We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–226 of 454. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 35 of 1968 ›

Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dillon reported progress on the entry relating to East Mayo.

Comment on this

I have nothing to add.

Comment on this

Coming from the constituency of East Mayo, it is only right that I should make a few remarks on this entry. Everyone now knows that the Minister had the power and the opportunity to divide the constituencies as he saw fit. Even though Mayo as a whole remains an electoral entity, there has been a remarkable change in the manner in which the boundaries between the two constituencies that exist there have been aligned as against the division that existed heretofore.

As the House knows, in the past there were the constituency of North Mayo and the constituency of South Mayo, and the boundary line was drawn horizontally across the county. Due to factors of population which we will not go into now, a portion of the county of Roscommon was taken in, in order to give a four-seat constituency in South Mayo. In the county as a whole, Fine Gael had four seats as against three for Fianna Fáil after the last election. Due to the factors mentioned earlier in all these discussions—the decision of Mr. Justice Budd, and so on—it was found necessary to reduce the representation by one seat for the county as a whole, and to have two three-seaters instead of a four-seater and a three-seater as it was heretofore.

In the division and alignment of the new constituencies, if they followed the old pattern two Government Ministers would be contesting the constituency which I have the honour to represent. I suppose the Minister who is responsible for this talked to the individual Ministers concerned, and decided that it would be far better for the Party not to have two Ministers contesting in the same constituency and he decided, willy-nilly, to divide the county vertically instead of horizontally. The line is now drawn from north to south instead of from east to west. If that line were drawn straight through the county I would see some reason for it and some sense in it. If anyone takes the trouble to look at a map of the constituencies of East and West Mayo, and tries to imagine what they resemble he will see that the eastern part, which is the constituency I hope to stand for, with the help of God, resembles a kangaroo with the pouch empty, and the other part resembles a star fish. A fish which is sometimes portrayed on television resembles the outline of the western constituency.

The Minister used to tell us—and this was talked about for hours and hours on every platform when we were discussing the referendum—that he wanted to ensure that an elector was within reasonable distance of the Deputy elected to Dáil Éireann. Anyone who looks at a map of the two constituencies of Mayo with the division we are to have if this Bill goes through, as presumably it will, and suggests that anyone will be brought nearer to his Deputy, as a result of that alignment, should have his glasses changed.

However, the alignment has been made and it was made for a particular purpose: in order to ensure that in each constituency Fianna Fáil would get two seats. Possibly I should not blame the Minister for that if he said: "Gentlemen, I am dividing the constituencies so that we can get an overall majority whether the electors like us or not." The fact remains that this alignment was made for a particular purpose and the people in the area, as well as the Deputies in the area, have to accept that fact. I know that the Minister for Health, Deputy Seán Flanagan, and I will be fighting in the same area. We have fought elections in the past without any recriminations and I have lost in many elections but we have never had any recriminations. They were fought toe-to-toe on the filed without the help of any dividing line that the Minister could put across a constituency.

Perhaps, on this occasion, the line that the Minister has drawn may do as much damage to the Minister I have mentioned as to anybody else. The people who supported me in the past have been put on the other side of the dividing line so that we must continue from there and attempt to make good as best we can. We must also attempt to beat Fianna Fáil at the Minister's game. That means that we must seek the support of people who we did not know before and people who do not, in the west at any rate, readily accept a new man. We will not be able to give the best representation to these people because we will not know them as well as we knew our constituents in the past and this Bill is supposed to give people better representation and better contact with the Deputies they elect to Dáil Éireann.

In the northern end of Mayo we have what, in the past, was North Mayo. We have people in this constituency who are dissatisfied because the southern end of the constituency has been foisted on them and we have people in the southern end who are dissatisfied because the people in the north have been foisted on them. They must accept the situation in which Deputies they do not know will represent them.

Earlier in this debate I asked the Minister if it was within the powers of Dáil Éireann to amend the Constitution in order to give representation to the west or to the rural areas and to ensure that the boundaries of constituencies as they were heretofore could be maintained, but nobody answered the question. Looking at the whole picture now from our side and from the point of view of the people— indeed, from the point of view of many Fianna Fáil people—it would appear that, if the Minister had been wise and if he had not attempted to change the electoral system to the one seat constituency, if he had asked the people to adopt what was his Third Amendment and give the tolerance without having the other thing involved, we would be able to have in Mayo the same alignment, the same amount of representation and the same constituency lines as we had in the past.

Comment on this
Seán Flanagan Minister for Health (Mr. S. Flanagan) Fianna Fáil

I wish to say only a few words on this, partly of course, because I must say goodbye to more than 50 per cent of the people of Mayo whom I have represented now for almost 18 years. My principal reason for speaking on this today is because of the curious attitude adopted by Deputy Dillon at the end of the debate last week.

Nobody appreciates Deputy Dillon's attachment to Mayo more than I, and he is to be commended for it, but how he could equate the present changes in Mayo with vindictiveness towards the area of Ballaghaderreen is something which I cannot fathom. Indeed, I would go further and say that, in so far as I am concerned, it is with the greatest regret that that part of the constituency of South Mayo as it now exists is to go back into Roscommon.

It is true that this town in the vicinity was traditionally part of the County Mayo until the 1898 Local Government Act. Incidentally, part of the deal at the time was that Árd na Ríogh came into Ballina while Ballaghaderreen came out of the county. Down through the years there certainly has been a sort of tension among the people of the area that it was ever thought necessary for administrative purposes to change the county boundaries at all. However, it was changed and we must accept that this is so. When the Minister for Local Government came to examine the matter, he discovered that the population of Mayo was now over 115,000 people and this was enough within the straitjacket enforced on him by the people as a result of their decision in the referendum to sustain six Deputies with a tiny margin of a few hundred votes left over.

This, therefore, precluded the possibility of Ballaghaderreen remaining in either constituency of my county. This, as I say, is something which I personally regret very much and with which I share the regard of Deputy Dillon. As I say, it simply mystifies me that he should regard this action on the part of the Minister for Local Government — an action which, in fact, is inevitable—as evidence of vindictiveness on the Minister's part in trying to frame suitable constituencies for the future.

The other matter on which I wish to speak arises from the remarks by Deputy Lyons. But before I do so I should like to say that I agree with him when he says that we have contested many elections without rancour and without recrimination and, as far as I am concerned, I will continue to conduct elections without any rancour or recrimination whatsoever. I should like to point out to Deputy Lyons that here in Mayo we have a situation where at the moment there are seven representatives returned to this House, whereas after the next election this number must be reduced to six. The seven are divided as to four in South Mayo and three in North Mayo.

If the Minister were to keep to his terms of reference, so as not to exceed the national average unduly on either side of whatever boundary he ultimately settles, then it is obvious that there would have been far too many of a population in the constituency of South Mayo and far too few in the constituency of North Mayo. In fact, North Mayo would not sustain three Deputies and, therefore, assuming that the Minister was right in keeping the county as an entity when this could be readily done, the question of shifting what is traditionally called the boundary line of east and west had to arise. It was merely a question of what way that line would be shifted so as to give some reasonable parity as between east and west or north and south, whichever it turned out to be. But the roughly horizontal line of the past twenty years or so simply had to accommodate the fact that the number of Deputies had been reduced from six to five and also accommodate the necessity of keeping within the terms of reference of the Budd judgment.

Deputy Lyons asked why the Minister for Local Government did not simply draw a line straight down from North to South once he had decided that this was the direction in which he was aiming. The answer to that seems to me to be quite simple. If Deputy Lyons looks at the map of his own county he will see that this would give a very compact constituency of East Mayo and an enormously large constituency of West Mayo. It did not seem to the Minister for Local Government equitable that he should ask the representatives of West Mayo to undertake roughly four times as much travelling as their counterparts in the east. It therefore seemed to the Minister that the line which, in any event, had to be swung either north or south, east or west, should be so adjusted as to try to make two constituencies roughly comparable.

As I said at the beginning, this Bill involves all of us who previously represented North Mayo in having to make very substantial adjustments and in having to undertake responsibility for vast areas of the county which we have not previously represented, but this was rendered inevitable by the Constitution. I think the Minister has done the best he could in the circumstances and I entirely repudiate the suggestion that there was anything Minister in what he did.

In conclusion—and I say this quite bluntly lest there be any doubt about it—I would say that no matter which way the Minister for Local Government redrew the lines of the two new constituencies in Mayo the Minister for Justice and myself would not have contested the same constituency in any event.

Comment on this

I do not know that there is any need for me to say much more after what the Minister for Health has said. I repudiate the suggestions that were made, and I know that the Deputies who made them did so knowing them to be incorrect or else out of pure ignorance of the distribution of population as between the two present constituencies in Mayo. It is a fact, as the Minister for Health has pointed out, that Mayo, which at present returns seven Deputies can, because of the decision made by the people at the behest of Deputy Lyons and his colleagues, now return a maximum of six Deputies. This could be done either by having one six-seat constituency or two three-seat constituencies, and I note that, although some members of the Fine Gael Party have been quite industrious in this matter and have been drawing up different schemes of constituencies, alternatives to the proposals that are before us, none of them has attempted to indicate how they would divide County Mayo up into two three-seat constituencies.

It is alleged that this should have been done by a movement of the present lines running east and west in a southwards direction. Deputies know that could not be done practically. I am sure that at least the Mayo Deputies in Fine Gael must know that the present line practically skirts the town of Castlebar and that at least 7,000 people have to be moved from the present constituency of South Mayo to the present constituency of North Mayo in order to form two three-seat constituencies in compliance with the requirements of the Constitution, and that, therefore, if this was to be done in the manner that Deputies opposite pretend to think it could be done, that line would have to run probably right through the centre of the town of Castlebar.

If we are to try to maintain the two constituencies, one called North Mayo and one called South Mayo, the only practical thing to do is to turn down the two ends of the present line, roughly around the town of Castlebar, at the eastern and western extremities. What has been done is that the line has been turned down at the east and turned upwards at the west. I think this is the only practical way of doing this thing which we tried to avoid doing, that is, reducing the representation of Mayo and creating two three-seat constituencies.

Anybody trying to do this in a practical way would appreciate the desirability, if at all possible, of leaving the natural hinterlands of towns associated with these towns in the new constituencies, and that is largely why it is not possible to have the line running almost directly north and south, because such a line would cut off the whole of the area that is naturally associated with the town of Ballina from that town. It is because of these practical difficulties which have shown up that none of these people, neither Deputy Hogan nor Senator FitzGerald, who have been so industrious in the Fine Gael Party, have attempted to show that what they say could be done could, in fact, be done.

Deputy Lyons says I could divide County Mayo as I saw fit. Of course, he must know that I could not. I had to divide it in accordance with the requirements of the Constitution. I had to comply with very strict rules and, from the practical point of view, I had to take account of considerations such as I have mentioned, of leaving as much as possible of the natural hinterland of the various towns in association with those towns.

Deputy Lyons suggests that the people should not have to accept the necessity of accustoming themselves to new Deputies instead of those to whom they have been accustomed. That is not my fault. That is because of the decision that was made in the referendum. Fianna Fáil did not want to have to perform this operation at all. We did not think it was called for by any democratic requirement. It was required by a legalistic interpretation of the words in the Constitution, and Deputy Lyons and the other Fine Gael Deputies insisted on retaining that straitjacket in regard to the delineation of the Constitution.

I invite Deputy Lyons to draft a division of Mayo on the lines of north and south into two three-seat constituencies. He asked me: "Is it not within the province of Dáil Éireann to amend the Constitution?" He also referred to the fact that he had asked me this on the Second Stage of this Bill and that he did not get a reply. Of course, the reason why he did not get a reply was that the Whips arranged that I would not be allowed to reply to Deputy Lyons. They artificially restricted my right of reply and I was able to deal with only some of the many misrepresentations that were made, and Deputy Lyons's question, which was really a silly question, did not make the required order of priority to be dealt with in the limited time that was available.

Surely, after having a long debate here on the proposal to amend the Constitution and having a referendum on it, Deputy Lyons must know it is not within the province of Dáil Éireann to amend the Constitution. The proposal to take this requirement out of the Constitution or to amend it must be decided by the people by referendum. Deputy Lyons must know that as lately at October, 1968, such a proposal has been before the people to amend the Constitution in order to enable counties like Mayo to be dealt with in a more rational way and the proposal has been decisively rejected by the people. It is ridiculous for Deputy Lyons to say if we had had this proposal separately it would have been accepted by the people. We proposed originally to put the two together. At the request of the Opposition Party we separated them into two proposals. We naturally assumed when this request for a separation of a comparatively simple proposal into two component parts was made that the Opposition would have been prepared to accept one of them. Deputy Lyons and his Party opposed a proposal which would have made this distortion of the traditional situation in Mayo unnecessary.

The responsibility for this is Deputy Lyon's and not mine. He and his Party voted against a proposal that would have made this unnecessary and campaigned against it. The result is that this has to be done. Even now does Deputy Lyons speak for the Fine Gael Party? Is there in fact anybody that can speak for the Fine Gael Party on any subject under the sun? In this particular Bill every Deputy who has put forward a proposal from the Fine Gael benches has emphasised that he is speaking for himself and himself only. He did not need to because he was contradicted by counter-proposals from his own colleagues. So far as I can see Fine Gael have already decided which of the seven Mayo Deputies will not be coming back here as a Mayo Deputy. Deputy Lindsay has already transferred himself to the city of Dublin. It was seen that the Mayo seat would be lost and that it would in future be a Dublin seat. The Fine Gael Deputy has taken the step of transferring himself here.

Comment on this

Speaking for Fine Gael, I would like to reply to some of the misrepresentations of the Minister for Local Government. I want to deny and to state that, so far as Deputy Lindsay is concerned, he has not transferred to any Dublin constituency. He has not left County Mayo. The Minister asked does Deputy Lyons speak for the Fine Gael Party. Certainly, so far as he is concerned, he spoke for the Fine Gael Party. He spoke as far as Mayo and the constituencies of Mayo are concerned. We are entitled to come in here and, if the Minister has put forward a vindictive plan to gerrymander and butcher the constituencies in a worse form than the Unionists of Northern Ireland would or could attempt, we are at liberty to come in here as public representatives, representing the Irish people and put one, two, three or four plans before this House and to say any of them would be fair to the people of this country.

It is a well-known fact that the Minister was interested in only one thing, and that was to gerrymander the constituencies of this country and to return to Leinster House the maximum number of Fianna Fáil Deputies. When the Minister for Local Government gets up here and makes allegations, we are entitled to speak. Deputy Michael Carty, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, is a decent respectable man and he is not here today to defend himself. He is a gentleman, a thing I could not say for the present Minister for Local Government. So far as I am concerned, I am prepared to come in here and defend him. Any agreement that was made with the Opposition or that was agreed between the Whips to curtail the Minister for Local Government was made with the full authority of the Taoiseach of this country and of the Cabinet. When it is put to us, it is our duty to come in here and tell the truth to the Irish people. The Minister deliberately held up this House. He spoke for seven hours, for five hours on two occasions, and for four hours.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is extraneous matter.

Comment on this

This is the third time this accusation has been made. As Whip of the Fine Gael Party, I am entitled to put it down on the record of this House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has made his point.

Comment on this

I will speak for only two minutes more, but I am entitled to make my point in full. The country is entitled to know that on this particular occasion the Minister refused to sit down for two Fianna Fáil Ministers.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This has nothing to do with the debate and the Chair must call on the Deputy——

Comment on this

The Minister spoke at length and stated he was not given time to reply. I want to place on the records of this House that it was discussed between the Taoiseach and the Cabinet.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I would ask the Deputy to come back to the section of the Bill we are dealing with.

Comment on this

Instructions were sent to the Minister himself——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is again contravening what the Chair is asking him to do. I am asking the Deputy to come back to the section of the Bill.

Comment on this

I want this on the records of the House. The Minister has got away with misrepresentation on at least three occasions in this House. I want to say that this is a typical example of Fianna Fáil butchery. When the Minister tells us in this House that Mayo can no longer return seven seats but a maximum of six because of the Budd judgment and the judgment of the High Court, who does the Minister think he is fooling in the country or in this House? Let him tell the truth to the Irish people. The fact that Mayo is reduced from a seven-seater to a six-seater is due to the fact that the Minister and the Government sitting there on those benches, the dead hand of Fianna Fáil, have reduced the population of Mayo from 152,052 in 1956 to 115,547 in 1966. In ten years they have emulated the feat of Cromwell and driven 17,505 people, boys and girls, the cream of the west of Ireland, from the homes of their birth to London, Birmingham, or some other city abroad. It is on the Minister's shoulders and on the shoulders of the Minister for Health, that the responsibility lies for what has happened in Mayo. If we had a reasonable Government——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are not discussing Government policy.

Comment on this

I am certainly entitled to make the point that, if we had good government, we could still have 133,000 people in Mayo as we had 12 years ago and Mayo could have been left a seven-seater constituency. The horizontal line could still be there instead of the vertical line we have now, trying to keep two Ministers apart. Does the Minister deny the reason for this vertical line is to keep Deputy Moran and Deputy Flanagan apart? Is it not true that he has done the same everywhere else? He has kept "Charlie the Greatest" away from Deputy Colley who talks about low standards in high places——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must refer to Members of this House by the title to which they are entitled.

Comment on this

He has done similar things in other constituencies. The reason is quite obvious. The Minister thinks that by having a Minister in West Mayo and another in East Mayo he will be able to get sufficient votes to bring in a second Fianna Fáil Deputy with him but I remember the arrogance of Deputy Boland, Minister for Local Government, before the referendum. I remember him coming in here day after day and shouting at the Members of this House: "We will humiliate you. We will defeat you. Wait until 16th October." The 16th October came and we know what happened. The Minister's Party was defeated by 234,000 votes. I want to tell him that, despite his vindictive butchering and gerrymandering of Mayo, when this election is over, because the people of Ireland have found them out and are not prepared to trust this Government any longer, in West Mayo we will have two Fine Gael Deputies and in East Mayo we will have two Fine Gael Deputies.

The Minister talks about Castlebar and says that he wanted to put some of the hinterland of the town in association with the town. Who does he think he is codding when, having done that, he has taken part of Athlone and the whole of the hinterland and put it into Roscommon? Does he remember what they did in 1961 to make certain that I would not come into Leinster House? They certainly defeated me at that time. They took Killucan and came to the bridge going into Mullingar, where there are 7,000 or 8,000 people, and they cut across the northern side of it, the eastern side of it and the southern side of it. They went around the town of Mullingar and put the whole lot into Kildare which did not even border County Westmeath. Does the Minister think there is anybody going to believe him now when he says that it was necessary to put Castlebar and its hinterland together into the one constituency, that the hinterland could not be separated from the town? The Minister fooled the Irish people long enough. The Minister even fooled his Taoiseach, but he is finding you out at the present time.

Comment on this

I have to point out that my reference to the machinations of the Opposition Whips prior to the Recess was in reply to Deputy Lyons's complaint that I had not replied to the case that he made on the Second Reading of the Bill.

Comment on this

You made the same lying accusations before.

Comment on this

I had not sufficient time to do this because of the fact that the Opposition Whips arranged that I would not. At that time they were in such a hurry to get home for Christmas. Now Deputy L'Estrange is at his wits' end to find ways of prolonging the debate on the Committee Stage of the Bill. We saw him last week sending in his Deputies in relays to prolong this. It is quite obvious that the sole purpose of Deputy L'Estrange's operations now, after he has had his Christmas holidays, is to delay the passage of this Bill so as to put off as far as possible a situation in which the new constituencies will be available for the forthcoming general election in order to give Fine Gael some time to try to get some semblance of unity into the Party.

Deputy L'Estrange now tells me, when I asked if Deputy Lyons was speaking for the Fine Gael Party when he said that if the Third Amendment was presented on its own it would be accepted, that Deputy Lyons speaks for Fine Gael in so far as the part of County Mayo he represents is concerned. I do not know what that means, but it certainly does not seem to me to be an unequivocal statement that the Fine Gael Party have now changed their minds, as Deputy Lyons would appear to indicate, and that they would accept the proposals in the Third Amendment if they got the chance. He says that they would have been accepted if they were separated. But they were separated and they were not accepted.

Comment on this

Who is being equivocal now?

Comment on this

They ensured that one of the present seats in Mayo would be transferred, unjustifiably according to any democratic principles, to Dublin city.

Comment on this

Will the Minister answer the question about driving 20,000 people out of Mayo in the last ten years?

Comment on this

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle ruled that that was irrelevant. At a relevant time I will certainly be prepared to discuss it with the Deputy, but I do not want to enter into a competition in disorder with Deputy L'Estrange. I do not think I would be fit to do it.

Comment on this

The Minister can incite disorder as well as anybody in the House.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange gets up and repeats the allegation that, in introducing this Bill, we are only interested in gerrymandering. In fact, we made every effort to have the Constitution amended so that there would be a requirement on the Government, in drafting constituencies, to adhere to county boundaries which were not drafted by the Fianna Fáil Government. In fact, the Fine Gael spokesman —or at least the Deputy who appeared to be last week the official Fine Gael spokesman as far as we could make out owing to the many people who occupied the Front Bench last week— Deputy Harte, described them as having been designed by God.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Corry speak for the Fianna Fáil Party?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister's Deputies have disowned him. They would not come in to listen to him.

Comment on this

This effort to adhere to county boundaries was frustrated by the Opposition Parties and it is because of that that this type of change is inevitable.

I do not know if it is in order for me to reply to Deputy L'Estrange's allegations in regard to the town of Athlone but if Deputy L'Estrange knows anything at all about Athlone he knows that the Athlone West urban area and its hinterland in fact lie in the County Roscommon and that it is, in fact, being associated electorally with its natural hinterland and he must also know that it is west of the River Shannon.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I wish to deny the charges made by the Minister for Local Government that the Fine Gael Party have decided to delay this Bill for the sake of delay only. That is not correct. It is our duty to come in here and go through the Schedule to this Bill, constituency by constituency, and expose it for what it is, an attempt to gerrymander the country as a whole to the unfair advantage of Fianna Fáil.

Assuming that an Opposition Party wanted to delay a Bill, I cannot think of any simpler operation to achieve that than to allow the Minister for Local Government to talk, because he simply talks and talks and talks for the sake of talking. He has talked here for hours on end and in the Seanad he set up a record by talking for seven or eight hours on the referendum. God only knows, he should have learned by now that his talking does not get him anywhere. I am saying this to the Minister's face. If talking were any good he would have won the referendum by a quarter of a million votes, but notwithstanding that, despite the fact that he talked ad nauseam, setting up a record in the Seanad, the people gave an answer he did not expect. So much for the Minister and obstruction and talking. It is very doubtful if we are in order in discussing the referendum at this stage but the Minister saw fit to do so and I wish briefly to put the record straight. The Minister sought to suggest that Deputy Lyons and other Fine Gael Members misled the people.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage, though the Minister made reference to it, it is not in order to discuss the result of the referendum.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not intend to delay too long on this, but the Minister said——

Comment on this

I did not say he misled the people.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The records will show. The Minister undertook in this House during the referendum debate that he and his Party would go into every humble homestead and explain to the honest, decent people of the country what was at stake. The Minister did so but the people did not accept what the Minister said because the people did not trust the Minister, the Taoiseach and the Cabinet.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I wish to point out again that to continue along these lines would be completely out of order.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I bow to your ruling and, with respect, I agree. I shall just say that the referendum had a mighty airing. It was explained to the people fully from those Benches, from these Benches, through the Press and the other means of communication. The people have spoken and I ask the Minister to be man enough to accept the decision of the people. After the referendum he should have done what the people had directed him to do—to go back to his office to prepare a Bill and to bring into the House a measure which would operate the system of proportional representation in three-Member constituencies.

The Minister said several times today that he did what he has done in this Bill because the Constitution and the decision of Mr. Justice Budd had placed him in a straitjacket. He said the decision of Mr. Justice Budd was brought about by an action brought by the Fine Gael Party. Deputy John A. Costello has denied that emphatically. The plaintiff in that action was Mr. John O'Donovan, a former Member of the Seanad.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage the Chair is at pains to understand what relevance this has.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I have been at pains throughout the debate to understand what the Minister has been saying. I am sick listening to the Minister talking about this and I just want to put the records right. The plaintiff was Mr. John O'Donovan, a former Member of the Seanad. He had not the support of Fine Gael. Shortly afterwards he ceased to be a member of Fine Gael and is not now a member. It is correct that he retained certain members of the legal profession who were members of Fine Gael but, my God, one sees members of the Bar in the Fine Gael Party acting for very queer people, including members of the Government and institutions like the Irish Press from time to time. I wish to say, further, that the judgment of Mr. Justice Budd, on which the Minister relies for the constituencies in the Schedule to this Bill, including Mayo——

Comment on this

He must rely on it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——is not the law of the land.

Comment on this

He must rely on it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is not the final interpretation of the Constitution. That judgment was not appealed by the Fianna Fáil Government to the Supreme Court. All that judgment decided was that a 17 per cent variance between one area in the country and another is constitutional. The Government of the day did not appeal that decision to the Supreme Court. They introduced another Electoral Bill following the rejection of the first one by Mr. Justice Budd. They accepted his decision, though some members of the Fianna Fáil Party were probably guilty of contempt of court by their reference to it in the meantime.

However, they introduced another measure and that Electoral Bill was sent to the Supreme Court under the provisions of the Constitution. I wish to put it on the records of the House that the law on electoral reform and the law on the number of people in one area who qualify for a TD as compared with another area is covered by the judgment of the Supreme Court on the Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1961, delivered by the Chief Justice, Mr. Justice Conor Maguire, in which he said that the ratio between the number of TDs in one part of the country and another should be the same as far as practicable.

I refer the Minister to that judgment in which the Chief Justice went on to say that what is practicable is a matter for the Oireachtas who are much better qualified to come to a decision on the matter than the court. He went on to say that the court would intervene to set aside a decision of the Oireachtas on the amount of tolerance permissible only if the Oireachtas obviously went mad— obviously had shown a complete disregard for the Constitution. The Chief Justice said that in arriving at a decision on what is practicable, the Oireachtas are entitled to take into consideration such things as lakes, mountains, county boundaries, the remoteness of areas.

We know that Mr. Justice Budd decided that a tolerance, as the Minister for Local Government would be pleased to call it, of 17 per cent was not acceptable to him and that five per cent was held to be acceptable to the Supreme Court. We know that the Chief Justice, in delivering the judgment of the court, said that the Supreme Court would accept what is reasonable. Therefore, what is reasonable may lie at some point between five per cent and 17 per cent.

Comment on this

You could have another High Court case on that.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Yes, and would it not be a good thing?

Comment on this

For the Fine Gael lawyers.

Comment on this

There are as many lawyers in the Government——

Comment on this

They do not make as much money on this sort of thing.

Comment on this

Some of them were briefless before they became members of the Government.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The lawyers who argued this case in the Supreme Court would not have been Fine Gael lawyers because they would have been appointed by the present Government, by the Attorney General. What was wrong with introducing some sort of reasonable tolerance, having regard to boundaries, mountains, lakes and so forth, as suggested by the Chief Justice, and then bringing in a Bill that would be acceptable to the House and the people, with some sort of in between tolerance, and leaving it to the Supreme Court, as the Bill defining the constituencies in 1961 was referred to the courts? That Bill would go quickly through this House, if it were a reasonable one, and the Minister could then, under the provisions of the Constitution, refer it to the Supreme Court if he had any doubt as to the legality of an election held under such a measure. If the Minister had any fear that, in doing so, he might enrich Fine Gael lawyers he could do what he has done quite frequently in the past; he could direct the Attorney General to nominate Fianna Fáil lawyers. Irrespective of Party affiliations, lawyers would argue to the best of their ability and they would present the case fairly. I am led to believe that the Minister's sole ambition in this Bill, and this is particularly true of the west, is to chop off seats where he thinks that would be to his own advantage and to add seats where he thinks such an addition would be to his advantage. Mayo had seven seats. Four of those were Fine Gael. If there is to be any loss of seats in the west, then bang goes Mayo. Galway had eight seats. The Minister believes, apparently, that Galway is worth preserving —he may get a rude awakening—and so he has preserved Galway with eight seats. Not alone that, but he gives it nine.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. One more.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Roscommon does not measure up. It cannot be relied upon. The Galway pattern is not followed; chop goes a seat in Roscommon. It is reduced to three seats. Clare, despite the mighty men who represented it, could never be relied upon to give Fianna Fáil more than two out of four; there is one Fine Gael and one Labour. The decision is to chop it down to three. Bang goes Labour. If that does not come within the definition of gerrymandering, I do not know what does.

Comment on this

What is the discrepancy in the number of votes in each case?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am just drawing——

Comment on this

On your imagination.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am talking practical politics.

Comment on this

Fine Gael politics, which are never practical.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am pointing out to Deputy Booth how extraordinary it is that, despite the decline in population in the west, one constituency can suddenly be promoted from eight to nine seats.

Comment on this

There is no nineseat constituency.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There are three threes and three threes make nine.

Comment on this

It is not one constituency.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The cheeseparing shows the shallowness of the mentality behind this. Prior to this Bill there were eight seats in Galway. We are told the population in the west is declining. Despite that, the county will have nine seats under this Bill.

Comment on this

It will not.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It has got an injection. I really think the Minister does not like this. He does not like me to point out that the antiGovernment constituency of Roscommon has been reduced from four to three seats and that Clare has likewise been reduced from four to three seats, obviously in order to get rid of Labour.

Comment on this

And Leitrim is wiped off the map.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick ought to take over Monaghan.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We will be in Monaghan and I will repeat publicly in Monaghan, and at some length, anything I have ever said about Monaghan. We are talking about people from Kells being driven into Cavan, a place they never visit except for a football match, maybe.

Comment on this

It is not right to take over part of a county, but it is right to take over the whole county.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It might be no harm for me to remind Deputy Cunningham what exactly I mean by gerrymandering. According to the Imperial Dictionary of the English Language, New Edition, Volume 2, the word “gerrymander” comes from the Governor of Massachusetts, named Gerry and it means to arrange the political divisions of a state so that in an election one party may obtain an advantage over its opponents.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We seem to be departing from the Schedule to the Bill before the House.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I will bow to your ruling but, remembering what Deputy Lyons and others have said, it is quite clear the Minister is gerrymandering in Mayo. He set out to gerrymander. The purpose of gerrymandering is, as I have pointed out, to arrange the political divisions of a state so that in an election one party may obtain an advantage over its opponents even though the latter may possess a majority of votes in the state. It is clear beyond doubt, then, what is happening here.

Comment on this

Not the slightest bit because the gerrymandering to which the Deputy refers is an arrangement whereby a certain number of votes are adjusted to correspond with a greater number of votes in another area.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And what does the Deputy think is the object of reducing a Fine Gael constituency from seven to six, building up a neighbouring allegedly Fianna Fáil constituency from eight to nine, reducing a hostile area——

Comment on this

There is provision for that in the Constitution. This is constitutional.

Comment on this

It is changing the name. One cannot change the population.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Booth poses as a fairminded man and as an educated person and, in his heart, he is heartily ashamed of this.

Comment on this

Not the slightest bit, but I can add and subtract and get the right answers.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Booth can also blind himself to what is going on. He can convince himself that anything a Fianna Fáil Minister does, even if it is repugnant to the Deputy's own nature, is all right.

Comment on this

It is not repugnant to the Constitution.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I have known Deputy Booth to defend the most extraordinary performances, something that must have been repugnant to him.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Booth is not under discussion in this. We are not discussing Deputy Booth's reputation.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He asked for it.

Comment on this

Perhaps we can pursue this at a later date.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If somebody wrote a thesis on Deputy Booth it would be very interesting. As I have said before, I do not know why the Minister, who is committed to this sort of dishonesty which he is now attempting to perpetrate on the country, did not rid himself of that and seek the advice of an independent body, and call it a constitutional commission. If he says that is not possible, why not have an informal commission? Deputy Booth could represent the Fianna Fáil side on it and I am sure he would argue on their behalf what was fair; we would have three and three and an independent chairman and we would at least have an impartial recommendation to the Minister. I wonder if Deputy Booth would see anything wrong with that.

Comment on this

That would not suit Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage we cannot have a discussion on a commission, or any kind of commission, because such is not contained in the Electoral Bill before us or in the Schedule thereto.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I bow to the Chair's ruling. What I am trying to say is that if we had an informal advisory body, such as I suggest, it would not be possible for Deputy Lyons to come in here and say that there was a constituency cut up to look like a kangaroo without a pouch in order to injure him and help separate the Minister for Justice and the Minister for Health. You would not have the Minister for Health in the position of being able to come in here and say another thing. We would not be able to attribute malpractices or mal-intentions if the Minister for Local Government were an honest man.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that the Minister is dishonest?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am posing the question. God knows, anything the Minister has not said about me is not worth saying. If he had honest intentions or if he had wanted to appear fully honest, he would have handed this over to an impartial advisory body to advise him.

Comment on this

I do not agree with the last speaker at all. What the Minister is doing is constitutional. There is provision in the Constitution for three-, four- or five-seat constituencies. Gerrymandering is something quite different. Gerrymandering does not create the situation which Deputy Fitzpatrick is talking about. It creates the type of situation which exists in Derry City where the greater number of people can elect only eight candidates and the lesser number of people can elect 11. Gerrymandering is where the votes of a minority can elect the majority of the members of the corporation, as is the case in Derry. Here, no matter what boundaries are fixed, no matter whether the constituencies are three-, four- or five-seat, the number of people to be represented by a Deputy is almost, or as nearly as possible, exactly the same in each constituency. So that this question of gerrymandering is a red herring. It was this same red herring which was used during the referendum, in the context of what was happening in Derry City. This is what made people afraid of the proposal in the referendum, and this red herring is being used again here quite dishonestly.

Comment on this

First of all, I should welcome back Deputy Fitzpatrick. I hope he has recovered from whatever kept him away from the House last week.

Comment on this

He was here at six o'clock last week.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I was engaged in constituency business.

Comment on this

At least his presence has had the effect of making Deputy L'Estrange more relaxed. He has more confidence in the ability of Deputy Fitzpatrick to delay the Bill than he had in the six or seven people he dragooned to come in for that purpose last week.

Comment on this

There was no need to dragoon them.

Comment on this

I did notice Deputy L'Estrange's failure a short while ago to attract another recruit into the Chamber but Deputy Fitzpatrick's return has had that effect on Deputy L'Estrange.

Comment on this

The Minister is wrong, as usual.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick did go away to collect his equipment.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick was at another meeting in Room 106.

Comment on this

He did not come when he was called. He had to go away to get the tools of his trade. With regard to the question of gerrymandering even if interpreted in the way Deputy Fitzpatrick wants to interpret it, gerrymandering in that context, which would not comply with the definition which Deputy Fitzpatrick read out, surely implies the selecting of areas to go into different constituencies. We on this side of the House have made every effort to get a position in which the Constitution would require the exact opposite, in which there would be a stipulation in the Constitution requiring the Government to adhere, as far as possible, to existing county boundaries. These boundaries were established, not by Fianna Fáil but, we are told on the authority of no less a person than Senator Professor Dooge, by the illustrious King John, between 700 or 800 years ago. This was a position which we tried to get into, whereby there would be a requirement written into the Constitution to adhere to the county boundaries as far as possible, and even to operate a maximum divergence of one-sixth in order to do that.

I cannot understand Deputy Fitzpatrick when he accuses the Government—now that we are complying with the requirements of the Constitution — of refusing to accept the decision of the people. This is exactly what the people decided and it was not I who complained about the position. Deputy Lyons complaining that this seat was being lost to County Mayo although he was one of those who ensured that this would have to be done. Deputy Fitzpatrick went on to argue—even now that the issue in the referendum has been decided—that the Budd decision on this matter is not, in fact, the law of the land.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I argued that during the debate here.

Comment on this

The Deputy spent some time trying to get away from the fact that it was as a result of a Fine Gael manoeuvre in the courts that this decision was extracted from the courts. He tried to get away from the fact that it was a Fine Gael Senator who brought the action; a Fine Gael Deputy who was his solicitor; a Fine Gael Deputy who was his Senior Counsel and a Fine Gael Senator who was his Junior Counsel. If Deputy Fitzpatrick thinks he can get away with trying to pretend that this was not an official Fine Gael manoeuvre let him try, but nothing could be more obvious.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You could say that it was a Fine Gael judgment.

Comment on this

It is true that the Government did not appeal the Budd decision. They accepted it. For one thing, I do not think there was time. The Constitution required that the constituencies be revised and it was coming up towards the time for statutory holding of the next general election. There was barely time to make a new revision of the constituencies——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And send it to the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

——and have it decided by the Supreme Court. There certainly was not time to go through all the process of appealing the decision Fine Gael extracted from the High Court, with the possibility that the appeal might not be successful, and then having to go through the whole operation even after that.

Comment on this

Why was it not appealed later?

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick contended that the only thing decided by Mr. Justice Budd was that a deviation from the national average of population per Deputy of 17 per cent was too high. In fact, Deputy Fitzpatrick is well aware—and argued it here in the House—that Mr. Justice Budd gave an indication that the maximum divergence permissible in his opinion was of the order of 5 per cent. The 1961 Bill was brought in on that basis, and the only clear-cut decision the Supreme Court gave was that that Bill, the Electoral Bill of 1961, complied with the requirements of the Constitution. They did say that the Constitution specified that the ratio of population per Deputy should so far as practicable be the same throughout the country, and that this was a matter for the Oireachtas to decide—Deputy Fitzpatrick left out the words—"in the first instance". The Supreme Court went on to say that the courts were fully entitled to adjudicate on the matter.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I said that.

Comment on this

What Deputy Fitzpatrick is advocating now in February, 1969, is different from what he advocated when we were discussing the matter in May and June, 1968. What he is arguing now is that instead of accepting the only firm indication we have of what deviation from the national average would be acceptable, we should bring in electoral Bills on the basis of trial and error, that we should start off with 17 per cent since he says that is the only thing we know is out—we do not even know that; it was not appealed to the High Court—or that we should start off with whatever deviation we saw fit, and refer it to the Supreme Court or, better still, I suppose, bring in a Bill and go through the same process as before of letting Fine Gael bring it to the courts as they did before, and if it is thrown out come back and try again —have a continuous process of trial and error.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Why not make a genuine effort?

Comment on this

Mr. Justice Budd indicated that there should be a maximum deviation of five per cent. If five per cent was not established by the courts, surely it was established by the decision of the people in October of last year. The whole debate on the proposal to amend the Constitution was conducted on the basis that this was the maximum amount of deviation permissible. It was conducted on the basis of for or against the amount indicated by Mr. Justice Budd. The people decided as definitely as they possibly could that that was the maximum amount we were entitled to operate. That was the only guideline available since the High Court action of 1961, and it has now been endorsed by the people. So, I think it is quite clear that it is the maximum we could operate.

After arguing against any tolerance whatever—as they call it—being permissible, Deputy Fitzpatrick now comes here and says we could have 17 per cent if we liked. Deputy Lyons tried to say the same thing after getting the people to refuse to allow a maximum deviation of one-sixth from the national average in order to take account of what we considered to be practical considerations but which the people have decided are not.

The most amazing allegation which Deputy Fitzpatrick made and which convinces me that his sole purpose is, as I have said, to delay the passage of the Bill, was the allegation that we are deliberately chopping off seats from the west and transferring them to Dublin although that is not necessary. Deputy Fitzpatrick knows that is not true. The Fine Gael argument in the referendum was that we wanted to retain seats in the west because it was to the advantage of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I said that the Minister was switching them within the west.

Comment on this

He now says we want to take them from the west and transfer them to Dublin for our own advantage.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I said no such thing.

Comment on this

The peculiar thing is that Deputy Fitzpatrick purports to speak for the Fine Gael Party, and only last week the Belton cousins were arguing that we had not taken enough seats from the west and should have taken another and given it to Dublin.

Comment on this

They never mentioned it.

Comment on this

It is on the record. They said last Thursday that another seat should be allocated to Dublin. The maximum number of seats in accordance with the Constitution is 144 so if you allocate another seat to Dublin you take it from somewhere else and the only place it could be taken from is the west. In fact, it was advocated specifically that we should take it from Donegal.

Deputy Fitzpatrick raised the question of a commission, and I understand it is out of order. I agree that it is out of order because a commission cannot be established without a constitutional referendum. The Constitution requires the Oireachtas to revise the constituencies and, even with an informal committee to advise, no one knows better than Deputy Fitzpatrick that if we had more than one Fine Gael representative on such a committee we could not get any advice from it, because Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy L'Estrange have failed to get any two Fine Gael Deputies, so far, to agree on a recommendation on any one of the sections of the Schedule.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I rise to say I think it is a pity that a responsible Minister of the Government should behave in such a way in this House as to cast a reflection on the superior courts of the country. Several times during this debate the Minister has seen fit to refer to the judgment of the High Court, delivered by Mr. Justice Budd after a long and attentive hearing, as the decision extracted from the High Court by Fine Gael. I want to go on record as saying that I consider that to be a reflection on the High Court. That reference has been trotted out here time and time again since the debate on the Electoral Bill began. I, for one, want to go on record as dissociating myself completely from it. It shows a very irresponsible attitude on the part of a Minister of State so to refer to a judgment given by a judge of the High Court.

Comment on this

Could we get back to Mayo or would that be too far for the Deputy?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Rush into the defence. Create a smokescreen.

Comment on this

I want to try to blow the smokescreen away.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Cunningham said there could not be any gerrymandering in this Bill and there was not any gerrymandering, but the Taoiseach believes that under these circumstances you could have gerrymandering because in his referendum document, “The Reasons Why”, he advocated ways and means of arranging the constituencies by an independent commission presided over by a judge, and here are the important words, “so that gerrymandering will be impossible”. Those are the words of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I was wondering about Mayo.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We have dealt with Mayo.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy sit down then or are we on something else?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am replying to some uncalled for remarks made by the Minister in his effort to escape from Mayo and to refrain from answering the charges levelled against him by Deputy Lyons from Mayo.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is there any relevance in the intervention by Deputy Fitzpatrick to the entry in the Schedule for Mayo which is before the House?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I must say, Sir, that the entry in the Schedule if the Deputy wishes to have it again——

Comment on this

I do not wish the Deputy to repeat himself.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy should behave himself. If he rises on a point of order, I am quite prepared to be guided by the ruling on that point of order but I am not prepared to accept suggestions or directions from Deputy Booth across the floor of the House.

The case has been made by Deputy Lyons that the carving up of the constituencies of East Mayo and West Mayo is unfair and has been made for unfair purposes, that is, to separate two Ministers and to injure Deputy Lyons. I wish to go on record as saying that one could expect nothing less than a job like this because the Minister for Local Government set out to do that. He set out to make PR look absurd. He threatened to do it during the debate on the referendum and the Taoiseach backed him up. That is the reason why we have a situation in Mayo which is in keeping with the position in the remainder of the west of Ireland.

I apparently, embarrassed Deputy Booth, through you, Sir, when I rose in a Committee discussion on this matter to deal with two points. One was the ignorant reference made by the Minister to a Judge of the High Court and the second was a reference by Deputy Cunningham to gerrymandering. I rose to deal with those two points raised by those two Deputies who had spoken since I spoke. I wish to say that I was perfectly within order in doing that and no amount of oily interjection by Deputy Booth would put me off what I got up to do and I consider that I have done it.

Comment on this

I wish to say that no matter how Deputy Cunningham or the Minister for Local Government may try to wriggle out of this, this is gerrymandering and Bolandmandering at its worst. We know that the present Minister for Local Government is steeped in politics and political intrigue and this is only what we would expect from the Minister after his speeches prior to the referendum. Deputy Cunningham stated that what the Minister is doing is quite constitutional. The Minister may be keeping within the Constitution but Deputy Tom Fitzpatrick made an excellent argument here pointing out that this was gerrymandering and gerrymandering at its worst.

He pointed out that Galway, in which in the past, there were two constituencies, a three-seater and a fiveseater, making eight seats, was supposed to be a Fianna Fáil county. We now have a situation where, instead of a Deputy being taken from the Fianna Fáil area, other areas have been brought in from adjoining counties and borders and county borders ruthlessly butchered so as to add a seat to this constituency which, in the past, was a Fianna Fáil stronghold. It is now being divided into three three-seater constituencies and Fianna Fáil are hoping by the grace of God to be able to get two out of the three seats in each constituency. This will misfire just as the referendum misfired.

Is it a coincidence that Mayo, which could be gained only by the nose by the Fianna Fáil Party in the past, where there were seven seats of which four were held by Fine Gael Deputies, is losing a seat and is being reduced to two three-seat constituencies? Is it also a coincidence that Roscommon, which never toed the Party line and in which, indeed, at one time out of four seats, there was only one Fianna Fáil Deputy, is to lose a seat? Is it not also a coincidence that lovely Leitrim which never at any time in the past toed the Party line, is to be wiped off the political map? The people of Leitrim are a proud people and they have never been misled by Fianna Fáil. In fact, they saw through Fianna Fáil before many other people did. Now they are to be wiped off the political map. Their name was not even mentioned in this Bill until a deputation of Leitrim county councillors came up to this House and the best thing that the Minister could then do in order to give them representation was to make constituencies with names like Roscommon-Leitrim, Sligo-Leitrim and West Donegal-Leitrim.

The Minister for Local Government said, "This is what the people decided in the referendum". The people decided no such thing. They decided to keep proportional representation.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair does not want a discussion on the referendum again.

Comment on this

I do not intend having a discussion on the referendum but I wish to say that in East Mayo and in the three Galway constituencies the Minister is flying in the faces of the people and their decision in the referendum, which was, to retain PR. Anybody who knows anything about PR knows that the system works best in large constituencies, in four-, five-, six,- or even seven-seat constituencies. It is very unfair of the Minister to throw the blame on the people.

I should like to agree with Deputy Fitzpatrick regarding our courts. During the past year, attacks have been made by the Minister for Local Government on the courts of this country. It behoves the Minister or any other Minister at the present time, when we may be at a critical juncture in the history of our country, to stand by the judges and by the laws of the country. It is very wrong for the Minister for Local Government to talk about a Fine Gael manoeuvre in the courts. A judgment was given by a High Court judge and if the Minister has not respect for the judgment——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage we cannot go on to discuss judgments of the High Court. A reference to the judgment has been made but we cannot discuss the judgment of the court now.

Comment on this

We are at least entitled, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle to reply to the statements made by the Minister. He stated that at that particular time they had not got time to appeal against the decision of the High Court judge but surely it is only fair to ask the Minister, as Fianna Fáil have been in power since then, what was to stop him from going to the courts during the last ten years and getting a decision from the courts if, as he claims, the decision at that time was a Fine Gael manoeuvre?

I do not think the Minister should make these statements here. It is also wrong that he should accuse Deputy Fitzpatrick of not speaking for the Fine Gael Party and say we are a divided Party. We all know who is divided in this country at the present time, and we all know that the Taoiseach, the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries are not united——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair cannot permit this kind of discussion.

Comment on this

The less the Minister has to say about unity the better. We are united on this side of the House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would the Deputy come to the Schedule of the Bill before the House.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government said that if Fianna Fáil did not come back to the principle of abolishing the Border——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This has nothing to do with the Schedule to the Bill.

Comment on this

But it has something to do with the unity of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

I had no intention of intervening again at this stage, but I would criticise the manner in which the Minister tries to shoot down backbenchers on this side of the House. He attributes ignorance to somebody in an effort to shake him and not allow him to make his point as well as he could. It is not the proper attitude for a Minister or for anyone else in the House. The Rules of Order can best be kept by Deputies speaking in a gentlemanly manner and answering points and reasonable amendments.

The Minister implied that I was ignorant of the state of affairs in the county of Mayo. I was born and reared in Mayo and I have lived there more years than I would like to say. I am well aware of the situation in the country, as to whether the dividing line runs this way or that way. Mayo is roughly, very roughly, a square, but there are many ways in which the dividing line could be drawn in order to give the representation necessary according to the decision given by Mr. Justice Budd. There are many ways in which it could be drawn to give a fair assessment of the political situation in a ballot box, but the Minister, designedly, draws a vertical rather than a horizontal line in order to separate two Ministers in the constituency, and they can talk about it until Doomsday and that fact will not be altered.

The Minister said I was ignorant of certain facts when I said that an amendment to give a tolerance to the west would be voted on and would be won on a ballot. He says: "Your Party and yourself went out to oppose the tolerance in the Third Amendment Bill." We did, certainly, because the Minister had tied another amendment with it, and the people spoke on that. But had the Minister held a referendum on a tolerance amendment without having it tied to anything else——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am sure the Deputy will appreciate that is not relevant.

Comment on this

I shall speak only one second on this. I would ask you to allow me to reply, because the Minister implied this in his reply to me; otherwise I would not be contravening the Rules of Order. Had there been a referendum to the people purely on the tolerance issue without an effort to change the electoral system, I have no doubt the people would have passed that.

The Minister refused to accept the amendments that Deputy Hogan, after long study and careful preparation, put before this House. Deputy Hogan deserves credit, and I am sure he is esteemed by many people throughout the country for the work he put into it. He proved beyond yea or nay that there was another way of doing it, a far better way than the Minister's. I shall not go to the lengths Deputy Fitzpatrick went on gerrymandering to estimate whether Deputy Hogan's proposals would be gerrymandering, but there is no doubt in my own mind that the proposals of the Minister with regard to East Mayo were gerrymandering in the strongest sense.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied that the Official Reports both of the debate on this Bill and of the debate on the Amendment to the Constitution Bills last year will show that no statement of mine could reasonably be interpreted as casting any reflection on the courts. I said that the decision of the High Court in regard to the interpretation of this phrase in the Constitution was extracted by Fine Gael and that the matter was brought to the Court by Fine Gael. Mr. Justice Budd did not come of his own accord to give his decision in regard to the manner in which a particular phrase of the Constitution should be interpreted. He did it at the behest of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

Was he not right in law?

Comment on this

It was a Fine Gael manoeuvre.

Comment on this

It was not.

Comment on this

That is a quite accurate description of what happened.

Comment on this

It was taken by an individual.

Comment on this

It is no reflection whatever; it expressed no opinion whatever as to whether or not the decision was right, and I have never at any time cast any doubts on the correctness or otherwise of the judgment delivered by Mr. Justice Budd.

Comment on this

If not, what has the Minister been complaining about during the last year?

Comment on this

I have merely said that, after agreeing to the proposals in the Electoral Bill of 1959 brought into this House, Fine Gael then brought this matter before the courts and obtained a reversal of that decision.

Comment on this

Are the courts not there to protect the people?

Comment on this

In other words, a correct description of what happened was the extraction by Fine Gael of this legalistic interpretation of the Constitution from the courts. The question was not at issue until it was brought before the courts by the Fine Gael Party. On the question of gerrymandering which the Opposition continue to repeat here, it is quite true we said that if gerrymandering is possible, if political Parties know how the people in individual areas, small areas, voted in the past and how they will vote in the future, if that type of information is available, then a situation which requires a continuing chopping and changing of constituencies, which requires the Government to revise constituencies, to take areas out of one county and put them into another, is the type of situation that makes gerrymandering more feasible than the situation we were trying to have established, where there would be a provision written into the Constitution requiring the Government to adhere as closely as possible to existing county boundaries in revising constituencies. That is the position we tried to establish. The Opposition Parties took the opposite view and they succeeded in getting the people to take the same view; and because of the decision that was taken in October last year this Bill has to be brought in and this type of operation must be carried out.

It is incorrect for Deputy Lyons or Deputy Fitzpatrick or Deputy L'Estrange to say that it is not necessary to reduce the representation of County Mayo from seven seats to six seats. This does not result from any desire on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party to take seats from the west of Ireland and transfer them to Dublin. It resulted from the population figures for Mayo in the Census Report of 1966. The population was 115,547 and if, as Fine Gael say should be done, Mayo should retain its present representation of seven seats that would give a population of 16,507 per Deputy but the minimum allowable per Deputy is 19,027. On the basis of six seats in County Mayo the population per Deputy is 19,268. Deputy L'Estrange knows he is quite wrong in saying that all that the people decided in the referendum in October last was to retain the system of election by proportional representation. They also decided, in a completely separate decision, to perpetuate the decision of the High Court in regard to the interpretation of the Constitution, which was obtained from the court by the Fine Gael Party. The decision was that there must be strict equality of population per Deputy irrespective of such considerations as we believed to be practical considerations, such as the existence of county boundaries. Deputy Lyons says if there had been a proposal to get rid of this requirement to ignore the existence of county boundaries in order to have strict equality as between one constituency and another per Deputy and if that had been put to the people as a separate issue they would have supported and accepted it. There was a separate proposal put before the people and the people decided, at the behest of the Opposition Parties, for the type of change which we are proposing to have made. I have admitted on a number of occasions that there is, practically, an infinite number of ways in which this operation could be carried out. Deputy Hogan and Deputy Fitzgerald have put forward some not quite complete alternatives that differ from one another and from the proposal we have before the House at the present time. There are many other alternatives. Deputies have suggested different arrangements for different areas of the country. There is not any limit to the number of possible alternatives. We believe our proposals are the fairest and, taking everything into account, that they make the least disturbance of the existing constituency arrangements in the country.

Comment on this

I must take up the Minister on his last words. There are many alternatives, we all agree. The Minister says his proposals are the fairest. I want to say that it is the unfairest system of all that could be devised. The Minister says it makes the least possible disturbance. Does he understand the meaning of the words in the English language? We do not need the Oxford Dictionary on this occasion. The Minister's proposals envisage chopping and changing 13 county boundaries, involving the displacement of 120,000 people. Other proposals have been made by Deputy Hogan and his proposals require only the changing of something like six constituencies and the displacement of only 20,000 people. Deputy Garret FitzGerald has submitted other proposals.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no such Deputy in the Dáil.

Comment on this

Senator Garret FitzGerald. He will be here before long. Coming events cast their shadows.

Comment on this

Did he get a constituency?

Comment on this

If the Minister had his way, no Fine Gael man would get a constituency. We will be the next Government, despite this Bill. The Minister is as far out as he was before the referendum when he was forecasting victory by a large majority.

Comment on this

Did we not win the three by-elections?

Comment on this

Senator Garret FitzGerald has submitted a scheme which envisages only nine changes of boundaries and the displacement of about 50,000 to 60,000 people. How can the Minister for Local Government have the effrontery and the arrogance to come in here and tell us that, while there are many alternatives, his is the fairest and will make the least disturbance of people? Have words lost their meaning? Who does the Minister think he is trying to fool in this country? The Irish people have found him out. That has been proved in the referendum and will be proved again at the next general election when he has to face the people.

The Minister for Local Government stated that Fine Gael stated that there should be seven seats in Mayo. I gave the population of Mayo at the present time as 115,547. The Minister stated that we were looking for something that could not happen and that it would require another 19,000 or 20,000 of population. The Minister forgot to get the number of people that were there ten years ago. There were 113,152 people in Mayo ten years ago. Since then, the dead hand of the Government has driven 17,505 out of Mayo. Five years earlier the population of Mayo was almost 140,000. There could still be seven Deputies representing the people of County Mayo if it were not for the maladministration and bad government which have driven the people out of Mayo and out of the west of Ireland despite the promises made to the people in the past.

The Minister also stated that the people, at the behest of the Opposition Parties, defeated the Government's proposal. In a free democracy, the people have the right to vote on any Government proposal. So far as we on this side of the House are concerned we are proud to say that we were in the vanguard in defeating the Government's proposal and we would be proud at any time in the future to stand up for the rights and freedom of the Irish people and to prevent them being walked upon by an arrogant, dictatorial Government or an arrogant dictator.

Comment on this

The question of what actually constitutes a disturbance of population electorally is one that can be argued. What I said was that taking into account all the practical considerations of convenient areas, of representation et cetera I believed the proposals I put forward were the fairest ones and the ones that involved the least disturbance of the existing constituency arrangement. Whether when some of the population have to be transferred from one constituency to another that should be minimised or not is a question that has been raised before. The Opposition, after arguing earlier that these things were of no importance whatsoever, now apparently argue that where such a transfer has to take place the objective should be to transfer the absolute minimum number of people. There is the other point of view, that if that is done the transferred community will form an insignificant part of the constituency into which they are transferred whereas, on the other hand, if a substantial number are incorporated in the new constituency they will form a significant proportion of the electorate and will therefore command the attention of all candidates in the constituency. That, of course, is a matter of opinion.

There is also the question as to whether it would, in fact, be complying with the Constitution merely to aim at reaching the minimum population per Deputy that is permissible in individual constituencies which require a transfer of population in order to make them up to the number required for a certain number of Deputies. The requirement in the Constitution is in fact, to aim at equality of population per Deputy. The Fine Gael argument now appears to be that it would be permissible, in making an adjustment as between two counties, to aim at having the minimum population per Deputy in one even if that resulted in having the maximum population per Deputy in the adjoining one.

I thoroughly agree that the people have the right to decide on these matters and that is just what the people have done. The people have decided that it is not permissible to take account of the existence of county boundaries except to the extent of the five per cent which is assumed to be permissible under the Budd judgment and just as the people had the right to do this the Government are right, and are, in fact, required, to accept this decision when it is made. It is because that decision has been made that this Bill has to come before the House and that it has to do these many objectionable things in many different parts of the country.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister has stated that he is doing just what the people under our guidance, under our propaganda, under our advice, decided. I submit that he is not exactly doing that. The people voted for two things—to perpetuate PR under one amendment and in the other amendment I think they were largely guided by the fact that they wanted to abolish any danger of gross gerrymander.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot have a further discussion on this point which has been debated and resolved by the Dáil. We are discussing the constituencies of Mayo.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): In this constituency the Minister is not doing what the people wanted. He is only doing half of what the people wanted. PR is being retained but the principle of gerrymandering, in so far as the Budd judgment will allow, is being followed by the Minister. He is gerrymandering up to the limit allowed.

I would put a simple question to the Minister: conceding his point that Mayo, which we are now discussing, would not be entitled to seven seats, particularly when the question of Ballaghaderreen had to be considered— and I readily concede that point to him—Mayo up to now had a constituency of North Mayo and a constituency of South Mayo and the boundary line was from east to west. I would ask him why is that boundary line altered now to from north to south. What is a complete reversal of the arrangement of the two constituencies in Mayo being determined on?

I have not been here for the full debate on the question of Mayo but as far as I know the Minister has given no reason why the initial method of dividing Mayo into north and south has been departed from. He has given an adequate reason as to why the number of seats was reduced from seven to six but why was it necessary to carry that further and alter the arrangement so that instead of there being a North Mayo and a South Mayo constituency there will be an East Mayo and a West Mayo constituency? It has been argued from this side of the House that the reason is to separate two Ministers so that they would not be fighting against each other and drawing from the same votes. Is there any other geographical reason or any special reason why this departure was decided on by the Minister? Perhaps he would like to answer that question?

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan alleges that this is gerrymandering in so far as the Budd decision allowed it to be done. The result of the proposal that I am putting before the House is that the total population in East Mayo will be 57,997, giving a population per Deputy of 19,332, while the total population of West Mayo will be 57,550, giving a total population per Deputy of 19,183. I think those two figures of 19,332 and 19,183 would be described by any reasonable person as being as nearly equal as is practicable in the circumstances. How Deputy Hogan can allege that this constitutes gerrymandering to the maximum possible extent I just do not know.

I have, of course, already explained why it was that the present distribution of population in Mayo seemed to me, at any rate, to require an alteration of the boundary somewhat similar to what is, in fact, proposed. The fact that Deputy Hogan was not in the House when this was explained does not require me to repeat the explanation every time a new Fine Gael Deputy comes into the House. They come and go here every half hour and we could go on for ever if we had to repeat the arguments over and again for each Deputy according as he came into the House. I can only suggest to Deputy Hogan that he should read in the Official Report the reason why it appeared to me that this was the only practical way to do what he failed to do despite all his industry in drawing up alternative schemes of constituencies, that is, to divide Mayo into two three-seat constituencies. Deputy Hogan did not attempt that task and I invite him to do so.

Comment on this

During the discussion on the entry relating to the proposed constituency of Kildare, I indicated that I was prepared to accept amendments Nos. 22, 24 and 25 in the name of Deputy Sweetman. These amendments propose to transfer parts of Cloncurry and Donadea District Electoral Divisions and all of Lullymore District Electoral Division from the proposed Meath constituency to Kildare constituency. An anomaly arises in relation to amendment No. 24. If the amendment were pased as it stands, the townland of Kilnamoragh North would remain part of the proposed Meath constituency but would be isolated from the rest of that constituency. If the Deputy were prepared to include the townland of Kilnamoragh North, which has a population of nine, with the other townlands mentioned in amendment No. 24 and which he proposed should be transferred from the proposed constituency of Meath to Kildare, I could accept the amendment as so amended, in addition to amendments Nos. 22 and 25.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We must come to the amendment before we seek to amend it.

Comment on this

These amendments have been agreed to and now they need only to be moved formally.

Comment on this

There is the question of the anomaly in relation to amendment No. 24.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I move amendment No. 22:

In page 12, in the second column of the entry relating to Meath, after "Cloncurry" to insert "(excluding the townlands of Ballycannon, Ballycahan, Killickaweeny and Pitchfordstown)".

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I move amendment No. 24:

In page 12, in the second column of the entry relating to Meath, after "Donadea" to insert "(other than the townlands of Kilnamoragh South, Kilmurry, Donadea, Donadea Demesne and Dumurraghill)".

Comment on this

I am proposing that the townlands of Kilnamoragh North be added.

Comment on this

May the Minister do that now or should he do it on the next Stage?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He may move an amendment to the amendment at this Stage and point out where the amendment occurs.

Comment on this

I propose:

Before the words "Kilnamoragh South" to insert "Kilnamoragh North".

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I move amendment No. 25.

In page 12, in the second column of the entry relating to Meath, to delete "Lullymore".

Comment on this

Amendment No. 25A; which I shall be moving at a later stage, reads:

In page 12, in the second column of the entry relating to Monaghan, to delete:—"Castletown, Rathkenny, in the former Rural District of Navan”.

This relates to two electoral divisions in the electoral area of Navan. It is proposed to put portion of the electoral area of Kells into Cavan and portion into Monaghan together with part of the Slane area. They are the only two areas to be disturbed in the Navan district. The people there live fairly centrally in County Meath. Some of them live as near as four miles to Navan and some of them live eight miles from Navan. It is their town, it is the centre where they meet their representatives as a rule. The Minister for Defence lives there as well as Deputy James Tully and I. It is the shopping centre for these people. They meet us there and tell us if they have difficulties or grievances with Departments of State and they ask us to deal with them for them. These people should not be deprived of the service of their public representatives who live so close to them.

The people I am speaking about are far removed from Monaghan. As we all know, the representatives in Monaghan live far to the north of the county and are 40 miles removed from the people concerned. It would be very strange if a neighbour of the Minister for Defence met him in the streets of Navan and asked him to help in some grievance with the Department of Agriculture or the Department of Local Government or any other Department and that the Minister for Defence should say: "You should bring that matter to the notice of the Deputy for your constituency, who is the Deputy for Monaghan." These people will be very pleased and thankful to the Minister for Local Government if they are left in the constituency in which they have been residing.

The Minister has agreed to slight adjustments on the other side of the constituency of Meath with regard to that portion of Kildare which was being brought in. The number of people moved back into Kildare is very small. The number of people I am asking the Minister to leave in Meath is also very small. It would not interfere very much with the national average of either the constituency of Monaghan or the constituency of Meath. It is only fair that I, as a public representative, should table this amendment and ask the Minister to agree to leaving these people in the heart of County Meath where they feel they belong.

Comment on this

Is the Minister accepting the amendment?

Comment on this

I should like, first of all, just to say what is involved. The population it is proposed to move from the proposed constituency of Monaghan to the proposed constituency of Meath is 1,295. The present population of the proposed constituency of Meath, as reduced by Deputy Sweetman's amendment, is 60,282; that is 20,094 per Deputy. It has been reduced from that to 59,883, which is 19,661 per Deputy. This will increase it again to 61,187, which is 20,393 per Deputy. That will make it more comparable with the populations of Kildare and Louth, which are 61,762 and 61,926 respectively, but it will have the opposite effect in so far as Monaghan is concerned. The population there will be reduced from 59,761—19,917 per Deputy—to 58,456, which is 19,485 per Deputy. The only argument that applies is the argument applicable in the case of Kildare and Meath. The overall result will be to increase the disparity of population per Deputy as between these five counties. The result of the change will be that in Monaghan you will have 19,485 per Deputy, in Cavan 19,893, both of which are below the national average, in Meath you will have 20,393, Louth 20,642 and Kildare 20,587, all of which are above the national average of population per Deputy. That will be the result. If, however, Deputies think it is acceptable to have some constituencies lower than the national average and others higher than the national average, I have no reason to object. I would be prepared to accept these amendments.

Comment on this

If we had our way we would naturally try to keep the whole of Meath together. As I said on a previous section dealing with Cavan, there has been unnecessary butchering in the Meath constituency. Not alone did the Minister cut a piece off, but he cut pieces off and added pieces from one end of the county to the other. The Minister must realise there is great resentment in Meath because of his action. Deputy Farrelly said the people would be pleased if the Minister did what he suggests. I do not think anything the Minister does now will please them. As public representatives, naturally we would be pleased to see that portion of Meath at least put back into Meath constituency. With regard to disparity, we have no objection to Monaghan having a smaller number per Deputy than the national average. The Minister may not understand this, but Monaghan is a very scattered area compared with the compactness of Meath. In Meath we have good, level roads. The roads in Monaghan are not so good. A great many of the people there live off the road and, if they have a small advantage from the point of view of the number per Deputy, we would certainly not be opposed to that. It is of interest to note that some of the other counties have quite a substantial advantage.

Comment on this

There are seven of them below.

Comment on this

I can see no reason why the Minister should not allow this. Deputy Farrelly's argument was very sound. The two electoral divisions concerned are in Navan area. It is bad enough trying to explain to people when a whole electoral area is moved, but when you take a particular area, such as Navan, and move it on its own it makes the whole thing that much more difficult. I, as representative of Slane area, will still be servicing portion of Monaghan. Deputy Farrelly, as a representative for Kells area, will have his council area in Monaghan, in Cavan and in Meath. The Minister will agree that it is ridiculous to create that kind of situation. If, in addition to that, councillors from Navan area have portion of their area in Monaghan, it makes the thing even more ridiculous still. I suppose we must be thankful for small mercies. This is a very small mercy. I ask the Minister to accept the proposal. I believe there will be no complaint from the people in the area. Many of us, including the Minister for Defence, would like to see the whole area back again in Meath. The Minister for Local Government says that cannot be done. His voting majority here will sustain him in his opinion, but I would ask the Minister to accept this.

Comment on this

As I indicated, I am prepared to accept this, but I am not prepared to accept the allegations made by Deputy Tully that there is any unnecessary butchering. I would be very surprised if there was not some resentment on the part of the people in regard to what has to be done. It was because we believed people would resent this type of thing that we tried to avoid having to do it. We asked the people to give us permission to avoid doing this kind of thing by amending the Constitution. Deputy Tully now says he would like to keep County Meath as a unit. He knows this is not permissible. He knows that both he and his colleagues in Fine Gael campaigned here and throughout the county to ensure it would not be possible to keep County Meath as an entity, except by the addition of population from somewhere else. In so far as County Meath is concerned, it was inevitable that there would have to be a transfer of population either from Meath or to Meath or, as I demonstrated on Second Reading, a combination of a number of counties. These were the only ways in which Meath could be kept intact.

The considerations with regard to the scattered nature of County Monaghan which Deputy Tully now finds to be so relevant were ruled by the people in the referendum held on 16th October last year to be irrelevant considerations. In fact, I know that Deputy Fitzpatrick is only waiting for the opportunity to suggest that not alone is County Monaghan not too scattered a constituency but that it should be joined with County Cavan to form one single constituency and the mere addition of a small portion of County Meath to County Monaghan does not, I think, create such a scattered constituency as would the addition of County Cavan to it.

I agree with Deputy Tully that it is a ridiculous situation that he as the representative of the Slane electoral area has to service part of what will now be the Monaghan constituency and that Deputy Farrelly as the representative of the Kells electoral area will have to service what will now be part of the Cavan constituency but this is a situation which we on this side of the House tried to avoid and which the Opposition insisted upon.

Comment on this

Might I make a comment in reply to what the Minister has just said? The Minister thinks if he keeps repeating a lie often enough it will be believed.

Comment on this

A Ceann Comhairle, is it in order for Deputy Tully to allege this?

Comment on this

I withdraw the word "lie". The Minister thinks that if he keeps repeating a terminological inexactitude often enough the people will believe it. The Minister knows quite well that if what his Government and he himself wanted to get away with in the referenda had been carried through, not alone would they have butchered Meath and every other county as badly as is now proposed but would have butchered them even further because, as the Minister knows quite well, there are not an exact number in the constituencies. What would the Minister have done with the number that would be over in each constituency? I suggest that the Minister would have cut a little bit off here and there and the knife which he was sharpening would have been used all over the place.

It is utterly stupid for an intelligent man like the Minister for Local Government to keep repeating this story about the Government wanting to save the people from themselves, when a former Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party is on record as saying that the people of Ireland had no right to do wrong, that is, when they voted against them. That is one thing the Minister cannot get away with. If the Government had got away with what they were trying to do in the referenda the position would be much worse than it is now.

With regard to the servicing of Monaghan or any other constituency, would the Minister tell me what exactly he means by "trying to keep compact constituencies"? A constituency that it is easy to deal with is one where the representatives are easily available. When the Minister talks of Monaghan, for instance, where one of the representatives is living in Monaghan town, one in Highfield Road, Rathgar and one in Ballaghaderreen, County Roscommon, does he know what he is talking about? Will he take his own Front Bench and consider where they represent and where they live? Those representing Clare and Cork City live in Dublin. The whole situation has become rather ridiculous. We are prepared to talk reasonably to the Minister. He need not try to put it across on Members of the House who are too used to listening to the Minister making stupid comments. Perhaps they are not so stupid; he has method in making them. He may get away with it when talking to cumainn members outside the House who do not know the facts as well as we do. The plain fact is that Fianna Fáil attempted to cut the country into little bits but, as they did not get away with that, have now cut the country into big bits.

The Minister said that Deputy Fitzpatrick was only waiting for the opportunity to comment on the question of how Monaghan could be serviced. I do not know if the Minister realises that two of the present Cavan representatives live closer to the constituency of Monaghan than do two of the Monaghan representatives. Let him work that one out for himself. It would be the easiest thing in the world to put Cavan and Monaghan together and with the number added to the present number it would still be possible to service it because there are people who believe in living in Cavan and probably after the next election there will be people who will believe in living in Monaghan too.

We want to do the best we can to have the constituency of County Meath kept together. There are other proposals on foot at the present time which may follow the Minister's line to try to cut another slice off, but that is another day's work.

The point I made on Second Reading and that I should like to make again, with regard to Cavan, is that it would have been very easy for the Minister, if he had the goodwill, to take one piece off Meath and add it to Louth or to take one piece off Louth and add it to Meath. That is all he would have to do. The Minister would then have four counties without any change or break-up at all but, for reasons of his own, the Minister did not do that and he cannot expect us to swallow the story that it was in the interests of the people living there that he did the slicing up.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): A Cheann Comhairle, are we on Meath or Monaghan?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are discussing Deputy Farrelly's amendment No. 25a.

Comment on this

Deputy Tully had no reason for getting up except to make the accusation, which he later partially withdrew, that I was a liar. The Deputy knows that what I have said is a fact. He knows that there was before the people on 16th October a proposal which not only would make it unnecessary to do this but which would make it illegal to do this — a proposal that there be a requirement in the Constitution to adhere to county boundaries in so far as it was possible to do so within a limit of one-sixth deviation from the national average of population per Deputy. I accept that Deputy Tully paid very little attention to the actual content of the two constitutional Amendments that we were proposing but that is what was in the proposals. Deputy Tully helped to ensure that we would not be permitted to adhere to county boundaries if adhering to them involved anything more than a minimum deviation from the national average of population per Deputy.

No unsubstantiated accusation of my being a liar will change the fact that that was what we asked the Dáil to pass in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill and that is what we asked the people to enact by their votes on 16th October. The decision of the people which was made—I think the Parties opposite will agree — on their advice, was to the effect that it would not be permissible to exercise anything more than a deviation of five per cent from the national average of population per Deputy in order to adhere to county boundaries. Therefore, when Deputy Tully states that he would like to do everything possible to keep County Meath together, he is saying what he knows is untrue because he has already ensured that it is not permissible under the Constitution to keep County Meath together, as he now says he would like to do. Deputy Tully says that all that was required was a simple transfer between County Meath and County Louth and the joining together of Counties Cavan and Monaghan.

That is quite true. It is one of the many possible solutions for those four counties. I do not think a solution that would involve joining those two scattered counties of Monaghan and Cavan together—and that was not my word; either Deputy Farrelly or Deputy Tully introduced the word "scattered"; I do not remember which—would be a desirable solution. Deputy Tully might consider that it would be desirable. He went on record as saying that such an arrangement would suit him down to the ground.

Comment on this

Down to the ground.

Comment on this

He is at least consistent in that on the proposal to amend the Constitution he advocated the transfer of an area of County Meath to County Louth.

Comment on this

I challenge the Minister to do it.

Comment on this

That is one possible solution to this. It is one of the many ways in which it could be dealt with, but what the Deputy forgets is that there are more than four counties involved. There are five counties involved, and the solution he is proposing now ignores the problem existing in County Kildare. The Government's proposal deals with the five counties of Cavan, Monaghan, Louth, Meath and Kildare.

Comment on this

One of the things which will prove the Minister wrong is that the national average is something around 12,000.

Comment on this

That just shows you.

Comment on this

It is 12,000.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

If there are 33,000 or 34,000 voters in Meath how would he get three constituencies into it no matter which way he used, whether he sliced a bit off from somewhere else or added a bit on. It was pure venom and spite which made the Minister take the action he took.

Comment on this

In case I might forget to contradict that last ridiculous statement, the national average is not 12,000. It is 20,028.

Comment on this

Take the census. If Deputy Tully cannot divide the total population by 144, I am sure he will find someone in his Party who can.

Comment on this

We are not talking about the population. It is the national average of voters, not the population.

Comment on this

I do not know if the resources of the Labour Party extend to a copy of the Constitution. If they do, I advise Deputy Tully, before he comes in here and makes a fool of himself, to get a copy of the Constitution and read it. He will see that it is the population, not the voters. The voters are irrelevant. The proposal did not contain any reference to the voters. It referred to the present provisions of the Constitution and proposed that for these practical purposes it should be permissible to exercise a deviation from the national average of population per Deputy of one-sixth. I do not know what Deputy Tully is arguing about or whether he agrees. He does not seem to know.

Comment on this

I have been looking after myself for a good while across the floor from the Minister and will continue to do so. He should not worry about me. He will have enough worries after the next election.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept Deputy Farrelly's amendment. I do not know if Deputy Tully is.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The position here is that the Minister proposes to establish Meath as a three-seat constituency, and he does this by means of a tremendous travesty of local authority boundaries. In this discussion it is impossible to discuss one constituency as a unit. One must take in a group of constituencies. The Minister, in dealing with this constituency and taking into consideration the neighbouring counties of Louth and Kildare, has given a total transfer of population from Meath to Cavan of 5,656 and from Meath to Monaghan of 6,426. It also involves him in a transfer from Louth to Monaghan of 7,532 and from Kildare to Meath of 5,041. That is a total transfer of population outside the local authority boundaries in these four counties of 24,655. That is a gross breach of county boundaries or local authority boundaries, whichever way you like to describe them.

I argue that Meath could be treated as a four-seater or a three-seater. That would involve a much smaller transfer of population than what the Minister is proposing to do. If Meath is treated as a four-seater, Louth and Kildare may become three-seaters by both giving some transfers to Louth. If Louth is treated as a four-seater, Meath becomes a three-seater by transfer to Louth and, then, Kildare being, so to speak, a three-and-a-half-seater, must be joined to Carlow to form a fiveseater, leaving Kilkenny as a three-seater. This gives a rather elongated constituency stretching from New Ross to Kilcock but it does allow the reintegration of 4,398 persons from Carlow-Kilkenny to Wexford. There was such a constituency at one time. The latter combination gives a better picture in terms of population transfer.

Louth has a population of 69,519. It takes 76,112 minimum to 84,112 maximum to form a four-seater. Thus Louth has a deficit of 6,593 minimum to 14,593 maximum as a four-seater. Meath has a population of 67,323. It takes from 57,084 minimum to 63,084 maximum to form a three-seater. So Meath has a surplus of 4,239 minimum to 10,239 maximum as a three-seater. Possible population transfers which I am suggesting to the Minister from Meath to Louth would be on the following lines: from Grangegeeth, Mellifont, St. Mary's, Julianstown and Stamullen, which would give a transfer of 6,644. Alternative transfers would be St. Mary's, Julianstown, Stamullen and Ardcath, which would give a transfer of 6,768. The result would be, in the first instance, 76,163 for Louth and, in the second instance, 76,286 for Louth and for Meath, in the first instance, 60,679 and, in the second instance, 60,556.

As a four-seater needs from 76,112 to 84,112 and a three-seater needs from 57,084 to 63,084, this arrangement would allow for Louth as a four-seater and Meath as a three-seater. With regard to Carlow-Kildare, Carlow has a population of 33,593 and Kildare has a population of 66,404. That gives a total of 99,997. The average for a five-seater is 100,140. This combination meets the requirements for a fiveseater and allows for the return of the sequestrated 4,398 persons to Wexford. Kilkenny with a population of 60,463 stands as a three-seater. That is one arrangement I suggest to the Minister leaving Meath as a three-seater and this would give a total population transfer outside the constituency boundaries of 6,640 as against his figure of 24,655.

Comment on this

Deputy after Deputy on the Opposition benches gets up now and complains about what Deputy Hogan refers to as local authority boundaries. I can only repeat that this is exactly what we tried to avoid. This is exactly what we regarded as objectionable. We regarded it as being objectionable ourselves and we believed from reading the contributions made by Opposition Deputies in 1961 on the Electoral Bill that they also regarded it as objectionable. However, that is where we made the mistake. We made the mistake of trying to interpret the minds of the Opposition when we should have appreciated that they make up their minds in regard to every matter purely on the basis of opposing anything suggested by Fianna Fáil. We tried to bring a position about where it would be permissible to avoid this breaching of administrative boundaries but Deputy Hogan does not agree. Neither does Deputy Tully and the Labour Party agree and the people do not agree.

Therefore, we are compelled to perform this sort of operation which we find just as objectionable as do any other Deputies. The only thing about it is that we are sincere and we have demonstrated our sincerity by asking the people to amend the Constitution so as to make this no longer necessary. Deputy Hogan maintains that the transfer of population involved in what is proposed is excessive. But in so far as the population per Deputy in the five counties is concerned, it is clear when that population is examined, that we could hardly have transferred any smaller numbers.

The resultant situation in Monaghan is that there will be a population of 19,485 per Deputy which is very close to the minimum permissible in accordance with the existing constitutional provision. In Cavan, the population per Deputy will be 19,893, in Meath it will be 20,393, which is above the national average but still within what we believe would be the permissible limits. In Louth it will be 20,642 and in Kildare it will be 20,587.

It is quite clear, therefore, that there has not been an excessive transfer of population in the cases of these five counties. I have never suggested that the alternative suggestions put forward by Deputy Hogan were not possible. What I have said is that I believe that they are more undesirable solutions of the problem than ours and I have admitted that this is purely a matter of opinion. Our opinion is that the proposal we put forward is the least objectionable. Deputy Hogan does not agree. He says that we could have solved this by making Meath a four-seat constituency with a transfer of population from Louth or by making Louth a four-seat constituency with a transfer of population from Meath, this involving the joining together of the counties of Kildare and Carlow and Counties Cavan and Monaghan. I have already said on a number of occasions that this is a possible solution to the problem, but I do not think that the formation of two constituencies like Carlow and Kildare and Cavan and Monaghan would be as desirable a solution as the one that we are putting forward.

I dispute Deputy Hogan's figures with regard to the population disrupted because, of course, he has conveniently ignored what is involved in uprooting the population of Carlow from the present constituency and creating a new constituency of Carlow-Kildare. He has ignored what is involved in the ridiculous suggestion of joining what either Deputy Tully or Deputy Farrelly referred to as the "scattered" constituencies of Monaghan and Cavan. The populations involved in those two operations would have to be considered in the same way as the disruptions that are involved in the proposals before the House.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister ignores the fact of the tremendous difference in population transfers as regards the suggestion that I have put to him and the one that he has formulated. I mentioned that in his transfers he had a total population transfer of 24,655; but in the suggestion I made to have Meath a three-seater and to reconstitute Carlow-Kildare as a five-seater, there would also be the transfer of 4,398 persons back into Wexford and that, added to the 24,655, would give the figure that he is giving of 29,000. Those 29,000 people can be put back into their own counties for a displacement of 6,640. The Minister's figure is five times mine. If that is not gerrymandering then I do not understand the meaning of the word.

The Minister could also solve the matter, if he has objections to Carlow-Kildare, by making Meath a fourseater. Meath has a population of 67,323 and its requirement for a fourseater would be a minimum of 76,112 or 84,112 maximum. There is just a deficit of 8,487 minimum to 16,789 maximum. But Louth with a population of 69,519 must, if treated as a three-seater, transfer out either a minimum of 6,425 to a maximum of 12,435, while Kildare with a county population of 66,404 must, if treated as a three-seater, transfer out a minimum of 3,202 to a maximum of 9,320.

A suggested arrangement for the Minister would be from Louth to Meath the district electoral divisions of Clonkeen, 446; Tallanstown 723; Ardee rural 1,897; Ardee urban 2,919; and Collon 754, making a total of 6,739. From Kildare to Meath the district electoral divisions of Ballynadromnee, 383; Dunfirth, 321; Kilrainy, 360; Cloncurry, 716; Kilcock, 1,140; Droichead, 201; and Carrick, 228. That is a total of 3,349.

The total transfer there, and that is less successful from the point of view of population transfers than the other suggestion, would be 10,088 which is still very much lower than the figure of 24,655 envisaged by the Minister; or, if we have to add the population that might go back to Wexford, 29,053.

Comment on this

I have not ignored the transfer of any population in any figures I gave. Deputy Hogan, on the contrary, has ignored what is involved in the transfer of the population of County Carlow and County Monaghan. He is arguing in favour of a constituency comprised of a part of Louth, the County of Meath and part of the County of Kildare. This would be an even more objectionable solution to the problem than anything he has suggested so far and I am tempted to enquire whether in putting forward this arrangement he speaks with the authority of Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Donegan or is this another case similar to Deputy Lyons's suggestion in regard to County Mayo: when I asked if he spoke for the Fine Gael Party, the Fine Gael Whip said: "He speaks for the Fine Gael Party in so far as the constituency of South Mayo is concerned", presumably just as Deputy Belton spoke for Fine Gael only in so far as Dublin is concerned.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Fianna Fáil Party are not allowed to speak at all.

Comment on this

Nobody else was prepared to take responsibility for their suggestion that there should be yet another seat taken from the rural part of the country and added to the Dublin area; so I am sure Deputy Hogan speaks for Fine Gael only in so far as the constituency of South Tipperary is concerned and possibly some time next week or some time in the future, depending on the success or failure of the attempt to delay the passage of the Bill by the Fine Gael Party, we may eventually come to discuss that constituency.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister has protested loudly that he has been consistent about county boundaries and that he and his Party have been consistent about county boundaries in the referendum debate and in this debate. Neither Fine Gael nor the people of the country were prepared to risk democracy, as we understand it and have understood it for a considerable time, for county boundaries as such. I think that can be interpreted as the people's decision and the arguments put forward here amounted to that. However, one would have thought that having regard to the decision of the Chief Justice in 1961 and having regard to the arguments put forward by the Minister on the Electoral Bill and the advice of the Taoiseach to the people, the Minister would have been consistent and that when he set out to draft this Bill, he would, as far as possible, have preserved county boundaries and that, more important still, he would have amalgamated like with like, amalgamated one constituency with another on the basis of the association of those constituencies with each other in the past.

I want to make it perfectly clear that in anything I have to say on the constituency of Meath as it affects the constituency of Monaghan and the constituency of Cavan, I have no personal axe to grind. I represent Cavan here and I am quite happy with the constituency of Cavan as it stands. I will be quite happy to contest and represent the constituency of Cavan and Monaghan, and I welcome the portion of Meath that has been thrown into Cavan. I am prepared to contest that constituency, if the Minister, by his majority here, insists on it, and I shall do my best to represent the people of Cavan.

I have a feeling, however, that the people of Meath would prefer not to be sent into Cavan and that the other portion of Meath would prefer not to be sent into Monaghan. That is what I am objecting to in this Bill. On these constituencies I am protesting not as a Deputy who is getting an electorate he does not want or as a Deputy who says his constituency has been treated to his disadvantage—I am quite happy with it, as I have said; I would also be quite happy with Monaghan and Cavan or with Cavan alone—but as one who thinks it is unreasonable to put approximately 5,000 people out of Meath into Monaghan and to put another approximately 5,000 people out of Meath into Cavan.

Let us have a reasonable look at this situation. The people of Meath have nothing in common with the people of Cavan. Their business or social activities do not normally bring them into contact with Cavan. People from the Meath border, if they set out for a big town, or go out on social or sporting or, indeed, business activities, naturally gravitate towards Dublin, towards Dundalk, towards Drogheda, towards the sea. Yet, these people are being sent into Cavan. If there were no alternative to that and if the decision of the people in the referendum had decreed that the Minister must do that in order to arrange a constituency, then, of course, the Minister would be justified in what he is doing.

In the referendum debate I said I did not regard—and I do not regard —county boundaries as sacrosanct or as being something that could not be breached in any circumstances. For example, as I said then, I would not hold on to county boundaries in exchange for democracy; I would not hold on to county boundaries at the expense of giving the Minister and his Party the right to create here an undemocratic, one-Party State. When the Minister came to this Bill he should not have proceeded in a fit of temper or in the mood of saying to the electorate: "I will show you. You will pay for your rejection of my proposals." He should have proceeded camly and in a reasonable manner and drawn up reasonable constituencies. I have shown that the people of Meath who are coming into Monaghan have nothing in common with the constituency of Monaghan for the simple reason that they are a different type of farmers. They are in the province of Leinster. They naturally move over towards the sea at Bettystown and to the towns of Dundalk and Drogheda if they are going on social outings. If they are going on business they are likely to come towards Dublin. The people of Meath who are coming into Cavan are in the very same position. They would never come down to Cavan except perhaps for a football match between the two counties. I can tell you that there would be keener rivalry between Meath and Cavan than between Cavan and Kerry or Cavan and Limerick, if Limerick had a football team.

Comment on this

They have. They beat Kerry once.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): They have a very good hurling team. The position is that Louth and Meath as neighbouring counties come in contact with each other quite frequently. As a matter of fact, up around Drogheda one would have the greatest difficulty in deciding whether he was in Meath or in Louth. There is quite a thickly populated area extending practically into the port of Drogheda that is in County Meath. The seaside resorts of Bettystown and Laytown are in County Meath but Louth people regard them more or less as their own. This, I think, demonstrates quite clearly that there is a growing association between Meath and Louth, that the people there are, in fact, the same type of people, who associate in business, and whose recreation brings them into close contact with each other.

I am not advocating, for personal reasons, a joint constituency of Monaghan and Cavan but let us not have any secret about the fact that I am a Monaghan man. That goes a long way to proving my argument and seems to demonstrate that Monaghan and Cavan are associated closely enough and that Monaghan people are not regarded as strangers in Cavan. Monaghan and Cavan have operated a joint health board for much longer than I remember. That brings them into contact with each other. The people are, by and large, the same type of small farmers. Anybody knows that when potatoes were potatoes Monaghan and Cavan practically supplied the Dublin market with table potatoes. Both counties go in for pig rearing on a large scale. They have much more in common than either would have with Meath or Louth.

The Minister refers to the constituency of Monaghan and Cavan as a long, unwieldy, unmanageable constituency.

Comment on this

I said "monstrosity".

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If the Minister thinks of any more objectionable term, it will probably be used. I am sure that the Minister appreciates that he does not represent all his constituents.

Comment on this

I certainly do.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I know the Minister does his best. I am sure Deputy Burke helps.

Comment on this

We work in harmony.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He would object to the Minister's objection more—if he said that Deputy Burke could look after some matter——

Comment on this

It is slander on my gracious colleague.

Comment on this