We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Industrial Relations Bill, 1966: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–187 of 375. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Industrial Relations Bill, 1966
Enacted

No. 23 of 1966 ›

Section 2 as it stands reads:

The Court shall consist of a chairman (in this Act referred to as the chairman) and, either, as the Minister may from time to time in his discretion determine, four or six ordinary members (in this Act referred to as the ordinary members) of whom (if there are four ordinary members) two shall be workers' members and two shall be employers' members and (if there are six ordinary members) three shall be workers' members and three shall be employers' members.

Does the Minister not consider that he should give himself authority to further extend the court? We have from time to time found ourselves in the position that for no reason except that too much business was being put before too few people, the courts have been held up and cases which may appear to be unimportant to the court but are important to the people concerned have been held up for a considerable length of time. I am not blaming the court. They could do nothing about it. I feel the Minister should have left himself a bit more scope there so that he could extend the court further if he thought it was necessary.

Comment on this
Patrick John Hillery Minister for Labour (Dr. Hillery) Fianna Fáil

Six is based on the experience to date and it is an assessment of what will be required in view of the experience of the court to date. The court is not always that busy.

Comment on this

Not always but the Minister does appreciate that from time to time over a period of months when wage rounds are being negotiated there can be a whole clutter of cases one after another. One of the annoying things is that cases can be heard and it can be literally weeks, in some cases longer, before the court gets an opportunity of considering the evidence and giving a recommendation.

As the Minister knows there are proposals in the Bill, and particularly in some of the amendments, to widen the scope of the court considerably. This will mean additional work. The Minister seems to be happy that three courts will be sufficient to deal with the volume of business. I agree with him that there are times when there is practically nothing to be done as far as ordinary court hearings are concerned but there are times when double the number proposed here would not be able to deal properly with all the matters that come before the court. Let the Minister not tell me that it is a question of cost because in a case like this the cost to the country often is very great because of the fact that the court is not available to hear a case.

There was a school of thought in the Labour Court a few years ago, which appears to have disappeared now, that a dispute should be allowed to mature, as if it were a boil and you were waiting for it to come to a head, as they used to do in the country long ago before it could be treated. Some of those boils were left too long and they caused considerable upset to everybody including the workers in the industries concerned and the industries themselves. For that reason I would ask the Minister to consider whether or not he is sure that he is doing the right thing by limiting the number to three rather than saying that the Minister may add courts if he considers it necessary.

Comment on this

This has been considered in consultation with the people using the court, with the people concerned, and from the experience to date the suggestion that arises is as embodied in the proposals, that there be provision for three sections to the court. I would leave it to the discretion of the experienced officers of the court to decide the question of whether it is comparable to a boil maturing or not but I understand that lack of sufficient staff is not as big a problem as the Deputy considers it to be. This provision does cover what are thought to be the needs of our circumstances.

Comment on this

Surely, on that point, up to date we have wage agreements at different parts of the year? The tendency is to try to get them into one period, to prevent leap-frogging. If this were to happen, would you not need a lot more than three courts? At the moment there are wage agreements in January, February, March and so on, but the tendency is to bring them into one period, one month or, if necessary, one week. At that stage would you not require more than three divisions?

Comment on this

I can see the need for an extra service but I believe this would be at conciliation level—a conciliation officer or industrial relations officer, as we call him.

Comment on this

On that point I agree but, if we are going to try to concentrate the demands into a period, which is a better way than leap-frogging, with an increase of £1 in January, 25/-in February, and 30/- in March, there will be a tremendous demand at one particular time. I agree with Deputy Tully that we might want six divisions in one month and for the rest of the year one would do. If the Labour Court delay it, this will extend the wage increase which will again start the leap-frogging.

Comment on this

What I had hoped was that the accent would be more and more on the conciliation aspect of the court's work rather than on decisions by the court. If we are to appoint people and they are to be paid from public funds, we will have to have some consideration of what we think will be the work available and, while I can see what the Deputy says about work coming together; I think this work will come to the conciliation service——

Comment on this

Most of it.

Comment on this

——rather than decisions having to be made by the court. The extra division made possible by what is proposed here is the estimate of what will satisfy the needs. If we go beyond what I am told by the people involved is sufficient, where do we stop?

Comment on this

Why not have the power to do it if required?

Comment on this

I had in mind that from time to time there would be amending legislation. As I have said, from 1946 to now is much too long. In future legislation will have to be introduced more frequently according as we discover what the needs are and as the trade unions and the employers discover what their needs are.

Comment on this

Yesterday during the discussion on the Criminal Justice Bill I was here and I was rather at a loss because all those debating that Bill, with the exception of myself, were practising lawyers. There were points which perhaps I was not able to appreciate for that reason. In this case the shoe is on the other foot. I have been a practising trade union official for 22 years. I grant that Deputy Belton on his side of the fence has experience of wage negotiations.

What the Minister says is correct, All of us would love if disputes could be settled at conciliation level because usually there is a better spirit there and eventually it is a matter of cooperation between different groups. The big trouble is that the Labour Court of itself has done what I consider to be an amount of harm, because it has been insisting on disputes which have no hope whatever of being settled at conciliation level being referred to a conciliation officer, and this is simply a matter of stalling.

It seems ridiculous if I have a dispute with an employer in Cork or Kerry that, after I have gone half a dozen times and discussed the items concerned and found we cannot reach agreement, I must go down there and go over the same ground again with an officer sitting there who will admit that there is no hope of reaching agreement at that level. He will say: "I think it is a matter that should be referred to the full court", or: "I will make a recommendation to the full court." This is one of the problems. People concerned with disputes should be the judges of whether or not conciliation is the answer to the problem. If they are satisfied that conciliation will not produce a result, then there should not be any necessity to have conciliation. It is expensive; it is timewasting; and it is terribly frustrating when one has to go over the same ground again and again.

A typical example of this is local authority disputes. Suppose we have a dispute over differentials for supervisory grades with a local authority and the county manager says: "Well, I cannot agree. This should be settled at national level." You go to the next local authority and it is the same. You refer those cases to the Labour Court and the Labour Court will arrange conciliation conferences with each local authority from Donegal to Cork, and we must go around to each one of them and do exactly the same as we have done before. We have already been told they will not agree and that it must be settled at national level. We must go to the trouble and expense of doing the same thing again. We are wasting the time of the Labour Court as well. The proceedings could be shortened if the advice of the employers and workers were taken on whether it was likely to be settled at conciliation.

The Minister says many of these matters could be settled at conciliation. That may be so, but I still think it is not the answer. I am not going to press the point but the Minister should leave himself the right to appoint two or three more courts if a volume of work builds up and the only way of settling it is either to have court cases and have them cleared quickly, or have strikes scattered all over the country.

Comment on this

The very existence of the Labour Court has tempted a big number of employers not even to negotiate. While Deputy Tully has deep experience in his field, my own experience over the wide field of trade union consultations is that many of them think they are dragged to the Labour Court as a substitute for meaningful negotiations. This is a fault they find in the employers' attitude to negotiations. I am certain that the Labour Court is not over-taxed with cases at that level of court sittings. I am satisfied that to provide more than we have provided in the proposal would be going beyond the estimate of those who are equipped to say what is wanted, and would be moving away from the idea of getting people to negotiate meaningfully in their own area. If they need the help of a conciliation officer or an industrial relations officer his services will be available. I think the whole movement should be towards negotiation.

Comment on this

I appreciate that the Minister has experience in his Department. I am quite sure he knows that quite a number of people who negotiate on behalf of firms represent the firms on whose behalf they are negotiating. If that representative makes an agreement which he thinks is reasonable there is always a chance that he will be turned down by his principals who will say: "It is not reasonable. You should have been able to get a better settlement." The temptation in that case is to go to the Labour Court and have a recommendation made by someone outside. The firm will probably accept it if it is made by an outside body, and may not accept it if it is made by one of the employees or colleagues. I do not think there is anything wrong in that case in having the matter dealt with by the court rather than having it dragged over a long period, and if this prevents an industrial dispute I think the Minister will agree with me.

Comment on this

I still think that three sections of the court will meet the need.

Comment on this

What is wrong with having the power to have four without using it?

Comment on this

You would be always under pressure to appoint more and more.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 3, line 31, to delete " prepare" and substitute "make".

The Parliamentary Draftsman considered that the word "make" would be better than the word "prepare".

Comment on this

I agree this is a good amendment, because as it reads the Minister could prepare something and do nothing about it.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Tully is drawing from a long, melancholy experience not applicable to this scheme.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 3, after subsection (5), to insert the following subsections:

"(6) The Minister shall grant and pay to Cathal O'Shannon, upon his retirement without reappointment from membership of the Labour Court, a pension for his life of one thousand, one hundred and twenty-five pounds per annum and a gratuity of one thousand six hundred and eighty-eight pounds.

(7) The Minister shall grant and pay to Ernest Edmonson Benson, upon his retirement without reappointment from membership of the Labour Court, a gratuity of three thousand pounds.

(8) The Minister shall grant and pay to Joseph Stapleton Quigley, upon his retirement without reappointment from membership of the Labour Court, a gratuity of three thousand pounds".

This is a special provision in respect of three serving members of the Labour Court who are now over the normal retiring age. It is proposed to provide for them under the pensions scheme which I shall submit to the Dáil in due course. Mr. O'Shannon is a workers' representative and has been a member of the court since 1946. On retirement he will be paid a lump sum of £1,688 and a pension of £1,125 a year. Mr. Benson and Mr. Quigley are employers' representatives and on retirement will be paid a lump sum of £3,000 with no pension.

Comment on this

What is the service of the other two gentlemen?

Comment on this

I can get that for the Deputy. Mr. O'Shannon is getting special consideration which I think is justified, and I was justifying it.

Comment on this

I am not querying the fact that Mr. O'Shannon is entitled to special consideration. If I had thought of it in time I would have recommended that he should receive a gratuity of a much greater amount.

Comment on this

Mr. Benson has 12 years' service and Mr. Quigley six years' service.

Comment on this

Are the three of them retiring in the near future?

Comment on this

The nominating body can put them forward again if they so desire. They are beyond the retiring age and if they retire they will get whatever is provided in the legislation.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Shannon has many years' service.

Comment on this

Since 1946.

Comment on this

That is 23 years' service.

Comment on this

There has to be a special provision because a pension within the scheme would be inadequate for him.

Comment on this

I would say the House would not cavil if the Minister had made the gratuity a much higher one than is mentioned here.

Comment on this

This has had a very thorough thrashing out with the Congress and the other people concerned.

Comment on this

I appreciate that, but I am just comparing six years' service with 23 years' service.

Comment on this

There will not be a pension in the case of the others.

Comment on this

This relates to changing "conciliation officer"?

Comment on this

Yes. Would the Deputy like me to explain it?

Comment on this

There is not very much to explain. Maybe the Minister could explain if I have taken it up wrongly. It appears to me that this does nothing except change the name. Could the Minister tell me if it is proposed that the industrial relations officers who are referred to here should operate within the system of promotion for civil servants? Are they people who will be in a section in which the first step in the line of promotion will be into the Labour Court as industrial relations officers and who, no matter how good they are at this work, when the opportunity arises for further promotion, will just step out again? Is it intended to continue that arrangement?

Comment on this

What I am trying to arrange is a flexibility of procedure which would make it possible to appoint people who are good at this type of work. This is a very special talent which cannot be discovered beforehand. I do not know of any aptitude testing that would show beforehand whether a person is good or not at this. As far as the law is concerned, the field is completely open on the number who may be appointed and how they will be selected. I am flexible in this regard. There are advantages in this movement through the Civil Service in so far as we may get a good officer who is not particularly good at this work and who can be transferred to other work to which he is suited. I discussed this in the Dáil before when the question was raised about the appointment of people from outside who may not fulfil expectations. It is hoped to make the conciliation service worthwhile and to get people in it who are good at this work.

Comment on this

It is very important to get suitable people. There are two things which affect it. One is that if a person is good he should not be left at the rate which is applicable to the job; in other words there would need to be promotion within the grade in the Labour Court.

Comment on this

This can be overcome.

Comment on this

It is a pity some effort was not made to do this before now. This has been dragging on for a long time.

Comment on this

There has been promotion within the service without the moving of personnel, and there have not been many losses in recent years.

Comment on this

There have been a number of losses where very good officers suddenly disappeared. On the one hand you will have the officer who will sit in at conferences, listen to both sides and say nothing, and, on the other hand, you will have the officer who will put in a suggestion at the right time. The officers who are good at the work suddenly disappear because they are due for promotion and it would not be fair to deny it to them. There should be promotion within the service so that these people could be kept rather than allowed to move to something else.

Comment on this

I am aware of this and the administrative procedures for making it attractive to people to stay are being applied. It can be done better administratively than by making a provision in law for it.

Comment on this

It can be done without making a provision?

Comment on this

Yes, my intention is that it will be done.

Comment on this

It is as important to have a good relations man here as to have him in business, more important in a way.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

Is this decision binding in relation to the interpretation of agreements?

Comment on this

It is only an interpretation. It is not binding.

Comment on this

The judge gives a decision, but the Labour Court can make recommendations.

Comment on this

It is a decision on interpretation. It will arise only if the Labour Court is asked to interpret.

Comment on this

I do not know if the trade unions would agree to that but, if it is only a matter of interpretation, I see no objection to it.

Comment on this

The trade unions do not even like the word "decision".

Comment on this

It is only an agreement.

Comment on this

There is no harm at all in the Labour Court's saying what they meant. If that is the idea, then we have no objection; if, however, they say: "This is what must be done; this is our decision" that is a different matter altogether.

Comment on this

They decide, on request, on the interpretation of the agreement or on its application.

Comment on this

It would be their interpretation of what they said.

Comment on this

If two parties come to an agreement and later they cannot decide what some particular part of that agreement means they can go back to the Labour Court and ask the Labour Court what it means. If they go and ask for a decision then I presume they would have it in their minds to accept.

Comment on this

This could be very dangerous.

Comment on this

It is not binding. It is a request to interpret.

Comment on this

Suppose two parties had a dispute before the court and the court made a recommendation that there should, for instance, be a substantial wage increase and the unions interpreted that increase as operating from the date of the commencement of the dispute and the employers, because of some earlier agreement, argued that it should be 12 months' hence and they went back to the Labour Court and the Labour Court said: "It was our idea it should date from 12 months' hence" that would not be binding because of the fact that the unions did not agree with it.

Comment on this

This section refers to an agreement already in existence between unions and employers. One part of that agreement needs to be interpreted as there are different opinions on it, but it is their own agreement.

Comment on this

But the agreement could be based on a misunderstanding. The Labour Court would have had to come into it somewhere. So long as it is only a matter of interpretation and so long as it is not binding, that is all right.

Comment on this

Suppose Deputy Tully and Deputy Belton make an agreement between them and, at some stage, they find they are not at one in the interpretation of some particular part of it, the Labour Court can then be asked to give an opinion on how it should be interpreted. That is the intention of the section.

Comment on this

I disagree with Deputy Tully. I think this decision should be final because it will be given by an independent body. It is not like looking for a wage increase. This should be final because, if it is not, everything will have to start all over again and eventually somebody will be unhappy. It should be a final decision.

Comment on this

This is one of the things that could cause one of the biggest rows that ever occurred in industry. If an agreement is made and there is a doubt about one section of it and the parties involved go to the Labour Court and the Labour Court say that the employer is right, the trade unions will not at any point of time hand over their right to take certain action and all that could be done, therefore, if Deputy Belton is right in what he is asking the Minister to do, is for the Labour Court to declare that their interpretation is binding, whereupon they do not come into the matter any further. Now, if a dispute occurs, the Labour Court would be precluded from investigating because they had already given a decision. That is why I stress that this should be only a matter of opinion on the part of the court; it should not be binding.

Comment on this

That is what is in the section at the moment. Deputy Belton's suggestion could be achieved by writing it into the agreement.

Comment on this

That is a different thing.

Comment on this

I am approaching it as a matter of interpretation.

Comment on this

It is not arbitration.

Comment on this

Both the trade unions and the employers would be scared if they thought they were going to get an adverse decision.

Comment on this

I move amendment No 3:

In page 4, line 20, to delete "may, at its discretion" and to substitute "shall".

Under the 1946 Act the situation is that the Labour Court may hold any sitting or part of a sitting in private. The matter is in the exclusive discretion of the Labour Court. Under this section the sittings will be in private but, if a party to the dispute asks for a public hearing, the court, at its own discretion, can hear in public. In the amendment I propose that a request for a public hearing will be granted at the discretionary consideration of the court. That would, I think, be a more clearcut procedure and would remove grounds for friction. The court may go into private session to deal with matters which are regarded as confidential.

Comment on this

I have had personal experience of this. Very many employers, who are prepared to negotiate behind closed doors because wages are so low and conditions so bad, would be scared to death of a public hearing at the Labour Court because, if the press are present, the world at large will learn what the dispute is about and, because of that, it is often very easy to make an agreement without going to the Labour Court at all. At the mere mention of the Labour Court these employers will say: "I think we can do a little better". Now, suppose there is a dispute at hearing before the Labour Court and the employer produces what he calls confidential documents and gives them to the court, saying that they are confidential and he does not want the other side to see them but is prepared to make them available to the court so that the court can see what the position is, a certain danger arises. I had experience of this: in the documents given to the court privately there was a suggestion that there had been a tremendous increase in overheads in the previous 12 months which had resulted in quite a loss and the firm were not, therefore, in a position to meet demands. In all innocence, the court said they did not think the union should press for an increase at that particular point of time. We could do nothing about it. Subsequently, because some member of the firm was a little indiscreet, we discovered what the facts were: he related how the firm had got away with it because the increases in the overheads were, in fact, increases in directors' fees, and nothing else. They succeeded in beating the claim by the union on what was, in fact, unfair evidence. Because it was alleged the information was confidential the court said: "It might do the firm harm if this information were published and we feel you should accept our word for it". I am not saying the court were remiss, but we were not in a position to refute the evidence. This happened a good many years ago. I understand the system has changed since but, if confidential information is provided, that information should be given in confidence to the chief negotiator at least on the other side. That is the only way in which such information can be checked. Now the Minister cannot write that into the Bill, but he is writing in that a public hearing should take place and I am in entire agreement with that.

Comment on this

Is it the employers who object to the public hearing?

Comment on this

My own thinking on this was influenced by the fairly remarkable success of the conciliation procedure, which is private, and by the fact that so much time is lost in going to the court for a public hearing; the whole thing has to be thrashed out then for the benefit of the public when it may be only a very small point that separates the two sides at the finish. There is also the behaviour of people on both sides who have to strike attitudes—a party line, if you like—in public. These can be perfectly intelligent and reasonable people in private but, when exposed to the public, they put on an act that is totally unrelated to the work they are doing.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking about employers.

Comment on this

They are to be found on both sides. They can create a lot of damage when they come out scream-ing that the proper machinery is not there—as happened last week. There can be posturing. In private, people behave more like human beings. It is not pressure from either side——

Comment on this

This has come from the officers of the Labour Court on recommendations of the unions or employers.

Comment on this

It is not one side or the other.

Comment on this

There is nothing mandatory that the hearing be held in private. There is discretion. If it is the request of the parties that it be held in public if they so desire it——

Comment on this

The starting point is private.

Comment on this

Labour Court proceedings might be shorter if more cases were heard in private. Can the Minister clear up a reservation I have in regard to subsection (2) of section 8 which reads as follows:

Where an investigation of a trade dispute is being carried out by the Court in public, the Court may, if it is satisfied that any part of the investigation concerns a matter that should, in the interests of any party to the dispute, be treated as confidential, conduct that part of the investigation in private.

Are we not back here to what we changed in the original part where, at the request of the parties, they wish it to be in public? Is the court not still left with a great deal of initiative to decide which part of a case should be in private and which part should be in public? In other words, I have in mind what Deputy Tully was referring to: the court could put an embargo on perhaps a vital part of a case to which, possibly, one of the parties to the dispute consider it essential to the success of the case that public opinion be alerted. Under subsection (2), the court could still decide that part of the case must be heard in camera. Therefore, there is still something unsatisfactory in subsection (2). The court is still left with a great deal of discretion concerning which part of a case should be held in private and which part of a case should be held in public.

Comment on this

I can see that in a perfect world, everything should be open to the public. However, there are parts of a businessman's affairs that cannot be exposed to his competitors and certainly, in the case of individuals —who may be considered as individuals—I think the court itself should have a discretion to hear things about them in private. I suppose there is an onus on the court to satisfy the side which wants everything in public. In any particular case that the court decides that part of it should be heard in private then that part should indeed be held in private. I can see that there is a need to have some discretion and I think the court should have it. If everything were held in private, we would not have half the troubles. Much of what goes on is done for the stage.

Comment on this

All you would have would be industrial relations backbenchers——

Comment on this

I do not think so. The conciliation service is remarkably successful and it is in private.

Comment on this

I do not think——

Comment on this

I do not say that they go for that purpose but they end up posturing.

Comment on this

You will have the representatives of the people concerned in the court and they will carry back their version. Therefore, if they posture in public, there will be posturing in private also. Maybe it is more necessary in order to make one's case stronger because the newspapers are represented there to report what was said or what happened. Deputy O'Leary is perfectly correct, in my opinion, because subsection (2) looks to me very much as if one went to the pictures to see a thriller only to find that the bit where the murder occurred is left out and therefore one has only the two ends of it.

As far as the case itself is concerned, those who are interested in it, unless they are present, will not be able to know what was the kernel of the dispute.

Comment on this

There will have to be areas where somebody uses discretion to protect with privacy certain information.

Comment on this

There has been an unwritten law that, if somebody hands in certain documents, they are treated as confidential.

Comment on this

I cannot imagine the court's functioning at all if somebody demands that everything that comes before it is for the public press.

Comment on this

Where an investigation of a trade dispute is being carried out by the court in public, that means that both parties to the dispute have agreed that it should be in public——

Comment on this

One party——

Comment on this

At any rate, it means that a request has been made that it be held in public. Therefore, there is disagreement obviously amongst one of the parties at least. If the court decides that some aspect of the case should be held in private so that——

Comment on this

We are talking about those few cases in which trouble of this kind may arise and it will be a matter of interpretation by the court——

Comment on this

One party wants it in public and then, as the case proceeds, something crops up about which the court says, in effect: "I think that is rather confidential. Can we close it for a moment?"

Comment on this

Before parties go to a court there is exhaustive investigation of practically every factor involved in the actual case under investigation.

Comment on this

Holding the hearing in private does not mean excluding either side from the evidence.

Comment on this

We know that. It is the press.

Comment on this

One can imagine certain situations where a person's personality may be so discussed or a person's business may be so exposed that it would not be desirable for those people to have it published in the press. Therefore, the court would have discretion to protect them.

Comment on this

The Minister is leaving it very wide.

Comment on this

As it is written in now, it is encouraging people going to the court to behave in a certain way. But I can see Deputy Belton's point of view as far as his side would be concerned: it is mostly from that side that the complaint would come. It does tend to encourage an employer going to the court to say to the court: "I think this is a private matter and should be discussed in private." I do not remember half a dozen cases in which I have taken part where, on one side or the other, I could not say: "These facts affect the personality of a worker or the personnel manager's attitude and, maybe, if it is in public, it might affect him again", and so on. Any kind of confidential data are entitled to be treated as confidential but I think it would be a great mistake if the tendency is to close every court for a period in the middle of a case and to say: "This is something we should discuss in camera". I am afraid we should soon find a worse position than that which obtained at the start.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy propose an alternative?

Comment on this

I think there is a feeling on the part of Deputy Tully and Deputy O'Leary that part of the function of the court is to be a sounding board of public opinion. I think Deputy Tully himself said so—that we can make sure we get a proper decision. This is an entirely wrong conception of the court. A court should surely reach its decisions on the facts put before it and should never be influenced by whether there is a leading article in a newspaper or whether there has been adverse comment by a columnist, and so on. The main trouble always seems to be, and this applies to both sides, the employers' side and the trade union side, that far too often they are uncertain of their own position, they are both a bit on the defensive. Both sides have to realise that the court as constituted is well qualified to reach an objective and fair decision on the facts as disclosed.

Once we start what the Minister has called "posturing", which is a natural human failing, once we try to influence public opinion through the evidence given before the court, the evidence will be heavily weighted on our own side. For that reason it is very much better that on all possible occasions the hearings should be in private. My own experience has been that when two sides get together before the court or a conciliation officer there is an atmosphere of more flexibility because nobody outside the parties concerned will know whether an attitude adopted in the first place has now been abandoned or compromised in some way. This gives a much greater flexibility. I do not feel that this provision in subsection (2) of section 8 weakens the position in any way. I have sufficient confidence in the court that they will not allow anyone on either side, employer or trade union, to make gratuitous and irresponsible applications for hearing in camera. You have to remember that many cases that come before the court involve public companies whose accounts have to be published anyway, their overall accounts, but there may very well be small details which cannot be disclosed without giving away vital information to a competitor.

You have to remember that once one party has said they want the hearing in public, and the court finds itself bound to hold it in public, it will be difficult to persuade the court that this matter complained of by one side is really confidential. I have sufficient confidence in the court to believe that Deputy Tully's fears are without foundation and that in actual fact the court will be very slow to close the proceedings to the public once it has opened them. It would put itself in a very difficult position. However, there can be cases where they should and we have to leave that discretion in the hands of the court. On the whole, I would hope that decisions would be reached by the court in private without any reference to public opinion at all. Public opinion does not come into the decision of a court. The decision of a court is purely a matter of a decision on matters of fact or of law and it should be kept that way and it would be far better

Comment on this

That explains our whole difficulty in bringing in amendments to this Bill. We have been attempting to drum into the heads of Deputy Booth's Party just what the Labour Court is and what industrial relations are but the Deputy stands up and shows that he does not understand what it is all about or what the Labour Court is. He persists in confusing the Labour Court with the Four Courts and of course there is a vast difference between the two. Industrial relations are not concerned with facts of law as in the civil courts. They are concerned with how much profit you want to make as an employer and how much wages your workers want. Despite what the Deputy says, public opinion plays a fantastically decisive part in deciding what justice should be given in this area.

Comment on this

Not in the Labour Court.

Comment on this

It is not a court in which individuals can preside and make out to the last particle what justice dictates. This is a question of income and nobody yet has devised the last word of what should be the basis of an incomes policy. Therefore, the Labour Court must, to some extent, be guided by and be sensitive to public opinion on the issues before it. Obviously, if two parties to a dispute are doing their best to achieve a settlement, and some aspect of the case comes up which is palpably one which should not receive public attention, or which they did not feel was necessary to the solution of the case, it would not be unreasonable for them to stick to their guns and refuse to have the hearing in private. It would be a mistake to think of the parties in a dispute being, at that stage, in any way antagonistic. You have the three sides involved, the employers, the trade union and the court, all attempting a settlement.

However, there is a loophole left here and which we sought to close, where the court can itself decide to close a case to public opinion. The Minister need not think that we are trying to make a mountain out of a molehill but after we pass this it will stand as law and every last clause of it could be a serious matter in future for interpretation. Therefore, we are not kicking up a dust over something trivial but attempting to avoid trouble in the future. It appears that a loophole still remains in regard to the opening of the court's proceedings to the public. There is still a large loophole for mistakes to occur and what we are trying to do is to rule out the possibility of mistakes occurring. Obviously mistakes will occur and there is no need to stop up these loopholes if you have an opinion of the Labour Court, such as Deputy Booth has, that it is just a suboffice of the Four Courts, but Deputy Booth has not got a clue in the matter.

Comment on this

I am grateful to Deputy O'Leary for putting the matter so clearly but I do not agree with him for a moment. I do not regard the Labour Court as a court of law or a subsidiary of the Four Courts but I regard anything which is called a court as a body which is trying to take an objective view of facts put before it. I do not agree for a moment with Deputy O'Leary's conception of the Labour Court's being something like one of these "people's courts" in the Iron Curtain or Communist countries——

Comment on this

Do not forget Cuba.

Comment on this

——where those courts are not dealing with fact but are there to express the opinion of the people, so called. I do not accept that the Labour Court is something which was set up to interpret and enforce public opinion. That, to my mind, would be an intolerable situation and something with which I could not agree for a moment. It has to deal with the facts as put before it and reach a decision or a recommendation to the best of its ability. I would resist to the limit any effort to switch the Labour Court from that line of action and merely make it a mouthpiece of a very vague public opinion. That is just asking it to be the victim of propaganda. We do not want to have the position that it would be influenced by the FUE or the decissions of the Federation of Irish Industries, or any of the other bodies, or of the Trade Union Congress. It must be an independent body dealing with the facts as put before it.

Comment on this

Before we go too far away from the section let me just point out one thing. Deputy Booth says that the question of having publicity given to it is not important and should not have an effect at all. Actually, this is where I disagree. The Deputy is reading up the next section; there is a comment on it in the Press today.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy converted?

Comment on this

We like to see cases published fully as heard in the Labour Court because if I have 100 similar cases and one goes to the Labour Court and the discussion on it is published widely there would be very little difficulty in getting agreement on the other 99 without going to the Labour Court with each one.

Comment on this

I agree with that.

Comment on this

For that reason, a public hearing is very important. If I tell the employer that this is so or tell him that something is definitely correct he may not accept it from me but if it appears in the Irish Press, the Irish Times or the Irish Independent on the following day as having been discussed in the Labour Court he will not even wait for the recommendation to come. When he sees it in black and white he seems to understand it in a different way and usually we find that publication of a case heard at the Labour Court settles very many more cases than go before the court.

Comment on this

That is the purpose of the amendment as I put it down—to permit a request to be effective to have a case heard in public. The portion with which Deputy O'Leary has trouble is where it allows discretion to the Labour Court. I can see that the Deputy's mind on this matter, perhaps, is that everything should be thrashed out in public but there are cases which we would agree should not be held in public—not the whole case at any rate.

Comment on this

I would agree.

Comment on this

The disputants might not agree on this and somebody must have discretion. I think the court should have this discretion which actually has been in practice since 1946. I see no alternative. It may not be the perfect solution but it is as near to doing the job properly as we can get in law.

Comment on this

This is an entirely new provision which I mentioned on the Second Reading. It relates to the conciliation and arbitration schemes throughout the public sector. There are different arbitrators for these claims and they always act in isolation from each other. They apply varying considerations, I think, to cases brought before them. The result has been discontent produced among different groups of workers because of different findings by different arbitrators. There has been an element of what has been called "leap-frog" introduced into the settling of wage and salary levels. I thought that both from the point of view of discontented people who came out less well-off than groups in other arbitration schemes and also from the point of view of the economy generally the arbitration part of any scheme should be done by the Labour Court. That was my original proposal.

I had intended that the Labour Court in acting in that sphere would be suitably augmented by people with all the necessary qualifications, economic and otherwise, and, if something was not resolved at conciliation, it would go to this extended Labour Court. This was not acceptable to the staff associations and unions dealing with the public sector. They objected strongly to having the arbitrator replaced by the Labour Court and what is here proposed now is a compromise which is as near as I can get to having some relationship between the decisions made in the different arbitration bodies and that is to have members of the court sit on each arbitration board. When I was introducing the Second Stage I said that I hoped those concerned would come around to my original way of thinking but I have no evidence of that as yet.

Comment on this

This is rather wide. I did not study the section until now. When I first looked at section 9 (b) I felt that "the staff of" might be taken out and it would save a lot of trouble at a later stage. The section reads:

The membership of any board established either before or after the commencement of this section to report on claims in relation to the pay and conditions of service and matters relating thereto of any person——

it does not say "officer," but "person"— who—

(a) holds a position in the Civil Service of the Government or the Civil Service of the State,

(b) is a member of the staff of the Houses of the Oireachtas,

(c) is a member of the Garda Síochána,

(d) is a sub-postmaster,

(e) is employed by a county committee of agriculture, a vocational education committee or a local authority for the purposes of the Local Government Act, 1941,——

I do not know exactly what this Act is concerned with—perhaps the Minister would say. This qualification means that the Local Government Act, 1941, must have a certain limitation as otherwise everybody who already has the right to go to the Labour Court would be included in this. The section continues:

(f) is employed as a teacher in a national, secondary, vocational or comprehensive school or in any similar school, or

(g) is employed by any such body established by or under statute and financed wholly or partly by means of grants or loans made by a Minister of State or the issue of shares taken up by a Minister of State as may be designated from time to time by the Minister for Finance,

shall include one workers' member of the Court and one employers' member of the Court who shall be selected by the chairman.

(2) Subsection (1) of this section shall come into operation on such day as the Minister may appoint by order.

Reading that without the Minister's explanation, which may clarify it, it appears that many people who are already entitled to have their cases heard solely by the Labour Court are included in this provision.

Comment on this

No. The list is in fact the list available to me of schemes covering persons already covered by schemes of conciliation and arbitration. It is put in that way to identify them as people who have their wages, salaries and conditions of service determined in this type of scheme. They are not people who go to the Labour Court. It is a list of people having conciliation and arbitration schemes.

Comment on this

The employees of local authorities, employees of vocational education committees and members of my union have a right to go to the Labour Court as of now. Does the Act of 1941 affect them in some way? I am referring to paragraph (g) of the section "is employed by any such body established by or under statute and financed wholly or partly by means of grants or loans ...". Does that not mean State and semi-State bodies? Many of these employees are already entitled to go to the Labour Court as things stand. How do you differentiate between those who go and those who do not? This is the sort of thing that may complicate matters later on.

Comment on this

I shall have to get a copy of the 1941 Act but what is intended is to identify the people who now have a scheme of conciliation and arbitration and thus are not entitled to go to the Labour Court.

Comment on this

"Officers" might. If the word "officers" were included——

Comment on this

But an officer is a person.

Comment on this

And a servant is also a person.

Comment on this

I think the drafting is correct. We have named here all the schemes covering persons and those covered by these schemes are not entitled to go to the Labour Court because they have arbitration and conciliation schemes. What we are doing is bringing into their schemes the idea of a member from the employers' side and a member from the workers' side of the Labour Court sitting in for arbitration.

Comment on this

I am not objecting at all to the idea. You want to have a certain amount of levelling off——

Comment on this

Not to have them acting in isolation. These are schemes already in existence and we are introducing the Labour Court——

Comment on this

On that I am with the Minister. Those people who have access to the Labour Court, because they are servants of a local authority or a vocational committee or are servants or minor officers employed by a State or semi-State body at present have nothing except the Labour Court, no arbitration or anything else, and, indeed, some of them have not even the Labour Court but only indirect negotiation. We are hoping that this Bill will bring them in. By putting them in this section the Minister is, in fact, blocking the hopes of these people and what they have might be taken from them. Arbitration and conciliation does not apply to them.

Comment on this

People mentioned here are people who already have a scheme.

Comment on this

It does not affect existing conciliation procedure. It affects only boards already set up to deal with those particular people.

Comment on this

That is not at all what the section says.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy that no rights are being taken away. It is introducing members of the Labour Court to boards already in existence.

Comment on this

It just adds two members to the existing board.

Comment on this

So long as it does not mean that at a later stage somebody will say to a person that he is not entitled to go to the Labour Court because of the fact that he is excluded under section 9 of this Bill——

Comment on this

No, it does not.

Comment on this

I have been in this House for long enough to know that quite innocent sections put in through error have had rather peculiar results but if the Minister can give me an assurance——

Comment on this

The accidental interpretation of the law of which the Deputy is thinking could not come from what is in the section. What is listed there are the schemes already in existence into which we are introducing members of the Labour Court.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister that everybody, including all these people, should come under the Labour Court. I do not see why one section of workers should go to one place and another section to another place. Perhaps the Minister is making this as an interim measure. I would hope that, in future, when the Act is in force, they would come to the Labour Court. What about the ESB who have their own tribunals?

Comment on this

I intend to deal separately with the ESB.

Comment on this

The ESB are another section but how do we know that industrial relations in these places are not just as bad as in the ESB?

Comment on this

The ESB tribunals are established statutory tribunals and the nominations to them are made by workers and employers. This Bill proposes to abolish the ESB tribunals and to put the Labour Court in their place. These schemes which exist in the different places mentioned are agreed schemes which can be terminated on six months' notice from either side and they can be changed by agreement. I had hoped that by discussion we would get agreement to having the Labour Court as the arbitrator. They were totally against this but I hope that some time they will come around to my original view that the Labour Court should be the arbitrator.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4 which is in my name and that of Deputy Corish:

In page 5, to add to the section a new subsection as follows:—

"( ) In Part III of the Principal Act `worker' shall include—

(a) an agricultural worker,

(b) a servant of a local authority,

(c) each class of officer of a local authority specified in the Second Schedule to this Act."

This is the first of a series of amendments that we have put down. The amendment to section 10 suggests the addition to the section of a new subsection. Section 10 reads:

(1) If an employer or a trade union representative of employers affected by a registered employment agreement complains to the Court that an employer affected by the agreement has failed or neglected to comply with the agreement, the following provisions shall have effect—

(a) the Court shall consider the complaint, and shall hear all persons appearing to the Court to be interested and desiring to be heard,

(b) if, after such consideration, the Court is satisfied that the complaint is well founded, the Court may by order direct the said employer to do such things as will in the opinion of the Court result in the said agreement being complied with by the said employer.

(2) If, where an order is made by the Court under subsection (1) of this section, the direction contained in the order is not carried out, the person to whom the direction is given shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds, and, in the case of a continuing offence, a further fine not exceeding ten pounds for every day during which the offence is continued.

(3) If a person affected by a registered employment agreement fails or neglects to comply with the agreement, the person shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds and, in the case of a continuing offence, shall be liable on conviction on indictment to a fine of one hundred pounds and a further fine not exceeding ten pounds for every day during which the offence is continued.

We put down the amendment because we seem to try to differentiate between different types of workers in this country and one such type of worker who, on every occasion that I know of, to put it mildly, has been treated as a second-class citizen is the agricultural worker. He has not been included in the Employees Holiday Act. There is an Agricultural Workers (Holidays and Wages) Bill before the House which proposes to give these people four extra days' holidays. We were to get that Bill before Easter but it has not been introduced because agricultural workers, according to the present Government, do not count.

Looking at section 10 of this Bill we see that agricultural workers are being left out. There is an Agricultural Wages Board and their job is to fix minimum rates but they have fixed minimum rates so low that even the Government themselves have stated that the rates of pay of lower paid workers are far too low. They pontificate on the necessity to have these rates increased. If the Government wanted that, they could go to the Agricultural Wages Board and tell them that they are not doing their job; that the rates are far too low and that they will find another way of fixing rates and that would be the same way as industrial workers' wages are fixed.

It is necessary that agricultural workers' wages should be included in a Bill such as this. There is no reason why agricultural workers should not be included. One may say that servants of local authorities should not be included but we have, in local authorities as, indeed, in some State employment, productivity agreements. Is there anything wrong with asking the Minister to include in this Bill the servants of local authorities so that productivity agreements could be made legally binding and so that we could ensure that they would apply all round and that the local authority employee would be treated in the same way as anybody else?

Comment on this

I am not quite sure why the Deputy came in on section 10 but I will, with your permission, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, deal with the amendments tabled by Deputies Tully and Corish in a general way. Their amendments seem generally designed, if they are taken together, to bring some provisions of the 1946 Act to bear on agricultural workers and certain workers in State and local authority employment.

Even one amendment would dissolve the Agricultural Wages Board in favour of a joint labour committee. I suppose I should mention that a joint labour committee cannot be set up merely by stating that the Labour Court can set it up. It has to come together.

Comment on this

The implications of amendments to deal with this matter would call for a great deal of thought and of consultation with other Ministers. In fact, I do not think it could adequately be dealt with by way of amendment to this Bill at all. I intend having discussed the matter with Deputy Tully in private session in the Department of Labour, to consider this departmentally and to have consultations with my colleagues about it.

As I said, when I was introducing the Second Reading of the other Bill, I would see this Bill as one of a series of measures designed to improve industrial relations stage by stage. As we reach the various stages, we can make certain proposals. The provisions in the Bill represent, after two years of consideration and discussion, the distance which I am willing to go at this particular time. It does not in any way represent a limit to the statutory improvements which could be and will be effected.

The amendments, if I may deal with them all together, to abolish the Agricultural Wages Board in its entirety and to provide for joint labour committees would be a fundamental change after years and years. We just could not consider this in a very short time like this.

Comment on this

At this time, having raised it now. I think it may be that close examination would indicate that there should be some changes in the method of determining the wages of agricultural workers. The House will appreciate my colleague, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, will be very much involved in this consideration, and I could not lightly make the changes proposed by incorporating the amendments. This is why I asked if I could deal with them in general. They represent a fundamental, substantial change and warrant special examination. I would undertake to have this special examination carried out fairly quickly. As I said, I would regard it as one step only. I do not see anything wrong with a series of Bills to deal with specific situations according as they are teased out, examined and some measure of agreement is arrived at.

At the same time, I would ask Deputies to recognise that the Bill is a product of long consultations and slow progress. Anything new added to it would have to go through the same procedure of consultation and examination. In asking the Deputies to withdraw those amendments I am only asking them to go back to what we have before the House now. If they want it, machinery can be set up quickly to examine the proposals. I would ask them to wait for another time to bring in those proposals as the product of our consultation and thinking on the matter.

I have the same feeling about the other amendments, which are designed to extend the whole of the 1946 Act to local authority employees. At the moment they only come under the part relating to access to the Labour Court. This is something new. I could not come to a conclusion on it without full consultation with everybody concerned. Those involved would be the Minister for Health, the Minister for Local Government, hospital authorities, health authorities and county managers. I am not rejecting out of hand the principle involved in the amendments. I am just saying I could not accept them without giving full weight to the views of the people involved. Again, I am prepared to do what I have done up to now—to find agreement on proposals. I am prepared to enter into consultations with the parties involved at once if the Deputies will accept that anything arising out of those consultations will be the subject of legislation at a later date.

Comment on this

There are a couple of things I would like to go back on. First of all, when we were dealing with the additions to bodies in section 9, one of the bodies to which it is not proposed to add a member on the Labour Court is the Agricultural Wages Board. It would seem to be a natural thing to put one of their members on the Labour Court but there is a very good reason why it is not done. It is because of the low wages and the hours of work. When we come to talk about the establishment of the 40-hour week, we find people in agriculture with a 50-hour week for eight months of the year. Therefore, the Minister conveniently leaves the Agricultural Wages Board out of the list of bodies whose members he proposes should sit on the court.

If the Minister was really interested in doing something for low paid workers here was the best opportunity he could get. If he was not prepared to go the whole way with us, at least he could take this step of putting a workers' and employers' representative from the Agricultural Wages Board on the Labour Court. We might get somewhere with hours and have some comparison with industrial wages then. The Minister says he is prepared to set up some type of body to discuss these matters. He says the amendments introduced by us should get the same attention and scrutiny as the other matters in the Bill. I agree with him, but he seems to forget that about two years ago he was kind enough to meet the president of my union and myself. I think the Minister cannot complain about the information and details which we gave to him and his private secretary. It is doubtful if any other union would go to the trouble we did to give him the facts of life so far as lower paid workers are concerned— local authority employees, agricultural workers and State and semi-State employees. Not alone did we give this to him verbally but we gave him as much detail in writing as we could and we have been keeping him up to date in regard to what is happening and what is not happening.

Comment on this

I was not saying the Deputy did not keep me fully informed. He did. But there are other people who have to be consulted and it is slow going.

Comment on this

Is it not unreasonable, after two years of discussing this and having given all the information, for the Minister to say he is looking after the workers of this country but that, in regard to the poor relations, he will introduce a Poor Relations Bill at a later stage for the fellows who must be left out of this now? Farm workers, road workers, certain other sections of workers we have mentioned in our amendments, certain workers of local authorities and non-nursing personnel all come into this. They are not included in this still. I am sure that the Minister will, if he can, persuade his colleagues in the Government—if he can get them all on talking terms—to discuss the matter of including those less fortunate sections of the community. I do not want to wait another two years for the Poor Relations Bill. I should like to have it now. If the Minister says he is prepared within a reasonable time, which I would say would be before the Summer Recess, if there is one—if there is a Dissolution it will not be entirely his responsibility —to implement his suggestion of some committee to go into this matter, I am prepared to withdraw the amendments on that understanding.

Comment on this

I do not know whether we will call it a committee or not. There will be some form of procedure for consultation with the people involved. We will do that. The Agricultural Wages Act will have to be changed.

Comment on this

I could tell the Minister what to do with that but I will not.

Comment on this

As I say, I do not reject these things or the consideration involved. We will have legislation incorporating the product of these consultations. It might not be everything the Deputy or others want but we will have legislation and I will set up whatever procedure is needed.

Comment on this

What does the Minister mean by "consultation"?

Comment on this

Up to now we have had consultation between my chief advisers in the Department, the Congress of Trade Unions, and the employers' body. This might or might not be what the Deputy would think right. There was a series of meetings going on.

Comment on this

This might meet the situation. The Congress of Trade Unions are sending representatives, and naturally they will come from unions. I do not want what is to happen with regard to agricultural workers' wages and hours decided by the employers' representatives or by the Agricultural Wages Board as set up. Nor do I want conditions of employment of local authority employees to be the subject matter of advice from people who are employers or who claim to have experience but who do not represent these people. That is what I am trying to get the Minister to understand. If we are to try to improve conditions for the workers concerned we should at least have the advice which the Minister has already got. He should have the advice and information he requires from the people who represent this type of worker. Forgive me for using the phrase but, having introduced an Industrial Relations Bill to cover workers, and having left a certain set of workers out of it, it appears that the appropriate description for the Bill would be the Poor Relations Bill. I object very strongly to the attitude which the State has adopted all along that there are two types of workers— workers and others. The "others" usually can be ringed around as agricultural workers, local authority employees and the lower-paid State employees. They are left in one category. One has only to compare their wage rates with the wages of others covered by this Bill. The wages of others covered by the Bill are not wonderful wages, but they are princely compared with those of the unfortunate people who are being left out of every Bill to improve conditions, including the Bill we are now discussing. If the Minister says he can, within a reasonable time —and I specify before the Summer Recess and I will not blame him if there is a Dissolution because it will not be his responsibility then—set up a committee to go into the matters and present a report in a reasonable time I will be satisfied.

Comment on this

The Deputy is as well aware of the factors and the pressures involved as I am. There would be difficulties but I can undertake to have this examination started in some form before the Summer Recess.

Comment on this

I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:

In page 5, to delete subsection (1) and to substitute the following subsection:

"(1) The Court may, after consultation with organisations which, in the opinion of the Court, are representative of any class, type or group of workers and of their employers—

(a) make rules which apply to, and which, in the opinion of the Court, provide for fair employment conditions for, that class, type or group of workers and are approved of by organisations representing a substantial number of the workers of that class, type or group and organisations representing a substantial number of those employers,

(b) make rules which amend any such rules and which apply to and, in the opinion of the Court, provide for fair employment conditions for that class, type or group of workers and are approved of by organisations representing a substantial number of the workers of that class, type or group and organisations representing a substantial number of those employers, and

(c) make rules which revoke any such rules."

The use of the word "industry" in the subsection as printed would give rise to arguments as to whether this or that type of employment was an industry. I would like the Labour Court to have as wide a field of action as possible in this matter and I think the amendment would achieve that.

Comment on this

The only thing is that it is rather a pity we have a very long section here. We have an equally long amendment moved by the Minister. It is pretty difficult to understand why, after two years' churning, we have a section like this and how the necessity arises to amend it so quickly.

Comment on this

It is a drafting amendment really.

Comment on this

That makes the matter worse.

Comment on this

We always have drafting amendments. The Dáil would not be the same without drafting amendments. It is to get away from the idea of "industry" where you might have a limitation on what the Labour Court can take as a class of workers. It gives more flexible interpretation.

Comment on this

In various Acts workers have been described in a certain way. I, however, have an amendment to this section which suggests that "worker" should include people who are not included in this. It does not do at all to have people left out. Since my amendment has not been moved I cannot deal with it but, if the Minister would have a look at it, he will see mentioned people who are workers but who are not included in the section.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister how the fair employment rules here work? What relationship do they have to the old minimum legislation involved in the old Joint Labour Committee and may I ask whether this is an extension in theory of the Joint Labour Committee idea or whether in fact the Minister hopes to see fair employment rules embodying far more than the old minimum rules? Could the Minister give us any idea of what he expects to get from the fair employment rules so far as wages, hours and general conditions and incomes are concerned? In other words, will they try to set up better standards in industry? Obviously the overall concern of this section is for workers who are not members of trade unions. As we know, in many parts of the country there are industries which the trade unions have found difficult to organise, possibly because of the small scale of many of the units making up the industry. In Dublin there are many backstreet textile and hosiery factories. We know ourselves of very inadequate work places for juveniles and girls in the city of Dublin which trade unions have been unable to reach and organise. They can only be called sweat shops because they do not, so far as one can see, live up to standards that should be in vogue in 1969. Mainly they employ young people, girls and juveniles, and while they may comply with the actual minimum conditions under the Factories Act we suggest that the Factories Act should be updated to take into account what we expect of conditions today. I would like to ask the Minister if this fair employment rule means something more far-reaching than what we have had up to now under minimum conditions. Of course, if he wishes it to be a far more extensive thing than the old minimum regulations, then obviously it will call for a very wide increase of his factory inspectorate. The Minister can come in here with the figures but we are convinced that the actual work situation in this country is insufficiently investigated, insufficiently known. We all know of back street factories in which people are working in very bad conditions and are not organised by the trade unions. There are also hotel workers who are not organised by trade unions and it is no exaggeration to say that in some hotels that are not organised by trade unions there are employees working a sixteen-hour day. This is occurring.

The type of employee who is exploited in this situation is very often a juvenile just left school. This is one of the biggest problems I want to bring to the Minister's attention. The most exploited section of Irish labour is the juvenile section. The section between 14 and 17 years of age are now the most sweated and exploited section in the Irish work force. The fact is that as a result of our low school-leaving age we are giving an open invitation to employers to exploit this section of our society which very often, not being involved in a trade union, is unable to answer back or in fact does not know its rights. It works very long hours at very low wages in very poor conditions. I would ask the Minister to enlarge his inspectorate and to begin a pretty thorough examination or inventory of these newer industrial establishments which emerge in city areas especially and where young people work in very poor conditions at a period in their lives when healthwise it cannot do them any good for their future adult lives.

Another section which must be looked at is juvenile employment in garages throughout the country; we notice a tendency to employ young people nowadays in dead-end jobs, attending petrol pumps, and so on. This must be looked at. The overall idea of the fair employment rule should be to root this out.

Perhaps unsatisfactory conditions have not yet been ruled out but certainly totally unjust conditions for certain sections of adult labour have been eliminated. The new problem which is now emerging and which the trade unions as yet have been unable to deal with adequately is the problem of sweated juvenile labour, a problem the full extent of which we do not know but, most certainly, parents and others, who may perhaps belong to trade unions themselves, have a job to bring the attention of their trade unions to this growing problem.

Comment on this

In answer to the quescer tion of safety at work I am not sure whether I have publicly announced or told the Dáil that I have given financial sanction for a greater number of inspectors, for the restructuring of the inspectorate, which is proceeding. Naturally we have to go at the speed at which suitable personnel are available to employ them but we have made all the financial and the administrative arrangements for a muchextended factory inspectorate and therefore more extensive activity on the part of the inspectorate.

The section here is in the nature of an experiment. In the case of registered employment agreements and joint industrial councils and joint labour committees the initiative now comes only from people who are interested. I want to get the Labour Court taking the initiative. Deputy O'Leary asked whether they would do more than the joint labour committees. I think these may have come to the stage of dealing always with the wages and I would like to see the court actively encouraging groups of workers and employers in different employments to work out agreed basic conditions of good employment, that is, in the various matters which would affect both the worker and the employer. This should lead to a work basis where people would have a better understanding of their rights and of course of their obligation in areas outside the area of wages already dealt with, in areas such as discipline, dismissal, complaint procedures, demarcation and so on.

If fair employment procedures are established on a voluntary basis by representative parties in a particular employment and if these are substantially approved by those concerned, they can be converted into statutory fair employment rules by the Labour Court and made legally binding. I think the difference here introduced is that the Labour Court will have the initiative to seek to make clear to every worker his rights in relation to dismissal, discipline, complaint procedures and in general have initiative to improve the position of workers in any type of work.

Comment on this

Suppose a Fair Employment Order were brought in in the case of a particular industry and was agreed by the representative organisations of employers and unions involved, there would still remain a section which would not be organised by unions. What investigation can we make into an area in which there is no check as to what is happening? We draw up the rules and we say: "This is the fair employment rule" but what do we do for the ten, 15 or 20 per cent which accounts for the real injustice and exploitation, the people who are running small industrial units in upper rooms in city streets, in back avenues, mainly employing juvenile labour— girls and boys? It is an especially big problem in the city of Dublin.

The Minister referred to extending the inspectorate. Would it be true to say that he is also considering extending that section of the inspectorate which would deal solely with conditions of young people at work?

The inspectorate, I know, has been overworked already. Many times the Minister has been asked in this House to increase the number of female inspectors to deal with women at work. I would ask the Minister to consider extending the interest of the inspectorate to young people of both sexes between 14 and 17 years of age at work. This is a growing problem in Dublin and one that has not received much attention, as far as I know, so far.

Can the Minister give us any further information? When we draw up the Fair Employment Order and it is agreed upon by the representative organisations of employers and the Court certifies it, what action do we take then to see that it becomes a reality in this ten or 15 per cent of work places which may or may not be living up to the spirit of this legislation?

I should like to ask the Minister whether he is satisfied that, at present, sufficiently close scrutiny is maintained on anonymous workshops where the practices I have referred to are carried out and where Irish youth is being exploited; whether he is satisfied that there is sufficient surveillance. When the Fair Employment Order is issued, can we be satisfied that such workshops will carry out the spirit as well as the letter of the law?

Comment on this

There is another section which should be dealt with under this and I am wondering how the Minister will deal with it. He may remember that some time ago an effort was made by the people engaged in quarrying for road materials to get a registered agreement. Firms employing men, paying them decent wages and giving them good working conditions found themselves in difficulty because a number of other people who could be referred to as pirates were undercutting them and could supply materials at lower rates simply by having men who could not otherwise get a job working for them and working long hours. I know some of them myself who start work at 7.30 or 8 o'clock in the morning and are still working, particularly in the summer time, until 10 or 11 o'clock at night, even on Saturday nights. They are not paid overtime. The employers say: "You are getting £17 a week which is more than a driver gets in a neighbourning firm."

So far it has been found impossible to get a registered agreement, even though a big section of the employers and the unions want one. I should like to see this practice stopped because, when an effort was made by a trade union to organise the employees of a pirate firm, what did they do? They closed down. They stopped work in that area and moved off somewhere else. They left their employees in the position that they had to go elsewhere looking for employment, and they were able eventually to resume as a nonunion firm and pay the scandalously low wages and give the bad working hours and bad conditions which they had been giving. If this section of the Bill succeeds in catching people like that, as well as those referred to by Deputy O'Leary, it will be doing a good job for everyone concerned. It is most unfair that firms giving good employment and good conditions, and paying good wages, should be put out of business by the antics of those people who are there for a time only to get the best they can out of it, and who get out when the going gets a bit hard.

Comment on this

The implementation will be done by the staff of the Department of Labour. They will be nontechnical officers. I do not see any problem in making them available as we observe the needs. The needs will arise as the orders are made and fair employment rules are accepted by the Labour Court. Once the Labour Court is satisfied that the rules are accepted by a substantially representative number of the workers concerned, then it can be made statutory, and then it becomes the duty of the Department of Labour to implement it. It does not require technical staff.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that he has the resources at present?

Comment on this

It is hard to say. I assume I will have the co-operation of Deputies and the trade unions and other people.

Comment on this

The unions will admit frankly that there is this uneasiness that in many of these small units starting up it is impossible to keep an eye on all the areas, that is, where there is a small shop employing ten or 15 people it is impossible to keep an eye on them all. Can the Minister say has any survey or any examination been made of this kind of problem? We may draw up fair employment rules and they may be observed in employment where there are trade unions, and where there are employers who have been civil enough to deal with trade unions, but what about the maverick employers who may be living in 1913—and there are such employers, regrettably, still in this country? It is all right for the employer to live in 1913, but the employees are living in 1969. He may insist on dealing with them in this way, as many of them do at present, many of the employees being young people who do not know, perhaps, what their rights are, and who put up with pretty bad conditions. We are permitting grave injustices to continue under our noses. We may have fair employment rules which look very elegant and full of the spirit of social justice but, in fact, there are still not only pockets but large areas in which very harsh conditions prevail.

Comment on this

I will examine it on the basis that the problem exists. All these people will have to register at their places of employment. Co-operation between the Department of Labour and the trade unions would be welcome and useful.

Comment on this

In the example which I gave to the Minister, would he consider that where you had a large volume——

Comment on this

That is the quarries? I do not know how you would handle that.

Comment on this

A large volume of employment is given by people like Roadstone who pay reasonably good wages, or at least negotiate on them, and give good conditions of employment. Then there is this swarm of small people who gradually build up. I have in mind two firms, but I will not name them, who have been cutting in. We go to the good employers and, rightly so, they say: "What are you going to do about So-and-So? He has taken this contract off us, and that contract off us and the other contract off us." Check back to find out how he took the contract and you will find he did it because he undercut the firm, and could do so by having men working for him for perhaps a couple of shillings an hour less, and working long hours.

There is no point in asking why do the men do it. There are still big areas where there is no other employment and the position is either to go to the labour exchange or work for those people. It is the standard of living of the worker and his family that is depressed as a result of the actions of these people. It is criminal, in my opinion. Indeed, I believe the Department of Justice should step in because when a man is driving a lorry from 7 or 8 o'clock in the morning until 11 o'clock at night he cannot be in the best physical condition. I believe the Minister should have this section of the Bill so framed that these people will be caught. I know that the better employers and the trade unions have applied to have an agreement registered.

Comment on this

If they had a registered agreement——

Comment on this

They could not get it registered because there were not enough of them involved. The Labour Court said: "What about Mr. So-and-So who is employing 50?" All over the country there might be 4,000 or 5,000 employees which would be more than there are in the bigger firms who are giving good employment and good wages. Because of this they refused to register the agreement. We had a lot of this in the building trade for a good while and eventually reason seemed to prevail there and it was settled. We have not now got the man we call the house sparrow who carries all his tools on a bicycle and can undercut everyone else. If the Minister can improve this by insisting on this type of people being included he will be doing a good job. It is not a job which cannot be done.

Comment on this

I do not know what can be done.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary was talking about these things being done in the back rooms in the cities but there is a new racket. When they found they were not getting youngsters in and around the cities they moved down to the country towns. It is usual for someone like myself to be approached by someone who wants to start an industry. We got very "ikey" about these things and we started looking for the details of the industry. We are told: "We are going to employ 50 people" but eventually after making inquiries we find that the 50 people must be between the ages of 14 and 16 years, and there is no guarantee of employment after the age of 17 years—and they are female. I do not need to go any further. They are simply stitching or something like that.

One employer told me the reason he employed that type of person was: "You know, their fingers are more nimble and their eyes are far more accurate at that age." I said: "The fact that they would be satisfied with a very much smaller wage packet would not have anything to do with it?" I do not think he is a friend of mine any longer. This is the sort of thing which happens not only in the cities but has to be pursued right down the country. Quite a number of inspectors will be needed.

Comment on this