We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Social Welfare Bill, 1970: Committee and Final Stages.

Contributions 181–361 of 361. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Social Welfare Bill, 1970
Enacted

No. 14 of 1970 ›

The amendment stated that "a woman whose husband is missing in circumstances in which, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, he may reasonably be presumed dead, shall be deemed to be a widow". Is there any way in which this can be dealt with? Again there is the matter of the man who returns after a long number of years. Such cases can arise. Men have disappeared and have not returned and the wives have been treated as grass widows—I think that is the term. Can there not be a limit to the number of years? It seems ridiculous that if a person is missing for four, five or ten years, he should not be presumed dead.

Comment on this

As I said on another section, in practice the Department operates what the Deputy had in mind in his amendment. There can be cases of 35 years where there is no presumption of death but on the other hand death can be presumed in a matter of weeks. What is involved is really the strength of the evidence which is available and not the length of time.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider advising investigating officers, who I understand investigate also for the Department of Defence, that it is not necessary to count the number of apples on a tree or to find out if hens are laying eggs? I know of such cases although I do not know of any in the last 12 months. This matter should be dealt with in a Christian way. It may be that they consider that if they do not do this strictly the Department may feel that they are not doing their jobs and they could be done without. They are a group of people for whom I am sorry because many people dislike them and feel that they are overstepping their duties. These officials should be told that they do not have to go into all the details. Apparently they start off with the idea that they must prove that people are not entitled to the benefit. I would suggest to the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary, who has a very soft heart, that the objective should be to see that deserving cases are considered and not to disqualify people, which appears to be the attitude of mind at the moment.

Comment on this

That does not happen weeks more.

Comment on this

A case like this occurred two weeks ago.

Comment on this

The Deputy will appreciate that this is a difficult problem because each person has a different idea of what is reasonable and what is unreasonable. There are divergent views on the question of shirking of duty by the officer and what is being unchristian. I know the attitude of the Minister for Social Welfare on this point because I have discussed it with him and I may add that my own attitude is the same. I do not go quite as far as Deputy Tully, to say that the attitude should be to see how these people can be fitted in——

Comment on this

Within the regulations.

Comment on this

However, one would hope that they would act as a normal conscientious person would act. Different people will adopt different aproaches but what is outlined by Deputy Tully seems to be going too far. I do not think it is common or widespread and I do not think the Minister for Social Welfare would want it to be widespread. That is not to say that the officers are to ignore the regulations and means but I think a reasonable approach is possible and, by and large, this is being achieved. In any case in which the bounds are overstepped, if this is brought to the attention of the Minister it will be made clear to the officer concerned where he should draw the line.

Comment on this

I think it would meet the wishes of all Members of this House if it went from the Minister to his most senior officers who are at present here down to the investigating officers in the country that they should have a more open and flexible attitude. If this is done I am convinced everything will be all right.

Comment on this

In this case it appears the operative phrase is "protect the fund". Apparently the officers work on this principle and I shall quote the following case to illustrate my point. An old man who had formerly been a tailor being self-employed had no stamps, and he had been getting food from people in return for patching clothes. An officer went so far as to visit all the people concerned in an effort to find out exactly what the old man had received. Eventually he got the old man disqualified not from a social welfare benefit but from an allowance he had from the Department of Defence. After some time the whole business was straightened out but it caused much distress. In cases such as this many of the officials are under the impression if they do not succeed in proving that an applicant is not entitled to benefit the Department will think they are not doing their job. I realise that the officers are doing a good job and if they get the same advice from the Minister which he has just given to this House there would be better relations all round.

Comment on this

Quite apart from the worry it may cause recipients and the unsatisfactory personal relations that may exist, I do not think an excessive amount of time should be spent on this aspect. On the other hand, it is not possible simply to ignore the fact that there are many people who try to defraud the Department of Social Welfare——

Comment on this

And vice versa.

Comment on this

What has been said here on this matter can be brought to the attention of the people concerned and perhaps it would help to clarify the situation.

Comment on this

Some instructions must be issued to investigating officers.

Comment on this

It is not the instructions but their interpretation that is the problem. This is not peculiar to the Department of Social Welfare but it exists in any large organisation. Instructions designed to meet both sides can be given but you will always find people putting their own interpretation on them. I am convinced that written instructions are not the answer; it is a question of attitude of mind.

Comment on this

Are there periodic conferences between departmental officials and investigating officers and how often do they take place?

Comment on this

I understand there are conferences about once a year and in addition they receive circulars from time to time.

Comment on this

There should be uniformity.

Comment on this

Yes, as far as this is attainable but it is not always possible.

Comment on this

There is one point about the number of people employed to which I should like to advert. It is said that there are not sufficient officers to go around and perhaps this may be partly responsible for the present rather unsatisfactory state of affairs. It is conceivable that if an officer has to do too much work he may be in a rather bad mood when he meets the applicant. I have been the subject of criticism from these officers because of the fact that they claim I have attacked them in the House. I want to make it clear that as long as they administer the system in the manner in which it is administered I shall attack the system and the person who, in my opinion, is guilty of maladministration. If there are not sufficient officers to do the job effectively, more people should be appointed; but they should be told that it is not their business to bend over backwards to deprive somebody of their just entitlement. Perhaps it is merely a matter of interpretation but if the officers think they are advised in a certain way very severe hardship can be inflicted on the poor.

Comment on this

I appreciate that point. However, steps will be taken to circulate this portion of the debate to the people concerned.

Comment on this

They buy the report. I am told they are very interested in the debate on social welfare.

Comment on this

I might add that a number of new posts were recently sanctioned by the Minister for Finance. They have been filled and the people have been trained.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Acting Chairman (Mr. P. O'Donnell) Fine Gael

I understand that amendments Nos. 7 and 8 are related and may be taken together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:

In subsection (1), page 14, lines 35 and 36, to delete all words after Part I in line 35 and substitute:—

"and Part II of the parts annexed to this subsection".

This is mainly for the purpose of putting down in tabular form what the benefits are. They are scattered all over the Bill as it stands. There is no easy reference. If someone wants to find out to what benefit he is entitled or what the regulations are he has to go from one page to another. I suggest it would be the easiest thing in the world to put them all together so that what is required could be easily seen at a glance.

Comment on this

I am in sympathy with Deputy Tully's aspiration in this but I am afraid I shall have to disappoint both himself and myself. First of all, the Minister on Second Reading referred to the fact that, because of the way this is done, it is difficult to know precisely what the position is but he went on to say that, specifically because of this, the explanatory memorandum had been designed to make the position clear. Despite my sympathy with the Deputy's aim, and I am very sympathetic to it not only in relation to this Bill but also in relation to other Bills, my problem is that I am advised that to do this would entail making other amendments in other parts of the Bill.

Comment on this

I have dealt with that actually.

Comment on this

It arises even more so out of the other part the Deputy mentioned.

Comment on this

I have dealt with it in other amendments.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, the Deputy has not yet come to that bit. This would, in fact, mean almost a recasting of the Bill by the Parliamentary draftsman. So I am advised and I must accept the advice.

Comment on this

I am always prepared to accept expert advice but, while I must accept the Minister's explanation, I am not happy with it.

Comment on this

I am not happy myself.

Comment on this

I do not believe it is as difficult as the Minister suggests. Why it has not been done has not been explained. I left out the death grant because it might have unfortunate complications. It would probably not be discussed. I imagine it would have put the whole thing out of order. Therefore, I had to do it this way. I honestly believe this is something which should not be thrown out immediately by the Minister. If the changes I suggest are made I cannot see how they could affect the drafting of the Bill. The Minister has his experts to advise him and I will have to accept what he says. If he says it cannot be done there is no point in trying to force the issue. All I ask is that someone will have a look at it. The Seanad will have to deal with this Bill and there should be no problem at all. It could come back here and we could agree to it. Usually, indeed, there is no debate on amendments from the Seanad. Because of the value of this I think it should be done. The Minister should consider it or recommend it to his colleague, the Minister for Social Welfare.

Comment on this

I would be misleading the Deputy if I undertook to do this. From what I am told it would entail so much recasting by the draftsman that it just would not be practicable to do this between now and the Seanad debate.

Comment on this

If there was a month to spare instead of a couple of hours I would have this out with the Minister. There is no time so I will concede it to him.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I should like to avail of this opportunity to ventilate a grievance a constituent has. She is a widow. She was married on 14th September, 1933, and she became a widow on 13th November, 1945. Her insurable employment record is as follows: she was in insurable employment with the Great Southern Railways from March, 1927, to August, 1933, prior to her marriage. She again entered into insurable employment on 12th December, 1949, and she remained in that employment until January, 1953. She entered the employment of CIE in January, 1953, and she remained there until 30th November, 1967, when she reached 60 years of age and retired. I understand CIE pay widows' and orphans' contributions for employees and, if that is so, this woman had a total of 24 years and four months insurable employment. Her application for a contributory pension was refused in 1968 under section 4 of the 1966 Social Welfare Act. Admittedly, the bulk of this woman's contributions would appear to have been paid after she became a widow. This is a case which would not arise very often and I would ask the Minister to look into the case on the facts I have given him. All her employment was with the railways, either the Great Southern or CIE. She was in insurable employment for six years prior to her marriage and 18 years subsequent to her widowhood. I ask the Minister and his experts to examine the case. It appears to me to have great merit. If the Minister agrees with me I would ask him to bring in an amendment on Report Stage to qualify this widow for a pension. I believe the Parliamentary Secretary knows the case.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Section 31 deals with the rate of benefit.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am sorry.

Comment on this

I will have a look at the case but, as a preliminary, I should say that it would appear as if the position is that there were no contributions to widow's pension before 1936 and, therefore, this woman did not make any contributions until after she became a widow. The Deputy will appreciate that one cannot really start contributing to an insurance fund after the risk has occurred.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The contributions were accepted.

Comment on this

But not only for widow's pension; for other purposes, too. If she were to marry again and become a widow, that would be different. That is what she would be insuring against. On that basis, I am not very hopeful.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Perhaps we could get a section on which this would be relevant?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 9 and 10, in the names of Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Tully, have been ruled out of order as irrelevant.

Comment on this

The Chair is entitled to rule an amendment out of order if its acceptance would involve a charge on the Exchequer and certain things. This is the first time I have heard of an amendment ruled out of order as irrelevant without the argument in its favour having been heard.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Ceann Comhairle is sorry to have to rule out so many amendments on this Bill on the grounds of irrelevancy. I must follow the long-established rule that amendments to an amending Bill must deal with matters relevant to some provision in the Bill as read a Second Time. The whole social welfare code is not thrown open to discussion on an amending Bill such as this.

Comment on this

I know—but I am not convinced. It is utterly ridiculous that social welfare benefit is not paid to entitled persons who have been stamping cards for a long number of years if, due to default by the employer, the card is not stamped. We incorporated a proposal in the amendment that there would be an extra 1d on the stamp to pay for the loss: therefore, nobody could say it would involve a charge on the Exchequer. I raised this point on the Second Reading. The Minister for Social Welfare expressed sympathy for the people concerned. He said it was difficult to recover from employers who went bankrupt. A great many wealthy employers fail to stamp insurance cards and brazenly refuse to pay the benefit due to workers even though they stopped the employee's share of the insurance stamp. Under the occupational injuries scheme the State pay the benefit and recover it from the employer. We suggest this as a way to deal with the problem. If the Minister for Social Welfare has not considered this aspect, or if it is not intended to do it immediately, would he and his advisers look into this matter and put an end to the grave hardship that arises due to the failure of an employer to stamp the insurance card for his employee. Frequently, such workers have been a long time with their employer.

Comment on this

The Minister for Social Welfare has been very concerned about this problem. He has been working on it. He believes he has a solution in sight that should be reasonably satisfactory to all parties concerned and that it can be done without legislation by way of regulation. He hopes to make such regulations in the fairly near future.

Comment on this

I wish it were done quickly. I am general secretary of a trade union which supplies legal aid to members. It is amazing the number of times we have to employ a solicitor to recover from employers money due to unfortunate people who are unemployed or ill and who may have been so for lengthy periods before coming to us with a complaint. Either the Department should recover it immediately or pay it and then recover it. They are in a much better position to do so. If there is a charge for the purpose of having it paid, I do not think there would be any complaint. Most people know that it could be their turn next time.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendment No. 11 stands in the names of Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Tully. I understand that amendments Nos. 12 and 13 are related and might be taken with it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 16—

(i) in line 18, to add "(Injury Benefit)";

(ii) in line 21, to add "(Injury Benefit)";

(iii) in line 24, to add "(Maximum Disablement Gratuity)".

Either these amendments will be accepted or rejected. They are matters which should have been included in the Bill. If the Minister wants to have them withdrawn and agrees to bring them to the Seanad that will meet me and my colleagues.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy's point is that they should clearly be visible in the Bill. He agrees that the benefits are provided for.

Comment on this

It is very difficult for people not used to reading Bills——

Comment on this

What I said last time about recasting the Bill applies with even greater force on this occasion. Therefore, I cannot accept the amendments.

Comment on this

I am not casting reflections on the parliamentary draftsmen who must experience extreme difficulty in finding all the awkward and big words used in any Bill coming before us, but how is it that they can find words which the ordinary person finds it almost impossible to understand and yet will not use words which would clarify the whole Bill? Maybe there is a legal reason for it that I do not understand. The late Deputy Seán Dunne always referred to Bills of this kind as "gobbledegook". There is a lot of gobbledegook in this. Perhaps, in next year's Bill, plain English might be used to describe what the sections mean.

Comment on this

Is this the section which prevents those in receipt of one type of pension from switching to the higher rate of pension for a short period?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

This is a rather mean section. To those who drafted the Bill, and possibly to ourselves in this House, the amount of money involved may appear very small. I travel among many people with limited means. The amount of loss sustained, even for short periods, is quite substantial to those people. They should not have been included. I am afraid I possibly tempted them to do it because I suspected something like this might happen and I put down a question to the Minister for Social Welfare a few months ago, shortly after the Budget, asking if this was happening this year.

I see it is being copperfastened by a section in this Bill. Normally they hoped no one would notice that, for a short period, they were entitled to a higher amount. It used to be August to the following January, or October to the following January. This time because it is a relatively short period and I am quite sure it was felt that the loss of £1 or £2 would not matter very much, but the loss of £1 or £2 to people who are depending on another few pounds per week to live represents luxury. This section should not have been put into the Bill.

Comment on this

The money aspect of this is, in fact, the least important from the point of view of the Department of Social Welfare. First of all, I should say that this section really underlines the policy decision taken by the Government that the increases should commence from the beginning of August. I should also say that, in a situation where a person would be entitled to the advantage envisaged here on a permanent basis, there is no restriction. It is only on the temporary one.

Comment on this

I know that.

Comment on this

A massive number of applications on a temporary basis would really strain the resources of the Department beyond endurance and would operate to the detriment of many other people who may, perhaps, be just as necessitous as these people.

Comment on this

Could the Minister not have considered putting in a small section saying that a bonus of £1 would be paid to certain pensioners who qualified? That would save all the massive correspondence to which the Minister has referred. In view of the fact that the Budget usually operated from 1st April——

Comment on this

Usually, but not this year.

Comment on this

The Minister will agree that this was an unusual year.

Comment on this

Not as far as the Budget was concerned.

Comment on this

In many ways.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that the time is coming when all payments should be made from the beginning of the new financial year? There is no use in saying that the amount of arrears would cause chaos in the Department. I know it would be difficult to make them up. The new prices these people had to pay operated from the day of the operation of the Budget and they should get compensation from the same date. If the will were there the way would be there all right.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is not careful we will not be able to pay them on time on the date announced.

Comment on this

We will manage.

Comment on this

It could be written up.

Comment on this

At least I know my social welfare legislation. I hope they are learning something.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 17, 18, 19, 20, 21 and 22 in the names of Deputy O'Connor and Deputy Tully have been ruled out of order as irrelevant.

Comment on this

I consider that suggestion from the people who ruled on those amendments, without explaining the ruling an insult to this House. Those amendments were put in pretty late and the people dealing with them were obviously in a hurry and the easiest way was to rule them out of order. I want to protest at the fact that this was done. I am not casting a slur on the Chair, who had very little to do with it except to send me a polite note saying they were out of order. That is as much as he had to do with it. It is too bad that this was done and I want to register a protest.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Would the Deputy like me to repeat the reason why they are out of order?

Comment on this

This is the section I wanted to deal with earlier. A number of years ago a change was made. For a long time a person could have an income of £26 per year without non-contributory benefits being affected. Then it was decided that there should be a change and the amount was reduced to nil. If a person had any income that could be assessed, the pension was reduced by 5s per week. This applied to non-contributory old age pensions and non-contributory widows' pensions.

When the question of income arose, many of us were surprised to find that a cottage or house occupied by an old person, no matter what condition it was in, was considered to be income. A vested cottage was considered to be income. A person who was unfortunate, or fortunate, enough to be living in a vested county council cottage, for which some of them were paying only 6½d per week, lost 5s per week to the State so the rent of the cottage was 5s 6½d and not 6½d. The same thing applied where somebody was living with a friend. A value was put on the bed and 5s per week was deducted because of the fact that the person had accommodation, even though he or she had to buy food, clothing and fuel.

The Minister for Labour tried to correct me here the other day. He said that so far as houses were concerned exceptions were made. I knew there was an exception and I said to him that the exception he was talking about was a tumble-down old thatched house in County Donegal. Deputy Paddy Harte had kicked up such a row that the house was eventually taken as not being means and that old lady got her extra 5s. I am aware of no other case in which the house has been exempted.

An exemption has now been put in for a county council vested cottage on which the annuity is not completed. For those who do not know what the situation is, let me explain that, when a cottage is vested, the amount of vesting may be from 6½d per week to 10s or 12s per week over a period of anything between ten and 44 years. The cottage and plot are one entity. Somebody put in a section here which precludes the house from being counted as income but not the plot. What did they think they were playing at? The two are paid for together and go together. In what way could the cottage be precluded without precluding the plot as well? Was the person who put it in not aware of this, or is there some special reason why it was done in this way? If it was put in with the full knowledge of the person who put this section into the Bill of what he was doing all I can say is, thanks for nothing. The people concerned get nothing out of it. They are living in the cottage and the plot is beside it. Can they dig up the cottage and move it away from the plot? Otherwise they are stuck.

When vesting is completed, all it means to the ordinary people is that they do not have to continue paying the small annuity of 6d or 9d or 11d per week, or whatever it is. If this went through as it is, the cottage and plot would be included and they would be back in the same position and would lose 5s a week as soon as they became full owners of the vested cottages. The Minister might have an explanation which may have escaped me and, if he has, I should be glad to hear it.

Comment on this

We have to go back a little to get the background to this. Some time ago the regulations were changed to bring the figure from £26 per year down to nil but in the case of unvested labourers' cottages the rent which was paid was deemed to account for the annual value of the House and, therefore, having the house did not count while you were paying the rent. Once you entered into the purchase scheme the value of the cottage was taken into account. The effect of this section is to take the value of the cottage out so that it is not true to say that people will not get any benefit. When Deputy Tully said: "Thanks for nothing; this does nothing for them" that is not correct. At least it takes the value of the cottage out of assessment where heretofore it was in.

Secondly, in the case of the plot, some plots may be completely unproductive and some quite lucratively productive and in practice there can be a considerable difference in the means derived from a plot. It is on that basis the distinction is made here. Even some people who have means in addition to the cottage and plot may benefit from a higher rate under this provision even though it may be a small improvement. To say this is not of benefit is quite inaccurate. It may not go as far as Deputy Tully would like but it operates as a relieving section and should benefit virtually all envisaged in this context and some who have a cottage and plot and some means in addition.

Comment on this

Does the Minister agree that the industry of the tenant in this case is being taxed, so to speak?

Comment on this

This is coming to the root of the whole question of means tests. One could argue—in fact, we have often heard it argued—that somebody who has been very industrious all his life and accumulated something for his old age, is penalised. This is a very old argument into which I do not think I should enter now.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will not think me rude but what he has just said shows that he does not understand the position. If the plot were productive and producing an income that income would automatically be counted whether or not the cottage and plot were put out of assessment. That income could be easily assessed and would normally be counted. If the plot produced only £26 a year, which would be the next step, it would not be very productive so that hare, as I said before, will not run.

The position, from what the Minister said, is that somebody was trying to be too clever and took out the cottage but did not take out the plot. Unfortunately, most of the vested cottages in which you find old people living have a plot either untilled or badly tilled because the old folk are unable to do it or it does not pay them. They do not use much of the produce and do not sell it. They are not in the market garden business. What the Minister has done by excluding the cottage and not excluding the plot is to leave them in the very same position as they were previously, and this applies to the whole class of vested cottiers.

I grant it may have been done in error by people who may not have known what the situation was. It is very easy to make a mistake. One can do something with the best intentions and it may still turn out wrong. I ask the Minister and his advisers to look again at this matter. The Bill will not have to be redrafted. It will simply mean taking out three or four words to rectify the position.

Comment on this

What Deputy Tully has said has reinforced what I said.

Comment on this

He always seems to be making the Minister's arguments for him.

Comment on this

I think it is unintentional on his part. He said that if the plot were very productive what was produced on it was taken into account and that there is no change as regards the plot. He is right in that but the point I made was that up to the operation of this section, which we hope will operate shortly, the vested cottage was taken into account in assessing means.

Comment on this

May I interrupt the Minister in order to save discussion? Even if the vested cottage is not taken into account the fact that the lowest level of the means test is nil means that even one penny income, which is the very least that could be put on the plot, will exclude the person from the highest category. There is no point in arguing.

Comment on this

They take off 5s a week.

Comment on this

That person loses 5s a week over one penny.

Comment on this

I should point out that it is the use that is made of the plot that counts. The ownership of the plot in itself does not constitute means.

Comment on this

If the ownership of the plot does not count, let it be taken out. There is no point in putting it in.

Comment on this

No, because that could get you into difficulty: there could be a substantial income from the plot in some cases.

Comment on this

But if the old age pensioner has a substantial income from the plot that will be assessed against him whether this section is here or not. We do not have to say to a farmer: "We are assessing you on what you are getting from your market garden and on the value of the land." Here we are saying: "If you have a market garden out of which you are not getting even a shilling we are still putting a value on it which will knock you out."

Comment on this

No, we are not saying that. Let me go back and point out to the Deputy that he has was wrong in what he said originally. We are, under this, taking out of assessment the value of the cottage. That is a change. Will the Deputy admit that?

Comment on this

Not unless the cottage and plot are taken out because they are the one entity, a point the Minister seems to miss completely.

Comment on this

May I repeat that the ownership of the plot by itself does not constitute means?

Comment on this

What does?

Comment on this

The use of the plot, the income derived from the plot is assessed.

Comment on this

It has not obtained up to now. If you had a cottage and plot it meant you did not get the maximum.

Comment on this

But that is for the reason I have been mentioning. Before it was vested the value did not operate because the rent was deemed to cancel it out. When it became vested it was calculated because there was no rent to set off against it. This section is restoring that position. You do not assess the cottage.

Comment on this

Suppose an old age pensioner has a small shop in a vested cottage, what happens? You assess what he is making whether this section is there or not. You assess what he is making out of his house and it will deprive him of the pension. What the Minister is saying here is that the land of the cottage, for which he is paying in his annuity just as he is paying for the cottage itself, is not taken into account but if he plants cabbage or potatoes in the garden, even for his own use, they are counted against him and this will deprive him of benefit. We are wasting too much time. The Minister either accepts it or he does not.

Comment on this

That would be the same as using the house for a shop, the same principle. Does the Deputy object to this?

Comment on this

I object to an effort being made to tell old people that they will get away with the full pension in future if they have vested a council cottage on which they are paying an annuity when this is not true.

Comment on this

They may well do so and what is more, as I pointed out to the Deputy, even in the case of people who have means other than the cottage and the plot, some of them will benefit under this section and get an increased pension.

Comment on this

The value of the cottage and plot is as low as 6½d per week. If the Minister would only realise that he would know that what he is saying is just not possible.

Comment on this

It is a fact.

Comment on this

In 999 cases out of 1,000 the plot is used to sow a few potatoes and a bit of cabbage.

Comment on this

That would deprive them of 5s.

Comment on this

It would appear we have become very mean and niggardly when we are paying out in the name of the taxpayers the smallest allowances that are paid by any Government Department. We have proposals and legislation here to pay grants to industrialists and to farmers. There are certain conditions but they are certainly not as strict as the qualifications in our legislation and regulations to provide a few pounds per week for an old age pensioner, a widow, an orphan and the various other social welfare classes. Here we are talking about a quarter of an acre or half an acre.

Comment on this

Or an acre.

Comment on this

Or two acres.

Comment on this

No, not two acres. That proves what I said earlier, that the Minister is not sure of his facts.

Comment on this

I am sure of this, that this section will benefit people. It will cost money, and the Deputies started on the basis that it was of no benefit to anyone.

Comment on this

It is of little benefit to anyone.

Comment on this

Oh, a little. Let us be accurate.

Comment on this

It will benefit about ten cases out of the thousands there will be.

Comment on this

We can count two thousand cases.

Comment on this

We are very careful in this House when it comes to the application of a means test for the payment of allowances to the poorest people in the country. There was strong objection here from all sides of the House when there was a provision proposed to the effect that a vested cottage would constitute means for the purpose of qualifying for an old age or a non-contributory old age pension, meaning that they would not get the maximum amount. Practically every housing authority in the rural areas has encouraged people to buy their cottages so as to relieve the ratepayers in the various areas of a certain amount of expense, particularly in regard to the repair of cottages. The Minister talks about the value of a cottage; as far as I can gather—I may be wrong in this—as soon as the payments are completed, the value of the cottage may be assessed as means.

Comment on this

Will be.

Comment on this

Will be assessed as means. Therefore, the Minister and the Government regard this little labourer's cottage as constituting value to old age pensioners of 75 or 80 years of age as if they intended to convert it or make some money out of it. As far as the cottage is concerned, it is a home for them for the remaining years of their lives. It is scandalous that it should constitute means for the purpose of deciding whether or not a person should get the maximum non-contributory old age or widow's pension. It is of no value to the pensioner where it is bought out only as a home. Surely we are not going to assess a home as means for the purpose of depriving these people of the maximum pension. We are merely talking about a plot of a quarter of an acer or half an acre. The Minister should know also that in the majority of these cases the plots are not used at all by the old age pensioner or by the widow. How does the Minister intend to assess the value of that plot to the applicant for the maximum rate?

Comment on this

They will not be assessed if they are not used.

Comment on this

What does non-use mean?

Comment on this

Non-use.

Comment on this

If they have six hens picking the grass, is that use?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

What will be use of the plot? If an old age pensioner decides to get a nephew or somebody else to till the plot and put down a few drills of potatoes and a few heads of cabbage, what will that mean? Because they are industrious they will lose some money per week.

Comment on this

Twelve pounds per year.

Comment on this

The Minister should consider this. Anyone in the country can get £300, or maybe more in some cases, as a grant from the local authority for building a house of 1,249 square feet. Any farmer—and I do not begrudge it to him—can get grants for various purposes without any means test. Anyone who wants to start an industry here or to expand one can get money. There are no qualifications like those that are applied to the poorest people in the land who are getting £4 or £4 5s per week and who would be deprived of 5s per week merely because they had a quarter of an acre or because they had a few hens or a few apple trees.

This is a very bad provision and this was said on both sides of the House when it was first introduced. The Minister, in consultation with his colleague, the Minister for Social Welfare, should do as Deputy Tully suggests— and this would be limited—exclude the plot of land with the cottage and do not let us here in this House keep badgering and plaguing these unfortunate people.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting we should exclude the plot no matter what use is made of it or what income is derived from it?

Comment on this

I propose that the Minister should accept Deputy Tully's proposal.

Comment on this

Is that not what it amounts to?

Comment on this

No, it is not, and I shall spell it out in words of two syllables if the Minister cannot understand it. If the land is being used for market gardening and the produce is being sold, then the Department are entitled to and will put a value on what comes off it. If it is simply being tilled or half-tilled or not tilled at all by the people who live in the house, it should not have a value put on it. The question was asked a while ago, what is "use"? If a county council plot is vested and you do not go near it at all it will grow grass and one of two things will happen: a neighbour may put a cow or a calf in it for a couple of weeks, or someone will cut the hay and give back a bag of potatoes to the old person instead of it; he may give nothing at all or he may give him a few drinks, if the old person is fond of a drink, at the weekend. That is all the value that is involved in this, a quarter of an acre or half an acre, or a maximum of one acre. We are not asking too much. In view of the fact that the Minister—and I give him credit for this—thought of the idea of excluding the vested cottage, surely he should now be prepared to go a little further and exclude the plot as well?

Comment on this

I think we are at cross purposes. I do not disagree with the Deputy. I would be prepared to accept that the use of the plot just for the household should not count as means, but excluding the plot, as the Deputy says, does not meet the situation.

Comment on this

Excluding the house does not exclude them if people start a shop in the house?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Therefore, excluding the plot, if they start a market garden does not exclude them either? The Minister is a legal man and he knows this better than I do.

Comment on this

The point I am making is that in any use of the plot where it might appear that it was being used for purposes——

Comment on this

Commercial.

Comment on this

—commercial in the sense other than use by the household, in any such case some inquiries would have to be made as to which is which.

Comment on this

I do not mind the Minister's officer making the inquiry but what I do mind is an investigating officer looking at a plot, as has happened where there was a ridge of potatoes for about 50 yards and about 50 cabbage plants planted by a widow and a value of 4s per week was put by the investigating officer on that produce in order to deprive that widow of the amount which she would get in one category as against another. This sort of thing can happen again and if this is left in we will be plaguing the Department's officials to have cases investigated. I suggest that cottage and plot be left out completely. Just omit the words which the Minister put in saying "excluding any plot". If the Minister takes those words out I am satisfied he can still catch the person concerned if he has a market garden or he is selling valuable produce off the plot. The Minister can catch that person just as if the person started a shop in his house. It is not a question of the Minister having to back down; we have had a good argument and we should have convinced him.

Comment on this

We could all agree here if we can say that where the plot is not being used commercially it will not be taken into account.

Comment on this

I would not go quite that far because I can see pitfalls. I will go as far as I went when I said that if the plot is being used only for the production of whatever it is producing for consumption in the house to which the plot is attached, we would exclude that. I can visualise that if you just say "commercially" it would open the door to other things. There are circumstances in which the plot is not attached to the house.

Comment on this

Somebody has led the Minister up the garden path.

Comment on this

The Deputy is thinking of the vast majority of——

Comment on this

The fact that the plot is not beside the house does not mean that the plot is not attached to the house. The plot might be beside the house or it might be a mile away, although it seldom is; it might be a couple hundred of yards away; it is still the one——

Comment on this

I think we are splitting hairs.

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this

I think we can agree with what the Minister said already.

Comment on this

I have a practical difficulty about this and how it should be dealt with.

Comment on this

The Minister knows what we have suggested and if he puts it through in the Seanad and if we object to it we can get somebody there to raise a row——

Comment on this

But if it goes through the Seanad the Dáil will have to get it again.

Comment on this

Surely an amendment can be circulated between now and the Report Stage?

Comment on this

I thought the Report Stage was today and that the Bill would go to the Seanad tomorrow.

Comment on this

Will there not be an interval after this?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments can be circulated at short notice.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle assures us that amendments can be circulated at short notice.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is a matter for the Government and not for the Chair. I am just stating the position.

Comment on this

The way the words are put in draws attention to the matter. If the words were taken out it would be the very same position as if there were a five acre, ten acre or 50 acre farm attached and you would take cognisance of that. The fact that there is nothing written in here to say that that should be taken account of would not affect the position. There is no danger at all if the Minister just takes out the words he has here, "excluding any plot".

Comment on this

Excluding the plot has no reference whatever to what we have been discussing, the use of the produce commercially or just for the house itself; it does not cover that point.

Comment on this

That has been already covered in social welfare legislation a dozen times.

Comment on this

If it is covered what is the Deputy arguing about?

Comment on this

I am arguing that the Minister is excluding the plot and by excluding the plot he is saying that although the house will not be counted any longer the plot will continue to be counted.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Of course it is.

Comment on this

No, let me——

Comment on this

The Minister is changing feet now. I get tired when I hear this sort of argument being put up after a two-hour argument.

Comment on this

Just listen to me. I get a bit tired too when I find this kind of changing of feet going on and I am accused of changing feet. I have said on a number of occasions, and the Deputy has not disagreed with me, that the effect of this section is to exclude the cottage from the computation of means. Secondly, that in so far as the plot is concerned the mere ownership of the plot does not and will not count for means; it is the use which is made of the plot that counts for means. The area of difficulty that arises is in the use which is made of the plot. The deletion of the words here does not affect the use which is made of the plot and how that is assessed. I said that I would be prepared to accept in so far as the use is concerned that the use of the plot for the production of vegetables and so on for consumption in the house would not count as means, but excluding the words here does not solve the problem and is not relevant to the problem.

Comment on this

It is quite easy: exclusive of the plot where it is used for the production of vegetables for the home only. It is as simple as that. There is no drafting problem.

Comment on this

If the vested cottage and plot had a farm attached the Minister would not have to say in this amendment that the cottage is excluded, or "excluding the plot and the farm", but he would take the farm into consideration and anything coming off the farm would be valued. I am prepared to take the Minister's word that he believes he can deal with this in the way he said he could but he is not the Minister dealing with social welfare and the interpreation put on it in this House is very often not the interpretation given by people outside. If the Minister can say how he can convey to those who will be administering this that they are not to take the plot into consideration if it is only being used for the purpose of the house I am prepared to let the matter drop.

Comment on this

I have never said that can be done without an amendment. This has been my problem. When the Deputy suggested that it could be dealt with simply by excluding——

Comment on this

So it can.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think that that would solve the problem?

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this

Of course it will.

Comment on this

I cannot see how just excluding the words about the plot would solve the problem.

Comment on this

We all appear to agree about what should be done. Would the Minister suggest an amendment?

Comment on this

I was about to say that all I can do is have it looked at very quickly. I will have to have regard to how long it is likely to take to go through the Seanad and whether the Dáil will still be in session and so on. I must get the opportunity to get it so worded as to cover only what I have been saying and nothing else.

Comment on this

The Minister could bring it in here tomorrow and we will pass it.

Comment on this

I except that the Bill will be before the Seanad tomorrow.

Comment on this

It can be before this House tomorrow, the first business.

Comment on this

I will have to ask the House to allow me to see what I can work out.

Comment on this

The Minister will discuss this matter with his officials and will make up his mind. However, on Report Stage unless there is an amendment the House will not have an opportunity of even mentioning it.

Comment on this

The Minister has given a guarantee there will be an amendment.

Comment on this

As far as I know there would have to be an amendment to achieve what we are talking about.

Comment on this

Can we recommit the section to make sure that we can refer to it. Can we trust the Minister?

Comment on this

The Deputy will have to trust me.

Comment on this