We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 227–454 of 454. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 35 of 1968 ›

The Minister got away from him in case he would lead him in the poll.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I would be interested to know if the Taoiseach would pass something on to the Minister for Local Government or to his gracious colleague, Deputy Burke, or to Deputy Foley.

Comment on this

He would not pass it to the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Somebody wrote to the Taoiseach about a little problem in Louth and today he referred it to the Minister for Lands. Presumably that was in the area of Louth within the jurisdiction of the Minister for Lands. Presumably if it were in Cooley he would have passed it on to the Tánaiste. That seems to me to give substance to my argument that you have in each constituency people who represent certain areas, by and large. I know constitutionally and electorally, that each Deputy elected for a constituency represents people from every limit and for every inch of the territory. As Deputy James Tully pointed out, at present Monaghan seems to be getting good representation from Highfield Road and from Ballaghaderreen.

The Minister might be surprised to hear that Monaghan and Cavan are one constituency at the moment and that the three Cavan Deputies are still in the Dáil. I live about eight miles from the Monaghan border. Deputy John Tully lives five or six miles from the Monaghan border and Deputy Paddy Smith lives within a mile of the Monaghan border. I am quite happy with the constituency of Cavan. I am not crying out for Monaghan and Cavan but I am protesting here on behalf of the people of Meath who are being quite unnecessarily driven out of their county and out of their province into another county and another province. I have good reason to believe that the deciding factor which influenced the Minister in arranging these constituencies was that he wanted to be absolutely certain he would deny a closely-knit Protestant community in Monaghan and Cavan of a quota.

The Minister has made the point on numerous occasions that when a group of people are being put out of one constituency into another a sizeable group should be put out. I say that when there are a goodly number of a Protestant community in a constituency of Monaghan and Cavan it would not be an unreasonable thing to leave a quota of their votes together if they chose to use them. Thinking within the Fianna Fáil Party would seem to agree with that at one level because they have honoured Senator John Copeland Cole by nominating him to Seanad Éireann. Why do they not go the whole way and leave this quota of Protestant votes in Monaghan and Cavan together if that community want to avail of it? I do not say they should avail of them or that they should not but if they want to avail of them it would be a reasonable thing to allow them to do so.

If the Minister had set out to be reasonable he could have avoided unnecessarily breaching the county boundary of Meath. He has parcelled it up in two directions into Monaghan and into Cavan. It is hard to understand that particularly, as I have tried to point out in a reasonable way, in view of the fact that normally either for local administration purposes or otherwise the counties of Meath and Louth are far more closely knit and that the counties of Monaghan and Cavan are more closely knit.

In this particular instance, as far as Cavan is concerned I do not think that the transfer will make a lot of difference. It is certain, of course, that if the Minister was absolutely certain that he had done the reasonable thing and joined like with like, joined Monaghan and Cavan, he could never hope to get two seats out of five. He knew that it was a foregone conclusion that he would not and that, with his effort to kill the Protestant quota, influenced him in this somewhat unnatural transfer of population from Leinster to Ulster, from Meath to Cavan and from Meath to Monaghan.

Having said that, again I say that as far as I or the Fine Gael organisation in Cavan are concerned, if I were to take it on that basis alone, there is not any real objection to what has been done. There are only about 2,000 votes drafted in. However, in so far as the people of Meath are concerned it is not their natural home, it is not their natural unit. The Minister has conceded at all stages of this discussion, and freely admits, that there are more ways of doing this than one. If there are, I would say that the method that he has adopted here is far less reasonable than that suggested by Deputy Hogan.

Comment on this

The constituency we are discussing now, the constituency of Meath, is a typical example of the length that the Fianna Fáil Government are prepared to go in a vindictive attitude to butcher and to gerrymander a constituency. Indeed it is on a par with, if not much worse than, anything that has ever been contemplated or done across the Border in Northern Ireland. There is one thing certainly that the Fianna Fáil Party have learned from the people across the Border and that is how to deny people their rights, how to gerrymander constituencies. We know that this is deliberately done in an attempt to suit the Fianna Fáil Party there and to harm Deputy Denis Farrelly. We know that there were many alternatives. For example, Cavan and Monaghan could have been connected and, as Deputy Fitzpatrick has stated, they have very much in common. Cavan and Monaghan could have been made a five-seat constituency. I want to say deliberately what I said here the last day, despite what we here in Ireland say about the ecumenical spirit, I know for a fact that Cavan and Monaghan originally was to be a five-seat constituency but the boys from the grass roots—and Fianna Fáil are inclined to listen to them at times, not always, they did not listen to them before the referendum but they listened to them on this occasion—came down from Cavan and Monaghan and said: "For God's sake, do not leave this a five-seat constituency. If you do, the Protestant community will get a seat here and we cannot trust them. We do not know what way they will vote. The danger is that we will only get two out of five seats and perhaps three will go to Fine Gael candidates".

Comment on this

Perhaps.

Comment on this

Those people are entitled to representation just the same as any other section of the community but Fianna Fáil, while paying lip service to them at times, have made certain in this Bill as they did in a previous Bill that they would not get representation either in Donegal or in a constituency of Cavan-Monaghan. If the two were put together there would have been no necessity for the Minister to interfere with county boundaries; or with any boundary. They would have made an ideal constituency and the number of population would have been within the limit laid down by the Constitution.

If Fianna Fáil or the Minister for Local Government, Mr. Boland, wanted it, he could have left Meath a threeseat constituency and he could have put, if necessary, 8,568 people from Meath into Louth and have made Louth a four-seat constituency but the Minister would not do that because he was afraid that if Louth were made a four-seat constituency Fianna Fáil would get only two out of the four seats and Fine Gael would get the other two or else Fine Gael would get one and Labour would get one. That would not suit the Minister and of course he had to make Louth a three-seater hoping to get two seats out of three and leave Monaghan, Cavan and Meath. As an indication of the type of butchery that had to be done in Meath, he had to uproot in one area in North Meath 3,829 people and in another area of Meath 1,827 people to be put into the constituency of Cavan. He had also to take from Meath 3,950-odd people and put them into the constituency of Monaghan. At the other end of the constituency we find that he had to take 5,041 people from Kildare and put them into Meath. There was a reason for that. The reason those 5,000 people from Kildare are being put into Meath is to suit Deputy Crinion. We know that the Minister for Defence kicked up a shindy, and that Deputy Crinion may not stand for Meath, but the original intention was to take the area in which Deputy Crinion lives and to put it into Meath to help to get him elected.

As I stated here on the last occasion, despite this gerrymander, despite this vindictive action in a vindictive Bill by a vindictive Minister against the wishes of the people expressed in the recent referendum, their plans for Meath will not succeed. When the next election has passed, there will be one Fine Gael, one Labour and one Fianna Fáil Deputy for the constituency, and Fianna Fáil will be lucky if they get one out of three. They certainly will not get two. When speaking about Castlebar, the Minister was at pains to tell us that the hinterland of Castlebar had to be left with Castlebar—he would not dream of separating the two. He is separating the hinterlands of Kells and Navan from the towns and he is putting them into the constituency of Monaghan. He is doing this to suit Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick tried once again to misrepresent the proposals which were put before the people in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Referendum. The principal proposal was, as he knows, simply to allow a certain small amount of scope for the specific purpose of taking account of such practical considerations as county boundaries. I said "small scope" because the amount proposed was much less than that which is available and utilised in any known democracy. How this amendment could, as he alleged at such great length, result in the creation of a one-Party State I cannot understand.

Surely, Deputy Fitzpatrick appreciates that the administrative county boundaries in this country were set up many years ago, long before there was any thought of Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour. However, he gets up here and maintains that a requirement to adhere to these county boundaries would result in the creation of a one-Party State. I cannot understand it. It is quite clear that Deputy Fitzpatrick was talking for the sake of talking, to keep the debate going. After arguing for weeks here and for months throughout the country that these administrative boundaries were of no relevance and that the proposal to adhere to them was merely to create a one-Party State, today he says we should adhere to them as closely as possible—that we should minimise the breaching of county boundaries—after he has helped to ensure that this cannot be done. Just to show the inconsistency of Deputy Fitzpatrick, I will give one quotation from Volume 235, column 145 of the Official Report for 28th May, 1968 where he is reported:

The Minister seems to think that county boundaries are sacred and that the counties and constituencies should coincide identically. I do not think there is anything sacred about county boundaries.

Later on he continues:

Therefore, there is nothing sacred about county boundaries — there never has been—but if I understand the case the Minister is making correctly, he seems to be saying that constituencies should coincide with county boundaries and that each county should be a constituency.

It was a terrible undemocratic suggestion as recently at 28th May, 1968. Now I am accused of being undemocratic because I accept the decision of the people that the boundaries must be breached in order to have near equality of population per Deputy. I am ensuring here that the transfer of population is as small as is reasonably possible, bearing in mind the distribution of the comparatively small group of people who have to be transferred, not being so small as to be completely submerged in the new constituency to which they are transferred; and bearing in mind the matter of distribution and of having reasonable areas as constituencies—areas that would be reasonable to associate together.

Deputy Fitzpatrick now, contrary to what he said in May of last year, says he believes that Meath people would prefer not to go into Cavan or into Monaghan. I believe that now, just as I believed it in May, 1968; but Deputy Fitzpatrick claims he believes it now though in May, 1968, he was of the opposite point of view. He and every member of his Party went around the country and persuaded the people that the proposal to allow a small amount of scope in order to take cognisance of county boundaries was in some manner a breach of their democratic rights and would result in gerrymander and the creation of a one-Party State.

I agree with what Deputy Fitzpatrick says now. I am quite sure the Meath people who are affected would prefer not to be transferred into Cavan or Monaghan. I asked the people to give us permission not to do that. Senator Fitzpatrick asked them not to give us that permission and they acceded to his request and so this Bill has to be brought in. Deputy Fitzpatrick, arguing from the basis that he is a Monaghan man representing County Cavan, maintains that the people of Monaghan and Cavan are for all practical purposes the same. I suppose that the people of all Ireland are the same fundamentally but that is a long way from suggesting, as Deputy Fitzpatrick did, that the people of Carrickmacross and Glangevlin are more closely associated than those on the Meath-Cavan border. The Government's opinion is that the creation of a constituency from two counties, Monaghan and Cavan, straggling along the unnatural border of this State and the Six County State, if we can call it a State — the Six County area set up with the connivance of the Party opposite——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The letters that came out recently exploded that myth.

Comment on this

—— would look ridiculous and it would be ridiculous in practice. One of the most interesting arguments that Deputy Fitzpatrick put up, in view of the arguments he put up in the past, was when he suggested that proportional representation does not work at all here—that Deputies, for all practical purposes, represent certain areas of constituencies though they were elected to represent the whole of these constituencies. But, having spent months arguing against the idea of single seat constituencies, he says that in fact the system works as if it were a system of single seat constituencies. If that is so as far as the Fine Gael Party are concerned, I assure him that, as far as Fianna Fáil are concerned, it is not so. When a Fianna Fáil Deputy is elected to represent a constituency he represents that constituency in so far as it is possible for him to do so.

The most despicable argument raised by Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy L'Estrange was the argument that we should create a constituency of Cavan-Monaghan in order to create a Protestant seat. That is an indication of the depths to which Fine Gael are prepared to sink when they try to arouse sectarian bitterness for the sake of purely Party political advantage. It is, of course, consistent with the record of the Fine Gael Party. It is what one would expect. Having made all these allegations about gerrymandering Deputy Fitzpatrick winds up by saying that this will not make a great deal of political difference anyway. What is gerrymandering but an attempt to make a substantial political difference? Successful gerrymandering surely assumes that a substantial political difference has been made by the arrangement of the constituencies?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister should quote me correctly. I said as far as Cavan is concerned.

Comment on this

The Deputy makes an allegation about gerrymandering in one part of his speech and he winds up by saying that the gerrymandering does not make any difference anyway.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): As far as the constituency of Cavan is concerned. The Minister cannot even be accurate.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick is followed by Deputy L'Estrange who says this is worse gerrymandering than the gerrymandering in Northern Ireland. Deputy Fitzpatrick says it will make no difference. Deputy L'Estrange obviously alleges that it will create two seats for Fianna Fáil in Cavan and retain two seats for Fianna Fáil in Monaghan and that this has been done by transferring part of County Meath into both these constituencies. If the result will be to create a second seat for Fianna Fáil in Cavan and retain the two seats in Monaghan then Deputy L'Estrange is, in fact, alleging that the people transferred are in the main Fianna Fáil supporters. But Deputy Farrelly claims they are his supporters and Deputy Tully claims they are his. Apparently these people support everybody.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): They keep their minds to themselves.

Comment on this

That is exactly what most people do and the result is that no Party has available information on which to base a gerrymander. That is why Fine Gael keep on contradicting themselves at every turn. They know that I do not know how to gerrymander because I have not got available to me the information on which to base a successful gerrymander.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Would the Minister, if he had?

Comment on this

All I can do is try to comply with the requirements of the Constitution which the people on the opposite side of the House have tied around the Government's neck. Having said this is a gerrymander worse than in Northern Ireland, Deputy L'Estrange goes on to say: "but it will not succeed". Surely that is a contradiction. He alleges we are taking people from Meath to Monaghan, from Meath to Cavan and from Kildare to Meath in order to bolster up Fianna Fáil Deputies. All these people are apparently, according to the Deputy, Fianna Fáil supporters. In fact, these transfers are necessary because of the figures in the Census of Population for 1966 and because of the constitutional requirement, the requirements which Deputies on the opposite side advised the people not to change. This is what makes this, or some other solution, such as the much more undesirable solutions put forward by various Fine Gael Deputies, inevitable.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister has successfully avoided explaining why it is more reasonable to transfer people from Meath into Monaghan and Cavan than it is to associate Louth and Meath together and Cavan and Monaghan together. I did not say, as the Minister suggests, that I do not believe in county boundaries. I said today what I have said before; I said that county boundaries should be disturbed as little as possible. That is all I am asking the Minister to do.

The Minister accused me of saying that the Third Amendment of the Constitution would have turned this country into a one-Party State. All I can do is to ask independent thought to look at the Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968, introduced by the Minister when, he says, his hands were tied by the Constitution and when he was bound to arrange constituencies on the same number of votes per Deputy throughout the country. Let independent thought then ask itself what might have been expected from the Minister had he been able to decree that approximately 16,000 people would qualify for a Deputy in one constituency whereas it would take approximately 23,000 to qualify in another constituency? I will leave the answer to the good sense of the people.

It will be no answer for the Minister to say he was giving us an infallible commission because the Minister was not giving us any such commission. He was giving us a bogus commission, subject to being overruled at every turn and twist by this House. This is what I meant when I said that the Third Amendment in the hands of the Minister and his Government would have led to the creation of a one-Party State. The Minister agrees with me that the people of Meath do not want to go into Monaghan and Cavan. He says he knew that last year and he knows it now. I want to ask him this simple question: if he knows they do not want to be in Monaghan and Cavan why does he send them there?

Comment on this

Where will he put them?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is the way. When you hop in and out here you are inclined to put your foot in it. The Minister has already conceded in Deputy Geoghegan's absence that there are many other ways in which this could be done, and that he never said Deputy Hogan's suggestions were not workable. Deputy Hogan threw out a solution of associating Meath and Louth. If the Minister concedes, as I understand him to have fairly conceded, that it is an unnatural sort of association to drive part of Meath into Monaghan and part of Meath into Cavan, and he also admits that there are other ways of solving the problem, why does he take the less reasonable of the two? Why does he not accept what I suppose he would agree is a more reasonable solution?

The Minister threw across the floor of the House accusations and counteraccusations about our intentions. He accused me of wanting to create a constituency of Cavan and Monaghan in order to give what are popularly known as the religious minority a quota. The Minister has done something much worse than that because he was influenced in keeping these two counties apart in order to deprive those people of a say in Parliament. That is a different thing.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That was the thinking which influenced the Minister. I say it is he who is being sectarian and not I. Here was a natural association. Leave this out of it altogether. Leave the minority out of it. Forget about it. I stake my reputation on it, and I know what I am talking about, that Monaghan and Cavan would have been together, but the Minister's sectarian mind came into it and he kept them apart on those grounds. I would never have thought of it, were it not for the fact that I heard on very reliable authority that that was what caused the change of mind.

When the Taoiseach came down to Cavan to launch the referendum campaign he spoke on the basis of Monaghan and Cavan being joined together if his proposals were not carried. The Minister did the same. In this House Fianna Fáil Deputies were talking in terms of Monaghan and Cavan being together days before this Bill belatedly saw the public or the public saw it. It came out a fortnight after it was promised. I say that during the interval Monaghan and Cavan were being talked about as one constituency. I know on reliable authority that that was what influenced the Minister. I say that is reprehensible. It was not I who introduced religion into this discussion or into our electoral system, but the Minister. That is what influenced him. The Minister is a past master at misrepresenting people.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a matter such as this there are many angles which one could discuss or criticise. When I spoke about this before, I concentrated my remarks on the inconvenience caused to the people of Meath by being driven into Monaghan and Cavan. I did not deal with the political effects of that in County Meath.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange did.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I did not deal with the political effects of that in County Meath, because I did not deal with the remainder of the Meath constituency. If you take 10,000 people or 5,000 votes from the immediate vicinity of a sitting Deputy, irrespective of the political outlook of those people, unless they are very pronounced politicians any schoolboy knows—or anyone who has ever acted as a personation agent—that it is bound to affect the sitting Deputy. The Minister sought to misrepresent me because in concluding I said that so far as the constituency of Cavan was concerned it would not make much difference.

Of course it is bound to make a difference to Deputy Farrelly because not only are 10,000 people, approximately, being taken from him but they are also being sent in different directions. They are being sent to different constituencies. Normally a Deputy could follow such a volume of votes and hope to keep most of them together on a personal and political basis, just as my colleague Deputy Reynolds followed such a number of votes into Roscommon and, to the surprise of the Minister's predecessor, and I am sure of the Minister, kept them together; but Deputy Farrelly was not allowed to do that. Not only were those 10,000 people shifted out of Meath but they were cut in two and 5,000 told to go one way and 5,000 told to go another way. Does the Minister consider that reasonable? Does he consider it consistent with the argument he made here last week to the effect that, when people were being transferred in sizeable numbers, they should be transferred so that they could retain their identity and influence?

In effect, what the Minister is doing here is transferring something between 2,000 and 2,500 votes from Meath into Cavan and over 2,000 from Meath into Monaghan, having already packed another parcel from Louth into Monaghan. He is associating in the constituency of Monaghan three counties: Monaghan, Louth and Meath. He is associating in the constituency of Cavan two counties: Meath and Cavan. We all know this is quite unnecessary and the Minister concedes that it is quite unnecessary. He could have the two northern counties together and the two Leinster counties together.

The Minister accuses the Opposition of prolonging the debate and dragging out the discussion. He deserves to win any prize that is going for that sort of operation, because he insists on misrepresenting the Opposition and, so long as he does so, so long will I keep the record right.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick apparently got up on that occasion to allege that I had avoided saying why I considered it undesirable to join Counties Cavan and Monaghan and Meath and Louth together. I have dealt with that, which I considered to be a ridiculous suggestion, already. I pointed out the difficulties involved in a Cavan-Monaghan constituency because of the configuration of the border with the Six County area and the obvious difficulty there would be for any Deputy representing the area.

Such a constituency is all the more undesirable because of the many solutions that have been put forward. Deputy Fitzpatrick argues that there should be the least possible interference with the county boundaries. I can only repeat that when there was a possibility of doing something about this he took the opposite course and ensured that it would not be permissible to pay any attention to the existence of county boundaries.

I cannot follow how Deputy Fitzpatrick can allege that the situation that we tried to bring about whereby there would be a constitutional requirement to adhere as closely as possible to existing county boundaries would give more scope for what he describes as gerrymandering than the present situation which requires the exact opposite. It requires constituencies to have as nearly as possible the same population per Deputy, irrespective of county boundaries, and that makes it inevitable that there will be these transfers of population from one county to another. Surely, if the information on which to base a gerrymander is available to a political Party, it is a situation like this where this type of transfer must be done that scope is provided for gerrymandering. But, of course, having alleged all this, Deputy Fitzpatrick goes on to say that this type of information is not available. He says that the people keep their minds to themselves and that nobody can say how they voted in a particular area in the past and certainly he must agree that nobody can say how they will vote in the future. He invites independent thought, whatever that is, to imagine what might have been expected if the proposal to permit adherence to boundaries had been enacted by the people. The proposal was that the deviation would only be exercised for the purpose of taking into account prominent physical features and, of course, any arrangements could be adjudicated on by the courts to see if these conditions were complied with.

I maintain that it is obvious to independent thought and that it is obvious to Deputy Fitzpatrick that in these circumstances there would be no scope whatever for gerrymandering and no scope whatever for Fianna Fáil to attempt to create what he describes as a "one-Party State". I suppose Deputy Fitzpatrick can get up as often as he likes and ask me why these people from Meath have to be put into Louth. The reason is contained in the figures of the census of population. That is the only document that I can take into account.

The population in Cavan is 54,322 and that is not sufficient, in accordance with the constitutional requirements which the Fine Gael Party arranged to have defined by the High Court and which they succeeded in persuading the people to endorse, for the minimum number of seats that is permissible under the Constitution and, therefore, if one rejects the solution, as we have rejected it, of bringing Cavan and Monaghan together and we have decided instead to try and retain a Cavan constituency as there always has been, one must transfer population from somewhere and the population in this case is transferred from Meath because of the fact that the other counties bordering Cavan have not got any population to spare. Meath is the only place from which a transfer could be made and the only part of Meath from which it could be transferred is the part from which we are proposing that it should be transferred. The same situation applies in so far as Monaghan is concerned. Monaghan has already been adjusted with County Louth. There was not sufficient surplus population in the remaining part of Louth to bring Monaghan up to the minimum allowable under the present interpretation of the Constitution. Therefore, since Cavan cannot spare any population for this purpose, the only place from which Monaghan could be brought up to the required population is from County Meath.

All these transfers in this particular area arise from the population figures in the census report and from the decision extracted from the High Court by Fine Gael and endorsed by the people on 16th October, 1968. The population of Louth is 69,519. That is too many for three seats and too few for four seats. The population of Meath is 67,323. Again, this is too many for a three-seater and too few for a four-seater. The population of Kildare is 66,404. This is too many for three seats and too few for four seats and it has been adjusted with some other county. The population of Cavan is 54,322. In this case it is too low a population for three seats and has to be adjusted with another county. The population of Monaghan is 45,732 and it has to be adjusted with some other county and the only place from which it could be brought up to the required number was from Meath and this involves the transfer of the surplus population from Kildare to Meath.

Apparently Deputy Fitzpatrick considers the proposed joining of Cavan and Monaghan more reasonable than the small adjustment between Cavan and Monaghan and Meath. He asks me if I consider the adjustment with Meath reasonable. I do not think it is reasonable. That is why I asked the people not to compel me to do it, but now it is inevitable. However, it is certainly less objectionable, in my opinion, than the other suggestion of creating the ridiculous and unworkable constituency of Cavan-Monaghan, which is apparently the official Fine Gael policy.

If anybody will look at Cavan and Monaghan on the map they will see that what I say is correct. I again say that the introduction of sectarianism into this by Fine Gael is a despicable tactic which has been adopted for mean Party political advantage. To try to suggest that this compliance with the constitutional requirements is in any way directed against the members of the Protestant religion is typical of what we can expect from Fine Gael, particularly when we remember that one of the main reasons for the action that the Fine Gael Party took in the courts in 1961 was to take away from the Protestant section of the community in Donegal a seat that the Fianna Fáil Government proposed to leave with them.

Comment on this

That is despicable.

Comment on this

One of the main reasons for the Fine Gael action was to reduce representation in Donegal from seven seats to six, to require two three-seat constituencies instead of what we were proposing to leave there, a four-seat constituency and a three-seat constituency, there being a representative of the Protestant minority elected to the four-seat Donegal constituency. That is one of the main reasons for the Fine Gael action and one of the inevitable consequences of the action that the Fine Gael Party took in the courts at that time. It is typical of them, having taken that action deliberately in 1961——

Comment on this

It is typical of the Minister's misrepresentation.

Comment on this

——to seek their own political advantage now, as they hope. I am quite satisfied the people will see through this despicable tatic of theirs.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I wonder does the Minister appreciate that he is disfiguring the records of this House by recording in them insults to the High Court. Twice since he stood up there on the last occasion he referred to the decision of Mr. Justice Budd as a decision which Fine Gael arranged to get from the High Court, and later he repeated the ignorant assertion that he earlier made when he referred to that decision as a decision extracted from the High Court.

It may be that the Minister does not realise he is insulting the High Court and that, if he was outside and said that, he could be brought before the High Court for contempt of court. I wonder does the Taoiseach approve of this sort of thing? I shall not differentiate between one judge of the High Court and another because I believe every judge of the High Court upholds the Constitution and upholds the laws of this country. I would appeal to the Minister for Local Government to realise that he is doing no good service to himself or to the institutions of the State by trying to belittle the High Court. If law and order breaks down it will only be broken down if we succeed in taking away respect from the courts which stand between the people and the Executive——

Comment on this

That would be nothing new to Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——which stand between the people and the Government. The courts are respected in this country, and these attacks, knowingly or otherwise, which have been made by the Minister in this House today and which have been made by him several times in the course of these debates during the past month against a learned Judge of the High Court, who discharged his duties fearlessly after much consideration and who was not appealed against by the very Minister who is now insulting him, seek to lessen respect for the courts. I do not want to appear to be speaking as an elder statesman or anything like that, but I do say that it will be a very bad day for this country if the people are led to criticise the courts publicly just because the courts gave a decision they did not agree with; and it will be an extraordinarily bad day for this country when a Cabinet Minister, with the approval of the Taoiseach, leads an attack on a decision of the people of this country, because the next thing——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would point out that the remarks of the Deputy are not relevant to the Schedule.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I shall conclude by saying that the Minister's behaviour here today towards the judiciary is only one step removed from trying to get control of the judiciary and to dictate their decisions to them.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that political Parties do not know how the people voted in the past. The Minister, being a director of elections and closely associated with elections, knows quite well that the different political Parties know how the people vote in nearly every polling booth in Ireland.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This has got nothing to do with the Schedule to the Bill.

Comment on this

Yes, it has. The Minister stated that in transferring those areas from Meath into Monaghan he had no idea how the people voted in the past or how they would vote in the future.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister was referring to a comment which had been made by Deputy Fitzpatrick.

Comment on this

If the Minister states something we believe is not correct, we are entitled to say so. Let me say, in any case, that as regards how people will vote in the future we have a fair idea what will happen. They certainly will not vote Fianna Fáil because the people have found them out. There is a large floating vote there today. The people will not be intimidated by Fianna Fáil. The Minister speaks about a surplus population in Monaghan and Cavan. Surely if he looked up the statistics he would see——

Comment on this

"Deficiency" I said.

Comment on this

Let us talk about the census of population in those counties. Since Fianna Fáil came to power in 1932 they have driven 28,030 people out of Cavan. If Fianna Fáil had not come into power there would be sufficient people in Cavan today to make Cavan a four-seat constituency. Since 1956 alone they have driven 7,700 people——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are not discussing the effects of Government policy on the population. The Deputy may state figures of population in relation to the Schedule but he may not deal with the reasons for them.

Comment on this

The Minister has given his reasons and I want to point out the truth. Let me say also, without giving reasons, that if the population of Monaghan had not fallen by 16,000 from 61,000 to 45,000 since Fianna Fáil came to office, Monaghan, with a very slight injection of less than 4,000 from some other constituency, could have been a four-seat constituency. The Fianna Fáil Government since 1956, have driven 7,002 people out of the county of Monaghan. Therefore it is only right it should be put on the records of the House why fewer Deputies are going to rural Ireland.

The Minister has come in here with a spate of misrepresentation. I suppose he believes that if he says a thing often enough certain people will believe him. It is despicable for the Minister to misrepresent the action that was taken in the High Court in 1961 by an individual member of the Fine Gael Party, as that member was quite entitled to do. If the Government of the country errs, it is only right that any private individual or member of a Party or combination of Parties should have the right to take a particular case to a court and upset the Government. That is what happened in this particular case but it is wrong for the Minister to come in here and say that we did that deliberately to do the minority in Donegal out of a seat. We certainly did not, and if Fianna Fáil were sincere in their beliefs they could now rectify that by making Donegal a five-seater constituency.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not discussing Donegal at the moment.

Comment on this

The Minister made those charges against us. He made the charge that, because a Fine Gael Senator took an action in the High Court in 1960, he deliberately put a Protestant out of Leinster House. The Minister stated that Fianna Fáil intended to have a four-seater constituency in Donegal so that a Protestant could get the seat there. I want to point out that that was a deliberate misrepresentation and that in the last ten years, and even now, he could make Donegal a five-seater and Cavan a five-seater constituency and the Protestants would have representation in both. They would have two representatives here. The Minister is making certain they do not get this. That cannot be denied and I want to give full credit to the Minister for clever political tactics in this Bill. He is due 100 per cent marks for clever, well-done, but avaricious, politics in his Party which is bent on keeping themselves in power and getting the maximum number of Deputies returned to this House with the minimum number of votes——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is a Second Reading speech which is irrelevant and which does not arise on the entry before the House.

Comment on this

I intend to show the gerrymandering of the Minister and how it is done. There were suggestions made here that, if Cavan and Monaghan were made a five-seater, Meath a three-seater and Louth a four-seater constituency, that would be 12 seats; but Fianna Fáil would not agree with that because they know that in Cavan-Monaghan Fianna Fáil would only get two seats out of five. That would be three anti-Government Deputies. The Protestant Association might get one seat but we call them anti-Government. In Meath there will be only one Fianna Fáil seat and two others. In all probability in Louth it would go two and two. Out of the 12 seats Fianna Fáil would have five only. They are not satisfied with that. They now change it in such a way that they make Cavan a three-seater, hoping to get two and one other. They make Monaghan three hoping to get two and one other. They make Meath three hoping to get two and one other and they make Louth three. They do this instead of adopting an alternative arrangement interfering with the minimum number of people. They are not prepared to adopt this but they bring in this vindictive butchering, and now they have the possibility of more seats, but the Minister may be as far out in this as he was in the referendum. The Minister is doing it in such a way that he has now the probability of getting eight seats instead of five, and that is the thinking he has indulged in. If it were left as has been suggested, and this could be easily done without disturbing any section of the population, the Protestants would have got a seat in Cavan-Monaghan, and let it be admitted that Protestants are entitled to a seat. Labour would have got a seat in Louth if it were a four-seater constituency. Through this gerrymandering proposal the Minister is trying to ensure that, instead of five seats, the Fianna Fáil Party could get the maximum number of eight from the minimum number of votes. If the Minister were serious about this and wanted to give fair play and to cherish all the people of the nation equally—as they are often inclined to speak about at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis—then he could have set up some type of impartial board or body to deal with this vexed question. Then we or any other Party could not hurl the term we are entitled to hurl across the House today—"gerrymandering".

The Minister claims that his hands are tied by the Constitution. He stated that Fine Gael made certain that the tolerance Bill was not passed. Knowing the Party that is in power we were quite right in doing that. We know what they would have done had the tolerance Bill been passed and had they been given the power to have a Deputy for from 16,000 votes to 23,000 votes. In a Fianna Fáil constituency of 69,000 people the Minister could have four and in a constituency that was anti-Government he could have three seats, using the maximum permitted of 23,000. In a pro-Fianna Fáil constituency he could have four Deputies for 64,000 votes. Surely there is no part of the country which could trust the Government and especially the present Minister, knowing the clever politician he is.

I want to agree with Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick (Cavan) and to object to the attacks that are being made here tonight and throughout this country on the courts of this country. We should be jealous of them and respect the rights of our independent courts. If we are heading towards anarchy today it is because certain people have not respect for the institutions of this country. Any Minister of State should be in the vanguard and should lead not alone this House but this country in this respect. He should have respect for and uphold the rights of the courts of the country. It is degrading to hear a Minister bellyaching in this House about a judgement. Mr. Justice Budd was a conscientious man.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That cannot be discussed here. It does not arise.

Comment on this

The Minister dealt with this at some length. If the Minister is allowed to deal with it I will certainly reply to him and will not let him away with it.

Comment on this

I must refute the allegations made by Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick (Cavan) and Deputy L'Estrange that I have on this Bill, or the Bill proposing to amend the Constitution, cast any reflection on the High Court or on any member of the High Court or that I have at any time insulted that institution in any way. I have, for brevity, referred to the decision of the High Court as being procured by the Fine Gael Party. I cannot see how that is in any way a reflection on the High Court, or how it is in any way even an expression of opinion as to the correctness or otherwise of the decision made by the High Court. Nobody can produce from the records of debates here or anywhere else any evidence that I have ever criticised the correctness of Mr. Justice Budd's decision.

Comment on this

What are you crying about so?

Comment on this

Nobody can whinge better than Deputy Reynolds. I am not crying about anything, Deputy Reynolds. You and your Party are making every effort to delay the passage of this Bill but making no real and no sustainable criticism of any of the proposals in it.

Comment on this

There is a hungry electorate waiting for you.

Comment on this

I referred to this decision as having been procured by Fine Gael, having been extracted by Fine Gael, but I made no reflection on the court and I expressed no opinion as to the correctness of the decision. It is a fact that the High Court did not automatically of its own accord give this interpretation of an Article in the Constitution that had been interpreted in a different way from 1922 right down to that time. They did it at the behest of the Fine Gael Party. They did it because the Fine Gael Party brought an action in the courts and asked the court to declare that the interpretation of the Constitution that had always obtained in this House was not a correct interpretation. That was done through a Fine Gael Senator taking an action with a Fine Gael Deputy as a solicitor, a Fine Gael Deputy as a senior counsel and a Fine Gael Senator as his junior counsel. Therefore, I think it is quite accurate to describe this decision as having been procured by the Fine Gael Party but it is not casting any reflection on Mr. Justice Budd or on any other member of the High Court and it is not in any way a criticism of the decision that the learned judge made. We accepted the decision.

Comment on this

Pity you did not.

Comment on this

We did not appeal against it and, if we did not appeal against it, is that not evidence that we accepted his decision?

Comment on this

The Minister has become a very law-abiding citizen.

Comment on this

In 1961 we drew up a scheme of constituencies conforming to the decision of Mr. Justice Budd and the two Opposition Parties at the time attacked us for not asking the people to remove, as a former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, said, this "constitutional infirmity". We did not ask the people to do that in 1961 but when it became obvious that we would have to do something even more objectionable in the constituencies on this occasion we complied with the request that the Opposition Parties made in 1961 and asked the people to amend the Constitution so that it would have the meaning that the Members of this House had always understood it to have until Fine Gael obtained a legalistic interpretation of it by the High Court and arranged that it could not be interpreted in future in the way in which it had always been interpreted. So far from showing any disrespect for the decision of the court we have shown that we accepted it. But we did not think that the position that was then established in so far as the Constitution was concerned was a desirable position and we asked the people to amend the Constitution so that we would have permission to take account of such practical considerations as the existence of county boundaries. We accepted Justice Budd's decision and we accepted the people's decision that county boundaries are irrelevant and that county boundaries may not be taken into consideration. That is what the people decided at the request of Deputy Reynolds, Deputy L'Estrange, Deputy Hogan and all the members of the Opposition Parties and we accept the decision that they made.

Comment on this

They were afraid of you.

Comment on this

I am not surprised that Deputy L'Estrange should contradict Deputy Fitzpatrick on yet one more point. It was Deputy Fitzpatrick who was the first to say here today that the information as to how people had voted in the past and how they will vote in the future is just not available. Deputy L'Estrange disagrees with him and attacks me because I have committed the unforgivable sin of agreeing with Deputy Fitzpatrick. I agree that it is quite likely that there are more points on which I am in agreement with Deputy Fitzpatrick than there are points on which Deputy L'Estrange is in agreement with him.

Comment on this

The Minister is not in agreement with the Taoiseach. The Minister is not speaking to him. The Taoiseach will not speak to the Minister.

Comment on this

I cannot identify any two Fine Gael Deputies that agree on any subject under the sun. I wonder is there a Fine Gael Party at all? There is no evidence of it here.

Deputy L'Estrange went on to renew the Fine Gael attack on Deputy P. O'Donnell's seat in Donegal, to renew the demand that Donegal should be reduced to a five-seat constituency although he knows that this can only be done by the exporting of some of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents to the province of Connaught.

We are supposed, according to Deputy L'Estrange, to be doing this in order to obtain for Fianna Fáil the maximum number of seats out of this area. He has not told us where it will benefit us.

Comment on this

I have.

Comment on this

Will it benefit us in Cavan? Will we gain an extra seat in Cavan? Will it benefit us in Monaghan? It cannot benefit us in Monaghan because we have two seats there already. Louth is not being touched. We have two seats there already. Is it going to benefit us in Meath or in Kildare? In these five counties there are 15 seats and we will benefit in all these places according to Deputy L'Estrange. So Deputy L'Estrange, with his intimate knowledge of how people voted in the past and how they will vote in the future, claims that this is going to result in 10 Fianna Fáil seats out of these 15. I wonder, with all these new policies that Fine Gael are churning out, is it not conceivable that at some time in the future these five three-seat constituencies might return 10 Fine Gael Deputies?

Comment on this

They will this time.

Comment on this

It is going to benefit us in all these constituencies and it is also going to benefit Fine Gael and we are all going to get 10 seats out of 15.

Comment on this

You are found out.

Comment on this

I must say that, as far as I am concerned, I think it is inconceivable that Fine Gael will get a majority of the seats in these areas but I would have thought that Deputy L'Estrange would at least have pretended to think that there is some possibility that they would gain a majority in some of these areas. After all, if this is going to benefit us everywhere, then the people of the area as a whole must be in favour of Fianna Fáil.

In regard to this question of the establisment of an impartial commission I have explained time out of number that this is not permissible under the Constitution. I have also pointed out from the evidence that we have got from Fine Gael in the debate on this Bill alone that there could be no possibility, obviously, of getting any agreed recommendation from any commission on which there would be more than one Fine Gael Deputy because they cannot agree.

Deputy L'Estrange went on to repeat the argument which has already been disproved that, if the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill had been accepted by the people, what would have happened then would have been worse than what has happened now, though he knows the proposal in that Bill was to require the Government to adhere to county boundaries.

He must know there could be no question of operating the one-sixth divergence below the national average in areas where Fianna Fáil support was strongest and above the national average where opinion was against Fianna Fáil, because it was provided in the Bill that this could be operated only to take account of clearly specified circumstances, such as the existence of county boundaries.

Somehow I do not think Deputy L'Estrange was sincere in his tribute to me as being a clever politician, because he followed it up by alleging that the result of all this operation will be to reduce Fianna Fáil representation, having already said that I was attempting to increase it as a result of this. I do not think that would be any tribute to my cleverness as a politician. Deputy L'Estrange will admit that any degree of cleverness I may have I would not try to operate to the benefit of Fine Gael.

Comment on this

The Minister may try to misrepresent us in any way he can but anybody looking at the map and studying the constituencies and the different alternatives available knows well that the Minister did this in a vindictive manner—that he gerrymandered the constituencies to get the maximum number of Fianna Fáil Deputies elected in Meath and elsewhere with the minimum number of votes. One does not have to be a Member of this House to appreciate that, because even those who know nothing about politics can see it. However, this will misfire on the Minister as the referendum did.

In this House four months ago the Minister smiled across at us, thumped the bench and told us the referendum would be carried by 100,000 votes. He is as wrong tonight as he was then. He further tried to misrepresent us when he said that we had stated county boundaries should not be taken into consideration. We did not say any such thing. I do not wish to repeat what we have said about alternatives but, taking the country as a whole, we pointed out the alternatives under which there could be a disturbance of only 20,000 voters through six changes. That would be keeping within the Constitution but it might be giving fair play to other Parties in the House and Fianna Fáil do not want that.

Therefore, the Minister set out deliberately to gerrymander. It is well known that the boys were brought up to the Party rooms and that they argued and fought about this polling booth being put in here and that polling booth being put in there, and we know there were eight meetings of the Party before the Minister came to a final decision.

Comment on this

How many?

Comment on this

Something like eight different Fianna Fáil meetings. The Minister may shake his head. He told us when we were discussing the referendum that there was no division, that Fianna Fáil were unanimous. It is well known now that another Fianna Fáil Minister told them at a Cabinet meeting that the referendum would be defeated by 100,000 votes, and that they should have sense and withdraw the Bill.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Can we come to the question before the House?

Comment on this

Certainly, but the Minister wants to know is there a united Fine Gael Party. There certainly is and the Minister will know that shortly. The Minister also referred to the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill and to the commission that was to have been set up. As usual, he told only half the story. He did not tell us that the final say rested with the Deputies and that they could alter the constituencies. We know from their past record that, if Fianna Fáil are not able to get the civil servants to do beforehand what they want a commission to do, 90 per cent of the people on the commission are Party hacks, put there because of their affiliations and because of what they have done for Fianna Fáil. With the proposed constituencies commission, the Minister was trying to do the same—if he was not able to speak into the ears of the Civil Service, he would try to bulldoze the commission——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of a commission is not before the House.

Comment on this

The Minister dealt with it at length and the Chair never said a word to him. The Minister continued his disparaging remarks about the decision of Mr. Justice Budd.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise on the question before the House.

Comment on this

Am I not entitled to speak about it? I have a full page of notes and the Minister spent eight minutes talking about it. He said there were a Fine Gael Senator, a Fine Gael solicitor and a Fine Gael counsel. He did not tell us there was a Fine Gael judge.

Comment on this

I would not criticise a judge.

Comment on this

The Minister has criticised——

Comment on this

I would not call a judge a professional lickspittle.

Comment on this

The Minister said this, and if it is not indirect criticism I do not know what is: "Fine Gael arranged for a legalistic interpretation of it by the High Court". Surely, the judge of the High Court ruled in law according to the Constitution which was introduced to this country by Fianna Fáil, and if the judge ruled according to law why should the Minister come in day after day to attack his judgment? If he did not agree with the judgment why has he not come in during the past ten years with another Bill or why has he not appealed to the Supreme Court? It is time that the bellyaching from you——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

From the Minister.

Comment on this

——from the Minister about the Budd judgment stopped. The judge ruled according to the Constitution, to the law of the land. It is open to any person to take action in our courts and the courts are there to protect us from Ministers like you, thank God.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): If I may coin a phrase, the Minister appears to be suffering from Budditis and I am afraid it is spreading to this side of the House.

Comment on this

What am I suffering from?

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Budditis.

Comment on this

A disease you got from a decision of the High Court.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): It is spreading all over the House. The Minister in one respect professes that he is merely doing what the people asked for. I contend that he is not— the fundamental decision of the people was that they wanted to support PR. The Minister has been very active in this respect. He has tried to introduce as many three-seat constituencies as he can in rural Ireland. PR is generally regarded as working better in larger constituencies, in fiveseaters and so on, but the Minister has followed strictly the three-by-four rule as far as rural Ireland is concerned. He has withdrawn county boundaries. He pretends—he deliberately misinterprets —to have decided, as a result of the referendum, that the people wanted to abolish county boundaries. That issue was never put to the people and they never voted on it. It is really a bit naïve of the Minister to pretend to interpret the results in that fashion.

I have already given the Minister a solution to his problem in regard to Meath. He is giving parts of Meath to Cavan and parts to Monaghan and then he is adding on part of Kildare to Meath. I have given the Minister samples of transfers which would give him Meath as a three-seat constituency, which is what he wants, leaving the other counties more intact than his proposals would leave them. I suggest Meath as a three seater, Carlow-Kildare a five seater and Kilkenny a five seater. That could be done by transferring from Meath to Louth 6,644 persons, or 6,772 persons, or 6,768 persons, depending on which district electoral division he may pick out. Any of these three transfers—I have already tabulated two for him—would suffice. If the Minister would get the returns from the Central Statistics Office for the townlands, plus a map of the area from the Ordnance Survey, he could work out other transfers on somewhat similar lines. Any of these transfers would be suitable. This would allow for the return of 4,395 persons back to County Wexford. The Minister has mutilated Louth, Meath and Kildare, with a total transfer of 24,655, in order to establish the kind of constituency he is seeking to establish. I suggest he leave Meath as a three-seat constituency, in which case the transfer would amount to only 6,644 persons. In doing that he would be compensated in so far as he would have 4,398 persons reintegrated into County Wexford. If you subtract that 4,000 odd figure from the 6,644 you get a net transfer of 2,246. That is an extraordinary figure compared with the Minister's transfer figure of 24,655.

Surely there is something here demanding explanation instead of the stereotyped reply the Minister has been giving for the last three or four hours about the referendum and the High Court judgment? These seem to have become obsessions with him. When the Minister is stuck he falls back on them, flogging away at them. He has given no real answer to the arguments I have put up. To say that making Cavan-Monaghan a five-seat constituency would be an impossible arrangement is not borne out by the facts. We have had bigger constituencies and they were managed. This would obviate the tremendous exodus of people from Louth northwards— from Louth to Cavan 5,656, from Meath to Monaghan 6,426, from Louth to Monaghan 7,532 and from Kildare to Meath 5,041. That gives a total population of 24,655. The transfer I suggest would give a total figure of 6,644 and, with the return of 4,398 back to Wexford, the net transfer would be 2,246 as against the Minister's 24,655. The Minister's transfer rate is more than ten times mine.

I do not know where logic begins or ends. There certainly does not seem to be much logic here when the Minister spends the time babbling away about the judgment of Mr. Justice Budd, the appalling behaviour of Fine Gael, their inconsistency, their lack of this, that and the other, their stupidity at one moment and their cleverness at another moment. I want a simple answer. I have given him an alternative. The final opinion on population transfer would come best from the people affected. I have given the Minister the alternative. I have given him the district electoral divisions he can transfer. He has his little red book. He can look up the possible transfers from Meath to Louth. I have given him five district electoral divisions— Grange, Mellifont, Saint Mary's, Julianstown and Stamullen. If he does not like that, he can take Mellifont, Saint Mary's, Julianstown, Stamullen and Ardcath. If he does not like these he can take the last four—Saint Mary's, Julianstown, Stamullen and Ardcath. Any of these could be transferred from Meath to Louth, leaving Louth a four-seater, Meath a three-seater, Cavan-Monaghan a five-seater, Carlow-Kildare a five-seater—it was a five-seater years ago—and then transfer back that area of Carlow-Kilkenny with 4,000 odd people to Wexford, giving a net transfer figure of 2,246 as against the Minister's 24,655.

The Minister is able to add and subtract. Nearly all the Ministers here are able to do that. I am sure the Minister will be able to do the sum. Can he give us any logical answer? Would he stop talking about Mr. Justice Budd for five minutes and the referendum for another five? If he would he might be able to spare five minutes giving us a logical answer.

Comment on this

If I refer to the decision of Mr. Justice Budd once again it is because Deputy L'Estrange has insisted on making the ridiculous allegation, an allegation he knows to be false, that I have in some way cast a reflection on the decision of this eminent judge of the High Court. If Deputy Hogan would sit in the House for even half an hour at a time rather than hopping in and out like a jack-in-thebox like every other Fine Gael Deputy, he would know that I have never referred to this matter except in reply to false allegations made by various Fine Gael Deputies coming in here in relays. I want once again to refute the allegations made by Deputy L'Estrange that I have in any way cast any reflection upon the decision of the learned judge, or the motives that prompted such a decision. They continue to raise it and I intend to refute it every time it is raised.

Deputy L'Estrange said these proposals are made in order to get the maximum number of Fianna Fáil Deputies elected and, in the next breath, he said the result will be that there will be fewer Fianna Fáil Deputies here.

Comment on this

I said the people are waking up.

Comment on this

Both things cannot happen. Both results cannot be produced. With regard to the question of county boundaries, I said that Fine Gael had helped to ensure that the county boundaries could not be respected. They, with other elements, encompassed the defeat of our proposal to permit this to be done. It cannot be done now because of the result of the referendum.

In so far as the Third Amendment of the Constitution is concerned, Deputy Hogan says that the people decided to retain PR. Deputy Hogan must surely know that two separate proposals were put before the people. We originally intended to put them as one single proposal but, at the specific request of the Opposition, we divided them into two separate proposals and, of the two decisions made by the people, one was to retain the system of PR. Now Deputy Hogan says that, in making that decision, the people opted for the full theory of PR, in other words, for the larger constituencies which are necessary in order that it could operate as its inventors intended it to operate.

It is reasonable to suggest that what the people intended was to vote for something approaching the system we have had here, where constituencies have varied between three and five seats, rather than to suggest that they opted for the full PR which would, as Deputy Hogan said, involve larger constituencies. In reply to the Second Reading I said that, in fact, I did consider dealing with the revision of the constituencies on the lines of larger constituencies, and I outlined a scheme of constituencies that would, in fact, avoid the breaching of any county boundaries. I said that the only way that could be done was by joining together a number of counties in multiseat constituencies ranging as far up, I think, as 15-seat areas. I agree this could be done. I agree that would be moving more towards what was in the minds of the inventors of PR.

The system has been operated here on the basis of areas returning a much smaller number of Deputies. I think the highest ever was a nine-seat constituency, but the system the people are accustomed to at present involves constituencies with from three to five Deputies. It is reasonable to assume that it is the retention of the status quo the people opted for in the referendum. Whatever room for doubt there might be in regard to that, there is no room for doubt as to the decision they made on the proposal contained in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. That was a clear-cut proposal to amend the Constitution so that in future it would say what all Parties in this House had assumed it said up to 1961, and give to the Oireachtas a certain amount of scope to take account of the practical considerations, such as the existence of county boundaries.

Again, contrary to what Deputy L'Estrange has alleged, there was no question of the commission proposed in the Constitution Amendment Bill being comprised entirely of Fianna Fáil supporters. In fact, it was proposed to be written into the Constitution that the commission would be comprised of three Members from the Government side of the House, and three from the Opposition side, presided over by a judge whom we on this side of the House would regard as being as nearly impartial as possible. We would regard the judge as being an impartial chairman. On the other hand, the Opposition described such a chairman as being a political lickspittle.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking through his hat.

Comment on this

That is typical of the manner in which the Opposition treat the judiciary.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil had a majority in the House.

Comment on this

If I am permitted to go into that I will show again the inconsistency of the Opposition on that aspect. In 1959, when it was proposed that there should be a two-thirds majority, the Opposition wanted a simple majority and, when we agreed to their suggestion, they wanted a two-thirds majority. No one, least of all Fine Gael Deputies, knows what Fine Gael wants.

Comment on this

Talk to your own Taoiseach. Get on speaking terms with him.

Comment on this

I have explained to the House—if not to Deputy Hogan, because he goes out of the House after he speaks — on a number of occasions why I think his suggested solutions are more objectionable than the solution I put forward. I cannot help it if Fine Gael Deputies keep going in and out of the House like shuttle-cocks. I do not think I should be required to repeat everything I have said in reply to Deputy Hogan's contribution just because on this occasion he decides to condescend to remain in the House. If he wants to know why I regard his solutions as more objectionable than the proposal before the House he can read it in the Official Report.

Comment on this

Due to the fact that the Minister is saying so much about Deputy Hogan going in and out of the House, it is only fair that the Minister should have someone in the House with some confidence in him, so I will call for a quorum.

Comment on this

The Deputy must be at his wits' end to delay matters now. The only one he can keep in the House is Deputy Hogan, and I think I kept him here.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

Obviously Deputy L'Estrange has failed to get any other Fine Gael Deputy to come in to delay the passage of this Bill further. I must admit that he has done his best to get them to come in one after another and he even managed to get Deputy Fitzpatrick, the so-called official spokesman on Local Government matters, to come in for two hours, but not two hours together. He was here for a total of about two hours in short spasms and he did manage to keep the thing going for a considerable time but now the only way in which Deputy L'Estrange can protract the debate, in the vain hope that some time he may succeed in getting sufficient of his Deputies to come to the House, is to call a division and inconvenience people like my distinguished friend, Deputy Burke here.

I do not know if it is that the Deputy wants to get his people up for a division or whether he wants to delay the passage of this Bill so as to delay the likelihood of their having to face the people in the present disruptive state of the Fine Gael Party. The funny thing is that I have not much more to say in regard to these last interventions of Deputy Hogan and Deputy L'Estrange. I have explained why I consider Deputy Hogan's various solutions much more objectionable than my own. He referred himself to the extraordinary figure he produced as to the total of people being transferred and I agree it is extraordinary. It is faked.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister alleges that I am using fake figures. Personal figures may, of course, be wrong but they are not faked. Can the Minister tell me which one is faked?

Comment on this

The ones that are omitted.

Comment on this

He means the 100,000 who were driven abroad by Fianna Fáil in the last ten years, or is it the people who have voted with their feet?

Comment on this

I thought Deputy L'Estrange had gone up to Paisley.

Comment on this

The Deputy may have had more connections with him than ever I had.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): To provide a solution for his three-seat constituencies in Meath, where he alleges I am producing faked figures, he proposes to transfer from Meath to Cavan a total of 5,656. Is that a faked figure? No answer from the Fianna Fáil benches. He proposes to transfer 6,426 from Meath to Monaghan. Is that a faked figure? No answer. He proposes to transfer 7,532 from Louth to Monaghan. Is that a faked figure? He proposes to transfer 5,041 from Kildare to Meath. Is that a faked figure? When these four figures are added the total is 24,655. Is that a faked figure?

I made a much more simple proposition to the Minister. I have given him three choices of district electoral divisions that he can transfer. I have given the districts to him and the population of each and he has his little red book there if he wishes to check. Leaving Meath a three-seater and transferring 6,644 he can end up with Meath as a three-seater, Louth as a four-seater and Carlow-Kildare as a five-seater. By that manoeuvre he can transfer back 4,398 persons from the Carlow-Kilkenny part of Wexford. These are Wexford people who are in the administrative area and who are under the administrative council of Wexford and they have now been put into Carlow-Kilkenny. If that figure of 4,398 is subtracted from the transfer from Meath to Louth, a net figure of 2,246 will be got and that is a net displacement of persons as against the Minister's figure of 24,655.

It is very easy for the Minister to get up and say these are all fake figures. I have given them to him now again and he is working there assiduously with his little pencil. By the time he has done these additions and small subtractions I presume that he will be able to stand up and give us some concrete proof of his allegations that these figures are faked and that he will depart for once from talking about Mr. Justice Budd, who is the only man he has been talking about since he came in here today. He has accused me of popping in and popping out. I have been out of this chamber on one occasion to meet the Minister for Finance's secretary and I have been out to have one meal. Yet he accuses me of popping in and out every five minutes. The Minister should have his stop watch here if he is making allegations like that so that he can take a note of the times I go in and out.

If we pop out we are doing the wrong thing and if we pop in we are giving fake figures, so I do not know how we are going to please the man. He will now have an opportunity of getting up and substantiating the allegations he has made about the fake figures. I have repeated to the House just what I said a short while ago and now we can hear his reply.

Comment on this

There are more ways than one in which Deputy Hogan can fake his figures. What he is doing is giving incomplete figures.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): How are they faked?

Comment on this

The figure to which I referred and that the Deputy described as an extraordinary figure was his final figure. I say the figures are faked because they are incomplete. They are completely selective. First of all, the Deputy makes no reference to the disruption in Monaghan. There is no reference to disruption in Carlow-Kilkenny, although when his colleague, Deputy Esmonde, put forward the same suggestion that Deputy Hogan is putting forward now and I asked him if he had his colleagues' support in this, he very promptly said no, he had not; this was his suggestion. That is the thing that makes it difficult to argue with Fine Gael: Deputy Sir Anthony Esmonde has his solution; Deputy Hogan has about 20 different solutions. Deputy L'Estrange has his solution and the Deputies Belton have a solution which nobody else apparently agrees with — at least I could not get anybody else to agree with it—that is, to take away a seat from rural Ireland and transfer it to Dublin. I do not know whether Deputy Hogan agrees with that. When I ask is there anybody who can talk on behalf of Fine Gael, Deputy L'Estrange says yes, they can talk on behalf of Fine Gael in relation to their own constituencies. I do not know how many Deputies Fine Gael have at present— they will have fewer after the next general election—but apparently they all have different solutions.

Comment on this

You will certainly have fewer after the next election.

Comment on this

We could not comply with all these different solutions. I do not think there is anything more I can say unless Deputy Hogan really wants me to repeat what I have already said during his many absences from the House. I do not say that he went out every five minutes; every half hour, and he is due to go out now any time. There are different points of view about when a population has to be transferred. Deputy Hogan thinks the whole objective should be to minimise the number transferred so that the people transferred will form an insignificant part of the constituency into which they are transferred. There is another point of view that it is a better solution, a less objectionable solution, to transfer a sizeable portion of the people from one county to another when such a decision is inevitable so that they will form a significant part of the electorate in the constituency into which they are transferred and therefore be able to command reasonable attention from whatever Deputies are elected for the constituency.

I have admitted that there are innumerable ways in which this whole problem could be solved. There are obviously as many ways as there are Fine Gael Deputies; I think there are more than as many ways as there are Deputies in this House. It might be presumptuous to say that this is the best way. I do not know. I have not examined every possible way; I have not discovered every possible way; but I am satisfied that this is a less objectionable way than any of the innumerable ways that have been put forward by different Fine Gael Deputies.

Comment on this

I want to come to the defence of Deputy Hogan and to say he is a conscientious Deputy. If the Minister's Government were doing their duty and draining the land and rivers in South Tipperary, it would not be necessary for him to go on a deputation with people to the Minister for Finance. If he has to go on such a deputation it is completely wrong that the Minister for Local Government should blame Deputy Hogan for not being in the House. He certainly cannot be in two places at the one time. The Minister blames Deputies who come in and are popping up and delaying the business; then he blames them if they go out. What does the Minister want?

The Minister has talked a lot about faked figures. He talked about minimising the number of people transferred. If he has a pencil on him now he can take the following figures from me and tot them up. I will demonstrate to him how, by making only one transfer of 8,568 people, he can still have working constituencies and keep within the Budd judgment, which he seems to have on the brain all night, and keep within the constitutional limits laid down by that judgment. The Minister has stated there are two alternatives, but we believe that the Minister's scheme has been drawn up for one reason and one reason only, that is, to gerrymander the constituencies, to get the maximum number of Fianna Fáil Deputies for the minimum number of votes.

In the Minister's scheme he is transferring 5,041 from Kildare into Meath; he is transferring 3,829 from Meath to Cavan; he is transferring 1,827 from another portion of Meath to Cavan; he is transferring 3,950 from Meath to Monaghan; in another area he is transferring 5,700 from Louth to Monaghan; and in another area he is transferring 1,837 from Louth to Monaghan. That makes a total in the region of 22,000 people. That scheme interferes with and crosses the boundaries of four counties and makes six transfers of 22,000 people. By a very simple operation, leaving Cavan and Monaghan a five-seater and Meath a three-seater, and transferring part of Meath—one block of 8,568 votes— into Louth and making Louth a fourseater, he will still keep within the limits of the number of people that should be in each constituency laid down in the Budd judgment. There is one transfer of 8,000 people instead of the Minister's transfer of 22,000. If that is not a case of gerrymandering in order to try to get the maximum number of Deputies, I do not know what is.

Comment on this

I wish to protest against the constant repetition by the two Deputies over there. Since I came into this House a while ago I have heard the exact same speeches as I heard last Wednesday.

Comment on this

From the Minister.

Comment on this

From the Deputy. The only thing the Deputy did not bring in this time was the Protestant Association.

Comment on this

They did that half an hour ago. He said he would be back to it again. In about ten minutes he is due to go back to it.

Comment on this

I want to protest against the holding up of this House. I have seen what happened. Deputy L'Estrange has been running around for the last two hours searching every hole and corner of this House to see if he could get even ten Deputies of his own Party to agree with him, and he could not get them. Therefore, these two Deputies have adopted the tactic of deliberately wasting the time of the House. A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, what about putting a stop to it?

Comment on this

I should like to respectfully second what may esteemed colleague, Deputy Corry, has said. I should like to support him. We received here this evening a lecture from Deputy Dillon in connection with the dignity of Dáil Éireann. He made a histrionic and dangerous speech in the context of the present industrial situation. He asked us not to abuse the dignity of the House. We also received a lecture from the Leader of the Opposition in the same context—the uses to which Dáil Éireann should be put. As a comparatively young Deputy here I would like to respectfully suggest that the people who are bringing this House into disrepute—and I mention Deputy L'Estrange in particular because he is bringing this House into disrepute by these delaying tactics—should refrain. I do not know the reason for the delay. The Fianna Fáil Party have been accused in the past of holding up the working of this House. Surely this is a perfect example of the delaying tactics that are now being used by the Fine Gael Party? This Electoral (Amendment) Bill has been going on for a number of days. The Minister at all times has been willing to let this Bill go through straight away and up to the Seanad. There is no question of this at all.

During the course of this debate whatever Deputy L'Estrange thought he might gain by it he brought in the question of religious bigotry and said that the Minister was in some fashion gerrymandering the constituencies to suppress the Protestant citizens of the Republic of Ireland. I think it is an intolerable and disgraceful thing that this matter should be brought up here. Coming from a constituency with a predominantly Protestant community I should like to say that the Fianna Fáil Party stand for the whole community regardless of religious background. It is deplorable that this debate should be used to bring these matters to the attention, particularly, of those people who want to run down our nation. A comparison here between this part of the country and Northern Ireland is intolerable. What it has to do with this particular Bill defeats me. I would ask Deputy L'Estrange and any other member of the Fine Gael Party if they are serious about this Bill going through to let the talking stop.

I should like to support my esteemed colleague, Deputy Corry, in this matter. It is a deplorable abuse of this House. The sooner the Parties in this House come together to stop this abuse in the interests of the House and in the interests of the nation the better.

Comment on this

I want to point out to Deputy L'Estrange that, far from blaming Deputy Hogan for going out of this House, I am blaming him for coming back and demanding that I repeat everything I said while he was out. I do not think, as Deputy Andrews has said, that it is treating the House with proper respect to go out when he has concluded making his ridiculous charges and then come back later and ask me to repeat my replies to them. In regard to these figures of disruptions he has been quoting here, where we differ is that I maintain it is the total disruption of people in the traditional pattern of representation that is the most relevant factor. Two large straggling constituencies along the Six Counties border of Cavan and Monaghan have never been joined together. I do not believe such a joining together would produce anything like a homogeneous type of constituency.

Similarly the counties of Carlow and Kilkenny have been joined together for a considerable time. There is an obvious disruption of the traditional pattern of representation and of the constituency alignment of the people involved in what is suggested with regard to that area. What we are trying to do in this area is to retain five constituencies that have been there always, or practically always, in so far as it is possible to do so without breaching the Constitution and to retain a Cavan constituency, a Monaghan constituency, a Louth constituency, and a Kildare constituency. I am satisfied there is not any other reasonable way in which that can be done and still comply with the Constitution.

Deputy Corry has been complaining that he heard last week these speeches of the Opposition Deputies that are here at present. I have heard them numerous times—last Wednesday, last Thursday and today—repeating the same speeches over and over again. I have seen Deputy L'Estrange's frantic efforts to keep this debate going from a different angle than Deputy Corry. Deputy Corry has been able to see him during his absence from this House tearing round the nooks and crannies of the House and frantically trying to get the Fine Gael or Labour Deputies to come in here. I have seen him in operation here. So far as Deputy L'Estrange is concerned, I have only seen him relaxed at one period—when he thought he had at last nailed down Deputy Fitzpatrick safely in the House and that he could now relax in the confidence that Deputy Fitzpatrick would keep this going. Eventually he reverted to his previous frantic state when even Deputy Fitzpatrick rebelled against the Whip and decided he was having no more of it. Deputy Corry saw Deputy L'Estrange around the House making the Deputies come in here to delay things either until such time as he could get sufficient of his Deputies to attend the House so as to have some kind of respectable muster for a division on the Bill in order to lend some credence to this pretence that there is really serious discontent in the Fine Gael Party with regard to what is proposed, or for the other reason that I have suggested which is that the Fine Gael Party are in such a state of disruption themselves at present that they want to delay the passage of this Bill which is for the purpose of ensuring that the constituency arrangements for the next general election comply with the requirements of the Constitution.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister that the Fine Gael Party are in no state of disruption. We would not like to be in the state of disruption of the Fianna Fáil Party where the Minister for Local Government is not talking to the Taoiseach and the Taoiseach is not speaking to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. I am sorry for Deputy Andrews because he was brought in from his tea or from having a stroll round. He was not in the House for long. He came in and gave us a lecture in this House. We on this side of the House since the foundation of the State have always stood for law and order.

Comment on this

Governor Wallace in America also stands for law and order.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage we are talking about the Schedule to this Bill.

Comment on this

If Deputy Andrews is allowed to make a personal attack on me——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy L'Estrange will have to relate his remarks to the entry in the Bill.

Comment on this

I was speaking on the gerrymandering that was taking place. I am not going to listen to a lecture from relatives of those who tried to tear down the democratic institutions of this State in the past.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will confine his remarks to the constituency of Meath.

Comment on this

As an Opposition Party, when we see a Government continuing and carrying on gerrymandering — the vicious butchering of a constituency for political reasons and for nothing else—we are entitled to come in here and place before the House alternative proposals. Deputy Hogan has put alternative proposals before the Minister. There is no need for me to put the same proposals Deputy Hogan put. We are making proposals that would meet with the judgment of Mr. Justice Budd, which the Minister has got on the brain all day and not only today but on last Thursday, last Wednesday and during the whole debate on the referendum——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I would direct the Deputy's attention to the fact that his remarks must be addressed to the Chair.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government, who talks about delaying tactics, has spoken on one occasion for seven hours, on another for five hours and on another for four hours. It is a pity Deputy Andrews was not here today. He states that the Bill is being delayed. Deputy Boland came in here today and bitterly complained that he was not given enough time by the Whips to reply to the debate; that he wanted more time and was entitled to more time and that if he had got it he would have explained more fully what was at the back of Fianna Fáil's mind. We all know what is at the back of their minds.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must relate his remarks to the constituency of Meath.

Comment on this

As far as Meath is concerned, we know that by swiping off a very small portion of Meath and transferring 8,000 votes into Louth, Louth could have been made a four-seat constituency. There was no necessity then to interfere with Meath. The remainder of Meath would have formed a three-seat constituency, Longford-Westmeath a four-seat constituency and Cavan-Monaghan a five-seat constituency.

In reply to Deputy Andrews, if he had been here he would have heard the Minister for Local Government accuse us, due to the judgment in 1960, of depriving the Protestants of representation in Donegal. From the foundation of this State we have cherished all the children of the nation equally. Never at any time in the history of this State did we try to take from them their legitimate rights.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is out of order.

Comment on this

I may be but the Chair allowed Deputy Andrews to get up here and for ten minutes make a personal attack on me.

Comment on this

That is not true. I made no personal attack on the Deputy or anybody else.

Comment on this

The Deputy said I was bringing this House into disrepute.

Comment on this

That is not a personal attack.

Comment on this

I want to say that, as far as I am concerned, at any time I will come here as long as I am a Member of this House and, if there is gerrymandering taking place in Meath, Louth, Monaghan or any of these constituencies, I will point out to this House and to the people of the country what is happening.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has now made his point.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister has taken me to task on the point that I have come in here and asked him to repeat his reasons for making certain constituency arrangements. I was on a deputation after Question Time regarding flooding in South Tipperary and, when I came to the House immediately after the deputation was over, the House was discussing the question of Mayo. At that stage I asked the Minister why it was necessary to alter Mayo from being a constituency of North Mayo and a constituency of South Mayo as it traditionally was, to being a constituency of East Mayo and West Mayo. I accepted the fact that it was necessary by virtue of population shrinking and the question of Ballaghaderreen to make it a six-seat constituency because that was under some question here but I did not understand why it should be necessary to——

Comment on this

Am I to go back to Mayo, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would hope that there would be no return to a constituency that has been disposed of.

Comment on this

The Chair will realise that I must reply to Deputy Hogan.

Comment on this

You will reply whether he realises it or not.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister mentioned then that he had given some indication——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I take it that what the Deputy is doing at the moment is giving an explanation in regard to his absence from the House? The Chair would appeal to the Deputy to come to the question of Meath.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I am merely dealing with the matter because the Minister took me to task for asking him to repeat himself. That was the only occasion on which I mentioned something which apparently had been dealt with before so I think it was unfair of the Minister to say that I have been putting him to the trouble of repeating himself. As a matter of fact he has a penchant for repeating himself. It does not require any stimulus from me to get the poor man to repeat himself. He has been doing it continuously since three o'clock.

He accuses us on this side of the House for not having unanimity in our proposals and in the next breath he says that there are several alternative methods of doing this. He cannot have it both ways. I agree that there are several alternative methods. In regard to Meath, apart from the Minister's suggestion which I think is ridiculous, I gave him three different methods of doing it and one could multiply those three several times and any other Member on this side of the House could get up and with a slight modification of the three methods I have given could give several other methods. They would all be reasonable and superior to the methods suggested by the Minister. Therefore, I do not think he is making much of a point when he accuses us of offering different solutions as he calls them and not having unanimity of opposition. The very nature of this measure means that there are several alternatives.

Comment on this

143 to be exact.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy fail again? He got one Deputy the last time. That was his most successful trip in a long time.

Comment on this

I tried to wash the sleep out of my eyes.

Comment on this

He has only three Fine Gael Deputies in the whole House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Hogan on Meath.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I am merely trying to point out to the House that there is more than one alternative. There are several and it is quite pointless for the Minister to make an issue of this matter that because each Deputy does not say exactly the same thing therefore they are all wrong. There are several good alternatives and any of the ones that have been mentioned are better than the Minister's.

Comment on this

I agree on a number of occasions with Deputy L'Estrange and Deputy Hogan that there are many different alternatives and, in my opinion, the proposals before the House are the best that we have heard so far. I think it is reasonable to expect that a group of people who describe themselves as a political Party should make a decision in regard to some definite proposal rather than that they should all have different proposals and expect me to deal in detail with each and every one.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I wonder would the Minister accept them though?

Comment on this

If you propose a better one, but the Deputies opposite have not done so and what is more they have not produced an agreed one. They have not produced one that they can agree upon themselves. I want to point out to Deputy Andrews, not to Deputy L'Estrange, that my reference to what Fine Gael did with regard to Donegal was purely in refutation of the previous attempts on the part of Fine Gael Deputies to introduce this despicable tactic of sectarianism into the debate.

Comment on this

The Minister was suckled on it.

Comment on this

Occasionally I have to refer to the constitutional position. Deputy Hogan now demands that I go back to deal with Mayo again. Since he cannot stay in the House, I should ask him to read the Official Report in connection with Mayo. Having regard to all he said about Mayo and to his industry, I am surprised that Deputy Hogan refrained from dividing the county into two three-seaters on the basis of east and west. That, however, was not the only occasion on which he asked me to repeat myself. He has been doing that in regard to all constituencies. I suggest that he reads my reply to his proposed solution in the Official Report.

Comment on this

There is little use in me putting up alternatives to the Minister. We have done so. We have given him figures. Deputy Hogan has given a figure but the Minister's solution would change ten times as many people as Deputy Hogan's. Fianna Fáil having a majority in the House, it does not matter how good our alternatives are, the Minister will bulldose his own proposals through. Though we admit this is unfair and unjust, there is little use in our discussing it further because the Minister is not willing to give way to commonsense, justice and fair play.

Comment on this

Because Deputy L'Estrange admits Fine Gael cannot agree on a proposal, it is just as well to stop talking about it.

Comment on this

I want to point out that, as far as the entry in regard to Meath is concerned, I have given figures. I asked the Minister if he had a pencil with which to write them down. I do not know whether he did so. The Minister's figures represent six changes and the switching of 22,084 people.

Comment on this

That is the fourteenth time the Deputy has said that.

Comment on this

We have given him an alternative which would mean switching only 8,000 people. Any of our alternatives is fairer and more just to the people concerned, but it is not suitable to Fianna Fáil. What is uppermost in the Minister's mind is to get for Fianna Fáil the maximum representation in Meath, Monaghan and Cavan. He is not interested in alternatives. The Minister could have chosen one which would avoid disruption and displacement of thousands of people; but all he is concerned with is to get maximum representation for Fianna Fáil by gerrymander, by the twisting around of constituencies and the crossing of county boundaries. Thanks be to God, the Irish people have become much more intelligent than they were. They have proved it in the Presidential election, in the local elections and in the referendum. Let the next election come when it may, it will prove that Fianna Fáil are in a minority in the people's regard. The people have lost confidence in them.

Comment on this

I have not denied that either Deputy L'Estrange or Deputy Hogan has given me a number of different solutions. One, at least, was a fairly complete one but I do not know if the others were. The others seem to be piecemeal but no doubt Deputy Hogan has ability to dovetail them into some composite arrangement. I will assume that, but I have continually stated that there is no limit to the number of possible arrangements. There are a great number of them but Fine Gael have not put forward any alternative solutions. The Party do not agree. There are only two of them in the House at the moment and even they cannot agree on a solution. Last Wednesday, Deputy L'Estrange achieved the incredible result of actually getting six Fine Gael Deputies together and they produced six different alternatives. How can we choose between them? We have come down in favour of the arrangement now before the House. There is as much dissatisfaction with it, from the personal point of view, among Deputies on this side as there is among Fine Gael Deputies.

Comment on this

Now is the Minister not contradicting himself?

Comment on this

Deputy Corry is displeased with his constituency, Deputy Dowling is displeased with his, Deputy Millar is displeased with his. Of the eight Fianna Fáil Deputies here, at least four are displeased.

Comment on this

Deputy Millar has announced he is not going forward. The Minister does not know what is happening in his Party.

Comment on this

Therefore, 50 per cent of the Fianna Fáil Deputies here at present are dissatisfied with their constituencies. We know from Deputy L'Estrange that he is personally dissatisfied with his. Of the Fine Gael Deputies present, therefore, there is a maximum of 50 per cent discontented with their constituencies. Indeed, there may be 100 per cent of them because Deputy Hogan has not said he himself is satisfied.

Deputy L'Estrange contends that the whole operation in so far as this area is concerned is to get the maximum Fianna Fáil representation in those five counties. Either there is majority support of Fianna Fáil or there is not. There are five counties concerned and we propose to have five three-seat constituencies, one in each county. I agree with Deputy L'Estrange it is inconceivable in the foreseeable future that these five counties or any other group of counties would ever return a Fine Gael majority. I confidently expect there will be a Fianna Fáil majority returned under this or any other scheme of constituencies. This scheme is the one which is least objectionable of the many presented to me so far.

Comment on this

If the Minister is not trying to gerrymander, will he tell us why it is that in Connacht and in Ulster wherein the referendum——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are dealing with Meath.

Comment on this

I shall deal with Meath and we are entitled to discuss Monaghan and Cavan. Will the Minister say why in the places where in the referendum Fianna Fáil got from 43 per cent to 45 per cent of the votes they are having three-seat constituencies and in Dublin where they were annihilated, getting only 29 per cent of the poll, they have four-seat constituencies?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

May I remind the Deputy again the result of the referendum is not relevant.

Comment on this

Is it not gerrymandering? I heard the confident Minister who sits over there before the referendum; he was as confident before the referendum about the result of the referendum as he is now about the next general election. He said they would win the referendum by 100,000 votes. He talks about the people on this side of the House. We have a Party meeting going on at the moment, a meeting we are quite entitled to have——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is not relevant on the Schedule.

Comment on this

We are discussing Meath. For the last two hours, until the bells rang, there was not a single Fianna Fáil Deputy in the House, with the exception of the Minister, and the Minister could get nobody to take his place this evening because nobody was prepared to sit in there and do the Minister's dirty work,

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That has nothing to do with the Schedule.

Comment on this

From three o'clock until ten the Minister was not able, despite being in touch with the Fianna Fáil Whip, to get another Minister, or even a Parliamentary Secretary, to take his place and do his dirty work.

Comment on this

The Minister is able to do his own job.

Comment on this

I have seen the Fianna Fáil Whip talking to him and the Minister has not been able to get anyone to come in here and sit here in his place. He is a one-man Party.

Comment on this

I dealt with the situation in Dublin when it was relevant. Apparently it did not penertrate as far as Deputy L'Estrange. That must have been during one of the occasions when Deputy L'Estrange was running around Lenister House trying to get Fine Gael Deputies to come in here and speak. I do not propose to convenience Deputy L'Estrange by dealing once more with the situation in Dublin. I should like to point out that the allegation that, because we got 43 per cent of the votes, in the referendum in certain areas, we decided to have three-seat constituencies is quite ridiculous. The referendum results were in relation to two specific proposals to amend the Constitution. Now, in case Deputy L'Estrange does not know it—maybe Deputy Hogan would explain it to him —43 per cent of the votes in a three-seat constituency would mean one seat, not two. If we have 43 per cent of the votes and if, as the Deputy and the Fine Gael Party say, the Labour Party have cut themselves off from support in such constituencies, then Fine Gael must get the remainder of the votes and, therefore, in these three five-seat constituencies Fine Gael will get ten seats.

Comment on this

With the help of God.

Comment on this

Surely Fine Gael does not expect to get more? What better arrangement could we make for Fine Gael than to provide them with the opportunity of getting this majority in that area? The fact of the matter is that a preponderance of three-seat constituencies makes it reasonably possible for some Party to get a majority and I agree with Deputy L'Estrange that that Party is most likely to be Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Why did Fianna Fáil not have that in 1961 when they had only 12?

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I shall deal with just one point raised by the Minister——

Comment on this

The Minister said he would start a new Party if Fianna Fáil did not abolish the Bordere.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Deputy Hogan is in possession.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister stated that no alternative system has been proposed from this side of the House. For the benefit of those Deputies who have been so conspicuously absent from the other side of the House, I think it is only proper that I should contradict that allegation absolutley. The extraordinary thing is that most of the suggestions and the majority of the speeches have come from this side of the House. The Minister accused us of trotting in and out every half-hour. During my time here I have heard very few contributions to the debate from the far side of the House and I am not aware that a single Fianna Fáil Deputy has made any suggestion so far to the Minister. Certainly, if they did so, it has escaped me. There are Ministerial amendments and any suggestions in relation to these amendments have come from this side of the House.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I take the Minister to task on his allegations that no alternative propositions have come from this side of the House. Along the western seaboard, including Donegal and Clare, I suggested a transfer of population of 9,000.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

May I remind the Deputy again that we are dealing with Meath?

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I am refuting the Minister's suggestion that no alternative proposals were made. I am pointing out that we made detailed alternative proposals. We have given him a transfer of population. The Minister has transferred a population of 101,000. The proposals put forward by us show that we could do a better job here with a transfer of 21,000. That is our transfer figure over the entire country. It is one-fifth of what the Minister proposes. In my opinion the Minister's proposal is gerrymandering. There is no other interpretation.

Comment on this

With regard to the suggestion that Fianna Fáil Deputies were not here while we were discussing Meath, I say they were here and they heard everything the Opposition had to say about Meath in the first half hour of the debate. The did not have to stay here to listen to Deputy L'Estrange and Deputy Hogan and everyone else. Fianna Fáil Deputies heard all that Fine Gael had to say in the first half hour. There was no reason why they should stay here.

Deputy Hogan is not serious surely when he alleges that I said there was no alternative produced from that side of the House. If he looks back over the debate he will see that on every occasion on which I spoke I admitted there were many possible alternatives. Indeed, so far as the Fine Gael Party were concerned, there were obviously as many alternatives as there were Deputies. What I have been complaining about is that I cannot get a concrete alternative from Fine Gael.

Not only can Deputy L'Estrange not agree with Deputy Hogan, but Deputy Hogan cannot agree with himself, because he has put forward I do not know how many different alternatives. I have not counted them. I do not think he knows himself. He has a different one every time he gets up to speak. This is just typical of Fine Gael. They cannot agree on anything. No wonder they have to have all those Party meetings. Deputy Dowling has given us the sad news that there have been more threatened resignations. I appeal to Fine Gael not to break up because we like to have some kind of Opposition here, even if it is an Opposition that cannot agree on any subject under the sun.

Comment on this

Is the Minister speaking to the Taoiseach? Will he tell us?

Comment on this

I want to congratulate Deputy L'estrange on succeeding in getting another Fine Gael Deputy to come in.

Comment on this

It took the bell to bring in the Minister's supporters.

Comment on this

His efforts have been reasonably successful today. He has finished up today with a total of four. After all the running up and down the stairs and in and out of the House, he has acheived the reamrkable total of four. I can see Deputy Dillon preparing to move the adjournment again today as he did on the last occasion we were discussing this. Apparently that is his function——

Comment on this

No better man to do it.

Comment on this

——in these Fine Gael deliberate delaying tactics, this effort by the Fine Gael party to prevent the enactment of this legislation——

Comment on this

Have we not got great patience to listen to him?

Comment on this

——to prevent the way being prepared for a general election. I can quite understand that, with the state of disunity that exists in Fine Gael, they must face the prospect of the forthcoming general election with more than their usual trepidation, and that is saying something.

Comment on this

The Minister should not bother about Fine Gael. He should think of the disunity in his own Party. The Minister is not speaking to the Taoiseach. He spent the past ten minutes talking about fine Gael disunity. We are united. We are quite prepared to face the people at any time. We will accept the result, and we know what it will be. I advise the Minister what it will be. I advise with the Taoiseach. Speak to him sometime.

Comment on this

Agree on something.

Comment on this

Is it not true that not one single person would take the Minister's place there today? He sent out for someone, but no one would take his place.

Comment on this

I am too interested in this to let anyone else in.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25a:

In page 12, in the second column of the entry relating to Monaghan, to delete:—"Castletown, Rathkenny, in the former Rural District of Navan".

Comment on this

He could not get five. Deputy Dillion has gone home.

Comment on this

This again is, a typical example of the gerrymandering to which the government are prepared to stoop. Monaghan and Cavan could easily have been made a five-seat constituency and the only disruption of population that minght take place, if the Government intended to interefere with a minimum number of people, would be to put 8,568 people——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that Monaghan has already been discussed with Meath.

Comment on this

Why is he holding up the House?

Comment on this

I am not holding up the House. I do not agree with your ruling. There was an agreement between the Whips, and it was pointed out to the Chair that when a constituency was being discussed the constituencies bordering on it could also be discussed.

Comment on this

We took Monaghan with Meath.

Comment on this

Up to this we were making a case against the gerrymandering of Meath constituency. We are now making the case that the Minister has also gerrymandered Monaghan and Cavan and that there was no necessity to do that. Cavan and Monaghan could have been joined together and made into a five-seat constituency. By doing that there would be no necessity to interefere with the borders of either Cavan county or Monaghan county. Those two counties have much in common. There would be only a minimal disruption of the population by taking 8,000 people from Meath and putting them in Louth. It is quite obvious why fianna Fáil did not want to do that, because if they conceded——

Comment on this

I take it the Chair is changing his ruling and that we can discuss this again.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is the Chair ruling that we cannot discuss other constituencies?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is pointing out that we have discussed Monaghan with Meath, that the entry in relation to Monaghan as amended by amendment No. 25a has been discussed already, but the Chair is awaiting any new material which the Deputy wishes to put forward and which he can discuss.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): This ruling would be applicable also to Meath. Is the Chair ruling that because the amendment was carried discussion on Monaghan is out of order?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is pointing out that the entry in relation to Monaghan, as amended, is under discussion. We do not want to have repetition of the same arguments, but there may be some new material which Deputies have to offer.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): There could be.

Comment on this

If you want new material——

Comment on this

Get a new man.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach could do with a Minister for Local Government he could speak to or direct to do something for him. We know that the Minister has refused to obey his direction on numerous occasions in the past. In any case, it might be no harm to point out to the Minister that since his Party came into office in 1932 the population of Monaghan has dropped from 61,000 to 45,000. The policy of Fianna Fáil, about which we hear so much, has driven 16,000 people out of the country. They voted with their feet because they had to emigrate to England.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not relevant to the entry we are discussing.

Comment on this

Surely if these people were driven out of Monaghan——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot discuss the movement of people or why they moved. We can deal only with the figures in relation to the entry in the Schedule.

Comment on this

There are at least two or three alternatives to the Minister's proposition, if the Minister were not so vindictive and did not want to get this vindictive Bill enacted, to make the people in Monaghan and Meath suffer because they had the effrontery, according to the Minister, to vote against his recommendation, and refused to vote for the Third and Fourth Amendments of the Constitution. We have already given numerous figures. The Minister is disrupting 9,000 or 10,000 people in this area. I do not want to go over all that was said before.

Comment on this

Not until tomorrow. He is hoping to get Deputy Fitzpatrick back tomorrow.

Comment on this