Private Business. - Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–237 of 479. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 35 of 1968 ›
When progress was reported last night I was outlining some of the riduculous things that my colleague, Deputy Clinton, had said about the necessary rearrangement of the County Dublin constituencies. I pointed out that even Deputy Clinton must know that the area he suggested should comprise the North County Dublin constituency would barely be sufficient to justify two seats under the existing constitutional provisions. I pointed out that even if North County Dublin were to be a three-seat constituency it would still be unavoidable that some population would have to be taken from the No. 3 electoral area. So that these delusions of persecution from which Deputy Clinton is suffering are completely without justification. Deputy Clinton is perfectly well aware that I reside in the same locality as he does and that any taking away of part of that area affects me just as it affects him. In fact, unlike Deputy Clinton who has announced that his roots are in County Meath, I have my roots in that area.
Comment on this
The Minister was born in North-East, and not County, Dublin. Fairview is not in that area.
Comment on this
If Deputy Clinton knew anything about the area he would know that. However, the position is that in so far as any locality affects Deputy Clinton it affects me as well. The considerations here were that there had to be two extra seats squeezed into this small area of County Dublin. As there are no constituencies returning more than five seats, there were two ways of doing this: having one five-seat and two three-seat constituencies or, as our proposal is, having two four-seat constituencies and a three-seat constituency. Obviously this would leave Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown a four-seat constituency and North County Dublin a four-seat constituency and the area comprising the surplus population from these two areas a three-seat constituency which is the new constituency of South County Dublin. That is the area I propose to contest and in which I have no doubt whatever it will be possible to elect a second Fianna Fáil TD as well.
Comment on this
We will come to the question of the unfortunate disruption of the long association between myself and Deputy Burke. This is one of the most regrettable things in this whole unwelcome operation that I have to perform. At least for a temporary period this very felicitous association between myself and Deputy Burke has to come to an end.
Comment on this
The total population of the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas is 57,822 which is 4,461 short of the average for three seats. Even after the Baldoyle ward from the city area had been added, and that was essential because of the distribution of population and because of the fact that there were only 38 seats available for the Dublin area, the addition of that would not be sufficient to make a three-seat area because the population that would be left would be too many for the number of seats that had to be squeezed in.
Comment on this
I got it by the addition of the population of the No. 1 electoral area to the population of the No. 2 electoral area. If the Deputy will write down 31,412 and underneath if he will write 26,410, draw a line under that and add them, even he will get 57,822 and if he adds to that the population of the Baldoyle ward which is 2,097 he will get 59,919. 57,822 is the population of the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas. If he adds to that the population of the Baldoyle ward which is 2,097 he gets 59,919 and if he deducts that from the total population of the County of Dublin including the Borough of Dún Laoghaire and divides the resulting figure by the remaining number of seats which is eight, Deputy Clinton will find that the result would be over the allowable figure of population per Deputy. Therefore, it was necessary even in order to create a three-seat constituency comprising the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas and the Baldoyle ward to take some population from the No. 3 area.
Comment on this
That is a fact which Deputy Clinton can work out for himself but maybe he is only able to do the addition, maybe he is not able to do the subtraction and division that are also involved in this. Therefore, some extra had to be taken and the obvious place to take it from was the Walkinstown area and since figures of population are available only on a townland basis it was decided to take all that area and make the North County Dublin area a four-seat constituency.
With regard to the suggestion by Deputy Clinton that this has been done to make a safe seat for Deputy Foley it might be no harm to remind Deputy Clinton of the result of the last general election in the area. In 1965, County Dublin was a five-seat constituency and for Deputy Clinton's information there were two Deputies elected on the first count with substantial surpluses—my distinguished and gracious colleague Deputy Burke and myself — Deputy Burke with a total of 19,076 and myself with a total of 14,022. Deputy Dunne was elected on the fourth count and on the sixth count Deputy Foley was elected, again with a substantial surplus of almost 1,000. That left the remaining seat, the fifth seat, to be allocated to Deputy Clinton without a quota.
Comment on this
Without a quota. He had the distinction of getting the sole Fine Gael seat, the last seat, without a quota. Therefore, there is obviously no need whatever——
Comment on this
He is quite safe. With regard to the suggestion that the purpose of this operation is to separate me from my colleague Deputy Burke, the figures of previous elections will show quite clearly that, so far from there being any reason why I should wish to do that, there is every reason why I should wish to remain in that distinguished company.
Comment on this
It would be useful to remember the first time the Minister was elected. It was a good job he was in the constituency then.
Comment on this
Yes, the first time was in 1957 when the constituency of County Dublin was a three-seat constituency and the quota was 9,561. Here again Deputy Burke was as usual elected with a substantial surplus of 2,498 and the next Deputy on the first count was myself with 9,412, 149 short of the quota. Of course on the distribution of Deputy Burke's surplus I got ten times more than the small number of 149 that I required. It took four more counts and on the fifth count the third seat was filled by the then Deputy Rooney who is now Senator Rooney. At the next election of 1961 when County Dublin had become a five-seat constituency again my colleague Deputy Burke was elected at the head of the poll as is his wont with the substantial surplus of 1,835 votes. I was elected also on the first count with a substantial surplus of 1,622 and as is usual in County Dublin we were the only two who were elected on the first count. It took until the seventh count to elect anybody else.
I do not think those figures show any reason for me to try to get away from my colleague, Deputy Burke. In fact, as he has often said himself, we have formed a great team and our association has certainly done a great deal to ensure the continuance of good government in this country by ensuring a Fianna Fáil majority in the constituency we represented. Indeed, in the near future when I will be attending a round of social functions to mark the 25th anniversary of my colleague's election to Dáil Éireann I can assure Deputies that there will be many sincere expressions of mutual regret at the breaking up of this association.
The arrangement that has been made with regard to County Dublin is the most suitable one that could be made. The line dividing the constituency of North County Dublin from South County Dublin is taking account of the necessity to follow district electoral divisions and townland boundaries as far as possible, the line running as closely as possible east and west, and the description given to the constituency, which is the logical one for the area lying north of that line is North County Dublin and South County Dublin to the other area and the description of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown is retained.
Comment on this
The Minister had the effrontery to come here last night and accuse us on this side of the House of wasting time. We all know that he and his Government have wasted the time of this House and of the country, as well as a considerable amount of public money, in a referendum that was unwanted by anybody except the Minister and a few other power-thirsty bullies in his own Party. However, we are speaking here this morning on the Bill. The Minister said very little on the Bill. He spent himself in his efforts to humiliate me but he has not succeeded, I can assure him.
I stood before the people in County Dublin on five occasions—three local elections and two general elections— and the people in County Dublin honoured me on each of those five occasions by electing me, which is more than the Minister for Local Government can say about the people of County Dublin. As far as he is concerned, it took him a long time to get in. That, again, is far away from the Bill. However, I shall take the Minister's own figures and I shall prove that it was not necessary to take in the No. 3 area in order to get a three-seat constituency in North County Dublin. For the area that we have known as the No. 1 area in North County Dublin, he gives a figure of 31,412 population and, if I got his figure correctly, 26,410 for the No. 2 area, making this 57,420 odd.
Comment on this
We still have plenty. We shall add 2,092—that was the figure for the Baldoyle ward that was added—and we arrive at 59,900 which is as good as 60,000 and, without using the tolerance, we have place for three Deputies. Who, now, cannot do addition? I take it that it is the Minister for Local Government who cannot do addition because it is obvious to me that it is made for a three-seat constituency without coming into the No. 3 area at all and using largely the well-known boundary of the Naas Road. However, the Minister came into the No. 3 area with the deliberate intention of splitting my council vote—I say it again because I know that it has been done. The Minister has not succeeded in proving that that has not been so. He spoke about my reference to the Navan Road as a natural boundary and referred to it and to the Naas Road as boundaries well known by the people and a natural boundary.
What I meant by the Navan Road was that the nearest point the people in County Dublin would recognise as North County Dublin would be the right-hand side of the Navan Road as you go towards Navan from Dublin. I think the Minister will agree that that is so. A nearer point would not be recognised by anyone as North County Dublin. Now he speaks about the impossibility of creating a three-seater on that side of the Navan Road. I see no impossibility at all. We had Sutton and Howth that were formerly in County Dublin. There is a population there of about 20,000. Furthermore, we had the position in North-East Dublin where they could easily give us 20,000 and more in order to accommodate a three-seater constituency in County Dublin. The Minister has set out deliberately to misrepresent me. He finishes up then by glorifying Deputy Foley and saying that, of course, Deputy Foley was elected before I was.
Comment on this
Of course he was—but the Minister made sure that he would not give us the first preference votes because, if he did——
Comment on this
If the Minister gave us the first preference votes the House would see where Deputy Foley came— he got the surpluses, good luck to him, and he got elected. He may have a good deal of trouble in getting elected the next time.
Comment on this
If the constituencies stood as they were, he would get no seat the next time. The Minister knew that. He set out deliberately to take that part of Baldoyle that he knew to be a Fianna Fáil stronghold and he put it into Deputy Foley's lap in order to get him elected. The Minister for Local Government is not fooling anyone when he tells this House that he was doing the best he could in all the circumstances to provide compact constituencies that were easily worked. Anybody who would describe a constituency running from beyond Balbriggan to Kimmage Manor as a compact constituency cannot be taken as speaking seriously when it was completely unnecessary to pass the Naas Road to get a three-seater constituency in North County Dublin that would serve the people and serve them well—but, then, Deputy Foley would not have been elected and the Minister knew that. That is the reason for making it a completely unnatural four-seater constituency. However, the Minister has made his decision. He tells us now that he is going to do well. He told us the same on the referendum—that he was going to do well. However, the people come in here somewhere. I know what the people will tell him in South County Dublin. If he does not get two seats in North County Dublin then certainly it will not be for the want of trying very hard in gerrymandering the area: he has done that very effectively. Not only has he done that to us but he has done it to Labour. He has made sure that he has thrown all the Labour support into North County Dublin so that they cannot possibly get a seat in South County Dublin.
Comment on this
I hope Deputy Tully is right in this but I cannot see it on the figures available to me. I think that this was deliberately done in order to put so much of the Labour support into North County Dublin that it would be impossible for them to get a seat in South County Dublin. Those are some of the motives and I am sure I can think of others: I shall leave it for the moment. I have effectively proved that the Minister had a perfect three-seater constituency without coming into the area or splitting it.
Comment on this
I just want to express my views on this matter and to say that I am glad to see that there is a bit of a change of heart as far as Deputy Clinton is concerned. Of course, we can understand the dismay in his attitude because he himself is probably basing his own Party on the figures of his own election at the last general election. If this is correct, and it seems to be so, it is no wonder Deputy Clinton is so worried about it because if I, myself, were the last Deputy elected out of five Deputies in the county in the last election, I should be worried too. However, if I can put his mind at ease, I would say to him: "Do not be too worried about me, Deputy Clinton, or worried about Deputy Burke because we will survive, as we proved to you in the last election, when you scraped home dragging your feet just because you deprived an honest man, who is now Senator Eamonn Rooney, of his seat." We all know that Deputy Clinton utilised the man who is now Senator Rooney to gather votes for him in the last general election. However, I do not think this will happen again because Senator Rooney is now based on the North side. Deputy Clinton does not know where he is based.
Comment on this
Did Deputy Clinton lead me in the finish? Did Deputy Clinton get the quota? Answer. How many seats did you get? You got one seat out of five.
Comment on this
Deputy L'Estrange was not here and therefore does not know that I am answering Deputy Clinton's argument.
Comment on this
If Fianna Fáil can do it, we shall do it with every constituency in Ireland, if the Chair allows Fianna Fáil to do it.
Comment on this
You will do it whether you are allowed or not. Deputy Clinton mentioned bringing in the Howth portion of the North East, bringing in 20,000 votes from Sutton. If the Minister was trying to protect me, I suggest to him here and now that he might bring in Howth, Sutton and a portion of the North East.
Comment on this
I have no doubt in the world about my being elected. I have a large circle of friends in that area. I have a large circle of supporters and I can muster up a considerable amount of support. I do not think the Minister was trying to protect me because he brought in a large portion of South County Dublin. Naturally, since I live on the north side I do not command a lot of support in it but my support is growing and increasing in that area and I have no doubt that, in the next election—whenever it may be—Deputy Clinton will have to eat his words once again. He has expressed dismay here on my behalf. I will express that dismay on behalf of Deputy Clinton at the next election, because I fervently feel it is his own seat he is worried about. From a Party point of view, he is not interested in whether Fine Gael get two seats, three seats or how many seats they get. His particular interest is that Deputy Clinton stays here, at the bottom of the poll, shall we say?
Comment on this
And why not? That is the interest of every Party. Let Deputy Clinton not think that, just because Fine Gael throw a kind, soft word towards the Labour Party, they would not take his seat tomorrow. Deputy Clinton is being misled by somebody— I do not know who it is. We shall probably take Deputy Clinton's seat.
Comment on this
In conclusion, if it eases Deputy Clinton's mind, I can assure him that the amount of work I have put into the constituency I represent is very substantial. He uses the national press to try to drag down any work which I have done. Because I do not go seeking publicity in the public press for every step forward I take on behalf of my constituents, Deputy Clinton and his colleagues are inclined to believe that I shall not be elected again. But the people of County Dublin are firmly convinced that I have worked hard on their behalf and I shall continue to work on their behalf. I have no doubt that when the next election comes they will satisfy critics such as Deputy Clinton and even critics in the Press by re-electing both Deputy Burke and myself and possibly even another colleague in North County Dublin.
Comment on this
I am very grateful to Deputy Foley for having disclosed publicly here the mind behind the introduction of this Bill by the Minister for Local Government. It proves conclusively what we said during the referendum campaign and what we have been saying in the House and outside it since the Bill was published, that it was designed and conceived solely for the purpose, as Deputy Foley has just admitted as one of those in politics who sometimes blab things out by mistake, of benefiting the Fianna Fáil Party——
Comment on this
——and for nothing else but to do what the Minister can to destroy other Parties opposed to Fianna Fáil. That is not the way any Minister for Local Government or any Minister in any Government should approach the national duty of his office. We are grateful to Deputy Foley for having exposed the manner in which the Minister has put his Party before his national duty.
What is the purpose of this constituency that we are now discussing? The purpose of its being drawn as it has been drawn is to provide an end to what I heard the Minister for Local Government describe as a felicitous association. It was a felicitous association for Deputy Burke, I suppose, because he was always able to lead the Minister for Local Government. The constituency is drawn for the purpose of ensuring that there would be an unnatural division between North and South County Dublin. I do not know whether Deputy Foley will remember or not, but I am quite sure the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister, if not the Minister himself, will remember that somewhere about 18 years ago the all-Party Committee of the Mansion House published certain pamphlets showing in relation to the North of Ireland the exact shape in which gerrymandering had been carried out. If anybody cares to look in the Oireachtas Library he can find one of the pictures in those pamphlets which is more or less an identical copy, or an original if you like, of the manner in which the Minister for Local Government has drawn North County Dublin. The unnatural shape shown in parts of the Six Counties is reflected exactly in North County Dublin by, for example, putting in part of Kimmage across the river.
I am grateful to Deputy Foley for having disclosed to the House and the country what we knew to be behind this method of drawing the constituencies. Is it not lucky that the people here were not codded by the commission that the Minister wanted to set up because, if it had been, then, if the commission had fairly done its work the Minister, in pursuance of the intention declared by Deputy Foley, would then come along and change the work of that commission? But the people said overwhelmingly last October that they would not be misled in that way— that they knew the Minister for Local Government and his Fianna Fáil colleagues would not approach the task of defining constituencies in a national way but that they would do it in a Party way. That was the reason why in Deputy Foley's and the Minister's constituency, as well as everywhere else, the people gave such an emphatic answer a few months ago.
Comment on this
First of all I should like to answer a few points the Minister made. He said he was born in County Dublin. I do not think he has ever lived in County Dublin. He was born in Fairview and Fairview was never in County Dublin. I have lived 36 years in County Dublin and have been six years outside it. Admittedly, some of the area goes into Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown, but I lived in County Dublin most of the time. When the Minister read out the results of the voting in the last general election, he pointed out that Deputy Clinton got the last seat. That is so, but the next person was a Fine Gael man. Fianna Fáil barely got three quotas——
Comment on this
——and a lot of that was because one man was a Gaelic footballer. Labour got just more than a quota and Fine Gael got just short of two quotas. Therefore, this latest effort of the Minister is another example of misleading the people, as he did before the referendum. Let us take the Minister's figures of 31,000 in the No. 1 area, 26,400 in the No. 2 and 2,092 in the other, a total of 59,900. The Minister says you cannot get more than two seats in these areas combined. You could get three seats with the tolerance, it being 57,000 without the tolerance.
As the Minister knows, the north side of Dublin is growing outwards. Plans for houses are increasing the city by between 5,000 and 8,000 people. In the areas I have mentioned, therefore, the Minister should start at the lowest possible figure of 57,000 because in the next year or two the figure will rise to 60,000 and in a few years the population will have reached 65,000. The Minister wants to ensure that Deputy Foley will be in on this. At the moment, the rumour is that Deputy P. J. Burke and Deputy Foley will stand in the north side—two Fianna Fáil Deputies with their roots in the north side. Deputy Burke would probably go south, but that would not suit the Minister because he might get the boot there, there being only three seats in it. The position at the moment is that there are two Fianna Fáil Deputies there.
However, if there are only three seats there what will happen is that one Fianna Fáil, one Fine Gael and one Labour Deputy will be returned and there will be no chance of Fianna Fáil getting two seats. So what does the Minister do? He moves right across to the far side of the city, as far as Kimmage Manor, passing the North-East, North-West and South-West and around the tip of South Central to hit Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. How often have I heard Deputies Burke and Foley and Deputy Clinton and others say that it is a tremendous distance for a Deputy to travel, particularly across a busy city, to see his constituents? It has been the Minister's argument in relation to country constituencies. It is the argument in relation to a constituency in which one has to travel 20 to 30 miles, from Balbriggan, through Swords, to the Wicklow mountains. It is far worse when a Deputy has to travel through a busy city.
The Minister has four seats in North Dublin in order to keep two Fianna Fáil Deputies. He has moved in a bit of North-East Dublin where you can easily pick out the Fianna Fáil vote, the Fine Gael and the Labour votes. In no other city area can you pick them out so easily because there are changes as the areas become built up. The Minister brings in portions of the old County Dublin where he knows the vote and, because Deputy Foley comes from the north side, he will get that, the Minister thinks. I have my doubts.
In the south side there might also have been four seats but they wanted to get rid of Deputy Seán Dunne so they move him into the city. He has gone, so the south is to have three seats. Not being from the country, there is only one main point of criticism I wish to make in relation to it and that is the butchery of Leitrim. Beyond that, I have not been worried about the country constituencies, though the Minister wanted, of course, to do the best he could for Fianna Fáil Deputies. Therefore, in country areas he proposed there would be three-seat constituencies and in Dublin, where possible, four seaters. We must consider Dublin North in which Dublin North-East becomes involved. Where there will be Labour representation, Fianna Fáil provide for four-seat constituencies but where there will not be Labour representation they keep to three-seaters. They hope to take two seats in the four-seat constituencies.
In the last general election, Fianna Fáil's percentage of the vote in Dublin was 30.6. In North County Dublin, if there were three seats the representation would be one Fine Gael, one Fianna Fáil and one Labour. In Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown, a five-seater, the representation would be two, two, one. In the North County area, with a four-seater, Fianna Fáil might get two, going on the last election, Fine Gael would get one and Labour one. In the South County, it would be one, one, one; and, as I have said, in Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown it would be two, two, one, making the representation in these constituencies Fianna Fáil five, and six against them.
We could take an alternative and say that with a three-seater in North County Dublin the representation would be one, one, one; in South County Dublin, with three seats, it would be one Fianna Fáil and two Fine Gael; in Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown, a five-seater, it would be two Fine Gael, two Fianna Fáil and one Labour or two Fianna Fáil and three Fine Gael. However, by gerrymander, Fianna Fáil can possibly get five seats out of 11 though they should get only four. That is what they tried to do in this Bill.
In Dublin, where Labour have a chance of winning a seat, they make the constituency a three-seat constituency, which would give one Labour, one Fine Gael and one Fianna Fáil. Where, however, there is a chance of Labour getting one seat and Fianna Fáil two, they make the constituency a four-seat constituency. There was the proposal in the referendum with regard to the setting up of a commission. Had Fianna Fáil won the referendum they would now have 144 constituencies with one seat each. I would be quite happy if the Minister decided to have every constituency a three-seat, a four-seat or a five-seat constituency. I would not mind that because, if one loses in the country, one gains in the city and vice versa. The whole western area is divided into three-seat constituencies but Dublin is divided into four-seaters because that is the area in which the Government hope to hold on. Now the western area is practically all Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. Labour comes in only in Cork and Kerry.
Comment on this
I am pointing out that these four-seaters should be three-seaters. Last night, when the Minister was discussing Donegal, he also discussed Clare, Leitrim and the West of Ireland generally. I am discussing three-seat constituencies as against four-seat constituencies and I say there should not be a four-seat constituency in North County Dublin. The Minister is making it a four-seat constituency because it suits him but in the west he is making three-seat constituencies, because it suits him. That is the kernel of this whole Bill and that is the fundamental gerrymander. I think I am quite entitled to refer to this.
The question then arises of the number of votes necessary to secure so many seats. With 50 per cent of the vote, where the result is usually one/ one/one, the result will be 66? of the seats or two seats out of three. In a four-seater constituency all one needs in order to get two seats is 42 per cent of the votes. That will be the result in North County Dublin. If it were a five-seat constituency the result would be two/two/one.
The Minister asked last night if we could add and subtract in order to get the figures. He almost bordered on impertinence. I have added the figures. The electorate in North County Dublin is 59,892, when one takes in the No. 2 area. Yesterday the Minister said one had to split the No. 3 area in order to get a three-seat constituency. You have this and you have the tolerance; within 100 votes of the tolerance you can get three seats, taking the No. 2 area. The Minister said it could not be done. He contradicted Deputy Clinton's argument. On his own figures it can be done. He has admitted that. In the city of Dublin it is perfectly obvious that Fianna Fáil are fighting for their lives to hold on to seats and their object is to get two out of four. In the country areas they are hoping to get two out of three. I believe it will take only a very small swing of the pendulum to defeat their calculations. The Minister is as remote from the grass roots now as he was when he held the referendum.
Comment on this
Deputy Clinton tried to brazen out his suggestion that the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas in County Dublin, with the addition of the Baldoyle ward, would be a feasible proposition and would permit of a three-seat constituency. I do not believe Deputy Clinton is incapable of investigating the figures of population in the Dublin area more intelligently than that——
Comment on this
——in the light of the existing interpretation of the constitutional requirement. The population of the administrative area of County Dublin, including the Borough of Dun Laoghaire, is 226,275. It is quite true that, if it were permissible to deal with this area on its own, it would be possible to have 11 seats in the area, without any addition from outside; but that would leave 27 seats for the city area and the population of the city area is 568,772. If one allocates 27 seats to that area one gets an average of population per Deputy of 21,065. That, of course, is outside the permissible tolerance in accordance with the interpretation of the constitutional requirements by Mr. Justice Budd. Even if one could arrange a division with that kind of mathematical exactitude, which one could not because it would involve not only dividing streets but dividing households, everything would be all right; but that kind of accuracy is impossible and, therefore, the city area, in order to contain only 27 seats, must lose something more than 1,000 of population. For practical reasons it would, of course, obviously have to lose some more because one cannot divide constituencies with this kind of mathematical exactitude.
The two smallest wards in the city are the Phoenix Park ward, with a population of 1,907, and the Baldoyle ward with a population of 2,097. If one starts on the basis of trying to keep the city and the county as separate as possible and, since the city must lose something over 1,000 of population in order to accommodate the 27 seats within the constitutional limits, one must obviously decide to transfer one of these two smallest wards from the city to the county. Because the Baldoyle ward was until recently in the county it was decided to take this ward, with a population of 2,097, and add that to the county. That leaves the county then with a population of 228,372, giving an average of 20,761 for 11 seats and an average of 62,283 for a three-seat constituency.
Deputy Clinton was not very accurate in his calculations, but he agreed roughly with the population figures I gave for the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas with the addition of the Baldoyle ward. It is true that, if one could consider that area in isolation, a three-seat constituency would be permissible, but one cannot do that because the population then in the rest of the County Dublin area would be 168,453 and there are eight seats to be allocated in that area; eight divided into 168,453 gives 21,057, which is again outside the limits permissible in the High Court interpretation of the Constitution.
Comment on this
It is not surprising. The whole of the Deputy's Party spent months here in the Dáil and months touring the country arguing that there should not be even that amount of tolerance allowed. Certainly the referendum campaign was based on there being a permissible tolerance of five per cent.
Comment on this
Even if the High Court decision did not specify that, certainly it was on that the people voted in the referendum in October last. So, it would not be permissible to have this constituency of the No. 1 and the No. 2 electoral areas with the Baldoyle ward from Dublin city because of the situation that would be left in the remainder of the county. Deputy Clinton put forward another suggestion, obviously at the instigation of Deputy Belton.
Comment on this
He put forward the suggestion that another way of dealing with the situation in North County Dublin, would be to take in more of the city, to take in Howth, Sutton and the rest of the Baldoyle area, in order to make up the population required for North County Dublin. That is something which came to my mind. I can quite understand that Deputy Belton would be very happy——
Comment on this
Deputy Belton had nothing to do with it. Deputy Clinton said it. Why does the Minister twist things?
Comment on this
The inspiration for that suggestion came obviously from Deputy Clinton's righthand side, from Deputy Belton. Anyone who has any knowledge of the Dublin North-East constituency, as I have, can well understand why Deputy Belton——
Comment on this
——would like to get rid of this area. Anyone who has any knowledge of the area and of the area of influence of my colleague Deputy Foley would realise that the surest way to consolidate him would be to give him some of this area in which he is so well known and so well thought of. If that were present in my mind, this is what I would have done.
Comment on this
Why did the Minister not do it? He would lose his seat if he did. He knew Fine Gael were strong there.
Comment on this
That was something which I considered seriously. It would be a feasible solution to the whole problem. To ignore the city boundary would give more compact areas generally speaking, but I do not think it would prove very acceptable to the Opposition. If we were completely to ignore the city boundary, as has been suggested now by Deputy Clinton at the instigation of his colleague Deputy Belton, in this instance, I am quite certain that the criticism it would draw would be even greater than the present criticism. What was decided in fact was to adhere to the city boundary so far as possible. I have demonstrated that we took from the city area the absolute minimum, the second smallest ward in the area, the Baldoyle ward with a population of 2,097, and that was done only because the population of the city was too great for the 27 seats available to it. I think that is fairly obvious.
Deputy Sweetman intervened to claim that Deputy Foley's speech had exposed that this whole thing was done in the Fianna Fáil interest. In fact, he disclosed the exact opposite. He disclosed that Deputy Clinton's suggestion would have been the ideal one so far as he personally was concerned and, since Deputy Clinton has been basing his whole case on the contention that the objective was to consolidate Deputy Foley's seat, I think Deputy Foley's speech completely disposed of that argument by demonstrating that it was Deputy Clinton's suggestion which would have done that much more effectively than the actual proposal I have put before the Dáil.
I agree that if one looks at the shape of the proposed constituency of North County Dublin it seems an unnatural type of constituency. This is because of the fact, for which I am not responsible, that it is cut almost in two by the city of Dublin. I did not build the city of Dublin. The city of Dublin is there. It is not my fault.
Comment on this
The only way in which it could have been made a more natural-looking type of constituency would have been to adopt the combined suggestion of Deputy Clinton and Deputy Belton and to ignore the city boundary and take in this area which would be of such great assistance to Deputy Foley. Apart from the fact that the city intrudes on the constituency, the constituency of North County Dublin is just about as natural as it is possible for a constituency to be.
All this song and dance that has been made about the Terenure district electoral division being incorporated is nonsense, because Deputy Clinton suggested that it should be only the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas, and part of that area is actually more southerly than the Terenure district electoral division.
Comment on this
In Clondalkin and Cheeverstown. Does the Deputy not even know that? There is part of the No. 2 electoral area, which Deputy Clinton admits——
Comment on this
——should be in this constituency, more southerly than the Terenure district electoral division. In fact, that is the only place where the line between the North County constituency and the South County constituency deviates in any substantial way from a line running east and west.
Deputy Belton claimed that I said that the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas were sufficient only for two seats. I did not. What I did say was that in the area Deputy Clinton maintained could form North County Dublin, that is the area north of the Navan Road, the population there was barely sufficient for two seats. The average for three seats in the area of County Dublin plus the Baldoyle ward would be 62,288 and the No. 1 electoral area plus the No. 2 electoral area plus the Baldoyle ward give a total population of 59,919. That would leave 168,453 people in the remainder of County Dublin which is too many for the eight seats which must be put into it. Therefore in order to deal with the situation you must——
Comment on this
There are some school teachers in your Party. Get some of them to do your sums if you cannot do them yourself.
Comment on this
Eight into 168,453 gives 21,056.5. That is more than the tolerance that we have assumed, and correctly assumed, is available to us in accordance with the interpretation of the Constitution which Deputy Sweetman's Party extracted from the High Court.
Comment on this
There must be some population taken, therefore, from the No. 3 electoral area. I can assure Deputy Clinton that I personally have as much interest in retaining as much of that as he has because, as I said, I was born in the constituency and all my roots are in that area of County Dublin just as Deputy Clinton boasts that his are in County Meath.
Comment on this
You cannot be in two places at the same time. Deputy Belton said that he knew you in Fairview.
Comment on this
I was born in the area in which I now reside and I have other connections with it, connections that ensure that I would get a lot more votes than Deputy Clinton would ever get in it and he knows why.
Comment on this
——he would be able to do it so as to reduce the Fianna Fáil representation. Maybe he could but I do not think so. Certainly the constituencies he suggested would result in even stronger Fianna Fáil representation. I have no doubt that if Deputy Belton got the chance he would try to arrange the constituencies to reduce Fianna Fáil representation but I do not think that he would be successful. The constituencies he outlined would give the Fianna Fáil Party——
Comment on this
This suggestion that we have tried to have four-seat constituencies in the Dublin area and three-seat constituencies in the west, is not true of course. The obvious tendency in the Bill, I agree, has been towards three-seat constituencies in general. There are only ten of the 26 three-seat constituencies in the west and only 16 constituencies altogether which are not three-seat constituencies.
Comment on this
Two of these are five-seat constituencies which did not have to be disturbed at all. Eight of the four-seat constituencies are in the Dublin area. There is also a four-seat constituency in Longford-Westmeath which was a four-seat constituency already.
Comment on this
There is also a four-seat constituency in Westmeath and in East Limerick which are four-seat constituencies at present.
Comment on this
Those were the four-seat constituencies — Longford-Westmeath, East Limerick, South Tipperary and Mid-Cork—and another four-seat constituency is North-East Cork which is being reduced from a five-seat constituency because we are adhering to the Cork County Borough boundary. Therefore eight of the four-seat constituencies are in the Dublin area where there is a total of ten constituencies and where I would say it would be difficult to find names for any more constituencies. As I said, the tendency obviously was to go for three-seat constituencies in so far as it was reasonably feasible in the Dublin area generally. The actual point at issue here is whether North County Dublin or South County Dublin should be a four-seat constituency and which should be a three-seat constituency. The decision we made was obviously the more feasible one, the one that appears to be best from looking at the map.
Deputy Clinton is suggesting that we should have South County Dublin a four-seat constituency by including practically the whole of the district electoral division of Terenure, which we could not do. That would be in fact the more northerly part of the No. 2 area, which Deputy Clinton admits would have to be in a three-seat constituency of North County Dublin. It is obviously a matter of opinion which should be the four-seat constituency and which the three and we think it should be the north side.
Comment on this
I am pleased that at last we have succeeded in nailing the falsehood that the Minister was trying to establish last night, that it was impossible to create a three-seat constituency by having the No. 1 area of North County Dublin, the No. 2 area and the Baldoyle ward. It was not until we fed him with his own figures that he admitted it was a possibility.
Comment on this
He now finds that he cannot lose a few votes anywhere in any of the city constituencies. If he made a three-seat constituency Deputy Foley would go. This is a Fianna Fáil Bill, a gerrymandering Bill, the same as the Referendum Bill, and we have exposed this and intend to continue exposing it. That is why we have gone to some trouble to feed the Minister with his own figures, to prove that he did not use the tolerance and still had enough people to form a three-seat constituency. I thought the Minister might have told us something about his plans for bringing part of Kildare into County Dublin. What happened to that idea? Was it the Celbridge Deputy who kicked over the traces and would not let it happen? Or was it just a further falsehood? Two nights before the referendum the Minister had leaflets circulated in the area of Newcastle and Rathcoole and the area bordering Kildare stating that, if the people did not support the Government, they would find themselves in Kildare. I saw those leaflets which were put into the people's letterboxes. These are the methods used to cement Fianna Fáil in power against the wishes of the people —threats. They will not work any longer and this Bill will be seen for what it is, another effort at gerrymandering to retain the maximum number of Fianna Fáil seats.
I gave the reason why it was important to split the No. 3 area and I am sticking to it. It was important because I headed the poll in three different elections, and by a long shot, and the Minister wanted to split that vote in two so that it would be more difficult for me to be elected on either side.
Deputy Foley came in and did a lot of blowing about the vote he got.
Comment on this
Deputy Foley got 3,367 first preference votes which Deputy Belton described as a football vote. I do not mind where it came from but that is what he got. I got 5,827, 2,500 more. I do not mind where he got the votes. I played football too and I see nothing wrong with playing football.
Comment on this
The Deputy got 18 votes more than I did the first time he stood and he was a county councillor at that time.
Comment on this
And the Deputy was the last elected without reaching the quota. He should be ashamed to talk about it.
Comment on this
The Minister for Local Government is a very sincere friend of Deputy Foley's. Not only did he elect him with his and Deputy Burke's surplus but he made sure as far as he could that he would bring in the Baldoyle area which is known to be fairly strong Fianna Fáil in order to assist this limping Deputy back into the House, a Deputy who everybody knows has done nothing since he was elected until the last couple of months when he started to get active and get his name in the papers. He had an advantage, unlike me and unlike the Minister, in that he was supplied with all sorts of reports from the Minister's Department before even the county council were informed regarding grants and so on.
Comment on this
You were not in the Chair at the time but these are matters that were raised on the other side of the House and it is unfortunate that I cannot try to answer them.
Comment on this
He did not do it when the Deputy was reading the paper from five past to twenty past eleven.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact he did not. I was aware of the fact that Sutton and Howth were part of North County Dublin previously. I was giving the approximate population figure which I thought would be about 20,000 and I am sure I was not far wrong because it is a very densely populated area.
Comment on this
This was a part of North County Dublin for a long time and it would be natural that it should go back there. It did not. When I sat down Deputy Belton assured me that if that happened Fine Gael would certainly get two seats in North County Dublin. This is a Fine Gael stronghold.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that this is a most ridiculous constituency running as it does from Fortfield Road, Terenure, from Kimmage Manor out to within a few miles of Balbriggan. Nobody can describe that as a natural or normal constituency when the Minister had an opportunity to provide compact constituencies and this was the thing that he felt was extremely important but he is not going to be in that constituency any more himself and he did not care how awkward it was so long as it succeeded in fulfilling the purpose for which he set it up and that is to get the representation in this House for Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
It is terrible to see a man of Deputy Clinton's years wailing because he finds himself out on a limb, as he says himself.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is not wailing, then I do not know what he is doing. I never heard such crying or saw so many bitter tears shed about losing portion of a constituency in which he got no votes.
Comment on this
Deputy Clinton knows the support the Fine Gael Party have in North County Dublin. If he does not know he will definitely know after the next election. He talked about the Baldoyle ward, Sutton and Howth which were in North County Dublin. He said the Minister was trying to safeguard me by making it a four-seat constituency. Why did he not go the other way and make a four-seat constituency by bringing in the area I have just mentioned? This portion would have suited me admirably. The only regret I have is that the Minister did not decide that that portion should come in to North County Dublin because Baldoyle happens to be my parish. It extends across the railway line taking in a small portion of Sutton.
Comment on this
I do not think Deputy Clinton realises this or he would not say he wanted the Minister to give me a portion of my own parish. The Minister did not do that. The Minister gave us a portion of the Baldoyle ward which was in County Dublin prior to two elections ago and he did not bring in the portion of Sutton or Howth which would have suited me admirably. The only regret I have is that this did not happen. As for Deputy Clinton's support on the North side I do not think he need worry about what he is going to lose because it is very difficult to lose something you have not got. Therefore he will not lose much anyhow. He said the Minister tried deliberately to cut his vote in two. If the Minister tried to cut his vote in two he would eliminate him completely because Deputy Clinton was the last Deputy elected in the last general election and he was elected without reaching the quota. He was the only Fine Gael Deputy elected in North County Dublin.
Comment on this
We could not buy a shop in Blanchardstown to sell Lemass and then sell it when the elections were over.
Comment on this
Deputy Clinton mentioned that he got more votes than I did. That is great credit to him. It was my first time in the field. I was one of four candidates selected by the Fianna Fail Party, not being a Deputy prior to the last election.
Comment on this
Deputy Clinton never reached the quota although he did increase his vote. I reached the quota and exceeded it. It is an extraordinary thing that a man in that position would try to betray me by saying to the people of County Dublin that he knows I did not work on their behalf during the past four years, practically. He knows quite well, and the people of County Dublin know quite well, that his statement is untrue. Deputy Clinton is only trying to secure for himself a press which will popularise his misinformation. He knows he has failed to capture the imagination of the people in County Dublin and therefore he has to resort to some devious means to try to get a public press so that the people will realise that there is such a person as Deputy Mark Clinton, the one Fine Gael Deputy for North and South County Dublin. It should be borne in mind that Fianna Fáil represent not only the Fianna Fáil people but the Labour people, the Fine Gael people and the people who have no Party at all. That is the policy of Fianna Fáil. We represent each and every member of the constituency of County Dublin and this is where Deputy Clinton has failed. It might pay him well——
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman was reading a newspaper here from 11.5 to 11.25 a.m. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle was not present. I do not think that that is in accordance with Standing Orders.
Comment on this
Being a young Deputy, I respect the view that age is honourable. Therefore I did not want to call the attention of the Chair to Deputy Sweetman's behaviour. However, I did think that an ex-Minister for Finance would have better manners than he showed here this morning when he sat reading a newspaper instead of listening to the Minister's reply to allegations by Deputy Clinton and Deputy Belton. At the least, one would expect that Deputy Sweetman, who interceded on their behalf on two occasions, would put down the newspaper and listen to the reply——
Comment on this
——of the Minister who castigated the Fine Gael Party for what they are. However, it is better to allow things to stand. I would say once again to Deputy Clinton: "Do not be worried about Deputy Foley. Irrespective of what kind of propaganda Deputy Clinton puts out, Deputy Foley will survive politically because he has worked hard for the people not only for the past few months, as Deputy Clinton has said, but for the past four years. Deputy Foley will continue to do so up to the next election and if the people of County Dublin deem it fit, Deputy Foley will continue to work for them after the next general election."
Comment on this
In North County Dublin Fine Gael have two county councillors and so have Fianna Fáil. I am glad Deputy Foley told us he is in the Baldoyle Parish which is now being given to County Dublin.
Comment on this
This is given to you. That is just to hide something. The Minister gave us plenty of figures. It is a question of doing addition. If I understood him correctly, we should divide 27 into 56,772. The figure he should divide is 20,000 and that gives us 28 seats and there would be no trouble seeking where to put the votes. That is the division he must also do in the country areas. The Minister is giving a favourable tolerance to them and an unfavourable tolerance in the city of Dublin, which is a growing area. If we divide likewise in respect of Dún Laoghaire/Rathdown we get our 11 seats and 6,000 over and if we add it into Dublin we have 14,000 over and that can be used as a tolerance.
The Minister mentioned that they had four-seat constituencies in the country. He mentioned East Limerick. He would not change that because Fianna Fáil have two seats out of four there. Tipperary: four seats. Fianna Fáil have two seats there. If he changed that he would be hurting the Fianna Fáil Deputies and would also lose a seat for Fianna Fáil. Wexford—Fianna Fáil have two seats out of four there and that could not be changed. Longford—they happen to have two seats there and an Independent who is favourable. That could not be changed or there would be terrible trouble; they would lose one and maybe two seats in that area. The Minister also mentioned that, if he were to change at all, he would have to divide streets. How can he divide Dublin except by crossing streets? He has already done it. His argument is beyond explanation. Take my old constituency of Dublin North-East and the constituency of North Central. How did the Minister divide them?
Going up the old Howth Road you find that is divided again on both sides of the road, across and down with a bit in and a bit out. This is done right through the city. The Minister said he did not like taking pieces of the city and putting them in the county or putting bits of the county into the city but he has done it to suit Deputy Foley at Baldoyle. Ballyfermot, which for years was in the city—I do not know the number of votes but I know that Deputies Seán Dunne, Mark Clinton and the Minister get so many votes out of it— voted in the county. What is wrong with continuing that? The Minister wants the county kept separate. Why does he keep Dún Laoghaire and the county separate? The big thing in Dún Laoghaire was that he moved a section out of it because the next seat after four had to go to Labour or Fine Gael, not to Fianna Fáil. Labour would have the better chance, I agree. In the case of that seat if you left Mount Merrion area in it, the fifth seat had to go to either Labour, which probably had the better chance, or Fine Gael. Fianna Fáil had no chance. This is the reason that Dún Laoghaire is not getting it, not to be good to Dún Laoghaire or anything like that or to keep county and city separate.
My understanding was that as far as possible we should elect a Deputy to represent 20,000 with a tolerance either way but the Minister has decided to give only 27 to Dublin. Then he divides by 27.
Comment on this
I suppose there is no point in putting the facts before Deputy Clinton. He insists on coming back with the same unsubstantiated statements that he knows are completely wrong. He claimed that he has nailed the falsehood that it is impossible to have a three-seat constituency comprising the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas and Baldoyle ward. I have proved to Deputy Clinton from the figures that that cannot be if—and I agree with this —you have only 38 seats for the Dublin area. It cannot be done on the present interpretation of the constitutional provision. It cannot be done except by exercising a greater tolerance from the national average of population per Deputy than 5 per cent which we believe is the maximum that we are entitled to use.
I have given Deputy Clinton the figures taken from the Census of Population. These are the only figures we are entitled to use and the Deputy knows that, if you have a three-seat constituency made up as he suggests of the No. 1 and No. 2 electoral areas and the Baldoyle ward, then there is too great a population left to contain the eight seats that remain in the County Dublin administrative area including the Borough of Dún Laoghaire. Deputy Clinton knows this and he cannot contradict the figures.
With regard to the suggestion that part of Kildare might be put into County Dublin, of course there are many different ways in which this problem could be solved and this would be one of the possibilities but we decided to try so far as possible to adhere to the boundaries of County Dublin and adhere to the boundaries of Dublin city and it was only in this case where it was forced upon us that we had this slight transfer of population from the city area to the county area.
As has been fairly well established, the suggestion that has been made by Deputy Clinton—I do not know whether it is on behalf of the Fine Gael Party or not because apparently nobody can speak for the Fine Gael Party——
Comment on this
——but the suggestion that he has made that we should have completely ignored the existence of the boundary of the borough of Dublin would, as has been established, suit the existing Fianna Fáil Deputies much better than the present proposed area.
Comment on this
Deputy Clinton claims that a three-seat constituency could be formed in the north of Dublin merely by taking in the area of Howth and Sutton. I think Deputy Clinton told me that he actually had a copy of the census.
Comment on this
If he has a copy of the census he can get the figures. If he wants to be accurate and truthful he can look up page 88 in the census report and he will see there that the population of Beann Eadair ward is 7,377. The population of the part of north County Dublin north of the Navan Road, which Deputy Clinton thinks should be the border, is approximately 42,300. It is not available with absolute accuracy because whoever designed the Navan Road decided for some reason or other not to adhere to the boundaries of district electoral divisions or townlands but decided instead to cut corners and so on. So, the nearest approximation that we can get to the population of County Dublin north of the Navan Road is 42,300. If you add the population of the Beann Eadair ward and the Baldoyle ward to that you get 51,774. As I have shown, the average for three seats would be in the region of 62,300 so that another 10,000 or 10,500 would have to be added to this area from some other part of the north city of Dublin. This would suit Deputy Foley even better because these could only come from the Coolock or Raheny wards. As Deputy Clinton is aware, and Deputy Belton even more so, this is an area that would suit Deputy Foley even better than North County Dublin.
Comment on this
It is no wonder that Deputy Belton should be saying to Deputy Clinton: "Get rid of this part of my constituency; this is no use to me." That is the area where my colleague, the Minister for Finance, gets the votes at present and where Deputy Foley would get all the votes if Deputy Clinton's arrangement were adopted. Admittedly, this could all be done in a different way if we had an extra seat for Dublin city as Deputy Belton advocates. I should like to know is this Fine Gael policy, that instead of there being 38 seats in Dublin there should be 39? Can anybody speak for Fine Gael? Deputy Belton says it should be dealt with by putting 28 seats instead of 27 into the city of Dublin and leaving the 11 seats in the county. That means an extra seat for Dublin. Will Deputy Belton tell us from where is this seat to come?
Comment on this
Have Fine Gael decided even this? Can they decide anything?
Last night we had six Fine Gael Deputies in the Front Bench and four of them put forward four different solutions which they said were their solutions for one corner of the country. Now Deputy Belton says that the way to deal with this is to take an extra seat from the rural areas and put it into Dublin city. But what part of it? Will Deputy Belton tell us where it is to come from? Has he cleared this with the Fine Gael Deputies concerned and with his Party? As far as I can see there is only one thing certain that Fine Gael are agreed on in regard to this Bill and that is to delay it as much as possible by a concerted effort with relays of Fine Gael speakers coming in here making ridiculous suggestions without any consultation with each other, contradicting each other at every juncture and on every part of the Schedule with the sole object of delaying the passage of the Bill as much as possible so as, they think, to make the possible date of the general election as far distant as possible. That apparently is their sole objective.
Comment on this
Why are the relays of speakers coming in and making these ridiculous suggestions which can so easily be disproved? Why is there no consultation? Why is there no agreed line? Why does Deputy Belton suggest that we have not taken enough seats from rural Ireland and that we should take another into the Dublin area? Has he cleared that with his Party?
Comment on this
Again, the Minister has tried to misquote what Deputy Clinton said. Deputy Clinton said "Sutton and Howth" and the Minister refers to "Howth, Beann Eadair." He speaks of Howth and Sutton, and he should know from his own Department that it takes in Kilbarrack where, at the back, many houses are built at the moment and they vote in Sutton schools and some of them go to Baldoyle. Howth should be taken into it. The Minister should not be trying to mislead by taking one section of what the Deputy said. I know it is all right for the Minister to get the average vote that would elect a Deputy, which is 20,000. To find the number of seats you divide by 20,000. This is what the Minister did. That is the number of seats we can now have with a tolerance of five per cent. That is the way to do it. But the Minister says "No, I am giving only 27 to Dublin and we can divide 27 into it and now we shall see how we can get rid of the surplus."
The Minister has a fleet of civil servants to help him to prepare this. The civil servants had to do what he said. I am not saying they are behind this proposal but the simplest thing the civil servants could have done was to divide 20,000 into the total votes. If you take Dublin with 568,000 and divide that by 20,000, it gives 28 seats with 8,000 votes as a surplus. Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown is 226,000, approximately, according to the Minister's figures.
Comment on this
Sorry. Dividing that gives you 11 seats with 6,000 to spare which is quite a good tolerance on both. There is nothing to be got rid of. All I am doing is dividing it. Yesterday, the Minister had Deputy Harte telling him that what he was doing was retaining an extra seat in Donegal but it is an extra Fianna Fáil Deputy he is retaining, not an extra seat. I did not hear the Minister denying that in the four-seat constituencies being retained in rural Ireland, two out of the four are held by Fianna Fáil. If Fianna Fáil held only one seat in these constituencies, they would have been changed very quickly. If there were five-seaters in Dublin they know the trouble they would be in. In every election since 1961, Fianna Fáil have been losing ground in Dublin. In general elections, in local elections and in the Presidential election, they continued to go down. Deputy Foley spoke about North County Dublin and County Dublin. In the referendum the "yes" vote was 15,755 and the "no" vote was 32,073—two to one against.
Comment on this
Deputy Foley spoke but he had nothing to say. All he could do was to draw attention to the fact that Deputy Sweetman was reading a newspaper. He did not tell us that what Deputy Sweetman was reading was the disastrous result of the referendum, showing that in County Dublin Fianna Fáil got the second worst beating they sustained in the whole of Ireland.
Comment on this
The Deputy need not fear for Deputy Clinton in those circumstances. When he spoke earlier, I appealed to the Minister to tell us something about Kildare. He wants to hasten this debate but I want to tell him something about the threats he had circulated during the referendum campaign in the County Dublin area bordering Kildare to the effect that the people there would find themselves in Kildare before the next general election. However, the Minister sat down without dealing with this and it was a serious oversight on his part. Obviously he had other plans for that area until his colleague in Celbridge upset them by kicking up and saying he would not have it. It must have been possible to make some other adjustment there and the Minister must have had some other adjustment in mind at the time. He put forward various plans today for the constituency but we have not heard about the area I have been referring to. I hope that before we finish the debate the Minister will tell us something about it because I feel sure there is an interesting alternative.
In order to make a point, which was not valid, about portion of the No. 2 area in Dublin, to the effect that that portion was more southerly than the portion of the No. 3 area which he has broken up and taken in, the Minister spoke about half a dozen votes and, in derogatory fashion, he spoke as if I did not know the area. The people of Dublin County know that they see me far more often in the various areas there than they see the Minister. Let the Minister know—he will learn it later—that the people realise who is doing the work, without having it advertised some days before with the Minister's assistance and the assistance of other people.
Comment on this
I sympathise with Deputies Belton and Clinton because apparently it was not sufficient for the Fine Gael Whip to come in to instruct them to keep this thing going. The Leader of their Party had to come in to compel them to do their duty by the Party and to delay this as far as possible by repeating the arguments already dealt with effectively.
Comment on this
I agree that it is constitutionally possible to take an extra seat from rural Ireland and to put it into Dublin, but Fianna Fáil decided this was something that should not be done. They decided that the allocation of seats to Dublin should be 38, not 39 as Deputy Belton has been advocating.
Comment on this
——in the Dublin area is substantially more valuable in so far as electing a representative is concerned than it is in rural Ireland. Deputy Belton knows that. He knows that every temporary resident in a hotel in Dublin is counted in order to increase the effectiveness of the votes of the permanent residents in the Dublin area.
Comment on this
They are not. They are counted where they reside. The figure for voters, compared with the figures for population, show that, even on the basis of the present proposals, the number of voters per Deputy in Dublin will be substantially fewer than in the rest of Ireland. Deputy Belton suggested there should be an extra seat in Dublin. I admit that is constitutionally permissible. What we are proposing is also, we believe, constitutionally permissible and also fairer. Do the Fine Gael Party agree with Deputy Belton that there should be a seat taken from rural Ireland and given to Dublin? If so, then I agree with Deputy Clinton's solutions for Nos. 1 and 2 areas. They would be possible, but only on the basis of an extra seat which Fine Gael propose, through their spokesman, Deputy Belton, to take from the country and put into Dublin.
I must admit that on the second occasion when Deputy Belton advocated this he indicated where the seat should come from—from County Donegal. There is one thing consistent about Fine Gael in this. It is their concentration on the possibility of getting rid of Deputy O'Donnell in Donegal. What exactly did Deputy O'Donnell do that there should be this concentration on exporting some of his constituents to Connacht, and on this deduction of a seat from that area and its allocation to Dublin? I do not know what the idea is.
I have dealt with the question of putting part of Kildare into County Dublin or part of County Dublin into Kildare. It is one of the ways in which this situation could be dealt with—one of the many, the infinite number of ways —but one of the decisions we came to was not to mix up parts of County Dublin with some other county. It would be feasible to deal with the situation in Kildare by adding part of South County Dublin to it, which apparently is what Deputy Clinton is advocating apparently realising that he has not got a particularly good chance in the constituency he has been misrepresenting for some years. What he wants to do is to get himself put into Kildare.
Comment on this
It is a possibility. The population of Kildare is too great for three seats and too small for four, and one of the many ways in which the situation could be dealt with is by transferring Deputy Clinton, as he apparently desires, from County Dublin to Kildare.
Comment on this
It would have suited Deputy Clinton better to have cut him off from the area he has been ignoring in County Dublin. It would have suited him better than the present arrangement. However, I think it is quite obvious that the sole object of Fine Gael is to delay the passage of the Bill, remembering that they had to have a joint effort by the Leader of the Party and the Whip to get Deputy Belton and Deputy Clinton to keep the debate going while Deputy L'Estrange went out to round up some more of his Party to delay the Bill further.
Comment on this
Listening to the Minister, nobody is surprised at his hypocrisy, his effrontery and his ignorance. He has been a Deputy of this House for some 20 years and he should know that when the register of electors is being compiled people in hotels and hospitals are not put on the register for either Dublin city or county but are put on the register in the area from which they come, let it be Westmeath, Louth, Monaghan or anywhere else.
The Minister knows that as well as I do, but he does not want to admit it. His one idea seems to be to cause confusion and to delay the passage of this measure. The Fine Gael Party are not here to delay the passage of this Bill. We are here to do our duty as an Opposition and to show up the unnecessary butchering and gerrymandering in this Bill in an effort by Fianna Fáil to keep themselves in office. As far as we are concerned, we believe in one man one vote. The Minister asked on whose behalf Deputy Clinton was speaking. Deputy Clinton was speaking on behalf of a united Fine Gael Party not on behalf of a Party divided as the Minister's Party is at the moment. In a recent speech the Minister stated that, if Fianna Fáil did not go back to their principle of abolishing the Border, there would be a second Republican Party started.
Comment on this
The Deputy is getting away from the Bill. We are on the constituency of North County Dublin.
Comment on this
The plan in relation to North County Dublin is quite plain. It is also plain in relation to Dublin city. The idea is to gerrymander. In Dublin city and county Fianna Fáil support has dropped to around 30 per cent of the vote—the figures are there to prove it—and it is Fianna Fáil's idea now to create four-seat constituencies in the hope that, by some miracle, they may get two out of four. In 1947 Fianna Fáil had a majority of the votes in Dublin. There were no four-seat constituencies in Dublin at that time; there were three-or five-seat constituencies. Now that the support has dwindled they want to make the constituencies four-seat constituencies in the hope that they will get two out of the four. In 1961 there were only two four-seat constituencies. Now the proposal is to have eight plus one in County Dublin, making nine.
Comment on this
I am sorry. I should have said eight. Deputy Foley is like a man whistling passing a graveyard. Despite what the Deputy said, in the referendum Fianna Fáil were beaten two to one. There was a majority of 16,318 against Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Order. Would Deputy Foley please cease interrupting? We are not discussing the referendum.
Comment on this
Judging by the votes cast against the referendum proposals, it is obvious now that Deputy Clinton and the other Fine Gael candidates will head the poll; we will get two out of the four seats in North County Dublin.
Comment on this
I, as Deputy L'Estrange well knows, never suggested that temporary residents were put on the register of the area.
Comment on this
I was talking about the document, which is the relevant one in the allocation of seats for Dáil elections, which is the census of population; not alone are temporary residents in hotels from other parts of the country counted in the population of Dublin but even sailors on board ship in harbour are counted, irrespective of their country of origin.
Comment on this
We know the reason for that. Nobody can tell Deputy Belton more about that than Deputy Clinton. Let Deputy Belton discuss the question of nurses on the register with his colleague, Deputy Clinton, because Deputy Clinton knows all about that. He knows all about stealing people's votes.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Minister has accused Deputy Clinton of stealing votes off the register. Is that parliamentary?
Comment on this
These political charges have been made here all down the years and there is very little the Chair can do about them.
Comment on this
Does the Chair support the Minister in making this allegation when there is no evidence to support it?
Comment on this
This is the second time the Minister has done this. I even wrote and asked him to meet me any time, and the people concerned, but I got no reply.
Comment on this
Sir, I was interrupted. With regard to the evidence of political support available to Fianna Fáil, we have had recent evidence of that support in winning six by-elections out of seven and we shall have more evidence of that support in the near future when we win the three pending by-elections.
Comment on this
The only other point is the question which seems to be agitating the minds of the Fine Gael Party so much that they keep sending in relays of speakers to delay this, that is, the question of the amount of support Deputy Foley gets in Dublin. The fact of the matter is that although Deputy Foley was on a panel including Deputy P.J. Burke and myself, and both had a substantial surplus over the quota, and there was also a fourth candidate who got a substantial first preference vote, he still got more first preferences than Deputy Clinton the first time he stood. He was elected with a surplus over the quota.