Committee on Finance. - Vote 20—Office of the Minister for Justice (Resumed).
Contributions 322–492 of 492. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
There is not a dance hall owner in the west of Ireland who did not get one of them.
Comment on this
I have not a dance hall. If I had I would not be here. I would have more sense.
Comment on this
The Deputy said the letter was to a Mr. Y. I think Mr. T. would be more to the point. If such a thing happened that is exactly how it arose.
Comment on this
There are plenty of them. The Minister has a couple.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not capable of doing it, of course.
Comment on this
It would be very, very difficult indeed, when one thinks of it, to descend to the same standards.
Comment on this
I know the inside of your party. I told you Oliver Flanagan would leave and I told you Richie Ryan would leave you. I was right.
Comment on this
I left ye too and why not? You are the rottenest lot. I got out in time. I had enough sense.
Comment on this
For the record, the only people who smuggle in Donegal are Fianna Fáil people and when they get into trouble——
Comment on this
I have already pointed out to Deputy Harte that it is not parliamentary to sit on the steps and interrupt. At least he should get into his seat.
Comment on this
I accept that ruling, I will take my seat, but it is equally unparliamentary to allow Deputy Lenehan to continue to interrupt.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Deputy Lenehan accused the Deputy from Donegal of being a smuggler. Surely that should be retracted?
Comment on this
If he can prove that he is not a smuggler I will withdraw it.
Comment on this
I did not hear the remark but if Deputy Lenehan used the word he should withdraw it. The word "smuggler" is out of order.
Comment on this
If I made any remark that should be withdrawn, Sir, I withdraw it but I do not know whether I did or not. I will withdraw it anyway.
Comment on this
I accept the withdrawal from the Deputy but for the record I want to point out that any smuggling that takes place in Donegal is carried out by Fianna Fáil people and when they get into trouble they go to a Fianna Fáil Minister——
Comment on this
This is entirely irregular. If there is any smuggling done in Donegal it is done by the Deputy.
Comment on this
No, I have not. However, I choose to turn over the pages for the Deputy. I emphasise the words "turn over".
Comment on this
I cannot accuse the present Minister for Justice of injustice to any of my constituents but I have a case on hand in which his predecessor made a decision. There were two individuals and if necessary I will give the name of one of them. In my area once, just before Christmastime, the gardaí raided their houses and it was found that they had a certain quantity of potheen. One of them had a bottle of potheen in the house while the other had three-fifths of a glass of potheen in his possession. They were brought to court and each was fined £25. The man who had the three-fifths of a glass came to me and asked if I might appeal it to the Minister. I must say that it was not the present Minister who was then in office.
Comment on this
If the matter does not relate to the present occupant of the post it may not be raised.
Comment on this
I am referring to the administration of justice as it affects my constituents and, if I can develop the point, the Ceann Comhairle will realise that I am entitled to do so.
Comment on this
The Minister found no grounds for reducing the fine but, when the man who was fined £25 for having the bottle of potheen in his possession appealed to his representative, the fine was reduced to £4.
Comment on this
Oh yes, an excellent representative. The point I am making is that the individual who had the bottle of potheen was a Fianna Fáil supporter but the person who had only the very small quantity happened to be chairman of one of the Fine Gael branches. This shows how justice is administered in this country.
Comment on this
Do you only give three-fifths of a glass to the chairman? How much do you give to the secretary of Fine Gael?
Comment on this
Anyway, a Cheann Comhairle, I have made my point and I would hope that when we come to the Estimate for this Department this time next year nobody will be able to point a finger at the Minister and say that during his term as Minister for Justice he did any injustice to anyone regardless of class or creed.
Comment on this
I looked to both sides of the House when Deputy Donnellan had finished and, as nobody offered, I called the Minister.
Comment on this
On a point of order, if a Deputy wishes to contribute he should be called and the Deputy has offered.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not even see Deputy Donnellan sit down. He is like a puppet over there.
Comment on this
I am calling on the Minister to conclude. There must be some conclusion to the debate.
Comment on this
On a point of order, it was physically impossible for me to know when Deputy Donnellan sat down. I intended to make just a few points on this Estimate.
Comment on this
It is grossly unfair as far as I am concerned as a Member of this House and I wish to protest in the strongest terms.
Comment on this
I was elected by the people to put forward views to this House and I claim the same right as any other Deputy to do so but you are not allowing me that right.
Comment on this
I did offer and I ask the Minister, through the Chair, to allow me five minutes to make two points.
Comment on this
Would the Ceann Comhairle not agree that it was impossible for Deputy Harte to see that Deputy Donnellan had sat down?
Comment on this
I was unaware that Deputy Donnellan had concluded and I think it is very unfair that an elected representative, Deputy Harte, is not being allowed the same right as any other representative. The Chair is failing in its duty to administer fair judgment.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot make a speech on this occasion. The position is that when Deputy Donnellan concluded I looked to both sides of the House and, as no Deputy offered, I called on the Minister to conclude.
Comment on this
I accept that. How was I to know that Deputy Donnellan had concluded? Perhaps the Minister might allow me five minutes. This has been done before.
Comment on this
I only wish to make a suggestion. There will be no other speaker from Labour and, if Fine Gael can guarantee the same and if Deputy Harte sticks to his promise of five minutes, the Minister would not lose a lot by giving way.
Comment on this
This is a question for the Chair. I was watching and it is untrue to say that Deputy Harte offered when Deputy Donnellan sat down. I was on my feet having been called by the Ceann Comhairle and was speaking for a second or two before Deputy Harte offered.
Comment on this
I do not suggest it is the Minister's fault. There may have been a misunderstanding. Deputy Harte says all he wants is five minutes. There will be no other speaker from our party and I am sure there will be no other speaker from Fine Gael, if Deputy Harte says so.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish cannot speak for the Fine Gael Party. This is an attempt to keep me out when called on to speak. I propose to reply to the debate.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I was under the impression that once a Deputy offered a Minister had to give way to him.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it not a custom when a Deputy gets to his feet more or less simultaneously with the Minister that the Minister——
Comment on this
I am going to make my point of order and I am not going to be stopped. Is it not the custom, when a Deputy gets to his feet more or less simultaneously with a Minister or with a Member of another party who is replying to a motion, that the person replying is not called so as to leave the debate open?
Comment on this
The position is that Deputy Donnellan concluded his speech and resumed his seat. I looked to both sides of the House and, no Deputy having offered, I called on the Minister to conclude. If Deputy Harte had offered before the Minister or any other Deputy had offered, naturally I would have called him.
Comment on this
I might point out that the Chair, when he is acting in his capacity as Ceann Comhairle, automatically looks to the left and to the right but this is no indication that he was going to call on the Minister nor did I know that Deputy Donnellan had concluded.
Comment on this
I want to give you notice the next time I am deprived of my rights in this way I will sit out in the centre of that floor. I am giving you that notice to make sure I get my rights. Your rulings are partisan and extreme.
Comment on this
Is it proper to allow things to be said as were said just now to Deputy Harte? If the same remarks came from this side of the House you would take the necessary steps to reprimand the Deputy who expressed them.
Comment on this
This is a point of disorder. The Deputies are determined not to let me reply to the debate.
Comment on this
This debate, as I said, has ranged over a wide number of subjects but first perhaps I should make it clear that, in view of your ruling, Sir, the various references to the RTE television programme cannot be dealt with by me and consequently anything which has been said by Deputies in connection with it must go unanswered at this stage. In a way it was a pity that the further aspects of this Estimate were not given the same kind of consideration by some Deputies as that particular item. At all events, there were some quite interesting contributions in this debate on the different aspects of it and I will try and deal with them seriatim.
In the first instance there are a couple of things I want to get out of my way, or at least to get on the records of this House. Deputy T. F. O'Higgins made some personal references to me, some old, some new. First of all, I want to say for the record—and because I have the permission of the people concerned, I propose to name them—that on the Monday in question I was for approximately 2½ hours after lunchtime in the city of Galway when the High Court was in session, and Mr. W. B. Gavin, solicitor, Galway, and Mr. P. J. McEllin, solicitor, Claremorris, were appearing in cases and instructing counsel on behalf of the firm of Michael Moran and Company. Let me also say that of any cases of my particular firm which were before the High Court in Galway the only one contested was on Tuesday when I was not there at all. Counsel on that occasion was instructed on behalf of my firm by Mr. W. B. Gavin, solicitor. Those are the facts and I want to put them on the records of the House. Indeed, I am quite sure they were well known to Deputy O'Higgins when he raised this hare here. I will deal with why he raised it at a later stage.
However, Deputy O'Higgins was evidently hatching something else. He waited a long time, a period of four years, to make allegations on this Estimate concerning the solicitors in my local town deciding on a five-day week and saying that I strenuously protested about the firm I founded being closed on Saturdays because I was going to lose business. I want to put this on the records of the House, too. It is an unsolicited letter from those concerned:
Dear Mr. Ó Moráin,
I am surprised by the report quoted in today's Irish Times of Deputy O'Higgins's allegations on a meeting of Castlebar solicitors which took place in my office in 1965. I wish to confirm to you what occurred at that meeting. The meeting was called by me as Secretary of the Mayo Bar Association. It was held in my office and six Castlebar solicitors and yourself attended. The meeting was unanimous that all solicitors in Castlebar should close on Saturdays. You agreed to this but informed us that while your legal office would be closed for business on Saturdays you would have to use a section of your office to meet constituents from time to time on Saturdays. You explained that your assistant solicitor and office staff would not attend on Saturdays but that you might retain a receptionist to deal with constituents and telephone calls. At no time did you say or suggest that you wished to keep your office open on Saturdays for legal business. The five-day week was agreed on. I arranged to have display notices printed and the announcement that all solicitors' offices in Castlebar would be closed on Saturdays was published in three local newspapers. I further confirm that printed notices informing clients that your office would be closed on Saturdays have been and are on display in your Castlebar office.
This is for the records. This meeting of the Mayo Bar Association took place some four years ago and evidently Deputy O'Higgins was hatching out this attack that I was alleged to be trying to keep my office—incidentally the premises in which I live in the town of Castlebar—open on Saturdays for legal business. I have got to get the records straight as far as this goes.
Let me say, in passing, that the amount of business that any solicitor or anybody else does while occupying ministerial office or the amount of time indeed he has for it, and particularly depending on where his home is, is utterly negligible, irrespective of what the business may be. I cannot, however, pass by the fact that this sudden concern for the public conscience so lately took time to develop in Deputy O'Higgins. He did not see fit when he was a colleague of Deputy Pa O'Donnell in Government to remonstrate with Deputy Pa O'Donnell about opening a legal office convenient to the Custom House. I do not say that Deputy O'Donnell had much time to deal with that office either but I say that this pricking of Deputy O'Higgins's conscience on this issue took him a long time. He did not, I think, lose any night's sleep over advising Deputy Sweetman, who was then Minister for Finance, to close his firm or sell his interest in it.
It is very, very lately that Deputy O'Higgins developed this sudden concern about what business, if any, any Minister should be allowed to do. Speaking for myself, having to travel the distance that I have to travel, it is often once a fortnight and sometimes once a month that I manage to get down to meet my constituents. I do try to get down once a week since the Saturday closing. It is not so convenient for me to try to keep in touch with those who run my business as it was for those colleagues of Deputy O'Higgins when they were in government to do so here in Dublin. At all events, it is now quite clear that the reason Deputy O'Higgins was raising these hares and stirring up this mud was because he was probably hatching, in the same way as he was hatching for four years these allegations about the Castlebar solicitors, his attack on his own leader, which has now transpired, to knife him in the back with all the finesse of Tim Healy towards his leader, Parnell.
He was muddying the waters in this House trying to throw in these red herrings in order to cover up the attacks his friends were engaged in outside in order to cut the political throat of his own Leader. I believe they had gone so far as to buy the going-away silver for poor Deputy Cosgrave while Deputy O'Higgins was in here craw-thumping about a Minister's public duty. In any event, we had him here at length. We now know the reason for these diversionary tactics to which we were treated by Deputy O'Higgins.
The Deputy went on to refer to law reform and he said that he did not think the situation was such as to cry out for drastic or radical change. Well, nolimus mutari is a good old legal motto but it is not my motto, nor the motto of my party nor of the Government. There is need for change in the legal system and need for fundamental change and it is not today or yesterday that I said this. As long ago as July 1953, as an ordinary Deputy, I said that our entire legal system was unsuitable and that the quicker the House realised that the better it would be. I should like to refer to the Official Report for the Second Stage of the Courts of Justice Bill, 1953, for the 20th July where, at column 876, I said:
Those of us who have been connected with the legal profession have seen people beggared as a result of litigation. The sooner the two branches of the profession are amalgamated the more satisfactory the position will be and the easier it will be for our people to obtain justice. That will not necessarily mean the wiping out of one branch of the legal profession, as some people seem to fear. As happens under the American system, different men will specialise in different branches of the profession. The securing of justice is limited now by the size of a man's bank balance.
Earlier in the same speech I said:
The quicker we get the reforms for which our people are crying out the better it will be for the country.
It was as far back as 1953 that I advocated the decentralisation of the law. I strongly suggested that the cases that then came to Dublin should be heard at local venues and I pointed out that when the case comes on it is not only a question of lawyers but of medical experts, engineers, actuaries and other witnesses being dragged up to Dublin. There are now local sittings in the country of the High Court to hear original actions. The main reason for that was the persistent advocacy of the present Taoiseach when he was Parliamentary Secretary to the Government in 1954. It is certainly not due to the Bar Council who were strongly opposed to that proposal at that time. I hope to be able further to improve the position in the new Courts of Justice Bill to which I have referred and which I hope to have before the House early in the New Year.
Deputy O'Higgins referred to the reports of the courts committee and said that they were gathering dust in the Department of Justice. He said he did not believe that I had even read one of these reports. All that, of course, is quite untrue but the Deputy is not worried about making wild charges that he is unable to substantiate. In my opening Estimate speech on November 21st last I referred to the courts committee in detail and I said what was being done about the reports. The Deputy appears not to have read my speech, or if he did he chose for his own reasons to ignore it and the facts. He went on to mention a speech which, according to him, I made to the solicitors' apprentices in County Mayo. Again, the Deputy is wrong. The speech to which he referred was made to the Society of Young Solicitors and the General Council of Professional Solicitors at a seminar in Galway to which I was invited by the joint organisers.
Deputy O'Higgins tells us that traditionally the Executive in Ireland have sought to destroy and end the Bar and he mentioned the names, amongst others, of John Philpot Curran and Dan O'Connell, and he said that there were hundreds of others of the great Irish Bar who stood up to the Executive. Anybody who has read Irish history and pretends to try to put over this fairytale, that the Irish Bar in olden times stood up to the Executive, cannot expect people to accept that kind of twaddle. The fact is the opposite. From Peter the Packer up and down they were all timeservers. You would have to search the whole list of them with a fine comb to find anyone who stood up to the Executive and anybody who pretended to do so at the beginning always sold out at the end. The whole of Irish history is full of them. As far as quoting Curran's struggle——
Comment on this
As far as quoting Curran and his struggle for freedom is concerned, it would be accepted by most historians that his main claim to fame was through his daughter, Sarah, who was an embarrassment to Curran in his relationship with the Executive at that time.
Comment on this
The famous advocate was no sympathiser with the cause of Robert Emmet. As far as O'Connell is concerned, he was a very controversial figure. I give him his due for whatever he tried to do in his time but there are many people who took a very poor view of him. One person who took a very poor view of——
Comment on this
——the same gentleman was Mitchel. At all events, there was this to be said about O'Connell. Possibly it is difficult for us to understand the material he had to deal with, but one thing he always made sure of was that he got his pound of flesh for defending all and sundry whereever he went. That is an incontrovertible fact so far as the same good O'Connell is concerned, with all due respect to whatever he did for his people in those days. As for all the rest of them, you could search the pages of history of any country and you could not find a greater shower of timeservers for the Executive from this to Timbuctoo and I defy anybody who reads Irish history impartially to say otherwise. The facts are there. In each and every age down through the years as far as the Executive are concerned——
Comment on this
Pádraig Pearse was one, but he practised little and spent little time down in the Four Courts.
Comment on this
——who fell in the 1914-18 war. These were the kind of people always honoured down there. These were the kind of people fostered down there. These were the kind of people who, from the very word "go" looked for and got their price from the Executive. Indeed, one of the very last of them that comes to my mind is the good Serjeant Sullivan—and it had to take an Irishman to complete the slander of a great Irishman, Roger Casement—and he was a timeserver. His standing-up to the Executive was to rush up in 1916 in his car and report for service at the Castle. Read his own reminiscences and what he has to say himself about our people; about our martyrs and about the same Roger Casement. He certainly stood up to the Executive in the right way. He stood up to them for every penny he could get out of them. As far as this nation is concerned, they will never raise any monuments to him, anyhow, or never will consider him in the way they consider men of the standard of Roger Casement. So, when Deputy O'Higgins——
Comment on this
Is it in order for the Minister to attack and traduce in this manner people whose names are honoured in their profession and in Irish history? He is attacking the late Serjeant Sullivan many of whose kinspeople live in this country at the moment. I think it is grossly unfair and unwarranted by anything said in the debate. That is a point of order.
Comment on this
Read what he said himself in this book which I have in my hand. The truth is bitter and Deputy O'Higgins cannot take it.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins treated this House to a sermon on the wonderful service that members of the Irish Bar, down through the ages, gave to our people and how they stood up to the Executive. I am pointing out the way they stood up to the Executive. I am pointing out how 99 per cent of them sold out the people to the Executive for filthy lucre—and that is their history. When Deputy O'Higgins tries to give his version of Irish history as fact in this House he certainly is entitled to be answered.
Now I want to come along to the question of a unified profession. I think I should put on record exactly what I said in Galway because Deputy O'Higgins seems again either not to have read my speech or to have misquoted it. I said:
In considering the jurisdiction of the courts, we must take account of the fact that membership of the Common Market may become a reality in the not too distant future.
Comment on this
I continued:
In Continental countries, the administration of justice is local and not central. Also, lawyers are not divided into solicitors and barristers, the legal profession being, for all practical purposes, a unified profession. The same is true in the United States. It is important to remember that one of the fundamental concepts in the Common Market is that lawyers of one member State may practise in the courts of any other member State. The idea of a unified profession should get far more thought in this country. I believe that unification should be our ultimate goal. We have inherited a legal system here that was designed to serve a very wealthy country and that, in my view, is in many respects suited neither to our means nor to our traditions. In England the division between barristers and solicitors is due to historial accident. Indeed at one time it appeared that there might be three or even four branches of the legal profession instead of two.
I make no apologies for saying that. What I said was factually accurate. I was addressing people who are interested in these questions. I wanted to get them talking about it. I suggested what in my view should be the ultimate goal. I was very glad to hear tonight from Deputy Enright on the Fine Gael Benches——
Comment on this
——that he welcomed some of the suggestions I made in that particular speech. I was very interested to listen to the contribution of that young Deputy.
Comment on this
As I was saying, I welcome Deputy Enright's objective contribution here tonight. He obviously read—unlike Deputy O'Higgins—my Galway speech. He disagreed with certain portions of it, for his own reasons which he gave. It is a good thing that men like him should discuss this matter. It would be a good thing if both branches of the legal profession would discuss this matter—a discussion on this matter is, I think overdue—to get rid of what, in my view, is an anachronistic system which does not suit us or suit our people The day will come, whether or not conservatives like it, when the ordinary citizen will refuse to pay an array of four lawyers where one would do. I think that is commonsense. It is absurd to say—it has been argued here by Deputy O'Higgins—that, having one special examination or one special degree, as suggested by me would be an imposition on legal students. He forgets that what I suggested in Galway—whether he read what I said at all I do not know—was that there would be one degree common to all kinds of lawyers. They could specialise however if they wished having got this degree and, if that were done, it would knock the ground completely from under this suggestion by Deputy O'Higgins, used as a special plea here for the sake of his own argument, that, in addition to whatever training they get now in Kings Inns, they would also have to do this degree.
I never suggested any such thing What I am suggesting is that it would be unnecessary to provide the training these students get in Kings Inns or the training the other students get in the Incorporated Law Society, if you had this common degree and common training for them. That is commonsense. Those with whom I have spoken, in the main—naturally there are disagreements on questions of this kind— received what I said very favourably, and discussions which have gone on since my Galway speech show that what I said was received very favourably by the vast majority of those concerned.
Deputy O'Higgins does not speak here for the Irish Bar. He speaks for Deputy O'Higgins and he frightens no one, particularly me, when he tells us he is a bencher of the Kings Inns. I have had letters from barristers and from some senior counsel who profoundly disagree with what they consider to be our outmoded system of training for lawyers and who have advocated—indeed, long before I did in some cases—legal reforms of this kind.
The English system of dividing work between solicitors and barristers has been likened to the civil law division of work between a notary and other lawyers. However, there is not much likeness at all. In dealing with the French notaries I must point out that a notary in France is an official publicly appointed who receives acts and contracts that people are required by law to have authenticated. In practice, he is really a conveyancer. In Germany, the notary who drafts and seals deeds, makes wills, and so on, is also publicly appointed. In many parts of Germany he is also a practising attorney. Perhaps, I should also say that in Germany, so far as my inquiries go, the cost for the employment at any stage of more than one attorney is never allowed and is never taxable, whereas all these people are taxable here.
If unification of the legal profession in some form is to be the ultimate goal, as I believe it should be, it must be examined in the context of a decentralisation of the administration of justice. Deputy O'Higgins said that I have not consulted the courts committee. As long ago as February, 1965, a detailed memorandum dealing, inter alia, with the organisation of the legal profession, the right of audience of solicitors in the various courts, and the number of counsel allowed for taxation on party and party costs, was submitted to the courts committee by my predecessor. The Deputy should check on his facts before making his allegations here.
He should also get it into his head that I will not accept that, before I speak on any subject that comes within the ambit of the Minister for Justice, I must first consult either the Bar Council or the Incorporated Law Society. The House may be interested to know that, as I have said, my speech in Galway was favourably received by those present, including representatives of the Incorporated Law Society. I have my job to discharge as Minister for Justice irrespective of the two trade unions concerned, that is, the Incorporated Law Society on the one hand, and the Bar Council on the other.
I am concerned with the position of the ordinary man and woman, and how the law affects them. I believe that this system needs reform. I believe that it must be reformed and, if the good Lord spares me, I propose to reform it. I propose to have legislation put before this House very early in the coming year towards that end and in which I will propose to increase substantially the jurisdiction of the lower courts and also provide rights of audience for solicitors in all courts.
On the matter of legal education, Deputy O'Higgins referred to my remarks in Galway as being rubbish but he did not mention the recommendation of the Commission on Higher Education, the Chairman of which is the Chief Justice. It said that if the law societies wish the universities to participate in the general training of lawyers they should be prepared to prescribe a university degree as an essential qualification. This whole matter has now been submitted to the Higher Education Authority and, as I have already stated in this House I am urging, through the Minister for Education, that the authority should deal with the matter as soon as possible.
These are the facts about my statements, which are now matters of public record, to those whom I addressed in Galway and I make no apologies to anybody for what I stated there. It is high time that these practices, some of them restrictive practices coming down to us from very long ago, were done away with in our society for the purpose of giving a better service to our people and for the purpose of cheapening the cost of litigation. I believe the reforms suggested by me will have these end results.
Let me point out that the practice in the neighbouring country, that is, in England, with which I am fairly familiar—at least as familiar as any other practitioner in this country down through the years—is very very different from ours as far as representation is concerned. I have had experience of cases of migratory workers who met with very serious injuries over there, cases that would be regarded as very heavy cases here running up to £8,000 or £10,000 in damages, as lawyers would say, and I have never seen, in Manchester or London, more than one junior counsel being instructed to deal with any of those cases. Here we would have an array of counsel, at least two seniors and a junior in all these cases.
I have seen a case which, if the plaintiff were successful, would undoubtedly be on its way to the House of Lords on a question of an unsafe system of work before Lord Justice Saxe in London. It went on for something like seven or eight days. Junior counsel were operating on both sides. This was a case, as I have said, which, if the plaintiff were successful, would mean thousands of pounds to the insurance companies concerned because if the plaintiff succeeded in his contention it would mean that there would have to be a handrail on every girder on every building which he might have to cross while it was going up. In that case which went on for that length of time there was one junior counsel on each side.
It is held out to us here that under our system there is nothing wrong in having two seniors and a junior in almost every High Court case. Having regard to the limited resources of the kind of people with whom we deal in this community, I want to point out what is happening in actual practice in the courts of our very wealthy neighbour across the Irish Sea. In cases where large amounts of money are involved, it is unheard of to have the array of counsel which is our practice to have here. I agree that it is part of our system but that is why I believe our system must and should be changed. It is all right, of course, for the poor man, the plaintiff in the case; if everything is going all right for him. He could not care less if there are two or 20 counsel but if something goes wrong for him and you have one counsel who has just looked in for the first day and has not been seen for the rest of the case, the instructing solicitor will be hearing something about the missing man whose fees are running up like the meter on a taxi. This is a situation which, in the interests of all concerned, should not be allowed to continue. If those concerned are sensible, this matter can be remedied.
If we aim at the ultimate goal, then, as I have pointed out already, people can specialise in one field or another and at least there will not be, as there are now in many instances, two, three or four lawyers where possibly one would do. Deputy Enright thinks that this system would not be suitable for us. It may take time to evolve but what I have suggested is that it is high time that those concerned with this system had a look at the matter. It is high time that they forgot the days of Charles Dickens and looked at modern society as we see it and the way the law is operating in other countries. Let us get down to giving the training and education for a profession that will give the best service to our people and be within reasonable reach as far as costs are concerned.
I know there can be a divergence of view on these matters. I also know that in Scotland, where you have local courts which in contract and in tort have unlimited jurisdiction, it would be unheard of to bring in, for instance, an array of counsel from Edinburgh or any counsel at all. An ordinary local lawyer, whether you call him an attorney or a solicitor, operates in the courts there, not necessarily the senior member of the firm either. The Scots had evolved their own system long before the British got hold of them, and it has worked very successfully to this day.
Comment on this
Exclusiveness in the Bar is on the way out, and exclusiveness in many other closed shops should be on the way out also. I have no evidence nor do I believe that the solicitors' profession or the legal profession in Scotland is a closed shop. The business here has been far more of a closed shop on both sides, and the time has come when, if the professions do not do it, the Dáil should initiate reforms for which the people are crying out.
This has not been my view merely since I came into this office. I put on the records of the House away back in 1953 what I thought about this problem, and in those days I was speaking as a person who had certainly some experience of the working of our system here. I would say that I had as much experience as most people of my age in this field. I put those views on the record of this House away back in 1953, and I have seen nothing in my experience since to change those views. In so far as I can get the House to go along with me I propose to implement these views. That is not to say that all the objectives that I set out in my Galway speech can be achieved overnight. I laid down what I considered should be guidelines. I wanted discussion on this, and there is no suggestion that I want to wipe out anybody overnight, but I think that the people in the legal profession and particularly the people at the Irish Bar are asleep if they think that this system can continue as it is for ever, and in particular they are asleep if they cannot see that if as now seems probable we will be in the Common Market in a short time, other people will have the right to practise here. Exclusiveness will be gone, and many of those closed shop ideas in the legal profession will have to go as well— things like keeping the solicitors' profession closed by allowing a solicitor to take only one apprentice. That should be abolished altogether. There should be no such thing as the present method by which solicitors are turned out, what I call this unfortunate legal slaughter of turning out young solicitors without any training. They cannot get get an opportunity of becoming proficient at their profession under the present system. They have to do lectures under the Incorporated Law Society. They have to do separate examinations under the Incorporated Law Society. They have to do lectures at the National University, irrespective of whether they do a degree or not, and pass examinations of the National University as distinct from those of the Incorporated Law Society. During all this going around from Billy to Jack they are supposed to attend at their master's office, that of the solicitor who employs them, and get a practical knowledge of their profession. It is utterly impossible and, as everyone knows, they do not get the proper opportunities. The result is that when they get these various examinations and qualify they come out utterly unfitted from a practical point of view for legal work until they serve wholetime as practising solicitors in some office.
Under this system we are getting the worst of both worlds, in both branches of the legal profession, the worst in the solicitors' profession and the worst in the barristers' profession. It is time that these two branches aimed at the one goal. I think the situation will come here as in the United States of America where there is no differentiation between solicitors and barristers. You may have one group specialising in one particular line, and another group in another particular line. As to the suggestion by a young Deputy here tonight that this would lead to all kinds of amalgamations, let me point out that at this time there are many legal offices in this city that could only be described as law factories. They have been drawing men away from the country because for some time there has been a great dearth of qualified solicitors. Solicitors also have been going into other businesses. Many of them have switched from the practice of the law to other fields, to work as company executives and so on. With the increase in economic activity in this country over the last number of years there has been a vast increase in the work of legal firms particularly here in this city, and it is fast coming to the stage where you will have some old name like the long ago Smith, Smith, Smith, Jones and Smith and company on the outer door and inside the office door names that never appeared on that outer door. This is the way matters are developing. The fears expressed by Deputy Enright as far as the amalgamation of the big offices are concerned are now real, but in my view what has happened in Dublin is not in any way going to affect the ordinary capable man—provided he is a capable man—from building up his own practice in a particular part of the country. The more complex legislation becomes the greater will be the need for trained men in the legal field. As I have already said, there is a scarcity of competent men at the moment, even in State departments. I know from official dealings with the Land Registry that they cannot fill many of the vacancies for solicitors there or in the Chief State Solicitor's office. They are, in fact, trying to train men to specialise in one particular field in order to meet the needs of the time.
As I have said, the days of restrictions, closed shops and high fees for apprenticeship should be wiped out. I do not think there is any harm in learning by the experience of other countries and we could well emulate the Scottish system whereby the prospective lawyer studies for his degree and takes the prescribed examination. In other words, he does his theory first and then spends two or three years working as a solicitor in a solicitor's office, during which time he is paid an annual salary. This idea of chasing round from one place to another is a relic of Dickensian days. I think we should bring some order into the training of our legal students in each branch of the profession. This would ensure, at a great saving to the parents of those involved, that not alone would we turn out better trained people but that we would turn out people who would know what they are at. Young doctors have to serve a year as interns in a hospital after they have qualified and in the same way the young legal student could concentrate on theory until he gets his degree and then—and only then—he could acquire practical experience by working with a solicitor for two or three years. He would, of course, be paid enough on which to live during this time.
These are the desirable aims towards which we should proceed, and they are being considered by the Higher Education Authority. I know they would welcome the views of all bodies in this particular connection. One thing of which I am sure is that we cannot live in the 1847 position and expect it to serve our needs. I believe all thinking people—except the most ultra-conservative in this field who hate change and hate interference with their privileges—know that this is a field which is crying out for reform. My Galway speech sought to get those concerned with reforms to consider these matters. Again, I would like to emphasise that I did not say I was going to legislate without consulting in full with particular sections of the profession. What I did say was that unification should be the ultimate aim. I know some reasonable men in the legal profession have welcomed what I have said because I have had letters from them; and they recognise the need for change just as well as I do. I do not think the Higher Education Authority will be swayed one way or the other by my view. I have my own views and I am entitled to express them. I do believe the Higher Education Authority will be glad to hear my views and the views of those concerned. I hope men in both branches of the profession will work towards the aim of the common good. I believe there are many such men in both branches of the profession who will consider these matters impartially to try to aim at the goal I have set— the ultimate unification of the legal profession.
Deputy Fitzpatrick has alleged that the Garda has not the men, equipment or time to enforce the 60 mph general speed limit. I should like to place on record the fact that the 60 mph general speed limit was introduced on the 1st April last and in the six months from April to September 912 prosecutions for exceeding the limit were brought by the Garda; and in addition, cautions were administered in 527 cases where the limit was exceeded only by a small margin. These offenders must be travelling at least between five and eight miles more than the limit before they can properly be checked by the radar before there is the necessary proof to bring the offenders before the courts. I should like to point out that the Garda have not been ignoring the matter. This is a new law and the Garda were instructed to give people a warning— as in the case of every new law—in order that the public could get used to it. The Garda were asked to warn in many cases and try to get people to accept that 60 mph was the limit. It was only in the bad cases that prosecutions were taken. The Deputy was not quite correct in alleging that nothing has been done about this matter.
It is true that with the multiplicity of duties in these times it is difficult for the Garda to keep check on everything, but this particular part of their duties has not been neglected. The speed traps are changed from area to area from time to time and I believe this is a good thing. They become much more effective when they are changed from one road to another, and from one stretch to another, because the deterrent to all motorists—and, indeed, to all those who break the law —is, in my view, as I have said recently in the House, not so much the question of the penalty or the fine but the fear of being caught. If the motorists who are inclined to offend against this law have the feeling that there is a Garda car with radar checking on them, which could be parked any place on their journey, they are much more inclined to watch their speed and keep within the limit.
Deputy Fitzpatrick dealt also with prison conditions and the courts and what I suggested about them. I shall not cover the same ground again as far as the Deputy is concerned. There is one point with which I shall deal but I will get around to it when I come to deal with a matter raised by another speaker.
Deputy Pattison mentioned the increase in the number of armed and unarmed robberies. Other speakers dealt with this matter also. It is a matter of great concern and while the figures available show some increase in these crimes the commissioner assures me there is no reason to think that there has been any serious deterioration. Some increase is to be expected as part of the general world-wide upward trend in crime. Deputies can be assured that the problems presented by crimes of violence against person and property are being vigorously tackled. When bank robberies occur they get very wide publicity. When the culprits are caught they do not get the same publicity at all. It very often happens in these cases that the Garda have certain evidence, but it is insufficient to bring the wrongdoers to book, and they can only wait and hope that they will get their men ultimately.
One speaker here this evening criticised gardaí being stationed at crossroads, the allegation being that they are useless there. The Deputy misunderstands the reason behind this. We are living in the days of fast getaway cars, mainly stolen cars, and, in our situation, it is all too easy for miscreants to get across the Border. Because of that road blocks have to be set up. The gardaí send out an all-station call for all cars to be observed. In some instances they know the miscreants are confined within a circle and, in certain circumstances, the circle is proving very effective. It is vital on these occasions to have gardaí stationed at crossroads so that they can observe the passing cars and, perhaps, identify them. It does not necessarily follow that the garda is there on his own, as I think the Deputy thought, for the sole purpose of apprehending the getaway car; he is there as part of a planned chain to deal with escapees, with their loot, and to observe where they are heading. This is all part of an overall plan. The plan is checked against practical results after each raid. The system is being perfected but I cannot, of course, go into details for obvious reasons. In the main the Garda are satisfied that the system is fairly effective. The very fact of the Garda knowing that those concerned in a particular robbery are still around and about, and possibly gravitating towards their usual haunts in the city, is of considerable assistance to the Garda. These "isolated" gardaí are there for a particular purpose and a very useful one.
Deputy Pattison complained that I made only a passing reference to road safety, traffic accidents and congestion. He suggested these are matters for which the Minister for Justice should accept complete responsibility. It is the Minister for Local Government who has overall responsibility in these matters. The Garda Síochána have responsibility for enforcing traffic laws. They compile statistics of road accidents. A new system, as I explained, is being introduced in regard to the compilation of statistics, formerly done by the Garda Síochána through the Central Statistics Office; this is now being undertaken by An Foras Forbartha. The Garda are, of course, concerned about road safety. But this is primarily a matter for the Minister for Local Government. The Garda co-operate with those interested in road safety, in publicising it and giving lectures on it and in helping to create a good healthy public opinion which I believe will in the long run be the most effective deterrent to those who misuse our roads.
Deputy Desmond spoke about the need for supervisory protection for children during the probationary adoption period. He suggested there should be supervision by the local authority during this period. As the Deputy knows, practically the entire burden of adoption work is carried out by voluntary charitable organisations registered as adoption societies. These societies provide food, shelter and care for unwanted children and seek and find adoptive homes for them. An Bord Uchtála has statutory responsibility for supervising adoption societies and dealing generally with adoptions. The law allows the Adoption Board to avail themselves of the services of trained children's officers employed by local authorities, except in Dublin and areas adjacent in which they consider their own inspectors more suitable to do this work. The only difference the introduction of the local authority into the system would make is that the reports of the local authority inspectors would be submitted to, or through, the local authority rather than direct to the board. Such a change would not improve the system in the slightest degree. Indeed, it would have several serious disadvantages. I would recommend the Deputy to read the debate both here and in the Seanad when the Bill was being discussed in 1964. Both the Adoption Board and adoption societies are conscious of the need to ensure that the safeguards undertaken in connection with adoption are kept under constant review.
Reference was also made by the Deputy to the tragic case in Waterford some time ago. The placement in that case was made by a registered adoption society. The tragedy occurred before any question of making an adoption order arose.
Comment on this
There was inspection. Let me say that, in this particular case, when it was investigated by the Adoption Board, the particular society were found in no way to blame for what had happened.
Comment on this
There was an inspection. The facts were that the priest concerned knew the people involved for a very long time and was quite satisfied with them.