in mind?
Comment on this
Unfortunately, no. I am referring to districts such as one in my constituency. People who are living, for instance, in a district known as Balreask, south of Carlanstown, County Meath, have to travel through the Monaghan constituency and have to vote miles away. A simple adjustment would have enabled these people to remain in either one constituency or the other.
Comment on this
They are in Meath constituency. They have to travel through Monaghan constituency and those who are nearer the Meath area are, in fact, in Monaghan. It is one of these things which have been handed down over the years. If it can be adjusted it should be adjusted.
Comment on this
"Handed down over the years": there has not been any adjustment between Meath and Monaghan before now.
Comment on this
The polling district in which these people are situated is so spread out——
Comment on this
The area in which these people are living is south of Carlanstown while the booth they are voting in is four miles east of it because the Minister has done a bit of carving to suit somebody around that area and he has taken this area and put it into County Monaghan.
Comment on this
It was done to suit the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
The following amendments—Nos. 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6—in the names of Deputies Seán Dunne, James Tully and Seán Treacy have been ruled out of order as not being relevant to the subject matter of the Bill as read a Second Time.
Comment on this
Section 8 reads as follows:
(1) The Electoral (Amendment) Act, 1961, is hereby repealed.
(2) Subsection (1) of this section shall come into operation on the dissolution of Dáil Éireann which next occurs after the passing of this Act.
Now, this says that, on the dissolution of the Dáil, the new Act will become operative, when passed. Could the Minister enlighten me and the House, perhaps, as to what would happen if the Dáil were dissolved before this Bill is passed? Is the 1961 Act still operative and is the 1961 Act still enforceable in law in this country? In other words, is it completely constitutional?
Comment on this
Yes. If the Dáil is dissolved before this Bill becomes an Act, the 1961 Electoral (Amendment) Act is still in force.
Comment on this
Therefore, I take it that if the Dáil were to be dissolved before this Bill, when enacted, came into operation, it would be absolutely normal to have elections under the present existing scheme of constituencies?
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I wish to oppose this section inasmuch as I believe that the creation of this constituency—what is now termed Clare-South Galway—is quite unnecessary.
Comment on this
We are dealing with section 8. The particulars mentioned by the Deputy would relevantly arise——
Comment on this
May I make a suggestion to the Minister at this point? I think it is a recognised fact in this House that, as far as possible, the administrative constituencies or counties should stay as they were before. I think the Minister will agree with that. I think his arguments on the Second Reading were to endeavour, as far as possible, to keep them as before. In 1961, under the original Electoral Bill, we found, in the administrative county of Wexford that quite a lot of it was taken out and put into the constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny. The reason for doing that was that the population register for the constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny was then insufficient to maintain five seats. The placing of this piece of Wexford in the constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny enabled that constituency to be retained as a five-member constituency.
In the readjustment that is now being made, I want to make this suggestion to the Minister that he restore to County Wexford the territory of that county that was originally removed from it to build up the Carlow-Kilkenny constituency. He can do that by restoring to County Wexford from the Carlow-Kilkenny constituency that area of County Wexford which was taken out and he can still maintain the status quo with regard to the number of seats in the Carlow-Kilkenny constituency in relation to the requisite population by uniting the constituencies of Carlow and Kildare into a five-member constituency and leaving Kilkenny on its own as a three-member constituency and still leaving Wexford as a four-member constituency but at least giving the Wexford people the right to vote in their own administrative county, as heretofore. Would the Minister consider that proposition?
Comment on this
That would be all right if we had only Wexford and Carlow and kilkenny to consider. Actually, we have 26 counties to consider. The situation in Kildare is relevant to the situation in Meath which is relevant to to the situation in Monaghan which is relevant to the situation in Cavan. Unfortunately, I cannot approach this on the piecemeal basis which Deputy Esmonde has in mind. I have to consider all the constituencies and not just the counties immediately adjoining the county of Wexford.
Comment on this
I am arguing in favour of the retention of the administrative areas. Could he tell me if the suggestion I am making to him means in effect that I am asking him to reduce the number of seats in any other constituency? I maintain I am not. He says unfortunately he has to consider other areas as well.
Comment on this
The Deputy is making it impossible to deal in a reasonable way with the situation in Cavan-Monaghan, Louth and Meath.
Comment on this
Would the Minister clarify this for me? Am I taking a seat away from anybody else? I do not want to deny anybody the representation they may wish to have in Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
The suggestion that Deputy Esmonde makes might be better in so far as the County Wexford is concerned but it would involve dealing with other counties as far away as Cavan and Monaghan in a more objectionable way than they are dealt with in the Bill.
Comment on this
The trouble is that Deputies like Deputy Tully and Deputy Esmonde only have to consider their own constituencies.
Comment on this
The Minister will have a bit of a job finding one.
Comment on this
I am arguing for the retention of the administrative centres as far as possible. Let us consider Carlow-Kilkenny in relation to Carlow and Kildare—to argue my point more clearly than I have been doing. Carlow and Kildare are one unit under one county manager and so what the Minister is doing by perpetuating the construction of my constituency which took place in 1961, is putting these electoral areas under three different county managers. In effect, that is what he is doing because Carlow and Kildare are one managerial unit. Carlow and Kildare are in the one diocese and it is largely in relation to diocese and parishes that the present system is compiled. There is every argument in favour of doing that. I do not know what the opinions of my colleagues from Carlow and Kildare on the matter might be. Also, to simplify the matter for the Minister, the Garda administration of Carlow and Kildare is under one chief superintendent. Therefore, it is a unit. It was originally a constituency before the Minister came to the House, and indeed before I came to the House a good many years ago. I cannot see how the Minister can say that he cannot do what I suggest because he has to consider the position all over Ireland. This is just a matter of refuting all the arguments he has ever produced here in regard to this Bill. He has said that he is trying as far as possible to maintain the boundaries as they existed before in relation to the existing conformation. I am offering him an easy way out here to rectify a situation which I consider is entirely wrong and will lead to electoral confusion and so on. He mentions vaguely Louth, Monaghan and Cavan. They are a very long way away from Wexford, even from Carlow and Kildare. He mentions disrupting the constituency situation all over. Would he clarify my mind on what he really means? I am arguing that he can do this without changing the number of seats in Dáil Éireann. Anything that will enable the Minister for Local Government, in drafting what I admit is a very difficult Bill like this, to leave the administrative boundaries as they are, can only be doing a service to the country as a whole.
Comment on this
I have explained to the Deputy that, unlike himself, I have to deal with other constituencies as well as County Wexford. In fact, I do not even know whether Deputy Esmonde has the agreement of his own colleagues for what he is suggesting. I do not know if it is the decision of the Fine Gael Party to recommend that Carlow should be taken away from the county of Kilkenny and added to County Kildare.
Comment on this
I thought possibly the Deputy was. The fact is that I have to deal with all the counties and, although I thoroughly agree that Cavan is a considerable distance away from Wexford, it is a fact that it is a relevant consideration and that is not my fault. It is not very long since the Deputy was arguing on the opposite lines that these transfers of population from one administrative area to another were completely irrelevant and of no importance. The proposal that I have made in the Bill involves the least disruption of the existing lay-out of constituencies. I am quite satisfied on that. What the Deputy suggests would be feasible if we had only these four counties to consider, but unfortunately we have more counties to consider.
Comment on this
While I accept everything the Minister said I should like to point out that I did not speak on the Second Reading of this Bill. I did speak in 1961 and I strongly opposed the disruptions of my constituency.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy also spoke on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill which was brought in to rectify the situation that he complained so bitterly about in 1961.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): Surely this is something the Minister could consider because it is feasible under the Constitution as it stands at the moment. The Minister mentions that any alteration like that will have repercussions in other counties. Of course, it will because there is a kind of chain reaction. He mentioned Cavan and also said that he was doing this with the least disturbance of county boundaries, but if you look at what he is doing to Meath——
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): Yes. Let us take county boundaries. In the case of Meath the Minister has simply mutilated the county and drafted much of it into Cavan and some into Monaghan. I do not think that is necessary.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy keep to the question before the House, the constituencies of Carlow-Kilkenny?
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I think it is impossible in this matter and I think the Ceann Comhairle mentioned this himself at the beginning——
Comment on this
Yes, I made an announcement about the constituencies under consideration forming a group but I think the Deputy is travelling a bit too far.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I think it was the Minister who travelled a bit too far. He said if there was a change made in any one it involved the whole country and that to make one in Wexford you have to take Cavan into consideration. With all due respect I think it is the Minister who has widened the scope of the debate.
Comment on this
I do not think I said it would involve the whole country but I certainly said it would involve as far up as Cavan and Monaghan.
Comment on this
Might I make a suggestion to the Chair? As we seem to be anxious to discuss the situation in the Cavan-Meath area and possibly Carlow-Kilkenny has been fully dealt with, we might move on to the other one where all these points would be relevant.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): The Minister himself mentioned Cavan and it has a bearing on the matter.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): If the Minister were prepared to consider certain population transfers and endeavours to preserve the integrity of the Counties of Monaghan and Cavan he could arrange for the transfer back to County Wexford of this area if he would consider the formation of a Carlow-Kildare constituency. Carlow's population is 33,593; the population of Kildare is 66,404—a total of 99,997. This combination meets the requirements for a five-seater and allows the return of the sequestrated 4,398 population back to Wexford. This would involve some transfers of population as between Louth and Meath but there is an easy way of doing it. It would be quite a feasible proposition ultimately if Louth and Meath were dealt with on these lines. There would be fewer transfers of population ultimately than envisaged by the Minister.
Comment on this
There is an infinite number of ways in which this rearrangement of the constituencies could be carried out, in view of the interpretation of the Constitution.
Comment on this
The Minister should tell the truth, that when Fianna Fáil were devising this rearrangement there was only one consideration. It was to keep Ministers divided. Let us come to Cavan-Monaghan as it stands.
Comment on this
The question is that the entry relating to the constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny stand part of the Schedule. Is that agreed?
Comment on this
In relation to Cavan, this constituency appears to be one place where the Minister or his henchmen made an effort to disrupt everything they could. I am not talking about the Departmental officials but of the Minister's local henchmen who not only knifed me, as the Labour Deputy for Meath, and Deputy Farrelly, as the Fine Gael Deputy, but one of their own candidates in Meath who stood on the last occasion. They wanted to get rid of him and they took a good swipe around and they got rid of their own candidate. The areas of Meath, Louth, Cavan and Monaghan could be settled easily. If they were fair they could have made Cavan and Monaghan a five-seater quite easily. Do not let anybody say parts of such a constituency would be too remote from a Deputy, because at the moment one Deputy lives in Ballaghaderreen and one lives in Highfield Road, Dublin. There are three Deputies in Cavan all of whom would be able to serve that area. One of the existing Deputies lives on the Monaghan border.
If what I am suggesting were done, Meath could quite simply become a four-seater with the addition of portion of Louth, or Louth could quite simply become a four-seater with the addition of portion of Meath. In either case there would have been very little knifing. However, that would not have suited the Minister. He cut portions of North Meath in a straight line, taking in the pockets of Fianna Fáil where they were needed and putting them on their own. The map is there. It is evident for anybody to see. Having looked at the map, it is fairly easy to follow who was the architect. Having done that, the Minister sliced it down the middle and gave portion to the Monaghan-Louth constituency.
Let me be fair to Fine Gael as well. It appears to me that some of the semiquavers put on the map have been for the purpose of picking a strong Fine Gael man. They took the tips from Deputy Farrelly's boots, they took away the area where I was born and reared. A decent man, the Minister for Defence, commented to the Minister for Local Government that he had roots in the area. Perhaps people do not have roots that carry them for 100 years. The Minister for Defence was born and reared in that area and probably his grandfather was reared in it but, as I have said, people do not have roots which carry them for 100 years.
There was a deliberate attempt made by the Minister, or by those responsible for advising him, to play a political trick. It is quite possible that the Irish people, being who they are, and realising that this trick is being tried, will blow it back into the Minister's face and it may become one of the most expensive day's work ever done by a Fianna Fáil Minister. He has given us back a portion of Meath. We are very glad, but he took a portion of Kildare and spliced it on to Meath and this aggravates ordinary people.
The idea is not alone to divide the constituencies in such a way as to be advantageous to the Minister's Party; there is also the effort to get at the areas of other Parties, to get at the dangerous areas and to wipe them out with one stroke. The Minister's story is that this has become necessary because the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill was not carried in the referendum. This is nonsense. The Minister knows that when he goes to the country the people will not accept that story. They know what he intended by the referendum on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill and the people dealt with it as it should have been dealt with. When he goes to them after this gerrymander attempt they will give him the same answer.
Comment on this
Cavan is a typical example of the butchering and the gerrymandering that Fianna Fáil are attempting in this Bill. They have not got anything to learn from the Six Counties. As Deputy Tully has stated, it is evident that in Meath, bordering on Cavan, their idea is to ruin Deputy Farrelly and to put him out of Leinster House but, no matter what Fianna Fáil do in this Bill, Deputy Farrelly will be back in this House after the next general election.
Comment on this
The Minister told us they were anxious to preserve county boundaries. What did they do in Cavan to preserve the boundaries? It is plain to be seen in Westmeath what they have done. It suits me admirably but it was not done for my benefit. It was done because there had been a bargain with Deputy Sheridan that if he appealed to the people there for the straight vote in the referendum the area of Kilbeggan, which was put into Kildare in their previous gerrymander, would be handed back to Longford-Westmeath to suit him. Incidentally it suits me. The Minister should stand up here and tell the truth to the Irish people. I have here a map drawn up by Senator Garret FitzGerald.
Comment on this
The map shows plainly that there was no necessity to butcher or to gerrymander the constituencies around Cavan or in any other part of the country. With six small changes, involving 40,000 electors, or less than one per cent, the Minister fairly and squarely, and in the interests of the people of the country, could have drawn up a Bill that would be acceptable to everybody here. But that would not suit the arrogant, dictatorial Minister for Local Government. He had to have 17 changes involving the taking away of 17 pieces of nine counties and over 100,000 voters. Cavan and Monaghan could have been left a five-seater constituency.
Dáil Éireann is the place in which to tell the truth. It is a well-known fact that Fianna Fáil did not want a five-seater constituency because there was a danger of a member of the Protestant Association from Cavan and Monaghan getting one seat out of the five. As I say, this is the place to tell the truth: originally it was intended that Cavan and Monaghan would be a five-seater constituency but the Fianna Fáil boys came down and said: "No. If you do that there will be a member of the Protestant Association elected, one out of five, and we cannot be certain that we will get the support. Therefore you must change it and make it two three-seater constituencies." In doing that they had to take into Cavan portion of Meath very convenient to where Deputy Farrelly is living and put it into Cavan. I claim that is gerrymandering. The Minister could have made Cavan and Monaghan a five-seater constituency. He could have made Longford-West-meath a four-seater constituency and there would have been no necessity then to know lovely Leitrim off the map because Donegal could have been made into a five-seater constituency. Again the message was carried from Donegal: "If Donegal is made a five-seater constituency the Protestant Association will get a member there, one out of five. Let us make it two three-seater constituencies in the hope that we will get two out of the three in both." We can tell them now that their hopes will be dashed. Now, had they done that, Roscommon and Leitrim——
Comment on this
No. There is agreement that we can take the groups surrounding the constituency we are discussing. As a matter of fact, a few moments ago, when we were discussing Wexford the Minister brought in Cavan and Monaghan.
Comment on this
We cannot discuss one in isolation. We have to even up and, if we did not make the case, the Minister would be the first to get up and tell us we were talking through our hats. I am pointing out to the Minister that, instead of doing what he has done, Cavan and Monaghan could have been left a five-seater constituency. Likewise, Roscommon and Leitrim could have been left a five-seater constituency, Sligo a three-seater constituency and Donegal a five-seater constituency.
Comment on this
At this stage, there would be a discussion on each of these on the Schedule; there would not be a group.
Comment on this
It was agreed between the Whips last night, and the agreement was read out here at the beginning of the debate, that we would deal with the Schedule, take the constituencies and base our arguments on a group around the constituencies. Otherwise we could not make any argument.
Comment on this
Yes, but I want to point out what can be done quite easily. The Minister went further. He took parts of North Meath, beside Deputy Farrelly, and put them into Cavan to do Deputy Farrelly all the harm he could. Then he took in parts of Kildare to suit a Fianna Fáil Deputy living there. The Minister is doing everthing he can in his alleged wisdom—I think things will turn out otherwise—to ensure that Fianna Fáil will capture two seats in Meath. They have not got a hope. I want to point out there was no necessity for this gerrymandering. The Minister assured everybody in the Referendum that he was anxious to preserve county boundaries as far as possible. He could have preserved county boundaries in this particular instance with the minimum of effort and without any necessity to change something like 10,000 voters; they have been switched from one constituency to another. There is no necessity for that.
Comment on this
Being one of those directly concerned I suppose I should say something about this proposed revision. The Minister told us on the Referendum that he wanted to make constituencies compact and easier to work. Now, even though Fianna Fáil lost the Referendum, one would imagine the Minister would honour his word and make constituencies easier to work under this reorganisation. It would have been very simple for the Minister to make Cavan-Monaghan and Louth-Meath very convenient constituencies for those representing them. Cavan and Monaghan are not entitled to six Deputies and the obvious thing to do, therefore, would have been to combine Cavan and Monaghan and make the constituency a five-seater constituency. I remember when Meath was lined up with Westmeath. Then the population in Meath increased and Meath was made one unit again. It remained a unit for a few years until the reorganisation prior to the 1961 election. Cavan-Louth could be made another constituency. It is absurd that people living within five miles of Cavan should be represented by a Deputy from the Monaghan constituency which extends from Rathkenny down to the border of Fermanagh. Rathkenny is only four miles from the town of Cavan. Nobody with common sense would draw up a constituency like that. Louth is a small area with a big population and it should be quite simple to take in portion of Louth and make it a four-seater, leaving Meath a three-seater constituency. I read in today's paper that a further area is to be brought within the Drogheda border. I am sure the Minister was aware of this change before he revised these constituencies.
If the Minister revises the constituencies along the lines I suggest he will be doing a better job for himself and for those who are represented here. I live in North Louth within four miles of the Cavan border. I live in Kilmainhamwood. The parish is divided in two, one portion being in Cavan and the other in Monaghan and 17 miles from where I live towards the seaside is still in Monaghan. The situation the Minister proposes is ridiculous. I can assure the Minister that people do not like it and, no matter what Fianna Fáil do about it, the people will not support them if this change is made. The Minister should reconsider making Cavan and Monaghan a five-seater, Louth a four-seater and leave Meath a three-seater and there will not be any objection.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I agree with the last speaker. Deputy Tully put it very cogently when he said the solution lay in Louth, Meath and Kildare. It is around those three counties that it hangs. If Louth and Meath were four-seaters all this abnormal transfer of population from Meath and Louth into Cavan and Monaghan could be obviated and Cavan and Monaghan could remain as a five-seater entity, two counties naturally grouped together. I do not want to anticipate the order of the Schedule. If Louth is treated as a four-seater Meath becomes a three-seater, and Kildare being, so to speak, a three-and-a-half seater would join Carlow, forming a five-seater.
The Minister proposes to make Cavan a three-seater. We feel it should be joined with Meath and made a five-seater. The transfers are 3,829 in one place, 1,827 in another place, 3,950 in another place, 5,796 in another place and 1,837, I think, in another place. This huge transfer of population from Meath and Louth into Cavan and Monaghan could be obviated quite easily if the Minister would consider treating Louth, Meath and Kildare on the lines we suggest. I will deal with it in more detail when we come to those areas.
Comment on this
I do not know what Deputies are driving at. They have complained that someone from Monaghan will be representing portion of County Meath. I understood from what I heard at Question Time that all those Deputies have moved in and are residing in Dublin.
Comment on this
I understood that from the way they "went after" Dublin Corporation. We endeavoured to prevent all this by having each square of the country marked out into single seaters. The Deputies who are now annoyed should have helped with that proposal. I know we will not see a trace of Deputy L'Estrange from tomorrow morning until after 20th February.
Comment on this
Because he will be above with Paisley. That is where the Deputy will be. The Deputy has deliberately alleged that this Government, this Republican Government——
Comment on this
That is the allegation which the Deputy has made. It is only natural that he should go up to help out Paisley for the next fortnight in elaborating on the corruption down here. I admit that is his natural instinct. I do not blame him for it but I think it is disgraceful for any Deputy to use that type of politics——
Comment on this
Not a bit. He was shouting about gerrymandering. Those people had an opportunity of having single-seat constituencies represented by one Deputy but they were not satisfied. They wanted five-seat constituencies or anything up to 15-seat constituencies. One Deputy says: "Look, this is the constituency now. If you turned it that way it would be handier. If you took a bit off and put a bit on it would be handier still." No one knows who prepared the map. If I were to look at my constituency as it stands at the moment, and as it stood a couple of months ago, I would say it was prepared by Deputy Fitzpatrick.
We must endeavour, as has been done here, to mark out the areas as fairly as possible, and to mark them out so that they will cause the least amount of annoyance to Deputies. The constituency I got in 1961 was like something drawn by a man who had been in delirium tremens for two months. I found myself with a constituency stretching from Youghal town to Loughchapel. Thank God the Minister has taken one slice from me, but there is another slice which he took from me about which I will be talking later on.
I think Deputy L'Estrange should apologise here and now in this Republican Parliament of ours which has prided itself at all times on having no religious discrimination. His attitude was a disgrace.
Comment on this
The Deputy should have the decency to say he is withdrawing his allegation and that he is sorry, or else he should pack his bags and go up to Paisley and stay with him. The two of them would be well matched.
Comment on this
The question is that the entry relating to the constituency of Cavan stand part of the Schedule. Agreed?
Comment on this
I wanted to say a word on this before we finish with it. On many occasions the Minister and members of the Minister's Party in the course of the referendum campaign said that the one thing they did not want to do was to interfere with county boundaries. That was something which was sacred and as far as possible the minimum disturbance should take place. Meath is now nearly like Leitrim. It is really non-existent. Part of it has been chopped up and put into Monaghan, part of it has been put into Cavan and part of it is being put into Kildare, while at the same time, as Deputy Farrelly says, quite an area is being taken into it for the enlargement of Drogheda. Surely it should be possible, if we are making any sensible re-adjustment, to ensure that it is not necessary to take bits of any one county in this way.
It is fair to say that it is not altogether a coincidence that it is the area in which Deputy Denis Farrelly has the greatest influence—indeed the area where he was born—that has been chopped up and part put into Monaghan and Cavan and it is not a coincidence that there is no strong Fianna Fáil force in that particular part of the county. It is an area of County Meath which I know very well. I know how much the people in the area that is cut away will resent being put in either Cavan or Monaghan because there has always been as much rivalry between Meath and Cavan and Meath and Monaghan as there is on the border between the 26 Counties and the Six Counties. I know how they will feel about it and they will show their resentment in no uncertain way.
Certainly, if Deputy Farrelly should lose on that end he will gain through sympathy in what is left and the Fine Gael organisation in the other two counties will benefit as a result. It is anything but a sensible chop-up and it makes a complete farce of the pious sentiments expressed during the referendum campaign about how sacred county boundaries were and how important it was not to chop them up unnecessarily.
Comment on this
On this matter the Opposition are displaying the limit in hypocrisy and effrontery in shedding crocodile tears for what they now describe as the breaching of county boundaries and which they described in the same way in 1961, despite the fact that it is only a couple of months since they expressed exactly the opposite sentiments, when they spent days and weeks here arguing that these were things that were of no practical consideration whatever and that they were entirely irrelevant. Now we have them singing the exact opposite tune.
On the other hand, the Fianna Fáil Party and myself have been consistent in this regard. In 1961, when the Fine Gael manoeuvre in the High Court required this to be done for the first time, we fought that case in the courts and reluctantly complied with the decision of the courts. At that time we were assailed by the Opposition Party for not giving the people the opportunity to remove what the former Taoiseach, Deputy J.A. Costello, described as this "constitutional infirmity". When again in response to the demands of the Opposition it became obvious that this practice would have to be necessary again and that those areas that were disturbed in 1961 were not sufficient and that this would have to be repeated, we did everything possible to avoid this. Our efforts to arrive at a situation in which it would be permissible to take practical things into consideration in drawing up constituencies were frustrated. We are now in the position that not alone have we the decision of the courts but the decision of the people that these are not relevant matters to be taken into consideration and we cannot take them into consideration.
However, at the same time, when it comes to drawing up a scheme of constituencies the duty devolves on the Government to try to have reasonable constituencies. It is a fact that these five counties of Kildare, Meath, Cavan and Monaghan have, generally speaking, formed constituencies of their own. There was, it is true, a short period when Meath and Westmeath were combined, but apart from that there have been Kildare, Louth, Cavan, Meath and Monaghan constituencies. That is the position at present. What we are proposing is to retain a Kildare constituency, a Louth constituency, a Meath constituency, a Cavan constituency and a Monaghan constituency. It is a fact that, in accordance with the position that has been cemented on us through the action of the Opposition Party, namely through the manoeuvre in the High Court of the Fine Gael Party, none of these five can form a constituency on their own, in a single county. In Kildare the population is 66,404 which is too much for a three-seat constituency and too little for a four-seat constituency. In Louth the population is 69,519 which is too much for a three-seat constituency and too little for a four-seat constituency. In Meath the population is 67,323 which is too much for a three-seat constituency and too little for a four-seat constituency. In Cavan the population is 54,022 which is too small for a three-seat constituency and in Monaghan, where the population is 45,732, it is again too small for a three-seat constituency.
As I have said, there are many different ways in which this totally unnecessary problem can be solved. If, on the other hand, our proposals had been accepted and it was permissible to take account of administrative boundaries, this complexity would not arise and a simple and an equitable solution would be possible. The solution as proposed involves the least disturbance and the least distortion of the present representation of these different areas. We are proposing that there should continue to be a constituency based in the main on each of these five counties and we have considered the possibility of joining the two counties of Cavan and Monaghan. In our opinion the creation of a constituency like that would be little less than a monstrosity constituency stretching along half of the boundary with the Six-County boundary, stretching in a U-shape so that we could not even go in a rational way from one part of the constituency to the other.
I am satisfied that the people in those two counties appreciate that a constituency of Cavan and Monaghan would in fact be what I described as a monstrosity and would not be convenient either for the electorate or their representatives. As I say, it is only a couple of months since every member of the Opposition Parties was arguing that administrative areas were completely irrelevant but now apparently, not alone am I expected to take account of county boundaries, but also expected to arrange the constituencies to be coterminous with county boundaries and parish and diocesan boundaries. That would be an impossible task particularly in view of the restrictions contained in the Constitution.
Deputies are complaining about the fact that the deficiency in population for three seats in Cavan has been made up from North Meath. It is quite obvious that that is the only rational place from which it could be made up. Monaghan borders Cavan but has no population to spare and neither has any of the other constituencies surrounding Cavan, except County Meath. The transfer must come from north County Meath and could not be taken from the other county in the area which has a surplus population—Kildare—or from Louth. It has to come from Meath and if it has to come from Meath it has to come from north County Meath. I am satisfied that the only area that it would be feasible to add to the County of Cavan in order to make up the deficiency in population is in north County Meath and the fact that Deputy Tully's forebears happen to have come from that area has nothing to do with it any more than the fact that the forebears of the Minister for Defence came from the same area. Neither has the fact that Deputy Farrelly happens to reside in the area. That is a fact. It is just an accident that apparently these three individuals happen to be associated with this part of north County Meath. There was nowhere else that this adjustment with Cavan could reasonably be made. Cavan has always been a constituency on its own. I think it would be a wrong step to combine it with County Monaghan particularly in view of the fact that, on the basis of the national average of voters per Deputy, Cavan would be fully entitled to three seats without any adjustment whatsoever.
It is of course questionable, when a transfer of population from one county to another is inevitable, whether it is the most desirable thing to minimise that transfer or to transfer a sizeable proportion so that the transferred population would form a fairly considerable element in the new constituency, or whether they should be, as has been argued by Deputy Hogan and others, made as few as possible in which case they would form an insignificant part of the new constituency.
The peculiar thing about the Opposition is that they argue from directly opposite points of view on the same subject. On the one hand, I am accused of having carried out a particularly skilful gerrymander to weaken the Fine Gael and Labour candidates in Meath and to strengthen the Fianna Fáil Deputy and potential Deputies in Cavan. On the other hand Deputy Clinton, who I agree has displayed a greater acquaintanceship with County Meath than with County Dublin——
Comment on this
Deputy Clinton tells me this will all rebound to the benefit of the Fine Gael Party in all these counties. Well, whatever that can be described as if it is a fact I do not think it can be described as a skilful gerrymander on my part because I can assure Deputy Clinton that although he may think to the contrary the last thing that is present to my mind is to benefit the Fine Gael Party in any way.
Comment on this
The Minister states that his solution here involves the least disruption. He talks about displaying the limits of hypocrisy and fraud. As far as his Party are concerned——
Comment on this
Surely the Minister knows that Fianna Fáil were split down the middle and that one Minister on television admitted that he had warned them that they would be beaten by 100,000 votes? The Minister stands up and accuses the Opposition and says it was cemented by the Opposition. It was cemented on you by the people of this country and you suffered an overwhelming defeat and you were beaten by over 240,000 votes. The plan that we have suggested to you would mean transfers of only one portion of voters, 8,568 voters from Meath into Louth. By doing that you could have Louth a four-seater, Meath a three-seater and Cavan and Monaghan a five-seater. Instead of that, your proposal transfers from one electoral area in Louth 8,374; another 5,780, roughly, from Louth into Monaghan; from Meath into Monaghan, 3,900 odd; from Meath into Cavan 1,827; from another electoral area of Meath into Cavan, 3,829 and from Kildare into Meath, 5,441 voters. You propose these transfers from four different counties and then you have the hypocrisy and the effrontery and the arrogance to get up here and to tell us that your——
Comment on this
——that the Minister's change involves the least disruption. If the Minister tells us that, words must have lost their meaning and we would want to go back to the old Oxford dictionary for the meaning of the words "least disruption" as the Minister seems to understand them.
Comment on this
It all depends on what the Deputy means. Disruption of what? Is it disruption of county boundaries, which his Party have been arguing over the past few months is completely irrelevant, or disruption of the existing situation?
Comment on this
According to Deputy L'Estrange now in February, 1969, county boundaries should be treated as sacrosanct although in October, 1968, we got a decision from the people that these things were irrelevant.
Comment on this
Apparently I am to ignore all other considerations, to ignore the existing pattern of representation and to create such ridiculous constituencies as the unit of Cavan and Monaghan for the sake of adhering to county boundaries which were held by the Opposition Parties to be completely irrelevant during the debate on the referendum. I will just give one quotation to show that this is so. In Volume 235 No. 1 of the Official Report for Tuesday, 28th May, 1968, at column 145, Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick (Cavan) who at that time was the official Fine Gael spokes man on local government matters—apparently he is not any longer, but in May he was— said:
The Minister seems to think that county boundaries are sacred and that the counties and constituencies should coincide identically. I do not think that there is anything sacred about county boundaries. For example, for years back, we have had county managers managing two counties.
He went on to say at column 146:
Therefore, there is nothing sacred about county boundaries—there never has been—but if I understand the case the Minister is making correctly, he seems to be saying that constituencies should coincide with county boundaries and that each county should be a constituency.
Fine Gael can change their feet from month to month, from week to week and even, in fact, Fine Gael Deputies change their feet in the same speech on this subject. We have been consistent all along but we have had a decision both from the courts and from the people that the county boundaries are not the important thing and I am satisfied that the scheme of constituencies for this area which I have proposed is the most reasonable one and is the scheme which will cause the least disruption to the present pattern of representation in the area, that we will continue with a Cavan constituency, with a Monaghan constituency, a Louth constituency, a Meath constituency and a Kildare constituency. If as Fine Gael represent this will benefit Fianna Fáil and also benefit Fine Gael then it appears to me that it is only the single seat that the Labour Party have in those five constituencies that is involved and they seem to be making the least complaint about it.
Comment on this
In reply to the Minister he need not talk about Fianna Fáil being consistent or about Fine Gael's consistency. As far as Fine Gael are concerned they are always consistent in observing the wishes of the Irish people and as far as this Bill is concerned the Fianna Fáil Party certainly are not consistent because the people spoke out loudly and defeated their proposal by over 240,000 votes. I want to put that on the record of the House. When the Minister speaks about Deputy Tom Fitzpatrick not being the spokesman I want to say to him that he had to go to a funeral.
Comment on this
We want to know how you stand with your Taoiseach when you go out and make a speech that Fianna Fáil are going back to their policy of doing away with restoring the Irish language. That is what you said recently. You stated also some minutes ago that there was a decision given by the Irish people on October 16th that the constituencies were irrelevant. There was no such decision given. There was a decision given by the Irish people that they would not trust the Fianna Fáil Government, that they did not stand for their arrogance and their dictatorial methods. There was a decision given by the Irish people that as far as they were concerned they were in favour of the retention of proportional representation. That is the decision that was given on the 16th October by the Irish people. The Irish people gave their decision in that huge anti-Government vote on that date.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): The Minister has said that this arrangement which he has suggested for the people in his proposal will cause less disturbance with regard to the shift in population. That is an extraordinary statement. In order to preserve Cavan as a three-seater, in order to preserve Monaghan as a three-seater, he has made substantial movements of population from other countries. For example, from Monaghan to Cavan the transfer is 5,656; from Monaghan to Meath the transfer is 6,426; from Louth to Meath the transfer is 7,532 and from Kildare to Meath the transfer is 5,041. That is a total transfer of 24,655 people from outside their county. The total transfer of population under the Minister's scheme for the whole country is 101,000. Deputy L'Estrange has said it could be done, and provide reasonable constituencies, with a transfer of population of 40,000. As a matter of fact it can be done with a figure a little over 20,000. The amount of transfer he is doing in order to preserve Cavan and Monaghan as two three-seaters would suffice to provide reasonable constituencies for the entire country. Instead of having a transfer of 101,000 of population it could be something a little over 20,000. The Minister has been consistent. He did threaten before the referendum that if his proposal was not carried he would butcher each constituency in the country and bedad he has done it.
Comment on this
Deputy Hogan, of course, knows it is not merely in order to make up the deficiency in the Cavan or Monaghan population that there has to be a transfer from Meath, Louth and Kildare. He is well aware of the fact that County Kildare with a population of 66,404 has too great a population for three seats, that the same applies with regard to Louth and Meath and that the interpretation of the Constitution, which his Party procured by their action in the court, requires those counties to be adjusted quite apart altogether from the situation in Cavan and Monaghan. As I said, there are innumerable ways in which this arrangement can be carried out and it is a matter of opinion which of the many ways is preferable. I think the least desirable thing to do would be to create such an unnatural and unreasonable constituency as Cavan and Monaghan. In his reference to disturbance of population Deputy Hogan has conveniently ignored the fact that his solution involves the addition of 45,702 Monaghan people to Cavan.
Comment on this
The Minister is most unreasonable in this argument. Does the Minister realise the distance from Crossakeel to Dowra and Rathkenny to the Fermanagh border? It is absolutely ridiculous to expect any Deputy in a constituency like that to look after the interests of the people. Would the Minister have common sense and rectify this? The referendum and the speeches during the campaign have nothing to do with the revision of the constituencies. I would appeal to the Minister even at this stage to look at this again and change this.
Comment on this
The Deputies opposite made the exact opposite arguments some months ago. Distances were of no relevance then. At least in opting so far as possible for three-seat constituencies we have reduced the distance to be covered to the minimum because three-seat constituencies are the smallest constituencies which are permissible under the Constitution.
Comment on this
I am not quite clear in relation to what is happening with Monaghan and Cavan whether I can raise questions relating to parts of Kildare that are being put into Meath. I do not mind in the slightest whether I do it now or later on when the amendments are reached numerically. It is entirely a matter for the Chair and I am quite happy to deal with it to suit the Chair or anybody's convenience but I do not want to be caught afterwards by not raising it at this point and being precluded from raising it later on.
Comment on this
A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, have we dealt with the portion of Meath that is going into Monaghan?
Comment on this
The portion as related in the Schedule has now been disposed of. In relation to the constituency of Clare there is an amendment by the Minister. In regard to amendments Nos. 7 and 8, amendment No. 7 is consequential on amendment No. 8 and amendments Nos. 19 and 27 are also consequential on amendment No. 8. It is suggested that amendments Nos. 7, 8, 19, and 27 be taken together.
CLARE.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 4, in the second column of the entry relating to Clare, to delete "Clare-Galway" and to substitute "Clare-South Galway".
The sole purpose of this amendment is to change the name of the constituency of Clare-Galway to Clare-South Galway in order to avoid confusion between the name of the constituency and the well-known Claregalway area which is in the constituency of West Galway.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): This is merely a subterfuge to appease the people of Clare who have been transferred into County Galway. The Minister proposes to establish a new constituency here by the transfer of a substantial amount of population from Clare. In fact, the transfer amounts to 14,765 people from Clare to Clare-Galway. This is a substantial transfer of population of County Clare and reduces Clare constituency to a three-seater. If the Minister is concerned with cutting down the number of people being transferred from outside the counties into other counties he could solve the matter more simply by transferring some population from East Galway into Clare and leave Clare as a four-seater. A transfer of 2,805 people from Galway would leave Clare with sufficient population for a four-seater. It does not matter an awful lot where these areas might be but a transfer from the region of Gort and Kilbeachy into Clare would allow Clare to remain a four-seater and you could still have West Galway as a three-seater and East Galway as a four-seater.
Comment on this
A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, tuigim go bhfuil sé de dhualgas ar an Teachtá Ó hÓgáin labhairt i dtaobh dáilceantair Cláir. Ní ar an Rialtas atá an locht ach ar na daoine a thug a votaí in aghaidh an reifrinn agus an chuir iachall ar an Aire agus ar an Rialtas de réir an Bhunreachta athrú a dhéanamh. Chomh fada is a bhaineann an cheist liomsa, ní raibh Contae an Chláir mar ainm ar an dúthaigh go dtí gur chuir Éibhlis féin an bhainríon iachall ar Shiarriam Chontae an Chláir a ghairm de na sean dúithchi Corca Baiscinn, Corca Rua agus Dal gCais. B'shin iad na seanteora. D'imigh an lá sin agus tháinig an lá seo. Roint bhlian ó shin cuireadh cuid d'oirthear Contae na Gaillimhe isteach le Contae an Chláir. Ní rabhadar ró-shásta bheith ag teacht isteach linne. Is mór é an meas atá ag an dá mhuintir sin ar a chéile.
Tá muintir Chontae an Chláir lántsásta roinnt a dhéanamh de réir an dlí agus de réir an Bhunreachta. Is cuimhin liomsa breis is 50 bliain ó shin in aimsir na trioblóide na daoine a bhí ag troid ag dul sall is anall thar na teora. Bhí fáilte rompu i ngach áit. Tá súil agam go mbeidh an fháilte chéanna rompu fhaid a bheidh Éire beo.
Pé roinnt a dhéanfaidh an tAire i láthair na huaire beidh sé de réir an Bhunreachta.
Comment on this
Mar adeir an Teachta Ó Ceallaigh, ní orainn-se atá an locht go bhfuil an t-athrú seo le déanamh, go mór mhór o thárla go raibh a fhios agam go raibh níos mó ná an neart de votóirí i gCláir le haghaidh na ceithre suiocháin atá ann fé lathair. Theastaigh uainn gan aon cur isteach a dhéanamh ar an gcontae sin. Ach sé a mhalairt ar fad de scéal a bhí ag an bhFreasúra. Dheineadar airgóint anseo ar feadh míosa agus sa tSeanad ag iarraidh an taobh eile den scéal a chur i bhfeidhm orainn. Rinneadar an rud céanna i dtaobh an reifrinn. De thoradh an reifrinn tá sé orainn an cineál seo d'athrú a dhéanamh anois. Deir an Teachta Ó hÓgáin anois gur cóir dúinn a laghad agus is féidir de dhaoine a athrú as chontae amháin go chontae eile. Ach a mhalairt de phort a bhí aige i rith na díospóireachta anseo nuair a bhí seans againn an scéal sin a chur faoi réir agus athrú oiriúnach a dhéanamh ar an mBunreacht. Is de bharr toradh an reifrinn anois go gcaithfear a leithéid seo a dhéanamh. Deirtear anois gur cóir dúinn an méid is lua is féidir a athrú. Sa slí seo, i gContae an Chláir, tá 14,765 daoine ag dul isteach sa dáilcheantar nua. Mar a fheicim an scéal, is féidir le muintir an Chláir atá ag dul isteach sa dáilcheantar nua Teachta a thogha. Sa slí seo beidh ceathrar Teachtaí ag Contae an Chláir mar atá siad i dteideal a bheith d'ainneoin an caoi ina bhfuil an Bunreacht.
I think that Deputy Hogan's attitude today is in very marked contrast with his attitude and the attitude of his Party during the time when it was possible to do something with regard to what is being forced on me now in regard to this Electoral Bill.
Apparently, his attitude now is to try and have the least possible number of people transferred from one county to another in so far as actual Dáil representation is concerned. After arguing for months here in this House and in the Seanad and throughout the country that this whole question of county boundaries was completely irrelevant, now apparently the whole objective, we are told, should be to minimise the total percentage of the population which will be required to be represented by Deputies from other counties over the country as a whole.
It is much more realistic to consider each individual problem that arises on its merits and in so far as this particular adjustment that is required by the Constitution between Clare and Galway is concerned, it is quiet a relevant factor that in County Clare at present the number of electors per Deputy is actually higher than the national average and here we are transferring a substantial portion of the County of Clare to this new constituency which has to be created and in that constituency they will form a significant portion of the population. In fact, the part of Clare that is being transferred to the proposed constituency of Clare-South Galway will be sufficient to elect a Deputy from Clare in that constituency so that it is quite possible that as a result of this, Clare will in fact have the four seats to which it would be entitled if it were permissible to arrange the constituency on the basis of one man, one vote.
Deputy Hogan adopts the opposite attitude. He thinks that we should put a portion of Galway into the constitutency of Clare or into the county of Clare where it would form an insignificant part of the total population. It is just a question of approach and something that would not arise if it were permissible to take cognisance of administrative boundaries, but the Deputy and his Party have already seen to it that that will not be permissible.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I do not understand the Minister when he asserts that we on this side of the House regard county boundaries as of no significance. I remember stating here that I regarded the county boundaries as of significance, not from the emotional aspect or the sentimental aspect but from the present administrative viewpoint. I cited at that time the question in my own constituency of having to travel into West Waterford where there were approximately 11,000 people and where I was not a local representative. I was a county councillor for South Tipperary but I was not a county councillor in the other constituency. I found it a handicap in so far as that half the problems one gets from constituents are local authority problems. It is not the emotional or the sentimental aspect of it that I am dealing with but the fact that I think central representation and local representation should be, in so far as is possible, coterminous. That is the reason why I have been advocating the transfer of people from outside the county boundaries. In nearly all cases the counties are in the local administrative areas, with the exception of Tipperary where the county boundary embraces two administrative areas, two Ridings, North and South. I have given the Minister here the figures he has arranged for a very large transfer from Clare into Galway. I would be inclined to call it almost a take-over bid and I would suggest that a smaller transfer from Galway to Clare and areas other than the ones I am mentioning could be worked out but a smaller transfer would suffice.
Galway has a population of 148,340 after transfers but the area I would mention for a transfer from Clare would be the district electoral division of Ardmullivan, which has a population of 512, Gort electoral division of 1,189, Beesh electoral division of 496, Kilbeacanty electoral division of 319, Ballycardon electoral division of 289. That is a total transfer of 2,805. That is a very much smaller figure than the Minister's proposal to transfer 14,765. That is a huge transfer of people from Clare into Galway and quite unnecessary when by a relatively small transfer, Clare could be kept a four-seater.
The Minister mentions that there is a higher electoral percentage in Clare than the national average and that is all the more reason why they should be entitled to retain their four seats and preserve Clare as a traditional county and a traditional constituency. I find that most of these people who are transferred are dissatisfied, certainly those in West Waterford are dissatisfied by being transferred. The Minister now would like to put the notion across that a big bulk of transfer of population is quite all right, that they will bring, so to speak, their own civilisation into the new county and their own interests and their own voting power and their own strength. But, in point of fact, unless one county is joined up with another, with transfers of population up to 9,000, 10,000 or 12,000, all one does is to create dissatisfied pockets.
I believe that if a gallup poll were taken among all these people whom it is proposed to transfer from Clare into Galway, it would probably be found that these people would opt to remain in Clare and there is no point in putting a fancy name on the constituency, like Clare-Galway, Galway-Clare or anything else. They will still be transferred out of their administrative county of Clare into a new constituency to meet the political notions of the present Minister.
Comment on this
Táim fíor-bhuíoch den Teachta Ó hÓgáin as ucht na spéise atá aige i muintir an Chláir. Ní hiad muintir an Chláir atá i gceist in aon chor san rud san.
Dá mbéimís uilig macánta déarfaimis nach bhfuil i gceist ach cúrsaí polaitíochta agus nach bhfuil leas an phobail i gceist ach chomh fada agus a bhaineann sé le toghcháin. Bhí an Teachta Ó hÓgáin agus Teachtaí nach é thíos linn deich mí ó shin agus ní mar a chéile an port atá acu inniu agus a bhí acu an uair sin. Tuigeann sé go maith nach bhfuil aon ghuth aige anseo ar son muintir an Chláir. Níl aon Teachta ag Fine Gael i gContae an Chláir i láthair na huaire. Tuigeann sé go bhfuil sé de dhualgas air nó ar dhuine éigin, ós rud é nach bhfuil aon Teachta acu i gContae an Chláir, an chúis sin a phlé chomh maith agus chomh géar agus is féidir leis. Sin a bhfuil le rá agam i dtaobh na ceiste.
Comment on this
Bhí an ceart ag an Teachta Ó Ceallaigh nuair a dúirt sé nach iad muintir an Chláir atá i gceist ag an Teachta Ó hÓgáin, ach go gceapann sé go mbeadh seans níos fearr ag a Pháirtí féin i ndáilcheantar le ceithre suíocháin seachas dáilceanntar le trí suíocháin.
It may be true, as Deputy Hogan says, that county boundaries were important. I am well aware of the fact that one can get exactly diametrically opposed quotations on this subject from practically every Fine Gael Deputy who has spoken on the matter but if Deputy Hogan adverted to the importance of county boundaries I think he will agree that it was on this particular Bill or, possibly on the 1961 Bill, that this happened. At the time when it was possible to do something about it the attitude of Fine Gael was entirely different. At the time when it was proposed to make it permissible to take account of established administrative boundaries, the Deputy and his Party adopted a completely different attitude, that these were matters which were of no importance whatever. Now that that issue has been decided, and we have both the High Court decision on it, which the Deputy's Party obtained, and the decision of the people — which they were responsible for ensuring — that these things are not relevant, they suddenly become of the highest possible relevance to the Fine Gael Party. We have been pressed to do something, which they have already ensured that we will not be permitted to do in accordance with the Constitution.
The arguments which have been put forward here section after section are completely bogus and hypocritical and show the insincerity of the Fine Gael Party on this question. Deputy Hogan in conjunction with the rest of his colleagues campaigned against a proposal to permit administrative boundaries to be taken into consideration. With regard to his argument that it would be more desirable to have a small transfer into County Galway of County Clare rather than have a significant portion of County Clare combined with a not much greater portion of County Galway, that is a matter of opinion. He would appear to think that it would be preferable to transfer a small population from Galway into a county in which they would be completely submerged, and in which they would be of no significance as a community, rather than the transfer which we propose of a significant area of County Clare being put with a portion of County Galway which will form an entity capable of electing a Clare Deputy to this new constituency. I believe under the Deputy's suggestion the people would consider themselves to be virtually disenfranchised.
A few months after a referendum on this very subject has been held, the Deputy suggests that if a gallup poll were to be held the result of that poll would be an indication that this type of transfer of constituencies would be undesirable. However, we have had something more reliable than a gallup poll; we have had a referendum on the subject and the people decided, in the light of the urgings of Deputy Hogan and his colleagues, that these are matters of no importance whatsoever and the very small amount of scope in order to take account of these things which we regard as practicable should not be allowed and the amount of scope which was suggested was smaller than exists in any democracy that we know of. The people in agreement with Deputy Hogan and his colleagues have decided that this should not be available but that the type of mutilation of county boundaries which is being provided for in this Bill must be proceeded with and proceeded with after every census of population is published.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In pages 4 and 5, in the first column, to delete "Clare-Galway" in both places where it occurs and to substitute "Clare-South Galway" in both such places.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I have already intimated some objections to this question of the creation of a new constituency of Clare-Galway and I have briefly given my reasons to the effect that to transfer a small area from Galway into Clare would still leave sufficient population in Galway to form a three-seater in West Galway and a four-seater in East Galway. In fact, not alone could that be done but the transfer of a small population from Galway to Roscommon can also be effected and still leave West Galway a three-seater and East Galway a four-seater. The suggestion I am making is that we can deal with Galway after the proposed transfer which I mentioned to Clare and which I have itemised giving the district electoral divisions and by a further transfer to Roscommon to allow Roscommon to remain as a county entity and as a three-seater.
Comment on this
The Deputy may be under a misapprehension. At the moment we are dealing with the constituency of Clare-South Galway. The amendments have just been dealt with.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I am debating the necessity for creating such a consituency as Clare-South Galway and in doing that I have to try to outline how Galway should be preserved as a county, Clare as a county and Roscommon as a county, with minor transfers of population, and that it is unnecessary to create this new hybrid constituency of Clare-Galway. In that respect I have to mention the transfers that must be made out of County Galway so as to leave it in such a position that it can form a three-seater and a four-seater. In that respect I am anticipating what is later on in the Schedule. I can deal with it later on if necessary but I thought it desirable to raise it now to show my reasons for opposing the formation of a new constituency entitled Clare-Galway. If it suits the House better, I can speak about that at a later stage because the Minister tells me—and I think he is correct—that West Galway, North-East Galway, is coming up at a later stage, so I can deal with it then or now.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page, 5 to delete the entry relating to Cork City (North) and to substitute the following:
Name | Area | Number of Members
Cork City (North-West) | That part of the county borough of Cork lying north-west of a line drawn as follows: | Three
commencing at the junction of the western boundary of the townland of Farrandahadore More with the county borough boundary, thence in a northerly direction along the said townland boundary to its junction with Wilton Road, thence commencing in a north-easterly direction and proceeding along Wilton Road and Victoria Cross Road to its junction with Western Road, thence commencing in an easterly direction and proceeding along Western Road, Lancaster Quay, Washington Street West and Washington Street to its junction with Grand Parade, thence in a north-westerly direction along Grand Parade to its junction with St. Patrick's Street, thence commencing in an easterly direction and proceeding along St. Patrick's Street and St. Patrick's Bridge to its intersection by the River Lee (North Channel), thence commencing in a south-easterly direction and proceeding along the River Lee (North Channel), and the River Lee to its intersection by the county borough boundary.
The purpose of these amendments is to change the dividing line between the two Cork city constituencies from along Model Farm Road, Magazine Road, Bandon Road, Barrack Street, Vicar Street, Dean Street, Saint Finbar's Place, Proby's Quay, French's Quay, South Gate Bridge and the southern branch of the Lee (as set out in the Bill as read a Second Time) to along the western boundary of Farrandahadore More townland which is immediately west of Saint Joseph's College, Wilton, Wilton Road, Victoria Cross Road, Western Road, Lancaster Quay, Washington Street, Grand Parade, Saint Patrick's Street, Saint Patrick's Bridge and the northern channel of the Lee. This, I think, would result in a more natural division of the city. As the new line runs from the south-west to the north-east of the city, it is also proposed to change the names of the constituencies from Cork City (North) and Cork City (South) to Cork City (North-West) and Cork City (South-East). The amendments do not propose any change in the proposed overall representation of the city —each of the two constituencies will return three Members. The proposed constituency of Cork City (North-West) would have a population of 60,989 which is an average per Deputy of 20,330 and Cork City (South-West) will have a population of 61,157 which is an average per Deputy of 20,386.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 5, to delete the entry relating to Cork City (South) and to substitute the following:
Name | Area | Number of Members
Cork City (South-East) | The county borough of Cork, except the part thereof which is comprised in the constituency of Cork City (North-West). | Three
That is covered by the decision on the previous amendment which affects the rearrangement of these two constituencies.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 6, in the second column of the entry relating to North-East Cork to delete "Imphrick" and to substitute "Kilmaclenine" and to delete "Streamhill,".
The purpose of this amendment is to transfer the district electoral division of Kilmaclenine, a former rural district of Mallow, from Mid-Cork to North-East Cork in exchange for the district electoral divisions of Imphrick and Streamhill, also former rural district of Mallow. Kilmaclenine forms part of the immediate hinterland of Mallow and should be included with Mallow in the North-East Cork constituency. The transfer of Kilmaclenine to North-East Cork would bring the population of Mid-Cork below the minimum required for four seats and it is proposed to transfer the district electoral divisions of Imphrick and Streamhill to Mid-Cork from North-East Cork to make up the required population. The result of the change will be to increase the population of Mid-Cork from 76,318 which was an average per Deputy of 19,079 to 76,352 which is an average per Deputy of 19,088 and to reduce the population of North-East Cork from 79,845 which was an average per Deputy of 19,961 to 79,811 which is an average per Deputy of 19,953.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 6, in the second column of the entry, relating to North-East Donegal, to delete "South-West Donegal" and to substitute "Donegal-Leitrim".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 12 is consequential on amendment No. 13 and, perhaps, by agreement, we could take amendments Nos. 1, 12, 13 and 29 together and, by agreement, 21, 26, 28 and 30 together——
Comment on this
——also dealing with a change of names of constituencies involving County Leitrim could conveniently be taken in this group.
Comment on this
County Leitrim is divided between the proposed constituencies of South-West Donegal, Sligo and Roscommon. It was argued here on the Second Stage that the name "Leitrim" should be included in these constituencies and I am accepting that suggestion. The purpose of these amendments is to include Leitrim in the name of these constituencies. If the amendments are accepted they will be renamed Donegal-Leitrim, Sligo-Leitrim and Roscommon-Leitrim.
Comment on this
This is a political device by Fianna Fáil to put Leitrim back on the map. Again, the Minister could not tell the truth. He told us that the Opposition sought this. It is a wellknown fact that all the Fianna Fáil county councillors came up to Dáil Éireann—we all met them—and they argued to have Leitrim returned to a constituency on its own. Fianna Fáil met them here and despite the fact that they were giving advice from the grass-roots the Minister refused to agree to their request. Leitrim is being knocked off the map. It is not sufficient for Fianna Fáil to have driven 60,000 or 70,000 people from the west out of the country in the past 20 years. That is why this measure is necessary. If we had good government the people would be still in the west and there would be no need for Fianna Fáil or any other Party to give extra seats to Dublin and take them away from the people in the west. Due to maladministration and the fact that Fianna Fáil have driven over 60,000 people from the west of Ireland in the past ten or 15 years we now find that seats must be taken from them.
The Bill shows that the political knife has been used to do much unnecessary surgery, indeed butchering. It is a typical example of Fianna Fáil gerrymandering and shows how far they are prepared to go in a bid to keep their seats and maintain themselves in office. We know that on the west coast where they think there is a chance that the people will still support them they have three-seat constituencies in the hope that they will get two seats, with Fine Gael getting one and that no other Party will have a chance. In Dublin City where they know they are about to be annihilated they have four-seat constituencies hoping that by some miracle they can hold on to two seats out of four.
Coming back to Donegal, I want to make the same charge as I made before. I do so with full deliberation because we know it is quite true. Donegal could have been left as a five-seat constituency by transferring 7,294 voters into Sligo and making Sligo a three-seat constituency and having Roscommon and Leitrim a five-seat constituency. By doing that there would be only one change and a very minor disruption but Fianna Fáil were not satisfied with that. Despite the fact that in the referendum on 16th October last the people spoke out clearly in favour of retaining proportional representation and despite the fact that the Minister understands well that PR works better in large constituencies of four, five, six or seven seats, he has wiped Leitrim off the map and has drafted 11,072 people from Leitrim into Roscommon to make it a three-seater; transferred 11,533 people from Leitrim to Sligo to make Sligo a three-seater and transferred 7,947 people from North Leitrim into Donegal to make the constituency of South-West Donegal a three-seat constituency. Instead of having one change and disturbing 7,294 voters we now have three changes involving over 30,000 voters.
The Minister will tell us that he is doing this so that we shall have the least possible disruption of population in the area. He will stand up here in his usual hypocritical way and with the usual effrontery that he displays in this House and tell us that before we finish. The ideal solution would have been to make Donegal a five-seat constituency. Again the grass-roots boys said: "If you do that the Protestant Association in Donegal will get one seat out of five and we cannot trust the man elected as he would not come under the Party Whip and could not be made toe the line and vote with the Fianna Fáil Party."
Therefore, despite all the Fianna Fáil preaching about the 1916 Proclamation to cherish all the children of the nation equally, this is a deliberate attempt to make certain that those people who pay rent and rates and who are entitled to representation here will not get a representative from Donegal in the Dáil. So instead we have the transfer of 7,947 people from Leitrim into South-West Donegal and we have Donegal divided in two to make two three-seat constituencies. Fianna Fáil are hoping that by some piece of luck they might get two cut of three seats. We can be assured they will fail in this but we object to the gerrymandering and the methods used here by the Minister in trying to perpetuate himself and his Party in office.