We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Social Welfare Bill, 1970: Committee and Final Stages.

Contributions 1–180 of 361. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Social Welfare Bill, 1970
Enacted

No. 14 of 1970 ›

In regard to the death grant, the Minister said it was not intended to be a funeral benefit, that it was not big enough to be such. Surely the whole object of the grant is that it will assist those who are really in trouble. Over the years I have been receiving requests from people who have had deaths in the family and who have been asked to pay fantastic sums for funerals. Local authorities will supply what somebody said had disappeared out of this country, a pauper's coffin, for about £9 10s. What I cannot understand is that the coffin appears to be exactly the same as the one for which the ordinary person pays £40 or £45. Either the people who supply the coffins charge far too much or this grant is far too small. There is a change in the amount of the grant given according to the size of the child. As far as adults are concerned the expense will be the same regardless of the size of the coffin. The grant of £5 even for a very small coffin does not meet the requirements at all. When it is said it is not a grant for the purpose of paying for a funeral, I think it should be or the nearest thing to it.

Comment on this

I suspect there is something in what Deputy Tully has said. I must confess it is purely suspicion. I have no facts on which to base it. Deputy Tully may be correct.

Comment on this

What I say is always correct. The Minister knows that for a long time.

Comment on this

I am afraid I do not, but in this respect in regard to the differences in the price of coffins what he says may have some substance. It may well be that far more is charged for a coffin in the circumstances of an ordinary funeral than is charged in the case of one provided for a pauper's funeral. However, in case I am doing an injustice to the people concerned I must make it clear I have no facts on which to base this. It is merely a suspicion.

I am not quite sure what can be done but certainly nothing can be done under the Social Welfare Bill as regards the amount of grant provided for here. We are making a start and we do not claim it is the end of the road. The whole scheme has been worked out and I cannot undertake at this stage to do anything to step up the grant.

Comment on this

This is a provision about which the Minister should do something. If I read the section correctly it means that a person who qualifies for an invalidity pension must have either 47 stamps or credits in the last year or 47 stamps or credit on average for his insured life. I assume that that dates back to 1953 when the change took place. For instance, take somebody who was involved in the recent cement strike and who for 12, 13 or 14 weeks was not allowed to draw unemployment benefit, and was not entitled to any benefit, and for that reason did not sign on at the labour exchange. Maybe it was stupid of such a person not to sign on; he might not have been allowed on the grounds that he was on strike when in fact he was not. Take also the people who were on strike. Both sections would be debarred from this grant, if my interpretation is correct, within the next 12 months. The number 47 is too high and the Minister should have gone back to the qualification for old age pension and disability benefit and made it 26 with a sliding scale up to 47 or 48. The other arrangement is far too harsh. I can imagine somebody saying "We are doing something good now and we will just put it in as it is" without realising what the effect might be. There is also the problem of people who go to England or who may have been employed on a "lump" job, about which we heard so much. Both of these sections could find themselves ineligible for this grant if they wanted to take advantage of it.

Comment on this

The same procedure applies in regard to all benefits and persons who are in the position described by Deputy Tully can, at a later date, qualify. The number of persons who would be precluded from qualifying in the circumstances he described must be quite small. He is assuming that the persons concerned have, say, been involved in the cement strike and within quite a short time become otherwise entitled to an invalidity pension, but the number of persons in that situation would be small.

Comment on this

I am saying that if any of the persons involved were applying within 12 months they would be ruled out. Things like this do happen, not every year but every couple of years. There are strikes; there are reasons why men take a few weeks extra holidays, or they will do some work for themselves and they will not have 47 stamps or credit. These people will or can come outside this particularly stringent provision. The Minister says that this is the same qualification but he knows that it is not. Twenty-six is the normal qualification and why should 47 be written in here? It is a new departure. The Minister should have another look at it.

Comment on this

We are dealing here with long-term illness and they get credit for that and will eventually come into this.

Comment on this

This is a principle which if we accept it then the Minister will say to me when we come to another section "We have already accepted that principle". If the Minister is persuaded of the validity of my argument will he try to do something about it before it goes to the Seanad? The Minister should not say that he is going to look at it when he is not going to do anything about it. The Minister said that several times already today.

Comment on this

I was about to say that I will ask the Minister for Social Welfare to have a look at it.

Comment on this

Here again we have the same argument and here it has even more force because this section applies to somebody who would be retiring. The reason which the Minister gave me would not apply in this case. A person is entitled to draw certain benefit but would not be entitled to draw this new benefit unless he had the new qualification. When we are talking about improving social welfare we should do something which will improve it rather than take a retrograde step.

Comment on this

The Deputy can hardly contend it is a retrograde step when it is a new benefit but I know what he means. He means that the conditions being applied are retrograde.

Comment on this

I am using the word "benefit" because it is the Minister's word. I know that the reason for this is to take people off the unemployment register and I commented on this on the Second Reading. There will be a substantial reduction in the unemployment numbers when this comes in but I do not want to go into that again.

Comment on this

Neither do I want to follow the Deputy up that road because we might spend a long time on it and we would not agree. In any case I will ask the Minister for Social Welfare to have a look at this before the Bill goes to the Seanad.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to explain this. When the Minister was introducing the Bill he said it was bringing in something which would allow people who did not apply for a non-contributory old age pension to apply for this benefit and I said that if they did not apply for a non-contributory old age pension I was sure they would not apply for benefit for somebody who was looking after them. The Minister changed that and in his Second Reading speech he referred to the fact that it was intended for people who were over the limit for non-contributory pension and their being 70 years of age the people looking after them would qualify. Is that the situation? Will persons who because of a means test are ineligible for the non-contributory pension be entitled to this allowance in respect of somebody who is looking after them?

Comment on this

I think the Deputy may be talking about another section.

Comment on this

No, section 10.

Comment on this

I think it is section 21.

Comment on this

I am sorry. I was looking at the explanatory memorandum which gave it as section 10. It refers to the original and it must have been altered.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 1 in the names of Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Tully has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

It has been the case that payment can only be made when there is proof that the person is dead. It occurred recently in my constituency that a person was drowned and there was no proof of death for a considerable period. As a result, social welfare benefit could not be obtained by the people affected. Eventually, an arrangment was made. However, if something were written into the Bill it would be possible to pay the money in cases where it is reasonable to assume that the person is dead. Would the Minister consider looking into this matter?

Comment on this

What the Deputy had in mind in his amendment involved more than we could contemplate. The House might be interested to know that there are some cases, with which the Department have dealt, in which the husband was missing for more than 25 years.

Comment on this

At one time Deputy James Dillon mentioned the case of a husband who had been missing for 37 years.

Comment on this

We know that the day after the wife got the pension the husband returned. In circumstances in which death may reasonably be presumed, the Department does presume death. In the circumstances described by Deputy Tully I think the benefit would be paid in a matter of perhaps weeks, or certainly months. Provided the other conditions are complied with, the Department in following the usual procedure in cases of presumption of death would follow that practice in this case and benefit would be payable.

Comment on this

It is stated in section 19:

Regulations shall provide for the return, subject to any conditions, restrictions and deductions specified in the regulations, of so much of any contribution paid by an employed contributor or a voluntary contributor who entered into insurance for the purposes of paragraph 9 of the Fourth Schedule to this Act after he had attained the age of fifty-five years as is determined in accordance with the regulations to have been paid in respect of retirement pension.

Perhaps the Minister would like to elaborate on this?

Comment on this

One of the contributions conditions proposed in the Bill for retirement pension is that the claimant must have entered insurance before reaching the age of 55 years. A person who enters insurance after the age of 55 years will be precluded from deriving any benefit from the element for retirement pension in any employment contribution or voluntary contribution paid by him or on his behalf. The purpose of this section is to provide for regulations to allow the refund to an insured person who enters insurance after the age of 55 years of his share of the element for retirement pension in any contribution paid by or in respect of him. The amount of the element attributable to retirement pension will be determined under regulations.

Comment on this

Would it not be more convenient to arrange that there should be a second stamp involved so that the person over 55 years entering insurance would not be required to stamp and thereby eliminate this rather ponderous business of refund? It is only a matter of pence that is involved so far as the retirement pension is concerned.

Comment on this

I am advised that it would not be practical to do it that way. A similar provision was made in the Social Welfare (Amendment) Act, 1960, which introduced the Old Age (Contributory) Pension Scheme.

Comment on this

Regarding the question of the voluntary contributor aged 55 getting a stamp each week, what is included in that stamp as a voluntary contributor?

Comment on this

I do not know the amount as it has not yet been determined. However, it will be small.

Comment on this

I should imagine it would be merely a matter of pence.

Comment on this

It will certainly be lenient.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 2 in the names of Deputy Tully and Deputy O'Connell has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 3 in the names of Deputy Tully and Deputy O'Connell has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I should like to avail of this opportunity to clarify some points. At present I understand that if an old person is living in his or her own house and a female relative undertakes to care for the aged person a sum of £2 5s per week is paid and under this section the amount is £2 15s. However, if an old person is living alone in an isolated district and a neighbour undertakes to care for that old person, does the woman of the house who takes in the old person qualify for an allowance under the present Act or will she qualify under this section?

Comment on this

In order to qualify the person who cares for the aged man or woman must be a relative. I take it the case the Deputy had in mind did not concern a relative?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I shall be satisfied if a relative who takes in the person can qualify.

Comment on this

That is the position if she fulfils the other conditions.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The case I have in mind does not concern a relative of the old person. However, would the Minister not think it might be a good idea to extend the section to cover such a case? Part of west Cavan is very isolated and there might be cases of an old person living on his own in a very remote area with no relatives nearby. The only alternatives open to the old person is to go to St. Phelim's Hospital or to live with somebody else. If a neighbour would be prepared to take in the old person and care for him would the Minister not consider it might be worthwhile to extend this section to cover this category? Conceivably, it could lead to abuses but I am sure that regulations could be worked out. I think the old people would probably be happier living with some people in their own locality than they would be living in an institution 40 or 50 miles away. At any rate, the Minister assures me that if a relative takes them in the relative will get the allowance. I should like him to tell us what he thinks about the person who may not be a relative.

Comment on this

That is a qualified relative?

Comment on this

Yes. The qualification is pretty wide, I think: sisters, half-sisters, daughters, stepdaughters, granddaughters, daughters-in-law and nieces.

Comment on this

Why is "wife" not included? Would the Minister not agree that the wife who is looking after an elderly husband should receive something?

Comment on this

The reasoning behind this allowance is in respect of someone who has to give up a job.

Comment on this

That was changed last year.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It just did not work at all under that regulation.

Comment on this

It is either someone who had to give up a job or who did not follow an occupation because of this situation.

Comment on this

The Minister has named the qualified female relatives. Why has he left out "wife"? There must be some reason why the wife is not considered to be a qualified female relative. In most cases it is the wife who looks after the aged husband.

Comment on this

It is to compensate for a situation that does not normally arise. The case of a husband and wife is a normal situation.

Comment on this

But they can be just as hungry. This is for the purpose of giving people something on which to live. This allowance is given so that an old person who has an approved female relative looking after him or her will have enough to live on but, if that old person happens to have his wife living with him, she is not covered. We cannot force the Minister to change his mind but I think he should have another look at this.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The object of this section—it is a very laudable section—is to encourage relatives to look after aged relatives at home instead of sending them into institutions. If the section is flexible enough it will encourage relatives to look after aged relatives and the old people will be happier among their own. Secondly, it will effect a considerable saving to the ratepayers and taxpayers because I am sure it must cost £10 or £12 a week at least to keep an old person in an institution. In the case of a relative taking an old person to live in her house there should be no means test so far as the former is concerned because she is effecting a saving for both taxpayers and ratepayers.

I strongly urge that the section should be made even more flexible. The whole idea is to encourage people to look after aged relatives. There should be no means test when the person being looked after is in receipt of a pension. In the case of an old person with means I would be in favour of a modest means test. An old person with means can afford to pay someone to look after him or her; but in the case of a person in poor circumstances, the means of the relative who is prepared to look after the old person should not be taken into account.

I am 100 per cent in favour of the principle behind this section. As things stood, this just did not operate. The number who benefited, as was stated in reply to a Parliamentary question, was negligible. There was a considerable improvement last year. I expect there will be a further improvement this year. The means of the relative should not be taken into consideration if the relative is looking after a person in receipt of an old age pension in the relative's own house.

Comment on this

I am concerned about this question of a female relative. In many cases a son looks after the aged person or, perhaps, a younger brother. Why should it be confined to a female relative? Why not a male relative? The whole purpose is to keep people out of the county homes and institutions. The saving would be tremendous. We should encourage relatives, male or female, to provide this care and attention for the elderly. In the case of those who give up employment to look after aged relatives, what happens about resumption of employment benefit? Do they lose that benefit? I should like the Minister to clarify these points. Sometimes a neighbour looks after an old person. Why should the neighbour not qualify? This must be made as flexible as possible in order to keep these old people out of institutions.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Sometimes a male relative comes home from England to look after the old people. The farm is just above the level that would entitle him to a small farmer's dole. He really considers he is wasting his time. If he got this small allowance it would be an incentive to him. I support the point made by Deputy Dr. O'Connell.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Fitzpatrick. It is an admirable approach. Introduced only two years ago, it has since been improved and improved again and, in all likelihood, will be further improved. I cannot undertake now to extend the improvement beyond what is contained in the Bill for this year. The means test applies to the pensioner—not to the recipient. In the case Deputy Fitzpatrick had in mind, a case where the benefit was not given, it probably arose not from a means test, because there is not one, but because the other person involved—possibly the husband of the niece, in the case he mentioned —was capable of giving the care and attention required, though I am not sure, in the circumstances he described. The pensioner is treated as living alone, even though he may not be living alone, if the people with whom he is living are not capable of giving the care and attention required.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): A form is sent out refusing this application. I think it is under the small figures “3” or “4” of that. The person in respect of whom the allowance is claimed is being looked after by her husband or her husband is capable of providing for her or something like that.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot throw any light on that particular case.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I should be better briefed on it. I am sure the officials of the Department know the case I am talking about.

Comment on this

With regard to the point raised by Deputy O'Connell, as to the extension of this to male relatives, I am sure he can visualise some of the problems of abuse of benefit involved. I cannot promise anything on this. According as experience is gained of the operation of this scheme, the likely development is that it will be found possible to extend it—very possibly on the lines he suggests—but with adequate safeguards.

Comment on this

The benefit is actually paid to the old person?

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

What about people who provide this care and give up employment to do so?

Comment on this

If a person gives up employment, in the circumstances described by the Deputy, and thereby ceases to make social welfare contributions, such person loses the benefit of that, as a result.

Comment on this

It is very unfair that such people would be thrown on the scrap heap.

Comment on this

They would have to go in under assistance schemes instead of insurance schemes. They are not completely bereft as a result. I admit they are in a somewhat worse position than if they had been working. When the scheme was confined to those who had given up employment, very few people were involved.

Comment on this

In giving up employment, these people forfeit pension rights, service promotions, and so on. Would it be possible for those who give up employment to be credited with stamps, and so on, during the time they are providing this care? In the event of death of the person they are caring for, can they resume and qualify for all the other benefits that go, in later life, to people contributing to the social welfare fund? It would seem only fair.

Comment on this

I could not contemplate that kind of extension at this stage of the Bill. I shall draw the attention of the Minister for Social Welfare to this point so that, in the almost inevitable extension of the scheme, it will be taken into account.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 4 and 5, in the names of Deputies O'Connell and Tully, have been ruled out of order.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Let us be gracious and welcome this section. It is something we have advocated for some time. It is long overdue. I want to repeat what I said on the Second Reading that this should be worked in a flexible manner. I was rather perturbed to hear the Minister for Social Welfare state that it would be necessary for wives who claim to be deserted to pursue as far as possible their legal remedies to claim maintenance from their husbands. If this is pursued any distance at all, it will render this section valueless. Very few husbands who desert their wives in this country stay around. They usually emigrate to Britain or to some other country. It is impossible for the deserted wives to contact them. Even if they did so, or knew their addresses, it would be unreasonable to compel them to take court proceedings. Litigation in Britain is quite expensive and almost invariably involves advance payment of fees and expenses. The regulations should be very flexible this year and, if it appears that there are obvious abuses, they can be dealt with by amending the regulations.

Comment on this

I support Deputy Fitzpatrick. Unfortunately, perhaps, for some of these wives, Britain is very close at hand and the husbands go abroad and the wives never hear from them. I have made representations on behalf of a few hundred of these women who have been deserted. They have their husband's British insurance number. If they write to the British national insurance authorities about it the British authorities will not give the address but say that, if they write to them, they will forward the letter. These husbands draw social welfare benefit in Britain in respect of their wives in Ireland. The husband in Britain may send £1 now and then. Even if they remain here, they very commonly send only £1. In many of these cases it may be claimed by the Department that the husband is contributing. If he contributes £1 every month or every two months, or very infrequently, I would still say the wife has been deserted by her husband. Perhaps the Minister might like to comment on this point.

Comment on this

It is not intended to interpret this absolutely rigidly. First of all, in the case where there are some contributions, if they are very infrequent, the Department would be prepared to accept that this amounts to desertion. Secondly, it is a relatively simple matter for a wife in these circumstances to obtain a maintenance order in the district court here, but the difficulty is in the enforcement.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

The Minister for Justice is looking into this question of enforcement in conjunction with the British. If a maintenance order is obtained in the district court, and if it is not possible to execute it, the Department of Social Welfare would accept this.

Comment on this

Excellent.

Comment on this

They would not insist that you go ahead and bring proceedings in Britain as well. In the normal case with which we are all familiar, if you get a maintenance order here and you cannot enforce it in Britain, in those circumstances, the Department will accept that as constituting desertion.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Will they insist on court proceedings here?

Comment on this

I think this is reasonable. Let us put the obverse, that the Department would not insist on this. It would be wide open to abuse and collusion if you did not have some effort made to have the wife at least try to make the husband contribute. It is only if you cannot do that that the Department should step in, I think.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I know of a case where a woman was deserted by her husband over 20 years ago. He left her with one child. He went to England and she has never heard from him from that good day to this. She does not know where he is. She reared the child in very difficult circumstances and made a good job of it. He is in employment now. The world and his wife in the district know that she was deserted. The husband has never been seen around there. She has been in receipt of assistance of one sort or another from the local authority on the grounds that she was destitute, or practically destitute, or in need of assistance. I do not know whether she could now take proceedings. I suppose she could but, without looking up the Act, I do not know. Probably the court where she is living has jurisdiction.

Surely a certificate from the local authority or the home assistance officer of the home assistance department of the local authority who have been looking after this woman for the past 20 years should be sufficient to satisfy the Department that she was, in fact, deserted. Local authorities are not too soft about paying out home assistance.

Comment on this

As I said, the Department do not intend to be rigid about this and, in the kind of circumstances described by Deputy Fitzpatrick, they would not insist on a maintenance order being obtained.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): So long as there is flexibility.

Comment on this

This is what is intended. If there is satisfactory evidence available, such as that described by Deputy Fitzpatrick, it would be accepted, but the cases I am describing are——

Comment on this

Recent ones.

Comment on this

Yes, and they are relatively frequent. As Deputies will appreciate, there is a danger of collusion in these cases. In such cases I think it would not be unreasonable that the Department should insist that the wife should obtain a maintenance order and see if it could be enforced. If it cannot, the Department should step in. Where it is quite clear that this would be a useless exercise the Department would not insist on that.

Comment on this

It is a very difficult problem, indeed, as everybody recognises, and there is a danger of collusion and even a danger of promoting this tendency, on the part of people who want to break up their homes, to go away and feel that the local authority and the State will look after them. Those dangers exist without a doubt. The proposal about the maintenance order is obviously a good one and Deputy Fitzpatrick's suggestion is also a good one. We all appreciate that if we were in the position of a local authority officer attempting to make a decision we would find it very difficult indeed.

I wonder could the Minister go into all the different kinds of situation that arise in order to give some guidelines to the local authority officers so that people in this very difficult position would be given some support by defining these situations, not so much for our benefit, but for the benefit of the local authority officers, which would help them in turn not to promote abuses but to feel that we have not circumscribed their right to allocate grants.

It is extremely vague at the moment. This is not a criticism of the Minister or the Department because I have nothing very helpful to offer myself. Those two proposals would appear to me to be the kind of proposal which would be of great help to local authority officers in their attempt to administer this valuable piece of legislation.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There is another society which have done much good work in this area over very difficult years, that is, the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children. The Minister's Department would be quite safe in accepting a certificate from one of the officers of that society who for years have been trying to trace these men in England and could not do so.

Comment on this

They have been able to find them in the majority of cases.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): They have not got any money out of most of them.

Comment on this

Very rarely did they get money out of any of them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): With respect, I think the Minister is on the right lines if he accepts a certificate from the local health authority, or the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children, or some reasonable evidence like that.

Comment on this

This is what we have in mind. I do not think I mentioned local authority officials. This came up in some discussion.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I mentioned them.

Comment on this

In fact, there would be a local social welfare officer who would make the inquiries and who would be briefed as to what he was to look for. A certificate from the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children would be satisfactory in some circumstances, or, perhaps, even a certificate from a local clergyman. It is intended to be quite flexible. It is not intended to adhere rigidly to either one form of evidence or a maintenance order. The guiding line has to be that, in the absence of an application for a maintenance order, the evidence available is reasonable and sufficient to ensure that there is no danger of collusion. It is intended to be flexible in approaching that.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I can never be accused of being in favour of giving blank cheques to Ministers or Departments but, in this instance, I would be inclined to give them a cheque for a limited amount. In the past hardship has been caused under Social Welfare Acts by laying down regulations for the protection of Revenue or the protection of the fund which is the word used in the Department. They could not go beyond those regulations. I would be in favour of writing into this that where reasonable evidence is available—and let some appeals officer decide it if necessary—that the woman has been deserted and has not been supported by her husband, and that she cannot reasonably enforce a claim for maintenance against him, it should be accepted.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any rough idea as to how many such people there are in the country at present?

Comment on this

About 1,000.

Comment on this

Would it be of any help to find out the kind of case put forward by those 1,000 people?

Comment on this

It would be difficult to do that, probably, until this is operating. I would suggest to the House that the situation as I have described it is about as flexible as we could make it, and that the wisest thing would be to see how it operates. If it is thought that it is being administered inflexibly the matter could be raised here but I am assured that it is intended to operate it flexibly as I have described consonant with the obligation to ensure that it is not used as a form of racket.

Comment on this

It is only fair to say that the Minister for Social Welfare said the very same thing.

Comment on this

The Minister says that there are approximately one thousand who would qualify under this section for an allowance. This provision is very much welcomed because up to now these people have been dependent on the local authorities for home assistance. It might be said of local authorities and those who approve estimates and strike rates that they are not very generous either with this group or with any other people who have not sufficient to keep themselves and in many cases their families. I am sure that all these people—whether they are more or less than one thousand makes no difference—are looking forward to the payment of this allowance from approximately, the first week in October. I am sure they will expect to have a decision made very quickly, in a month at the outside. I want to ask the Minister if he has sufficient outdoor staff to deal with not only these cases but with the various other changes this measure will bring about.

I know many social welfare agents and I think it would be no exaggeration to say that they are very much overworked. Their job is supposed to entail a five-day week but the Minister and his officials must know that they are constantly engaged after normal working hours in their own houses still working for the Department of Social Welfare. They do this work also on Saturdays and Sundays. If they are to investigate circumstances and establish that wives have been deserted it will mean much more work. I am concerned about both parties, the social welfare agents and the deserted wives who expect to get this allowance reasonably soon. There have been complaints—and possibly in this House also—about the work of social welfare agents. I suppose many Deputies can particularise, but I think it can be said in respect of all of them and, at least, of those with whom I have contact that they are very hardworking. They are deemed unpopular with certain people merely because they must carry out the law as decided by this House and the regulations as decided by the Minister.

The Minister should have a serious look at the new work that will be imposed on social welfare agents, particularly in the period when desertion must be established. I suggest the Minister should, if possible, try to recruit personnel from his Department to ensure that deserted wives will get their allowances in good time if they qualify. Failing that, the Minister should give the agents some compensation for the overtime they do every weekday and on Saturdays and Sundays.

Comment on this

The officers who would be involved would be social welfare officers, not the agents the Deputy mentioned.

Comment on this

I beg the Minister's pardon: it was social welfare officers I meant.

Comment on this

I understand the Department anticipates that they will be able to handle these cases reasonably expeditiously. I would anticipate that in a number of cases there will be no great problem. For instance in some cases maintenance orders must have been obtained and found to be unenforceable. There would be very little difficulty in these cases.

Comment on this

They would be very much a minority.

Comment on this

These are some cases. Others will fall into the category described by Deputy Fitzpatrick where the local knowledge forthcoming will be conclusive and there will be no problem. The number of applicants who will present a problem will, I hope, be relatively small. I cannot speak with any certainty about it at this stage but I do not think that the Department of Social Welfare has any reason to anticipate that the number concerned or the problems will be so great as to cause undue delay in payment.

Comment on this

The Minister does not like hypothetical questions but if it appears to him after a few weeks that these applications will, of necessity, have to wait another month or two, will he have the position examined and, if necessary, give compensation for overtime, say, at weekends or employ more staff? Does he intend to get social welfare officers to consult, as has been suggested here, with the ISPCC? I know they have their fingers on practically all these cases in a majority of, but not in all the counties of Ireland?

Comment on this

Yes, this is intended.

Comment on this

I can see great difficulties in the administration of this scheme. Once the pension is issued how often will it need renewal? Will there be spies to see if the husband is home or anything like that? We want to be assured that the deserted wife is not humiliated by these activities on the part of officials. Will there be many problems about the administration of this scheme?

Comment on this

The deserted wife in this case will be treated in the same way as the widow is treated. I admit that in the widow's case there is no risk of the husband turning up but there is the possibility that she may marry again. There are periodic checks in the case of widows but I do not think this is found onerous.

Comment on this

Will they be more frequent in the case of deserted wives?

Comment on this

No. It is intended that they will be on the same basis as in the case of widows.

Comment on this

Perhaps I was wrong when I said that this and nearly every measure that has been introduced for a long time by the Department of Social Welfare have meant more work for the social welfare officers. Could the Minister say if, in respect of the whole Bill, an undue amount of work will be placed on these officers?

Comment on this

We cannot say positively at this stage but if there is, steps will be taken to deal with it. There are over 200 of them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): As this is a new section it is no harm to throw out all possible suggestions. The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to children has been mentioned. It has done great work and I am glad the Minister will refer to that Society. Another society that has done good work in its own way is the St. Vincent de Paul Society. In many cases they have been doing their best to contribute to the support of deserted wives for years. It might be no harm to have it on record that it was suggested that an assurance from that society that, to the best of their knowledge, a wife was deserted should carry considerable weight in convincing the Department she was, in fact, deserted.

I should like to add to what Deputy Corish said about social welfare officers because I believe they are concerned about the amount of work this Bill will place on them. I am not sorry that it will place additional work on them because that means that more benefits will be brought to people who need them but if the officers are to have considerable extra work thrust on them they should be adequately compensated. I understand they are looking into the matter at the moment——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that we are moving away, and have been for quite some time, from what is in the section.

Comment on this

We want to make sure that the deserted wives will get their allowances in time and this is related to the number of officers who will do the investigating.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The section is concerned with the payment of benefit.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): With respect, Sir, this was a very worthwhile discussion on this section, and it is a new section. I shall not delay the House very much longer, but I do appeal to the Minister to see to it that the social welfare officers are looked after and compensated for any additional work they do or time which they will have to spend in operating this Bill when enacted.

Comment on this

I wish to ask the Minister a couple of questions. If a lady had paid an insurance contributed of an amount which would have made her eligible for a contributory pension, could she get the contributory pension as a lady who had been deserted?

Comment on this

Could she get a contributory widow's pension?

Comment on this

A contributory-level pension.

Comment on this

No, unless she can establish she is a widow she cannot get a widow's pension.

Comment on this

The Minister does not think that if she had paid contributions she would be eligible for the contributory widow's pension?

Comment on this

Not unless she establishes she is a widow.

Comment on this

Supposing she was deemed to be a widow under legislation some time ago?

Comment on this

That is different.

Comment on this

Wait a moment. Will there be a means test and will the pension of which she is now in receipt be regarded as means for the purpose of assessing the allowance she will get as a deserted wife?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be more specific. I am not quite clear what he means. Is he talking about a pension?

Comment on this

Married women have been deemed to be widows by reason of the fact that they have not heard of or could not trace their husbands for a certain number of years. They may qualify for a widows non-contributory pension. What I want to know is this: in deciding as to whether or not there would be a deserted wife's allowance paid, would this widow's pension be deemed to be means?

Comment on this

If she is qualified for a widow's pension she would not be qualified for the deserted wife's allowance. It would be one or the other.

Comment on this

No, but she is deemed to be a widow because her husband has deserted her.

Comment on this

I do not think there is any such case. It is only where the husband is deemed to be dead; then she is treated as a widow. If he has deserted her she comes under this.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It takes a lot of evidence to have him deemed to be dead.

Comment on this

We had the case earlier this afternoon of the man missing for 35 years who reappeared the week after his wife got the widow's pension.

Comment on this

The day after, I believe.

Comment on this

Sorry, the day after. I hope she took appropriate action to qualify. There is a qualification here that she must be between 50 and 70 if she has no children. This could limit the number of people who would qualify and the amount of money which will be paid out. Can any provision be made for the person who has no children to look after, who has been married for a number of years, whose husband has deserted her, who is unable to work due to illness and who has no entitlement to sickness benefit? There are quite a number of these people.

Comment on this

The woman in that situation would be in the same boat as the single woman who was unable to work, ill and so on.

Comment on this

The Minister is very kind to make that point. I was hoping he would, and I intended to ask why some provision could not be made for these people. People over 50 are in the very same situation as the single people, as the Minister says, but under 50 if they are ill there is a difference. Many of them would be suffering from mental strain and so on. A single person has this advantage. She may possibly at that age get married, whereas the married woman whose husband has deserted her, being under 50, cannot hope to. If she is unable to work due to illness she is in a very poor way, depending on the charity of the local authorities, and local authorities look with a very jaundiced eye on these people before they give them any benefit. They are really hardship cases.

Comment on this

I agree that the situation of such a woman is a difficult one, and a single woman in these circumstances has to depend on public assistance, and this would be the position of a deserted wife under 50. Fifty was chosen because from that age on it becomes increasingly difficult to get a job anyway, but Deputies will appreciate this is new and it is experimental. It certainly is conceivable that the qualifying age would be lowered in the future, but at this experimental stage we do not consider it prudent to put it any lower than that.

Comment on this

Could a small subsection not be added that they would be entitled to benefit on production of a certificate showing they were ill and would be permanently ill? There is just one other matter. In regard to the woman who is drawing a widow's pension, if my memory serves me rightly the age has been reduced from 50. If it was 50, and if it has been reduced, what is it now?

Comment on this

There is none now, I believe.

Comment on this

The Minister will agree that what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

Comment on this

There are certain overriding considerations. First, there is no reason why a deserted wife should be treated better than a widow. That would be accepted, I think.

Comment on this

She should be treated as well.

Comment on this

I agree, and I hope this will be so. There are a couple of snags to it but I would hope she would be treated in the same way as a widow if it is accepted that she is a deserted wife.

Comment on this

This year?

Comment on this

Not this year.

Comment on this

Always mañana.

Comment on this

In view of the uncertainty of the definition of the word "deserted" and the Minister's own problems and our problems, would it be any help to his Department to introduce draft regulations and have them discussed here so that they could be amended when the Minister is bringing in regulations under subsection (5)?

Comment on this

There is a problem about this. We should not get the scheme going by October. I see no possibility of getting them before the House between now and then. However, they will come before the House, so that Deputies will have an opportunity, if they wish, of expressing views but, as I say, we could not get the scheme going by October if we were to adopt the Deputy's suggestion.

Comment on this

There is one final question in relation to the payment of allowances. It says here:

...has been paid in excess of the rate determined by that decision to have been payable shall be recoverable as a debt due to the State.

Would this be from a local social security official? If he had overpaid somebody, is this an attempt to recover money from him?

Comment on this

No, from the recipient.

Comment on this

If the recipient had misled the official then I see the case for taking it back but if the officer had not been able to make up his mind, like most of us here today, about what constituted a deserted wife, would he be liable for any error he was considered to have made?

Comment on this

No, not the officer.

Comment on this

Who would recover? The local authority?

Comment on this

As far as the officer is concerned if he makes a mistake, suppose he makes a blatant error, then this is a matter for discipline within the Department and the question of recovering money does not arise. The money is recovered from the recipient only where there was a fraudulent application.

Comment on this

That is not clear in the subsection. There is no saver.

Comment on this

It might frighten the officers and they might be afraid to make any decision.

Comment on this

I would be a bit afraid of that. There is a remote case where we might attempt to recover the money from the recipient in the absence of fraud, say if the recipient won the Sweep.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think that it will frighten the officers?

Comment on this

Normally the attempt to recover would not be made except in the case of fraud.

Comment on this

There is no mention of fraud. It is very specific. I know that the Department does not operate that way but we should see it in the legislation.

Comment on this

I think it would be in the regulations. It is necessary to have a slight saver in the Bill.

Comment on this

If the Minister gives us an assurance that it will be in the regulations——

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It does not mention anybody, the recipient or——

Comment on this

I think it is implied that it is recovered from the person who receives it. However, I will undertake that it will be in the regulations.

Comment on this

In the case of an annulment of a Roman Catholic marriage in which the State does not recognise the annulment would the lady be eligible as a deserted wife?

Comment on this

This will have to be considered as we go along. The decision in such cases will amount to whether or not the husband has deserted the wife.

Comment on this

If they are separated.

Comment on this

But if he has deserted her, in other words, they could be separated and he could be contributing to her maintenance. If he has deserted her then this would apply.

Comment on this

The marriage is annulled by the Catholic Church.

Comment on this

An annulment either in the church or in the courts does not absolve him from the obligation to contribute.

Comment on this

But in the particular case which I have mentioned will she be considered——

Comment on this

If he has deserted her then she would come in under this.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Surely if the marriage has been annulled and the husband has gone off, that would be the best possible evidence legally that he had deserted her. He would not have deserted her for the purposes of what we are trying to deal with here, failure to support. You would have excellent evidence that he had in fact deserted her.

Comment on this

We are getting on to theoretical ground now. You could have an annulment by the church without the husband being relieved of his obligation to contribute to the maintenance of his former wife. You could have, but in the circumstances described by the Deputy I agree that the evidence would be pretty strong.

Comment on this

Is this the section which refers to the cottage and not the plot?

Comment on this

It is an increase of rates of old age pensions.

Comment on this

But substituting the means test.

Comment on this

I think section 36 is the section to which the Deputy is referring.

Comment on this

I will wait for that section.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 6 in the names of Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Tully has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this