We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Housing Bill, 1968: Committee and Final Stages.

Contributions 124–250 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing Bill, 1968
Enacted

No. 30 of 1968 ›

Not at all. Relax, now. Castro has not come yet, friend.

Comment on this

I am delighted with that interruption by Deputy O'Leary. There are people coming——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Norton must have got a constituency and he is celebrating.

Comment on this

Some of your friends had difficulty.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Burke, without interruption.

Comment on this

I wonder where Deputy Dunne is now.

Comment on this

We have people here coming from the east who are causing a good deal of trouble and interfering with the rights of citizens in this city and encouraging many people to do many things. To anyone who has been dealing with the housing position in this city over the years and who is aware of the demolition that has to take place it is perfectly obvious that the Opposition Parties are now trying to misrepresent that position. We have witnessed a few hoboes and members of the Housing Action Committee shouting and screaming and saying that every house must stand. We are to have no progress in this city at all: let this city melt: let the houses fall down: leave them down: nothing else is to be done—that is the attitude, apparently. I can assure the House and the country that I do not subscribe to that trend of thought. I am very concerned about the housing of our people. In this city of Dublin in which we have the honour to be, over 60,000 families have been housed since this State was founded: I am giving credit to all political Parties for their work in this connection.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order. Is this in order on section 5?

Comment on this

It is as much in order as the contribution by Deputy O'Leary.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It sounds like a Second Reading speech or as if we were discussing housing on the Estimate for the Minister's Department. Section 5 deals with the right of the housing authority to go in and to reinstate a house which has deliberately been allowed, by the owner, to go into decay. That is all that is in it.

Comment on this

Thanks very much. I am very grateful to the Deputy for his advice——

Comment on this

——but you will not take it.

Comment on this

——but I am afraid that, in this case, I shall not accept it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I have made my submission to the Chair.

Comment on this

I am dealing with Deputy O'Leary's point. To listen to him, one would imagine that nobody was housed in our city. May I claim the gracious indulgence of the Chair for a moment?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will relate this to section 5.

Comment on this

——and relate it to my remarks, too.

Comment on this

The general implication is: "We are the saviours of everybody. If the corporation wish to knock it down, we will keep up the house."

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is what the section says.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick should not interrupt. Relax.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Norton is well relaxed.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick is just as venomous as he ever was.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick is anxious for a seat in Dublin. He is very welcome to it if he can get a nomination.

Comment on this

I do not know where Deputy Norton is going.

Comment on this

Do not worry. You did not get your nomination back.

Comment on this

Where is Deputy Dunne now?

Comment on this

Where is Deputy Blaney, too—gone home?

Comment on this

He is in Donegal.

Comment on this

I shall conclude by saying that I am anxious to see the workers of Dublin housed in proper offices.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I am anxious, also, that bad, old, rotten houses should be taken down and rebuilt for our people.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Burke is opposing the section which says that houses that have been allowed to go into decay should be reinstated. He is opposing the section in the Bill.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Burke, without interruption.

Comment on this

I want to assure Deputy O'Leary that Fianna Fáil are deeply concerned about the housing of our people. I have represented the people of part of Dublin city and county for 25 years and I can assure him that, along with my colleagues in the Fianna Fáil Party, I have contributed quite a good deal in working to further that worthy objective and I shall continue to work towards that objective.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Opposition Parties not to misrepresent facts. To Deputy Fitzpatrick I shall merely say: some other time, some other day, we shall have a discussion on this matter.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——when it will be more in order.

Comment on this

I think that this is a case of locking the stable door after the horse has bolted. We are all agreed in our condemnation of the ruthless demolition of houses in this city in the past few years—not just in the past year, as I have heard it stated—for the purpose of serving commercial interests. I remember being told by a dispensary doctor about a house which was being demolished. He was told that the two children who were ill would have to be moved immediately as they were in a dangerous building. He, with his limited knowledge, did not see anything dangerous about it. He called in an architect to inspect the building and was told that there was nothing wrong with the house and that it did not need to be demolished. Of course, when he raised his objection the night marauders were in, stripping the roof of this house and leaving it exposed for this poor family who lived at the top of the house. This is one example of what happened in Dublin over the last few years. The Minister will agree that the reckless demolition of these houses created a housing shortage because everybody who was evicted helped to swell the Dublin Corporation's housing waiting list. Then these houses were repaired for conversion into offices but the people could not return to them. This was very wrong. We see a glaring example of this situation in the pock-marked city which we have. If the Housing authority decide what houses will be demolished——

Comment on this

The Deputy is becoming muddled.

Comment on this

I am not becoming muddled. I should like to see some justice being done. I like to hear Deputy Burke expounding on what he would like to see done for this city and its people. He must not forget that there are some 5,000 families on the housing waiting list in Dublin city, or some 20,000 people. He can say what he likes about the wonderful work being done but we still have that number waiting and that does not include married couples who are not provided for nor——

Comment on this

Is it in order, Sir, to deal with the housing situation in Dublin and in the country, on this section?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of housing in Dublin is not relevant.

Comment on this

The Minister is very quick to——

Comment on this

We have had two speeches on it, from Deputy O'Leary and from Deputy O'Connell.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And Deputy Burke.

Comment on this

It is relevant to the situation in Dublin where a housing shortage has been created.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not open up a discussion on Dublin housing

Comment on this

We are asking about the demolition of houses and asking that where people do not renovate or repair houses they should be compelled to do so.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy can advocate that.

Comment on this

I should like to know what experts will the housing authority have to decide what houses should be demolished and what houses need repairs. At present in deciding what houses are dangerous we have not got experts in our housing authorities making these decisions.

Comment on this

We have; that is wrong.

Comment on this

I am telling the Deputy that we have not. This is the great tragedy.

Comment on this

We have architects.

Comment on this

The architects do not visit the houses. We have tradesmen who are not in a position to decide.

Comment on this

We will get doctors to do it.

Comment on this

They might make a better job than some of the people the Minister has doing the job.

Comment on this

I should like to know what staff are employed and how they could possibly cope with the number of cases that come before them at present. I say that we have not got sufficient architects to inspect every case referred to them as a dangerous building. Far from it. Because of this I would like to know the number of architects we have employed for this purpose.

Comment on this

With respect to Deputy O'Leary and to Deputy O'Connell, they are missing the point. I do not want to infringe the rules of order but this is relevant to the section. We must not lose sight of the fact that this section, and indeed the whole Bill, is an emergency measure designed to deal with a particular situation which, when all is said and done, is a temporary emergency and marginal matter, the fundamental problem of housing, which we cannot go into, being a much bigger thing. What I would like to say about this section, to balance what Deputy O'Connell says, is that it is all right where clearly you have a habitable house but there are a lot of old type tenement houses all over the city about which, even if the Minister or the Corporation were to devote an exorbitant amount of money to them, because of age or fundamental structural defect, nothing could be done.

Deputy O'Leary may not have been a Deputy when this occurred but for as long as I can remember there was a problem in the older part of Dublin to the north, ranging from Temple Street, Dorset Street, Queen Street, Blackhall Place and around that area, where there were buildings 200 years old which had been allowed to deteriorate into abominable slums. At one time this city enjoyed the unenviable reputation of having nearly the worst slums in Europe. Those of us who knew that area were confronted not with the problem of keeping the people in the houses but with the problem of the people coming to us and saying: "For God's sake, will you get us out of this?" It was a very interesting social experiment—the Ceann Comhairle will pardon me for referring to this but it is relevant to the question of repairs—to find that when these people were housed properly in new estates, the first being Cabra, they blossomed forth into good citizens. I will not name the precise location for Deputy O'Leary because people have their sensitivities and do not like to be pinpointed, but if the Deputy wants the addresses I will give them to him privately.

The Deputy should know that there are areas still in that constituency where houses are being maintained although uninhabitable and where the best thing that could happen would be for these houses to be cleared out. Any attempt to assist the existing landlord to maintain people in those houses is doing a disservice and keeping people living under sub-standard conditions and defeating the prospect of the people bettering themselves. To come now to a much more recent experience in regard to this, several years ago the situation was brought home forcibly by two tragedies. The first was in our constituency—we have the honour to represent Bolton Street—and that tragedy was followed up by the Holles Street collapse in which two children were killed. From my own knowledge I know that we had the greatest difficulty getting these houses condemned. Deputy O'Leary will know that by now the Queen Street-Blackhall Place area has been demolished, as well as the whole of Dorset Street, but he might be interested to know that representatives both of the Corporation and of this House spent anxious nights personally watching houses in Dorset Street in case they would collapse and so as to see what could be done because the machinery of the public authority was too slow. I remember also one night of crisis in Blackhall Place where, if it had not been for the priests in Halston Street who accommodated the people temporarily in a school, these people would have had to remain on the streets because nothing that could be done would have made those houses habitable. They were unrepairable. If they had been patched up they would still be dangerous and our problem was to see that no temporary patching was done. It is interesting to see this change of attitude in the House because one of the Deputy's colleagues was down there with us at the same time. Our anxiety was to get houses condemned and we had great difficulty in doing it. There are still houses that I believe should be condemned and cleared. This is the background to this section.

More specifically in regard to this section, what I find difficult to see, in its interpretation, is how it can be enforced. Clearly, if there is a case such as Dr. O'Connell is talking about where there is a really habitable house which for purely commercial reasons is being removed, the Deputy will not have to push me very far to be in sympathy with him. But I want to see the other side of the coin and the dangers in this Bill and the danger that we in this House should think that there is a panacea or general remedy, or even a significant contribution to the solution of Dublin's housing problem in this Bill. There may be a peripheral problem to deal with. If the Deputy gives me evidence of that I shall need very little convincing. But let us not enlarge on the problem or be swept away in consideration of another aspect of this matter, just because this other aspect is there.

I wonder if the House would permit me to make what is, strictly speaking, an irrelevant observation although it is still related to this Bill?

Comment on this

Is it relevant to this debate?

Comment on this

It is not irrelevant. It is not this section that is the problem. It is when the houses are cleared what will go up instead?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I hope the Deputy is not widening the scope of the debate.

Comment on this

I cannot let slanderous statements by Dr. O'Connell go unchallenged in the House. I know the architects and engineers associated with the dangerous buildings section of Dublin Corporation and they are decent, honourable men. It is very much against their wishes to condemn any house and I have yet to know of a case where they condemned any house that could be made habitable. For that reason alone I shall defend them here. I have been associated with them for many years and I know that they would not be party to condemning any house that should not be condemned.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order, a Cheann Comhairle, for the Minister to say to you: "Are we going to have an Estimate speech here in order to have Deputy de Valera cut short?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is in order in asking the Chair if references are or are not in order.

Comment on this

I rather thought it was an authoritative statement rather than a request.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It was a request.

Comment on this

I think the question was whether we would need an Estimate debate also in view of the fact that we were apparently discussing the whole workings of the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister's opinion is only an opinion like that of Deputy Dr. O'Connell or myself?

Comment on this

Yes; I asked the Chair if we would have an Estimate debate also.

Comment on this

I think I should get an opportunity to make clear what I said. There is no question of my making slanderous remarks or statements. I merely mentioned the fact that the Dublin Corporation are so much understaffed as regards architects that they cannot possibly inspect every single house or dwelling that may be dangerous. The Minister knows it is a fact that there are not sufficient architects employed in Dublin Corporation because they cannot get them. We have a serious shortage of architects. This is very important: what I said was that we cannot and Dublin Corporation cannot possibly provide architects for every case of a building that is reported to be dangerous.

Comment on this

When the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was in the Chair I referred to the fact that section 19 of the 1931 Act seemed to do everything covered by this section 5 and from that point of view it is possible that there is an element of window-dressing in this Bill, as suggested by Deputy O'Leary. I was amazed to find Deputy de Valera, a man of some sensitivity, talking about the happening in Dorset Street in Dublin and elsewhere and saying that there was no panacea. I say there was a panacea; there is none now. If the Deputy's Party had not cut down the number of houses built in the years 1958, 1959, 1960 and 1961 to 50 per cent of what had been built previously, the sad fatalities referred to would not have occurred. That is a matter of finance and general local government law and I do not want to dwell on it in here but I must refer to cross-talk between the Minister and myself. When I said that in my 14 years in this House and the Seanad I had never made a personal remark to any Deputy, the Minister retorted: "Deputy Donegan, indeed! Of course you did." I have vigorously contended in the House with the Minister himself and with everybody else on the opposite side. I have contended with some of my own Party members in the Party-room as hard as I could but I do not think that I have ever gone further than making a humorous remark to another Deputy. Perhaps the Deputy might not consider humorous or perhaps my humour might differ from his but I have never made a personal remark. I have never called anybody a coward and I have never yet tried to hit anybody in the passages. If the Minister wishes to make this charge against me I should like to know if he will now substantiate it and say when I made a deliberately personal and insulting remark to any Member of this House or the other House in the 14 years I have been here.

Comment on this

To clear up a point on section 3 without going into any general discussion, it is a fact that this matter of deliberately bringing property into disrepair and afterwards demolishing it and putting an office block in its place has been a burning question in Dublin and other areas. This section seeks to end that situation and it is very important that it should do so. We regret it has not been done sooner. The idea that by welcoming such a section we are in the same breath condemning people to live in existing bad conditions is of course quite wrong. The rehousing of people depends on the standards we have and I suggest that in all the older parts of the city people must be rehoused. I think that those in the older Corporation housing schemes should also be considered for rehousing because the standards of the 30s are not the standards of 1969. That is by the way. The point we now strive to make is that the immediate priority in Dublin is not office building but the provision of houses, not the provision of better office blocks but the provision of better housing. Any building programme that is to succeed must put its resources to work at the point of greatest need, which is not office blocks but housing. That is a matter of priority. It is exceedingly wrong of Deputies to suggest that we were talking about iron dictatorship when we are merely talking about a system of priority when it comes to buildings. We do not suggest that somebody should not make legitimate profit in certain areas but we see that the profit is being made out of office blocks which we cannot afford at present.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will appreciate that there is nothing in section 5 about commercial buildings or office blocks.

Comment on this

No, but we have seen sites that could be of value turned to commercial use. It is regrettable that at the moment there is a quicker return on money put into office blocks and that sort of development than on money put into housing development. We have seen "hot" money pouring into this city from cross-Channel sources for the purpose of building office blocks. I certainly think Dublin has enough office blocks and not enough housing at present.

Comment on this

The decision I have to make is whether I should follow the example of Deputy O'Leary and Deputy O'Connell and deal with the whole question of housing in Dublin, the question of relative progress made in housing under the Coalition Government and the condition in which they left both the finances available for housing and the industry itself and the contrast with the sustained rate of progress under the present Government. Despite the temptation to deal with this subject, my decision is to leave this to the appropriate occasion and, that being so, there really is not much point in my intervening at all because, in fact, in so far as this section of the Bill which we are supposed to be discussing is concerned, the only dispute is between Deputy Donegan on behalf of the Fine Gael Party and every other Deputy in the House. The only argument here is whether or not this provision is required in the Bill. I say that this is vital to the Bill and, as far as I know, every other Deputy, except Deputy Donegan, agrees that it is vital.

Comment on this

Is there anything in that section that is not contained in section 19 of the Act of 1931?

Comment on this

I am going to talk and if Deputy Donegan wants to talk afterwards, he can.

Comment on this

I will.

Comment on this

If Deputy Donegan's sole intention is to disrupt the proceedings of the House, he is at liberty to do it as far as I am concerned but I listened to Deputy Donegan speaking twice on this Bill and, as I said, the only dispute I can see in so far as this section is concerned is between Deputy Donegan and the rest of the House. I say this section is vital to the Bill and that the Bill would be pointless without this section.

I may say that as Minister for Local Government I do not know of any case in which demolition of houses took place in the absence of permission for development of the sites. Deputy O'Connell talks of ruthless demolition of houses but no evidence has been produced in the various debates that we have had here of ruthless demolition of houses in the absence of planning permission having been granted for alternative development of the sites and that is why I say that the control that we are seeking to provide under this Bill could not be operated under the Planning Act because in the case of any demolition that we know of, in the City of Dublin at any rate, planning permission had already been obtained for the development of that site. So, it is quite clear that if it was necessary to seek planning permission for demolition, there were not sufficiently strong planning considerations to reject such application. Therefore, that shows, as I have been claiming all along, that it is only under housing legislation that this question of the demolition of habitable houses can be effectively dealt with and that the proposal to deal with it under the Planning Act was just an impractical suggestion and one that would not secure the objective that we have in view of preventing the demolition of habitable house in conditions of a shortage of housing accommodation.

Comment on this

Does the Minister realise that demolition could take place first and planning permission sought then?

Comment on this

I am saying that I do not know of any case in which that happened. What we are trying to provide against in this section is the case of the individual, the speculator as he is referred to, who, in order to circumvent the provisions of this Bill, will deliberately allow a sound, habitable house that is needed to house people to deteriorate into such a condition that it will be no longer habitable. It may be, as has been suggested, that in order to operate this section properly, increased staffing will be necessary. This may or may not be true. It seems to me that if there is to be really adequate inspection this will probably be so and certainly the whole exercise of bringing in this legislation will be futile if there is not adequate inspection and if those people who would deliberately allow, or, indeed, deliberately cause, a house to deteriorate are not discovered in time to operate this provision but this is in my opinion vital to the Bill and I agree, as far as I can see, with the rest of the House, except Deputy Donegan, that that is so.

Comment on this

I want to point out that what I said was—and this has not been dealt with by the Minister—there is nothing in this section that is not contained in section 19 of the Act of 1931 which, in my view, gives the same power which I as a member of a local authority have seen operated by that local authority. I described precisely what could be done: the buildings could be entered; the reconstruction work could be specified; if the landlord did not do it the local authority could enter upon the building, could avail of the grants given and seek the money from the landlord, could take his goods from him if he would not give the money; could then put an instalment order upon him and then repeat the entire process on the tenant, if they wished so to do. I have asked the Minister is there anything in this section that could not be done under the Act of 1931.

Comment on this

Of course there is.

Comment on this

The other question I asked was whether or not the Minister can give an instance when during the shorter period he has been in the House I was personally insulting or provocative to anybody, when I hurled a personal insult at anyone rather than an argument, vigorous or not, against his line of thought.

Comment on this

I would draw to the attention of the other Deputy for my constituency, Deputy de Valera, and the Minister, that they will recall that a whole street disappeared in the last three years. Dorset Row disappeared from the map of Dublin. A public street was closed in at either end and the houses on either side were knocked down. That was under the conditions prevailing up to now. I do not know that it ever received any attention. A public thoroughfare was closed in at either end. The older inhabitants can remember that houses existed on either side. These were definitely sound houses. Probably people could point out other instances around the city. In no sense were these houses bad. They were good houses. They were in the centre of the city. They had many more years of useful life. Their retention could have saved a strain on the municipal housing position. But, because the existing situation allowed a complete open game to those involved in the business, this street was taken over for commercial purposes. I recall the case of Dorset Row, in which a public street was taken over for commercial purposes.

Comment on this

The 1931 Housing Act has of course been replaced by the 1966 Act and part of the provision to which Deputy Donegan refers is of course that these repairs must be possible at reasonable cost. Here we are dealing with a different situation. We are dealing with a situation in which a house is deliberately allowed to fall into disrepair and the question of its restoration at reasonable cost does not enter into the provision in this Bill. As well as that, obviously the section of the Housing Act to which Deputy Donegan refers deals with cases of tenanted houses but this provision deals with habitable houses whether they are inhabited or not. It deals with the case of the habitable house of which vacant possession is obtained and which is deliberately allowed to deteriorate in order to try to circumvent the other provisions in this Bill. There is an obvious difference.

I have not got the complete volumes of the Dáil Debates here which would enable me to look up instances of Deputy Donegan's past conduct in the House. Perhaps, he would go through them himself. I can only rely on my own experience.

Comment on this

By way of explanation, I wish to point out that the context of the statement by the Minister was that when it was suggested that a person who is now known to be a candidate for this House was involved in improper property dealing, I said that Members of the House should not say these things, but I was told that I did it myself. The Minister, having said that, should give the instances during the past 14 years in which I, in this House or the other one, suggested improper dealings in regard to any Member of this House, or instances in which I was insulting or provocative. I am entitled to that and if I do not get it I shall have to take the matter up, either now or later, with the Committee on Procedure and Privileges.

Comment on this

The Deputy should look up the Dáil Debates.

Comment on this

If I were the Minister, I would certainly have apologised but, perhaps, that would be old-fashioned.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Section 9 is a far-reaching section. It is a section that excludes certain buildings from the Bill and in my opinion it could undo everything that the Bill sets out to do. The section reads:

(1) This Act shall not apply to the demolition in whole or in part or the use otherwise than for human habitation of any habitable house where—

(a) a planning authority or the Minister has, before the passing of this Act, decided to grant a permission or approval under section 26 of the Act of 1963 for development involving the demolition or change of use, or

I have no objection to that but I regard subsections (2) and (3) as being dangerous. It is very difficult to follow what exactly subsection (2) means. The subsection reads:

A permission under this Act shall not be required in relation to the use otherwise than for human habitation of part of any habitable house for, but only for, so long as the house is principally used as a dwelling and the change of use does not cause to reside elsewhere a person who, immediately before the change of use, was ordinarily resident in such house.

It is not easy to understand that subsection and while I am doing my best to follow it, I believe it could operate in the following way. A person could have a large house set out in flats and if the halldoor flat became vacant and was vacant for some time, the owner of the house could decide to turn the ground floor of that house into an office and, in my opinion, subsection (2) of section 9 would relieve him of the necessity of applying for permission to change the use of the house because, of course, the ground floor or halldoor flat being vacant, there would be no question of anybody being compelled to reside elsewhere as a result of the change in use. The community could be deprived of this house which was ordinarily used for human habitation.

I know the subsection says that the house shall be excluded from the measure for, but only for, as long as the house is principally used as a dwelling.

I should like the Minister to tell us what he has in mind in relation to subsection (3) which says:

This Act shall not apply in relation to the following, namely—

(a) the demolition of a habitable house in case the demolition is of a class, or complies with conditions, prescribed for the purposes of this subsection,

(b) the use of a habitable house otherwise than for human habitation in case such use is of a class, or complies with conditions so prescribed, and

(c) a habitable house situate in an area which for the time being is so prescribed.

This subsection, in so far as I can see, gives the Minister power to make regulations prescribing certain things which, in effect, exclude whole streets or areas from this subsection. It is a pity that some of the Labour Deputies who spoke at such length on some of the other sections did not remain to try to find out what this particular subsection means. It is my opinion that we are dealing with this measure because the Minister was enabled to make regulations under the Planning and Development Act and when he was making those regulations he decided that demolition was not development and, therefore, demolition was excluded from the Planning and Development Act. In other words, it became unnecessary to get planning permission to knock down a house or to knock down a whole street of houses That is the only reason why the Minister found it necessary to introduce the Bill with which we are now dealing. As I have said, subsections (2) and (3) of section 9 can undo all that the other sections, especially section 3, sets out to do. I shall not say any more at this stage but I should like the Minister to tell me and to tell the House what, precisely, is the meaning of subsection (2) and what he has in mind in subsection (3).

Comment on this

I do not think subsection (2) is so difficult to understand. The type of thing we have in mind is the case of, say, a widow who has lost her husband and decides to utilise a room in the house for the purpose of dressmaking, hairdressing and so on and the change of use obviously does not involve the displacement of any person from living accommodation. In the case Deputy Fitzpatrick put forward, that is the conversion of one flat in a house into an office, that clearly involves the loss of a full unit of accommodation and therefore I think it would be clearly outside subsection (2) as the change of use would entail any person who was resident in the flat getting out.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not want to interrupt the Minister. I am not anxious to prolong this thing. Supposing a flat were vacant because the owner bought a house, would this subsection apply?

Comment on this

The flat is a dwelling. What Deputy Fitzpatrick is putting forward would be a change of use of a complete dwelling. If it is a habitable dwelling then permission would have to be obtained under this Bill, when it is passed. Clearly the changing of use of a complete dwelling from a dwelling to an office does involve the displacement of any person residing in it. The mere fact the flat happens to be vacant does not change the issue. I agree that subsection (3) is a subsection which may never be necessary. What is intended is that it may at some later stage appear to be desirable to exempt from the provisions of this Bill some particular class of building. I think many Deputies will see there may be no necessity for this Bill to operate at all in certain parts of the country. That is the idea of subsection (3): to give power to prescribe by regulation either the omission or exemption of certain classes of premises or the exemption of certain areas from the application of the Bill.

It is not definite that this will ever be required. If Deputy Fitzpatrick has any strong objection to this subsection I have no objection to dropping it. It may be desirable to bring an amendment at some stage to insert it into the Bill but I agree there is no obvious need for it at the present time. It was felt it was desirable to have it in in case it was needed. As regards subsection (2) I think it is necessary to have that in and to me it is quite clear that the case of changing the use of a complete flat would be outside that subsection.

Comment on this

I agree with what the Minister says with regard to a complete flat. There are cases, and this is likely to happen in certain areas of the city, where you have a complete house, say a five-roomed house, with two rooms on the ground floor and bedrooms above where, as in the case mentioned by the Minister, a widow is left without her husband and the family may elect to live in the top storey and to let say the two front rooms —what is in effect the ground floor— as an office. How does that fit in with this particular subsection?

Comment on this

If it does not involve the displacement of any person it is all right.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): In that case it would come in under subsection (2).

Comment on this

Yes, this would come in under subsection (2).

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am obliged to the Minister in so far as subsection (3) is concerned and I would be glad to accept his proposal to delete it. The Minister quite fairly says that it is not necessary now and I think he goes further to say that it does not appear to be necessary in the foreseeable future. If it becomes necessary an amendment can be brought in to cover this. I do not entirely agree with the Minister about subsection (2). We would all have the greatest sympathy with the poor widow who finds it necessary to turn one or two rooms into a dressmaking business, a hairdressing saloon or even to let portion of her house in order to augment her income. However, we would find, if that subsection is put in to facilitate the poor widow, that wealthy or unscrupulous landlords would come in on the bandwagon to avail of that. I do not agree with the Minister that changing the use of the entire flat, which was occupied but vacant at the moment, would not exclude it from this subsection.

Say the flat is vacant for a month and you change the use of it into a workshop or an office room, this would not cause anybody who is residing in the flat immediately before the change of use to reside elsewhere and that is the text of the subsection. The Minister relies on saying that the flat is a dwelling. Subsection (2) says:

A permission under this Act shall not be required in relation to the use otherwise than for human habitation or part of any habitable house.

Comment on this

Look at the definition of house.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The definition of a house means a building or part of a building which is used as a dwelling. I think the Minister has a point there. A house means a building or a part of a building which is used as a dwelling. I suppose then a flat would be regarded as part of a building. I can only say if that is so my main objection to subsection (2) would then be removed. I can only suggest to the Minister between now and when he brings this Bill to the Seanad that he satisfies himself that that is in fact so and that subsection (2) does not provide a loophole for somebody by degrees to turn a house which was let out in flats to some other industrial or commerical use.

Comment on this

I do not mind having another look at it. I am quite clear that under this Bill the term house includes a flat. In any case I propose the amendment:

To delete subsection (3) of section 9.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We on this side of the House welcomed this Bill when it was introduced. We recognised that a coach and four was being driven through the Planning and Development Act, 1963, in so far as the obvious intention of that Act was being evaded. It was being evaded because of regulations made by the Minister which declared that the plastering of the outside of a house and the demolition of a house were one and the same thing. Following those regulations it was possible to demolish one house, two houses, or a whole street of houses. In that way houses which were badly needed as dwellings in a city in which there is an acute housing problem were being either demolished altogether or changed from dwelling houses into office suites, or commercial buildings of one sort or another. We felt so strongly about that position that in 1967 we introduced a Bill into Seanad Éireann to amend the Planning and Development Act in order to ensure that such houses would not be demolished or changed into offices or buildings other than dwelling houses. What is being done in this Bill would have been done equally well in the Bill which we introduced into the Seanad in 1967. The Minister thought otherwise. He thought the Bill we introduced in the Seanad was not as effective as the measure which he introduced here some time ago and with which we are now dealing. The pity is that the Minister did not introduce this Bill into Dáil Éireann sooner.

Having said that, I want to give credit where credit is due. I have often had occasion to complain that the Minister adopted an unreasonable attitude about either legislation proposals or electoral proposals. I want to go on record as saying that the Minister behaved in a most reasonable manner in so far as this Bill was concerned. The only exception was his refusal to impose a time limit on the Minister with regard to appeals.

Comment on this

The Minister is blushing.

Comment on this

I am examining my conscience.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Maybe the Minister has remembered the election.

Comment on this

It is the election.

Comment on this

It is a dangerous mentality to have approaching an election.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I welcome particularly the deletion of subsection (3) of section 9. It is very important. In my opinion, if subsection (3) of section 9 had been allowed to stand part of this Bill, then the Bill might as well never have been introduced. The deletion of subsection (3) of section 9 is a very worthwhile amendment. I wish to thank the Minister for accepting it. The Bill only does what we say should have been done in 1967. The two amendments which I have mentioned are a considerable improvement on it.

Deputy P.J. Burke, in one of his sanctimonious speeches, spoke about the necessity of providing proper office accommodation for workers. I entirely agree with the sentiment, but I say there is only one thing more necessary than proper office accommodation for workers and that is proper housing.

Deputy de Valera referred to this as a temporary measure and as a measure necessary to deal with an emergency. I can only hope that the emergency will soon be cleared up. I can only hope that, until such time as the workers of this city and of the country as a whole are provided with proper living accommodation and dwelling houses, it will not be possible to pull down dwelling houses and convert them into luxurious office blocks whether those office blocks are for the use of the Civil Service or any other workers, whoever they are.

Comment on this

I was not here for most of the debate but, as Deputy Dowling, who is not here now, knows, we have a monitor in the room and can listen to what is going on here—although we did not stay until midnight to listen to him last week.

Comment on this

It was 11 p.m. last week.

Comment on this

I would not know. I was half way home by then. During the debate we had two Dublin Deputies who knew what the conditions in Dublin were like. This Bill applies to the whole country, but mainly refers to Dublin. It was only right to have people who knew the conditions in Dublin speaking on it. The reference which Deputy Burke made to office blocks replacing houses, and that workers needed to go in out of the rain, was, I think, beside the point altogether. So far as the office blocks are concerned, the people working out in the rain do not go into the office blocks except to collect their pay. They are allowed in for that, if their boots are clean. The Minister says that buildings were not knocked down in the city. The buildings in Mountjoy Square have been half-knocked down and left in a dangerous condition for a long period. The Minister might be able to use his influence to have something done about them.

The Bill is a good measure and the only pity is that it was not introduced long before now. A lot of damage was done, perhaps not to as great an extent as has been alleged—we all like to exaggerate at times—by the indiscriminate pulling down of buildings. From time to time many of us were embarrassed when some of our friends or erstwhile friends engaged in this business. Buildings were allowed to go into disrepair so that the unfortunate tenants could be put out and the buildings demolished.

I wish to make one other comment on this matter, because the Minister seemed to be adamant on the question of the type of person who condemned buildings. I have experience of being in a building during the dangerous building scare in this city when one of these people came in. I have no hesitation in saying that he had no qualifications whatever and he admitted this. However, he condemned the building and put the owner to the expense of £1,400 to £1,500, though an architect had said the repairs were not necessary. A person without qualifications said they were necessary and they had to be done. I am sure the Minister is aware that was the situation. Perhaps, there are not enough trained people available and, perhaps, they could be better employed than in inspecting buildings, but where inspection involves expensive repairs being carried out, it should be by somebody other than an ordinary person without qualifications. The Bill will be welcomed because it will undo something which could have been harmful. The Minister said this matter could not have been covered in planning legislation.

Comment on this

I wish to make a few remarks on the Bill. I was glad to hear Deputy Tully welcoming it and I was surprised to see the Labour Party voting against its provisions in the one division which took place.

Comment on this

It was against the Minister's failure to put a time limit on it. Let us be accurate, at least.

Comment on this

Even the Labour Party did not understand the provisions of the Bill. I was surprised to see them going to the other side of the House when the division occurred. The Bill meets public demand and it is a pity it took so long to go through the House. I do not think there will be any serious amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

The Report Stage has gone.

Comment on this

The Report Stage is over but the Deputy did not know it.

Comment on this

He has not got an intercom like other Deputies.

Comment on this

He has not got a clue. It is the Housing Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Tully would not have known if he had not an intercom.

Comment on this

I knew what was going on.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Lemass on what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

I should like to say that the preservation of buildings, not having them knocked down, to be replaced by office blocks and to give the local authority much greater power in this respect, is desirable. I hope, however, that the Bill is not designed just to give way to some pressure that is being put on by the Georgian Society or the Old Dublin Society or such people. The corporation gave way to pressure by these people and Georgian buildings in Seán McDermott Street were preserved at a cost of £1,000 per room at that time. It would cost £3,000 per room now.

These buildings are nothing more than substandard slums and there is no point in preserving buildings if they are to remain slums. Similar buildings were pulled down and replaced by brick-faced structures and they provide comfortable, modern dwellings sought after by many people who wish to live in the city centre. Those people who demonstrated in Islandbridge should see what is being done to provide modern flats for working class people. Let us ensure that buildings can be pulled down if they are to be replaced by habitable accommodation but do not let us do what is being done in London—pulled down buildings being replaced by office blocks.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass's remarks have tempted me to repeat a point I made on Second Stage about a danger in this Bill. It is precisely that this Bill might, from the long-term point of view, react on efforts to solve the housing situation. Deputy Lemass said that the experiment to preserve old houses in the north side of the city and, so to speak, to adapt them, was not a success and that it does not compare with properly designed new buildings. The kernel of this Bill is that it gives power to the Minister which is necessary in the present situation. When all is said and done we are dealing with a peripheral problem in the housing situation in Dublin and as Deputy Lemass has said the important thing is to get ahead with the provision of proper housing for the future.

That will involve the demolition of many existing dwellings and the practical problem is to supply the new as quickly as we destroy the old. Deputy Tully spoke of the type of persons carrying out inspections and I can assure him from my personal experience on sites during the crisis of falling houses, in Mountjoy Square, in Dorset Street, in Queen Street, in Blackhall Place, the problem was to get the buildings condemned. It was not a question of people being too willing to condemn and to force repairs. The trouble was that, there being no alternative accommodation available for those people, they were being left too long in dangerous circumstances.

Comment on this

I was speaking of a good part of the city.

Comment on this

I am mentioning only my experience and there are two sides to every story. I speak at this stage only to reinforce what Deputy Lemass has said. If this Bill is looked at coldly in its context, it is not a general remedy for the housing situation. It will not do much to help in the long run. It is a holding operation. If misused—this may be an unpopular thing to say—such a provision could operate in a directly opposite way to that in which we wish it to operate. I should like to say, therefore, on the Fifth Stage of the Bill, that its proper application will be as important as its passage through the House.

Comment on this

This is a housing Bill, not a planning Bill. It has not been brought in, as Deputy Fitzpatrick has said, because a coach and four was being driven through the Planning Act. If the Planning Act had been found to be deficient in any way, it would have been amended. This Bill had nothing whatever to do with it. As I have said, there has been no evidence that the Planning Act was being circumvented in any way.

I do not know of any way in which demolition of houses took place in which permission for some other development was not obtained. This legislation was introduced because it was decided by the Government that in existing circumstances it was desirable to have effective control over the demolition of habitable houses and the matter we desired to be taken into consideration in this connection was the question of the need for housing accommodation in the local authority area concerned. Clearly then it was housing legislation that was required in order to provide this effective control to ensure that housing considerations would be the deciding factor. It must be quite clear that, if planning considerations did not preclude the development proposed on the site of these houses, then planning considerations could not preclude the demolition which was an essential part of the whole proposal and that obviously, since there were cases of habitable houses being demolished, the only way of dealing with it was through housing legislation, through legislation that would promote the taking into consideration of the question that there was a housing shortage and that it was not in the public interest that useful and sound housing accommodation should be removed and replaced by other development which did not conflict with planning considerations.

I refute the suggestion that what we are proposing to do could have been done in any effective way whatever under the Planning Act. The Planning Act could not be utilised for this purpose. There is ample evidence available in this city to show that that is so because, as I said, in every case that I know of where houses were demolished there was in existence already permission for alternative development. That shows that planning considerations could not have secured the retention of those houses.

Comment on this