We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968 — Committee Stage.

Contributions 328–495 of 495. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 35 of 1968 ›

Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am entitled to put the record right. I said on television that I was against a bogus commission. I wanted to put the correct commission into both Bills and I would not be let. After the referendum was over I introduced a Bill to set up a genuine, workable, independent, honest commission, to take politics out of the arranging of the constituencies and ensure that they would be arranged in the interests of fair representation of the people rather than in an effort to suit one political Party. I will leave it at that. Thank you, Sir, for allowing me to put the record right. I am satisfied that I have done so.

It is a public disgrace that a county with a national tradition like that of Leitrim should be cut up and put off the political map. Sinn Féin was founded here in 1905 and two years afterwards Charles J. Dolan in Leitrim resigned his seat as a representative of the Irish Parliamentary Party in the British House of Commons and contested a seat on behalf of Sinn Féil. I am glad to be able to claim relationship with the said Charles J. Dolan. He put sinn Féin on the map and in the history books of this country.

As I say, it is a disgrace that a county with its own tradition should be cut up deliberately into three and virtually removed from the electoral map of the country. The amendments we are dealing with now to reinstate the name of Leitrim in three constituencies will not satisfy the people of Leitrim. What they want is what the Minister in his last contribution very correctly said was necessary: to keep a group of people who could exercise their influence on whatever constituency they were in. The Minister made that point and it is a good point and one with which I agree, but he is doing the very opposite here. He wants to ensure that Leitrim will have no voice, that the votes of Leitrim will be ineffective. It is a great pity that the Minister did not accept the commission and avoid all this wrangle and difference of opinion.

The Minister concedes that there are many ways of doing this. There is the right way and the wrong way, the fair way and the unfair way, there is the political way and the independent way, but surely the one person who should not have been entrusted with a task like that is the political head of a Department, the man who was committed in this House last year to saying that what he is now doing was impossible. The Minister is on record time and time again as having said that it was impossible to arrange the constituencies under PR in a reasonable way. I want to go on record as saying that the Minister in drafting and introducing this Bill set out to vindicate the speeches he made during all of last year. He set out to prove that what he then said was right. In other words, he set out not to introduce a Bill that would be as reasonable as possible, not to introduce a Bill that would give as fair representation as possible to all constituencies, but to reduce the whole matter to an absurdity. As far as Donegal and Leitrim are concerned he has succeeded and more is the pity.

He took on an impossible task. No wonder he was able to introduce the Bill within days after the referendum was over. He had preconceived ideas about this. He was committed to destroying Leitrim, not to preserving it. That is the tragedy of what is happening now in this constituency as in other constituencies. It is something that is not necessary. It is only necessary to sustain the argument that the Minister was making all last year, that it was impossible to arrange the constituencies fairly. I suppose it is not permissible to deal in detail with the commission in view of the Chair's ruling, but surely one would think that, if the Minister for Local Government during the last 12 months committed himself to saying that PR is unworkable, that it is impossible to arrange reasonable constituencies under the present Constitution, then the obvious, dignified and responsible thing for that Minister to do when the people disagreed with him to the tune of 250,000 votes would have been to say: "I give in" and to say to the Taoiseach: "I will accept any other Ministry you want to give me but, as far as arranging constituencies is concerned, I have campaigned up and down the country that this cannot be done on the basis that any Bill introduced to revise the constituencies would produce a monstrosity, an absurdity. I am sorry, Taoiseach, I cannot undertake that. You will have to get another man to do it." That would be the reasonable approach of a man holding a Cabinet position in a democracy. But not at all, that was not the attitude of the Minister. He gladly accepted. He said: "Give me the knife, let me at it and I will show them." That is what he did and this is the result. That is what we are talking about here this evening. It is our duty to expose it.

I know what the end result will be as far as this House is concerned, as I said before, so far as the Minister's majority in the House is concerned. The Minister once thought that with his majority in the House he could change the Constitution but the people said "no"——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid the Deputy is getting away from the question before the House which does not deal with——

Comment on this

He only wants to delay.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is the Minister in a hurry?

Comment on this

That is a matter for you.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question before the House deals with North-East Donegal.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): As far as North-East Donegal and Leitrim are concerned, the Minister has succeeded in doing what he promised to do last year, what he set out to do after the referendum, to rub the noses of the people in Leitrim in the dirt, to chastise them, to punish them and to remove them from the political map and render them ineffective. I was amazed that Deputy Dr. Gibbons for whom I have the height of regard, was foolish enough to endorse the Minister's action in this House. This is not the first time that the Minister and his Party tried to play a dirty trick on Leitrim. They thought when they linked up Roscommon and a comparatively small part of South Leitrim that they would remove the name of “Reynolds” from the public life of County Leitrim but they did not succeed because the people of South Leitrim reacted violently and elected Deputy Reynolds and he is in the House today, just as the people of North Leitrim resented the mutilation of Leitrim and divorcing it from Sligo and they saw to it that Deputy Joe McLaughlin was elected. The people of Leitrim proved that they were loyal to themselves and showed they resented the attitude of the Government in trying to disfranchise them and they sent two Fine Gael Deputies into this House. I am satisfied that now that it is divided up into three they will again react by playing their part in sending three Fine Gael Deputies back into this House.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I wish to join issue with Deputy Dr. Gibbons on a point. He seems to have misinterpreted the discussion. I gather that he had the notion we were suggesting adding on to his electoral area. In point of fact the opposite was the case. He demurred at the idea of Taghboy and Ahascragh being added on to his constituency. I gathered that he thought that this would be an undue extra burden. The Minister seems to ride in with him. As a matter of fact the constituency which Deputy Dr. Gibbons represents is Roscommon plus some of Leitrim.

I do not know what the present census figure in Leitrim would be for the area the Deputy represents but, according to the 1966 census, it was 16,600. I suppose it would be something the same now, perhaps a bit less. The population of Roscommon, according to the last census is 56,228. The suggestion I made was that the county of Roscommon be an electoral area with this 56, 228 people plus 953 people from Taghboy and Ahascragh. These 953 people would replace the 16,000 people from Leitrim so, instead of increasing the man's burden, we are removing a population of 16,600, or whatever it is in the present census of Leitrim people and just adding a small amount from Galway—Taghboy and Ahascragh—of 923 people so that on balance he would be getting a more compact and smaller constituency. It would be a three-seat constituency. The suggestion I made was that Roscommon should be just Roscommon alone plus this small number of people from Galway and with this small number you can have Roscommon county as a single constituency and leave the greater part of Leitrim intact. As Deputy Fitzpatrick has said, you could just transfer a little over 5,000 people into Donegal.

Comment on this

Contrary to what Deputy Hogan stated in his last contribution but one, he has not put forward any suggestion for re-distribution of the representatives in the western area on the basis of ten three-seat constituencies. He has made various vague suggestions of larger constituencies. Possibly, for all I know, there may be some three-seat constituencies in these various schemes that he has been suggesting; but on the whole he has been suggesting larger constituencies than the three-seat constituencies that are in the Bill. Generally speaking, his approach now on this Bill, unlike his Party's approach when the proposal to amend the Constitution was before the House, is that the transfers of the population that are required to comply with the Constitution should be so small as to ensure that the transferred population will be completely submerged in the county to which it is added.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Like Leitrim.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, unlike Deputies on the opposite benches, I have to look on the situation as a whole. I cannot put forward vague suggestions with regard to the county of Roscommon in the context of Donegal and Leitrim. I have to look at the area as a whole and I think that the reasonable way to look at the western area is to consider the problems of Connacht, the county of Donegal and the county of Clare and the logical thing to do is to start at the two extremities, to start at Clare and to start at Donegal. Deputy Hogan is now full of this idea of the desirability of preserving counties wherever possible, preserving counties as his colleague Deputy Harte said "as God designed them," though during the debate on the referendum we were led to believe that it was an infamous British monarch who designed them but now Deputy Harte wants to preserve them because God designed them.

Comment on this

God designed Lough Foyle and put the Atlantic where it is.

Comment on this

Whoever designed them we did everything possible to obtain from the people permission to exercise a smaller amount of tolerance than is available in any democracy in the world in order to adhere to those boundaries which, whoever designed them, are practical considerations. But at the behest of the Opposition Parties the people rejected our request and we now have to deal with the situation as we find it due mainly to the machinations of the opposite Parties. To preserve county boundaries is exactly what Deputy Hogan and Deputy Harte and the other Deputies over there have ensured we are not permitted to do.

Deputy Hogan believes that his suggested solution—which of them I do not know because he has put forward so many at once that I do not know which he means—is better and maybe it is. We believe ours is better and, as I admitted, this is largely a matter of opinion. Deputies on the opposite side of the House may consider it quite a feasible and reasonable suggestion that each Deputy should have to represent the whole of the county of Donegal or that a constituency stretching from Ballyshannon in Donegal down to Shannonbridge on the Offaly border of Roscommon is a reasonable constituency for a Deputy to represent, but that is just where the difference of opinion comes in. We think that in this area, where only 30 seats can be allowed as the result of the Fine Gael action in 1961 in the High Court, we should have constituencies of the minimum size permitted by the Constitution, that is three-seat constituencies.

Deputy L'Estrange asked me what I mean by "duress". What I mean is that we made every possible effort to avoid doing what we have to do but we accept the decision of the people that county boundaries may not be adhered to and we are doing what is required to be done in accordance with the Constitution. Fine Gael, of course, want to have it both ways. First of all, having made sure that county boundaries cannot be adhered to, they now want to have it both ways and complain that what they required to be done is now being done.

The position with regard to what has been done with Leitrim is that under what is proposed each group of Leitrim people will form a significant proportion of the electorate in the constituency to which they will be attached. Deputy Fitzpatrick would have it otherwise. If he were arranging things, apparently he would detach the minimum number of Leitrim people from Leitrim and attach them to Donegal leaving them an insignificant number in the constituency of South-West Donegal.

Under what we propose there will not be any group of Leitrim people who will be in the position of having no influence in the constituency to which they will be attached and no Deputy or no candidate will be able with impunity to ignore the part of County Leitrim that will be attached to any of these three constituencies. In fact, there will be almost 7,000 Leitrim voters in each of these three constituencies, so that the Leitrim vote will be an important factor in the consideration of every candidate. In fact, it will be quite feasible, or almost feasible, for a Leitrim Deputy to be elected in either of the three constituencies— quite on the cards that it could happen. If Fine Gael have all this massive support that they claim to have in the county of Leitrim this may result in three Leitrim Fine Gael Deputies being elected here.

Deputy Harte also came out with the remarkable statement that a maximum of about 3,400 people would have to be transferred from Donegal under present circumstances when in fact he must know that this would be the minimum. What he said was that any number up to 13,400 odd would be transferred from Donegal. When I was speaking in Letterkenny during the referendum campaign I was referring to a specific proposal which Senator FitzGerald said he put forward on behalf of his Party to transfer this 6,319 people from Deputy O'Donnell's constituency—from the Ballyshannon and Bundoran area of Donegal—to Leitrim and this was a figure above the minimum Deputy Harte mentioned. It was the maximum I mentioned and it could be any figure within that in so far as the situation in Donegal was concerned.

In so far as the whole situation in this western area is concerned, and the requirement to have the ratio of population per Deputy as near as possible the same in every constituency, if that is to be the objective a substantially greater number would require to be so transferred. I do not remember which of the Fine Gael Deputies first brought up this question of a commission. The fact of the matter is as they know, and certainly as Deputy Fitzpatrick knows, the Constitution requires the Oireachtas to revise constituencies and to determine the constituencies by law and a commission can only be established if a referendum to amend the Constitution is held.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister knows that is not correct.

Comment on this

When there was a proposal to establish a commission Fine Gael were against it but here they want to have it both ways.

Comment on this

They want to be for and against a commission. They want to be for and against a simple proposal and a simple majority of the Dáil, to appoint a commission, for and against the two-thirds majority.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It was the same at the Ard Fheis. They were for and against Taca.

Comment on this

So far as we are concerned we have not changed our opinion about the desirability of adhering to administrative boundaries but the people at the behest of the Opposition have decided that the administrative boundaries are of no importance.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): You are going to stick your nose in it now.

Comment on this

I am ensuring that each group of Leitrim people will form some considerable proportion of the electoral constituency to which they are attached and their interests cannot with impunity be ignored by any political Party or any candidate. As regards Deputy Hogan's suggestion that the Fine Gael suggestion is to add merely Taghboy and Ahascragh to the administrative boundaries of Roscommon it is quite possible that this may have been one of the many suggestions put forward. It may have been one which was put forward. Certainly it is a fact that one suggestion made from the Fine Gael benches was that there should be a constituency with part of Donegal which presumably should be, as Senator FitzGerald suggested, the Ballyshannon and Bundoran areas, added to Leitrim with a small proportion which would be needed to make up Sligo to a sufficient level to justify three seats and require the constituency of Roscommon to form a five-seat constituency. There is not much point in arguing any further on this so far as I am concerned. It is quite clear that the Opposition have no intention of being consistent and that in fact their only objective here is to delay this Bill as far as possible.

Comment on this

Seven or eight hours delay.

Comment on this

The Minister in his concluding remarks said there was not much point in debating this any further as the Fine Gael proposals were not consistent. Let me point out that Deputy Fitzpatrick has given the Minister his proposals, Deputy Paddy Hogan has given his proposals, Deputy L'Estrange has made his suggestions and I have given mine. If the Minister considers that it is inconsistent to put forward point of views——

Comment on this

I am waiting for Deputy Clinton and Deputy Belton to give theirs and we will have all of them.

Comment on this

Wait until we come to Dublin.

Comment on this

What about Clare?

Comment on this

As the Minister knows we are consistent when we put forward a recommendation for a commission. If he claims duress is his trouble we have put forward reasonable proposals. The Minister in his opening remarks mentioned we had proposed out of a figure of 108,000 people putting a minimum of 3,400——

Comment on this

A maximum you said.

Comment on this

Let it be maxies. The maximum number of people to be transferred would be 3,400. I never used the word maximum or minimum. The mere fact that the Minister has mentioned a maximum of 3,400 indicates to the House that the Minister does consider this proposal and that it is not an unworkable one. The most reasonable aspect of it would be to have one less TD in Donegal. The Minister does not want that because it would be one less Fianna Fáil TD. The Minister says he had to look at the problem in the country as a whole. If this is the position why did the Minister invite every county councillor from every electoral area in the 26 Counties of Ireland to come to Dublin, expenses paid out of Taca money, to advise him and to consult with him on the proposals he was going to introduce to this House? Is this the type of duress the Minister is subjected to? Are members of the local cumainn who have been elevated to the county council to represent the Fianna Fáil Party at that level using undue influence on the Minister for Local Government? Is this what he means by duress? If this is what he means by duress then again, like Deputy Fitzpatrick, I submit if the Fianna Fáil Party were to accept the Fine Gael proposal to have a commission the Minister would be relieved of this headache.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot discuss the question of a commission. We are still debating the constituency of North-East Donegal.

Comment on this

Yes, I quite agree and a commission would have made a far better job of it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A commission has been debated in the House and the Dáil has taken a certain decision on it. It cannot come up again.

Comment on this

I quite agree. I submit to your ruling. If you had a commission you would not as the Minister wrongly indicated, have to amend the Constitution. The authority lies with the House to introduce and to amend Electoral Acts but a commission could advise the House. I am certain that if the Minister invited Members to participate in a commission and accepted their advice they would produce a fair, reasonable and rational Electoral Act. It would not be designed as the Minister obviously designed this one.

The Minister also mentioned that the county boundaries were described by me and by other members of the Fine Gael Party as being designed by God and took exception to that. In case the Minister has forgotten the geography of the country, I would remind him that most of the county of Donegal is decided by the Atlantic Ocean. The River Foyle is on one side, and Lough Foyle. The River Finn is a continuation of the River Foyle. If this is not designed by God I do not know who did it. I do not accuse the Minister of doing it.

Comment on this

It could be Paisley's doing.

Comment on this

The Minister also mentioned that I knew very little about geography when I referred to Urney West. The electoral division of Clonleigh South is what I could describe as the most easterly part of Donegal and is mostly my native parish. Urney West projects into County Tyrone. The people living there are, to a major degree, oriented towards Tyrone rather than towards Donegal.

Comment on this

We know who drew that border.

Comment on this

It was not God.

Comment on this

It was that Party over there.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We could have a debate on that too. The Minister conceded there would have to be some sort of arrangement with the North. It is in black and white and cannot be denied.

Comment on this

The Minister's remarks are very appropriate to this debate.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Totally irrelevant.

Comment on this

Completely irrelevant. Clonleigh South is the southern part of the parish of Clonleigh, which is my native parish. We have in that parish electoral divisions of Aghawee, Ardnaglass, Ballybogan, Camus, Churchtown, Gortin South, Gortnavilly, Legnabraid, Tirkeeran, Unshinagh Lower, Unshinagh Upper. If I were to describe them as South-West Donegal as the former Minister for Local Government described them people would say I had lost all sense of direction and had little knowledge of geography. The present Minister describes them as South Donegal-Leitrim. Am I to walk into the electoral division of Clonleigh South and tell people who go to church in Lifford that they now belong to North Leitrim just to satisfy the Fianna Fáil Party so that they can retain the status quo of four seats?

The Minister also suggested that there was a difference between four TDs representing Donegal in 1918 and the present position by virtue of the fact that the four represented four different constituencies, and said the comparison was unfair, that there was an imbalance and that we were not comparing like with like when saying that five TDs should represent the entire county. His argument appeared to me to be that the imbalance amounted to this—that four TDs elected to represent 168,000 people in the county of Donegal in the 1918 election were elected from four different constituencies. As such they controlled only the constituency which they were elected to represent. If there were five TDs in the county now with one constituency unit there would be a man in Inishowen representing somebody at Glencolumbkille. This is true. Is the Minister really serious in inferring or suggesting that anyone wanting to consult a Deputy at Glencolumbkille would travel to Inishowen to consult him? Does he suggest that anyone living at Fahan would go to Ballyshannon to consult a TD? The Minister must know very well that under the present system of proportional representation there is is local representation to a very major degree. It is only in extreme cases that a constituent would bypass a local Deputy and go to a Deputy of his own Party, because under proportional representation a person can vote second or third choice for a local Deputy.

The 1918 proposal, indeed, gave constituents only the right to vote for one Deputy. I cannot understand why the Minister disputes the argument or challenges the logic that this country elected its first Dáil with Donegal sending four TDs to represent 168,000 people.

Comment on this

How many are there now?

Comment on this

In 1918 they were without remuneration and without expenses and without protection. The Minister suggests that the county would be underrepresented with five TDs enjoying the privileges that this House gives them. I do not think that the Minister is serious when he suggests this and certainly any reasonable person would not accept his argument.

I am putting forward the argument that it was much more difficult for four men to represent County Donegal in 1918 under the then conditions than for five people to represent 60,000 people fewer—108,000 people. The Minister is not even satisfied with that but wants 50 per cent extra representation which would be six TDs to represent fewer people, and give them the privileges which we all enjoy. If the Minister says this is an unfair argument then I will accept it. My argument is of such force that even members of his own Party will concede that it is unfair to take 10,000 people from Leitrim just to satisfy the Fianna Fáil Party that four Fianna Fáil TDs will be returned out of that six, because if the county were one unit with five TDs—one TD is already elected by virtue of the office which he holds—four seats would be contested of which, despite the fact that it is the strongest constituency for votes controlled by the Party, it would be physically impossible for Fianna Fáil to win three. They could only hope to win two out of the four and one can take one's pick as to the two who would still be here out of the three men. Mr. Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Mr. Joe Brennan, the Minister for Social Welfare and Deputy Cunningham from Inishowen. I know and the Fianna Fáil Party know that the weakest of these three men is Deputy Cunningham. He would be the last man of the three whom I would defeat. There could be another permutation, but that is not within my authority.

The Minister, of course, goes on to say that Leitrim is now divided into three parts and that, in fact, Fine Gael could get three seats in Leitrim. This is utter folly. The population is approximately 30,000 and the Minister has divided it pretty evenly. He has transferred approximately 10,000 each to South-West Donegal, to Sligo and to Roscommon. We know that the quota is about 6,400 votes in order to elect a Deputy to the House and the largest number of votes in any one of these areas is 5,000.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

What is it, then?

Comment on this

There are almost 21,000 votes in Leitrim.

Comment on this

I do not wish to dispute the matter with the Minister but my mental ready reckoner suggests that for every two of the population there is one vote. The Minister can reach for his electoral list and he will find that the total electorate is 13,000 out of 20,000. These are his figures but he forgets—or is it that he is so far removed from the scene of the crime that he does not advert to the fact that there are at least 3,000 of those people in Birmingham, Glasgow, London and Manchester. Does the Minister dispute that?

We now see that out of every two of population, one has a vote. I should like to ask the Minister where are the 20,000 votes out of a population of 30,000 in Leitrim. As I have said, some of them are enjoying the luxuries being given to them by the British Government in places like Manchester, Glasgow and London. They will not be in Leitrim to help to elect a Deputy.

I believe as Deputy Fitzpatrick has said, that if the Minister were a conscientious person and if he believed in the things that I believe in and in view of the insults that were flung at him by every constituency in the country with the exception of one or two, he would have gone to the Taoiseach's office and said "I have no longer got the confidence of the people; I am no longer satisfied that I know what the people want. I must be a square". That is what the Minister is. The Minister is removed from reality. His dignity was so much offended by the result of the referenda——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We seem to be having a Second Reading debate on this amendment, which deals with North-East Donegal. That very clearly appears. The Deputy should get back to the matter before the House—the Minister's amendment.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir. I quite agree that it would appear that I am making a Second Reading speech but I shall come back, if you will permit me, to the point I am elaborating. I believe that the Minister's dignity and intelligence were offended——

Comment on this

The Minister has not got any.

Comment on this

That is debatable— that he said to his colleagues in the Government and the Parliamentary Party: "I will show the Irish people what is meant by arrogance; I will show the Irish people what power a Minister for Local Government has in a Fianna Fáil Cabinet; I will show the Irish people that no matter what they say we are still in power and we will introduce an Electoral Bill that will keep us in power——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let us get back to North-East Donegal if the Deputy has anything to say about it.

Comment on this

"——we will start with North-East Donegal and we will design accordingly every constituency from there to Wexford and to Kerry." This, in my judgment, has been the type of thinking of the Minister for Local Government during the drafting of this Bill. There can be no other explanation as to why a Minister should pluck from an electorate the contents of an Electoral Bill, drafted long before the two questions were decided in the referenda and which was available for inspection on the Minister's desk months before the referenda. It is not now so illogical for Fianna Fáil to put forward these proposals for amending the Constitution in defiance of the wishes of the Irish people? The Minister will say: "Hold it, lads; if it comes off, we are here for keeps: if it does not come off, there is the Electoral Act that will keep us in power——"

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be discussing the Electoral Act that has been approved by the House and on which we can have no further discussion.

Comment on this

I agree, a Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy agrees there should be no argument. We are discussing the constituency of North-East Donegal and the Deputy should try to relate at least some of his remarks to the amendment.

Comment on this

I quite agree with your ruling, a Cheann Comhairle, but surely I am entitled to refer to and to state clearly here the things which motivated the type of thinking which went into this Bill, which has now been described by everyone who has taken an interest in it, even those who have only taken a passing interest in it as a gerrymandering piece of legislation.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot have a further discussion on the Electoral Amendment Bill. What is before the House now is the Minister's amendment dealing with the Deputy's own constituency and the Deputy might relate some remark to it.

Comment on this

The reason why I deviated for those few minutes was that I felt the Minister commenced the carving up in North-East Donegal and that in this he was aided by his colleague, the former Minister for Local Government, who is a Deputy from that constituency, and he advised him on how the Minister could preserve four Fianna Fáil TDs out of six. During the referendum, the Fine Gael organisation—and this relates to the Electoral Amendment Act——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has already said that the referendum is not a matter for discussion on this amendment.

Comment on this

I agree, but the gerrymandering that went into this Bill is not the first piece which has affected Donegal. The Electoral (Amendment) Bill and the amendment now before the House affect North-East Donegal, and in order to debate North-East Donegal one must include the entire county of Donegal. If we take the entire county of Donegal we must take Sligo-Leitrim. I do not want to go any further than Leitrim. In 1918 we had four TDs representing 168,000 people, and in 1923 we moved up to a onecounty basis with eight TDs, after which time the population declined, as I have already stated, by an average of 1,000 per year.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair recollects that this has already been mentioned this evening.

Comment on this

I agree, but the Minister has put forward arguments and I want to knock them down. To preserve the Fianna Fáil representation, in 1937 the Fianna Fáil Government divided the county in two. They had four Fianna Fáil TDs out of eight. In 1937, under the Constitution, the population fell and they could only return seven TDs. The Fianna Fáil Party then drew a line in such a manner that they still retained four TDs out of seven. In 1961 the population declined further; they changed the line and retained four Fianna Fáil TDs out of six. This was a perfect piece of gerrymandering. Now, because the population has fallen so low that we can only, in all honesty, return five TDs, the only way to maintain the status quo of four TDs out of six is to bring the people of Leitrim into the administrative county of Donegal and make a bigger constituency. I know it is irrelevant to mention the referendum.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is glad the Deputy appreciates its irrelevance.

Comment on this

I use it only to underline my argument that Fianna Fáil had four TDs out of eight prior to 1937, that they had four TDs out of seven between 1937 and 1961, that they had four TDs out of six from 1961 to 1969, and now by another piece of gerrymandering they will maintain that position. It was not for any other reason that the Minister sent for his county councillors and paid their expenses—out of Taca money, I presume—to advise as to how he could bring in part of North Leitrim and so ensure that Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Brennan, the Minister for Social Welfare, and Deputy Cunningham, would be returned.

Comment on this

The farmer and the cowboy must be friends. We have the cowboy over there, Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not the kind of remark a Deputy should make.

Comment on this

That was the only reason why the Minister for Local Government called his posse from the different parts of the Twenty-six Counties to advise him as to how he could gerrymander every constituency to the best advantage of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This amendment deals with only one constituency.

Comment on this

Of course it does, and I have referred to the members of the Fianna Fáil Party who came from Donegal and every other constituency to advise the Minister as they did. This is the type of administration we have. It is one of the reasons why the Minister rejected the amendment proposed in the last session by Deputy Tom Fitzpatrick. The Minister has interfered with every constituency in the entire country. He admitted on numerous occasions, but particularly at a Fianna Fáil convention in Donegal, that only 24 of the 38 constituencies needed adjustment to comply with the Constitution.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must remind the Deputy that the amendment before the House deals with only one constituency.

Comment on this

I am quite aware of that, but it is rather difficult, to say the least of it, to discuss North-East Donegal without crossing the Border to South-West Donegal or Leitrim. I apologise if I have taken up the time of the House, but if the Minister feels I am expressing an opinion which is contrary to the wishes of the Donegal people, I shall debate with him in Donegal any of the matters I have raised during this short contribution.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I rise to deal with one net point dealt with by the Minister when he last spoke. The question of the commission, rightly or wrongly, has crept into this debate and it has been dealt with by both sides. I referred to it when last speaking, and the Minister in his reply stated that constitutionally a commission to arrange constituencies is not possible. He says that the Constitution lays down that the constituencies must be arranged by Oireachtas Éireann. I respectfully disagree with that proposition. However, assuming for the purpose of this debate and for one moment that the Minister was correct, what was to prevent the Minister from entrusting the arrangement of the constituencies to a Select Committee presided over by an independent person to advise Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am sure the Deputy will appreciate that if we were to discuss at this stage the implications of this, we would have a wide debate on it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I respectfully agree. I shall reply briefly, in a few sentences, to what the Minister said. What was to prevent the Minister from asking an independent body to advise him and advise the House? Then, even if the Minister did not see fit to accept the opinion of that body, at least the public at large would have had the benefit of having had it considered by an impartial and independent body.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte thinks he has made his point. Well, I must admit that I have not been able to see what point Deputy Harte was trying to make.

Comment on this

That is easily understood.

Comment on this

I shall resist the temptation to go to the same depths as Deputy Harte went to and to spend some time telling him what I think of him.

Comment on this

The Minister is a skin diver.

Comment on this

With regard to this allegation that I sent for every Fianna Fáil county councillor from every electoral area in Ireland I think that, at some time, Deputy Harte, if he is able to bring himself to do it, should read the contribution he has just made to this debate and see just how contradictory it is. He accuses me of having done this. Shortly before that, Deputy Fitzpatrick of Cavan assailed me for being able to produce this Bill within a matter of days. Shortly before that again, or at least during the last session of the Dáil, he was attacking me for having such a long delay in bringing it forward. Now, Deputy Harte says that, prior to drafting this Bill, I was able to bring every Fianna Fáil county councillor from every electoral area in Ireland to discuss with them how we should devise these different constituencies in order to maximise Fianna Fáil representation. Later on, Deputy Harte himself alleged that this Bill was drafted before the referendum.

I do not know what kind of nonsense this is or how anybody is to be expected to take Deputy Harte or any other member of the Fine Gael Party seriously. The only other point that I can remember Deputy Harte making is the question about the defeat of the Government proposals in the referendum and the magnitude of the defeat——

Comment on this

Annihilation.

Comment on this

——the suggestion being that this was a political reverse for the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Of course, it was.

Comment on this

Fine Gael will have an opportunity very soon of discovering whether or not that is so.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): How soon?

Comment on this

The people were asked to decide on a net issue in regard to the amendment of the Constitution in so far as it provides for the electoral system here and the delineation of constituencies. We have available to us quite recent evidence with regard to the state of political opinion in this country——

Comment on this

And the financial resources.

Comment on this

——the six by-elections out of seven that we won and, before this Dáil comes to an end, we shall have a record of nine by-election wins out of ten.

Comment on this

The Taca brigade.

Comment on this

Is the Minister laying odds on that?

Comment on this

Fine Gael will get the same type of electoral rebuff from the people as they have been getting throughout all the period of their existence. Our proposals in regard to electoral reform were defeated by a substantial margin of the people. But this, as I said, was dealing with a specific issue and a non-political issue. So far from feeling in any way disappointed about this, we are quite happy to face the people at any time with, behind us, the endorsement of our policy that we have got in seven by-elections six of which we won and in the other of which there was a clear indication that there was no diminution in Fianna Fáil support and in the knowledge that there are three further by-elections pending, all of which we confidently expect to win.

The most ridiculous of the suggestions that have come forward from the Fine Gael Party in their fairly obvious attempt to delay the passage of this Bill so that they will not have to face the electorate, is the suggestion of setting up a commission. If I were prepared to accept the commission's advice, Deputy Harte said there would be no contention about the Electoral (Amendment) Bill. All I can say is that if we were to set up a commission or a select committee or whatever one might call it to advise with regard to electoral changes and to expect advice from them, we would have to ensure that there would be very few Fine Gael representatives on it.

Comment on this

That would be of no difficulty to the Minister.

Comment on this

That is the understatement of the evening.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte has put forward his solution. Deputy Hogan has put forward his solution. Deputy L'Estrange has put forward his solution and I have put forward my solution. But nobody has put forward a Fine Gael solution because Fine Gael do not know their own mind on anything. Fine Gael are not able to agree on any subject under the sun. If Deputy Harte had been here longer he would have known that Deputy Esmonde put forward his solution for another part of the country and that, when I asked him if he had discussed it with one of his colleagues, he told me "No; this is my own solution" because one of his colleagues concerned was sitting on a bench below him. A commission comprising more than one Fine Gael representative obviously will not advise me on an electoral amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister would not take advice from an Archbishop because the Minister is incapable of adherence——

Comment on this

I wish to deal with two very brief points. The Minister says that if he were setting up a commission as an alternative, he would make sure there would be no Fine Gael people on it. That statement requires no comment. What I really said was that if he were working under duress, as he said he was, one of the solutions of his problem was to invite a commission to advise him. I did not forecast that the commission would bring in anything that would be as controversial as what the Minister has now brought before the House. I submit that the Minister does not want to understand the force of our argument. These are not Fine Gael proposals. These are logical proposals put forward by four or five different Fine Gael speakers, all of which are better than the proposal put forward by the Minister and it is in that light that they have been put forward. It does not follow at all, Sir, that the proposal which Deputy Fitzpatrick of Cavan has put forward is a contradiction of my proposal. Indeed, it is to say to the Minister: "Here is my proposal, Minister, which is a better one than yours". The Minister, apparently, does not accept that. Therefore, Deputy Hogan then steps forward and says: "Minister, here is my proposal which is different from Deputy Fitzpatrick's proposal and which is a better proposal than yours" but the Minister is not prepared to accept it. Deputy L'Estrange then says: "Minister, here is my proposal which is different from that of Deputy Fitzpatrick and that of Deputy Hogan and that of Deputy Harte and which is better than your proposal", but the Minister will not accept it. My intention, with respect, is to state clearly exactly the same thing. It is different from Deputy L'Estrange's, Deputy Hogan's and Deputy Fitzpatrick's but it is not acceptable to the Minister. The four proposals put forward by my three colleagues and myself are all fairer than the Minister's proposal but he will not accept any of them. It is grossly unfair of the Minister to say that we are in conflict with each other. We could certainly agree on any one proposal and, no matter which one we agreed on, it would be a fairer decision than the one the Minister is forcing, by pure Party strength through the House.

My other point is that he mentioned that I had contradicted my statement by saying that the Bill was drafted before the referendum and that I had also said later on that he sent for Fianna Fáil councillors from every electoral area to advise him on the Bill after the referendum. I say this Bill was drafted, available for inspection by every member of the Government, long before the referendum issues were decided by the people. By members of the Government I mean exclusively the Cabinet Ministers. If anyone thinks that is an illogical conclusion I do not know the meaning of reason. The Minister had this drafted before the referendum issues were decided and he and his Cabinet colleagues knew the terms of the Bill. He knew where the boundary lines would be between North East and South West Donegal but again, to wriggle his way out of it, he tries to confuse the issue as to what, apparently, he thinks I have said.

I further said that the Minister said to his colleagues: "If we lose the referendum this is the alternative. This is what will keep us in office and we will stay long enough in office to purchase the goodwill of the people again." This they did on previous occasions. This is the logic of my argument. Having lost the referendum to the extent they did, the Minister then sent for the county councillors from the different parts of Ireland and from County Donegal to come and advise him as to whether it would be right to keep Donegal as one unit with five Deputies, to chop off the head of one of their own Deputies, or whether they should bring in part of Leitrim to supplement the population of County Donegal to enable him to draw a different division line between North and South Donegal so as to keep four Deputies out of six, as they kept four TDs out of seven prior to 1961.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must point out to the Deputy that this seems to be repetition of what the Deputy has already said.

Comment on this

I am correcting for the record the inaccuracies of the Minister who is trying to confuse the issues. I agree that it is repetition. I have stated and I conclude by saying this, that the Bill was known to members of the Cabinet. I did not say that it was known to every Tom, Dick and Harry. If the Minister says the referendum was not a defeat for the Government I should like to know who lost?

Comment on this

I just want a little information related to a remark which the Minister passed in his allegations against members of the Fine Gael Party and what he described as their delaying tactics. He said they obviously wanted to delay the passage of the Bill in order to avoid facing the electorate. Are we to infer from that that as soon as the Bill is passed we will have a general election?

Comment on this

To deal with Deputy Corish's intervention first, I think it is fairly well known that the Fianna Fáil Party believe that we are required to accede to the demands made by the Labour Party for a revision of constituencies. We believe it would be desirable to comply with their request that we comply with the terms of the Constitution before having a general election. It is in order to comply with this requirement of the Constitution that this Bill is before the House and until this Bill is passed by the House and by the Seanad the constituencies will not have been brought into line with the provisions of the Constitution. Therefore, this is in fact preparing the way to ensure that the next general election will be held on constituencies that comply with the Constitution.

Comment on this

The Minister has not answered the question. He said it was a matter of urgency to get the Bill passed. Is that not so?

Comment on this

I said that the Fine Gael Party are engaged in an obvious attempt to delay the passage of this Bill.

Comment on this

But the Minister took six hours 15 minutes on the Bill in the Seanad.

Comment on this

They are obviously trying to delay this Bill which is designed to bring the constituencies into line with constitutional requirements. Fine Gael, because of the disarray in which the Party are at present, are seeking to delay the passage of the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister said it was because we were afraid to face the people.

Comment on this

The Minister has not answered my question.

Comment on this

He does not know himself.

Comment on this

Of course, I do not know when the general election will be held.

Comment on this

Because you are so divided.

Comment on this

Because I do not know when we will get the Bill through. I do not know when we will get even the Schedule of the Bill through. I do not know when the general election will be held because the Taoiseach will decide to have a general election when he sees fit and when he decides to have the general election we will come back here in a stronger position than we are now. While on the subject of the general election I must thank both Opposition Parties for the assistance they have given us to ensure——

Comment on this

The Minister did not answer the question.

Comment on this

——that we shall come back in a stronger position than we are at the moment. They have both been of the very greatest assistance.

Comment on this

The Minister was pretty far wrong early last year.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte alleged that if there was to be a commission I would make sure that there would be no Fine Gael people on it. What I said, as Deputy Harte knows, was that if I wanted a commission to give advice it would be obvious from what the Fine Gael people said today that the only possibility of getting advice from such a commission would be not to have too many Fine Gael people on it, because even the limited number of them who have come in here today cannot agree among themselves in regard to a small section of the country. We had four speakers, four different solutions, and I have no doubt that if Deputy Belton and Deputy Clinton decided to contribute to the debate they would have two different solutions also. Obviously, if we had a number of Fine Gael people on such a commission we would get as many advices as they had members on the commission and that would not be of any assistance in arriving at a final decision.

Comment on this

A final point——

Comment on this

The Deputy reminds me that I forgot something.

Comment on this

I shall give way to the Minister. I would not like to delay him.

Comment on this

I should not like to interrupt Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

Lest perhaps the Minister is serious in trying to lead the people astray by saying that the purpose of this debate is to delay the Bill so that Fine Gael would not have to face an election, if the Minister guarantees us that the Taoiseach will dissolve the Dáil tomorrow, we will give him every section of the Bill right now.

Comment on this

What about the Seanad?

Comment on this

You can have a special meeting of the Seanad tomorrow.

Comment on this

Seeing that Deputy Harte cannot speak for his own colleagues——

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister——

Comment on this

——in this House, I will not accept that Deputy Harte can speak for Senator FitzGerald, because I cannot visualise Senator FitzGerald giving all sections of the Bill without discussion.

Comment on this

The Minister has my word for it.

Comment on this

Senator FitzGerald's plan for Donegal was to transfer Bundoran and Ballyshannon out of it. I refrain from dealing with Deputy Harte's statement on the representation of Donegal in 1918. I did not consider it very relevant. I am not called on to defend the level of representation which the British Government allocated to Donegal in 1918. There is no reason why I should have to defend the allocation of four seats by the British Government to represent the whole of Donegal. It is not my business.

Comment on this

Are all these amendments now being put?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Each amendment will be put in turn, without debate.

SOUTH-WEST DONEGAL.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:

In page 7, in the first column, to delete "South-West Donegal" and to substitute "Donegal-Leitrim".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:

In page 7, in the second column of the entry relating to South-West Donegal, after "Magheraclogher" to insert "(with the exception of the townland of Glentornan)".

This amendment proposes to transfer the townland of Glentornan in the district electoral division of Magheraclogher from the proposed constituency of South-West Donegal to North-East Donegal. The electors in this townland vote in Dunlewy which is in the proposed constituency of North-East Donegal. I understand that, having regard to the mountainous nature of the area, it would be difficult to make suitable alternative polling arrangements for these electors if they were included in South-West Donegal. The total population of the townland is only eight.

The change would reduce the population of the proposed constituency of South-West Donegal to 58,338, an average per Deputy of 19,446, and increase the population of North-East to 59,208, an average per Deputy of 19,736.

Comment on this

We agree to this amendment not because we agree with the general contents of the Bill but because here we are dealing with Donegal people being transferred from one part of the county to another, still being represented by a Donegal man. Irrespective of which Party these people will support, they will be selecting a Donegal man to represent them. This kind of thing indicates the muddled thinking of the Minister in regard to the entire Bill. It demonstrates clearly that the Minister must comply with boundaries as God designed them. He went to great lengths to dispute that God could design county boundaries.

Apparently, the Minister has had second thoughts. Here, God designed a mountain range separating one part of Donegal from another and the Minister has decided that the people in Glentornan would be best served, that it would be in their best interests to have them represented by Deputies in North-East Donegal rather than leaving them with Deputies representing South-West Donegal and North Leitrim. These people have more in common with the people of North-East Donegal. This has been the basis of our argument and of the whole trend of the debate on these amendments— that people are entitled because of their background and heritage and because of their wishes in the matter of representation, to be coupled with people of their kindred. The people of Glentornan are very welcome to the constituency which I represent and which I hope I will continue to represent. I hope that before long the people in the areas described by the Minister as being in South-West Donegal and North Leitrim, who have a lot more in common with the people of North-East Donegal, will be treated in a similar manner.

Therefore, in agreeing to this amendment I wish to say that this Party will guarantee that, if given a mandate after the next general election we will acknowledge the boundaries as God designed them and as man followed— we will introduce an Electoral Bill in respect of which no one can accuse us of attempting to gerrymander nature. The Minister may not think I have the authority to speak for Fine Gael.

Comment on this

I thought it was for God the Deputy was speaking.

Comment on this

The one man in Ireland who got confused with God saved Fianna Fáil from a major defeat in the Presidential Election in 1966. He was the only man who became confused with God. If the Minister feels we are delaying the Bill, then if he gives an assurance to the House that the Government will dissolve Dáil Éireann tomorrow and have an election within the next month, I guarantee now that the Fine Gael Party will give him every section in the Bill without a vote.

Comment on this

Is the Minister moving an amendment?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is no amendment to it. It is part of the Schedule.

Comment on this

I understand. Earlier today the Minister said that he was aware that I knew a good bit more about Meath and Cavan than I did about County Dublin and that he was well aware of the fact that I did not know County Dublin. Looking at this proposal here, all I can say is that the Minister obviously not only does not know County Dublin but he does not know even the townland next to his own. When I was speaking on the Second Stage I pointed out to him how ridiculous he was in the mapping out of this constituency. People in one part of the constituency who had been voting for as long as we can remember in Newcastle were put voting in Lucan and those nearer to Lucan were put voting somewhere else. I cannot object to this amendment because that ridiculous situation was an obvious mistake in the first instance. The whole area of Ballymakaily, Brownstown, Coolscuddan——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate we have not yet reached that.

Comment on this

I thought you said we were on amendment No. 15.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are on that portion of the Schedule which deals with North County Dublin.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 15 is surely related?

Comment on this

Maybe, if we discuss the grouping of constituencies in County Dublin. The amendment, while it specifically relates to one, does in fact deal with the three actually.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

If it is agreed to take the entry in regard to North County Dublin with South County Dublin——

Comment on this

And Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

And Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown.

Comment on this

Do I take it there has been a change in the decision given earlier that related constituencies could be discussed together? If that decision stands Deputy Clinton can talk about related constituencies.

Comment on this

I thought it was a point about the amendment.

Comment on this

That is a later stage.

Comment on this

The amendment affects the three of them.

Comment on this

Of course, it does.

Comment on this

I find it somewhat difficult. These areas are in fact, in North County Dublin and it is now proposed to exclude them. These were included in what the Minister described in the Bill as North County Dublin and the amendment proposes to exclude them and it is very difficult, therefore, to discuss the new constituencies without referring to that fact. The proposed constituency of North County Dublin starts a couple of miles beyond Balbriggan. It goes out to Skerries, comes back to Blanchardstown, takes in Newcastle, Clonsilla, Lucan, out to Mulhuddart, Clondalkin, comes up again to the fringe of Newcastle, on to Clondalkin, across to Crumlin, Walkinstown, Greenhills, Manor Estate, Perry Estate, Kimmage Manor and, in fact, Fortfield Road. Anyone who knows Dublin could tell the Minister that anyone who regards that as a compact constituency certainly knows very little about County Dublin. The fact is the Minister knows County Dublin well. He was not, of course, motivated with the idea of drawing a compact constituency in this case certainly. He was thinking of one thing and one thing only: that was how he could preserve the seats of two Fianna Fáil Deputies in North County Dublin.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not accuse him of such a thing.

Comment on this

I said earlier he made a mess of the referendum. He proved he was not in touch with the people. The result showed that the Minister did not know what the people wanted. That was obvious. It is even more obvious now that the Minister is making another mess of this. He may think he is doing a great thing for Fianna Fáil. He will find he is making the mistake of his life. He thinks he has broken up County Dublin in such a way that Fianna Fáil will get quite wonderful support and equally wonderful representation in it. There is another shock in store for the Minister just like the shock he got in the referendum. He is as wrong in his ideas here as he was in the referendum.

I should like him to tell the people why he drew this constituency in this peculiar way. Why did he put four seats in North County Dublin and three in South County Dublin instead of four in South County Dublin and three in North County Dublin? Why was it necessary to split No. 3 area right down the middle? He will not tell the House why he did that. I say he could have left this area intact were it not for the fact that he was at pains to split my council vote. He knows that in three county council elections I headed the poll in that particular area and he wanted to ensure that where I live would be on the border of the two constituencies. Strangely enough — I said this on Second Reading—he also wanted to ensure that a certain Fianna Fáil councillor—he is a man who has done a good deal of work in the area but he is not one of the favoured— would not be successful and he also wanted to get far enough away himself from Deputy Burke. I said all this on Second Reading in the Minister's absence. I am glad he is present now when I repeat what I said then. I cannot see any other motives for the Minister producing this extraordinary constituency of North County Dublin. Nobody in the area affected can understand why it is North County Dublin.

One of the reasons why the Minister did not do what I suggest, make South County Dublin a four-seater and make North County Dublin a three-seater is that he knows that in a certain area which I would include in South County Dublin he has fallen into disfavour and he does not want to make things more difficult for himself than they will be. He is not motivated by any intention to produce a compact constituency. He just chopped it up to save and suit himself. That is really what I want to emphasise.

Comment on this

It is rather a pity that Deputy Clinton did not say as much about this as he did on Second Reading. I mentioned in passing today, when Deputy Clinton put forward his close knowledge of County Meath, that it would appear from his contribution on Second Reading of this Bill that he must know more about County Meath than he does about County Dublin, because some of the suggestions he put forward on Second Reading with regard to this matter of North County Dublin and South County Dublin show either of two things: either Deputy Clinton is entirely ignorant of the constituency he now represents, or else he is deliberately feeding his supporters with what he knows to be false arguments and false propaganda. In column 1969 of the Official Report of the Dáil Debates of 4th December, 1968, Deputy Clinton has this remarkable and ridiculous statement to make:

Why not take the Navan road and make North County Dublin a three seater and give South County Dublin four seats?...

If he took the Navan road he would have the population for a three-seater on the north side and a four-seater on the south side.

If Deputy Clinton knew anything about the constituency he represents he would know that that is absolute nonsense. It is in complete contradiction of the facts. I am sure he could procure a copy of the Census of Population Report, 1966.

Comment on this

I have it.

Comment on this

If he would look at that and at the Swords electoral area, the No. 1 electoral area, he would see that the population of that electoral area is 31,412 and that, as he knows, comprises almost all of the territory in County Dublin north of the Navan Road, and that the Lucan electoral area, the No. 2 electoral area, has a population of 26,410. If he would get a pencil and add the two figures together he would see that the total of the No. 1 electoral area and the No. 2 electoral area comes to 57,822, which would be barely above the minimum allowed under the Constitution as interpreted by the High Court for three seats. If it could be considered on its own—that area stretching far south of the Navan Road— even Deputy Clinton will know that the No. 2 electoral area comprises, in addition to the area north of the Navan Road, Castleknock, Lucan, Palmerstown and Clondalkin—the total of these two areas——

Comment on this

And Manor Estates.

Comment on this

——if they could be considered alone, is in compliance with the constitutional requirements for three seats. As Deputy Clinton should know, they cannot be considered alone. They must be considered in the context of the fact that, having allocated seats to the rest of the country, there are 38 seats left in the Dublin area and that if one constituency with only 57,822 of population is to be made a three-seat constituency, then the remaining population would be far in excess of what would be permitted for the remaining 35 seats which is the maximum that can be allocated to the remainder of the Dublin area. So Deputy Clinton knows that what he suggests, what he tries to propagate, that North County Dublin should be a three-seat constituency, is not possible and that, in fact, you can barely squeeze in two seats. Surely he must know at this stage that the Constitution does not permit of a two-seat constituency.

Deputy Clinton knows that the whole of the No. 1 electoral area and the No. 2 electoral area would not be sufficient even for a three-seat constituency. It would be deficient by 3,000 or 4,000 of population and, therefore, even to make North County Dublin a three-seat constituency you must take some population from the No. 3 electoral area.

Comment on this

A very slight number.

Comment on this

Deputy Clinton knows that the adjoining parts of the No. 3 electoral area are the Walkinstown area or the Newcastle, Saggart and Rathcoole area. If you take the Navan Road as the boundary, there is no doubt that neither Walkinstown nor Lucan nor Clondalkin are north of that boundary. Still they are more northerly than any part of the proposed constituency of South County Dublin. That is what I was referring to when I said that Deputy Clinton has already demonstrated quite clearly that, whatever he may know about County Meath, he is completely ignorant about the distribution of population in the constituency he represents at present.

I do not think I ever claimed that under this Bill the constituency of North County Dublin or any other constituency, except possibly the urban ones, is a compact constituency, but certainly North County Dublin is a more compact constituency than the one Deputy Clinton and I represent at present. Therefore, as to making North County Dublin a three-seat constituency, surely is a toss up, since there are seven seats, which you make a three-seat constituency and a four-seat constituency. Deputy Clinton apparently would consider himself more convenienced if South County Dublin were a four-seat constituency, and so would I. I think I would probably find it easier to be elected in a four-seat constituency than in a three-seat constituency, as would any Deputy. If Deputy Clinton's vote will be adversely affected by the fact that North County Dublin is a four-seat constituency so will mine. I will retain only a very small proportion—on the assumption that I go up in South County Dublin——

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is gone.

Comment on this

——of the constituency for which I was originally elected, and only a comparatively small portion of the constituency for which I was elected in the last general election.

Deputy Clinton knows this is a reasonable and rational division of the constituency, in fact, I would say, one of the only two feasible divisions of the constituency that could be made. Eleven seats had to be squeezed into this small area of County Dublin. Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown has always been a four-seat constituency and, in order that it should remain a four-seat constituency, it had to be reduced. There was a surplus population from the existing Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown constituency.

Comment on this

Why not make it five?

Comment on this

I do not know what Deputy Belton is saying.

Comment on this

Why not make it five in Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown?

Comment on this

There are 11 seats. You could have one five-seat constituency, and two three-seat constituencies, or two four-seat constituencies and one three-seat constituency. We decided——

Comment on this

In the interests of the Party.

Comment on this

——on the same basis as in other rural constituencies to have two four-seat constituencies and one three-seat constituency, whereas we could have gone for one five-seat constituency and two three-seat constituencies. The more likely thing to have done was to have kept the five-seat constituency where it is already.

Comment on this

We will come back to it tomorrow.

Comment on this