Nomination of Members of Government: Motion.
Contributions 1,391–1,547 of 1,547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 8 parts.
It was necessary to have the Blueshirts so that decent people could walk the streets during that particular era. If Deputy Foley realised what he was talking about, I doubt if he would have referred at all to this matter.
However, so much for that. I must deal with the motion before the House, namely, the filling of vacancies in the Cabinet created by the expulsion and resignation of certain Ministers. Three young men have been named to fill these vacancies: Deputies Cronin, Molloy and Collins. To my mind, they are three quiet young men who will be very capable in their respective Ministries, if they are afforded the opportunity of carrying out their duties. But this I doubt because of the situation that led up to the necessity for their appointment. It is this that is the core of the whole matter.
While I was passing through the corridors yesterday I heard two Fianna Fáil veterans, one of whom is a former Parliamentary Secretary, talking loudly and one commented to the other: "Is this not a tragic situation?" to which his colleague replied: "It would not happen in our time." Unfortunately, however, it has happened in the 1970's. These veterans of Fianna Fáil were, of course, referring to the situation which resulted in the Taoiseach having to ask for the resignation of certain members of his Cabinet. Fianna Fáil have nobody but themselves to blame for this situation.
Let it be said that the situation was known to the Taoiseach for some time. Were it not for information having been made available to him by the leader of our party, Deputy Cosgrave, perhaps the facts would never have been made known. Deputy Cosgrave, with his traditionally national outlook, called on the Taoiseach and made him aware of the information he had in his possession. Deputy Cosgrave need not have gone to the Taoiseach at all. He could have come to the House with the information; he could have called a Press conference or have appeared on television and let the country know about the situation but, being the man that he is, he did not do any of these things because, as I have already said, his traditions and his birth would not allow him to do such a thing. He courteously presented the Taoiseach with the information. He did not make political capital out of it because that is not the approach of either Deputy Cosgrave or the members of the Fine Gael Party. They are above such tactics.
The Taoiseach's action in calling for these resignations immediately created the situation that we now have to deal with here. Deputy Foley blamed us for being unfair to the staff of this House. I sympathise with those members of the staff who are on duty for long hours, but that is not the responsibility of the Fine Gael Party. The people on the Government benches are the people responsible for this. They have created the situation and it is necessary to give everybody who is interested in the future of this country an opportunity of voicing his views. It is necessary to cross every "t" and dot every "i" in this debate.
The disclosures which the Taoiseach, so mildly presented to the House will need a lot of explaining before Deputies or the people of the country will be satisfied. The situation is referred to in the Cork Examiner of today's date, Cork's own paper. Remember, the Taoiseach comes from the same town. I quote:
There is an obvious temptation, in times of national difficulty such as those which are now upon us, to become a little hysterical, a little over-alarmed about the course of events and the manner in which they may affect the future of the country and the well-being of its people. There is, on the other hand, a tendency to be a little too blasé, and to play down the dangers in the situation which has now arisen in national affairs.
That is what is being done by the Government and the Fianna Fáil Pary. They have played it down and they are playing it down. There is no crisis, they tell us, nothing at all wrong; we are all one big happy family—after the sacking of Ministers and the resignation of another. Everything is rosy in the garden. No crisis at all, despite what the news media have put before the public every day since and the headlines that everybody who had an opportunity of having a Dublin paper on last Wednesday had for their breakfast. Their digestions were not helped when, over their breakfast last Wednesday, they saw headlines like these in the Dublin papers: "Ministers Sacked; One Resigned; Serious Crisis in the Country." Here in the House we have been told more than once that there is no crisis, none whatever. Two Ministers were asked for their resignations, which they did not give, and one resigned. Despite three senior Ministers leaving the Government Fianna Fáil are quite happy. They are again a united party, having the full support of those Ministers the Taoiseach did not think fit to hold office. I shall continue my quotation from the Cork Examiner:
There is every reason to avoid promoting an atmosphere of panic, since this will serve no purpose at all, but it is equally apparent that the widespread public concern that is being felt about a grave national issue cannot be shrugged off with the simple words: "There is no crisis." In the strictly literal sense, this may be true. The Government is continuing to function; Ministers have been dismissed or have resigned, and they have been replaced, but while the process of Government continues, there can be no doubt whatever that the startling events of recent days have resulted only in engendering an atmosphere of public bewilderment and not a little fear for the future.
It is no wonder we have statements, counter-statements, more confusion and the situation is far from being clear to the public. We know very well it is not clear to the party concerned. In the present situation it behoves everyone to speak and to act with not a little restraint. There are enough wild rumours and half truths circulating already. Emotional outbursts will not help but, in spite of this, there are still things that must be said and actions that must be taken. The Taoiseach informed the House that it was necessary to ask two Ministers for their seals of office.
I have already stated that another Minister resigned. Deputy Boland made a statement denying that he had anything to do with any gun running or alleged gun running in this country.
He probably, which he was entitled to do, cleared himself but it was rather extraordinary to do it by way of the inflammatory speech he made. It could not be called anything else. He categorically denied he had anything to do with the gun running. By implication he made the Taoiseach appear he was cutting their throats. He told him in no uncertain terms he had nothing to do with it and that whatever information he got from the special ministerial watching organisation, as Deputy Boland called it, and the Gestapotype methods used was not the truth. He resigned because he considered if the Taoiseach had not confidence in him it was time to get out.
When Deputy Boland realised that this ministerial watching organisation was set up to watch the Ministers, to know what they were doing, to "bug" houses and tap phones, surely it was quite apparent the Taoiseach must have been lacking in confidence in those people on whom he had put this watching organisation set up by the named civil servant. He said he definitely knew of one Minister whose house was bugged. The ministerial watching organisation was able to enter in their diaries anything which went on and to convey it to the Taoiseach. It was hard to blame Deputy Boland for resigning as a protest when he found out the true situation.
Deputy Blaney also came into the House and denied that he had anything to do with the alleged gun smuggling to this country or to the north. He made a very warm speech as regards his youth and his early days and he again, like Deputy Boland, levelled all his remarks at the Opposition side of the House. The Opposition were responsible for everything. It is unfortunate that some people want to make capital even at this late stage out of references to the unfortunate Civil War.
Deputy Blaney made good use of it. He spoke for a long time but he did not really tell us anything. Both Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland asserted their loyalty to the Taoiseach and to the Fianna Fáil Party. They freely gave their loyal support in order to keep Fianna Fáil in office.
There are fresh allegations of widespread intrigue which must be either substantiated or refuted. In this regard the Government will have to be much more forthcoming than they have been. They have not told anything yet. The Taoiseach in a very short statement in this House gave an account of what he did. He gave no explanation but naturally he is called on to give one now. There presists a feeling that the public have not been told the whole truth. While there may be reticence on the grounds of national security there is also a crying need for a fuller explanation of what has happened, both within and outside the national territory within recent months.
The public are further bemused by the fact that one of the former Ministers has categorically denied that he is in any way implicated in the alleged incident on which his dismissal was said to have been founded. The public are also bemused by the fact that the veracity of the information which led the Taoiseach to act as he did is being openly questioned. There persists the feeling that there is more in the matter than meets the eye, that too many questions remains unanswered. There is nothing answered at the moment and the situation is becoming worse. In today's Irish Press I saw the headings “Confusion lies in the crisis. Cabinet changes overshadowed. Blaney, Boland defend their stands. Minister, Army man exchange fire. Ranks close to election calls.” There is, therefore, a lot to be told and that is the responsibility of the Taoiseach.
It is the responsibility of the Taoiseach to come into this House and answer these important questions in a detailed way. The facts will have to be brought to light because the country cannot accept less than the truth. The people are entitled to a full explanation of the events that led up to this unprecedented situation. It is a tragic occasion when a Taoiseach finds it necessary to ask his Ministers to resign because it was alleged that they were engaged in subversive activities within and outside the State.
There is the feeling that law and order must be more strictly enforced against any section of the community which is guilty of transgression and this impartial enforcement must become a reality in order to restore public confidence. There is justifiable concern about the fact that a new element of lawlessness is creeping into Irish society. There have been too many instances of armed robberies, allegedly for political ends, and too few arrests. It matters little whether the planning of these raids is carried out in the North or in the South. What matters is that the security forces are not operating with maximum effectiveness and a worried public is beginning to ask why. It is no wonder that our country is getting a bad name as regards gangsterism and hold-ups and robberies which have been increasing.
From conversations with Garda officers I know they are not happy about such matters but I must say that, both individually and collectively, these officers fearlessly carry out their duty. Unfortunately, they are short of personnel which hinders them in their work. These is a suggestion in newspapers reports that there may be other elements at work which, if it is true, is not going to improve the position but will worsen it. I know one case which occurred last year in County Cork involving either 98 or 102 charges. However, the Attorney General or whoever was responsible gave a direction in the matter and the people responsible never came to trial. I consider this is a matter that calls for explanation although I must admit that there may be some legal formality involved in this case of which I am unaware.
It is bad if the impression is created that the maximum effectiveness of our police force is not maintained at a high standard. In some of the towns I know there is a policy—I do not know if it came from an unnamed Civil Service commissioner or not—of closing down Garda Síochána barracks throughout the country and depriving many parishes of any kind of protection by the Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
It is time they were shifted. We had enough with the Black and Tans.
Comment on this
The lack of Garda personnel is responsible for much of the lawlessness throughout the country. It is very bad when people and areas are deprived of the protection and service of the Garda Síochána.
Today's leading article in the Cork Examiner states:
This is not at all to suggest that freedom of speech or expression should be curtailed in any way. To attempt any such course of action in the present circumstances would be to cause disaster but the law as it stands must be clearly seen to be adequately and properly enforced. This must be seen to be done with justice to everybody.
It goes on to say:
These are testing days not only for the Government but for the entire nation and in the strange and worrying situation that has arisen it behoves all public representatives to put party political considerations to one side and to fulfil their onerous trust as best they can in the wider interests of the whole nation. In particular, since the Opposition is the people's watchdog, it is incumbent upon them to maintain a constant vigilance and to play as constructive a role as they can in the developing situation.
That is what we have been doing here today and yesterday, maintaining a constant vigilance and playing a constructive role in helping to solve this problem and to get the necessary information so that the situation created within the ranks of the Government of the Fianna Fáil Party will be satisfactorily concluded, and so that all loose ends will be tied, and there are quite a few loose ends to be tied yet. The House expects that when the Taoiseach comes in to reply he will be able to satisfy everybody on these questions. I quote again:
The Government's task is simply to govern firmly, fairly and effectively. It is becoming manifestly more difficult.
I am beholden to this morning's Cork Examiner for giving me a great deal of most helpful information. It is extraordinary that in 1970 there is still talk of guns not alone in the south but in the six north eastern counties. With regard to the speeches made here yesterday by the two former Ministers in justification of their attitudes, they took a hard line in referring to the importation of guns into this country. Unfortunately, providing arms, or attempting to provide them for either people above or below the Border in the name of patriotism is a gross misrepresentation of the principle. It creates a serious hazard for young people who can be led or misled. One must have regard to the unfortunate situation that developed up north last August. The people of this country were happy and relieved when the gun was taken out of Irish politics. It would be regrettable that the gun should be returned to politics here by responsible Members, former Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Party, and that the foundations of a civil war should be laid.
These disclosures have shaken the country. The views of Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland are well known; they are hard liners. However, it shocked the country completely that an intelligent, able man like Deputy Charles Haughey should be allegedly associated in this affair. As regards Deputy Ó Móráin, the Taoiseach tells us he was not implicated in the gun running but resigned for health reasons.
Deputy Boland, speaking from the benches over there yesterday, said in no uncertain terms that he was pushed. That again, by implication, suggests that the Taoiseach has told more than one untruth or misrepresented such information as he had.
I do not think that it is necessary to delay the House but, as tragic as the situation is and as unwelcome and unnecessary, one good thing came out of it. There is a section of our people, a very hard working section who, no doubt, will welcome and applaud in a loud manner the removal or departure of Deputy Blaney from the Department of Agriculture. It is well known that he was on their backs for some years and was the bane of their lives. He availed of every opportunity, whenever they had demands and when he did meet them, to tell them that they never had it so good; that it will be better next year; to keep it up. He plagued their lives, especially the dairy farmers. He was the man who carried on the cold war with both the dairy farmers and the NFA. He denied to them the opportunity which is afforded to other sections of the community to make a decent living, not alone for themselves but for their families. He had never any sympathy for them, until this year, when, lo and behold, three weeks before the Budget——
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that agriculture would not be a subject for the debate. There will be an opportunity when the Estimate for Agriculture comes before the House.
Comment on this
I am aware of this. This is just a reference to the departure of Deputy Blaney from the Department of Agriculture. I thought those few words would not do him any harm.
Comment on this
He had no sympathy with the farmers. However, he relented and told them he would get them £14 million this year. They got a sop, unfortunately.
Comment on this
I bow to the ruling of the Chair. I have no intention of getting into an argument. He gave them a little sop this year, which of course was absorbed two years ago by rising costs, and the farmers are now worse off than they were then.
The Taoiseach has a big responsibility in this matter. He has a great deal of explaining to do. I would suggest to the Taoiseach, as a great many other Deputies have suggested, that the easiest way this matter can be dealt with is for him to take a trip to the Park. The sooner he goes to the country the better. Well and good if the people give him a mandate to return to office, he will have justified himself but under the circumstances it is very doubtful. The Fine Gael Party would offer themselves to the people as an alternative Government and I am quite sure that, when the people will have had an opportunity of studying the long-awaited statement of the Taoiseach by way of explanation of this whole tragic situation in 1970, in Ireland, that will be a factor in the decision as to who will be the next Government. I have no hesitation in saying that it will be Fine Gael led by Deputy Liam Cosgrave.
Comment on this
I have said in this House before that I do not like taking part in this type of debate because it is essentially a debate on personalities. I rise now because in the special circumstances in which we all find ourselves we have a grave responsibility to join in this public condemnation and denunciation of an administration that has shown itself to be riddled with intrigue against the security of the State.
I listened earlier this evening to Deputy O'Kennedy complaining that this debate had gone on as long as it has and suggesting that the matter had been discussed in detail. He accused Opposition Deputies of trying to create the impression that there was a crisis in the country. We had the Taoiseach on Radio Telefís Éireann saying the same thing—that there was no crisis. I should like to inquire what constitutes a crisis in the Fianna Fáil organisation. Two Ministers resigned, two more are dismissed. In the case of the two who resigned we do not know whether there was some pressure on them to resign or not—this is still not clear—and a Parliamentary Secretary resigns, and this is not a crisis in Government
It makes one wonder how much the Fianna Fáil Party can cover up, how much they can gloss over, telling the people: "There is nothing at all; not a ripple on the wave; everything is going perfectly." How much is it possible for them to smother up in this way that there is no crisis now? There is no crisis after a serious situation of attempted gun-running, of attempted importation of a large cargo of guns and ammunition, for which the Taoiseach felt he must dismiss two of his senior Ministers. And this is not a crisis. These are not our accusations. It was the Taoiseach himself who said this. The onus is on him to prove that they are guilty and I do not believe that the Taoiseach has taken this action without having conclusive evidence that they are, in fact, guilty.
I, personally, am not satisfied that the ex-Minister for Defence is in the clear either. I think it will take fairly careful handling to convince the country that he is in the clear. The statement made last night by Captain Kelly certainly creates grave doubts. The impression everybody had before that was that Captain Kelly was a person himself very much involved in this illegal importation. But Captain Kelly makes it quite clear that any part he played in this whole business was fully known to the Minister for Defence and authorised by him. All these matters will take considerable clearing up. It is all very well for Deputy O'Kennedy to try to convince the people on these benches that there is no crisis over there. A statement of that kind will not convince the people that there is no crisis. The people are not going to be convinced that we were ever in a worse situation for very many years. There is only one solution. It has been recommended on many occasions here today.
The motion before the House is, of course, on the nomination of three new Ministers but, as the leader of this party, Deputy Liam Cosgrave, said when opening this discussion, the people are not at present concerned as to what member of the Fianna Fáil Party fills which post in the Cabinet. They know there is a serious crisis and they know that it would be quite unreal to be concerned about what might be regarded as a trivial matter in comparison. The people are simply horrified to think that it would be possible by any means for Fianna Fáil to continue in government under present circumstances. Several Deputies have said there is only one solution and that is for the Taoiseach to dissolve this Dáil and got the country in a general election. He may decide to hold on to power, but I do not think that public opinion will let him, and it certainly will not let him for long. I think he might as well take the bull by the horns now and let the people decide who is capable of giving them the fearless and honest type of leadership that the country now so sorely requires. I believe that when the people get an opportunity of passing a verdict on the situation as we all now see it the man who will come back here to lead the people is the man who has been responsible for exposing this whole sordid affair, Deputy Liam Cosgrave.
Comment on this
One never knows what would have happened if Deputy Cosgrave had not gone down and told the Taoiseach what he knew and told him how concerned he was that the necessary measures would be taken to ensure that the country was not landed into chaos. Of course, we all know that an hour or so later there were two Ministers dismissed and another resigned. Prior to that we had a Minister resigning, allegedly because of ill-health, and his colleague, the Minister for Local Government, says, of course, that he was pushed and that what the Taoiseach has told this House is, in fact, not true. I did not think that we would ever see the day when Ministers in an Irish Government would be guilty of deeds that would so imperil the security of this State. I did not think we would ever see the day when it would be possible for a Government containing such Ministers to carry on as the Government of the country. I did not think we would ever see the day when a Taoiseach would so humiliate himself as to hold on to power with the votes and the support of Members of this House whom he himself considered unfit to hold office in his Government.
This takes an immense amount of explaining. Every Deputy on that side who stood up to speak boasted of the solidarity and the unity of the Fianna Fáil Party. They are all behind the Taoiseach and, at the same time, they are all behind the Ministers who have been knifing him in the back. We find it difficult to accept this. The Taoiseach cannot expect us on this side of the House to regard this House as a large confessional into which Fianna Fáil Deputies can come and be absolved from their sins and in which the Taoiseach can give them absolution, give them a little penance, and say: "Now be good boys in future and come back and we will all live happily ever after". This is what has happened on this occasion. But the Taoiseach well knows that every sinner has a partner in crime and I believe that these partners are still there to be flushed out.
I believe the Taoiseach knows he is taking chances. He knows he is playing with fire, but he is prepared to play with fire in order to hold on to power in this deplorable way. I said earlier that there is only one solution and the sooner the Taoiseach adopts this solution the better for the country as a whole. We are told that this has all arisen because certain Ministers in the Government did not fully agree with the Taoiseach's views on the re-unification of the country and the means to be used towards that end.
All of us were led to believe that all parties in this State had abandoned the idea of force as a means of regaining the lost territory. The Ministers who are supposed to be implicated in this illegal traffic in arms have also said this and pledged their support and their loyalty to the Taoiseach in pursuing this peaceful means of re-uniting our country. As somebody said, it is really annoying to listen to Deputies on that side of the House trying to give the impression that only they are concerned about the Border, only they are concerned about the situation in Northern Ireland. All of us in this House are equally concerned.
What is mainly wrong in relation to the North of Ireland is, I think, the fact that there is no policy on the north. There never was a policy on the north and all we know now is that the Taoiseach says, if we are to achieve the re-unification of the country, it must be done by peaceful means. We all agree with that but, when troops were being sent to the Border, and when there was a serious situation in the North of Ireland, nobody on these benches on this side of the House was consulted. Fianna Fáil were the only party that were concerned and they yet have not got the good sense to set up an all-party committee of this House which would concern itself constantly with the situation in Northern Ireland. Nothing is being done. It is a case of peaceful means—full stop.
I have taken advantage of the fact that I am a member of the Council of Europe to discuss the Northern Ireland situation with the British Labour and Conservative delegates. The impression I get from all these people is that they are sick and tired of the situation in Northern Ireland and that they would gladly get out of it if the right approach was made. This is a matter that should be discussed seriously with the British Government and an agreement could be reached by which they would announce a phased withdrawal. They know they could not jump out of Northern Ireland with a serious situation arising there. We also know that. I agree with Deputy Boland when he says the British are responsible for the situation in Northern Ireland. It is only with their co-operation that the difficulties that arise there will end. We must be more active about this matter. We are just pledging ourselves to peaceful means and doing nothing after that. We are losing contact with both the Northern Ireland and British Governments.
This whole situation has been well discussed here in the last day or so and I do not want to repeat what has already been said again and again but I should like to appeal to the Taoiseach to make a clean breast of things because either he is not telling us the whole truth, telling us all he knows, or some of his dismissed Ministers are not telling the truth. There is a clear contradiction between what he has said and what the dismissed Ministers have said. He should be at pains to clear up this situation and tell the House the extent to which these ex-Ministers, in his opinion and with the knowledge he has, are guilty. If they are guilty they should be pursued for their guilt in the normal way and through the proper courses. He should tell us what is going to be done about that. It is a very serious thing to dismiss two senior Ministers unless there is fairly conclusive evidence that they are guilty, and if they are guilty they should not be let go free.
I should also like to hear from the Taoiseach what part Captain Kelly has played in all this. If the man is in the clear his name should be cleared here because it has been smeared and it is only fair to have the situation clarified.
We have this attempted gun running, these efforts to import ammunition illegally. This is at a time when the Government have deliberately allowed the Army to run down to a deplorably low level in strength and equipment, at a time when we have serious trouble on both sides of the Border and when we should be making a considerable effort to increase the strength of the Army and equip them properly. In saying that I do not intend that the Army should be used to cross the Border. We need a stronger and better equipped Army and we shall have more peace when we have them. The sooner serious consideration is given to this matter the better for all concerned.
As regards the new Ministers whose appointments we are discussing, I have considerable doubt as to whether the Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons, has been cleared. The Taoiseach should state positively that he is cleared and that he had no hand, act or part in the whole business. If that is so he should be left in the Department of Defence rather than put somebody there at this critical time who has no contact with the job.
My own belief is that he is quite unsuitable to be in charge of the Department of Agriculture. It is well known that he is in serious conflict with our largest farming organisation. That is a bad foot for any man to start off on. I have also the objection that he is a Minister who cannot give a civil answer at Question Time. He is always acting the smart alec with Deputies. Even when asked a simple, straightforward question you cannot get an answer except a smart alec one.
Comment on this
He may have, but he has a few more to learn. I should not like to say anything wrong about anybody nominated to take up an important position in the Government. I wish the other two nominees luck and I hope they will do well—if membership of this Government is ever completed. I have a strong suspicion that it never will be completed. If the Taoiseach has the wisdom I think he has he will dissolve the Dáil this evening. I do not believe that Deputy Moran is seriously ill.
Comment on this
His colleague, another Minister, says he was pushed, that he did not resign of his own volition or through illness. That must be answered.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not usually engage in this kind of talk. I can assure the Deputy that Deputy Moran is under medical care.
Comment on this
If the Tánaiste says that I accept it but I want the Tánaiste to ask the Taoiseach to explain why Deputy Boland says he does not believe that Deputy Moran resigned but believes he was asked to resign.
Comment on this
It was my impression that he was not seriously ill because we all saw him very shortly beforehand. I should like the Taoiseach to tell the House also where is Captain Kelly if he is a guilty man. If he was guilty in any way he should not be free. There are many details that need to be filled in.
Comment on this
Where is Deputy Gibbons now? We have not seen him since 8 o'clock last night on the front bench.
Comment on this
I should like the Taoiseach to explain why having got sufficient evidence to dismiss two Ministers, he left it nine days before interviewing Deputy Blaney. Why that delay? All these details are important because these incomplete facts are disturbing the minds not only of Deputies but of the people.
I should like the Taoiseach to tell the House how long is this gun-running going on. For how long has he been aware of it? There is a report in The Guardian which indicates that this has been going on since last October or November and that there was considerable knowledge of traffic in this type of arms and ammunition on numerous occasions during the period which has intervened. Was the Taoiseach aware of this? If he was, what serious action was taken to stop it?
Deputy Tully referred to the fact that some guns and ammunition were being delivered at the North Wall. There is a reference in today's Irish Independent to this. It is stated that in the Dáil the Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons, said the suggestion made by Deputy James Tully that weapons for illegal organisations had been collected at Dublin Docks by Army lorries was fantastically untrue. It is headed: “Guns on lorries at North Wall.” The report says:
A claim that the warehouse area around the North Wall, Dublin, is being used as link in gun-running for the past six months was made by a resident of the area last night.
Mr. William Lynch (40), unemployed carpenter, who lives near a cargo terminus in the warehouse area at Mayor St., said last night: "On at least three occasions I have seen guns unloaded from cattle or hay lorries.
"For months there has been heavy late-night traffic in Mayor St. and I have seen guns unloaded from lorries and carried down a laneway which leads to the warehouse block and also links up with Guild St.
"The lorries usually have cattle——
There is a misprint there—
——or hay in them but when these are unloaded I have seen teams of shouting men carrying guns—I have seen the butts of the guns hanging down.
"The most recent night when I saw guns being unloaded was Wednesday."
Deputy Tully was telling the House and the Minister what we are all hearing about this sort of thing. It is very disquieting and the more information the Taoiseach can give the House the better.
I should also like to ask the Taoiseach what information was given to him by the British Secret Service, when was the Minister for Justice given this information, and did he fail to pass it on? This is important. Were the Minister for Justice and the Department of Justice in receipt of information which the Taoiseach was not getting, in spite of the special Gestapo machinery that he was supposed to have at his disposal tapping people's telephones and that type of thing? It presents the Taoiseach in a very different light to me. He is a very different man to me now, if that is the type of man he really is.
I would think twice before I would accept that the Taoiseach would have what was described as a super-Special Branch investigating the conduct and carry-on of his own Ministers and tapping their telephones. Surely it must be unheard of in a democratic country. If the Taoiseach is driven to this, surely it is time for him to quit and time to break up an organisation where that is necessary. I would be very slow to accept that the Taoiseach is the type of man who would live with that sort of machinery.
Reference was made earlier to Taca and Tacateers. Reference was made on many occasions to a crisis, and there were several denials from the other side of the House that there was such a thing as a crisis. Since this debate started this House has been haunted. The gates have nearly been knocked down by members of Taca in case anything would interfere with the avenues they have to special favours.
Comment on this
This place has been haunted. We are all well able to recognise them. They are seriously concerned because the favours might disappear if Fianna Fáil disappeared. This was a very serious business, obviously, an extremely serious business to them and they have crowded out this House——
Comment on this
The superintendent had nothing to do with this. These people have passes and they do not have to talk to the people at the gates.
Comment on this
Before I finish I will quote the Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons:
He had formed the opinion that Capt. Kelly was becoming unsuitable and certain suspicions had formed in his mind.
That needs a little further explanation. In what way had he become unsuitable? What suspicions had formed in the Minister's mind? This man is entitled to have his name cleared. There should be nothing that it is necessary to hide from the people. In the last analysis there is only one thing that will allay the anxiety, or help to allay the anxiety, of the people and that is to let the people decide on the new situation. There is a very different situation in the country now. The people over there have been found out for what they are.
Comment on this
They have been found out now, if they are ever to be found out. The people are howling it in the streets and now it appears that they are afraid to go to the country in a general election.
Comment on this
I do not intend to delay the House for more than four or five minutes. I want to try and reemphasise some of the points which are serious and deserve answers from members of the Government who were elected to run this country. Deputy O'Kennedy said that members of Fine Gael were instructed to come in here one after the other and speak in this debate. That is not true.
Comment on this
We were told that if we considered the situation which arose in this country as a result of what happened on last Tuesday and Wednesday was serious, this was the place to say so. A number of Fine Gael speakers emphasised how seriously we take this situation. I was elected here last June and I am very sorry that in my first year in this House I should have to take part in such a debate. I am sorry and angry. I am sorry that this House, for which so many sacrifices were made and over which so much blood was spilled to allow us to establish the right to govern ourselves, has been threatened by the events of the past fortnight and to the Taoiseach's knowledge, of the past month, according to some of the papers.
I am angry that a party that claims to represent the Irish people and received 45 per cent of the votes of the Irish people should so desert the traditions for which they say they stand. I am angry that a party with the ideals which Fianna Fáil claim to hold would allow within their ranks people of the kind mentioned by the Taoiseach who would be associated with the bringing of guns illegally into this country. Talking to these people in the lobbies, as I have been doing for the past three days, I cannot believe they are satisfied with what is happening here over the past week as to how this country should be run. Members have said to me that it is the saddest day for many years in this House and that this is the biggest blow the Fianna Fáil Party have ever suffered. I hope they will be strong enough as a party and will live up to the patriotism they profess by ensuring that those people in their midst who are acting in what I consider an un-Irish, unpatriotic, undemocratic way will be rooted out and that, whatever the pain to the party itself, it will get rid of them. I can assure Fianna Fáil that, in so doing, they will be all the stronger.
We have had Deputies saying that there is no crisis but when we meet them in the corridors it is different: there is a crisis. It is our job as an Opposition to be the watchdogs of the people. It is a role I would not wish for myself. I should much prefer to be on the Government side of the House. However, I shall fulfil the role for which I was elected. I wish the same could be said about the Government.
The Taoiseach should answer the allegations by Deputy Boland that Deputy Moran was fired or "pushed", as he said, and did not resign of his own accord. Deputy Blaney, speaking for Deputy Haughey here, and also Deputy Haughey's own statement, very categorically denied that they knew anything about the importation of arms into the country. These are not frivolous matters that can be shrugged off. As somebody said here in the past few days, the gun can be used only to take a life and once a life is taken it can never be restored. Anybody who takes the responsibility of buying guns and giving them to impressionable young people will have a lot to answer for. They will answer for it to the Irish people and not in this House. The other matter the Taoiseach should clear up when he comes to reply is the statement by Captain Kelly in relation to the Minister for Defence, Deputy J. Gibbons. I was amazed that Deputy Loughnane made a joke about Captain Kelly. This situation is far too serious for that.
Comment on this
He must be a very miserable, unhappy man now. I must say I believed Deputy J. Gibbons last night and thought that what he said sounded true. But the spontaneity and the quality of Captain Kelly's denial of that makes me wonder. The Taoiseach has an obligation to this House and to this country to answer and adjudicate on them.
Before I conclude I want to refer to the leading article in this morning's Cork Examiner which I think reasonably sums up the attitude of the people in this country at present:
In the present situation, it behoves everyone to speak and to act with not a little restraint. There are enough wild rumours and half truths circulating already, and emotional outbursts will not help. But in spite of this, there are still things which must be said, and actions which must be taken. There are fresh allegations of widespread intrigue which must be either substantiated or obliterated, and in this regard it must be felt that the Government will have to be much more forthcoming than it has been.
If the Government are to be forthcoming, this is the place and now is the time.
Comment on this
A great Longford man, Richard Lovell Edgeworth, declared over 150 years ago that to speak the truth without harshness is the most certain way to succeed in every honourable pursuit. This I shall now proceed to do. The truth which can no longer be concealed from the Irish people is that, to-night as we sit here doing the nation's work, we are faced with a grave national crisis. The Government say we do not face a grave national crisis, but read the newspapers. Let the Government read today's Irish Press—the paper which has as its motto “Truth in the News”. What do we find? In large type we find the words “Confusion rises in crisis”; “Cabinet changes overshadowed”; “Night of the Dark Knives”; “Plot to kill the Taoiseach”. I am only quoting headlines from today's Irish Press. I am not commenting on them. I mention them just to show that we do face a crisis or else this paper is not telling the truth. If Government Deputies regard the Irish Press as their gospel, then they must believe what is printed on its pages. It goes further and states that the Government are in serious trouble. The present Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch, has always been looked upon as a decent man. But to be decent is not a sufficient qualification for every job, and especially for the job of being leader of the Fianna Fáil Party or Taoiseach. It is essential to have the right man in the position of Taoiseach so crucial is his job for the welfare of all the people of Ireland.
We all know that the present Taoiseach is Taoiseach by accident—an agreed result between two or three warring factions in the Fianna Fáil Party. No one of them would accept the leadership of anyone else. Unfortunately, in Fianna Fáil, the maintenance of party unity is their supreme objective, no matter what the national cost. Unfortunately, that is the position which so many of us witnessed to our chagrin —others perhaps to their horror—on Wednesday night last. What is now clear is that the war between the factions did not end with the election of Deputy Jack Lynch as Taoiseach. The price he is paying today for providing the smooth, Fianna Fáil facade is that, behind that facade, these factions did what they liked and disregarded the well-intentioned private and even public advice of the Taoiseach to his Ministers.
No one of the Taoiseach's predecessors would have allowed the present disorder and disunity to develop in the country. They would have nipped it in the bud as the present Taoiseach should have done six months ago or, perhaps, even further back than that if he had been master of his job. It has been said that Seán Lemass fears that history's verdict on his career will be that it will be said Lemass led on all right but that he led on to Lynch.
This is a very sad day for each one of us who holds responsibility as a Deputy in this Parliament. Thank God, we have a responsible Opposition who have always put country before party as, indeed, Fianna Fáil should have done. Let us compare the attitude of Fianna Fáil with the attitude of our Leader, Deputy Liam Cosgrave, son of the late Mr. W.T. Cosgrave, the man who helped in dark and evil days to build up this country. I do not wish to refer to the harsh words that were said here this morning. Perhaps they are better forgotten, and at the moment it is better that we think of the future of each one of us.
When Deputy Liam Cosgrave received the information about this plot for the importation of illegal arms, he could have come into the House and disclosed that information. If he had done this, his action, without doubt, would have brought down this Government; but then, perhaps, there might have been other dangers for the nation. There might have been a danger of civil war, but he was prepared to put country before party.
When there were subversive elements in this country threatening the lives of our people, when there was warfare on our brothers and sisters in Northern Ireland in 1956 and 1957, I, as a member of Westmeath County Council, where Fianna Fáil had a majority, remember the resolutions of sympathy that were passed encouraging those people using the gun, telling them they were right and that the only way to take the Border at that time was by armed rebellion. If anybody wishes to deny, I would refer him to the newspapers of the time for confirmation of what I am saying. At the Westmeath Convention of Fianna Fáil at that time a resolution was passed stating that the only way to get the north was by armed rebellion. That convention was presided over by the then Minister for Local Government, Deputy Paddy Smith, and, in all fairness to him, he advised the delegates not to pass that resolution, but they did so.
We hear talk about the great Republican Party who, for many years, had the word "Republican" in brackets. During the time to which I am referring the much maligned inter-Party Government were in power. That Government, of course, were led by Mr. J.A. Costello at that time when men of all parties came together, sat around a table and worked together for the good of the country. The only aim of the Fianna Fáil Party at that time was to put the inter-Party Government out of office as quickly as possible so that they could regain power themselves.
I will admit that by their supporting the subversive elements of that time they were helped in getting back to power, and I wish to go on record as saying that the responsible Opposition today did not behave in the irresponsible way in which Fianna Fáil behaved during those inter-Party Government years. Fianna Fáil have always put party before country.
In relation to the present unfortunate crisis I want to say that on the 5th of May our leader, Deputy Cosgrave, acting in the national interests, deemed it his duty to go in private to the Taoiseach with certain information he had which was of such importance—it was without parallel in the history of the State—that it could have brought down this Government if it had been mentioned in the House in the first place. The House already knows from the list given to Deputy Cosgrave of the Departments that were involved. These were the Department of Finance, Department of Defence and others. Two hours later on that evening two Ministers had been asked to resign but had refused and the third had handed in his resignation.
So began the crisis which is still with us and which, unfortunately, seems to be growing in intensity. It is only natural that we should ask, if the Taoiseach had not been pressurised by Deputy Cosgrave, whether he would have taken the action he did because at column 642 of the Official Report of 6th May, 1970, the Taoiseach is reported as stating:
On 22nd April, the day I decided to interview the former Ministers, I received news of the accident to Deputy Haughey and, as a result, I was unable to interview him.
What was to stop the Taoiseach from interviewing the then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries on that day? Here was a man being paid by the State and enjoying the facility of a State car while engaged in the importation of arms into the country. He was engaged in importing ten tons of small arms which, we are told, would cost about £80,000, arms that could easily have started a civil war which could only lead to the annihilation of perhaps thousands of our brothers and sisters on this side of the Border as well as on the other side.
None of us would ever want to see a civil war in any part of our country. Since the foundation of the State we have believed and we still believe in peaceful means to end the unnatural Border which politicians on all sides of the House long to see abolished. We believe that the Treaty could have been used as a stepping-stone to achieve that freedom. The Taoiseach should tell us why from the 22nd to the 29th he did not interview Deputy Blaney. I admit he had good reason for not interviewing Deputy Haughey. The Taoiseach goes on later in the same column to say:
I felt it was my duty to request their resignations as members of the Government. Each of them denied he instigated in any way the attempted importation of arms. They asked me for time to consider their position. I agreed to do so.
How did it happen that the two were exactly of one word? One was in hospital and the other I think he brought to his room and both of them said: "I deny having anything to do with the illegal importation of arms but I would like time to consider my position". He goes on then and we know that he refused to take any action until Deputy Cosgrave went with the information that he had and the Taoiseach then, knowing that the game was up, immediately took action. Again, lo and behold, the twins are both of one word: "each of them told me that he would not give me his resignation until this morning". How were both of them of one word again? We are entitled to know from the Taoiseach whether he is telling us the truth. Unfortunately, we have heard so many half-truths from the Taoiseach, from Ministers of State, one saying one thing, another something else, that I do not think any reasonable man could believe any of them now but I do think that the people are entitled to the truth and the whole truth from the Taoiseach when he replies here tonight.
I am inclined to think that the Taoiseach was out to pull a fast one and he failed to get away with it this time. He says Deputy Ó Móráin his resignation. Deputy Boland, who was one of his right hand men up to last Tuesday, said Deputy Ó Móráin was pressurised and had to hand in his resignation. Now whom do we believe? Do we believe the Taoiseach or do we believe Deputy Boland? Seventeen of the Fianna Fáil Party clapped Deputy Boland so they must think he was right and at the same time many of them clapped the Taoiseach. We are entitled to know who is telling the truth.
We know that on Tuesday the Fianna Fáil Whip, Deputy O'Malley, got in touch with our Whip at least twice or three times and I think the Taoiseach's office was also in contact with Deputy Cosgrave. They wanted to put on the Order Paper for that day the nomination of Deputy O'Malley as Minister for Justice. We believe that the Taoiseach hoped to make Deputy Ó Móráin the scapegoat and had we agreed to that on that day as far as the Taoiseach was concerned the whole matter was closed, but Deputy Cosgrave with the information that he had did not agree and when he asked the Taoiseach on that evening was this the tip of the iceberg, were other Ministers to resign, the Taoiseach, who is supposed to be Honest Jack and a decent man who tells the truth, asked him what he was talking about. He pretended he did not know at the time. A man in the position of Taoiseach should tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth especially in Parliament. We also know—the plot now seems to be unravelling—and realise why the Taoiseach and the Fianna Fáil Party moved the writ for the Longford-Westmeath by-election before Deputy P.J. Lenihan was one week in his grave. It was because the Taoiseach had the information. He was afraid the bubble would burst if the by-election was held at the normal time which would be about now and he knew that they would certainly lose the by-election then, they have lost it since, as they would lose the general election if they faced the people of this country now.
The explanation the Taoiseach offered to the Dáil on Wednesday evening was so incomplete and superficial that I do not think even schoolchildren would believe him. Here were Ministers of State appointed by the Taoiseach who refused to hand in their seals of office. One of them told reporters the other day that he was not handing it in and he did not believe he would ever hand it in. We had the Taoiseach going down to a dinner in Laois and describing his colleagues, whom he had thrown out of the Cabinet barely 12 hours before, as able, brilliant and dedicated men. There is not a word about their being trustworthy. How could the Taoiseach describe those men as being able, brilliant and dedicated?
Comment on this
How can they be described as dedicated men? What were they dedicated to? Were they dedicated to work in the interests of the Irish people?
Comment on this
Were they so brilliant that they were able to fool him, to draw the people's money as Ministers of State while at the same time trying to usurp the functions of the State? Do you call men who behave in that way able, brilliant and dedicated? Were they dedicated to bringing arms in here, to starting a civil war, to drawing the people's money and, at the same time, engaging in those subversive activities? I do not know who the Taoiseach is fooling but it is surprising to find a Taoiseach kicking men out of his Cabinet and at a dinner less than 12 hours later saying they were able, brilliant and dedicated.
Comment on this
Deputy Lalor said it was heartbreaking for him to lose three of his colleagues. How could it be heart-breaking for any man to lose three colleagues if they had behaved as we were told they behaved by the Taoiseach? There is not a word about being heart-broken for the Irish people whom they had been fooling for so long. We should like to know what exactly is happening because at 11.55 on Friday, 8th May, having swept the ground from under the Taoiseach, Deputy Boland walked up to the Lobby and was joined by Deputy Blaney. Then Deputy Dr. Hillery went up, put his arms around the two of them, and they walked out arm in arm. I cannot understand, if Ministers betrayed the trust reposed in them, betrayed the trust of their own Taoiseach, betrayed the trust of their own colleagues, betrayed the trust of this Parliament and betrayed the trust of the Irish people, how the Taoiseach and other Ministers can still fraternise with them and call them able, dedicated and brilliant men.
We are still entitled to ask how many other Ministers are mixed up in this sordid affair. Somebody else mentioned Captain Kelly who was asked to resign from the Army. If Captain Kelly broke the laws of this country he should be prosecuted. If he has not, and if he was working, as he said he was, at the request of Deputy Gibbons, the Minister for Defence, then that Minister should be punished. I want to quote from today's Irish Times, where it says that Mr. Kelly stated:
I met Mr. Gibbons in his office in Leinster House as recently as Wednesday night, April 29th, and discussed the situation with him as it then existed. We parted on amiable terms. Mr. Gibbons had indicated on several occasions that I was doing an excellent job for the country as an intelligence officer.
He further goes on to state:
When I was arrested by the Special Branch on last Friday morning, I claimed privilege and asked that Mr. Gibbons be called. He came to the office of Chief Superintendent Fleming of the Special Branch, where we had a conversation in the presence of Superintendent Fleming. Mr. Gibbons's advice to me was to tell everything I knew concerning my activities as an intelligence officer. In the event, I rejected this advice because of the implications involved.
We are entitled to know what implications were involved. We are entitled to know, and this House is entitled to know, if Deputy Gibbons was mixed up with him. If he was fired, was it right to fire him? If he was fired, should he be prosecuted? If Deputy Gibbons was mixed up in any sordid affair with him, should Deputy Gibbons not be expelled from the Cabinet or asked to resign along with Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey? The Irish people are entitled at this moment to know where they stand because there are so many rumours floating about that nobody knows where he stands.
Mr. Kelly went on to state:
It was then suggested that I speak to the Taoiseach. I did so.
The Taoiseach appeared here twice last week and spoke but he did not take the House into his confidence. He did not tell the Irish people that on the 29th April he met Mr. Kelly, a man who was immediately afterwards dismissed from the armed services of this nation and brought to the Bridewell for questioning. It is the duty of the Taoiseach, and it was his duty last week, to come into this House and tell us the truth about this matter. Was this to be hidden and kept from the people of Ireland? Was it to be hidden and kept from Parliament? If Mr. Kelly did not speak out his mind last night, would this also be swept under the carpet? The people of Ireland are entitled to know the truth about this affair. The three men met. We are entitled to know what happened. We are entitled to know on whose instructions ex-Captain Kelly was working. The Taoiseach should certainly come into this House and give the full truth to the people of this country.
In today's Irish Times there is an article headed “Allegation on Army offer on North by Gibbons”. It states:
The Minister for Defence, Mr. Gibbons, who has been nominated as Minister for Agriculture, was alleged yesterday to have given an assurance to a deputation of Belfast Republicans that the Army was now prepared, if there was a repetition of last August's events in Belfast and Derry.
It goes on to state:
Mr. William Kelly, the chairman of the Citizens' Defence Committee of Patrick's Parish in Belfast, said that the four-hour meeting had taken place at Leinster House about a month ago. Mr. Kelly told a press conference that he and the deputation had also met Mr. Blaney and Mr. Haughey, as well as the Taoiseach, Mr. Lynch. "Mr. Lynch asked me not to give any publicity to the press", he added.
Now we have Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney who have both been asked to resign from the Cabinet; we have Deputy Gibbons and we have the Taoiseach connected with this matter. The Taoiseach asked Mr. Kelly not to give any evidence to the press.
God knows who is mixed up in this. Is the Taoiseach himself mixed up in it? If he is not, then it is his duty to come into this House, contradict this article and say this meeting never took place. It was the Taoiseach's duty to tell us the full story about this matter the other day. There is no use coming in and telling us those things when he is found out, then trying to find a way out. If he met those people, what transpired? Was everything above board? Further on in this article it is stated:
Mr. Kelly said that one of Mr. Gibbons's final assurances was that "if the worse came to the worst, there is no need to fear".
This House are entitled to an explanation. Let us put an end to the rumours that are so widespread today. Let the Taoiseach come before us and tell the people if there are any officers of the Army, any members of the Garda Síochána, any members of the Department of Justice, any members of the Department of Defence, the Minister for Defence or even the Taoiseach himself mixed up in this whole affair. It is the duty of the Taoiseach tonight to take the Irish people into his confidence and deny what is said in those articles and those rumours.
A few minutes ago somebody referred to the fact that on Wednesday evening the corridors, the bars and indeed the restaurants of Dáil Éireann were infiltrated with Tacateers. It was very disturbing for all of them to hear what the Taoiseach had to say. Some of them looked at the Opposition with arrogance, as if we had no right to criticise them. They supplied the money that put the party opposite into Government, not to govern in the interests of the plain and ordinary people of Ireland, but unfortunately— and this is something we do not like saying—they are governing and have governed in the last year or two in the interests of the speculators, in the interests of the racketeers and in the interests of the Tacateers. The whole idea now seems to be that, for the continuance of Fianna Fáil in office, they are prepared to unite to keep them there. Self-preservation seems to be their aim and to heck with the country.
The Taoiseach, at column 720 of the Official Report of 6th May, 1970, when he was speaking about the removal from office of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney, said:
I took these actions in circumstances where I felt, as I said at the outset, even the slightest suspicion might attach to a member of the Government.
As far as the Minister for Defence, the designate Minister for Agriculture, is concerned there does seem to be more than the slightest suspicion attached to him and it is the duty of the Taoiseach to prove to the House that he is innocent. The Taoiseach should come to this Parliament and, in the national interest, tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Four Ministers are no longer in his Cabinet and we are entitled to know where the Taoiseach stands and where the country stands.
There are many questions which need an answer. Many contradictions are evident; so far as the Taoiseach is concerned the credibility gap is growing and we seem to be going from crisis to crisis. We are entitled to ask: can the Taoiseach place any trust in the vote of confidence he got from his party? If he could not trust his Ministers who received their seals of office from the President, after taking an oath to serve this country conscientiously and loyally, how can he trust the same men in the back benches and how can he be confident that they will support him?
It is well-known that on Wednesday Deputy Boland, Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey were in the precincts of this House, surrounded by television cameras. They were going among their friends trying to get all the support they could and when they found they could not get this support they went into the party meeting and behaved like the accused people we frequently see pictured at trials in Moscow, Czechoslovakia or similar countries.
We are entitled to ask did those able, clever, dedicated men—to use the Taoiseach's own words—not say "If we can't win tonight, let us go peacefully inside and pretend we are united behind the Taoiseach"?
Did they not perhaps plan that when they were inside the party they would use their talent and power and dedication, to whatever they were dedicated, to oust the Taoiseach and to come back to power in a short time?
Comment on this
It is well known that Deputy Blaney said he was not relinquishing office and that he might never do so and we know that Deputy Haughey's parting words in the Department of Finance to the people there were "I'll be back again". People are entitled to get answers to these questions because in the midst of Fianna Fáil, keeping this Government in power, we have men who have betrayed their trust to the people. They are men who betrayed their trust to their own colleague, who betrayed their trust to the President, and who have betrayed their trust to this Parliament. We are entitled to know from the Taoiseach when he comes here tonight what kind of coalition he has got.
Comment on this
Is it not true that they are staying together because they are afraid that "if we rock the boat we will all sink; let us stay together or we will all drown together"?
Comment on this
We are also entitled to ask the Taoiseach what information he has regarding the arms. We know he said that to the best of his knowledge arms were not imported. We are entitled to ask him if it is not true that a Minister and another Member of the Oireachtas collected money in a particular county, and made speeches inciting the people to cross the Border and that the Minister or his brother actually took in arms to the Falls Road area. I am sure the Taoiseach's intelligence officers will be able to tell him that happened as far back as August and September last.
We are entitled to ask the Taoiseach what proof has he that the arms were not destined for the north. There are also many people who claim that they were for subversive elements in the 26 Counties. If that is true, then this country is facing a serious crisis. Unfortunately the Fianna Fáil Government and Party were riddled with intrigue; there were ruthless men eager for power and they were determined that if they could not overthrow their leader they would do it another way. The fact that militant Republican subversive elements were able to parade through our streets and were not arrested lends credence to this belief. It is the duty of the Taoiseach to put the public mind at ease because many people believe that some of those arms could be used in this country.
It is very interesting to hear Fianna Fáil speak about Republicanism. Do Fianna Fáil understand, with all their Republicanism, that they have thrown a liferaft to the Unionist Party who are in the same state of disarray as Fianna Fáil are in now, that they are lending credibility to the rantings of Ian Paisley instead of helping to solve the Border problem? I am afraid the conduct of those two gentlemen has set us back 20 years or more. Again, I want to ask whom are we to believe at present. I wish to quote what the Taoiseach said in volume 246 of the Official Report of 6th May, 1970.
I said at the start in my opening statement, and I repeat it now, the resignation of Deputy Ó Móráin was tendered to me on the grounds of ill health.
Again in the Official Report of 8th May, 1970, Deputy Boland stated:
If we include the new vacancy filled yesterday, it has become necessary to replace four members of the Government and I am the only one of the four who was not in one way or another overtly pushed out of Government.
Here are two contradictory statements from members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Again I quote from the Irish Times:
At last night's monthly meeting of the Shankill, Co. Dublin, Cumann of the Fianna Fáil Party a resolution was passed pledging absolute loyalty to the Taoiseach, Mr. Lynch. The resolution added: "The members look forward to all members of subversive organisations being brought to justice."
I entirely agree with the last sentiment but on another page there is a heading in respect of another Fianna Fáil Cumann: "Haughey gets vote of confidence."
How does all this tie in? I should like the Taoiseach to explain that to the House. I do not like going back and saying to the Taoiseach "I told you so", but for many months past I put down questions to the Taoiseach about the drift to anarchy. I warned the Taoiseach often enough in this House over the last year. Indeed, he was warned by Deputy Cosgrave and by myself and many others about the drift to anarchy, about the disagreement in Government and in the Cabinet in regard to the peaceful solution of the nothern question. But the Taoiseach did not heed any warnings. He continued on in his own easygoing way, allowing things to drift from bad to worse. Nothing less than a full confession will satisfy the people now. We have been told a great deal about strong Government from Fianna Fáil. They may be strong, but what we want today in Ireland is not strong Government but good Government. I wish to quote now from column 1402, volume 243, of the Official Report of the 16th December, 1969, where Deputy M. O'Leary is questioning the Taoiseach:
Is the Taoiseach aware that opposition MPs in Belfast on the Saturday of the weekend before the speech was made were aware that Deputy Blaney on Tuesday night in Letterkenny, or on whatever night he spoke there, would in fact be making a speech in which force under certain circumstances would be advocated to solve the Northern problem?
The Taoiseach stated he was not aware of the contents of the speech in advance and did not know it was being made. I know there were at least a dozen Deputies in this House who knew that speech was being made and the Taoiseach should have known also that it was being made. We have heard about collective responsibility in the past. We are entitled to ask if the Taoiseach knew what was going on under his own eyes. Did he realise the seriousness of it? Surely the Taoiseach was warned often enough about the speeches of Deputy Blaney. We had the famous Letterkenny speech. The Taoiseach is supposed to have reprimanded him and informed the House he had reprimanded him. I wish to quote from column 1404 of the same volume:
The Taoiseach: May I say, to help Deputy Corish, there is no conflict in the Cabinet with the situation and with the policy, as I have announced.
The Taoiseach said that on 16th December, after Deputy Blaney made his famous Letterkenny speech advocating force. The Taoiseach continued:
I can assure you that you people are not going to divide the Government anyway.
It was not we who divided them. It was his own members who divided them. A week after the Taoiseach had informed this House that he had reprimanded Deputy Blaney, Deputy Boland, Deputy Blaney and the Taoiseach were on the radio and Deputy Blaney said to the Taoiseach:
You did not reprimand me. You said something to me in the corridor.
The Taoiseach then said:
Neil, it was a little more than that.
There is no denying that the Taoiseach has not done his duty over the years. I should also like to bring to the Taoiseach's notice—I do not intend to read all the questions I put to him— what was said at column 12, volume 244 of the Official Report of 4th February, 1970:
Mr. L'Estrange: Is the Taoiseach aware that the Ulster Volunteer Force is arming to the teeth and that many people of repute claim that civil war is inevitable, that hate and fear are rampant, and does he not think it a good idea to point out all those things to the British Government and try to get the people to come together? Further, does the Taoiseach not believe that the speeches made by Mr. Blaney and by the hardliners at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis are also doing untold harm? Further, is the Taoiseach aware of the fact that he only reprimanded him in the corridors——
Again at column 13 the Taoiseach replied:
In the first place, in so far as Deputy L'Estrange's supplementary questions are concerned, I think the first part of Deputy L'Estrange's supplementary question is likely to do more damage than anything that has been said on either side of the border in recent months.
Now we are entitled to ask who was right when I was asking those questions. Here we had a Taoiseach who, when those questions were put to him, was not prepared to face up to his responsibility and reprimand his own Minister as he should have done. I further asked the Taoiseach at column 13:
Is the Taoiseach aware that his own Ministers and Fianna Fáil Deputies are going around to club meetings at night telling the people that they were ready to go in on 15th August——
I told the Taoiseach I could name the Ministers who were doing it and the Taoiseach said at column 14:
What the Deputy has just said is false, mischievous and highly irresponsible.
Where are the false, the mischievous, the highly irresponsible individuals? They were not on this side of the House. They were in his own party, in his own Cabinet, supposed to be his own friends. If he had heeded the warnings at that time and if he had taken the action then that he should have taken, this nation would not be in the peril it is in tonight.
I have spoken for the last six or eight months about the drift to anarchy in this country. I questioned the Minister for Justice on Guard Fallon's death. I asked him would he not agree that there is a drift towards anarchy and that the Government were not prepared to take unpopular decisions.
On April 16th—volume 245 of the Official Report—I further asked the Minister:
Is it not true that the Government are not doing their duty, that they are not giving full backing to the Garda Síochána to enforce law and order in this country? Is it not also true if the Government did their duty that unfortunate garda would not have been shot in the exercise of his duty?
Deputy Moran said:
I have nothing to add to the reply I have given to the Deputy's mischievous question, which was put down to hinder rather than to help the Garda Síochána in their work.
Here were we, members of the Opposition who were prepared to do our duty and who were prepared to try to prod the lawfully elected Government into doing their duty but they were not prepared to do it. I further went on:
Is the Minister aware that this party has stood by the forces of law and order since the institution of the State? Is the Minister further aware that, on the evening of the Wicklow bank robbery, the Garda authorities....
Is it not true that on that particular evening high-ranking gardaí asked the Minister for Justice to introduce section 30 of the Offences Against the State Act so that they could take those people in and their request was refused....
It is well known that they knew where they were at that particular time but the Government refused. If the Government had done their duty at that particular time we would not have had the unfortunate death of a guard that has since taken place.
Further, on the 16th April I questioned the Taoiseach about a case that I dealt with the other night, and I am not going to go into it at any length now. It is a case where criminals fired on the garda and were arrested and when they went to court the judge allowed them out because the doctor did not appear and only a medical certificate was produced. The Taoiseach gave an answer to that. I am still not satisfied with the answer but I suppose there is very little I can do about it. At that time, well over a month ago, I asked the Minister if he was prepared to set up an inquiry. He refused to do that.
On 23rd April—volume 245, column 1944, I asked the Minister for Justice:
Is it not true that the Government or the Minister for Justice have not, over the past year, backed up the senior Garda officers in their request to the Government to enforce law and order?
I know that that has not been done. I asked:
Is it not true that the present drift to anarchy in this country is due to the Government's neglect and to the fact that the Government have not done their duty? Will he tell me why the Taoiseach will not go on television and condemn these anarchists, the bank robbers, as he did the farmers of Ireland three years ago?
Here is the reply by a man supposed to be a responsible Minister, Deputy B. Lenihan:
In my view and I would say in the view of the Government the leading political anarchist in this country is Deputy L'Estrange.
I want to throw those words back now at Deputy Lenihan and at the Taoiseach and to tell the Taoiseach that the leading political anarchists were in his own party, in his Government, in his Cabinet and they were being sheltered by the Taoiseach and by the Minister for Justice.
We have spoken in the past at length of the splits in the Fianna Fáil Party. On 29th April—volume 246, column 259—I accused Deputy Blaney of walking out from a Government meeting because I knew it was true. Deputy Blaney said:
To put the record straight, I came out of that meeting in the same manner as I have come from every meeting in the 13 years that I have been a Member of the Government. We came out as we went in, a united Government with our leader Deputy Jack Lynch, still our leader and no question about it.
That was on the 29th April, the day the Taoiseach told us that he approached Deputy Blaney and confronted him with this serious allegation that he was engaged in gunrunning. On 29th April Deputy Blaney informed us that he and his colleagues walked out of a meeting as they had walked in, a united Government "with our leader Deputy Jack Lynch still our leader and no question about it". Who can we believe? Deputy Blaney was a Minister when he gave that information in the House and Deputy Lynch, the Taoiseach, tells us that on that particular day—and he knew for a week before it—he had asked Deputy Blaney for his resignation. Deputy Blaney went on to say:
Deputy L'Estrange and others like him who would like to start trouble over here are only codding themselves and wasting time.
He talked about splits and cracks and he said:
You will not find them over here between any Minister in the Government or between any Minister and the leader of the party, the Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch. This seems to be the position in Fine Gael at present.
I want to say that at that particular time when Deputy Blaney was making those denials in the House he himself had been asked by his Taoiseach to resign and he had asked for time. Who are we to believe? Are we to believe the statements the Taoiseach made or are we to believe the statements made by Deputy Blaney?
I think we are entitled to speak of the drift to anarchy that is in this country at the present time, the fact that in Ireland today and, indeed, for the last few years we have one law for the rich, one law for the speculators, for the racketeers and for the tacateers who are prepared to subscribe handsomely to the Fianna Fáil fund.
When the Taoiseach was speaking on the Budget he talked about the conscience of the Labour and Fine Gael Parties. Any Taoiseach who at an election meeting in Mullingar or Longford takes £100 from a tacateer who is interested in getting loans and grants from the ratepayers and taxpayers should examine his conscience before he asks members of the Labour Party or the Fine Gael Party to examine theirs. In my county I mentioned it off every platform because I think the day has come when any man no matter how wealthy he may be should not be in a position that by subscribing to the party he can get from that Government what he is not entitled to because that money belongs to the ordinary taxpayers and to the ratepayers. If a man is entitled to a loan or grant he should get it. Let it be remembered that in this city today it is a well known fact that unless you go to a Fianna Fáil solicitor, unless you go to a Fianna Fáil accountant, unless you have a Fianna Fáil TD or Senator or a friend of theirs or a sister or a brother, as director of your hotel or business, you will not get a loan or grant.
The time has come when that must stop because there is a loss of confidence and, for too long, have we had low standards in high places. The Minister-designate for Finance, Deputy Colley, certainly knew what he was talking about a few years ago down in Galway. He is a very decent man. I know nothing but good of him. If I knew anything else I would say so. I will say nothing but the truth and, if the truth hurts, it is not my fault. If people permit low standards in high places it is the duty of this House to show them the error of their ways. These people are merely the custodians of the ratepayers' and taxpayers' money. It is not theirs and they should do with it only what they would do with their own. They should use it honestly. They should cherish all the children of the nation equally, not dishing out money to those who subscribe to their own political party and ignoring others.
I have said here before, and I repeat it now, that the gardaí are frustrated in their efforts to administer the laws of this land. The vast majority of them do their duty conscientiously. They are being frustrated because, having spent time and money hunting criminals, drunken drivers and so on, they very often find that when the papers are sent to the Attorney General they are very often forgotten. If a case is so bad that political influence cannot help, there is unfortunately connivance in the courts, and very often malefactors get off on a technicality. Singer got away on a technicality. We know he paid well for it.
I will give an example of a case not far from my own county. A young man, drunk in charge of a car, killed an unfortunate man. I knew someone connected with the family and I was asked to approach the Minister for Justice. I said it was a thing I did not do, that I never brought pressure to bear on anyone but, if the person insisted, I would mention it, telling the Minister that I had been asked to do this but I was not asking him to do anything for the particular individual since I believed the law should take its course. The Minister, when I approached him, told me that there had been plenty of representation. I knew there would because the father was one of the head men in the cumann. Actually nothing could be done. The case went to trial. The witnesses were brought in. The evidence was given but nobody was called to give evidence of identification of the dead man and the moment the case for the State closed counsel for the defence got up and said: "On a point of law, your honour, the body has not been identified" and the justice said: "That is right" and the man walked out scot-free. That man could tell for months before that his case was being fixed and he would be allowed out scot-free. I know plenty of others. I mentioned them on the Vote for the Department of Justice. I put a question to the Taoiseach the other day about a particular case in my home town of Mullingar connected with people dressed in green. This is our Parliament and, if we are doing our duty, we will see to it that there is only one Army in the country, our National Army of which we are so justly proud. If the Blaneys and the Bolands and the Haugheys want a private army it is the duty of the Taoiseach to put his foot down and to ensure that there is law and order and only one Army.
Comment on this
I apologise. In this particular case these people fired live rounds of ammunition. They appeared on television. The files were sent to the Attorney General. The Garda were prepared to do their duty. The dust is still collecting on those files somewhere and not so much as an acknowledgment was made of the receipt of the files and nothing has happened since. Let us have law and order. The Taoiseach may be "Honest Jack". He may be a decent man. Many of us have mentioned these things many times and, if the Taoiseach is interested in justice, interested in seeing the laws enforced fearlessly and without regard to person, he should know that these things are happening. I am sure the Taoiseach reads "This Week". An article appeared in an edition of that magazine which states:
In January last we confessed to a suspicion that there had been political intervention in the rather remarkable judicial performance in Buncrana court.
The details are given. The State Solicitor withdrew charges against seven men of having firearms in their possession with intent to endanger life. The facts of the case, the State Solicitor said, did not sustain the requirements of the Act that there should be an immediate intent. That was something which should give immediate consolation to all those harbouring arms throughout the 26 Counties, the IRA or the UVF not to mention all the unlicensed owners of shotguns for shooting fowl and other flying objects. The men from the Bogside said they were doing a bit of training and the reason they were training was to defend their homes in case the occasion arose again. "Let them go in peace," said the State Solicitor, "and leave their firearms behind them". This would echo the sentiments of the vast majority of the people: perhaps they would undertake not to do it again. It is well known that out of the seven at least five were from the 26 Counties: some say the seven were. I cannot argue that.
Here we had men found with guns, stenguns, machine guns, ammunition et cetera and at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis immediately afterwards Donegal delegates could propose a vote of thanks to Deputy Blaney for ensuring that no Republicans from Donegal were sent to jail. Surely the Taoiseach is aware of all this and of all that is happening in the country? He should now come into the House and say that he will ensure that all Departments of State are properly run and that all sections of the people will get justice in future.
We have a right to speak out about public order. One of the founders of our party, Kevin O'Higgins, lost his life while performing nobly and fearlessly his duty as Minister for Justice. We founded the institutions of this country and we are justly proud of them. We are proud of the National Army but we believe there should be only one Army. We are proud of the Garda Síochána. We believe their strength should be increased but, above all, they should be immediately freed from political interference and allowed to do their duty and enforce law and order as it should be enforced.
Why are statements from illegal organisations permitted to be published? Why have the perpetrators of vicious crimes, arson, the killing of Garda Fallon and the robbery of nine banks, gone unpunished? When we now find two members of the Cabinet who are supposed to be enforcing law and order were engaged in importing ten tons of small arms costing £80,000, do we not realise why those people have not been apprehended in the past six or eight months? Is it not time political interference stopped and that the Taoiseach, now that he has got rid of those Ministers, should say to the police force of Ireland: "Do your duty. We, as a Government, will stand behind you and if you arrest a Fianna Fáil Deputy or a Fine Gael Deputy or any relation of theirs you will not be sent to Donegal, Kerry or somewhere else." Let the law be enforced as it should be enforced. The Taoiseach should condemn the bank robbers and the murderers of Garda Fallon. If they were thugs dressed in green, as they may have been, they were so dressed because they knew the people would talk about the Republican tradition and Fianna Fáil would see that they were not arrested.
The Taoiseach should tell those in charge of law and order that the Government is behind them 100 per cent. It is galling for some of us to find cases like that of a man and his friend who went out in a racing car travelling at 80 or 90 miles an hour, crossed the road, mowed down and killed an unfortunate child. They failed to stop. There were two passengers in the car who at the first opportunity reported this to the Garda. Those concerned denied they killed the child but the evidence was there. They were brought to court and they appealed and in the end they got out with two £2 fines. That is not the type of justice we want to see.
Many people are inclined to ask why did the Taoiseach allow this situation between himself and Deputy Blaney to go from bad to worse. Why did he allow the disagreement which existed for a long time between himself and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in regard to the Border question to continue? I refer specifically to an interview with Deputy Blaney reported in the Irish Independent of 27th March in which Deputy Blaney acclaimed the views of somebody speaking in Derry who said that if the use of arms was justified in maintaining Partition, then the people of the Six Counties could claim the right to undo it likewise.
Did the Taoiseach rebuke Deputy Blaney in public or in private for making that statement? The person in Derry to whom Deputy Blaney referred was Mr. Seán Ó Cionnaith of Sinn Féin who made that speech at Dungiven on Easter Sunday at a Republican commemoration. The Sinn Féin speech was bannerlined in the Irish Times on March 30th as a battle call by Sinn Féin which it was. Surely it was the Taoiseach's duty, if he had a Minister advocating armed intervention in the Six Counties to call him to account or, indeed, dismiss him at that time because that was the third time in five months that Deputy Blaney, to the knowledge of all of us, had publicly repudiated his own Taoiseach.
Yet the Taoiseach took no action. We are inclined to ask what price even now the Taoiseach's declaration that the Government is committed to a solely Constitutional settlement of Partition because I think Deputy Haughey, Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney are officers of the Fianna Fáil organisation. Their policy is indicated by the fact that they tried to import arms to start a civil war. What proof have we that they may not continue from inside the Fianna Fáil Party the same disruptive tactics that they have practised for the past year or so?
Comment on this
Yes, but I said "the same disruptive tactics". We are entitled to ask here the question which is being posed by many people: what effect will this crisis have on our economy? What effect will it have on the tourist industry? We have had Deputy Colley, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, travelling the world endeavouring to bring industries to this country while at the same time, according to the information we now have, we have Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey and some say Deputy Ó Móráin, biting the hand that fed them. This year we have an adverse trade balance of over £150 million. What we need is peace and prosperity.
Some of us listening to Deputy's Boland's speech yesterday were saddened because his speech tried to undermine the Taoiseach and his authority. It was an emotional appeal to the Republican traditions in the country and in the Fianna Fáil Party. It was also an emotional appeal to the subversive elements in our community. That is the unfortunate thing about it.
As I said, I should like to see in this country a Taoiseach, a Minister for Justice, an Attorney General, men who were prepared to act without fear or favour, men who were prepared to prosecute the highest in the land where they deemed it necessary. We want a Taoiseach, a Minister for Justice and an Attorney General prepared to consider the liability of Deputy Charles J. Haughey, Deputy Neil T. Blaney and Deputy Michael Moran to answer to criminal charges under the Firearms Act of 1925, the Offences Against the State Act, 1939——
Comment on this
——the liability of those persons for the alleged charges under the Defence Act, 1954, and any other relevant enactment. That is necessary
We have heard much in the past about collective responsibility. It seems now to have been turned into collective security to save the Fianna Fáil Party. If we have collective responsibility in the Government, which we are supposed to have, the Taoiseach should have known what was going on over the past year. He was told often enough. If he did not know what was going on and was not kept up to date, he was not fit to be Taoiseach. If he knew what was going on, then he should stand condemned in the dock with Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey.
It should be stated that everyone's faith in the Taoiseach is now shaken. Indeed, there is an old Chinese proverb which states that he who knows not and knows that he knows not, could be a wise man and you could follow him; he who knows not and knows not that he knows not is a fool, and you would want to be aware of him. I do not know into which category to put the Taoiseach but the people are entitled to know where they stand. The Taoiseach was given a mandate by the people who have been betrayed by the betrayers in the Cabinet. It is the Taoiseach's duty in the national interest to go before the electorate and face them in a general election. If he does that I, for one, have no doubt what the answer will be. The Taoiseach seems to be a disciple of the dictum of Lord Melbourne: Ponder, pause, prepare, postpone and end by leaving things alone; in fact, earn the people's pay by doing nothing every day, and that is what the Taoiseach has done until today.
Comment on this
I shall be very brief. As a fellow Corkman, I make a special appeal this evening to the Taoiseach to save the honour of the Irish Government and the Irish people by disclosing all the facts at his disposal and the whole truth of the crisis which has shocked this nation.
This debate, the longest in the history of this State, has been used to the full by the Fine Gael Party to demonstrate the seriousness of the situation and the terrible consequences which could result from it. For some time past, arms have been imported into this country from the Continent for the alleged purpose of re-uniting the 32 Counties by force. We in Fine Gael fully agree with the Taoiseach's view that Partition can be abolished by peaceful means only.
However, this view was not shared by all the members of his Cabinet. It now appears that the Taoiseach has been aware for some time that some members of his Cabinet, Deputy Haughey, Deputy Blaney and Deputy Ó Móráin, were involved in conspiracies to import arms illegally. The people of this country have been shocked and frightened by the immediate expulsions of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney. We now know that these expulsions were brought about by the intervention of our leader, Deputy Liam Cosgrave. The doubt about the resignation of Deputy Ó Móráin was strengthened by the expulsions. One apparent mystery led to another. At the same time, Deputy Kevin Boland resigned followed by Deputy Paudge Brennan.
People wondered if the Government were cracking up completely. People are still wondering, and they are not convinced. The security of this State, the honour of our country and the future of our country are at stake. The eyes of the world will look to the Taoiseach this evening to unravel the whole mystery. Was Deputy Gibbons involved? Did he fulfil his duty as Minister for Defence in the national interest? Is Captain Kelly's story false? Who betrayed the national interest? Were MI.5 or MI.6 responsible for uncovering this conspiracy?
The Taoiseach and I are both Corkmen representing different and opposing political interests. Our fellow Corkmen of all those interests expect him to lay the evidence on the line here this evening. The whole country awaits this speech from him tonight. Nothing short of the whole truth will satisfy the constituents of Cork city north west which we both have the honour to represent. the people of our native Cork, and the people of Ireland.
Comment on this
A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, before you call the next speaker will you take note that there are four members of the Government Party in the House and a heading on the paper today read: "Fianna Fáil Party fights for its life."
Comment on this
I am calling for a quorum.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
It is inconceivable in the history of this House and the history of this State since its inception that such an upheaval should take place involving three senior Ministers and that, so far, the Taoiseach has refused to expel them from the Fianna Fáil Party. We await his reply to this debate to-night when we shall see what the consequences will be.
Ireland to-day, because of the actions of some of our Ministers and the crass ineptitude of her Taoiseach, stands shamed and discredited in the eyes of the nations of the world. The Island of Saints and Scholars is fast becoming known as the island of gunmen and desperados because of the selfish actions of the Paisleys and the Blaneys, the Craigs and the Bolands. As a result of all that, this House has been brought to the lowest ebb it has ever reached in the past 50 years. Never, to my mind, will our former proud position be retrieved until such time as the Taoiseach takes immediate action and exposes to this House and to the Irish nation the facts behind the alleged gun-running involving some of our Ministers.
Appeals have been made from some Government Deputies to be sympathetic towards those Ministers. Personally, I would be sympathetic towards one Minister, Deputy Moran, the ex-Minister for Justice, because he is in hospital. I shall not mention his name here to-night. I believe any man in hospital should be allowed time to come back and to be present here for any accusation or attack that may be made on him. Were it not for the action of the leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Liam Cosgrave, I have my doubts that these Ministers would ever have been expelled from the Cabinet. Were it not for the confidence which senior Garda officers and senior officials in this country had in Deputy Liam Cosgrave arising out of their trust in his late father, Mr. W.T. Cosgrave and his great tradition of service to this State of which he was a founder member, we might not yet know as much as we now know. Fortunately, these senior Garda officers and senior officials knew they could turn to Deputy Cosgrave in the confident assurance that the matter would carefully be considered and dealt with. These men knew, when they approached Fine Gael, that they were not approaching gunmen or gun-runners.
We know perfectly well what gun-runners are because of what has been going on in Europe for the past four or five years. Some people have been making fortunes through the export of guns to the African States, for instance. It has occurred extensively in the whole of Africa.
This is really what is happening here. Just consider this alleged gun-running attempt here involving an Army officer and two Ministers of State. I wonder what is in the mind of the Irish people tonight on this subject while they are looking and listening here to Dáil Éireann and waiting for the report of the Taoiseach? It is not my intention to delay this House too long. I would ask these questions however: Where did the money come from? Was it patriotism or was it graft? This is the one thing that must be put before the Irish people. I have my doubts in relation to whether it was patriotism or whether it was graft. However, I shall await the Taoiseach's statement to see what action he has taken. Certainly, he would never have dismissed or expelled or asked two of his senior Ministers to resign if he had not evidence of some deep involvement.
We all remember when the former Deputy James Dillon was making his final speech in this House. I was not a Member at that time. He gave one piece of advice to every Deputy: to preserve the dignity of this House, the dignity of Ministers of State, the dignity of Parliamentary Secretaries and the dignity of every Deputy. Throughout the whole of Europe and the world the dignity of every Member of this House has been degraded as a result of this alleged conspiracy. I believe it will take years to regain the ground we have lost in this respect. There was only one way open to the Taoiseach to save this nation.
I would venture to say that 80 per cent of our population want only peaceful means employed for the solution of the problem of Partition. They stand firmly for a middle of the road approach and are not interested in extremism. They do not support any extreme element, Maoists or any other group, no matter where they come from.
We have a Christian tradition. Thank God, I have confidence in the Irish people. After his speech here to-night the Taoiseach should go immediately to the Park and seek a dissolution of Dáil Éireann and thus let the Irish people decide on this issue. I am certain I know how they would decide.
Comment on this
I came down here from Donegal at the beginning of this week to debate a Fianna Fáil Budget introduced by a Fianna Fáil Government. Were the rules of this House to permit me to dwell on the damage that Budget will do, I would tell the House that I was sent down here because there was an outcry throughout the country on account of the disorganisation of our economic position and of our financial position. I know the Chair will tell me I am out of order. Surely I am entitled to tell the House why I came down here? I came down here to tell the House that the building trade throughout rural Ireland was at a standstill as a result of the cement strike. I came down here to tell the House—were I permitted to do so— that were that strike to continue, the business of this State would be in a tragic position. I intended to tell the House that, as a result of the bank strike, the business economy of the State was practically at a standstill but no member of the Government appeared to be in the slightest way interested in stopping this rot that has set in. Unfortunately, when I got here I saw on the Order Paper the motion to appoint Deputy O'Malley as a Minister of the Government. I regret very much to have to intervene in this debate. This is not a debate on the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government; this is an impeachment of Members of that Government, and of the Government elected under the Constitution enacted by the Irish people.
It grieves me more that the people involved are and were close personal friends of mine. Deputy Blaney's father was a personal friend of mine for many years. I had great respect for Deputy Boland's father and he and I are still very good friends. Deputy Moran was a colleague of mine. We have known each other for many years and, socially, we have associated no later than the beginning of this year. As for Deputy Haughey, I was associated with him in the late 1920s when his father was proud to wear the uniform of the Irish Army.
Comment on this
I can assure the House that it gives me no pleasure to come here and endeavour to put together the puzzle we have been faced with since Tuesday last. The Taoiseach was a personal friend of mine long before he and I entered politics. He is a man for whom I had nothing but respect, as I had respect for the other members of the Government. If each or all of these men gave me their word I would accept it. It was in that spirit, then, that I came in here on Wednesday last. I was surprised that, when the motion was moved, there appeared to be a reluctance to grant the motion to the Government. I did not know why. I was told that Deputy Moran was sick and that as a result of his illness he had retired from Government. I accepted that. I was told that the Taoiseach was anxious to appoint a successor. Therefore, I could not understand the reluctance of the Opposition Parties to grant the motion. However, when I got my daily papers next morning, to my shock and surprise I read not of the resignation but of the dismissal of two Ministers of the Government. I read the allegations made against them as to why they were dismissed. I read also that one of their colleagues, against whom no charge was made, had resigned in support of them. This was unbelievable.
I came to the House and was horrified while listening to the Taoiseach's speech. The Taoiseach told us that their names had been impeached in some way or other. He did not tell us there was a case against them. He is a lawyer, and a very good one, but he told us that the evidence which he procured established a prima facie case against them. Any lawyer in this House knows that when there is a prima facie case against an accused or an alleged accused he must then go forward for trial and the onus is on the State to prove him guilty, not on him to prove himself innocent. The Taoiseach told us that this prima facie case was there. I decided that it would not be fair to interfere in the debate.
Deputies who are also lawyers, such as Deputy de Valera, are well aware that when a prima facie case is established it is then sub judice and should not be discussed. However, during the course of the Taoiseach's speech I discovered there was no intention to take criminal proceedings against the accused. I was horrified to think that a lawyer who was satisfied that a prima facie case had been established was prepared to let the matter drop at that and not give the accused an opportunity of putting their case before the court of the Irish people.
On Wednesday, Deputy Boland made a statement in which he said he did not believe that Deputy Moran had voluntarily resigned his office as Minister for Justice, thereby contradicting what the Taoiseach had said. He went further and told us that, for months back, his telephone and the telephone of other Ministers was being tapped. By whom were the telephones being tapped? Was it on the instructions of the President? I am satisfied that that was not so. Was it on the instructions of the Taoiseach that these Ministers had their portfolios taken away? As an ex-Minister of State I know what is collective responsibility and I know the confidence there must be between a Taoiseach and his Ministers. If that confidence is not there, the Government must fall. But, when we have an ex-Minister telling us that for months the Taoiseach's mind must have been suspicious, I ask why did the Taoiseach wait so long? At that stage there was only a suspicion that arms were involved and I cannot understand why arms should be involved. The three main Parties in this House—Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour—had enunciated the unanimous policy of all of us some months ago——
Comment on this
——and in that enunciation we ruled out force. The Civil Rights Movement in the north, led by John Hume and Ivan Cooper, told us many times that they did not want force. The Nationalist Party made a similar statement and the official Unionist Party said that they were not believers in the use of force on their side or on the side of the opposition.
Though we are unanimous that force should be ruled out, let us not forget that it was tried. Immediately before the Civil War, when the IRA after the truce had time to reorganise, time to arm and time to procure uniforms, General Frank Aiken with an Eastern Division marched north from Dundalk through Armagh. It may be history to some of you. General Seán MacEoin pushed through Cavan; General Joe Sweeney with the First Northern Division pushed into Pettigo and Peadar O'Donnell with his Brigade pushed into the Six Counties through Claggan. Here was an opportunity when the IRA or the army were united to take by force the Six Counties. I will not tell you what each of these three distinguished soldiers found. They were driven back not by the British army but by the bitter armed Specials of those days. That was our first and last attempt at force.
I do not mean to cause trouble or to open up old sores when I say that when Fianna Fáil got into office in 1932 Mr. de Valera, who was then their leader, said after a short time that he wished to give credit to the outgoing Government: that he found on taking office a well disciplined Army willing to obey the instructions of the Government of the day. There was no question of mutiny. They were willing to take from the Government and its Minister for Defence whatever instructions were issued. He found a Civil Service prepared to take the instructions of the new Government. He found the police force to which he paid tribute.
We all know of the dreadful executions of the Civil War. We all detest even the mention of them today. We know what brave men were executed. We know what brave men died on each side. We know that if executions took place the Government of the day thought it was in the best interests of establishing law and order in the State. Whether they were right or wrong that was their opinion and they were the elected Government. These unfortunate executions took place. Again in the 1930s and early 1940s the Fianna Fáil Government found that they had to take the very same action though there was not a civil war. They had to have executions and I do not blame them and I am not casting it up. These things occurred and the Fianna Fáil Government, in their wisdom, saw that it was essential to keep law and order in the State and they were right because they were the people who were elected to do it. They carried out I think between 20 and 26 executions.
Comment on this
I am not blaming them. It was their duty. They were the lawfully elected Government just as the other Government were earlier on. I have never heard since of any organised Constitutional opposition to the State until now.
Deputy Boland spoke first. He came into the House and told us he did not believe the Taoiseach when the Taoiseach said that Deputy Moran who was then sick resigned of his own volition. He said he was pushed. He said that Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney were dismissed or their resignations called for on spurious evidence. He said they refused to hand in their seals of office. Does anyone know what the handing in of a seal of office is? When one has the honour to be appointed a Minister of this State one is handed his seal by the President. He takes it in his right hand and transfers it to his left and hands it back to the President's secretary. He does not see it again and he does not even get a replica. How did they refuse to hand in their seals of office? In other words, what I think he meant was, that they refused to resign, and, therefore, the Taoiseach had no option but to dismiss them. Now here we had a conflict.
Deputy Blaney made a very moving, touching speech. When he referred to his parents I am satisfied that what he said was true. He went on to tell us here in this House that he had neither hand, act nor part in any subversive organisations and he had nothing to do with Saor Éire. We know that while the headquarters of certain illegal organisations are down here they have companies and divisions in the north, not Saor Éire. I agree with all the speakers over there that the IRA refuse to recognise Saor Éire. I believe they are, as was stated by the Minister, bank robbers climbing on the bandwagon and taking advantage of what occurred. He said he had nothing whatever to do with these subversive organisations. He went further and he said that no brother of his had any connection with any illegal operation in this country—"in this country," Deputy Blaney said: Fianna Fáil was Republican and he was born a Republican. Let us, for God's sake, forget this republicanism. In 1948 the Government decided to declare this State a Republic. We are all Republicans whether we like it or not. I remember the former Deputy Con Lehane of Clann na Poblachta from those benches saying: "Thank God we have taken the gun out of Irish politics." His view was endorsed by every side of the House.
Here we have Deputy Blaney saying that he never advocated the use of force. I will not say he did but we all remember what he said. He did go a little bit further. He said: "We cannot stand idly by while people in the north are being penalised." I thought over that. What did he mean? He said: "I was in Derry. I was in the Bogside last August and later on I was in the Falls Road" and, he said, that within the recent past he was again in the north "assisting" I think is the word he used—if it is not I withdraw it—but encouraging our people to resist attack.
I read in today's Irish Independent, on page 11, the heading: “McAteer pleads for Blaney”. Mr. McAteer was a member of the Northern Parliament for many years. He was the leader of the Nationalist Party in Parliament. He is no longer in Parliament. He was succeeded by Mr. John Hume. This is what Mr. McAteer said, bearing in mind that Deputy Blaney told us that he was in the north, both in the Bogside and in the Falls Road, last year and recently:
A plea for an end to "Blaney-bashing" was made yesterday in Derry by the Nationalist Party leader, Mr. Eddie McAteer. Mr. McAteer said: "I am not a man of war, but everyone knows there are two views on the end of Partition. One see-saws regularly from one to the other, and the rebels of today become the Government of tomorrow. There are matching examples in the Unionist world. My Party remains committed to the Lynch peace line,
It would be better if he said to the peace line of Dáil Éireann. He said: "To the Lynch peace line". He goes on further to state:
but this does not mean that we will meekly bow down like sheep for summer slaughter. The screeching doves may well remember that Neil Blaney stood beside us in our hour of need and is still willing to sacrifice a bright political future to help his fellow Ulstermen. If the midnight knock comes to our door would not the gentlest of us love the feeling of security which a pike in the thatch can give.
What is the "pike in the thatch"? Is it the pike of '98? If it is, it would not be much use against the arms borne by the Ulster Volunteers and those other organisations in the north. Is that not a method of describing a firearm? I do not know. I leave it to this House to draw the conclusion. Mr. McAteer also inferred that it was Deputy Blaney who put it there.
Yesterday and since Wednesday last there have been rumours and suggestions in the national and local papers that Deputy Blaney advocates the distribution of arms in the Six Counties. I am not saying he does, but the papers suggest he does. Deputy Blaney came in here yesterday and denied this. But tonight I read in the Evening Herald:“Bonfires blaze for Blaney”. I do not mind the people of his constituency of East Donegal blazing bonfires for him. Is it because he was dismissed from the Government? I leave that conclusion to Deputies, but I do not think it is. If it is not because he was dismissed from the Government, is it because he advocated the supply of arms to the Six Counties? I do not know. Again, I leave it to Deputies. But why do bonfires blaze on the Hills of Donegal to-night? I do not think it is because the Taoiseach has rejected him. There must be some other reason, and I respectfully suggest to you that when we read the speech which Deputy Blaney will make tonight in the Market Square in Letterkenny it will not be the denial about the supply of arms in the Six Counties that was made here. However, I do not know.
I am not going to mention Deputy Haughey because he has not been here. We sympathise with him and do not intend to criticise him in his absence. The Minister for Defence, Deputy Gibbons, was here. I am not concerned with the rumours which have been circulating. The Minister came in here and made a speech. One of the things he said was:
I have been informed that Mr. Patrick Kennedy, MP, in the course of a radio interview suggested that any participation by Captain James Kelly in an attempt to smuggle arms could only have been made with my knowledge and consent. I wish emphatically to deny any such knowledge or consent.
I did not know then who Captain Kelly was, but I know something about Army structure. I never heard of a captain reporting to a Minister unless he was his aide-de-camp. He was bound to send his report up through the line, through his next in command and so on, until it reached the top and then it was handed over to the Minister. I want you to bear with me further. The Minister went on to say:
I want to say also that in recent times I formed the opinion that Captain Kelly was becoming unsuitable for the type of work he was employed in.
How could he know, unless it was through that pipeline I have referred to, whether the man was suitable for the work? If he was unsuitable, surely he could have become what some of us would know as a foot slogger, an infantry man. They could find some other post for him. It is quite evident he was asked for his resignation, but that is not all. Later on, the Minister said:
I want to say that certain suspicions were forming in my mind.
That is evident from the result of his personal contacts with the captain, but listen to the next sentence where he says:
I was kept informed by the Director of Intelligence but nothing concrete emerged.
Here we have the Minister for Defence kept informed by the Director of Intelligence that a subordinate who had bypassed the Director of intelligence had gone direct to the Minister. There is something wrong there. I am not saying what it is. I ask the House to judge. In view of that this Captain Kelly, about whom I know nothing, immediately came on the air and this is what he said to the BBC:
Under privilege of the Dáil Mr. Gibbons has attacked me. All he has said is a tissue of lies. Any work which I did I brought to the knowledge of Mr. Gibbons at any and every opportunity.
Why should he bring this information to the Minister over the head of the Director of Intelligence? He went further and said "He is completely aware of anything I did prior to my leaving the Army on May 1st." I am leaving it to the House to judge; but in my opinion there is something peculiar about a junior officer going over the head of the Director of Intelligence, making contact with the Minister and keeping the Minister informed when, at the same time, there is no mention of the information he has given to the Director of Intelligence.
He goes on to say "When I was arrested by the Special Branch I claimed privilege". I think he was right, but who did he ask for? Not for his superior officer, but for the Minister. The Minister called to see him at the police barracks. We are next told "Mr. Gibbons advised me to tell everything I knew concerning my work as an intelligence officer. I rejected this advice because of the implications involved".
We are then told "It was suggested that I speak to the Taoiseach, which I did". Why should a subordinate officer speak to the Taoiseach when he could have gone to his Director of Intelligence or to the legal advisers in the Army? He goes further and tells us "In my hearing, Mr. Gibbons before leaving the office indicated that I was a competent and respected officer and that I should be treated as such." The office in this case was the police barracks. According to Captain Kelly, Deputy Gibbons indicated that in the presence of a senior officer of the Garda, a Chief Superintendent Fleming.
He goes on to speak of Deputy Gibbons and, let us remember, he is speaking of a Minister whose confidence he had and whom he contacted over the head of his Director of Intelligence. He said "That man is an unmitigated scoundrel and I say this not under any privilege of Dáil Éireann". Were I a Minister of State and if a civil servant said that of me.
I would see that he was sued for slander or libel or both. We have not seen the Minister for Defence and we do not know what happened. I am not drawing any conclusions but I am asking this House to draw its own conclusions about what happened. I do not know if all this is true or not; if it is true well and good, and if it is a lie it can be denied and I shall accept the denial.
I do not know if it is true that Deputy Blaney found alternative employment in his Department for this man but it will be easy to check. However, a peculiar coincidence occurred last night. A photograph appeared in the Evening Press last night showing Captain Kelly, his legal adviser and another gentleman, Mr. Séamus Brady. Mr. Brady is a clever journalist. We all know that all Ministers, from the Taoiseach down, have scriptwriters. It is suggested that here we might find the Minister's scriptwriter. When Captain Kelly made his statement he used the expression “an unmitigated scoundrel”. I never heard an Army officer use language such as this. I know language which Army personnel would use to convey the same meaning, but I could never imagine the use of words such as those ascribed to Captain Kelly. I shall leave it to the House to make up its mind if the phrase was suggested by a scriptwriter. Was it a mere coincidence that that scriptwriter should be there when that interview was given to the BBC? Again, I do not know.
I have spoken for much longer than I had intended. This debate will do good down here, but it will do much harm in the north. In the north we had civil rights groups of all religions coming together. As a result of this debate what I may describe as the Unionists have become more united and we have gone away from the position we were in eight or nine months ago. I pose this question to-night to the Taoiseach, one of the oldest questions in Christendom: Quo Vadis?
Comment on this
I want to add my protest to that of other speakers who have condemned the tragic situation in which we find ourselves today. We are in this crisis because of the treachery of those appointed by the Taoiseach to look after the interests of the Irish people. These Ministers are the servants of the people and are not their masters, as would appear from events of the last week. Untold damage has been caused to the whole fabric of the institutions of this State, and to our image throughout the world, by these events. By their actions these former Ministers have betrayed the high office entrusted to them by the people and the people are entitled to ask what action will be taken to bring them to justice. The people cannot realise why the Taoiseach, who stated he had a prima facie case against the former Ministers, still accepts their votes in this House. The Taoiseach is failing in his duty to this House and to the people if he continues to accept that support. The Fianna Fáil whip should be withdrawn from them.
Respect for law and order in this country is in great danger should the Attorney General not treat the actions of these people with the gravity and urgency they deserve. The Taoiseach should without hesitation set up a public inquiry into the events of last week and the events which led up to them. There was a very comprehensive inquiry carried out recently into a "Seven Days" programme. If it was necessary in that case is it not all the more reason why we should have a thorough inquiry into this matter? The law must be administered equally for all sections of the community. The ordinary upright citizen is convinced that should he be involved or suspected of being involved in activity of this nature he would be quickly and firmly removed to the Bridewell and would not be given bail. It appears there is one law for the citizens of this State and another law for high-ranking Fianna Fáil people. I ask the Taoiseach to spell out in his reply the action he or the Attorney General intends to take against these people.
I mentioned earlier that the image of our country is seriously impaired by the happenings of last week. We were held in high esteem and respect by the people of the world as a country of proven democratic principles. In the sixties we were accepted as a respected and utterly reliable country in the United Nations Council. Our ambassadors and other people who went to Nigeria during very troubled and difficult times were treated with the utmost respect and dignity. Our fight for freedom and our democratic institutions were held up as an example to the people of India. The Zambian Government sent her young soldiers to our country to be trained by our Army personnel.
This situation was brought about by the actions of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Boland who betrayed their own leader and their own people. Many doubts and question marks have been created in the minds of the people. In recent times there have been a number of bank raids carried out openly and daringly, and the culprits have not been brought to justice. Unfortunately in one of these bank raids Garda Fallon lost his life protecting the property and the lives of the people. This is not a densely populated country where people will get lost in large centres of population. Rumours circulate which undermine the confidence of the people in the forces of justice. Therefore we must have a clear statement on these matters.
Another question mark in the people's minds is in regard to authorisation given by the Department of Finance for the clearance through customs of guns which would put the lives of our people north and south of the Border in peril. This situation has created very serious misgivings in the minds of the people. The question the people ask themselves is: if clearance was being given for illegal importation what other authorisations or permits were or could be granted to people whom the Minister would want to facilitate? This situation has left a cloud over every Department.
Another question concerns the resignation of Deputy Moran, ex-Minister for Justice. Deputy Boland is adamant that Deputy Moran was sacked. The Taoiseach told the House on Tuesday last that he resigned for health reasons. There were also charges of phone-tapping and of Gestapo methods being used by the Taoiseach against members of his Cabinet. These charges were made by Deputy Boland against the Taoiseach. There is a grave accusation that the Taoiseach did not trust the Cabinet and had to employ extreme measures of this nature to spy on them. When did this phone-tapping commence? What information had the Taoiseach received to make him take this decision? What information did he gain from this phone-tapping?
The Taoiseach alleges in relation to the dismissal of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney that he had asked for the resignation of Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney before Deputy Cosgrave went to him on Tuesday night. At 4 p.m. on Tuesday the Taoiseach announced for the information of this House that Deputy Michael Moran had tendered his resignation as Minister for Justice on the previous day. Deputy Cosgrave then asked the Taoiseach could he say if this was the only Ministerial resignation we could expect. The Taoiseach replied: "I do not know what the Deputy is referring to". Deputy Cosgrave asked if it was only the tip of the iceberg. The Taoiseach then inquired whether Deputy Cosgrave would like to enlarge on what he had in mind.
At 8 p.m. that night Deputy Cosgrave went to the Taoiseach in his office and told him of the information he had received. Within a few hours two Ministers had been sacked from the Cabinet and another had resigned. This to me is a clear indication that had Deputy Cosgrave not given this information there would have been no action in this matter. I would ask the Taoiseach to open the book and give the people the full information to which they are entitled in relation to these matters.
Comment on this
I do not intend to speak for very long as at this stage of the debate it is very difficult to find anything original to say but, because of the seriousness of the situation, every Deputy has something to offer to the debate.
The motion before the House is asking the Dáil to approve of the appointment of three new Ministers to the Government. We are asked to approve of the appointment of Deputy Molloy as Minister for Local Government. I should like to know from Deputy Molloy and from the Taoiseach, are we going to have the same policy and the same problems as we had when Deputy Boland was Minister? What will the attitude be to the housing situation? There are many questions left unanswered and a cloud of mystery has surrounded the debate for the past few days.
It is extraordinary to go back over the past eight or nine years to study the policies adopted by Fianna Fáil towards agriculture. We are asked to approve of the appointment of Deputy James Gibbons as Minister for Agriculture. My immediate assessment is that whoever will be appointed could not be any worse than Deputy Blaney. In view of the many problems confronting the agricultural community at the present time, we need a clearcut statement from the new Minister for Agriculture as to what the policy will be in relation to our entry to the Common Market. In relation to the appointment of Deputy James Gibbons as Minister for Agriculture the Taoiseach tonight in his reply will have to state clearly Deputy Gibbons's position in relation to the accusations made against him in the past few days. The dignity and honour of the House are at stake because of the attitude of the Taoiseach and of some of his Ministers over the past few weeks.
Having been back in my constituency in Mid-Cork since we heard about these three Ministers I can say that there are so many conflicting reports and rumours in this House and outside it that the Taoiseach must state clearly tonight what is his position in relation to the new Cabinet. Are we going to have further resignations? It is strongly rumoured around this House tonight that as soon as the approval is given and the House adjourns the new Minister for Agriculture will hand in his resignation as a result of the conflict between himself and Captain Kelly over the past few days.
The Ministers in question did in fact make a determined effort to undermine the security of the State. As far as the Minister for Defence, the proposed Minister for Agriculture, Deputy James Gibbons, is concerned, we are informed by the Taoiseach that an effort was made to import arms illegally into this country under the guise of being for the Department of Defence. This is something that in relation to the Minister for Defence must be answered. The questions that are asked by the people outside this House must be answered. It is asked, if they were illegally imported under the guise of being for the Department of Defence, was the Minister for Defence aware of this? If he was aware of this, there is no place for him in any new Government. If he was not aware of it, he is not capable of holding a Ministry in a new Government because he was not on top of his job.
These are the questions that must be answered by the Taoiseach here to-night. The country is shocked and stunned into silence by the news of illegal importation of arms and a threat to the security and the livelihood of our people in the Twenty-Six Counties and in the six north eastern counties.
I have been in this House since 1965. The strangest thing that has occurred in that time here was Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland speaking from the back benches of the Fianna Fáil side of the House, pledging their support and loyalty to the Fianna Fáil Taoiseach, to the Fianna Fáil policy in relation to the reunification of the country and, at the same time in their respective constituencies, organising protest marches and meetings and cavalcades of cars in order to protest against the Taoiseach's action in dismissing them. Surely there is no consistency in this?
We were told here in recent months how united the Fianna Fáil Government were, how united the Fianna Fáil Party were. We heard about collective responsibility. Surely all the statements made by the Taoiseach in this House in the past few days are only fairy tales, not accepted by any reasonably-minded person either inside or outside the House?
I regard as a very important aspect of this matter the first resignation which we were asked to approve of here, the resignation of the former Minister for Justice, Micheál Ó Móráin. If the former Minister is ill or in poor health I sincerely wish him a full recovery as soon as possible but the whole question of his resignation is suspect. I listened to the new Minister for Justice being interviewed on the day the critical meeting of the Fianna Fáil Party was held on the issue as to whether they would support the Taoiseach or support those who were aspiring to leadership. Deputy O'Malley, the new Minister for Justice, was asked if he expected a full attendance of Fianna Fáil Deputies at this meeting and the answer was, "Yes, certainly, we will have a full attendance apart from the Minister for Lands who is abroad and may not get to the meeting in time". When asked if he was expecting that Deputy Michael Moran would attend the meeting, the answer was: "Certainly, yes."
Now, on the following day the Taoiseach came in here at ten o'clock at night and he said he wanted to make it quite clear that, as far as the ex-Minister for Justice was concerned, he had handed in his resignation on health grounds. Then we had Deputy Kevin Boland coming in here yesterday and saying that the ex-Minister for Justice was asked to hand in his resignation.
These are the conflicts that must be resolved. These are the points that must be clarified by the Taoiseach. These are the points that are causing confusion, concern and anxiety. Whether the Taoiseach himself is or is not involved, I appeal to him to come clean and make the truth known. There are too many conflicting rumours. There are too many conflicting statements from the Taoiseach and from those who have pledged loyalty to him within the past few days, Deputy Boland, Deputy Blaney and Deputy Brennan.
Last week, on the Budget debate here, we were told by Deputies on the opposite benches about the collective responsibility within the Fianna Fáil Cabinet. Reading last Wednesday morning about the Taoiseach sacking two of his most important Ministers, the first thing one asked oneself was how near were we to an even much more serious situation than we are in at present? What I am mainly concerned about is the attitude of people who are inclined to revolt against authority. There is a growing tendency here amongst certain sections of our community to revolt against authority and that is one of the reasons why I think it is so necessary for the Taoiseach to make clear to this House, and through this House, to the people the true position as far as the ex-Minister for Justice is concerned.
I know it to be true that the whole question of the administration of justice is suspect at the moment. That has been mentioned here time and again on this side of the House. It has been raised by way of Parliamentary question and by way of debate. Even though the Fianna Fáil Party are heading towards the rocks now, justice must be administered. In my opinion the Taoiseach has no choice but to dissolve this Dáil and go to the country. I was amazed on Thursday morning last at the obvious rallying of the clan in the corridors of Leinster House, the Taca men who came from as far away as Cork to lend moral support to the Taoiseach when the whole future of the Fianna Fáil Party was in jeopardy.
Comment on this
One must give them credit. This morning one finds one of the Taca kings in this city engaged in writing to cumainn and to supporters all over the country asking are they for or against Jack Lynch. Everyone in this House knows perfectly well to whom I am referring. Only yesterday morning I had a discussion with a strong Fianna Fáil supporter in my own constituency, an active worker in the last general election, and when he asked for my opinion my answer was: "We have been telling you this for years" and his reply was: "We are disgraced". That is the view of the decent element of the Fianna Fáil supporters throughout the country. Fianna Fáil got a mandate from the people to govern in the last general election and they were never so strong as they are in this Dáil and, if ever there was an example of power corrupting and absolute power corrupting absolutely, this is a classic example of it.
Comment on this
We told the people not in the last general election, but in the election before that, and the election before that again, that the Fianna Fáil Party had such a lust for power and were so anxious to remain in office at all costs that they were highly dangerous. I would advise the Taoiseach now not to underestimate the organising ability of Deputy Neil T. Blaney, Deputy Kevin Boland and Deputy Charles Haughey. If he remains as head of the Government his life as leader of this Government will be made impossible. We have so many anarchists, so many subversive organisations that it is even frightening to think about them. If there was trouble in the six north eastern counties, which is quite possible, think for a moment of the people who are now lined up in Donegal and in Dublin in the constituencies of Deputy Kevin Boland and Deputy Charles Haughey. These people are doing untold damage to the civil rights movement in the north because of their attitude in regard to the reunification of this country. There is only one man who is pleased with this. He is delighted with Deputy Kevin Boland, Deputy Neil Blaney and Deputy Charles Haughey. He is the Rev. Ian Paisley.
Comment on this
This strengthens his position and makes impossible the position of the minority. The attitude adopted by the ex-Ministers was reckless and irresponsible. I appeal to the Taoiseach to make a clear statement tonight, to answer the questions that are unanswered, resolve the doubts in people's minds about the resignation of Deputy Michael Moran, about the allegations made by Captain Kelly against Deputy Gibbons, Minister for Defence, because these are the things which are causing anxiety.
Comment on this
I do not intend to delay the House by speaking at length on this motion. I listened to various speeches made from opposite benches and I was sorry to hear some of the Fianna Fáil speakers go back to the bitterness of the Civil War 50 years ago. In this day and age we should forget that bitterness. The country does not want that wound reopened. I listened with interest to Deputy Blaney and he went back to an incident that happened to him when he was four years of age. That was over 50 years ago. It is time we forgot what happened 50 years ago and time for us to live in the present.
Listening to Deputy Blaney what struck me was that the speech he made should not have been made in this House but at the Fianna Fáil Party meeting. The Taoiseach in Volume 246, column 642 of the Official Report said:
On 22nd April, the day I decided to interview the former Ministers, I received news of the accident to Deputy Haughey and, as a result, I was unable to interview him.
He went on to state:
However, I ultimately got the doctor's permission and I decided to interview Deputy Haughey in hospital on Wednesday, 29th April. Having made that decision and before I went to the hospital, I then summoned Deputy Blaney to my room and interviewed him, upon which I went to the hospital and interviewed Deputy Haughey.
The Taoiseach should tell us why he waited from 22nd April to 29th April. I can understand him waiting in the case of Deputy Haughey but there is no excuse for the delay in seeing Deputy Blaney. If we move on to the 5th May, the Taoiseach was then asked by Deputy Cosgrave:
Are there going to be other Ministerial resignations?
and the Taoiseach replied:
I do not know what the Deputy is referring to.
Deputy Cosgrave then went on to say:
Is this the tip of the iceberg?
Later that evening at 8 o'clock Deputy Cosgrave interviewed the Taoiseach and put certain information which he had before the Taoiseach and it was only then that the Taoiseach moved. At 10 o'clock that night three Ministers had resigned. It is perfectly obvious that if Deputy Cosgrave had not placed the information before the Taoiseach the Taoiseach was prepared to sit on this affair and let it ride the storm if that were possible. I do not think that is possible now. The people and the country want a new Government that they can stand behind. The Fianna Fáil Party are now split down the middle and have lost the confidence of the people. I call on the Taoiseach to dissolve this Dáil and go to the country——
Comment on this
——this evening. Fianna Fáil think time is on their side. That is not so. The country is aware of what has happened and wants to be rid of the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
We regret that it was necessary for us to have such a prolonged debate. We regret that the Government's decision to rush this debate through before the week-end made it necessary for us to be here for more than 24 hours. The Taoiseach originally said that he was willing to have a debate next Tuesday. We were prepared to start it yesterday and adjourn until Tuesday.
With a certain lack of logic Fianna Fáil insisted that the debate must be finished by the week-end even though originally they were quite happy to wait until Tuesday. Therefore, we had no alternative but to have the debate in this form. We were not going to be prevented from speaking our minds. Every member of the part wanted to say what he thinks of the situation and make his contribution in this crisis.
A long debate has been necessary because of the total inadequacy of the information given to us by the Taoiseach and the misleading character of that information. It was necessary also because of his trivialisation of the whole matter ending up with his remark at the end of his speech that again the country had a Government in which they could have confidence. These words rang very hollow in this House. They certainly made it necessary for us to make clear to the country that there could be no confidence in such a Government.
Let there be no criticism of this party from the Government benches because we performed our duty on this occasion. If anybody has any criticism let him think what would have happened had the boot conceivably been on the other foot and had there been in this party in Government any member capable of betraying the State. That is unthinkable. If we had faced this kind of situation and crisis what would the response have been from the other side of the House? Can anyone think it would have been the responsible response such as came from these benches? Can anyone think that in those circumstances no voice would have been raised from the other side of the House in favour of the kind of policy that would bring this country to ruin and to civil war in the months ahead? What kind of debate would there have been here if the leader of the Opposition, instead of going to the head of the Government with his information, had chosen to come into this House and catch him unawares and launch the discussion in that irresponsible way? Is that not what Fianna Fáil would have done in those circumstances? Is it not more likely that they would have adopted that tactic? We acted responsibly.
Comment on this
It was incredible to hear from the Government side of the House Members like Deputy Blaney attacking the Opposition for having provoked the crisis. All that we did in this whole affair was when the information came to our notice to go to the head of the Government. Could we have done less? Should we have sat back and remained silent and done nothing? Should we not have warned him of the situation of which to some extent he might have been unaware, although from our information, it seems that he had been aware of it for some time previously and had done nothing about it?
The only action we could take responsibly was to go to him with that information, tell him we had it and that he must act in the interests of the State. We have been accused by Deputy Blaney of trying to provoke a Constitutional crisis. There is a crisis but it has not been provoked by us. It has been provoked by members of the Government and by the Taoiseach's handling of the crisis. Blaney and Haughey themselves broke the law of the Constitution——
Comment on this
They are still Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey. I apologise to the Chair but not to the other side of the House. These Deputies broke the law of the Constitution when they refused to hand in their seals of office and insisted on hanging on to power to the last moment. The nearest we have got to a constitutional crisis has been their refusal to obey the Constitution. This is a debate on an issue of confidence in reality if not yet in form.
It should have been clear that we on this side of the House have for some time past had no confidence in this Government. That is not just a cliché. An Opposition is forced to say from time to time that it has no confidence in the Government. Sometimes it is just a debating tactic. The simple fact is that the performance of some Ministers —and I say "some Ministers" deliberately because the conduct of many Ministers has been above reproach— for some time past has been such that no Opposition could have confidence in such a Government.
No Opposition could have confidence in a Taoiseach who continued such men in office. God knows we warned the Taoiseach often enough. We pointed out how some of these men were disgracing the country. We all remember a few short months ago the debate on the former Minister for Justice. We came in here and presented the information at our disposal. We showed the kind of letter he was prepared to write on official notepaper urging people to act illegally. The Taoiseach defended and condoned his action.
We protested again and again against the repudiation of Government policy by Deputy Neil Blaney, then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. We urged on the Taoiseach to get rid of this man who was undermining his position, who was untrustworthy, and who constantly repudiated the Taoiseach's own policy. We urged on the Taoiseach to assert himself as the leader of this Government so that we could have confidence in his leadership of the Government. He did nothing. If he is now in a mess—and he is in a mess—it is his own fault. He did not act when he had ample warning.
It very often happens that a Taoiseach can be caught out because some Minister unexpectedly lets him down without warning. One could understand such a thing happening. One could have sympathy with a Taoiseach or Prime Minister caught in that position. One cannot easily have sympathy with a Prime Minister who continues to maintain in office people who have disgraced themselves by their behaviour and who continually repudiate his authority and challenge it. A Prime Minister who in those circumstances refuses to act must, I am afraid, deserve what he gets and, may I say, he is certain to get it in time if he lets the issue continue.
We have been saying this for months. We have no confidence in the observation of the principle of collective responsibility. This principle has been thrown to the winds by this Government. It is a vital principle of a Parliamentary democracy, a vital principle of the system of Cabinet Government, and something which has not existed here for some time past. This crisis may do one good thing. It may—and I cannot say more than that—lead to the re-establishment of this principle. There is reason to hope, but I can say no more than hope, that the new Government formed here will once again operate on the basis of collective responsibility. There is reason to hope that the Taoiseach, having so belatedly established his authority, will maintain that authority for whatever remaining period he is in office.
The Opposition has been mindful of its responsibilities. Not one voice has been raised on this side of the House in private or in public in favour of the kind of aggressive policy advocated openly by Members on the other side of the House who, until two or three days ago, were members of the Government. Our concern in this debate, and our concern in the statements we have made outside the House, has been to reassure opinion in the north. I myself took part in several programmes on northern television, for one of which I went to Belfast, in order to get this point across. It seemed to me from the newspaper reports I read that in Northern Ireland and in Britain some kind of delusion seemed to exist that this country was faced with a choice between Lynch and Blaney. That is not the choice, or certainly not the only choice.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach and Deputy Blaney. There exists in this House—and I shall come back to this point again because it is vital that this be stressed in this country, in Northern Ireland and in Britain and to the world in general—a vast majority in favour of moderate policies, a vast majority of men who want this country to live in peace. They are on our benches. They comprise every Deputy in this party, every Deputy in the Labour Party and a very large number, I hope the vast majority, on the other side of the House. We—and I presume to speak for all these people—will ensure that no man will destroy the peace of our country no matter how he plots and, by God, the plotting has started already. He will not get away with it.
It is arguable, and was arguable up to yesterday morning, that the national interest might have required us to pull our punches in order to maintain the credibility of the Government. I considered this seriously. I discussed it with several of my colleagues but any doubts I had on this score ended when Deputy Boland rose to speak in this House. As the Government party spoke one by one to destroy their own credibility, it became clear that there was no good in our trying to prop them up. Any idea which I had, and I think other Deputies on our side of the House had in the national interest, that perhaps it would be better not to press for an election at this time went out the window. We could see as they got up to speak one by one a situation emerging. If we do not now clarify that situation, if we do not now at this moment establish before the world the existence in this country of a vast majority in favour of moderate policies, we could drift into a situation and a crisis in which an election could be forced upon us in very different conditions. An election in August or September, if there is trouble in the north, could be very dangerous for the peace in this country.
Accordingly, I have, quite frankly, changed my mind on this matter. I changed my mind within the past 34 hours since this debate started. I no longer feel as I felt, and as I said on television in Northern Ireland, it would be unwise to have an election now. I feel that not to have one now would leave us in a situation where at any moment these men would be able, choosing their time, to pull down the Government and to force us into an election on their terms against us—and by "us" I mean not just these two parties but the majority of the party opposite—and that would be the most dangerous thing that could happen to this country.
I urge on the Taoiseach to consider this. I do not expect him to get up and reveal his mind on it tonight. He must say what he has to say to preserve the forms but, in his own mind, he must be pondering this because, although he has acted imprudently, although he has misled this House, I am afraid, although he has acted improperly, he is a man I know who has at heart, as most Deputies on the other side of the House and most members of the Government have, the interests of this country. He will have to ponder now what he will do. What is important now is not the fate of any one party. It is the fate of this country.
It was, perhaps, natural that the first instinct on the other side of the House should be: "How can we save Fianna Fáil?", an instinct which one would expect to be upper most particularly in the minds of a party who have always tended to think in terms of party more strongly, more immediately, than, perhaps, other political parties here or elsewhere.
When they have had time to settle down and think, and when the implications in the speeches by Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland have sunk in, when the activities—and I shall come back to this—of Deputy Blaney's PRO yesterday have sunk in, when the threat of the bonfires on the road to Letterkenny sinks in, then I think the Taoiseach will have to reconsider his position. He will have to consider what he risks by remaining in office at the mercy of these dangerous men, bent on ousting him and bent on bringing this country to disaster. I hope that we can rely on his judgment to do the right thing for this country. I believe we can. Time will tell.
There are some lessons we can learn from this affair, two in particular. I believe they are ones that will be learned and remembered by Governments in this country for a long time to come. The first is that a Government must never tolerate low standards. If you let standards slip little by little, small things that may seem individually unimportant, you will eventually founder. The innocent who do not rapidly check the guilty eventually get involved in their guilt.
The second conclusion is that the leader of a Government must, above all, act decisively. He must not dither. He must not give conspirators time once, twice, three times when they ask for it. He must grasp the nettle the first time the issue comes before him.
I think that future Governments here for many years and decades to come and all parties will not fail to remember those two lessons learned in this crisis.
The issue before us is confidence in the Government in substance if not in form. The actual subject of the debate is slightly different. I fear that the question of the nomination of three new Ministers-designate was rather overshadowed during the 34 hours of this debate but that is their fate to be appointed in such a situation.
We must be able to trust the leader of the Government. Trust is essential in politics. The Parliamentary system demands trust between Government and Opposition. There will be battles to be fought—tough and difficult at times—but there must be some trust subsisting between the leaders of the different parties. Only in that way will the system work. If that breaks down, the country is in trouble. I am sorry that this trust has been badly, perhaps irretrievably, shaken.
I have always personally had respect for the Taoiseach. I regret he has found himself in a position which he has not been able to handle as it should be handled and that our confidence in him has therefore been disturbed. Normally, there is a measure of confidence on the part of the Opposition in the leader of the Government—not support for his policies but confidence that he will not mislead Parliament and confidence that he will exercise his judgment decisively in the interests of the country.
By reason of the difficulty in reconciling the truth of the statements made on the opposite side of the House, we now have too many doubts raised. Let us try to reconstruct the story. I apologise in advance if my reconstruction is incorrect. I honestly tried to put together what seems the most probable explanation of a totally improbable course of events. If I am wrong in any point—I am bound to go wrong on some point—perhaps the Taoiseach will correct me. I apologise in advance if I mislead the House in any way. It is not easy to put together, out of this incredible collection of statements from so many different sources, conflicting to such a high degree, anything resembling a consistent account.
Comment on this
I admit that what I am about to say is impossible to substantiate in every detail. When we are faced with assertions that are in complete and total contradiction of one another between Ministers and ex-Ministers opposite, how can we reconcile them? We can only do our best to establish, with the aid of any bit of evidence, who is the most credible and which is the most likely part of the story to be true. It appears from various papers that a section of the IRA have been trying to import arms into this country since last October. The story goes on—several accounts—that much of the money was raised from Irish contractors in Britain largely on the basis of telling them that one of the leaders of the group was in close contact with someone high up in Dublin.
Interpol and the various police forces and intelligence services in different countries got on to this situation. We cannot be sure but perhaps all of these consignments were stopped. We have in this country an efficient force; it may well be that all the consignments were stopped. We hope so, for the sake of future peace here and in Northern Ireland. Where repeated attempts to import what appeared to be, on the whole, fairly small consignments of arms are frustrated, the people concerned tried to find a way round the difficulty. Particularly where several were closely involved—and even in two cases related to members of the Government —it appeared that the way round they sought was some mechanism by which they could get the vigilance of our security forces relaxed and set aside so as to get these arms in unknown to them or without being able to stop them.
According to the Taoiseach's account, approaches were made to Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney. One account, circumstantial in character and containing certain elements in it which concord well with other evidence suggesting the account may be, in larger measure, true—I am sure there is some unreliable evidence in it —indicates that, since last October, there has been contact between leaders of this particular IRA group, one among several, and Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney who were Ministers in this Government.
These contacts came to the knowledge of the Taoiseach last year. He challenged the two Ministers on these contacts but did not take the matter any further, having warned them, even though he got evidence of further contacts after they had been given the warning.
However long the Taoiseach has known about them and done nothing about them, we hope to hear the full truth tonight. They did, it appears, approach these Ministers some time in the not very distant past, a matter of weeks ago, on the basis that, if they could get clearance for one consignment to come by air, by getting in a large consignment on this occasion they could get over the frustrations of smaller consignments. Reports suggest five or six tons of small arms worth about £80,000. In the absence of a full statement by the Taoiseach, we can only reply on circumstantial reports; they have not been denied.
The plan, apparently, was that Deputy Haughey, Minister for Finance, would secure that the Customs check would not take place; that an official of the Department of Finance, acting under his instructions, attempted to secure this by telephoning the Customs authorities at Dublin Airport. The plot was somewhat clumsy. It assumed our security services were lacking in vigilance or that their efforts would be frustrated through treachery at some other point. The plot required these arms to come in here in the guise of equipment for our Defence Forces and an officer would collect them. The officer chosen had nothing to do with ordnance supplies and his presence at the airport on such a mission would immediately be suspect, anyway, even if he had not already been under suspicion.
I shall come back to the suspicion and to the extraordinary confusion that seemed to exist between the different security services in this State. Special Branch had already been alerted. They got on, not once, but twice, to the Department of Justice seeking authority to over-rule this instruction from the Department of Finance. These approaches stopped at the desk of the Minister. The question of the culpability of that Minister is something on which we cannot easily judge. The Taoiseach has told us he was not concerned in this affair: this we cannot accept.
It may be that, faced with this problem, faced with a situation in which he was being asked to intervene in a plot by some of his colleagues, he could not face a decision; he opted out; he went away. It was not, I am afraid, the first time. Once again, the Taoiseach must have known of that Minister's frequent absences from his office and of his failure to carry out his duties properly. One cause of this was the fact that he was carrying on his practice as a solicitor. The Taoiseach stood over that, too. It is a disgraceful episode and one of which he should be ashamed. He opted out and our security services were totally frustrated. They required a Ministerial decision from their Minister to over-rule the decision of the other Minister. They could not, themselves, control the customs and excise directly.
Under the Ministers and Secretaries Act, it is the law of this State that each Minister controls his own Department and that only he can give decisions in respect of it. How did he get round it? One account has it that the secretary of the Department of Justice, faced with this appalling situation, found it necessary to go to the President for advice as to what to do. In any event, whether through that channel, whether through such advice or whether on his own initiative he appears to have gone to the Taoiseach. But there were wheels within wheels. It appears from Deputy Boland's statement, though it is difficult to follow this precisely because he spoke loosely, that, for some time past— there is a conflict here as to what he said because several accounts, including that of several members of the Press, have it that he said for "several" or "seven" months past: people could not hear—Ministers have been under surveillance. If this is true, how do we reconcile it with the Taoiseach's statement? How do we reconcile the evidence that he knew last year of the contact between Deputies Haughey and Blaney and members of the IRA Army Council? According to the Taoiseach's statement, the first he knew of the affair was on 20th April. Are we to believe that Ministers were under surveillance without the authority of the head of the Government, or are we to take it that Deputy Boland has misled the House or that he has developed paranoia about being watched? We must know the truth. It would be disturbing if the security services were keeping Ministers under surveillance without the authority of the Taoiseach, and the fact that such suggestion has been made indicates the utter demoralisation to which this Government have brought us. Think of what would be in the minds of the secret service officers of any country if they found out that the Minister under whom they were serving could not be trusted.
There was a further complication in all this. It now appears that Deputy Gibbons, as Minister for Defence, was employing an intelligence agent, Captain Kelly, in Northern Ireland and that he was also in some way involved in this plot. At any rate, Captain Kelly was the man sent to the airport to endeavour to clear the arms cargo, but Deputy Gibbons has made a statement saying there is no truth whatsoever in this. Captain Kelly is inhibited by the Official Secrets Act from giving details and has confined himself to remarking that the Minister is a scoundrel, that what he has said is a tissue of lies.
Surely this entire incredible affair requires some investigation? Could it be that the Minister for Defence, as soon as he got wind of this plot, went to the Taoiseach while pretending to collaborate in some way with his colleagues in the Departments of Agriculture and Finance while, at the same time, informing on them to the Taoi-search? If so, that would explain the justification for the retention of Deputy Gibbons in the Government. However, we do not know the full story. How can we know whether Deputy Gibbons was acting as a single agent, a double agent or a treble agent and, if so, whom was he referring to whom? If the Taoiseach considers that, in spite of the disclosures of his involvement, he is justified in retaining this man in the Government it may well be that he may be able to tell us that the loyal Minister for Defence was, in fact, watching and informing on his colleagues for some time past and that for his loyalty he is now retained—although it seems a rather curious reward for him to have been removed from the Department in which he was doing such excellent work. I trust we will have an explanation from the Taoiseach. That explanation is given some similitude by the remarkable campaign being organised by Deputy Blaney against Deputy Gibbons.
I wish to say a word now about this character, Mr. Séamus Brady, who managed yesterday to give three Press conferences under different guises. He is Deputy Blaney's PRO and the purpose of these conferences was to blacken Deputy Gibbons's name and to bring down the Government during this debate. Could this be Deputy Blaney's first move in his game—"game" hardly being the word—to bring down the Government? Let us consider now these curious Press conferences organised by this curious individual, Mr. Séamus Brady. First of all, in today's Irish Press, Brady who is described as “the Derry-born journalist” in an interview defends Captain Kelly, and no doubt properly. He goes on to make a number of interesting disclosures including the disclosure that the Fianna Fáil publication, Voice of the North, which has been doing such harm in Northern Ireland was, for a short period, financed by the Department of External Affairs.
Comment on this
Yes, I thank the Deputy. At any rate, this individual was not content to give a Press conference on his own. When journalists arrived at Captain Kelly's house, the ubiquitous Brady was there. As reported in today's Irish Press:
At his home last night, Captain Kelly, who was accompanied by his legal advisers, Mr. Christopher Anthony Gore-Grimes and by Mr. Séamus Brady said....
and the report continues with the captain's full statement in which he describes Deputy Gibbons as a scoundrel and says that what the Minister said was a tissue of lies. Those words are not in the statement printed here because the papers could not publish that part of it until it was on the records of the House, but in a statement given to the papers and to the BBC relating to a press conference given under the auspices of Mr. Séamus Brady it is clear that the purpose was to blacken the name of Deputy Gibbons and to endeavour to make it clear that he was involved in anything that went on.
Brady is featured again and I quote:
"A deputation of people from Northern Ireland which met the then Minister for Defence, Mr. Gibbons, about a month ago was given to understand that the Army was being prepared for any eventuality that might arise in the Six Counties" it was claimed in Dublin last night. The speakers were introduced by Mr. Séamus Brady.
Mr. Brady described the conference as a spontaneous gathering. He is a very spontaneous individual who managed to give Press conferences all over Dublin yesterday. We are not in the High Court trying this case but it is clear that Deputy Blaney is out to get Deputy Gibbons. It is also clear that Mr. Séamus Brady is Deputy Blaney's PRO. It is evident that Deputy Blaney's attitude is that, if he is going out of the Government, Deputy Gibbons is going too. We may ask why. The most probable explanation is that Deputy Gibbons was not, as Deputies Blaney and Haughey thought, working for them but that all the time he was informing on them to the Taoiseach. Deputy Blaney will not forgive that particular betrayal.
Comment on this
There is more to it than that. Apart from the interventions of Deputies Blaney and Boland it is difficult to conceive anything more harmful to the Government during this debate than these three Press conferences which throw a bomb into a debate that has shaken the Government to their foundations.
When this debate started the general view of the people in the House and in the country was that the Taoiseach had survived the crisis remarkably well, that he was in firm command of his party, that all was well under his leadership and that the man must be preserved and not shaken. However, 34 hours later this is not so, partly because of the incredible interventions of Deputies Blaney and Boland in this House but also because of the activities of the ubiquitous Mr. Séamus Brady, Deputy Blaney's PRO.
Deputy Blaney works fast. He is a man of remarkable ability—ability which is not always well used and which is being used intensively and consistently to bring down the Government. He is the man on whom the Taoiseach depends for support.
How could the Taoiseach, how could the Government go through the humiliation of remaining in power at the hands of a man who is doing all he can to tear them down, a man who has betrayed them in this way and who, while coming into this House and presenting himself as loyal and telling the Fianna Fáil Party he was loyal and telling this House of his loyalty to the Taoiseach, was doing his best to stab him in the back and who is now about to go back on a trimphal entry to Donegal planned by his great colleague and friend Senator McGlinchey? Let me read from tonight's Evening Herald.
Sacked Minister for Agriculture Mr. N. Blaney, goes home to a hero's welcome in Donegal tonight— bands, bonfires, torchlight procession—and will even be escorted in triumphant style through parts of the Six Counties.
The "home coming" has been planned by his Donegal supporters who have pledged him their full backing, come what may.
Ominous words for the Taoiseach.
Mr. Blaney's election agent, Senator Bernard McGlinchey said:
"We plan to have three bands and begin our 100 mile motorcade from Monaghan to his constituency passing through Aughnacloy, Omagh, Newtownstewart, Strabane and Lifford, where he will be carried shoulder high across the Border."
As yet no fixed time has been made for the Monaghan welcome.
Just as well. The debate went on a little longer than Deputy Blaney had counted on. I understand his heroes welcome has been postponed until tomorrow.
Comment on this
This hero is a man who is out to take over the party opposite not for any good purposes but to destroy this country. Most Deputies opposite know this. There are not many naive people in the Fianna Fáil Party nor in the Fianna Fáil Government. They know what faces them. They know what this man is up to and they know what the country faces at his hands. I hope, I pray that the Taoiseach will handle this situation well and will cope with this man. He handled him briskly the other day but he is still there and, by God, is he fighting back?
These friendly people in Fianna Fáil who are wielding their knives so delicately behind this facade of unity and loyalty include our friend, Deputy Gibbons. I am prepared to accept, until there is evidence to the contrary anyway, that he was loyal to the Taoiseach and merely being a double agent, not a treble agent, but I do not think he was very nice to his subordinate Captain Kelly. He came into this House yesterday to ditch Kelly, his agent, the fall guy, the man who did what he was told, thinking it was for the good of his country, the subordinate, the Army officer whom he suborned. Perhaps I should not say he suborned but somebody suborned. In fact, it was apparently the Minister for Defence who was using him although Captain Kelly did not know apparently that all the time Deputy Gibbons was really working for the Taoiseach, at least as far as we can make out. Nice friendly people these Fianna Fáil Ministers, are they not, not just those who have gone but one at least who remains?
In all this there are many questions left unanswered and many details that I may have got slightly twisted. I have done my best to get a straight picture but one cannot get a straight picture of a crooked situation. I will now ask a number of questions and I would urge on the Taoiseach to answer them. I do not think this country will tolerate unanswered questions at this time and I would like, when I ask these questions, to see somebody opposite writing them down as a sign they will be answered. If they do not write them down we know what to expect from the Taoiseach's reply. Have they pen and paper? First of all, as reported in the Irish Times of 7th May:
Mr. Lynch assured the House that Mr. Ó Móráin's appointment was terminated on health grounds and he was not involved in these matters.
We had in conflict to that Deputy Boland's statements in the Irish Independent that morning, on radio, television, in this House repeatedly—I wrote them down myself—that he was convinced, he was certain that Deputy Ó Móráin was sacked. We had the curious fact that Deputy Haughey, who is ill, was able to issue a statement while Deputy Ó Móráin who is a lot less ill will not issue any statement. There is no statement from him concerning the truth of what was said. What do we get from Deputy Ó Móráin, who is not all that ill? We get “No comment” when he was asked about the truth of Deputy Boland's statements. We need clarification of this. We need some kind of assurance that Deputy Boland is wrong, that he is not telling the truth, some assurance that the Minister for Justice did resign voluntarily and that it had nothing to do with this. It seems to me that it has something to do with it.
It may well be, as the Taoiseach's statement is, perhaps, intended to convey, that he was not guilty, that he was not actually involved in the plot but that he merely lacked the courage to foil it and ran away. It may well be that this was because of ill health. The Taoiseach, I think, said that not only was he ill and would be ill for some months but that he had been ill for some time or if he did not say that at least that was stated in the papers. It may well be that Deputy Ó Móráin faced an intolerable burden and he was not up to the job because of illness. If this is the case this was known to the Taoiseach. Frankly, I never thought Deputy Ó Móráin was a suitable Minister for Justice from the day he was appointed but at least at some stage he was hale and hearty. It appears that he was left in the job when he was so ill that not alone would he not be present for much of the time but that when he was present he was not prepared to do his job. It is the Taoiseach's job to see that his Ministers are competent. If he failed to do so it is the Taoiseach's responsibility and he is answerable to this House for it. We want the full story on Deputy Ó Móráin's resignation.
My second point: the Taoiseach waited nine days to approach Deputy Blaney because of Deputy Haughey's illness? Why? I can conceive of a good reason for this—he has two potential plotters and might want to pick them off separately so that one could not get in touch with the other. Is this the reason? Let us be told if that is how he stood.
Thirdly, the Taoiseach said:
I told them both I had information on the basis of which information I felt it was my duty to request their resignations as members of the Government. Each of them denied he instigated in any way the attempted importation of arms. They asked me for time to consider their position. I agreed to do so.
Certain questions arise here. This is a most interesting denial. We all, as politicians, know the art of the denial of what was not said, the art of saying that one did not do something which is not, in fact, the crime one committed.
These men apparently denied to the Taoiseach that they had instigated this. I was not aware that anybody suggested they did instigate it. They were asked by this illegal organisation to facilitate the passage of arms. The IRA were the instigators: they were the facilitators. When these men denied they instigated this, did the Taoiseach accept this at face value. Did he simply say: "Oh good. I am glad you did not instigate it" or did he say "Right, you did not instigate it, but were you involved?" What is the significance of this curious phrase and why is he so careful in using it in this House? Why does he not tell us that they denied being involved if they did deny it? Why is the denial he reports to us confined to instigation because if, of course they simply said to him: "We did not instigate it" he must have known instantly that they were guilty, if that is all they were prepared to deny. No Deputy in this House with experience of Question Time can be so naive as not to perceive that point instantly.
We have a curious point that each of them asked him for time to consider their position. It is interesting that they both reacted in the same way. It is interesting to wonder what they wanted the time for to consider their position. If a man is innocent he does not ask for time to consider his position. If he is innocent he says he is innocent and, by God, he wants it accepted there and then. A man who asks for time to consider his position is a man with a guilty secret. That is the second reason why the Taoiseach must have known, even if the evidence he had was not conclusive, that he was dealing with guilty men.
Why did he give those guilty men time? It is not the first time he gave them time. As the story unfolds they were given time more than once. Why did he give them time? He had already decided, according to himself, that it was his duty to request their resignation. He had certain evidence. He had now the evidence of their refusal to deny the matter fully, if we can judge correctly by the Taoiseach's words, and the very request for time which showed them guilty. He tells us that if the slightest suspicion attaches to Ministers they must go. Here was much more than the slightest suspicion. Here was strong circumstantial evidence of guilt on the part of the reaction of the men themselves and yet he gave them time. This was a matter involving national security. The requests for resignation should have been immediately enforced. We are entitled to an explanation as to why they were not.
He then goes on to say he authorised the continuation of investigations following which he decided to approach the two Ministers again. He repeated his request that they tender their resignations, a very patient man. He tenders request and request and request until it is too late for him and too late for the Government. He did so on the basis that he was convinced that not even the slightest suspicion should attach to any member of the Government in a matter of this nature. Again his approach to each of those Ministers was separate yet according to his statement each gave the same answer. Each asked for time, more time. After having told the Ministers he expected their resignations forthwith, each of them told him that he would not give his resignation until the 6th May. Why?
First of all, what reason did they give to him for both choosing this same day? What was the significance of this date? Why did they both choose this date? What are they planning by this date? I do not understand why the Taoiseach gave them time. It should have been obvious to him as an experienced politician that time could be needed for two purposes only in those circumstances, One was to falsify the evidence if this were possible and the second was to bring down the man who was accusing them. In neither case was giving them time desirable in the national interest or, indeed, in the interest of the Taoiseach and the Fianna Fáil Party. Yet he gave them time until the 6th May according to his own account. During this entire period those Ministers, those guilty men had continued access to all the information available to them as Ministers. Why did he permit this?
There is another point, upon which we would like to inquire. There is a note of omission in this part of his account. He does not tell us the date of this second request. When they asked for time to the 6th May what date in May was this? How many more days were involved? We are entitled to know this date. It is curious he does not mention this date when the other dates are mentioned. Could it be something to do with wishing to fuzz the issue? What ultimately precipitated his action was, in fact, Deputy Cosgrave's move. Let us know this date.
It is to be noted, in fact, that neither of them ever resigned and their explanations given for this are surely the most unconvincing reasons ever given by Ministers, whether for resigning or not resigning. The next question I should like to ask is at what time on 29th April did the Taoiseach request Deputy Blaney's resignation? Could it have been during the morning or afternoon? We all remember this guilty man at six o'clock that evening, this guilty man, this disloyal Minister, came into the House and proceeded to proclaim his loyalty to his Taoiseach in nauseating, exhibitionist terms. Was this because he had just been approached by his Taoiseach with this accusation? Was he trying to cover himself? Was he using the House for that purpose? Was this massive attack on the Fine Gael Party designed as a blind to cover up his position, to strengthen his flank while he proceeded to mobilise his forces against the Taoiseach? Will the Taoiseach please tell us when on the 29th April he requested Deputy Blaney's resignation?
Did either of those Ministers—I think we know the answer in the case of one because he was ill—attend Cabinet meetings subsequent to the Taoiseach forming the suspicion which led to their resignations and subsequent, particularly, to his first request for their resignations? On my reckoning there were after 29th April two Cabinet meetings. I do not think Deputy Haughey attended them. He could not because he was ill. Did Deputy Blaney attend them? Is it the position that a man who already, because of the suspicions attaching to him, has been asked for his resignation, was allowed to attend meetings of the Cabinet. Is this the position? Let us be told the truth about that.
From Deputy Cosgrave's statement it appears that the information about the matters referred to was first presented to the Department of Justice through the commissioner of the Garda Síochána whose advice was sought but no directive given. From Deputy Cosgrave's statement again the commissioner of the Garda formed the view that the situation was not being handled with sufficient seriousness and a further request for a directive from the Minister was then made. It was at this stage that the matter was notified to the Taoiseach apparently. This means that the Department of Justice had this information before 20th April. Indeed, they must have had it because the attempt to import the arms was on the previous Thursday or Friday and according to one report again on the intervening Sunday.
The House should be informed as to when the Department of Justice received this information and we should be told precisely why the Minister did not give the directive. Is it correct that he dodged this issue, that his state of health led to him refusing to face it, leaving his office with this file on his desk? Has any examination been made of the conduct of those Ministers since the request was made for them to resign? What inquiries have been made about their performance? I do not want to press this point unduly but we have had introduced into this House a very curious Budget. Has that Budget been examined from this point of view? Has the Vote for the Department of Defence been examined? That Vote was not very generous in a year in which the Department of Defence were looking for, and were entitled to, a considerable increase in funds to enable it to become effective. When it was shown to be ineffective last year, when the lack of supplies and the state and the condition of its equipment made it inadequately mobile and when, as a result, requests were made for substantial increases in the allotment to that Department, nothing was done about it. The figures for the Estimate for the Department of Defence in the Budget do not disclose any net increase. In fact, under headings like stores there is a reduction. While the Minister was facilitating the import of arms for an illegal organisation, he was deciding, as Minister for Finance, not to provide the arms and stores required by the legal army of the nation.
I would ask the Taoiseach to re-examine the Vote for the Department of Defence. It is my understanding that, in fact, the Department of Defence considered the Minister for Finance as being well disposed towards them despite the fact that he did not give much to them in the Budget but they were preparing to submit requests for further consideration and were hopeful of getting from him, perhaps, by way of Supplementary Estimate, additional funds. If this request is furnished I hope it will be examined carefully in the light of the fact that the refusal came from a man who is now known to have been more concerned with providing arms for an illegal body than for the Army of the State.
Why was a Minister suspected of criminal and corrupt activity of the worst kind allowed to take away papers from his Department without surveillance? Almost the only activity of Deputy Haughey since then has been to collect his papers and many of us saw him doing so with the white car of his friend outside Government Buildings. What check was made on those papers before he took them away? Were they checked to see what he was taking away? Was his house or Deputy Blaney's house searched as those of other conspirators in less high places would and should be searched? Anybody else suspected of crimes of this kind would immediately have their houses searched. Was this action taken or have they been left immune from the process of the law?
Again, I should like to ask the Taoiseach if the Minister for Defence was aware of Deputy Blaney's interference with the Army? Was he aware of the constant and persistent flow of intelligence reports he kept forcing on the Army from his own private intelligence service, trying to force the Army to change their policy? If the Minister for Defence was aware of this intervention by Deputy Blaney direct in the affairs of the Army did he refer this to the Taoiseach? Since when was this reported? If it was not reported, why? Did Deputy Gibbons know about this? There are other aspects of this matter which have been referred to which I need not go into here. They have already been reported in the press. There were some months ago reports of the Army or FCA being involved in training activities in Donegal with which Deputy Blaney was also associated. Have those been investigated? Where do we stand in regard to this? Just how far did he go in interfering with the Army? How much was known of this? How much was accepted of this? Was he allowed to do it while being watched? For how long was he watched?
Deputy Boland let slip a significant remark. In attempting to challenge the veracity of the accusations levelled against his colleagues he asked "Where are the arms?" knowing full well that this consignment of arms had not come into the country and were, therefore, not available as evidence. He asked "Is there anything available as proof in this case except documents?" Deputy Boland admitted that there were documents although he seemed to think they were not conclusive proof of the complicity of the ex-Ministers. What are these documents and to what extent do they prove the complicity of the ex-Ministers concerned? Were they clever enough to ensure that any documents were signed by subordinates, that there was nothing in writing from them, that they gave verbal orders? Was there a civil servant so foolish as to accept a verbal order from a Minister for an act of potential illegality and put himself in the position of then giving directions without having written instructions? What were those documents Deputy Boland mentioned so significantly, although, perhaps, he did not intend to let that particular bit of knowledge slip out?
What about the surveillance of Ministers? How long has this been going on and who has been under surveillance? Is it even conceivable that the Minister for Justice himself was under surveillance? How can a Government survive in these conditions? I have a little sympathy with Deputy Boland, and I am not given to having sympathy for him, to find that he apparently was under surveillance. It must in fairness be said that he seems to have been an innocent party and no breath of suspicion is attached to him in this affair. He is a man with whom I have often crossed swords and with whose views I have little sympathy but we must be fair to him. When he resigned he did so honourably because he resented the treatment meted out to his colleagues and he resented the fact that apparently he was under surveillance.
How long has this business gone on? Has the surveillance of Ministers by the Special Branch been at all times under the direction of the Taoiseach and when did the Taoiseach first put Ministers under surveillance? All these facts we need to know. It seems from what has come to light that the Taoiseach knew a great deal for a considerable time beforehand. We have had the significant phrase used by Deputy Boland about "several or seven months" of which there are several records by different people who took it down. We have the fact that Captain Kelly's activities have gone on for quite a considerable time. We are to imply from Deputy Gibbons' retention and promotion that he must have kept the Taoiseach informed about matters since the end of last year. All these things point to the Taoiseach knowing about this matter much earlier than he led this House to believe. Of course, the evidence put before him may not have been sufficient. We should be told how early was he told that Ministers of State were under suspicion. When was he first told they were in touch with the IRA? Was he told this fact last year? Did he issue them a warning as we are told now was the case and, after that warning, what further information did he get about their activities? This House is entitled to know the answers to these questions and, if we leave this place tonight without getting those answers, the country will really have cause for lack of confidence in the Government and in the State.
I shall be interested to see whether Deputies Blaney and Boland will vote for the Taoiseach in this House tonight and thereby ditch Captain Kelly. Deputy Blaney has been anxious that he should put his case forward and has lent him his PRO for that purpose. Before I go any further, I should like to say that I consider the Taoiseach has a special duty to people involved who were not Ministers, particularly Captain Kelly. There is some evidence to suggest that throughout this entire business Captain Kelly believed he was acting properly. He may have acted injudiciously. He may be in the rather curious position of thinking he was acting for a Minister who had no authority to do the things he was doing when, in fact, the Minister had such authority from the Taoiseach to do these things with a view to misleading other Ministers he was having watched. All this is possible but we would like to know just exactly what was Captain Kelly's position. If he acted throughout under the authority of the Minister, although, perhaps, he ought to have known the Minister's requests were improper, we should be told this. This House owes a special duty to Captain Kelly to clear his position. If his position is clear, he, this House and the country should be told that this is so.
We come then to the Taoiseach's famous statement which has been repeated frequently in the last 35 hours, "I do not know what you are referring to". When the Taoiseach was asked that question by Deputy Cosgrave he could have evaded it—politicians are used to evasions. He could have tossed off some phrase in which the evasion would not have been noticeable at the time. However, he chose to say, "I do not know what you are referring to". We have to face the fact—it is a miserable fact to face and I have difficulty in facing the Taoiseach when saying it —that that statement was not true. The question put to the Taoiseach by Deputy Cosgrave was whether further resignations were coming. He has told this House that he requested the resignations about ten days earlier. The two statements are irreconcilable. Either he never requested the resignations and made up the story—this I refuse to believe as the evidence is too circumstantial—or he had requested the resignations and he told this House a lie. Another man in another Parliament told a lie in a much more disreputable matter and he left public life. I should like to hear the Taoiseach explain the statements and I hope he can give a convincing explanation.
However, we must face the fact that the clear implication of this untruth and certain other significant occurrences at the same time—and I refer in particular to the attempt to rush through Deputy O'Malley's appointment as Minister for Justice—clearly suggests that it was intended to deal with this whole matter by brushing it under the carpet. I do not suggest that the Taoiseach necessarily intended to leave these men in office. He had got rid of one Minister who had failed to live up to his responsibilities by getting him to resign on the grounds of health. He was, perhaps, about to announce urbi et orbi that Deputy Haughey was resigning on grounds of health. That would have been accepted by people as reasonable not only in view of Deputy Haughey's recent unfortunate accident —the nature of the accident is obscure to the point of causing further confusion—but in view of the Deputy's health in the last couple of years.
I do not know what the Taoiseach might have had up his sleeve as regards an excuse for Deputy Blaney's resignation but it seems to me that when he made the statement, "I do not know what you are referring to", when he was trying to rush through Deputy O'Malley's nomination, he could not have intended at that time to announce the resignation of two further Ministers and announce the reasons. It looks as if he intended to announce the resignation of Deputy Haughey shortly afterwards on grounds of health and intended to tell this House that he did not know at the time he made the statement that Deputy Haughey had been so ill, and thereby justify his statement. However, it puzzles me what he intended to do about Deputy Blaney. If he was planning to sweep the matter under the carpet in this way, he could not have got away with a forced resignation by Deputy Blaney immediately after that and still stand by his original statement. I begin to wonder whether he did intend to insist on Deputy Blaney's resignation then or whether it was to be delayed for some time so that some verisimilitude could be given to his statement, "I do not know what you are referring to".
I think the Taoiseach will understand in view of all that has happened, of what he has said and the sequence of events, that we simply cannot take what he said at face value. It is literally impossible for both his statements to this House to be true. We must try to reconcile them as best we can and the most charitable explanation I can put on it until I hear the Taoiseach's explanation, which he has withheld from this House until now, is that he did intend to get rid of these men one by one, while misleading the House with his statement, and that he intended to do this without announcing the reasons. He might justify that to himself on grounds of raison d'état, that the security of the State demanded that public confidence should not be disturbed, that Deputies Haughey and Blaney would not be released in the country in the condition in which they have been released, in a way that would enable them to bring down the Government and disrupt peace in this country. Perhaps that was his intention. Perhaps in not telling the truth to this House in that statement he was doing something which he knew to be wrong but in which he felt justified for the security of the State. I do not know. Anyway we are owed an explanation. I do not think it can be a satisfactory explanation but, whatever it is, we must have it. The time has come for the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.
Let us consider now these four men: Deputy Blaney seems to me in the light of all that has happened—indeed. I had this impression before that—a sinister, a ruthless, ambitious man. Deputy Boland, is of very different calibre, sincere, loyal to his principles and his friends, deeply misguided and irresponsible. I do not recall in my lifetime in this country a more irresponsible statement than his attack on the security service of this State, and I was ashamed that it came from his father's son. His father did this country great service, a service which cost him dear. It was not easy for a Republican like Gerry Boland to take the actions he did in the past war to save this country and the people who are plotting against it. It was not easy for him or, indeed, for another earlier Government to do these things, but they did it. Deputy Boland's father was well served by the security service of the State and he was loyal to them, too. To hear his son say in this House in the not very distant past that the security service for which his father took responsibility have deliberately failed to catch people in order to justify their continued existence, what can his father have thought of that man today? That was the utmost limit of political irresponsibility. He has shaken confidence in this country to its foundations. Perhaps he did not realise what he was doing. He spoke with some emotion, but I shiver to think that man was for 13 years a Minister of this State, a man who could act in this way within hours of ceasing to be a Minister.
Then we have Deputy Haughey, the inexplicable figure in this, the unexpected figure, the man whose involvement shocked the whole nation. People could understand Deputy Blaney; they were not surprised, but Deputy Haughey was a different matter. There were criticisms of him of many kinds which I need not go into here; it would be unfair to do so. However, he was a man of great ability. He was betrayed, I think, by a curious, casual arrogance of power. I do not understand it. I do not understand how a man who had so much power could still be ambitious for more in such a way as to betray and undermine his own Government. He is the enigma in this. Let us say charitably that his health, which has been bad for several years quite apart from his accident, may have contributed to it. I think it is the best epitaph of his life as Minister that we can give here.
As regards Deputy Gibbons, I shall say no more because we do not know the position until the Taoiseach speaks. I shall merely say that in the evidence before us his performance in what he said in this House about Captain Kelly was at best unworthy of Deputy Gibbons.
Let us now try to stand back from all this to see it from outside. What do we look like to the world outside today? Deputy Creed said a Fianna Fáil man in Cork said to him yesterday: "We are disgraced." I say that that "we" goes far beyond the Fianna Fáil Party. We share in their disgrace. We, too, are tarnished, we of these other parties, we the people of this country. What damage may this have done us in other countries?
Before all the later developments, the time when the Taoiseach seemed to have handled his position well, when he was being acclaimed, how long ago was it? Thirty-five hours ago he was acclaimed as the man who had resolved this crisis successfully, when sighs of relief were being heaved here and elsewhere. Let us read what is being said in reaction outside this country: "The Taoiseach loses prestige in Whitehall. By our diplomatic correspondent." That is the Irish Times of Thursday, 7th May last. That was long before the Kelly-Gibbons emanations.
Comment on this
I have given the authority I am reading from in accordance with the custom of the House. Deputies may make up their own minds as to whether they attach any importance to the words included here:
The revelations made by the Taoiseach in the Dáil last night must have serious repercussions in London, and may well cause raised eyebrows in Common Market countries on the eve of negotiations for Irish membership...
If, as is suggested in reports from London, pressure was actually brought to bear on Mr. Lynch by the British——
The Taoiseach has denied this but we should like to have this denial re-asserted.
——to act against the Cabinet Ministers reputed to be involved, his prestige would have been reduced still further.
British Parliamentary tradition——
May I say we in this House have inherited that tradition and maintained it——
Comment on this
Yes. I quote again:
British Parliamentary tradition has always held a Premier responsible for the actions of his Cabinet and in the British context the events of the past 24 hours would almost certainly have spelled——
"Almost certainly"—it is traditional.
——the end of Mr. Lynch's career.
While I have not got it here, did the Taoiseach read the editorial in yesterday's Guardian, that most friendly paper to this country, which says more in sorrow than in anger that the term “Banana Republic” was the one that came to mind in relation to the happenings in this country. From the Daily Express one would have expected the insult and ignored it but from the Guardian it did cut many of us.
Comment on this
If we cannot get to the bottom of this, how can we expect foreigners to sort out which, if any, members of the Government can be relied upon? If we do not know where we stand ourselves, how can we expect people in other countries to know whether there is a Government on which they can rely in this country? They have seen two senior Ministers, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, fired for illegal activities. They have heard that members of this Government have been under surveillance by their own security service. The police could not trust their own Minister, who was either unwilling or afraid to act. They have seen also in the papers today reports of a proclamation of bitterness, hatred and sectarianism from a man who has been negotiating with them in London, Brussels and elsewhere as a responsible Minister. Above all, however, they will see a Government kept in power by the votes of those who disgraced it.
They will see the sinister Séamus Bradys working like beavers to disgrace a ministerial colleague, who on the best interpretation of his actions has been a double agent, working to bring down the Taoiseach to whom they make nauseating claims of loyalty. How can they have respect for such a Government? How can they know where they stand with such a Government? How can Ministers go out from this country to London and Brussels and look at their opposite numbers in the face in those circumstances? How can these countries continue to work with such a Government with any confidence?
As regards the new Government, how much solidarity and trust can be expected even now from them—some of these Ministers, one newly appointed, who loudly applauded Deputy Boland and Deputy Blaney but who did not applaud Deputy Lynch at 2.30 on the morning before last? Fianna Fáil has made this country at this moment the laughing stock of the world.
Comment on this
I would wish that there would not be any ambiguity on this point. I was not referring to Deputy O'Malley. If anybody thought so, I certainly wish to say that I was not.
Comment on this
The Minister for Justice has got across his point, that it was not he, that it was the other man.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil have disgraced our democratic traditions. They have brought shame on this country and the guilty men, instead of taking their punishment now they have been caught, have compounded their shame by attacking institutions of the State, as Deputy Boland did particularly.
Fortunately, a sense of loyalty to the State, while atrophied and weakened by the elevation of loyalty to Fianna Fáil, still survives in some members of this Government, including the Taoiseach. May I assert again that both Opposition parties are totally loyal? In these benches there is not one dissentient voice on these issues. No one on this side of the House dissents from the agreed national policy of abjuring the use of force in the north and the national policy which we in this party put forward last September, which the Taoiseach endorsed within hours, which was endorsed by the Labour Party, a policy of re-union by consent, the policy that Partition can and should end only with the consent of the majority of the people in Northern Ireland. That policy put forward by this party last September, the Taoiseach said within hours, not totally truthfully—but politicians have to, perhaps, dress up their remarks at times—has always been the policy of Fianna Fáil, but he endorsed it. Since then he has had to avoid endorsing it further. I have tried again and again in this House to get him to actually use those words and because of his fear of Deputy Blaney and an outburst from Deputy Blaney he has not done so. But basically, I think this Government accept that policy even if up to now they have been inhibited from saying so openly since that first endorsement of it on, I think, 22nd September last. It has the full and total endorsement of everybody sitting on this side, every member of the Labour Party sitting on that side. I see somebody else missing from the Labour Party and I do not know whether he endorses it or not.
Comment on this
This plot was scotched and once it was scotched the Fianna Fáil instinct of self-preservation re-asserted itself and operation "cover up" started but it was bungled or undermined by Deputies Blaney and Boland. What do we face in the months ahead? —a vicious power struggle in Fianna Fáil, Deputy Blaney, a ruthless and unscrupulous man, feared by so many members of his party, the Paisley of the Republic, with the Hitler-like ability to stir a mob, determined to oust the Taoiseach, working away at this now through his agents, seeking to bring down the Government while at the same time mouthing sycophantic platitudes, a man of civil war, a man exploiting divisions of the past with a view to deriving vicious benefit from them in the future, a man who could well capture power in Fianna Fáil.
But, one thing is certain, and I want this message to go out from this House to Northern Ireland in particular and to the rest of the world too: this country, the people in Northern Ireland and the people in Britain and other countries should know this, that in no conceivable circumstances will Deputy Neil Blaney ever be Taoiseach in this country. The vast majority of those who vote for Fianna Fáil, the vast majority of Fianna Fáil Deputies, are loyal to this State and only a tiny handful of them are bigoted sectarians. They genuinely believe in a policy of ending Partition peacefully. They will not permit this State to be launched on a venture that would bring this country to death and to ruin.
There is in this House, I assert again, a vast majority in favour of policies of moderation, policies of peace and no matter how Deputy Blaney plots and no matter what he does to the Fianna Fáil Party, no matter how far he goes to get control of it, I believe and I think the world should know that if the time came that he ever managed to get himself into a position of majority, I am sure there are honest and decent men who care for this country on the other side of the House who would join with us on this side of the House in ensuring that peace would prevail. I am certain that would happen.
I am not prepared to believe that people I know in Fianna Fáil, the men of peace and moderation, the men who care for this country and its future, would ever, ever join with Deputy Blaney in the kind of policy which he wants to pursue to bring this country to ruin. Let the world know that there is a majority in this House— how that majority expresses itself remains to be seen, in what combination or what way, if crisis arises, but it will express itself. This country is safe. It is safe from Deputy Blaney, safe by the voice of the majority of the Members of this House, however they come to express themselves, and we cannot foresee the future as to how they would come to express themselves in the months ahead.
At this point in time, because questions have been raised in the House which should properly concern us about Northern Ireland, I should like to say to Britain that her responsibilities are great. Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland have said, and it is true in a historical sense, that Britain is responsible for Partition. Indeed she is, through her actions particularly in the 17th century. In both the legal and the moral sense she is responsible for the maintenance of peace in Northern Ireland today. If Britain does her duty as she set out to do belatedly last August, if she keeps the peace fairly in Northern Ireland, if she refuses to be intimidated by Protestant fascists or to be provoked by Catholic fascists— although to use the words "Protestant" and "Catholic" for this purpose is to degrade religion—if that happens, peace will be maintained throughout this island.
Britain must face reality. Britain has been far too complacent about the situation in the north. I do not think that at this moment the British Government or their agents in Northern Ireland are yet certainly aware of how serious the situation can be. I am by no means certain that the forces available are sufficient to meet the kind of crisis that could arise. It is vital that they should be, vital not only for the security of the people of Northern Ireland but vital for the peace of this whole island that at no time should it be possible for anybody to say in the months or in the years ahead that people in Northern Ireland of either religion, minority or majority, are being massacred and cannot be protected.
Britain has a duty never to allow a situation to arise which could create pressures of a kind that could disturb the peace of this part of Ireland as well as the country as a whole. Britain must face that. Britain has a duty to ensure that her forces are adequate for this purpose and to ensure if at any point in time those forces ever proved inadequate she would immediately call in forces from elsewhere, from the United Nations, to protect that situation. She must never have a situation in which the people in Northern Ireland are being killed and left without protection. That would be intolerable. If Britain did that she would have to take a terrible responsibility for any consequences. That needs to be said.
To the minority in the north one can only say, put not your trust in the Blaneys and Bolands. They are using you for their own ends. Do not, I appeal to you, be dragged into a power struggle within the Fianna Fáil Party. We all know that it is impossible and will remain impossible for this country to provide armed protection under any conditions for the people in the Falls Road. To pretend otherwise in order to play politics with the situation would be to encourage people to go to their deaths and their blood would be on our hands.
What we now need to do in this situation is to rebuild the relationship of confidence with Britain that has been shattered by these events, to ensure that if a crisis arises we shall have the moral authority necessary to demand adequate action from Britain or if Britain were ever incapable of taking that action to demand and secure she handed over responsibility to the United Nations.
To all the people of the north can we from this House say that there is something approaching unanimity, except for the small group that supports Deputy Blaney? Can we tell them that the great majority of the people here wish them well, that they want to foster the forces of moderation in Northern Ireland?
I do not think that we can too often repeat the policy that we ennunciated last September and which has the support of the vast majority of this House, that the re-union of this country can and should be achieved only with the consent of a majority of the people of Northern Ireland. If that is accepted, if that is maintained, if all of us or most of us, the great majority of us, stand firm on that, then, in time, the tension will diminish and the fears will diminish and policies of pressure and force will give way to alternative policies of co-operation of different kinds. That is the only road to the ending of Partition, the end of force. That we can do if we stand firm against the Blaneys and their allies.
To the world we can only say: do not judge us by these men, nor by the fumbling of a Government, unprepared for this crisis, elected at a time of political aberration in our holy past. Ireland remains, all appearances apart, a democratic state with a Parliamentary system which, whatever its defects, can rise to a situation like this. A country, we are, in which the rule of law applies as the prompt action taken by the Taoiseach to deal with these guilty men must demonstrate.
Every State has its own point of weakness; Britain has assimilation problems; in France, Algeria; in Italy, the Mafia; and, in the United States of America, the problem of integration. It is not easy for a man to become fully civilised. There are forces in all of us, in all countries, in all peoples near the surface, easily aroused, which can easily break out. We are not alone in this. We say to the world that we are not the only guilty people—far from it. Our record is better than most. But these forces are all too easily aroused by dangerous men.
We are a young State overshadowed by an immense burden of history which we are struggling to master. Out of a bitter Civil War we created a soundly based Parliamentary system, and it is a source of pride to this party, a proper pride, that less than ten years after that Civil War ended, this party handed over power peacefully to those whom it had defeated. That has not often happened in the history of the world. It was the foundation of peace in this country. Let us forget all the divisions that the Civil War created. That was the crucial test. Out of that we found the peaceful existence of this State.
There was in the early years of Fianna Fáil Government moments of aberration on both sides, but quickly we settled down and before the end of the 1930s this was a Parliamentary democracy of, I think, a model kind until shaken to its foundations by these events. The surprise is not that the forces of unreason and violence exist, because they are in all of us, but rather that we have mastered them so well against the background of that history. Let us tell the world that Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland are atypical. Their Civil War mentality is not shared by the rest of their generation, nor by the next generation, nor, may I say, by the previous generation who have for the most part forgotten and forgiven those events.
Others have made personal references. I do not wish to do so, though I could do so to make a point, but I should like to refer to one Deputy on the other side of the House, to make a contrast, if I may. I should like to contrast the Tánaiste with Deputy Blaney. Deputy Blaney told us his father was under sentence of death. The Tánaiste's father was executed in circumstances which were particularly tragic. The Tánaiste has never in word or deed shown resentment for that. He has throughout forgiven his father's enemies and we honour him for it. If Deputy Blaney were that kind of man this country would have hope of peace.
Comment on this
I have one more thing to say. I want to emphasise again that throughout this affair the Opposition's role has been constructive. It took one action only. Deputy Cosgrave went to the Taoiseach to tell him what he knew. We have, I think, shown that we can act responsibly and we have shown that we are united. We have shown that we can serve the interests of this country in Opposition and, possibly, we have shown too that we can serve the interests of this country in government, as we may well have to do before very long.
Comment on this
It is now about 35 hours since this debate began yesterday morning. Something up to 80 speakers have already taken part. We can, I think, say that it has imposed a great strain on many people and particularly on the staffs of Leinster House. At this stage, and lest I might forget later on, I should like to pay tribute to them all.
Comment on this
The restaurant staff had a particularly heavy task, helping to sustain us during these long hours. I should like to pay tribute to the Editorial Staff who worked so efficiently and almost heroically in the circumstances. I do not think I could go through all the various members of the staff but, on behalf of Deputies, I convey to the staff our thanks and appreciation. I should also like to convey our appreciation to the members of the various news media who covered this important debate so excellently and so well.
Last, but by no means least, I should like to thank the members of my own party for the stamina, forbearance and good humour they have displayed despite many provocations, over the past 35 hours.
This is one of the longest debates, if not the longest debate, in the history of this Parliament. It is not the longest in the history of these islands, as they are called. There was a debate some years ago in 1881, which lasted 41½ hours, a continuous debate. We have as yet nothing to boast about. We have not made a record.
I hope Deputies will forgive me if I do not reply to all the points made in the course of the debate. I know they appreciate that it would not be possible for me to reply to every point. There was much repetition during and I anticipated that there would be these 35 odd hours and 80 speeches a good deal of personal criticism of myself and of my colleagues in Government, criticism of decisions I took or the way in which I took them. I am not minimising the importance of the subject matter of this debate but in many cases, I think Members on the benches opposite used the occasion for purely political party advantage. I think that applies particularly to the overall conduct of the Fine Gael Party. One speaker after another got up, asking me for information. All contrived to keep me from replying until after half-past nine when they knew that what I would say could not appear in the Sunday papers, except, perhaps, in those circulating in the immediate environment of Dublin.
Comment on this
It matters not that the Opposition, and Fine Gael in particular, used this situation for their own political advantage. What matters is that the trust the Irish people placed in me through electoral and constitutional means, when I was elected Taoiseach, has been honoured as far as I am concerned to the best of my ability and to the best of my judgment.
I hope I will be able to answer most of the points raised by Deputy Dr. FitzGerald, at any rate. I dealt with this situation as far as I could and to the extent I could within certain strictures imposed upon me, first, because of the source of the information available to me and, secondly, because of subsequent action that might have to be taken.
I shall start by referring to a 'phone call on 17th April from Aer Lingus Cargo Terminal to the Department of Transport and Power about an approach regarding the bringing in of a consignment of arms from Vienna to Dublin Airport. I think the purpose of that communication was that under the rules of IATA, the International Air Transport Association, arms may not be carried on certain types of planes and they required clearance from the Department of Transport and Power. The official in the Department of Transport and Power who received that telephone call from Aer Lingus immediately communicated with his opposite number in the Department of Justice. That official in the Department of Justice felt it was an unusual request and decided immediately to consult the Minister or secretary, or both. He discovered, however, that they were both in consultation and instead he consulted immediately the chief superintendent in Garda Headquarters. He informed the chief superintendent that the Minister and secretary of the Department were in conference and he did not wish to disturb them but that he would like a report from the chief superintendent in the meantime and as soon as he had an opportunity of speaking to both the Minister and the secretary he would do so.
At this point I think there is a slight mistake in the account given by Deputy FitzGerald. There was no question of a delay or no complaint about delay from Garda Headquarters in respect of this query. The Minister and the secretary having consulted, perhaps together first and then with Garda Headquarters, decided that it would be as well to let this consignment come in and immediately opened up an alert on Dublin Airport. The consignment did not come in and the alert was extended to other parts of the country.
I am talking now about the inquiry on Friday 17th. When I came into the picture on Monday 20th I ensured that this alert would be as effective as it could possibly be made. In the meantime the Garda took statements from officials of Aer Lingus and of Customs and Excise and on Monday 20th I received from the secretary of the Department of Justice, in the absence of his Minister, reports of these statements and investigations. Having perused them I asked for further reports and on the following day, Tuesday, 21st April, I received these further reports. They included a lot of names and dates and I decided to take the reports home and study them. Because of the reference to two members of the Government in some of these reports I decided to interview these members of the Government.
The following day was Wednesday 22nd and the Minister for Finance being one of the members of the Government mentioned I rang him soon after I arrived at my office, because he was on my own floor of Government Buildings. I was told that he was due in but that he had suffered a fall from a horse as a result of which he was slightly injured and was expected later.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt, but could the Taoiseach tell us was the Minister for Justice in the country on that day?
Comment on this
He was in the west of Ireland. We had a Fianna Fáil Party meeting starting at 11 o'clock that day here in Leinster House and I went to the party meeting having left word for the Minister to contact me. At about 12 o'clock I was approached by the secretary of the Department to say that the Minister's injuries were more serious than anticipated and that it might well be that he would not be in a position to introduce his Budget. About 1 o'clock, when the party meeting was over, the secretary and deputy assistant secretary of the Department came and told me that the Minister would definitely be unable to introduce his Budget because he was seriously injured and was then in the Mater Nursing Home. I decided there and then to introduce the Budget. The Financial Resolutions following the Budget were not very complicated and it was not a very difficult task on this occasion.
Having introduced the Budget, I made further inquiries about the condition of the Minister and I was told that he was very seriously ill, that he had a fractured skull, a broken eardrum and an injured clavicle. I forget if it was fractured or dislocated. I decided to await some progress by the Minister and I did not then interview the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. I telephoned the doctor of the Minister for Finance on two or three occasions and he told me that, while the Minister could talk on matters that would not be of any serious moment, even if they were not serious, he could not concentrate for more than a few minutes. I did not ultimately get permission from him to go until the following Wednesday, 29th April.
Having got permission from the doctor to go then but to be sure to be brief and not to be too serious—I did tell the doctor that it was a serious matter that I wanted to discuss with the Minister for Finance—I summoned the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries just before I left for the Mater Nursing Home. As I told the House already, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries denied that he had any part in the transaction in connection with which his name was mentioned. After a very short time talking to the Minister for Finance, having heard his denial, I felt it was unfair for me to continue because he was in a very weak state. He was almost unable to articulate and his breathing came heavily. His hand was in a sling; his face was swollen and I decided to leave rather earlier than I had intended; but I had said to both of them, as I indicated, that the information that I had would justify my asking for their resignations. I should have said that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries asked for some time to consider the position. Because of the condition of the Minister for Finance I felt I just could not possibly pursue the inquiries with him. However, I had investigations continued because the information was by no means conclusive—far from it, in fact. As part of these investigations, I had consultations jointly with officers of the Special Branch of the Garda and the Army Intelligence Service, and the Attorney General and the Minister for Defence were also present at these consultations. The Minister for Justice, who would have been the other appropriate Minister, was not present because he had entered hospital some days previously.
The purpose of that meeting was, first of all, to co-ordinate as well as I could the evidence that was available from both of the special sources and also to receive guidance from the Attorney General as to what steps could be taken in the circumstances in interviewing two persons whose names were mentioned in connection with this importation.
I want to say before I proceed that I did not at any time have Minister's homes watched during this investigation. There is in all States a security system whereby telephones and other communications are intercepted. It applies in this country as well as in other countries. The intercept, as they call it, is put into operation only on the basis of a warrant signed by the Minister for Justice under the Post Office Act, 1908, and it may be issued only where required for security purposes or for the prevention of detection of serious crime, information as to which could be got in no other way.
It is circumscribed by other conditions in that the request for a warrant must come from the commissioner of the Garda Síochána or the deputy commissioner, and the officials of the Department of Justice must advise that they are satisfied the information concerned can be obtained in no other way.
I want to say, Sir, that it has always been the policy to decline to say whether or not a warrant has been issued in a particular case. This policy is necessary for the obvious reason that, if denials become customary, a refusal to deny an allegation in a particular case would be taken as an admission that a warrant existed thereby nullifying the value of the warrant. In the unusual circumstances which have arisen however, I feel that an exception, limited to this occasion only, is justified and I, therefore, now give a categorical assurance that neither in recent times nor, for that matter at any other time, has a warrant been issued either in respect of the telephone or the correspondence of any member of the Government. I can go further and give the same unqualified assurance in respect of each and every Member of the Dáil and Seanad. I say this, Sir, to indicate to my former Cabinet colleague, Deputy Kevin Boland, that there was no attempt whatever at imposing Gestapo methods on any member of the Government, certainly none that I directed and none so far as I could ascertain.
I have referred to the conference I had on 30th April with the Attorney General, the two top security men from the Army and the Garda, and the Minister for Defence. I said that the reason was to co-ordinate some of the information that I already had and to get guidance about what might be done in respect of two individuals whose names were mentioned in the course of the reports I had read.
On the day following that consultation and directly as a result of it Captain Kelly who has been mentioned in the course of this case—and there is another individual whose name has not been mentioned and, because of the sources from which I have my information I feel I cannot disclose it at this stage, and because of other action that may follow—was arrested under section 30 of the Offences Against the State Act which could require his detention for a limited period of 24 hours, I think, renewable if necessary without specifically bringing a charge. Its purpose is to give a man a chance of explaining himself if he has an explanation and to let him out within a limited time. I should, perhaps, have made myself familiar with the particular section but I do not think it was necessary for the purpose of my statement.
At all events Captain Kelly was interviewed on Friday morning, 1st May, and some time before 1 o'clock I received a telephone message to say he refused to make any statement in the Bridewell Station but that if he was confronted face to face—I think he said that in his own statement as published and, therefore, I feel free to say it here in the House—with the Minister for Defence he would make a statement. The Minister for Defence went to the office of Chief Superintendent Fleming in Dublin Castle to which place Captain Kelly had been brought in the meantime, having been given lunch.
The Minister told him that he should tell everything he knew and made some reference about his competence as an officer. I believe the Minister felt rather sorry for the plight in which Captain Kelly found himself. However, the Minister then left and, at about 4 o'clock or shortly before it, I had another telephone call to say that Captain Kelly had begun to make a statement but after the usual preliminaries, date of birth, occupation, address, decided to say no more. He said that if he was brought to me— and this is the message I got—he would name names. I readily agreed to see Captain Kelly and perhaps, within 20 minutes or so, he and Chief Superintendent Fleming arrived at my office.
I then asked Captain Kelly was he prepared to talk to me and, if so, would he prefer to talk to me alone or with the Chief Superintendent in the room. In the meantime I had asked the Secretary of my Department whether, if I needed him, he would be able to come in and he said he would. I told Captain Kelly, when Chief Superintendent Fleming left the room, that, if he was going to make a statement to me I was not an investigator nor was the Secretary of the Department, and that I should like to have him present so that what Captain Kelly said could be corroborated. He objected to the Secretary of the Department coming in so I agreed to his telling me what he wanted to say. He refused to tell me anything.
I said to him: "You asked the Minister for Defence to go face to face with you in Dublin Castle and that you would make a statement then, and you refused. You asked permission to come to me and said you would name names and make a statement and again you refuse." He said: "Well, that is the position." I kept him for some minutes talking around the subject but he refused to give me any information whatever, so then I consulted with Chief Superintendent Fleming and I asked if he could leave. Captain Kelly did say that if he was let go free people would come and make statements. I consulted Chief Superintendent Fleming. I told him this and Chief Superintendent Fleming said he had no authority to let him free.
In the meantime, I consulted the Attorney General. He told me the chief superintendent had authority to detain him for some further period and did, in fact, do so. I believe that ultimately Captain Kelly was released the following morning or early afternoon—not yet having made any statement. Some time later—I think on the Friday evening— the other gentleman who was named was brought to the Bridewell, I think, and he made a fairly comprehensive statement. It appeared to corroborate to some extent—I should say to a considerable extent—some of the reports of which I had had sight.
Before I leave this part of what I am going to say I should just like to mention that as a result of my investigation, I was perfectly satisfied there was an attempt to import arms; that the source was Vienna, not Czechoslovakia.
Comment on this
I think they were transferred from Frankfurt to Vienna. There was no mention whatever of Czechoslovakia in this transaction. I have told the House already that, in relation to the action that I subsequently took, in asking the two Ministers to resign, I felt I would have to take that action not on the basis of legal proof but on whether either or both Ministers was or were touched by the slightest suspicion following my investigations. Then, as I saw it, my duty was clear.
After having got further reports in the meantime, I think I went to the IMI conference in Killarney that weekend; yes, it was on the Saturday, 2nd May. When I came back to my office on Monday, I got some further evidence which was not very conclusive but nevertheless it was evidence. As I said already, because of the security aspect of this matter, I am unable to give the source of this information. I have already indicated Army Intelligence and Special Branch of the Garda. Having already passed copies of the relevant documents to the Attorney General for his perusal, and for whatever action he advises, I am also inhibited from disclosing the content of the statements I have read. I want to say, as well, that Mr. Berry of the Department of Justice and the Garda officer, an Army intelligence officer whom I met, acted most efficiently and conscientiously.
I made specific inquiries as to whether any Exchequer moneys would cover, roughly, a transaction of this size. I am told that the probable cost would be of the order of £30,000, not £80,000. I had the usual sources from which one might expect these things could be paid for, checked. The Secret Service Funds amounted to £11,500 and had to be spread over the Departments which draw on these funds. Therefore, there was no question of the Secret Service funds being used. As well as that, it was established for me that all moneys expended by the Department of Defence were expended as voted by this House. Therefore, I do not know where the moneys came from that paid for these goods, if they were paid for.
I want to say categorically that I have had no contact with any other source and, specifically, that I had no contact with Westminister or with anybody in Westminister. I got no information from Westminister about this transaction. I got no direction from Westminister and no advice from Westminister about any action I took. I want to say that here deliberately and categorically.
One can understand that, during the two weeks while I was receiving and sifting information and interviewing people, these two weeks were not easy ones for me. Much less easy, of course, was the decision I took. I think it is not unreasonable that I thought long and considered much the action I was to take.
Deputy Blaney came into this House in the same year as I did. With Deputy Boland, we received our seals of office on the same day 13 years ago from An tUachtarán. We had grown to political maturity together.
Deputy Haughey became a Minister some few years later. The four of us were close as far as harmony in administration was concerned. Each one of us, in our different Ministries, in our own way, desired to serve the country in the most efficient way we knew. Certainly, it was for me a sad day when our Ministerial paths had to part. All three of them had long family traditions—as we have heard. I think they are entitled to proclaim that service to the country and towards the fight for freedom. Through their families, they have given service and endured considerable suffering. It made the task all the less easy that I realised that my family had not the same traditions of service or of membership of the Fianna Fáil Party and that I was asking these two men to resign and that Deputy Kevin Boland resigned because he objected to my handling of the affair, obviously. This did not case the heartbreak of my decision. I knew the effect it was likely to have on the political future of able and brilliant men.
Deputy Haughey has, in a statement issued yesterday, said he regarded his political future as less important than the future of Fianna Fáil. But his political future was and I hope could yet be particularly bright. I had to put all these considerations aside. I had to put aside any consideration I would have for my own personal position. I did not know what effect it would have on the party. I did not know what view the party would take and I felt it was my duty to do what I did. I should like to come now to the position of Deputy Moran, and later I shall answer as well as I can some of the specific points put to me by Deputy FitzGerald. I felt, for some time before he entered hospital—I think it was on Budget day or the day after it—that the Minister for Justice, Deputy Moran, was far from well. The information I got from his medical adviser was that his immediate treatment would require some three weeks detention in hospital and that he would also require some months subsequent treatment. I obtained permission from his doctor to visit him. I went to the hospital on the morning of the 4th May and I discussed with him his political future. I returned to him on the evening of the same day and he tendered to me his resignation, in his own hand, on health grounds.
I announced the resignation of the Minister to the Dáil the following day. After I had made the announcement Deputy Murphy asked me if the resignation was asked for. I replied that it was tendered. Some point is being made out of this to the effect that I was not truthful but I never said that I did not ask for the resignation.
Comment on this
I wish to say quite candidly that to my knowledge Deputy Moran was not involved in the importation of arms. I did not wish him in any way to be associated with the action that I felt was imminent in the case of two other Ministers. I was conscious, too, of his physical condition and, frankly, I did suggest to him that he should resign because of that condition and mainly because of the length of time that he was likely to remain under medical treatment.
That brings me to the suggestion about the reply I gave to Deputy Cosgrave after I had announced the resignation of the Minister. Deputy Cosgrave asked:
Can the Taoiseach say if this is the only Ministerial resignation we can expect?
I replied:
I do not know what the Deputy is referring to.
The Deputy says that I passed that off by some kind of remark but I think if it is read within the context of my next exchange with Deputy Cosgrave when I asked if he would like to enlarge on what he had in mind, it will be seen that there was nothing sinister in it. I do not consider that a crime. I knew what I had in mind but I was not going to give information there and then to Deputy Cosgrave. However, if he had given me any indication as to his knowing something I might have said that I had something in mind.
Comment on this
I have read the question and my reply and I do not think there was anything sinister in that reply——
Comment on this
——if it was read in its full context. However, if the Deputies opposite wish to make capital out of that they are welcome to it.
Comment on this
I should have said that Deputy Cosgrave came to me that evening. I acted quickly then but I had already made up my mind. I will not comment any more about where Deputy Cosgrave got his information. He showed me a document but I will not even tell the House what that document was like because there has been some comment as to whether the information was on headed paper. I will leave it to Deputy Cosgrave, if he feels like it, to do so. At any rate, he was kind enough to show me a document on which was a cryptic message.
At this point I wish to say a word about Deputy Gibbons, the Minister for Defence. Deputy Gibbons came to me occasionally, sometimes of his own volition, sometimes at my request, and we discussed largely the operation of the military units along the Border. We also discussed his information in so far as activities within the Six Counties were concerned. He came to me on occasions for advice about different matters but on no occasion did he ask my advice or make any report to me about any other Minister. There were many rumours in circulation in August and September last about IRA activities. I do not remember these rumours going on as late as October. I made certain statements at the time. If I had followed up all the rumours that were then in circulation I would not be here today but in some other kind of institution.
At no time had I any reason to suspect that Deputy Gibbons was engaged in any activity that did not befit his office. Allegations made following the opening of this debate have been thoroughly examined. As a result, I am satisfied that Deputy Gibbons was not involved in the importation of arms. If I were not so satisfied I would not now be asking the House to approve of his nomination as Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.
Comment on this
I wish to say that I regret the departure from the Cabinet of the Minister for Justice. He was a gruff man but he was also a brilliant lawyer and a good Minister. As some newspaper commentator has said about him, he has a tough exterior but he is a tender man at heart. I also regret the resignation of Deputy Paudge Brennan. He, too, was very conscientious in his postion as a junior Minister and I regret that he decided to take the action he did.
All these events which were precipitated by my request for the resignations of two senior Ministers might have had a serious effect on our party. I am glad that the party have solidly stood behind my action. I expected that they would not do otherwise because, as Taoiseach, I was entitled to take this action. It was my prerogative. Not only the party generally but the persons in respect of whom I had to take action have fully endorsed my right to do so.
Whatever about the party, whatever I did, my primary duty was to the country and to the people and I did not shirk it. It was part of that duty to pursue the policy that I have pursued in relation to Partition and especially the current situation in the Six Counties. I need not state it again. I stated it more fully than ever it was stated at the last Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis and I am sure Deputy Dr. FitzGerald will have access to that. Our policy is to seek reunification of the country by peaceful means and to avoid anything, especially in present circumstances, that would induce in any way violence, destruction or bloodshed.
Mention has been made frequently of the sacrifice of the 1916 men. At Arbour Hill earlier this week we commemorated the sacrifice of these men and women who fought in 1916 and who subsequently fought in the War of Independence. There are not very many of them left but the vast majority of those who are still alive say that the use of arms again to try to unite our country is abhorrent to them and would not be conducive to reunification and, indeed, on the contrary would be counter-productive. They do not want to see the unity that we have achieved jeopardised. Certainly I do not either. They want to see peace maintained both here and in the Six Counties and I do too.
Extremists on both sides may well wish that this peace would not be maintained but I believe that the availability of guns in unauthorised hands, no matter in whose hands they are—I know little about guns, in fact I get sick in my stomach when I think of guns in the hands of immature, unauthorised or irresponsible people— but no matter in whose hands they are if they are not authorised, then they are a danger. They may be bona fide held for defensive purposes but these defensive purposes can, in certain circumstances, easily become offensive purposes. I do not know if many of the Deputies opposite are old enough to have seen a film that I saw in my young days called: "They Gave Him a Gun." It was the story of a young soldier who went to war, got used to firing guns for legitimate purposes and continued it for illegitimate purposes when he left the army. I believe, Sir, that it is my duty to ensure, as far as I can, that no guns or arms of any description are sent from this country to the territory of Northern Ireland. I believe that by the children of those who feel guns are necessary—they may be extremists on one side or the other—by their children and their children's children, I would stand condemned if I, in the position I hold, having some authority or some influence in relation to these matters, facilitated or assisted in any way the sending of guns to the Six Counties which might be the cause of bloodshed. I said that they might be held for defensive purposes but that they might easily become offensive. There have been allegations—and let us be quite clear about it—of unlawful importation of arms into the Six Counties not from this part of the country but from abroad. If this is true—and I believe there is some considerable evidence of it, particularly on the Unionist side—then this is highly dangerous but, no matter whose hands these guns get into, I want to say that they can only lead to destruction and bloodshed and only retard whatever unity or whatever fraternity we have been trying to promote in these counties.
I want again to express my disagreement with my colleague, Deputy Boland, when he says that it is a matter for them to get their guns if they want to from some other source but not from here. It certainly is something that we could and should ensure that they will not get them from here but, because of my abhorrence of this violence, I would feel that guns to any unauthorised source from anywhere are a very serious danger.
In answer to another allegation by Deputy FitzGerald that no attempt was made to prevent the Ministers taking their private papers from the office. I said that I was not convicting them of any crime on what amounted to legal proof. There was no attempt to search their houses and I do not think there should have been in the circumstances.
I want to come back again, Sir, to the Northern Ireland situation and I think it is relevant to the matter that we have been discussing here for the last 36 hours. People have been coming down frequently from all parts of the Six Counties ever since and even before 12th August last year. They have come down for many purposes. Some of them have come down asking for ammunition and for guns. They have seen me and other Ministers. They have seen the Minister for External Affairs and the Minister for Defence. I want to say —since the Minister for Defence will not be intervening again and the Minister for External Affairs has not intervened in this debate—that neither of them gave any indication whatever that our Army was standing at the ready to go into the North of Ireland. I have that categorically from them. I told successive groups that we could not and would not send troops across the Border. I said to do so would be an act of war and only this House, not the Government, is entitled to make an act of war. I told successive groups too— and they came I am sure in genuine fear and in the conviction that they needed guns—that we could not supply any guns either because I felt possession of arms on any side would be dangerous.
One person who had seen me early on—Patrick Kennedy, MP—said he came to see me and he deplored my lack of knowledge of the situation. I feel that was rather unfair comment. He said that all he got from me was a ticket to London to see Mr. Callaghan or Mr. Wilson. I think I did try to arrange some facilities for him to fly out from Dublin Airport. He was particularly disappointed that I could do nothing else but that was perfectly consistent with my policy right through this period and with the policy of my colleagues.
Whether I like it or not—and I do not like it—British troops are in the Six Counties. The British Army have responsibility for keeping the peace there and I agree entirely with Deputy FitzGerald on this. They have the responsibility of protecting the lives and the property of all the people and if, because the Catholic population are in the minority in the Six Counties and feel that they are defenceless in the event of an attack by Unionist extremists armed or otherwise, then the British Army and the other forces of law and order have a special duty to protect them there. I have been assured that those forces are adequate for the purpose. It seemed to us that last year they might not be adequate. Deputy FitzGerald referred to the idea that we should go to the United Nations. The Deputy will see the difficulty we had going there last year. I agree entirely that unless the British—and there is an obligation on them in present circumstances—can guarantee the protection of all the people in the Six Counties, then they will have to do something else as well.
Comment on this
Unless they can guarantee the protection of all the people. I do not like this situation any more than anybody else here. I have been pressing for the full and speedy implementation of reform and the provision of civil rights in the Six County area. I believe that the moderate Unionists wish to live in peace and harmony with all their neighbours, that the removal of discrimination at all levels will show to others, the people who do not want to live in peace and harmony, that they, too, can live side by side, that they can work together, play together and I might say even pray together as, thank God, we Christians of all denominations are doing on this side of the Border. This is in pursuit of the Christian ethic. I believe it could extend from one end of the land to the other so that ultimately we could all say that we could live as the one nation we really are.
I want to assure all the people, north and south, especially those who are apprehensive of coming months in the north, that the Government here and the Fianna Fáil Party will do everything they can to avoid an outbreak of further trouble. I want to say to Deputy O'Brien that we are not stricken with a dangerous, infectious sickness nor incubating germs of possible future war. I think I have spoken enough about the Six County situation. Deputy Garret FitzGerald has also referred to it.
The general debate has thrown up many attacks on the Government, on individuals of the Government and on me personally. The members of the Opposition spoke about the dangerous situation in the Six Counties. Some of them said the situation was highly charged so in the light of that situation some of these contributions were irresponsible when at a time, according to their own assessment, one would expect a more reasoned and responsible debate. Their tactics in exaggerating and embellishing the position out of all proportion and in trying to convince the country that there is a major, national crisis is the height of irresponsibility.
Most outlandish rumours were trotted out in the course of the debate. Anything anybody learned about anybody, no matter how unbelievable, was quoted as if it were a fact. It was quoted with a halo of authenticity. We even had a coup d'état coming up in a short time. Of course, inevitably we had references to civil war on several occasions. If there is a tense situation in the north, because of apprehension about the availability of arms, the situation has been well and truly defused by the action taken by me. This reprehensible and irresponsible type of tactic by the Opposition—dangerous in the extreme— suggesting civil war and coups d'état was employed for party political gain.
If the purpose of the debate was to show the country a responsible alternative to the Fianna Fáil Party, then we have nothing to fear. Members of the Fine Gael Party in particular, by their filibustering tactics and their repetitive speeches, succeeded only in bringing ridicule on themselves. Every Deputy from the Fine Gael benches who was in a physical position to stand —I am not making any allegation in this—or read had a script thrust into his or her hands. Speeches were turned out from the type of slot machine which so readily provides Fine Gael policies as they are required. They had the happy advantage, give them their due, of having a well-organised roster. The rest of us had to stay up all night. It was good organisation for once but it was not any great credit to the propounders of the Just Society who had little regard for the people who wanted to end the debate and hear as much as they could.
This long-drawn out debate had, however, one merit. It was a typical example of democracy in action. A matter of national importance was debated without limitation in our open Parliament. The Government and their members, individually and collectively, were subjected to the severest criticism, some of it, perhaps, deserved. This is the democratic way. This is the precious heritage we have. We must safeguard it dearly and never allow any action of ours or even any suspicion of any action to undermine this heritage and this birthright.
The motion before the House is to approve of the three young men I have nominated to be members of the Cabinet. The approval by the Dáil will complete the Cabinet and will enable us to get on with our work. I know it will be a source of great relief to Opposition Deputies when I say there will be no dissolution. This great democratic party will survive the present difficulty. Indeed, it has already done so because it is a great and democratic party and a resilient party—the only party capable of embracing the aspirations of all sections of our people. It is the only party really capable of leading them to the fulfilment of a united, peaceful and prosperous Ireland.
Comment on this
Would the Taoiseach be good enough to clear up a matter to which he referred, but not in full? I refer to Captain Kelly. Captain Kelly admitted that he had some part in the smuggling of arms. He also said that the designate Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Gibbons, had full knowledge of what he was doing. Deputy Gibbons came into this House and denied this. There was a rejoinder from Captain Kelly that Deputy Gibbons was telling lies——
Comment on this
I think he went so far as to call Deputy Gibbons an "unmitigated scoundrel". I should like to know if any further action is to be taken here or if this taint of suspicion is to be attached to the designate Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries —possibly the same type of suspicion that has led to the resignations of the two ex-Ministers sitting behind me?
Comment on this
I explained to the House that I was satisfied before this debate started that Deputy Gibbons carried out his duties in accordance with the full requirements of his office. When these allegations were made during the course of the debate I had him very carefully and thoroughly investigated. As a result of that investigation I am satisfied that Deputy Gibbons——
Comment on this
There appears to be a discrepancy between the Taoiseach's initial statement the other night and his statement tonight. Could he please elucidate this point? Between the 17th and 21st April, acting on what the Taoiseach first described as the "slightest suspicion" and what he described tonight as "by no means conclusive evidence, far from it"— those are the Taoiseach's words—he visited Deputy Haughey and Deputy Blaney. Did the Taoiseach then on that "slightest suspicion" type evidence ask for their resignations?
Comment on this
First of all, I do not think the Deputy should read any significance into the different phrasing. I think it means much the same thing. I was speaking from notes this evening that were not comprehensive. The following day was Budget day. I think I told the House fairly clearly, both tonight and on the last occasion, that because of the accident that befell Deputy Haughey I could not interview him on that day.
Comment on this
It appears from the Taoiseach's initial statement that he asked for the resignations on the "slightest suspicion". Does the Taoiseach still stand on that statement? If he does, why did he not sack Deputy Gibbons on the "slightest suspicion" ground also?
Comment on this
It was somebody else, not I, who cast suspicion on Deputy Gibbons. I did not see any statement from Captain Kelly.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?