We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968 — Committee Stage.

Contributions 165–327 of 495. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 35 of 1968 ›

He is about 100 years behind the times.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange is fighting a pitched battle when all the other troops that were on that side have deserted him and it means that he now has available to himself more muck to throw than he had previously. He is certainly doing it. It is very mischievous and dishonest on his part to suggest, in addition to the other suggestions he made about gerrymandering, that there is any discrimination against the religious minority in the constituencies under discussion in this section.

Comment on this

There certainly is.

Comment on this

That is quite untrue. At the moment in Donegal County Council we have religious minorities there in the various Parties. This is something that has taken place only in recent years and it is good that these people are playing their part in all political Parties, so much so that at the moment, outside of the major political Parties, there is only one county councillor of the religious minority in Donegal County Council. Indeed, it could not be said that he is there as such. It is very low politics to suggest that what we are now discussing, the divisions which have been made, have been done with this object in view. It is untrue. Thank God, the religious minority are playing their part in all political Parties not only in Donegal but everywhere else.

Comment on this

What is the reason for doing it then?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

Let us take the Opposition's alternative. Deputy L'Estrange suggested taking a strip from Donegal town, though Leitrim——

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

He said even this would not be enough. If you could do it by taking a certain number of the population from Donegal and putting them into Leitrim, then you would have a case. However, the suggestion is this: put 7,000 people from Donegal into a constituency which then would run from Donegal town right through Bundoran and, on the other hand, from Glenfarn or Blackline on the Cavan-Leitrim border, down to the most southerly tip not of Leitrim but of Roscommon. That is the suggestion Deputy L'Estrange has made. It is that we should take pieces of Donegal and add them to pieces of two other counties to make a five-seat constituency. What a ridiculous, serpentine constituency that would be.

Comment on this

What is it now? It runs from Manorhamilton to Tory Island.

Comment on this

The suggestion is to form a five-seat constituency by taking portions of Donegal, from Donegal Bay in a lengthy strip to the southern side of Bundoran, then to take a portion from Blackline or Glenfarn in Leitrim and to go right through to Carrick-on-Shannon and into Roscommon and through Roscommon to the southern tip of that county. Surely that is the most ridiculous suggestion we have had from the Opposition.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like to see the map?

Comment on this

I should not like to see that map. The Deputy can keep that kind of a map—I do not want it.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister is proposing.

Comment on this

The other suggestion is to make Donegal a five-seat constituency. Let us examine that, having looked at the type of five-seater Deputy L'Estrange proposes—running from Donegal town right down to the most southerly tip of Roscommon. The Deputy would also have a five-seat constituency in Donegal. The distance from Malin Head to Bundoran is 100 miles. Cut off at Donegal town, it is still 80 miles.

Comment on this

Donegal South West is now 109 miles long.

Comment on this

I do not believe what the Deputy is saying. That is the kind of set-up he would impose on the people of Donegal, having first shoved a number of them into Leitrim. If this man were Minister for Local Government and if he were allowed to do this sort of thing throughout the country, one could only term it unreasonable and illogical because it is just an excuse to get across the point of gerrymandering and of religious discrimination. There is no reason in it, there is no logic or geography in it. However, he is prepared to do it.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): On this question of Donegal, the Minister's proposal to establish two constituencies there——

Comment on this

To retain them.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): To do so he has drawn too heavily on Leitrim. It is not necessary to transfer the large amount of population he proposes from North Leitrim to Donegal. The figure I have is 8,997. Even conceding the Minister's idea of retaining two three-seat constituencies in Donegal, the county needs 5,619 extra population to form two three-seaters, and Sligo-Leitrim can spare, at most, 5,723 to remain a four-seater. A transfer of 5,641 may be made from North Leitrim to South Donegal by the addition of the following: Tullaghan, Gubacreeny, Kinlough, Aghavoghill, Aghanlish, Aghalateeve, Melvin, Glencar, Glenaide, Ballaghameehan, Manorhamilton, Kiltyclogher, Glenfarn and Glenboy, a total population of 5,642. This transfer would reduce Sligo-Leitrim to 76,193 and would increase Donegal to 114,191. Both suffice respectively for a four-seater and a six-seater. South Donegal, as a three-seater, can be made up of Bundoran Urban District, Ballyshannon Rural District, Donegal Rural District, Glenties Rural District, Stranorlar Rural District, involving 16,632, plus 5,642 from Sligo-Leitrim.

North Donegal would then consist of Letterkenny, Milford, Dunfanaghy and Inishowen, and the district electoral divisions of Meencargagh, Lettermore and St. Johnstown, which would give a population of 57,097. By having a lesser transfer from Leitrim, you could allow sufficient population to form a four-seater for Sligo-Leitrim and you could have two three-seaters in Donegal. By working on these lines there would be a much lesser transfer of population and a much better effort to retain existing county boundaries than through the Minister's suggestion. He introduces Leitrim as a mere sop to the people there, having obliterated their county. He is transferring a considerable number of the population from North Leitrim to South Donegal, from mid-Leitrim to Sligo and from South Leitrim to Roscommon, though with a transfer of 5,642 from Leitrim to Donegal he could have constituted two reasonable three-seaters in Donegal and a four-seater in Sligo-Leitrim. The greater part of Leitrim will remain as an entity and Roscommon can remain as a constituency on its own by the transfer of the two small areas I have mentioned and there will then be no need to bring the urban area of Athlone into the western counties.

Comment on this

I have different views on this matter of the re-alignment of constituencies from those of my colleague, Deputy L'Estrange. While it is true to say that this is being done with a view to keeping the Fianna Fáil Party in power, it is not true to say that it is being done to keep a minority religious Party out in the wilderness. We must be realistic. If Donegal were one constituency the Ceann Comhairle would be returned unopposed and that would leave only four seats; in that situation it would be utterly impossible for any minority Party to gain any of those four seats. The only purpose behind this is to consolidate the present Fianna Fáil strength in Donegal. The Minister came to the Fianna Fáil Convention in Letterkenny. That Convention was pretty well reported, better reported than it was attended.

Comment on this

The hall would not hold any more.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Convention was held on the same night and the people left that Convention, having swamped the local hotel and eaten all the food available there, and, when they landed up at the Fianna Fáil Convention Restaurant, they found there was plenty there to eat and drink. Despite the Minister's presence it was not such a success at all. Indeed, it gave a fair indication of what the result of the referendum was going to be in that part of the country.

I see nothing in these proposals except gerrymandering. I see no reason why Donegal should not be one constituency with five seats. We can forget about the cat-calls of the Minister when he speaks to his converted brethren and tells them what Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Harte would like. That was the burden of his speech in the latter part of 1968 in Letterkenny. Indeed, I thank him for the publicity he gave me; he talked about little except what Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Harte had in mind, as if what we had in mind would influence the Minister for Local Government.

What I have in mind are natural geographical boundaries — mountain ridges, rivers, lakes and so on. There will be an election before the end of this year and, if this Party is given a mandate to form a Government, I will use my influence to ensure that natural boundaries are preserved. I suggest we give the Government this Bill and let the people decide whether or not this is gerrymandering. If the people are made to understand the far-reaching effects this type of thing can have, I believe the decision in the election will not be complimentary to the present Government. The people will tell the Minister, as they told him in the referendum, how far removed he is from reality.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This seems to be a Second Reading speech. We are discussing the constituency of Donegal.

Comment on this

We start with Donegal but what happens there has an effect on Leitrim, Sligo, Roscommon, Cavan, Mayo and, in fact, all over the country right down to Wexford. Donegal should be one constituency. There is no reason why it should not be a five-seat constituency. In round figures the population is 108,000. In 1961 it was 113,000. The average decline in population over the last 30 years was 1,111. We can take it then that in the last three years approximately 3,000 people left Donegal and the population at the moment, therefore, would be 105,000. If the five per cent tolerance is applied, which the Minister can legally apply under the Constitution, then no people would have to be transferred from Donegal to any other constituency. Donegal should be preserved with its ancient boundaries and no one should be transferred from Ballyshannon and Bundoran to Leitrim or to Sligo. The only realistic boundary is the natural boundary and I forecast that Donegal will have to be adjusted back again in the future because the population will fall to such a degree. The population will also fall in Leitrim and Sligo. Of course, if Donegal were one unit then the last Fianna Fáil speaker, Deputy Cunningham, would not be here at all. Mark you, that is the only reason why the Minister has revised the boundaries in this particular fashion. Deputy Cunningham talked about the unwieldy proposition of Deputy L'Estrange. When one thinks of people in Dromahair and Manorhamilton in Leitrim, now deemed to be identical with the inhabitants of Tory Island, one wonders which proposition is the most unwieldy. I have never been to Tory Island, though I am a native of Donegal. I would suggest that less than three per cent of the people of Donegal have visited Tory Island. Yet, the Minister has the audacity to tell us that these people are the same as those living in Dromahair and Manorhamilton, with the same problems and the same kind of thinking.

Comment on this

I never suggested that.

Comment on this

But that is what the Minister has done.

Comment on this

That is what the Constitution makes me do.

Comment on this

It does not make the Minister do it. Under the Constitution, with a five per cent tolerance, Donegal could be one five-seat constituency. That is not too much to ask when one remembers that we celebrated last week the 50th anniversary of the First Dáil and in that First Dáil there were four Deputies elected from Donegal—Deputy Joseph Ward, Deputy Joseph Sweeney, Deputy Joseph Doherty and Deputy Edward Kelly. These four represented 168,000 people. That was the population of Donegal in 1918, 60,000 more than the present population. Yet the Minister for Local Government tells the House that he is forced under the Constitution to bring in the people living in Leitrim to keep two three-seat constituencies in Donegal. Is this one of the reasons why Senator Sheehy Skeffington was forced to withdraw certain remarks during the debates in the Mansion House?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the question before the House.

Comment on this

It is very relevant. In 1918 there were four men——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

According to the Deputy anything he says here is relevant. It is not relevant.

Comment on this

The relevancy is this. A fortnight ago Members of both Houses were summoned to a meeting in the Mansion House to commemorate the meeting of the First Dáil on 21st January, 1919, and the survivors of that Dáil were on the platform. Two of the people I have named were on the platform. One is on an extended visit to the United States of America and one has passed on to his just reward. I am pointing out that these four men——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is now discussing two constituencies. At the moment we are discussing the constituency of North-East Donegal.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see how it arises.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I want to submit that Deputy Harte is in order. He is dealing with the history of this constituency and showing that it has always been one constituency even in 1918. It is more relevant because it is a good reason why it should be retained as one constituency. That is the point Deputy Harte is developing.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would point out that it was not one constituency. It was two constituencies.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick is doing Deputy Harte an injustice. I am sure Deputy Harte is not suggesting Donegal was one constituency in 1918.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting it was one constituency.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick says the Deputy is. It shows the attention he is paying.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick is making the point that I am talking about North-East Donegal.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick said Deputy Harte said it was one constituency. He said it was one constituency in 1918.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): When history comes to be written the Minister and the referendum will not figure well in it.

Comment on this

The Deputy said it was one constituency in 1918. At least he said that was what Deputy Harte said.

Comment on this

I know it is difficult to follow the reasoning of the Minister.

Comment on this

I am listening and Deputy Fitzpatrick is not.

Comment on this

I would suggest with respect that if the Minister wants to convey his feelings to me through the Chair he should confine himself to his own feelings. He will get into a terrible muddle if he tries to say what Deputy Fitzpatrick is thinking. The Minister has blackguarded Deputy O'Donnell and myself for making statements which we did not make at all. I want to bring out in this debate—because he and other Members of the Cabinet declined to debate it in public during the referendum—what could be an alternative Electoral Bill.

The Electoral Bill before the House to me suggests gerrymandering of the first degree because it is there to consolidate the Fianna Fáil position in County Donegal. Some people may think my argument unreasonable, but I am telling the House that in 1918 four Members were elected to represent County Donegal, and they had fewer privileges than the six Members who represent it today. Their remuneration was much less if, indeed, they had any at all.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has nothing to do with the question before the House.

Comment on this

I want your guidance. I am talking about the present constituency of North-East Donegal and I think I am entitled to make an alternative proposal. Is not that so?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Relating to what?

Comment on this

If I do not accept the Minister's proposal for North-East Donegal, surely I am entitled to make the argument, if I am objecting to it, that there must be an alternative. Is not that so?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of remuneration does not arise.

Comment on this

The situation in 1918 is not an alternative.

Comment on this

Am I entitled to make the argument that there is an alternative to the Minister's proposal?

Comment on this

I am pointing out that the situation in 1918 is not an altertive.

Comment on this

I am addressing my question to the Chair.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy mentioned remuneration which would not arise at this stage.

Comment on this

Only in passing. If I am out of order I will withdraw because I want to respect the rulings of the Chair. My argument is that I do not accept the Minister's proposal for North-East Donegal and I am offering an alternative. If I offer an alternative, how can I move away from North-East Donegal without being involved in South-West Donegal which takes in the boundaries of the entire county?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be in order as I have already announced.

Comment on this

Thank you. Therefore the argument I put forward is that Donegal should not have two constituencies but one. The one constituency I propose is within the boundaries of Donegal. The population at the moment is 108,000 as laid down by the 1966 census. The population is declining at the rate of 1,111 per annum. This would perhaps suggest that the population is 105,000 and when you apply the five per cent tolerance of 20,000 per head of population per Deputy that would give you 105,000. Therefore, I can prove without any great drama that there is gerrymandering in this Bill to preserve Deputy Cunningham's seat. That is the elementary deduction from the political situation in Donegal. To support that argument I go back to 1918 to the First Dáil and say that four Members were elected. They had no travelling expenses. I do not know what remuneration they had. Probably it was very little. They had no free postage, no free telephones, and little or nothing to compensate them for coming from Donegal to Leinster House, as against the privileges we have today.

Comment on this

They did not come to Leinster House.

Comment on this

In North-East Donegal we have a Fianna Fáil Deputy with £2,500 and expenses, a Fianna Fáil Minister with £6,000, a State car, a private secretary and all expenses laid on.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see how this arises on the section we are dealing with at the moment which deals with townlands and areas. The question of remuneration or cars does not arise.

Comment on this

The townlands and areas I am talking about comprise the ancient county of Donegal. I do not want to go into the question of whether Urney West is in North-East Donegal or South-West Donegal. I know and anyone with any knowledge of geography knows that Urney West is in East Donegal. The former Minister for Local Government, either by getting his compass confused or something going wrong, described it as South-West Donegal. I am saying Urney West is in Donegal. Geographically it is in East Donegal.

I want Donegal to be one constituency with five Deputies. I am pointing out to the House that this would be no great disadvantage or no burden on any Deputy elected there. As Deputy Cunningham knows, if that were the position—I do not mean this as a personal slight: I respect Deputy Cunningham as one man respects another—it would be tough luck on Deputy Cunningham that he is in the part of Donegal that could not elect a Deputy. That is my summing up. Is not this correct? If Deputy Cunningham is to remain as a Fianna Fáil Deputy it might be Deputy Blaney who would go. That might suit me better.

Comment on this

It might be the Deputy himself.

Comment on this

Quite right, but I would lay odds on that.

Comment on this

The Deputy came at the bottom on the last occasion.

Comment on this

The position as I see it is that in County Donegal you have six TDs and you have two Fianna Fáil Senators and another Senator who is the Taoiseach's nominee. Yet the Minister has the audacity to tell us that Donegal would be without adequate representation if he allowed County Donegal to be one constituency with five seats. I am telling the House, lest it should go unnoticed in the country, that County Donegal should be one constituency with five TDs, four seats would be contested and you would have two Government Deputies and two Opposition Deputies. Unfortunately Deputy Cunningham would not be a Member of the House, or it might be that Deputy Cunningham might be elected and in that event it could be Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, who would go; or perhaps Deputy Blaney would be elected a Member and in that case it would be Deputy Joe Brennan, the Minister for Social Welfare, who would go. I do not know what the permutations would be but I am quite satisfied whoever was left out would be a Member from that side of the House. Of course, they would be sitting on this side of the House after the election.

In support of my argument I was telling the House that the four elected Members had no privileges whatsoever. They were representing 60,000 people more than the six Deputies are representing today. In my constituency there are a Government Deputy and a Minister of State and the Government Deputy has the same privileges, the same remuneration and the same travelling expenses as I have and I am quite satisfied. If I indicated that I was not going to contest another election there would be many members in my Party who would be anxious to get the nomination. The Minister has a total remuneration of £6,000 plus a private car, plus a private secretary, plus an all-in expense account and he has a Member of the other House to support him. There is a similar situation in the south-west. This is the type of representation that the Minister for Local Government maintains is not adequate to serve the people in North-West Donegal. If it is not, how does he explain the inadequacies of the 1918 general election when these four men—whose names will be written into history and will be remembered for more noble things than the present Minister for Local Government will be, if his name will ever be mentioned in history— were elected?

We could talk for the next hour about this matter and I would love to debate it for the next hour with Deputy Cunningham but if it were pushed to a division the Minister for Local Government would say: "We are sticking to our guns and Leitrim will disappear from the political map of the 26 Counties and we will have two constituencies in Donegal, not to preserve the status quo but to keep Deputy Cunningham in the House.” The Minister would push that through the Division Lobbies and it would become an accomplished fact. For that reason, I would not even oppose the Minister's proposal. I strongly object to it and will continue to do so. I am prepared to debate the matter with him outside any chapel gate—that is if he is allowed near any chapel gate after his attack on the clergy. I will debate in any part of Donegal, in Bundoran or Ballyshannon, the contents of this Electoral Bill and how it will affect the people. If he puts his arguments to them and I put mine, the people will adjudicate at a general election and I am satisfied that the answer they will give to the Minister is: “It is time you got out.” People in other parts of this country have been branded as gerrymanderers and if we were doing our duty we could give the Minister a formal transfer because they are looking for some type of leadership up there and we could do without him.

The Bill which has been introduced by the Minister should have been introduced in 1961. The census of population in 1961 allowed Donegal as a unit with 113,000 people. In spite of this the boundaries of Donegal were preserved; a division line was drawn somewhere across the centre of the county and one part was described as North-East and another as South. There were six TDs elected and this was unconstitutional. The census of population figures were delayed until after the introduction of the 1961 Electoral Act. Prior to 1961 the constituency of County Donegal had seven TDs. The old constituency of East Donegal had four and the old constituency of West Donegal had three. The 1956 figures brought the population up to 118,000, 2,000 less than the required figure to keep six TDs there but, as I say, the census of population figures for 1961 were delayed. I say that deliberately. The figures usually come out at a certain time but they did not come out at that time in 1961. Unless my information is wrong, they were delayed for the sole purpose of allowing the Fianna Fáil Party to introduce the 1961 Electoral Act and allowing Donegal to keep six Deputies when there should have been five Deputies.

For this reason I oppose this Bill and I will continue to do so. I want to put on record that if it is ever my lot to be part of a Government at any future date not alone will I recognise the boundaries of County Donegal but I will listen sympathetically to any similar proposal from any part of Ireland.

There is no reason, as Deputy Hogan of South Tipperary said, why the entire Electoral Act could not have been introduced in a form acceptable to all Parties, if the Minister for Local Government had done what Deputy Tom Fitzpatrick wanted him to do, and that is to have a commission to set the boundaries. That, however, would not satisfy the greed, the political thirst of the Minister, Deputy Boland. He had other things in mind. If there is a change of Government, and I hope there will be, County Donegal will be one constituency at any general election after 1970. I am satisfied that the people of Leitrim will be enabled then to select and elect a Leitrim candidate to represent them in this House, something Fianna Fáil have deprived them of by introducing this Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte said that he would guarantee that the boundaries of Donegal would be sacrosanct but he is opposing the Minister's proposal. He is suggesting that Donegal should be a five-seat constituency and this could mean having Donegal carved up and a slice of Donegal going into another county or counties. So his anxiety about preserving the Donegal boundary is not a genuine one because he would have 7,000 to 8,000 people going from Donegal, as a five-seater, into Sligo-Leitrim or both. He has issued a challenge that he can bring the Minister to any area of County Donegal and get an indication from the people there that they would be happy with a five-seat constituency. He admits that it will mean a four Deputy representation in the light of the Ceann Comhairle being a representative from that area.

Comment on this

I do not wish to interrupt but that is not true. There would be four seats contested but there would be five TDs, one being the Ceann Comhairle. The Ceann Comhairle still represents County Donegal. That would be five TDs.

Comment on this

Yes, not politically of course.

Comment on this

As a TD.

Comment on this

As a politician.

Comment on this

I did not say that; you said that.

Comment on this

The gist of his contention is that the people of Donegal, if they were tested tomorrow, would indicate that they would be quite happy with a five-seat constituency and he indicates that that would be a contest for four seats. The people of Donegal at the referendum accepted the proposal that was put to them by the present Minister. That proposal was that there should be six TDs in Donegal, that there should be six single-seat constituencies. They accepted that which gives the lie to the suggestion made by Deputy Harte. I find it very difficult to understand the logic of his argument in a county where the people no later than the 16th of October indicated that they wanted six TDs in Donegal. Yet, by bringing the Minister tomorrow, as he said, to any part of East or West Donegal he will prove to him—I do not know how, but he will—that they are happy that at the next election there will be four TDs fighting for four seats. This is the gist of his argument.

In regard to the argument about which area should be in according to the Minister's proposal, if one looks at the map one finds that the line is pretty straight. It is drawn right across the county with equal areas on both sides and I think there should be no quarrel there except that I do know that if the place Deputy Harte mentioned—Urney —were brought in it would be chocolate to Deputy Harte because it is right beside him. It would suit him nicely to have that done. This sort of thinking is an indication that if he were in the Minister's position and doing a constituency re-alignment job he would look after himself.

Comment on this

A very noble pastime.

Comment on this

Even now he has the neck to ask the Minister to look after him by giving him Urney chocolates. The district of Urney, surely, if it were shifted into North-East Donegal would be a nice bonus for Deputy Harte but I presume the Minister's job is not to give bonuses to Deputy Harte——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Or to Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

——but to conform strictly to the limits laid down by the Constitution unamended, and Mr. Justice Budd's decision. So, Deputy, you have to take it that that is the criterion on which the Minister had to operate.

Comment on this

Deputy Cunningham's point is that the people of Donegal gave the Minister a mandate in the referendum. Harold Wilson in Great Britain had a lesser swing in the first election as an outgoing Prime Minister than the swing against Fianna Fáil in County Donegal in the referendum. We wanted 16½ per cent of a swing in Donegal to retain the position. We got a 16 per cent swing. I am quite certain that if the conversion continues Deputy Cunningham will be sadly disappointed and disillusioned.

In regard to Deputy Cunningham's argument—I think I made this point abundantly but maybe Deputy Cunningham was not listening—if the Donegal county boundaries were to be preserved and the boundaries were to be, as he said, sacrosanct, Donegal would not have only four TDs; it would have five TDs, four seats being contested. I submit to the House that if four seats were to be contested Fianna Fáil could not get three out of four. Therefore, the bonuses Deputy Cunningham refers to as being given out by the Minister for Local Government would in no way come across the floor of the House but must land up around Bridgend where Deputy Cunningham's home is situated.

What I was telling the House before Deputy Cunningham came in was that in 1918 the First Dáil elected to meet in the Mansion House had only four TDs representing 168,000 people, 60,000 people more than the present population of Donegal would have six TDs. I do not want to go over again the remuneration which Members of this House have for representing the people of Donegal. I am quite satisfied with what I am getting and I am sure the two Ministers who have the privilege of serving in the Government and representing Donegal for the Government Party are quite satisfied with their remuneration and privileges. The four TDs who represented the people of Donegal in that Dáil and demonstrated in a democratic way and asserted to the world that the people of Ireland wanted freedom, who came here under duress, who could not go into a hotel and openly book there for the night but probably had to steal into the city and stay with friends, were asked by the people of Donegal to represent them—four TDs to represent 168,000 people. Now the Minister for Local Government is not satisfied with five representing 108,000. We will not talk about the disparities in privileges and remuneration.

This is the type of thinking which has muddled Government approaches. Indeed, it is very akin to the type of thinking that there used to be in other parts of the country.

When I suggest that the Minister should be transferred to Stormont, I am quite satisfied that certain steps taken by former administrators in that part of the world have influenced the present thinking of the Minister for Local Government, that all he was interested in was keeping Fianna Fáil in office. By bringing part of Leitrim in with South-West Donegal and preserving the boundary line as far as possible he could keep North-East Donegal as we know it at the moment but his proposals are to change it. This type of thinking was purely for the purpose of keeping the Fianna Fáil Party in office, of designing every constituency so that every backbench member of the Fianna Fáil Party was able to sit down with the Minister and discuss with him the far-reaching effects that this Bill generally speaking would have on the future of that particular member.

Comment on this

That is not correct.

Comment on this

I am not at all satisfied that Deputy Cunningham was not in on those talks.

Comment on this

I certainly was not.

Comment on this

I accept the Deputy's word but I give full credit to the Minister for Local Government for interpreting the type of thinking the Deputy would have expressed if he had been in on the talks. In private conversation Deputy Cunningham has told me he knew nothing of the Bill. I accept that and I accept it without reservation.

Comment on this

It did not prevent the Deputy from saying it.

Comment on this

What the Deputy told me was that he never informed the Minister for Local Government of his precarious position.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

Maybe not. You told me you were not speaking to the Minister about it nor did you ask him to give you any concession but that does not say that you did not know something about it long before I did. I want to state here and now that at least Deputy Cunningham has got the message that I am quite prepared to debate with the Minister for Local Government or either of his two colleagues, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries or the Minister for Social Welfare, the present position of County Donegal and the proposals that would be fair thinking and reasonable to the people in County Donegal. I forecast if it was put to the people they would reject the present proposal because they know it to be gerrymandering. They know the people of Manorhamilton and Dromahair have nothing in common with the people of Tory Island. Deputy Cunningham comes from the constituency where Tory Island is but he has never been on it. I have never been on it either. How can the Minister coming from a Party of reality tell the people he is being realistic in proposing that the people from Manorhamilton and Dromahair should be asked to sit down and talk out their problems with the people from Tory Island, some 107 miles away with a completely different background and heritage? This is ridiculous and the Minister knows it but he does not care about those things.

The only prerequisite the Minister is concerned about is what keeps Fianna Fáil in power. This Electoral Bill is the best piece of butchering any Minister for Local Government has ever performed. He is bisecting every constituency to suit the pattern of the Fianna Fáil political machine, to ensure maximum return. If I had complete control of the political thinking of the House I would say to the Minister: "Here, take every section with you, pass it and have a general election and let the people adjudicate on it". The people would then adjudicate on it and give the Minister the same answer he got in the referendum, that is, they would not allow this gerrymandering to take place to keep Fianna Fáil in power. They would put Fianna Fáil out. If that happended we would give the people an Electoral Act whereby their wishes would be respected by county boundaries and constituencies where county boundaries do not exist.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I understand in my absence that the Minister for Local Government had a few things to say about me including that I was not prepared to come in here and stand over statements I made on other issues in this House dealing with electoral reform.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy but the only problem in question before the House at this moment relates to the constituency of North-East Donegal.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I respectfully agree and I would assume it was that sort of problem which was before the House all day. Nevertheless, I think I am entitled briefly to put the record right as far as my absence from this House is concerned. I understand the Minister also alleged I had ceased to be the Fine Gael spokesman on Local Government. I want to say I was absent from this House discharging my duty as a public representative in my constituency in Cavan and that I am still the spokesman for Fine Gael on Local Government. I do not intend to take up the time of the House much on this. I can understand changes and sackings being uppermost in the Minister's mind or indeed in the mind of any Minister of the Fianna Fáil Cabinet at the present time. If anybody was to be removed from his portfolio following the referendum I would suggest to the Minister to look around him and it would not be me. It would be more appropriate that the Minister for Local Government who led his Party to such a disastrous defeat in the referendum should pay the price of being removed from office rather than that I should be reduced after my helping to lead the victorious side in the referendum.

Comment on this

He misled them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is all I want to say about it beyond saying I can understand, as I say, the Minister thinking in terms of sackings and changes in the Cabinet and changes in the Opposition because that has been running right through his mind and that of his colleagues ever since the referendum. We are dealing here with the constituency of North East Donegal and we are dealing with County Leitrim in so far as the constituency of North-East Donegal affects County Leitrim. I want to suggest to the House that in drafting the constituency of North-East Donegal, and in dispossessing County Leitrim as he did, the Minister for Local Government was not motivated by an effort to provide a fair representation for Donegal and County Leitrim. He was motivated by other things. He was influenced by an effort to provide six seats in Donegal just as he increased the representation of Galway from eight to nine. He was influenced by an effort to remove the county of Leitrim from the political map.

The Minister for Local Government, in setting out to draft this entire Bill, set out not to make the constituencies as reasonable as he could but to make them as absurd as he could. Indeed, I suppose he could not be blamed because he was committed by his speeches in this House over the last year to the proposal that it was impossible to arrange constituencies in a reasonable manner. The Taoiseach committed him at Drumshambo to the proposition that Leitrim would cease to figure in the map of Ireland. It was in pursuance of that speech made by the Taoiseach at Drumshambo when launching the referendum campaign in Leitrim, a speech to the effect that if the people did not vote "Yes" Leitrim would disappear, that he did this. That is what the Minister set out to do here. He set out to completely destroy Leitrim, to remove it from the political map of this country and at the same time to ensure that there would be six seats retained in Donegal in the hope that he would get four of them. That is only wishful thinking. The Minister thought he would win the referendum but he was incorrect there to the tune of a quarter of a million votes. If the Minister puts this through, he will not get the four seats he thinks he will get in Donegal.

I am concerned here with the destruction and the annihilation of Leitrim. It is a vicious and unnecessary attack on a county that has been neglected economically, industrially and agriculturally by the Fianna Fáil Government for the last 30 years. The Fianna Fáil Party are now determined to destroy it politically because down through the years it has refused to toe the Fianna Fáil line. What the Minister is doing here in this amendment which we are taking in conjunction with this constituency of North-East Donegal, and rechristening North-East Donegal as Donegal-Leitrim, is an insult to the people of Leitrim and can only be accepted by them as such.

The Bill as it appeared on 23rd October—although it had been promised by the Taoiseach on 5th October —and as it came into the hands of the Deputies first made no mention of Leitrim. To be accurate, it made no mention whatever of County Leitrim in the title of any constituency. That was done with the knowledge, approval and consent of the leaders of the Fianna Fáil organisation in County Leitrim. With their full knowledge, approval and consent, as evidenced by their visit to Leinster House, this was done. Apparently when the people of Leitrim got down to thinking about this and realised that the title of Roscommon-South Leitrim and Sligo-Leitrim had been altered and that Leitrim had been dropped from Roscommon-South Leitrim and that it was being dropped from Sligo-Leitrim and that in the new constituency of North-East Donegal which proposed to include 8,000 voters from Leitrim the name Leitrim was not mentioned in its title they revolted against that. They were not revolting about the fact that the name of Leitrim was not appearing in the title of a consituency; they were revolting about the unnecessary carving up of the county of Leitrim into three in order to justify and vindicate the bullying threats of the Taoiseach in Drumshambo and to prove that what the Taoiseach then said was right.

The people did not accept the Taoiseach's warning. They were not impressed by his prophecies. They voted in no uncertain way against the Taoiseach's proposals and the proposals of his Minister. Now, for no other reason than to punish this gallant little county of Leitrim and to neutralise the independence of the voters of that county they are, to use the Minister's favourite expression, being butchered. It was his pet expression last year. I do not know whether he is adopting it in this debate or not. They are being butchered into three parts quite unnecessarily.

There has been a long tradition and a long alliance between Sligo and Leitrim. They are joined together for administrative purposes and for local government. They have a joint hospital. They have been linked together in one way or another down through the years for election purposes. The Minister could not tolerate that. The Minister knows that Sligo is a county that never tolerated the Minister and Leitrim has shown its independence. There does not appear to me to be any reason why Sligo-Leitrim could not be put together in a reasonable fourmember constituency. I have no doubt at all that if we were to talk here for weeks the Minister would come out on top. The Minister will get his way. The Minister will steamroll his proposals through this House just as, as he has been reminded, he steamrolled the referendum proposals through the House. The Minister laughed at the arguments that were put forward against him and the Fianna Fáil Party laughed at the warnings they received from independent thought in this country. They ridiculed the warnings given to the Minister by the non-committed newspapers in this country and by the other mass media of communication.

One would have thought that as a result of that operation the Minister would have learned that he is not infallible. While he might still think he is infallible in these proposals for North-East Donegal and Leitrim he should have learned that the people do not accept him as infallible. The Minister should realise that the day is gone when the people of this country can be bamboozled or bulldozed into accepting what the Minister for Local Government says or what any political Party in this country say. People can react very violently if they believe that proposals put before them are not bona fide proposals for the interest of the people in general. If they believe that the proposals are really put forward in the interests of a political Party for political Party purposes— and that is what these proposals are in the drafting of the constituency of North-East Donegal to be renamed Donegal-Leitrim—the people will react to these proposals just as they reacted to the Minister's proposals last year. I only wish to refer to the constituency of Galway in so far as it is relevant to Donegal. The point I am making is that we were warned in the referendum debate that Galway would lose seats if the referendum proposals were carried; but we know that Galway has, in fact, gained a seat contrary to what the Minister and his colleagues said. We know what the purpose of this is— the purpose of unnecessarily bolstering up Donegal by robbing Leitrim of almost 9,000 people in an effort to retain six seats in Donegal.

Deputy Harte suggests that Donegal should be a five-seater. That could be done and Leitrim could still be retained as a county without being divided up into three or, indeed, Donegal could be retained as a six-seater with less votes from Leitrim if the Minister wants to have his own selfish way. Half of the people who are being taken from Leitrim could be put in with that county's ancient colleague and neighbour, Sligo, to remain a four-seater. However, that would not suit the Minister because the Minister wants to neutralise, destroy and render ineffective the Leitrim vote. I do not know whether the Minister is in a hurry with this Bill——

Comment on this

No, I am not.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——but I say that the sooner it goes through the House and the Seanad and the sooner there is a general election the sooner will the Minister get the very same answer as he got on the 16th of October last.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): To anybody who looks at the amendments put in by the Minister to this Bill there is a rather interesting feature. He has put in about half a dozen amendments in which he tries to placate counties which he has dismembered; in particular, he has gone to a considerable amount of trouble to placate Leitrim. That county had originally disappeared from the electoral map. We now find one of his amendments, No. 21, reading:

In page 11, in the second column of the entry relating to Longford-Westmeath, to delete "Roscommon" and to substitute "Roscommon-Leitrim".

In amendment No. 26 he has put down:

In page 13, in the first column, to delete "Roscommon" and to insert "Roscommon-Leitrim".

Again, in amendment No. 28 he has:

In page 13, in the first column, to delete "Sligo" and to substitute "Sligo-Leitrim".

In amendment No. 29:

In page 13, in the second column of the entry relating to Sligo, to delete "South-West Donegal" and to substitute "Donegal-Leitrim".

In amendment No. 30:

In page 13, in the second column of the entry relating to Sligo, to delete "Roscommon" and to substitute "Roscommon-Leitrim".

He has divided the small county of Leitrim into three parts of almost equal size. Out of a population of approximately 30,000 people, one-third will go to Donegal, one-third to Sligo and one-third to Roscommon in order to placate these people, allowing their names to appear in the registers of Sligo-Leitrim, Roscommon-Leitrim and Donegal-Leitrim. This is the sop which the little county of Leitrim is now receiving.

I have suggested to the Minister here that the difficulties of altering these constituencies could be overcome with the transfer of a lot fewer of the population into Donegal than he proposes. I gave him a minimum figure of 5,642. That would cause less disruption and it would leave about 25,000 people still in Leitrim which, when joined with Sligo, would be able to maintain its own interests and would be sufficient to form a reasonable joint constituency. Sligo would be practically the same constituency as it was years ago and this would entail a much smaller transfer of population.

If the Minister had adopted our suggestions in regard to Donegal North-East, Donegal South and Sligo-Leitrim, the final position would be, with the transfer I have mentioned, Sligo-Leitrim, 76,193—sufficient for a four-seater; South Donegal, 57,094—sufficient for a three-seater and North Donegal, 57,097—sufficient for a three-seater and, as I have mentioned, the population transfer would be much less.

This, to me, is a much more suitable arrangement of the constituency than the one suggested. However, since the Minister has his heart set on all these three-seaters and giving him his two three-seat constituency in Donegal, this arrangement could be made, with Sligo-Leitrim maintained as a four-seater, and the gross dismemberment of Leitrim could be avoided. Furthermore, Roscommon, as an administrative unit, would remain intact with the addition of a couple of small electoral areas. The only transfer of population in respect of County Roscommon under that system would be of about 900 people and that is a very small transfer in order to preserve County Roscommon as a three-seater. I do not know why the Minister will not accept this, but he is obviously wedded to the notion of three-seaters in rural Ireland, in the hope of getting two out of three, and in the metropolitan area of Dublin to four-seaters in the hope of breaking even. This threefour rule has obsessed him. He is operating on that basis in order to secure as much electoral advantage as he can. He is completely disregarding the interests and sentiments of the 100,000 whom he is transferring. The figure could be reduced to 20,000 if he really wanted to do it.

Comment on this

I do not know whether there is any point whatever in talking to the Fine Gael Party on any of these amendments or on any of the proposed constituencies because they say completely opposite things. In fact, sometimes the same Deputy puts forward exactly opposing cases. The amendments which we are discussing clearly show that they are in response to the request of the Fine Gael Deputy, Deputy McLaughlin. In so far as a number of Fianna Fáil councillors from Leitrim were in this House, I would point out that they were here to put forward a suggestion that Leitrim should, if at all possible, be left undisturbed. They made a strong case for that and, I may say, a more intelligent one and a less hypocritical one than has been put forward by the Fine Gael Party, but because of the position with regard to the Constitution and because of the decision made by the people on the 16th October, it was not possible to do what they requested.

As I have said, there are, of course, many ways in which the requirements of the Constitution could be complied with but the suggestion put forward by Deputy Harte is not one of those ways. Deputy Harte boasted about his knowledge of geography but even more relevant than a knowledge of geography in so far as this operation is concerned is a knowledge of the Constitution. Deputy Harte has not taken it upon himself to acquaint himself with the constitutional provision in this regard, although the literal adherence to the Constitution that is required is something that was imposed by the Fine Gael Party when they took their action in the High Court in 1961.

Comment on this

The Constitution was adopted by the people in 1937.

Comment on this

The constitutional position is that the ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time in each constituency and the population of each constituency as ascertained at the last preceding census must as far as practicable be the same throughout the country. I do not know whether or not the Deputy knows what a census is. The Deputy spent a long time arguing that it was not the population at the last preceding census that was the relevant thing but an estimate of the present population made by Deputy Harte himself. Deputy Harte or anyone else may make an estimate of the population. I am confined to the population as ascertained at the last preceding census, which was in 1966, and even if Deputy Harte did conduct a census since then, as he tries to pretend here, on which he could make an intelligent estimate of population, the Constitution does not permit me to take Deputy Harte's scientific findings into account.

It is not possible, as Deputy Harte knows, to make the County of Donegal into one five-seater constituency without breaching the county boundaries. Deputy Harte knows that that is not permissible and what Deputy Harte is, in fact, arguing for now is the same thing he put forward during the debate on the referendum and that members of his Party have put forward today, that is, that something up to 13,400 of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents should be removed——

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

——from the County of Donegal and transferred to a constituency comprising part of Donegal, part of County Leitrim and part of County Roscommon——

Comment on this

That is completely inaccurate.

Comment on this

——because the only way in which County Donegal can be a five-seat constituency is by the transfer of some of its population—up to 13,400—and these, as Deputy Harte knows, must come from Deputy O'Donnell's present constituency.

Comment on this

Could the Minister tell us where he gets the figure of 13,000?

Comment on this

The one thing on this question of Donegal on which the Fine Gael Party are all consistent, the one thing about which none of them have contradicted themselves, is that this matter should be dealt with by transferring some of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents——

Comment on this

It is a commission we want.

Comment on this

Apparently the decision of the Fine Gael Party is that if there is a seat to be lost in Donegal it should be Deputy O'Donnell's seat.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is the kind of nonsense the Minister talked during the referendum.

Comment on this

It has been admitted that it is inevitable that Leitrim would have to be mutilated in some way.

Comment on this

Leave it alone for a couple of years and there will be nobody left.

Comment on this

The most despicable suggestion of all had to be made by Deputy Harte on this and that is that this is in some way directed against the people of the minority religion in his constituency.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte knows why the former representation which the minority religion had is no longer available. They were deprived of it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Since I came into this House, when Deputy Harte rose to speak he emphatically said he disagreed with another Member of this Party who said there was a proposal against the minority in Donegal. Not alone did Deputy Harte not say what the Minister is saying but he said the direct opposite.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

It is for the record.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is a point of truth.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte and his colleagues know that this representation which the people of the minority religion had prior to this in the House was taken away as a direct result of the Fine Gael manoeuvre in the courts, that prior to 1961, under the 1959 revision of constituencies, there was a four-seat constituency and a three-seat constituency proposed for Donegal, but because this would be likely to have retained the then representation in Donegal under which the now Senator Sheldon had a seat here, Fine Gael contested that in the courts with the result that that representation had to be taken from Donegal.

I would agree with the Chair that the long digression into the position in 1918 was hardly relevant but since Deputy Harte insisted on dealing with it in a very fanciful way, I think I should point out that he is incorrect in suggesting that the four Deputies of Donegal had to represent the whole county of Donegal. Deputy Harte should know that at that time there were single-seat constituencies and even if the population of Donegal was at that time 168,000, these Deputies had not to represent 168,000; they had to represent an average of 42,000. However, what Deputy Harte is proposing is that each Deputy should have to represent 108,000 or something in the vicinity of 100,000, which would be much more than any Deputy had to represent in 1918, or, indeed, at any other time.

The inconsistency of the Fine Gael Party is again shown by the fact that one Deputy argues that we should have smaller constituencies, that the proposed constituency of Cavan-Meath, that is, part of Cavan with the addition of a small part of Meath, is too large; and within the space of halfan-hour other Deputies are arguing that the whole county of Donegal should be one constituency. The fact of the matter is that if you take the whole western area of Donegal, the Province of Connacht and Clare, due to the sparseness of population and the constitutional provision, the maximum number of seats there must be 30, which gives an average for a three-seat constituency of over 970 square miles, so that that would be the average area to be covered by each Deputy under the scheme of constituencies which we propose. Although other Fine Gael Deputies have argued that constituencies are too large, Deputy Harte is proposing that Donegal, which is 18,075 square miles—almost double the average of the constituencies we propose for the West—should be all one constituency. I do not know that there is any point in arguing against such inconsistent and contradictory statements and contentions by the Fine Gael Party.

Deputy Hogan maintains that we have drawn too heavily on County Leitrim to make up the deficiency in Donegal for the maintenance of its present representation to which it is entitled on the basis of one-man one-vote because the number of voters per Deputy in Donegal entitles it to this. Here again this is a question, which is a matter of opinion, whether it is better to have the minimum number of people transferred, and have a position where they will be an insignificant element in the constituency to which they are transferred, or whether it is better to transfer a significant number of them who will form a proportion in the new constituency which will ensure adequate attention by the public representatives.

I do not see how anybody can accuse me of being in favour of a constituency stretching from Tory Island to Manorhamilton just because this Bill proposes that. As I have said, I am bringing in this Bill under duress. The Fianna Fáil Party did everything possible to avoid bringing in such an unrealistic Bill. However, it has to be brought in because the Constitution, as interpreted at the behest of the Fine Gael Party, requires this to be done. The proposition in relation to Tory Island is in my opinion excessive. But so is the alternative proposition that has been put forward by Fine Gael—a constituency stretching from the Bundoran-Ballyshannon area through County Leitrim and almost down to Shannonbridge at the southern extremity of County Roscommon.

Deputy Hogan asks me to accept Fine Gael's suggestions. What are their suggestions? On this simple issue alone, we have had four or five different suggestions. The Fine Gael Party do not know what their suggestion is. Deputy Hogan and Deputy Harte and Deputy Fitzpatrick of Cavan have put forward three different vague suggestions on this particular subject. Obviously, they do not know themselves what they actually would like done instead of what is proposed in the Bill—and, of course, that has been what we have been hearing ever since this Committee Stage started.

At the very outset, Deputy Esmonde put forward suggestions with regard to County Wexford and which involved Carlow, Kilkenny and Kildare, but he very quickly admitted that these were his own opinions only and did not represent the opinions of the Fine Gael Party. It is a fact that, on this subject, as on many others, Fine Gael have no definite opinion whatever. As I said, there are many alternatives to every one of these problems and it is just a matter of opinion which is the best.

We think that, on the whole, the proposals we are putting forward are the least objectionable but we do not say that they are not objectionable. They are objectionable. We did everything possible to avoid having to bring them in. However, in view of the vast extent of the western area we are dealing with and the fact that the maximum representation permitted is 30 seats for this area, I think our decision to have ten three-seat areas rather than a number of five-seat areas and a number of four-seat areas, as the Opposition are apparently suggesting, is the best one in the circumstances and in fact we have not any alternative before us.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister pleads he is introducing this Bill under duress. I made suggestions to him and these suggestions were made under the same duress because they must be made in conformity with the Constitution, as is the Bill the Minister is introducing here. According as we have come to these western counties, I have suggested at different points to the Minister certain methods of allocating the constituencies' population. As he says himself, there are different methods. The ones I have suggested are not necessarily the best but they are the ones I thought out, at least, and others may think out a better one for a particular area.

In effect, the Minister's proposals for the counties of the western seaboard, plus Roscommon and Leitrim, mean a population displacement totalling 59,274 persons. He is doing that in order to create ten three-seater constituencies. I have given him alternatives here of population transfers. I have given him the areas and he can check the figures from his book of statistics, if he wishes. Summarising it now, I suggested, as we went along, three four-seaters and six-seaters in the same area, which would give a total population displacement of 9,399 versus 59,274. If there is any value in trying to preserve county boundaries—and I believe there is—surely these suggestions which are solid practical suggestions merit consideration? By means of the transfers I have mentioned you will get 30 seats just as the Minister is getting by having ten three-seat constituencies and you will get them with far less breaching of county boundaries. There will be a breaching of county boundaries at three points. I have lost track of the number of breaches of county boundaries that there will be under the Minister's proposal to displace over 59,000 persons.

The Minister stands completely condemned. Fine Gael and other people may say this is gerrymandering. Here we have the statistics of what the Minister has been doing and it is pointless for him to stand up here and speak about hypocritical suggestions and to say that no practical suggestions have been made from this side of the House. These are counter suggestions which I am putting to him. If they are incorrect or have defects, let the Minister point them out but he should not babble about getting no practical suggestions from us. My suggestions give him what he says he is so anxious to have, two three-seaters in Donegal, leaving Mayo as it is, establishing Sligo-Leitrim as a four-seater constituency and displacing a minimum number from Leitrim, preserving almost 25,000 of the population intact as a unit to be joined up with Sligo. It preserves Roscommon as a county with a small addition of population from Ahascragh and Taghboy. It also preserves Clare as a unit but transfer a relatively small number from Galway. It preserves Galway as he wants it as a western three-seater and an eastern four-seater. We have done our utmost to meet the Minister in what we have submitted. Even though I say it myself, this is a far better, more practical and more just allocation of constituencies and population than the blunt ten by three which the Minister is putting forward.

Comment on this

I have the greatest sympathy with the Minister for Local Government in having to come in here and bring in this Bill before us "under duress". What does he mean by the word "duress". Surely the Irish people are entitled, even when the Fianna Fáil Party are divided before going to the country, to give their decision in a free vote and if by a majority of 240,000 the Irish people say to the Minister: "We do not trust you; we want to retain PR", it is hypocritical on the Minister's part and an effrontery for him to say he is bringing in this Bill under duress.

We are entitled to put forward alternatives. Deputy Hogan is entitled to make his suggestion just as I am entitled to make mine. I have pointed out that the Minister could have made Donegal a five-seat constituency, Sligo a three-seater, and he could still have left Leitrim on the map as a five-seat constituency. He would be displacing only between 8,000 and 9,000 people. He chose a different way and he is displacing over 30,000 people. He is doing this purely for selfish, political reasons so that Fianna Fáil can at least try to get the maximum number of Deputies returned. The Minister has spoken about the distances involved in the constituencies and about these being excessive. If the length of some constituencies is excessive, and perhaps it is, then if he can speak about the sparseness of the population, he should realise that the blame for that position rests on him and his Government. If he looks up the official statistics he will see that 6,464 people were driven out of Leitrim in the last ten years, since 1957, and that the population fell from 37,056 to 30,572. On the western seaboard alone since the Fianna Fáil Party came to power, some 150,000 people have been driven out. If there is the sparseness of the population the Minister has spoken about for the past ten minutes, the Minister and the Government must take the blame because since 1932 they have driven out 150,957——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I must point out that this is getting away from the amendment.

Comment on this

Perhaps it is. I shall bow to the ruling of the Chair, but when the Minister argues about excessive distances to be travelled by Deputies and about the sparseness of the population in the West, I think we are entitled to say that bad Government—his Government—has driven out 150,000 of the population in the past 25 years.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is getting away from the amendment with which we are dealing at the moment.

Comment on this

We are entitled to know the reasons. It is in reply to the Minister's allegations.

Comment on this

We are not talking about population.

Comment on this

The Minister was. He spoke about sparseness of population in the West and excessive distances. I took down his words.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are dealing with a specific constituency and we cannot have a general debate at this stage.

Comment on this

The Minister misquoted what I said when speaking earlier on this amendment when he alleged that I insinuated that the motives for his actions were that he wished to attack the religious minority in County Donegal. I want to put on record that this was far from being the truth and very far removed from my intention and from my exact words. This had been said by another Deputy and the first remark I made was to the effect that it was not absolutely correct that the motives behind the Minister's proposals simply were to consolidate Fianna Fáil in office, to ensure the return of the present Fianna Fáil representation for the entire County Donegal. For the record, I wish to tell the House that what the Minister said was inaccurate, and if he were a man of integrity he would withdraw it.

Comment on this

It was Deputy L'Estrange who made the remarks about the Protestant minority.

Comment on this

I stand over what I said.

Comment on this

The Deputy is getting out now.

Comment on this

Deputy Booth now says it was not I who made the reference.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy L'Estrange say it. I did not hear Deputy Harte say it.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Booth for acknowledging that. However, it does not mean to say that Fianna Fáil can absolve themselves for their attacks on the religious minority in Donegal. People of an older generation than I know exactly what I say. The Minister shed crocodile tears and spoke about what his Party did to protect the religious minority in North-East Donegal. It is tommyrot. It is ridiculous for the Minister to suggest such a thing and nobody knows this better than the religious minority. Recently, I met a lady at the Church of Ireland Cathedral in Raphoe. I had been invited to a service there to commemorate a function. She said: "God look to the Protestant minority if Fianna Fáil could do without them."

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is away from the amendment.

Comment on this

I agree and I would not have mentioned it if the Minister had not tried to blame me for something.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy come back to the amendment?

Comment on this

The Minister demonstarted what I thought was impossible —that he could go below his own level.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy come to the amendment?

Comment on this

The Minister also said I had stated that four Deputies represented the Donegal constituency in 1918. I said that but I also said they represented four different constituencies. If the Minister did not hear that I repeat it—four Deputies represented Donegal in four different constituencies in 1918. They represented 168,000 people, without remuneration and without travelling expenses. They came to this city and had to seek overnight accommodation from their friends. They wanted to assert to the world in a democratic way that the Irish people had the right to govern themselves. I do not come to Dublin under duress. I am elected by the people in a free democracy and I am being duly rewarded for it.

My argument is that it is not unreasonable to say to the House that the people of Donegal, bearing in mind and appreciating the feelings of the people of Leitrim, would be content to accept a constituency of five seats representing the entire county of Donegal. The Minister insinuated that Deputy O'Donnell and I advocated the transfer of portions of Donegal to North Leitrim and that in a way someone was blackmailing someone else. That is not so, and just to prove how incorrect the Minister is I shall give some figures. He said that 13,400 people would have to be transferred from Donegal to North Leitrim.

Comment on this

Up to 13,400.

Comment on this

During the Fianna Fáil referendum campaign in Letterkenny, in September, 1968, the Minister is reported in the Derry Journal as follows:

Mr. Boland said that the Fine Gael plan was to "subtract" the Ballyshannon and Bundoran districts, with a population of 6,319, from Donegal and "add" them, with a portion of the County Leitrim, to Sligo.

Someone has put the Minister wise because now he says the figures should be 13,400. Lest, perhaps, some people have not got the message, let us put the record straight. The population of Donegal, according to the last census figures, is about 108,000 people. The Minister is entitled to a five per cent tolerance under the present Constitution, which is the Constitution of his Party. Therefore, he could in effect have a constituency with five seats and the transfer of a maximum of 3,000 people to any constituency he wishes. I do not want the people of Ballyshannon and Bundoran to say that I am advocating this. I do not want the Minister to go there and tell them I want this. I wish to say in all fairness that these people—I have spoken to them—would be prepared to say: "Right, it is better that 3,000 people from the southern tip of Donegal should be transferred to Sligo-Leitrim instead of 10,000 being transferred from Leitrim into South West Donegal." This is the basis of my argument, lest perhaps the Minister may again misunderstand me. He can go on the figures in the Census of Population and not on my figures.

I wish to repeat that since Fianna Fáil took office in 1931 the population in Donegal has dropped to a figure of 108,000. It has dropped continually to the tune of plus 1,000 per year. Therefore, if we were to have an election with a five-seat constituency, and if the Minister were to take this ultimate and extreme measure of transferring 3,000 people from the southern end of Donegal into Sligo-Leitrim, it would be for only one election because the Minister would have to bring them back again to maintain the status quo of five seats in Donegal.

This is why the Minister has brought so many people from Leitrim into Donegal—because, as has been pointed out by Deputy L'Estrange, the rate of emigration, the rate of decline in population in Donegal and in Leitrim is more pronounced than in any other region in the country. I submit that the transfer of 3,000 people from one area to the other now would mean that the entire matter would have to be reexamined before the next general election, bearing in mind that any increase in population would be caused by people coming home on holidays. I do not know what the Minister means by "realism". I am referring again to the speech he made, the speech I quoted earlier. In that speech he said:

The difference between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil is that we see the figures in the Census returns are not just digits to be subtracted and added at will, but that these figures represent real live people and that the 6,319 population in the Bundoran and Ballyshannon areas are 6,319 Donegal people whose interest is in their own country and who should be represented by Donegal Deputies.

Here is the Minister now shedding crocodile tears over the people in Donegal. How does he explain the Leitrim situation? Does he not think the Leitrim people are entitled to the same treatment as the Donegal people? I ask that question as a Donegal man. I ask it because I believe the people in Donegal are a fair-minded people. I am pointing out now to the people in Donegal that this appears to be as inaccurate as so many other things in the selfsame speech of the Minister. The people in Ballyshannon and Bundoran want a Donegal man to represent them just as the people in Leitrim want a Leitrim man to represent them. But the Minister has listened to the call from the wilderness, as others have listened to it, and, instead of having Leitrim disappear from the map, he has a certain amendment in to delete "South-West Donegal" and to substitute "Donegal-Leitrim". He has another amendment to delete "Sligo" and to substitute "Sligo-Leitrim". He has a third amendment to delete "Roscommon" and to substitute "Roscommon-Leitrim"—three Leitrims in one go. This could be described as the trinity of Leitrim. Is this not hypocrisy, the kind of hypocrisy which makes the people hold the Minister in such contempt? Is not this the kind of hypocrisy which made the people reject the proposals in the referendum? Is not this the type of hypocrisy which motivated the Minister into producing these proposals, which can only be described as gerrymandering? That is why I am prepared to give the Minister his amendments and let the people adjudicate on them. I am certain the people will exercise the same freedom of choice as the people of the entire county of Donegal, including those of Ballyshannon and Bundoran, and reject the Government proposals if they are put to them in conjunction with a general election. If that should be the pattern of events, and if this Party are given a mandate to form a Government, I guarantee that I will do my utmost to ensure that county boundaries will be preserved, not alone in Donegal but also in Leitrim, Sligo, Cork, Kerry, Mayo and Galway. I will do that so that those who go to Cork Park, proudly displaying their county allegiance, will not have their pride offended by a Minister who knows nothing more than Party interest and who is prepared, for Party political purposes, to introduce a Bill designed at gerrymandering constituencies. If the Minister says he does this under duress, my answer is that he does not have to do it. He can appoint a commission. I am quite certain a commission would make a better job of it and would have a fairer approach to the whole matter than the Minister has.

Comment on this

Listening to the exchange here one begins to wonder how one can win a debate like this. We in the Roscommon-Leitrim constituency are very conscious of what the amendments mean to us because Roscommon is one of those counties which have been partitioned from time to time in order to make constituencies in other counties. We, in Fianna Fáil, in both Roscommon and Leitrim put it to the people that, if the Third Amendment was not accepted by them, both our counties would once more be partitioned. We were the people who sought methods to avoid such partitioning. We have been listening here for the past hour and more to Opposition Deputies pillorying us for partitioning these areas. That is most unfair. It is most unreasonable. The one method available to prevent such partitioning was offered to the people. For various reasons it was not accepted by them, the most telling reason being that the Opposition Parties recommended the people not to accept the Third and Fourth Amendments. It is the Opposition who should be pilloried for this partitioning. We were told a moment ago that a commission should be appointed. But the commission was also rejected on the advice of the Opposition. It was proposed and it was rejected.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

By you people.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Dr. Gibbons must be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

I have heard some of the solutions offered. One solution offered by Deputy Hogan suggested part of Galway should be added to my constituency. He must think the Deputies in my constituency people of great endurance. Deputy Harte mentioned that one of the new constituencies will be over 107 miles. I think my constituency is that at the moment and, if Deputy Hogan's proposition were accepted, it would be up to 120 miles. It is long enough as it is.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Two district electoral divisions, 900 population.

Comment on this

The Deputy mentioned Ahascragh and Cloughbawn, which would make it 120 miles.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): And take off Leitrim.

Comment on this

The Deputy included Leitrim.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Roscommon alone.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Dr. Gibbons.

Comment on this

We have the situation now in Leitrim that groups are parading the county protesting against the partition of the county. It is only fair to say the Fine Gael Party are not associated with this. I have told some of these people that, if they are sincere, the time they should have paraded was before the amendments were voted on; had they done so with the same frequency and determination in that area the vote on the referendum would have been very different. Had those who opposed us on the referendum seen the matter in the same light as they see it now, they too could have used their influence to get the amendments accepted by the people. That was not done. It is ironic that we should now in this debate hear this side of the House blamed for not doing what the Opposition side of the House advised the people not to do.

Comment on this

The people want it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If I understand Deputy Dr. Gibbons correctly he endorses and approves of the proposal to cut the county of Leitrim in three and give a third of it to Donegal, a third to Roscommon, and a third to Sligo. It is admitted in this House that there are ways of dealing with the situation other than that. Even the Minister accepts that. That being so. I should have thought that Deputy Gibbons, who enjoys the support of some Sligo constituents, would have opted for one of these other methods, a method which would leave intact, or virtually intact, the county of Leitrim.

The Minister in his last contribution seemed to think there was virtue in preserving a county or the most of a county, so that the Deputy representing it would have to take an interest in it. It is common case here, that even on the Minister's own proposals, if he wants to give Donegal six seats and insists on doing it, all he has to do is take 5,000 people from Leitrim and put them in Donegal, and give Donegal six seats, leave 25,000 Leitrim people together as an influential unit and put them in Sligo-Leitrim where, by and large, they have been for the past 50 years, and leave Sligo-Leitrim together as a four-seater. Is not that a reasonable proposal? Is there anything wrong with it? Does it not leave Leitrim virtually intact? Does it not leave 25,000 Leitrim people together with a voice that will have to be listened to, and with enough votes to elect representatives of their own and make their voice heard.

One thing has emerged from this debate. We are discussing the Electoral Amendment Bill, 1968, which proposes to revise the constituencies. The object of that Bill should be to provide fair representation for the people of Donegal, and fair representation for the people of Leitrim. That should be the object of the Bill. It should be the intention of any Minister setting out to draft the Bill. It has emerged from this debate—and the Minister has conceded it—that there are a number of ways by which this can be achieved. The Minister proposes one: take 9,000 people from Leitrim and put them in Donegal, making Donegal two threeseaters, take another hunk of Leitrim and put it in Roscommon, and take another few thousand and put them in Sligo. We on this side of the House say that the net object and intention of that exercise is not to give fair representation to Donegal and Leitrim but to give added strength to Fianna Fáil. They are hoping—and I do not concede that it will happen—to get four seats in Donegal and destroy Leitrim. At least two other proposals have been put from this side of the House which would have the effect of preserving Leitrim, if not entirely intact, practically intact. Put 5,000 people from Leitrim into Donegal and have it a two three-seater, if the Minister insists on that, or put 25,000 people from Leitrim into Sligo and give them four seats. Those are two ways of doing it.

Deputy Gibbons introduced a commission and then shot it down. Of course, the way to do it is through a commission. We did not shoot down a commission as Deputy Gibbons said, and he is usually a very fair Deputy who makes a reasonable contribution in the House. Of course, he is wrong when he says we shot down a commission. I introduced a Bill to provide a commission to arrange these constituencies, and the Minister led his Deputies, including Deputy Mooney and Deputy Gibbons, into the Lobbies to shoot down the First Stage of that Bill and ensure it would not happen.

The reasonable thing to do would have been to entrust the arranging of the constituencies to an independent, non-political commission, presided over by a judge, which would make representation to the House. I agree entirely with Deputy Gibbons that that would have been the right thing to do. I want to correct him when he says we were against it.

Comment on this

The Deputy said it himself on television.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I said I was against a bogus commission, which would be subject to change here by the Minister with a simple majority.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of a commission has been resolved by the Dáil and we can have no further discussion on it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is very unfortunate if that is so because Deputy Gibbons has put this in issue from the Government side of the House. He spoke immediately before me.

Comment on this

It was started over there.

Comment on this