Housing Bill, 1968: Committee and Final Stages.
Contributions 1–123 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1968 ›
I move amendment No. 1:
In subsection (1), page 2, to delete lines 18 to 21 and insert:
"‘habitable house' means a house situate in the functional area of a housing authority other than—
(a) a house in relation to which a housing authority have made a closing order, a demolition order or accepted an undertaking under section 66 (5) of the Act of 1966, or in relation to which a notice under section 3 (1) of the Local Government (Sanitary Services) Act, 1964, has been given, or
(b) a house which in the opinion of such authority is in a ruinous condition;".
This is to bring within the scope of the Bill houses which, although still inhabited, are not in good condition and to do away with the difficulty that under the original definition if a person demolished a house without permission, the housing authority could be faced with the problem of establishing that the house was a habitable house without even having seen it. We are now proposing to define "habitable house" so as to mean any house in the functional area of the housing authority other than a house which in the opinion of the authority is ruinous or in respect of which the local authority have served a dangerous building notice, or made a closing or demolition order, or accepted an undertaking on the grounds that it was a dangerous structure or unfit for human habitation. In the case of a house which is demolished without permission in future, if this amendment is adopted, the local authority will merely have to check their own records to see whether they have taken action under the 1964 or 1966 Acts. If they have not taken such action they will be required to establish whether the house was in a ruinous condition. This was a weakness in the Bill as drafted and this will make it more effective.
Comment on this
(Cavan): There is not much objection to this amendment. As I see it, were it not for this amendment a person who sought to demolish a house for which a closing or demolition order had been made might still have to apply to the council for permission to demolish it. This amendment will do away with the necessity for doing that. In other words, a person who owns a house in respect of which a closing order or a demolition order has been made, or where the owner has given an undertaking not to use it for human habitation, may in future proceed to demolish it without applying to the housing authority for permission to do so. The only matter that appears to need some clarification is in regard to paragraph (b) of the amendment which says: “a house which in the opinion of such authority is in a ruinous condition.” What exactly is meant by the word “ruinous”? Does that mean that it is ready to fall, or that there are no windows in it or there is no roof on it? It appears to me that the word could give rise to some——
Comment on this
It means that if the local authority is of the opinion that the house is in a ruinous condition, then it will not be necessary to apply for permission.
Comment on this
(Cavan): How would the owner of the house know that the local authority were of the opinion that it was in a ruinous condition? Would they keep a register of such houses or would the owner simply put a preliminary query to the housing authority to ascertain whether or not the house was in a ruinous condition?
Comment on this
The housing authority, of course, will have records of houses that they have decided are in a ruinous condition but this is really to cover a case where somebody has demolished a house without getting permission and if the housing authority decide that such a house was in a ruinous condition, then they can dispense with the need.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I suppose we could have a long argument about this. Section 2 of the Bill says that “Subject to section 9, permission shall be required under this Act in respect of—” paragraphs (a) and (b) which deal with demolition or the change of the use of any habitable house. What we are doing here is defining what we mean by “habitable house”. I clearly understand paragraph (a) of the definition because that deals with houses in respect of which closing orders have been made, or in respect of which demolition orders have been made, or in respect of which an undertaking has been given not to use it for human habitation. Paragraph (b), however, refers to “a house which in the opinion of such authority is in a ruinous condition”. If I am the owner of a house, I will know whether it falls within paragraph (a) of that definition and if it does I know I need not apply under section 3 of the Act and that I can go ahead and knock it down if I want to, or use it for a shop or anything else, but how am I to know whether the house is in a ruinous condition or whether the local authority think it is in a ruinous condition? If the local authority are of the opinion that it is, then I need not apply under section 3 but it would be very difficult, if not impossible, for me to know the mind of the local authority.
Comment on this
The local authority, of course, must interpret "ruinous" in the ordinary way. If an individual believes that the house is in a ruinous condition, then he can interpret it himself. It may appear perfectly obvious to him that it is in a ruinous condition but personally I think he would be foolish to do that. The more obvious thing to do would be to make the application under section 3 in a case where the local authority had not already made a decision in respect of the house. Any individual will be capable of forming an opinion himself as to the condition of the house and the local authority would be required to interpret the word "ruinous" in the normal way and there could eventualy be an appeal to the court. My own opinion would be that an individual would be foolish to do that and that he should make an application in respect of any house that did not come under subsection (a).
The original drafting was that "habitable house" means a house which in the opinion of the authority is "reasonably fit for human habitation or is capable of being rendered so fit at reasonable expense". If that were to stand and a person did demolish a house without making an application to do so then, although no official of the local authority might have seen the house before it was demolished, in such cases the local authority would have to establish that prior to being demolished the house was reasonably fit for human habitation, and that would be very difficult. The substitution of paragraph (a) is making it more effective.
Comment on this
Paragraph (b) provides a way out in a case where a person genuinely thought the house was in a ruinous condition and the local authority agreed with him but had not taken any positive action as indicated in subsection (a). In my opinion a person would be foolish not to make the application.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I certainly think he would be foolish. I have no quarrel at all with paragraph (a) of the definition. That is clear and can be ascertained and the owner of the house knows where he stands in relation to it because registers are kept by the local authority or he will have received notices or will have given an undertaking. But paragraph (b) says:
A house which in the opinion of such authority is in a ruinous condition.
But when I inquire how a person is to know that the council will take the view that the house is in a ruinous condition the Minister tells me that the house-owner will have to take a chance and that he would be foolish to take that chance. I agree with that. I think it is a dangerous and loose sort of definition. If it is to stand at all it should read: "...or a house which is in a ruinous condition". The owner could then say: "This house is in a ruinous condition and I am going to knock it down". If he did that, when the house is knocked down he can still be prosecuted because the council could say: "We were not of opinion that it was in a ruinous condition." I think the Minister should delete the paragraph altogether.
Comment on this
If we did what the Deputy is now suggesting we would really be getting back to the present position. The local authority would, in fact, in every case have to establish positively that a house was not in a ruinous condition. Here, what we are providing is that if a person does knock down a house without making an application because he genuinely thinks it is in a ruinous condition and if the local authority agree, then the authority can allow him away with it. But, as I said, anybody would be foolish to do that because not only must he think it is in a ruinous condition but so must the local authority.
Generally speaking, if the local authority believe the house is in a ruinous condition they will have declared it as such in one of the various ways mentioned under paragraph (a). This provision is to provide that action need not be taken when the local authority knows that, in fact, the house was in a ruinous condition. If we were to put it in the more positive way the Deputy now suggests, then anybody could knock down a house and the local authority would have to prove positively that the house was not in a ruinous condition. They might not have had an opportunity of inspecting it beforehand and they might find it very difficult to establish their case. Here, it says that they must be "of opinion".
Comment on this
As the Minister said here there has to be a second opinion, that of the local authority, to confirm that the house is in a ruinous condition because if we leave it to the opinion of the owner alone, as the Minister says, we merely bring about the anarchic situation which has obtained up to now as a result of the Minister's own regulation in the original Act. We found the situation existing in Dublin where people began to knock down perfectly good houses. Hence, we had perfectly legitimate agitation on the basis of the kind of speculation which arose out of that big loophole in the regulations which permitted the demolition. The regulation, in effect, negatived the whole basis of the Planning Act. I agree with the Minister on this occasion that if we are to correct the regrettable situation which has obtained in which we have seen avenues of perfectly good houses knocked down because of this loophole in the old Act, we must put the local authority in a position to intervene on behalf of the community whether a house, in fact, may be demolished. If we give the sole right to the owner of the house, the situation will be as before.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I do not want to be misunderstood about this. I am in total agreement with this Bill being brought in to prevent demolition of houses that are fit for human habitation. As I said on Second Stage this Party actually introduced a Bill in the Seanad a couple of years ago with exactly this in view, but what I complain about in paragraph (b) of this definition is that the owner of the house will not know where he stands.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I know, but I would be quite satisfied if it were deleted altogether and if the owner of the house was, with the exception of cases set out in paragraph (a), compelled to apply to the council for permission to demolish the house. But here, in paragraph (b), you have also excepted from clause 3 “a house which in the opinion of such authority is in a ruinous condition.” The question I pose is: how is the owner of a house to know whether or not the local authority thinks that the house is in a ruinous condition?
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister says he need not. If Deputy Lenihan and some other Deputies would read the Bill before coming into the House, it would be a great help.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Will the Deputy please let me proceed? I should be quite happy if paragraph (b) is deleted. That would then impose an obligation on the owner to get permission in every case other than the cases excepted by paragraph (a). These are ascertainable cases. But here you may have a man who may genuinely believe that a house is in a ruinous condition and he proceeds to demolish it by virtue of subsection (b). He may then find when that is done and the house is not in existence that the local authority says: “That house was not in a ruinous condition.” It would be more in the interests of the owner of a house to have the more stringent condition imposed on him of applying under section 3 for permission. If by “ruinous” is meant a house without a roof or a house without doors or windows or a roof and that sort of thing, everybody would know that was in a ruinous condition but this is the sort of legislation and the sort of section in Acts of Parliament that I disagree with because nobody knows what they mean. The owner of the house here must ask himself the question: “Is this house in the opinion of the local authority in a ruinous condition?” That is an absurd question because he cannot know that unless he asks the local authority.
Comment on this
(Cavan): But the section tells him that this is the case in which he need not ask the local authority. If you put into the section: “Having made inquiries from the local authority...” you are inviting him by this subsection not to go near the local authority and to go and demolish the house but at the same time you are providing the local authority with the right to prosecute afterwards. That is unreasonable. The Minister cannot have any argument with me. Far be it from me to give any owner of a house the right to determine whether he should knock it down or not. That is the very thing I am complaining about and about which this Party have been complaining for the past two or three years. That is why we introduced the Bill in the Seanad to amend the Planning Act. I believe that was the measure which gave rise to this one. I have made the case as clear as I can. I also disagree with people who say that if the Bill were to read: “...a house which is in a ruinous condition” it would give the owner the right to say whether or not he should demolish it. In my opinion, he would have to establish that it was in a ruinous condition if he was prosecuted by the local authority.
Comment on this
(Cavan): To the court before whom he would be prosecuted. This is an exclusion section. It is a subsection which says that he need not apply if the house is in a ruinous condition and in all other cases he must apply. Therefore, if he is prosecuted, in my opinion, that would be a matter of defence for him to bring himself within the exception provided by this paragraph (b). If the Deputies clearly understood the case I am making, they would realise that it is a reasonable case. I do not want an owner of a house to be put in a position where he does not know where he stands. My argument is as simple as that. Here I submit we are saying to the man “If the house is in a ruinous condition you need not go near the council” but then the council can come along afterwards when the house is knocked down and say that the house was not in a ruinous condition. In the meantime the house has been knocked down and no one can say whether it was in a ruinous condition or not.
Comment on this
This is the type of provision that is normal. It is in the Dangerous Buildings Acts; it is in the Planning Acts. There are certain developments classified as being exempted. But there may be cases of doubt and in cases of doubt people sometimes seek planning permission but, at the same time, claim that it is an exempted development. In such cases the local authority will tell the person whether it is exempted or not. There are very few people who would not be able to say whether or not a building was in a ruinous condition and in such cases they could claim that it was not necessary to apply for permission. If this paragraph is dropped, I think local authorities would have to deal with a lot of applications for permission which are really pointless. I agree that it is not all that important but it is a usual type of provision to have in this type of legislation. I think the legislation would be better with it in. However, at the same time, I think the advisable thing for anybody proposing to demolish a house that did not come under category (a) would be, certainly, either to make application or to ask the local authority to confirm his opinion that the house was in a ruinous condition. I should like to retain the paragraph because it is a usual provision. It is in both the Planning Acts and the Dangerous Buildings Acts but the more important things in this amendment are in subparagraph (a).
Comment on this
(Cavan): I can see a certain amount of force in the Minister's argument. Certainly, if a person came in to me in my capacity as a solicitor and said that he wanted to knock down a building and asked if it was necessary to get permission, I would use the telephone and contact the local authority and ask them if they would go out and look at the building and let me know. You would have some cases of an owner making the case that the house was in a ruinous condition and knocking it down without consulting anyone. He is invited to do that under this Bill. That is what I am complaining about.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In subsection (1), line 30, to delete "or yard" and insert ", yard or garden".
This is a very minor drafting alteration. There was a mistake. The first part of the definition in the Bill refers to "any out offices or yard"; it does not mention "garden". The second part of the definition refers to "such out offices, yard or garden", obviously on the assumption that "garden" has already been mentioned. The amendment proposes merely to remedy the omission in the first part of the definition by inserting "garden".
Comment on this
(Cavan): Subsection (3) says that any person who contravenes subsection (2) shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding £100 together with, in the case of a continuing offence, a further fine not exceeding £10 for every day on which the offence is continued or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months, or to both the fine and the imprisonment. The only query I have there is about continuing offence.
It is easy enough, I suppose, to understand the meaning of continuing offence in reference to change of use but could he be guilty of continuing offence in relation to demolition? Surely, if he demolishes a house, that is the end of it? It is a more serious offence, I agree, to knock down a house than to change the use of a house. I should like to hear the Minister on that.
Comment on this
This deals not only with demolition but with change of use and if the change of use continues, it is a continuing offence.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I can quite understand that but what I want to query is whether a continuing offence can take place in the case of demolition.
Comment on this
Are the fines mentioned here the continuing fines in the old Act? How far do they go? Have the penalties here for breach of the regulation been revised?
Comment on this
These are the maximum penalties that can be imposed on summary conviction. To increase them they would have to be treated as indictable offences.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I just throw out a suggestion which maybe the Minister would consider between now and when the Bill goes to the Seanad. If he were to put in “together with, in the case of a continuing offence, in case of a change of use, a further fine”, it would put the matter beyond doubt. I do not imagine any court would ever think of imposing a fine of £10 for every day a house was flattened out until something was put back in its place. I do not think that is likely but the drafting is rather ambiguous and I suggest that it should be made clear that the continuing offence relates only to change of use.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In subsection (2) (b), page 3, line 40, to insert "(indicating in particular the nature of the tenancy, if any)" after "house".
This amendment is to make it clear that an applicant should state his interest in a house when making the application thereby saving time both for himself and for the local authority by eliminating the necessity for the local authority to request further particulars later as to the applicant's interest.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister tells me that these words —“indicating in particular the nature of the tenancy, if any”—are intended to make it obligatory on the owner to satisfy the local authority as to his interest in the house. I take it that this only obliges him to disclose details of any tenancies in the house and that it does not oblige him to state his title to the house. Perhaps it is not intended that he should?
Comment on this
(Cavan): The words “indicating in particular the nature of the tenancy, if any” are not very clear. Even to me, as a country lawyer, I should have difficulty——
Comment on this
It is merely to save the local authority time in writing to the applicant for further particulars.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Is it to ask him whether the house is let and, if so, must he give particulars?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I move amendment No. 4:
In subsection (6) (b), page 5, line 56, to delete "(other than subsection (5)".
Section 4 provides the machinery whereby the housing authority shall give a decision on applications made to it for permission to demolish a house or for permission to change the use of a house from a private dwelling to some other purpose. It is very properly set out in subsection (5) of that section that the housing authority shall give a decision on an application made to it within a specified time and the time specified is described in subsection (5) (a) (ii) as "the appropriate period". The appropriate period, in round figures, means five weeks from the date of the application if no inquiries have to be made by the local authority; and if such inquiries have to be made it is five weeks from the date of the supplying of the information required by the local authority.
The object in imposing that time limit is to make sure that the owner of a house who wishes to demolish it will know where he stands within a reasonable time. This sort of provision has always been inserted in the Planning Acts. Indeed, in the old Planning Acts of the 1930s a time limit of, I think, two months was set and it was provided that the local authority had to give a decision within two months of an application being made to it or within two months of the required information being supplied to the local authority.
This is very reasonable because otherwise a person could make an application to the planning authority or the housing authority and he might not get a decision on it for six months, 12 months or even five years. Actually it is provided in all these Planning Acts that, if a decision is not given by the planning authority within two months, the application will be deemed to have been granted and the owner can proceed accordingly. It is very properly provided here in subsection (5) that——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I should like to know if that is correct; that if an application is not granted within two months the applicant can proceed.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I have heard of many points of order but this is the most extraordinary yet. That provision is in the Bill.
Comment on this
I should like to get it from the Minister. We hear a lot of complaints about cases——
Comment on this
(Cavan): The ones we are complaining about are with the Minister. If they are with the local authority they are deemed to have been granted after two months.
Comment on this
(Cavan): For once, the Minister and I are agreeing. In so far as the local planning authority does not give a decision within two months, the application is deemed to have been granted and that is very properly carried into subsection (5).
Comment on this
That means that if the applicant proceeds with the house without having heard from the local authority within the specified time, he cannot be compelled to pull it down.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I shall read subsection (5) for Deputy Kitt's benefit. The subsection states that:
(a) Where—
(i) an application is made to a housing authority in accordance with section 3 for a permission under this section, and
(ii) the housing authority do not give notice to the applicant of their decision within the appropriate period.
a decision by the authority to grant the permission shall be regarded as having been given on the last day of that period.
Subsection (6) provides for an appeal to the Minister and the Minister provides in this Bill that the machinery which applies in the case of an application to the housing authority shall apply in the case of an appeal to the Minister, save that there should be no time limit and that the Minister can have as long as he likes to consider the appeal. My views on this method of appeal from the decision of the local authority—in this case, the housing authority—are well known. I do not think that the appeal should be to the Minister. The Minister has, more or less, come round to my way of thinking because he has put another Bill on the Order Paper to amend the Planning Bill of 1963 in relation to appeals. He proposes to set up some sort of an independent tribunal or body to deal with this. That is only by the way. As I say, here we have an appeal to the Minister against the refusal of the housing authority to grant permission to demolish or to change the use of a house or against the granting of such permission subject to conditions. As I say, the procedure in regard to the appeal is to be on all fours with the procedure applying to the original application except the Minister will have as long as he likes to give his decision.
I think some time limit should be imposed on the Minister. I am not speaking of the Minister now as an individual. I am speaking of the holder of the office of the Minister for Local Government. It is only reasonable that a householder should know where he stands and that he should not be kept on the long finger indefinitely. If he is not allowed to demolish this house he may have other plans or he may have to make other plans but as long as the decision is withheld he does not know where he stands.
I know of a case in which an appeal against the decision of the planning authority is going on for about two years. It is not an answer to that to say it is the fault of the applicant because in the case I have in mind the applicant gave all the information he was required to give. The Minister's inspector held an oral inquiry nearly 12 months ago—it is certainly more than 9 months ago—but notwithstanding that the decision on the appeal has not yet been given. It is against that sort of thing I want to provide and I think it would not be unreasonable to write into this measure that the Minister must give his opinion within so many months of getting all the information he requires.
It is all right to say if a person has a grievance, if an applicant appeals and the Minister is not giving his decision within a certain time the applicant can come to this House, through his public representative, and raise the matter here. He might be slow to do that and human nature being what it is it might not be wise to do it. That is the case I am making. I do not think it is unreasonable. If my amendment were accepted in toto, as it is here, it would mean that the Minister would have to give his decision within five weeks of this receipt of the application or within five weeks of the receipt of all the information asked for by the Minister or his Department following the receipt of the application. I can see that five weeks might be too short but this was the handiest way of putting down this amendment to ventilate this grievance. I would be satisfied with a longer time but I would certainly say a period of three months should be ample to decide an appeal and give a decision. As I said, the wisdom and the sound commonsense behind the case I am making now has long since been recognised in so far as the local authorities are concerned.
It has been recognised in the Town and Regional Planning Act of 1934 or 1935, the Town and Regional Planning Act of 1939 and the Planning and Development Act of 1963 and it is recognised again in subsection (5) of section 6 of this Bill. It is thought necessary there to provide that the owner shall know where he stands within a reasonable time. In the Planning Acts it is two months and in this measure it is five weeks. All I am saying is that that should be carried on into the appeals subsection of this section.
I have mentioned a case of which I am personally aware in which the appeal is going on for most of two years. Certainly, the Minister's Department must accept responsibility for almost 12 months of that delay. We could have a case, as, indeed, in the case I am talking about, where a youngish man invested well over £1,000 in buying two public house licences and then applied for planning permission to build a house. The £1,000 is frozen for the time I have mentioned. In the meantime the court order is nearly running out. I am putting those facts on the record to show the necessity for the provision I am now asking.
Comment on this
One would agree about the period for the local authority being five weeks to make up their minds about whether the application can go through or not and to decide whether they will give permission, but one wonders how exactly are the local authorities equipped to perform this service in the five week period mentioned here? I know in the Dublin area if tomorrow morning applications for demolition and alterations coming up under the Bill in which people wish to get rid of sound property or property they wish to demolish for another purpose were received the inspectorate available in Dublin Corporation is, in my opinion, understaffed to cope with the requirements of this measure. Whilst it may be good to say in "less than five weeks" I just wonder how, in fact, local authorities, perhaps, are equipped to carry out this provision under the Bill? I am glad to see the housing authority must have regard to the state of repair and the inadequacy of the housing available in the area. This is extremely important. Here I should like to ask whether the local authority, in considering the housing available in any area, would have regard solely to the amount of municipal housing in the area or all private and municipal housing?
Comment on this
The Chair would remind the Deputy that we are discussing the amendment. At a later stage the section will be dealt with.
Comment on this
I see you are going to stick to the amendment first. I think the same provision would hold in regard to the amendment. I presume the reason is that the Minister feels he is equipped to do this. Does the Minister or his Department feel that they can, in fact, enforce this period of "less than five weeks", which is the period mentioned here for the local authority? Like Deputy Fitzpatrick, we are all aware of the limbo that cases appear to be in when they go to the Custom House. Apparently, it is like "the undiscovered country from whose bourn no traveller returns" because nothing has returned from that limbo of forgotten applications in the Custom House. Do the Department feel they are, in fact, equipped to open up the dusty archives in which many of the applications lie seemingly forgotten? If the Minister feels confident that his Department can live up to the challenge of meeting requirements within five weeks fair enough.
I may say from my experience I cannot see any local authority being able to do so. I would support Deputy Fitzpatrick that if this provision is to have any meaning, then there must be a period set to the Minister's examination. We must not allow applications to go through, as they apparently do at the moment, to study on top of Mount Olympus. For many years no Minister does not feel up to meeting the five-week period of determination, I would be prepared to suggest that the Minister merely stipulate a period, not necessarily holding himself to five weeks. I do not reflect personally on the Minister in saying this, but perhaps he has to deal at present with many years backlog of applications. The public impression is that the Custom House must be filled to the roof with forgotten applications.
Comment on this
Possibly I will be out of order because I want to talk on planning as it affects my own county. We had a very interesting meeting last Monday week. We were asked to provide more staff to deal with planning applications but that was turned down.
Comment on this
I must remind the Deputy that this amendment deals purely with the question of time in so far as a decision regarding derelict buildings is concerned.
Comment on this
I will confine myself to time. I am happy to know there are people who can have a decision in two months. I voted against giving extra staff, although Deputy M. O'Leary wants to give more. I am glad I voted against giving them more time in Galway. I am glad I voted against giving them more time for turning down applications. There must be an awful lot of applications in the Minister's Department now.
Comment on this
Again I must remind the Deputy that this amendment deals only with the demolition of buildings. It does not deal with planning as such.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Come in on the Minister's Estimate, if it is ever reached, and deal with him then.
Comment on this
I certainly will. I have given my opinion on planning before and I will certainly give it again. I will be as helpful as anybody but, so far as planning in Galway is concerned, I can only say it is in a state of chaos at the moment. I am sorry I will not be allowed to go on the lines I had proposed.
Comment on this
I cannot accept this amendment. The effect of the amendment would be that, in the event of the failure of the Minister to determine an appeal within five weeks, the developer would get permission to demolish or change the use of a house by default. This is the case under the Planning Act at present, but the period, of course, is a period of two months. It must be obvious that this would not be a desirable thing to happen. The difference between appeals and original applications should be clearly understood. It is a general principle that there is not a prescribed period laid down for the decision on an appeal. The reasons are obvious, because the ability of a Minister to determine an appeal within a prescribed time may be affected by factors completely outside his control. The Minister may have to get the views of outside bodies who either cannot, do not or will not give their opinions within the time which would enable him to comply with the prescribed time limit and, at the same time, give the appeal adequate examination
It is all right for Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick (Cavan) to say that the wisdom of the time limit in the case of applications to a local authority has been recognised. This is a completely different thing. An application to a local authority involves only investigation of the proposal by the local authority. It involves only proposals within the local authority area. Appeals against decisions by the local authority involve arguments and counter-arguments as between two parties at least, and they involve also the whole country. As Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick (Cavan) has mentioned, they often involve members of the legal profession, who are not always as efficient in dealing with matters as Deputy Fitzpatrick says he was in this particular case. We had a case mentioned here before of a long delay in a planning appeal. When I looked it up, I found that a request for additional information to the applicant solicitor had not been dealt with over a period of five months. In many cases delays in appeals were caused by the inertia of professional people of one kind or another, acting on behalf of the applicant himself. Very often an appeal would be delayed in an endeavour to explore to the full the possibility of reaching a decision which would be acceptable to the parties involved and fair to the community.
Deputy Fitzpatrick obviously believes that the insertion of a time limit for dealing with appeals would be a help to applicants. It is obvious it could very well work in the other way, particularly if it did not give time for an adequate examination of the case. If a decision had to be made quickly it might appear that the only feasible thing to do would be to assume that the local authority had been correct and to endorse the decision of the local authority, although a fuller examination of the whole matter might have resulted in the conclusion that the applicant's case was correct. Deputy Fitzpatrick is making a mistake in pressing this type of amendment. Appeals will be dealt with as speedily as possible. It would be foolish not to make it possible to give every appeal adequate investigation. Applicants are entitled to have the assurance that their applications will be thoroughly investigated rather than that they should be dealt with on a hurried basis and in a period of time that might not be sufficient for a thorough investigation of the appeal.
Comment on this
No. I do not think it is desirable to lay down any definite period because, as I said, the time can be, and often is, drawn out in an endeavour to reach agreement between the parties involved and, at the same time, ensure that the decision will be fair to the community as a whole.
With regard to Deputy M. O'Leary's suggestion that the five-week period allowed by the local authority is too short, I do not think it is. If the House feels that that period should be extended to two months, as in the case of planning applications, I would not oppose it. It is felt that five weeks should be sufficient to deal with this type of application.
Deputy M. O'Leary alleged that there were a large number of forgotten applications in the Custom House. Of my own knowledge, I know that is not so. Apart from anything else, I want to point out to Deputy O'Leary that the Custom House does not deal with applications. It deals with appeals in cases in which decisions have already been given by the planning authority.
Comment on this
It is a completely different thing and obviously involves a much lengtheir process. Because the views of the planning authority and of the party making the appeal—and possibly also of third parties—have to be ascertained, and because on many occasions these people are represented either by legal people or technical people of one kind or another, delays are inevitable. There are not any forgotten applications. There are some applications which are difficult to decide, that take longer than others; but generally speaking, in view of the large volume of appeals, I do not think the average period taken to deal with them is excessive. I am convinced, therefore, that it would be wrong to impose any time limit in the matter of dealing with these appeals.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I regret I cannot agree with the Minister. In the first place, the Minister seemed to make the case that it should take longer to determine the appeal than the original application. I find it hard to accept that. By the time the appeal stage has been reached, a lot of the spadework has been done: the file has been complied, the premises have been inspected and reported on and the arguments for and against are already available to the Minister. Therefore, one would think it should be easier, or less difficult, to deal with an appeal than with an original application.
The Minister has made the case that sometimes professional people dealing with these appeals are dilatory and slow in furnishing information. That may be so: there are exceptions to every rule. Very often the professional people engaged are not members of the legal profession but engineers and architects. At any rate, my amendment does not seek to impose a restriction on the Minister which would permit the time limit, whatever it is, to be shortened by the failure of the applicant to supply information, because if my amendment is accepted the time would begin to run from the date the Minister has got all the information he requires. That is as clear as ABC. It is clearly provided for in subsection (5), and my aim is to provide that the period of five weeks should run from the date of the application or from the supplying of any additional information the housing authority might require. The time would begin to run only from the date on which the Minister has got all the information he wants.
In moving the amendments, I expressed the opinion that five weeks may be too short, but for goodness' sake, give us a time limit, let it be five weeks, five months or even six months, as Deputy O'Leary suggested. In such circumstances, the applicant could proceed on the understanding that a firm decision would not be delayed longer than six months. He would know he can be held up for six months but no longer.
I do not wish to keep on harping back to the case I am interested in professionally. The oral evidence was taken in that case on 30th June last. It was over and finished with as far as the applicant was concerned: he had done all he could be expected to do—he had subjected himself to examination and had put his cards on the table—and all that poor man could do was to wait for the result. There were all sorts of technicalities hanging on the result. I was pushed about the matter of renewing the publicans' licences which the applicant had purchased, and all I could say was: "Keep quiet for a minute and I hope we will have a decision in time to clarify the position at the annual licensing session of the district court in September." Now, I hope we may be ready by next September.
I point this out only for the purpose of emphasising the necessity for a time limit. I will be satisfied with six months, which is a good long time. Then, a professional person could say to a client: "We will get a decision in two months, three months. Have patience and we will know where we stand in six months at the outside." I do not think that is unreasonable. Courts are sometimes blamed for holding things up. If the Minister has not the necessary staff in his office to enable him to give a decision on appeal within six months, he should provide himself with the necessary staff, especially where the rights of citizens are being interfered with and where it is in the interests of the community as a whole.
I trust the Minister will reconsider his opinion. I realise that probably it would be against Departmental policy to accept a time limit or to impose regulations which would restrict the discretion of Departmental officials. I am not saying that the holding up of these matters is done for the sake of holding them up, but sometimes it is difficult to understand why they are being held up.
Comment on this
I want to say only that it is not correct to state that the arguments for and against are already available to the Minister in an appeal. The appellant submits his case against the decision of the local authority and the ground for the appeal must be submitted to the local authority for their observation. These observations must be made available to the appellant for his comments and it is only after that process has been gone through that the examination of the case can start in the Department. Even at that stage, it may appear that there is very little between the two cases and that there may be some prospect of a solution being worked out acceptable to both parties. Therefore, it would be unjust to the appellant to lay down a definite time limit. It is all right to say that the appellant will know that his case will be decided in a period not longer than six months, but it will be poor consolation to the applicant to realise that the result of that stipulation is that his appeal cannot get adequate consideration.
In many of these appeals, six months is adequate; but in others it is not. Deputy Fitzpatrick should appreciate that. I cannot deal with the case to which he refers because I do not know what the considerations are. There have been many cases, for instance, in which oral hearings had been arranged and in which one of the parties felt unable to go ahead on the date decided and put forward a case for an adjournment.
Comment on this
The particular case Deputy Fitzpatrick mentioned may very well have been, I do not know, but I know that this other thing has happened also and that delays can occur. If a decision must be given, in spite of the fact that the case has not been fully examined, then I think that would be unfair to the applicant rather than to the local authority. I can well understand the frustration of people whose appeals take a long time to deal with but some of them are very complicated and I think the suggestion of Deputy Fitzpatrick is not a good one.
Comment on this
Question proposed: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".
Do you agree with this result?
As I remarked, section 4 is highly necessary. A five week period is given to local authorities to decide on applications. I want to raise the question as to whether the local authorities, as they are staffed at present, can cope with this provision. I am all for the provision being instituted and it is then a problem for the local authorities to see whether they can fulfil the demand. Certainly in the city of Dublin I can see difficulties, having regard to the present staffing position, as to how exactly they will be able to comply with this provision. I certainly think a terminal period of five weeks is reasonable.
Before a local authority decide on an application for demolition, regard will be had to the supply of housing available in the area. Will this be restricted purely to municipal housing, or will regard be had to the overall supply of houses in an area? With regard to the provision of alternative accommodation, or contributing to the cost of alternative accommodation, the question is: what cost is reasonable? What cost could compensate someone for a loss of accommodation? The cost of providing alternative accommodation in Dublin could be quite astronomical. There are many people who may have had tenancies for a number of years who would find it very difficult indeed to get alternative accommodation. What would it cost to compensate them for a fresh quest for housing as things stand in Dublin today?
The provision in relation to adjoining buildings is also necessary because we have had cases of almost deliberate sabotage of adjoining houses in demolition work. There were numerous instances of this in Dublin over the past two years. I want to ask what kind of contribution to the cost of providing alternative accommodation is understood here? What would be the criteria of the local authority? It is very hard to see that any financial contribution, in the present conditions in Dublin city, would compensate anyone for a loss of accommodation that takes place as a result of an application like this.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I want to say very briefly, now that this amendment has been rejected and the section stands, that I should like to avail of this opportunity to urge on the Minister to see to it that there will be no undue delays in his Department in dealing with these appeals. I do not expect the Minister to overcome the shortcomings of the applicants or the applicants' advisers, but I am appealing to the Minister to see to it that, in so far as he and his Department are concerned, there will be no delays and that decisions on appeals will be given promptly. It must be conceded that these delays inflict great hardship. This House has given the Minister the Planning Act and is now giving him this measure in the interests of the community as a whole. Having done that, the House is entitled to expect that the interests of individuals will not be interfered with any more than is necessary and that undue hardships will not be imposed on individuals by unreasonable delays.
Comment on this
I have seen certain cases where efforts have been made to have families evicted from places on the pretext that the places are dangerous. Is there any provision to protect families who are living, say, in flats over shops; the landlord requires these for business purposes, has someone come along and declare one wall dangerous and these people are evicted? I do not know whether it comes under this or not, but it is a serious situation that could develop to the detriment of the families concerned. There is one other point. It says here "within five weeks". What happens if the authority does not give permission or does not make a decision within five weeks? Is there some penalty against such an authority?
Comment on this
Where the local authority just falls down on the job what action does the Minister take? It would be serious if a house was demolished and the adjoining houses were damaged in the process. There should be some protection for the people in the adjoining houses. This is happening all over the city. There was a case the other day where a house was declared dangerous and demolished, but the adjoining houses were damaged in the process. The tenants seem to have no redress as yet in matters like this.
Comment on this
With regard to Deputy O'Leary's fears that local authorities may not be able to deal with applications under this Bill within the period laid down, I can only say that I believe and my Department believe that five weeks is an adequate time to deal with these applications. If Deputies feel strongly that the period of five weeks should be extended, I would be prepared to agree to some extension, but five weeks was deliberately put in because it was felt this was sufficient to deal with this type of case.
As Deputy O'Leary says, it is provided that the local authority will take into account the question of the supply of housing available in the area. This does not mean municipal housing only; it means the availability of houses for the people as a whole. The question of the provision of alternative accommodation or the making of a contribution towards the cost of providing alternative accommodation by the housing authority is a matter for decision by the housing authority.
I can assure Deputy Fitzpatrick that there will be no undue delays in the Department, that every effort will be made to streamline the procedure and have appeals dealt with as quickly as possible. It is obviously desirable that appeals should not be decided except on the basis of adequate examination of the whole case both for and against the proposal. If a decision on an application is not given by the housing authority within the period of five weeks, that permission is then available by default. That is the same as the position under the Planning Act, that is, if the decision is not given within two months then the applicant can assume permission by default. The question of the protection of adjoining buildings is dealt with under the Bill.
Comment on this
What happens where a local authority defaults in regard to giving a decision in a case where action is called for against plans to demolish a house? Does it rest there or does the Minister have any scope for action?
Comment on this
The local authority, I think, can be depended upon to make sure that that will not happen. It does not happen, except in very rare cases, under the Planning Act that permission is obtained by default. Local authorities are able so to arrange their affairs as to ensure that these things come up for decision within the statutory period. The only provision that can be made, if a time limit is laid down, is that, if the decision is not given within that time, then that permission may be obtained by default.
Comment on this
We are not making a mountain out of a molehill but we can see a case arising, say, where there was a very valuable site for office development and, through overwork or for some other reason, no decision is given within a five week period. Nobody is responsible, in effect, and nobody can be blamed, and the development goes on.
Comment on this
Somebody is responsible. The local authority are responsible if they do not give a decision within that time.
Comment on this
We are trying to remove loopholes. Legislation has been passed here which appeared to be comprehensive when going through but later it was discovered that a coach and four could be driven through the Minister's own regulations. Are we leaving similar gaps in this Housing Bill so that, because a local authority fails, for one reason or another, to give a decision, development goes through by default? Have we no authority, either under the Minister or elsewhere, to look for penalties in such an event?
Comment on this
What does the Deputy suggest? It can be assumed that the local authorities will arrange a system so that it is practically impossible for it to happen, so that applications will automatically come up for decision before the statutory period has elapsed. There are upwards of 20,000 planning applications dealt with in a year and very few, if any, go by default, because planning authorities arrange their internal organisation so as to ensure that the application will come up for decision before the statutory period has elapsed. You either lay down a statutory period within which applications must be decided or you do not. Deputy O'Leary really seems to be arguing against any limit. I do not see what else can be done.
Comment on this
It appears to me that this section runs parallel to section 19 of the 1931 Act. That section provided that a landlord, who failed to keep a house in repair or allowed it to fall into bad condition, could be served with notice to repair the property and, if he did not comply with the notice, the local authority could enter on the property, carry out the repairs and recover from the landlord. If the landlord refused to pay, the local authority could avail of the ordinary process of the law to get the money by instalments, or to take goods belonging to the landlord or whatever other method appeared appropriate to them. If they failed again they could go to the tenant and repeat the entire process with the tenant. My experience in the Louth County Council and Drogheda Corporation has been that this is a bad section because it has been utilised to cover up the fact that new houses were not being built and it has resulted in the repair of houses which should have been certified as unfit for human habitation. We had the situation in which houses which were not suitable for reconstruction were actually reconstructed and at the end of five or ten years the people had to be rehoused out of those houses. Very often trouble arose because a person in a reconstructed house was not regarded as eligible for a new house since there was a file somewhere saying that the house he occupied was fit for human habitation. I am puzzled as to why this section is included in this Bill.
Comment on this
This section is designed to plug a loophole. It is a tragedy that the Bill is introduced within earshot of the general election and the dissolution of this House.
Comment on this
The Minister's regulation turned speculation in houses into an El Dorado for the unscrupulous who have battened on the Minister's grace for the past year and the Minister is only at this late hour plugging the loophole.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Leary wants to know about speculation he can inquire from one of the Labour candidates in North County Dublin who knows all about speculation.
Comment on this
I acknowledge the Minister's mastery at political baiting. Over the past 12 months perfectly sound property has been knocked down to make way for supermarkets and office blocks. The tenants would be in these houses today had the Minister acted sooner.
Comment on this
The Minister allowed a chaotic situation to develop and it is a tragedy that it is only now, when this House is on the eve of dissolution, with conventions being held all up and down the country, the Minister comes in with a Bill designed to plug the loophole.
Comment on this
May I protest against these personalities? In all my years in this House I have never yet descended to personalities. I can hit as hard as anyone else and I can take it equally well.
Comment on this
I regret my few remarks should get that kind of response from some of the businessmen on the Fianna Fáil benches. I suppose it is a case of bad consciences. It is true that people have deliberately set out to wreck perfectly sound property. This is a very important provision. There have been cases in which the lead has been stripped off the roofs to ensure that the property would deteriorate all the quicker, and that at a time when we have a grave housing shortage. This will be a question of staffing because there will have to be much greater surveillance and more frequent inspection to ensure that property is not allowed to run down so that the speculator can go in and enrich himself at the expense of the unfortunate tenants. There are hundreds of people at the moment living in property which has been described as unfit for human habitation. The local authority have been unable to house these people.
Comment on this
I was rather amused listening to Deputy O'Leary. One would imagine that someone came out with a steamroller and knocked down houses for fun.
Comment on this
We hear a good deal about these office blocks. In an affluent society it is inevitable that there will be a great number of factories built. If we are to take Deputy O'Leary's contribution literally workers are not to go into any office block at all: they are to work out in the rain. They are not to dare to turn a house into an office block, good, bad or indifferent. They may not even say: "This house is declared dangerous".
We must be reasonable in all things. We had the position here in 1963 that more houses fell down in the area I then represented than had to be taken down by the dangerous buildings section of Dublin Corporation. It is not correct to give the impression that houses were taken down wholesale. With other members of the housing committee of Dublin Corporation, of which Deputy Denis Larkin was Chairman, I was a member of many deputations, and the Minister always received us courteously and listened sympathetically to our representations. As a result, we started the Ballymun housing scheme under which 3,000 families have been housed. There are still some houses which are dangerous.
I want to make it quite clear that I am all in favour of decent accommodation for workers in this country. There are places in Dublin where unfortunate clerical workers are trying to carry on their duties under very unsuitable working conditions and the same can be said of some Government offices also. The conditions are a danger to the health of those people.
We must be fair. We cannot go so far east that we will be west again or south that we will be north again or any other way you like to put it. However, from time to time, people will buy a house. Certainly, that will happen in a democratic society. I should not like to see this going too far. In a completely socialist State, nobody can do anything without the permission of a dictator and anything he demands must be done. This matter in this city has been misrepresented and magnified out of all proportions. Any office blocks built in this city——