Committee on Finance. - Industrial Relations Bill, 1966: Committee Stage.
Contributions 188–375 of 375. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 23 of 1966 ›
Can the Minister say whether the fines for contravening the fair employment rules have been altered, or are they a continuation of older fines which we had previously for breaking registered agreements?
Comment on this
The cost of living goes up every year. If you park a car now for 10 minutes in any part of the city of Dublin it is £1 immediately. Those vigilantes who are now clearing streets and avenues have acquired an enviable reputation for efficiency in planking their tickets on the cars of the citizens of Dublin. That is £1 for 10 minutes' contravention of the law. Other matters have been updated but we do not believe we should update our legislation in regard to the penalties being inflicted on an employer who is guilty of anti-social activity. He is guilty of a serious crime against the community in that he ignores rules drawn up by representatives of employees and employers. Would it be correct to say that the fine would be the same as was imposed, say, 20 years ago?
Comment on this
If we have the same fine on an employer who contravenes an order in 1969 as obtained in 1946 we are not being serious about ensuring that the Act is a reality for those employers who wish to ignore it. Subsection (4) says:
A person who contravenes a fair employment rule shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds and, in the case of a continuing offence, a further fine not exceeding ten pounds....
Could the Minister tell us how many employers were brought to book under the old code for contravention of an order? Does the Minister not think that a more realistic figure commensurate with the offence should be imposed? I would suggest that this subsection (4) of section 11 is merely a pious finish-off to this legislation and is never meant to be implemented. Would the Minister not consider that a fine of £500 would be more in line with what is required?
Comment on this
It seems to be ridiculous that the same fine should be provided for in an Act in 1969 as was provided for in the 1946 Act. The same thing occurs in subsection (3) of section 10. Where there are penalties provided the Minister should look at them generally and upgrade them just to keep in touch with reality and, if necessary, bring in a subsection amending the old section of the 1946 Act.
Comment on this
I shall examine that. I have not the information Deputy O'Leary sought about the number of convictions. I shall have a look at that, too.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 5, to add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"( ) In this section `worker' shall include—
(a) an agricultural worker,
(b) a servant of a local authority,
(c) a person designated for the purpose of section 17,
(d) each class of officer of a local authority specified in the Second Schedule to this Act."
Could the Minister say whether or not it was his intention to include these types of workers in the Bill? The fair employment rules are confined to industry. It would be better if the Minister put in the word "business" instead of "industry". In the Redundancy Payments Act, 1967, it was not the word "industry" that was used but the word "business".
Comment on this
What I have done here is to refer to a class of workers engaged in industry. I have proposed an amendment to that.
Comment on this
What amendment is the Minister talking about?
Comment on this
We are on section 11, and my amendment No. 5 changes the word "industry" to "class, type or group of workers" so as to make the field wider for the Labour Court.
Comment on this
I still think he would have covered it much better if he had deleted "industry"——
Comment on this
It would be a much tidier provision and would have included all these people I am talking about. At least it did include them in the Redundancy Payments Act and, if it stood up there, there is no reason why it should not stand up here. Another point is that we have been hearing in this House for a long time from the Taoiseach's predecessor, from the Taoiseach and from the Minister of the desire to bring certain sections of workers under the Industrial Relations Act, including particularly State employees. Does the Minister intend to include them or does he not?
Comment on this
That is a great step forward since 1946.
Comment on this
I know; I have experienced it here this morning.
Comment on this
I should like to draw the Minister's attention to subsection (3) (a) which says:
Before making fair employment rules the Court shall cause to be published in such manner at it thinks fit....
I do not think we should give so much discretion to a creature of the Legislature. These fair employment rules are going to be important and we should give explicit directions to the court that it shall publish fair employment rules at least twice in each daily newspaper published in the State, or something to that effect. Under this provision the court would be carrying out a statutory obligation if it published these fair employment rules in Our Boys. The Minister should, accordingly, direct the court to publish these rules as widely as possible through the daily press and through Iris Oifigiúil.
Comment on this
They have been there for 23 years and I have had no record of any complaint about inadequate publicity.
Comment on this
That may be so, but I do not think it is sufficient to say it has been there for 23 years and still give the court discretion to act as it wishes.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree with me it would be desirable to do something like that? The fact that we have not done it for 23 years does not mean that we should not do it now when we have the opportunity.
Comment on this
We have not had anyone saying there should be better publicity and anything written in might limit.
Comment on this
I do not suggest we should limit, but we could give a direction specifically in regard to the daily papers and we could go on and say "in such other manner as it thinks fit give notice of its intention". One is not limiting in doing that, but one is making sure they give at least reasonable publicity to their intentions and that is very important and highly desirable.
Comment on this
It is not often I find myself in agreement with Deputy Barrett but, when I do, it is a pleasure. The Minister says he does not see any need for this but all of us are aware of employees who are puzzled about the actual details of the conditions governing their work. Unions do their best to inform members of employment regulations but there still remains in many employees' minds an ignorance of their conditions. What we should do is go to the actual point of presenting each individual employee with a copy of the conditions appertaining to his place of work. The Minister may not be aware of complaints, but there is a good deal of confusion. Bad feeling can be caused by ignorance about conditions. If we have fair employment rules we should ensure that each employee will have a copy of those rules so that he or she will be aware of both obligations and rights. I agree need has not arisen but, from my knowledge of factories and so forth, I know there is a good deal of confusion on the part of employees about rights and obligations.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Barrett and Deputy O'Leary are actually agreeing about two different things. One is the question of the publication of the agreement by the Labour Court in order to allow people to make representations before it becomes law. Now I shall have to examine this to see what we should do. I have an open mind. The Labour Court is a responsible body. It has been operating for 20 years now. With regard to publicising the rights of workers, we dealt with that adequately, I think, in the Redundancy Act. If these statutory rules come into operation it might be a good idea to see in what way the Department of Labour can help.
Comment on this
That is not required, but I will see what we can do in the line of publicity to ensure workers are aware of their rights. From both the employers' and workers' point of view it would be very important that they should know their rights.
Comment on this
The Minister is satisfied because the Labour Court is a responsible body, but sometimes responsible bodies act irresponsibly. I instance the case of the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries and the farmers' publication. The Labour Court might react in the same way as the Department of Agriculture did on a certain occasion.
Comment on this
If the journal mentioned in the Act had gone out of publication and they were required to advertise in it that would put them in an awkward position.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to have another look at subsection (1) (c). The Minister will tell me this was in the 1946 Act but the fact that it appeared in the 1946 Act should not make us complacent about it and accept that it is right. First of all, there is a different personnel here in this House today. There is different thinking on these matters. There are, in fact, different conditions. The inspector can walk in at what he considers to be a reasonable time to almost any place and examine any person whom an inspector has reasonable grounds for believing to be or have been a person affected by a registered employment agreement and require such person to answer such questions, other than questions tending to incriminate himself, as the inspector may see fit to put to him. It was iniquitous to incorporate this into the 1946 Act.
Speaking from memory, I think that Act created only summary offences. This Bill creates, in addition, indictable offences. We are now in the position of telling a citizen that he is under an obligation to answer any questions put to him by another citizen, dignified by the name of inspector and fortified with a certificate to that effect. That is contrary to natural justice. It is all very well for the Minister to say the person questioned need not answer questions tending to incriminate him, but who will judge what questions would incriminate? If an inspector asks another person questions and the other person says that the answers to the questions would incriminate him, will the inspector be satisfied or will the man who refuses to answer find himself in the position of committing an offence under this Bill when it becomes an Act? The average person questioned by an inspector is not in a position there and then to decide whether the answer to a question is likely to incriminate him. If the Minister is not prepared to alter the subsection drastically, he should at least alter it to the extent of adding that the person need not answer the questions put until such time as he has had the benefit of legal advice. It is highly desirable that the citizen questioned should be able to say, when the inspector tells him that he must answer certain questions and, if he does not do so, he will be committing an offence: "Go to hell. I will not answer until I have had legal advice." At least give the citizen the freedom of being able to say he will not answer until such time as he has had legal advice. By modern standards this is an oppressive section and we should not be oppressive where any of our citizens are concerned, whether they be employers or employees. I appeal to the Minister to have another look at this.
Comment on this
I do not think it could be taken as a refusal to answer questions if one insisted on not answering until one had seen one's legal adviser.
Comment on this
As the section stands, the inspector would be within his rights in saying: "I went to the house. I produced the certificate and the citizen refused to answer."
Comment on this
The Deputy is saying that a man, whose job it is to protect the interests of both workers and employers, will act like a bullying drunk.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that one must always presume one is dealing with the lowest type of inspector? He may be up to his tonsils in drink. He is the fellow against whom the citizen must be protected. Ninety per cent of them may be the finest fellows in the world but, for the purposes of this legislation, one must legislate against the oppressive fellow, the bully, the drunk, the objectionable fellow and say: "I shall look after the citizen and I shall protect the citizen against that sort of fellow."
Comment on this
You must remember that we are dealing with a citizen and that the inspector goes to some place where he has reasonable grounds for believing that a person affected by a registered employment agreement or fair employment rules works. He is going somewhere where he has grounds for believing that the employer concerned has flouted an order by the Labour Court in regard to some matter as between employer and employee. My sympathy would not be with such a person. If our penalties mean anything the inspector must have the right to call on that man who is more than a private citizen. By flouting the rules that have been drawn up by his fellow employers and employees, he is depriving his employees of their just rights in the situation.
Comment on this
Right—he is suspected of it. It seems to me that to base the whole case almost in the style of the Soviet invasion of Prague is to overstate the position. We are dealing with a very small number of employers, namely, those who are living in the atmosphere of 1913. I am sure such employers are scarce in the country. I am sure, likewise, the inspectors conjured up who may be going out drunk to call on such employers are non-existent. Some of my best friends are inspectors. I therefore think the Deputy is exaggerating the case here.
I am more worried about the fact that we are dealing with a very small number of employers, we would hope, who do not live in our age or in our world, who cause a great deal of trouble, who do not wish to live in our age or in our world. My only worry about this section or about the previous one, with which it is connected, is whether the penalties involved are commensurate with the offence. The drafting here is "...enter at all reasonable times any premises where he has reasonable grounds for believing..." Presumably he will enter premises only on the basis of some kind of report, some kind of prior information. It appears to me, as we are legislating here, that what he can ask for is the minimum. I do not agree that any citizen's rights are impaired under the section.
Comment on this
I am pretty horrified to hear Deputy O'Leary talk as he has been talking. I hope he will never be in a position to introduce legislation of this type if this is the view he takes. He says, in effect: "This does not matter because they are only a very small section of the community and, in addition, they are employers. Therefore, their rights can be clipped and it does not matter". We are supposed to cherish all of the children of the nation equally. The fact that they are employers does not in the view of Deputy O'Leary, entitle them to protection. We have here a reference that an employer is convicted under fair conditions. I would appeal to Deputy O'Leary to think twice before he says that, because they are a small number and only employers, they are not entitled to the same treatment as I am entitled to, as Deputy O'Leary is entitled to and as everybody else is entitled to.
Comment on this
I think it is unfair of Deputy Barrett to make the comment he has just made. Deputy O'Leary gave a third cause. They are a small number, they are employers and they are people who are not treating all the people of the nation equally. They are people who are——
Comment on this
——and there must be good reason for the suspicion.
Comment on this
This is wrong. You cannot presume that this is so. They are only investigating an offence at this stage.
Comment on this
They are people against whom a complaint has been made either by individuals or trade unions for not doing what they should do with regard to wages or conditions. In fact, they would be people like some of the people I have referred to here and who, in my book, are in fact stealing money out of the wages of their employees. If the wage is fixed at £12 a week and they pay £8; if it is fixed at £16 and they pay £12; if it is fixed at £20 and they pay £16, they are stealing £4 a week. We still have some of them in this country who are doing that. I do not believe we should be a bit chary about whether or not we knock on the door and say: "Please, can we come back in a week's time to see your books?" because, by that time, a damn good job will have been done on the books.
Comment on this
My respect would be more with the bank robbers, the housebreakers, and so on, than with people who act in breach of these agreements.
Comment on this
I am saying that you should not be able to walk into the premises of any citizen. In fairness to Deputy Tully, he thinks that, no matter what a person's status is, you should not be entitled to walk in and to say: "I am not leaving until you answer questions." An inspector is not entitled to walk in and to say: "I am telling you that you must answer these questions. This question is not intended to incriminate you but you will not get advice as to whether it will incriminate you."
Comment on this
Then the bank robber who escapes into his own house, although he has been followed there by the Gardaí from the bank, should not be interviewed?
Comment on this
This is wrong and woolly thinking. In section 12, you are taking steps to prove that the man has not committed an offence. In doing so, you should approach him fully cognisant of the rights he has resident in him because he is a citizen. I think Deputy Tully and Deputy O'Leary are stating an outrageous principle when they say an employer is guilty because some of his employees have complained against him. An employer is innocent until he is proved guilty. Anybody who proceeds on any other premise is negativing justice in this country.
Comment on this
I think you are saying that you proceed with all gravity against a man but you make sure you cannot catch him.
Comment on this
No rights are being taken from a man here. If you are entitling an inspector to ask a question and if the man refuses to answer or obstructs the inspector, the inspector goes home and, if convinced that the refusal was a real obstruction to the carrying out of his duties, he can go to court and it will be the court that will decide whether or not the man was guilty of an offence; it will not be the inspector. This is not a question of tanks moving in on anybody. It is a matter of whether you are able to investigate and, if you are obstructed, then you must have some punishment which will be applied by the courts, not by an inspector. If you cannot investigate then you might as well not have any law at all.
Comment on this
Look at the subsection. At the moment, if he does not sign the declaration of truth, then, there and then, he has had it; he has committed an offence.
Comment on this
The attitude of inspectors up to now has been not to get to the court but to make a man, by persuasion, apply the rules to the workers. Naturally, the thing is to try to get workers properly dealt with by their employers rather than to seek punishment for an employer and let him carry on as he was. The inspector seeks to get the agreement and co-operation of employers to apply the rules.
Comment on this
The section says that a person who shall be guilty of an offence shall be liable to a fine not exceeding £20. In fact, he may be saving three times that amount by not carrying out the regulations.
Comment on this
Put two noughts on and we will be satisfied.
Comment on this
This is an entirely new provision and one on which I touched on Second Reading. Disputes can arise in regard to matters other than pay, hours and holidays. An example would be a dispute in regard to discipline or the dismissal of a worker or indeed in regard to a variety of things which have come to be regarded by workers as their right, whether they are written down or of long standing practice and custom. They can develop into a dispute situation with strike action being taken and the Labour Court being involved. Often the dispute leads to widespread action, although it relates only to one person. If we could remove these cases from the Labour Court and try to have a new system, to have a rights commissioner, we would be making an advance. From the text of the provision it will be seen that the whole concept is based on the voluntary acceptance by the parties of the commissioner and there is no crossing of lines in regard to what the rights commissioner would do and what the Labour Court would do. If the court has heard a case and issued a recommendation, then the commissioner could not hear the same case. If the commissioner has heard the case and issued a recommendation, then the Labour Court can be brought in only by way of appeal. With a view to encouraging acceptance of the commissioner's recommendation it is provided that if his recommendation is appealed to the Labour Court it will be on the basis of a moral commitment to accept the court's decision.
We have often seen a rejection of the Labour Court's recommendation and people have said "We were dragged before the court and we did not want to go". They cannot be dragged before the commissioner. The idea is to have the third man who is an experienced officer come in and make recommendations in a rights issue which could lead to a strike. I think in this way we would solve a big number of cases. If one of the parties is opposed to this the commissioner would not be able to come in at all. It is experimental and I could not say how the idea will work out.
It is proposed to appoint a commissioner in Dublin for a start and to appoint others in various centres. We may need a big number of them and they may be a great success. I hope they will be. It is one thing that we should try out in order to deal with disputes arising out of rights issues rather than conditions of employment or questions of wages.
Comment on this
The Minister is saying something which we have always held. He will be aware of what we have said in our publication Workers' Democracy—it refers to this matter— that many problems in industry are far deeper and more widespread than purely wages issues and are caused by resentment against the whole work situation. We have expressed this view in this document. However, it is not before the House now and it may take some years before it does come before it. In regard to recruitment of these rights commissioners there has been a tendency when dealing with industrial relations to concentrate exclusively on recruitment from the legal profession. The legal profession is an august body but we want to be careful in this area of industrial relations. I have repeatedly stated that if we really wish to tackle the problem in a realistic fashion, we must understand that the ordinary lawyer, with his common law background, and all the judicial training with which he is equipped, has possibly a mental attitude which is not attuned to the realities of industrial relations, and the valued judgments that are involved in mediating in industrial relations. We have to realise that in regard to the whole idea of industrial relations between employer and employee there may be several political philosophies with regard to how those relations should be solved. The whole period of industrialisation over the last 200 years, since the industrial revolution, has not given us any final answer to what the exact balance of power should be. Since we came to know the exact situation we have not been pragmatic towards the problems which cropped up and certainly we cannot be accused of being doctrinaire in this situation which is one of a shifting balance between important forces in our society.
Therefore the recuitment of these rights commissioners should not be concentrated exclusively on the legal profession, many of whose members may have professional limitations in dealing with problems in this area. The Minister should get men of goodwill from the business world and the trade union world to act in the capacity which he has outlined. He should not simply comb the legal profession for commissioners. I am not saying that we will not need people from the legal profession, of course we will, and many of them have made a pretty good contribution in this area, but we must not recruit commissioners exclusively from that profession. We must go into society and get business men who have ideas, who are of acknowledged goodwill in this area, practical industrialists who have day to day knowledge of dealing with employees, who have grown up dealing with employees, and also people in the trade union movement who also have first hand knowledge of the problems. The Minister, indeed, should cast a wide net.
I do not know if the idea of appointing regional commissioners is a good one, that it would be a good idea to appoint fixed commissioners for certain regions. However, the Minister certainly is on the right track in one regard and that is that we must keep amateur mediators out of industrial disputes. Too many amateurs have been interfering in the past. The Press itself at all times has a habit of looking for a Galahad who will, by a miracle, solve an industrial dispute when the people in the dispute cannot do so themselves. Miracles do not occur in the resolution of industrial disputes, either at the rights level or any other level, and it is no inhibiting factor at any stage to have a knowledge of the facts of industrial life. The Minister has taken a first and a healthy step towards eliminating these amateur mediators.
In the past few years we have seen false hopes being raised on three or four occasions that disputes were about to be settled either by some municipal figure or a prominent figure in the community, men who may have many qualities but who are not possibly bestequipped to deal with these thorny questions. Some fingers have been burned in the process in the past few years. The whole status of the Labour Court has been devalued where it can be suggested that somebody emerging from the sidelines has settled a complicated industrial question. It is the bane of those who are involved in a dispute from first to last suddenly to discover that a deus ex machina has arrived on the scene to settle the matter and, without any prior study or any knowledge of the underlying tensions at work, suddenly a solution is reached. It obviously means that respect for the reputation and status of all the existing institutions is devalued. Therefore, I think the rights commissioners could certainly ensure that industrial relations are left where they rightly belong, in the hands of those intimately involved.
Comment on this
The rights commissioner investigates the matter and then goes to the court and on this and other occasions where the court hear a case no time limit is set within which they must give their recommendation or decision. Surely there should be a seven-days or 14-days period in this case within which they must give a decision? This is very desirable rather than that the decision should be held over for two or three weeks.
Comment on this
I do not like the term "rights commissioner." Perhaps mini-ombudsman or something like that would be appropriate. Rights commissioner is a big mouthful for what might be a pretty small man. I agree entirely with what Deputy O'Leary said about the question of the amateur who dashes in to settle a dispute. It always reminds me of the story told of two men employed in a quarry. All morning they had been banging a very big rock with two heavy hammers. They did not appear to be making much impression on it. Towards lunch-time, the foreman came, took one of the hammers, hit the stone in the middle and split it in two and said: "That is how to do it." One man said to the other: "We were softening it all day for him." That sort of thing happens in these disputes where often people have been attempting to find a solution by direct negotiation for weeks and when they have almost reached a solution somebody steps in and succeeds in getting credit for much hard work. On occasion all of us have cursed the foreman who hits in the right place or arrives at the right time. It is regrettable that these people take some of the credit which is due to the Labour Court conciliation officers particularly.
This seems to me to be simply a continuation of the arbitration which the Labour Court operate at present. On a number of occasions where a single worker was involved in a dispute I have asked the Labour Court to provide an arbitrator. They produced one man and we agreed to accept the recommendation if it was one that could be accepted and the decision was given pretty quickly, in a matter of days rather than weeks as is the normal practice in the case of the Labour Court itself. I should like to know a little more about this proposal. Is it proposed that this rights commissioner should sit in Dublin? Will his only function be in the Labour Court? Will he go out to investigate disputes? Will he travel around the country? If he does, one would be very little use because the time spent travelling, unfortunately, unless we provide a helicopter service for the Labour Court, is very considerable as far as the Labour Court is concerned. If somebody must drive from one end of the country to the other it takes a good deal of time. I think it would be necessary to have more than one and perhaps they should be interchangeable. We find that while it is nice, if you are covering a particular district in the country, to know the officer you are getting and the side to approach and the side not to approach, at the same time this is equally evident to employers and others concerned and for that reason the fresh approach might be the better one.
I am intrigued with another matter here. Subsection (8) says:
An investigation by a rights commissioner shall be conducted in private.
That is fair enough, but subsection (9) says that a party to a dispute in relation to which a rights commissioner has made a recommendation may appeal to the court against the recommendation and subsection (9) (c) says that a hearing under this subsection shall be held in private. Why? I do not understand that. In the case of the hearing by a rights commissioner it might be a good idea to have it in private; but if it goes to the Labour Court is it not an ordinary case and why should it be decided that in this case it should be dealt with privately?
Comment on this
"A rose by any other name...." As far as we are concerned as working trade unionists, it is simply another case going to the Labour Court for investigation, just as if we had taken it to a conciliation conference and had made no headway. That was in private and we handed it over to the Labour Court. I think this is a restriction which should not be included. There should be the right to have the case in public if necessary because it may affect just one person and it may appear to the Labour Court to involve only a small matter but, in fact, it might have very great repercussions. I am all in favour of letting the general public know what is happening when cases between workers and employers have to be investigated, if that is possible.
Comment on this
I am quite convinced of the benefit, from the point of view of speed and normal commonsense, in having the business done in private. It is an experimental idea to have rights commissioners. I would hope they would act speedily and give their recommendations and that, if there were an appeal to the Labour Court, it would be heard quickly and decisively.
Comment on this
But you are finished with the rights commissioner as soon as his recommendation has been rejected. From that point on is it not the same as if the Labour Court——
Comment on this
Yes, on the assumption that they will accept the recommendation of the court. I still think we should try this method of doing things quietly and quickly in small cases that could escalate into big disputes. There should, I think, be regional rights commissioners. Deputy Tully thinks we should have one as distinct from Deputy O'Leary——
Comment on this
I do not think that there should be one, say, in Cork to deal with the people who are still down there. I did think at one stage that it would be no harm if we had a section of the Labour Court in Cork to deal with cases in the Munster area. Certainly, a dispute arising suddenly out of a question of some right which is being infringed should have a quick service if the service is to be successful.
Comment on this
So long as the Minister does not move the Department to Clare we shall not mind.
Comment on this
We might do that also. I was referring in the case of Cork to Deputy O'Leary when I mentioned the people who are still left there.
Comment on this
To return to the question of the number, this will depend on the success of the idea in the first instance and also on the availability of people who can perform this service. We are in an area where talent and acceptability must be combined and I would ask people in the field to let me have suggestions about how this should be done. I had in mind fulltime rights commissioners resident in certain areas. Deputy O'Leary was thinking, I think, in terms of part-time operators on a panel accepted by trade unions and employers, who could be called on to serve when required. This is an idea that emerged while we were discussing the section.
Comment on this
The Minister is going back into the field of the amateur again.
Comment on this
No. I am talking of acceptable people. I am not doing it; I said that Deputy O'Leary had proposed it and if the Deputy wishes to argue he should argue with Deputy O'Leary. There are people in the trade unions who could not be regarded as amateurs and who might be good at this job on a part-time basis. They are not amateurs. There are also business people, who have not neglected the personnel function, who could be good at this task and would be acceptable to the trade unions. The animal whom it is difficult to find is the neutral one who has the talent and acceptability; but no one is quite sure how neutral one can become. Time and again I have been pleasantly surprised to find a lot of employers who were acceptable to trade unionists as people who would give a fair opinion on a trade union question. There is a problem in finding people who can do this job but, if we do find them, they can make a success of it and create a demand for more people of the same kind. I would ask people in this House and in organisations outside, if they have any suggestions to make, to send them to me because this problem of selection is a very real one as far as my job is concerned.
Comment on this
It is stated under this subsection that the hearing shall be in private. In view of the fact that the decision has to be accepted, and, more important, that the facts on which the decision was made should be understood—because the result of the hearing would almost certainly be publicised; this is something that might be misunderstood by workers—the right to have it publicised would be a good idea.
Comment on this
I am quite certain, although I may be wrong, that we should try to get away from appealing to public opinion. We have no way of hearing clearly what public opinion says in reply. If this were to be done, money would be spent by one side, an advertisement would be placed in the papers, and then the other side, if they had the money, would put in another advertisement.
Comment on this
I am not talking about advertisements. I am talking about the Fourth Estate.
Comment on this
If those involved in a dispute were to appeal to public opinion they would be likely to be rebuffed. There is a great case for appealing to somebody who can answer back, such as the Labour Court. Let them give a decision. If we had some way of knowing what public opinion was, there would be something in this argument. But, since we have not, this idea would be only frustrating to the people concerned in trying to solve the dispute and irritating to the general public who, themselves, often suffer by disputes.
Comment on this
Those involved in a dispute at this stage would not be eager to worsen the situation and they themselves are the best authority about whether they should be conscious of public opinion. Public opinion certainly plays a large part in this area of industrial relations. I do not know if the Minister gets public opinion loud and clear but I do know that we are all in a profession in which, if we do not hear the tune, our deafness will prove mortal in the long run to our continued presence in this House. That is something which we must understand.
The trade unions are getting the tune loud and clear. I agree with Deputy Tully that we should not rule out the possibility of public opinion as playing a very constructive role in this area. I am not suggesting that we have a Seven Days programme on it immediately, but I am saying that public opinion should not be placed in the position of being an obstruction in this matter and something to be avoided.
Comment on this
We are covering a wide area. We talked about this earlier. I brought in an amendment to make it possible to have, at the request of either party, a Labour Court hearing in public. This is where the Fourth Estate, as Deputy Tully calls them, would come in. He was not so nice to them the last night we were here.
Comment on this
I am sure that, if I called them something, they called me something much worse.
Comment on this
I think that, if this information is not available, very often the workers will be blamed for going on strike; but, when the facts come out, the public often realise that it was necessary for the workers to strike. I am talking in this particular section about experimentation. I am quite sure that in disputes affecting one man a quick and quiet decision could be made by the Labour Court who, in this case, would be an arbitration board. In such a case there would be no point in asking the public to decide if it is the employer or the worker who is right. If such appeals are to be made to public opinion, the arbitration body will be pushed out of the way again.
Comment on this
I am afraid that Deputy Booth's remarks of this morning have had more effect than I thought they would have.
Comment on this
I had this in before Deputy Booth spoke. I am sure the House will agree that disputes which very often affect only one individual could be solved quickly without any extraneous motivation being brought in.
Comment on this
The Minister seems to be under the impression that a dispute in which one man is involved affects only the one man. I had a case where there were 150 workers involved over the driving of a lorry. In that particular case, a relatively junior man got the driving of the lorry and 149 people said they would go on strike unless another worker, who had 20 years' service and who was entitled to get the job, got it. Could I reasonably say that this was only a minor case?
Comment on this
I did not mean to make cases of that sort minor ones. I am saying that the public cannot give a quick decision.
Comment on this
If a case is taken to the Labour Court which affects even one man and if the case and the result are published in the press and read by employers all over the country, the publication of that one decision could prevent many other disputes all over the country. It could affect not only my own union but dozens of other unions as well. I see no reason at all why, if it is an ordinary Labour Court case, it should not be possible to have it held in public on request.
Comment on this
If the Minister wishes to conduct an experiment which would be valuable, let us have it. The Minister's point that you would have a rights commissioner who would concern himself directly with matters relating to incomes and wages, is a good one. Leaving aside the possible attractions of explaining one's case in all its detail in public, the temptation will always be there, when proceedings are held in public, to say that, in fact, more speedy results could be achieved by holding them in private. Against that, why can the same latitude not be given at the commissioner level as was sought to be given in the previous part when we were talking about the Labour Court and cases held in public? Why can we not say that an investigation by a rights commissioner may be conducted in private? Why must we be completely rigid in this area and say "It shall be conducted in private"?
Much educational value attaches to Labour Court proceedings if they are properly reported. When the facts of any dispute are revealed by good reporting, it is of great educational value to the public. We then have an early warning system instituted for the public, letting them know that a problem is beginning to grow and increase. I suggest we should not be very rigid about this section here. We should say, even at this level, that an investigation by a rights commissioner may be conducted in private. In other words, he would still retain the right to hold it in private if necessary. But we would not have the present straitjacket situation, where the commissioner has no choice. We are saying to the commissioner: "You shall hold all cases in private". I believe that is against the spirit of the experiment the Minister wishes to conduct.
Comment on this
I cannot change my mind. We have had 23 years of publicity. I have amended the early sections to allow for matters of wages and conditions of employment to be still held in public at the request of a party, whereas in other areas you appoint a rights commissioner. We hope he will succeed. We hope to be able to get the people to do this job well. He may hold his inquiry at the plant, at his own house or he may hold it at the house of an employee. It will be privately held and he will make his recommendation. Then if the employer, the employee or the trade union want to appeal against this, if they do not accept it and think the Labour Court might act differently, they can go to the Labour Court with it. My feeling is that you get down to solid business if you go into the Labour Court without publicity. If you have publicity, you will get the people concerned appealing to public opinion instead of trying to adduce arguments and accept decisions. It is an experiment in procedure which is worth carrying out. It may very well fail. If it does, we can always have public hearings of the Labour Court as our first procedure. But I have a feeling it is worth trying in those areas where wages and salaries are not involved.
Comment on this
Will there be any tendency, could the Minister say, if a case is heard in private at commissioner level and it is finally not resolved there and goes to the court, that the court will be predisposed to hearing the case again in private? Will there be any tendency for the court, having seen that the matter was already heard in private under a commissioner, to consider that the same conditions prevail and there is no need for publicity?
Comment on this
This is in the thing. As far as the rights commissioner appeal is concerned, this is in private. It is an experiment which should be tried and probably will work.
Comment on this
I am talking about the decision where we have failed at commissioner level. Would the appeal to the Labour Court be in private?
Comment on this
I did not appreciate this. Are we not building up a total chain of secrecy? This certainly is more serious than I thought. In other words, the case which was held at commissioner level in private must continue behind closed doors to the very end.
Comment on this
It is an experiment. A new type of person can make a quick examination and a quick recommendation. I think it would all be done very quickly. If people want, and both sides agree, to have the rights commissioner, that is all right. If they do not want to have that, they can go directly to the Labour Court then and have all the arguments and appeals to public opinion. As I say, I feel effective action in some cases has not been taken on decisions because people were appealing to public opinion and public opinion cannot make the decision for them. The Deputy mentioned in this House that we are responsible to public opinion at election time; but, in the case of disputes quickly flaring up which need quick solution, I believe they are better conducted in this way. What I want to introduce here is a third person who will make recommendations on a rights issue. I think it is something worth trying.
Comment on this
I thought, on my reading of this, that if the investigation was held in private at commissioner level it could be held in public afterwards if necessary. There may be virtue in what the Minister says for having a case held in private, but it should be at the discretion of the commissioner to hold it in public if he so desires or if any of the parties so desire. In the case the Minister referred to, I think most parties would prefer to see it held in private, but I do not think we should deprive them of the right of holding it in public if necessary. We now have the situation where, in cases of victimisation or, as Deputy Tully says, in an individual case which could be a flashpoint for a larger confrontation at the place of work, the individual concerned can have his case referred to a commissioner, but, if no solution is reached and he wishes to utilise the Labour Court, he can only utilise it behind closed doors.
Comment on this
Wait a moment. Are we not contradicting ourselves if the whole idea is to have an experiment?
Comment on this
I hope everybody who uses the Labour Court will be willing to settle their problems.
Comment on this
The Deputy will know that people will want everything settled their own way. This applies both to employers and employees.
Comment on this
I hope this prophesy does not come true. I rather think what may happen here is that the rights commissioner will be dealing with very few cases indeed.
Comment on this
What could easily happen here is that the rights commissioner avenue, since it does not allow of cases being published, will become a cul-de-sac used by nobody.
Comment on this
It could happen, but the idea is that it will lead to solutions rather than justification. If they do not wish to use it, we cannot help it. But I think we should put this in.
Comment on this
If they do not have a clientele for solutions, then they will not have any solutions.
Comment on this
All your arms in this voluntary system depend on a market. If you do not cater for the existing market then your solutions here are interesting but——
Comment on this
I do not want to provide another stage for performance. I want to give those who want solutions a way of getting them without this extraneous appeal and self-justification in public.
Comment on this
If the Minister wishes to tempt people or to improve an existing situation then he cannot be too theoretical in the solutions he proposes. It is interesting for me to accuse the Minister of being over-theoretical. From the commissioners here up to the court he is, in fact, following rather rigidly a theory in which he believes. He has made up his mind that public opinion is, in fact, a stumbling-block or that the proceedings being held in public is a stumbling-block in arriving at a solution.
Comment on this
There are sections of the old Industrial Relations Act which are now for the birds, and which never operated, never grew or developed. It appears to me that there is a grave possibility of this again because of the rights commissioner dealing with an extremely sensitive area of the interpretation of the law, a potential flashpoint area for the further spread of a particular dispute, perhaps one that refers to relations between employers and employees, dismissals, or questions of interpretation or possibly of resentment. The Minister says the whole point is to ensure informal proceedings which can be held in secrecy. There is a side to that particular viewpoint but I am suggesting also that if the Minister wishes this service to be really availed of he should not close the door to the idea that the proceedings can see the light of day even at Labour Court level. Once one participates in the rights commissioner's hearing and once one goes before him, one is cut off from outside opinion. From beginning to end that is going to be the last public view of the justice. One must take it just as it comes within the four walls of the place within which the case is being heard. The Minister's answer to that is "go to the Labour Court in the first place". In other words, take your case straight away to the Labour Court. This would probably continue the tendency to use the Labour Court initially in a particular complaint which was not properly processed and which did not need that solution at that period. It seems to me that the Minister is being over-rigid and over-doctrinaire in his approach to this matter by suggesting that he is trying to divide industrial relations into those in need of rapid solution and who must get rapid solution in secret, and those who wish to go to the Labour Court and have the solutions in public. He is being needlessly coy about public opinion in this. I do not see proceedings being held in public in the same light as the Minister does. Proceedings held in public have a constructive part to play in the forming of public opinion and in educating the parties involved.
Comment on this
The purpose of this section is to shorten the period to 21 days instead of 30 days. When a joint committee makes a proposal in the Labour Court for fixing a minimum rate of pay or regulating the conditions of employment of workers the court must publish the fact and give to interested parties an opportunity to make representations about it. The provision in the 1946 Act allowed for 30 days within which they would receive representations. I am reducing this to 21 days which appears to the people concerned to be sufficient.
Comment on this
I might ask just one simple question about this. The report goes to you in future as the Minister. What does that mean?
Comment on this
I had a general arrangement with Deputy Tully that if he withdrew these amendments we would set about studying their application.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 8, line 11, to delete paragraph (e).
A health inspector is mentioned as a worker for the purpose of Part VI of the 1946 Act, so he has access to the Labour Court in the event of a trade dispute. The trade union representing health inspectors have told me that inspectors wished to participate in the scheme of conciliation and arbitration available for local authority officers. This scheme does not apply to local authority officers who have access to the Labour Court. They have asked to have their name removed from paragraph (e), section 17, subsection (1). It is to meet the wishes of the health inspectors themselves which were conveyed to me by their union that I propose to delete paragraph (e), section 17, subsection (1).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In subsection (2), page 8, line 19, to substitute "shall" for "may".
All we seek in this amendment is that the Minister for Finance "shall" do what is in the section. We wish to make it "shall". Whatever the intention, there was a loophole that the Minister might not designate from time to time and we wished to ensure that the Minister for Finance would live up to the intention of the section so we propose "shall" instead of "may" and hope he will act accordingly. There is nothing like a little help.
Comment on this
I can see the point but I have a problem in this. If everybody who could be designated has been designated, what happens then?
Comment on this
All we sought to do was to ensure that where from time to time all were not designated, if there was any new category we wished to involve, we would do so.
Comment on this
It is not necessarily that we do not trust the present Minister for Finance—he is a respected member of an adjoining constituency —but what we sought to do was to ensure that legislatively there was a compulsion to make sure that all were involved in the particular designation. I do not know how the Minister sees that that will land him in a difficulty.
Comment on this
I see the point and the intention is that they will be designated from time to time as they come up.
Comment on this
I do not know if I am authorised to ask for a division on the words "shall" and "may".
Comment on this
I am advised by the people who did the drafting that "may" is a better way of doing it. It is a matter of trust. The Deputy wants to force the Minister to do it.
Comment on this
If I did not think I was doing violence to the Bill it would not bother me at all but I am not an expert on drafting and neither is the Deputy.
Comment on this
I will consult with the draftsman again but I was advised that "may" is better for the purpose of getting the Minister to do this. Whether an assurance here that it is intended to carry out what the Deputy wants would satisfy him I do not know.
Comment on this
"Shall" appears to me to be slightly stronger than "may" but still it does not seem to me to be totally comprehensive. Even with "shall" the Minister could still slip out without cutting his own throat.
Comment on this
"Shall" is a term that has a meaning in law, that has a compulsion of some kind attached to it.
Comment on this
I think it is really a matter of semantics as far as the Deputy is concerned, not as far as the Minister is concerned.
Comment on this
For God's sake grow up. This is a serious question. Would the Minister consult with his advisers?
Comment on this
Section 18 says:
... Subject to subsection (1) (b) of this section, the Court shall not investigate a trade dispute unless—
(a) it receives a report made by an industrial relations officer who has acted as mediator in the dispute stating that the parties to the dispute have failed to arrive at a settlement of the dispute through conciliation, and
(b) the parties to the dispute have requested it to investigate the dispute.
What exactly could the Minister say would be the exceptional circumstances where the court may investigate a dispute irrespective of the foregoing provisions?
Comment on this
The 1946 Act which invests the Labour Court with general power to investigate disputes, has specified restrictions on this general power. These provide that the court will not investigate the following types of disputes except on certain conditions: (1) a dispute involving persons on a registered joint industrial council, that is unless the council asks for an investigation or the court thinks a stoppage of work is imminent; (2) a dispute involving the ESB Tribunals, that is unless the tribunals ask for an investigation; (3) a dispute involving an agreement between the parties which provides for other methods of determining the dispute, that is again unless the court thinks the dispute is likely to lead to a stoppage of work; (4) a dispute involving matters dealt with in registered employment agreements, again unless a party to the agreement asks for an investigation or the court thinks the dispute is likely to lead to a stoppage of work.
That is the general situation in regard to the power of the Court to investigate disputes and the intention of section 18 of this Bill is to provide on a formalised basis that before the court will investigate a dispute, the conciliation procedure will first have been tried and if conciliation fails then the court may investigate the dispute if the parties ask it to do so and if the industrial relations officer who had acted as mediator at conciliation reports to the court that the parties failed to settle at conciliation. This should be normal procedure and I hope will be normal procedure but it would be unwise to set up rigid, unqualified machinery or statutory procedures. Accordingly, it is being provided that the court may investigate a dispute which has not gone through the conciliation service and for which it has no request from the parties if the court thinks there are exceptional circumstances which would warrant an investigation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 9, line 7, after "request" to insert "or requests".
Amendment No. 12 is a grammatical amendment to the second line of subsection (1) and amendment No. 13 is an amendment to subsection (3) to remove a possible source of conflict with section 8 which we dealt with already as regards the public and private investigations by the Labour Court.
Comment on this
The Minister talks about the arbitration aspects here. Where both parties agree in advance to accept the recommendation of the court in a particular case, he talks about this being given priority presumably on the basis of a speedy solution being arrived at. Could this in any way be taken to take priority over a rather serious case in which the parties have not agreed to accept the recommendations as binding? As the Minister knows, a complaint of the court in the past has been that cases have not been heard rapidly enough. I know we have taken steps to ensure that the court may more readily involve itself and deal with cases but where there is obviously a declared preference for arbitration or where such is acceptable to both parties is there a possibility that such cases may take precedence over other cases in which the parties have not agreed?
Comment on this
The possibility is there but I do not think it would happen to the detriment of the public interest.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 9, line 25, before "An investigation " to insert "Notwithstanding anything contained in section 8 (1) of this Act,".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 9, line 37, after "deemed" to insert ", unless a party concerned in the matter objects to its being determined by the tribunal to which it is referred,".
There are two tribunals in the ESB. The first one, which is popularly known as the manual workers tribunal, was established in 1942, and the other, known popularly as the employees' tribunal, was established in 1949. They are the only statutory tribunals in the public sector charged with the task of determining disputes between the employing body and the workers. There is no such machinery in CIE, Aer Lingus or Bord na Móna.
The statutory provision dealing with the determination of disputes in both the 1942 and the 1949 Acts is quite rigid, that is, that disputes between the ESB and its workers shall, at the request of the board, or of the other parties to the disputes, be referred to and determined by the tribunal. There are further statutory provisions, one in the Industrial Relations Act, 1946, and one in the 1949 ESB Act which prohibit the Labour Court from investigating a dispute in the ESB, except at the request of the tribunal, whichever tribunal has the dispute before it.
This again is further complicated by the fact that investigations by the Labour Court, if asked for, still leave the tribunals with the statutory obligation to determine disputes so that, in fact, recommendations by the Labour Court would not be made to the parties of the dispute, but handed back to the tribunal to enable the tribunal to determine disputes as laid down by law. While the tribunals have a statutory obligation to determine disputes, there is no obligation on the workers to accept that determination. It is an unusual situation to say the least of it.
I wanted to change this rigid procedural pattern and allow the ESB and its employees to set up whatever procedures are mutually acceptable to them, so that they can negotiate pay and conditions in a flexible manner, with the possibility of suitable conciliation procedures. I do not intend imposing any procedures on the parties. I think these will come from their own decisions to set up their own procedures. My proposal will have the effect of making the Labour Court available to the parties, without the present circumscription whereby the court investigates only on the request of the tribunal, leaving the tribunal to make the determination. So that the situation as I see it evolving now would be that in the ESB the board and the workers will have to come together and set up procedures and agree on procedures to replace this rather rigid system, and they will have procedures at conciliation, with the Labour Court available to them for any situation in which they want an opinion and a recommendation from an outside body or third party.
Comment on this
That is what I mean. The Minister wants them to meet and try to get agreement. Does he not think that the relationship has been so bad there to date that for them to get some agreement now would be quite difficult? Why not let the tribunals run on for a period until something concrete is arrived at? What will happen between now and such time as they come to an agreement? It might take them six months to come to an agreement. So far as I know, the engineers in the ESB have refused to accept the Labour Court the same as other bodies such as the civil servants. There are various factions in the ESB who are not willing to go to the Labour Court. In the white-collar workers, if you like to call them that, there are 2,800 members and 2,000 are outside Congress. There will be trouble there.
The final report of the Committee on Industrial Relations recommended the abolition of the tribunals but recommended that for the white-collar workers there should be some special arrangement, and that thought should be given to their situation. The interim report on the ESB said that a body of this size should have an adjudicating body inside its own framework. It is so big that it is completely different from the normal situation. We have here also a multiplicity of unions. Will they work the old system: one union, one vote, or will this be fixed up between themselves? In the case of the ESB, what will happen between now and when this is fixed up? Will they sit back and do nothing or have they no way of working at all?
I mentioned earlier that there are many groups at the moment, like the Civil Service, who will not go to the Labour Court. What will happen there? Will not that lead to more disputes? If the tribunals were allowed to run on until such time as they got agreement it would be better, or the Minister might give them something to work on in the meantime, even something similar to what the Civil Service have, and that could be there until they get some agreement between the ESB and its workers.
Comment on this
I realise the problem is there, but it is very difficult to get anything done until we change the present situation. What I am trying to promote, and I think it is happening, is to have direct negotiations between the board and the employees. The interim report on the ESB recommended setting up machinery. The final report, having heard all the evidence, recommended that there be no formal rigid machinery set up instead of the tribunals, and that they should be encouraged to develop procedures by agreement. I have met some of the trade unions concerned and I am meeting them again, but I think it is desirable that the tribunals should go. It is also desirable that useful agreed procedures should replace them. The difficulty is to know whether this will happen while the tribunals are still there, or whether the fact that we are legislating here will encourage both sides to greater efforts to produce agreed procedures themselves. I do not want to impose any and I cannot impose any procedures on them.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not say it is strange to find this section in this Bill? We are now dealing with industrial relations in general. This is a large semi-State concern and it has an unenviable record of fraction and strife over the past few years. The two reports published on the situation make interesting if pretty sad reading.
Exactly what kind of consultation has the Minister in mind? Is he satisfied that this represents the overall opinion of the employees of the board? Does he think the present situation is being improved, the rather sad relations which have existed between the majority of the board's employees and the board? Can he tell us on what information he is acting in the suggestion to abolish them? In fact might he not be disimproving the situation with this idea that they should be abolished? There has been in the past some tension between the manual tribunal and the other tribunal under the board. Whether the situation is being helped by dissolving the tribunals with a stroke of the pen remains an open question. I think the Minister will agree that he is taking a step in the dark and does not know whether he will be confronting a piranha in the process of going into the dark. It is a South American fish.
Comment on this
Could the Minister tell us what espionage activities led to his decision to dissolve the tribunals?
Comment on this
There is a recommendation from the committee which examined the ESB situation. I am not quite clear on the date but there was also a fairly thorough criticism of the tribunals by the employees after the last ESB strike. The general rigidity of the procedure seems to have made it difficult—not that industrial relations are easy at any time—for decisions to be made. Even if the Labour Court were to come into the picture, it had to be invited in by the tribunal and could give its answer back only to the tribunal. At one stage we had a case going from one to the other. All in all, apart from the discussion which I had with the trade unions at the time of the dispute, the setting-up of the committee to examine the question shows our anxiety to help the ESB and its employees to have better procedures. The ESB may be regarded as having bad industrial relations because of the massive anxiety caused when there is any dispute. The unions and the Government now have a fair body of information on which to base further action to improve relations, and we should be able to get away from the idea that the ESB will always be in a bad industrial relations situation.
I believe from what I have been told all round that the tribunals were an obstruction to normal procedures and that their removal will allow a more natural type of negotiation between the board and its employees. The trade unions have complained that because there is a determining body at the end of the road there is a tendency to let the case off to this body. In some cases this could be used intelligently; in some cases it might be helpful to a personnel officer so that his employers would not be saying he gave too much. This tendency I have spoken of is militating against proper industrial relations and proper negotiation. It has led to rigidity in procedures and has frustrated trade unions, workers and employers. If we could move away from rigidity and give much more attention to the personnel aspect of management, we would get an all-round improvement. It is part of that general thinking that leads me to believe that we should abolish the statutory tribunal. As regards the setting-up of other machinery it is easy to see, if we think it out in connection with the report of the committee, that the same objection that arises in the case of statutory tribunals is there in the case of any formal, rigid machinery. That is the main objection, that it moves people away from meaningful, direct negotiation and conciliation.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say whether there are any grounds for believing that the vacuum created by the two tribunals will be filled by something else? One can see that, if the ESB has had a bad industrial relations record in the past few years, we in this House have not helped in our own dealings with the ESB. Witness the monumental blunder with the ESB (Special Provisions) Act. I cannot understand why we did not get a section in this Bill to abolish those provisions, seeing that the Minister time after time has announced his willingness to remove that Act from the Statute Book. This is a time for admitting mistakes. The Minister for Labour and the Government have some mistakes to their name in the matter of the ESB (Special Provisions) Act.
Comment on this
If the Minister abolishes these tribunals he should not leave the ESB without some method of negotiation. I suggest that he should give them, in the interim period, the same machinery as is available to the guards and civil servants, as the Minister mentioned in connection with section 9.
Comment on this
I should like to appeal to the Minister to consider the abolition of the ESB Act. This would assist in bringing about better relations between the workers and the ESB. This is not the first time I have asked the Minister in this House to repeal this legislation. With the introduction of this Bill the time has come when the Minister should reconsider the situation in the hope that the elements making up the different groups who negotiate will get a better grip on their members and, in that way, create more satisfaction and better agreement between people who are more fully and more comprehensively represented and with a greater degree of responsibility. I would ask the Minister to consider the repeal of this enactment. Such repeal would serve a useful purpose and would inspire greater confidence and engender better industrial relations.
Comment on this
I understand that when the last war was nearly over a number of the guards in the concentration camps in Germany took off their uniforms and put on the prisoners' rags in the hope that they would not be recognised for what they were, that the invading forces might think they were prisoners and treat them well. That would almost seem to be the position now where some Members of this House are concerned. Deputies who were not so sympathetic to the ESB when the Act was being passed and who voted for the Bill now say, on the eve of a general election, "I am not in favour of it now and we should never have put it on the Statute Book. It should be taken off now."
With regard to the abolition of the tribunals, I do not know whether or not the Minister has fully considered this. He seems to be playing with fire. He and the country may get a shock if he proceeds with the proposals in this Bill. Deputy Belton is correct: what is sauce for the goose should be sauce for the gander. If certain people can say they will not go to the Labour Court and, because they will not go to the Labour Court, the Minister decides that is all right, they can keep their method of arbitration or conciliation and the Labour Court will put on a workers' and an employers' representative to keep in line with what is going on, then I cannot see why the ESB employees should not be treated in the same way. If others have the right to say they will not go to the Labour Court is there not a danger that ESB workers will also say that they will not go to the Labour Court, that they have their own system and want to retain it?
The Minister referred to the fact that there was some dissatisfaction expressed with the ESB tribunals some time ago. There was, but I do not think all the adverse comment came from the workers. I distinctly remember dissatisfaction being expressed by Government supporters because there was an award made with which they did not agree. It is freely rumoured— the Minister must know this—that this is one of the main reasons why the tribunals are being abolished; it was felt that at least one of the awards made should not have been made. Apparently, if someone steps out of line and gives the workers what is considered to be too much then they must be dealt with in the only way the Government know and that is by abolishing them completely. That seems to be the approach.
We are asked to accept this for the good of industry. The Minister said, fairly enough, that because the ESB was such an important industry we tended to give it more attention than would normally be given to other industries of its size. Of course it is an important industry. The entire industry of the country depends on it. This is the extraordinary thing—despite complaints that it has a bad industrial relations record, and a number of Deputies commented that it had, that is not actually true. If we check we will find that the record is not at all bad. It is, in fact, reasonably good and it would be unfair that it should go out from this House that we consider the industrial relations record bad. However, I do not think the Minister will improve the record by removing the tribunals set up for the purpose of settling disputes and putting nothing in their place. At the moment ESB employees have the tribunals and they have the Labour Court as a last resort. Under this they will lose the tribunals; they are told: "You can take it or leave it. If you do not take the Labour Court you will get nothing."
On serious consideration, I am sure the Minister will agree that he is experimenting here. He said earlier on in another connection that he was trying an experiment. Here he is trying an experiment which may explode into his own face. The Minister will offer ESB workers the Labour Court as a means of settling their disputes. Without in any way decrying the Labour Court, I suggest the Minister is trying a very doubtful experiment. If he said there would be a particular section of the Labour Court, with specialist knowledge, to deal with disputes and that they would investigate ESB disputes, then I could see some slight merit in the proposal but, as it stands, I cannot see any merit in it at all. This is very dangerous. I am sure that in the two years during which the Minister has been discussing this matter with the trade unions and the employers he has time and again had advice as to what should be done. Perhaps he would tell us if some of that advice was that he should abolish the tribunals. Did the advice come from the workers' representatives? Have the unions at any time suggested it would be a good idea to do away with the tribunals and give these workers access to the Labour Court? If that advice was given I certainly am not aware of it.
The Minister is not being fair to the workers concerned and he is not being fair to Members of this House when he asks them to agree to the passing of a section like this. It is no use saying it will prevent duplication because people will know they can go eventually to the Labour Court if all else fails. That is not the answer. The Minister has got it into his head that he will lump the whole lot into the Labour Court and that special consideration will not be given to the ESB employees. I claim these employees are entitled, because of the important work they are doing, to special consideration. It is quite a common thing here for people to decry the claims of those who are doing special jobs with special rates. People doing special jobs are entitled to special rates. They are entitled to be adequately paid for the work they are doing. It is not sufficient to say there is a court to deal with everybody else and it should be good enough for them. It is not good enough for the people concerned here and they will not take it. Before the section is passed the Minister should reconsider it. The matter is too serious to have the section as it is. Perhaps the Minister will tell us whether or not he will give further consideration to this particular section before the Report Stage?