Nomination of Members of Government: Motion.
Contributions 1,181–1,390 of 1,547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 8 parts.
His contribution was short and the reason he gave for that was, he said, that the members of his party trust the Taoiseach. However, from some of the speeches made here yesterday it is very doubtful whether some members of the Fianna Fáil Party still trust the Taoiseach. If this debate has gone on for too long the person who must be responsible is the Taoiseach. We have now had almost 30 hours of debate if we include yesterday, today and 4½ hours on Wednesday night.
In not giving a fuller explanation of the situation, the Taoiseach has done a disservice to the House and to the country. He has had three opportunities during the past few days to give such explanation. I am reminded of Hamlet without the prince, although we did have the prince here for a very short while in so far as his contribution was concerned. The Taoiseach says there is not a crisis. One would not know whether to have been amused or appalled by the television interview he gave on Wednesday evening. I know he is a tired man. He has had many worries but he very blandly said that there was no crisis, that there never had been a crisis and that there would be no crisis. He said that there would be no more resignations, but I suggest that there should be, that the Minister for Defence should resign, but, above all, that the Taoiseach himself should resign.
What have we to go on? Is anybody in the Fianna Fáil Party or in the country wondering why all these speeches have been made and why questions are being repeated? The reason is that there has not been a clear explanation from the Taoiseach as to what happened with regard to two Ministers who were sacked, one who resigned and one who either resigned or was sacked. Neither has there been a full explanation as to what was the role played by the Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons. I do not know whether it is that the Taoiseach is very cute or very simple minded.
On Wednesday night he complained of not having enough time to reply to the debate. Whose fault was that? Was it his Whip who arranged the order in which the last three speakers would get in and the time that should be made available to them? He gave me at least the impression that the shorter the time he had the better for him because his tactics over the last three or four days have been to gloss over this whole affair in the hope that the public and the members of the Opposition will forget it. He wanted to get a quick vote on his proposals for these three or four Ministers in order to pretend to the country that because he had 13 Ministers again, because there was a full Government, all was right in the land.
The Taoiseach wasted the short time he had. I know this was a motion to nominate a Deputy to be Minister for Justice but I do not think the Taoiseach should have used up his time in order to give a description of an incident that happened at Shannon Airport in which the man who is now Minister for Justice was involved. It may have been a nomination for the position of Minister for Justice but the general debate was intended to be about the two Ministers who have been sacked and the one who resigned. I regard the comment about that as irrelevant. I do not know anything about it but it was a waste of time for the Taoiseach to take up two, three, four or five minutes in an explanation of what happened down at Shannon Airport. In present circumstances the people do not give a damn what happened at Shannon Airport. They do not care what Deputy O'Malley, the Minister for Justice, did. What they are concerned about now is stability in this country and they are concerned about the allegations the Taoiseach has made about two colleagues who have served with him for 13 years.
I know there may have been a certain amount of confusion in the mind of the Taoiseach in the last few days. I know that he has had a certain amount of physical and mental strain but it was only reasonable for us to expect that when this debate opened yesterday morning he would have made a more detailed statement. Despite what has been said by the ex-Ministers, despite the intervention of Deputy Gibbons and despite the other contributions, do we yet know the details of the allegations, the evidence that can or should be produced with regard to the sacking of Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey?
I proposed in this House, and was derided by some of the Fianna Fáil members, that the Taoiseach should get extra time. He refused it. Why did he refuse it? Because, I believe, the shortest possible time in those circumstances suited him. I trust that he will take a far longer time to answer the questions that have been posed here, the questions that have been posed in the press, the questions that have been posed by citizens of the six northeastern counties. One would imagine that he would have spent his time yesterday preparing the statement that he should have delivered yesterday morning but instead of that—I suppose in normal circumstances it would have been all right—he went down to the constituency of the Minister-designate for Industry and Commerce to a Fianna Fáil social. In ordinary circumstances that would have been all right but I believe that in the last 24 hours and since the last debate he should have been preparing a statement demonstrating to this House the justification for sacking two Ministers. It was his duty to anticipate today's discussion and nothing he has said since 2.15 a.m. on Wednesday has allayed the grave public disquiet, the fears, the doubts and the suspicions that are in people's minds throughout the country with regard to the allegation the Taoiseach made against two of his colleagues in the matter of the alleged smuggling of arms into this country.
Of course, since we had the contributions from Deputies Boland and Blaney and a statement from Deputy Haughey there is even more confusion. We wonder what sort of approach the members of the Government have to this crisis, because crisis it is, when again we remember the television appearance of the Minister for Lands, Deputy Flanagan, who when he was asked about this crisis and about the situation in the Fianna Fáil Party replied, with a smile on his face: "I know I missed a game of golf". For the first time he was interested in golf. He was asked then about the split in the party and he said arrogantly: "No split ever, now or in the future". His ignorance is such that he does not believe there could even be a split in Fianna Fáil. It is an indication of the stubbornness of members of Fianna Fáil and it is indicative of the attitude of the party who believe they have been there for such a long time they can be there for ever.
What has happened since the Taoiseach last made comment in this House on these events? We can all sympathise with and have a certain regard for what appears to be the sincerity of Deputy Blaney, particularly when he spoke of his experiences as a boy and as a youth, but I would regard Deputy Blaney's speech, apart from these reminiscences, as the greatest example of brazen evasion that a politician ever uttered in this House. He never referred once to the man who sacked him. One would get the impression, listening to Deputy Blaney, that it was the Opposition who sacked him. All his attacks were directed over here as if somebody here, or we collectively, had ordained that he should be sacked from his Ministry, that his seal of office should be wrenched from him, as the Taoiseach finally had to do.
I regard it too as an inflammatory speech. One can understand his emotions when he thinks of things gone by and of his family connections but he must learn restraint and not be giving vent to the type of speech one would expect in other circumstances from a Paisley—one that flows over to others, influences other people. That is what happens in the case of Paisley. We had that type of speech from at least three Fianna Fáil Deputies yesterday. That sort of emotion can be infectious. The Minister who is sitting before me knows that in a minor way this often happened with some over-emotional football fans, for instance. Who is the cause of a riot on the field? Who is the cause of a disturbance? It is a very small example but I think it is an analogy to the type of behaviour we have from a Paisley, a Blaney or a Boland when they start to talk about the situation in the Six Counties.
Deputy Boland spoke longer and in greater detail than the Taoseach. I ask, therefore, why did the Taoiseach not give the details, make a longer speech, take the House and the country into his confidence? Deputy Haughey has also made a statement in which he denies the allegations that have been made by his boss, the Taoiseach. However, after making these speeches, after denying that they had anything to do with the smuggling of arms, we have a most extraordinary expression of loyalty to the party and to the Taoiseach. Remember that 75 Fianna Fáil Deputies did not express loyalty to the country or to the Government; they expressed it to the Fianna Fáil Party and to the Taoiseach. The whole exercise in the last 24 or 48 hours is an exercise designed not for the good of the country, not for the good of the people, but merely to keep Fianna Fáil together and in office. Deputy Boland must be recognised by members of the Fianna Fáil Party as being somewhat contradictory if not hypocritical. He professes loyalty to his leader, Deputy Jack Lynch, the Taoiseach. He says he will abide by his decision. The Taoiseach has the right to sack and appoint Ministers. He likens the Taoiseach to a pimp and a spy. He says the Taoiseach's agents are following him. He says the Taoiseach's agents tapped his phone. He says Gestapo methods were employed by the Taoiseach. Those were the methods used by the Nazis. Those are Communist methods yet Deputy Boland professes loyalty to one who applies those methods. He says his phone is tapped. That certainly is not the action of a colleague. I wonder how far the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is engaged in that.
Comment on this
He is another Minister who must be involved. It must be with his permission that Deputy Boland's phone is tapped. I should like to ask the Minister if my phone is tapped. I am entitled to that information. Is Deputy Cosgrave's phone tapped? Is Deputy Treacy's phone tapped? Are the phones of business people who might not be supporters of the Government tapped? We have come to a pretty pass nine months after an election and after a campaign in which this country was described as prosperous. The ex-Minister for Local Government says that Gestapo methods are being used and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, his colleague, tapped his phone. He probably tapped mine and that of every member of the Opposition.
Deputy Boland professes loyalty to the Taoiseach but he says there was an execution without trial in respect of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney and that was why he resigned. He accused the Taoiseach of telling lies about the ex-Minister for Justice, Deputy Moran. He suggests that it is not because he was sick that he was asked to resign but for some other reason which he did not explain too clearly. He professes loyalty to the Taoiseach and says he agrees with whatever decision the Taoiseach makes but says he is not correct when he accuses Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey of being implicated in the smuggling of arms into this country.
His phone is tapped. He is pimped and spied upon by the Taoiseach. He says that Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey were executed without trial. He says the Taoiseach did not tell the truth about the ex-Minister for Justice, Deputy Moran. He does not accept that Deputies Blaney and Haughey were guilty but still he is loyal.
I referred before to the press statement issued after the Fianna Fáil meeting but I want to refer very briefly to it again. At that meeting they swore their loyalty to the Fianna Fáil Party and to the Taoiseach with no mention of the number who voted to the contrary. There was a shock when I suggested that there was some division in the ranks of the Fianna Fáil Party at that meeting. I do not know how the case was presented. I submit that anything which happens inside the Fianna Fáil Party or any other political party is their own business.
I suggested there might be a split. In view of what has been said here and in view of what has happened, surely there could not be unanimity with regard to their loyalty to the Taoiseach, particularly when one remembers what Deputy Boland said here yesterday morning? It reminds me of a statement of Mr. William Craig, who after a similar type of Unionist meeting in the Six Counties, when asked about support for the Government and their Prime Minister said: "Well, it means support for today." It is not my business but the Taoiseach and his colleagues must wonder for how long this shaky sort of loyalty on the part of Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney will continue.
There is significance in the applause which greeted the speech by Deputy Boland. Somebody said 17 were involved in the applause but there must have been a very quick count. Many more applauded Deputy Blaney. In the main Deputy Blaney's speech was an inflammatory one. Therefore, one wonders what support there is in those benches for the type of speech he made and the type of action implicit in the manner in which he delivered the speech and the words and phrases he employed. One wonders, therefore, whether the policy announced by the Taoiseach at the Ard-Fheis and the proposals he made in Tralee have the support of the majority or the support of all the members of the Fianna Fáil Party.
I should like to know why the applause was given to those two men. Were they applauded because they had announced they still supported the Taoiseach, again remembering what Deputy Boland accused the Taoiseach of in his speech? The Taoiseach should say what is right, whether his description of the resignation of Deputy Moran is correct or not.
The Taoiseach was loud in his denunciation of those who suggested that Deputy Moran was sacked. Deputy Boland had his doubts. Deputy Boland suggests that the Taoiseach's explanation is not correct and by inference suggests that he, with the other two ex-Ministers, was sacked.
Deputy Boland does not believe that Deputy Blaney or Deputy Haughey were guilty of the offences which were attributed to them by the Taoiseach. He suggests it is an informer's plot and that it was a method of exercising control. I do not know what he means. Perhaps somebody else in the House does. Maybe he could further expand on that. Perhaps the Taoiseach possesses a little more knowledge.
Deputy Haughey in his statement says that he was not in any way involved. This is the crazy situation we find ourselves in. Who would blame us for talking about a crisis? Who would blame us when one remembers that this time last week Deputy Blaney, Deputy Boland and Deputy Haughey were over there answering their questions faithfully, or so we thought, and within a week they are denounced by the Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch, and within hours they make statements tantamount to saying that the Taoiseach is a liar.
This situation does not occur daily. It is not a situation that is peculiar to many Parliaments on this side of the world, in Europe at least. Here we have a categorical denial by Deputy Haughey and by Deputy Boland. I should like to know, apropos of what Deputy Boland says, whether the Taoiseach suspected a plot to get rid of him. That is what Deputy Boland implies and that is what I infer from his speech. If Deputy Boland and Deputy Haughey are right it is lunatic and, might I say, criminal that the Taoiseach should use the explosive Six County situation to retain power.
We still do not know what to believe or whom to believe. I do not lightly question a person's integrity. I am careful in questioning the integrity of politicians who are much maligned, not only in this country but elsewhere. However, I implore the Taoiseach, not so much for his own sake but for the sake of the country, to let us know the facts. He has not done this so far although he has had three opportunities. On one occasion he complained there was a limitation of time but on two other occasions he had ample opportunity to give the facts. Because he has not given them, representatives from every constituency in this country have been asking that the Taoiseach would give them.
No matter what closing of ranks there may be, no matter how important it may appear to members of the Government Party there must not be a wall of silence. The Taoiseach, theoretically and in practice, could stand up at 5 p.m. or 6 p.m. this afternoon and say "The Fianna Fáil Party agree with me; I have 75 votes" and then sit down. He would get 75 votes as against 62 or 63. That would be a victory in this House for Fianna Fáil but it would still leave the doubts and suspicion; it would leave dread in the minds of the people of the Six Counties.
For that reason I earnestly ask the Taoiseach to give the full facts and not let this whole matter be surrounded by a wall of silence. The Taoiseach has been asked in the last 30 hours what happened between Monday, 20th April, when he said he first heard of these allegations to Wednesday, 29th April, when he requested the resignations of two senior Ministers. What happened during the week from Wednesday, 29th April to Tuesday, 5th May, on which day he demanded that the resignations be given to him by 10 p.m.? We are entitled to know what happened between these two dates.
As Deputy Boland has said, these men have been executed without trial. Therefore, it is incumbent on the Taoiseach, if we are to make a judgment on these Ministers, or if they are to make any attempt to clear themselves, that he tells the House and, through the House, the public, what was the information he received. All we know is what we read in the Press, what the Taoiseach said here the other day. He alleged that these two Ministers were suspected of being engaged in the smuggling of arms into this country. We do not know from where; somebody suggested Czechoslovakia. We do not know from whom; all we know is what the Taoiseach said in about two or three sentences.
We would also like to know who else was involved in this matter. I am sure these two ex-Ministers had many other things to do in the last nine months but we do not know whether anybody else was involved. We do not know whether the former Ministers are taking the blame for others who might have been involved. A question frequently asked is: where did the money come from? Was it private money, subscriptions from private people, or was it financed in some way from the Exchequer? For whom were the arms intended? I am sure it was not for the Irish Army. The arms must have been consigned to a particular place and the Taoiseach must have this information.
I should also like to know how they were to be imported and distributed; to what part of Ireland was it intended to send them; were they to go to another part of the Thirty-two Counties? The Taoiseach must also tell us what Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney said when they were confronted with these allegations. They say now that they denied them. It is none of my business, but perhaps he would also tell us what information, if any, did he give the very brief meeting of the Fianna Fáil Party on Wednesday evening, 6th May. If there was a suggestion that it was an appeal to close the ranks, to back the Taoiseach in any vote that might occur on this critical issue, that is not good enough. From the contributions we have had here today it seems to me that no information was given and I trust it will not be the same when the Taoiseach rises to reply in this House. If the Taoiseach does not give this information he should either "put up or shut up".
We must remember that Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey refused to resign and this should be regarded as revolt. Deputy Blaney attempted to give some sort of explanation as to why he thought it better—for whom I do not know—that he should be forced out of office rather than resign. We do not know what he meant by that, whether it was to facilitate this Government or to ease matters in the Six Counties. His statement was quite vague and we should know why these two Deputies refused to resign.
What action does the Taoiseach propose to take in regard to those Deputies? I do not think it is sufficient to smother them up in the back benches—whether they want to be smothered is a matter for themselves. They are three Deputies with very forceful personalities, who are well able to express themselves in this House. These were two Ministers and their punishment was demotion. If similar allegations had been made in respect of two Deputies, either from this side or the other side of the House, what would have happened to them? Would the Taoiseach, the Government, the Attorney General or the Ceann Comhairle take action against them? It is not sufficient to leave those ex-Ministers on the back benches to be smothered.
If this is the only action that will be taken I suggest that the Government should resign in accordance with Article 28 4.2º of the Constitution. This article spells out the responsibility of the Government and members of the Government; it states that the Government shall meet and act as a collective authority and shall be collectively responsible for the Departments of State administered by the members of the Government. If Deputy Blaney or Deputy Haughey is guilty so also is Deputy Lynch, so also is Deputy Gibbons and so also is every single remaining Minister in the Cabinet. The Constitution says they are all responsible for the acts or alleged acts of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney.
According to the Constitution, apart from the shame and disgrace of this, Deputy Jack Lynch should resign and take the members of his Government with him. I do not think he will do that, but, again, may I ask what further action is to be taken? Would he not consider invoking Standing Order 67 of the Standing Orders of this House and appoint a select committee to take evidence on this matter and report back to the Dáil? We do not need to have any precedent for this. There have been many minor incidents here in this House, one recently in which Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien was involved, when it was alleged he made some remark about the Ceann Comhairle. He has since been proved innocent, but there were many meetings on this and a lot of evidence was taken. It was a flimsy thing.
Now we have two members of an Irish Government who are accused of smuggling arms into this country and all we do is demote them to the back benches and they get their £2,500 per year and three of them at least get pensions based on 13 years service as Ministers. They are punished by this retirement. May I suggest, therefore, that the Taoiseach look at Standing Order 67 and appoint this select committee to inquire into the allegations that he himself made against his colleagues?
I do not think the Taoiseach will do that. This select committee would have access to papers, records, would have power to summon persons before it. The Taoiseach would be summoned before it and maybe the Attorney General. Many others who would be involved would be summoned before it. The papers and the records that would be available to the Taoiseach would have to be produced. However, it seems their only punishment will be to be consigned to the back benches.
I regard the second part of Deputy Boland's speech as an incitement to civil war. He seems to believe this could be contained within the Six Counties. Deputy Boland talks about illegal organisations in this country. He has no use for them. Does he imagine that any conflict would be confined within the Six Counties? Does he not know the nature of the violence in the Six Counties in August last year when we had this terrible battle in the Bogside, in Newry and in the Falls Road in Belfast? Does he think we could remain immune from the violence of that type of battle which he believes would be legitimate in the Six Counties? Incitement of such a nature is bound to involve the entire country. He cannot talk about a peaceful policy of reunification. This, he says, he subscribes to because it is the Taoiseach's policy. On the other hand, he endorsed the right of people to engage in armed revolution in the north. This is a contradiction which Deputy Boland refuses to recognise today.
Technically, I suppose, this motion is a motion to complete the Cabinet. Is this the solution to the whole affair, to this awkward mess? Does the Taoiseach expect that on completing his Cabinet it will mean the end of the crisis? We have heard three members of Dáil Éireann proposed for ministerial office. I say as I ought to say, like everyone else, that I have nothing against them, that I have the greatest esteem for them, et cetera, et cetera. But may I ask does the Taoiseach trust them? Have they given him any guarantee that they will not behave as the Taoiseach suggests Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney behaved? Would they be good little boys and send him a declaration to the effect that, come what may, the Taoiseach would have their full support? There is another question that could be asked on this question as well: do they trust the Taoiseach? Do they know whether or not their phones will be tapped? Do they know whether or not this super-Special Branch will be on their tails? Do they know whether or not if they transgress or are accused of a transgression they will be executed without trial?
These have been three days in which there has been suspicion, allegation, counter-allegation, charge and counter-charge, three days in which the business of the nation has been held up, three days in which our democratic institutions have been in doubt. We have not been responsible for this. We have not behaved in the last three days or even as long as I am in this House in a manner that would bring our democratic institutions into doubt or in a manner which would hold up the business of the House. The sole responsibility for this lies with the Taoiseach and maybe with the two Ministers who were forced to resign.
The Taoiseach will have to give us an explanation for it.
This patching up of the Cabinet and of the Fianna Fáil Party is being carried out at the expense of disrupting the country and deepening the division between the Six Counties and the 26 Counties. The Taoiseach and the Fianna Fáil Party are responsible for it. The facts must be made available to the Dáil and to the people of Ireland. The people of Ireland must be allowed then to judge, and the only way they can judge is by a general election.
Comment on this
The eyes of all Irish people are focused now on this Assembly. They are wondering how long more the tragedy of the last few days will go on. It is difficult to find the truth. The Taoiseach says one thing here and he is immediately contradicted by his former Cabinet colleagues. The happenings are stranger than fiction. I hope—and I say this sincerely—that when the Taoiseach concludes he will dispel all the rumours and disown some of the statements made by his colleagues. As a new Deputy I looked to the seventies for progress and goodwill towards our fellow Irishmen. Little did I know that such hatred existed in anyone's heart as we heard from Deputy Blaney. It is not for me to condemn Deputy Blaney for his beliefs. I hope some day he will see Ireland as it is in 1970 and not as it was 50 years ago.
I have no intention of opening up old sores. Too much of that has been done already and very little is accomplished. It is time for all of us to be realistic about the disastrous consequences of the last few days and put them in proper perspective.
Over the last ten years the State has spent millions of pounds in selling our image abroad. The money was well spent—fair play to Bord Fáilte. They coined the phrase "Ireland of the Welcomes." Thousands of Irish people, taxpayers, invested hard earned money in hotels, motels, chalets, souvenir shops. They were assisted by substantial State grants. Now every one of them is in for a lean time this year, if not, possibly, bankruptcy. Let there be no doubt in anyone's mind, the tourist industry is already suffering.
I was in Killarney last week and met the manager of a CIE hotel and managers of a few other hotels. It was a sort of social gathering. Every one of them said that already bus tours to this country for this year were cancelled.
Comment on this
Yes. They were cancelled already. They were fearful as to what every day's post would bring by way of cancellation.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt but is the Deputy sure that it was last week that this happened?
Comment on this
What is the reason for the change of heart on the part of tourists? There is no point in deceiving ourselves. We must realise that 75 per cent of our tourists come from England or Northern Ireland and their money is very welcome. If the Englishman feels there is trouble in any part of Ireland, not knowing the north from the south, he decides to keep away. All the newspapers and television reporters who have come here from other countries are not doing us any good. They are doing us a disservice. This type of publicity abroad is of no use to Ireland.
I hope it is not too late to urge that this madness must cease, that we must revert to the idea of "Ireland of the Welcomes" and create the image that if a person wants peace he will get it in Ireland. We owe it to the people; we owe it to those who invested in tourist amenities and we owe it to the hotel porter, the night watchman, the waitress, the kitchenmaid, all of whose jobs are in jeopardy in a bad season.
I was surprised at Deputy O'Kennedy's outburst. I always admired Deputy O'Kennedy's contributions to debates. They were always well worth listenig to. I listened to him a while ago and, perhaps, it was because he had been up all night, but one got the impression that he wanted to stifle discussion in the House. The present political situation is the biggest event that ever happened in the history of the State and every Deputy is morally bound to make his contribution to the debate even if that involves prolonging it for another day. A Deputy must answer to his constituents when he returns to his constituency. It was good stuff from Deputy O'Kennedy. I suppose he is in the running for a Parliamentary Secretaryship and it is only right that he should have his say now. More power to him if he does get a Parliamentary Secretaryship. He would make a good Parliamentary Secretary.
The three new Ministers that the Taoiseach has nominated are from Munster. I offer congratulations to the three of them and wish them well in their Ministries. Is the Taoiseach afraid to appoint a man from Leinster or Ulster? Galway could almost be taken as part of Munster. Is the Taoiseach afraid of appointing persons from outside Munster? The Taoiseach was a good hurler and he is a Munsterman. Did he say to himself that he could trust the Munstermen more than he could trust Leinstermen or Ulstermen?
I have no intention of detaining the House but I should like to make the point that there is no room for bigotry in this country. This House should mould public opinion. Our slogan should be, "Love thy neighbour" and, as we say, "Peace on earth to men of goodwill".
Comment on this
I feel called upon to rise to support the Taoiseach's nominations because of the many speeches made by the Opposition over the last two days which were an attempt deliberately to give the people of Ireland the impression that Fianna Fáil is split. That is a sadly mistaken idea. I rise purposely here today to assure the supporters of Fianna Fáil throughout the country that they need have no fear whatsoever. The Opposition parties share a lack of belief in their own parties. We in Fianna Fáil believe in our party as a way of life and as a way of life for the people. We have never let the people of Ireland down and we do not intend to let them down.
When this crisis has passed we know that the people who supported us for so many years will be just as proud of us as they have been in the past. They will see that their trust has not been misplaced. Far from Fianna Fáil being split, I assure those people who may be codded by Opposition speeches that it is the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party which are in a shambles. Our supporters, who have assisted us so loyally down through the years, will recognise the Opposition speeches for the typical invective that has been so often poured on Fianna Fáil by Opposition Parties down through the years. This is nothing new. We have heard it all before.
Deputy Begley talked about the crisis affecting the tourist trade and he said there had been a cancellation of a bus tour last week. This crisis only occurred this week and Deputy Begley was trying to mislead the people. That is a typical example of what Deputy Begley and his party try to do. It has been said that Fianna Fáil is a tired party. Fianna Fáil is not tired. It is vibrating with life. If anything, Fianna Fáil thrives in an atmosphere like this where our enemies are yapping at our heels.
Comment on this
The Opposition have clearly demonstrated by their speeches that they are the enemies of Ireland.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it in order to say that Opposition Deputies are the enemies of Ireland? I suggest that should be withdrawn.
Comment on this
The charge is a political one and such charges are often made in the course of debate.
Comment on this
I make no apology for saying what I said. The people supported us at successive elections. Their trust has not been misplaced. I share, in common with the Taoiseach and other members of the Fianna Fáil Party, a deep sense of loss in this experience. Fianna Fáil, being the metal it is, will survive this. If they could not weather this they would not deserve to survive. The Opposition are delighted that something like this has happened because it hides to some extent their own shortcomings and their inability to impress the people. They are incapable of forming a Government. People will never put their trust in them. Fianna Fáil is as strong today as it has ever been. It is gaining strength all the time and no small measure of that strength is drawn from the attacks made on it by the Opposition parties.
Comment on this
In my opinion these protestations of loyalty and unity seem a complete farce. Government speakers do not even mean what they say. Two Cabinet Ministers were sacked. Deputy Blaney came in here and pledged his undying loyalty to the Fianna Fáil Party, and his colleague, Deputy Boland, who resigned, also came in here and pledged his undying loyalty to the Fianna Fáil Party, to the party whose leader kicked them out a short time earlier. I cannot see the logic of this at all. The Taoiseach and the shattered Fianna Fáil Party are now earning the wages of sin, the sin of long years of neglect, of arrogance, of indifference to the needs of the people. The wages are now being doled out to Fianna Fáil in payment of their irresponsible attempts to be all things to all men.
The party was so determined to retain power that they endeavoured to be at one and the same time Republican hardliners and passive moderates—the friends of the farmer and the enemy of the NFA, the upholders of law and order and fixers of criminal proceedings, the helpers of the underprivileged and the entertainers of the Tacateer financiers. The image of the mohaired mogul has been stripped away by the events of the past few days. Fianna Fáil now stand discredited before this House and before the people. I have no sympathy for Fianna Fáil and, so far as I am concerned, the sooner they are defeated the better it will be for the Irish people, north and south.
We are concerned with the effect of these political events on the nation. Because of some of the alleged actions of former Ministers and the inaction of the Taoiseach Ireland today stands discredited and shamed not only in the eyes of our own people but in the eyes of the world. This island was once known as the Island of Saints and Scholars. In the past year the Six Counties may have been known as the place for gunmen, Paisleyites and that type of person. The 26 Counties are now linked with the Six Counties in this crisis. You have the Paisleys and the Blaneys, the Craigs and the Bolands, the Unionist Party in the North and Fianna Fáil in the South, and their motto seems to be: "Power at any cost."
Recently I watched a television programme in which various political commentators were giving their views on the political structures and political parties in the north and south. Somebody said that the Fianna Fáil Party in the south is similar to the Unionist Party in the north but has not the same machine and is not nearly as ruthless.
Today we are asked to accept the nominations of Deputy Molloy, Deputy Collins and Deputy Cronin as members of the Government. By virtue of the Fianna Fáil majority this motion will be passed. I suppose I could do as the leader of the Labour Party did and wish them well. I do not wish them any harm. I hope that whether their reign in their new offices will be long or short it will not have a similar ending to that of the reign of the former Minister for Finance, the former Minister for Local Government, the former Minister for Agriculture and, I might add, the former Minister for Justice.
Not only has an attempt been made to break the law of the land seriously but these allegations suggest that large shipments of arms have been moving, or were about to move across international borders. It appears that the deposed Ministers, or some of them, are actually engaged in violating national law and perhaps international law also. Particularly upsetting is the calculating, cold-blooded attempt to utilise the institutions of the State which have been given the job of maintaining law and order, the Gardaí and the Army, in an effort to import a quantity of small arms. I am sure that bloodshed would have resulted, north and south of the Border, if the attempt had succeeded.
It is right to pay tribute to men who resigned rather than be bullied by the Fianna Fáil Party. Some of these have rendered patriotic service to the country. It is a sad day when we hear that Ministers have been connected with the Army and the Gardaí in an attempt to bring arms into the country.
Whether we like it or not this is a national crisis regardless of what has been said by the few on the Government benches who, so to speak, decided they would make their position clear. When an officer of the National Army was involved in this, are we to take it that he violated the oath he took when he was being commissioned? Will he be paid a State gratuity as is usual in the case of an officer retiring honourably? This is one of the questions I should like the Taoiseach to answer.
I am also concerned with a report which I read in The Guardian, a British newspaper, last Thursday. It is stated, in effect, in that paper that people from the North of Ireland were coming across the Border and being afforded the opportunity and the facilities of the FCA for training in Donegal. Judging by the viewpoint expressed in recent months in many speeches by the ex-Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Blaney, this could be quite true. From the interpretation I put on what he has said, I feel that he would go hand in hand with this.
It is up to the Taoiseach to make a clear statement and to put the mind of the people of the country and of this House at ease regarding these statements and this alleged illegal activity.
The last time the Taoiseach got a chance to reply he made the excuse that he was short of time. He never told us exactly what we wanted to know. I hope he will do so on this occasion. The Government have been silent. Probably the most distressing thing of all was the contribution of the ex-Minister for Defence when he emphatically denied that he had anything to do with any of the charges made against him. Maybe he is right. Maybe he is not. We want to know whether he is implicated. I assume that it is up to the Taoiseach to clarify the position this evening.
I now come to the ex-Minister for Justice, Micheál Ó Moráin from Curradrish. He said himself when he talked of the Maggot Durkan case, as it has become popularly known, that it was he, Micheál Ó Moráin from Curradrish, who did all those things. What is his position? The Taoiseach said he resigned and Deputy Boland said he was pushed. Surely the people of this country and the Members of this House are entitled to know who is right and who is wrong. I do not hear anyone over there contradicting me and saying that the Taoiseach makes one statement and the ex-Minister for Local Government makes another.
Comment on this
If we tried to contradict the Deputy it would take too long.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy is looking for one. Is he interested in the business? Deputy J. Lenehan will inform him on any of these matters. He is very good at that type of work, as, I may say, are many Members on that side of the House.
We had a few contributions from that side of the House and there were references to 77 people who were shot. We had passionate speeches from Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney. We could all go back and talk about our family history in politics. I have no doubt that every Member of this House could do that. I am here by tradition, I suppose, and I could also do that. I have nothing of which to be ashamed. I should also like to remind Deputies over there that I was elected to this House on 4th December, 1964, a day they will never forget.
Comment on this
We were 6,000 behind and we came from behind to beat the entire forces of Fianna Fáil in their greatest stronghold. Of course, I can always say this as well: you were the first to approach me to stand on your behalf.
Comment on this
It was quite clear that the Deputy was not referring to the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
I refer to Deputy Brian Lenihan. He was the first man to approach me to stand in the by-election after my father died.
Comment on this
The reason I asked that was that I was alone with the Deputy in Croke Park after that tragic incident.
Comment on this
I just wanted to make sure that the Deputy was not referring to me. I accept his word.
Comment on this
There is no need in the world to refer to the Taoiseach in a matter such as this. If I ever want his advice I will certainly go to him for it. I want to put on record that the first individual who approached me was Deputy Brian Lenihan. When I hear the representative from Kildare trying to hurl an insult at me I want to say that I have nothing of which to be ashamed. I hope the Deputy's own record is as clean.
I was referring to the ex-Minister for Justice and to the fact that Deputy Boland says he was pushed and the Taoiseach says he resigned. I should dearly like the Taoiseach to make a clear statement this evening as to whether he was pushed or resigned and to tie up the events of the previous week in the Gresham Hotel with that, if that would be possible. In actual fact, I do not think it would.
What strikes me is this: where and when did all this start? The Taoiseach himself has stated that the first intimation he got of it was on 20th April, 1970. He had to wait until 6th May, 1970, before he decided to act. It is rather a jigsaw puzzle. I think the 6th May, 1970, must have been the day following the approach of our leader, Deputy Cosgrave, to the Taoiseach. I am not for one moment saying that it was on account of whatever communication Deputy Cosgrave had with the Taoiseach that two Ministers were sacked. However, it prompts me to ask the question and to say to this House that were it not for the fact that Deputy Cosgrave approached the Taoiseach on that fateful evening, would the Taoiseach have taken the action that he took the following morning between two and three a.m.? I do not know.
The ex-Minister for Local Government told us that one reason he resigned was because of the Gestapo tactics by the Taoiseach's intelligence service. Surely these tactics which Deputy Boland alleges were used against himself, and the information service or spy ring that Deputy Lynch seems to have at his disposal, were very ineffective if it took from 20th April, 1970, to 6th May, 1970, to find out all the facts he did find out? Even at that, he does not seem to have found them all. I wonder if many more Fianna Fáil Deputies or Ministers or ex-Ministers are involved in this.
From observations over the past few weeks around this House and from watching or keeping an eye on the Deputies who congregated together on the day this news broke, I noticed Deputy Molloy very much in the company of Deputy Blaney, also Deputy Gibbons. What part did they play in this? I hope that, when he is replying, the Taoiseach will tell us the whole truth and will come out in the open with the whole story—if he knows it.
I wonder what the position is of the Minister for Lands, Deputy Seán Flanagan. He was out of the country when this crisis broke.
Comment on this
Possibly the Taoiseach will give us the answer. On his arrival at Dublin Airport it was interesting to see and hear his television interview. I have no doubt that Deputy Flanagan had nothing to do with either side of this but I should love to hear his views on it. I would like if he would come into this House and express his opinion on this crisis.
Comment on this
I would bet it would be one vote less for the Taoiseach's motion to appoint the three Members he has in mind for his Cabinet.
Deputy P. J. Burke made an appeal for charity as also did Deputy Moore —an appeal for charity for the fallen, charity for our fellowmen. I have been a Member of this House for 5½ years and I can say that I have seen damn little charity from Fianna Fáil. There was one incident above all in this House since I came here which exemplifies the mind and the thoughts of some Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party. When Deputy Moran was Minister for Justice he was asked a question, I think by the leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Corish, regarding a television programme; it took him 17 minutes to reply. The first man on his feet after that was Deputy Flor Crowley of Cork. He used words to describe the staff of Radio Telefís Éireann—and, naturally enough, he was hinting at the Labour Party and insinuating that they were communists, Maoists, Trotskyites and as many more things that I would not have the vocabulary to describe——
Comment on this
Indeed, he can. But imagine a Fianna Fáil Deputy getting up on that side of the House and making such a silly statement—maintaining that many Members of this House were what he called them. So long as the Taoiseach allows Deputies on that side of the House, who are in that frame of mind, to express themselves in that way, then the chaos in which the Fianna Fáil Party find themselves at the moment will become even worse in the future.
I say to the Taoiseach that in his reply he should let us know the truth regarding Deputies Blaney, Boland, Haughey and Moran. Surely the Taoiseach would not have dismissed two of his Ministers without having very good reason for doing so? However, they themselves maintain that they are innocent, so that I fail to reconcile the statement of the Taoiseach with the statements of these two Ministers. The Taoiseach should lay his cards on the table when replying to this long drawn out debate and tell us and the country what exactly is the position. It is possible that some of the statements that have been made, maybe some of those made by the Taoiseach and by some of the speakers on his side of the House, may have been untrue. It may be difficult for an individual to admit he was wrong in something he said but, if this should be the case in this instance, the only thing to do is to tell the truth because, in any case, the truth will come out eventually. It is the truth we want to hear.
When Deputy O'Kenedy spoke some time ago from the Fianna Fáil benches he expressed shock that so many Deputies on this side of the House were contributing to the debate. He did not fully realise the gravity of the situation, and neither does Deputy Davern, if one is to judge by the cynical grin on his face.
Comment on this
Regardless of whether it suits the Taoiseach or his party the truth must be told. As a result of the events of the past few days the Taoiseach should go to the country and let the people decide whether, in view of these events, they still wish him to continue in office.
Comment on this
It is my belief that today and yesterday will be regarded as two memorable days in the history of this nation. As an elected representative, I consider it my duty to the people of my constituency who were responsible for returning me as a Member of this House to comment on the events which have taken place in this country over, what is apparently, an unknown length of time.
I regret the comments which I must make. I regard it as a shame that any Deputy, regardless of which side he is on, should find it his duty in this day and age to stand up and question the elected Taoiseach in relation to certain matters affecting the democratic, social and political security of the State.
On Wednesday night last the Taoiseach made the following statement to Dáil Éireann:
On Monday, 20th April and Tuesday, 21st April, the security forces of the country at my disposal brought me information about an alleged attempt to unlawfully import arms from the continent. Prima facie, these reports involved two members of the Government. I decided to interview the two members of the Government—Deputy Blaney, then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and Deputy Haughey, then Minister for Finance. I decided to do this on the following day, Wednesday, the 22nd April, which was the day of the Budget. In the meantime I ensured that adequate steps were taken to prevent any unauthorised importation of arms. On 22nd April, the day I decided to interview the former Ministers, I received news of the accident to Deputy Haughey, and, as a result, I was unable to interview him...
According to the Taoiseach he received this very important information from the security forces of the State but yet he let the matter stand until the 29th April. Admittedly, the then Minister for Finance was in no fit condition to be interviewed but he was in a fit condition to be interviewed on Monday, the 20th April and Tuesday, the 21st April. I suggest to the Taoiseach that, when he is replying to the debate, he should state fairly and squarely what information he received and how authoritative was that information. The Taoiseach said in his statement that he made certain personal inquiries but yesterday the former Minister for Local Government questioned the authority of the Taoiseach in this matter. Deputy Boland did not seem to think that the information received was of a nature to merit the dismissal of two senior Government Ministers.
The Minister for Local Government is quoted as follows in the Evening Herald of 8th May:
He said he was astonished that Mr. Lynch dismissed two senior Ministers on the basis of secret and unconfirmed information supplied to the Government as against the word of the Ministers who denied they were implicated in any arms plot. He said he would not be surprised if the whole thing was concocted by the British Secret Service for its own reasons. "Mr. Haughey and Mr. Blaney have told me that they did not arrange the importation of any arms into this country and I believe them" he said.
I suggest that, when the Taoiseach is replying to this debate, he should come out and tell this House and the Irish people who was telling the truth, whether his information was authoritative or whether Deputy Boland was correct when he stated—I believe in all sincerity—he believed it was not authoritative. The Taoiseach has a duty to Deputies and to the nation to clarify this point and to let the people know on what grounds he called for the resignation of his two senior Ministers. Deputy Haughey has denied the allegations. He is quoted in the Irish Independent of 9th May as follows:
I regret that on medical advice I cannot make a personal statement in Dáil Éireann concerning the termination of my office as a member of the Government.
Since becoming a Minister, I have endeavoured to the best of my ability to serve my country, Dáil Éireann and the Government.
I have never at any time acted in breach of the trust reposed in me and I regret that I am now compelled to refer to the circumstances which brought to an end my membership of the Government.
The Taoiseach informed the Dáil that he requested my resignation on the grounds that he was convinced that not even the slightest suspicion should attach to any member of the Government.
I fully subscribe to that view, as I have been able to gather the Taoiseach received information of a nature which in his opinion cast some suspicion on me.
I have not had the opportunity to examine or test such information or the quality of its source or sources.
In the meantime, however, I now categorically state that at no time have I taken part in any illegal importation or attempted importation of arms into this country.
At present I do not propose to say anything further except that I fully accepted the Taoiseach's decision as I believe the unity of the Fianna Fáil Party is of greater importance to the welfare of the nation than my political career.
The Taoiseach has made a certain statement. The ex-Minister for Finance has denied it in no uncertain terms, supported by the ex-Minister for Local Government. Yet these two Deputies claim that the welfare of the party comes before their personal prestige and welfare and that, in order to preserve the image of Fianna Fáil as best they can at this time, they are prepared to support the Taoiseach. I would suggest to the Taoiseach, however, that he should clarify these two statements. He says that not the slightest suspicion should attach to any member of the Government. Either Deputy Haughey in this statement is a confounded liar or the Taoiseach is a confounded liar.
Comment on this
I withdraw that statement, but if Deputy Haughey can substantiate what he said then the Taoiseach must have made a false statement in this House because the two do not coincide.
The Taoiseach said here on 6th May in relation to the ex-Minister for Justice, Deputy Micheál Ó Moráin:
I want to assure the House that that appointment was terminated on health grounds, as I have already stated, publicly and in this House. The Minister was not involved in these matters.
In his concluding speech that day he said:
In relation to the former Minister for Justice I wish to say that there is no "perhaps" as Deputy Keating tries to suggest in his case as far as involvement in this matter is concerned. I said at the start of my opening statement, and I repeat it now, that his resignation was tendered to me on grounds of ill-health.
The ex-Minister for Local Government says that he does not believe this. He says quite clearly that he believes the Minister was asked to resign. He says quite clearly he believes he was pressurised into tendering his resignation. Deputy Boland made this speech in a most convincing and, I believe, most sincere manner. Again, as in the case of Deputy Haughey, there is no similarity between what Deputy Boland says and what the Taoiseach says is the truth about the resignation of the ex-Minister for Justice.
The Taoiseach has won in this country the reputation of "Honest Jack". The first time I had the pleasure of speaking here my opening remarks were that I did not doubt the sincerity of the Taoiseach. Since that time, I regret to say, I have had to change my mind. I have heard on a number of occasions accusations made from the Opposition benches of alleged incidents which took place throughout the length and breadth of this country. Every time they were made the Taoiseach repudiated the person making them and said they were without foundation, that his Ministers were above reproach.
There is a magazine called This Week and I am sure everybody has read this week's edition. It has the Taoiseach's picture on the front page. It says here: “Fianna Fáil splits for the third time.” I want to say at this stage I am not concerned if Fianna Fáil split for the 33rd time; I am not concerned if they split and the crack never heals; I am not concerned if it is papered over three hours after I speak, but I am concerned with an incident which was brought to the notice of this House some months ago. The person who mentioned it was told that it was without foundation. I will read a couple of extracts from this magazine. The first one is:
Blaney delivered his Letterkenny manifesto last December when he said that the Fianna Fáil Party had never taken a decision to rule out the use of force if the circumstances in the Six Counties so demanded.
It goes on further to state:
In January last we confessed to a suspicion that there had been political intervention in the rather remarkable judicial performances in Buncrana court. It bears repetition.
Comment on this
Not a bit. Unfortunately, we are not short of this type of ammunition. I said at the outset that it was no pleasure for any Deputy to have to make the kind of comments I am making here today. On the contrary, it is a great disgrace to the country that comments such as this have arisen. Further on this article states:
There the State solicitor, Mr. Liam McMenamin, withdrew charges against seven men of having firearms in their possession with intent to endanger life. The facts of the case, Mr. McMenamin said, did not sustain the requirement of the Act and there should be an immediate intent. This is something which should give immediate consolation to all those harbouring arms throughout the 26 Counties, IRA or UVF, not to mention all unlicensed holders of shot guns for shooting fowl and other flying objects.
Later on the article said:
"Let them go in peace," said the State Solicitor, "and leave their firearms behind them." This would echo the sentiments of the vast majority of people. Perhaps they would undertake not to do it again.
There is also contained a photograph of the weapons and the loot which was found. I respectfully submit to the Taoiseach and to the Tánaiste that there must have been some intervention by either a Minister of State or somebody in a position to tamper with justice for that to happen in a case of this nature.
I have experience in my own neighbourhood of people out for a Sunday's sport with a shotgun owned by a father or brother. The Tánaiste might have some information on this. When they were intercepted by the local gardaí in the course of their duty, and charged accordingly, in one particular case the gun was confiscated, and a fine imposed. I suggest there is no connection between an offence of that type and an offence of the magnitude of this case in Donegal. In the case of an unfortunate young fellow out for a Sunday's shooting the law was allowed to take its course, and rightly so, but a much bigger case, involving the type of weapons displayed in this picture, was allowed to go unheard. I believe the Taoiseach owes it to this House to explain how this could happen. It was quite obvious when I began to read this that the Tánaiste had knowledge of it.
Comment on this
I have no knowledge of it. It has already been read. I thought the Deputy might simply save time by saying this document had already been read. I have no knowledge of it.
Comment on this
I accept that the Tánaiste may not have any knowledge of it, but the last time it was read there was no reply made to it. I suggest there should be some reply now because it is very peculiar that a matter of this sort could be quashed without the knowledge of the Minister for Justice. Surely, if the Minister for Justice had knowledge that this case was not going to take its course, the State Solicitor acted out of turn and was entitled to be reprimanded. I have said it gives me no particular pleasure to speak on a matter of this sort.
Comment on this
I think we should have a quorum to listen to this very good contribution by Deputy Fox.
Comment on this
This is more of the tomfoolery in this debate. When they are talking about responsible attitudes on this side of the House they should show the same themselves. They are making a farce out of the House.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
On a point of order. I am sorry to be transgressing the laws of courtesy, and I will obey your ruling, Sir, but is there no charity for the reporters of this House and the staff of this House who have been on duty since 10.30 a.m. yesterday morning? There is no relief for them. It is sheer slavery.
Comment on this
I want to protest very strongly. There is no charity for the staff of this House. The reporters, the official staff and the staff of the House have been on duty all the time.
Comment on this
I hope it is on the official record that Deputy Treacy's remark to the charitable statement of Deputy Burke was that it was "humbug".
Comment on this
I do not know who is responsible but it would not happen in any other country in the world.
Comment on this
Order. The Chair would ask Deputies to please co-operate and allow the Deputy in possession to speak. Deputy Fox.
Comment on this
I agree with part of what Deputy Burke has said in respect of the staff of this House. I have been here for as long a time as any of the Members opposite and, if they are agreeable to have a break for one or two hours to give the staff an opportunity to have their meals, it is all right with me; I can resume afterwards. I have a responsibility to my constituents. As has been pointed out by many Deputies, the matter we are discussing is a grave one. When I report to my constituents in Monaghan they will ask me to render an account of my stewardship. They are justly entitled to ask where I stand in relation to the mess into which this country has been plunged. Every Deputy, irrespective of party, is entitled to speak if he wishes on a matter as serious as this. If this necessitates the House sitting continuously day and night, that is not my concern, nor is it my fault. Having said that, I suggest that I might be allowed to continue my speech.
I resent having to speak on this motion and I consider that the people who were involved in this matter have brought shame on this nation. I have listened to a few of the speeches from the opposite side of the House and I was amazed to hear some of the remarks made. Deputy J. O'Leary said that the name of Fianna Fáil was synonymous with the people of Ireland. When he spoke last night he said that we on this side of the House were responsible for the late sitting of the Dáil. He spoke of republicans and told us what he stood for. I should like to tell Deputy O'Leary that six weeks ago I had the pleasure of addressing an after-Mass meeting at Klonbroney Church in County Longford at which Deputy O'Leary also spoke. I want to point out that the people who stood attentively and listened to me did not listen to Deputy O'Leary very long. Later that day I was informed that I was the first politician to address an after-Mass meeting outside Klonbroney Church for the past 14 years. I was told the previous politician to address such a meeting was the present Tánaiste and I was told he was attacked that day——
Comment on this
If I am allowed to continue it will be seen to be relevant. The Tánaiste was not permitted to speak for any great length outside Klonbroney Church because certain people claimed they were cousins of Dick Goss, who had been executed. I am suggesting that this man was executed for an offence similar to the alleged offence committed by the people we are discussing today.
We have had many references during the general election campaign and from time to time in this House about reds, communists, Cubans and others. On a number of occasions the Tánaiste has issued statements in the local papers in the constituency. He has continuously attacked this party. He has spoken of a coalition of Fine Gael and of Labour. He continually attacks Cubans, reds and communists. I suggest that he reconsiders his views in the light of the circumstances prevailing at the present and forget about reds and Cubans.
Comment on this
I did not refer to reds and Cubans. I quoted from the Labour Outline of Policy, which is a much better way.
Comment on this
On his election platform and in addresses in papers the Tánaiste tied up the Fine Gael Party in a coalition with reds and Cubans.
Comment on this
I suggest that he should, if possible, find time to state where he stands in this situation. There are a number of very important matters before us. This sitting is unprecedented in so far as it has been the longest in the history of this House. The reason it is the longest sitting is that the subject matter of the debate is of such great importance that it merits such a sitting. Could the Taoiseach tell us when he is replying if State funds were used in the alleged purchase of these arms? I do not think it is too much to expect the Taoiseach to tell me if State money was used for this purpose.
Would the Taoiseach also tell us if figures are available at this stage to show what the estimated loss in tourist earnings would be to the country? If figures are not available at this stage —and I doubt very much if they are— I suggest that as soon as they become available he give us the monthly returns.
Would the Taoiseach also inform us of the amount of foreign investment that has been withdrawn from this country since this affair became public knowledge, or if any foreign capital has been withdrawn, or if applications have been received for the withdrawal of foreign capital? If that information is not available today, I suggest that it be made available as soon as it becomes known.
I have the greatest respect for each and every individual, and if Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney were so nationalistic and felt so strongly on this matter that they thought it merited the action they allegedly took, they are entitled to their opinion and that is their business. However, I believe that as members of the Government they were wrong. If they wanted to do this they should have resigned their membership of the Government. I could understand some illegal organisation having the desire to import arms and ammunition, but I cannot understand senior Ministers of the Government having such a desire. As there can be only one army in this country it is ridiculous, to put it mildly, that any Ministers of State should be employed by any organisation or allow themselves to be employed to import arms into the State.
I want to suggest to the Taoiseach that he should drive up to the Park as soon as possible and dissolve the Nineteenth Dáil. It is the only method at his disposal whereby he can come clean and let the people pass judgment. I have no doubt that the voters of this country, having seen how the leader of our party, Deputy Liam Cosgrave, brought this plot to light, will have no hesitation in doing what they did in the twenties when faced with a similar crisis—going to the polls and electing a Fine Gael Government under the leadership of Deputy Liam Cosgrave, a son of the late W. T. Cosgrave who steered this country through similar circumstances.
Comment on this
I wish, first of all, to refer to a very critical remark which has been made here by none other than one of the Labour Party front benchers, Deputy Treacy, in regard to the reputation of the staff in this establishment. My colleague, Deputy Burke, made a plea on behalf of the staff here, knowing full well they had been working from 9.30 yesterday morning until now without a single break.
Comment on this
It is a matter for the Restaurant Committee. It is the Deputy's job as Chairman of the Restaurant Committee. He could do it without any publicity. He is vote-catching.
Comment on this
I will, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. I say it is typical of the Labour Party when one of their members can applaud the effort of Deputy Burke and the other front bench member can say that it is humbug.
Comment on this
This is a matter which was brought up in the debate. The responsibility for this lies nowhere else than with the Fine Gael Party's efforts here last night to frustrate the staff and each Member of the House by holding caucus meetings to try to bring about the downfall of this House.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy is speaking about the staff of this House and Fine Gael have nothing whatsoever to do——
Comment on this
The Deputies will obey the ruling of the Chair and come to the motion before the House.
Comment on this
I bow to your ruling, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. Having said that and having cemented in the minds of the people concerned exactly where they stand, I want to say that the motion before us has not been dealt with by any of the Opposition Deputies because, of course, that would be too trivial. It would be too much to expect any respect for the men nominated here for ministerial posts, that their reputation would be debated in this House rather than the reputation of the Fianna Fáil Party. We do not deprive them of this opportunity because as long as we in Fianna Fáil are on this side of the House the reputation of Fianna Fáil will stand before the people and we will not be afraid of what Deputy Oliver Flanagan, Deputy Liam Cosgrave, Deputy O'Higgins or Deputy Belton have to say about us. The reputation of Fianna Fáil is far above those individuals. Regarding the claim made by the coalition or inter-party Opposition as to splits, cracks, haircracks and volcanoes in the Fianna Fáil Party I want to assure them that their efforts to denigrate Fianna Fáil have failed miserably on numerous occasions before and have failed also on this occasion because the reputation of the Fianna Fáil Party will stand jointed as long as we have people such as Deputy Kevin Boland, Deputy Neil Blaney, Deputy Charles J. Haughey, Deputy Michael Moran, and our Taoiseach, Seán Ó Loinsigh.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton, whose reputation would not stand in front of that of any of the five men I have mentioned, has made allegations in this House not alone today. He made personal attacks against the reputation of none other than Deputy Charles J. Haughey.
Comment on this
I appreciate the frustration that Deputy Belton has suffered over the last number of years because he has been dragged in on the tail of the coat of other individuals whom he has forced into standing with him in his constituency so that he could get the flagging votes of those individuals when they were eliminated. The one thing in his mind was that he would some day top the poll in front of Deputy Charles J. Haughey. He has been frustrated in his efforts and he will be more frustrated when the next election is called in four years time.
Comment on this
The Chair is dealing with remarks like this. Personal remarks are not in order and the Deputy should withdraw it.
Comment on this
The guttersnipe attitude of the Fine Gael Party which we have just witnessed in the front benches has been displayed on no fewer than seven occasions since I came into the House. I remember, when the Taoiseach made nominations for ministerial posts in the past, Deputy Belton and some of his frustrated colleagues stooped so low as to use extravagant means of dealing with personalities and having done so found themselves with a worthless deed, receiving no acclamation from the press. Having failed miserably there they went back to their constituencies fully convinced that the only way to defeat Fianna Fáil was to join in a coalition with Labour. These efforts have been made and we realise their frustration in this matter also. Of course the Labour Party stand on this is not too clear because they themselves are not clear who is their leader. Neither are Fine Gael. In 1965 when I came in here as a young Deputy, helped in by my colleagues Deputy Kevin Boland and P. J. Burke —I am more than grateful to both— Fine Gael had as their leader Deputy James Dillon who was paraded around the country to every fair with a ring in his nose like a bull.
Comment on this
They said during the election campaign that the Fine Gael Party were expressing the wishes of the people when they said it was time for a change. The people listened to what they had to say and they returned Fianna Fáil to office with a majority. Fine Gael on that occasion came into this House to parade that same ex-Deputy around the House and they told the Members that it was time for a change. Fianna Fáil having selected their Taoiseach, the Fine Gael Party resorted to cloak and dagger activities in the Fine Gael rooms and paraded that ex-Deputy there and whispered in his ear, "Deputy Dillon, it is time for a change" and they elected Deputy Cosgrave as their leader. This is a clear indication of the kind of skulduggery that goes on within the Fine Gael Party. This type of skulduggery is probably being concocted at present and who knows but that in the same Fine Gael rooms the new President-elect, Deputy O'Higgins, is being paraded in the same way with a view to having a successful run?
I appreciate that the hypocritical remarks of Deputy Flanagan and Deputy Keating are but fitting to those two individuals. I listened with some grief to the remarks made by Deputy Oliver Flanagan regarding the reputations of Deputies Kevin Boland, Neil Blaney and Charles A. Haughey. It does not grieve me one bit to hear men trying to denigrate the reputation of these two particular individuals. This man is well known as a character assassin. It is not today or yesterday the Fine Gael Party realised this and that is why Deputy Flanagan has found himself in the back benches of the Fine Gael Party not knowing whether he is going to shift outside the railings to the Seanad or across the stairs to the Labour Party.
In defending the reputations of these three men I want to make it quite clear that I am fully behind them and behind anyone with republican traditions. The traditions of those three men are well known to Deputies and to the people. I can assure you no individual in the Opposition would be fit to tie their shoelaces.
Comment on this
We have listened to all kinds of slagging. I am sorry I have to use the word. They dragged people into the mire and then lifted them up and said they were not bad fellows only for this happening them. It is the typical way of knifing a person in the back, cold-blooded assassination. They are cold-blooded assassins. We realise the dilemma they are in. This is an opportunity for them to try to grab a slice of the cake they have so hungrily wished for for many years and of which they have been deprived because of their policies. The people have realised the irresponsibility of Fine Gael in rebuking the Government and rebuking individuals that the people themselves had selected—the Fianna Fáil Party and their Leader, Deputy Jack Lynch. The people gave us our mandate in June 1969 and we will hold on to that mandate. When the Taoiseach decides it is time to have an election we will be satisfied to face the people with a reputation, untarnished up to this——
Comment on this
——and that reputation will stand. If the people do not accept us then, and only then, will we decide that the alternative to Fianna Fáil is inter-party Government, a Government who on two occasions have deceived the people and had to run away from their responsibilities and leave Fianna Fáil holding the baby.
I want to say to Deputy Cosgrave— he was greatly concerned about the Taoiseach being such an honourable man and having such gurriers behind him and, having been knifed in the back by men like Deputies Kevin Boland, Neil Blaney and Charlie Haughey——
Comment on this
The Deputy's best contribution since he came in here was "Hear, hear." It is the best thing I heard him say.
Comment on this
It is 50 times better than anything the Deputy has said. There is no doubt about that.
Comment on this
I want to assure you and Deputy Cosgrave that you will never have the troubles Fianna Fáil have at this moment.
Comment on this
These troubles will never touch the Fine Gael benches or the Labour benches, and do you know why? Because you will never accept the responsibility of governing this country, of having to decide whether you will be the popular fellows with the people or whether you will act only in the interests of the economy of the country. The making of those decisions was rejected by Fine Gael when they were in office. Today they are still afraid of having to make such decisions and that is why I say they will never have the troubles which they imagine we are sorely and deeply grieved by today. I would like to say on behalf of my colleagues—Deputies Kevin Boland, Neil Blaney and Charlie Haughey——
Comment on this
They are proud men who served in the party with republican traditions; a party that accepted that the Taoiseach made the decision on the evidence available to him. These men accepted this like men. I would like to reiterate on their behalf that Deputy Kevin Boland when he was Minister for Local Government and Minister for Social Welfare was a man of distinct character. He was a man whose reputation was completely untarnished and remains untarnished because of his willingness to serve this State in every way possible. This man worked day and night, with limited sleep and with all the energy available to him, to serve the people in the way in which he thought fit. The way in which a Boland thinks fit to serve the State is a way of which I and my colleagues are particularly proud. I am firmly behind my colleagues, not one of them, but each and every one of them, and this is something which Fine Gael hypocrites, the Fine Gael guttersnipes——
Comment on this
I will withdraw that remark and say that anyone who refers to the people mentioned here in the manner in which Fine Gael and Labour have referred to them are nothing more than guttersnipes.
Comment on this
On a point of order, that is a reference to the Opposition. The Deputy referred to the Opposition as guttersnipes. Is the Chair going to accept that?
Comment on this
The Deputy changed his phrasing and has made a political charge. The Chair cannot control these charges, but deprecates them.
Comment on this
As well as trying to denigrate the reputation of Fianna Fáil they have, of course, tried to bring in the name of a dead man. They have used the name of Garda Dick Fallon here so freely that one would think this man, who should be honoured for his heroism, had something to do with this particular action which the Taoiseach has taken.
Comment on this
On a point of order, when Deputy Foley says the late Garda Fallon's name was mentioned in the debate here, is the Deputy referring to Deputy Boland?
Comment on this
If the Deputy were here he would know who mentioned it. It was the reprobates in the front bench who mentioned it. They used Garda Fallon's name in such a way as to convey that they had the sole concern for the late Garda Fallon and his widow and that they would take it upon themselves to catch these people whom they assume we have allowed to go free. I have another slant on that. Infiltration by the Blueshirt movement still exists within some of the forces——
Comment on this
I was not a Blueshirt. I deny that I ever had any association with the Blueshirts. They were the lowest type ever.
Comment on this
I did not wear one or if I did, I wore it as a blue shirt, not as a member of an organisation.
Comment on this
We are proud of the Blueshirts. We had to ensure we could hold public meetings and that Fianna Fáil would not stop them.
Comment on this
The possibility of capturing the murderers of Garda Fallon has been limited in no small way by the implications in what was said here by the leader of the Opposition and those who support him.
Comment on this
Why did you not ask the Minister for Justice to publish the photographs of the seven men you wanted?
Comment on this
Deputy Harte must cease interrupting. The Deputy will complain if the Chair takes action.
Comment on this
Deputy Harte should conduct himself. If he does not do so, I shall ask him to leave the House.
Comment on this
I recognise that the Chair can have me removed. It will not be the first and I presume not the last time but Deputy Foley has raised a very important matter and, through the Chair, I want to ask why the Government have not published photographs of the seven wanted men.
Comment on this
Having given Deputy Harte rope to hang himself, I want to point out that when I spoke about the hyprocritical attitude of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party I was being moderate in regard to those who used this opportunity to mislead the people of the country and try to convey to them that the Fianna Fáil Party have been hiding something from them. We have made our case openly here, in the public press and through all media. That case is that we stand united behind the Taoiseach in his decision.
Comment on this
I realise that the smell of the rashers brought the Deputy down from the mountains. That is an accepted fact in the House.
Comment on this
It is a perfect example of the scent the Deputy has. I hope he did not smuggle in the pigs for the bacon.
Comment on this
I am sure the Opposition Parties will go into the Lobbies and vote against the three Deputies nominated to be Minister, not on the reputation of the Deputies concerned but on the pretence that this great barrage is justified. They will say that they made the Dáil sit all night and have the longest sitting in its history to show their great concern about the running of the country and about keeping the Government on the straight and narrow path. But no less than a few weeks ago their concern for the old age pensioner and the less well-off citizens was such that they voted against the increases in the recent Budget.
Comment on this
If these new Deputies make allegations here they should be able to produce the evidence. Some of these Deputies are only freshly imported and their reputation may well be made known to the House if I am sufficiently provoked. If they have evidence it should be produced because it is a matter of national concern and would be a help to the Taoiseach. Those people who ran so quickly to the Taoiseach with superficial evidence should now give conclusive proof if they can, that we concocted a Budget and that the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Haughey, had hidden away secret money in order to purchase arms for the people in the north. If one Fine Gael Deputy wants to make that type of allegation he should put the evidence before the House.
Comment on this
It is typical of the Party opposite to make allegations that they cannot stand over. It is not the first time we had this.
Comment on this
The Deputy would not need as much because he has not as much hair. I personally stand over the action of the Taoiseach and I also say that the reputation of my colleagues, Deputy Boland, Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey remains untarnished.
Comment on this
Yes, and Deputy Micheál Ó Móráin and Deputy Paudge Brennan. Deputy Brennan resigned on principle and this is something that no Member of the Fine Gael Party——
Comment on this
On a point of order, it is disgraceful the way Deputy Foley has been harassed here today from the Fine Gael benches.
Comment on this
Deputy Foley should be allowed to continue. It is disgraceful the way Deputy Harte and his colleagues have heckled Deputy Foley in an endeavour to provoke him and get him put out of the House.
Comment on this
He wants to go home. I do not want to enter into personalities. I do not mind Deputy Harte interrupting me.
Comment on this
The Chair has been very patient with Deputy Harte and if he is anxious to be put out I will oblige him. The Deputy will please keep quite. If Deputy Foley has concluded I will call another Deputy.
Comment on this
We in the Fianna Fáil Party stand united in our aims and in our principles. We stand united as a team behind our Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch. These men have been mentioned with discredit by the Opposition and with credit by the Members of this side of the House. The Opposition have failed miserably to live up to the dignity of this House. They have shown to the people exactly what their contribution would be if the people were so naive on some occasion as to select them as the alternative to the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
It is worth stating once again why we are here on a Saturday afternoon at 3.15 p.m. after almost 30 hours of continuous debate. It is not because of the actions of anybody in Opposition but because of the action of the Taoiseach in sacking two of his senior Ministers and accepting the resignation of a third. Since the previous speaker tried to give the impression that this was brought about in some way by the actions of Deputies on this side of the House, it is as well to make this qualification right here at the start.
In a small village in Wicklow some weeks ago, the village of Rathdrum, for 1½ hours the normal law of the land ceased to operate. For 1½ hours two car loads of semi-military individuals, dressed in military clothing, invaded that small village and held up a branch of the Hibernian Bank. At least six individuals terrorised the occupants of that village firing shots into the air and firing shots at random both inside and outside the bank. This was not an isolated incident. It was not an incident for which there was no precedent. This was one of a series of raids on Irish banks that took place last year.
It was obvious to everybody in Dublin that Gardaí were watching outside each of the major branches of the banks in the city. I was not aware that this direction was given to the Gardaí in the rural areas because there was no surveillance by the garda on bank branches in rural parts. These individuals turned their attention to these banks not only in Rathdrum but in Baltinglass and Meath and other parts of Ireland.
As a result of that raid I tabled a question to the Minister for Justice asking him what further steps he was prepared to take to ensure the safety of the people in the banks and to ensure the safety of ordinary individuals going about their normal business. The Minister's reply was short and curt, as was his wont. He said, in effect, that adequate measures were taken to look after people employed in the banks in this State. Very shortly afterwards, there was a raid on a bank in Arran Quay, Dublin, which resulted, unfortunately, in the death of a very brave garda who was trying to prevent the bank robbers from escaping. These raids have been going on for some time, yet nobody has been brought to justice, to my knowledge in any case, in the past few months.
The death of Garda Fallon was mentioned by the previous speaker. He said we on this side of the House had used it to make a case against the Taoiseach and the Government. I mention it purely to illustrate the fact that in the past year the safety of individuals in this State has not been adequately looked after. When this House asked for further protection where it was needed we were told—and this is on the records of the House—that the protection was adequate.
I was horrified that the sound of shots was heard in a village of 600 inhabitants in my constituency and that peoples' lives were put in danger. The last time I heard shots fired in anger was when I visited Belfast last August. I was a member of two delegations from the Labour Party who went to make an on-the-spot inquiry into the troubles going on there.
Deputy Blaney made a rather snide remark about the Labour Party members of those delegations, as though we in the Labour Party had no right to be concerned about the people of Northern Ireland, as though we had no right to go over the Border and talk to people on the Falls Road or in Derry or in Armagh, who were beleagured by the Orange extremists there.
I was accompanied by Senator Jack Fitzgerald and Deputy James Tully on that occasion. Deputy Boland suggested that we were on a glory-seeking mission. In fact, it would be difficult to find two more unassuming Members of the Oireachtas; they would shy away, I believe, from any attempt to seek glory for themselves. We went by train, without any fanfare, and so on. We went around to various places as far as we were permitted to do so. We made inquiries and found out the needs of the people in the area.
On the Saturday-Sunday of the most dreadful week in the recent history of Northern Ireland we were able, by the fact of our being there, to get in touch with Deputy Corish in Dublin to let him know the plight of the people in Northern Ireland and the plight of the people in the urban parts of Belfast. We were able to ask him to make the Taoiseach aware of the severe plight of people on the Springfield Road and in the Ardoyne area of Belfast who were threatened by mobs of Paisley extremists that their houses would be burned out as several had been burned out in the Falls Road area. As a result of our being there, and as a result of sending back these views on the people in that area, we felt that the Taoiseach would be able to get in touch with people in charge of security in the north. As a result, British troops were put into the Ardoyne on that Saturday afternoon, thus staving off a bloodbath which seemed imminent that afternoon. Having heard for the first time shots fired in that area of Ireland, in anger against fellow-Irishmen, I never want to hear the same thing on this side of the Border.
When as a member of the inter-party delegation in London, the news came to us that there was a crisis in the Government and we were asked to return home immediately and then, when we came back and found the reason for this crisis, I was terribly saddened to hear who were involved. These people were not named by anybody on these benches but by the Taoiseach himself—people of the calibre of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney who have, I would say, international reputations. I felt it would be very sad if these allegations were true.
It was the Taoiseach who felt he must remove these men from office in case there was any suspicion, as he said himself, that they were implicated in the importation of arms for an illegal organisation. As a result of that action, the nation has reeled in shock over the past few days. As a result of that action, we here in these benches and also on the Government benches have been discussing the possible repercussions of the alleged actions of these men and of the Taoiseach's actions.
The people on these benches have every bit as great a love for their native country as Deputies on other benches. They have been protesting their love of country and their long traditions of serving the Irish nation. We, too, and our forebears have also served the Irish nation. When I listened to my colleague from Wicklow, Deputy P. Brennan, explain quietly and sincerely why he felt he must resign, I felt a great sympathy for him. I know Deputy Brennan, his family and his relations. His wife's family come from my own town. I am deeply sorry for Deputy Brennan in the decision he felt he had to make. He suggested that the people of Wicklow would decide whether he should serve them in the future. I am sure the people of Wicklow will understand the great loyalty Deputy Brennan has to his party and to his ideals and that they will therefore understand the reasons for the action he took.
In the past year, or almost a year, since I first became a Member of this House, it has been a time for me to learn my trade here. I had to decide the occasions when I should speak and on many occasions I decided not to speak. From these Labour benches I noticed that certain Ministers arrived here at Question Time and chatted together, passed jokes and so on, among themselves. I notice how this usually happened on the right hand side of the benches as I look at them and the Taoiseach and his colleagues were left severely alone. It was not surprising, therefore, when the crunch came, to discover that it was these men who generally consorted amongst themselves who were the persons affected. On many occasions we saw the attitude they took to the leader of their own party. When we heard two of them make their statements here yesterday we had little doubt that they at no stage, or only on very few occasions, held their leader in the high regard in which one should hold one's leader and the Taoiseach of the country.
It is indeed sad that in a few hours' time the Taoiseach must explain to this House, more fully than he did in his earlier remarks why he has had to let these men go. The reasons he gave for dismissing them—that it was suggested they were connected with the importation of arms for illegal purposes—have been refuted by these two men, who strenuously denied this accusation. The Taoiseach must give the reasons to the House why he had to take this action. The Taoiseach said that not even the slightest suspicion should attach to a Minister.
When the Taoiseach comes here to-day he will also have to explain the situation in relation to the Minister designate for Agriculture and Fisheries —the disclosures concerning him in the newspapers and on television. These disclosures have left doubt and suspicion about Deputy J. Gibbons. One cannot be unmindful of the fact that, up to now, he has held the portfolio of Minister for Defence. I hope that the Taoiseach will lay the full facts before the House and will let the people decide whether the action he took in relation to the particular individuals was right. The only way in which the Taoiseach can do that is to call a general election.
Comment on this
Listening to Deputy Foley a while ago I formed the opinion that his attitude is typical of the attitude of all Fianna Fáil people. That attitude is that, outside of Fianna Fáil, there can be no good and that it is they who have a monopoly of patriotism and nationalism here.
Deputy Foley more or less implied that the Opposition were responsible for having an extended sitting of the House. Of course, the Deputy would not accept that his party are responsible for the situation, but we all know they are. This country finds itself in a situation that has never before been experienced in the State. We are all interested in the welfare of the State. That is why we take this opportunity of expressing our views on this unprecedented situation.
Deputy Foley referred to the guttersnipe tactics of the Opposition which allegations, of course, are untrue. It was rather laughable when he said he did not wish to be personal—after he had attacked two or three Members of this side of the House. I know that he was enjoying himself at the time, so we will let him away with that. However, he referred to an era in this country when it was necessary to have an organisation to preserve the rights of democracy and to allow freedom of speech. The Deputy referred to the Blueshirts. I was a Blueshirt. I was proud to be one and I make no apology to Deputy Foley or to any member of Fianna Fáil for that.