We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Nomination of Members of Government: Motion.

Contributions 978–1,180 of 1,547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 8 parts.

That is only fair. We want to honour this man. This man, acting in a public spirit, sent a letter to Deputy Cosgrave. I am sure he will get the plaudits of the country for his great act.

Comment on this

We know the plaudits he would get from the Deputy's party.

Comment on this

We cannot do this unless we know his name.

Comment on this

Was Deputy Lenehan not a member of the Blue Shirts when this happened?

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I was not. You were not born at that time. You would not be taken into the Blue Shirts as bad as they were.

Comment on this

You were.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I was not.

Comment on this

Yes you were.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I swear on my oath that I was not.

Comment on this

Yes you were.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I was not. You were in the Four Courts and you were executing people.

Comment on this

I am recognising another Blue Shirt.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I was never a Blue Shirt.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I was bad enough but I was never a Blue Shirt in my life.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is loathe to deprive any Deputy of his opportunity of voting on this motion but, if the Chair is not permitted to conduct the debate or attempt to conduct it, the Chair will ask Deputies to leave the House for the day. The Chair is loathe to do this but he is getting no co-operation. He has repeatedly asked for the co-operation of Deputies and he is not getting it. I will ask Deputies to remember that.

Comment on this

A common strain running through the Fine Gael speeches since yesterday morning was the fact that Fianna Fáil were too long in power. They never seem to remember who put the Fianna Fáil Party into power, the people, at every election in 40 years with the exception of two. There is no hope for the Fine Gael Party that the people will make a decision in their favour in the future so the point out of which they are trying to make capital, this incident or the appointment of these Ministers, will not gain them one more vote. They and the Labour Party and ourselves are classed as the Establishment. They are part of the Establishment so they are just injuring the democratic set-up and gaining no kudos for themselves. The two parties might approach this whole matter in a more constructive way.

We had an exhibition from some members of the Labour and Fine Gael parties which would have done credit to the late Senator McCarthy of Wisconsin. I have never seen anything like the witch hunt that went on here. I saw absolute hate on the faces of Fine Gael speakers when they spoke. There was no charity. I am not asking the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party to pull their punches when criticising the Government. Let them hit the party but let them not try to bring down democracy also.

This debate has gone on now since 10.30 yesterday morning. Perhaps a better description would be an inquisition rather than a debate. They attributed all kinds of base motives to the Ministers who resigned. Indeed, at about 3 or 4 o'clock this morning a Fine Gael speaker suggested that this had been done for money. I do not know how low some speakers can go. I would ask them to remember that they are members of the national Parliament and to try to maintain some tone and dignity. When the Nazis brought down the German democratic Government they did it just by ridiculing it. After that it was easy.

The Taoiseach has handled the matter with great ability. The men who resigned conducted themselves with great nobility. The Fianna Fáil Party, from the Taoiseach to the newest backbencher, acted with dignity and responsibility in trying to meet this problem. Every Government in the world has and always will have problems. The Government are here to solve these problems. I have no doubt that the Ministers designate will be appointed and that the Fianna Fáil Government will again carry this nation forward, as it has been doing in every year of office.

One of the most maligned men here is the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Charles J. Haughey. He is the man who, in every Budget, gave some extra help to the less well off of our people, to the maimed and the handicapped. Indeed, I got a letter from the Garda Síochána Pension Association; other Deputies may have got such a letter also. It read as follows:

Please convey our thanks to the Minister for Finance

—who was then Deputy Haughey—

At last we have a Minister for Finance of integrity and ability who saw that these ex-public servants did receive an increase in their pension.

That happened only this year. I am not a physical force man, although I do not rule it out at times. The men who resigned have paid a great price. They have shown they did not just measure politics by the amount of money they got from it. Therefore, let us approach the matter in all charity and try to see the problem as it should be seen. To attempt to make cheap capital out of the present crisis is despicable.

I feel that this episode will be seen in its true perspective after a lapse of time. I feel that then we will understand. There is the old proverb "To know all is to forgive all".

Comment on this

Is that from some lament?

Comment on this

On a tombstone.

Comment on this

During the night, Deputy Enright quoted some line from a poem which he said was written by Patrick Pearse. In fact, it was not Pearse who wrote that poem.

Comment on this

Pearse was a Fianna Fáil man.

Comment on this

He would have been. All the best people are in Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

That is my point.

Comment on this

Each Member of this House, whether on the Government or on the Opposition Benches, has a duty to approach this whole matter with the sense of responsibility it deserves. I do not intend to deal with the subject in the way some of the Deputies opposite have. An awful lot of harm is done by ridiculous talk about Partition. We, on this side of the House, were not responsible for it. I am not going to go back to civil war days or to the Government of Ireland Act. We have now to face the problem that is with us.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is a sensible, practical outlook.

Comment on this

We must do whatever we can to remove it——

Comment on this

Gun running.

Comment on this

We shall not do it by emotional speeches. The people in the north have suffered for almost 50 years. Therefore, our approach towards the problem should be one of responsibility. If we cannot say anything that will help, then I think we should withhold our comment. I do not claim to have done anything heroic for the north during the last row up there. Perhaps if we paid more attention to the problem, we would come to the solution. It cannot be an easy one. However, I think our national Parliament must give the lead, and that is a matter for all the parties in it. We have an opportunity in this debate to show that Parliament is relevant. Some of the contributions would suggest that some people here think it is not relevant. Bear in mind a former Deputy of this House, Deputy James Dillon, be it said to his credit, always stressed here the importance of Parliament. One of the best speeches I heard from him before he left this House was one in which he mentioned trouble in Europe and here. It was a most responsible contribution. I do not want to think that, with the departure of Deputy Dillon, the Fine Gael Party is now less responsible. However, some of the Fine Gael speeches tonight were absolutely irresponsible. I am told the leading Member prepared scripts for some of the speakers. I would not give such scripts to my worst enemy.

I trust that my short contribution will help. My plea is for a more reasonable attitude to the problem facing the country at the moment. It is the primary duty of the Government to lead and to govern. Democracy will not work unless all the parts in the democratic machine are working, too.

Comment on this

We are to believe that there is no problem in the Fianna Fáil Party on the matter of unity and that yesterday's events were a sort of bad dream. I have never seen so many of them appearing so fit as they appear after the events of the past few days. I can understand the condemned man in the cell having a false gaiety on the morning of his execution. The gaiety of Fianna Fáil today is of that nature. The attitude is that these events were thought up by television, newspapers, the communications media who have always been against Fianna Fáil and that Fianna Fáil will fiddle away.

We have even had calls for charity. It is a long time since I heard that in this House. It is a welcome and a reasonable approach. We even had Fianna Fáil Deputies asking that there be no witch hunting. They quoted the manuscripts of Senator McCarthy. The kind of unity Fianna Fáil would ask us to accept as existing in their party at present is the kind of unity we have seen in the disputes between the various parts of the various communist parties in Eastern Europe. It is a peculiar analogy in relation to Fianna Fáil in its present crisis. There is unanimity and votes of confidence, but the true position is exposed in this House. All the elements of a Greek tragedy appear in this particular case.

I suppose there is a kind of poetic justice, too, in the fact that Parliament is discussing this national crisis. How often have we had the example in previous years of some of the Ministers who are now no longer in office, as well as other prominent spokesmen of Fianna Fáil, giving important national information at various functions of outside bodies throughout the country? At least we can now say that, during the past 48 hours, this Parliament has reasserted its place as the national forum of debate.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

There may be people who will say that this debate shows ragged edges and repetition but let us not fool ourselves because this debate is being closely followed by every man and woman in the country. A national debate is in process and this parliament is in full session exploring and questioning. The people are in touch with every new development in this crisis. There are new developments. There was a new development when Captain Kelly made a statement in relation to his working for the Minister for Defence. Had the House adjourned yesterday evening that statement would not now be part of the discussion. There may be some fresh developments during this day. The impression that most speakers have got is that we have not yet reached the bottom of this plot.

Some Fianna Fáil people will have us understand that all this is merely a matter of suspicion on the part of the Taoiseach. We had this explanation of the Taoiseach's conduct enunciated by the Minister for External Affairs during a television interview last night. The Minister said that if the Taoiseach had any suspicion of any member of his Cabinet, that member could be got rid of immediately. I am at a loss to understand how the suspicion which resulted in a call for the resignation of two members of the Government cannot now alight on the head of the Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons. There appears to be a highly selective principle at work in the manner in which the Taoiseach's suspicions fall on different members of the Cabinet. I can understand the sense of grievance of those members of the Cabinet who have lost their portfolios. I have seen a look of impatience on the faces of the new men whom the Taoiseach has proposed that we appoint. Their seals of office are awaiting them in the Park but there has been a delay and they must endure this interminable talk. With all due respect to them, other matters detain us for the moment and before these new members can go to the Park certain matters must be cleared up. One can understand the feelings of the proposed Minister for Local Government who expressed himself in a vigorous interview yesterday evening, his fair locks blowing, when he said that he is anxious to get down to the challenge of his job.

None of us have any special desire to keep this House in all night session. We do not like the uncomfortable arrangements of the House but because of the importance of the subject matter of this particular debate which is not being held for the sake of argument but because the democratic institution of this State has been undermined in a way in which it has never been undermined before in the State's history. My principal charge is that if there is any guilty man in this Cabinet, it is the Taoiseach. He is the person who, in reality, is in the dock and not any member of his Cabinet. He is the man who must answer the questions that have been raised during the debate. On Wednesday night we saw the two sides to the Taoiseach. During his opening statement we had a contrite Taoiseach under obvious physical strain, explaining his very carefully prepared case and the reasons for his delay in approaching those members of his Cabinet whom he suspected of being involved in this plot. At the end of the debate we saw the other side to the Taoiseach: we saw the Taoiseach looking at the clock and blaming the shortage of time for his failure to explain and answer adequately the questions raised during the debate.

I do not know whether the Taoiseach is mentally prepared to brazen out the questions raised during this debate or whether in reply to the valid questions raised he will repeat his subterfuge of the other night and again, looking at the clock, refuse to answer questions. It would be most unwise for him to take such a course because the questions that have been raised are not ones that can be blown away. They are too serious for that and too many people are interested in hearing the replies. I would say to any young member of the Fianna Fáil Parliamentary Party that he should use all the influence he can to persuade the Taoiseach to answer the questions because the worries and the puzzlement of the people will not be assuaged by evading these questions.

I say the Taoiseach is the guilty man because he states that until about a fortnight ago he knew nothing of this plot but a report in yesterday's edition of The Guardian suggested that the British Secret Service were in possession of facts in relation to the importation of arms into this country by illegal organisations as far back as seven months ago. It is not beyond the bounds of possibility—in fact it is very probable—that if this were the case, the British Secret Service must have been in touch with whatever security there is in the State as far back as last autumn.

The Taoiseach must have been aware of gathering rumour in relation to this matter. No facts have been given to us which would connect the ex-Ministers with any such previous attempts but what is clear is that if the Taoiseach considered his information to be such that they must be relieved of their portfolios, these ex-Ministers must have a long acquaintance with organisations involved in such importation. If the Taoiseach makes the point that he did not know the scope and extent of such associations and that he did not know until recently of his Ministers' collusion in such activities, he is incompetent and if, as I suspect, the Taoiseach had reason for suspicion some months ago we are left with the other conclusion, that he acted as a politician putting his leadership of the party above all other considerations. He is a Taoiseach who is obviously, throughout this debate, avoiding the doctrine of Cabinet collective responsibility, one that has always been adhered to in this State by every Cabinet.

From very early in the Taoiseach's public life his style of politics—if one could call it a style—has been a style of declared integrity. No politician in the last 20 years has made his honesty more his trade mark—his integrity, his political honour being the thing that set him apart. In any problem affecting his leadership of this Government, of this House, his concern has always been to prove that his hands were clean, cleaner than anybody else's. That, I submit, has been his one concern throughout this particular event.

I concurred with the general public opinion of the Taoiseach—that he was a decent, honourable man. The general election of 1969 changed my opinion of the Taoiseach. He then used the high place he enjoyed in public opinion to traduce members of my party in scurrilous fashion. He misrepresented and told lies about our policy. He said we wanted to rob money from the banks. He alleged from his high position, suggested, insinuated that we were not what we purported ourselves and our policies to be. The question could be asked: what do the convents of Ireland think of the Taoiseach now? I submit that he has been in top training in the longest and best-prepared Presidential campaign in the history of this State. I would like to say this to the children's Cabinet, to the young men he has now gathered around him: do not be certain that your turn will not come. He ditched abler men than any of you. He ditched Charlie Haughey. Do not be too certain that your phones will not be tapped. We have the word of Deputy Boland that he has a super-branch of the secret service reporting to him personally. Keep your secret thoughts to yourself because we have also the word of the sacked Ministers that he trusts no man in his Cabinet, that his manner is to tap their telephones, eavesdrop on their conversations, trusting none of them. We know also about his background. It is well known. I do not attack any man's background in this House save when it blends with a matter of public policy. We know and Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney know that he knew nothing about the older traditions of the Fianna Fáil Party. He had no tradition in the Fianna Fáil Party. He has shown in Government, in his style of Government, that he will not act on major problems facing the nation. His style, in fact, is non-action, taking no decision. His concern at all times is to preserve an impregnable alibi for himself—no action on the Devlin Report, no action on the plans for the decentralisation of Ministries, no action on university restructuring, no action on the grave issue of incomes, no action on the planning of industrial growth areas —all questions affecting one's standing with the public—and, gravest of all in this debate, no action on devising a policy of unity.

He was, if you remember, the reluctant Taoiseach. He did not want the office. All the newspapers knew he did not want the office. He smoked his pipe; he was in no hurry; he had no ambition. The strange thing is that all his opponents of that time, with the exception of Deputy Colley, are now vanquished, lost, gone out of public life in their role as Ministers. They are still Members of this Parliament but they have lost all official might in that particular party. I said "with the exception of Deputy Colley" and maybe his turn to be pushed will come soon also.

Now since the Taoiseach, in my analysis of the situation, is the man in the dock the way he acts or the way he does not act and the reasons why he does not act, his background, the way he looks, his motivation, is relevant to this debate and as I see it the style of non-action on his part is a snare devised by him to trap any rival in that party. My advice to the new members of this Cabinet is: if you wish to remain on in this Cabinet do not be photographed too often, do not become too popular. I think of his manner yesterday when he was explaining why he did not contact these erring Ministers sooner. He was contrite and he explained how his suspicions gathered force. His sterling honesty was proven in the way in which he gave us date and time. I noticed how shaken he was, how much he rested his case on the health condition of Deputy Haughey. He was so worried, he told us, in case Deputy Haughey's health would be impaired and naturally he, being a considerate Taoiseach, did not wish to impair the health of Deputy Haughey so he did not put these questions to him at that time. We all applauded that decent streak in the Taoiseach. Then in his concluding remark he attempted to trap the Opposition into interruption, attempted to get away on inessentials, attempted to evade the questions raised.

It is fair to say that his sole concern throughout these terrible events has been to maintain his own personal popularity while he plots his own route to the Park. Every decision this Government will take in its remaining days will be subservient to that need of the Taoiseach for permanent popularity at all costs—sedulous fostering of that image of being everyone's uncle. He will play for public sympathy at the expense of decision. He will attempt to nurture something he nurtured before now—that public sentiment which will say: "Poor Jack, surrounded by all those rough thugs—Blaney, Boland and Haughey". Where are these formidable men now? No longer Ministers. Poor Jack is still the Taoiseach. In fact he shares a deeper guilt than any of those sacked Ministers because he trapped them, executed them for offending against a policy which allowed for private reservations about the use of force in the north whilst publicly talking peace. That has been the dilemma of Fianna Fáil policy, privately talking war, in public pursuing the ways of peace.

When those Ministers made their first public utterances advocating force in certain unspecified circumstances the Taoiseach in this House defended them saying that this was Fianna Fáil policy also. No wonder they must now feel indignant and outraged. He has done no work, felt no obligation to develop this policy of his on unity. It has been easy for him to suggest that the Fianna Fáil Party are united behind a policy which, in fact, has not been worked out. He has referred vaguely to a federal solution but in answer to questions earlier this year he said no appreciable work had been done on that as yet. He dispatched Deputy Hillery to the United Nations last year on what turned out to be a fool's errand.

I saw one of the new Ministers, Deputy Gerry Collins, on television. He kept repeating with touching faith that the people trusted the Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch. They did to some extent but it is now the duty of every Member of the House to look again at the Taoiseach, to question him closely on those events, and to demand the answers to those questions and not be fobbed off.

The new Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries to be must swear their loyalty to the Taoiseach. He evidently likes that. It is true they would not have won the last election but for the high regard he was held in by the people. He did not win that election in any manly fashion. In it he played on fear and he played on the genuine religious beliefs of the majority of our people suggesting that somehow we here in this party were anti-God. You may say that political argument is selective but I believe the manner in which he conducted that argument was unmanly and a genuine clue to the Taoiseach's character in the way he talks down his enemies, in the way he gets what, in fact, he wants.

I would say, therefore, that the concept of collective Cabinet responsibility is broken in the manner in which Ministers have been sacked and Ministers have been punished. Further punishment may be in store for them but I would say the man who is in reality in the dock, the real culprit in this situation, is the Taoiseach because he refused to develop a policy on the north. When those Ministers came out in public utterances advocating force he suggested that, in fact, was Fianna Fáil policy also. When he saw the signs earlier on of ministerial difference with what he claims to be his policy now he did not correct them and he did not check them. Instead, obviously, all along his deliberate plan appears to have been to execute those men at the first available opportunity. I am not defending the mistakes which those men have made but I consider the guilt of the Taoiseach is far greater.

The Fianna Fáil policy on unity has been a confidence trick from the very start. We had the theatricals of last August; we had that famous television address of the Taoiseach. In diplomatic language to talk of sending troops, even in ambulances, to the Border was a diplomatic way of drawing the sword. We have referred before to this ambivalence in the policy, peace in public, war in private. It is extraordinary when you think of the way this policy has faltered between those two extremes without being resolved in any direction.

We had the long north-south talks which went on under Seán Lemass, the former Taoiseach. The basis on which those talks went on was that areas of contention were to be avoided. In 1967 in this House I spoke about the need for seeking a price for the continuation of those talks because at that time we had the beginning of a general civil rights movement on that side of the Border. At least, during this period when Seán Lemass was Taoiseach that party over there spoke through one man on this problem of unity and relations with the north. This, of course, is also the de Valera tradition. One man, the Taoiseach, spoke on this particular problem, this national issue. It is only under the present Taoiseach that we have had a deliberate confusion of voices on the north.

It may be that other Ministers have been involved in anti-Fianna Fáil policy, as the Taoiseach understands it, on the northern question. It may be that the Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Dr. Hillery, may have made those mistakes against the party in his meetings with the various groups from the Six County area. It may be that Deputy Dr. Hillery has at various times spoken in two voices to them, repeating the same permitted mistakes. Before this affair comes to a conclusion it may be that the Taoiseach's suspicion will rest on the Minister for External Affairs.

Under his "Taoiseach-ship" he has wilfully permitted confusion on the northern question. Like so many other things he hoped the problem would go away, would disappear, no hard decisions would be taken on it and everybody would be allowed to say his piece. When discrepencies and divisions were pointed out to him in this House he denied any such divisions existed. I do not know what the background to the bargain was that made him Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party originally, whether the bargain made when he became leader was that this freedom would be permitted within his party. I do not know, but it is a freedom which he certainly has profited by because he has been able to trap his enemies, to trap his rivals, when they offended this non-existent policy, which he never developed.

Of course, the Fianna Fáil preoccupation in regard to the northern question has been to present a view that would prove popular in the Twenty-Six Counties. This has been the over-riding factor in all Fianna Fáil approaches to this question. When declaring their sincerity in regard to achieving unity they have in practice been interested merely in winning seats in this part of the island, in maintaining their control over this part of the island, fanning secret hopes of force and publicly protesting their pursuit of peace. This particular two-way approach, this devious manner of dealing with this important national question meant that they, in fact, for party political purposes continued in this dishonest way to defend and perpetuate their own political fortunes on this side of the Border.

In fact, I would surmise that the secret confidential advice of all Fianna Fáil Ministers or spokesmen to northern exponents of a physical force solution has been to offer hope of help. Their attitude has been "trust us and wait". We saw some of the spokesmen of the northern groups in Dublin yesterday evening, and there may be more in the next few days, giving their versions of interviews with various Ministers in the last few months. How many Ministers have offended the policy of peace towards the north in these interviews? Dr. Hillery may say that he never met these groups except with the permission of the Taoiseach. However, there may be others who met these groups and who legitimately, as they understood Fianna Fáil policy, offered them solace in their hour of need. Without specifying the circumstances, they certainly fanned their secret hopes that help would be available in large measure from this side of the Border.

The fact that there was no Fianna Fáil policy on the north explains the fear of having a full-scale discussion in this House on the many occasions we asked for such discussion. In the area under his control in the 26 Counties there has been a reluctance on the part of the Taoiseach to reform the laws which were ridiculed and criticised by so many people desiring unity in the north. We had his reluctance to change our Constitution in the areas that northern spokesmen criticised.

His fear of vested interests in the 26 Counties showed his lack of sincerity on this question. We could have gone ahead with plans to reform the area under our control to make this part of the country less objectionable to certain people in the north but there was a failure to act. There was reluctance to have a Dáil debate last summer and we had to wait until October. The Taoiseach indicated his fear was that the Dáil might lead the nation astray. In the event, it was a mature debate and some of us thought it would be a major influence on informing and educating public opinion on this side of the Border to the realities of the northern situation.

As our spokesmen have made clear, the Taoiseach's fear was that divisions in his own ranks would be exposed. The Taoiseach did not refer to the northern question at great length in his final speech before Christmas. It is good that this Parliament is the centre of this national discussion today. It is poetic justice that the Taoiseach and his Ministers who have often attempted to bypass this Parliament have come home here to explain these great issues of State to the elected Members of this House.

After Christmas last year the Taoiseach gave an interview to Mike Burns. During that season Deputy Blaney had made a speech in Letterkenny on the Northern Ireland question at a gathering commemorating his 21 years in Parliament. I afterwards described it as a meeting of the Letterkenny Parliament. The press spoke about the firmness of the Taoiseach; there was a much publicised firm discussion with Deputy Blaney and in this radio interview the Taoiseach amplified the nature of the discussion. He said: "I had a firm chat with Deputy Blaney." Deputy Blaney was on the same programme and when the Taoiseach had said this, Deputy Blaney replied that it had been "the shortest firm chat on record" as he claimed it had taken place on the gangway at Question Time. According to Deputy Blaney the Taoiseach said to him: "Do you agree with official Fianna Fáil policy?" Deputy Blaney replied: "Yes" and that was the end of the matter.

The problem of Fianna Fáil policy on unity is that one did not exist. Publically there was a commitment to a peaceful solution and in private there was this secret conviction that force could be used in certain circumstances. Many other members, apart from the deposed Ministers, may have been guilty of offending this peculiar policy of Fianna Fáil of which only the Taoiseach had the correct interpretation. All the Ministers accepted the policy because there was no policy; the Taoiseach alone knew the secret interpretation of this policy. He allowed these Ministers to advocate force and at this stage when they have now gone over the brink they can feel aggrieved that the Taoiseach did not correct them.

On television yesterday evening John Hume remarked that a policy of reconciliation or unity had not been worked out by this Government. This is a sensitive matter for members of the Fianna Fáil Party because they boasted that they alone understood the national question. That party above all other parties saw its role as being one of bringing about unity. However, the party is now exposed as one without any policy and Ministers are sacked because they have offended against a non-existent policy. The Taoiseach deliberately allowed them to make mistakes and now that those Ministers have gone over the brink he has punished them.

The fact that Fianna Fáil have got away with this double thinking and paucity of policy is due to the nature of the party and their Ard-Fheis. How often have we seen the Ard-Fheis at long weekends, behatted and begloved, the great ones gathering, the rural cumainn meeting together in happy congress for the weekend, the pragmatic party——

Comment on this

We held only one Ard-Fheis at the weekend.

Comment on this

Oh, yes. You abridged your discussions last year in imitation of ourselves——

Comment on this

It is for the same length of time but not at the weekend.

Comment on this

That is right. You met in more leisurely days at midweek. At the Ard-Fheis there was no policy discussion; members seemingly talked about anything they liked. Various Ministers got up at different points and made speeches. The nature of the Fianna Fáil Party seemingly is one in which the Cabinet executive wield all control. The Ard-Fheis boils down to being a public relations exercise——

Comment on this

There is a clár from different cumainn around the country.

Comment on this

There is no obligation on anyone to take action?

Comment on this

If passed by the Ard-Fheis, the Government act on it.

Comment on this

Through the National Executive.

Comment on this

We will probably have time at the Vote of No Confidence next week to go into that matter. However, I have a good idea if I examined your clár for ten years back I would find matters on which no action has been taken.

Comment on this

What about the socialist Republic?

Comment on this

We will come to that. At least we honestly attempt to promulgate what we think our policy is to our members. There are many divisions and disagreements on the content of that policy. We see here the terrible penalty of being purely a pragmatic party, a "Party of Reality". Here we have Ministers punished for voting against a policy that nobody understands save the Taoiseach. This is the essence of their tragedy. Their Ministers meeting northern groups tell them they can hope for force to be used. They honestly believe that to be an aspect of Fianna Fáil policy. I heard one of the northern groups saying on television last night he understood this to be the upshot of a conversation he had with the Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Dr. Hillery. However, we shall hear more from other northern groups in the weeks ahead.

There are many similarities between Fianna Fáil and the Unionists. They share the same confusion between country and party. They share the same intolerance of any opposition. Just as the Unionists consider their loyalty to be beyond reproach Fianna Fáil consider their patriotism beyond reproach.

Let us get down to the problem of Deputy Blaney in particular. Enough attention has been given to these former Ministers, and I would prefer to see this debate concentrate on the position of the Taoiseach. However, Deputy Blaney said he thought his resignation might cause a further explosion and that was his reason for not resigning. He did not specify the explosion, whether it would be in Montrose or Belfast. Deputy Blaney made a sincere speech, according to his lights. It did not contain any reasoning that I could see in the heart of it but there was certainly emotion. What I could not understand is how he could square this emotion and his memories of childhood horror at the hands of Free Staters and other villains with the co-operation and the happy relationship which exists between the Fianna Fáil Party and the Unionist groups on Donegal County Council.

Comment on this

There is no Unionist group on Donegal County Council.

Comment on this

I know the name they call themselves now.

Comment on this

They do not call themselves anything.

Comment on this

And very convenient that they do not.

Comment on this

There are only two, and one belongs to the Fine Gael Party and the other to the Fianna Fáil Party, and there is one Independent. There is no Unionist group by any name.

Comment on this

Not by name. A very happy relationship exists all round the Border areas at county council level with the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

The Deputy is caught out. There is no Unionist group in the Donegal County Council.

Comment on this

I am not caught out. The only thing one could say about Deputy Blaney is that his political growth appears to have been arrested. Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien referred to people's feelings on this matter of unity being based on childhood experience, people who in adult life had not considered this problem afresh, and this apparently is Deputy Blaney's position. Let us recall Deputy Blaney's activities in recent times. In the northern elections he called on nationally-minded people to vote, in effect, Nationalist.

Comment on this

What did he say?

Comment on this

In effect, to vote Nationalist.

Comment on this

Those are the Deputy's words.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy look up his actual words.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making the case, not I.

Comment on this

He has shown by his advice in that area that he does not understand the development of politics there. In fact, his advice in his speeches at different times has interrupted very hopeful development in that area. He has delayed a Catholic and Protestant meeting ground politically in that northern area. His speeches have from time to time been criticised by the leaders of the movement in that part of the country. His remarks have been unhelpful to the civil rights movement at critical stages, and he has been attacked at various times by their leaders.

Comment on this

Who are their leaders now?

Comment on this

I was astonished during this debate at the number of interjections in lieu of speeches from Fianna Fáil Deputies. Their problem is that their alibi is so shattered that the Taoiseach cannot trust any of them to make an extended speech.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Lenehan does not cease interrupting I shall ask him to leave the House.

Comment on this

Who has been Deputy Blaney's adviser on the northern question? None other than Mr. Eddie McAteer. True to form yesterday he spoke out in defence of Deputy Blaney. Mr. McAteer is the man who advised the civil rights movement to be satisfied with half a loaf instead of a full loaf. He is the one that criticised the march that ended in Burntollet. The function of the Nationalist Party was to be the creature of Fianna Fáil. I suppose the relationship between the Nationalist Party and Fianna Fáil can be compared to the relationship of the satellite communist countries to Big Brother in Moscow, obedient to directions from Dublin at all times. Of course, it has gone the way of all political flesh. When it does not live up to the problems of its own area, it is no more. One of Deputy Blaney's mistakes on the northern question was that he was listening to politicians who no longer represented anything vital in the northern part of the country. I recall on several occasions here criticising the content of the speeches he made, pointing out that they posed a danger of having a divisive effect on the growing unity of the civil rights movement. I was howled down by Deputies in those benches who had no understanding of the complexities of the northern question. The Taoiseach attacked what he called the scurrilous charges and stood over the loyalty of his Ministers who were fully committed to his policy and whom he has now sacked.

Our recognition has been that the diverse traditions in that area must be welded together in a unity of the common people. I recall speaking last year at Carrickmore on the final rally election platform of Bernadette Devlin and telling the people there-and it was not a popular thing to say in Carrickmore—that they need expect no help from the south. I thought that the honest advice to give them. I said their only salvation lay in seeking and working for co-operation with Protestant working people in their areas and I said that the difficulties before them were as formidable as that job, in fact, was.

Similarly, as Deputy Dr. Browne here has made clear, when events in that area had finally taken a bad turn last August, when we visited Derry, a visit which was sneered at by Deputy Blaney as being something for the television cameras—there were things more dangerous than television cameras on the weekend we were in Derry—we met the defence committee, these young people, and gave them the honest although unpopular advice that they need not expect any help in the form of Irish troops coming across the Border. We pointed out to them something they already agreed themselves, that slaughter would follow in Belfast if there was any such intervention in Derry and we recognised the seriousness of the Belfast situation. We found it difficult to give such advice. They referred to the television address by the Taoiseach and obviously they expected some help in the form of force as indicated by the Taoiseach.

It is obvious that like Deputy Boland, Deputy Blaney shares total distrust of the intentions of the British Government but we accept, as people who understand the problem in that area, that the British Government in present circumstances has a continuing role in pressing reform in that area because the kernel of our difference with you is that we accept there are Irish men and women in that part of our country who do not as yet desire unity. We accept that and we accept that one million or more of them do not wish to join us in any kind of unity apart from Britain.

The ominous thing in the statements of both Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland is their concept that their fellow countrymen in the North of Ireland are Catholics. We reject that definition of our countrymen in the North of Ireland. So, it is clear when they talk about "our people" that they mean simply the Catholics. This is seemingly their sole concern.

First, look at the record of this Wilson Government. They have abolished the B Specials, changed them out of all recognition. Wilson's phasing away pledge has been fulfilled there. Major reforms are on the way. If this British Labour Government is returned, as now seems likely, is there one member opposite who will deny that a major initiative on the Irish question will be the next step of this Government? Here is the first British Administration in half a century which has by sad experience learned something of this problem and yet Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland see this argument in simple racial English/Irish enmity. Let us all agree on the main thing.

Comment on this

The members of the British Labour Party in the Council of Europe do not subscribe to that.

Comment on this

To what?

Comment on this

To your statement that if the British Government was elected again——

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking about his friends the Tories.

Comment on this

I am not. I am talking about the members of the Labour Party. I met them.

Comment on this

They do not agree that the Wilson Government will continue reforms in the area?

Comment on this

Not entirely.

Comment on this

I do not know what members the Deputy was speaking to. It is his right to state his understanding of the matter but we have had consultation in more official quarters. I am sure the Deputy is talking about the Tories. We accept, however, that the British have a continuing role in the present situation. We do not like the British being there, naturally, Certainly, we do not like them being there but they happen to be there and we accept, of course, that British imperialism is at bottom the enemy. British imperialism is as much the enemy of the English people as it is of ourselves and it is not confined to the Six County area. It is all around us down here and both Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland have aided and abetted the spread of British imperialism down here in years past. I recall these republicans of one-eyed vision talking about this northern question. I recall that they worked for the implementation of the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement which, of course, puts the final flourish of reconquest on this part of the country by British cheque books. I recall John Taylor in this House. Some Deputies will remember John Taylor, a man who has displayed his own reactionary nature even from the time of the O'Neill administration. He was in this House on that night and he said to me after all you republicans had trotted into the lobby there without as much as a thought. Not a question was raised on your side, because your Cabinet said it was a good bargain, it was necessary. The Ministers whom the Taoiseach has now sacked, who now proclaim themselves to be republicans, signed that agreement and John Taylor said that a leather medal should be struck for Seán Lemass that night, that he had finished the problem for them, this adventure of independence had ended that night. That was John Taylor's conclusion as to the political effects of the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Do you accept his conclusion?

Comment on this

I accept the validity of that conclusion, yes.

Comment on this

Do you accept the validity of the person who made it?

Comment on this

Sometimes the devil speaks truth.

Comment on this

As long as you recognise that.

Comment on this

We must examine statements on their merits. Constantly, every day, I read the Deputies' speeches and have to make the same decision. We accept the British Government has a continuing role in the area. We accept that the area has not the will to reform from within, has not got the community resources to reform from within. There is no cohesion there. Connolly, the founder of this party, saw many years ago with great clarity that if there was division in this country there would follow this political reaction on either side of the Border.

In fact, no political movement has suffered more than ourselves as a result of this division in our country. No party would have greater benefit in its political fortunes following on unification. We do suffer politically as a result of this division. Working people, common people on both sides suffer as a result of this division and the conclusion must follow that Fianna Fáil over the years have indulged in baby talk, infantile formulations, on this grave problem.

There was the de Valera formulation of an all-Ireland plebiscite. That was your alibi for a number of years. Of course, the all-Ireland plebiscite could hardly arise until the great reconciliation had been arrived at. It practically assumed the job of reconciliation had been completed. Then, for years, your sincerity on this northern question, from far back, has been questioned. There was the whole matter of the 1937 Constitution, scarcely a Constitution that would appeal to people of different traditions in the other part of the island. Always your temptation has been to put the Partition issue simply as English versus Irish, ignoring the complicating factor of loyalty which many Irish people in that part of our country had for the British connection. The British imperialism about which Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney talked yesterday is a far more complex thing than they realise. It exists in the 26 Counties as well as in the Six Counties.

It was interesting to hear Deputy Boland's comment on the murder of Garda Fallon. Deputy Boland was indignant, justifiably, about his telephone being tapped and he spoke out strongly about the Taoiseach's secret political police. The suggestion has been made throughout this debate that the delay in bringing the murderers of Garda Fallon to justice was connected with recent events. The Taoiseach described the suggestion as a most heinous and slanderous one and denied it vigorously.

Deputy Boland suggested yesterday, however, that he, a former member of the Cabinet, was not satisfied with the tardy pace of the investigations. His reason, which I do not accept, was that he saw this delay in apprehending these murderers as being a device by the Special Branch to extend their own influence. Frankly, I do not follow this reasoning, but it is remarkable that a Minister in the Cabinet should himself declare his disquiet.

Comment on this

Deputy Boland is not a member of the Cabinet.

Comment on this

He was a member. The Minister for Justice is only 24 hours old as a Minister and he should not be pontificating on the Cabinet position.

Comment on this

I am not pontificating. I am correcting something that is wrong.

Comment on this

Stop pontificating. More able men than the new Minister for Justice have fallen down from their thrones. I will not withdraw my admiration for Deputy Charles J. Haughey as a brilliant and able administrator. I did not agree with his politics, but he had my admiration in the areas I have mentioned. The Taoiseach yesterday sought a certain credit for soft-heartedness in that he did not speak to Deputy Haughey when he was ill; but Deputy Haughey was also a victim of this double think on the part of the Taoiseach and on the part of Fianna Fáil policy on the northern question. We do not have the details of Deputy Haughey's involvement, but I think it is fair to say that the Taoiseach must have known all along the real feelings of these men, his close advisers and his able lieutenants. He allowed them to develop these feelings and he set the trap into which he allowed them to walk. It was a principle of Machiavelli that one got rid of one's most able rivals. The Taoiseach marked down his opponents within the Party, refused to clarify his views on the north, and executed his colleagues when they made a mistake. The Taoiseach has an immense reserve of cunning. He has knifed his most able supporters within the Cabinet.

John Hume spoke last night on this question. He said that the fundamental question was the achievement of unity on the part of the people. It is not a matter of territory but a matter of combining together all the people of this island. It is quite obvious that both Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney did not regard people like Albert MacElroy, a direct descendant of Armour of Ballymoney, as one of the acceptable people of this small island. They were concerned purely and simply with the Catholic population.

We seek an election now. That is the only way to settle the issues raised here in this debate. This Cabinet smells, and that is putting it mildly. The Taoiseach is suspect. This place now smells more rotten than Denmark smelled to Hamlet. The contagion going out from this Administration will affect all the institutions of State unless we cleanse this House and replace the administration. Originally, the Fianna Fáil Party were based on sincerity and radical policies, but always there has been this double approach to the problem of unity. Some of the Fianna Fáil Party believe in a solution based on violence. There are those who believe that the north can be beaten into a kind of submissive unity. With the help of our party Fianna Fáil attempted to create a state that would become a beacon of independence, both economically and culturally. Early on, however, Fianna Fáil shelved that objective. Its main supporters became obsessed with what turned out to be their main occupation: the accumulation of greasy pence. Membership of the party became the path to patronage and wealth. Still both city and rural workers believed, while the party was under the inspired leadership of Eamon de Valera, in the radicalism of its origins.

It is, however, true to say that the people are now beginning to understand fresh things about the Fianna Fáil Party. I would hope that the events of the last few days, so to speak, enlighten them to see more clearly this so-called "Party of Reality", show them what it has in fact become and lead them to see how bankrupt it is with regard to policy on this question of unity. I hope that events will show that, though Ministers have been sacked, they have been sacked unjustifiably, because the Taoiseach never spelled out his policy on peace where the north is concerned. These Ministers have done wrong. The Taoiseach believes they have gone over the brink in the matter of using force. But the accusation can be levelled at the Taoiseach that he never attempted to rationalise and formulate in clear terms what, in fact, Fianna Fáil Party policy was on the northern question. Whatever wrong they have done, these Ministers can plead ignorance of the grand design in the Taoiseach's own mind in regard to policy on the northern question.

These Ministers could always claim that they did not know. They thought they were acting for the best and in accordance with the Taoiseach's policy. Both sacked Ministers have said they still believe in the Fianna Fáil policy on unity. Yet both are sacked for offending against the policy to which they still believe they subscribe. They cannot see where they have gone wrong.

Fianna Fáil have attempted to thwart political development and the hopeful things that have occurred in recent years in the north. They have attacked Bernadette Devlin. At this very moment they are preparing, in company with the Nationalist Party, to defeat her in the coming general election by putting up a candidate against her to ensure that she cannot be returned. This is the plan and the co-operation that exists between Fianna Fáil and the Nationalist Party. What Fianna Fáil want in the north is a green Tory Party so as to have a docile party there which would suit them for their propaganda purposes on this side of the Border. I submit that the Fianna Fáil attitude has been to utilise the problems of the north and play to the passions of the south for their own political advantage. Perhaps Fianna Fáil are even now in that area in collusion with the provisional republicans against the constitutional republicans, because both Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland said that illegal organisations were no longer illegal when one crossed the Border.

Comment on this

Who is responsible for the Red element going up there?

Comment on this

The Ho-Chi Minh trail?

Comment on this

I do not know but I saw these people in Newry distributing leaflets from their headquarters here in O'Connell Street. Who sent them up there?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

The Deputy should be able to tell us.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think I have some superior knowledge of these groups?

Comment on this

I am only asking.

Comment on this

I have been making the point that Fianna Fáil have been thwarting developments in the north and preventing people of different religions from coming together.

Comment on this

Green elements. Who is sending the Red elements?

Comment on this

I have said that the Deputy's party, along with the Nationalist Party, is preparing to put up a candidate to defeat Bernadette Devlin in the coming election.

Comment on this

The lady who sneered at our flag.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy sneering at her?

Comment on this

I would sneer at anybody who would——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies should abandon this question and answer session.

Comment on this

I do not know what Bernadette Devlin may have sneered at but she has lived in great peril of her life for many years. I would say it is a small offence to sneer at our flag, if this is true, after those years of peril. This young girl has probably put up with more physical peril than all the pseudo-republicans opposite.

Comment on this

I think she was sneering at people who waved flags as substitutes for thought, not at the flags themselves.

Comment on this

That seems more correct.

Comment on this

She sneered at the flag when she came out of the court in Derry.

Comment on this

We do not know. The Deputy should make a speech about his suspicions and we shall judge his evidence.

Comment on this

I shall do that.

Comment on this

We had Deputy Blaney practically weeping here at one part of his speech, quite sincerely, I think, as he looked over his family history. What was going through my mind was: how many people were forced to go abroad whose families also took part in the fight for freedom and who are not here to tell the tale about the sacrifices they made to win that freedom?

The really serious policy charge that can be levelled at these Republican posturings by Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney is that they neglected to understand the changing situation in the north. They were members of a Cabinet which, year after year, went up for conversations about the weather with Captain O'Neill and, year after year in this House, we warned them of the nature of the Unionist Party. I recall being called a Paisleyite by the other custom-built republican, Deputy Colley, now Minister for Finance. I remember saying that the price of their conversations with the Unionist Party should be some progress on reform in that area. I did not expect them to go up seeking unity, but at least they should raise the injustices people were enduring in that part of the country.

The extraordinary thing is that these latterday republicans, who rushed into speeches when these talks broke down, were silent throughout these years. If we dug up the files I am sure we would see many happy photographs of Deputy Boland with Mr. Craig or Deputy Blaney with other bigots. How do these Republicans explain the years of silence? Late in the day they began to make speeches and began to attempt to divide the movement in that part of the country. The doubt remains as to whether they were addressing themselves to Twenty-Six County prejudice so as to continue misconceptions in this part of the country about the northern problem and its solutions. They certainly had not done any mature thinking on that problem.

At another time I think one of these gentlemen attacked Gerry Fitt. They attacked people who were working hard in that complex situation. First, they met the Unionists; they sought no gains. The talks broke down and they returned to their Republican base with denunciations of the Border and so on.

It has been clear that since last August a policy of collusion between sections of Fianna Fáil and extremist groups in the north has been operating. This has been noted in articles published in the past year. This makes it more extraordinary that the Taoiseach should know nothing about these developments until a fortnight ago. This is quite incredible.

Yesterday The Guardian reported the fact that the British Secret Service was acquainted with these problems for many months back. The conclusion is that the Taoiseach is either incompetent or dishonest. In either case it is clear that he should do the decent thing and resign. The credit of Parliament and the power of a party depends on more than a majority vote. It is true that Fianna Fáil can hang on, that they have a majority. They can reassure themselves and say this morning: “There is no problem; we have a majority. It does not matter about public opinion.” This can be done; but it is my profound conviction that so much public disquiet has been caused, so many suspicions aroused in the past few days of this extraordinary sequence of events that the only honest thing to do is to face the people in an election. The leader of the Fianna Fáil Party will be further discredited, as the people explore more and more the implications of this squalid business, and more people are implicated.

The other night none of them came out to defend Charlie Haughey or the other Ministers. I have often seen them here when Deputy Haughey was Minister for Finance and they were happy if he looked in their direction, but the other night none of them were here to defend him. Over previous months, obviously many people in that party shared the opinions of these sacked Ministers. In fact, many of them may still have these feelings secretly wrapped up in this party unity of theirs, in which they can have these public disagreements, in which they can plot and in which they can go into the company of illegal organisations and still declare they are behind the Taoiseach and Fianna Fáil policy.

Some speakers mentioned that nobody in the country accepts this unity. It does not matter what divisions they accuse their enemies of having because, from now on, they are a divided party in the public mind. The only honourable thing to do, since in my opinion the elements in that party who pin their hopes on a holocaust in the north later this year and whose political future depends on this occurring and who now stand to gain strength in that party, is to hold an election.

Do not tell me that this children's Cabinet will be any match for a party which allows Boland, Blaney and Haughey to roam amongst the party faithful around the country. These children may have the best intentions in the world. Deputy Molloy, the Minister designate for Local Government, said that he is looking forward to the challenge. Indeed, he may face a greater challenge than he thinks and it will not be confined to continuing the dedicated work of the building of more houses which he suggests was Deputy Boland's concern.

It is obvious, therefore, that if the Taoiseach is the statesman he proclaims himself to be, and is so concerned about the national interest, before this meeting gains any more strength within that divided party he should go to the country to prevent this contagion spreading. By pretending that this problem does not exist, by hoping that it will go away, matters become worse. As I said earlier, the whole style of the Taoiseach is to take no decision on anything, to take no action. This has been his style of politics and if he is true to form he will take no action on this matter.

When the debate concludes today he will give us no answers. He will look at the clock and blame Father Time for his lack of explanation. He will hope that someone in the Opposition will interrupt him so that he can get away with some trivial excuse. This matter is too serious. The problems and questions here in the past few days are too serious. If the Taoiseach has integrity, if he wants to live up to the opinion of him of the ordinary man-in-the-street as Honest Jack, there is only one honest thing to do at this stage and that is to hold an election.

Some of us may have a shrewd idea that others may be in trouble in the election but that is common to all politicians. However, Fianna Fáil may win. In that case they have nothing to fear but, at this critical hour, they must get a renewed mandate from the people because in their midst there are people who have other policies on the north. To stop their pernicious influence spreading the Taoiseach must cancel their support within the party and go to the people for a renewal of his mandate.

Obviously we need a new Administration here with a policy grounded on true experience of the problems of the north. Quite obviously this Administration have been too cowardly to develop a policy. They have developed no policy on unity. Over the past months since August last, when we were given ample warning of the explosive possibilities of the situation, the conduct of the Taoiseach has proved that he does not intend to develop a policy. Therefore, since they have not got the resolution within their party to take any national leadership on this problem, the most disastrous thing for them to do would be to continue with the subterfuge that all is well within the party, to continue until we reach the middle of this summer with this divided party, with certain former Ministers openly backing different militant groups in the north. In that serious situation, should they continue in power, they will put the lives and liberties of every man and woman in this country in peril.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

No matter what any Government Deputy says in this House this country is facing a crisis. There is no good in the Taoiseach trying to get the headlines in the national papers and claiming that there is no crisis. We are facing the most serious crisis. The attempted illegal importation of arms into this country by members of the Fianna Fáil Government will never be forgotten by the people. The man who must bear the responsibility for not taking firmer action is the Taoiseach, the so-called Honest Jack Lynch. It is fair to say that the British papers are unanimous in their view that arms have been imported into the Republic of Ireland over the past few months. How much arms, we do not know. Where they are, we do not know. What they were intended for, we do not know.

I should like to quote from the Irish Times of 8th May in which it is stated:

In London last night, Scotland Yard Special Branch, MI.5 and MI.6 were said to have infiltrated and destroyed an international plot to smuggle arms to Ireland. The report said that investigations started seven months ago and that the Special Branch intelligence officers had made investigations in Belgium, Austria, Switzerland as well as the Republic, Northern Ireland and Britain.

It is folly for anyone to say that this was going on and the Taoiseach or the Government did not know about it. I believe they did know about it and that they did absolutely nothing to stop it. As has been repeated time and again during the past 24 hours, the Government must go to the country because they are a dishonest Government containing people who, according to the Taoiseach, and I quote from volume 246, column 642, of the Official Report:

On Monday, 20th April, and Tuesday, 21st April, the security forces of this country at my disposal brought me information about an alleged attempt to unlawfully import arms from the continent. Prima facie, these reports involve two Members of the Government.

It now transpires that more members of the Government are involved. The statement issued by Captain James Kelly heightens the crisis in no small way. He has stated that the Minister for Defence, Deputy J. Gibbons, was in some way knowledgeable about the whole affair. The Taoiseach stated he did not want any slight association with anything treacherous concerning any of his Ministers. Yet, in the motion before us, we continue with the appointment of the Minister for Defence in another capacity. We do not know where this treacherous plot will end. It is only leading us and the people to a greater suspicion that the whole truth is not being told, that some information is being suppressed somewhere.

The people and this Parliament are entitled to know what in God's name is happening to our country. Such information apparently is not forthcoming. It would seem that the existence of the Fianna Fáil Party in Government is more important than the integrity of government in Ireland: let Jack Lynch lead on. He is leading us to anarchy. He is leading us into a banana republic situation. The Fianna Fáil Party does not seem to care so long as they are in power. The people will not forget the so-called unanimous vote of the Fianna Fáil Party the other night. Whatever shipments of these arms have got inside the country, and the consignments that were stopped, were apparently intended for an illegal organisation. What use was this illegal organisation——

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Were these arms going to be used for——

Comment on this

The courts must not have started yet. Did Deputy O'Higgins have a good sleep?

Comment on this

I did not have a sleep at all.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

It is important to know the uses for which these arms were intended either outside or within the Republic. For instance, some of them might be used in the robbing of banks or in the North of Ireland where they could jeopardise the lives of ordinary people. There is a crisis in the Fianna Fáil Party whether they like it or not. There are two wings in the Fianna Fáil Party. There is the gun element and the gun type of Republicanism, which is not defined by anyone, and there is the old, non-gun element. I noticed that a few Fianna Fáil speakers who had the guts to speak in this debate were playing to their constituents. On the one hand they backed the Taoiseach but on the other hand the passive, radical elements wanted arms up in the north. That is that. I suppose they have to please everyone in their constituencies.

We, in Fine Gael, are unanimous that no force should be used by the Government of the Republic in Northern Ireland. Apparently that is also the policy of the Taoiseach but it is not the policy of everyone in Fianna Fáil. You still cannot settle down to ordinary parliamentary Government: you must have the guns again. If you ever bring in guns again, we in Fine Gael will do as the Cumann na nGaedheal Government did when we established this country: we will take guns out of politics again.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair warns Deputies that the patience of the Chair is nearly exhausted with interruptions like this. Furthermore the Deputy who is speaking will please address his remarks to the Chair and not to Members across the floor of the House which is provoking these interruptions.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

It is important to note the reaction of people abroad and the possible effect on our country. Our tourist industry must suffer and will suffer because of developments that have taken place this week. This is a most unfortunate state of affairs and nothing that can be said can change it. This year our tourist earnings will decline radically. Consequently, this country could be faced with a serious crisis in its balance of payments.

Comment on this

The Deputy has no evidence to substantiate that statement.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

How long will the patience of the Chair tolerate interruptions from the Government side of the House?

Comment on this

Sit down.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

When I am finished I shall sit down. I am asking the Chair how long it will put up with rude, ignorant interruptions from the Fianna Fáil Party while Deputy E. Collins is making an intelligent speech?

Comment on this

They were interrupting over there all night long when Deputy O. J. Flanagan was not present.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Are you defying the Chair just as you are defying everything else?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair repeats the warning given several times during the night It may be necessary for order that the Chair may have to ask Deputies to leave this Chamber. In that event the Deputies would be deprived of their voting rights today. The Chair is loath to do anything like that and therefore seeks the co-operation of all Deputies in the keeping of order to the end of the debate.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If the Chair would put three or four out one would hear a pin drop in this House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair appeals to everybody on all sides of the House to co-operate.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

That the tourist industry will suffer because of the present crisis is common knowledge, unfortunately. I would like to refer, also, to the Budget that was introduced a short time ago. This Budget was a most irresponsible piece of budgetary thinking. While we welcome the increases in social welfare which the Budget contained we must point to the incipient inflation that is taking place at this point of time and say that these increases were necessary if only to maintain the purchasing power of the people concerned. However, that Budget did not deal with the important economic problems facing the country. Practically every official report published by the Central Bank and by research institutes points to a very serious balance of payments position during this year.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I suppose the Government had more important matters on their minds but the country should come first. We are faced with an autumn Budget which, in my opinion, will be the severest ever to be introduced here.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has no wish to interrupt Deputies in this matter but they will understand that the Budget is still available for discussion before the House but must not be discussed on this particular motion.

Comment on this

That is, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, if the House is available for discussion of the Budget.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I merely refer to it in passing in order to emphasise the lack of interest of the Government in the affairs of State which affect the lives of so many people. We listened to a most contradictory speech from the former Minister for Local Government who, only yesterday morning, made the headlines in the Irish Independent because of his revelations of phone tapping and Gestapo-like surveillance of the Taoiseach. How could that same man sit behind the Taoiseach and vote for him? I cannot see the logic of all this. It does not add up. Perhaps the hunger and thirst for power is more important than the welfare of the country.

We also heard the speech of Deputy Blaney. I accept that he had a Republican upbringing, that he is entitled to his sentiments in that regard as he is entitled to be a member of Fianna Fáil, but there are as many Republicans and patriots in Fine Gael as there are in Fianna Fáil so I do not think that has any bearing whatsoever on the current crisis with which we must deal separately, namely, the illegal importation of arms. This is a serious offence. It is probably a treasonable offence and it does not matter under what guise the attempt to import these arms was made.

While the Taoiseach had prima facie evidence in relation to the plot I cannot understand how he, the so-called Honest Jack Lynch, could accept the vote here on Wednesday night of Deputy Blaney. If someone did behind my back what Deputy Blaney has done to the Taoiseach I would not accept his vote. It is also interesting to note that when Deputy Blaney came into the House on Wednesday and sat behind the Taoiseach's back there were quite a few handshakes for him and there was a fair bit of applause after he had made his speech. This only heightens the division within Fianna Fáil. I do not believe that the former Ministers will be happy sitting on the back benches and voting for Jack Lynch. They are much too hungry for power and will seek power in whatever way they can.

Other speakers have said that there is a drift in this country towards anarchy. If there is such a drift it is being aided by Fianna Fáil. The Garda force have been demoralised because of the failure to track down the murderer of Garda Fallon. Many cases have been cited here against various Ministers of what can only amount to corrupt practices or sharp practices at the very least. All of these incidents are aiding the drift towards anarchy. The people of this country have no desire for a situation in which gun power would be the order of the day. I say that the only decent thing for the Taoiseach to do is to go to the Park and hand in his resignation so that the people can make their own judgement on this crisis. The people should have their say about this conspiracy. The result of that would be a massive swing away from the Government because people are not prepared to trust such a Government. Too much has been proven against them. This Government is a dishonest Government and must get out for the sake of the country. The sooner they do that the better.

Comment on this

I do not mind admitting, Sir, that it is with considerable reluctance I take part in this debate. It is a sad occasion for our country. I have a personal reason for my reluctance and that is because of the admiration I felt for the Taoiseach when I first heard of the action he had taken in this matter. However, it was a very different matter when I heard the Taoiseach's opening statement in this House. It was thin to an astounding degree and his speech at the conclusion of the debate on Deputy O'Malley's appointment as Minister for Justice was even more astonishing. Let me take one example: Deputy Keating had asked logical questions and many Members of the House, not associated with the Labour Party, felt that he had put his finger on a number of points that were difficult to answer. The Taoiseach showed extreme irritation when replying to him.

Similarly, in relation to the Limerick letters which I had seen first two months ago and of which subsequently numerous copies were around the House, photostat copies and otherwise. The Taoiseach's explanation just did not hold water. Above all what upset me about the Taoiseach's reply to that person, who is supposed not to exist, though the Taoiseach replied five or six days later and he had all the resources of the State to find out whether the person existed or not, was the extreme language in the final sentence of the Taoiseach's reply that whatever had happened had taken place under insupportable provocation. I have high regard for Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries and I do not think under any circumstances should Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries—and indeed this has been the tradition of the House—ever get themselves into positions in which they would suffer insupportable provocation, in other words provocation that they could not stand up to. This is the person whom we now have as the Minister for Justice—of all portfolios in the Government—this young man who could not stand up to whatever remark was made to him, presumably. I do not know what it was because we have not been told. The Taoiseach's letter was all right up to the final sentence. The final sentence in my opinion was to use his own word, insupportable, or unpardonable. I do not remember exactly which word he used.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I should like to point out to the Deputy with no disrespect that this letter was proven to be a frame-up and a readyup——

Comment on this

Not the Taoiseach's letter.

Comment on this

The address of the original letter was proven not to exist or, alternatively, nobody lived at the actual address from whence the letter came. I think it is only fair to say that this was a frame-up.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it not right that the Taoiseach stated he had investigated this case and had shown that the facts were as stated?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

These points are not points of order.

Comment on this

The point I want to make is that the final sentence of the Taoiseach's letter to me was not the kind of sentence the Taoiseach should write. If the matter was of no significance, as he suggested in the first part of his letter, why did he say what he did say in the final sentence? This is some months ago. If it happened in the middle of this serious crisis I would have said the Taoiseach had very serious matters on his mind and got irritated and added this sentence. I would say no more. But it has not been disposed of to the satisfaction of any reasonable person. It is not for me to sit in judgment on the Taoiseach but as a public representative on a serious occasion like this, even though I do so with great reluctance, I must contribute to this debate. I feel it is incumbent on me to give an honest opinion and I have attempted to form an honest opinion about events that have taken place.

We have had in this country a long tradition that politicians did not become wealthy. This was an excellent tradition. Unfortunately, in recent years, even if they have achieved it most honourably, a number of Ministers, while they were Ministers, have become wealthy. This has never happened before in this country and it is a matter of the utmost seriousness from the point of view of our status. One member of the Government—I am not saying he is the only one—has certainly come out of this with an enhanced reputation. That is Deputy Colley, who spoke some time ago about low standards in high places. An attempt was made at that time to suggest that he was not relating to his colleagues. I do not think anybody accepted that he was referring to anybody else but his colleagues. Where were the high places if they were not among his own colleagues? Unfortunately I did not hear Deputy Blaney's speech but I was here for Deputy Boland's speech and I had considerable sympathy with Deputy Boland in the way he spoke. If a man is fit to be a member of the Government his phone should not be tapped.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I was aware at one stage some years ago, and I made an official protest to the then head of the post office, that my 'phone was being tapped. Not alone that, but when we had our convention for the Labour Party in Dublin South-West in March, 1967, the Special Branch squad car was parked in the lane near the hall where we were having our function. What for? What were we supposed to be doing? It was a perfectly straight, above-board, political convention. What was it doing there? What has happened? Since I came back to this House nine months ago I have found that the security arrangements here are extreme to the point of being grossly irritating and objectionable from any decent person's point of view. It is only eight years since I was a Member of the House for a long period and the whole thing has changed. It may be that Deputies here have not noticed it but I have noticed it. I was here for a long period and I say this in all sincerity. This is so to a degree that irritates me extremely and indeed I am afraid I have shown that irritation at times. There are security arrangements around here. Why are they here? Why has this change occurred? Obviously there must have been some feeling somewhere some years ago that it was necessary to indulge in these extreme protective measures, the kind of measures that presumably were here during the Civil War.

I was not in the House when Deputy Blaney concluded his speech but I was informed by a responsible Member of the Seanad that when he concluded he was applauded by 17 members of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

This does not hang together for rational people. Two young Deputies spoke this morning. One of them who happens to be a relative of my own, even though a distant relative, Deputy Meaney. He was subjected to interruptions, including, I regret to say, an interruption by myself. I admire those young men who come in to defend their party, but it is no use depending on young men alone. I do not notice the shrewd old operators in the Fianna Fáil Party getting up to defend the Taoiseach. Deputy J. O'Leary also got up to defend the Taoiseach and his Party. One thing he said was that the Fianna Fáil Party were the only party capable of running the country. Many men of my age will remember what happened under the Nazi system. Many of the present generation know what happens in communist countries where the people there are of the opinion that it is only the communists who are capable of running the country.

The other evening we had the extraordinary spectacle of groups of Deputies walking around Leinster Lawn during the afternoon, meeting at 6 o'clock and all coming away from the meeting an hour later saying they were unanimously supporting the Taoiseach. Could it be that the Taoiseach said to them: "Unless you support me I am going to the country". Could that have been what happened? That is a fair and reasonable question to ask. Could it also be that they all said: "We had better toe the line"? Perhaps some of them felt a bit more uncomfortable after following that line.

Any suggestion that the importation of arms into this part of the country under an official cloak will help to reunify the country is really tragic. However, it could easily result not just in civil war in Northern Ireland but in civil war in the Republic of Ireland. We certainly have seen in recent months men who were apparently able to act with impunity and rob banks. We have not had that kind of thing for a long time, but now it is almost a common occurrence.

We have every reason to object to the kind of smear campaign which was engaged in last year during the election. I must say that was not done in my constituency but it was in the neighbouring constituency. The performance of one man in that constituency was appalling, but yet he got 2½ times as many votes as another man who was associated with him, but who did not engage in the smear campaign. That shows the extent of this kind of thing. We in the Labour Party have every right to stand up in this House and speak about this matter.

Deputy Murphy yesterday afternoon made a very serious point in his speech. He said those arms originally came from Czechoslovakia. The serious point he made was not that they were bought in any particular place but that there was a communist government in that country. We all know that the communist government there at present is very different from that of Mr. Dubcek. The point made by Deputy Murphy was that you could not really buy a pencil in that country without being checked on; yet this is the country from which those ten ton of guns were bought.

A former member of the Defence Forces who was retired, not dismissed, made a savage attack on the Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons, now the Minister for Agriculture designate. In this country the Ministry of Agriculture is regarded as a more superior Ministry than that of Defence. I had the highest esteem for Deputy Hilliard when he was Minister for Defence, but that is not to say that there is not a certain understanding about the ranking of Ministers.

Deputy Gibbons's name was originally mentioned in this matter, but then it disappeared from it. I am not making any allegations one way or the other but it certainly is most disturbing to think that the name of the Minister for Defence should be linked with this smuggling of guns. There is no doubt about it, whether or not you accept the story of the former Captain Kelly, he was operating closely with the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

That is not what he was charged for.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy understand how very serious this matter is? There is no doubt about it that what Captain Kelly said yesterday was extremely slanderous. We are not living in cuckoo-land.

Comment on this

The Deputy should read his statement carefully.

Comment on this

I did not read it carefully. In the last few days I have not seen television or listened to the radio. I have been relying on the newspapers and I have not been able to read this statement carefully.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said that not the slightest suspicion should attach to the Minister.

Comment on this

I am told that Telefís Éireann refused to publish the statement of the former Captain Kelly, that it was accepted by the BBC and then Telefís Éireann broadcast it. This is most extraordinary. I have said in recent times that we were rapidly becoming a banana republic in this country. The countries of South America will soon be able to say: "What can one expect from a turf country". If I might strike a light note on a serious matter, the word "turf" means two different things in this country and, therefore, it would apply on the double here. This country is fast becoming a happy hunting ground in recent years for all kinds of international chancers——

Comment on this

You have a few on the benches over there.

Comment on this

On these benches? At any rate let me say that they have not lined their pockets out of the Exchequer yet.

Comment on this

You have.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Deputy O'Donovan must be allowed to continue his speech.

Comment on this

Deputy John O'Leary told us that Fianna Fáil were the republican party. We all remember the long period during which the term "republican party" was put in brackets under the Fianna Fáil Party. However, they never made this country a republic whereas the man who became Taoiseach in the despised anti-republican Fine Gael Party made this country a republic. When a certain day was declared republic day Fianna Fáil deliberately boycotted it. I well remember that my neighbour and myself both put out flags because we considered it an important day in the life of this State. It took the gun out of politics for a considerable period in this country.

I am of the opinion that any political party is greater than any individual in it and I go further and say that the country is greater than any political party. However, there is a great deal of evidence that Fianna Fáil have persuaded themselves that they are the country. If they want evidence on this point, as a party they got 45 per cent of the votes cast in last year's election. They are here by accident——

Comment on this

On behalf of what percentage of the population is the Deputy speaking?

Comment on this

A much greater percentage than our representation shows and the Minister knows this.

Comment on this

You are not entitled to speak on behalf of everybody. We are entitled to speak for the majority.

Comment on this

I am speaking on behalf of John O'Donovan. He is the individual on whose behalf I am speaking.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not entitled to speak on behalf of everyone in Ireland——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Deputy O'Donovan must be allowed Nolan can make his speech afterwards, to continue.

Comment on this

In a matter like this one has to try and think for oneself; it is essential. Let us not fool ourselves. No Deputy wants an election 12 months after there has been one. We put down a vote of no confidence in the Government before it was known that the Fianna Fáil Party were going to vote unanimously. The Deputy may smile but that is absolutely true. We in this party have been accused of being communists, Maoists and so on. Since there has been so much talk about this, let me tell you that by accident I passed by the Maoist march last Tuesday week in Pearse Street and one would weep for them. I told a young member of my family that I had passed this march and I said, "Give a guess how many were there". The young girl in my family was right on target, "About 30?". There were about 30 youngsters marching along, flanked by about half-a-dozen policemen, who were mainly there to see that the march did not unduly interfere with the traffic. When we in the Labour Party are called Maoists and communists the people on the opposite side know there is no truth in this statement.

I do not believe that the Fianna Fáil Party can paper over the cracks. It would have been much better if, when his Ministers refused to resign, the Taoiseach took the same decision as Deputy Costello took in the spring of 1957 when the second inter-Party Government had taken the harsh decisions which made it inevitable that they would lose the election. This shows the different approach to Government in this country. Far from demonstrating that Fianna Fáil are the only party fit to govern the country, it shows that there are other people who have higher standards about how they should behave in certain circumstances.

I saw a note in the paper about a "government of boys". Perhaps it was because it would create the least trouble in his party that the Taoiseach did, in fact, promote to ministerial rank those who had been Parliamentary Secretaries. However, they were not made Parliamentary Secretaries because they were ministerial timber. I think they were made Parliamentary Secretaries because they were young and energetic and, with the help of their official cars, they would do the organisational work of the party. I seriously object to young men who have no experience worth talking about in political life being made Ministers of State. Ministers in this country take precedence over everybody else; they are the first people in the country. Yet we had the situation where Ministers were tailed by squad-cars and their 'phones were tapped. Either they should never have been made Ministers or before anything like that happened the Taoiseach should have said to them, "I am sorry about this but I must ask for your resignation." He has an absolute right to do it. I find it very hard to believe that these Ministers were engaging in activities which were not directed towards the welfare of the country. If that is so, they will not rest on the backbenches. It is not in the nature of such men to rest; they will not go farming or anything like that. I am inclined to think the Fianna Fáil Party are in serious trouble and, if there is not a general election now, there will have to be one before the end of the year.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I speak as one of the longest-serving Deputies in this House and as one who has participated in most of the debates over the past 28 years. Never in all that long membership of this House has any matter come up for discussion that has lowered this Parliament more or brought the Irish Government into greater ridicule than the matter before us. Is it any wonder that this debate carried on all through the night? Is it any wonder that Members of this House are viewing with astonishment and alarm the serious implications involved?

I never agree with the contributions of the Honourable Member for Bannside, the Rev. Ian Paisley, but he did say a few days ago, when this disgraceful conduct was made known, "The chickens are coming home to roost"—a very accurate summing up. How true. If only Mr. Paisley knew a little more about southern politics he would not include the whole south in that statement about the chickens coming home to roost but would confine it to Fianna Fáil.

Is it not true to say that the Fianna Fáil Party has its origins in hatred, division, arms, revolt, disrespect for the law? These are the seeds from which the Fianna Fáil organisation has bloomed. To that bitterness, division and revolt one can add the exercise of robbing banks. Therefore, we can see that the wheel has turned full circle. This party has been in office for a long, long time. Deputies are expressing astonishment that the Fianna Fáil Party should hold a meeting and after less than 60 minutes of deliberation, come out with a united front moryah. I believe it to be united. It must be united. If there is any break they all lose the spoils. They are there for what they can get out of it.

Can anyone tell us how one can become a millionaire in five years? It is possible to become a millionaire in a very short space of time, because all down through the years the history of Fianna Fáil has been extremely shady. It has a bad history: railway shares, Monaghan bacon factory, Locke's Distillery, the Singer case, the Potez investment. These are all connected with Fianna Fáil's conduct in the past 30 years. It is only right that very serious note should be taken when we see that the attention of the Taoiseach has been directed to certain irregularities. The Taoiseach has explained that he could not act with any greater speed. One would assume that immediately the Taoiseach was informed of a serious situation of this kind he would act as a matter of urgency. There are thousands of people in this country who believe it was the intention of the Taoiseach to cover up this matter if it had not been for the fact that the leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Cosgrave, decided to act in the interest of the country.

There are a lot of conflicting views in relation to the resignation of Deputy Moran, the dismissal of Deputy Blaney, the dismissal of Deputy Haughey, the resignation of Deputy Boland. All the members of the Government have had experience of team-work. It is a fact that Deputy Moran, Deputy Blaney, Deputy Haughey, Deputy Brennan and Deputy Boland represented a very major portion of the Government. Many people want to know why the Minister for Defence has been excluded from the list of Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries now out of office. The position is—and it is well that the country should know it— that when there was a line-up between Deputy Colley and Deputy Lynch, Deputy Gibbons took the side of the Taoiseach and the Taoiseach did not forget it when the Minister for Defence was in difficulties. I venture to say that no matter what evidence is presented by Captain Kelly, no matter how strongly he makes his case or no matter what accuracy is attached to it, it will not help in endeavouring to have the Minister for Defence removed from office because when the Taoiseach needed a friend he had Deputy Gibbons, so when Deputy Gibbons is in a spot of difficulty, he has the Taoiseach in return.

On the front page of today's Irish Press there is part of the text of Captain Kelly's statement:

Under privilege in the Dáil Mr. Gibbons has attacked me. All he has said is a tissue of lies. Any work which I did I brought to the knowledge of Mr. Gibbons at any and every opportunity.

It is a very serious situation if a public statement is made by a man of the standing of Captain Kelly in which he accuses the Minister for Defence of misleading this House and describes what the Minister said as a tissue of lies. Surely the most serious possible steps must be taken to ascertain whether Captain Kelly is accurate in his description or whether in fact the Minister for Defence has deliberately misled Parliament? This is where the responsibility rests on the Taoiseach.

I do not think it is right to kick a man when he is down. There was a very sad spectacle in the House the other evening. I watched Deputy Haughey in the House and he was shunned and deliberately avoided by his own party colleagues, people who on another occasion would have thrown themselves in his way to seek perhaps a concession of one kind or another or to have a pleasant exchange of greetings. Human nature being what it is, when a man is down everybody is down on him. So it was that Deputy Haughey was avoided like the plague when he came into the House the other evening, by people who otherwise would have put their arms around him. We cannot condone the activities of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney.

Comment on this

Alleged.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Yes, I accept that very fully because the Taoiseach has not given this House any proof. I accept that. In the case of these men who occupied very high public positions, it is most extraordinary that there is from Deputy Haughey a blank denial and a blank denial from Deputy Blaney. In the case of Deputy Moran the Taoiseach went to great pains to tell the House that he had tendered his resignation because of ill-health. Deputy Boland, the former Minister for Local Government, went to great pains to tell the House and the country that Mr. Moran's resignation was asked for. Who is telling the truth? We have Deputy Gibbons being charged with misleading. When Deputy Cosgrave asked the Taoiseach were there going to be more resignations, the Taoiseach, innocently, asked what did Deputy Cosgrave mean, said he did not know what he was talking about, and asked could Deputy Cosgrave be helpful, and let him know what he had at the back of his mind, knowing at the same time the facts which he was endeavouring to keep from Parliament.

This is a very serious matter. A prime minister has extraordinary responsibilities. Is there any prime minister in the world who would have the telephone of his Ministers tapped? Rather than the low, mean, mangy practice of tapping a telephone or putting one's ear to a keyhole, or sneaking up behind a person's back in an endeavour to overhear a confidential conversation, would it not have been better for the Taoiseach, the moment he became suspicious of Deputy Boland, to have relieved him of his responsibility at that time, to be frank and straight with him and say: "Look, honestly, I do not like you in my company. I do not trust you. I cannot rely on you. You are not the kind of company I like to be associating with." But, no. He has not the frankness to tell Deputy Boland that.

Mark you, I sympathise with Deputy Boland as I would sympathise with anyone who laboured in that extraordinary position for so long. Fianna Fáil supporters are loud in their efforts to spread throughout the country that it is "Honest Jack" who is trying to clean up his own pigsty; that it is "Honest Jack" who is endeavouring to wash his hands clean, but it is my opinion that it is the Taoiseach himself who is the arch villain of the piece because he misled Deputy Cosgrave. He was not straight and honest with his own Ministers. He proceeded to devise a trap; he tapped their telephones. He did not have the courage to tell them he did not want their company. This is the man who is going to parade now before the whole country as the honest man, the sincere man, the man who would not be associated with anything except that which could be described as 100 per cent perfect. That is why I have a feeling that if Deputy Cosgrave had not approached the Taoiseach, poor Deputy Mick Moran would have been the scapegoat. There would have been no question of Deputy Haughey coming into the picture at all. There would have been no question of a resignation from Deputy Boland or Deputy Brennan. There would have been a complete cover-up, under the guise of the ill-health of the former Minister for Justice. The Taoiseach himself, the honest man, was going to play that trump card, and he would have got away with it, were it not for the fact that Deputy Cosgrave had the facts.

Comment on this

Or, perhaps, he was being blackmailed as well.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Deputy Michael Moran would have been used as the cover-up and the scapegoat. I want to say, without fear of contradiction, that from time to time we have difficult situations arising. One would imagine that in this case efforts are being made by Parliament to inquire into the activities of these former members of the Government. The position is that it is their own leader who has them in the dock, not Fine Gael and not Labour. It is their own leader. A Government which is revealed to the public as a Government in which there is suspicion and distrust between the head of the Government and his Ministers is not a Government that can rule effectively, well and efficiently. We are dealing with the appointment of three new Ministers. I wish them good luck.

Comment on this

They will need it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

A little bit of good luck would not come amiss on this occasion. I want to inquire now how these new Ministers propose to carry out their duties. Will they immediately take on the róle of making a special concession to the Taca subscribers? This is a very serious situation. It has become rampant all over the country. Unless we can get the people all over the country to revolt against it it will have very serious consequences for our people. Is it not common knowledge that a subscriber to Taca gets an authorisation card, which is tantamount to a key to the office door of a Minister, entitling him to go to see the Minister? The membership cards of Taca have been seen. We will have three new Ministers, probably tomorrow night—Deputy Collins, Deputy Cronin and Deputy Molloy; in order to get an audience, or what can be described as preferential treatment, all one need do is produce a Taca membership card and special consideration and privileges will be afforded. If "Honest Jack" is as honest as he pretends to be, why has he not disbanded Taca? It is well-known that Taca is the medium through which quick decisions and preferential treatment can be obtained by a loyal supporter and substantial subscriber to Government party funds. One cannot have good government if Ministers are influenced by Taca membership in their decisions. This deprives citizens of equal rights and equal opportunities since the same concessions are not available to them as are available to holders of Taca cards.

I would put the three new Ministers and the Minister for Justice, Deputy O'Malley, at ease by saying that they should take warning from what happened to their immediate predecessors. Although it is very hard to put an old dog off his track these young men possibly starting off on brilliant political careers would begin well by endeavouring to treat all persons equally. Human nature being what it is, I suppose it is difficult not to give concessions to those who may subscribe £500 or £1,000 or to the building contractor who can make a gift to the Minister of a new house. These problems exist. For young men in public life it must be very difficult to have a guilty conscience and to know that in order to comply with the wishes of their party they must condone injustices in order to do an irregular "justice" to the holder of a Taca card.

This Government have lowered their standards and their dignity to the lowest possible level by their association with Taca and the Tacateers and all those in the industrial, building and commercial spheres who are out to get rich quick through friendship or concessions to be obtained rightly or wrongly from the Minister. That is wrong. If the Taoiseach wants to pose as having even a semblance of honesty let him act practically and disband that organisation which is based on graft, greed and injury.

I should like to know if the Taoiseach has had any discussion with the Minister for External Affairs in regard to 25 uncompleted passports that became suddenly missing from that Department in November, 1969. Does anybody know where they went or how they got out of the Department? Who got them? What became of them? Have appropriate inquiries been made into the disappearance from the Department of passport covers which have not been written on? Is this not a serious matter? I do not know the means by which photographs can be applied or the nature of the stamp that goes on these documents but if 25 passport covers have been missing from the Department since last November I presume somebody has them. How did they get out of the Department? Were they allowed out? Handed out? Were they abstracted?

Little if anything has been said of this matter but I think the time has come when the Taoiseach should comment on it. Is it part of the campaign? Is it a sister activity of the illegal import of arms to allow passport covers to fall into the hands of unauthorised persons?

I am sure many Deputies who have spoken have been thinking about the situation in this country in recent times. The unity of Ireland will come about eventually and no matter to what party we belong we will all welcome it. Fine Gael are as enthusiastic about unity as are the most ardent supporters of the Government. That unity, we believe, can be brought about in time by peaceful means, by co-operation and negotiation. I could never understand how hard-headed northerners cannot realise that if their people came down to the Parliament in the south they would have at least 50 Deputies and could put Governments in or out. They could run the country.

Comment on this

They are not very likely to come after the past few days.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is what I fear. Those past few days have done untold damage and put us back at least 50 years. This is most regrettable. Those in Parliament in the Six Counties could gain outstanding advantages from a united Ireland because we would have the industrial north allied with the agricultural south. They would be entitled to have at least 50 or 60 Deputies. I am afraid the events of the past few days will not be helpful to us in that regard. We have a very serious responsibility in the part of our country over which we have jurisdiction in relation to the administration of law and order.

Is it not true to say that law and order have broken down completely in the Republic? Is it not true to say that there is a law for the rich and a law for the poor? Is it not true to say that there is the legal law and the Taca law? Taca law is the law under which if you are a supporter of the Government your case is dismissed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a reflection on the judiciary.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Oh, no. I meant the Department of Justice, not the judiciary. I want to make that very clear.

Comment on this

The Department of Justice does not dismiss cases.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Department of Justice deals with fines. I have known district justices to impose fines which were wiped out by the Department of Justice. I have known cases in which the rulings of the Attorney General were rather questionable and I honestly feel that the law is not administered as fairly as it might be.

Comment on this

The Deputy stated publicly that he wrote to a superintendent to quash convictions about cockfighting. The Deputy said that on television.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I beg the Minister's pardon?

Comment on this

The Deputy said publicly that he wrote to the Garda authorities to quash cases in connection with illegal cockfighting.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister knows the circumstances under which cockfighting became illegal. It was during the Fenian times. The Fenians were making pikes and they used cockfighting as an excuse for the making of the pikes. In order to get at the Fenians a law was brought in which made cockfighting completely illegal.

Comment on this

So cockfighting is legal now, according to the Deputy.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

No, cockfighting is illegal.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let us get away from cockfighting.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Cockfighting is illegal except when the cocks are within the Fianna Fáil Party when fighting is legal. Believe it or not, there are a good many cocks jumping very high at the moment.

Comment on this

There are three from the Deputy's constituency anyway, with all his talk.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Does the Deputy want to see four or five?

Comment on this

It will probably be four next time.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If the Deputy is so anxious for that to happen, will he use his influence with the Taoiseach to go and see the President this evening and give us the opportunity? There is a bit of good news for us. We will have the dissolution. An extraordinary state of affairs prevails as a result of an effort to import arms into this country under the guise of a genuine order for the Army. This is a matter of the greatest possible seriousness. I am astonished that so many Fianna Fáil Deputies seem to find this a cause for laughter.

To endanger the State, to endanger life, to endanger property, to encourage bank robberies and the shooting down of police are not matters to be laughed at. The shooting of our Garda may provide Fianna Fáil with laughter; the robbing of our banks may provide Fianna Fáil with laughter; the endangering of our State and the institutions of our State may provide Fianna Fáil with laughter. Remember it took great courage and sacrifice to build up the institutions of State which we have today. We have, perhaps, one of the best police forces in the world today. It can be described as criminal if the Government are undermining the activities of the police force.

We have known cases in which warrants were asked and refused. We have known cases in which the police force asked to have certain rules of procedure followed in the detection of crime. There was intervention from the Government denying them the facilities they required. In a democracy there is a great danger of a take over by the State of the role of the police. We are slowly but surely heading in the direction of the setting up of a one-party dictatorship. This is very evident when we hear voice after voice from the Fianna Fáil Party saying that no one can run the country but Fianna Fáil and that if they are not the Government there can be no Government. If they do not exercise the law there can be no law. That is all poppycock. Everyone knows that at a general election the people can have a change of Government whenever they so desire. It is very evident that they desire to have that change now.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Last June?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It is also correct to say that in the general election last June a complete scheme of misrepresentation was undertaken in a shameful and disgraceful manner by the Fianna Fáil Party who had endless funds at their disposal to misrepresent their political opponents through their Ministers, some of whom are under review today. It is correct to say that at almost every general election Fianna Fáil won as a result of a gimmick. We remember a number of these gimmicks: the drainage of the Shannon, the biscuit factory in Ballina, the round of increased wages, fake budgets, calling their opponents Communists and getting some of the clergy who were politically favourable to whisper it from the pulpit and church door.

Comment on this

The Deputy was the only one in the constituency of Laois-Offaly who made an accusation against this party in the last election.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If the Minister interrupts me again I will ask him if he will tell the Taoiseach about the raisins which he took out of a shop window in a hurry and those that were also taken out of the shop window of Mr. Joe Dunne in Portlaoise. Let him rest with that. I would not like the shame of having a Minister representing my constituency added to the roll of dishonour of Fianna Fáil today.

Comment on this

You can spend the next 28 years trying that—and you know that. Have a look at your votes over the last three elections my buck.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Before I was interrupted I was saying——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

We will be back again: do not worry.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

They succeeded in calling their opponents all kinds of names including communists. I heard it. In my day, I was described by Fianna Fáil as a communist—and I beat them and beat them and beat them on it. I was described from the altar, from the pulpit, from the platform, and so on. If the Labour Party, Fine Gael or anybody else takes up the challenge, they will beat them. Despite the fact that I am a knight of Columbanus, I was described as a communist.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I must leave the House now; I could put up with anything but that.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That shows how accurate Fianna Fáil are with their information. Despite the fact that I was a council member of the Knights of Columbanus, Fianna Fáil described me as a communist. In addition to all this, Fianna Fáil won an election or two on the strength of the Churchill speech. They won four or five elections on the pretence that they kept this country out of the war. Let us have an election within the next fortnight or three weeks without these gimmicks.

Comment on this

Why does the Deputy——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I like Deputy M. Smith; he is new to this House. When he is here as long as I am, he will not be as enthusiastic as he now is about interrupting. I should be delighted to meet Deputy Smith or even Deputy Connolly for an hour or two hours any evening down in the library and give them the benefit of my reminiscences. I have seen people come into this House who were never returned at subsequent elections or by-elections. I realise very well that if the Taoiseach goes to the Park this evening it is extremely doubtful that you will come back.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Perhaps, the Deputy would proceed with the debate and avoid personalities.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If the President were Taoiseach and a Member of this House he would have no hesitation in the world in disolving Parliament on the information which has resulted in the resignation, the suspension and the distrust shown by the Taoiseach. I feel that this whole exercise has held us up to worldwide ridicule.

When the Taoiseach claims to have evidence which he did not give to this House and which, I understand, he need not give to this House that the members of his Government have been guilty of treason, have been guilty of dishonour, it means, in other words, that these members of his Government have been discharged with ignominy. I think that that is a very serious situation. But the most serious part of it all is that, bad and all as the four or five who are gone are, there are equally as bad left whom the country does not trust. The sooner an opportunity is given to the people to rid this country of the type of happy-go-lucky adventurer, the get rich quick enthusiast who is running this country then the sooner we shall have all our national and economic ills tackled with courage, determination and, above all, with sincerity.

This whole exercise is a disgrace. It is disastrous. It is sad reading for this country and sad and bad advertising abroad for this country. I want to subscribe to the pleas made by every Deputy who has spoken from this side of the House for the Taoiseach to prove his honesty, his sincerity. He has been caught out badly. He does not trust his team. He has not trusted his team. His team have not trusted him. They are not all in step. Therefore, there is one way in which this despicable spectacle of dishonesty in public life can be dealt with and that is to allow it to be dealt with by the voters of this country on the merits of honesty.

This is a bad Government. As I said the other night, not knowing what was going to follow this Government are breaking up like the crumbs of brown bread. They have broken up. They are a corrupt collection of enthusiastic people who are out to get all they can to make themselves and their friends rich quick—and they could not care less about the Border; they could not care less about the problems of our fellow Irishmen in the north; they could not care less about unemployment or emigration; they could not care less about the housing of our people or the health services or the educational facilities. They are concerned only with swelling their own bank accounts. It is well known that after five years, men who have served in the Fianna Fáil Government can be described as millionaires living on estates. May I ask, where do they come from? With those few words, I very sincerely add my voice to that of every Deputy who has spoken from the Opposition benches in asking the Fianna Fáil Party not to be afraid to put this issue of sabotage and treason in so far as the solvency or security of the State is concerned before the public for appraisal and decision. It is a matter on which our people should be permitted to express a view and opinion. I trust the Taoiseach will see fit, over the weekend, to dissolve the Dáil so that an opportunity will be given to the Irish people to pass judgment on a Government that has lost respect, that never had dignity, that failed to have any form of a policy to deal with our national and economic problems—a Government that has not acted in the best interests of the Irish nation.

Comment on this

It is seldom that one decides to use as one's opening quotation the closing quotation from Deputy O. J. Flanagan. I must agree entirely with him when he tells the House in his own words that "this whole exercise is a disgrace; it is sad reading for this country". In regard to this whole exercise, the exercise which we have sat up through and listened to all last night and this morning, is it that the Fine Gael Deputies have no confidence in the view of their leader or leaders, such as they are and as numerous as they are? Is it that there is no united view or collective strength in that party? The issues have long since been stated here by their leader, by the leader of the Labour Party and, have certainly been fully met by the Taoiseach, and I am sure that any relevant question that has arisen during the debate will be dealt with in full by the Taoiseach in his reply. Is it that they are trying to create a situation of crisis in an effort to instil the notion into the minds of the people that the Dáil sat all last night through an emergency debate; that the situation has arisen in which this matter cannot be developed or discussed except through a full emergency debate which has been unprecedented in the history of the House?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that we have not the right to speak?

Comment on this

Nobody in this House doubts for one moment that Deputy Desmond has the right to speak because nobody has used that right or, indeed, has abused that right more often than he in questioning at length the views of persons on this side of the House. Indeed, the Deputy has often engaged in uncharitable remarks on comments from our side of the House, which did not measure up to his intellectual capacity.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Whether or not they have the right to speak, that right must always be tempered by responsibility. This is something that the Opposition Members very often forget and during the course of this debate it has been evident that responsibility has been greatly forgotten.

We must re-affirm the good sense of our Press because, despite this exercise in political mockery and despite the positive attempt to create a real fear in the minds of the people that this country has been through a night of crisis, the Press have treated this attempt with the contempt it deserves. Every member of Fine Gael has been under instructions to speak so that we have heard from members who have never before given us the benefit of their views. Speeches have been written for them, so that even those Members who disagree have to stand up here under strict instructions and speak. We have heard speeches from them in 46 or 47 different voices. One voice only will be expressed on this side of the House.

Comment on this

What about Deputies Boland and Blaney?

Comment on this

We trust our Taoiseach as the leader of our party. Even those Ministers whose resignations have been asked for have accepted that the Taoiseach has this constitutional right as Taoiseach. The Taoiseach speaks with our support and with our voice. He is our voice and, as long as he is, we will back him to the hilt. If we were to indulge in the same kind of political mockery as we have been hearing from the Opposition we would be here until tomorrow morning. But it is not necessary for us to come in here and speak with 72 or 75 voices and engage in the same kind of disgrace to democracy. I will say to Deputy O. J. Flanagan that, every Deputy from his side of the House has been heard but I will also say to him and to the House that every one of those Deputies has repeated the same useless and utterly treacherous attempt to instil fear into the people. However, they should get on to their telephones because they will find that the people have not been confused and will not be terrorised by these typically useless efforts of the Opposition. In conclusion, may I say that, of course, this is a time of serious crisis for the country.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

This is a matter of serious concern not only for us in this Parliamentary democracy but for the country. In taking the steps he took, in dismissing men of such outstanding ability great credit is due to the leadership of the Taoiseach. It is a tribute to his leadership. All the useless and treacherous attempts by those on the other side of the House to reflect in some way on that integrity will be seen very shortly by the people of Ireland for what it is—an exercise by those who have no responsibility and who never will have responsibility.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Kennedy accuses members on this side of the House of creating a crisis and then, unless it was a slip of the tongue, he talks himself about there being a crisis.

Comment on this

I did not say "creating a crisis".

Comment on this

The Deputy said that by their speeches during the past few days the Opposition were endeavouring to create a crisis which did not exist. The Deputy also said that the papers had ignored the efforts, as he described them, of the Opposition to create a crisis. Those involved in newspapers, television and radio are well able to make up their own minds. If the Deputy had had time during the past 24 hours to read the newspapers or to listen to radio or television he would easily understand the difficult position in which not only Fianna Fáil find themselves but in which the country finds itself at this time.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this