Committee on Finance. - Vote 20—Office of the Minister for Justice (Resumed).
Contributions 1–162 of 492. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
When discussing this Estimate last week I mentioned particularly the conduct of the Minister for Justice as a public representative. My colleague, Deputy Dr. Cruise. O'Brien, has dealt at length with the Minister's conduct and I do not intend to repeat what he has said. The Office of the Minister for Justice is a very important one because it deals with the supervision of the administration of justice and its ancillary services. How this Office behaves and how the Minister is seen to behave has a bearing on how law and order is administered. It is important the public should know that not alone is justice done but that it is seen to be done. We should expect and demand that the Department of Justice be in the control of a man who is both human and humane; who will exact a high standard of public morality as well as being a man from whom high standards can be expected in return
I find it very difficult to understand the language used by the Minister. I would think that a man in his position should be concerned with truth and honesty, with the good name of others as well as that of himself. When a particular letter was produced in the House I noticed there was more concern in finding out who the "Maggot" Durcan was than with the fact that the Minister wrote the letter. It is a very bad reflection on public representatives and Ministers that there should be more concern over who the "Maggot" Durcan was than over the fact that the Minister for Justice wrote this letter. I think this accounts for the lack of respect for politicians and for the general acceptance that there is corruption in public life. The Minister has said that he stands by every word of that letter. I think it is deplorable that a letter coming from the Minister for Justice should contain such phrases such as, "for obvious reasons you will destroy this letter". We are not expecting too high a standard from the Minister for Justice when we expect him to be concerned with justice. We do not expect him to have the patience of Job or the morals of an archbishop but we do expect him to be a man who will not concern himself with breaking the law.
Comment on this
I did not say there was any law breaking. I said that the Minister was concerning himself with the breaking of the law. I did not say that the Minister personally broke the law. Far be it for me to suggest that the Minister broke the law. I am commenting on the fact that the Minister has stood by a letter which to any normal person would seem to imply that the law was being broken.
Comment on this
The suggestion— may be I have read this letter wrongly, but from what I gather—was that a person should squat.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy aware that this woman went in with her cousin and she was with her cousin before she went to England? There was no question of squatting.
Comment on this
If what the Minister says is correct then thousands of people are fully justified in doing the same thing in the city of Dublin.
Comment on this
Is it wrong for somebody to go with a relative to try and get the transaction through?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy is not concerned with getting houses for people in distress; I am.
Comment on this
It would seem to me that by using the phrase, "for obvious reasons you will destroy this letter" the Minister was aware at the time that what he was suggesting to the person was illegal and immoral. The Minister's Department is responsible for historical documents; I think this is one of the most historical documents to come before the House.
Comment on this
If we condone such actions by the Minister, if we do not stand up here and protest violently against them, then we are throwing public representatives into disrepute. It is time for this House to cast a cold eye on the situation.
With regard to legal aid in non-criminal cases, Ireland is one of the signatories to the European Convention on Human Rights but Ireland had reservations on the actual clause. The article provides that if a person has insufficient means to pay for legal assistance he has a right to be given aid free when the interests of justice so require. Ireland was one of the few countries to enter a reservation on this article. We should at least have an extension of the existing scheme to ensure that no one is sent to prison without being legally represented. I should like the Minister to give us details of the number of persons convicted in the last year and sent to prison who did not have legal aid at their trial. It is important that the Minister should provide this figure. It is a dreadful indictment of us that we should have reservations on such an important matter as this. Nowadays there is greater need for the provision of free legal assistance in non-criminal cases. The aid provided in 1965 is provided in the case of murder; in other cases it is provided only in exceptional circumstances. We cannot pretend to be a progressive country so long as we withhold free legal assistance from the necessitous. I would ask the Minister to give serious consideration to this. It has been estimated that the cost would be some £200,000. By effecting economies surely it should be possible to provide legal assistance at a much lower cost? I mentioned one case last week in which a person was deprived of legal aid because she could not provide at least £50. Since then I have had a few more cases in which people have not been able to pursue civil cases because they did not have the necessary finance. This is not a question of one law for the rich and another for the poor; it is a question of one law for the rich and none for the poor.
Desertion of wives and children is one of the greatest social evils of our time. Last week I read that 800 families were reported last year to the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children and it was stated that this was merely the tip of the iceberg. It should be obvious to the Minister that such families stand in great need. It is all very well making maintenance orders but we must have the facilities to execute these orders on deserting fathers in Britain. This is an urgent priority and I ask the Minister to give very close attention to it.
Last year, I raised with the Minister the question of people committed to prison for non-payment of debt. The Minister said at that time that he wanted to make it clear that no one was committed to prison because he had not got the means. I wrote to the Minister subsequently about this because, on average, there are 150 persons committed to prison each year for non-payment of debt. This is a matter in relation to which I receive a great many inquiries, requests and representations asking me to appeal on behalf of these people. These people are denied legal aid. These are some of the unfortunates who cannot afford solicitors to defend them: unfortunate people, who, ignorant of the law, sign documents about which they know very little; they become involved in hire purchase transactions which they cannot afford to meet. The Minister said no one goes to prison because he cannot pay a debt. He said there must be an examination of a person's circumstances before he is committed to prison. I do not want to mention names but those closely involved in the execution of warrants have told me that the Minister's reply was bunkum, wrong, inaccurate and that he had no awareness of the facts. I would ask the Minister to look into these problems. We must ensure that those who cannot pay are not committed to prison because, when they are ultimately released, having served their sentences, the whole process of the law starts all over again. I raised this with a solicitor acting for a hire purchase company and I told him he served no purpose by having these people committed to prison and his answer was: "Oh, yes; when he is released we will start proceedings again and have him committed again". This process could be never-ending. It is important that the Minister should look into the matter and not just rest content with the bald statement that no one goes to prison because he cannot pay a debt.
The Minister said that he has no concern with new-fangled ideas about psychiatrists. He ridiculed the whole idea and he said when Freud and Jung disagreed, why should he bother. Surely he must be aware that those who commit crimes do so for various reasons or, perhaps, no reason at all? I had a case recently of a man who was sentenced to three years imprisonment for robbery. This man was utterly unaware of the gravity of his offence and, when I went to see him and suggested that he should seek legal aid, he was much more concerned about a trivial matter, a draught under a door and Dublin Corporation not providing a proper door, than he was about his impending trial and the risk he ran of being committed to prison. It was obvious to me there should have been a psychiatric report in his case. The act of armed robbery was so juvenile in concoction that it was obvious this man could not have been of sound mind when he committed the offence. His actions after being arrested would suggest to me the very same thing but still there was no psychiatric report on the case. The Minister has said that only when the courts ask for psychiatric reports or only when there is some obvious aberration is a psychiatric report sought. We have a Minister for Justice who should be concerned with the rehabilitation of criminals, with the fact that every effort must be made to restore them to society in order that they shall have their proper place in that society, saying "I do not go for that bunkum". That is exactly what he says if not in those words; he is not interested in these modern ideas. He says a prisoner goes into prison and that is it.
People were enlightened by a programme last week on television in regard to the lack of rehabilitation, lack of proper work-shop facilities in prison and the poor attempts being made to help prisoners. This is an indictment of the Minister who says: "Everything is fine in my Department and everything is going well." It is not good enough for a Minister to say this when we know there is something wrong in that system. I hope the Minister will extend facilities to other Deputies in our party and to myself who are anxious to visit the prisoners and see the conditions under which prisoners work and live. It is important for us as public representatives to see these conditions. I should like the Minister to apply himself a little more diligently to this problem which concerns so many people who find themselves in very serious difficulties.
Another point I want to raise before I conclude concerns probation officers for persons who have committed first offences. Are there adequate facilities? Are there enough probation officers to watch these cases and pay a little personal attention to them? Is the juvenile liaison officer scheme operating properly and have we sufficient personnel employed under this scheme to help matters?
I am very pleased that prisoners can be released on parole if their prison behaviour is exemplary. I had occasion to congratulate the Secretary of the Department because of what was done. The Secretary was very humane in acting for the Minister and he acted with great speed in having a man released because his wife was being hospitalised for a birth. We must be humane in matters like this and it was nice to see the Department act with speed.
In general, prisons and prisoners should concern us because our own people are involved. We should be concerned with this big social problem and I should like to see the Minister approach it with a determination to introduce the latest and most advanced methods in the rehabilitation of prisoners.
I should also like to see the question of road traffic offences dealt with so that the gardaí would be relieved of this aspect of their work. It imposes too much strain on them. If more traffic wardens were doing this work the gardaí could be relieved and thus enabled to perform the duties for which they joined the force. I should like to see this done because if more serious attempts are made to streamline the Garda Síochána we may reach a point where we will be able to cope with the vandalism about which the Minister agrees with me, especially in urban areas like Drimnagh and Bally. fermot. It is not sufficient that gardaí should be in patrol cars making fleeting trips through these areas. I do not believe one can detect or prevent vandalism in this way. You must have the man on duty there. The Minister will I think agree—if he makes inquiries he will accept it—that the number of complaints from these areas about vandalism is considerable. People are having distressing times with vandals. One boxing club recently built a club premises at tremendous expense and with the co-operation of the people of the area. The building was broken into and much of it destroyed. It is not sufficient for a police car to make one trip around the area at night because the vandals know when the police car is coming and when it has gone. There can be adequate protection for the public only if the police are on duty in the area. The number of gardaí mentioned by the Minister is inadequate to patrol this area and I would ask him specifically to consider increasing the number patrolling Drimnagh and Ballyfermot areas which need extra police protection.
These are the only matters on which I want to speak. I want again to ask the Minister to have an inquiry into the detention of the boy of 14½ to whom I referred. The father, whose word I must take, maintains that there has been confusion about the records of these twins. I would ask the Minister to be humane in this matter and again consider the detention of this boy.
Comment on this
I have been able to get to my feet at last after listening to at least 15 final points from Deputy Dr. O'Connell. It gives me a pain in the neck to hear people, particularly Opposition speakers, launching violent personal attacks on the Minister. It makes me think they have not studied their subject; that they simply have to vent all their frustration and hate on whoever is Minister.
I have heard various contributions about the probation and prison services, all made with great authority. The speakers usually conclude by saying that they would like to have an opportunity of visiting the various centres such as St. Patrick's or Mountjoy. All the research has been done in books. They have criticised various officers who are performing duties with a great sense of dedication in most instances, without having met these people or having any knowledge of what these people are up against. Listening to Deputy Bruton last week I realised that he has done a lot of homework but that he did it with books and did not actually go out and investigate the problem. For his education, if I may use the term, if he should read this debate, I should like to point out to him that when he criticised the probation officers and said he thought they should be of a higher educational standard, he had not met these people.
I know that the probation officers working in Dublin are very dedicated people, very sensitive to the lack of appreciation of the huge job they have to perform. They have a mammoth task to do when you consider that in Dublin, which has a population of 600,000 people, there are only five probation officers as against Belfast with a population of 400,000 and where there are 18 probation officers. The figure of 50 was quoted as a caseload for each probation officer, but in Dublin certain probation officers have as many as 300 cases, which is far in excess of the 160 mentioned by Deputy Bruton.
It is very difficult to get up here and criticise constructively when you have to listen to your Minister being attacked in the manner in which he has been attacked because one feels reluctant to add to criticism, although the criticism from his own side of the House is given with the best of intent and if only to assure him that his own public representatives are doing their homework. The question of the probation service is of particular interest to me because we have heard so much lately about young people and drugs. One of the causes of this drug problem is that many young Irish people who go to England get into trouble there and are sent back to this country. They may serve a short sentence in a Borstal institution in England but eventually they return here and very often they exert a bad influence on people here. This is why I take this whole question of the probation service so seriously. We must nip this in the bud and a first-class probation service is needed not only in Dublin but in our major cities such as Limerick and Cork. It is not enough to rely on voluntary organisations. We need full-time dedicated people in this work and if we have not got a sufficient number of those full-time people the probation officers will become so frustrated that they will eventually give up what they are doing and, as a consequence, the labour turnover in the service will be so high that at any given time we will not have people with any great experience to deal with the young offenders.
The Minister has stated in his Estimate speech that he has appointed an officer of his Department to examine the probation service. I hope the Minister will forgive me if I say that an officer of his Department is not the person to look at this. I may be incorrect in this assumption, but I feel if such an officer discovers great inadequacies in the service he may be fearful of offending his superior; he may be afraid of offending the Minister by drawing attention to the fact that there is something wrong within his Department. I am sorry to say this before I have seen this report, or even before the Minister has seen it, but I feel he will not get the true picture until someone is appointed from outside, maybe someone from across the water who has set up a probation service in some other place—it need not necessarily be England—but for an honest-to-goodness report the Minister will need to get someone from outside.
The problem of juvenile delinquency is growing and will continue to grow. Improvements cost money but it is going to cost much more money when these young offenders become hardened criminals. I understand from the Minister's speech that the crime detection rate has increased quite considerably. He states:
It is a cause for satisfaction and it is worth noting that the detection rate still continues at a high level, 61 per cent, which is above that achieved in any other country whose statistics we have studied.
I should like to know from which countries those statistics have been taken; are they bigger or smaller countries than Ireland? This country is so small that it is very difficult really for major crimes to go undetected—people notice strangers more easily in country areas—so that therefore it is only right that we should have a higher detection rate. We cannot take any great satisfaction from this fact because it is merely the geography of the country that allows this situation to exist.
There has been much talk about the various new attitudes being adopted towards those convicted of crimes. I do not know if anyone who, say, has had his house burgled has this particular feeling about those people, as one Deputy suggested, paying them trade union rates and stamping their cards. If a person embarks on a life of crime he should be prepared to take the consequences. There are, moreover, all sorts of crimes. This year, when my father was being buried, his younger brother discovered on his return from the funeral that his home had been broken into and burgled. This is a particularly mean type of crime and it is a particularly mean kind of person who does this. Some of these people look at the papers each day to see who is being buried so that they can rob the bereaved persons' homes. This type of crime is on the increase and I do not think we should go very soft on that kind of criminal.
A couple of years ago I visited St. Patrick's Institute and met the then governor, Mr. Kennedy, who may still be there, and I was impressed by the care they showed those in their charge. People say offenders should be taught to read and write—Deputy Bruton referred to that—but very often the sentences are not sufficiently long to teach those young people to read and write and the best one can do is to give the young person a trade in the shortest period possible. In actual fact, if we could have a situation where these people could voluntarily stay on to learn a trade, it might be helpful. There are, of course, bad children and there are good children.
I remember remarking to the governor that it was the parents of some of the children who should be in the institute and not the children themselves. The wardens in St. Patrick's Institute are most concerned for the welfare of the people in their charge and they would like to see a system coming in where there could be a follow-through by them. I sometimes think that no one has more knowledge about compassion than those prison warders. Some of these warders, in prisons like Mountjoy or in St. Patrick's Institution, should, if possible, be channelled into the after-prison services if they have a calling for that sort of work. I am convinced that the probation service needs serious attention. I think I have made my point on that.
I do not wish to appear to be one of those so-called authorities who sweep through every aspect of the work of the Department of Justice. No one, even Deputy Garret FitzGerald, can be an authority on every aspect of the Department's work—even a lawyer could not be such an authority. Sometimes we hear some of the most appalling statements—appallingly incorrect. I mean—by Deputies. For example, Deputy O'Connell referred to a person who does a term of imprisonment for not being able to pay hire purchase instalments and who, when he comes out, can be prosecuted again. What the Deputy did not say is that the prosecution is not for the same offence. A person might get the impression from what the Deputy said that someone could be gaoled over and over again for the same offence. That is not so. Sometimes it is not what one says but what is left unsaid which puts people in doubt.
Another subject, on which I have already spoken to the Minister, is the question of a house of ill repute, otherwise called a brothel, which exists in my constituency and which has caused considerable annoyance to people living in the neighbourhood. Bottle parties go on there continually and every time there is a ship in sailors go into this place. From reports I have, it sounds to me very much like the genuine article. I have been up to the local police about it, in the station at Rathmines. They know about it but there is not a thing they can do about it simply because they must catch somebody in the act. It appears to me that the only way they could do this would be if one of the gardaí volunteered to enter the building in disguise.
There is something wrong with the law if there is not some way around it. If there is not, some changes should be made in the law. It is a fact that young girls who have been reported as missing on "Garda Patrol" on television—girls of 14 years of age—have been found in this place. It is being run by a woman formerly known to the gardaí as having been working in the streets. She was thrown down the hold of a ship, sued the shipping company and got enough money to set her up in business.
It may be all right for us to appear to have a sense of humour about this but it has worn very thin with people living in the vicinity of this house who are afraid for their young children coming home late at night in case somebody in a drunken state might attack them. The sooner the Minister can change the law in order to be able to deal with that kind of situation the better.
I am delighted to hear that the report of the Conroy Commission will be issued shortly because the morale of the Garda is low mainly because they cannot properly perform their duties.
Last night I was driving home and a car driver behaved in the most offensive manner because I attempted to overtake him. First he accelerated and then stopped in front of me. I pulled off the road into a garage allowing him to get ahead of me. Within seconds I saw a garda on a patrol bike. People say the gardaí are never there when you want them. This man was. He engaged me in conversation in the course of which he said: "There is very little we can do about these people: motoring offences take two years to come to court."
If we are serious in our undertaking to solve the road safety problem and to punish the offending motorist, we must have the facilities to do so. The Minister should consider the setting up of special courts. I know there is one court in the city which deals specially with motoring offences but it does not appear to be enough because it takes two years to deal with some offences. I do not know if motorists know about this situation but it appears from the way they act as if some of them did. I should like to inquire what happens if the garda in the case has retired in the meantime, or if he has died, and is not there to prosecute the offender. The Minister knows better than I whether a garda who has retired can be called to give evidence or if it is true that in such circumstances there is no case against the offender. I hope something will be done there.
Dangerous driving is on the increase and I am afraid accidents occasionally occur because too many drivers tend to concentrate on other drivers only. Perhaps I am digressing but I may be allowed to do so because the month of December is a special one. I discovered I was a bad driver last week because while I was anticipating all the time the actions of other drivers, I did not sufficiently anticipate the action of pedestrians, and it is pedestrians mainly who get killed in road accidents—I think the figure is 41 per cent of the total. Therefore, instead of drivers concentrating entirely on anticipating what other drivers will do, they should always be careful to anticipate what pedestrians will do.
While on this subject, I suggest that gardaí would pay more attention to dangerous driving if they realised they had the courts behind them—if they appreciated that offences would not take two years to come to court. At the moment, gardaí say it is no good reporting a person for dangerous driving because it will be years before the case will come to court.
I wish to mention traffic wardens briefly. This will be a particularly busy month for them and I should like if a message could be handed down to them to concentrate more on cars exceeding the time limit of one hour in places where one-hour parking is permitted than on taking the easy way out and catching those cars which are illegally parked in places where no parking is permitted. I know these wardens have a difficult job but I should like to see them concentrating more on cars exceeding the parking time limit. I should like also to see towed away more cars parked in dangerous spots, an offence which is very prevalent nowadays.
Before I close I should be interested to hear from the Minister the arrangements in respect of the collecting of fines by hire-drive firms in respect of clients involved in parking offences. I am told the figure involved amounts to something in the region of £60 a day. I refer to on-the-spot fines. I suppose I had better be careful in case I should damage the tourist trade, but I am prompted to ask whether fines imposed while cars are being driven by tourists come back on the Irish people who hire out cars. In matters of parking, it is the person who owns the car, not the person who has been driving it, who is fined. Could some arrangements be made whereby the hiring firms would not be held responsible for fines for offences while cars are being driven by clients?
I do not want to sound pompous; I do not intend to be, but I wish Deputies would stop some of this clinical approach to the tasks which they set themselves. Instead of just learning it from a book, Deputies—particularly new Deputies—should go out and examine a particular problem. In that way, the debates would be far richer and the Minister's fund of knowledge would be greatly improved, since one could take it that when people stood up here they had a genuine sense of performing a public duty through having a genuine knowledge of what they are talking about. It is very important that when people in this House criticise a Department they should at least have researched the particular aspect they are dealing with.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe in his opening remarks stated that it gave him a pain in his neck when Opposition Deputies came in here and vented their frustration and their hate by attacking the Minister for Justice, whoever he may be.
Comment on this
As far as I am concerned the majority of Ministers for Justice, from Kevin O'Higgins down to the present man, did their duty according to their consciences. High standards are expected from any man who occupies this exalted position and if we believe he is not living up to the high standard expected of him as Minister for Justice, if we believe that there are low standards in high places, then it is our duty to speak and let our voices be heard. I will be referring to that later on in my speech.
The Minister in his opening remarks said that legislation to deal with the jurisdiction of the circuit court and the district court was to be introduced shortly. I believe that is long overdue. He further stated that he must deal with a particular project on a priority basis and having regard to what appeared to him to be practical considerations. It is over three years ago since many of us here mentioned drug abuse. On 3rd October, 1966, I was told by the then Minister for Justice that legislation was to be introduced immediately to deal with this menace. We know this is a menace. We know this is a menace that affects ordinary human beings. We had at another time the threat of foot and mouth disease in our country. All the resources of this State were brought to bear on that. We congratulated the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the people concerned for the wonderful work they did at that time. In this case we are dealing with young boys and girls, our own kith and kin, brothers, sisters, relations, and I believe that the Department of Justice have been very remiss in this. Now, three years later, we are getting the legislation that should have been introduced in 1966. When I spoke about it in this House the Minister for Justice at that time, Deputy B. Lenihan, pooh-poohed the idea that we were faced with a problem. Unfortunately, we now know only too well that we have that problem. We know that over 80 raids have been carried out on dispensaries in this city alone during the last year. We know that drugs have been freely peddled in clubs and in schools. Even though it is better late than never, I still claim that the Department should have given this top priority and dealt with it three years ago.
We have also been promised legislation with regard to deserted wives. I should like to know what is the present position, when a man goes over to England and deserts his wife, about bringing him back. Those of us who are members of county councils know that ratepayers are paying very large sums at present in every county to help these unfortunate wives and children to exist. The State should try to bring the law up-to-date so that the husband can be brought back to honour his responsibilities in that regard. We have had repeated assurances that legislation would be introduced to provide more adequate maintenance for deserted wives and children over the last seven or eight years but very little has been done.
Three years ago we were promised legislation to deal with the carrying of flick knives. This is a serious problem. It should get top priority but nothing has been done in the last three years. Those of us who have been in this House over the last four years know that over a year and a half of Ministers' time, the Government's time, the country's time, the taxpayers' time, was used discussing and pushing through this House a Marts Bill and a referendum. I believe the time of this House and the State would have been much better used if we were bringing our existing legislation up-to-date. Indeed the Minister seems to react in the same manner as Lord Melbourne who once used the famous words, speaking of putting things on the long finger: "Ponder, pause, prepare, postpone and end by leaving things alone. In fact earn the people's pay by doing nothing every day". That is what the present Minister for Justice seems to be doing.
The Minister in his speech dealt with the question of bail. I happen to agree with him on this although some members of my party may not. He pointed out that 214 persons granted bail by the courts committed, while they were awaiting trial, over 900 fresh offences against property. That is a well-known fact. I spoke here of a particular man who stabbed a member of the Garda Síochána. He was sentenced to a year by the district justice, appealed against that and while he was out on bail he killed two other people. Those facts are known to the Minister and to the Department of Justice. I do not want to give his name. He has been sentenced recently for that crime. It is a well-known fact that there are bank robbers in this country. They dine very often in some of the biggest hotels here in the city. They are out on bail and on the day on which they were being allowed out on bail they told the Garda Síochána that they would commit eight other crimes between then and the day they were tried and that they would only get the same sentence. According to reliable information they have at least six crimes committed and still have not been apprehended. That is well known to the Garda authorities. I certainly think that if something cannot be done about allowing those people out on bail then extra justices or judges should be appointed. As Deputy Briscoe has said, people have to wait two years Cases, especially of a criminal nature, should be tried inside a month or six weeks or a maximum of two months, certainly as soon as the Garda authorities have got their file complete and while the trail is hot. It is wrong that many of those cases should be put on the long finger for as long as two years I hope something is done in that direction immediately.
The Minister spoke about the Adoption Board. Wonderful work has been done and we would all join in commending the Minister and the members of the Adoption Board for work well done, for bringing happiness to many homes. It is up to everybody to encourage this and do everything they possibly can to see that it is expanded.
The Minister also mentioned the closing of country barracks and the review being held. I do not agree with the Minister on this. It is a retrograde step to close many of those country barracks. The Minister claims that because of the peace in the countryside gardaí are not so urgently required and can be moved into cities and towns. The countryside is peaceful because the police force are in those areas. There is much more co-operation between the people and the police in country areas than there is in cities and towns. They have their fingers on the pulse of things. When a robbery takes place they are quickly at the scene. I appeal to the Minister not to close any more barracks. Rural Ireland is dying. When a village loses its barracks and perhaps its school there may be nothing left but a few public-houses. Apart from these reasons, it is desirable that gardaí be left in the rural villages so that they can help to prevent crime over a wide locality. In cases of accidents, too, the nearest town may be 15 to 20 miles away while the local Garda barracks might be only two or three miles away.
The Minister spoke also about the number of indictable crimes. I am aware that the detection rate is at a high level but 40 out of every 100 lawbreakers are getting away free. Recently there have been five or six bank robberies for which no arrests have been made. This is causing uneasiness throughout the country. I came from Mullingar on three occasions within the last few months after bank robberies had taken place and at every crossroads from Mullingar to Dublin there was a garda on duty. I do not know what one individual garda could do by standing at a crossroads. Was it expected that the bank robbers would drop the money beside him? Other Deputies told me that they saw gardaí on duty at other crossroads. Certainly, they should be out in the squad cars endeavouring to track down culprits especially in the immediate area but I do not know how one garda standing at a crossroads could be of any help.
Reference was also made to St. Patrick's Institution and to people who are sent to prison. As far as rehabilitation of prisoners is concerned, we should try to make useful citizens of them but they should not be pampered. Lawbreakers should be penalised, not pampered. In their rehabilitation they could, possibly, be given the opportunity of acquiring a trade if their term in prison were long enough to permit that and this would be useful particularly in the case of young people so that, on discharge they would be better members of society.
The Minister has promised legislation with regard to the Land Registry that will bring it up to an efficient standard. There have been many complaints about the long delays experienced in dealing with that body and we hope that the Minister will be successful in his endeavours so that cases can be dealt with more efficiently and with less delay.
Somebody has mentioned traffic wardens. I thought that these people were supposed to assist strangers in directing them in traffic and in any way possible but I now find that instead of being a social asset they are operating punitive measures against the public and that the greater part of their time is spent in putting stickers on cars. I would agree with Deputy Briscoe in his suggestion that they might spend more time tracking down offenders who might, perhaps, park in a one-hour zone for two or three hours.
Another matter which I mentioned last year, and which I shall not dwell on at length, is the question of the gardaí in squad cars badgering lorry-owners for illegal trafficking. Many of those people are labouring men or small farmers who are struggling to make a living and who, when they got a few pounds together through hard work, industry and initiative, purchased a lorry but when they proceed to transport a neighbour's cattle, they find that it is illegal to do so. We have been promised legislation to ease that situation but in the meantime I would appeal to the gardaí in squad cars to be as easy as possible on those people because there is a vast difference between a criminal who goes out to plunder his neighbour's goods and a hard-working man who may have a wife and family to support and who works, possibly 13 or 16 hours a day to make a living. It would be better for the gardaí if they tried to catch the bank robbers or other criminals than to spend their time arresting those unfortunate people.
I dealt earlier with the question of the number of blackguards in this city who carry flick-knives. Somebody else has made the point that there are not enough gardaí in the city to deal with the situation. We can say that there is under-staffing of the Garda in the city. We can also say that, nationally, the gardaí are underpaid. They should be protected. I know that we cannot discuss the judiciary but I would mention that our district justices seem to be too lenient with some of the blackguards brought before them by the gardaí, particularly in the city of Dublin.
There was a case recently where a garda was stabbed but the offender got away under the first offender's Act. Recently also, a student at a procession held here called a garda "an RUC ‘B'". He was arrested and brought to court but he got away with a warning. In a case of the stabbing of a garda, the very minimum penalty should be two or three years in Mountjoy.
The time has come when a statement should be made in this House to the effect that when a garda carries out his duties, he should be backed by his sergeant, by his superintendent and superiors, including the Minister. Nobody should have the authority to say to a member of the Garda Síochána who is conscientiously doing his duty that if he does not close his eyes to a particular thing, such as a publichouse remaining open half the night, he will be transferred to some remote part of the country. Unfortunately, that is happening in this country today and it is well known that in certain cases TDs and Senators can threaten gardaí. That is a deplorable situation and one which must not be allowed to continue. I gave examples last year of cases of young members leaving the force because of the amount of interference which they experienced in the operation of their duty.
The bankruptcy laws are completely outdated and need to be revised. As they are at the present time people can, it seems deliberately, buy cattle at sales marts and go bankrupt afterwards and it is a well-known fact they may have £40,000, £50,000, £60,000, £100,000, or more salted away in the wife's name or somebody else's name. It is a well-known fact that over the last ten years hundreds of people have gone bankrupt in this country and have ruined unfortunate families but they have been able to set up in business in less than a year with money which they had salted away. The bankruptcy laws should be brought up-to-date so that people who commit such offences will not get away with them.
As regards Garda programmes on television and the part they play in the detection and prevention of crime, everybody concerned is to be congratulated. Anything which gets the people to co-operate with the gardaí is commendable. The gardaí are our own kith and kin and they are there to protect our lives and our property. Unfortunately in this country, probably due to the fact that we had British Government for over 700 years, at one time people were not inclined to co-operate with the authorities. That attitude may have been understandable when the British were in control in this country but now that we have our own Government such an attitude is unjustifiable. Therefore, it is the duty of everyone in this House to appeal to the people to co-operate and participate in any way possible in the detection of crime and to bear in mind that if they do give information to a garda they are not, and should not be styled, informers.
People who co-operate with the gardaí are public-spirited citizens doing their duty. Unfortunately, in the city people do not come to the help of a garda who is in trouble. There was an example of this last year in a case where a garda had two or three men with knives cornered in an area. A crowd of two or three hundred people gathered and when the garda called for assistance there was not one public-spirited person in that whole assembly to come to his aid. They shouted to the men who were cornered to escape. They helped them to escape and they obstructed the garda in the execution of his duty. That was deplorable. The justice commented on it at the trial. Each of us should appeal to the people to co-operate with the gardaí and should remind them they are not informers when they help our own police force.
I should like to deal briefly with the carnage on our roads. We are sitting here on 9th December, 1969, and before this day 12 months at least 500 persons who are in their health and prime today will be done to death on the roads of Ireland. It is generally accepted that if there were more care, courtesy and consideration on our roads it might help to reduce accidents. The number of fatal road accidents is something which should shake everyone of us out of his complacency. Drunken drivers should be put off the road. I am not against people who drink but they should not be allowed to drive cars. The breathalyser test has been introduced but a great mistake has been made in regard to it. There was a build up about the date the breathalyser test was to be introduced. People who are fond of drink made arrangements that their wives or somebody else would drive them when they wanted to drink. Now, a month later there has been only one case in Cork and one in Dublin of the use of a breathalyser. We had got people to the point where they were going to co-operate with the gardaí but now we find that there is not a breathalyser in every Garda station. It would have helped greatly if car drivers knew they would be pulled in immediately if they had taken too much drink.
It is now rumoured that people are lapsing into their old habits. We should immediately instal breathalyser testing equipment in every Garda barracks so that drunkards will know that they have to comply with the law. The law states that a person who has consumed a certain amount of alcohol may not drive. A number of fatal accidents are caused by excessive drinking. The Minister should insist on the full operation of the law in this respect with a view to reducing the number of deaths on the road.
I am not sure if we are entitled to refer to the appointment of justices, although a Deputy has already referred to that matter. However, I think that the 44 per cent of the electorate who support this party should be aware of the facts.
Comment on this
I want to say that I believe every section should be entitled to a fair number of appointments.
Comment on this
Nobody on this side of the House will be made a judge so long as the party over there are in power.
It is only right to pay tribute to the Garda Síochána for the work they have carried out since the foundation of the State in the detection of crime and the protection of the lives and property of the people. The pay and living conditions of gardaí should be as attractive as the State can possibly provide. At present, the Garda Síochána are understaffed and underpaid. Unfortunately, unrest exists in the Garda Síochána. The reason for the unrest and agitation is the political interference at all levels by politicians and others who try to influence the gardaí in the execution of their duty. Many gardaí cannot do their duty according to their pledge and they are upset. As I said earlier, the Minister should make a statement that political interference with gardaí in the execution of their duty should cease.
As far as we on this side of the House are concerned, since the foundation of the State we have always believed in law and order. We believe in the proper enforcement of the laws but we believe in justice tempered with mercy. Unfortunately, at present the Government in certain aspects are conniving in the drift towards anarchy. No organisation should be allowed to take the law into its own hands.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy deny that in Mullingar four people took out revolvers and fired live ammunition? These people had their photographs in the newspaper, appeared on television and are well known but the Government, because of the "Blaneyites", the Republicans and the revolutionaries on one side, and other elements of our people on the other side, are afraid that they will lose a single vote and are conniving in this drift towards anarchy. They will not arrest them because if they did Deputy Blaney would kick over the traces and Deputy Boland would again resign as a Minister and go to the Park in a uniform and ask for permission from the President to go to the north.
Comment on this
I will take one of the Deputy's allegations at a time. I could not look into all his allegations.
Comment on this
It is a well-known fact that the Government know the people who have burned down some of the big places in County Meath but they think that politically it would not be a good idea to arrest them and charge them because they would lose votes. If that is not conniving in the drift towards anarchy I do not know what it is.
Comment on this
I never encouraged the NFA to break the law. My statements were made at meetings of the Westmeath County Council and the Westmeath County Committee of Agriculture and I appealed to the farmers as owners of property not to break the law and not to be concerned in any drift towards anarchy because if they did they had more to lose than anybody else. My statements at that time are on record.
Comment on this
I should like to deal with the outmoded discipline by which gardaí are being harassed and badly treated. Some of their rules and regulations have no place in any police force. These conditions must be changed and the change must come without any further messing and without the red tape which has caused so much harm. The demands of the gardaí seem to be just and fair and therefore they cannot be ignored any longer. The gardaí deserve a much better deal if we are to attract young men to the force and hold on to the well-trained men we have at present because the gardaí are serving this nation well and doing a good job. They deserve our full support. If necessary new regulations should be negotiated by the authorities and the Garda Representative Body. Certainly we want different conditions because we should have a happy and contented force.
Recently I was speaking to a young garda and he admitted that there was dissatisfaction at present. The average garda works 15 or 16 hours a day because even if he is at a football match or a dance or even if he is off duty if he sees a person breaking the law he has to apprehend him. As long as the force is happy and content the members will give a full service to the State; they are giving it at present but the danger is that if the regulations are not brought up-to-date we may not have their co-operation in the future. The Minister cannot afford to ignore the complaints which are being voiced by members of the Garda Síochána and indeed he will have to take proper action if we are to avoid a dispute which perhaps could close the doors of every Garda barracks. The Minister and the Government are aware of the growing unrest within the force. It is not something new and the complaints have been aired on a national basis by the Garda Representative Body and on several occasions in recent years by the newspapers. Some moves have been made in this regard. A commission was set up and we were told today that the Minister may have a report from them by Christmas. This question should be dealt with with all possible speed. The gardaí have become tired of outworn promises.
We hear much talk about justice and many people are disturbed about what is supposed to be justice. There is a grave suspicion that there are two laws, one for the rich and those connected with the Fianna Fáil Party, Taca and other such organisations and another law for the poor. Unfortunately, many of us can point to actual cases in which prosecutions were stopped in court and this seems to lend credence to these suspicions. It is hard to blame people if evidence is produced that confirms these suspicions.
Comment on this
The question of prosecutions in court and the withdrawal of prosecutions in court and court proceedings generally are matters for the Office of the Attorney General.
Comment on this
I am not blaming the Attorney General for anything so far. There are many devious ways of doing this about which the Attorney General knows nothing.
Comment on this
It is not the Attorney General who is to blame very often for things that happen in court. I know of a case where a man was charged and I was approached at the time as a Member of the Opposition. The people were told: "If L'Estrange asks the Minister for Justice then Fine Gael cannot criticise it". Things can be very well planned. Nobody could stop the case and it went to court. The only way it could be stopped—and here, unfortunately, there was connivance with the police force—was that the witness who was to identify the body was not called until the prosecution case was closed. The moment the prosecution case closed the counsel for the accused said "On a point of law, your Honour, the police called nobody to identify the body" and the judge said "That is right; case dismissed" and the man got out, scot free. The Attorney General knew nothing about that. It is the political connivance that goes on which is doing so much harm to undermine the people's belief in law and order and which gives credence to the belief we have that there is one law for the poor and another for the rich and the people with political influence.
There are numerous other cases which I could go into but which I will not go into. We know about the housing scandal case in Cork. I want to put this on the record because the people concerned told me. The first person they approached was the present Taoiseach: he was not Taoiseach at that time. They gave him full information of what was going on in Cork. They met him week-end after week-end and he would tell them that it was very difficult but he was doing his best to see what could be done. It was not until the late Deputy Seán Casey and former Deputy Stephen Barrett were given the facts——
Comment on this
It certainly relates to the Minister for Justice and to justice in this country. When the late Deputy Casey and former Deputy Stephen Barrett raised the matter in this House the Taoiseach said that, as far as he was concerned, the full rigours of the law would apply and the people concerned would be brought to justice. On this Estimate, I cannot criticise what happened in the court——
Comment on this
Deputy O'Kennedy is quite right. Deputy O'Kennedy has put his finger on it. The man did all of these things. He was given an opportunity to repair the houses. He has got off scot free.
Comment on this
The Deputy now is criticising the decision of the court which, he has been told, is not in order.
Comment on this
The reason he got off, he was told, was because he had suffered enough. Less than a week later, he paid £50,000 for the County Hotel in Cork and, to date, he has not served one single day in prison. If that is justice and if that is the type of Fianna Fáil justice, I am surprised that Deputy O'Kennedy, whom I have always looked upon as an upright young man, would stand for it.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach promised us in this House that the full rigour of the law would apply.
Comment on this
There were another 209 cases in Cork but, because Fianna Fáil people were concerned——
Comment on this
Again, the Deputy is going back to deal with court cases. The Chair has already asked him to desist from criticising judicial decisions.
Comment on this
I raised a case here last year and it was in order then: it was discussed here at length. The reference number is 1967. No. 94 OP.: Kelly, N. T., Donegal man v Dundrum Enterprises. Mr. Kelly said he was a mutual friend of the Minister for Local Government and that he could get planning permission for a certain consideration. The amount agreed on was £3,000. Five hundred pounds was paid and post-dated cheques were given for the remainder —post-dated cheques for £1,000, £1,000 and £500.
Comment on this
No, Sir, I am not discussing the case that was in the court. No action was taken in relation to this corrupt practice. Last year, when this matter was debated here for half an hour neither the Ceann Comhairle nor the Leas-Cheann Comhairle intervened, with all due respects. This was in January, 1966: the post-dated cheques were dated for March, 1966. The defendant got his planning permission through the intercession of Mr. Kelly but we know that gratitude can be a heavy burden: the post-dated cheques were stopped. The case was settled before it came to court. Why did the Minister for Justice not set up a judicial inquiry into this matter? They did not bring the case into court because, fortunately or unfortunately, I mentioned it in this House the day before and, the following day, there were photographers and press people from all over the country in the court. A settlement was made. I want to draw attention to the fact that this could happen. The evidence is there. The Minister could have set up a judicial inquiry and got the full facts. He did not.
Comment on this
The amount agreed on was £3,000. Five hundred pounds was paid and post-dated cheques were given for the remainder—post-dated cheques for £1,000, £1,000 and £500. This was in January, 1966, and the post-dated cheques were dated for March, 1966. The defendant got his planning permission through the intercession of Mr. Kelly but the post-dated cheques were stopped. Mr. Kelly sued for £2,500, representing the stopped cheques. The court case was to be held on Thursday, 7th March, 1968. The first defence entered was a denial that planning permission had been obtained through the good offices of Mr. Kelly or that the site had been sold at an enhanced price.
Comment on this
I am not dealing with anything the Attorney General had to do with. I was told it was ruled out where the Attorney General comes into the case. He had not come into the case up to this. I claim he should have come in afterwards. He should have had those papers confiscated that evening. Action should have been taken immediately——
Comment on this
The Deputy will have an opportunity to raise the matter, if he wishes, on the Estimate for the Office of the Attorney General.
Comment on this
No, it was stopped before they went into the court. A settlement was made. Mr. Kelly said he had got planning permission for the plaintiff. The Minister could have set up a judicial inquiry and got the full facts as regards those cheques and he did not do so. Now, the Minister for Justice is paid by the taxpayers of this country.
Comment on this
The reference number of the case has already been given. The Government knew that, if they got the full information at that time, too much dirty linen would be washed in public. The Minister for Justice is paid by the taxpayers of the country. When that case was raised here, he called on the Bar Council to hold an inquiry into it. I want to refer now to the Irish Times of 18th February, 1969, where there is a report headed Bar Council Asks for Apology. Minister's Dáil Charge. Then we read:
The General Council of the Bar of Ireland has found that accusations made in the Dáil by the Minister for Justice, Mr. Ó Moráin, against a member of the Bar were entirely unfounded and unjustified. The Council suggests that Mr. Ó Moráin should publicly withdraw his statement and apologise.
He did not do that. The Minister would not apologise. The report continues:
The following statement was issued by the Bar Council yesterday:
On Tuesday, 10th December, 1968, in Dáil Éireann, during the debates on the Estimate for the Office of the Minister for Justice, the Minister for Justice, Mr. Ó Moráin, made certain allegations concerning Mr. Garrett Cooney, a member of the Bar. As a result of those statements, the General Council of the Bar of Ireland wrote the following letter to the Minister:
The General Council of
the Bar of Ireland,
Law Library,
Four Courts,
Dublin 7,
79684,
13th December, 1968.
The letter is addressed to:
Micheál Ó Moráin, Esq., TD.,
Minister for Justice,
72, St. Stephen's Green,
Dublin, 2:
Dear Minister,
In the unrevised Official Report of Dáil Éireann Debates, for Tuesday, 10th December, 1968, Volume 237/13, on the Committee on Finance's consideration of the Estimate for the Office of the Minister for Justice, you are reported at several places between Columns 2284 and 2288, and again in column 2312, as having said that Mr. Garrett Cooney, Barrister-at-Law, had handed over his Brief in a High Court action to Mr. L'Estrange, TD.
These averments constitute a grave reflection on Mr. Cooney in his professional capacity, and would, if true, subject Mr. Cooney to severe penalties by his professional disciplinary body. This Council, therefore, requests you to supply it with whatever information you may have on these matters in order that it may carry out a thorough investigation.
Yours faithfully,
(Sgd.) G. D. COYLE,
Secretary.
No reply to that letter was received, and, therefore the Bar Council wrote the following letter on 8th January, 1969.
This is a public servant. This is the man who accused Deputy O'Higgins of not being in his seat here at 10.30 a.m. He is a public servant who is paid £8,500 of the taxpayers' money. He had not the courtesy to reply to the letter he received from the Bar Council of Ireland.
The report goes on:
The General Council of
the Bar of Ireland,
Law Library,
Four Courts,
Dublin, 7.
79684.
January 8th, 1969.
Micheál Ó Moráin, Esq., T. D.,
Minister for Justice,
Department of Justice,
72 St. Stephen's Green,
Dublin, 2.
Dear Mr. Ó Moráin,
I am directed to say that the Bar Council has received no reply to its letter to you of December 13th, 1968.
The Council regards the matter as urgent, and proposes to deal with it at its meeting on Friday, January 31st, 1969.
The Council would therefore be grateful if you could reply to its letter as soon as possible.
Yours faithfully,
(Sgd.) G. D. COYLE,
Secretary.
On January 13th, 1969, the following letter was received by the Council:—
Oifig an Aire Dlí agus Cirt
(Office of the Minister for Justice)
Baile Átha Cliath
(Dublin)
10th January, 1969.
15/69
Dear Mr. Coyle,
I am directed by Mr. Ó Moráin, T. D., Minister for Justice, to acknowledge receipt of yours of the 8th instant which will be brought to the Minister's attention as soon as possible.
Yours sincerely,
(Sgd.) LIAM DALY,
Private Secretary.
G. D. Coyle Esq.,
Secretary,
The General Council of the Bar of Ireland,
Law Library,
Four Courts,
Dublin 7.
No other communication from the Minister on this matter has been received by the Council. The Council met on Friday 31st January, 1969 to consider the results of its investigations and to make any consequential findings:—
FINDINGS.
"The Bar Council finds:—
"That each of the statements by the Minister for Justice, Mr. Ó Moráin, to the effect that Mr. Garrett Cooney had handed over his brief or a copy of it, in the action referred to in the Debate, to Mr. L'Estrange, T.D., is untrue.
"That each of the statements by Mr. Ó Moráin to the effect that Mr. Cooney gave information to Mr. L'Estrange about the proceedings in the said action is untrue.
"That in so far as Mr. Ó Moráin's statement: ‘You and your friend Cooney seemed to have made money', suggests that Mr. Cooney made money other than his proper professional fees, it is untrue.
"That Mr. Ó Moráin's statement: ‘He is Cooney, the same as Locke's Distillery', is untrue.
"The Council therefore finds that none of Mr. Ó Moráin's references to Mr. Cooney was justified: that there is no foundation for any criticism of Mr. Cooney's conduct in this matter and that his professional integrity is fully vindicated."
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
The report continues:
"The entire of the foregoing statement was sent to Mr. Ó Moráin on the 3rd February, 1969.
"The Minister had invited the investigation by the Bar Council when in the same Debate he said, referring to Mr. Cooney:—It is the duty of the Bar Council to deal with it and if they do he will deserve all he gets. The Council would in any event, of its own accord, have investigated the matter, as the Minister's charges, if true, would have involved a grave reflection on the professional conduct of a barrister.
"The Council, with the statement, sent the following letter to Mr. Ó Moráin on the 3rd February:——"
Comment on this
The letter is as follows:
The General Council of
the Bar of Ireland
Law Library,
Four Courts,
Dublin 7.
79684.
3rd February, 1969.
Micheál Ó Moráin, Esq., T.D.,
Minister for Justice,
Department of Justice,
72 St. Stephen's Green,
Dublin 2.
Dear Mr. Ó Moráin,
I enclose the finding of the Bar Council in the matter of Mr. Garrett Cooney, Barrister at Law, concerning which letters were sent to you on the 13th December, 1968 and the 8th January, 1969.
The Bar Council is of opinion that you ought to withdraw your statements publicly and apologise to Mr. Cooney.
The Council will meet on Friday, 14th February, 1969 at 3.30 p.m. to consider your reply.—Yours faithfully,
(Sgd.)G.D. Coyle,
Secretary.
"No reply has been received from the Minister."
Is he a fit man to represent this council?
Comment on this
No sane man would reply to a dose of tripe like that.
Comment on this
Those charges were made by a Minister against a barrister. The Bar Council wrote to him on two occasions. He acknowledged one letter but refused to reply. He has neither apologised nor replied. He was proved to be completely wrong in the five or six charges he made here in this House.
Comment on this
Give them to Deputy O'Higgins and he will deal with them. You are not a barrister.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins is well able to deal with his own cases and I will deal with mine in my way.
Comment on this
Deputies should avoid cross references across the House and carry on with the debate.
Comment on this
I want to deal now with another matter which was claimed to be Fianna Fáil skulduggery in the Taoiseach's own constituency. I have a letter here which states:
It is very interesting, but very aggravating for a person who is fined without compunction for a minor traffic parking offence——
A person could be fined £5, £6 or £10 for having a bald tyre——
——in the same court to note how the "Dear old Pals" act works.
The lucky escapee on this occasion happens to be the local City State Counsel for Prosecutions. His only offence happened to be that he crashed into a man's car parked outside his own door after midnight and was found to be so incoherent by the car-owner that the Guards were called and the culprit was arrested and charged. After several adjournments by the Defence the strings were eventually pulled.
As reported in the Cork Examiner, 23rd October, 1969, other people were heavily fined for minor offences but the charge against this man was withdrawn at the last minute without any reason being given.
I should also like to deal with what I claim to be further interference with the police in the exercise of their duty. The gardaí have a hard task at times collecting information, catching criminals and prosecuting them. I should like to quote a statement from the Limerick Leader of 28th June, 1969:
The judge said that there was a careful plan, a concerted scheme, to steal public property destined to feed one of the most helpless sections of the community.
Further in the course of his statement the judge said that it seemed to him there was a double standard of ethics in the minds of many people where public funds, where insurance companies, were concerned. He also praised the guards for detecting the crime and said the people of Limerick were indebted to the gardaí but for whose intervention the campaign might have been continued up to the present day. The judge then said, and this is what I want to refer to:
He had not been told how much was involved but he was quite satisfied that the defendants' estimate of £800 was the lowest figure.
I want to charge that there was blatant interference with the Garda authorities in pursuing and trying to prosecute these individuals. I want to put this to the Minister for Justice, that the police had information on their files that in this case at least £10,000 worth of meat was stolen over two years. That information was not divulged to the court due to political pressure. While the superintendent was doing his duty he was informed by politicians that if he pressed this case to its final conclusion he would not get the promotion he was due. He was torn between loyalty to the pledge he had made and fear of politicians, and this information was not given. In Limerick at the present time people say that it is not £10,000 worth of meat that was stolen over the years but anything from £50,000 to £100,000 worth. This mental hospital has an excellent RMS but he must rely on his officials, on his secretary, on his storekeeper and on his steward to see that the hospital is run efficiently and honestly.
On the date that the gardaí went to the mental hospital and asked what amount of meat had been weighed in, they were told 600 lbs., but when the gardaí checked there was only 300 lbs. there, and, as was stated, the best quality meat, centre loins, fillets, hindquarters of beef, et cetera, was stolen from the hospital and on that particular day there was nothing there but inferior hocks, shins, brisket, neck beef and bad mutton.
This political influence in court cases should end. There was bound to have been connivance with somebody in that mental hospital for five, six or ten years. Those people should have been brought to justice but they have been protected and are being protected today by politicians in Limerick, because some of these people are members of the Fianna Fáil Party. That is wrong, and it is wrong that a judge should have to say in court that he has not been told the amount involved. It is doubly wrong when the superintendent prosecuting has on his file that the gardaí have information that in the last two years £10,000 worth of meat at least was stolen and that that is not disclosed to the judge.
Comment on this
I do not know. As far as I am concerned, there should be justice whether it is Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or anybody else that is involved. I do not know about any Fine Gael person being involved, but I do know about the tampering with justice and the fact that the superintendent was not allowed to give the full information. Furthermore, the case was to come on before the general election.
Comment on this
The police had it on their files that £10,000 worth was stolen in the last two years.
Comment on this
I know full well what I am talking about. I have quoted from the Limerick Leader and the Deputy can read all about it in that paper. Those people were charged only with stealing £800 worth, what was in the deep freeze the evening the gardaí moved in. The gardaí had information there was £10,000 worth stolen——
Comment on this
I know it, as there are other things I knew and nobody will ever find out where I got the information. As I have said, the gardaí were told there was 600 lbs. of meat there but when they checked there was only 300 lbs. there. Nobody in the hospital was prosecuted.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean the row between the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the Taoiseach?
Comment on this
There is no use in preaching a policy to this House that we stand for a federation when we have a Minister going to shoot his way in and take over the border himself by force.
Comment on this
I mentioned in this House last week another case of a man who got away with what I believe was murder, who mowed down a child of seven years of age. Since that, a man who is paid a great deal of money by the Department of Justice, a Mr. Anthony Hederman, Senior Counsel, Treasurer of the Fianna Fáil Party——
Comment on this
Is it in order that a name should be mentioned in these circumstances? There are very serious charges made against this individual by Deputy L'Estrange.
Comment on this
Surely this is against all the traditions of what is good in Irish politics? I appeal to you, a Cheann Comhairle, to give a ruling in this matter.
Comment on this
It is not in order to mention the names of people outside this House. It is an abuse of the privilege of this House because these people are unable to reply.
Comment on this
It was stated in the Irish Press on 2nd December, 1969, that this man, when defending a case in Dublin, took it upon himself to attack me for daring to raise this question in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I am embarrassing no one. The same law should apply to everyone. I do not think a man who mows down a seven-year-old girl and does not stop to report the accident should get two £2 fines. I believe justice should be tempered with mercy but not that type of justice.
Comment on this
I am not dealing with two separate cases. The man who knocked down that little girl should have called a priest and a doctor but instead he went on and yet he was only given two £2 fines; whereas a poor unfortunate truck driver or an agricultural worker with a bald tyre would have been fined £6. If that is justice I do not understand it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is attacking the independent judiciary which we are proud to have in this country.
Comment on this
I have attacked the political interference which has been used to prevent doing their duty members of the Garda Síochána who have taken a pledge to do their duty according to their conscience in our courts, and I will continue to attack that. I believe in justice tempered with mercy. I do not believe in what is going on today, where if you are well enough off, you can buy yourself out of murder in this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy has attacked the judiciary for their decisions in cases they have tried. He has been attacking them for the last half-hour and I feel if he has nothing else to contribute he should sit down and let somebody else speak in honesty on this Estimate.
Comment on this
The Chair knows its duty and if I had attacked the judiciary it would have ruled me out of order, but I have made no attack on the judiciary. I have attacked the political influence and the political interference with people trying to do their duty, who are told to go easy on so-and-so if they want to get promotion.
In the Limerick case I have said that the judge stated he knew the full facts were not being given. I am praising the judge for being man enough to say that he knew what was going on. My point is that I will not stand for this kind of justice. Neither will I stand for Mr. Tony Hederman, Senior Counsel, attacking me in the courts. I have the statistics of what he was paid for being Secretary to Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
That has nothing to do with the case. The Deputy is out of order in referring to people outside this House because they have no way of replying. The Deputy is abusing the privileges of Parliament.
Comment on this
If judges had the same respect for the courts as the Deputy has for this House we would be in a fine position.
Comment on this
The gentleman I have been talking about was paid £14,795 of the taxpayers' money in the last three years. He does not want to see anyone rocking the boat.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister for Justice on the 19th February, 1969, what these people were paid. In the year 1966-67 the sum was £3,600; in 1967-68 the sum was £4,046; and in 1968-69 the sum was £7,149 making a grand total of £14,795. I do not think it is right for this gentleman to reprimand me. It is all the more interesting to see from that list that over 95 per cent of that money is paid to members of the Fianna Fáil Party and only five per cent is paid to barristers or counsel who support the Opposition.
Comment on this
If the Deputy thinks I am wrong he can correct me. On this list after the person's name and his party, if he is a Fine Gael man, I see the sums of £5 and £35 but in the case of Fianna Fáil men I see sums of £2,335 and £2,005.
Comment on this
I was accused in this House of encouraging the farmers to break the law and I repudiated that. The fact of the matter is that as far as the Government were concerned they broke the law, if anybody broke the law, because we had selective justice for the farmers of this country. The farmers were not allowed to march and when they paraded outside Leinster House they were taken to Mountjoy. I should like to know if that was justice. If it was justice, then I would ask why the Tenants' Association a month later, when they paraded outside, were met by Deputy Boland along with RTE reporters and the news reporters.
Comment on this
The Deputy can twist it any way he likes. All I want is justice in this country. I do not think it is justice to arrest one section of the population and not another.
Comment on this
It was a well-known fact that at the time of the farmers' dispute instructions were sent by the Government to all district justices informing them that they should enforce the rigours of law as far as the farmers were concerned.
Comment on this
We agree with free assembly and free speech. That has been our policy since the foundation of the State. We agree with peaceful marches and demonstrations. They can be a safety valve. But it is wrong for people to take the law into their own hands. There is a report in today's Irish Times which says that there was a picket outside the Golden Grill in Letterkenny last night for the function for the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and they were attacked by no less a person than Senator McGlinchey and other members of the Fianna Fáil Party; their peaceful picket was broken up. When people are protesting peacefully, then they should be allowed to protest, and no man, Senator or anyone else, should be allowed to take the law into his own hands, break up a picket and take the placards from them. That was what happened in Letterkenny last night.
Comment on this
He did not drive over a picket. What about the man who jumped out of the window in Liberty Hall?
Comment on this
What about Deputy Brian Lenihan, then Minister for Education, jumping out of the toilet window in Trinity College?
Comment on this
Deputy Brian Lenihan was the Minister for Education at the time. Unfortunately, crime is on the increase in all our cities and towns. Juvenile delinquency is increasing. Something should be done to provide more playing fields and more grounds for youth. I know this does not arise on this Estimate and I shall not stress the point. On 12th November, 1969, at column 721 of the Official Report, I asked the Taoiseach "whether any directorships or other positions in any business or other concern are held by Government Ministers; and, if so, if he will state their nature." The Taoiseach, in reply, told me:
No Minister holds any position that could reasonably be regarded as interfering, or being incompatible, with the full and proper discharge by him of the duties of his office.
That is entirely wrong. The Minister for Justice practises as a solicitor and what he is doing is certainly not in conformity with what the Taoiseach told me on 12th November last. There was a letter read in this House, a letter from the Minister, encouraging a certain person to break the law. The fact that the Minister told the recipient of that letter to keep the letter a secret and to destroy it proves that the Minister knew that what he was doing was wrong. The lady to whom the letter was written was encouraged to go into a particular house and she was told that, when she had gone into the house, the Minister would do his best to see that she was kept on as the tenant. He encouraged that lady to break the law.