We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 129–258 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 35 of 1968 ›

I said four, Minister.

Comment on this

These changes, then, are being made because they are required by the Constitution. I must say that I was wondering, when Deputy Hogan stood up, which of his many solutions for this area he would produce. On this occasion, it was the Taghboy-Ahascragh one.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): That was the one I had in mind all the time.

Comment on this

That is one of the many possibilities. You could transfer Taghboy and Ahascragh from Galway to Roscommon if you only had Roscommon to deal with and if decisions made elsewhere did not preclude that type of solution. However, as I said, the first decision that we made was that there should be three-seat constituencies because of the vast extent of the area, the comparative sparseness of population and the fact that, therefore, only 30 seats could be allocated to the province of Connacht and to the large counties of Clare and Donegal. Having made that decision, these shifts of population were, I believe, necessary.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 28 and 29 have already been discussed and agreed to.

SLIGO.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:

In page 13, in the first column, to delete "Sligo" and to substitute "Sligo-Leitrim".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:

In page 13, in the second column of the entry relating to Sligo, to delete "South-West Donegal" and to substitute "Donegal-Leitrim".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:

In page 13, in the second column of the entry relating to Sligo, to delete "Roscommon" and to substitute "Roscommon-Leitrim".

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 31 and 32 seem to be cognate and might, therefore, be discussed together.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I move amendment No. 31:

In page 13 to delete the entry relating to South Tipperary and to substitute the following:

Name | Area | Number of Members

South Tipperary | The administrative area of Tipperary South Riding except (a) the part thereof which is comprised in the Constituency of North Tipperary, and (b) the District Electoral Divisions of Carrigbeg (Urban), Tullagharton, Ballybacon, Newcastle and the townlands of Ballybeg, Ballymorris, Ballynamona, Burgesland, Flemingstown, Garrancasey, Greenmount, Knockeen, Moloughabbey, Moloughnewtown in the District Electoral Division of Tullaghmelan. | Three

In this amendment I am advocating that South Tipperary should be treated as a three-seater and Waterford should be treated as a four-seater and not, as suggested in the Minister's Bill, South Tipperary, with a bit of Waterford, as a four-seater and the remainder of Waterford as a three-seater.

To put the House in the picture, let me give the population figures. The population of Tipperary North Riding is 53,843 and of the South Riding 68,969, so that the county as a whole has a population of 122,812. The population of Waterford county is 73,080. Therefore, ab initio, Waterford would appear to have a greater claim, on a population basis, to being a four-seater than Tipperary South Riding.

Now, in 1961, a population transfer of district electoral divisions was made from Tipperary South Riding to Tipperary North Riding. That transfer amounted to 2,597: it was necessary in so far as the population of North Riding would appear to have gone down. Now, in this Bill, there is a further transfer of two district electoral divisions—again from South Tipperary to Tipperary North Riding—giving a population transfer in this case of 875. That means that the total transfer now will be 3,472 according to the 1965 census. This will give Tipperary North a population of 57,315, that is, 231 above the minimum for three seats. It reduces Tipperary South to 65,497. However, by adding 10,749 from West Waterford, this gives, for the South Tipperary-West Waterford proposed four-seater in the Minister's Bill, a population of 76,246. That is a small margin of 134 above the minimum for four seats.

I submit that a better arrangement, in terms of population transfer, would be to make South Tipperary a three-seater and County Waterford a four-seater. Waterford needs a minimum of 3,132 population to become a four-seater. Tipperary South, with its population of 65,497, needs a transfer out of 2,413 as a minimum under the Constitution to qualify as a three-seater. While Tipperary South has sufficient population to make Waterford a four-seater, I thought it might be expedient to spread the transfer on to another county.

Cork is a large county—if not the second largest then the largest in Ireland. So far, under the Minister's Bill, it has got only a small transfer. There has been very little mutilation of Cork county, as a county. In fact, the total transfer from Cork is only 2,025 and that is on the Kerry border. North-East Cork, which is the county from which, I am submitting here in my amendment, a small transfer should take place, is only 63 below the national average. Therefore, North-East Cork is in a position to allow for a transfer, without upsetting its level and bringing it too much below the national average. As far as rural counties go, Cork is one of the counties with a pretty large population per Deputy.

I have suggested in the amendment the areas which it might be possible to transfer and I have suggested that South Tipperary should consist of the administrative area of Tipperary South Riding except (a) the part thereof which is comprised in the constituency of North Tipperary—which I have already dealt with—and (b) the district electoral divisions of Carrigbeg (Urban), Tullagharton, Ballybacon, Newcastle and the townlands of Ballybeg, Ballymorris, Ballynamona, Burgesland, Flemingstown, Garrancasey, Greenmount, Knockeen, Moloughabbey, Moloughnewtown in the district electoral division of Tullaghmelan. I have also suggested that Waterford as a four-seater, should consist of the administrative county of Waterford and in the administrative area of South Tipperary the district electoral divisions of Carrigbeg and so on as I have mentioned in amendment No. 32 and in the administrative area of County Cork the district electoral division of Konckmourne and the townlands of Kilmacow and Lackenbehy in the district electoral division of Curraglass.

Comment on this

The Deputy's colleague in North-East Cork would not agree with that.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Strange to say, all the Cork men have agreed with me. This transfer of population is inconsiderable as compared with the transfer of population which would take place under the Minister's Bill. The position is that under the present system, more than 11,000 people in 1961 were transferred from Waterford into South Tipperary and this is a difficult constituency geographically.

The Minister, when speaking here in the debate on the referendum, adverted to the ridiculous situation of throwing 11,000-odd people across the Comeragh mountains into South Tipperary. If one travels from most parts of South Tipperary into this South Tipperary-West Waterford constituency, one must go over what we call the "V" which is part of the Comeragh mountains above Cloheen. It is a difficult situation geographically and I am suggesting that instead of transferring these 11,000-odd people—that figure has fallen now to about 10,750 people—it would be more reasonable to transfer about one-third of that figure from Tipperary to Waterford.

The minimum required by Waterford would be 3,132 and the transfers suggested in my amendment amount to 2,413 so that 719 more will be needed from somewhere else and I have suggested that they could be got from the area between East Cork and West Waterford by bringing in the district electoral division of Knockmourne which amounts to 687 persons and the townland of Kilmacow which provides 29 persons and also the townland of Lackenbehy which provides seven persons, making a total of 723 persons, these last two townlands being in the district electoral division of Curraglass.

That is the amendment I have put down and I consider it to be a more reasonable solution that the Minister's. Admittedly there are other alternatives. For instance, instead of bringing in Knockmourne and a couple of townlands from Curraglass, you could bring in Curraglass and a couple of townlands from Knockmourne. The present transfer of population from Waterford to South Tipperary is 10,749 persons. That is a much larger figure than the one I am suggesting which is a little over 3,000. This would entail much less mutilation of county boundaries and the transfer of 10,750 persons, which is the Minister's proposal.

On general principles, the Minister has offered the view that in transfer of population there is an argument to be made for transferring large areas of population inasmuch as that a large area will, so to speak, be able to make its personal impact on the county to which it is transferred.

Comment on this

And have a Deputy of it own, which Waterford has.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): A Deputy of its own, but in each transferred area like that even if it does succeed in having a Deputy of its own, it will really only succeed in having a Deputy of its own of one Party.

Comment on this

Now we see the reason for this.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The only justifiable transfer to my mind may be one of two types. Either you transfer a small number of people and keep the amount of distress to a minimum—all populations who are transferred like that are disaffected people—or else you amalgamate two counties. The population has to be big enough to enable it to have a reasonable chance of providing a Deputy of any of the three major Parties.

I may point out that in West Waterford there was a notice of motion before Waterford County Council on this matter. It was unanimously agreed that West Waterford should be returned to Waterford to provide an integrated Waterford constituency in conformity with County Waterford as a four-seater. I may mention also that the two Fianna Fáil Deputies who are members of Waterford County Council voted to have West Waterford put back into Waterford.

Comment on this

Did you test yours in Tipperary?

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I would be anxious to know how those two West Waterford Deputies will vote here today.

Comment on this

Allegations have been made on every part of this Schedule that gerrymandering was involved, that the layout of each of these proposed constituencies was directed against the interests of some individual Fine Gael Deputy. Deputy Hogan has now let the cat out of the bag when he discloses that this was aimed at the elimination of Deputy Fahey from this House. I do not think Deputy Hogan will get rid of Deputy Fahey as easily as he thinks.

The Deputy's proposals involve the transfer of a district electoral division and part of another electoral division from the proposed constituency of North-East Cork, which has already been passed by the House. We have an amendment to adjust that after it has already been agreed. It also involves the transfer of 2,413 of Deputy Hogan's South Tipperary constituents from their own county into the county of Waterford. Deputy Hogan apparently considers that because these people are small in number they do not count, that because there are only 2,413 of them they are of no importance and that they may with impunity be submerged in the four-seat constituency which he proposes to create around the county of Waterford. I agree they form a comparatively small community but, unlike Deputy Hogan, I do not think that because the number of individuals is small they should be ignored like this.

The existing situation is that there is, as Deputy Hogan has said, a substantial number of people from Waterford county joined with the part of the administrative county of South Tipperary for electoral purposes, and, as Deputy Cunningham has pointed out, these people, because they form a significant element in the constituency of South Tipperary, have been able to elect a representative. In other words, they have not suffered disfranchisement because of having been transferred to another county. This illustrates the point I have been making, that these people have not the same sense of frustration and disfranchisement as will the 2,413 Tipperary people that Deputy Hogan proposes to transfer to County Waterford.

I would point out also that this proposal would make the population per Deputy of the South Tipperary constituency exactly the maximum permissible. I do not know if the solution that achieves that exact result is within the spirit of the Constitution. It certainly does not disclose that there was any effort made to comply with the actual terms of the Constitution, to have the population per Deputy as near as practicable the same in different constituencies.

One of the principles underlying the scheme of constituencies that I have proposed in the Bill is that any constituency the population of which is within the permitted range in accordance with the Constitution and which is not affected by the constitutional necessity for changes in neighbouring constituencies would not be disturbed. In accordance with this principle the constituencies in the south eastern part of the country, including Waterford, are exactly as they were constituted under the 1961 Act. There is a slight adjustment in the case of the two Tipperary constituencies because that was unavoidable but, apart from that, the constituencies in that part of the country have remained as they were. Deputy Hogan's proposed amendments involve the disturbance of 13,885 people from the existing constituency of South Tipperary and North-East Cork and involve the breaching of the CorkWaterford boundary in addition to the Waterford-Tipperary boundary, and all in the laudable effort of Deputy Hogan to get rid of some of his present constituents and in the process to try to get rid of Deputy Fahey.

It is obvious that Deputy Hogan is conceding the pending by-election in the South Tipperary constituency. Apparently he does not visualise the embarrassment of a colleague when he proceeds to contest this three-seat constituency which he proposes in the next general election. Indeed, that is a bit of realism on the part of Deputy Hogan, because he will not have that embarrassment, as he well knows. But, as I say, it is not surprising that he should want to get rid of this part of the constituency which he was elected to represent. He may as well admit that he has never represented this part of his constituency. Of course, it is too late now to try to make the appearance of doing so, in the same way as Deputy Fitzpatrick has tried to do, because time is running out. I agree with Deputy Hogan that these people are likely to give their votes to the Deputies who have actually represented them, and that must weaken Deputy Hogan's chances considerably.

I also agree with Deputy Hogan that a three-seat area is easier to represent. In fact, I think this is one of the fundamental principles in the Bill. We have endeavoured, where it was reasonable to do so, to introduce three-seat constituencies but, because the distribution of population in this part of the country did not call for any disruption in the existing constituencies, the operation of creating a three-seat constituency was not carried out in that part of the country.

I can see Deputy Hogan's objection to having to cross the Comeragh Mountains to get to his constituency, although if he is an admirer of scenery it is a nice journey. However, it is a pity that Deputy Hogan did not think of this before 16th October when I drew attention to the fact that compliance with the Constitution did involve this anomaly for Deputy Hogan if he decided to represent the constituency for which he was elected. If he decided to represent the constituency for which he was elected making occasional journeys over the Comeragh Mountains but in May, June, July, August, September and October this journey over the Comeragh Mountains was of no importance to Deputy Hogan. Now it suddenly assumes such gigantic proportions that he proposes disrupting the whole constituency layout in that part of the country and transferring these 13,885 people out of the constituency in which they are at present into the constituency of Waterford.

Comment on this

Back to their own county.

Comment on this

I must congratulate Deputy L'Estrange on getting Deputy Fizpatrick back to the House once again.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister could not get anybody to relieve him last night.

Comment on this

These frantic efforts of Deputy Fitzpatrick to catch up on his constituency work which he has been neglecting since 1965 have been very embarrassing to Deputy L'Estrange, who has been wearing himself out running up and down the stairs and in and out of the door looking for Deputy Fitzpatrick. At least he has had another temporary success.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I shall not stay here very long.

Comment on this

The situation which was required by the circumstances that existed in 1961 has been established. There is no need in so far as the distribution of population is concerned to change it now. For that reason we did not propose this unnecessary disturbance of the existing situation. Deputy Hogan, for personal reasons of his own, is proposing this disruption of the situation. I do not agree with him. I wonder if Deputy Hogan got the sanction of Senator Garret FitzGerald on this proposal of his which is completely contrary to the proposal put forward on behalf of the Fine Gael Party. All talk on behalf of the Fine Gael Party but with different voices. Deputy Hogan may think he has rehabilitated himself with the Carrick-on-Suir people and he is proposing this transfer to other areas. That is a matter for the Fine Gael Party. I have given the reason why we avoided disrupting the situation in this area.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 65
·
Níl 47
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We now come to the postponed sections— sections 3, 4 and 5.

Comment on this

I thought we would first go through the Schedule as a whole.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There will be no further discussion on the Schedule.

Comment on this

I thought the Schedule as a whole would be put.

SECTION 3.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This is the section which specifies the constituencies for which Deputies will be elected to this House in the next general election. I wish to say briefly that in section 3 the Minister has done what he promised to do before the referendum, and he has done it very effectively; that is, he has gerrymandered the country from top to bottom. I was rather surprised when the referendum was over to learn that the Minister for Local Government proposed to continue to act in this office notwithstanding the fact that he was completely rejected by the people to the tune of a quarter million votes. I was also amazed when I learned that the Minister, whose electoral reform proposals had been rejected in a national contest, proposed to bring back to this House further proposals for electoral reform by way of revision of constituencies.

I say that, because the Minister stood committed to introducing absurd proposals. In the discussion in this House on the referendum, the Minister intimated time and time again that the requirements of the Constitution in reference to constituencies as they stood, and as they stand at present, were unworkable and both he and the Taoiseach made it quite plain, both verbally and in writing, that it would be necessary, if the Third Amendment to the Constitution Bill was not carried, to butcher constituencies all over the country.

That was the frame of mind in which the Minister for Local Government set upon the task of revising the constituencies. He had a preconceived idea about the feasibility of the task to which he was committed. He had convinced himself—I will give him credit for that—in the House during the long and dreary months of debate on the referendum proposals, a debate which went on week after week and month after month and which many of us thought futile. However, it proved fruitful: the Minister's long, agonising contributions to the debate were very valuable because they convinced the people that the Minister was up to no good and they rejected his proposals. The Minister had convinced himself before he set about drafting this Bill that his task was impossible. He thereupon set about justifying himself by bringing into this House, not a reasonable scheme of constituencies, not the best possible scheme he could devise, but the most absurd scheme within his competence. He has succeeded in that.

Now I am satisfied that the electorate will react to these proposed revisions just as they reacted to the referendum proposals. Not alone has the Minister introduced these absurd proposals but he has gerrymandered the whole country. We have an example of that in the West of Ireland where some rearrangement was necessary. In arriving at that rearrangement the Minister made sure that those counties which could be regarded as favourable to Fianna Fáil retained, or even increased, their representation. A glaring example of that is County Galway, which not alone increases its preCensus number of Deputies of eight but is given a bonus of one in order to arrange three constituencies favourable to the Minister and his Party. That is what the Minister set out to do.

Donegal is another example. According to the Minister, before the referendum, Donegal would have to lose a seat. But the Minister has seen to it that it will not lose a seat. Mayo has seven seats at the moment — three Fianna Fáil and four Fine Gael, despite the fact that the Fianna Fáil Party have two Ministers in that county. The Minister has seen to it that its representation will be reduced from seven to six. Clare, the pride of the Fianna Fáil Party, could never be relied on to give the Party more than two seats out of four. Down through the years there has always been a Labour seat in Clare. The Minister arranged matters there by reducing the number of seats to three in the hope that the Labour seat will disappear. The same can be said about Roscommon. It was a "dicey" one for the Minister and his Party, so he reduced it from four to three.

I want to make a passing reference to Leitrim which has been dealt with already. Leitrim has been annihilated, as foretold by the Taoiseach in Drumshanbo; it has been divided into three and distributed, quite unnecessarily, between three other counties. In all these constituencies—let it be noted— the Minister has created three-seat constituencies. He could argue he was honest in that if that were the pattern throughout the country. If the Minister were to be taken seriously in his statement that he does not believe in proportional representation and that he wanted to reduce the effectiveness of proportional representation to a minimum, while one would not agree with him, one would have expected him to produce three-seat constituencies throughout the country. He created three-seat constituencies where he hopes Fianna Fáil will get a majority of the votes, two seats out of three. He hopes that will be the result, but I believe he will be just as far out in that vain hope as he was in his forecast of the result of the referendum.

If the Minister were sincere about proportional representation and if he wanted to create the same pattern throughout the country then one would have expected him to create three-seat constituencies right into Leinster and the city of Dublin. There are no three-seat constituencies in the city of Dublin. There are four-seat constituencies all over the place. Again the hope is that the Minister will gain a political advantage for himself and for his Party. The Minister has created utterly unnatural boundaries, putting a piece of Meath into Monaghan, and another piece into Cavan and putting practically the whole town of Athlone into Roscommon, to please the Minister for Education. All this indicates that the Minister's efforts are not bona fide. All this is evidence of the fact that the Minister wanted to gerrymander the constituencies for his own benefit and the benefit of his Party. This is a most reprehensible performance. If the Minister were honest in all this he would have sought independent advice.

I said he should have an independent commission. He tells me a commission is not possible without a Constitutional amendment. I do not agree with him in that. I say that is not so. Even if it is so, the Minister, without any trouble, could have set up an informal committee of this House to report to him and advise him on the new constituencies. He did not do that. He did not do it because he wanted to have the last word, because he wanted to do the job that he thought would best suit his own Party and do as much damage as possible to the Opposition Parties.

I have no doubt that the people will realise what the Minister has set out to do. The people can no longer be taken for granted. That has emerged from the result of the referendum. The people can no longer be relied upon to act blindly or without considering serious proposals in a serious manner. When the referendum was first mooted, and the intentions of the Government first disclosed I remember saying that the slogan against those proposals should be: "They are not fair." I believe that message got across to the people, that the proposals of the Minister were unfair and unjust. I think they knew that and, knowing what he was at, they reacted violently. It is not an exaggeration to say the people reacted violently to the Minister's referendum proposals.

One would have thought that the Taoiseach would have heeded the warning and said: "Here is a man who is discredited; here is a man who has been rejected by the people; here is a man whose proposals were not accepted by the people, and I am asking for trouble if I ask the same Minister to do a similar job." As we all know, the Taoiseach had his own troubles in the weeks following the referendum. He was being challenged. There was complete disharmony in the Fianna Fáil Party, and he preserved the status quo. He took this gamble, and for that he must be blamed.

I would not expect any other sort of Bill from the Minister, having listened to him here for months last year, knowing his views on PR and knowing his views on tolerance. The Minister complains that he is forced to do what he has done here because he did not get sanction for his tolerance proposal. He indicated during this debate that, if he had been given the Third Amendment of the Constitution by the people, he could have done a reasonable job. The House and the country have seen the result of the Minister's handiwork operating within the reasonable guidelines provided by the Constitution.

He asked the people for a blank cheque. He asked the people to empower him to differentiate between constituencies to the extent that it would take as many as 23,000 people to qualify for a TD in one place—in Leitrim we will say—and that it would take only 16,000 people to qualify for a TD in Galway or Donegal. The wisdom of the decision of the people can be appreciated when, as I say, we see the Minister's handiwork operating within the reasonable confines of the Constitution. The people are entitled to ask themselves: "What in the name of goodness would he have produced, or what would he have done, if we had given him a blank cheque?"

I know this Bill will go through the House because the Minister will insist on its going through. In the constituencies as they will be when the Bill becomes law, we will take on the Minister and his Party, just as we took them on in the single constituency of the Republic of Ireland. As I said earlier today, I am satisfied that the Minister in these proposals will have done his own Party irreparable harm and our Party considerable good.

Comment on this

On this occasion Deputy Fitzpatrick started off by saying I had succeeded in gerrymandering very effectively. He alternates between two propositions: one, that I have gerrymandered very effectively, and the other that the result of this Bill will be to reduce Fianna Fáil strength. I have not got the dictionary which Deputy Fitzpatrick carries around with him but, as I understand the word "gerrymandering", it means arranging constituencies so as to get Party advantage. If I have gerrymandered effectively I must get some advantage for the Fianna Fáil Party as a result of that gerrymandering. Deputy Fitzpatrick's contention, then, is that we will do better in the general election that will be fought in these constituencies than we did in the last general election when we got 72 seats. I wonder what Deputy Fitzpatrick's forecast is? By how many seats will we exceed 72 as a result of this very effective gerrymandering? Of course, he knows there is no such thing. He knows that when constituencies have to be disrupted, the most likely thing is that every one of the Deputies involved will feel that he is losing as a result. That is my experience. That is what the position is. When I have time I must go through the debates and find out how many times Deputy Fitzpatrick has contradicted himself in this matter.

The remainder of his contribution was a return to his favourite theme, a personal attack upon me. I want to assure him that I consider the fact that his main objective is to attack me personally, the highest compliment I could be paid. I am glad to know that his objective is to get rid of me. That is the most sincere tribute I could be paid.

Comment on this

It would be a sin to get rid of the Minister.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Fitzpatrick for it. The Fianna Fáil record with regard to local government is not confined to the matter of the referendum. We will have a very good record with regard to local government to put before the people. That is one of the main reasons why we expect to have a greater number of Deputies after the next general election than we had after the last general election. It has nothing to do with the constituencies. It has to do with their adjustment and particularly with the contrast that those adjustments provide as between our performance and the miserable performance of the alternative Government. Our record in local government embraces a lot more than the referendum. It embraces the significant improvements in housing, water and sewerage schemes and so on.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I think the House will be open for debate on this.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may think nothing of the sort. The question of housing does not arise on section 3 of this Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that Fianna Fáil will shortly be on the roads.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I know the Minister would rather be talking about anything other than the referendum.

Comment on this

I only mentioned this in passing because the long dissertation on the referendum seemed to imply that it was on this single issue, which was of a non-political nature, that the effectiveness of Fianna Fáil in so far as local government is concerned would be decided. However, we will go on to deal with the proposal in the referendum. This was a single proposal. It was divided into two. There was a proposal to change the electoral system, which was rejected by the people. It was no more than that. Combined with that was a proposal to allow a very small amount of scope in regard to population per Deputy in different constituencies in order to have regard to such practical considerations as the existence of county boundaries. This proposal also was rejected by the people.

The referendum proposal was no more and no less than that. The result of the decision on the Third Amendment of the Constitution made this Bill necessary in order to comply with the Constitution. This is being done in order to comply with the provisions of the Constitution. I am perfectly satisfied, particularly after this debate, that the proposals we are making are the most reasonable proposals that are possible. They involve the least disturbance of the population and constituency layout.

Comment on this

Did you ever hear worse than that?

Comment on this

They involve the most reasonable size constituencies. We have obviously tried to eliminate the large five-seat constituencies. As a result of this Bill there will be only two of that type of constituency. Those are the areas known as Carlow-Kilkenny and Leix-Offaly, where the movement of population did not require any adjustment to be made. Those are the only two remaining five-seat constituencies. No doubt further changes in the distribution of population will result in those two also disappearing eventually. Of the 42 constituencies there are only 16 constituencies which are not three-seat constituencies. Of those, eight are in Dublin, where the areas involved are small. Of the remaining six constituencies, five are four-seat constituencies at present where either no adjustment or only small adjustments were necessary and the sixth outside Dublin, is North-East Cork, which is at present a five-seat constituency.

The obvious tendency disclosed by the Bill is to have as many three-seat constituencies as possible. At least one prominent Fine Gael speaker, Deputy O'Donnell, agreed during the debate on the referendum that three-seat constituencies were the most desirable because they went furthest to enable the people to make a definite decision at election time. It is quite true that this is so, that it is in circumstances where there is a preponderance of three-seat constituencies that the people are most likely to be able to elect a Government. Fine Gael conclude in those circumstances that Fianna Fáil must always be returned as a Government. That may be so. I would not argue with that point of view.

I think, as Fine Gael do, it is just as unlikely in circumstances like these that the people will ever elect a majority of Fine Gael Deputies but I think it is a rather poor reflection on a Party putting themselves forward as serious contenders to form a Government that they should believe that in those circumstances of three-seat constituencies Fianna Fáil will always get the majority. Deputy Fitzpatrick, contrary to the tendency we have adopted and followed in this Bill, advocates more large five-seat constituencies, particularly in the west of Ireland, where I think there is an obvious reason for moving towards three-seat constituencies. As I have said earlier in this debate the average area of a three-seat constituency in the west of Ireland would be 970 square miles and the average area of a five-seat constituency, which Fine Gael favour, would be 617 square miles. The peculiar thing is that during this debate the same Deputies who were advocating the creation of those large five-seat constituencies in the sparsely populated western areas were also complaining about the distances which would have to be travelled in some constituencies from one point to another.

This is typical of the contradictory nature of the Fine Gael approach. We had Deputy Fitzpatrick arguing that because Clare was a four-seat constituency, and because Fianna Fáil had very strong support there, Clare was reduced to a three-seat constituency and arguing again that because Roscommon was an area in which Fianna Fáil had weak support it was reduced to a three-seat constituency. Obviously, no matter what Fianna Fáil did would be wrong when apparently it is alleged it would be good tactics on the part of Fianna Fáil to reduce a four-seat constituency in which they are strong to a three-seat area and to reduce a four-seat constituency in which they are weak to a three-seat area.

I have dealt on a number of occasions already with the question of seeking independent advice. It hardly seems necessary to do it again. Deputy Fitzpatrick has not specified the type of advice he recommends. When somebody suggested setting up a non-political body—I do not know if there is such a thing as a non-political body— that person said if it was done it would be 90 per cent Fianna Fáil and that that would not be independent advice. I am assuming Deputy Fitzpatrick had in mind a body such as the commission, which was proposed in the Amendment to the Constitution, on which there would be representation from both sides of the House. I pointed out that if that is what is in mind you could not hope to get agreed advice from such a body if there were more than one Fine Gael representative on it because Fine Gael have failed to agree on this matter here themselves.

Deputy Fitzpatrick knows that of course I did not, and the Fianna Fáil Government did not, ask for a blank cheque in regard to drawing up constituencies in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. We asked for a very small amount of scope, smaller than that available in any other democracy we know of, to be utilised and this was to be written into the Constitution only for clearly specified reasons. Deputy Fitzpatrick and the Fine Gael Party know it could not be utilised in the manner he suggested. If that proposal had been accepted there would probably be only the one possible and reasonable solution to this question of drawing up a scheme of constituencies in accordance with the present system, unlike now, when as Deputies opposite themselves have shown, the number of possible arrangements is practically infinite. There does not seem to be any limit to it. The longer this debate went on the more suggestions of different solutions came from the opposite benches. There are innumerable possible solutions now. If the proposals we suggested or advocated requiring adherence to existing established county boundaries had been carried there would possibly have been only a few rearrangements of constituencies but, of course, that would not suit Fine Gael because they would not be able to make this ridiculous and bogus song and dance they are making now.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister has just stated that he set out to create as many three-seaters as possible: he thought that was desirable in the interests of manageability of constituencies. He also mentioned three-seater constituencies as desirable from the point of view of being able to return a Government. I agree with him as regards manageability. Two-seaters would be even more manageable. If the Minister's objective was, and if he had been guided by it, to produce three-seaters with a view to bringing about a set of circumstances where the election of a government would be achieved with a measurable degree of certainty, why did the Minister not make three-seaters in Dublin? If the three-seat constituency system is the one which will elect a Government—which we accept as a desirable thing—why did the Minister not extend the three-seater idea to Dublin? If it was valid in the country, why was it not valid in Dublin? The answer is quite simple. The Government have some measure of support in the country but have lost considerably in Dublin and, therefore, the three-seat and the four-seat constituencies were introduced—three-seaters in the country, in the hope that the Government would get two out of the three seats, and four-seaters here in Dublin in the hope that they might pull in and get two seats out of four.

If the Government introduced three-seat constituencies here in Dublin, their fear would be that they would get only one seat out of every three seats. That is the reason why the Minister introduced the three-seat and four-seat rule and that was the overall plan for the entire country. Furthermore, at the last referendum the Government asked for only a small amount of scope which would not be abused——

Comment on this

Not "would not" but "could not".

Comment on this

(South Tipperary):——could not be abused. I am not so sure the Minister would not be able to get a way around it.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Certainly, the country did not believe him and the people showed their disbelief in no uncertain fashion. Considering that the Minister is now within the straitjacket of the Constitution, and is accepting the Budd judgment as the correct interpretation of the Constitution, then, within that straitjacket, he has done an excellent job of gerrymandering. With much lesser scope, he is now abusing the electoral system to the limit, which really goes to prove that the people, when they refused to trust him on the occasion of the referendum and refused to give him, as he called it, “a little more scope”, were well advised to do so. If he can do what he is doing now, within the limited scope of five per cent, what could the Minister not do if he had succeeded in getting what he called “a little more scope” from the electorate at the last referenda?

On more than one occasion during this debate the Minister mentioned that I was just putting up piecemeal suggestions here and there as regards the entire Electoral Bill when, in fact, in so far as the Bill was taken in stages, I dealt with these stages as they came up and made any suggestions I had to make. If there was an area in respect of which I had no ideas to offer, I said nothing. For the entire area of the west of Ireland, I gave the Minister a completely different solution from the one he presented to the House. He presented a picture of about 30 seats— ten three-seat constituencies. I offered an alternative of six three-seat constituencies and three four-seat constituencies, giving the same number of Deputies from the west of Ireland.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that we cannot go back on matters discussed on the Schedule. We are now confined to a general debate.

Comment on this

Everything that is in it, without going into detail.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The general pattern I offered on the west of Ireland was quite different from what the Minister suggested. He had the simple solution of ten three-seat constituencies. I suggested the alternative of six three-seaters and three four-seaters and this could be accomplished and would give reasonable size constituencies with a small displacement of population relative to the numbers the Minister has offered to us. On my suggested arrangement, there would be population displacement in the west of Ireland for the entire area stretching from Donegal down to Clare west of the Shannon and including those two counties of approximately 9,000-odd as against the Minister's displacement of 59,000. I submit that it takes an extraordinary stretch of imagination to understand the approach of the Minister, if he was trying to be logical and if he agrees with the importance of local authority boundaries and the importance of keeping them coterminous with Dáil constituencies in so far as it is practicable and possible under the Constitution so to do. I have offered him an alternative method giving him reasonable size constituencies, no five-seater and a majority of three-seaters under which the transfer would be of 9,000 people as against 59,000. I submit that that is a reasonable suggestion for the entire western area. I have gone into the details of all these counties as the debate progressed.

As the Leas-Cheann Comhairle has said, it is not necessary and neither is it permissible to go into these same details again. Regarding the other regional area comprising Louth, Meath and Kildare, these would of course involve Cavan and Monaghan and I have offered a suggestion——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must point out that we cannot go back on individual portions of the Schedule which have already been discussed and which have already been disposed of as far as the House is concerned.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot think of any other way to delay the Bill.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I am taking them as regions.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

They have already been discussed as groups. They were taken both individually and as groups in so far as they affected each other.

Comment on this

It is rather difficult to delay it. It is a pity about the Rules.

Comment on this

The Minister breaks the Rules more often than anybody else.

Comment on this

The Deputy together with Deputy Harte holds the record for being put out of the House.

Comment on this

The Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Aiken, and Deputy Smith, an ex-Minister, hold the record.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Unless I can discuss the Budd judgment——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Budd judgment would not be relevant.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Apparently I cannot deal with them individually and I cannot deal with them in groups——

Comment on this

The Deputy will have to go back and say again what he has already said.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary):——and I asked if I could discuss the Budd judgment and I was told that that was talked out already but the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was too polite to say that it was talked out entirely by the Minister. Taking the Minister's proposal over the whole country—I presume I can at least discuss the entire country——

Comment on this

I am afraid Deputy L'Estrange will have to get Deputy Fitzpatrick back.

Comment on this

Will the Minister get someone to take his place?

Comment on this

The Deputy could not get Deputy Fitzpatrick back yesterday.

Comment on this

He was here for four or five hours and he was doing constituency work.

Comment on this

He was not doing constituency work last night.

Comment on this

He is entitled to do that and he has now gone for a cup of tea. The Minister cannot even get anybody from his Party to relieve him while he has a cup of tea.

Comment on this

I do not want any tea.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Hogan on section 3.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Minister blandly suggests to the House that he still has consideration for county boundaries and that he has never varied in his viewpoint in that regard and yet he produces a Bill which involves at least 14 breaches of county boundaries. In doing that he has transferred 101,000 people outside the local authority areas and he says that he is doing that at the direction of the people of Ireland. I am not aware that the people of Ireland ever voted on an issue like that; I am not aware that the people suggested that the Minister should do that and I am not aware that the people of Ireland would approve of that.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair does not like to interrupt the Deputy but these matters have been discussed during the discussion on the Schedule to the Bill and the Chair does not now want a repetition of arguments that have already been put forward when various sections of the Schedule were being discussed. The Chair is trying to keep the discussion within the section as it is at the moment.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): The Chair is becoming so restrictive in his admonitions that the discussion will be completely nullified.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle informed me that it was wide open.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is trying to keep the discussion to section 3 as it is at the moment and to avoid repetition of matters already discussed.

Comment on this

The only subject which the Deputy has not discussed so far is the weather.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I would tell the Deputy that I have contributed far more to this discussion than he has.

Comment on this

They are not trying to delay it. They are not afraid of a general election.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I do not know how many more times the Minister will tell us about the Budd judgment but when he has finished talking about that——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair does not wish to hear about the Budd judgment any more.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Can the Minister tell me how he pretends to justify so many breaches of county boundariese in this Bill when it has been pointed out to him from this side of the House that half the number of breaches of county boundaries would suffice and yet give reasonable constituencies?

Comment on this

This is the second week that this farce has gone on here. I had occasion last night to call attention to the repetition. There is not the slightest honesty in those people over there. They have been complaining about Monaghan, Cavan, Donegal and the lot of them. The only one they considered serious enough to call a division on in the full two weeks was the proposal to take 725 of my constituents and throw them into a maximum gatherum, a piece of Waterford, a piece of Tipperary and a piece of East Cork. The people who are complaining about breaching county boundaries are here proposing to breach three county boundaries. Where is the honesty or the decency in that? If I stand up and make an argument I will follow it to its natural conclusion by calling a division of the House on it. These people over there complain about Monaghan, complain about Donegal, complain about Cavan——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate we are starting to go back on the Schedule.

Comment on this

But Deputy Corry is not repeating himself.

Comment on this

I occupied very little of the time of the House on this matter. I am only calling attention to the deliberate waste of time of this House for a full two weeks, when those putting forward arguments were not prepared to follow them to the logical conclusion of getting the opinion of the elected representatives on what they were proposing.

Comment on this

We shall do that on the Schedule.

Comment on this

I did my damnedest from 9.30 to 10.30 yesterday to get you to call a division, but you knew you had only 17 Fine Gael Deputies. You had to search every hole and corner in the House trying to collect them, and you failed.

Comment on this

You could not even hold Deputy Fitzpatrick.

Comment on this

I know the truth is a scarce thing in this House. I know it is unpalatable. If Deputies over there put down an amendment to take 720 people out of another county to add to two more counties in order to make up a constituency, and they call a division on that, I would not waste my time on them. They have neither decency, honour nor honesty.

Comment on this

It is 723 people.

Comment on this

I am a long time here and in Cork County we were handed back, after ten years, a piece of the town of Youghal that was thrown into County Waterford for ten years. It was like a squeezed orange with not 20 people having employment in it. We are sick of this kind of thing. People do not want it. That is why we brought in the referendum.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot discuss the referendum again.

Comment on this

The people did not want that sort of thing. They wanted a Deputy that could be nailed down and made do a bit of work. You are over there now for 36 long years. There have been two changes of Government during that time, three years in which——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is irrelevant.

Comment on this

——you were pulling against one another and getting smashed up; three years more and you ran the country into bankruptcy and ran out with a tax on ladies' curlingpins imposed by the Minister for Finance. I have been here for 36 years and I shall be here for 36 years more looking at you.

Comment on this

It is very interesting to listen to Deputy Corry's remarks about decency, honesty and honour and about people putting up arguments and voting on them in this House. Deputy Corry is going out of the House and I want to remind him that he came in here and proposed amendments on the Cork Boundary Commission Bill and then went into the Lobby with Fianna Fáil to vote against his own amendments.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This has nothing to do with section 3.

Comment on this

That may be so but——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will not allow anything that is not relevant.

Comment on this

It is very hard to listen to the like of that from a man who proposes amendments here——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must come to the section.

Comment on this

This section proves to the House and to the people that Fianna Fáil have a mania for the exploitation of our people for Party political purposes. This ruthless changing of people and chopping of county boundaries and of constituencies is for one reason only, and that is to try to perpetuate the Government in office. I asked the Taoiseach a question a few months ago and I was told that 1,220,000 people had left the country.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This matter is not relevant to section 3.

Comment on this

Section 3 refers to 144 constituencies and specifies the have been two changes of Government in Ireland.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Section 3 deals with what will occur after the passage of the Bill, and it is not connected with people who may or may not have left the country. It deals with constituencies.

Comment on this

The Minister made the argument while you were out and while the Ceann Comhairle was in the Chair.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would ask the Deputy to deal with section 3.

Comment on this

There is no necessity to have this gerrymandering, this ruthless chopping and changing of county boundaries and constituencies involving 14 pieces of over nine counties and changing 101,000 people instead of changing only six pieces of constituencies involving fewer than 40,000 people. That is one proposition that was made to the Minister and he refused to accept it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is an argument which has been put forward previously.

Comment on this

The Minister spoke at length, while you were not here, about three-seater constituencies.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is not concerned with what happened when the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was not here. What the Chair is concerned with is avoiding repetition of the discussion that has already taken place.

Comment on this

The Minister only replied to Deputy Fitzpatrick, and he ran away and Deputy L'Estrange ran after him.

Comment on this

On the section I claim I am entitled to discuss the fact that there are now 26 three-seat constituencies, 14 four-seat constituencies and——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is in section 4, which we have not come to. It was also discussed on the Schedule.

Comment on this

I cannot understand your ruling, because the Ceann Comhairle told me that on this we were entitled to discuss anything that is in the Bill. The Minister spoke at length about the referendum, about the people's wishes and about what had happened in this regard. However, I think we are certainly entitled to point out the vindictive type of gerrymandering that is taking place in this Bill, that it was deliberately done to suit the Fianna Fáil Deputies and their other candidates and to harm as many as possible of the Fine Gael Deputies. We have given examples of different areas where this has happened. I shall not go back over that, but it is another effort to try to rivet Fianna Fáil in power against the wishes of the people. They know their backs are to the wall at the present time. They know they are fighting for their seats and indeed "seats" is the operative word at the present time because we have so many of the mohair boys who have so much to lose and who had not a seat to their trousers——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Again, the Chair would point out to the Deputy that matters like this have been repeated previously. We are dealing with section 3.

Comment on this

That is the reason I raised it. Unless Fianna Fáil get back the maximum number of people, whether they are entitled to it or not, the mohair boys who had not a seat to their trousers in the past and who are battening like parasites on the people of this country——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This would seem to be more relevant on the Second Reading of a Bill like this and not on the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

It would seem to be more relevant to some tailor or other.

Comment on this

Talking about Taca——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair does not want any comments. Will Deputy L'Estrange please come to section 3? The Chair would appeal to the Deputy to keep to section 3 in order that the debate may move forward.

Comment on this

In their efforts to rivet themselves in power Fianna Fáil are due 100 per cent for gerrymandering and work well done. They have nothing to learn from the Unionists in the North as regards gerrymandering. The Minister has deliberately set out to deprive Fine Gael and Labour Deputies of seats in certain parts of the country.

Comment on this

We did not.

Comment on this

Why is it that in the Dublin area, where the Fianna Fáil vote has dropped so low, the Minister has all four-seater constituencies, hoping to get two seats out of the four?

Comment on this

We have heard that before.

Comment on this

In other areas he has three-seaters, hoping to get two of the three. The Minister has produced a vindictive Bill against the express wishes of the people, expressed a few months ago when there was a massive vote against the Fianna Fáil Party. The people love freedom and justice. They like a Government prepared to give justice to all sections of the people and to cherish all sections of the people equally. This Government have not done it in the past and they are certainly not doing it in this section of the Bill. An enraged electorate are only waiting for the chance to show their rage. The Fianna Fáil Party will face a massive defeat such as they suffered on 16th October last.

Comment on this

I am not going to be too long at all and I will come straight to the point. Perhaps the Minister would be so kind as to give me information, if he can. At the present time we are working, so to speak, on the register of electors that has been compiled in September and October of last year and finalised in the various constituency areas in the last week or two. I do not know whether or not this exercise has been worth while because this register of electors will be in operation from 14th April next. I do not know whether we are going to have a general election before 14th April. If we have it, and if we have it before this Bill is law, we will have to operate on the old constituencies.

I should like to know from the Minister what effect the changes now proposed in this Bill would have on the register of electors. What effect will it have on the new register? Will it be necessary to take a census of the people entitled to vote or will there be, as I imagine, a transfer from one to another? The Minister nods his head so I presume that will be the case and it will not be necessary to take a new census. What amount of time will be taken? Will there be a big difficulty in this or has this work been done before the passage of this Bill into law?

Comment on this

Apart from Deputy Corish's query and Deputy Martin Corry's contribution, everything else that has been said since Deputy Fitzpatrick escaped from the clutches of Deputy L'Estrange, and nailed Deputy L'Estrange and Deputy Hogan to keeping this going on their own, has been out of order. Since Deputy Corry was on my side there is no need to reply to anything he said. Since I do not want to co-operate with the Fine Gael Deputies in ignoring the rules of order I will just deal with what Deputy Corish has asked me.

The position is that until this Bill is enacted by the two Houses of the Oireachtas the present constituencies are the only legal constituencies. Therefore, the register will have to be compiled on the basis of these existing constituencies. Even after this Bill is passed the existing constituencies will be the constituencies for by-elections. Possibly Deputy Corish is more immediately concerned with the constituencies in which the by-elections are imminent. I agree that the other constituencies are relevant also but certainly in so far as the constituencies in which by-elections are imminent are concerned, it is on the basis of the present constituencies that they will be contested. There is always the possibility of other by-elections before a general election. Registers will have to be compiled for the existing scheme of constituencies in any case. I would not be surprised if the people who are in charge and responsible for the compiling of registers have plans in mind for the compilation of the new registers that will be required for the proposed scheme of constituencies, but there will certainly be no authority for them to start compiling registers for these constituencies until the Bill becomes law. What will be done then is that the existing registers will be adjusted to take account of the new constituencies. That will obviously take a certain amount of time. I do not know how long it will take. All the information will be available and it should not take too long. They will have to be printed. I do not know how long that will take but it would not be legal to do it until the Bill has been enacted.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister are county registrars entitled to engage in this switch legally? A certain amount of expense must be incurred.

Comment on this

Are they entitled to incur expense in this operation? No, they really would not be. It is the county secretaries, not county registrars now.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 62
·
Níl 44
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 3, line 2, to delete "South-West Donegal" and to substitute "Donegal-Leitrim".

Comment on this