We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Business. - Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 238–479 of 479. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 35 of 1968 ›

What was the total poll?

Comment on this

Deputy Clinton got the fifth seat without the quota, the sole Fine Gael seat.

Comment on this

Tell the truth.

Comment on this

He got the last seat without the quota.

Comment on this

If they finished the count he would have got 4,000 over the quota.

Comment on this

We got our three Deputies elected, Deputy Dunne got in and there was a residue of one seat which Deputy Clinton got.

Comment on this

Another false statement.

Comment on this

We do not have to do any gerrymandering in County Dublin to ensure a Fianna Fáil majority. It is there. Perhaps Deputy Clinton will not get in even without the quota now, but that is not my fault.

Comment on this

If we are to stoop to personalities I will tell the people what MacEoin did to save the Minister. Do not draw me.

Comment on this

He did nothing.

Comment on this

Yes, he did. If we are to stoop to personalities I will tell the House how he saved the Minister.

Comment on this

I saved him from having to thumb his way home from Spain.

Comment on this

I want to refer to what the Minister said about delaying tactics by this Party in relation to this Bill.

Last night he raised this matter and we assured him that, if he would tell us that at the end of the discussion on this Bill we would have a general election, we would give him all Stages last night.

Comment on this

I am not the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

If the Minister will say now that at the end of this discussion we will have a general election we will give him all Stages now. That offer puts an end to the foolish argument that we are delaying the Bill. He said it was constitutionally possible to have another Deputy in the Dublin area. If that is so why has it not been done? Talk about worrying about the people in rural Ireland where the population does not exist did not work even in the referendum. Tolerance was held out as the carrot to win the referendum in rural Ireland, but it was rejected by the people because they believe in the principle of one man one vote. We now have a constituency of North County Dublin which no one recognises as North County Dublin and no one ever will recognise as North County Dublin running from Balbriggan to Fortfield Road in Terenure. This is done for the purpose of splitting the No. 3 Area.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Foley allow the Deputy in possession to speak?

Comment on this

Deputy Clinton knows that, unlike the Fine Gael Party, there is only one Taoiseach, one leader, in the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Since when?

Comment on this

Therefore, I am not competent to say that we will have a general election tomorrow or any other time. So far as I can see, every Deputy in the Fine Gael Party has a completely different and personal solution to this problem. I admit that many solutions are possible. Deputy Clinton asked why, if it is constitutionally possible, we did not allocate an extra seat in the Dublin area. I have told him the reason already. It is also constitutionally possible to allocate the number of seats we have decided to allocate to the rural part of the country. The decision we took was to allocate the maximum number of seats to that area. That left 38 seats for Dublin which I think, and which the Fianna Fáil Party think, is adequate representation for that area.

Deputy Clinton and Deputy Belton think that an extra seat should be taken from rural Ireland. That is their opinion. We think otherwise. I want to know was this a Fine Gael Party decision. No one can assume that because Deputy Belton and Deputy Clinton say it is Fine Gael policy, it is Fine Gael policy, because no one knows what Fine Gael policy on anything is. They speak with different voices.

Comment on this

I wonder would the Minister tell us—it is a detail—why in forming the South County Dublin constituency he crossed the Bray Road and took in a pocket of votes on the far side. Now he sees that was stupid and he throws it out again. He accused us of not knowing County Dublin but I have enough knowledge to know that that was not sensible.

Comment on this

So far from throwing out the crossing of the Bray Road again what we are doing in this amendment is the exact opposite. I do not want to cross the Bray Road at all. If Deputy Belton wants to know the significance of the amendment of that part of the proposed constituency of South County Dublin he can more usefully make inquiries within his own Party.

Comment on this

Wrong again. It was Deputy Clinton who asked the question, not Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

Why was it necessary to cross the Bray Road in forming that constituency?

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy that I do not want to cross it. It is a dangerous occupation crossing the Bray road.

Comment on this

The Minister brought in the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister should give a few pounds for the purpose of having a job done there and it would be quite safe.

Comment on this

When money was given to do the Bray Road the Coalition of Labour and Fine Gael——

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Is a discussion on the Bray Road in order?

Comment on this

——combined to refuse to take the money when it could have been done at a reasonable cost, and not at the expense of the roads in other parts of the country.

Comment on this

Why was it not done years ago?

Comment on this

We were not in power in Dublin County Council.

Comment on this

Last year your man was chairman.

Comment on this

The only way we could get the Council to do any work was to abolish it and to put in a commissioner.

Comment on this

He appointed three rate collectors and they ran away with the money.

Comment on this

Fine Gael and Labour control Dublin County Council.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This does not arise.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

It is about time Fianna Fáil realised it.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

It is a pity they would not widen the road.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:

In page 7, in the second column of the entry relating to South County Dublin, to delete "(with the exception of the townlands of Ballymakaily, Brownstown, Coolscuddan, Gollierstown, Grange, Mullauns)"; after "Dundrum" to insert "(except the part thereof which is comprised in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown)"; and after "Milltown," to insert "Rathmichael (except the part thereof which is comprised in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown)."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 15 and 16 form a composite proposal and perhaps they could be discussed together.

Comment on this

The purpose of the amendments is to transfer the townlands of Mount Merrion South—district electoral division of Dundrum— Brennanstown, Kerrymount, Kilbogget, Loughlinstown, Blackthorn, Carmanhall, Carmanhall and Leopardstown and Carrickmines Little—all in the district electoral division of Ballybrack— to the proposed constituency of Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown from South County Dublin in exchange for the district electoral division of Rathmichael —except the townland of Shanganagh. It has been represented to me that these changes are desirable for the convenience of electors and to improve the boundary line.

This proposed adjustment between South County Dublin and Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown will enable the part of Newcastle district electoral division which is in the proposed constituency of North County Dublin, that is, the townlands of Ballymakaily, Brownstown, Coolscuddan, Gollierstown, Grange and Mullauns, to be taken into South County Dublin and the amendment also proposes to make this transfer. This will bring the entire Newcastle district electoral division into the proposed constituency of South County Dublin and I believe that it is an obvious and desirable thing to do.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:

In page 8, in the second column of the entry relating to Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown, to delete the matter in the second column and substitute the following:

"The district electoral division of Stillorgan and the townlands of: Blackthorn, Brennanstown, Bullock, Carmanhall, Carmanhall and Leopardstown, Carrickmines Little, Kerrymount, Kilbogget, Loughlinstown, Rochestown, Rochestown Domain, Thomastown, in the district electoral division of Ballybrack; Mount Merrion South, in the district electoral division of Dundrum; Shanganagh, in the district electoral division of Rathmichael; in the former Rural District of Rathdown No. 1; and the borough of Dún Laoghaire."

Comment on this

In Dublin Central for the first time for quite a while—it may have happened some time back— there is a situation where a four-seat constituency has been set up which Dublin rarely had. There were a five-seater and a three-seater in Dublin but now there is a four-seater.

As the support of Fianna Fáil has been dwindling, they are hoping, by having four-seaters in Dublin and three-seaters in the country, to hang on to power. If it were a three-seater in North County Dublin, the result would be one/one/one and if it were a five seater, the result would be three/two against Fianna Fáil but they are looking for a four-seater in the hope that they will get two out of four. In order to do that, it would be necessary for them to get 42 per cent of the vote but this they will not get. However, they have set this out and have gerrymandered the whole country in the same way hoping to get the best out of it.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton maintains that it is not necessary to cross the boundary of the River Liffey. I do not know if Deputy Clinton has left his copy of the census behind but if he has and if Deputy Belton looks at page 88 he will see that the population of the north part of Dublin city is 287,846 and with the Baldoyle ward taken out of that, the population will be 285,700 odd. The population of Dublin South City is 280,926. On the basis of 38 seats for Dublin, that is 11 in the county area and 27 in the city area, it must be quite clear to Deputy Belton that the boundary of the Liffey cannot be adhered to. I will agree that if we take what now appears to be Fine Gael's official suggestion—since, unlike some of their other suggestions, it has not been contradicted by anybody else —we should have taken an extra seat from rural Ireland and then we would have 28 seats for Dublin. It would not then have been necessary to breach the traditional and physical boundary of the Liffey but with 27 seats and with the distribution of the population this, of course, was unavoidable.

Squeezing these two extra seats into the confines of Dublin borough boundary made it inevitable, if we were to have any kind of rational constituency at all, to create this extra constituency, to have seven constituencies instead of the existing six and to create this extra constituency of Dublin Central which, as I have said, inescapably takes in areas on both sides of the Liffey.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Surely if, as the Minister says, it would be possible to have this extra seat in Dublin, and it would be constitutionally correct, the fact that that would leave North Dublin and South Dublin as two distinct units, should have had a bearing on it. Prior to the last local elections when the south side came in on the north side, the Minister regarded it as the correct thing to do to make a clear-cut division between north and south. At that time every member of the Party and of every other Party agreed with him that it was a major advance but now he has gone back on that for Dáil purposes and he has the north and the south coming into one constituency. Surely, if the allocation of an extra seat could have avoided this, that should have been the course adopted?

Comment on this

The Minister is using this argument hoping that in some way he will get publicity which will help him to take a seat from the country.

The Minister first got the answer he wanted and then worked backwards. The proper way to do a sum is to start at the beginning and get the answer but the Minister wanted to know the answer first and then work back from there to suit himself and this is what he has done.

Heretofore, the basis of ministerial effort in setting up a constituency in Dublin was to have five-seaters and, if this was not possible, to go down to four or three, whichever was suitable. In this particular area of the north side where there are 14 seats, why would it not be possible to have two five-seaters and a four-seater? Something similar could be done on the south side. The Minister is trying to safeguard some of his Deputies and he is doing his best to hold on to these two seats. It is just a gerrymander. What he could not do in the referendum he is now trying to do in spite of the people's wishes.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Listening to the Minister here, one would be pardoned for thinking that it was a very reasonable proposition that he has put before the House and that it was the only thing that could be done. It is neither reasonable nor the only thing that could be done. In fact, the Dublin constituencies can be split up in any way and should be split up in more five-seat constituencies.

The purpose of PR is largely defeated if the constituencies are made too small. Generally speaking, over the whole country the three-member constituencies have been enormously increased and the five-member constituencies have virtually disappeared; I think there are two left in the whole country. The Minister's argument that the only way to divide the city was in four-member constituencies is not true. His Party have decided, for various reasons, all political, that the four-member constituencies will get the maximum return from the Fianna Fáil vote in the city of Dublin, north and south. If they had split them up into three-member constituencies in certain areas they would probably only get one person in. Likewise, they were afraid, if they split them into five-member constituencies, they would not get three seats. They think they stand a better chance of retaining two in four-member constituencies than of getting three in five-member constituencies. It is a kind of statistical game, and I do not suppose it will be completely clear until after the next general election, but the alteration of the Dublin constituencies has been done for no other reason than the advantage of the Party in power. That is the sole reason, and that is why we have this anomaly in Dublin of crossing the Liffey. It has been done in the past on occasions, but it was broken away from whenever it was possible.

The Liffey is a natural boundary running through the centre of the city —I have referred to this earlier on the Bill—and the interests of the North side and the South side are not always exactly the same. Any electoral boundary which has crossed the Liffey in the past has never existed very long. It was inevitably put back with its natural components; in other words, the South of the Liffey stood for a big constituency and the North the same way. But the purpose of this crossing of the Liffey is a purely political move. The idea that it is necessary in some way to have four-member constituencies is nonsense. If it was desired, it is possible to have seven or even 11-member constituencies. I am not necessarily advocating those, but there is no reason why they could not be made, so the contention of the Minister that we must have four-member constituencies is incorrect. The truth of the matter is that whether you have 27 or 28 Deputies who represent the city of Dublin, you can divide the seats up any way you like. It is possible to have so many five-seaters, so many six-seaters and so on. I must, therefore, contradict the Minister's statement that this somehow was the only thing to do. This is not so. It was done for political reasons.

Comment on this

Both Deputy Beltons are now on record as saying that this extra seat should have been taken from rural Ireland.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

If it would avoid crossing the Liffey.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton says this should have been done in the very noble cause of trying to avoid a Dublin constituency crossing the Liffey. It would not, of course, matter if this involved a rural constituency crossing the Shannon. Contrary to what Deputy Belton says, it is not just a question——

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying none of the new constituencies crosses the Shannon? He crossed it in Roscommon.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Yes. He brought Athlone into it.

Comment on this

Yes, on the western side of the Shannon. I am coming to that. We are not crossing the Shannon; we are adhering to the Shannon boundary. It is not just a question of the allocation of an extra seat. There is also the question of the deduction of a seat from some other part of Ireland. While Fine Gael have told me that we should allocate this extra seat to Dublin, they have not told me where we are to take the seat from, and this is something it is essential to know. Contrary again to what Deputy Dockrell has said, there is no way of avoiding crossing the River Liffey with some constituency except by the allocation of this extra seat to the city area. Deputy Dockrell must know that, deducting the Baldoyle Ward from the North City area, if you have a population of 285,749 there and in the South City area a population of 280,926, with 27 constituencies available and approximately the same population north and south of the River Liffey, whether you use an 11-seat constituency or not you cannot avoid crossing the Liffey. Deputy Dockrell must know that. The furthest you can go is to have a 13seat constituency and a 14-seat constituency, but either of these would be in breach of the constitutional provision in regard to equality or near equality of the ratio of population per Deputy. Any other arrangement whatever that Deputy Dockrell or anybody else suggests in the area of Dublin city on that basis of 27 seats must involve some constituency crossing the boundary of the River Liffey.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Why did the Minister take out Baldoyle?

Comment on this

I explained that to the Deputy's cousin and if he had been here I would have explained it to him. If Deputy Belton is interested in that —and I doubt if he is—he can read it in the Official Report. On the other hand, if you think, Sir, I should extend to Deputy Luke Belton, who has now come into the House, the courtesy of repeating what I have already told Deputy Paddy Belton, then I am quite prepared to do it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Repetition is not in order.

Comment on this

But it is on the records of the House and it would not be too much to suggest to Deputy Belton that he should look it up there.

I agree that on a previous occasion, when constituencies in Dublin crossed the Liffey boundary, they were found to be unsatisfactory and had to be changed. As far as this one is concerned, I would not have agreed to it unless I had to do it. I hope that with the passage of time it will be possible to change this as well and go back to recognising the Liffey as the boundary which it has always been for Dublin city. This is only done because of the situation that is there.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

It is only a shortterm solution.

Comment on this

There is another thing there. The Minister was quick to say he could not have nine-seat and seven-seat constituencies on the north side without crossing the Liffey. He could have three- and four-seat constituencies and he could have some three-seat, four-seat and five-seat constituencies. The Minister must have a very good reason for going for the four-seat constituencies. We could have three- and four-seat constituencies but the Minister is insistent on four-seat constituencies and he has a reason. He wants to get back at the people and get his own way which was rejected in the referendum.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton says that we could have 12 seats on the north side and 12 seats on the south side of the Liffey but that could not be done because there are 27 seats. Let us say that the 12 was a slip of the tongue and say it is 13 instead. He would then find that the population per Deputy would be too great on the north side or the south side.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

What about fourteen?

Comment on this

I would agree with the Deputy if we had 28 seats but we have not. If Fine Gael were doing this I would agree they would have taken two seats from rural Ireland and put them into Dublin, but we decided not to do that. There are only 27 seats, not 28. If there were 28 seats this difficulty of the Liffey boundary would not arise. It arises because there are only 27 seats and the population is much the same north and south of the Liffey. I never said, as Deputy Belton suggests, that there was only one possible way of arranging the constituencies in the city of Dublin. There is an infinite number of ways of doing this. You could have one 27-seat constituency, you could have three nine-seat constituencies or you could have nine three-seat constituencies. We have decided we should have seven constituencies.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Why pick seven? Is that your lucky number?

Comment on this

The five-seat constituencies have proved to be long, straggling constituencies in the city of Dublin and it was quite obvious in arranging some five-seat constituencies on this occasion that there would have been great difficulty in division of streets and in straggling areas stretching from one to the other. As I said, we in Fianna Fáil believe the most suitable type of constituency is the three-seat constituency. But this would involve thinking up extra names.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

Let Deputy Belton think up names.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean to say that the only reason for not doing this is because he would not have enough names? That is the most stupid argument I ever heard.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean to say he could not think up names for constituencies? I hope that the people read this. That is the most ridiculous argument I have heard, that he cannot get names. Surely there are enough names and numbers available? The Minister says that is the only reason why he is doing this.

Comment on this

Think up names.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Could he not number them the same as in local elections.

Comment on this

It is so easy to confuse the Fine Gael Party. They would not know the difference between the No. 1 constituency and the No. 1 electoral area.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

I want to assure the Minister it is not so easy to confuse the people of Dublin and he will find that out.

Comment on this

When he goes to the country he will find it out again.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Surely his own Taoiseach put before him that they had to remember the result of the referendum which they received in no uncertain terms?

Comment on this

Are you trying to form a Coalition over there?

Comment on this

Does the Minister think we should adopt his line and not talk in the House?

Comment on this

We are not like him.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

What about the Bray Road repairs?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We had that before.

Comment on this

His Taoiseach had to apologise for him recently.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am putting the question.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton is on his feet.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He is not being relevant. He is not relating his remarks to the question before the House.

Comment on this

He is as relevant to the question as Deputy Foley was.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

You are making one rule for one side and another for the other.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is quite untrue.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

It is correct.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not make such a charge against the Chair. I will ask the Deputy to resume his seat.

Comment on this

Is he entitled to withdraw his remark?

Comment on this

It is a matter for the Chair.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Of course, he makes one ruling for one side of the House and another for the other.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Belton please resume his seat?

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

As a protest I will leave the House.

Deputy L. Belton withdrew.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the entry relating to Dublin Central agreed?

Comment on this

Put the question.

Comment on this

I have made my protest against your ruling.

DUBLIN NORTH-CENTRAL.

Comment on this

The Minister spent quite a while here, when I brought up the number of people in a constituency per elected Deputy, putting forward the view that my argument would not work. I am again here objecting to a four-seat constituency when it could be a five-seat one but that would not suit his Party. They are trying to gerrymander here again but the people will give them the same answer.

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Belton has made any point here.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:

In page 9, in the second column of the entry relating to Dublin North-East, to delete "south-westerly" and to substitute "north-westerly", and to delete "north-easterly" where it first occurs and substitute "southeasterly".

This is an amendment which proposes to correct minor inaccuracies in the description of the boundary of the proposed Dublin North-East constituency at Clontarf golf course.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us how many people are involved?

Comment on this

There are not any.

Comment on this

How many inaccuracies will that correct?

Comment on this

It is an inaccuracy only in the description.

Comment on this

There is no change in the population?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I just want to say as regards Dublin North-East that the same thing happened here as happened in a Mayo area. It was divided so that it would suit two Ministers. It is the same thing here. In the last general election we had one Minister and a member of his Party got another 300 or 400 votes. He would not have come into the Dáil otherwise. They made sure this would not happen. They split the area in the hope of giving one of their Ministers a viable vote in another area. It is a four-seat area. I do not know why it could not be a five-seater and a three-seater which would suit geographically.

That cannot be done, but there is the River Tolka and the canal which could be used. They could have used many crossroads going through the area and have a five-seater and a three-seater but the Minister insisted on a four-seater and a four-seater he is going to push through.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton knows this is not so. The constituency of Dublin North-East was not split for the purpose of separating two Ministers. It was revised because of the fact that the present population of Dublin North-East is 139,163 and it cannot any longer continue as a five-seat constituency. It is agreed that it could have been made a seven-seat constituency but we decided against that. We think seven-seat constituencies are ridiculous.

Comment on this

A five and a three then?

Comment on this

We decided on four and four.

Comment on this

Why did you not make it five and three? The Minister says he is fond of three and he will not take five. He will not take three. Four or five is the only hope.

Comment on this

Four is halfway between three and five. Split the difference.

Comment on this

Why not have five and three? The area suits because there are crossroads every half mile, or the river, or canal. There would be no trouble. Divide it five and three. The Minister wants four because he thinks it is going to suit the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

If Deputy Belton had suggested earlier, as he suggested today, giving part of his constituency to Deputies Burke and Foley I would have considered that favourably.

Comment on this

At no stage did I say anything about giving this. If the Minister thinks I am worrying about my constituents thinking I want to get them out, this just will not wash in the city of Dublin. This just does not wash. The Minister is saying something that is untrue if he says I said that.

Comment on this

Deputy Clinton said it for you. You got Deputy Clinton to say it for you. I forgot that. It was Deputy Clinton speaking on behalf of Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

This is the same four-seater again.

Comment on this

What about Dublin South-East? It is a three-seater.

Comment on this

You know that you will not get the second seat there.

Comment on this

We have a majority now and we will have it after the next general election.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:

In pages 9 and 10, in the second column of the entry relating to Dublin South-Central, to delete "Cowper Road" and to substitute "Cowper Drive".

Cowper Road was inadvertently included in the description of the boundary of the proposed Dublin South-Central constituency instead of Cowper Drive. This amendment proposes to make the necessary correction.

Comment on this

The Bill was not rushed through at all.

Comment on this

Somebody said I was too slow bringing it in.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:

In page 10, in the second column of the entry relating to North-East Galway, to delete "Clare-Galway" and to substitute "Clare-South Galway".

Comment on this

On the constituency as amended, anybody who looks at the map in relation to this and sees the way in which the two parts are taken in from Roscommon cannot fail to appreciate and understand that that must have been done for a quite deliberate, sinister purpose. Part of the sinister purpose here is to ensure that Roscommon would be down so much in relation to population that the necessity would arise to bring in the portion of Athlone that has been brought in for the sole purpose of serving the Minister for Education.

In the whole of this Bill there is no more glaring gerrymandering ramp than the manner in which a substantial part of the town of Athlone has been deliberately transposed into Roscommon simply and solely for Deputy Brian Lenihan, Minister for Education. On the calculations, the Minister could not have brought that bit in in Athlone unless he had taken these portions off Roscommon. When the Minister went to take them off Roscommon they were not even taken off in a cohesive part. They were taken off in two separate splits. This has been done. These people in Roscommon have been thrown out of their own county simply for the reason I have given and for no other reason. I am sure the parts in question will be very welcome to North-East Galway but that is not the point we are discussing. The point we are discussing and considering is the reason for it. The reason for it is simply and solely to devise an extra chunk of support for the Minister for Education in that Athlone corner. The Minister for Education will find when an election comes along he is not going to have his own way, as he thinks.

Comment on this

The parts of Roscommon added to this constituency are obviously the only parts that could reasonably be taken. When this necessity arises to transfer population from one county to another one must take areas contiguous to the county into which they are being transferred. This transfer has obviously been kept to the minimum since the population per Deputy in the constituency of North-East Galway will be very near the minimum that is allowed.

Comment on this

Is there in West Galway any change from the existing West Galway constituency?

Comment on this

No, I think there may be——

Comment on this

I think it is the same.

Comment on this

There is a very slight change of about 670 people.

Comment on this

It must be in the second paragraph.

Comment on this

I think it is Liscannon, but it is a very slight change anyhow.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20:

In page 11, in the second column of the entry relating to North Kerry, after "Deelis," to insert "Kilquane," and to delete "Cordal,".

The purpose of this amendment is to transfer the district electoral division of Cordal, in the former rural district of Tralee, from the proposed constituency of North Kerry to South Kerry in exchange for the district electoral division of Kilquane, in the former rural district of Dingle. It has been represented to me that this change will result in a more satisfactory division. It straightens out the line of division between the proposed North Kerry and South Kerry.

Comment on this

What are the differences?

Comment on this

It will increase the population of North Kerry from 57,207, which is an average per Deputy of 19,069, to 57,389, which is an average per Deputy of 19,130. It will reduce the population of South Kerry from 57,602 which is an average per Deputy of 19,201 to 57,420 which is an average per Deputy of 19,140. The average per Deputy will be closer in the two constituencies than it was in the original position.

Comment on this

It means a difference in population of 182. Is that not right?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I have a series of amendments down and I thought I said that amendment No. 25 should be put down first when I was sending the amendments in but I may be wrong. I do not think it matters very much but it would be more logical to take No. 25 first.

Comment on this

Nos. 23 and 24 are alternatives.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Nos. 23, 24 and 25.

Comment on this

Nos. 23 and 24 are related but No. 25 is entirely different. I do not mind which we take first.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think it would be better if we took them in order.

Comment on this

The basis of amendment No. 22 is to change only a very few townlands because these townlands have been accustomed over the years to voting in the Kilcock polling booths and it seems desirable that, in so far as one possibly can, one should stick to this. The Minister knows that I can be political if I want to be, and so can he, but this is purely an administrative matter. It seems desirable not to change people's habits in regard to polling booths which they have attended. The townlands concerned have a population of 142 and for as long as I can remember they have always gone to Kilcock to vote. It is most undesirable to have in the same place booths for two constituencies and if this change is not made the result will be that the people in these four townlands will have to change their habits and go to Newtown to vote.

Comment on this

Section 7 provides for making suitable arrangements for electors in polling districts that are split. I would imagine that there would be a number of instances in other parts of the country where this happens also and that a case could be made for similar amendments in other areas. However, I can see the undesirability of this where traditional voting arrangements have been in existence for some time. The only point I would like to make is that if these amendments are accepted it will increase the population of Kildare constituency and reduce the population of Meath constituency. It is taking a positive step to put the population per Member in these two constituencies more out of line than the original proposals as they are aimed at getting the population per Member, as near as practicable, the same. It is a fact that the proposals in the Bill go nearer in that direction than will be the position after this amendment, after the acceptance of amendments No. 22, 23 and 25, which is one of the possible alternatives, and will increase the population of Kildare to 61,994 and reduce Meath to 59,651.

Comment on this

But they will both be still far nearer the average than many other constituencies.

Comment on this

They will, but as between the two, and this is the only point I am making, the result of accepting these amendments will be to increase the disparity in population per Member between the two constituencies compared with what it is in the Bill at present. However, if Deputy Sweetman thinks that is all right I have no objection.

Comment on this

I think it is desirable so that, as far as possible, people can continue to go to the same polling booth.

Comment on this

Then I would suggest Nos. 22, 24, 25 rather than 22, 23 and 25.

Comment on this

I will settle for that.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The question is that the entry relating to the constituency of Kildare stand part of the Schedule?

Comment on this

The entry as amended.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The amendments deal with Meath. It is not amended.

Comment on this

But it will be amended. I am intrigued by the manner in which the constituency of Kildare, leaving out the small borderline variations, was prepared. I am surprised that I do not find my colleague, Deputy Crinion, here today to discuss this section in the Schedule. Deputy Crinion of course does not live in County Kildare; he lives in County Meath and the part of County Meath in which he resides is now being transferred back into the county of Meath and a large part of the county of Kildare, including Carbury, which I may say was one of the areas responsible more than any other in County Kildare for sending me into this House, has now been transferred from the county of Kildare into the county of Meath. Its eight polling districts which are contiguous to where Deputy Crinion resides have been transferred and I have a very strong suspicion that when the Minister was drawing up Kildare in this way he believed that Deputy Crinion was going to move over into the county of Meath. In fact rumour has it that Deputy Crinion also believed that but that the Minister for Defence would not have him and threw him out of the Meath constituency and this carving that was done out of the kindness of his heart by the Minister for Local Government to assist Deputy Crinion as he thought is now, in fact, boomeranging against Deputy Crinion and Deputy Crinion is no longer moving over into the Meath constituency. Rumour has it that the Minister for Defence indicated that he would not have him under any circumstances.

Comment on this

You cannot blame him for that.

Comment on this

No, I am not offering any comment on that. The comment I am making is that the people of Carbury are now going to have to suffer under this Bill by being taken away from the rest of Kildare because the Minister for Local Government wanted to assist Deputy Crinion by giving him eight polling districts next door to him when the Minister believed that the Deputy was moving over into the plains of Meath. However, that apparently is not to be.

I was also intrigued to see that the district electoral division of Cloncurry and the polling district of Newtown in that district electoral division are likewise being transferred. Of course, that polling district contains one of Deputy Crinion's strongest backers in the whole of Kildare-Newtown polling district—about which I think the Minister for Local Government knows a little because he visited it one day during the by-election with the Minister for Education if my memory serves me correctly. The whole of that North-West corner of Kildare from Kilpatrick to Carbury, to Clogherin-koe, to Broadford and Cadamstown, is now to be cut off from its natural home which is of course the rest of County Kildare. The part that is going will be my loss personally in Kildare but it certainly will be Meath's gain and it is a little humorous to say the least of it that this having been done for the benefit of the Fianna Fáil Deputy in the constituency he now has been forced to spurn the gift that was given to him by the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

As Deputy Sweetman knows of course this had nothing whatever to do with the proposed transfer of these areas to County Meath. It arises from a completely different reason altogether. It arises from the fact that the population of Kildare is 66,404, the population of Louth is 69,519, the population of Meath is 67,323, the population of Cavan is 54,022 and the population of Monaghan is 45,732. It arises from the fact that the county of Kildare cannot of itself constitute a three-seat or a four-seat constituency, that the only way in which these areas could be left in Kildare is by joining the whole county with the county of Carlow as some people have suggested or else making some other two-county arrangement such as that and that the decision was to have in this area where there is a total population of 303,000 five constituencies, one based on each of these five counties. This involved a transfer from Kildare to the part of County Meath remaining after Monaghan, Cavan and Louth had been dealt with. When a transfer such as this is being made it is natural that it is the areas that are contiguous to the County Meath that would be dealt with and as Deputy Sweetman has pointed out Deputy Crinion lives in County Meath and these areas are contiguous to the area in which Deputy Crinion lives, therefore obviously also contiguous to the county of Meath and are the natural areas to be transferred when such a transfer is made inevitable because of the constitutional position.

Comment on this

I must say I am amused by the Minister. It is such an extraordinary coincidence but what he is saying of the district electoral divisions that are being transferred does not happen to be entirely true. Carrick, Kilrainy, Cadamstown and Dunfierth are contiguous to County Meath but then he has gone on and stuck a dagger right down in the heart of Kildare with Carbury, Windmill Cross, Kilpatrick and Donadea. I am quite prepared to accept that Lullymore was a genuine mistake because I do not think it was realised when looking at the map that the canal was there between the two. I make no case for Lullymore more than that. It was a genuine mistake. Because of the canal it had to be brought back because otherwise one would have had to travel into the polling district of Kilmeague North in order to go anywhere. It would not be worthwhile putting a booth in Lullymore for 52 voters. However if the contiguity argument was to be made what was being moved would have been entirely different. These areas go right down into the centre of Kildare so a wedge was deliberately inserted there for the purpose of ensuring that Deputy Crinion standing in the Meath constituency would have a nice bloc of home votes all round. It did not work that way, whether it was because of the intricacies and the power grabs within the Fianna Fáil Party or not. The only point I want to make is that the people in those areas can blame Deputy Crinion and no one else for being transferred out of their home county.

Comment on this

Of course if, as Deputy Sweetman says, not all these district electoral divisions are contiguous to County Meath and if as he says Deputy Crinion lives in County Meath then his own opening statement that these areas were transferred because they were contiguous to where Deputy Crinion lives cannot be true either. It is a fact that they are all contiguous to one another.

Comment on this

If the Minister is arguing like that he could go right from east to west.

Comment on this

Let Deputy Sweetman suggest which areas we should leave out and which areas we should substitute for them.

Comment on this

When we go over there on the Government benches after the next general election we shall bring in a redistribution and we shall show Fianna Fáil, then.

Comment on this

Would we be able to go back to Kildare, please, as Deputy Crinion has just arrived in the House? I should like to give him the opportunity of defending himself.

Comment on this

I heard all that Deputy Sweetman said.

Comment on this

We have no worries about East Limerick. We shall handle that situation, do not worry.

Comment on this

It is a little bit unfortunate that Deputy Jones, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, is in the Chair just now when his constituency is being discussed. Do I understand that the Chair changes at 2 o'clock?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At 2.30 p.m.

Comment on this

If the Chair changed at 2 o'clock I should keep going until then in order to allow the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to speak on his own constituency, if he so desired. Will not the effect of this method of joining East and West Limerick be that one goes now from Abbeyfeale at the Kerry end right across to Galbally up at the Cork end——

Comment on this

Kilbehenny.

Comment on this

That would be even further than Galbally on the map though I am not quite sure whether Kilbehenny or Galbally would be further from Abbeyfeale. Here we have a complete contradiction of the case the Minister was making earlier that he wanted to provide in his constituencies that there would be the shortest distance between the two extreme ends of a constituency. By doing it in this way, it does seem on the map that there is a much longer distance than there would be by any other methods of division within the county of Limerick. I should like to hear exactly why the Minister decided to make the journey longer, so to speak, as the Chair is precluded from offering his observations on his own constituency just now.

Comment on this

I think the offer made by Deputy Sweetman to delay the proceedings long enough to allow the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to take part in the debate is an indication of the lack of success of the Fine Gael effort to compel Fine Gael Deputies to come in here to take part in the debate.

Comment on this

The Minister should look at the benches behind him.

Comment on this

We do not desire to delay. It is Fine Gael who desire to delay and who even had to get both the Leader——

Comment on this

On a point of order. As the Minister has no supporters, perhaps we might have a quorum?

Comment on this

That is another way of delaying the proceedings.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I was going on to point out, when I was unnecessarily interrupted, that the adjustment between East and West Limerick constituencies is made purely and simply because of the fact that the Census of Population carried out in 1966 disclosed that the population of West Limerick is now 54,335 and that this figure divided by three, which is the number of Deputies for the area, would not be in accordance with the constitutional provision. On the other hand, the population of East Limerick is 83,022 and these two figures added together give 137,357 which is sufficient for seven seats, just barely, and therefore it is not necessary to go outside the boundaries of County Limerick in order to adjust the situation. However, this slight disruption of the boundary between the two Limerick constituencies is necessary in order to comply with the Constitution. I think anybody would agree that the place at which the adjustment is made is the most logical place to make such an adjustment.

Comment on this

It means the longest distance.

Comment on this

The longest distance from where to where?

Comment on this

From one end to the other end.

Comment on this

The East Limerick constituency has always been based on Limerick city.

Comment on this

Yes, agreed, but you could still do it the other way.

Comment on this

I think it is logical to keep it that way. You could do all these things in practically an infinite number of ways. This is the obvious way to do it.

Comment on this

This is the way that gives the longest travelling.

Comment on this

As a result of the by-election surely the Minister should have taken cognisance of the fact that in every polling booth in the City of Limerick the emigration——

Comment on this

How did we win it so?

Comment on this

As a result of the by-election it is quite obvious to us that no matter what you did in Limerick we would retain our four seats out of seven and the only possible rearrangement that could be made would be to increase our representation and it would be gerrymandering to approach it in that way.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In page 11, in the second column of the entry relating to Longford-Westmeath, to delete "Roscommon" and to substitute "Roscommon-Leitrim".

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This amendment has already been discussed with amendments Nos. 12 and 1.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): In Longford-Westmeath area there is a transfer of Athlone urban to Roscommon. Athlone urban has been traditionally associated with Longford-Westmeath. I gave the Minister figures yesterday to show that this transfer of Athlone urban to the north-west counties, taking them as a group, was unnecessary and that as we agreed to accept some four-seater constituencies, three four-seat constituencies on the western seaboard, it would be unnecessary to move the population of Athlone urban into the western counties.

For example, I mentioned that Roscommon itself could stand as a single constituency by just bringing in Taghboy and Ahascragh. These are two small areas, Taghboy with 290 votes and Ahascragh with 663 votes. That small number of 953 people taken from Galway would allow Roscommon a single three-seat constituency which is a far better arrangement than what the Minister suggests.

Similarly, Galway, even after giving some to Clare, could remain and have sufficient population to form West Galway as a three-seater and East Galway as a four-seater. Similarly also, you could have Donegal as two three-seaters and Sligo-Leitrim as a four-seater, and there would be a transfer of only a little over 5,000 of population out of Leitrim. The Minister has argued here that we gave him no proper suggestions and that, in effect, we did not know what we were talking about. I have given details, so far as one can in a debate, of all the transfers that may be made and the populations and the amount of transferred population outside administrative areas in the scheme which I put to him was less than one-sixth of the transferred population under his global scheme of ten three-seaters. The alternative I suggested of three four-seaters and six three-seaters, leaving reasonable constituencies of reasonable size and manageability and paying respect to administrative areas, would leave something like 9,000 people transferred.

In fact it is possible, as regards the entire country, to merge constituencies and give reasonable results with a transfer of population outside of administrative areas of something a little over 19,000—I have totted the figures since—as against his figure of 101,000. I admit it would pare things rather fine but it is possible to elect 30 Deputies from the area I mentioned, the western seaboard, the north western counties, without impinging at all on Athlone urban. I realise that this quite unnecessary transfer is being done for political purposes and in the interests of a specific Minister but it is not necessary under the Constitution.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I should like to draw the Deputy's attention at this stage to the fact that we seem to be moving from Longford-Westmeath to a general discussion again on the country at large as distinct from the constituency which is under review at the moment.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Yes, but this movement of urban population from Longford-Westmeath, this moving of the Athlone urban population, is being done to get the necessary population for all that group area. Under the method which the Minister has used he has found it necessary, and will be able to argue statistically that it is necessary, to move that population into the western seaboard, if you call it that, in order to provide the ten three-seat constituencies. If he were prepared to accept an arrangement of six three-seaters instead of ten, and three four-seaters, which would give the same representation to all these counties west of Athlone, it could be done without moving the urban population of Athlone into that area. I can give him the areas and the figures whereby he can still have three seats in West Galway, four seats in East Galway, still retain four seats in Clare, four seats in Longford-Westmeath and have his two three-seaters in Donegal. Mayo does not come into it because it is an internal rearrangement that is being made there. This is statistically quite possible under the Constitution, but apparently the Minister does not want to hear of it that way and wants to proceed to establish ten three-seat constituencies. To do that, you have to drag in Athlone urban which, as I have shown, is quite unnecessary. I can give the figures again, if he wants them, showing how all these arrangements can be made within the Constitution.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Hogan knows that we are not proposing to transfer Athlone urban but we are transferring Athlone west urban, a completely different thing.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): That is what I mean.

Comment on this

It is situated west of the Shannon and in fact Athlone west urban is the county town for a large part of South Roscommon. The Athlone No. 2 rural district is, in fact, in the administrative county of Roscommon and it is to this part of Athlone that is west of the Shannon that all the people of that area of Clonowen, Drumlash and Taghmaconnell and Curraghboy and so on come to do their business. It is looked upon, and always has been looked upon, as the county town for that part of south Roscommon. In fact, Athlone west urban is known locally as Irishtown, that part of Athlone west of the Shannon.

We are still adhering to the Shannon boundary in that particular area. Deputy Hogan says he gave me figures but he gives incomplete figures. We must consider this in the context of the whole western area and in the context of the average of population per Deputy. Deputy Hogan keeps putting forward this alternative of the transfer of Taghboy and Ahascragh from Galway to Roscommon but, of course, that transfer is from Galway.

The Athlone west urban area is traditionally associated with that part of South Roscommon which is roughly divided by the Athlone No. 2 rural district, and there is nothing anomalous in it. It is a rationalisation rather than anything else.

Comment on this

It is purely coincidental that it is the area of the Minister for Education.

Comment on this

Fine Gael would consider they have reasonably strong support in Athlone.

Comment on this

We will show you, later on.

Comment on this

It cannot suit everybody. It is only one man one vote.

Comment on this

It is to provide that Deputy Lenihan will put out poor Deputy Gibbons.

Comment on this

We will have two seats.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister said I gave incomplete figures. The only one I did not give completely is in respect of County Galway. The population there, after transfers to Roscommon and to Clare, is 104,582. In Clifden rural the population is 9,064, in Galway rural, 18,334, in Oughterard, 10,610 and in Galway Borough, 24,597, making 62,605. This leaves 80,977 to East Galway, after transfers to Roscommon and Clare, and gives a three-seater in the west and a four-seater in the east. I do not know what other figures I could have given.

Comment on this

The Deputy could have started in Donegal and stopped in Clare.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Does the Minister want me to start on a bicycle ride from Donegal down along the west coast?

Comment on this

I do not care. It is one other way to delay the passage of the Bill.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I am an obliging chap and if the Minister wishes I will start at Donegal and will do the type of bicycle ride for which he has earned such a tremendout reputation, having been able to speak for, I think, six hours on one occasion. I could not compete with that but if he wishes I will try. I have given the figures for Donegal. I have given the areas but I have not given the populations which are in the red book in front of the Minister.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At the moment we are dealing with amendment No. 21. It has been discussed already and we are rediscussing it.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister has advised me to walk to Donegal and to start on a bicycle ride right down the Galway coast, though I have given him the figures already. The situation is that the Minister has transferred too many people into Galway and Donegal. If he had done a little more cheeseparing in relation to Galway and Donegal he need not have drafted Athlone west urban into Roscommon. However, he has treated the spread of population so generously, having liquidated Leitrim completely and having treated Roscommon so harshly, he has left himself without population and he had to draw on Athlone in order to redraft Roscommon. It suited him to do this also for political reasons. Had he desired to confine himself to the counties concerned, he would have found sufficient population, though it would have been cheeseparing, without using Athlone west urban. He could have left most of the counties concerned intact. He has wiped Leitrim completely off the map and has cut up Roscommon.

Comment on this

This is another example of dividing east and west contrary to all traditional methods. For as long as the records stand, any division in Mayo has always been on the basis of north and south.

Comment on this

Not at all. East Mayo was with Sligo for ages.

Comment on this

That is a revelation to me who have lived there during the past 40 years. East Mayo was not in Sligo since the dawn of time.

Comment on this

Look up your history.

Comment on this

The point of dividing it east and west now is to prevent the Minister for Justice and the Minister for Health being in the same constituency. Again, as in many other constituencies, the traditional pattern is being changed simply and solely to suit Fianna Fáil. There is no other reason. We all know it and it is perfectly patent on its face. The more one examines this Bill the more one sees that it was drawn up by the Minister purely for personalities in his own Party and not in pursuance of the national interest.

Comment on this

In consideration of certain circumstances to which I do not at present propose to refer, I have not participated actively in this debate regarding the realignment of constituencies, particularly that which I have the honour to represent, but when the issue of Mayo arises, and when Deputy Gilbride, who is an experienced Deputy, intervenes to say that East Mayo was for a considerable time incorporated in Sligo, I think the voice of protest must be raised. I never remember any time——

Comment on this

The Deputy's memory must be getting very bad.

Comment on this

I suppose the time has come when my memory might be called into question. I do not think, however faulty it may have become with the passage of time, that it fails me now. I have lived personally and vicariously in the constituency of Mayo for almost 100 years now and it has never been part of Sligo as far as I know. My father represented it from 1883 to 1918. Mr. de Valera represented it after that, having defeated my father in 1918, and East Mayo was a constituent part of Mayo down the years.

I intervene at this stage of the Bill in relation to Mayo and the handling of the county for reasons which I think Deputy Sweetman has rightly pointed out. This is a device employed by the Minister for Local Government to separate Deputy Flanagan, the Minister for Health, from Deputy Moran, the Minister for Justice. One can fully sympathise with the Minister for Local Government in his desire to separate these two Deputies because their contiguity in the past has given rise to more than one dramatic incident in the electoral history of this country. As a Mayo man, I want to direct the attention of the House to the fact that, apart from the immediate political gerrymandering that is being carried on in various areas in the country, I think those of us who are concerned with public decency ought in respect of the areas where they are ordinarily resident —Mayo is that for me—to register a protest against the form of this Bill and its Schedule. I am prepared to stake my reputation that there is in the Department of Local Government at this moment a draft Bill for the redistribution made necessary by the previous census which would have breached virtually no county boundaries and that the Minister for Local Government has rejected that draft preferring to bring in this crazy patchwork for the purpose of wreaking vengeance on the people because they turned down the Government proposals in the referendum.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

That was what Deputy Martin Corry said anyway.

Comment on this

That is the fact. There is a healthy local patriotism amongst our people. They like to be associated with the counties to which they have traditionally belonged. I understand that in this proposed redistribution Ballaghaderreen is being moved back to Roscommon. Ballaghaderreen constitutes part of County Mayo and has done so from time immemorial. The first time it was ever transferred to Roscommon was for the purposes of parliamentary elections subsequent to 1918. It is an interesting thing to note that, when the Local Government Act of 1898 was passed by the British House of Commons for the purposes of local administration, the area of Ballaghaderreen was moved to Roscommon.

Comment on this

The Deputy's memory is coming back.

Comment on this

The relevancy of that observation is not, to me, immediately apparent.

Comment on this

Where did Dr. Farren represent in his time? Was it not Sligo and East Mayo?

Comment on this

Not that I am aware of. Neither Dr. Farren, whom I never heard of before, nor any other doctor represented Sligo or East Sligo. It is interesting to remember that, for the purposes of local government, the British House of Commons transferred part of what had been the administrative county of Roscommon for parliamentary purposes; they recognised the traditional loyalties of people to their own county and they left Ballaghaderreen in the constituency of East Mayo. It was for that reason that the famous anti-conscription meeting was addressed by my father and the father of Deputy Vivion de Valera in Ballaghaderreen 51 years ago, because it was part of the constituency of East Mayo, which was then the constituency of the Leader of the Irish Party in the person of my late father. I think the present procedure shows a vindictive desire to affront our people because they asserted their right in the referendum to reject the radical proposal the Government put forward anent the crooked vote and the single seat condu stituency. I think that is all wrong. I think it is indicative of the vicious——

Comment on this

Sir, I take it I will be permitted to reply on these lines.

Comment on this

Am I entitled to speak on the proposed division of Mayo?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

On the division of Mayo, but any reference to the referendum is not in order.

Comment on this

I am, surely, entitled to suggest that the reason Mayo is so divided, and parts of what are traditionally Mayo are now being transferred out of it, is that this is a vindictive Bill. Am I not entitled to call in evidence the fact that 70 years ago, in 1898, the British Government did not do this? They recognised that in this country, as in Great Britain, people have traditional county loyalties.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that we are dealing with the Schedule to the Bill and discussion is confined to the entries that appear in the Schedule or to associated areas which may be treated as a group.

Comment on this

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle is aware that, under this Schedule, it is proposed to take part of the traditional constituency of East Mayo and transfer it to Roscommon.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That may be discussed, but wider references to the referendum are not in order.

Comment on this

I shall not trespass on your patience, but surely I am entitled to state the reason for this? I compare the proposal of the Government of the Republic with the conduct of the Imperial Parliament in Westminster. It appears to me our Government is actuated by a vindictive desire to hurt the people because the people would not accept their electoral proposals in the referendum.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

The Deputy may say it is nonsense, but I ask the Deputy to reflect and to ask himself why it is that this Government of the Republic take a different line in regard to this matter from that taken by the Imperial Parliament in Westminster 70 years ago. Why did the Imperial Parliament 70 years ago, at a time when it would have been convenient to put Ballaghaderreen into Roscommon for county council purposes, not do so? Why did they say to themselves that these people look upon themselves as Mayo people and why did they decide they should be left in Mayo for parliamentary representation? I think it was because they recognised traditional loyalties. The Bill before us at the moment, which is designed at butchering the county, is not drafted for the purpose of securing satisfactory parliamentary representation. It is drafted as a kick in the teeth because the people refused to respond to the crack of the Fianna Fáil whip and the Fianna Fáil majority in this House. I think that is wrong. I deplore it. The Government have a majority in Dáil Éireann and they will be able to force this Bill through. Mark you, there is an uneasy tittering amongst Fianna Fáil Deputies; I do not mind Deputy Booth because he lives down in Monkstown, or somewhere, and he does not know what is happening in the country, and never will, but the Deputy from West Galway —I do not see any smile on his face— and the Deputy from Sligo——

Comment on this

The Deputy is not suggesting he will be defeated.

Comment on this

In the coming general election?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

As sure as an eye in a goat, and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making sure he will not be defeated anyway.

Comment on this

He has got cold feet.

Comment on this

For pity's sake, when some of you have served the country as well as Deputy Dillon has done——

Comment on this

They do not worry me. I am making the case that they are actuated by vindictive viciousness. They know it is true. I must concede this. Though they are poisoned by the vileness of their presence on those benches, individually I have found most of them extremely civil to me since they learned that it was not my intention to return to this House after the next general election. So let us not make the case that they want to affront me.

Comment on this

They are on the run.

Comment on this

That has not been my experience and I have no such ground for complaint.

Comment on this