Committee on Finance. - Vote 20—Office of the Minister for Justice (Resumed).
Contributions 163–321 of 492. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The Minister did not deny that he wrote the letter. It was read out here and it is a simple matter to paraphrase what was in that letter. It told a particular person to go into a house and squat in that house, to say that she was a relative and, when the other tenant left, she would be appointed as the tenant. I do not know what right the Minister for Justice has to encourage anybody to break the law.
We have proof that the Minister is practising as a solicitor. It has been stated here and in many of our leading newspapers that the highest possible standards should obtain where the Minister for Justice is concerned. If the Taoiseach turns the Nelson eye on what is going on we will in time become a banana republic and not a parliamentary democracy. The Minister for Justice should not practise as a solicitor. Proof has been given here of his advising counsel in a court of law. That is utterly wrong. The Minister for Justice is in a position to have at his command information which is not at the command of every other solicitor in the country and, because of that, it is possible for the Minister to abuse his position as Minister for Justice. The Minister has told us that he will be introducing legislation dealing with landlords and tenants. A great many clients go in as either landlords or tenants and the Minister is in a position to give his clients information which could be very valuable to them.
I should like now to quote from the Longford Leader on 29th November, 1969. The leading article deals with the current controversy raging around Deputy Moran and states that this again raises the question of the single-mindedness of Ministers of State. The matter of whether a Minister who is qualified in a profession should continue to act in that profession while in office should be sorted out in the same manner as the situation of a Minister holding directorships in firms was dealt with. It goes on to state that it may be argued that Ministers hampered by laws governing them in these matters might find ways and means of avoiding the financial penalties by securing outside benefits in a roundabout manner and that such avoidance would be difficult to control. It further states that it is an unfortunate fact that, whereas the law might be obeyed in the letter in this country it might be evaded in the spirit. “The setting up of stooges to sit in for Ministers on businesses they clandestinely are involved with has many precedents in Irish life.” I do not want to quote the whole article but it should certainly bring home to us the fact that the Minister should resign either as a Minister or as solicitor, if he intends to remain on as Minister. If the Taoiseach will allow him to remain as Minister he should resign as solicitor. The Taoiseach will hardly remove the present Minister for Justice for very good reasons. First, I do not believe he is strong enough and, secondly, it is a well-known fact that the Minister supported the Taoiseach and was not prepared to support Deputy Colley because Deputy Colley did not at that time agree with low standards in high places such as we have in the Department of Justice today. In all probability, that is what Deputy Colley was hinting at because it was down to the west of Ireland he went to make that important statement.
What we want today in Ireland are high standards in high places and especially in the Department of Justice. I deplore the attack made by the Minister for Justice last week on Deputy O'Higgins, an honourable Member of the House. When the Minister speaks about the Bar there are few who know more about it and its use than Deputy O'Higgins. I want to say——
Comment on this
——when Deputy O'Higgins's grandfather and uncle were working and fighting and dying for Ireland the Minister's father and grandfather were using the Bar and the crowbar and the battering ram as Lord Lucan's agents to put the people out of holdings in Mayo.
Comment on this
The Deputy is making charges against people who are not present. He is abusing the privileges of the House.
Comment on this
If the Minister attacks decent, respectable men who have worked with honour and dignity, we are entitled to tell him what we think of him.
Comment on this
Do not talk about respect for this House. We know what was said about this House in the past.
Comment on this
It is a matter of regret for almost all of us that we had to be here for what Deputy L'Estrange had to say. Most of us would prefer not to have been here——
Comment on this
We shall deal with some of that "truth" later on. Even with our experience of Parliament we do not like to see it being debased to the level to which Deputy L'Estrange has debased it with the mud he has thrown around from the time he began to speak this afternoon. I regret that as a Member of the House I became involved in some way even with the denial of some of the allegations that Deputy L'Estrange made because I think those who sent me and the other Deputies on this side of the House here to represent them would wish us to do something more important and positive than deal with allegations of muck and filth which Deputy L'Estrange has produced from his own personal archives for the past few years. We shall deal with some of the allegations but my capacity to deal with them cannot match Deputy L'Estrange's capacity for digging them up. I hope the Deputy will come back at some stage because I have some very pertinent things to say.
The Minister in opening the debate covered a wide range of matters relating to his Department and matters far removed from what we have heard in the past two or three hours. I was somewhat disappointed that the trend of the debate did not develop as broadly as indicated by the Minister's speech. Up to this afternoon the debate appears to have covered "Seven Days", the Garda Síochána and the personal suitability of the Minister for Justice. The "Seven Days" programme has been ruled out because of the judicial inquiry now to be set up and, accordingly, I direct no remarks towards that issue. As regards the Garda Síochána I had better declare a personal interest in that I represented the Garda Representative Body before the Conroy Commission and many of the points made by Deputies here were, I think, made fairly fully by the representatives of the Garda at that Commission. It would not be inappropriate, therefore, for me in that I did enjoy that particular position of trust for them to make a further plea to the Minister, or any other Minister, to implement as soon as possible the reforms sought by the Representative Body.
I have been encouraged by the fact that representatives on all sides of the House have acknowledged that it is not just in the interests of the force but is equally, or even more, in the interests of the community that this matter should be dealt with expeditiously. I hope the Minister will ensure that as soon as the report from the Conroy Commission is made available it will be published with all possible speed as all of us and the community at large, apart from the Garda Síochána altogether, are very anxious that the recommendations be implemented as soon as possible.
I was disappointed that Deputy Fitzpatrick, who led for Fine Gael, also narrowed the terms of reference considerably because if what he had to say on the Department of Justice represents official Fine Gael policy it is very poor indeed. Deputy Fitzpatrick lectured certain Members of the House as to the propriety or otherwise of acting in a professional capacity as prosecutors for the State and he indicated that two Fianna Fáil Members of the House were prosecuting in their own constituency. I do not know what research he undertook before he made the statement but I know I am quite right in assuming that one of the prosecutors to whom he thinks he is referring is myself. I have every reason to know that he does base his charge on my being one of the two Fianna Fáil prosecutors and this is not creditable conduct, according to Deputy Fitzpatrick.
I have been a Member of the Upper House for four years and of this House since last June, and I have been an associate and active member of Fianna Fáil for I do not know how long, and in all my years at the Bar, not only have I not prosecuted but I have never had a State brief. I have never even on one occasion—and this gives the lie to what Deputy L'Estrange argued— earned one guinea from the State; I do not say there would have been anything wrong if it had happened. It is hard to sit here and listen to a lecture from Deputy Fitzpatrick when I know he is referring to me when he says two of us—it can only be two of the three Fianna Fáil members and I know he does not mean my colleague in Dún Laoghaire/Rathdown—are prosecuting in our own constituencies. I hope that somebody will tell Deputy Fitzpatrick that his facts are wrong and tell him and Deputy L'Estrange and others like them that from now on before making any allegations or giving any sermons they should ensure that their facts are a little better established.
To deal broadly with the Minister's opening speech which, as I have indicated already, was very broad, there is a matter which causes some concern to the Minister and his staff and also to practising lawyers and the public. It is the matter of law reform. The Minister indicated the scope and nature of legislation which is at present under review by the law reform section of his Department. He indicated also in his opening remarks that the strength of the skilled advisory staff in his Department is severely limited. This is a fact which, of course, must have some effect on the programme for law reform being promoted by the Minister and the Department, but it is because of the numerical limitation on the personnel in the Department that some doubts arise from time to time in the legal profession, and possibly with the public also, as to the fullness of the advice available to the Minister on the basis of his law reform programme, as to how wide are the views made available to him and also whether they are experienced views from the standpoint of practical problems.
I do not for a moment suggest that no consultation has taken place but it is particularly important where there is a limited number of people in the Department dealing with such a vitally important matter as law reform, that no individuals would themselves determine without full consultation with all interests concerned what is the most enlightened programme of law reform for this country. There is a fear abroad that a certain amount of this is happening at present in the Department of Justice.
Law reform, whether landlord and tenant, criminal law, criminal practice and procedure or any other aspect, is a very detailed and difficult matter and I hope that henceforth it will be seen that every consultation is made available to all professional bodies, the Incorporated Law Society and the Bar Council, before any programme for law reform is implemented. Secondly, such consultation having taken place, the experienced views of experienced men at whatever level should be noted. I know in the nature of things that when you have a limited staff problems will arise but I think because of this very limit consultation should be extended as far as possible.
The Minister referred to some legislation, proposals for which he has in his Department, such as the increase in jurisdiction for circuit and district courts, the right of solicitors to be appointed to the circuit court benches and to plead before every court, and the question of the merged profession. I shall leave that for a moment but I should like to deal with a question more important than personal isolated issues—the general question of administration of justice. Perhaps it is just as well that Deputy L'Estrange is not here just now because if we had a repetition of what occurred when he was here it would not serve any purpose and certainly would not help those people who are concerned with the administration of justice.
Comment on this
Deputy L'Estrange made quite a number of very valid points which he backed up with quotations and reports.
Comment on this
If quotations from newspapers or from Deputy L'Estrange's own personal file are what we are going to accept as gospel in this House, then I am afraid we are going to act on very flimsy evidence.
Comment on this
There was a lot of material, some of which I shall prove to be untrue. Deputy L'Estrange is concerned that there is one law for the poor, one law for the rich, one law for Taca and another law for everybody else. Let it be clearly understood that Taca is not going to be hurt or offended by what Deputy L'Estrange has to say. It is well able to protect itself and the effects of any of Deputy L'Estrange's allegations will not have any far-reaching consequences on it; the decision at the last general election was sufficient justification for its existence despite all the allegations made against it beforehand. Neither will Fianna Fáil nor any member of the legal profession greatly suffer if Deputy L'Estrange is going to accuse them of malpractices or anything else; nor will the individuals who, as Deputy L'Estrange said, have got favoured justice, who apparently have had the benefit of Taca justice, who have had personal allegations made against their character or whose families have suffered injury, suffer permanent and serious damage.
However, what will leave a permanent scar is something mentioned by Deputy L'Estrange this afternoon— an allegation against our judiciary and against their impartiality. If the public think there is any substance in these comments then a permanent ill has been suffered, damage has been done to the impartiality of the judiciary, but much more important, to the whole concept of justice in this country. This I regard as being the utterly sad and reprehensible result of Deputy L'Estrange's allegations.
It has been rightly said that you can guarantee all kinds of rights in a country where you do not have an independent and impartial judiciary. It is significant that these rights are available in many of the totalitarian States; it is significant that in newly-emerging States who have not yet learned the value and necessity of an independent judiciary, sometimes the decisions of the judiciary are upset by personal values of the people concerned. However, we in this country pride ourselves that we have reached an advanced stage of sophisticated democracy. I had such an impression until this afternoon, but it has collapsed completely. We are now expected to accept from Deputy L'Estrange and Deputy O.J. Flanagan, who has something to say on this also, that trial by words whispered in the ears of Deputies L'Estrange and Flanagan is nearer to the justice the people of this country want than trial by the judiciary established here.
It amuses me when we hear cries from the Opposition side for a judicial inquiry or investigation into the "Seven Days" programme, into moneylending and so on, yet when they have that same judicial investigation every day of the week they make allegations that the judges are reaching their decisions because they have been influenced, that the penalties imposed are reached because the judges are so influenced, and this is surely a sad reflection on the standard and calibre of this House.
May I refer specifically to one of the numerous cases mentioned by Deputy L'Estrange. He spoke of a case recently heard in Portlaoise Circuit Court where the accused was charged with both manslaughter and dangerous driving causing death. The accused was also charged with summary offences for failing to stop, for failing to give information to the Garda under section 106 of the Road Traffic Act. Deputy L'Estrange said this afternoon, and he and Deputy Oliver Flanagan said previously, that they asked the Minister for Justice, who could not have been in a position to reply to the allegations they made at the time although he did make a full statement, if he could give the full details, the full circumstances in which the charge of manslaughter was reduced to one of careless driving or of dangerous driving, bearing in mind the fact that the driver drove on to the footpath.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan was not here to continue with this matter. He had been asked to leave the House and he duly left. The Chair made the decision that this matter should not be discussed.
Comment on this
Therefore, I believe that if Deputy Flanagan was not allowed to raise the matter here——
Comment on this
The Chair intervened on that occasion because Deputy Flanagan was criticising the decision of the judge.
Comment on this
I have not yet got to that stage and I hope I never will. If what Deputy L'Estrange said was relevant——
Comment on this
Deputy O'Kennedy has gone on record today as saying that if a person were a member of Taca he could do anything. I do not wish to get involved——
Comment on this
And I trust he will inform Deputy L'Estrange and Deputy Flanagan of the facts of the case. The charge on that occasion was under section 106, that the accused failed to stop and failed to give appropriate information to the Garda. I have taken the opportunity of consulting people who were not concerned with either side, who were in court, and I have also consulted with prosecuting and defence counsel. I should like to put the record right as far as all the allegations about Taca influence, on the judiciary or otherwise, are concerned. It was suggested that the charge was dropped—that the charge of manslaughter was reduced to one of careless driving. The fact is that the representative of the accused, some time previously, offered a plea of guilty to dangerous driving causing death. The accused offered to plead guilty to that offence, offered that to the prosecuting counsel, and prosecuting counsel—this will no doubt come as a surprise to Deputies L'Estrange and Flanagan—refused to accept that plea of guilty to a charge of dangerous driving causing death and said: "Irrespective of the fact that the accused is pleading guilty to that charge we will continue with our charge of manslaughter".
It may be more significant that even when the State proceeded with the charge of manslaughter the defence, the accused, still allowed his plea of dangerous driving causing death to stand: he did not withdraw that plea, as he could have done. I wish these facts—and they are the facts—to be considered by Deputies L'Estrange and Flanagan and I should like them to consider whether this is an indication of unequal justice or of a man being allowed off because of some connivance. The State on that occasion proceeded with the most serious charge possible against a person accused of a driving offence. That was not the end.
The State called all the evidence in that case—that of two passengers in the back seat, one in the front and all the other evidence—notwithstanding the fact that the accused had pleaded guilty to dangerous driving causing death, and none of the evidence disclosed had any basis whatsoever on which a prima facie case of manslaughter against the accused could be established. This was by common consent of everybody in court. We must remember that the accused still faced a penalty on a charge of dangerous driving causing death.
The accused himself was not obliged to do so, but he went into the box to give his version relating to the matters on which all of the witnesses called had given evidence. Then, the defence counsel applied for a direction from the court which had not then heard the entire case. As I have said, a direction to the jury was applied for and everybody in the court agreed that there were no facts to justify the jury even considering a verdict on the manslaughter charge.
As the accused had pleaded guilty to dangerous driving causing death, the judge dealt with that offence and on that conviction, to which the accused had pleaded guilty, he was disqualified for two years and a fine of £100 was imposed. We heard Deputy L'Estrange this afternoon say that somebody can come along, mow down a child and get away with a £2 fine. The danger is that people outside might accept that kind of dangerous rubbish.
That sentence stands. Where Deputy L'Estrange is confused, or wants to be confused, is that in imposing that sentence the judge was aware of and took into account the summary charges of failing to stop and failing to give information: these charges were pending against the accused and the judge took that into account in imposing a fine of £100 and a disqualification of two years.
It is regrettable and it is sad whenever there is a fatal accident involving a little one, but the burden of the parents is not lightened by the fact that their tragedy is being misused in this House. It is sad also for the person who was unfortunate enough in some way to be the instrument of such a death, but in case anyone has a notion that this gentleman or anyone like him is getting favoured treatment, let me point out that it is unusual for anybody found guilty of dangerous driving to be sentenced to imprisonment. It is very unusual indeed. There has been one such sentence, however, and that was imposed on a brother of the accused in this case. We are asked to believe, by Deputies L'Estrange and Flanagan, that this is Taca justice. If this is Taca justice it is a great credit to Taca.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy tell us the term of imprisonment the brother got and the term he served? I believe it is relevant since the Deputy raised it.
Comment on this
As I said when I raised this matter, I am sorry that poor family had to be used, or that the accused and his family will have to listen to it all over again or that a member of the Bar Library, who happens to be a supporter of Fianna Fáil, was involved, but the important issue here is that the judiciary are before the public seen to be and have been for so long, to the pride of this country, an independent judiciary and that the people of this country, despite the mudslinging allegations of Deputy L'Estrange, Deputy Flanagan and others, can have confidence in that judiciary. The day that confidence is undermined will be equally as sad as the day that the confidence of people in this House is undermined. Much of what Deputy L'Estrange has gone on with today, I am afraid, has gone a long way towards undermining the confidence that any reasonable person could have in the function of Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
Nobody takes him seriously except the Egyptians.
Comment on this
While the function of Telefís Éireann and their right to protect their sources and all matters of that sort are, of course, very important, while other matters that arise here from time to time are of importance to the structure of the State, nothing is more important than the impartiality of the judiciary and I regret that it has been called into question by people who are so uninformed and apparently so unconcerned about that same impartiality.
The Minister referred to the fact that he intends to introduce legislation to reform the Land Registry or if not to reform it to lead to greater efficiency and speed in dealings in the Land Registry. It is fair to say that the Land Registry as it stands at present is, in fact, doing, as best it can, a very efficient job and doing it in a very speedy manner. The whole basis of the compulsory registration of title, which is under the jurisdiction of the Land Registry, means, in fact, that title can be transferred from one person to another purely by the simple and expeditious manner of effecting a change in ownership of the folio concerned. This has given rise to very expeditious work in the transfer of title throughout the country. In recent times sites have been bought for housing development, for factory development, for so many other developments that we have seen, and the Land Registry, even allowing for the expeditious manner of their dealings, find that they, too, are under severe disability in coping with the volume of work being referred to them. Remember that each time, for instance, a site is acquired for development there must be not just a transfer from the original owner, A, to the new owner, B. There must be a new folio created to apply to the new site which has been acquired by the new owner, B. A new map will have to be drawn up for him. Obviously, the Minister is aware of the problem because he says that he has introduced a member of the Ordnance Survey section to the Land Registry to expedite the mapping facilities in the Land Registry. The very nature of the work demands that this be done. I hope the Land Registry will be enabled, either by an increase in staff or more modern business methods, to deal with the great burden of work that at present they are, unfortunately, not able to cope with as adequately as one would wish.
I am also glad to hear from the Minister that he is introducing shortly compulsory registration in certain counties of all kinds of title. I think he mentioned Wexford, Carlow and one other. This will mean in the long run much more expeditious dealings throughout the country in all kinds of title transfer. It will mean incidentally too, for those who are concerned, that conveyancing lawyers will not be as much sought after as they are at present, that certain counsel will probably earn less fees, if any at all. I suppose that in itself will commend itself to a large number of Members of the House. The important consideration, however, is that it will lead to efficient and cheap transfer of title. I hope that this pilot scheme of compulsory registration in Leinster will be extended as soon as possible throughout the country if and whenever the scheme has proved a success.
In the course of debates here we have heard some views expressed on the legal aid situation. Generally there have been arguments for the extension of legal aid to civil cases. I do not want to take everything that every Deputy says in the House as being literally his opinion. I do not want to take a chance word as representing what his considered view is but I trust that when Deputy Desmond spoke about the well-heeled barristers and the fact that no member of the public wanted to rely on the charity of such well-heeled barristers——
Comment on this
The Deputy may well have, but if my hearing serves me that expression was used in the House when I was present. In any event, I should like to say that the criminal legal aid system as it applies at present has been covered in the Estimates for 1968-69 by an expenditure of £9,289. The actual amount voted for the purpose was £16,000 so that there is an excess of almost £7,000 available over that which was in fact used. This, everyone will admit, is rather unusual in this day and age. Here I make the case seriously, not just in the interests of the Bar or the solicitors profession who, in fact, have borne more of the brunt of this than members of the Bar. The fee which is payable to counsel or solicitors for defending a criminal charge in the Circuit Court or the Central Criminal Court is the sum, for one day, of ten guineas. This may seem to be adequate money for anybody but what is not taken into account is that the cost of going to Waterford, Cork, Donegal or anywhere else and the cost of preparing one's case and the cost of staying overnight in a hotel, and such like, swallow up the ten guineas that is made available by the State to defence counsel. The same applies to the solicitor on a criminal charge. The fee payable to him in a case of that sort is also ten guineas. That is the gross fee for the first day.
When the scheme was introduced both branches of the profession were very anxious to ensure that it would be made to work and almost universally members of the Bar and the solicitors profession put their names on the legal aid panel to be available to anybody who was granted legal aid by the court. Unfortunately the expense and the loss which counsel and solicitors have been involved in in accepting legal aid nominations have changed the minds of many of them. While this was, as I understood it and as both branches of the profession understood it, meant to be a temporary matter to see how it would work out, unfortunately the scale of fees—perhaps the subject of negotiation now—is still the same, no change has been effected, and in recent times large numbers of solicitors and barristers have been obliged to withdraw their names from the panel of legal aid. I witnessed a situation recently in Waterford—this will concern all who are concerned about the defence of accused people—where only one solicitor in the court was actually on the legal aid panel, and when, some legal argument arose as to whether the accused was entitled to a transfer to Dublin or should be tried in the circuit court in Waterford, the judge adjourned his decision until the end of the afternoon to consider the authorities that had been mentioned to him. That solicitor who was not even from Waterford waited in court all day until about 5 o'clock, as did his counsel, to hear the judge's decision on the matter. I may be wrong in this but I do not think that either one or the other was entitled to any fee for that particular service on that day.
The concern here is, as I have already said, that so many of his colleagues have withdrawn their names from the panel and I am quite sure that he cannot be very enthusiastic at this stage about allowing his name to remain on the panel since he was obliged to stay in court from about 10.30 in the morning until 4 or 5 o'clock in the afternoon waiting for a decision and, in fact, performing a service for which he would get no remuneration whatsoever. This scheme was introduced by the Department in the best interests of the people absolutely concerned—the accused—and I presume that it is retained in their interests but I would make a strong plea to the Minister, without making any special reference to appropriate figures because his own advisers and others will be able to give him much better assistance in that regard than I could, that, at least, this probationary scale fee which was introduced some time back for both professions be changed as soon as possible. Otherwise, the whole basis of the scheme will collapse and the very worthy idea behind it will fade completely.
A case has been made for an extension of the legal aid system to civil legal aid. This may be desirable and, naturally, the Minister and his Department would need to have some idea of how much it would cost. However, I am quite sure that if he were to introduce a scheme of civil legal aid the Minister would get the same co-operation in its implementation from both branches of the legal profession as he has had up to now on criminal legal aid.
When Deputy O'Higgins said that no man ever went without legal advice or legal assistance because of lack of money and that any time anyone goes to court he is entitled to the best solicitor and the best counsel, he may have been putting it just a little too roundly. I would be the first person to concede that this is not universally so. I do not wish to question the basis of Deputy O'Higgins's statement but while members of both professions would like to think that such is the case, many of us who are no more endowed with the gift of charity than anybody in any other profession or occupation, have found that in the case of a penniless plaintiff we will get out in the heel of the hunt with nothing if the case for the plaintiff is dismissed.
This is quite a regular experience with lawyers. The credit for this is due more to the solicitors profession than to my profession because we merely devote time and whatever energy and ability we have whereas a solicitor has to do quite a bit more. He provides not only time but expense. He must undertake the cost of getting civil bills issued and served and he has to pay stamp duty. He also has to bear the cost of engaging professional witnesses, doctors, engineers and so on. This practice has been carried on almost universally and in an understanding with them counsel have also acted on the basis "no foal, no fee".
I should like to pay that tribute to the solicitors profession. While it may apply to 98 per cent of cases there will be the two per cent with whom Deputy Desmond or anybody else must be concerned who, initially, will not go to a solicitor because they have no money and who consider that it would be too expensive to go to a solicitor.
Comment on this
Not very much more and Deputy Corish will be surprised to hear that about 75 per cent of that two per cent do not belong to the poorer classes as we understand them because the poorer classes generally know that if they are beaten they have nothing to lose.
Comment on this
That is so but, on the other hand, I would like to make it clear that it is the person of limited property who generally pays the piper when it goes to law because, if he is beaten, his property can be taken. We are dealing with a matter which, if not significant in number, is significant in importance. It is for that reason that I suggest to the Minister that if he is dealing with civil legal aid, although this may not be the time to do so, he might consider the possibility of extending criminal legal aid which, in my view, is more important. If a limited fund of £25, £30 or even £50 was made available to solicitors to reduce the problem of making available such witnesses as doctors, engineers and others, it would help a great deal.
At present, the real difference between the person who wishes to go to court and cannot afford it and the person who wishes to go and can afford it is that the latter can get his case heard more quickly. No solicitor can be blamed for leaving over a case for which he knows he will get no remuneration until after he deals with matters that will give him normal remuneration.
The other problems as to the administration of the system and who would qualify I leave to the Minister and to the consultations I hope he will have with the appropriate professional bodies.
Another matter that has been mentioned in the course of the debate is the function of the Department in the maintenance of public order. Deputy Keating said—and I think he was "hear-heared" at some stage in this by Deputy Desmond, if Deputy Desmond did not in fact repeat the same sentence:
We see young people all over the world claiming the right to demonstrate. In my opinion, this is a profoundly important and absolutely basic and central human right, and we must do nothing in legislation to limit that right.
Deputy Desmond would probably agree that his sentence on that subject re-echoed those sentiments.
We on this side of the House are as concerned as anyone else that fundamental rights, the right to demonstrate, the right to speech and any other right be given in this country under the legislation enacted by this House to those who wish to avail of them. This is something which this Parliament is charged with ensuring. Our Constitution has something to say on it too and this point has been forgotten by so many who would regard the right to demonstrate as being an absolutely basic right, unqualified, unlimited and certainly not such as should be tampered with by legislation. The Constitution, Article 40, section 6, subsection 1º says:
The State guarantees liberty for the exercise of the following rights subject to public order and morality.
Among those rights are:
The right of the citizens to assemble peaceably and without arms:
They provide a second qualification here and state:
Provision may be made by law to prevent or control meetings which are determined in accordance with law to be calculated to cause a breach of the peace or to be a danger or nuisance to the general public and to prevent or control meetings in the vicinity of either House of the Oireachtas.
You have then those rights subject to two qualifications. The first one, the general one, is "subject to public order and morality" and then the right of the citizens to assemble peaceably and without arms is also subject to the qualification, that provision may be made by law to prevent or control or regulate the holding of meetings. Here we get back to basics because too often, and judging from the expressions of view from the Labour Party in the course of this debate, people regard this right, the right to free assembly, the right to free speech or the right to anything else as being not a right at all but a licence——
Comment on this
——as if it was something never to be touched, never to be questioned at all. If I can at least interpret Deputy Desmond's concern, it is most important that our gardaí would be trained in the techniques of handling those matters so that they will all pass off nice and quietly, that the people who indulge in demonstrations will be subject to the laws that apply to all of us in this country. Anyone who thinks a fundamental right means an absolute, unqualified right—I think the term "absolute" was used by Deputy Keating—is certainly on a very wrong line indeed. One has not to go too far to see how people are deprived of those absolute rights in the totalitarian States in Europe and elsewhere. Those are rights which are sometimes claimed absolutely by those most in sympathy with those same totalitarian States. Let it be understood that the public order and morality and the public interest, in whatever legislation is being discussed, whenever it will come before the House, must be taken into account by this House, by this Minister or any other Minister, if they are answering their responsibilities under the Constitution and they must enact laws to control and regulate demonstrations.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy suggest that the Criminal Justice Bill be continued? Is that what the Deputy is arguing about?
Comment on this
I am not talking about the Criminal Justice Bill now. I am arguing about what Deputy Keating and Deputy Desmond had to say. Deputy Keating said:
We see young people all over the world claiming the right to demonstrate. In my opinion, this is a profoundly important and absolutely basic and central human right and we must do nothing in legislation to limit that right.
Comment on this
I am not saying any such thing. I can go further and tell you what he said. He said:
We have seen that, because wide sections of the community and particularly the young are now claiming that right more freely than was the practice, perhaps, ten or 15 years ago, the police authorities in many countries, not traditionally equipped and not specially trained to deal with situations of proper and legitimate and, almost invariably, peaceful demonstrations, are overreacting and provoking violence.
He goes on to deal with this matter.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting they should be restrained any more than the demonstrators should be restrained.
Comment on this
You are trying to say that the monopoly of restraint is, as he put it, on the left and the monopoly of provocation is on the right.
Comment on this
Further on, Deputy Keating said:
It is important that we should make the point that where violence has occurred it has come frequently not from the demonstrators who generally are people of what one might call a left political opinion, but from those who want to deny the demonstrators the right to demonstrate
That is a lovely little bit of special pleading that the violence comes not from demonstrators, who generally are of left political opinion, but from those who want to deny them this absolute basic right. Other people may feel that it is interference with public order and morality and that, in fact, as the Constitution says, it is interfering with them exercising their rights. Might I say in this connection when people demonstrate for the old and the ill— I have taken part in demonstrations and I hope I will again and I want to let it be known clearly that I am not here questioning the right to demonstrate and nothing any Deputy says will put that interpretation on what I am saying——
Comment on this
The Deputy wants to put his own interpretation on what Deputy Justin Keating said and wants to deny any other person the right to interpret his speech.
Comment on this
There are four or five more pages on this but I do not see any reference to any particular legislation. He talks in general about the right to demonstrate and matters of that sort.
Comment on this
He said he was concerned about public order. He was talking about the Criminal Justice Bill.
Comment on this
He was talking about public order and that is what I am talking about too, not about the Criminal Justice Bill which is not before us. I would like to make this point in connection with demonstrations in general. I do not question the enthusiasm and I do not question the ideology behind those who would demonstrate but do they ever consider the rights of other people? Henceforth I would ask them to consider that the very people they may be concerned about are possibly the people who are most interfered with and in some instances frightened by the developments of public demonstrations. The holding of demonstrations would seem to those whose only defence is a very limited one, and who naturally are concerned, as interfering with their rights when they cause noise or turbulence. Those are the people who first take fright, those are the people to whom fear is a real thing. I have seen it in some of the demonstrations I took part in as a student. Those are the people who suffer, not the young students who are strong and healthy, not the young lads who can go and shout at the gardaí and get a push or a shove from the gardaí.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows this as well as I do. I am making the plea that henceforth regard would be had for the old and weak people who have expressed concern to me about this matter. They have a real fear, whether it is well-founded or otherwise. I am sure this fear has been expressed to many others in the House. This kind of thing will lead to the chaos that I am afraid those old people in particular fear more than anything else. That is just a thought for those who suggest that the right to demonstrate is not subject to the rights of others.
There were many references made, and may I say many obviously informed references, in the course of this debate to our probation facilities. Obviously many of the Deputies who spoke on every side of the House had more information regarding the city of Dublin than I could hope to make available so I do not intend to repeat what I think has been better said by others. However, I want to make a simple point to the Minister that, as he knows both as a Minister and in his practice as a solicitor, as well as many others who have seen the probation service in action, it is generally understaffed and that the Garda Síochána throughout the country, particularly where they do not have probation officers, exercise the function of probation officers themselves, that they advise the court very considerably. Far from endeavouring to punish an habitual offender who has been brought to justice they endeavour to explain and to mitigate as much as possible the circumstances under which he has been brought before the court again.
One matter of which all of us who practise in courts are aware, is that the vast majority of criminals are people with a deprived background, who have had almost a criminal environment from birth. These are the people who arouse the greatest sympathy in us when we speak here. Unfortunately, however, because of their attitudes generally towards the gardaí, although they may be sympathetic, towards the courts and officers of the courts, though they too may be sympathetic, they are often not in a position to benefit from whatever treatment the court may direct for them, by way of penalty or otherwise. There is an urgent need for the probation officer system to be extended so that one can get to the actual root of the problem, the home environment. In my experience, and it is the experience of most lawyers, the vast majority of criminals, even those who do such terrible things as those to which Deputy Briscoe referred—looting houses when the owners are at a relative's funeral, and this indeed is a terrible offence—are people who have had a criminal background from infancy.
We should, therefore, spare no effort to get the guards in amongst those young people who are in that environment, to become respected by them and to be available to help them when trouble arises, because trouble will arise. In the nature of things these people are in the front line of temptation. With the experience which the Garda Síochána have had, and because of the great work done by probation officers, this is almost a matter of simply increasing the number of probation officers. This should be done in the city first of all because their numbers are too limited and their jurisdiction too great. If necessary, then, the number could be extended, at least in the larger towns.
Hand in hand with this goes the question of after-care and consultation. The probation officer, of course, is the person who will keep in constant touch with the young offender whether he has been released from prison fully or is on temporary release. There is need here for a better education of what one might call the habitual criminal and a better tolerance of him by society. This would go a long way towards meeting what is a great social ill.
In this connection, the Minister should consider extending the work of the ban-ghardaí. The case for this was adequately and fully stated at the commission and I do not intend to repeat it. The ban-ghardaí are particularly suited for dealing with young offenders and experience has shown them to be both dedicated and successful. If the Minister could increase the number and scope of the ban-ghardaí he would be providing a very useful service.
I come now to a final aspect of what I wish to say. I had intended to say it earlier but I was aroused by what Deputy L'Estrange said and I took the impartiality of the judiciary as being a matter of first consequence. I should like to refer to the reorganisation of the courts and related matters. Probably everyone would agree that there is no reason why solicitors should not have the right of audience in the High Court and even in the Supreme Court. Equally, there may be cogent reasons why the Minister and the professions concerned should consider the possibility of a fusion of the professions. The committee dealing with this matter have issued invitations to the public to express their views and I hope that Members of this House who have strong views on the matter will communicate those views to the committee so that the matter can be dealt with in an objective and enlightened manner and not on the basis either of antagonism towards any branch of the profession or a personal interest in any branch of the profession.
The Minister also mentioned the possibility of appointing solicitors to the circuit court. If solicitors are going to practise in the circuit court, or in the High Court, or in the Supreme Court, I do not think anybody could deny they are as entitled to be appointed to that court as any other member of the profession. However, I am sure the Minister will take into account that while solicitors at present do have the right of audience in the circuit court they exercise it in a very limited way. This is for well-founded reasons which I do not intend to go into. One can query then, that if people have not had experience, or have had limited experience, in the court, whether they would be qualified to act as judges in that court. I am not one who claims that any branch of the law has any monopoly either of knowledge or experience, far from it; each branch fulfils its own function in its own way. However, where there are special fields in which one branch has a monopoly of experience then surely as things stand it is only appropriate, in the interests of the public, that the judiciary for that particular tribunal should be selected from that branch of the profession. I would hope that solicitors would use the right of audience more in the circuit court for only when they do could they be regarded as being the appropriate people, the same as anybody else, to be appointed to the appropriate court.
One thing which shocks people who have to travel to various courthouses, particularly those who are in the happy position of having to visit them only once in a lifetime, is the terrible condition of those courthouses. By and large they are in a very dangerous condition and in some cases they are positively unhealthy. Recently I was in a courthouse in Waterford which was in a dangerous condition because of excavations nearby and because of the actual state of the courthouse. There are plans for renovating it but it is typical of many courthouses. There are rats in the vicinity and some were even in the judge's chamber before the court sat. One can imagine the damp atmosphere of some of these places. People going into such courthouses nearly expire from the cold and damp but members of the legal profession have practically to live in these places. Going around on circuit one wonders why there are not adequate facilities for carrying on business in the courthouses in regard, say, to consultations.
How can one deal with a client's business if one has not a suitable room to sit in while hearing him on the merits of his case? I practise on a circuit where, I regret to say, in at least two instances, there are no consultation room facilities at all. The consultation, such as it is, takes place outside of court. The court sits between October and June—generally. Throughout the winter, particularly, one can appreciate the impossibility of doing the job properly. One can go to the solicitor's office if the staff are not using portion of the office on that day: it might be some distance from the court. I wish to express a personal view—not the view of the bar nor indeed even of a collective group of my profession but a view which I think may coincide with some views —that the Minister might consider, when increasing the jurisdiction, a regional court rather than the present structure of the courts. After all, we subscribe to the concept of regional development in various spheres. Some years ago, it was necessary to have four circuit courts in a county when travel facilities were not as convenient as they now are. With present travel facilities, the Minister might consider having in each county one good, fully-equipped, modern courtroom with conveniences and comfort not just for lawyers and the judge, though they are perfectly entitled to them like anybody else, but for the litigants and witnesses. It would go a long way towards saving expense—certainly from the point of view of maintenance —and it would go some way towards increasing the amount of litigation dealt with. I suggest that these regional courts be set aside purely for civil business and that another court in the same region would at the same time be set aside for criminal business. Nobody denies the right of the criminal to his trial, least of all the legal profession who want him to have his trial as quickly as possible. However, in some cases, ordinary litigants have frequently to wait for hours, sometimes days, in the environment of these old courtrooms until such time as some criminal business is disposed of. In some instances this arises because we have not, perhaps, a sufficient number of judges.
While this House might not take kindly to my plea for, if necessary, three, four and five extra circuit court judges to be appointed, I would point out that judicial time, as such, and judicial expense, as such, are far less and indeed far less important than public time and public expense in the context where people have to wait days because of lack of facilities or lack of opportunity for the hearing of a case in the vicinity of a courtroom. If we consider here expensive and important witnesses such as a doctor—the court facilitates doctors as soon as it can— one can see that we may be penny wise and pound foolish. If we could have more judges available in better-equipped courts than the present situation of fewer judges in very ill-equipped courts, it would be very helpful. I term it a "regional" court for want of a better word. It might be one court exclusively for civil business and another court exclusively for criminal business in either a large county or in a combination of two counties where every litigant, every witness and every lawyer would be sure that, on a particular day, their case would be dealt with satisfactorily and in normal comfort.
I suppose that, in a way, it is almost regrettable that I, a lawyer, should end my contribution with something directly relating to lawyers. The more important aspect of what I want to say concerns the impartiality of the judiciary. I want to assure the Minister that the legal profession—certainly the branch of it to which I am attached and I am sure the same can be said for the solicitors profession—are anxious that the profession they practise will enjoy not just their own respect but the respect of the public whom they serve. It is fundamentally in their interests, and they realise it, that whatever reform is undertaken will be undertaken in the interests of the public. Therefore, I recommend that whatever reform is undertaken will be done in full consultation with the professions concerned.
Comment on this
As one qualified in law only a short number of years and who had no connection with solicitors or barristers prior to entering the solicitors profession, may I say that I do not believe that any member of the judiciary has at any time—to my knowledge, anyway—accepted bribes or come under political pressures. If they have come under political pressures, I believe that, in the vast majority of cases in regard to the circuit court, the district court and the High Court, it is very rare indeed that these people have succumbed to temptations which might occasionally arise. Deputy O'Kennedy criticised Deputy L'Estrange for mentioning Mr. Hederman. I would point out that he was mentioned recently in a court by that same senior counsel and Deputy L'Estrange was trying to put his point of view on record.
Comment on this
I should like to think that what the Deputy says is true. Unfortunately, with the best will in the world, I cannot. He questioned the basis of the judge's decision.
Comment on this
The question was asked whether Deputy L'Estrange was right in raising the matter. If something comes to the attention of a Deputy which he believes should be raised in this House, I believe, after due consideration, it should be raised if the Deputy considers so. I believe Deputy L'Estrange gave the matter some consideration. The facts of the case were serious and unusual and it deserved discussion.
The Minister's opening statement covered a lot of matters. I just want to refer to something mentioned by the Minister when addressing the Society of Young Solicitors in Galway and dealing with the fusion of barristers and solicitors into one profession. This first came under consideration when Deputy Haughey was Minister for Justice and later when Deputy Lenihan was Minister for Justice. Its head has now been reared again by Deputy Moran as Minister for Justice. In his Galway speech the Minister said: "The idea of a unified profession should get much more thought in the country. I believe that unification should be our ultimate goal." Different people will have different views on this.
Comment on this
Some thought should be given to this. Thought and discussion on this subject are necessary. The system in operation is working well. If this matter is not given full consideration and, if a merger is rushed through, this could be disastrous.
A barrister's role is that of an advocate. This is a specialised role. At the moment this role is filled by a relatively small group of people, almost all of whom practise from the Bar Library. A barrister is to the legal profession what a specialist or consultant is to the medical profession. A person goes to a solicitor and if he wishes to get further advice, the solicitor gets that advice from a barrister. At the moment, the cost of obtaining such an opinion is not excessive. As a general rule it is quite reasonable. In the country in particular, if solicitors require specialised advice they bring the facts of the case to a barrister and get his opinion for something in the region of three to five guineas. This is a cheap way of getting precise information on a point of law. If we had a merger it might lead to an amalgamation of the larger firms in Dublin. It might eventually transpire that we would have firms of solicitors practising in the larger towns only, towns like Athlone and Castlebar. This could lead to increased costs. It could also lead to the country solicitor, as we know him, becoming obsolete over a number of years.
The Minister said that he did not think it would be desirable for us to have two separate professions in view of our prospective entry into the Common Market. If we had a fusion of the two professions it would be far worse having regard to the Common Market. In the country in particular, there would be limited library facilities, limited means of access to court decisions, and limited means of access to decisions in the various Common Market countries but, if barristers continue to practise in the Law Library, if a solicitor in Birr or Tullamore or any other town wants advice on some point of law in one of the Common Market countries, he will be able to get it. The barristers in the Law Library could give him specialised advice on any point of law. For this reason I think amalgamation would be undesirable. This is my own viewpoint and I believe that if the Minister has any steps in mind he should proceed with caution.
Deputy O'Kennedy referred to people who want to take a case to court and who cannot pay the costs. Very few people have not had their case heard. Solicitors and barristers have taken on cases at times and paid for them out of their own pockets. They have paid for advice from doctors and engineers and professional people to enable them to bring a case to court. However, I believe this is a mistake. We should consider a change in the form of the legal aid scheme. Expenditure on the legal aid scheme in criminal cases shows that, even though the scheme is working, it is not working to its full extent.
The fact that £9,298 was spent on this scheme this year shows that it has not got off the ground yet. We should look into this matter because the scheme is not being properly utilised. The young men and women who are coming before the courts on criminal charges are not getting the full benefit of it. The reason they are not getting the full benefit of this service is that the solicitors and barristers who are representing them are not being properly paid. A sum of £16,000 was voted for this on the last occasion and over £9,000 was spent. The Department of Justice should do all they possibly can to improve this service. This is badly needed.
In regard to the civil matters a limited form of aid should be introduced. It is not good enough that a person with a genuine case should have to go to a solicitor and ask for charity. Nobody should have to fall back on charity. Even though his case would be brought, it should be brought as of right. It could be that this would cost a great deal of money but the importance of so many different aspects of law relating to workers, tenants and other categories of people, I believe that now more than ever a form of civil legal aid is needed. It would be tragic if a person who had a case were deprived of the right to bring it forward through lack of finance. It would be a question of law for the rich and none for the poor, leading to a situation where a litigant who had means at his disposal would have an advantage over the person who had not the wherewithal to fight him.
From the number of cases with which I have had to deal in the years I was in practice, I believe that in England free legal aid is working reasonably well. When a person is involved in an accident or something else like that he can get whatever advice he needs and have his case heard and decided. This is something to which the Minister should give urgent attention.
The Minister gives the various figures for crime for 1968, and says that in the year ended 30th September, 1968, there were 23,104 indictable offences recorded as against 17,700 in 1964, that is to say, in a period of four years, an increase of 5,404 indictable offences or approximately 30 per cent. This is an alarming increase. I note also that 54 per cent of the people convicted of indictable offences last year were under 21 years of age. It is very serious that people of such a young age should be convicted of an indictable offence and grow into manhood or womanhood with that blot on their character. We would like to think that an offence of this nature does not stand against a person but unfortunately the truth is that it can deprive a person of a position.
The reasons for the increase in crime are mostly social and economic. This increase in crime involves not only the Department of Justice but the Department of Local Government as well. Housing schemes are created but there are no playing fields; there are very few recreation centres. These are perhaps some of the reasons. Another reason is something that is world-wide: thousands of flats are built in an area and are occupied by people of the same walk of life, people who have not the same benefits as people in other areas. These places sometimes develop into ghettoes. Because it is economic to build houses in a certain way, this problem does not get the attention it deserves.
The ideal situation would be to have people from all walks of life living in the same area; there would be no Foxrocks or Fatima Mansions. People of different backgrounds would be mixing with one another and getting different views of life. Young people from these ghettoes to which I have referred, where crime is on the increase, are going around with flick knives and various other weapons to protect themselves. A lot of hard things have been said about the people who commit these crimes, but unfortunately they never got the opportunities which they so badly need. If houses are built down a back road or on plots of land which are not suitable, the occupants tend to lose a sense of pride in their property and in themselves, and one could almost say they disintegrate and degenerate. It is a pity to see various councils providing this type of housing. A survey could be made of housing on back roads or on roads cut off from the rest of the world. Such a study would show that these people are socially under-privileged and that they give vent to their feelings by committing crimes against society, which in turn sentences them to a period in prison. We should all be saddened by a situation wherein 54 per cent of the people convicted of indictable offences are under the age of 21.
The Minister said and I quote from his speech:
Last year I mentioned the opening, in August, 1968, of a semi-open institution in Shanganagh, County Dublin, for the accommodation of suitable first offenders and selected long-term inmates in the 16 to 21 age group who show promise of improvement and of responding to guidance.
Such institutions are very desirable because they allow people to pay the penalty which society demands without having to go to prison. We have between six and eight probation officers in this country and I think this is deplorable. In England at the moment there are over 2,000 probation officers. Probation officers can help a person when he is in prison and they can also help him to get a job and settle down when he leaves prison. When a person leaves prison with a blot on his record he needs help and assistance. If he does not get such help he is likely to rebel, commit another crime and will be sent back to prison.
The Minister also mentioned the appointment of a psychiatrist to the prison service. Psychiatrists can be of great help to prisoners. When I read an American book on the treatment of prisoners I found they were a long way ahead of us. They have discussion groups which the psychiatrist attends, where the prisoners recount the various crimes they have committed and why they committed them. They also discuss their social background and even though on occasion it could be said that a prisoner might obtain new knowledge about how to commit certain crimes, it does appear that this sort of discussion has an excellent effect on the people concerned. It gives these people an opportunity to find out just where they have gone wrong and why they have gone wrong. I am pleased with the Minister's announcement of the appointment of a psychiatrist.
I do not think a proper study has ever been made of the effectiveness of our penal methods in reforming the criminal, as distinct from merely punishing him. The various forms of sentencing people—a fine, a term of imprisonment or the suspension of a licence—should be studied.
The Minister stated that we have a 61 per cent detection rate. That means, however, that 39 per cent of the crimes committed in this country are not accounted for.
With regard to the closing of Garda stations, this is something which should be undertaken very, very slowly. The closing down of Garda stations could have serious social consequences. The Garda are held in very high esteem and one of the reasons why they are held in such high esteem is their close contact with the people. The gardaí in my area are accepted as members of the community in which they are living. They are welcome in every household. They take part in social events and games. They get to know the people in this way and, in turn, the people get to know them. If Garda stations are closed down the people and the gardaí will lose these contacts. That would, in my opinion, be a retrograde step and one to be deplored. Once these contacts are lost they will never be regained. Again, the closing of a Garda station means a loss to a district. That should be borne in mind, particularly as so many other institutions such as schools, hospitals, and so on are being closed down.
I have occasion to visit Garda stations and I am appalled at the conditions of most of the stations I visit. If convicted criminals were asked to spend a weekend in some of these stations there would be a public outcry. But these are the buildings in which our gardaí are expected to live and work.
Comment on this
Ag éisteacht lena bhfuil ráite ar an meastachán seo agus ag déanamh staidéir air, níl aon dabht ná go bhfuil an meastachán seo ar cheann de na meastacháin is tábhachtaí a thagann os comhair na Dála. Tá a fhios agam go bhfuil daoine anso atá níos cáilithe maidir le cúrsaí dlí ná mar atá mise ach de bhrí go dtuigimse go mbaineann cúrsaí dlí leis an ghnáth-dhuine agus gur gnáthdhuine mé féin measaim go bhfuil dualgas orm smaoineamh nó dhó dem chuidse a nochtadh anso.
Listening to the speeches here and reading others in the Official Report, one is reminded very forcibly of the importance and significance of the Department of Justice—not that one should need any special reminder of that. We all realise that where you have people you must have order and you must have an acceptance of the code under which we operate, each man allowed his own freedom but asked not to contravene or impinge upon the freedom of others.
Again, listening and reading, one is reminded of the very unwelcome fact that notwithstanding the material advances which have been made, notwithstanding the extent to which man has succeeded in conquering his environment, known and unknown, there has been, unfortunately, not alone in Ireland but all over the world, a movement away from good and towards ill and wrongdoing. It would be wrong—this is something we should all ponder—to accept that any movement away from discipline is the key to social order, that any movement away from discipline is the key to human or community happiness. At a time when we should be concerned with positive proposals and with positive action, it seems unfortunate that we should be obliged to spend £12 million in forcing people to accept what was presented to them not in the last year, not in the last century, but many centuries ago, in simple commands given to a largely pagan people. I say this without sanctimony, without any special advocacy and uninspired with any idea of superiority. These commands were presumably the minimum and, notwithstanding all our material advances, we are all likely to expire hitting our heads against these simple commands.
Did I detect in certain contributions an anti-social note? Perhaps there is an obligation to express every point of view here; I concede that. In the situation in which we find ourselves there is an onus on the Government to ensure there are sufficient gardaí available in situations in which there are collective protestations. It is suggested that there is an onus on the Government to see that sufficient gardaí are available to look after those demonstrations, to look after those mobs but we have reached a point where we should cease looking after the alleged down-trodden and showing concern for the small minority and think more about the majority who are anxious to go about their business without injury to anybody. They are the people who are contributing most towards the payment of the officers we are asking to look after the mobs. The second point I would make is that we seem to be more concerned for the non-conforming minority than we are for the majority of righteous, respectable people in the community.
Deputy Bruton looks at me in pretended amazement. Presently, I shall develop my point to include the Deputy. The Deputy quoted a statement from an unnamed garda who said he was obliged to spend 15 or 16 hours a day on the streets of Dublin on the occasion of the NFA demonstration. The Deputy would have us accept and assume that the responsibility was the Government's. Some of it may have been, and perhaps there was a tragic lack of communication, but Deputy Bruton might also suggest to the NFA or to the Housing Action Committee, which he also mentioned, that they might consider making their protests in some way that would not require the eternal vigilance of the members of the gardaí about whom the Deputy is so concerned.
The Deputy also mentioned, and I was with him 85 per cent of the way, that the gardaí nowadays were being asked to carry out their duties under a code of regulations which was operating here when the police force was the force of the oppressor and the enemies of the people. We have not, apparently, considered that sufficiently and reminded people often enough that the gardaí are their friends. There is need for a better relationship between the gardaí and the people. There may be some problems there, such as in a situation like that which Deputy Enright mentioned, where you have the local garda sergeant visiting people in his barrack area. It may not be very easy for him if on the following day he has to carry out the law against such people. Yet, we should have done more to remind people that the gardaí are their friends. I suggest that in the teaching of civics in schools the teachers should bring in the local sergeant and members of the Force occasionally to have a chat with the children, tell them how they look after them and so on. Then we would not have the situation that when a garda is seen around a school one immediately wonders what window has been broken but we would see him there as a friend of the children and the community.
Deputy Bruton was concerned as I am about our delinquents. Having made the point that he was concerned earlier about senior delinquents he went on to speak about delinquents obliged, because of their delinquency, to spend some time in our institutions. I am also concerned about that delinquency but to suggest, especially when the information was available from a recent parliamentary question that on average, these delinquents spend four to five months in these institutions, and that, generally speaking, 35 per cent of them are neither educationally nor intellectually as advanced as they might be, that there is a responsibility on the Minister to introduce expertise and skilled personnel so that after the expiration of four months these boys could be released and put into worthwhile employment, is a rather ridiculous statement.
Comment on this
Yes, but I am talking about those who stay much longer and I am sure the Deputy would agree that employment is the best deterrent to crime and that if you can train them for employment they are less likely to commit crime.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy will concede that when the average student outside who, we can assume, is entitled to the same rights as a delinquent, takes two years or three years to prepare for a trade, it is a bit much to ask that we set up machinery whereby in four months we can prepare a retarded boy for employment.
Comment on this
Yes, but there is another 65 per cent who are not retarded. One could work wonders there.
Comment on this
On that score I would be in a slightly different position from Deputy Bruton. I have talked to these boys and for the past four years I have been endeavouring to do something extra on their behalf. Something extra is needed. From my experience most of the boys brought before the visiting committee for misdemeanour, when questioned about the work they were doing, invariably referred to the mat shop. I went to see the mat shop.
Comment on this
I would suggest that a psychiatric case or a boy not blessed with the same wisdom or understanding or mental balance as the rest of us, would not be improved by the mat shop. Some other alternative exercise might be used instead. On the other hand, we should mention that these boys have not been totally neglected educationally. There is a gentleman there who has his leaving certificate. Those of us who have degrees are perhaps too ready to look down our noses on people who have not but in my opinion this man has something which is much more important—he has teaching experience obtained elsewhere before he came into the service. The man with the leaving certificate and with teaching experience, having regard to the standard of boys in the institution, is a far better and much more suited teacher than some psychologists, psychiatrists or academics with degrees stretching from here to Connemara but who know very little about handling human beings.
Comment on this
That is a very reactionary statement. I do not believe that as a teacher the Deputy really believes this.
Comment on this
As a teacher I believe that the man who is trained to teach is a better man than the one who has just studied education.
Comment on this
As a teacher I believe the man who is trained to teach is much better than the person who has spent four years learning about education.
Comment on this
I thought, having regard to the interest which Deputies pretended to show in this matter, that they might have made inquiries in the proper place. I am telling you of my experience and opportunities will be given to others to make their case against mine. I am not entirely satisfied but we should give credit where credit is due. As far as the present holder of the office of Minister for Justice is concerned it has been my experience on the committee that he was the first Minister who made so much of the visiting committee as to bring them over to his office and talk to them about matters relating to the institution. We should also give credit to the city librarian of Dublin who has made suitable books available to these boys.
Regarding the matter of diet, I have seen what these boys get for breakfast, dinner and tea. Not so many years ago I saw men who were obliged to go out and work, men who were obliged to rear families, and the food they got was not very much, if at all, superior to the food now being given to the boys in the institution. I am not saying I am happy that it is the best we can do but we should not be too derogatory about the situation that now exists.
Comment on this
I am not the Minister. I should not like to see the place closed down until some other better place had been prepared.
Comment on this
The Minister has made a forward move in that he has acceded to the request of the committee in the matter of segregating the boys. We were not satisfied with the situation formerly where a criminal of 21 years could fraternise with a young boy of 16 years who was in for some minor offence. Another suggestion I would make to the Minister—I do not know what the views of others might be—is this; there is a big lack in the institution at the moment and that is the lack of women.
Comment on this
Most of the children in the institution come from homes that have been broken up, from homes where they did not enjoy the normal comforts, but it can be said that whatever homely comforts they had came from a mother. They are now in an environment completely surrounded by men and I do not think that psychologically it is good for them that they should not at some stage be able to go and chat to a lady. I think they would confide more in a lady than they would in a man.
Comment on this
I offer my opinions and I am sure that when my good colleague contributes to this debate he will suggest what kind of lady he would like to have there or elsewhere. I am not going to dwell any further on the institution except that in the matter of diet the Minister and other people have spoken about protein, starch, spuds and murphys. I would suggest in the matter of the presentation of the spuds they might be given to the boys in the fashion they have been accustomed to getting them—in the form of chips.
I shall leave the judiciary, the lawyers and solicitors to those who know more about it. One comment I shall make, with which I think everybody will agree, that whether the fault lies in this House or with the judges or lawyers, the ordinary man in the street still does not appreciate what the law is doing for him. He has a certain feeling, a certain dread sometimes bordering on suspicion, regarding the law and perhaps we should speak about the law in a fashion which the ordinary person will understand.
My final point refers to Deputy Bruton. I mentioned earlier that he was making a good case for all people who have been neglected in our community. He made a good case for members of the Garda Síochána; he suggested, and I agree with him, that they should have more money. He made a good case for the inmates of St. Patrick's and Mountjoy, for the psychiatric cases and for the psychopaths, for any other half-right type he could afford to mention. Before finishing, nevertheless, he mentioned one matter which disturbed me very much. He suggested it was not necessary, he thought, for a member of the Garda Síochána to be able to execute his duties in the language of this country, in one of the languages of this country. I quote from column 13 of the Official Report for 2nd December:
Mr. Tunney: Does the Deputy deny me my constitutional right to talk to a garda in the Irish language?
Mr. Bruton: I deny the Deputy the right to expect the garda to have to listen to him.
That was not enough. His foster-father joined him: "Hear, hear".
Comment on this
To me this is not a joke. There are people in this country who, without offending any law or requiring the gardaí to warn them in O'Connell Street, or who, without breaking a window or doing injury to anybody, have the feeling that most Irishmen have, that some day we may reach a position where the people of Ireland will be speaking the Irish language.
Comment on this
I am hoping there would not be any animosity or emotion about this, but in a situation where during the last few days we have been defending and making a case that every warped person in the country should be listened to—I concede we should listen to him—that we should go out of our way to listen to every statement that is made in this country——
Comment on this
——it is an extraordinary situation that you have members of the party who claim and hope that one day they will lead the people of Ireland standing up in this House and applauding and complimenting each other when one member says that his policy—and apparently the policy of the party—is that they will tolerate in this country every type except the type who will make so bold as to say that he should be allowed to voice his thoughts in the Irish language.
Comment on this
An bhfuil Gaeilge agat? Níl oiread agus focal agat.
Comment on this
He comes from a constituency into which Governments of this country have moved people from certain areas which were congested, uneconomic, where people could not live. Governments have moved people from these areas to Deputy Bruton's constituency. He has living in his constituency people who are not prepared to give full voice to their thoughts except through the medium of the Irish language and Deputy Bruton, representing them here—maybe it is because he resents their presence there——
Comment on this
Ar mhiste leat dá leanfainn? Deputy Bruton, representing these people, will deny them the right to go about their ordinary business in the Irish language.
Comment on this
The point is that I do not believe every garda should have the obligation to speak Irish. Perhaps he should in Irish-speaking districts, but I do not think it is fair to require that every garda, as a condition of his employment——
Comment on this
Tá a fhios againn nach bhfuil Gaeilge acu. Focal níl ag na daoine sin.
Comment on this
Ní fíor é sin. Níl le rá ag na Teachtaí thall ach: "Níl focal aige, níl focal aige".
Comment on this
Tá a fhios ag na Teachtaí gur thosnaigh mé i nGaeilge. Ar eagla go dtuigfí go raibh mé ag déanamh leithscéil, dúirt mé go raibh mé ag súil leis an lá nuair a bheimid go léir ag labhairt Gaeilge anseo. I do not hope, and I did not say so, that we can turn this House into an Irish-speaking assembly overnight. I am happy to concede that anybody who does not wish to speak or listen to Irish being spoken is personally entitled to say so if he desires. What I am concerned with is that Deputy Bruton and Deputy FitzGerald would deny to Irishmen the right to speak in the Irish language if they so desire.
Comment on this
I shall quote again from the debate on 2nd December:
Mr. Tunney: Does the Deputy deny me my constitutional right to talk to a garda in the Irish language?
Mr. Bruton: I deny the Deputy the right to expect the garda to have to listen to him.
Dr. FitzGerald: Hear, hear.
Mr. Geoghegan: Deputy Bruton should be ashamed of his remarks on the language of his country.
Mr. Bruton: I thank the Members of the House for their attempt to edify me in this matter.
Dr. FitzGerald: There is no need to thank them for their hypocrisy.
Comment on this
The Deputy may have a few pigs in his pocket.
Comment on this
Ability to speak Irish is not a requirement for entry to this House. Why, therefore, should it be a necessary requirement to be a member of the Garda?
Comment on this
Later that day, Deputy Bruton said, having stated that learning Irish is something which a garda should not have to do:
There are other duties which a garda has to fulfil and which are very detrimental to his morale.
For Deputy Bruton's information—I challenge it very much—the Garda look on the Irish language as something that would not be detrimental to their morale. In saying that he has done quite an injustice to the Garda force.
Comment on this
Or their morals, which? They would not know the difference.
Comment on this
I must say that I owe Deputy L'Estrange an apology. Earlier on I suggested that he had some hand in the NFA demonstrations which took place. He assured me in reply that he had not. I accept that and I credit him with perhaps a little more responsibility than I was prepared to do earlier on.
I sincerely hope that I have not done anything to injure a cause which I shall, in my own quiet way, I hope, as long as I remain a Member of the House, be advocating. It is not appropriate to this Estimate I know but I shall be quietly, unemotionally advocating the cause of the Irish language, advocating it in the hope that when we will all have it—and this would be the main reason why I would advocate it—there will be among us a greater family feeling, a feeling that we do not have at the moment, a family feeling which will help, among other things, to reduce the size of the Estimate for the Department of Justice.
Comment on this
My intervention in this debate will be very brief indeed. At the outset I should say that if this debate on the Estimate for the Department of Justice is known for anything it will be for the fact that so many irrelevant subjects were brought into it.
I had no intention of speaking on this Estimate but on Tuesday, 2nd December, at column 101 of the Official Report Deputy Lenehan from Mayo made reference to the fact that one Pat Donnellan——
Comment on this
I have a dozen of those letters here for the Deputy if he wants them.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants fun he will get it, I can assure him.
Comment on this
The Deputy had not got the gumption to interrupt me because he knew what I would give him.
Comment on this
At column 101 of the Official Report of 2nd December, Deputy Lenehan stated that one Pat Donnellan used the postage facilities which only Members of the Oireachtas are allowed to use. As the brother of that individual I feel it is my duty not to defend but to express my point of view on that. Deputies on the other side of the House are aware that every representative here gets some assistance from one individual or another with his correspondence. In the course of giving me a hand with my correspondence an envelope which should only be used for parliamentary purposes was used for a letter which was not connected with parliamentary business. Of course, there is no definite proof of that. Deputy Lenehan did not produce any concrete proof here that such an envelope was used——