We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Nomination of Members of Government: Motion.

Contributions 774–977 of 1,547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 8 parts.

Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Coughlan.

Comment on this

A charge was made against me by this Deputy that I condoned and encouraged violence in Limerick in my position as Mayor of Limerick. Nothing could be further from the truth. I said in my opening statement when I was asked to comment——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is making a statement now.

Comment on this

——that I did not condone violence.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is making a statement He will have an opportunity of speaking.

Comment on this

I demand that the Chair call on this Deputy to withdraw the allegation; it is completely false and unfounded.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has no way of controlling Deputies making political charges in the Chamber. The Chair deprecates this but Deputies can make their own denials in their own time.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it not the accepted procedure in this House that if a Deputy against whom a charge is made says it is false that the speaker withdraws the remark?

Comment on this

On a point of order, will the Deputy who alleged that the speaker told a confounded lie be asked to withdraw that remark?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, is there any truth in the rumour that Deputy Cunningham is in the running for a parliamentary secretaryship?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

These are not points of order. The normal procedure in the House is that when a Deputy states that a statement made is not true then normally that is accepted. If a Deputy states that a statement is a lie he is not thereby imputing that the individual who quoted it is a liar. He says it is a lie. That is what the Chair understood.

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Deputy to say that what Deputy Meaney alleged is a lie?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

What the Deputy said was in reply to an accusation; he said it was a lie. This is what the Chair understood the Deputy to say.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is no wonder that Deputy Cunningham has had to wait so long for promotion. He does not even know the rules.

Comment on this

We do not like to discuss people individually because the Dáil is the place where one discusses party policy. However, we on this side of the House have since early morning listened to attack after attack under privilege of this House on our Ministers and Deputies——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And ex-Ministers——

Comment on this

And we are proud of them. This is a united party. The Fine Gael Party are sorry for themselves——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is the Taoiseach proud of them?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is not going to permit interruption of the Deputy in possession.

Comment on this

We are a party who will go into the lobby and vote together. The only regret in the Fine Gael Party is that the pro-O'Higgins group have lost the opportunity to unseat Deputy Cosgrave at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis which will take place in the near future. Some of the Deputies in Fine Gael know that he is getting a little too strong and they are sorry that he is not in a weaker position. Many of the Fine Gael Deputies have been trying to tell us that it was he who really forced the Taoiseach's hand in this case. The Taoiseach knows what is happening and, as happens always between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael were a fortnight behind with the news.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): £2,500 a year would make you vote for anything.

Comment on this

No. I was taught to stand for a principle.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

What principle?

Comment on this

The Republican principle.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Which Republican principle?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy Collins resume his seat?

Comment on this

Why does he not resign like Deputy Paudge Brennan did?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy L'Estrange cease interrupting?

Comment on this

I would suggest that the cement strike be settled as soon as possible to plug the broken walls around here.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange has come in here as usual. We all know by now what he is, the muck spreader of the Fine Gael Party. He says that we on this side of the House have committed treason and so on, but he is the man who when he was disposing of his farm did not offer it to the Land Commission. It was the same as selling his birthright for gold.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Deputy is completely wrong. I sold my farm and bought another. I offered the farm to the Land Commission, but the man who bought the farm paid only 5 per cent——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will have an opportunity of speaking later.

Comment on this

Therefore, Fianna Fáil must not have looked upon him as a foreigner.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy L'Estrange please resume his seat.

Comment on this

I offered my farm to the Land Commission——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Land Commission had no money to buy it.

Comment on this

——so the Deputy can withdraw that falsehood.

Comment on this

I will not withdraw it. It is a fact. He sold it to a private individual maybe for £25 more instead of giving it to the Land Commission to divide among smallholders. I put it to the Deputy: did he for the sake of a few pounds——

Comment on this

I offered it to the Land Commission but they did not buy it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is irrelevant.

Comment on this

There is a great deal of talk about this side of the House being in disarray, but we can state emphatically we are not in disarray. We are not here just for a month or a year but for the rest of this term. We are not afraid to face the people. If we have any difficulties, we are well able to resolve them. We have in our Taoiseach an honest man, a man with the highest reputation.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must be allowed to make his contribution.

Comment on this

It is getting funny now.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies must not interrupt.

Comment on this

Our Taoiseach has the highest ability. He has the best reputation of any politician in this country and the people as a whole look up to him. He is well fitted to lead this nation. Having regard to all the personal attacks that have been made I should like to refer to an incident which occurred when we were voting for the appointment of Deputy Des O'Malley as a member of the Government a few nights ago. A scene occurred the like of which was never seen in this House before. While I was acting as teller Deputy Paddy Belton made a personal attack on me, using obscene language. That should not be tolerated. He is a member of a party who claim they can run the country in a proper manner, but the people will never give them a mandate. They can talk away for the rest of the night but we know we can defeat them tonight and when we go to the country in 1973.

Comment on this

It is quite noticeable by the tone of the speakers on the other side of the House that they do not want to go to the country. It was particularly noticeable on Wednesday night last when they succeeded in bringing in three Ministers and a Parliamentary Secretary who tried to convey to the people that all was well in the Fianna Fáil camp. That was a desperate attempt to paper over the cracks in Fianna Fáil.

This night reminds me very much of our history of many years ago when this State was being founded. Late nights were spent here by Ministers because it was too dangerous for them to leave this House. They remained firm because they had a job to do, to establish this State and to establish law and order. Those men who spent long hours here, as we are doing here tonight, achieved their purpose. A crisis has arisen here and the party on this side of the House are here to emphasise the danger in the attempt which was made at gun-running by men who were Ministers only a few days ago.

News got to the people throughout the country at 7.30 or 8 o'clock on Wednesday morning that two Ministers had been asked to resign by the Taoiseach. Everyone is convinced now that Deputy Moran was also asked to resign. The Fianna Fáil Party may say what they like, but the people took a very serious view of the announcement and became very suspicious of the conduct of the Government they had elected with one of the biggest majorities of any Government yet elected. Naturally enough the electorate were disappointed. They were promised all sorts of benefits; prosperity was around the corner, but ten months after the election this is what they were told, having suffered the shock of a server Budget about a week ago, a Budget that was introduced by a Minister who could not appear in the House.

Saddened as the people were on hearing such serious news it was a consolation to them that such a discovery was brought home to the Taoiseach and that it was on the advice of the leader of the Opposition that those two gentlemen had been told they would have to leave office. Nearly 50 years ago Deputies were in this House until 4 and 5 o'clock in the morning. Fifty years later another leader of our party is responsible for the Dáil being in session last Wednesday and tonight. That goes to show the sincerity of the party to which we belong.

I think, and the public think, that the Taoiseach should have moved far more quickly. This State was given a Garda force and an Army second to none. The people have the greatest confidence in the Garda force and in the Army, the Garda established by General Eoin O'Duffy and the National Army established by General Michael Collins. It is too bad that the Taoiseach should have remained silent in regard to information of a serious nature, without taking drastic action and getting to the root of the trouble, until at 8 o'clock Deputy Cosgrave told him that, if he did not move, the matter would have to be made known to the Dáil the following day. Then at 10 o'clock two Ministers were relieved of their offices. That is a very serious thing to have happened. That is not the way in which the people of the country should be treated. The people treated Fianna Fáil generously and appreciation was not shown.

The people wondered why more changes were not made in the Budget. They now realise why there was not some effort made to redress the balance of payments position. They now know that there was trouble in the camp and that the easiest thing for the Minister for Finance to do was simply to double the turnover tax and to give some small increases in social welfare payments and in the beef subsidy scheme. There it ended. It was, as Deputy Tully described it, a lazy man's budget. It was not that the man was lazy; it was that there was trouble in the camp and he had other things on his mind.

Fianna Fáil must realise that the people are becoming suspicious of them. For 12 or 18 months past throughout the country banks have been raided and the raiders got away. There was an attempt made at pursuit but no arrests were made and there were no prosecutions.

Recently a young garda was shot dead in a Dublin street. There was a great hue and cry. Nothing came of it. The people are becoming very suspicious of the Government. I do not wish to detract from the Garda Síochána or the Army in any way. About a week ago the Minister for Justice, following an incident in a hotel in the city of Dublin, went into hospital and shortly afterwards tendered his resignation. That and the other things I have mentioned arouse suspicion.

Law and order is breaking down throughout the country. If an ordinary person is discovered with firearms or if somebody in a quiet rural area fails for any reason to have his gun licensed. he is summoned and severely reprimanded and may have to surrender his gun.

The people are now very anxious to know what action will be taken in regard to the two Ministers who have been relieved of their offices. The Taoiseach, being the honest man that he is or supposed to be, did not relieve those two gentlemen of their Ministries without very good reason. The country is inclined to the view that the Taoiseach would have tried to get over the problem without dismissing those Ministers had it not been for Deputy Cosgrave.

It is time that Fianna Fáil got out. It is noticeable that they do not want to get out. I do not blame them because Fianna Fáil could not go to the country and ask the people for their support in present circumstances.

Fianna Fáil have succeeded in getting 75 Members returned to this House. Fianna Fáil worked hard for the last number of years. Many of them worked hard in their own interests. The information available today is that some of them have become very wealthy men. That is a sad thing to have to say. When the people put their confidence in those gentlemen that confidence should not have been betrayed. The persons concerned should justify that confidence. They should live on the salaries provided. When men become millionaires, go into the million bracket in the course of ten or eleven years, the public become suspicious. The privileges and the power that those Ministers had were used in order to accomplish wealth through the purchase of land and the purchase of property. That is something that should not happen. People have told me what they see going on around this city and in many parts of the country.

If Fianna Fáil were to go to the country today there would be no doubt whatsoever as to the result. The result would be a change of Government and the affairs of the country would be put into the hands of men who would be capable of dealing with them. They would be put into the hands of the sons and daughters of some of those men who sat here in this House, as we are doing tonight, so that the safety of this country would be ensured. That is something of which we are proud on this side of the House. The very fact that it should be a son of the late President William T. Cosgrave who was responsible for bringing this matter to light is something that proves beyond all doubt that the Fine Gael Party, whether in Opposition or in Government, have the very same fundamental interest in the affairs of this nation.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

I, like every other Fianna Fáil speaker in this debate, am fully behind our Taoiseach, Jack Lynch, and the policies being carried out by the present Fianna Fáil Government. I know that Fianna Fáil is the only party capable of running this country. I believe in the policies of Fianna Fáil. My constituents in South Kerry want Fianna Fáil to remain in office because they, too, know that Fianna Fáil is the only party capable of running the country. Fianna Fáil is synonymous with Ireland.

We have heard in this debate character assassinations. We have heard vilification of ex-Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Government. I say, without fear of contradiction, that we are proud of these men and what they have done for Fianna Fáil and for Ireland.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Is the Taoiseach proud of them?

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

I represent Republican South Kerry. No one will silence the voice of Kerry in this debate. We entered the last general election knowing full well the smear campaign that would be carried on by the Opposition Parties and we had the smear campaign against the Taoiseach and his Ministers.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Will the Deputy particularise?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy Collins cease interrupting?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I only want clarification.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will permit no clarification. The Deputy in possession will be allowed to speak. Others can speak in their turn. The Chair again appeals to Deputies on both sides of the House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

When will Deputies have any respect for the Chair? When will Deputies co-operate with the Chair in trying to conduct this debate?

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

We carried out a very successful election campaign despite the allegations and the accusations made in this House just as in the last few days and we came back with 75 Deputies, an overall majority. It must be remembered that there were allegations that we would have a mini-Budget.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

We had gun-running.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The next time a Deputy interrupts the Chair will send for the Ceann Comhairle and will ask that the Deputy be dealt with. The Chair is no longer prepared to put up with these interruptions.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

The Opposition were shocked when our books balanced at the end of March. They were even more shocked when they discovered on Wednesday night that there was not even a splinter in Fianna Fáil not to mind a split. Fianna Fáil is more united now than ever before, and that is some solidarity.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Tá an ceart agat.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, will you send for the Ceann Comhairle?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will decide when to send for the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I did not interrupt.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

You said you would send for the Ceann Comhairle at the next interruption. There is the next interruption. Send for the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

The primary objective of the Fianna Fáil Party is the re-unification of our country. The 26 Counties are on a firm footing. We must maintain our steady economic progress. At the same time, we are all of us deeply committed to the Fianna Fáil programme and policy. We have our priorities right. We must think, too, of our fellowmen across the Border and our primary objective of re-uniting the country. The people of Kerry know that that is the primary objective of Fianna Fáil. Whether the Opposition realise it I cannot say. As Deputy Tim O'Connor said, the people of Kerry have a very proud tradition. He could recall events that occurred long before I was born. I and every other Deputy am 100 per cent behind the Taoiseach and the Government and I deplore the disgraceful tactics of the Opposition in their efforts to create a crisis when, in fact, no crisis exists.

I deplore the efforts of the Opposition at character assassination. I deplore their insistence on an all-night sitting of Dáil Éireann when there was no need at all for such a sitting. I deplore their attempt to link our ex-Ministers with Saor Éire and illegal organisations, without any proof whatsoever. I shall not detain the House any longer. We are quite happy in Fianna Fáil so long as Fine Gael and Labour maintain their present tactics. While they do so they will always be in Opposition.

Comment on this

The leading news item in Thursday's Irish Times reads:

The Taoiseach, Mr. Lynch, last night with emotional frankness accused his two former Ministers, Mr. Haughey and Mr. Blaney, of the attempted illegal importation of arms from the continent.

Arising from the motion before the House concerning the elevation of three members of Fianna Fáil to Cabinet rank, this discussion has developed. This is the most serious affair to come before the Parliament since the foundation of the State. We had difficulties in the past and it is in the nature of things that every government and parliament will have difficulties, minor and major scandals, but this is of such primordial importance, so very fundamental that it has rocked the foundations of the State.

I think none of us could do justice to the enormity and gravity of the offence which the Taoiseach claims his Ministers have been party to or privy to. This is not a question of a Minister being guilty of some minor default or appropriating to himself some money or assuming undue privilege. It is a most fundamental issue involving the lives, property and safety of every individual north and south of the Border.

We have heard much tonight from Members on the opposite side and it all revolves around one thing, the one problem uppermost in their minds. The only thing that seems to affect or bother them at present is their unity, in other words, their self-interest. We heard that before.

To come back to Thursday's Irish Times, the first paragraph of the leading article reads as follows:

If we lack unity in other things there is certainly a consistency of pattern in party politics, north and south. The unanimous vote of confidence in the Taoiseach expressed last night at Leinster House will raise a watery smile from the least sophisticated citizen: we have heard it all before; the names, then, however, were O'Neill and Unionism.

That simple paragraph may be prophetic. It may show what is about to happen in this country in the next few days, weeks or months. I do not know how long the Taoiseach will be able to preserve that unity about which we heard so much last night. The previous speaker, particularly, hammered the table in front of him to emphasise the tremendous unity and solidarity of the Fianna Fáil Party. In fact, it is obvious to everybody that there are serious difficulties and disruption in that party.

Uncontrolled importation and distribution of guns and similar lethal weapons can mean only intimidation, robbery and murder and it will not be confined to one part of Ireland but will be all over this island. Its extent will depend on the number of guns and lethal weapons imported uncontrolled. Two Ministers have been formally accused of this appalling conduct by the Taoiseach and have been dismissed. These men have remained members of Fianna Fáil and of the House to date. It appears they have friends and backing in the House and God knows what friends and backing they have outside it. A dangerous situation has been created and allowed to develop.

I must censure the Taoiseach as the man mainly responsible for his vacillating behaviour in allowing these developments to reach the stage to which they are now come. It is completely unconvincing to me for anybody in the opposite benches to try to cover this up as some kind of a patriotic gesture calculated to abolish Partition. It is no such thing. Despite any protestations coming from the opposite benches I do not believe that Fianna Fáil are interested, or have been interested for many years, in the abolition of Partition. They have been in power since 1932 and they have done damn little about it. Up to yesterday they believed they would be in power to the end of this century. Does a party occupying that monopoly position, a party that so obviously has an avarice for power really want to have 1,000,000 Protestants join us here in the south and, perhaps, go out of power as a result? They are doing nicely at the moment; why rock the boat?

I am not, and have not been convinced for a long time that all the Fianna Fáil protestations about Partition are genuine. I do not believe the present crisis arises from either patriotism or republicanism or idealism. These are merely clichés, merely embroidery, a nice covering with which Fianna Fáil members have tried to wrap up a horrible performance. I believe it derives primarily and fundamentally from avarice for power, place and privilege, avarice for financial gain and economic opportunity. Primarily, I say, it derives from avarice for power. I believe this development does not extend to all members of Fianna Fáil; it is probably limited to a few but the few have been strong and forceful enough and greedy enough to force us into the present terrible crisis.

This crisis did not happen today or yesterday. It is the end product of a rot, of progressive moral deterioration, which has been inbuilt in the Fianna Fáil structure for many years. We had minor incidents in the past. I say minor because they are minor when we view them vis-à-vis the present crisis. For instance, we had the famous case of the Locke Distillery. That upset the nation at the time but, looking at it in the context of the present situation, it was, as the Minister for Health, Deputy Childers, would say, small beer. It was merely wrangling for a bit of loot and it caused serious repercussions inside the country at that time.

What repercussions will this cause? It is a far graver situation altogether because it affects life. It affects the lives of hundreds of people perhaps. The Taoiseach must be aware, and I am sure he is aware, that last October there was a move in Huddersfield to spend £200,000 for the purchase of arms. The men were charged. Purchases of that nature, purchases mentioned in the newspapers of close on £1 million, coming into this country by various channels, apparently, make for a frightening situation. Does anyone think that we in this island of saints and scholars are such holier-than-thou people that, given guns freely and completely uncontrolled, we will control ourselves? We are no different from any other people. Perhaps we are even worse. The uncontrolled distribution of lethal weapons can lead only to the things I mentioned in the beginning.

Fianna Fáil tell us they have closed their ranks. I wonder do Fianna Fáil know exactly what their position is? Do they know how far this malaise has spread amongst their own members inside or outside this House? I wonder are the Fianna Fáil members walking around here looking over their shoulders and wondering if they can trust the next man? How many members of Fianna Fáil knew of this situation before it broke? I assume the majority were surprised, shocked and humiliated, but did they know or do they now know, how deep-rooted this is and how far it has spread even in their own party? A situation like that is like an infection. You do not know where it has been incubated or how far it has spread. Nobody knows, because nobody can read into another man's mind and nobody can examine another man's conscience.

We do not know even now, and we may never know, how close we were to a coup d'état, how close we were to a military takeover or, perhaps, the establishment of a dictatorship. The wholesale dissemination of arms in a small island such as this can result only in one thing, bloodshed, the shedding of the blood of Irishmen be they Protestant or Catholic, and be they northern Irishmen or southern Irishmen. Deputy Boland spoke here today——

Comment on this

Yesterday.

Comment on this

Yesterday. He spoke well for Deputy Boland. In many ways, misguided though he is, he has his own honest, rough approach to things and, while I think Deputy Boland is completely wrong on many aspects, we have to judge him on his past performance. He was the strongest mover, the dominant man, the strong man of the Fianna Fáil Party some short time ago when that party moved to abolish proportional representation. The people at that time did not accept Deputy Boland's thesis. They did not give him or his party the power which he sought. They believed that the abolition of PR would result in too much power for one party and that that would be dangerous. I would never accuse the Irish of being people of great perception but in this respect they were wise. Now they can all look back and say how wise they were.

How narrowly we have escaped. Events as now unfolded must show clearly to the people how wise they were in their time to preserve some check over the establishment in this country of one all-powerful monolithic party, certain members of which have seen fit to behave, as they appear to have behaved according to the Taoiseach in the past few days and over the past few months. Deputy Boland having failed to abolish PR did what he could within the constitutional limitations open to him. He butchered and gerrymandered the majority of the constituencies to secure the maximum representation and the maximum power for himself. Some 100,000 people were displaced outside their constituencies in the re-arrangements he made, which culminated in his being able to secure probably four or five extra seats for his party.

I showed here by a series of amendments at that time, and the validity of those amendments was not questioned, that this could be done quite simply by a movement of 20,000 people. There is nothing sacrosanct in county boundaries but the purpose which motivated Deputy Boland was not good local administration or good government, but merely to secure a monopoly of power. While Deputy Boland probably made the best case, and was not dismissed but resigned, we have to take the plausible arguments which he made in that context.

Deputy Boland says that he will not serve under Gestapo rule. Apparently he regards the Taoiseach as a modern Herr Himmler who was the head of the secret police in Germany. He resents any form of check or control upon his movements as a Minister. I would certainly agree that, in normal circumstances, it would be highly objectionable that any Minister should be subjected to phone tapping or other forms of control of that nature, but we must recognise that we were not passing through normal times. We were passing through a terrible crisis and, if the Taoiseach had not done even that much—and God knows he did little enough and late enough—we would be still more critical of him here today.

Deputy Boland says he will serve in the Fianna Fáil Party and as a Deputy. He would take ministerial office again if asked but, apparently, he would not take it under the Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch. He must therefore set about removing that Taoiseach if he is to fulfil his ambitions. That is apparently the loyalty that we now have in the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputy Haughey is also fully behind the Taoiseach, as he feels the unity of the Fianna Fáil Party is more important to the nation than his own political career.

We can all recall a time in Hitler's Germany when there were various purges of the officers and politicians in Hitler's following. How many of them died under Hitler's orders with their hands raised shouting "Heil Hitler"? It seems that we will have the same mentality here. They are all loyal; they will all serve again. Are we convinced? Is the Taoiseach himself convinced? Is the country convinced? Ultimately that is the test we must face and the question we must answer. If the country is not convinced and has not confidence in this assembly, the trust in Parliamentary methods will break down.

Will the Irish people believe in the Ministers who have been removed from office protesting that they were not guilty, that they did nothing wrong, but still remaining in the party and professing loyalty to the Taoiseach whom they claim has treated them wrongly? Will the Irish people believe in these protestations of loyalty? If the Irish people do not believe in the fundamental reality of this institution and of the men here, they no longer believe in Parliament. It is clear, then that the Taoiseach must clear out the stable and must go to the people. The Taoiseach must realise now that in the minds of many people there will be a sense of distrust.

The Taoiseach has named two ex-Ministers, Deputies Haughey and Blaney. The position about Deputy Boland is rather ambiguous. The Taoiseach said that Deputy Boland tendered his resignation. Deputy Boland says that he was, in effect, pushed. I do not know what measure of equivocation is being used to describe what happened here. Am I to understand that Deputy Boland tendered his resignation but did so after being ordered or requested to do so? That is something which the Taoiseach should make clear. One is left with a very unpleasant suspicion that both of these gentlemen have many fellow-travellers in this House who are masquerading behind the Taoiseach and protesting their unity and loyalty. Time may unfold that and then it may be too late.

I have sympathy with the Taoiseach in the position in which he finds himself. Deputy Cosgrave confronted him at 8 p.m. with information which he had at his disposal. At 10 p.m. two Ministers were dismissed and a third Minister had resigned. It is only reasonable to conclude that, had that confrontation not taken place, these Ministers might still be in office. The suspicion remains that efforts have been made to cover up this disgraceful episode, and that this was done in the interests of party unity and of remaining in power. No doubt the Taoiseach may tell us now that he had no such intention and that he moved as quickly as possible once he got positive confirmation that there was serious trouble in the offing. The suspicion must remain in all our minds that the Taoiseach might have attempted to cover up, under some pretext or other, the sordid, despicable and dangerous practices of his Ministers for which he was later compelled to publicly sack them.

Great power is vested in a Prime Minister. He appoints all the Ministers of State and the Parliamentary Secretaries. He can reshuffle the Cabinet if he thinks fit and terminate ministerial office at any time without offering any reason. I understand this to be the constitutional position. Great authority also carries corresponding responsibility. That responsibility must be exercised continuously and must be exercised immediately the occasion demands. It permits of no dilatory procedure and of no procrastination. Anything else is merely vacillating and can only lead ultimately to graver troubles. This is where the Taoiseach failed. I am not in any way implying anything improper in respect of the Taoiseach. In his personal capacity he is a very estimable and good-natured man. I doubt if he has the rigidity of character or the grit to be a Taoiseach, and particularly a Taoiseach in charge of the type of men of whom, unfortunately, he was placed in charge.

The Taoiseach may not be able to remove his offending Ministers as Deputies from this House but they have emphatically stated their determination to remain in Fianna Fáil. To what purpose? Do the Fianna Fáil Party, as such, or whatever Members are here, or does the Taoiseach himself think that this is in the interests of the party or of the Taoiseach or of the country? Does he see any inherent dangers ahead?

In these islands, and we have not a perfect code here, we have been comparatively free for many years both in England, Scotland—not so much in Northern Ireland recently—and down here of organised crime. Our murder rate is low. The murder rate in the United States is, I believe, about ten times that of the British Isles or here. There are many reasons for that. I would submit that the primary reason is the easy access to guns and lethal weapons which obtains all over the United States and which the United States Government has so far failed to control or contain. Admittedly, it is a different country. You have racial problems there. Probably, even under the circumstances obtaining here, they would still have a higher crime rate.

However, it largely derives from the easy access obtaining in American States to guns of various descriptions. We had in this Chamber, standing there on the left of where the Ceann Comhairle sits, the late President of the United States, Jack Kennedy. He died in America. He was assassinated. His assassination was made much easier, if not caused by, the easy availability of lethal weapons for every Tom, Dick and Harry in the United States. Do you want a similar position to obtain here? Does anybody think that, once guns come here, their distribution can in any way be controlled? Is it not obvious to anybody who thinks about it that any organisation in possession of modern, attractive, lethal weapons would easily secure young men to join that organisation merely to be in a position to secure a gun or a revolver.

As I said already, I have a certain sympathy with the Taoiseach. Allowing for the fact that he has shown an undue degree of vacillation, weakness and incompetence he did—I must say this in mitigation of his position—inherit some of the problems now besetting him. He has been hoist with the petard of years of posturing in this country—since 1932, 1933, 1934, indeed, since the foundation of the State. We have talked about Partition but we have done practically nothing about it. In fact, we have moved more and more away from fellow Irishmen north of the Border. I know, I accept, that they are open to the most severe criticism; but have we put our own house in order? Have we not, in this country, introduced every possible barrier against re-unification—legally, constitutionally, industrially, culturally? We have wrapped ourselves up in a little green flag in our 26-county state. We have not moved towards the development of the foundation of a pluralistic society. Our flag here is green, white and orange. It was first raised in my own county, Tipperary, by John Blake Dillon under arms. We have forgotten the orange in that flag. We have made no serious attempt— as we should have been doing from the day the State was founded up to the present—to create an atmosphere which would ultimately lead to unity and to the development of a pluralistic society. We have moved merely to develop our green celtic state.

If, now, we find these difficulties more firmly rooted than they ever were before, we here in the south are as much to blame for it as the north. Yet we keep prating about Partition. I blame the party on the Government benches principally for that. They had a longer time to do something than any other party but they did not do it. True enough, at any Fianna Fail gathering it was trotted out—the one outstanding problem, the re-unification of the national territory. This was like a ritualistic war-dance, performed for local consumption and then discontinued until the next occasion; but nothing really happened and no effective effort was ever made to establish a situation here conducive to ultimate unity.

We adopted the notion that the north should accept us on our terms— terms which could not ever be acceptable to many in the north. If we were genuine in our wishes to do that, we should have made attempts, all down through the years, to try to understand the conditions obtaining in Northern Ireland so as to establish some rapport between them and us. It is this position; it is this inherited attitude; it is this peculiar, hypocritical brand of Republicanism, this posture by Fianna Fáil, which has now placed the Taoiseach in his present position. This is what he inherited. It half absorbs him. But, added to that, was his own weakness, his own vacillating character, which some might call good nature. He now finds himself in a political crisis. He now finds himself in the position that his personal word, his personal integrity is being questioned by Ministers who were yesterday sitting with him in his Cabinet.

The interview given by Deputy Boland, as reported in Friday's Irish Independent, covers some of the points made by the Deputy in his speech here today and elaborates on some further points. The interviewer, Mr. Kerry McCarthy, had this to say:

He also told me that he believed that for some time members of the Government were of the firm opinion that their telephones were being tapped. "In the case of one Minister this has definitely been established," he declared.

The report continued:

He repeated again a declaration he had made earlier in the day that he could under no circumstances work in a Government whose leader kept members under Gestapo-type surveillance. "I could not see the events of the last few days happening in any other democratic country. All that was missing was the beautiful blonde spy," he said.

I do not know to what extent Deputy Boland missed the beautiful blonde spy but apparently she was all that was missing to make his day complete. Further on in the interview, Deputy Boland is quoted as having said:

He was astonished that Mr. Lynch had dismissed two senior Ministers on the basis of secret and unconfirmed information supplied to the Government as against the word of the Ministers who denied they were implicated in any arms plot.

When the interviewer asked Mr. Boland if he was surprised that Mr. Lynch had so readily accepted his resignation, Mr. Boland said "certainly not." He added:

Of the four senior Ministers who have gone in the past few days, "I am the only one who voluntarily resigned. I am sure that the ex-Minister for Justice, Mr. Ó Moráin, was asked to resign."

These remarks are apparently contradictory to what the Taoiseach has told the House. It is the duty of the Taoiseach to take the House and the people into his confidence and to make a complete statement on the whole situation. I expect that the Taoiseach has much more information than he has given the House in his opening statement on this matter. Deputy Blaney made a very emotional speech here today.

Comment on this

A very inflammatory speech.

Comment on this

I made some notes of the speech——

Comment on this

A very mischievous speech.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Unctuous Desmond.

Comment on this

Deputy Blaney denies that he had any association with Saor Éire or with any other subversive organisation. He stated that he had not contributed one penny towards the purchase of guns and he asserted that he had nothing to do with the escape of those who murdered Garda Fallon. He also stated that he knew of no association of his brothers with any illegal organisation in the country. He admitted that he refused to resign but we are not clear about the reason he gave. I gather it was in some way calculated to help the people in the north.

Deputy Blaney then went on to relate ancient history. It was an inflammatory speech in which he paraded his own ideas and his impeccable patriotism and loyalty to the Taoiseach and to Fianna Fáil. It did not appear to him that there was anything in his recent behaviour as alleged by the Taoiseach that might be irreconcilable, hypocritical and bellicose.

Comment on this

Very clever.

Comment on this

It was an emotionally charged speech calculated to inflame primitive emotions, a speech not befitting the position that he had held.

I was present at a meeting of the Dáil some time after the northern crisis in August. Perhaps I am a simple man, but I concluded as I think did most people, that there was unanimity in this House among all Members that the use of physical force in relation to Partition was out. We all welcomed that declaration but it now appears that there were some silent dissenters. When the matter was discussed at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis in January, the Taoiseach appeared to have been satisfied that he had the approval of his own party.

I can understand a member of any party not seeing eye to eye with various points in relation to some matters or acts of his party. Generally, one thinks the matter is worth raising, one expresses one's opinion and then one abides by the majority decision. However, there are certain times when there is a crisis of conscience. Perhaps it might happen once in a man's life. If it happens to a man who is a member of a political party and he finds that he can no longer reconcile his conscience with the majority opinion of that party, he owes it to himself and to those whom he represents to state his case and to resign from that party.

If he occupies a senior position and finds himself unable to agree with the policy of his party, he should resign. Deputy Blaney, for instance, could not see eye to eye with the unanimous decision of this House taken last year. That was the time for him to talk. That was the time for him to come in here and say his piece, and not today. That was the time to place himself in the hands of the Taoiseach and to say to him quite simply and openly: "My conscience does not allow me to agree with you on this matter. What do you want me to do?" The Taoiseach might have said to him: "If you can still continue to do your job as a Minister you may continue on, provided you do not let your views impinge on the general attitude of the majority of your party". Or he might have said to him: "I think you should go" or the man might have said it himself. That was the time to do it. That was the time for him to state his position unambiguously. That was the time for any other Deputy of any party, if he did not agree, to stand up and to say his piece. Deputy Blaney did not do that. Deputy Haughey did not do that. They remained in this Government, in this House, apparently accepting and apparently agreeable to the unanimous decision of this Parliament but, at the same time, according to the Taoiseach's allegation, apparently also indulging in practices of quite the opposite nature.

Now the Taoiseach finds himself in the ignominious position of having to come into this House and wash his dirty linen in public. I have already referred to the Taoiseach's weakness, his vacillation, his failure to come to grips and to nip in the bud the situation which has now developed into a national scandal.

During all last summer there was as we all know a dangerous situation developing in Northern Ireland. There was also a less dangerous situation developing down here. There was a general election. We profess to have a tremendous interest in Northern Ireland. Perhaps it is a lately awakened interest, since the civil rights movement began—it has been rather dormant for many years—but, at all events, we all profess it. Yet during all that summer—and the Taoiseach, I am assured, was kept reasonably informed of developments in Northern Ireland—he made no determined effort to secure a consultation with his opposite number in Great Britain, Mr. Wilson.

If Partition is an evil largely deriving from British actions in the past they still possess some responsibility in the matter and they still have effective jurisdiction over Northern Ireland. Here was the Prime Minister, the head of the Fianna Fáil Party, the party of reality, the party that was always going to abolish Partition, standing idly by during the long, hot summer. Beyond some feeble letter sent some time in the spring, no practical, concrete step was taken by him to secure consultations with his opposite number in Great Britain. In effect, the Taoiseach spent most of that time campaigning around southern Ireland, calling on reverend mothers and giving exhibitions with a hurley ball. I suppose it won the election. I am sure it helped. But it was not the kind of activity, the kind of exercise, that one would expect a responsible, effective Taoiseach to indulge in during that long, hot summer.

There is recognised in all modern Governments what we call collective responsibility. During all that long, hot summer Deputy Blaney was allowed to put forward his own peculiar solution for the problems of Northern Ireland. These solutions were contrary to those the Taoiseach and the Government had apparently adopted. Ultimately, on 14th August, the Taoiseach took action. It is now clear, or it seems to me anyway, that this was an action partly forced upon the Taoiseach at that time by a recalcitrant and difficult Deputy Blaney. He sent our Army shadow boxing to the Border and he sent poor Deputy Dr. Hillery clowning to the United Nations. I know Deputy Dr. Hillery did his best. His best was very little. He did not even succeed in getting the Irish problem put on the agenda, but he was allowed to make a statement. They heard him politely. That was the sum total of Deputy Dr. Hillery's efforts at the UN. Mark you, he was lauded when he returned to Ireland as a man who had done something marvellous, a man who had achieved something. He had been allowed to read a statement.

The anties on the Border were, to my mind, quite inexcusable. At different times our Taoiseach who apparently was, perhaps, against his better judgment, led into this type of action has given different explanations. One explanation which he offered is that troops were there in case the British troops might ask them in to provide a joint peace-keeping force. Fat chance that the British would invite our troops into Northern Ireland. The next explanation he offered was that they were there to help those who might flee across the Border from the issues which were likely to break out in Northern Ireland and which, in fact, did break out. If that was the purpose it would surely have been a prudent thing to keep communications very clear and very open. If mere medical help was the purpose, then the Army Medical Corps with some help from the Red Cross should suffice and the Government Information Service make it very clear that no equipment or officers were being dispatched to the Border. The last and most recent explanation he gave was that the troops were on the Border to prevent infiltration from the south into the north. These are three different explanations and you can pay your money and take your chance.

This was to my mind a most dangerous exercise by a small country. It was beyond our capacity in a military sense then and is now to embark on force in respect of Northern Ireland. We all knew and agreed that even if we could do so a captive people are no use to anybody. The Taoiseach attempted to rectify the situation. Shortly after the Fine Gael Party published their ten point programme on Partition the Taoiseach took himself to Tralee and there made his conciliatory speech affirming, among other things, that the ten point Fine Gael programme was actually the traditional Fianna Fáil programme. We were all together again and Deputy Blaney was out of the running for the time being.

I recite those events because they should not have occurred. I believe a resolute Taoiseach with the strength of the House behind him should have insisted from the beginning on collective responsibility. He was vested with the authority to do so and if he had done so he would not be sitting in the dock accused by this side of the House and by his own ex-Ministers.

I should like at this point to put a few questions to the Taoiseach to which I hope he will reply. I should like to ask him if at any stage he received any information from Interpol or any agency outside the State in regard to this matter. Apparently investigations into the importation of arms had been going on for a considerable time. It was stated that sums of money up to £1 million had been offered to procure arms. I mentioned the Huddersfield deal already. It seems to me extraordinary that information that was apparently available to international agencies was not available to the Taoiseach.

I should like to ask the Taoiseach when he applied the security arrangements to his ex-Ministers. How long has this form of surveillance been in operation? Was it merely put into operation following the approach by Deputy Cosgrave to him? I should like to ask him whether the statement by Deputy Boland to the effect that Deputy Moran was sacked is correct and if he would state whether or not Deputy Moran was invited or requested to tender his resignation. I should like to ask the Taoiseach if he would give us the date he first instructed our security forces to begin investigations on the question of ministerial implication in the importation of arms into this country. I should also like to ask him if he is in a position to state how the purchase of the smuggled arms in question was negotiated and the source of the money for the purpose.

According to the newspapers, there was a considerable inflow of money from American sources. The money was collected in Great Britain. I would be particularly anxious to know that no State funds under one guise or another were in any way diverted to those purchases. I should further like to ask the Taoiseach if he could tell me whether the Garda have interrogated Deputies Haughey and Blaney and their respective brothers in regard to the activities for which he dismissed the two Ministers, or analogous activities in respect of the importation of arms. I would ask him if he is in a position to state whether citizens of Northern Ireland were brought to the south at any time last year for special army training and if he will state on whose authority this was arranged, the extent of the operation, whether he was informed about it beforehand and if he gave his approval and whether any financial commitments fell to be met by the State.

He has already told us when he first received information about the arms smuggling that has culminated in the present difficulty. I would ask the Taoiseach whether crates labelled for the Red Cross arrived at Dublin Airport and, if not, where they were intercepted? I should like to know what arms they contained and whether such crates got through customs without examination after ministerial intervention. I should like to know the name of the Minister who intervened, the name and address of the consignee and the ultimate disposal of the consignment. I should like to ask the Taoiseach what legal action is open to him or contemplated by the Government in respect of the deposed Ministers and others involved in recent arms smuggling. I know the Taoiseach will probably reply that this is a matter for the Attorney General and that the Attorney General is dealing with it already.

I should like to ask the Taoiseach if he proposes to take steps to tighten up our security arrangements with a view to avoiding further illegal activities. This is a matter of paramount importance. We have no guarantee that further smuggling of arms will not be continued in this country. I do not know to what degree arms have already arrived here. The recent spate of bank robberies would suggest that they certainly are coming in. I would ask the Taoiseach to furnish the people with complete details, so far as security arrangements will permit, of this arms smuggling episode. It may be that at this point he will not have the fullest details but I trust that he will let us have all the information at his disposal. The position in which the Taoiseach finds himself is an unpleasant one and his credibility is being questioned.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Not alone in fairness to this House and to his own party but also to himself he should make the fullest disclosure of all relevant information dealing with this unfortunate matter. I do not believe we have seen the end of it; it will not merely disappear because we wish it to disappear. For too long the Taoiseach has indulged in this kind of wishful thinking, trying not to see something that was only too obvious, trying to avoid an ultimate confrontation with circumstances and conditions that would not go away. It is the tragedy of a man in one of Shakespeare's plays who could not make up his mind.

Since the foundation of our State we have unfortunately had an extremist element which has been always difficult to contain. Both political parties have been embarrassed. A political party often fails to face up to a difficult situation. Every party lives by votes but one can buy votes at too high a price. During the years Fianna Fáil have found themselves in that difficulty partly due to the fact that they are prisoners of their own past. Now the chickens have come home to roost and they are some chickens. When the Taoiseach comes to reply this evening or tomorrow——

Comment on this

He has better staying power than your leader.

Comment on this

——I would ask him to give us the fullest possible information. I would also say to him to take his courage in his hands and, whether he remains Taoiseach or not, for his own peace of mind he should go to the country and ask the people if they want a change of Government. Do they want a change of party in this House or do they not? Procrastination is bad for the country. The vacillation the Taoiseach has shown in handling the problems of his Government has got him into the present difficulties and further procrastination which he may be inclined to indulge in will merely lead him into greater difficulties. It would be better for the country if the Taoiseach would now make up his mind to call a general election.

Comment on this

Speaking on this motion to replace the Ministers who have been found by the Taoiseach to be unfit to retain office does not give any Deputy pleasure. However, as it is of vital importance to the nation every Deputy feels it is his duty to contribute to this debate. The events of the past few days have moved so rapidly that one finds it difficult to keep pace with the statements, the denials, the counter-statements and further statements. At this hour of the morning it is difficult to know who to believe and what to believe. We must rely on the statement of the Taoiseach that some of his Ministers have not been loyal to him. This is a rare thing to happen in any Government. The people of this State are alarmed at the situation which has arisen when men who have been trusted with office and who have been given their seal of office by the President have betrayed the trust reposed in them. It would be normal to expect any Taoiseach to be saddened by finding himself in such a position.

Over the past few days the people were wondering where we were going, what security there was within the State and what efforts were being made to secure some stability for themselves and their families. Were it not for two important institutions we have, our Army, under our Minister for Defence, and our Garda force, under the Department of Justice, we might wonder where we would be this morning. It is well to know that in the future if in a Government any Minister of State should be tempted to be disloyal to his Taoiseach we have within the State two organisations which would prevent any Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries from throwing the State into chaos.

It is well to remember that when our predecessors in Cumann na nGaedheal established the Army and the Garda force they did so in spite of severe opposition. Both of those institutions justified the confidence that was placed in them by the people who founded this State and have never been found wanting, but in recent months there was a growing fear among the members of those two organisations who could not get from the Government assurances that everything was being done that should be done and there was a general feeling of uneasiness and unrest which is a bad thing in any State.

It has been said time and time again since this debate started that rebellious tendencies had shown themselves in many ways and in many counties. Questions have been asked: when will we have respect for law and order? When will those who break our laws be brought to justice? Every Deputy would like to see that we would have within the State when this debate finishes, a respect for the people who maintain law and order and that the Ministers concerned who hold the portfolios will see that this law and order will be enforced. Some time ago the Taoiseach made a wild statement that the Fine Gael Party had nothing to be proud of. I was rather surprised that he should make such a statement. Now he can remember that the leader of that party in the very gentlemanly way you would expect him to do it approached the Taoiseach and warned him of the danger the State was heading for. I hope the Taoiseach is grateful for that warning. We are glad he acted on the advice and on the warning given by our leader.

I am very proud to be in that party that the Taoiseach thought had nothing to be proud of. I should like to remind him that, when an emergency faced the country in 1939, our leader put on the uniform of an Irish soldier and served the country, as many Deputies on the opposite benches did also. I should like to remind the Taoiseach that Deputy Liam Cosgrave's father, many years before that, gave service when the first spark took fire which inspired this country to stand before the world and to fight in order to show its nationhood. I am proud to be in that party despite the Taoiseach's suggestion that we have nothing to be proud of. I am proud to serve under a leader who, when the State was in the present crisis, again stepped in and prevented a serious situation arising.

We, as a party having within our ranks young intelligent men, will always be in a position to provide an alternative Government, a Government which can be relied upon. We can select from the Deputies on this side of the House men who can be depended upon to be loyal to our Taoiseach when we come into office.

I am sorry that three responsible Ministers of State are in the position that they are in this morning. It is a rare occurrence. I hope no such situation as has arisen this week will ever again arise in this country. I do not propose at this stage to lay too heavy a hand on any of those men. Their actions speak for themselves. We could be charitable at this stage. We should devote the time that is left to us to an effort to restore confidence in the institutions of the State, to undo the harm that has been done, to convince the people that the primary concern of Deputies is to have a Government in power which will make a serious effort to restore stability for a period and, if then unable to do that, that will take the alternative course of asking the people to elect a Government that will be in a position to do that.

It was an extraordinary thing to have a former Minister objecting to the methods employed by the Department of Justice and to the source of information available to the Taoiseach as to what is happening within the State. When that Deputy was Minister for Defence he was well aware of the methods employed by our Army, fully aware that there was an intelligence section within that Army, as there is today, thank God, through which necessary information would be obtained in order to secure our safety against fifth columnists either from within or without the State.

I find it very difficult also to understand why any Minister who on his own admission was an officer in the Regiment of Pearse, who swore loyalty to the State and to the Constitution, should object to the methods employed by our Army to obtain necessary intelligence for the security of the State. It is difficult to understand the change of heart that occurred in a person who one day was a Minister and the next day became a Deputy.

The sequence of events has been so rapid that it is very difficult to know at this stage who is discredited. Reference has been made to an Army officer who served in the capacity of intelligence officer and who should be relied upon and whose information should be acted upon. I listened to a statement made by that officer quoted here tonight by Deputy Bruton and, as far as I know, the former Minister for Defence, now the designate Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, has denied the authenticity of this officer's statement, which complicates matters still further. A statement from the Taoiseach at this stage should clarify many of the things about which we are not clear.

There is one Minister, who, I feel, is very embarrassed because of the position in which we find ourselves. He is an honourable man who can always be relied upon to be loyal to any trust reposed in him. I refer to the Minister for External Affairs who is recognised in this country, in Clare and in every country where he has gone, as being a decent and respected man.

Comment on this

Up Clare.

Comment on this

Yes. He is from County Clare. Have the events of the past few days made his position any easier in the negotiations for our entry to the Common Market? Have the events of the past few days improved the status of our representatives abroad? Has the respect for our peace-keeping forces abroad, in Cyprus, the Gaza Strip and the Middle East, increased as a result of the events of the past few days? It would take a very united front by all Deputies within this House to restore the confidence which the world generally had in us and bring the country back to what we would like it to be. Because of what has happened in the past few days I believe it is now necessary to increase the strength of our security forces.

Now that we are approaching the tourist season, I should like to feel that those who come here can be assured that they are coming to a country in which there is stability and in which the Government are in full control of the affairs of the State. In the interests of those who are dependent on the tourist trade we must do everything we can now to bring about an atmosphere which will encourage tourists to our shores in the assurance that they are coming to a peaceful State. Every medium of communication should be used to spread the message abroad that we are a peaceful people. The sooner that is done the better it will be for everyone.

I think the men proposed to fill the vacant Ministries cannot be overrated. As far as I know, they are all reliable men. I am glad to see Deputy Jerry Cronin in the Department of Defence. He can be depended upon to act in a responsible way and I am sure the Army will give him the same loyalty they have always given to Ministers for Defence. Despite some of the things that have been said, I am sure Deputy O'Malley will be able to ensure that the forces of discipline he controls will get full authority to act in a way which will ensure that our people are safeguarded in their individual capacities.

If we could divorce our approach from emotional considerations and deal with the important principles involved that would be very beneficial. The security of the State and of its people is of primary importance. Nothing should be done and nothing should be said which might endanger that security. When this debate is finished I hope that those whom we represent will feel that we have made an honourable effort to ensure for them a peaceful existence. I hope people will be satisfied that this is the last occasion on which it will be said that there were rebellious tendencies within the State which attempted to overthrow or bring into disrepute certain Departments of State.

Comment on this

I do not often speak in debates here. I do so now in sorrow. May I be allowed to voice my views not merely as a Deputy but also as a mother? I am apprehensive for the future, the future not alone of my own family but the future of all the families which, since the end of the last war, have enjoyed peace. In any true democracy the only real asset is peace— peace in the city, peace in the town, peace in the market place and, above all, peace in the home. This country is renowned for such peace and security in the home. I do not mean that financial security is the dearest wish of every mother, wife or sister. Fear is the natural enemy of such security. Anything that gives rise to fear should be carefully avoided. Not to cause fear and thus preserve security should be the aim of all public representatives.

The Taoiseach by his delay and his failure so far to give the facts has initiated this fear. The speeches of Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney have fanned the flame of fear. Their words are calculated to upset individuals and families north and south of the Border. To do this may, in the short term, give them some sort of heroic image: in the long term their words will be judged for what they are—messages of hate. On such words the people can place no reliance. These are upsetting words, harmful to peace of mind. I fear that these are words that will drive young minds along the path of destruction. I appeal to the Minister, to the Taoiseach and to the Government to stop this talk now, to tell the truth. The people who sent them here deserve it.

Comment on this

When one rises to speak in this debate, which deals with the appointment of three Ministers, one's mind is immediately directed to the circumstances that brought about this situation and to the reasons for this motion. As one living in the east of the country and not as closely connected with the northern problem as many other Deputies are but at the same time very much concerned that every effort should be made to establish moderation, I feel it is reasonable to say that a Government from which two Ministers are sacked and one has resigned is in dire trouble, not only because of the three people involved but especially because any of the three was a potential leader of Fianna Fáil. They were certainly policy-makers within the party.

Deputy Blaney was crack organiser and strong man whose strength, at the grass roots level of the party, is unequalled in many constituencies. Deputy Haughey was, one might say, the economic and financial expert whose ability was recognised by all sides of the House. Deputy Boland was the man who, after the referendum campaign, did so much with his Electoral Bill to return Fianna Fáil to office. Having regard to all these facts, how can anyone now say that all is well in the Fianna Fáil Party and that the dissensions that so obviously exist have now been healed? How can anyone say that, particularly after hearing the emotion-packed speech of Deputy Blaney and the statement by the Taoiseach—the first the words of a republican hardliner and the second the words of a passive moderate?

The Fianna Fáil Party cannot be all things to all men. The events of the past few days leave it discredited before the House and the country. It is not a pretty sight. It is one that brings the credibility of members of the Government into question and leaves the House and the nation discredited and shamed in the eyes of the world. In the past few days talk in the corridors and lobbies of the House has been generally about the credibility gap that exists but with the events of the last 48 hours that gap has widened to a yawning gulf that no change of Ministers can close or paper over. The Island of Saints and Scholars will soon be known as the island of gunmen and gun runners.

What really must concern everybody is the effect the disintegration of Fianna Fáil is having on the nation. We are being asked to appoint three Ministers. No matter what members of the Government may say or how anxious the Opposition, in charity, might be to believe them the facts are that the people have lost confidence in the Government. Its duty is to the country, not to itself or the Fianna Fáil Party, nor is its function to ensure retention of power. The principles of democracy must be clear. Only 11 months ago the Fianna Fáil Cabinet was the youngest in Europe; today it is the youngest burst-up Cabinet in Europe.

In the Irish Independent of yesterday, Deputy Ó Moráin, when asked why he resigned, is reported as having said: “No comment”. Obviously, the question arises: did he fall or was he pushed? One hears from Fianna Fáil speakers on many occasions that the interests of this country are synonymous with the interests of Fianna Fáil. Perhaps that is apparent within the Cabinet or within the Parliamentary Party, but it is certainly not apparent from the outside to the people in the country in general.

When Fianna Fáil first came into office nearly 40 years ago, to a great extent they pursued a policy of idealism which was not consistent with the economic requirements of the State. Nevertheless, it was an idealistic policy. Many people felt at that time that more realism was called for and, as the years went by, some realism did manifest itself. The party could now do with some of the idealism of the past so that their duty to the country and to democracy would be done.

I say this with a certain sense of sadness and also because of the outbursts of emotion by Deputy Blaney here this evening. One respects a person with deeply held views, but outbursts of that nature will no nothing but harm at this time. Those of us who were born since the Treaty should respect the people who were prepared to make the supreme sacrifice so that we might be able to come into this House in freedom and peace. We should respect those people no matter what side they took during the terrible tragedy that followed the Treaty.

In this House in 1970 no effort should be made to inject into Irish political life some of the heat, hate and bitterness of the past. Any member of the Cabinet whose opinions did not conform with the policy on Northern Ireland as defined by the Taoiseach should, in all honesty, have severed his connection with it. How many times have we heard the Taoiseach say there was unanimity in the Cabinet and how many times had he to put the record right after members of the Cabinet had made statements on Northern Ireland? In the light of the happenings of the past few days these statements are further proof of the deep rift that existed within the Government and the Fianna Fáil Party for some considerable time.

This debate is taking place not because of any act or any action of ours but because the Taoiseach felt that he could not allow certain Ministers to continue in office as a result of information he had. While some people may request Deputy Cosgrave to place the source of his information on record, the Taoiseach knows the source of his own information and, when Deputy Cosgrave made available to him the information he had, he decided to take action against members of his own Cabinet before the country became aware of the real position.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Where is he now?

Comment on this

Where is who now?

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Fathead, shut up.

Comment on this

Certain things have been said, but can they in all honesty say that everything has been said? There is a duty on people who are elected to this House to find out the real truth so that the people of the country will be given an opportunity to make up their minds. The main duty of an Opposition is to make the Government do their duty, and more particularly a reluctant Government.

Over the past number of years there has been a growing sense of frustration among our people. Our young people have become cynical because of the broken promises of the Government, because so many things were promised and so few delivered. Over the past few days all hope has been shattered and, no matter what changes take place, the Government have been discredited before the people. I say with great respect to the Taoiseach that this is not a question of keeping Fianna Fáil in office.

Comment on this

It is a question of getting them out of office.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Not a chance.

Comment on this

It is not a question of the Members of the Fianna Fáil Party remaining in power. It is a question of bringing politics in the minds and hearts of our people back to what it was in the early days of this State. This is what should determine the Taoiseach's attitude now.

Comment on this

There is a great obligation on every Member of this House to contribute to this debate, which is one of the most important debates that has ever taken place here. I should like to add my contribution. I am a young Deputy. I am a young man who has taken a keen interest in Irish politics since my days in national school. I have admired all of those men I read about in our Irish history books, the brave men of different generations who worked for Ireland, who fought for Ireland——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

And lived on Ireland.

Comment on this

——and many of those men made the ultimate sacrifice of giving their lives for Ireland. I have great admiration for all of those men down through history, men like Owen Roe O'Neill, Red Hugh O'Donnell, Wolfe Tone, Robert Emmet, Kevin Barry, all those patriots who served Ireland so gallantly and so well. They were men from all parts of this country. They were men of different religious views but they all had one thing in common and that was their love of Ireland. Perhaps the most glorious period in Irish history was 1916. Perhaps it is the one that we all read about much more attentively than we read about any other period.

Easter Sunday, 1916. Everybody here should remember with pride the heroic stand taken by Pearse, Connolly, Plunkett and the other true and loyal men who loved Ireland more than life itself. A few short years after this event, we succeeded in wresting independence for 26 of our counties. The event, in its own way, set in motion a trend of events that reverberated throughout the world. These events at that time offered hope to people all over Europe and all over Africa. These events offered hope to men of every class, colour and creed. A flame was ignited in 1916 which has never been quenched throughout the world.

In Ireland at that time, Michael Collins described the Treaty and regaining of independence as but a stepping stone. I feel it still can be a stepping stone. I believe that ultimately it will prove to be but a stepping stone. Time passed and tragedy followed with civil war. Former comrades in arms, who had fought side by side, separated and fought on different sides. I believe no one will doubt and very few will contradict that, on both sides in that civil war, there were brave and loyal men dedicated to a cause in which they believed. Many men died in the struggle at that time. I cannot say who was right or who was wrong in this civil war. However, I think an epitaph written over the graves of two young men who fought and died in the American Civil War will help to illustrate the point I was making. It was written by the father of those two sons who died fighting on differing sides. The epitaph the father wrote was as follows: "God knows which of them was right for I certainly do not know".

The effects of the civil war here set this country back decades. We missed the opportunity to show our fellow countrymen in the Six Counties that we here could manage our own affairs, could provide our own Government, could live in peace and harmony. Instead, we provided the doubtful, the cynical, the hesitant with an opportunity of finding reasons for not coming in with us. From this civil war they got the material for their argument that we could not live and work together.

In later years we have overcome a lot of these disadvantages. We have overcome the setback, the bitterness, the hatreds and the wounds brought by the civil war. We have overcome those wounds and at last they have begun to heal. We could meet people with different political views and discuss events. We could all meet as Irishmen and we could discuss our different feelings in regard to our country. People began to forgive and people began to forget.

Deputy Blaney, however, has been able to forgive but, I am sorry to say, he has not been able to forget. I believe that events such as those are better forgiven and forgotten. When I was growing up in this country and when I was a young man I believed that this country at that time was one of the finest and greatest examples of a democracy in any part of the world. I felt it offered freedom and equality. I felt it was a place where a person could live in peace and harmony with his neighbour, where one could go about one's business without fear of interference or molestation.

I felt is was one of those countries where a person could apply for a job without being asked his religious or political beliefs, where a person could conduct his business without fear of attack by armed bandits, a place where people could live life as it should be lived, a place where people could interest themselves in the various arts, in the culture and history of this country, in sports and language. I felt it was a place where people could interest themselves in everything that helps to make life worth living; a place where people could live for the present and plan for the future. I felt it was a country that was becoming renowned all over the world for its hospitality, its friendship and its peace.

Irish boys and girls who had left this country at different times, because they were unable to get jobs here, looked back on it and remembered home here as something that offered peace and happiness. They were anxious to come back here. I believed that in the Six Counties until a few short years ago any reasonable man or woman could look down here and note how things were progressing. I am certain many of them would have wanted to join and work with us.

The night had been long but, with the dawn, one felt a new day would break over Ireland. The poet said: "All is changed, changed utterly; a terrible beauty is born". I should like to paraphrase that a little bit and just say of this moment: "All is changed utterly—and it has changed in the past few years." We have seen a situation arise in Ireland where jobbery has become a way of life. We frequently hear now that, all other things being equal, a person belonging to Fianna Fáil has a better opportunity of getting a job here. We have become accustomed to violence in our streets. Armed bank robberies have almost become commonplace.

There have been at least 13 bank robberies during the past two years and, as far as I know, there is not one person serving a sentence as a result of being convicted for any of these robberies. Recently there was the tragic event of the shooting during the execution of his duty of a member of the Garda Síochána, one of the most highly respected police forces in the world. These, then, are some of the events that have taken place. We now have a former Minister who has said that the Taoiseach has appointed a Super Special Branch to spy on members of the Government. The former Minister for Local Government, as quoted in Friday's edition of the Irish Independent, said:

A ‘Super Special Branch' had been secretly set up by the Taoiseach, Mr. Lynch, to spy on members of the Government.

The columnist added that Deputy Boland told him:

... he believed that for some time members of the Government were of the firm opinion that their telephones were being tapped.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Good man yourself.

Comment on this

This morning the same ex-Minister openly contradicted the Taoiseach in regard to the resignation of a Minister. In the interview to which I have already referred, Deputy Boland is quoted as having said that:

Of the four senior Ministers who have gone in the past few days, I am the only one who voluntarily resigned. I am sure that the ex-Minister for Justice, Mr. Ó Moráin was asked to resign.

We have had different information in regard to this particular Minister. On Wednesday, 6th May, as reported at column 642 of the Official Report, the Taoiseach told the House:

On Monday, 20th April and Tuesday, 21st April, the security forces of the country at my disposal brought me information about an alleged attempt to unlawfully import arms from the continent.

Further on in the same column the Taoiseach is reported as saying in relation to the two Ministers:

I told them both I had information which purported to connect them with an alleged attempt to unlawfully import arms, on the basis of which information. I felt it was my duty to request their resignations as members of the Government. Each of them denied he instigated in any way the attempted importation of arms. They asked me for time to consider their position. I agreed to do this. In the meantime I authorised the continuation of investigations and I made personal investigations myself, following which I decided to approach the two Ministers again and to repeat my request that they tender to me their resignations as members of the Government. I did so on the basis that I was convinced that not even the slightest suspicion should attach to any member of the Government in a matter of this nature. Having told the Ministers that I wished to have their resignations forthwith, each of them told me he would not give me his resignation until this morning.

As we are all aware, the Ministers concerned have denied any association with the importation of arms. A further situation has now developed whereby a Captain Kelly has involved the Deputy whom the Taoiseach has proposed to be Minister for Agriculture. Why did the Taoiseach propose the appointment of this Deputy if he believes that not even the slightest suspicion should attach to any member of the Government in a matter of this nature?

There have been contradictory statements. People who had been held in high esteem by this House and by the country have denied that they were connected in any way with the importation of arms while the Taoiseach claims that they were so involved. The Taoiseach should give the House further information in this regard. He should tender all the information at his disposal so that we can see for ourselves why he has dismissed the two Ministers. A further explanation is needed so that we can judge for ourselves, because the explanation already given is not adequate.

For now, we shall have a look at the situation as it exists. We have people who adopt the old hard line attitude, the attitude of hatred and bigotry, and who endeavour to stir emotions in people in all parts of the country. Whatever else can be said about these gun-running plots nobody can deny that this situation has been brought about by Government inaction or, shall we say, Government action. There can be no doubt but that the Government have allowed themselves to slide into this situation and that they are solely and collectively to blame for any repercussions that may result from these events. This is the year 1970.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Did the Deputy think it was 1960?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M. E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Now, now. Do not be naughty.

Comment on this

We are preparing to enter the EEC. After entry it appears certain that the Border will go. After our entry to the Common Market I believe the Border, after a very short time would become an anachronism. I believe that the lives of the people here would benefit from entry. Everyone would benefit. The people in all parts of Ireland would receive equal social welfare benefits. The Government White Paper would lead us to believe that after entry we would see an improvement in our standard of living and in our living conditions. A few years is a short time in the life of a nation; a few days is even less. Let us hope that the events of the last few days do not jeopardise our chances of entry to the EEC.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Let us hope that these events in the past few days will not damage our negotiations for entry. Nowadays we must look outward. We can no longer be insular. We must look to Europe; we must become part of Europe, if we are to survive and live and work as an Irish nation. The events of the past few days have shocked and saddened the people of this country. I am certain this crisis will pass——

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin South Central): It will, of course.

Comment on this

——and even though the people are shocked at the moment I am certain that all over this country commonsense will prevail in the coming months. The one lesson all of us can learn and if I could send a message to the people who are not here this morning, many of whom will never hear what I have had to say, it would be this: the mechanism of a democracy is extremely delicate and because of this it requires regular examination. If a party is in power for too long patronage follows and this can result in a situation in which the Army comes completly under the control of one party; the judiciary in its own way can be manipulated by a political party.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

That has never arisen here. That is nonsense.

Comment on this

I am making the point that democracy——

Comment on this

The Minister must have a guilty conscience.

Comment on this

Certainly, in regard to the judiciary too—all hand out Fianna Fáil touts.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

It is an awful thing to have to say but it is quite true.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The judiciary should not be referred to as touts and the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

That is my view, too, a Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this

The point I am making is that in any country in the world if a Government continues too long in power it can lead to a situation in which there is manipulation by the Government of the Army, of the judiciary and of the police.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

I object to this in regard to the judiciary——

Comment on this

The Minister may object but it is perfectly in order.

Comment on this

He said it can happen, not necessarily that it did happen here. The Minister has a guilty conscience.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, Deputy Enright.

Comment on this

The point I was making—and I believe it was a valid point—was that it can, in its own way, lead to a situation in which the Government can manipulate the judiciary. It can lead to manipulation of the police and of the Army.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

We appointed Deputy Tom O'Higgins presidential legal adviser to the supreme court in this country and I am personally responsible for it. Deputy Tom O'Higgins is presidential election adviser in regard to legal matters and was appointed by the Government on my advice to the Supreme Court of this country.

Comment on this

The Minister should get some sleep.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Deputy Tom O'Higgins knows it.

Comment on this

The Minister should get some sleep.

Comment on this

If a Government are left in office, if democracy is not worked properly, it can lead to the situation I mentioned. This is one of the greatest dangers facing this country at present. There must be checks and there must be balances. They are essential in the Army, in the police and in the judiciary. This is one of the fundamentals of a democracy. The Government have been in power for a continuous run of 16 years and, again, for the last 12 years.

This is bad for democracy and people outside should remember that to safeguard this democracy, to safeguard this House, to safeguard the institutions of this country they will have to have a change of Government. They will be offered an alternative Government and, in their own interests, in order to prevent situations like this recurring, they should make certain that they change the Government.

I believe the only way we can ever hope to bring in our fellow countrymen in the North of Ireland is by the example we show them of living in peace with our neighbours, whether they are Catholic or Protestant, rich or poor, old or young. We must all live together; we must all work together for the good of one another and for the good of Ireland. With examples like that I feel we can become a 32-county Ireland, an Ireland which will be held in respect, an Ireland which will be able to look to the world with dignity as a complete unit. I believe this can happen if we make the most of our democratic institutions.

Comment on this

I would like, speaking on this motion, to refer to the resignation which has caused one of the vacancies in the Cabinet. On the 5th of this month at 4 o'clock the Taoiseach stated:

Deputy Michael Moran yesterday tendered his resignation to me as a member of the Government.

Yesterday morning we heard Deputy Boland in this House contradict this statement. We heard him say that this resignation had been called for. The Taoiseach denied this when Deputy M. P. Murphy of the Labour Party asked: "Was the resignation asked for?" The Taoiseach in reply said: "The resignation was tendered." This is at Vol. 246, column 519, of the Official Report for Tuesday 5th May, 1970. This is the first appearance of a crack in Fianna Fáil and it is the first appearance of a crack in the Taoiseach. At column 519 Deputy Cosgrave asked the Taoiseach: "Can the Taoiseach say if this is the only ministerial resignation we can expect?" and the Taoiseach replied: "I do not know what the Deputy is referring to."

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

We heard this ten times before. Have you all got a prepared script?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

You will hear it many times.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave then asked: "Is it only the tip of the iceberg?" The Taoiseach, quite innocently asked: "Would the Deputy like to enlarge on what he has in mind?" He then assured us all he was in complete control of whatever situation might arise.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

We have heard that before.

Comment on this

I know it is very hard for the Minister to stay awake but he should not do it by interruption.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Byrne should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Mea culpa, mea maxima culpa.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach asked Deputy Cosgrave to enlarge on what he had in mind and enlarge he did. At eight o'clock that night Deputy Cosgrave went to see the Taoiseach and approximately within an hour of leaving him the Taoiseach had sacked two high-ranking Ministers and had the resignation of a third high-ranking Minister. The Taoiseach had got to take those steps because of the allegation and the prima facie case which he said he had that those Ministers were involved in unlawfully importing arms.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Is it in order for the Deputy to read out something like this?

Comment on this

The Minister is interrupting to keep himself awake.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dr. Byrne is entitled to refer to his notes.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

He is reading out a prepared script. I would suspect it is Deputy Garret FitzGerald's.

Comment on this

This was not the end for quite soon afterwards we had the resignation of a Parliamentary Secretary. In the meantime, since we started to debate this motion, further cracks and crevices have appeared in the Fianna Fáil Party. An Army captain has alleged that the then Minister for Defence was involved in some way in this subversive activity and has stated to the press that he informed Deputy J. Gibbons of all his activities. When will this resignation come? When will it be handed in? Will it be handed in like Deputy Moran's resignation was handed in? What can we believe from what is being said over there? It is in black and white in the Official Report of the 5th of this month, it is contradicted on the 6th and now again on the 8th we have further contradictions. This is coming from supposedly reputable people on the far side of the House and coming from the Taoiseach. Yet the Taoiseach still accepts the support of people he does not think are of high enough calibre at present to be members of his Cabinet.

The Taoiseach has kept those people in his party and he has kept them on his back benches, where they are paid their ex-Cabinet Ministers' pensions and also their salaries as Deputies. They are still being paid by the taxpayers even though they are not good enough, even though they are so bad they had to be sacked. The Taoiseach insists that he remain in office, and that his Government remain, with the votes of those men and their associates in the Fianna Fáil Party. The money for the guns was meant to come from the taxpayers' money. We witnessed Deputy Blaney yesterday in the House making——

Comment on this

Has the Deputy any evidence? That is a serious charge.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

The Deputy does not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this

The Minister was asleep all night. Will he whist now?

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

Deputy Blaney went around the country, following the events of last August, making speeches promoting the use of force, purporting to support the use of force for solving the problems in Northern Ireland. The Taoiseach at one time in his life was a sportsman and distinguished himself on the playing field. I can remember in 1967 when James Dillon, the previous leader of our party, was on a television programme, a self-portrait, and he was asked what advice he would give to young people who were going to enter politics. He said: "Beware of entering politics lest your soul shall be damned". I feel this would now apply to the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach has allowed his soul to become damned in this matter. The Taoiseach is ignoring the will of the people. He is bringing back on to the pitch players who have already been thrown off. He has no mandate from the people to do this. The Taoiseach is allowing the disqualified men to fight on. He has disqualified the boxer and he is now letting him back into the ring. He has given him a platform. The Taoiseach by his action in staying in power, with the support of the men he has kicked from his Cabinet, is kicking the Irish people when they are on the ground. I would like to know what action, if any, the Taoiseach would have taken had he thought nobody else in this House was aware of the activities of certain members of his Cabinet.

As late as four o'clock on 5th May the Taoiseach stated that he was in full control of the situation and was not expecting any more resignations. Yet at ten p.m. that night three Ministers had been removed from the Cabinet. Would these men still be in the Cabinet had the Taoiseach not been made aware that others knew what was happening? The Taoiseach has given top priority to loyalty to Fianna Fáil when he should be loyal to the country. He should go to the country and ask the people what they want him to do. Our leader, Deputy Cosgrave, is and always has been loyal to this country as was his father before him. He is the greatest statesman this country has and he has proved it by the way in which he has handled this delicate affair.

The Taoiseach as a sportsman knows that there comes a time in every fighter's career when he must lose. In my opinion the Taoiseach is no longer a sportsman, he is a bad loser. He will not go and seek his new mandate from the country, which is now essential in order to continue the democratic procedure necessary to maintain the institutions of this country. He should resign and call a general election. When he loses the election he should ensure that Fianna Fáil do not come back into the Opposition benches as they first came into this House in 1927. They should come in to present a formidable Opposition and thereby contribute to the good Government of the Fine Gael Party.

We must remember what has happened to the country under Fianna Fáil rule. In 1932 when Mr. W.T. Cosgrave handed over Government to Fianna Fáil he handed with it a loyal Army, a loyal Civil Service and a loyal Garda force——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

It was more than you handed over; you had no money.

Comment on this

——all of whom were fully prepared to serve whatever Government was elected by the people. It was the insane economic measures adopted by Fianna Fáil which, in 1932, caused our exports to drop from £36 million to £18 million in 1938. This is something from which the country has never recovered. It was the time of the introduction of the dole and free beef and the small farmer never recovered his independence.

Comment on this

It is early in the morning to tell fairy stories. Tell us about loyalty to the British Army.

Comment on this

Do not get annoyed.

Comment on this

What is Deputy Cosgrave going to get back from Fianna Fáil? He is going to get an Army demoralised by recent events and by maladministration in the past five years. He is going to get an Army which has been completly run down and whose Minister has been accused by one of the Army captains of being a participant in this plot to bring guns into the country.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

We are well able for you.

Comment on this

So this is what Fianna Fáil are like early in the morning.

Comment on this

We will get a Navy without any ships which will be very convenient indeed for the smuggling of arms to this country. We are going to inherit an economy which is in a disastrous state. Let us look at the Army. The Taoiseach has appointed a Parliamentary Secretary to try to make some attempt to clear up the mess into which the Army has fallen. There is no confidence whatever in the administration of the armed forces. During the year I pointed out certain deficiencies that existed in the equipment available to the armed forces. They were supplied with 16 armoured cars and yet the shells supplied for these cars misfired two out of three times because they were mortar shells and the Army could not get the Government to purchase the proper shells. As a result the armoured cars are practically useless. I pointed out these defects last year and I said that the number of troops our Army can actually put into the field is less than 1,000——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Nobody needs you.

Comment on this

Do not be rattled by the sage from County Mayo. Make your case, we have plenty of time. There will be new incidents every hour during the day.

Comment on this

It is quite possible to allege that the Army, Air Force and Navy have been allowed to be run down deliberately. The morale of the Army is a its lowest ebb due to the bad housing and service conditions in which the troops find themselves at the moment. With the permission of the Taoiseach we have troops serving side-by-side with the British Army in Cyprus. If we are going to accept the position that the British are capable of keeping the peace in Cyprus, are we not going to accept that they are in a position to keep the peace in the North? If we do not accept that there is no point in having our troops in Cyprus. When the troubles started in the North of Ireland last August it appeared to me that we should have sent for these men and brought them back here. I do not know why they were not recalled.

I am in full sympathy with fellow republicans and I could understand the tremendous upset which occurred last August when people were being shot down and attacked in the Bogside. But, if anything was to be done about it as regards Army intervention, then was the time to do it and not now. The situation which exists in the North of Ireland now is completely different from what it was last August. There is now a completely different arrangement there. Our people were then attacked by the B Specials and by the extreme Protestants. Now the B Specials have gone and the extreme Protestants are kept away by the British Army regiments. The Catholics up there have some defence and are permitted to join the new Ulster Defence Regiment. It is either one thing or the other: either accept the British as a responsible peace-keeping force as we appear to do by our action in sending our troops out to keep the peace with them, or else do not accept them in Cyprus. However, it is a contradiction to say these men cannot be accepted as keeping the peace in the north while our Army serves with them in Cyprus.

Deputy Blaney made a heart-rending and inflammatory speech here. One has great sympathy with him because he holds his republican views very strongly but obviously the road to hell has been paved with good intentions. We all felt great sorrow and wanted to do something last August, but what could we do apart from diplomatic negotiations and what the Minister for External Affairs did at that time? It appears as if it was working out fairly well. Now we have brought on a position similar to that which existed here in the Thirties. We have now replaced the arch-Republican de Valera with Blaney in a small part, and in the north instead of Brookborough they have Paisley, once again in a minority, but even though a minority very dangerous to the lives of people both north and south of the Border.

I was speaking recently to an MP from Stormont who tells me that the activities of members of the Taoiseach's Cabinet of recent days has really polarised these extreme groups and has set back for many years the progress that had been made in the North of Ireland negotiations for reunification. The credibility gap between what the Taoiseach says and what is actually true appears to be increasing rather than decreasing.

It is easier to get guns into Ireland at the present time than it was a short time ago to get food and medicines into Biafra. I have no evidence of this but it appears that one of the small airports in Ireland has been used over the past six months by small aircraft for gun running from the Continent.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Which airport?

Comment on this

There is a great lack of Fianna Fáil defenders in speeches but plenty of interrupters.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Which airport?

Comment on this

In Kerry. It is not a question of whether guns have come into this country but how many. Is the Taoiseach prepared to tell this House how many guns have come in here?

The position the Garda Síochána find themselves in at present is an unenviable one. They have just lost their Minister for Justice. It was reported he tendered his resignation but it appears the portfolio was taken from him. I spoke recently to a senior member of the Garda Síochána who had resigned and he pointed out to me that when he joined the force first they used to look round and say: "What more can we do for the building up of the State? What way can we help?" He resigned in disgust over political interference in the Garda Síochána. Many gardaí have gone to the stage where they realise what has been going on. They have had their ear to the ground and realise that while they may have had a little bit of proof it did not get very far. They have lost all confidence in the Government.

I wish to refer to Deputy Childers's appearance on television on Wednesday last. He said there was no split or division in Fianna Fáil. Yet Deputy Kevin Boland received tumultuous applause from the backbenchers in the Fianna Fáil Party following his statement in which he referred to the Taoiseach's dismissal of Deputy Moran and in which he referred to the Gestapo-like handling of the situation and the extreme surveillance which had been exercised by the Taoiseach over his Cabinet. It is very obvious that not only is there a split but quite a big crack and it is only a matter of hours before this crack widens. Deputy Childers referred to the magnificence of the Fianna Fáil Party and the fact that it could purge itself and how tragic it was it had not purged itself more often in the past. I agree with him on the second part of his statement that it was a pity it had not been purged more often. However, would the Taoiseach have carried out the purge this time but for the fact that he was aware other people knew of the allegations which had been made? This is the biggest point in this whole matter of the resignations. Would these men still be in the Cabinet but for the fact that the Taoiseach was made aware of the situation approximately six hours after he had stated in this House on three separate occasions that there was nothing whatsoever to be worried about, that he did not know what Deputy Cosgrave was referring to, that he had complete control over whatever situation might arise? This is the biggest credibility gap that could possibly have occurred, that within six hours of his making this statement three Ministers should go from his Cabinet.

What purge has the Taoiseach carried out? He is still sitting over there. His party is still attempting to run the country. The members he has thrown out of his Cabinet for subversive activities are still members of his party and are supporting him to keep him and his party on that side of the House. I would expect them to resign from the House.

Comment on this

There will be a new Taoiseach. That is the next move— the week-end move.

Comment on this

Is this an honest approach?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy in possession.

Comment on this

The credibility gap which Fianna Fáil has presented to the country over the past number of years has been increasing of recent years and there is now a fantasic credibility gap. We on this side of the House just do not know what to believe. We do not know when we are being told the truth.

Comment on this

That feeling is shared by the other side as well.

Comment on this

It appears as if the attitude is to put the Fianna Fáil Party before everything else, to put forward this cloak of unity, to put forward the Fianna Fáil Party before the people, before the welfare of the State. This is not honest. Anyone who is labelled with the tag "honest" for supporting this or initiating it is certainly not being honest with himself. We have known for some time the open declarations made by Fianna Fáil that political jobbery is a necessary evil. We know why Fianna Fáil are in power, why they are over there. It is not because of their policies on economic expansion, of education or external affairs. It is because of the fact that so many people—I know many of them— are receiving certain special attention in their different walks of life. It is obviously an open policy with Fianna Fáil. It is not a policy that deserves any credit. It is one thing to do it; it is another thing to come out and say you are doing it. It shows the contempt they have for the Irish people.

I remember recently in the Dublin South-West by-election being outside a church when a Fianna Fáil man was speaking and his contribution was that the great advantage of having the Fianna Fáil candidate elected was that he would be able to get the Minister to do whatever one requested him to do, whereas the other fellow would not.

Comment on this

Can Fianna Fáil, in all honesty, claim to be the government of the people at the present time? Do they feel that the people have any confidence left in their party to govern the country? Can they really say in all honesty that now or at any stage they have been a government of the people? In the 1965 election they had 500,000 votes against approximately 600,000 and in the 1970 election they had approximately 600,000 against a combined 700,000 for the Opposition parties. Yet, the Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch, will say that he represents the majority of the people and he does not.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy talking in favour of the straight vote now?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is sitting over there because of gerrymandering, misrepresentation and personation.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is a Deputy addressing the House.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party are not giving government by the people or for the people. Down the years that party have shown that it is for themselves and their supporters. The distress which has been evident over a period has now come to a head. The one ting that the Fianna Fáil Party can say about themselves as regards integration with the Unionist Government in the North is that they can gerrymander, misrepresent and personate every bit as well as the North of Ireland and that is what has them over there but they will not be there again.

We should like to know how the Fianna Fáil Government in 1965 could by some wave of a magic wand open up all the mental hospitals in Ireland and allow the patients out to vote and yet deny the vote to the 18 years olds, the people that they have recruited for the Army, who pay taxes to the Exchequer. They will not even consider giving them the vote because of some fear for survival. They will not spread the voting. We in Fine Gael have called for this. It is a progressive step. We fully support this and would like to see this change made in the Constitution. Our 18 year olds have gone to the Congo and Cyprus. Some of them have died in Cyprus. They should certainly have some say in the running of the country. This has been denied them because of the intense will and desire of Fianna Fáil to hold on to what they have. I do not think that Fianna Fáil particularly want to hold on to what they have now because they certainly have not very much. It is safe to say that the country is not left very much at present. This country is the laughing stock of the world. The eyes of many countries are centred on this Parliament. We are the laughing stock of Europe. How can we negotiate for membership of the European Economic Community when members of our own Government have been sacked because the Taoiseach felt he had sufficient information to indicate that they were participating in importing arms into this country for alleged use against the forces of authority in the North of Ireland? What kind of reputation are we going to bring in with us? What kind of heritage are Fianna Fáil going to hand over to Fine Gael when we take over government in a very short time?

It is quite clear that there is now grave doubt as to whether the Taoiseach would have taken any action were it not for the fact that he was made aware that other people had authoritative information on this whole matter. There is a possibility that these gun-running activities would still be going on and would have been covered up were it not for the fact that other people saw fit to raise this very serious matter. Possibly there were two investigations carried out by the Taoiseach, one to discover how much had gone wrong and another to discover if it could be covered up and how much others knew. You cannot have it both ways. The situation blew up and Fianna Fáil can count themselves extremely fortunate that the leader of the Fine Gael Party——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has repeatedly said that it will not tolerate interruptions. The Chair's job is being made very difficult by this constant spate of interruptions.

Comment on this

There was no effort on the part of our Leader to gain any political kudos whatsoever from this.

Comment on this

A lot of hypocrites.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it in order for Deputy Andrews to refer to the Leader of the Fine Gael Party as a hypocrite?

Comment on this

I did not use the word "hypocrite". I used the word "hypocrites".

Comment on this

Is it in order for Deputy Andrews to refer to the members of other political parties as hypocrites?

Comment on this
A Deputy

On a point of order. Is it in order for Deputy Harte to speak from the passageway?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

We are prepared to take over and govern this country. Why will the Taoiseach not go to the country? Because he is afraid. We have had the recent commemoration of the 1916 patriots. It is rather bizarre to find them also commemorated in these monstrosities up in Ballymun. The blocks are named after the 1916 patriots. All these monstrosities have done is to foment hatred in the people living in Ballymun. They are called after patriots who should be revered by some proper monument, not by these monstrosities. I cannot see how a competent Minister could have sanctioned the building of these hideous flats. We know now, of course, that he was not attending to his job. The people who are living in Ballymun are utterly dissatisfied; it is called "Blaney Heights".

We, in Fine Gael, are quite prepared to take over the running of this country. It was our party founded the State and built up the economy of the State. Very little improvement has been made since Fianna Fáil took over in 1932. In fact, the country was driven close to bankruptcy, with exports dropping from £36 million to £18 million inside five years. The country is still trying to recover from that misguided economic policy. Part of that policy was alleged to be getting rid of the British landlords. What do we find today? We find the foreign-based development combines coming in here buying up our land. The landlords we got rid of in 1932 are now coming back in droves, taking over all the prime development sites and charging fantastic rents, mainly to Government Departments, and vast quantities of money are leaving the country.

This party has the tradition behind it of having handed over in 1932 to Fianna Fáil a country with a healthy economy. We will get back very little from Fianna Fáil. There can be no doubt about the integrity of this party or the reason why Fine Gael want to get into office; they want to rectify some of the grave social evils which have grown under the Fianna Fáil administration. We have the necessary endurance and honesty.

We have heard very little about the cache of ammunition found under one of Dublin's canal bridges some time ago. I never saw any further mention of the large cache of machine guns found in the North Brunswick Street area in 1967. All these things together give rise to suspicion. But there is no need for suspicion: we know what is happening now. How long has it gone on? How many men are armed? Is the present system of administration safe?

When we were in government we set up State boards and companies and if the Government had representation on them we ensured it was minority representation, the exact opposite of what Fianna Fáil do. They load their members on to such concerns. This was very much apparent when the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Blaney, was setting up the agricultural board.

Either the Tánaiste or the Taoiseach, I think, said that the only party capable of administering law and order was Fianna Fáil. What law and order have we? We have numerous bank raids, armed bank raids in daylight. We had a series of farmers' marches and sit-downs in Dublin. We have the cement strike at present and anybody who visits my constituency will be sure to see a very large protest walk because they are continually walking for some injustice or other. It might help Deputy Burke to join these walkers; he might shed a little weight. These people were driven into the gallery here one day on Deputy Burke's invitation. They kicked up a row and had to be removed. I believe it was the first time in 35 years that this happened.

Comment on this

Was the Deputy responsible for them?

Comment on this

It was Deputy Burke who issued the invitation.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke will show in the next election how well he represents his area.

Comment on this

I am sure he will. It is not my area. Even though it appears that Ballymun town should be in one constituency it is divided among three. Charlie has a slice. P.J.'s parish goes into it and Deputy Tunney has part.

Comment on this

We have three common grounds for unity in Ireland of which two are open. These possibilities should be pursued at all costs. Our basic common unity is that of the playing field. This was demonstrated quite recently when the Irish rugby team played Wales and everybody, north or south of the Border, declared themselves to be Irish. We should encourage sports organisations that do not recognise the Border. Also, at heart every Irishman is a politician and interest in the formation of a common Government or the introduction of a federal system could be promoted.

If members of the Fianna Fáil Party had any self-respect to begin with or have any now left and if the Taoiseach retained any degree of honesty he would immediately go to the country. Because of the lack of confidence all over the country in the Government there is no alternative. The Taoiseach must be aware of this. He makes us suspicious of his motives in political life. We wonder whether he is here to rule for the welfare of his fellow countrymen or for his own welfare. It appears that he is prepared to hold on to power at all costs and swallow any principles he may have had. The events of the past few days leave this very dubious.

Putting a name of two words over 74 or 75 individuals does not necessarily mean they will all pull the same way. We are aware of the big division and difference of ideals existing in the Fianna Fáil Party from the grass roots up to the top and of the disillusionment felt by the rank and file at the last Ard-Fheis. Many of them questioned the validity of the words "Republican Party" appearing on their membership cards. Fianna Fáil cannot go on because, despite their shortcomings there are men in its ranks who are honest and will, perhaps, insist on going to the country for the great mandate they say they have from the people. I know they have not got it at present. They know in their hearts that they have not got it.

They can best be called an imposter Government, a party of imposters. To have any right to sit in government after the events of the past few days, after dragging the country through the mud and making it the laughing stock of the western world, they should go back to seek a mandate from the people.

Comment on this

I had not intended to speak but I have gone through Purgatory listening to seven consecutive Fine Gael speakers and from each one we had a eulogy of the Leader. I do not object to that because I think their Leader is held in high esteem by most of us at least on this side of the House. Listening to the eulogies, I recalled the statement a few months ago by Deputy Ryan when he prophesied that the Leader would be knifed in 1971.

All the prepared scripts given to members of Fine Gael—although I am told the previous speaker did not take a prepared script and, having listened to him, I am inclined to believe that— stressed the responsibility shown by that party, and especially by their Leader, in handling this matter. It was stressed so much that one came to the conclusion that responsibility was not the Fine Gael Party's strongest point and that on this rare occasion they acted responsibly. They certainly never stopped preaching about it.

I listened to practically every speaker. I do not think the motion to appoint the three new members of the Government was mentioned by two of them. They went on their very hypocritical way and shed many crocodile tears about the state of the country and the economy in general. All the time they used this to blacken the Fianna Fáil Party as much as possible.

Comment on this

They blackened it themselves.

Comment on this

This party have not been blackened in any way. I have not been here for a long time but, during the years I have been here, I have heard Fine Gael and Labour speakers prophesying: "You will go the next time." There was one doctor who was not a member of the Labour Party, strange as that seems, a man called Dr. Coue. He believed in auto suggestion. The idea was that you kept saying: "We will win, we will win, we will win." In that way you convinced yourself you would win. If he were alive today I am sure he would join the Labour Party. This foolish notion that they are serving democracy by their attacks here, when all the time they are just helping to damage the democratic fabric of this State——

Comment on this

We are waiting for the next resignations.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Moore is in possession.

Comment on this

Deputy Byrne knows, just as Deputy O'Leary and other Deputies know, that the last thing the Opposition want is an election.

Comment on this

That is not true. We will take you on tomorrow morning.

Comment on this

I personally wish that the Taoiseach would decide on that.

Comment on this

Why not say that to him.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Moore is in possession.

Comment on this

The other night when the Fianna Fáil meeting was about to start, some people over there were very worried in case anything would happen at that meeting which might precipitate an election. If you want to attack us, attack us honestly. If you want to criticise us we do not mind, but at least do it honestly. Deputy Byrne gave us all the old clichés. He talked about the credibility gap, but that was not the worst one he used. He talked about the 10,000 homeless families in Dublin. There are not even 10,000 applications for houses or dwellings in the city.

Comment on this

There is no problem.

Comment on this

The Minister was so busy with other affairs that he would not even prepare a list.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach dealt with the whole matter in his speech. Fine Gael speakers said that he would not have acted if their leader had not got this anonymous letter.

Comment on this

We said he might not.

Comment on this

I want to ask Deputy Cosgrave will he let me see the document from which he read the other night.

Comment on this

Why should he?

Comment on this

Why should he not? He mentioned it in the House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave gave the impression that he was speaking from an official document sent to him by some anonymous scribe.

Comment on this

He knows who it came from.

Comment on this

That is something else. Perhaps he would disclose to the House who sent it, if he knows.

Comment on this

Why should he?

Comment on this