We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–128 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 35 of 1968 ›

Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange reported progress.

Comment on this

I was pointing out last night that this entry is another typical example of Fianna Fáil butchering and gerrymandering. I said that the Minister had at least two other alternatives which would have avoided this ruthless butchering of constituencies. I do not think it is necessary now to occupy the time of the House by going back over all the facts and figures we produced to the Minister yesterday evening. We know they have a majority in the House and that it is their intention to bulldoze this Bill through.

At the same time, it might be no harm to point out to the House and to the people of the country that when Fianna Fáil came into office there were 61,000 people in the County of Monaghan but in the 1966 Census the population had dropped to 45,732. During those years Fianna Fáil have driven about 17,000 people out of that county alone. Due to their mismanagement of the affairs of the nation and due to their bad government they have driven out sufficient people to have an extra seat in Monaghan. It is entirely wrong for the Minister to get up in this House and try to foist the responsibility and the blame on the Opposition Parties and on the judgement of Mr. Justice Budd. The responsibility for the fact that there are fewer Deputies in rural Ireland today rests on the shoulders of the Minister and the Fianna Fáil Party——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise.

Comment on this

——because they have driven out those people——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle ruled this out of order last night and I cannot see any reason for allowing the Deputy to continue with an irrelevant argument.

Comment on this

I have said all I want to say.

Comment on this
Kevin Boland Minister for Local Government (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange, of course, is well aware that no unnecessary butchering is being carried out. He is well aware that if it is now necessary to transfer portions of one county into another that is because he and his Party and the people in the referendum refused to accept a proposal which would make it unnecessary to do this except in cases where there would be a comparatively large deviation from the national average of population per Deputy.

He must also be aware of the stand his Party took on this matter when it was relevant. When it was proposed to do something about it the official Fine Gael attitude was that it was a matter of absolutely no importance whether a person voted in his own county or in an adjoining county. Yesterday I gave a quotation from Deputy Fitzpatrick's contribution on 28th May, 1968. I can give another quotation today from Volume 235, column 517 of the Official Report of 5th June, 1968, at which Deputy Fitzpatrick said:

I find it very difficult to believe that people have all that dislike of moving from one county to another. Really, the arguments that the Fianna Fáil Party in this House are prepared to adduce to justify these measures are amazing.

As lately as last June, Fine Gael said they found it an amazing suggestion that anyone would have any "dislike of moving from one county to another". It was because they succeeded in getting that attitude accepted by the people that we are now precluded from leaving these people to vote in their own county. Although we have a three-seat constituency based on each of these five counties still, in order to satisfy the whims of the Fine Gael Party, it is necessary to require people from one county to vote in another county.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We are now dealing with the entry in the Schedule relating to Monaghan. I readily concede that I said all I had intended to say in relation to the constituencies of Cavan, Meath and Monaghan when dealing with the entry in the Schedule relating to Meath yesterday. Apparently, for some queer reason best known to himself, the Minister for Local Government wants to drag this thing on. If he does not I must say I am quite prepared to co-operate with him. My position has always been quite clear in relation to the county boundaries. I say it is desirable to maintain county boundaries but it is not fundamental.

When we were dealing with the referendum we were dealing with something which was absolutely fundamental. We were dealing with the type of electoral system which we were going to have here. We were considering whether or not we would authorise the present Minister for Local Government to decide that as few as 16,000 people approximately would qualify for a TD in one area but that the same Minister might make the figure 23,000 in another area. Fine Gael thought that was fundamentally wrong and we told the people we thought it was fundamentally wrong. The people accepted our advice and rejected the advice of the Minister and his colleagues.

That was dealing with fundamentals. The Minister was ordered by the people, or at least his Government were ordered by the people to come in here and prepare a reasonable scheme of constituencies having regard to the decision of the people that they wanted proportional representation retained and that they wanted the constituencies defined within the decision of the Supreme Court in 1961.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I take it the Deputy is now referring to the constituency of Monaghan which is before us. This is not a general debate.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I fully appreciate that but every time the Minister gets up he has a record which he plays which says because the people said something in 1968 he has to do what he is doing now. Every time he plays that record I find it necessary to put the record right by correcting him. I am saying now it was quite unnecessary, as a result of the decision of the people on 16th October last, for the Minister to introduce here the type of monstrosity he has introduced and the type of monstrosity the Taoiseach and himself committed themselves to introduce before the referendum.

I say in relation to the constituency of Monaghan and the constituency of Meath, as amended, the Minister could have produced, had he wanted to do so, a much more reasonable scheme, much more reasonable constituencies. I said yesterday that due to the types of land and the types of farming in Monaghan and in Meath the people have very little in common. They are engaged in different types of farming and they have different types of farms. Monaghan is predominantly a pig-rearing county. It might be said that by and large pig-rearing is unheard of in Deputy Tully's county of Meath. Monaghan is largely a milk-producing area but Meath does not go into milk production at all. They have nothing in common.

I pointed out that Louth and Meath have a great deal in common from the geographical point of view and from the industrial and agricultural point of view. I suggested to the Minister it would have been much more reasonable for him to have had some such arrangement as has been outlined here between Louth and Meath and I pointed out that I had no personal axe to grind in regard to this. The Minister could quite conveniently have had the constituency of Monaghan and Cavan where from the agricultural and the land point of view the people have a great deal in common. I said that they have been operating a joint hospital board for many years and they come into contact with each other to a great extent. They belong to the same province. They are both counties of small farmers. They are both heavily engaged in pig production and milk production. Indeed, up to recently both counties went in for grass seed production which is a type of farming which is practically unheard of in the greater portion of the rest of the country with the exception, perhaps, of Donegal.

I said yesterday if the Minister wanted to be reasonable and to do the reasonable thing he could have joined Monaghan and Cavan together. Whether or not I believe the county boundaries are vital and sacrosanct there is no doubt the Minister does if we are to believe him because the Minister and the Taoiseach are on record throughout last year as committing themselves to the statement that county boundaries should not be disturbed. I am sure the Minister does not deny that that was his gospel last year, that he preached that in this House throughout most of last year and also up and down the country in conventions launching the referendum campaign. The Taoiseach did likewise.

I am sure the Minister would not say, or maybe he will say, that he is fully converted to a new belief that county boundaries do not matter at all. I have made my position clear about them. I do not believe they are fundamental. I believe if they can be conveniently retained they should be retained. I repeat that the Minister's position on county boundaries is clear or it was clear and there can be no doubt about it. Here he is, for some reason best known to himself, splitting up the county of Meath between Cavan and Monaghan. Not alone is he doing that in the entry for Monaghan, which we are now dealing with, but—outside Leitrim I do not think the like of this has happened in the country—the Minister is putting a bit of Louth into Monaghan and a bit of Meath into Monaghan and he is also putting a bit of Meath into Cavan. If the Minister wants to keep this debate going on those lines, I will certainly facilitate him.

The Minister seems to have committed an absolute somersault on the question of county boundaries. He conceded yesterday there are more ways of doing this than one. He conceded he could have constituencies by dealing with the counties Louth and Monaghan and with the counties Cavan and Monaghan and in that way there would be far less disturbance. The Minister also said that he had stated that people had no objection to being shifted about. If you transfer people from one county to another then transfer them in a direction that they would usually travel; do not transfer them in an unnatural direction.

I want to go on record as saying that to transfer people from Meath to Monaghan is to transfer them from one province to another, from one type of county to another and it is transferring them in a direction which they would normally never travel. It cannot be denied that Meath people and Louth people gravitate towards Dublin rather than towards the North of Ireland. That is the sort of complaint I am making. That is the sort of unreasonable approach to this matter by the Minister that I want to expose. I confess that I thought I had done it adequately on the Meath entry yesterday but here we have the Minister bouncing in again with the same old hackneyed arguments he made yesterday, relying on the same arguments in relation to the referendum and in relation to the decision of the High Court, neither of which hold water.

I say that it is patently obvious that the Minister sought to punish the people of the country in general because they did not accept his advice and that he thinks that, by these unnatural distortions and unnatural carving-up of counties and constituencies, he will reap some political benefit for himself by way of gerrymandering —as the Taoiseach had in mind when he wrote his expensive pamphlet The Reasons Why. It will be seen from that document that the Taoiseach warned the people that, if there was not a commission, presided over by a judge, there would be gerrymandering —and here we have it——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We seem to be getting away from the motion before the House relating to Monaghan.

Comment on this

I appreciate that, since Deputy Fitzpatrick was here for only an hour or two yesterday, he may not fully be aware that those whom he left behind to carry on this debate until such time as he would find it convenient to return to the House, repeated this same type of dishonest allegation that he gave to them as their cue in the short period he was here.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I give my constituents great attention.

Comment on this

Even if Deputy Fitzpatrick was not here to hear Deputy L'Estrange, and others whom Deputy L'Estrange was able to force into the House yesterday, he was here when Deputy L'Estrange repeated this allegation yesterday. Therefore, he knows it is incorrect to accuse me of getting up unnecessarily to repeat the refutation of these allegations that Deputy L'Estrange made at his instigation. Nobody knows better than Deputy Fitzpatrick that there is no desire on my part to drag this out. Because Deputy Fitzpatrick did not find it convenient to attend to his duties here in the House for the past two weeks, he had to obtain assistance from Deputy L'Estrange to ensure that this would be kept going until such time as Deputy Fitzpatrick would be present.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I give my constituents great attention —with tremendous effect.

Comment on this

If Deputy Fitzpatrick will look at the report of the debate which took place here yesterday he will note the strain on the resources of the Fine Gael Party yesterday in order to keep this debate going to suit Deputy Fitzpatrick's convenience.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is this relevant to Monaghan?

Comment on this

It is dealing with the beginning of Deputy Fitzpatrick's last contribution when he accused me of wanting to drag on this debate. Deputy Fitzpatrick went on to say that his position on this question of the breaching of county boundaries has always been clear. To a certain extent, I would agree with that. Certainly, during the debate on the proposal to amend the Constitution in order to permit of consideration being given to the question of county boundaries, his position was perfectly clear to me. His position, and the position of his Party, at that time was that these were matters of no account. I would say that his position now is reasonably clear to me also. His position, and the position of his Party, now is that these are matters of great account and that they should not be breached at all.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What is the Minister's view?

Comment on this

His position now is the direct opposite of what it was in May and June, 1968, and right up to October, 1968. My view, on the other hand, has not changed, My view in 1961 was the same as the view of the then Minister for Local Government— that these were matters of importance —and, in 1959, that these were matters of importance and that it was desirable to adhere to county boundaries as far as possible; that there was nothing undemocratic in having a slightly smaller population per Deputy in one county than in an adjoining county and that there was nothing so undemocratic in that as to require the uprooting of people from one county and their transfer into another. That was why my predecessor in 1959 introduced constituencies that did not do any of these anomalous things that are being done today, as in 1961. That was my view then and that was my view in May and June of last year when Deputy Fitzpatrick held the opposite view— that it was undesirable to breach county boundaries unless there would be some comparatively large difference in the population per Deputy between different areas—and that is my view now. But, in the meantime, the view that Deputy Fitzpatrick had in May and June, 1968, prevailed, and the people have endorsed it. I am accepting that view. I am introducing this Bill because the Constitution requires it.

Deputy Fitzpatrick went on to say that the referendum dealt with the electoral system. Deputy Fitzpatrick knows, of course, that that is not so. He knows that the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill dealt with the electoral system. He knows that the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill dealt with the subject that we are actually discussing here and that he recommended that the permission that we sought to exercise very small amounts of deviation from our national average, for specified purposes, be refused by the people. Deputy Fitzpatrick knows it is incorrect to say that, if that amendment was passed, the Minister could decide to utilise for Party political purposes the small amount of deviation that was proposed. He knows that the Bill proposed to write into the Constitution that this deviation could be exercised only for clearly specified reasons.

I thoroughly agree with Deputy Fitzpatrick that the Government have been ordered by the people to prepare a reasonable scheme in accordance with the constitutional provisions. That is exactly what is being done and what has to be done. I agree, again, that many alternative schemes could be produced but, in my opinion, any of the large number of alternatives that have emanated from the Fine Gael benches are more unreasonable and more undesirable than what has been put forward. Again, I agree that this is a matter of opinion. Our opinion is that the type of solution that has been put forward from the Opposition benches would be worse than this and would be attacked much more severely if it had emanated from here.

It is not true, as Deputy Fitzpatrick says, that the county of Meath has been split for some reason known only to myself. Part of Meath has been added to Cavan and part to Monaghan because the population of Cavan— 54,022—is too small for a three-seat constituency and the population of Monaghan—45,732—even when added to by the transferred population from Louth which is already there, is too small for a three-seat constituency. Deputy Fitzpatrick says that I should have tranferred the population from Meath to Dublin where they would naturally go.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this

The point is that it was Cavan and Monaghan which had a deficiency of population and not Dublin. In Dublin, the opposite was the case. It was necessary to allocate four extra seats to Dublin without transferring any population from Meath.

Comment on this

The Minister has transferred 20,000 people to Birmingham and Manchester during the past 20 years.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister is tending to cause confusion as regards this entire Bill and the thinking that is behind it. He says that he believed back in 1960 or 1961 that county boundaries were important; he says he believed it when the referendum was under discussion here and he says that he still believes it. He claims, however, that the people have given a contrary decision and that the result of the referendum may be interpreted as meaning that the people have said to him that they do not care about county or local authority boundaries and that he may go ahead and break them up as he wishes. This is the interpretation which he has deliberately put on the referendum and this is the defence that he offers for doing what he is doing now to this particular constituency and to the constituencies that we have discussed here during the past couple of days.

I disagree entirely. This is a question of interpretation of the people's decision and which is important and relevant to this Bill. The people did not say that county boundaries were unimportant. They merely refused to accept the Third Amendment which the Minister claimed was calculated to preserve the all-important county boundaries. The people did not believe the first and they took no notice of the second as a consequence. They rejected the third because they beleived that the purpose behind it was gerrymandering. The Minister has used this wrong interpretation of the people's decision to justify this gerrymandering Bill that he is now bulldozing through the House.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This dreary debate is really clarifying the position somewhat because at last we have the Minister pinned down to this point—that in 1961 he believed that county boundaries should be breached only for important reasons, that last year his opinion on county boundaries was the same and that today it is still the same. It does not matter what my opinion is but that is the opinion of the Minister for Local Government. He says that the people, on 16th October, told him to do what he is doing. The people told him no such thing. They told him to introduce a reasonable scheme of constituencies under the law as it stands. The Minister concedes that there are many ways of doing this but he picks on the most absurd one.

Comment on this

For political reasons.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He knows well that it was not necessary to have done all the butchering that he has done. We are labouring this point on this particular entry, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, because nowhere is it more evident than in relation to Meath which is tied up with the constituency of Monaghan with which we are now dealing. He cut Meath into three, part of it for Monaghan, part of it for Cavan and part of it for Meath. This was utterly unnecessary.

The next point which the Minister did not deal with in relation to my last remarks was why, if he is determined to change people from one county to another, he does not change them in a natural direction. I did not suggest, as the Minister knows perfectly well, that he should take people from the constituency of Meath and put them in Dublin. I did say that people from Louth and Meath move in that direction and what I did suggest was that a scheme for the constituency in relation to Louth and Meath should be linked up with those two counties because they are natural associates of the same province, et cetera.

Now that the Minister is doing something in this Bill in which he does not believe, we have unnecessary carving up of counties and if we find somebody doing something in which he does not believe, we must assume that he is doing it for some ulterior motive and the ulterior motive here is obviously for political party advantage. That is what was meant when the word "gerrymander" was coined around Senator Gerry from Massachusetts who wanted to get unfair political advantage for his own party.

Comment on this

There is no denying that as regards this constituency of Monaghan, the gerrymandering and the butchering that have been done there have been done for political purposes, to try to keep Deputy Childers, the Minister for Transport and Power, and Deputy Patrick Mooney in Leinster House. If we had a reasonable Minister for Local Government, out of all the alternatives which have been put to him he could have drawn up a reasonable scheme that would be acceptable to all Parties in the House. He has stated that Fine Gael proposed alternatives but that these alternatives were more unreasonable than his own scheme.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would like to draw attention to the fact that there seems to be repetition of the same argument with regard to the entry before the House.

Comment on this

The Minister has made those observations and he has got away with it. The Minister believes that if he says a thing often enough and tries to misrepresent the people on this side of the House often enough, some people may believe him.

Comment on this

The people on the other side of the House are past masters at that.

Comment on this

We could learn a lesson from you. You have a President in the Park and I remember his speech when he promised to abolish the Border and to restore the Irish language. Where are those promises today?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will have to keep to the Schedule.

Comment on this

They broke every major promise they made to the Irish people.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will have to keep to the Schedule.

Comment on this

To come back to this entry, I think it is quite reasonable for us to put forward the alternative proposals we have put to the Minister.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is not saying the Deputy has no right to do that. What the Chair is saying is that we seem to be repeating the arguments which have been made in regard to the entry.

Comment on this

We want to put before the Minister the proposal we mentioned last night when we were discussing another constituency, the constituency of Meath. We suggested that if a small portion of Meath was put into Louth and Louth made a four-seat constituency, it would be much better because we would be transferring only 8,568 people, whereas in the Minister's scheme it is proposed, for political Party purposes and none other, to get the maximum number of seats with the minimum number of votes, by transferring 22,084 people. How can the Minister tell me that his scheme, which is butchering the constituencies, which is taking in part of Meath——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would again point out that this seems to be a repetition of the arguments which have already been put.

Comment on this

Yes, when we were discussing Meath. However, if the Minister claims our scheme is unreasonable, we are prepared to put on the records of the House that we believe a scheme that would mean transferring only 8,000 is much more reasonable than the Minister's scheme which envisages the transfer of over 22,000 people.

Comment on this

I am surprised to see Deputies so much annoyed about County Monaghan. From Enniskeen to the bottom of County Cavan represents a distance of 142 miles. The distance from Dublin to Galway is 130 miles, so if you put Monaghan and Cavan together you would have a constituency far longer than from Dublin to Galway.

Comment on this

Ah, now.

Comment on this

The Deputy forgot about the Border.

Comment on this

You have forgotten about it for the last 40 years. You will never be let forget about it. The Minister has threatened to establish a second Republican Party if the Taoiseach does not do something about abolishing the Border.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Mooney is entitled to speak.

Comment on this

You need not talk about the Border. You made good use of the Border. I never smuggled anything across the Border.

Comment on this

I will tell the Deputy something if he does not shut his mouth. I know something about him, and it will not do him much good.

Comment on this

Some people grew rich.

Comment on this

Do not start that dirt or we shall talk about Belgrave Road.

Comment on this

Say anything you like.

Comment on this

The Deputy says things under the protection of the House that he would not say outside.

Comment on this

You made well out of the Border.

Comment on this

You are vulnerable.

Comment on this

The breadth of the constituency——

Comment on this

Surely the people from Monaghan have a right to have a say in the making of their own constituency? You are not denying that?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Why does the Deputy not shut his mouth? If Monaghan and Cavan were put together the breadth of the constituency would be 140 miles. That would be an excessive distance to have to travel. Some Deputies mentioned the Protestant section of the people. I have many friends among this section of the community. We would do nothing to interfere with them. That is only a political stunt of Fine Gael.

I know this whole area very well, and there is no necessity for Deputy Hogan coming from Tipperary to tell us what to do in County Monaghan. We are not interfering with Tipperary. Deputy Fitzpatrick is very keen on putting Monaghan and Cavan together which, as I say, is 142 miles long. What sense would there be in having a constituency like that? Where would the people ever get a Deputy in an area that size?

Deputy Fitzpatrick has been the cause of all this. He stood up in this House all last summer advocating that the people should vote "No" in the referendum. If he had asked them to vote "Yes" on the Third Amendment and "No" on the Fourth Amendment it would have been sensible, but he was afraid PR would be lost. They did not get any help from the Labour Party on this issue either, and so Fine Gael told the people to vote "No" on both issues. I would advise Deputy Fitzpatrick to leave Monaghan and Cavan alone. Joining them would only mean longer distances to be travelled by the people living in them in order to look for TDs when they want them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Mooney has shown a keen interest in this matter. I am very interested to know that he credits me with such powers of persuasion that I was able to carry the referendum. What puzzles me is that, if Deputy Mooney was so interested in the tolerance issue, why he did not come into the House all last summer and put his weight behind the Minister and support the proposal——

Comment on this

I did not need any support.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——which he was putting to the country.

Comment on this

The Minister did not get much.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I did not interrupt the Deputy when he was making his maiden speech.

Comment on this

I was here long before the Deputy was.

Comment on this

And he will be here after the Deputy.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He is a marginal Deputy.

Comment on this

We have two seats out of three which is more than Fine Gael ever had.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He had not half the votes in the county the last time. Perhaps that has something to do with the measure we are debating now. Deputy Mooney is talking about the difficulties of Deputies representing a constituency if it is too big. Deputy Mooney is the only resident Deputy in County Monaghan at the present time. Deputy Childers, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, resides in Dublin, as Deputy Tully told us yesterday, and Deputy Dillon resides in Ballaghderreen, and this was pointed out yesterday when Deputy Mooney was not here——

Comment on this

The Deputy was not here long himself.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Do not worry about me. I would not want to sit in the House all the time to reply to the Minister's arguments, especially when I have more important constituency work to attend to. The Minister plays the same record every time he gets up, and, having heard it once, all I have to know is whether the Minister for Local Government has spoken since I was there, because it is a certainty he will say the same thing. It was pointed out yesterday when Deputy Mooney was not here——

Comment on this

If the Deputy makes the same accusations he will get the same reply. Say something new.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister for Local Government spoke for seven hours. At any rate we were pointing out yesterday that three Deputies in Cavan all reside on the Monaghan border. Deputy Mooney is one of the Deputies who do not like work.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are not discussing Deputies. We are discussing the entry relating to Monaghan.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am entitled to answer Deputy Mooney's questions. He is one of the Deputies who do not like work.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would appeal to Deputies generally to avoid personalities in discussing a measure such as this.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am afraid——

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange had to send out for the Deputy. The Deputy was gone.

Comment on this

The Minister could not get a single Minister or Parliamentary Secretary to replace him. The Minister sent his Fianna Fáil Whip out but none of them would come to do his dirty work. They left him here from 4 p.m. to 10 p.m. yesterday.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Fitzpatrick is in possession.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If the Minister is so interested in my activities I can tell him I was on the telephone dealing with another constituency matter. I give my constituency great attention. It does not matter whether the matter is big or small.

Comment on this

It is lately it happened. There must be an election coming up.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I have put on record here that I was dealing with Meath today in relation to Monaghan and saying that it was quite unnecessary to carve up Meath in the way it is carved up. I do not know whether Deputy Mooney is of the opinion that there is something in common between Meath and Monaghan. I do not think there is. I pointed out that there is a different type of farming in each of these areas and that the people are completely different in agricultural outlook. I pointed out that, generally speaking, Meath people never gravitate towards Monaghan; they gravitate towards Louth or Dublin. I think that is a reasonable argument and that is the sort of argument I was putting up. The constituency of Meath has been unnecessarily butchered for this reason. Deputy Mooney has shown a particular interest in this matter and he is quite entitled to do so as he is a Deputy for the constituency. The mystery of it is that he did not carry on the same campaign last year. He might have been able to save the Minister from such a catastrophic defeat. The Minister and Deputy Mooney know that in the constituency of Monaghan at the last general election the Fianna Fáil Party had a minority of the votes but through some strange happening——

Comment on this

Proportional representation.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——they got two seats.

Comment on this

Proportional representation.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister still has not accepted the opinion of the people. The Fianna Fáil Party found themselves in the constituency of Monaghan in a minority with a couple of hundred votes less then the Fine Gael Party and they found it necessary to do something. Deputy Mooney is anxious to get a life-raft thrown to him in any shape or form.

Comment on this

What about Carnew?

Comment on this
Patrick Brennan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government (Mr. P. Brennan) Fianna Fáil

I had more votes than the Deputy had the last time.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Parliamentary Secretary had a close run there.

Comment on this

I had a bigger surplus.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Fitzpatrick.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Parliamentary Secretary and Deputy Mooney get annoyed about this. The Parliamentary Secretary will be busy enough looking after Wicklow. The Parliamentary Secretary has brought in here statements about Cavan and the last election. I know it is annoying but I have to refer to it. In 1961 there was a general election and, in Cavan, the Fine Gael vote was, in round figures, 7,000. There was a general election in 1965 and in Cavan the Fine Gael vote was 10,050. It went up by 50 per cent and we were within a whisker——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would appeal to Deputies to co-operate in trying to get the discussion on this matter to move forward.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I certainly will co-operate, but I want to put the record right in view of the Parliamentary Secretary's foolish interjection about this Cavan constituency. In the same contest the Parliamentary Secretary's Party lost a seat. That is the reason very particular care was given to the constituency of Cavan and the constituency of Monaghan by the Minister for Local Government in this measure. That is the very reason. I am glad it has been possible for me to say that. In my opinion they should have lost a seat at the last election. There was a minority of votes for Fianna Fáil. In Cavan they did, in fact, lose a seat. There is the cat out of the bag. Deputy Mooney wants to stay in the House and I do not blame him for that but he is taking a particular interest in this because in some way or another he sees his personal political survival depending on it.

Comment on this

Not at all. What are you getting from me?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): So far as I can hear, the Deputy and the Minister are not waiting for the Bill to become law. They are reconnoitring up there and making a gallant effort to find out all about me. They might have the common decency to wait until the Bill becomes law before they set out on that business. That was brought about by Deputy Mooney's interjection.

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, I want once again to refute Deputy Hogan's allegation that I am doing anything to cause confusion with regard to this Bill. On the contrary, the large number of people that Deputy L'Estrange has been able to coerce into coming in here on the Fine Gael side have all been putting forward their own piecemeal solutions for different parts of the country without any coordination whatever. Any confusion there may be is obviously on the Fine Gael side of the House. I have never said that the people decided in the way that Deputy Hogan said, that they decided that county boundaries should be breached or made any positive decision. The decision they made at the request of the Opposition Parties was that the Government may not operate any significant deviation from the national average of population per Deputy in order to avoid the breaching of county boundaries. Deputy Hogan knows that he is wrong when he says that there was any proposal in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill to operate a rural versus urban bias. He knows that that is not so, that the proposed small deviation from the national average of population per Deputy could only be operated to take account of clearly specified reasons and that the question of giving greater representation to rural areas as opposed to urban areas was not one of those reasons and that therefore it could not be utilised for that purpose. Knowing that to be flase he comes in here again making this deliberate false allegation because of the fact that he is benefit of any other ideas to prolong this debate and postpone the enactment of this legislation and postpone the revision of the constituencies——

Comment on this

He has plenty of ideas. He wrote a book on it.

Comment on this

——and prepare the way for the holding of the next general election in the vain hope, I suppose, that Fine Gael will be able to resolve their internal differences before that time comes and possibly even in the hope that even at this late stage they may be able to make some new rapprochement with their former coalition Parties. I think I have made it clear what my opinion is with regard to this matter of county boundaries: that they should be adhered to in so far as is possible. I have said that that opinion of mine has not changed, that county boundaries are important but the decision that has been given to me is that I may not deviate significantly from the national average of population per Deputy in order to adhere to county boundaries.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Chief Justice said otherwise.

Comment on this

In those circumstances I approached this task of revising the constituencies with the objective of breaching county boundaries only where it was required in order to achieve near equality of population per Deputy.

I have said a number of times that I agree there are many solutions but I do not think any solution has been put forward that is as reasonable and as workable as the one that we have put forward in this Bill. It is necessary now to breach county boundaries in this case because of the fact that the population of Cavan and the population of Monaghan——

Comment on this

You have driven out 50,000 from this area.

Comment on this

——are not sufficient and because of the fact that we decided that this monstrosity of a constituency, which Deputy Fitzpatrick wants for his own benefit, of Monaghan and Cavan should not be created.

I was interested to hear Deputy Fitzpatrick saying that the people of one county should be joined to other areas towards which they naturally gravitate. I do not think the people of Enniskeen naturally gravitate towards Dowra. There is no need for Deputy Fitzpatrick or anybody else to point out that I do not believe in this policy of breaching county boundaries. There is no ulterior motive involved now that it is being done in a number of cases in this Bill. The only reason it is being done is that the Constitution requires it to be done.

Deputy L'Estrange's allegation that these areas of County Meath are being added to Cavan and Monaghan for political purposes in order to regain the seat that was lost in Cavan at the last election and in order to retain the two seats that we have held for some considerable time in Monaghan is a rather peculiar allegation because the two Opposition Deputies from County Meath have claimed that these areas are the areas where they get their major support. Deputy Farrelly and Deputy Tully are both on record as saying that these areas of County Meath have been selected for extradition from County Meath because of the fact that these are the areas where they get their support. I must say I think it is a great tribute to the effectiveness of Deputy Mooney and his colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and Transport and Power, to assume, as Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy L'Estrange do now, that these traditional supporters of Deputy Farrelly and Deputy Tully who will now be voting in the county of Monaghan will naturally vote for Deputy Mooney and Deputy Childers.

Indeed, more direct evidence of that belief amongst the Fine Gael Party than what Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy L'Estrange have said is that the result of that proposal in so far as the Fine Gael Deputy for County Monaghan is concerned is that he decided not to contest the next election at all.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What about Deputy Lemass? You drove him out, according to my information.

Comment on this

If Deputies opposite can think of no other way of keeping this debate going until such time as the frantic efforts of Deputy L'Estrange over the past two weeks to get sufficient of his Deputies here for a vote are successful maybe we might reach some other arrangement that would not involve this interminable wrangling with the Chair about irrelevancy. Maybe if Deputy L'Estrange could now give an estimate of what he would consider a reasonable total of Fine Gael Deputies in the House we might adjourn until such time as his efforts meet with this small amount of success. If Deputy L'Estrange would tell us how many Deputies he wants here and when he thinks he will have them——

Comment on this

You are talking through your bloody hat. I have not been in the Party Room today. I was talking to one of the reporters outside the door who wanted some information. You are talking through your hat.

Comment on this

——we might adjourn. How many do you want? I believe you got 12 yesterday and I actually counted 15 here today.

Comment on this

You were beaten by 234,000 in the country and that is what has gone to your head.

Comment on this

If I could suggest different tactics by Deputy L'Estrange—I counted 15 here today—if he could hold them and get five or six more, would that not be enough?

Comment on this

I will mind my own business. You mind yours.

Comment on this

I suspect what they are at is what Deputy Fitzpatrick suggested Deputies Mooney and Childers are at, they are trying to get themselves known in the new constituencies that it is proposed to create and possibly they are even doing what has kept Deputy Fitzpatrick out of this House while this Bill was being debated, trying to catch up on the arrears of work for their present constituents that they should have been doing for the past three or four years. Deputy Fitzpatrick was able to spend a reasonable amount of time in the House before but now he has to be running out on constituency business that, if he managed his affairs properly, he would have finished long ago.

Comment on this

He had to travel 80 miles to his constituency last night, leaving at 9 o'clock.

Comment on this

It is quite natural that Deputy Mooney should show a keen interest in his constituency. His contribution here was quite a useful one. He demonstrated more effectively than I could the absurdity of the solutions for his area put forward by Fine Gael Deputies.

I can only say that the solid and continuous support Deputy Mooney gets in his constituency is a tribute to his continous activity on behalf of his constituents and that is why, no doubt, he can still get 5,000 more votes than Deputy Fitzpatrick can get in his constituency. It is not surprising, therefore, that Deputy Fitzpatrick is making such a desperate effort to annex another county, with which he apparently has associations, in order to improve his vote.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I will let the Minister in on a secret. Part of our object here in analysing this Bill as closely as we are doing, with particular reference to this entry, is to encourage the Minister to talk and to talk and to talk, because we know from experience that on the eve of a national contest the more the Minister talks the better it is for us. He talked in this House for months last year and the result was that his Party were defeated to the tune of a quarter of a million votes. We will have another national contest this year and I believe if we can persuade the Minister to come in here and to talk as he is doing now he will antagonise the people to such an extent that it will do us incalculable good and his Party irreparable harm.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 26 and 27 have already been discussed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 13, in the first column, to delete "Roscommon" and to insert "Roscommon-Leitrim".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:

In page 13, in the second column of the entry relating to Roscommon, to delete "Clare-Galway" and to substitute "Clare-South Galway".

Comment on this

This is most blatant. It is the worst type of gerrymander perpetrated.

Comment on this

Here we go again.

Comment on this

It is typical of a Party and a Minister who are fighting for their political survival. We know that the Fianna Fáil Party and their mohair boys are fighting for their political survival. We know, as the Minister for Agriculture told his Ard-Fheis, that many of them had not seats to their trousers a few years ago and there is no doubt they will go to any length to gerrymander constituencies to hold on to representation and to do what harm they can to Deputies who differ from them. In one part of this constituency, 1,975 voters are being put into Clare-Galway. In another area, 4,884 people are being put into North-East Galway and in another area 3,474 are being put into North-East Galway. Then, to bolster up the chances of Deputy Lenihan, the Minister for Education, the great promiser, 4,024 people are to be taken from his home town in Westmeath and put into Roscommon. The county is being mutilated to help the chances of Fianna Fáil.

At the other end of the county, Leitrim has been liquidated. It was not enough for Fianna Fáil, since they came to power in 1932, to drive more than 20,000 people from lovely Leitrim. In 1932, the population of that county was 55,907. Now, because of Fianna Fáil maladministration and bad government, the population has been reduced to 30,570, more than 20,500 of its people having gone to Liverpool, Birmingham, Coventry and other places.

In respect of this constituency, we have put forward different propositions and we have shown how, without interfering unduly with the constituencies, with only a few minor changes, Roscommon and Leitrim could have been made a five-seat constituency; a small part of Leitrim in the north could have gone to Donegal; Sligo could have been left a three-seater; Mayo could have been left a five-seater and Galway could have been divided into two constituencies of three and four seats respectively. Of course, that would not suit Fianna Fáil because when there is so much at stake—let it be learned that in the coming election there is a good deal at stake for Fianna Fáil Deputies and for the mohair boys now attached to them —Fianna Fáil have no hesitation in adopting this tactic. They are now the Party of the "haves". After the Ard-Fheis they adjourned to the Shelbourne and the Hibernian hotels.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This has nothing to do with the Schedule.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil know that if they do not get extra seats in the west some of their Deputies will have to go back and work for their living instead of, as many of them are doing at the moment, fattening like political parasites on the State. We object to the type of gerrymander that is taking place here. There is no denying that it has been done to injure Deputies Joan Burke and P.J. Reynolds. Deputy Burke is a hard working Deputy and no matter what Fianna Fáil try to do she will get back into Leinster House. Deputy Reynolds and his father and mother before him have represented the people of Leitrim truly and well. The people there know that and no matter how Fianna Fáil work against him he will be back here after the next election proud to represent his people.

Fianna Fáil have tried to put Leitrim off the map. The word "Leitrim" was not mentioned, of course, until the grass root boys and the county councillors came up and appealed to the Minister to restore Leitrim as an entity. He did not do it. The only thing he did was to put back the word "Leitrim". Despite the worst Fianna Fáil can do, Deputy Reynolds will be back here because the Irish people love justice and fair play. They love to see all of the people cherished equally.

Fianna Fáil have never hesitated to use the people's money to buy votes. In Roscommon and in every other county they are putting Fianna Fáil before the State. Their idea here, as in other constituencies, is again to get the maximum number of seats in this area with the minimum number of votes and in order to do the maximum amount of harm to the Fine Gael Deputies. The Minister told us across the floor of this House that Fianna Fáil would win the referendum by 100,000 votes. He misled his own Party and he misled the country. The people in Roscommon will not now believe him and his political intrigue and gerrymandering will be defeated in Roscommon as his proposal in the referendum was defeated.

Comment on this

What is happening in this part of the country is quite obvious. There is a movement of voting population by the Minister to the constituencies of East Donegal, South-West Donegal, East Galway, West Galway and probably also to the new Galway constituency. It is easy to understand the reason for the movement from counties like Leitrim, Sligo and Roscommon. One has only to look at the results of any general election to discover that these three counties do not give a majority vote to the Fianna Fáil Party.

The gerrymandering started in the 1961 revision. Roscommon was left as a four-seat constituency and likewise Sligo/Leitrim. East Galway was a five-seat constituency because Fianna Fáil knew they had a slender majority there and would get three seats out of five. West Galway was a three-seat constituency; Fianna Fáil got two seats and Fine Gael one. Clare was a four-seat constituency and there the Fianna Fáil Party got two seats, Fine Gael one seat and Labour one. Now this constituency has been gerrymandered by moving portion of it into Galway and this is done in order to deprive the Labour Party of their seat in Clare. North-East Donegal was a three-seat constituency returning two Fianna Fáil Deputies and one Fine Gael Deputy. In South-West Donegal, again a three-seat constituency, there were two Fianna Fáil Deputies and one Fine Gael Deputy.

The people rejected the Minister's proposal for the straight vote. I do not agree with Deputy Mooney that it was Deputy Fitzpatrick who got the people to reject that proposal; Deputy Mooney said Deputy Fitzpatrick got the people to reject it because he talked so much in this House. I do not think that is the reason they rejected the proposal. I believe the proposed amendments were defeated because the people were afraid of the Minister for Local Government and they were not prepared to give him that kind of power. He comes in here now and he tells us that he does not want to interfere with county boundaries and he does not want to breach boundaries except where there is no alternative. If that is the approach, then the situation in Sligo, Leitrim and Roscommon is unique. Why not put Roscommon and Leitrim together and make that a five-seat constituency? The answer is quite obvious. If that were to be the situation Fianna Fáil would get only two seats and Fine Gael would get three. Sligo is ideal for a three-seat constituency. Again, the Minister knows that, if Sligo were made a three-seat constituency, Fine Gael would get two seats and Fianna Fáil would get one. That is the reason why Leitrim is being carved up. During the referendum the Taoiseach, who found time to come down to Leitrim, warned the people that the county would be butchered and "butchered" was the word he used.

The Minister, when preparing this revision, decided to take the name of the county off the political map and, as Deputy L'Estrange says, it was only when some of the grass roots of the Fianna Fáil Party came up here to Leinster House and talked to the Minister that he decided to put Leitrim back. What he did was to call constituencies, Roscommon-Leitrim, Donegal-Leitrim and Sligo-Leitrim. The Minister for Local Government—a very busy man, according to himself— found time to go down to Leitrim before Christmas to a Fianna Fáil jamboree and he disclosed there that he was going to put Leitrim back on the map. This is the way he tries to hoodwink the people of Leitrim. Leitrim is divided into three parts.

We had some talk earlier here about the Border. Everybody was blaming everybody else for the Border. Now we have the Minister for Local Government creating more borders than ever existed in the past. If there were any little bit of sincerity in the Minister he would leave Sligo a three-seat constituency and Roscommon a five-seat constituency. Roscommon has been ferociously butchered. Portion of it has gone to the new Clare-Galway constituency, portion to another Galway constituency, and portion of Leitrim that was in Roscommon is put back into Sligo-Leitrim. It is an odd situation, but the number of votes taken from South Leitrim, which were in Roscommon up to this revision and which are now put into Sligo-Leitrim, is the very same as the number of votes being taken out of Westmeath and put into Roscommon. I am curious to know why this has been done. Some people think it was done at the instigation of the Minister for Education, who wants to protect his own seat. Other people think it was the Minister for Education who got South Roscommon divided so that he would not find himself with Councillor Doc Callaghan selected as a candidate in the Fianna Fáil interest because the councillor, he is afraid, would take the seat from him. If that is what Fianna Fáil are doing, protecting individual seats, then I do not think this is a fair approach. It is not being fair to the people in these counties.

Every Deputy is entitled to try to protect his seat. The Minister for Local Government will get an even more telling answer in the general election than he got in the referendum. I do not think anybody, even the Taoiseach, knows when the election will be held. I do not think the Minister knows what is going on in his own Party. I believe there are a number of Ministers in the Party who are not speaking to one another. The situation is becoming desperate but apparently they are agreeing to preserve this desperate situation by gerrymandering the constituencies.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): As two previous speakers have said, this is an example of madness on the part of the Minister for Local Government and on the part of the Party he purports to represent here. Here we have a traditional county, Roscommon, being virtually mutilated.

Roscommon, taking it as an administrative unit, as a county, is only a little short of the population necessary to form a three-seater in its own right. I see no reason why the Minister could not have done that. When discussing the other contiguous areas on the western seaboard from Donegal to Clare, I have already outlined to the Minister, step by step, how we could establish three four-seaters and six three-seaters for that area, instead of the ten-by-three rule which he is proposing in the Bill. Roscommon could be a three-seater quite simply and practically within the confines of Roscommon county, but he is proposing to mutilate this area in the following fashion.

He is proposing to transfer 1,975 people to Clare-Galway and he is proposing to transfer 7,938 people to North-East Galway. That makes a total of 9,913. Then, to balance that shift of population on the western side, he proposes to transfer 4,025 people from Athlone west urban in order to compensate in Roscommon for the people he is transferring into Galway—the new constituency of Clare-Galway or Clare-South Galway, as he calls it in his amendment. That means a total transfer of 13,938 persons in respect of that county, arising from his mad desire and devotion to forming ten three-seaters.

I told the Minister when discussing this previously that a transfer of 953 people, namely 290 from Taghboy and 663 people from Ahascragh—that is a total of 953 people from Galway—and added to the official county of Roscommon would give you sufficient population to form a three-seater in Roscommon on its own. Surely that is a far more reasonable method of dealing with this question than the method employed by the Minister?

He admitted here that he thinks the preservation of the local authority boundaries or constituency boundaries is important. I agree, not for emotional reasons. Many of our public representatives are also county councillors in their own areas. It is a help if they happen to be members of local authorities and Dáil representatives for a particular area. They cannot do that if part of the county is in one constituency for Dáil purposes and in another constituency for county council purposes. Surely it is very desirable from a smooth functioning point of view to have them conterminous?

Against the figure of 953 which I have suggested we have the figure of 13,938 suggested by the Minister. He cannot complain that a three-seat constituency is too big. It is the minimum we can have under the Constitution. For the neighbouring counties, Clare, Galway, Roscommon, Mayo, Donegal, Sligo and Leitrim I have suggested three four-seaters and six three-seaters, instead of the Minister's ten three-seaters. That is not a great departure from what he has suggested, and it could be done with a much smaller shift of population than he is proposing. For instance, the shift of Roscommon population which I suggest is approximately one-fourteenth of what the Minister suggests.

For the life of me I cannot see by what system of logic any Minister could make a defence in a situation like that. The figures are damning. I have been after the Minister for the past couple of days. He is like a punch-drunk boxer running around the ring. All he is able to utter and mutter is "referendum" and "Budd". I have reached the stage where I hate to hit him any more. Having pinned his ears back so often it is mutilation to go after him again. If he gets up to speak now I am sure it will be "Budd" again.

Comment on this

There are only seven more occasions on which Deputy Hogan and his colleagues can repeat these so-often refuted allegations. Of course, they can do it as many times as they like on each of these. At least we have got through quite a large part of the Electoral Bill and I suppose we can see some end to the constant repetition of this completely unsubstantiated charge that this is being done in order to gerrymander. It has been established that what is being done in this Bill is being done only after the Government have taken every possible step open to them to avoid doing it. We took every step we possibly could to obtain from the people permission to revise the constituencies in a rational way. These breaches of county boundaries which the Opposition pretend to find so objectionable now, but which they saw as completely unobjectionable only a few months ago, are being made because the Constitution requires it and because, in our opinion, this is the least objectionable way in which what we consider this objectionable provision can be operated.

Deputy Hogan says he does not agree with it. He produces different schemes, piecemeal schemes for each different constituency. There is no continuity. He has a different one every time, one more objectionable than the other. He produces figures which are not the total figures with regard to shifts of population and, then, he continues to make the point that the objective should be to make the total shift of population as small as possible, without any consideration as to the extent or the wholeness of the communities being transferred from their own traditional county into another county.

Apparently Deputy Hogan believes it is all right to put people into a position where they will feel they are disfranchised, so long as they are a comparatively small number of people only, that individuals are not important that, so long as they are a small percentage, it does not matter if they feel disfranchised or completely lost in the constituency into which they are transferred. That has been the approach of the Fine Gael Party all along. To them it is purely a matter of figures and percentages and the individuals involved do not count.

I suggest that there is also another point of view. When people have to be uprooted and put into another constituency, in order to lessen the sense of frustration and the feeling of disfranchisement that those people must have, the idea should be to transfer a reasonable number of them so that they will form a significant part of the new constituency, so that all the Deputies for the new constituency will find it advisable to pay equal attention to their views and their needs as to those of the county with which they are more naturally associated. What is being done with regard to Roscommon is inevitable because of the fact that Roscommon is inevitably involved in adjustments with other constituencies and the need to transfer the portion of what is described as Athlone town, which lies west of the Shannon, known as West Urban, to Roscommon, the county in which it is physically located. This necessity arises because of the fact that Roscommon is involved in adjustments with Galway.

I agree all those adjustments are undesirable but they are inevitable because of the rigid requirement of the Constitution which the Fine Gael Party sought to have copperfastened in regard to the constituencies. Deputy L'Estrange says we have made a different proposition. Of course that is the understatement of the year. I agree we have made a different proposition. Every Deputy who spoke made at least one proposition which differed from every other one that had already been made. Deputy Hogan, I think, probably made as many different propositions as the rest of the Fine Gael speakers put together.

With regard to the particular proposition Deputy L'Estrange put forward on this occasion, I may say I have not bothered to check all those propositions up to now but because of the fact I knew what Deputy L'Estrange had to say, as he had said it so often already, I decided I would check over the particular proposition he put forward with regard to this particular constituency we are discussing. What Deputy L'Estrange said was that what should be done here was that Roscommon county, as an entire county, should be joined with the portion of Leitrim which would remain after some of it had been transferred to the county of Donegal. The very minimum that would have to be transferred from Leitrim to Donegal is 5,619 and that deducted from the population, which is 30,572, leaves a population of 24,953 which when added to Roscommon, 56,228, makes a total of 81,181. This is just sufficient for four seats, not five as Deputy L'Estrange contends.

This, apparently, is the type of proposition that has been emanating from some of the Fine Gael Deputies in this regard. While I have said that in my opinion what is proposed here in many cases is objectionable, it also seems they are just put forward without any reference to the requirements of the Constitution. As far as I understood the last time I checked some of those Fine Gael proposals, the five-seat area involving what was called Leitrim was the whole of the two counties of Roscommon and Leitrim plus part of Donegal—some of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents which Fine Gael are so anxious to deprive him of. As I said earlier, the number of those people who could be transferred from Donegal and still leave sufficient remaining for the one five-seat constituency which Fine Gael advocate for Donegal would be anything up to 13,409, so the constituency that I understood Fine Gael would be advocating was a constituency comprising part of Donegal, the whole of County Leitrim and the whole of County Roscommon, but there were of course variations on that theme.

There were suggestions regarding part of Leitrim and Sligo but I do not consider that would be a desirable solution. I think to have almost the whole of County Donegal as one constituency would not be a very reasonable type of constituency and I do not think a constituency stretching from Ballyshannon right down to Shannonbridge would be a reasonable type of constituency at all. I think in the vast area from Donegal to Clare, including the whole of the Province of Connaught, which has to be represented by a maximum of 30 Deputies, the most reasonable solution for the area is to have ten three-seat constituencies. Even at that the constituencies will be very large, extensive and, I think, difficult for Deputies to cover. But I think it is the best we can do under the circumstances. The decision of the Government with regard to this area was to have ten three-seat constituencies and, having made that decision, those other adjustments that have to be made throughout that whole area naturally follow.

The thing about the Opposition's approach to this whole matter is that when we are discussing this Bill piecemeal, as we are at present, they can base their whole approach by starting from the particular constituency that happens to be under consideration at the particular time. That is why they can put forward so many different propositions, as Deputy L'Estrange calls them, because they are not interrelated in any way. Unfortunately, when you have to undertake the practical proposition of drawing up a scheme for constituencies for the whole country you cannot adopt that piecemeal type of approach. You have to look at the problem as a whole. What has happened with regard to County Roscommon arises because of the decision to have three-seat constituencies and because of what that involves in other counties such as Donegal, Clare, Sligo and Mayo. Therefore, all those solutions that have been put forward are, in my opinion, less reasonable than what is proposed. I have agreed already that is a matter of opinion.

Deputy Hogan believes it is of no importance that small sections of the community should be put into constituencies in which they will be submerged in other counties. I do not think that is a very desirable approach and I do not think that just because a group of people is small in number their interests should be considered as of no importance. Deputy Hogan disagrees with me so we can only agree to differ.

Deputy Reynolds put forward what I have no doubt appears to him to be a very simple solution, that is, to put Roscommon and Leitrim together and have a five-seat constituency. First of all, assuming the figures are allowable for that, which they are not, I cannot just consider Roscommon and Leitrim alone. I have to produce a scheme of constituencies for the whole country and, therefore, unlike Deputy Reynolds I cannot see the simple approach of just considering the area Deputy Reynolds happens to be interested in.

That is why Roscommon and Leitrim just cannot be considered on their own. If Deputy Reynolds would get a copy of the census report he will see that the population for Roscommon is 56,228 and for Leitrim 30,572. If he adds those together, he will get a total of 86,800 and if he divides that by five he will get a quotation of 17,360. In case Deputy Reynolds——

Comment on this

Divide it by four.

Comment on this

If you are putting five seats into it——

Comment on this

I did not say five: I said four.

Comment on this

——as Deputy Reynolds advocated, and if you want to get the population per Deputy you divide by five, not four, and you get 17,360. The people decided that, even for the purpose of avoiding the breaching of county boundaries, you could not have that amount of deviation from the national average of population per Deputy.

Comment on this