We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Confidence in Taoiseach and Government: Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 1–220 of 442. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

When I started to speak the other day I had time merely to summarise the four main themes of what I have to say. These are that we on this side of the House indict the Taoiseach and one of his Ministers for misleading the House on four occasions. We indict them for the misappropriation of public funds in respect of which, moreover, the House was misled. We are concerned about the collapse of collective responsibility, something which is required by the Constitution, and we are concerned about the evidence of gross incompetence in Government that emerged in the course of this trial. These are the four issues, it seems to me, in the debate and they have an impact on confidence. They have an impact on confidence of the people in Government, an impact on the confidence of the people in the stability of this country and, indeed, at a time of financial crisis an impact on the financial stability of the country because of the reflection they cast on the Government who are concerned with the management of our economic affairs. They have an effect, too, on confidence amongst people, even of goodwill, in Northern Ireland in this part of the country and in its Government. They have an impact on the confidence of people in other countries—the British Government, and indeed, the EEC Governments — in working, negotiating and discussing problems with the Government of this country.

I want in the first instance to come back to this matter of misleading the House. I regret that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries has left the House. He was there a second ago and I had hoped he was going to remain because I prefer to attack a man in his presence rather than in his absence and it is my duty—although certainly I have no personal animus against the Minister with whom I have had no contact, either personally or politically—to attack him and to attack him strongly today. I hope that he may come back so that we may deal with the matter across the floor.

First, I have to deal with the Taoiseach. There are two counts on which the Taoiseach has been accused of misleading the House. I shall not dwell on the first because it has been debated at some length in the House. This is in regard to the reply he gave to the Leader of the Opposition in the Dáil on the 5th May in response to a question as to whether there were further dismissals or resignations to come. He replied on that occasion in a manner which was misleading. I am prepared to accept that the Taoiseach on the spur of the moment, and seeking not to disclose his hand too much, used a form of words which was inadvertently misleading, that he was trying to be evasive and, unfortunately, in the literal sense told an untruth. It is a pity that he did not apologise to the House for that and instead attempted to exculpate himself and justify what was at its best a serious error of judgment. I am concerned more particularly, however, with a later case where the Taoiseach misled the House. Again, it may well be, and I am quite prepared to accept it if the Taoiseach says that this is the case, that this was due to incompetence on his part rather than to a desire deliberately to mislead the House. The matter is one of great seriousness because it is a matter with which this House is properly and deeply concerned and that is the control of public expenditure.

The House will recall that on May 9th at column 1336, volume 246 of the Official Report, the Taoiseach in reply to that long debate gave the House some assurances about public moneys. They were limited and restricted assurances, assurances that no money had been used from the Secret Service fund to buy arms and that no money from the Department of Defence had been used for that purpose. He said that there was no question of the Secret Service fund being used and that as well as that it was established for him that all moneys expended by the Department of Defence were expended as voted by this House. Therefore, he did not know where the moneys came from that paid for these goods, if they were paid for.

In the third debate on this subject on May 14th I raised with the Taoiseach the question of whether this money might have come from some other source. It seemed to me that the assurances he had given to the House were too restricted, that money could have come for the purchase of arms from some source other than the Department of Defence Vote or the Secret Service fund. On that occasion I said:

The Taoiseach says he is satisfied that no Secret Service money was used because it is spread around so much.

Again it is a very unconvincing denial when one reads the actual words, and I quote:

I had the usual sources from which one might expect these things could be paid for, checked.

"It is nice to know"—I added—"that we have the usual sources from which it is usual to finance illegal arms imports." I went on to quote the Taoiseach:

The Secret Service funds amounted to £11,500 and had to be spread over the Departments which draw on these funds. Therefore, there was no question of the Secret Service funds being used.

He did not say he checked to see had they been used for it but he looked at the figure of £11,500 and said with four Department getting £11,500, you would never get £30,000 out of that: there is no need to look any further.

I went on to raise with the Taoiseach specifically the question as to whether money had come from other sources. I asked him if he had checked the most obvious place, the Department of Finance. That is where one of the Ministers concerned was involved. It seemed improbable—if the Minister for Defence is innocent, as we are told —that the money had come from the Department of Defence. The most likely place is the Department of Finance. He does not tell us whether he has checked there. There is no denial in respect of there; this is no indication that the Taoiseach had checked.

In replying to that debate, the Taoiseach endeavoured to give some kind of answer to each of the questions I put him. Let me read to the House the answer he gave on this question to the House as reported at column 1757 of the Official Report. He said:

I want to add that I made specific inquiries as to whether any moneys could have been voted or could have been paid out of Exchequer funds or out of any public funds in respect of a consignment of arms of the size we have been dealing with and I am assured that there was not nor could not have been.

It is difficult to think of a more explicit denial—"...was not nor could not have been"—not merely that there was not but that there was no possibility that such a thing could have happened.

We now know, from the evidence given on oath in court—indeed, evidence not contested by the prosecution—that, in fact, the funds to buy arms did come from a Government Vote—the Northern Ireland Relief Vote. Moreover, of all Votes that this Dáil voted in the course of the last financial year, is there any Vote more obvious, is there any Vote to which one would be inclined to look sooner, to see whether money had been used for this purpose? If any Deputy of this House were Taoiseach, where would he look for this money? Given that the money was used for arms for the north—this is what we we are told— given that the Minister for Finance had been dismissed and was about to be charged with complicity, to what Vote would one look first to see if money had been used from that Vote? The answer, obviously, is, from the Vote under his personal control, which, we have been told in court, was under his personal control, money from which was paid out under his direct authority for the purpose of a northern relief fund.

I am prepared to believe that the Taoiseach, when he told us that in this House on 14th May last, did not know he was telling an untruth. But, quite frankly, a man who fails to check completely and totally such an obvious source of funds for a purpose of this kind and assures this House that the money not only did not come from any Government funds——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy please quote me again—the first three words?

Comment on this

I shall be happy to quote the Taoiseach: "However, I want to add that I made specific inquiries as to whether any moneys could have been voted or could have been paid out of Exchequer funds or out of any public funds in respect of a consignment of arms of the size we have been dealing with and I am assured that there was not nor could not have been."

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

These are the three words I have been looking for—"I am assured".

Comment on this

Collective responsibility.

Comment on this

I have said I am prepared to accept the Taoiseach told the truth as he knew it. He claims the defence of incompetence. On that defence, this House has no confidence in him.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy calls it an untruth.

Comment on this

I did not. I specifically said I was not accusing the Taoiseach of an untruth. I specifically said I was prepared to accept from him the alibi he has given of incompetence. He has given it now. I accept it. That is why this Government should go: that, in a matter as serious as this, a Taoiseach who is prepared to accept an assurance, and not even to look into it in any detail whatever, about this particular fund, is a man who should not be in charge of our affairs.

Let us consider the position here. The Taoiseach knows that this Minister is involved. He has sacked him for it and he is about to have him arrested for it. Let us get to the facts of this and let us quote the evidence of the former Private Secretary to the Minister for Finance in the report on the trial of 24th September, 1970—Irish Times, first page, last two columns. We read, referring to Mr. Fagan:

He was aware that the Government had made funds available for relief works in Northern Ireland in the summer of 1969 but he did not agree this money was to be used, according to the Government's submission, by the Defence Forces. In practice, this money was available for administration by the Intelligence Division of the Defence Forces.

——available for that——

He agreed that Captain Kelly was primarily and officially connected with the distribution of this money by the Intelligence Division.

We move on to the next page—first column:

A minute of the Government decision to establish a contingency fund had come in the normal course to his office. It was as a result of that minute that the accounts in the Clones and Baggot Street banks were set up.

He went on—I shall come back to this again: I shall come back to the question of the actual misappropriation of funds. I shall come back to deal with the fact that certain Ministers, other than the Minister for Defence, sought the money. This House has not been told who these Ministers were. Then, on 8th October this matter is raised again in the second trial. When the jury was recalled, Mr. D'Arcy resumed his cross-examination of Mr. Fagan and asked:

Were you aware that, in August, 1969, the Government made a sum available for the aid of distress in Northern Ireland?—I was.

Was part of that fund administered by the Intelligence Department of the Defence Forces?—Not administered as such; on requisition to me, the Private Secretary to the Minister for Finance; from Captain Kelly or from Colonel Heffron, and with the approval of the Minister for Finance, sums of money were paid from this fund.

It is perfectly clear that the Government decided at a meeting on a date unspecified that this money—voted by the Dáil on 18th March retrospectively in respect of a relief fund, announced many months earlier — that this money should be under the control of the Minister for Finance; should be issued under his authority and with his approval. That was the Government decision. The Taoiseach knew all about that. He was responsible for it. There he was; having dismissed this Minister and being about to charge this Minister with a criminal offence in connection with this matter, what action did he take before assuring the Dáil on this matter, not only that he was assured that the money did not come from public funds, but could not have come from any Government funds? He does not have to do much: he merely has to ask the relevant official what happened that money. Had he asked, he would have been told—we are told by the Irish Red Cross—I shall come back to this later in another context—that a written instruction was issued by the Department of Finance to the Irish Red Cross to pay this money into a fund to be administered by three names which, if the Taoiseach had inquired, he would have discovered were people who did not exist but apparently were false names for people in Northern Ireland. One does not need to be a Sherlock Holmes to discover that.

No man who either fails to inquire that far, or who, having inquired that far and found that this money had passed out of the hands and control of the Department of Finance and into the control of people in Northern Ireland operating under false names, could legitimately give such an assurance to this House as that which he gave. I am prepared to accept that the Taoiseach had not pursued the matter that far. I am prepared to accept that when he said he had this assurance he got it from somebody; that he had not bothered to look any further; that he was content to accept assurances—even as late as 14th May—on this matter that no Taoiseach in command of his Government and concerned that this House should know the truth, could possibly have accepted. That is my charge. I think the Taoiseach should answer it.

May I once again deprecate the practice that has grown up in this House that the Taoiseach, in opening a debate of this kind, talks platitudes or tries to make some funny remarks about the Opposition, but totally fails to deal with the matter to hand; a practice in which he does not deal with the matter but waits for the debate and for the last word when he cannot be contradicted and when—if he is challenged—he says in an offended way, in effect: "I must not be interrupted. I did not interrupt you"—which is not always true. That practice is one which this House should ask to be ended.

In coming in to debate a motion of this kind, the Taoiseach should have come to us, as he promised in May he would come to us and tell us the whole truth. He has told us nothing. If he intends to tell us the whole truth— maybe he does—he apparently intends to do it at the end of the debate and, if any of us want to clarify a point or check a point then, he will tell us: "I did not interrupt you. Do not you interrupt me."

May I say that if the Taoiseach needs more time to reply and to give us the truth even at this late stage we will not insist on limiting him to three-quarters of an hour. He can talk all night so long as at last he tells us the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Comment on this

I will come back to this matter later. I am dealing at the moment with the question of the misleading of this House by the Taoiseach twice—he may say inadvertently on both occasions. On the first occasion one can accept a slip of the tongue, although one cannot accept a failure to apologise if it was a slip of the tongue. On the second occasion there was no excuse. It was a failure on his part to do his duty. He had no right to give an assurance to this House until he had checked the matter personally and, in giving that assurance which was falsified by events, he has shown himself, as he has shown himself in other respects also, to be a man who should not be leading the Government of this country.

I want to pass now to the other cases of this House being misled, misled by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. Once again I regret his departure. If there are any of his friends in the House who can persuade him to come in again I wish they would do so. I should like to talk to him to his face.

Comment on this

None of his friends are present.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister is listening to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was going to say he had no friends. I am concerned here with two cases in which the House was misled. The first of these relates to the training of civilians at Dunree Fort. The form which the misleading took in this instance was a deliberate half truth—a deliberate half truth, however, of a kind deliberately designed to mislead the House. It is one thing for somebody in the heat of debate inadverently to say something that may mislead on a matter of minor importance. One might forgive that especially if, which we never get from those benches, there is an apology afterwards. It is a different matter to deliberately and in a planned manner mislead the House as was done on this occasion.

The House will recall that when Deputy Richie Ryan was speaking from this side of the House he referred to training which was given in at least one Army camp to civilians in the use of arms. The Minister, in a phrase which is becoming a little repetitive from him, said: "That is not true"; but he was not content with that denial, which might have been elicited from him on the spur of the moment. He wanted to go on record misleading the House. He wanted to make sure that there would be no question of the House having any inkling of the truth. He wanted to nail the truth. We talk of nailing a lie but the Minister wished to nail the truth. He said that in the course of a Radio Éireann interview Mr. Patrick Kennedy, M.P., suggested that any participation by Captain James Kelly—I quote from column 839 of the Official Report of 8th May—in an attempt to smuggle arms "could only have been made with my knowledge and consent. I wish emphatically to deny any such knowledge or consent." Note: "knowledge or consent" not "knowledge and consent". "There was neither knowledge nor consent."

I am sorry. I picked the wrong paragraph. I should be dealing with Dunree Fort. I will come back to that one. My apologies for having confused the House but, when Ministers tell so many untruths to the House, one tends to get confused between them.

To come back to the relevant untruth at this stage. As reported at column 841 of the Official Report of 8th May, 1970, the Minister said:

There was some reference to the training of civilians in Donegal. I want to point out the position of the Defence Forces in this regard. The Defence forces train only members of their own ranks, whether they be FCA or Army or Naval personnel. That is the extent of their training. This story first got currency in the Protestant Telegraph. It is time that stories of this kind ceased.

It is a sad stage when we have to go to the Protestant Telegraph for the truth about what is happening in this part of Ireland. I do not think many of us thought we would be reduced to that by any member of the Government, but that is what we have been reduced to by the Minister. No doubt the Minister will tell us when he speaks—and the sooner the better; I wish he had spoken before I did so that I could deal with him more effectively — that of course these people were enlisted in the Defence Forces for the week and presumably “delisted” again at the end of the week, but let us be quite clear. That statement was deliberately designed to mislead the House. The accusation made related to civilians from Northern Ireland being brought in and trained. They were brought in; they were trained. Technically they were enlisted and on that technicality Deputy Gibbons rests. May he rest in peace, but it will not be forgotten for a long time to come that a Minister of this House misled the House in this manner.

Let me come to the second case which I inadvertently launched myself into in the confusion between the various misleading statements by Deputy Gibbons. I am concerned here with the importation of arms. I come back now to the quotation I was making. Referring to a statement made by Mr. Patrick Kennedy, M.P., in the course of a radio interview, Deputy Gibbons said that Mr. Kennedy suggested that any participation by Captain James Kelly in an attempt to smuggle arms "could only have been made with my knowledge and consent. I wish emphatically to deny any such knowledge and consent". Not "knowledge and consent"—"knowledge or consent". He went on to say that he discharged his duty to the full extent of his knowledge of the situation and that he had formed the opinion—and this is one of the more humorous passages—in recent times "that Captain Kelly was becoming unsuitable for the type of work that he was employed on." He was failing to get the arms in? He went on:

I want to say that certain suspicions were forming in my mind.

Here was this energetic, able Minister, closely watching the Intelligence Service and nothing very acutely that something odd was going on. The fact that this detective process consisted of Captain Kelly coming to him and pouring out his mind about arms importation and not being pulled up or in any way reprimanded does not emerge, but we are to honour the detective work by Deputy Gibbons in finding this out by actually listening to Captain Kelly telling him—and so suspicions formed in his mind. There is an able and energetic Minister for you.

In this House last Thursday Deputy Cosgrave referred to this matter. He referred to what had been said at the trial. He said "On 9th October, according to Press reports of the evidence given in the court he (Deputy Gibbons) said that on several occasions in March and April Captain Kelly had told him in some detail about attempts to bring in arms in which he was involved." Deputy Gibbons then said the famous words: "That is not true."

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

I am not clear as to whether Deputy Gibbons is making a distinction even more subtle than the previous one, but this will no doubt emerge when he comes to speak.

Comment on this

I am pointing out that what Deputy Cosgrave said was incorrect.

Comment on this

I will go through Deputy Gibbons's evidence at the trial.

Comment on this

So will I.

Comment on this

Good. Let me start the process. Let me get in first. Let us be told which of the statements by Deputy Gibbons at the trial was not true and was perjured, or in what way he suggests he can reconcile the statements at the trial with lack of knowledge. He can make a spurious case about consent. He tells us he never actually said to Captain Kelly: "Go ahead", but he did nothing to stop him; but on knowledge I do not see how he can challenge us.

Let me take these one by one. The Minister was asked:

Now, was anything said as to the form of service or assistance he (Captain Kelly) wished to give to the people about whom he spoke?— Well, at the first meeting, I can't be certain that any specific mention of the importation of arms was made. I rather tend towards the belief it was at the second meeting that the specific mention was made.

Then a further question:

And you think that that was at the second meeting?—I cannot be certain of it but I tend towards that belief myself.

It may indeed have been mentioned at the first meeting earlier in March. The report goes on:

Mr. Gibbons said that the second meeting he had with Captain Kelly would have been in the last days of March or possibly early April, and Captain Kelly told him there had been an attempt to import illegal weapons through the port of Dublin.

I pass on now to the next passage:

Mr. Gibbons went on: I asked him what happened then.

This was down at the Port of Dublin; this is the operation of which Deputy Gibbons had no knowledge; all this conversation is completely imaginary, but given on oath of course.

Did you or did they—

the Army personnel who were collecting legitimate arms there—

disappear into the shadows?—I recall using that particular expression, and I think he shrugged in an affirmative kind of way. I said to him: "I suppose that's the end of that lot anyway" or words to that effect, and he indicated in words that I don't exactly recall that it was not, and that further efforts would be made to import this particular batch, and he mentioned a port on the Adriatic as a possible port of transmission.

These were all matters of which he had no knowledge at all in March or April! The report goes on:

Mr. Gibbons said he asked Captain Kelly if that port might possibly be Trieste, because it was the only port in the Adriatic he could think of offhand, and he thought Captain Kelly answered yes, rather vaguely. Mr. Gibbons said he felt he should mention that when Captain Kelly mentioned the failure of the goods to come in from Belgium, Captain Kelly had not mentioned the port in Belgium, and it was only when he (Mr. Gibbons) suggested Antwerp that Capt. Kelly said that that was the port. So far as he recalled Captain Kelly had not identified any of the persons identified with him in this enterprise.

That is a fair amount of detail and yet what did Deputy Cosgrave say in this matter? Let me quote Deputy Cosgrave again—he said that:

On several occasions in March and April Captain Kelly had told him

—Deputy Gibbons—

in some detail of an attempt to bring in arms in which he was involved.

How much detail does there have to be? Is the name of the ship necessary? The fact that arms were being brought in and the names of the ports were discussed—that is not knowledge, however.

Comment on this

Several occasions.

Comment on this

Let us move on to consider how much knowledge there is here. I shall quote from the newspaper of October 10th reporting on the trial of October 9th.

You would agree with me that as of the moment of your conversation at the end of March, you had never expressed to Captain Kelly any disapproval of what he told you he was going to do or what he told you he had tried to do on the 25th March?

Mr. Gibbons: Yes.

No criticism.

Does that mean your position at this time was you did not mind if arms came in as long as an Army officer was not involved in bringing them in?

Mr. Gibbons: No. That is not the case.

If that was not the position why didn't you, in the last days of March, when told by a serving Army officer that he had just failed to bring in one load of arms and that he was now going to get them in by some other route—why didn't you tell him not to?

Mr. Gibbons: Because I felt that if Captain Kelly went out of the Army with any sense of grievance of being let down, especially after having made that declaration to me, that he might be tempted to make use of the great deal of secret information to which he had access...

This goes on for pages. The amount of knowledge Deputy Gibbons had is so long-winded that I cannot detain the House with it but there is another little bit of the cross-examination which I think is worth referring to. Deputy Gibbons in the course of his cross-examination had admitted to that very delicate thing: "vestigial knowledge"—a form of knowledge this House has not hitherto been acquainted with, but that is the kind of knowledge he admitted to. The cross-examining counsel were not satisfied with "vestigial knowledge". Mr. Sorahan then asked:

You had vestigial knowledge, is that right?

Mr. Gibbons: Yes.

Mr. Sorahan: But you had knowledge simpliciter, is that not right?

Mr. Gibbons: Yes.

Is there any more specific admission of knowledge that one can make than that? After an attempt to say there was vestigial knowledge, knowledge of the ports of Trieste and Antwerp, merely vestigial knowledge, nothing definite, nothing that would make anybody think of guns actually being attempted to be imported, after that, he admitted to knowledge simpliciter. Is there any word in the Latin language, or the British language, that could be more complete or total? No. The question was phrased in the most complete way and to that question Deputy Gibbons replied: “Yes”. Yet in this House, when Deputy Cosgrave said that on several occasions in March and April Captain Kelly had told him in some detail about attempts to bring in arms in which he was involved, Deputy Gibbons said: “That is not true”.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

As an ordinary member of this Parliament, as an ordinary Irishman, as an ordinary man in the street——

Comment on this

Not ordinary, surely?

Comment on this

——I cannot begin to reconcile those statements. The only interpretation I can put on that—and it does not appear to be what Deputy Gibbons wishes put on it—is that he is saying he perjured himself in court.

There can be no more time for this. We cannot go on with a Government which plays games with matters like this, a man who gets up in court and swears that he had knowledge simpliciter— no qualification, knowledge simpliciter of the matter, and comes into this House and says: “That is not true.” How can we have confidence in such a man? We are not dealing here with half-truths or evasions. We are dealing here with blank lies, lies of a kind this House has never before heard, lies of a kind I hope this House will never have to hear again.

Comment on this

At least Deputy Kevin Boland was honest about it and it is to his credit. We may disagree with him but he was honest.

Comment on this

I shall come to the one honest man later on.

Comment on this

Why did Deputy FitzGerald not make those statements where he was not covered by the privilege of the House?

Comment on this

I have been making frequent statements on the subject not covered by the privilege of the House and I hope the Deputy takes time to read them in the papers two or three times a week.

Having dealt with this matter of misleading the House—four examples, two by the Taoiseach, possibly a third one but the second certainly culpable, two by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, the first of which can be regarded as an evasion but one which was designed to mislead the House, the second of which is a blank lie—I come now to the question of the misappropriation of funds. First of all, I comment merely that it is interesting that the prosecution did not raise this matter. One would have thought that in a trial on a conspiracy to import arms, the fact that one of the people charged had money under his authority which he had released by written instruction apparently through a certain channel to a fund under the charge of people who were from the area for which the arms were being imported, one would have thought that such a fact would be thought relevant to proving conspiracy. Yet, interestingly enough, the prosecution did not rely on this or refer to it. It was Captain Kelly's counsel who in cross-examination brought out this question of misappropriation of funds.

I have already quoted what Mr. Fagan said on the subject, his instructions to pay the fund into an account in Clones and then payments made into the account in Baggot Street. I have already asked how the Taoiseach could have failed to check this. There are other questions. How could the money be spent in this way? People who have longer experience than I have of this House have found themselves amazed that Government money could be dealt with in this way. Let us trace the transactions.

A Supplementary Estimate was introduced. The Minister concerned makes no statement on it. It is however entitled: "Northern Relief Fund". There are other items in it but that particular matter is not referred to. The money is voted by the Dáil in the innocent belief that it would be used for the relief of distress in Northern Ireland—the rehousing of people, the provision of clothing for people, the provision of assistance to individuals who had lost their homes in these troubles. What happens? The Minister arranges that this money be transferred to a group of people in whose names the account is opened except that they are false names—a rather peculiar feature—through the Irish Red Cross. There are a number of questions raised here. What authority had the Minister for Finance to give instructions to the Irish Red Cross to pass funds to accounts outside their control and his control which are held in false names? Indeed what authority had he, even if they were in the true names of the people? None, it seems to me. I feel that the whole question of the management of the Irish Red Cross has been called into question. The whole idea of the Red Cross is that they should be above suspicion, that they should concentrate on giving aid to people in distress, that they must never be associated, even in the most vestigial way, with the importation of or any handling of or dealings in arms. Yet in this country the Minister who was subsequently charged with this offence instructs in writing the Red Cross to transfer money into a fund from which money was used for arms. The role of the Red Cross and the management of the Red Cross in this whole matter must come under review. I presume the International Red Cross are looking into it and we will expect to see some shake-up in the Irish Red Cross or else its disaffiliation in the near future. I do not know that there is any alternative after this disgraceful performance by the Government.

How could the money have been spent in this way? What terms of reference were given to the Minister for Finance? As far as we were concerned it was the Northern Relief Fund. The money was put under his personal control. He was apparently empowered to issue it to people. On what terms? By what criteria? What was laid down? Where is the Government minute on this matter? Can we be told what was the basis on which this fund was to be handled? What instructions were there from the Government to the Minister for Finance? Were there any? Are we dealing here with another case of the muddle and incompetence which surrounds this whole affair? Then the Minister delegated this function to a civil servant, Mr. Fagan, and left it to him, according to his nonchalant statement in the matter, to decide what money should be issued from this fund into the hands of this group of false names in front of whom Captain Kelly was operating. What criteria did the Minister give to Mr. Fagan when he issued these funds? Is this the normal procedure by which the Government handles funds? I had always under stood and everything I ever heard about the method of handling Government accounts and my experience, limited though it be, on the Committee of Public Accounts had suggested to me that, when money is to be issued from any Government account, it is tightly controlled, it is necessary that the purpose be specific, that it be clear to whom the money is being given, that the people concerned should be an incorporated body or people on whom specific responsibility can rest, necessary that the purposes for which the money is issued should be known and specified, necessary that there should be a process of inspection to make sure the money is used in that way. Yet in this case the Minister simply says to his secretary: "Transfer the money into this fund whenever Captain Kelly asks for it". Is this the way moneys are normally handled and if not normally, how did this abnormality arise? What authority was there for acting in this abnormal way?

There is another question that arises on this fund, and indeed it is shrouded in obscurity, because the whole account given of it is unclear, but certain things are clear. Mr. Fagan, in giving evidence, said there had been requests from several Ministers for money from this fund. He then went on to say that those Ministers did not include the Minister for Defence. I am not perfectly clear in my own mind as to whether he meant that several Ministers had indented to the Minister for Finance on the £100,000 held in Finance or whether they had got money from the fund in the three false names operated by Captain Kelly, to which a large part of the £100,000 was transferred. The evidence to me is obscure on this point but obscure or not, the probability, from the fact that Mr. Fagan is giving evidence on the point, seems to me that the money was secured directly from the Department of Finance. The question which arises, and for which no answer has been provided since by the Taoiseach or anybody else, is what Ministers got money from this fund and for what purpose?

When this House votes money for northern relief it does not vote it so that Ministers can indent on it for sums they require for other purposes. Or, are there perhaps other Ministers who are busying themselves with northern relief? What form did the relief take? What Ministers got what money from this fund? For what purpose? What check has been made to discover what they did with it? Why have we not been told this? We have been told that because of the bank strike it is impossible to complete the investigation. Indeed, had Deputy Cosgrave not probed the matter further we would not even have known that the investigation was well advanced, that in fact some of the cheques drawn on the mysterious account in the names of three false people, are already known and the names on them are known. We would not have got that had Deputy Cosgrave not probed the other day, because once again the Government endeavoured to mislead us by talking about the bank strike and implying that no information was available yet. If, as I think from Mr. Fagan's evidence, money was drawn, not only by many mysterious people, from the fund in Baggot Street and the fund in Clones, but by Ministers other than the Minister for Defence, as he then was, from the fund held in the Department of Finance, why have we not been told what Ministers got the money and what for?

The Taoiseach, although not apparently a very vigorous investigator, judging by the assurance he gave the House on 14th May, must by this time surely have got round to asking Mr. Fagan: "Who asked for the money? Who got it? How much?" He might even have got as far as asking the Ministers what they did with it. He does not tell this House about that. Why not? Why has this House to wait until the bank account in Baggot Street is investigated to be told what happened the money that was not transferred to Baggot Street? I would like to know that. I hope somebody over there is making notes and that the Taoiseach, who failed to answer those questions in advance of the debate as was his duty, would answer them at the end in reply to this debate. As I have said he can have as much time as he wants for the purpose so far as this side of the House is concerned.

The question has been raised with the Taoiseach as to whether he would transfer investigation into this matter to the Public Accounts Committee. Mention has been made of a Select Committee but it seems to me that it would be inappropriate to appoint a different committee because the Public Accounts Committee will be investigating this matter in due course. It is the function of the Public Accounts Committee to investigate the audited accounts when they are received. Therefore, it will be doing this job when the audited accounts for the year come in. It would seem to me inappropriate to set up a special committee to do the job now because the Public Accounts Committee will be doing it in due course. What we on this side of the House propose is that the Public Accounts Committee should now be given the job of doing what it will have to do in due course anyway, that in view of public concern in this matter the Public Accounts Committee should forthwith be given charge of this investigation.

We are told that the Taoiseach will have to wait and see what the Garda investigation shows and then he will decide what to do with the results of that investigation, then he will decide how much to disclose to this House and how to carry the matter further. May I say to the Taoiseach that is not the way the control of public expenditure is carried on under the Constitution of this country? It is a matter for this House to control expenditure. This House is entitled to the information. This House has a committee whose job it is to inspect how money is spent. We are asking, and it is not too much, that instead of putting off this investigation, instead of postponing it, until after an election perhaps, that the Public Accounts Committee should be given the job at this stage. It is they who should be supervising the investigation by the gardaí, not the Taoiseach, not the Minister for Justice, not, please God, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. At this point in time the Public Accounts Committee should be given authority to look into this matter now, to be in touch with the gardaí and to get the full information direct. It should not have to depend on the polluted channels of information from the other side of the House. It should not have to depend on people who are capable of, at best, half truths, at worst, of lies. It should be put in charge of this investigation now and should get the full information. This House should through the Public Accounts Committee be informed as to what has happened the money we voted here last March.

There are a number of matters in connection with this which require investigation. It is not perhaps necessary for me to go into them in detail now. There are those puzzling references to assumed names, including Captain Kelly's reference to approaching an unnamed woman for authority to use a false name for her. This is a very interesting concept which I have never heard before. I know of people using false names but how you use a false name for somebody else I do not know. If I go in to open an account in a bank and I open it in the name of Joe Murphy how is anybody to know that Joe Murphy is a false name for, say, James Doyle? A false name is a false name is a false name as a famous writer once might have said. It is not a false name for somebody else in a case like this. The other person does not come into it. How do you go to a woman and say: "May I open an account in the name of Mrs. Murphy?" when the woman's name is Mrs. Doyle? How does a Mrs. Doyle come into the picture? The account is in the name of Mrs. Murphy. Mrs. Doyle does not draw on it. No, it is Captain Kelly who draws on it, not the imaginary Mrs. Doyle. What function has the woman who gives authority for a false name to be used for her for an account on which Captain Kelly draws?

Comment on this

I think this is the blonde mentioned by Deputy Boland earlier in the year.

Comment on this

The colour of her hair is something I am afraid we have not been told. We have in fact been told nothing about this woman except that she "facilitated" the operation. She could not have facilitated it by allowing a false name to be used for her because this is a meaningless exercise. When the account was not to be drawn on by her she had no function in the matter. How did she facilitate it? What was her role? What function had she? Had she some other connection with this affair? We need to be told more about this. If she facilitated it other than by saying: "Yes, use a false name", which means nothing, she must have had some other function. She must have been involved somewhere, in the Government service, the Irish Red Cross or somewhere. We want to know more about this.

This House cannot accept that the identity of this woman should be kept secret at this point when her facilitation must have consisted of something more than simply saying: "Use a false name for me." The whole question needs a lot more clarification. We have not got much so far. Where now are the Taoiseach's fine promises that this thing would be fully displayed, that we would be told the full truth in due course? There has been a great clamming up since the trial ended. All the loose ends, all the bits of anonymity, all the bits of uncertainty, all the conflicts of evidence given under oath, be it said, by Ministers and former Ministers of the Government, are left in mid-air and clarification we have none.

May I emphasise this point I have just referred to? Evidence was given on oath by, among other people, a Minister of the Government and a former Minister of the Government. The judge had something to say about this.

Comment on this

The second judge.

Comment on this

The second judge, indeed. I am not bothering to refer to the obiter dicta of the first judge which confused the issue somewhat earlier on.

He (Mr. Gibbons) was cross-examined about many of the events that I have referred to here. He recounted deputations he had met and so forth. He was cross-examined about the rifles he sent to Dundalk, about the training given to civilians from the Bogside——

the judge's words, not mine

——who were inducted into the LDF at Fort Dunree in Donegal and there trained by the Irish Army and it was suggested to him that the statement he made in the Dáil was untrue, half true and in fact was a lie. And he said "no, it was not, that technically training was not given to any civilian, that before training was given to people who came from Derry, the nine people or so, were all inducted into the LDF and thereby became technically members of the Defence Forces so that the statement was technically true".

I am quoting the judge:

When pressed on this point he said that this was a statement in Dáil Éireann thereby implying that statements of this kind which are not the literal truth are frequently made in Dáil Éireann.

That is the verdict of a judge on the view expressed by a member of the Government, the view of someone who is still a member of the Government, that it is quite normal, frequent, for Ministers deliberately to mislead the House with half-truths. I quote again:

It is a matter for you to decide whether his conduct in regard to the statements he made in Dáil Éireann about the training of people in the Bogside or the statements he made in Dáil Éireann about his suspicions or that nothing concrete had emerged, are within the category of technically correct statements which are made by politicians in Parliament; or whether they show Mr. Gibbons to be a man given to half-truths and lies and whether as a result you should see him as being discredited as a witness. I express no opinion but leave the matter to you.

He goes on to say more about it, however, in relation to another aspect. In discussing the conflict of evidence between the Minister and the former Minister he says:

As you will see later, Mr. Haughey denies it and he cannot explain how his former colleague could say it is so. It is not like something said in the course of a conversation that could be misrepresented. It seems to me, and you are free to dismiss my opinion, either Mr. Gibbons concocted this and has come to court and perjured himself——

the judge's words, not mine.

——or it happened. If there is another explanation please act on it.

There does not seem to me to be any way of avoiding the total conflict on this issue between Mr. Haughey and Mr. Gibbons. I do not put forward the matter by the suggestion that you should balance a State witness against a defence witness. I do not mean anything I said to be in derogation of the warning I gave you earlier that the onus lies on the prosecution to prove the case against each and every accused beyond reasonable doubt.

But let us go back to those words "there does not seem to be any way of avoiding total conflict on this issue between Mr. Haughey and Mr. Gibbons". There is no way. One or other perjured himself in court. Either the present Minister or the former Minister, both leading lights of the Fianna Fáil Party — one who has been stood over by the Taoiseach; the other who aspires to be Taoiseach — perjured himself in court. The judge has made this clear. It is clear to this House; it is clear to the people of Ireland. We are to have confidence in a Government which exists in office and may exist in office tomorrow night by the vote of Deputy Haughey one of the possible perjurers, and which contains Deputy Gibbons, the other possible perjurer.

Comment on this

Do not call me a possible perjurer.

Comment on this

The other possible perjurer, one or other of you——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Deputy FitzGerald has called me a possible perjurer.

Comment on this

Indeed.

Comment on this

I ask you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, to ask him to withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I am quoting from the judge. Will the Minister ask the judge to withdraw it?

Comment on this

There is only one Deputy in this House of whom a judge ever said he was guilty of perjury and he is not on this side of the House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would draw the attention of Deputies to the fact that on many occasions it has been ruled as disorderly to state that a Member is telling a deliberate untruth.

Comment on this

On a point of order. May I say that this volume, which is probably the biggest volume ever produced in the Debates of this House, and this debate itself, are laid on by the Opposition Parties evidently for one purpose alone, to discredit this Government and in particular to discredit me, and it comes very ill from a Deputy on the Opposition front bench.

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister knows, of course, it is not a point of order.

Comment on this

The Deputy has suggested I am a possible perjurer. I object to this and demand your protection.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has pointed out it will protect Deputies from any statements made which impute lies to anybody in the House.

Comment on this

A lie is one thing; perjury is another.

Comment on this

I see, so——

Comment on this

Does the Deputy withdraw that?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know the difference?

Comment on this

Indeed I do. The suggestion is that it is all right to tell a lie——

Comment on this

I shall deal with that in due course. I suggest the Deputy is a slanderer.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has ruled that allegations of deliberate untruths by Members towards other Members have on many occasions been ruled out as disorderly.

Comment on this

How can we refer to this matter at all?

Comment on this

You can refer to what a judge said.

Comment on this

I can repeat what the judge said. The judge puts it in much better, clearer language than I could. Why should I bother addressing either of these gentlemen directly? The judge has done it for me. He said:

It seems to me, and you are free to dismiss my opinion, either Mr. Gibbons concocted this and has come to court and perjured himself, or it happened. If there is another explanation please act on it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair does not rule on statements made outside.

Comment on this

That is a false, edited version of what the judge said.

Comment on this

How many paragraphs does the Minister want me to go back?

Comment on this

The Deputy is deliberately editing it——

Comment on this

I am editing nothing.

Comment on this

——in order to further his intentions to slander me. He is a slanderer.

Comment on this

I have read about half a column. How much more does the Minister want me to read?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister knows such statements as he has made are disorderly.

Comment on this

You must realise by now that Deputy FitzGerald's intention and the intention of his colleagues over there is to slander me and to slander my party. I object to that and I claim your protection from it.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil are running for cover.

Comment on this

They slander themselves.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will protect the rights of Members on any side of the House. Over the years statements which have imputed deliberate untruths to Members have been ruled out as disorderly. The Chair would hope that the debate could proceed on the basis that such allegations are not made by Members.

Comment on this

I am glad of your protection from being called a slanderer. In view of the suggestion by Deputy Gibbons that I edited the report and because I would be concerned not to be unfair to any Member of the House, including Deputy Gibbons—I have no personal animus at all against him; I do not know him and have had no contact with him; I never heard anything against him in my life until this thing happened — I should like to read the full text. The first part of what I read finished with the following sentence:

It is a matter for you to decide whether his conduct in regard to the statements he made in Dáil Éireann about the training of people in the Bogside or the statement he made in Dáil Éireann about his suspicions or that nothing concrete had emerged are within the category of technically correct statements which are made by politicians in Parliament or whether they show Mr. Gibbons to be a man given to half-truths and lies and whether as a result you should see him as being discredited as a witness. I express no opinion but leave the matter to you.

I then omitted some sentences which I thought were irrelevant but if Deputy Gibbons feels I was in any way unfair to him let me read the full text of the relevant passage from the judge's speech:

It had been put to Mr. Gibbons that it was an invention on his part when he swore that he had a meeting with Mr. Haughey in Mr. Haughey's room in Government buildings, where he asked Mr. Haughey if he could call off the illegal importation and Mr. Haughey said he would call it off for a month and Mr. Gibbons had said "call it off altogether." It was suggested to him, said the judge, in plain unvarnished language that that was an invention. His reply was: "I expressly say that it was incorrect to suggest that I knew about this matter" and he denied that it was an invention. Now I regret to say, gentlemen, that it seems to me — and I think it will seem to you—in regard to the conversation which Mr. Gibbons says took place in Mr. Haughey's office on Friday, April 17th or Monday, April 20th that it either took place or it did not take place. Either Mr. Gibbons, it seems to me, has concocted, invented, as Counsel put it to him, this conversation or it had happened in substance. As you will see later Mr. Haughey denies it and he cannot explain how his former colleague could say it is so. It is not like something said in the course of conversation that could be misinterpreted. It seems to me, and you are free to dismiss my opinion, either Mr. Gibbons concocted this and has come to court and perjured himself or it happened. If there is another explanation please act on it. There does not seem to me to be any way of avoiding the total conflict on this issue between Mr. Haughey and Mr. Gibbons. I do not put forward the matter by the suggestion that you should balance a State witness against a Defence witness. I do not mean anything I say to be in derogation of the warning I gave you earlier that the onus lies on the Prosecution to prove the case against each and every accused beyond reasonable doubt.

I have now read the entire passage. Then the judge goes on to deal with something else.

There is no editing and if Deputy Gibbons thinks the full regarding improves the position as regards himself and Deputy Haughey he is welcome to it. I have not said that he is a perjurer; I have said that one or other of them was said by the judge to be a perjurer. I have my suspicions as to which it is but I am not permitted to disclose them to this House. What is clear is that either the former Minister for Finance, on whose support this Government depends, did not tell the truth in court or the present Minister did not. The electorate can take their choice as to which wing of Fianna Fáil is responsible for this conflict of evidence. I do not think either wing of Fianna Fáil has emerged from this case with sufficient credit to continue to be responsible for the affairs of the country.

The third point I want to deal with is the collapse of collective responsibility under this Government. It is not necessary to go into it at great length —I do not propose to speak at great length today — because it has been so evident and obvious to the country that every vestige of collective responsibility has disappeared during the reign of Deputy Lynch as Taoiseach. We know why, because the Taoiseach in a very telling phrase, when he was concluding the debate on 9th May, explained why he had not felt able to handle the situation more effectively—I am not saying those are his exact words—and why he had not acted quicker against the two people whom he suspected of importing arms illegally. He told the House that he did not have the long Fianna Fáil background that they had. This was news to me because, as someone who knew Deputy Haughey 25 years ago in university, I was quite unaware of his long Fianna Fáil background. The Taoiseach seemed to think it was longer than his own and he felt himself in difficulties in dealing with men with such a background behind them because he did not have the equivalent background.

It was a very revealing phrase. It told us a great deal and it explained a great deal. It explained to me how a man, for whom most people in this country have had great respect, could fail so totally in the management of the affairs of the Government. It is clear that he meant well but when he found himself tackling these people with their long Fianna Fáil traditions — and the longer the tradition the further they have to fall—he felt inadequate for the task.

It was not only at the end of April, when he found out what was going on, that he felt inadequate for the task— he had felt and sounded inadequate during the previous winter when trying to deal with Deputy Blaney who was making his aggressive speeches. The Taoiseach was weakly answering him on radio — I forget the exact turn of phrase he used—but he explained that Deputy Blaney felt strongly about some things and could not be restrained. This is a new concept of collective responsibility; Ministers who feel strongly about something can say what they like about the Government's policy and apparently they can denounce the policy of the Government and the Taoiseach as long as they have strong feelings. That is not what the Constitution says about collective responsibility, but that was the Taoiseach's excuse when the Government line was persistently bucked by Deputy Blaney during last winter. The Taoiseach failed to act. He did not feel he was strong enough to act, he was not in command of his Government and he was not able to deal with Deputy Blaney or Deputy Boland when the latter burst forth with his somewhat more genuine republican utterances during last winter. He had to bide his time, he had to wait until he caught them in flagrante delicto and when he caught them in that state he dithered for a fortnight before acting.

Comment on this

When did they catch me?

Comment on this

If my grammar in any way appeared to include Deputy Boland my grammar was at fault. Deputy Boland and I might have certain differences of opinion in relation to certain political matters but I have no criticism of him in relation to this affair because he was in no way involved.

Comment on this

Honourably discharged.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach might perhaps have been a passable leader of a government of honest men in a period of peace and economic prosperity but as the leader of the kind of "gang" he has had to lead, which he inherited and failed to purge in time——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should not use the word "gang" in reference to a government.

Comment on this

It was the term used by the Minister for External Affairs in relation to his own party.

Comment on this

I apologise. I was quoting deliberately from the Minister for External Affairs and I am sorry to use his unparliamentary expression about his own party. I do not blame him and I apologise on his behalf.

Comment on this

It could be described as "airport slang".

Comment on this

The Taoiseach was not capable of dealing with the particular kind of people he inherited in that Government. He was not capable of dealing with the kind of situation which arose in the North of Ireland. He was panicked into foolish statements which gave rise to false hopes amongst decent people under great pressure at that time in the North of Ireland. He failed to cope with his Ministers, he failed to cope with the economic crisis. During the last crisis he came into this House and asked the question: "What went wrong?" One can sympathise with such a man. One feels he is a little more honest than other Ministers for Finance who have tried to cover things up. But one cannot feel he is a man adequate for the kind of situation this country faces. One cannot feel he can lead a Government containing such, to use his own words, "able and dedicated men" as Deputies Haughey, Blaney and others—perhaps he included Deputy Boland in that. He is not the man to lead such a Government even in times of peace and he is certainly not the man to lead a Government facing an economic crisis. It is his bad luck that he found himself in that position and we are entitled to be sorry for him.

I would, however, suggest through this House to the people that one should not choose one's Taoiseachs in times of great stress and emergency because one is sorry for them. That is not sufficient. There is a danger that the warm-hearted people of this country may fall into the trap of choosing their leaders on this basis. There is a time for warm-heartedness and a time for a sense of realism, but when a man shows himself through no fault of his own, not lacking in goodwill or in the will to do the job, but through reasons of personality and through reasons of his ability related to the particular crisis he faces, unable to cope, and exposing the country to obliquy, to contempt and to ridicule abroad, and when as a result one reads in a consistently and persistently friendly newspaper like The Guardian words like, “Banana republic” about this country, the man who lets affairs get into such chaos should realise, and above all the country should realise, that he should not continue to lead the Government, and that the party which has disgraced the country, the Taoiseach and other decent men in it should not continue until it has purged itself — I hope the word “purge” is not out of order. I am quoting from another Fianna Fáil Minister and it is rather difficult to quote a Fianna Fáil Minister speaking about his colleagues today without being unparliamentary—of these men and their supporters. Until then it is not entitled to come to the country with clean hands and to look for the right to continue governing the country either with or without an election.

There are other instances of a lack of collective responsibility. There was the remarkable instance of Deputy Blaney announcing to the public what he was looking for the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries and the then Minister for Finance acted with prompt response and showed a greater regard for collective responsibility on that occasion than he did on other occasions. That was a totally improper performance. A Minister was bidding for personal popularity at the expense of the collective will of the Government. This was the case of a Minister acting deliberately and directly against the Constitution of the State for personal popularity but nothing was done about that and he was sacked for something else shortly afterwards. We have had other cases of the Taoiseach standing over behaviour inappropriate to a Government abiding by this principle of collective responsibility.

A practice seems to be growing up where Ministers take publicly a different line from the Government; in fact some Opposition Members may even agree with the particular line they take—that is irrelevant—but that is no way to run a country. The principle of collective responsibility is one that is vital. We have learned the hard way how vital it is. I had not myself fully appreciated the depth or the importance of this until this whole thing occurred. I had always understood that it was important, but I am not sure I ever understood why it was important. I am not sure I ever understood fully the difference between a presidential system and a collective government system in a parliamentary democracy until this whole thing occurred.

Certainly we can now see that in a country with parliamentary democracy, which is not a presidential system, it is vital that the Government act collectively and together, vital that the Government should take clear-cut decisions, clearly written down and communicated and abided by and inspected to make sure they are abided by. Otherwise there is chaos, the kind of chaos we have suffered from in the last six months.

One would have thought that the Taoiseach, after these bitter experiences —and they must have been bitter for him—would have learned his lesson. One would have thought that at this stage he would have realised that unless he puts himself in a position where he can say that there is no member of his Government under shadow of suspicion, he cannot present himself to the Irish people as an appropriate leader. He has not done so. He has maintained in his Government Deputy Gibbons over whom there hangs certainly a shadow of suspicion.

Comment on this

Suspicion of what?

Comment on this

I am now coming to that.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Can the Deputy do that without being out of order?

Comment on this

I can because I am not referring to the other matter now. On that question of suspicion of perjury there is a problem between a Minister and an ex-Minister: I am not going back to that. I am quite prepared to believe that Deputy Gibbons may be the innocent party; I am not suggesting that he is the guilty party there but there is another matter: his performance of his duties as Minister in this whole affair was such as to make it impossible in any democratic system for such a man to continue as Minister. This is the problem with which I am concerned at this time. There was the other question which he and Deputy Haughey can fight out between them. It would make an interesting debate if they would debate it together, but I am concerned at the moment with the way he carried out his duties. He was given the full detailed knowledge of this affair by Captain Kelly——

Comment on this

What does the

Comment on this

He was told of the plan to import arms. He was told the port they were coming from——

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

He was told the next port they were to come from. He was not told the name of the ship apparently, if that is the detail that was missing.

Comment on this

That is not true and the Deputy has not a scrap of evidence to show that it is true.

Comment on this

Captain Kelly says he told you.

Comment on this

I have read out to this House every word I could find that the Minister said on this subject. Every word of the Minister in court convicts him. The Minister said Captain Kelly told him of his visit to the port of Dublin—he went down on March 25th. The Army was there at the same time. You asked did the Army disappear into the shadows or did he. You found out what port the goods came from. You found out what port he was trying to bring them from next, Trieste.

Comment on this

Yes, and it was wrong.

Comment on this

It was wrong?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Captain Kelly never went to the port of Dublin?

Comment on this

That was the first one.

Comment on this

I see. Let us be clear about this. Deputy Gibbons suggests that arms were not attempted to be imported to Dublin port on March 25th and that all the people who gave evidence to that effect, customs officials and so on, were perjuring themselves.

Comment on this

The Deputy is trying to mislead the House. I suggest he is back on his slander track.

Comment on this

I am trying to get at the truth.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not trying to get the truth.

Comment on this

Let us take it stage by stage. Captain Kelly told you in your office, possibly at the first meeting in March, but you think more probably at the second meeting at the end of March or early April, that he had gone to Dublin port to bring in arms——

Comment on this

Of an event that had already taken place.

Comment on this

——of an attempt to bring in arms——

Comment on this

An abortive attempt that had already taken place and he did not tell me of the part he played in it.

Comment on this

He did not tell you whether he or the Army disappeared into the shadows? Is that what you did not know?

Comment on this

He did not——

Comment on this

Come off it.

Comment on this

He did not tell me of the part he played in it.

Comment on this

The Minister is going on record again.

Comment on this

Yes, I know.

Comment on this

It is on the record here again.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

You will be quoted from that.

Comment on this

Yes, of course.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy FitzGerald is in possession.

Comment on this

Let us be entirely fair to the Minister. Let me quote his own words again. Apparently, he is anxious to have them repeated.

Comment on this

They are rather more accurate than the Deputy's version of it.

Comment on this

I read out every word before and I am happy to read it out again.

Comment on this

And the Deputy can then give his own version of it again.

Comment on this

And the Minister never thought of telling the Taoiseach about what was going on.

Comment on this

I shall deal with that point, too.

Comment on this

Credibility, how are you!

Comment on this

I want to get the right papers together again. I think there is probably not much use wasting time going over all the bits I read before but I can do so if the Minister insists. Let me just read the concluding part in relation to this. Let me read rather more fully than I did before the end of the cross-examination here:

Mr. Sorohan handed to Mr. Gibbons a copy of the Official Report of the Dáil Debates and asked him to read it.

Having read it, Mr. Gibbons said the relevant piece of his speech in the Dáil was that it was suggested in a Radio Éireann interview that any participation by Captain James Kelly in an attempt to smuggle arms could only have been made with his (Mr. Gibbons) knowledge and consent.

Mr. Sorohan asked Mr. Gibbons to read the next sentence and Mr. Gibbons read: "I wish emphatically to deny such knowledge or consent".

Mr. Sorohan: You did have knowledge, did you not? I am not suggesting at the moment that you consented but did you not have knowledge from March?

Mr. Gibbons: I had vestigial knowledge.

Mr. Sorahan: What do you mean by that? Would you use perhaps a more mundane or down-to-earth word than that?

Mr. Gibbons: I had been given to understand previously by Captain Kelly in the most vague and nebulous way that he proposed to leave the army in order to take part in the assistance of the people in Northern Ireland and I understood that this could very well embrace the importation of arms. But the fact that he recognised that his resignation from the army would be necessary to do this...

Mr. Finlay (for Captain Kelly): The witness is not answering any question that was put to him. He is not giving an account of any conversation...

Mr. Sorahan: I agree. He has gone off the rails.

—not for the first time—

Mr. Sorahan then asked: You had vestigial knowledge, is that right?

Mr. Gibbons: Yes.

Mr. Sorahan: But you had knowledge simpliciter, is that not right?

Mr. Gibbons: Yes.

What more can anybody say in regard to that? I can go back and read out the business about the attempt on 25th March, the discussion of the question as to whether the Army or he had disappeared into the shadows, the question of what port the arms were coming from, where the next consignment was to come from, but what is the point? Is there one person in this country, Deputy Gibbons included, who would raise any question or shadow of a doubt that he had knowledge? He has admitted in the fullest sense to this knowledge. The only thing missing is the name of the boat.

Comment on this

I have not.

Comment on this

Do not let us waste time with this man.

Comment on this

The Minister admitted it to Mr. Sorohan.

Comment on this

On a point of order—I said in court that I had vestigial knowledge of a scheme to import arms and I stand over that. What I meant by that was that a scheme to import arms was under way, but having any comprehensive knowledge of that, I denied in the court and I deny now. Deputy FitzGerald—and I have no doubt his colleagues as well — for the last six months have been endeavouring to slander me——

Comment on this

——and they are going to fail.

Comment on this

Let him condemn himself.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister knows that this is not a point of order; it may be a point of explanation, but not of order.

Comment on this

It is useful to have it on the record. The more he says the happier we are. The Minister does not deny that he had this discussion which he swore to on oath in court with Captain Kelly about the attempt to import arms on March 25th. He does not deny that, as he swore in court, he discussed it with him amicably, asked him questions about it, discussed with him the port from which the arms came and what was the port from which the next consignment would come. He does not deny these statements that he gave on oath, I take it, and yet he calls that "not knowledge"—or no, he calls it "vestigial knowledge". But when pressed to the full truth and asked: Was that not knowledge simpliciter? he has to say “Yes.”

Comment on this
Mr. Gibbons

What does the Deputy understand by the word “simpliciter”?

Comment on this

Unqualified knowledge: knowledge without qualification: knowledge not to be discounted, run down, or diminished.

Comment on this

True and full knowledge.

Comment on this

Unqualified knowledge of the fact that there was an attempt to import arms.

Comment on this

Go back to Nkrumah.

Comment on this

At least Nkrumah knew when to go.

Comment on this

We have this Minister who is told of this attempt to import arms, who is told that a further attempt to import arms is being made through the port of Trieste, whose reaction to this attempt to import arms illegally — because, on his own evidence, it was done without his authority —is anything but what it should have been. With all that knowledge, how did he act? There are a number of possible ways in which a man could act in those circumstances. He could call the Chief of Staff and ask for immediate action to be taken against this officer engaged in, in the Minister's view, the illegal importation of arms. He could have this officer court-martialled. He could report to the Taoiseach. He could report to the Special Branch.

Comment on this

I did not have to. The Special Branch were aware of the position.

Comment on this

Did he do any of these things? No. The only thing he did was to try to get a job for this officer on the Border so that he could continue all these illegal activities. All the Minister for Defence at the time was concerned with was to get this man off his plate and on to someone else's. It was OK so long as the Minister was off the hook.

Comment on this

I will not be lectured by a British Army deserter. Let the Deputy go back to the British Army and serve his time. He is absent without leave.

Comment on this

They say that the octopus, when he is in danger, exudes an inky dye. Fianna Fáil is exuding such a dye now.

Comment on this

I shall deal with my enemies all right.

Comment on this

The Labour Party are not getting the full honour: the Minister will "fix" the Opposition leader but he will only "deal with" the Labour Party.

Comment on this

How clever, how subtle, the Deputy is.

Comment on this

I suggest both Members of the Government front bench at the moment should leave the House.

Comment on this

Again, the action the Minister took, when given this knowledge of an attempt simpliciter to import arms illegally and of a plan to import arms again illegally from the port of Trieste, was to seek to get the officer transferred from the Department of Defence to a position in which he would be involved in activities near the Border. In court it became clear in the Minister's cross-examination that he was not concerned if the officer went on importing arms illegally so long as he was no longer an Army officer. That is what the Minister said in court.

Comment on this

The Special Branch knew that Captain Kelly was engaged in these activities and I knew that they knew.

Comment on this

And, yet, the Minister did not know that there was an attempt to import arms.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would point out again that this House is not a court of law and, if a Member says that a statement is not true, it is the established practice in this House that the Member's statement is accepted.

Comment on this

We are left in some difficulties at this stage.

Comment on this

We certainly are.

Comment on this

The duty of a Minister in Government, when there is no policy decision to import arms to distribute in Northern Ireland, given knowledge of this, was to take action to prevent it, not to take action to facilitate it; not to consider his own skin or his individual responsibility in the Department of Defence but, as a Minister in the Government, to act collectively in dealing with this matter and in preventing this illegal act taking place. This he did not do. He did not inform the Taoiseach. When asked about informing the Taoiseach he said he told Deputy Haughey to inform the Taoiseach. There are various ways of dealing with a conspiracy, if I may use the word the Tánaiste used, and the most unusual way of dealing with a conspiracy is to tell one of the people you believe to be a conspirator to inform on himself. It does not seem an adequate way to discharge one's duties as a Member of the Government.

The excuse given by Deputy Gibbons is a rather curious one: he was only a junior Minister and it was not for him to go direct to the Taoiseach. I did not know the Taoiseach was held in such awe by his colleagues. This commanding figure! We know the Taoiseach as an approachable man. The idea that Ministers in Government are so junior that, when they discover an attempt to import arms illegally, they cannot approach the Taoiseach direct but can only do so through a man who is suspected of being one of the chief conspirators, is quite ludicrous. This does not lead one to believe there is much collective responsibility in the present Government as a whole. Deputy Gibbons, Minister for Defence at the time, could have told the Taoiseach what was happening.

An article appeared in This Week last May, which seemed to emanate from the Minister in which it was said, apparently on his authority, that he had informed the Taoiseach about these gentlemen in, I think, the previous December. The Taoiseach, however, did not accept this. He denied in the debate that the Minister had ever informed him about or reported to him on any other Minister. Once again, we are faced with a conflict of evidence. Are we to believe the statement which came from Deputy Gibbons, Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, this week, exculpating himself hastily right in the middle of the debate, or are we to believe the Taoiseach? As between the two I have my choice as to whose evidence I would prefer, though I cannot suggest to the House that one can accept either statement with complete confidence.

There was, of course, a complete collapse of collective responsibility. More than that, there was in the handling of this whole affair the most utter incompetence. There was an absence of any chain of command and a complete breakdown in the system of Administration and Government. An army usually runs on a fairly strict basis from the point of view of the chain of command. If action is to be taken by a junior officer of the rank of captain, he will be told by his superior officer what that action is and what he is to do and that superior officer gets his instructions from higher up and ultimately, if it is a policy matter, it goes back right to the Government itself. If arms are to be imported for any purpose, legally or sub-legally, that can only result from a collective Government decision and the instruction goes through the Minister for Defence to the Chief of Staff and so on down along the line. If it is to be done through the Intelligence Corps it will go from the Chief of Staff to the Director of Intelligence. That was not the chain of command in this case. The accepted chain—this was given by the Director of Intelligence publicly in court as being the normal satisfactory way of receiving instructions in a matter of this kind—was for the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to tell his subordinate that arms were to be imported and the Director of Intelligence got the instructions from his subordinate, his subordinate having got them from the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. A more ludicrous, incompetent way of doing an action of this kind is difficult to imagine.

The reason was that the authority of the Government had been subverted by Deputy Blaney. When one reads this trial carefully Deputy Blaney crops up time and time again and disappears again into the mist, covering his tracks so well that the District Justice refused information against him. He is the man who asked Mr. Luykx to help. He is the man to whom Captain Kelly was reporting every week. He was involved in this affair long before he came to the Minister for Defence and involved him in the affair and got his "negative" authorisation, when the Minister for Defence was so afraid of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries he was not prepared to countermand what was being done on the authority, we are told, of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. How can we carry on the government of this country on that basis? How can we tolerate a position in which you have a senior Minister, the Minister for Agriculture, running his own intelligence service in Northern Ireland, interfering in the Army, giving instruction to junior officers in the Army in a matter of this kind and purporting, apparently, to instruct the Director of Intelligence, through his subordinates, as to how he was to carry out his duties, with the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries being reported to weekly — I do not mean "w-e-a-k-l-y"——

Comment on this

To whom is the Deputy referring when he speaks of "the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries"?

Comment on this

I am sorry. The then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. There is a difficulty here because of the reshuffle. The then Minister for Defence had not been approached by Captain Kelly until long after he, Captain Kelly, had been in weekly contact with the then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. I am glad Deputy Gibbons enabled me to clarify that point. One could get into some confusion here because of the change-over of portfolios.

We cannot tolerate a situation whereby the peace of the country is put in jeopardy by Ministers acting in that way, subverting the normal channels of authority, undermining Army discipline and acting without any authority. We were told in the evidence that a committee for northern affairs was appointed by the Government at some point. I hope I am correct when I say it consisted of Deputies Haughey, Blaney, Faulkner and Brennan. If I am wrong in not including the name of Deputy Gibbons I trust I shall be corrected. We were told the committee met once but that it became so clear to all concerned what they had to do that it did not meet again. Each person dispersed to his job. Just what the Ministers for Labour and Education were doing from then on in connection with this matter I do not know; their names never reappear. Perhaps they were engaged in some more constructive activities in connection with Northern Ireland, but we have not been told about this. After this one meeting, out of which it became so clear as to the action to be taken, the two other Ministers went about their duties, and the duties devolving from the Government through this committee, to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries were interpreted by him as being to take charge of the Army intelligence.

Comment on this

What Minister?

Comment on this

The former Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.

Comment on this

Since the nature of the Deputy's motion against me is on the basis of accuracy, the Deputy had better be accurate himself.

Comment on this

I was not inaccurate but I admit when one refers to a Minister by the title of his office this can lead to lack of clarity. I am glad to be reminded to be clear as well as accurate. The Minister will appreciate I am not attempting to confuse the issue here and am trying to explain clearly what happened.

We are talking about Deputy Blaney and I am happy to continue speaking about him in this manner rather than refer to him as Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if this will make things more clear. Throughout the entire affair Deputy Blaney keeps popping up: he calls the meeting to see what has gone wrong, when somebody had got wise to the plot. At each stage Deputy Blaney emerges and when Deputy Gibbons was afraid to go to the Taoiseach because he was only a junior Minister, this reminds me of the word "fear" that was used by the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries——

Comment on this

In what context? Will the Deputy elaborate?

Comment on this

In relation to Deputy Blaney. I have not the records before me now but during the course of the trial it was said by a person giving evidence—I thought it was the Minister but if he denies it I must accept his word; I cannot check it at the moment—yes, it was the Minister —that he was afraid Deputy Blaney would do something worse or more rash. Having said he was afraid, in subsequent evidence he actually used the word "fear." It was the Minister opposite who said that. It seems to me when the Minister failed to do his duty and to report to the Taoiseach on the conspiracy that, in his view, was taking place, if there was fear in his mind it was not fear of the Taoiseach. I do not think the Taoiseach is a man who inspires fear. He may inspire other emotions; affection in some people——

Comment on this

Awe?

Comment on this

——he may arouse discontent in others but not, I think, fear. The only person about whom the word "fear" has been used in this case by the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is Deputy Blaney. It appears to me when Deputy Gibbons failed to take action against a subordinate who had been reporting to Deputy Blaney week by week and getting his instructions from him, it was not because he was afraid to go to the Taoiseach because of his junior position but because he was afraid of the man behind it all—Deputy Blaney.

Comment on this

The Deputy is misrepresenting facts again.

Comment on this

Not only will the Minister have an opportunity of intervening throughout my speech to clarify points, which he is doing, he will have an opportunity to speak at more length later on. In all this Deputy Blaney emerges from the mists again and again and disappears, covering his traces. May I say I have heard the words "afraid" and "fear" from members of the party opposite used in relation to Deputy Blaney before now? I have heard it several times during the years as he is a man who inspires not affection but fear in the minds of many on the other side of the House. That is why there are so many Members opposite — they may include Deputy Haughey—who are hoping that on next Wednesday night Deputy Blaney will sit in his seat instead of walking into the Government Lobby so that thereby they can get rid of him. If the Dáil were rid of him I believe it would be a good thing; it is a harsh thing to say and there are few Deputies in this House about whom I would say it.

There has been incompetence in the running of the more serious aspects of our affairs; and there are few matters more serious than matters involving guns in relation to another part of this country. This matter was handled casually and incompetently, handled by people who suffered from "the casual arrogance of power" and who were so sure of themselves that they did not worry about being caught. Their shock and horror at discovering that there was a security service they had not subverted became evident at this meeting, called and recalled by Deputy Blaney when the whole thing began to come out.

There has also been incompetence in the control of Government expenditure: the way in which the money was gaily handed out to a fund to be placed in the names of three imaginary people, to be spent for purposes unknown, which we now know to have included the illegal purchase of arms. There has been such a total breakdown of the Government machine, so many attempts to subvert public servants, using them for illegal purposes against the interests of this State, that the men who did it and those who let them do it and tried to cover up for them should not be allowed to continue in power. At no time in the history of this State has there been more justification for a vote of no confidence in the Government.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Has Deputy FitzGerald promised Deputy Desmond some job in the Coalition?

Comment on this

You called out to Mr. Haughey to commiserate with him——

Comment on this

Not to commiserate.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy FitzGerald.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Desmond going to support homosexuality and divorce when Dr. Noel Browne brings it up?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy FitzGerald.

Comment on this

There may be times when an Opposition party puts down a vote of no confidence that, for reasons of tactics, may not mean very much. It may be part of the Parliamentary game but this is no game. Things are much too serious to play games.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy FitzGerald please continue?

Comment on this

Let us look at the Government and consider how qualified they are to carry on the government of the country after getting rid of so many of the able men, as we were told. Ability is not so rife throughout the Fianna Fáil benches that you can get——

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's problem.

Comment on this

Deputy Colley has awoken at last——

Comment on this

He disgraced himself last week.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

One speaker at a time is enough.

Comment on this

I do not think that the picture of this Government, photographed together at Dublin Airport welcoming back their Taoiseach, is such as to inspire great confidence.

Comment on this

In Deputy FitzGerald.

Comment on this

This does not give the picture to me, or perhaps to many other people, of a Government likely to be in command of our affairs, or even to run them more efficiently than they have been run for the last six months or a year. The Government that maintains Deputy Gibbons after his performance in court is a Government which cannot command much confidence.

Coming now to the patriots, or fellow-patriots, I ask what has happened them? What has happened the patriots? How many are left? Were there ten little nigger boys and are we down to two, or one, or any? What has happened them? Have the patriots been purchased and, if so, on what terms? Is it fear of losing their seats or fear of being unpopular in their party through precipitating an election that their party would lose, that has made them so tame? Is that why they have become so tame all of a sudden? Where now is the state of euphoria of Friday week? Where are the loud voices calling for the departure of Deputy J. Lynch? Where are the voices of men confidently saying that they feel arms should be sent to the north? I do not hear them so loudly. I would be interested to hear any of them in this debate. I would be more interested still to see them walk through that lobby to save their skins, but let them not use the word "patriot" to cover either what they have done or will do next Wednesday night.

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, this motion calls on Dáil Éireann to reaffirm its confidence in An Taoiseach and the other members of the Government. I would like to ask for a ruling from you, in view of the fact that the Attorney General is not a member of the Government, as to whether or not it is in order for me to discuss on this motion the suitability of the Attorney General to hold his high office. The precedent established in this House has been that the Taoiseach answers for the activities of the Attorney General. I would ask you to rule that it is in order to discuss the Attorney General as well as the members of the Government and the Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has been aware that judges or the law officers are not subject to a debate in this House. The Taoiseach answers for them.

Comment on this

This is a particular law officer who was appointed by the Taoiseach and, just like members of the Government, holds his office at the will and pleasure of the Taoiseach. The precedent has been that the Taoiseach has, on previous occasions, answered for the activities of this particular law officer and, in fact, there have been occasions when the Attorney General was a Member of this House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that the motion that is before the House is one expressing confidence in the Taoiseach and in the members of the Government.

Comment on this

The point I would like to put to you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, is that the Taoiseach in this instance must include the Attorney Genral who is his law officer, who is his creation, and who remains in office only as long as the Taoiseach wishes him to remain there and whose actions must be considered to be the actions of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is aware that if someone wants to make a specific law officer or judge or the Attorney General the subject of a motion in the House then a specific motion in that regard must be put down.

Comment on this

Is this true of Ministers?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

I hope this will be discussed in the future. One of the matters which have emerged from the recent trial is the question of the suitability of the present holder of this very important position of Attorney General. The Attorney General is in such a position of power and, in view of the way in which he has conducted this particular trial and has not even been prepared to refrain from attacking the character of a distinguished retired Army officer, who had reached the highest rank which it is possible for any officer, except the Chief of Staff, to reach, and in a way that must be considered an attack on the whole morale of the Defence forces of this State, his suitability should surely be discussed. In view of that, and of your ruling, I hope that at some time somebody will arrange that the suitability of this individual to hold his high office will also be discussed in this House.

In so far as this motion is concerned the Members of Dáil Éireann are being asked to say by their votes, at a time which apparently has been fixed by the Whips of the three parties for 10.30 p.m. on tomorrow night, that they have confidence in the Taoiseach and in each individual member of the Government. In other words, we are to say by our votes that we believe the Taoiseach and each individual member of the Government is qualified to hold the high office which they occupy at present. While the Opposition naturally are at liberty to range over the whole field of Government activity and deal with every member of the Government if they like, I think it is quite clear that in fact this motion boils down to the question as to whether the Taoiseach is fit to be Taoiseach and the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is fit to be a Minister. I do not think anybody can be in any doubt as to my opinion on that question. Although it can be said with some force that my opinion is so well known that there is no need for me to expand on it, I propose to put on record the immediate considerations which made my attitude on this motion inevitable. It is also known that I am only one of a number of Fianna Fáil Deputies to hold the same opinions on this matter. That is something which is known to everybody including the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

We will know tomorrow night.

Comment on this

The exact number of those Deputies is, of course, not known. It will not be established as Deputy FitzGerald thinks. It will not be established by the vote tomorrow night. Neither will it be established by a roll call vote at a meeting of the Fianna Fáil political party at midnight under the threat of the immediate dissolution of the Dáil. The Taoiseach will not discover by this motion the number of Deputies on this side of the House who are of the opinion that he is not, in fact, fit to be Taoiseach and that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is not fit to be a Minister.

I want to say that I know there are a number of Deputies who have the same opinion as I have on this matter. If my action on this motion differs from that of others who hold the same views, I do not want to imply any condemnation of them because I act differently from the way they do. I am not so presumptuous as to assert that I must be right and they must be wrong. All I say is that it appears to me after long consideration and after hearing other views very forcibly put forward, that the action I propose to take is the right one and that, since I am fully convinced it is the right action, then it is the right course for me to follow. I can accept that others may sincerely see their duty differently and, if they do, that is their business. If they simply see their duty differently from me, then they are right to act as they think proper.

But I do say this: on the basis of established facts — and I think it is reasonable to assume that a matter that has been decided by a jury in the High Court after a long trial, after a trial and a half, is a fact and that if we are to accept anything as a fact we must accept such a decision as a fact—it is my opinion that no one who has any respect for the important institutions of the Dáil and the Government could actually believe that the time has not come for those two individuals to move to the back benches.

It is already on record that I have grave doubts as to the Taoiseach's adherence to what has hitherto been the Fianna Fáil attitude to the partition of our country. I have made it clear also what I think of the action in arresting John Kelly and I accept the Taoiseach's charge that what I advocated on that occasion would be a selective application of the law. That is right. But it would not be unusual, as Deputies on both sides of the House know, if there was a selective application of the law. It is beyond question there has been, in different instances, selective application of the law.

In regard to these things, on which I am on record and on which my thoughts are already known, I have doubts about the Taoiseach's credibility as a Fianna Fáil Taoiseach. I am prepared to wait until the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis or until finally the Taoiseach comes down to brass tacks and enunciates his new policy.

Before I deal with the particular issues that must decide my attitude in this matter, in view of the continued misrepresentation by certain members of the Government I want once again to make it clear that I am and always have been totally opposed to a policy of force towards the solution of the evil of partition and that I agree, as I have always agreed, that our approach in the Twenty-six Counties area should be as Fianna Fáil policy already has been.

These fundamental differences are, of course, more important than the actual immediate issue of personal suitability which cannot be avoided in this vote tomorrow night. In so far as I am concerned, these more fundamental differences could be postponed for some time, and since I have already dealt with them inside and outside the House, I do not propose to take up the time of the House now. It seems to me that the result of the recent conspiracy charge decided in the High Court is sufficient for me to consider in making up my mind. It does not seem to me to be necessary to go into it in any great detail: I do not see it is necessary for me to go into all the evidence given, as Deputy FitzGerald did. The judge's charge to the jury and the jury's verdict is sufficient to make it clear that the Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries are not entitled to the confidence they are asking this House to vote in them.

The issue seems to me to be perfectly simple and straightforward and the decision I will have to make at the conclusion of this debate does not seem to allow of any equivocation. If I am to abide by the majority decision of the Fianna Fáil Party, of the Fianna Fáil party parliamentary group—and that is what I understand by the word "party" as used in the pledge I signed prior to contesting the general election although I know I could, if I liked, quibble about the definition of the word "party" because it is not defined in any relevant document, what I understand is that it means the Fianna Fáil parliamentary group—I must vote to express confidence in the Taoiseach as Taoiseach and in the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries as a Minister, and that is absolutely out of the question.

I regard a vote in Dáil Éireann as a matter of grave significance and because of the action that has been forced on me I must show why I could not possibly support this motion, and this, unfortunately, involves showing why it appears to me that neither the Taoiseach nor the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is fit to hold the important position he holds.

The position in regard to Deputy Gibbons is perfectly clear. Probably he was the principal State witness in the recent conspiracy trial and, as Minister for Defence at the time to which the charges in the High Court referred, he was one of the two Ministers who could make an importation of arms legal. There was no suggestion that the Minister for Justice had in any way acted to make the importation of arms in question legal, and the trial judge, in directing the jury, told them in the clearest possible terms that unless they were satisfied the Minister for Defence at the time had authorised this importation of arms they could not bring in a verdict of not guilty. The Minister for Defence, now the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, swore that he gave no such authority. The judge also told the jury that unless they were satisfied the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries had concocted his story of a conversation with the former Minister for Finance they could not bring in a verdict of not guilty.

They did bring in a verdict of not guilty and it is clear as daylight that the jury, in addition to finding the four accused not guilty, also brought in a verdict against the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. So, in helping me to make up my mind as to how I will vote tomorrow night, I have this verdict of this jury who had been charged by the judge and who had sworn to administer the law without fear or favour.

I feel that I should quote from the reports of those proceedings. In addressing the jury the trial judge said:

It is a question of whether Mr. Gibbons authorised the import of arms and ammunition for the use of armed forces, and he begins by saying he gave no such authorisation.

Further on, the trial judge said:

The only person authorised by Parliament to give approval was the Minister for Defence.

In opening his address to the jury, he told them that they must accept the law as he stated it and apply it as he stated it, and the jury of 12 men had sworn that they would do that. With regard to the conversation between the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the former Minister for Finance, the judge said:

It is a matter for you whether that conversation took place or not. If it took place in substance as Mr. Gibbons had recalled it, it would indicate that on that Friday or on that Monday Mr. Haughey knew of an illegal shipment and that he was undertaking to stop it for a month. And if it is correct, there can be no question that this was being imported under the authority of the Minister for Defence for the use of the armed forces because Mr. Gibbons was forbidding it...

Either Mr. Gibbons, it seems to me, had concocted — invented as Counsel put it to him—this conversation or it had happened in substance.

Further on he said:

It seems to me, and you are free to dismiss my opinion, either Mr. Gibbons concocted this and has come to court and perjured himself, or it happened.

It is quite clear that the jury decided in fact that Deputy Gibbons, the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, in whom the Dáil is asked to express its confidence concocted this story and, in the words of the judge, "came to the court and perjured himself".

Having gone on to deal with the evidence of Mr. Berry—and surely his case must be dealt with also by the Government because the jury by implication made the same decision in respect of Mr. Berry—the judge said, having dealt with his evidence:

...I would like to be able to suggest some way you can avoid holding there is perjury in this case. You have a solemn and serious responsibility to decide in this case firstly whether Mr. Gibbons's conversation took place or not; and secondly, whether Mr. Berry's conversation took place or not.

Further on, the judge said:

I shall not give any opinion on these crucial matters, because if I were to do so, I might be thought to be constituting myself the jury. These are matters reserved exclusively for a jury. But I would be wanting in my duty if I did not point out the crucial pieces of evidence. If you went to the jury room without having your attention drawn to these conflicts, these irreconcilable conflicts, you might reach a wrong decision.

Clearly, what this motion asks the House to do is to say that the jury, having had their attention drawn to these irreconcilable conflicts by the judge, having been told at the outset that they must accept the law as he stated it and apply it as he stated it and having sworn individually in open court to administer the law without fear or favour—that, in spite of all these things, they did perversely reach a wrong decision. That is what the Members of this House are asked to say by their votes tomorrow night but, of course, the Members of this House have not sworn an oath and this, in the immortal words of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, "is a Dáil debate".

The people are entitled to be assured that the elected legislators and, in particular, the Taoiseach and his Ministers will respect the due processes of the law. To reach our decision, we have available to us a duly recorded verdict of the High Court. The judge said that he could not find any way that the jury could avoid holding that there was perjury in this case. It is beyond doubt that the jury found there was perjury and it is crystal clear where the jury found that perjury to be. Apparently, however, such was the importance of Deputy Gibbons to the Taoiseach or to the Government—I do not know which —that during the trial the character of a most distinguished Army officer was savagely assailed and, as I said, this was done in a manner that struck at the morale of the Army as a whole— the Army which is one of the fundamental institutions of the State. Apparently, such is still the importance of Deputy Gibbons to the Taoiseach or to the Government—I do not know which—that now the character of the 12 jurymen who swore a solemn oath to bring in a just and true verdict is being attacked by the Taoiseach in press interviews, in New York and at Dublin Airport, as well as by this motion in the Dáil. Obviously, this constitutes an attack on another of the fundamental institutions of the State — the courts of justice.

Of course, it is evident beyond any shadow of doubt that the Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries are inextricably associated with each other in this whole business and that what goes for one must go for the other.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

In this situation where there is such an open and indissoluble relationship between the Taoiseach and the Minister, between the man who gave the sworn testimony in court and the man who procured his services, it is correct to say that if there is culpability then the major degree of culpability attaches to the principal and the minor degree of culpability attaches to the instrument.

The Taoiseach has clearly and indissolubly associated himself with the Minister. During the debate on the nomination of Members of the Government on the 9th May, the Taoiseach in concluding, as reported at column 1339, Volume 246 of the Official Report said:

At no time had I any reason to suspect that Deputy Gibbons was engaged in any activity that did not befit his office. Allegations made following the opening of this debate have been thoroughly examined. As a result, I am satisfied that Deputy Gibbons was not involved in the importation of arms. If I were not so satisfied I would not now be asking the House to approve of his nomination as Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.

Further on the Taoiseach said at column 1346:

I explained to the House that I was satisfied before this debate started that Deputy Gibbons carried out his duties in accordance with the full requirements of his office. When these allegations were made during the course of the debate I had him very carefully and thoroughly investigated. As a result of that investigation I am satisfied that Deputy Gibbons——

Deputy Corish interjected:

Who is the liar, Kelly or Gibbons?

The Taoiseach continued:

As a result of that investigation I have no suspicion.

It is clear that the Taoiseach endorsed the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries before this trial and the abortive trial did not come to an end until after the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries had concluded his direct evidence and cross-examination. The result of that direct evidence and cross-examination was there for all to see. The proceedings were reported fully—I do not know from which trial Deputy FitzGerald was quoting—but they were reported fully both of the abortive trial and the trial that was concluded.

I do not think that anybody could believe that the Taoiseach and his Ministers did not read these reports, so that before the start of the actual trial that was decided they knew the performance that had been put up by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries on the first occasion. They must have been aware of the conflicts of evidence to which the trial judge drew the attention of the jury. They must have been aware also of the conflicts in the evidence of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries himself. The case could have been withdrawn at that stage in view of the obvious unreliability of the principal State witness but it was not.

Such was the determination to secure a conviction that the Taoiseach and his law officer — who, I understand, I am not permitted to discuss on this motion — sent the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries back again to the High Court to repeat the performance, although this time, it is true, that again such was their determination to get a conviction that certain unworthy and unfair precautions and preparations were made to try to improve upon the performance that had created such a bad impression with everybody who read it or saw it on the first occasion. This action of continuing with the trial and the manner in which it was attempted to bolster up the evidence of the Minister, Deputy Gibbons, on this occasion clearly constituted a re-endorsement of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries by the Taoiseach during the trial and was a further very definite identifying of himself with the Minister by the Taoiseach.

Since then, since the verdict of the jury, the Taoiseach has further continued to endorse the Minister at his press interviews in New York and at that wildly enthusiastic reception at Dublin Airport under the auspices of Ryan's Tourist Holdings Ltd. Now, again, despite the fact that he has had time, following his return from New York to re-adjust himself to Irish circumstances and Irish conditions, and despite the fact that irrespective of the result of this vote he knows that not all the Fianna Fáil Party here by any means endorse the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, he insists that the Fianna Fáil Party will vote confidence in him. As I said, he has clearly and indissolubly identified himself with the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in so far as this matter is concerned. He is welded to him.

Last May the Taoiseach said that it was not tolerable that there should be the slightest taint of suspicion attaching to a Member of the Government. I wonder can the Taoiseach seriously suggest that there is not at least the slightest taint of suspicion attaching to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and through him, in view of the fact that he has sponsored him before, during and after the trial, to himself as Taoiseach? If this is so, it surely is a new concept of the law, that suspicion attaches to those who are adjudged to be not guilty by the courts of justice and that those who are condemned by implication are without suspicion. It is a new concept of the law to me and it is, indeed, to use the Taoiseach's own word, something of a novelty.

I understand that I cannot deal with the Attorney General although the fact that the Attorney General at the time of that court case is still Attorney General is a reflection on the Taoiseach at whose will and pleasure he holds his office but that can possibly be dealt with at some other time. I daresay I cannot deal either with the fact that it has been established by the courts that the permanent head of the Department of Justice also perjured himself in the witness box. In any case, to deal with these matters might only confuse the issue that we have to decide. However, I must point out that it was not necessary for the jury in making the decision they made to make a judgment as between the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the former director of Army Intelligence, to make a value judgment between them merely on the basis of their own performance because the Minister's own evidence under cross-examination was sufficient to show who was telling the truth. In this respect the trial judge—I do not think it is necessary to do any more than quote what he had to say—said, and I quote:

Mr. Justice Henchy said that at the end of March or early in April Mr. Gibbons alleged that he was told by Captain Kelly that there had been an attempted importation of arms at the port of Dublin on March 25.

The report went on to say:

Mr. Gibbons had also said that when he suggested to Captain Kelly that this was the end of that consignment, Captain Kelly indicated that further efforts would be made to bring it in, probably from Trieste.

Clearly the Minister, who denied any knowledge of or any consent to the operation, actually admitted discussing the importation of arms with this junior officer. He described it, of course, as "vestigial knowledge" and I do not know whether it was vestigial knowledge or not, but he did discuss the importation of arms in which Captain Kelly was personally involved with Captain Kelly. The judge when dealing with this later said that:

The jury might say that Mr. Gibbons should have put his foot down and told Captain Kelly that he must not import arms in any circumstances, that that was a matter for the proper Army authorities and that when he (Mr. Gibbons) got information about the attempted importation into the port of Dublin and the projected importation from Vienna, and when he, Mr. Gibbons, did not say no in categorical terms, Captain Kelly was entitled to presume that Mr. Gibbons was saying yes.

"That is the view that is open to you; I will say no more about it" said Judge Henchy.

This is the view, which the judge said was open to them, which the jury, having heard all the evidence, clearly decided to take. It was obviously the only reasonable view to take. They could not have taken any other view in view of the oath they had sworn to bring in a just and true verdict They were ordinary, reasonable, intelligent men and they would know that if this importation of arms was a breach of Captain Kelly's duty as an Army officer it was not a minor breach of conduct such as not paying his mess bill but a major breach which was just about as serious a breach of conduct or as serious a misdemeanour as an Army officer could commit. However, the Minister who admitted being told about it, and that the attempt was to continue, also admitted that he did not even tell this Army officer to stop doing it. He did not have him transferred, he did not ask him to resign and he did not do what, if his story was true, was his absolute minimum duty to do, have him dealt with by military law. Of course, there is only one possible explanation for it and that is that he knew of this, that he approved of it and that he was part of it——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——it was only when to his surprise he discovered that the Taoiseach was not prepared to stand over what was being done in pursuance of a Government decision that he admitted to in court, it was only then that he did a deal and the deal was to put on the performance that he put on in the High Court.

So the evidence of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in court made the jury's task simple. They naturally decided that the two tried and trusted Army officers were honourable men. They decided that the Army's estimation of these people was vindicated. They decided that the man who had been serving as a junior officer in the most trusted branch of the Army—the intelligence service— was properly assessed by the army Authorities as being fit for that job. They decided that the man who had progressed to the highest rank he could reach in the Army, the highest rank that can be reached by anyone in the Army except the chief-of-staff— colonel — and had held the position of maximum trust in the Army— director of intelligence — they decided that the army's assessment of these people was the correct assessment: it was vindicated. They decided also that, in this business, it was the then Minister for Defence who was the weakling.

So far as I am concerned, then the decision I have to make seems to be very clear-cut. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries are one. If there is culpability, the major culpability is that of the Taoiseach. In view of all that has happened and particularly in view of the jury's verdict, there can be no question of my supporting this Motion of Confidence.

There remains this matter of the party pledge I signed before contesting the general election. I pledged myself to abide by the majority decision of the party or else to resign my seat as a Teachta Dála. This seems to me to be a perfectly clear undertaking. I have listened to and considered very carefully very forceful contrary arguments put forward by many people who I respect greatly, both members of the political organisation to which I belong in my constituency and other constituencies, and other people. However, these do not seem to me to outweigh what I believe myself, and know myself, to have undertaken when I signed this pledge. I cannot see that I am morally entitled, in view of what I have undertaken to do, to vote against this motion or to abstain. There is no question whatever of my voting for it. I have no doubt I will be given further arguments before 10.30 tomorrow night but the prospect I see before me is perfectly clear. In so far as I am personally concerned, there seems to me to have been an inevitability about this whole thing from the very outset. My resignation from the Government last May was inevitable. I gave my reasons at the time. However, I suppose there is no need to repeat the reasons I have already given. A further reason for my resignation at that particular time is now apparent. Had I remained, I would have had to accept collective responsibility for this whole shameful action which was, even at that time, known to involve the dishonourable features that have since been exposed in the courts. Again, I think my action at the time of the arrest of John Kelly was inevitable. I think it was essential. It would be pointless to try to disassociate the republican party from this action after the failure of the conspiracy charge. What I said had to be said: it had to be said then—and, with Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey also arrested, there was not anybody else to say it.

My resignation as honorary secretary of the Fianna Fáil Party was also inevitable. Of course, this is an internal party matter which does not specifically concern the House and which probably is not really relevant. My resignation there arose because of a new concept of democratic procedure introduced into our organisation for the first time by the Taoiseach and insisted upon by him. Briefly, members had to allow the finger to be put on them through the medium of a roll call "Yes" or "No"—with the double-barrelled gun or threatened resignation and a general election pointed at their heads. In other words, an immediate split was decided on in the event of a vote. I decided at that time—inevitably, I think—in the interests of unity or in the hope of possible future unity, to avoid the introduction at that time of this new hallmark of a democratic party. Now, there is this decision which is demanded by the Taoiseach. My action in regard to what is required of me at 10.30 tomorrow night is also inevitable.

I have been assured—and I am inclined to agree—that this latest move, which possibly is the last move so far as I am concerned, is a planned inevitability intended to embrace myself and Deputy Blaney—to quote the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries —the big fish that got away. The fact that I recognise that this is a well-prepared and baited trap does not mean that it can be avoided. The Taoiseach holds the cards by virtue of the decision we all helped to get from the people in June of last year. He is the dealer of the cards. If he dexterously selects the cards he deals me, I can only play the losing hand that I have been dealt. Nobody knows better than he does that, under no circumstances whatever, could I, in the parliament of this country or of this State—I suppose, this State—declare that I believe that the man who has been pronounced on so adversely by the High Court, by a jury in the High Court, is suitable for the high office of Minister in the Government or that the man who procured his ignoble services is fit to be Taoiseach and I am sure that somebody has made the Taoiseach aware of the terms of the pledge that I signed.

I have no desire to split or damage in any way the Fianna Fáil Party. All of my energy since I left the Army after the Emergency—and both before and since my election to the Dáil—has been spent in an effort to maintain the efficiency of the party organisation and the strength of the party here in this House. But, since last May, I have had an opportunity of surveying the end product of all that effort by myself and by others—notably by Deputy Blaney and Deputy Haughey. I have had an opportunity of seeing the end product of all that effort since last May. As I look around me, I can see quite clearly that there is nothing left to me but my own personal honour, such as it is—and I propose to retain that.

Comment on this

I am very pleased indeed that I have the privilege of being the first member of the House to congratulate Deputy Boland on the stand he is taking on this matter: I shall come back to that later on. Now, Sir, this is a peculiar type of Vote in as much as, for the first time, Dáil Éireann is asked, as a body, to vote confidence in a Government where the real test and the real need for that confidence lies within the Government and the Government party itself. These Motions have not been brought about by Fine Gael: neither have they been brought about by Labour. They have been brought about entirely by the Fianna Fáil Party and particularly by senior members of that party. We have a volume of this size containing the words which were spoken on this question in this House last May. During the past few months we have had numerous pages of newscript covering the sordid details of this business and I think we have had enough.

I did not bring into this House with me any documentation to make a statement on this Vote of Confidence because I am well aware that the people of this country from Malin Head to Cape Clear are quite conversant with the issues before them, and I am well aware that the people are only too anxious to express their verdict of confidence or no confidence, as the case may be, in the Government. It may be said that Labour speakers and Fine Gael speakers in making contributions to this discussion would naturally have a slanted view and be biassed against the Government, and that their observations would in no way be impartial so I propose, to a large extent, to dismiss the statements made by Fine Gael and Labour Party speakers in this debate because I think the outstanding statement was not made by a Fine Gael speaker. Neither was it made by a Labour Party speaker. It was made by the speaker who has just resumed his seat.

Who is this man who has just resumed his seat? As he mentioned himself, he is one of the chief architects of the Fianna Fáil Party. He is the man who, when he came in here in 1957, was seen to be suitable and fitted for ministerial advancement straight away, and he was appointed Minister on the first day of his membership of this House. Since then he has held exalted office as Minister of State. He has served in a Government headed by the present President. He has served in a Government headed by the former Taoiseach, Mr. Lemass. He has served in a Government headed by the present Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch. Surely a man with his insight and his long record of public service as a Minister of this State is much more capable of giving an objective view on the merits of the present Government than any Opposition speaker?

To sum up Deputy Boland's case as made here—and I agree with it largely—he claims that the Taoiseach who is asking this House for a Vote of Confidence in him is an intriguer. He also mentioned one other Minister of the Government, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries as an intriguer.

Mention has been made in the course of this debate of slander and there was a question as to whether slanders in this House should be withdrawn or otherwise. During the course of a speech in the House earlier today that matter arose between the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the presiding Chairman at the time, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle. Slanders there are and numerous slanders. We are sick of listening to slanders since May of this year, but who is doing the slandering? We are not doing it. I do not think the Fine Gael Party are doing it. It is the people over there who are doing it. The Fianna Fáil people are slandering each other. You will agree with that, a Cheann Comhairle, I am sure. They are slandering each other.

We had statements made by responsible Members of this House. We must accept that ex-Ministers, four of them, with long records of public service within this House, have charged and violently charged the Taoiseach, the present head of this Government, with being an unsuitable person to head this Government, and that he is also guilty of gross intrigue. He has been charged with bullying members of the party and intimidating them on Tuesday night of last week. I do not know whether he did or not. I accept Deputy Boland's statement in toto. I think I took down what he said. The Taoiseach, says Deputy Boland, got votes at the meeting by intimidation, by holding out the big stick of a general election over the heads of the members of Fianna Fáil. He intimidated them into voting for him, a number of them against their will and, as he said in another phrase, he had the gun to their heads that a general election was in the offing and they might possibly lose their seats.

I have no doubt that that statement of Deputy Boland's is quite correct. He made another very lucid and clear-cut statement that a number of Deputies within the Fianna Fáil Party share his views on the Taoiseach and some members of the present Cabinet but, for some reasons which I think he specified subsequently—such as an early general election—they were prepared to change their minds and vote for the Taoiseach and for the Cabinet even though they shared Deputy Boland's views on them.

I said here in May and I now restate that I believe that once a Government are elected through the democratic process in operation in this country they are entitled to govern for five years. I am a believer in and an upholder of that view but I said then and I repeat now that, despite the inconveniences or difficulties it may mean for any Member of this House, or to the Government, or their henchmen some of our senior civil servants, in view of what has happened, which no one could visualise or anticipate last year, there is only one course open to the Taoiseach and that is to do as Deputy Boland and Deputy Haughey and a number of other Deputies in his own party, together with the combined Opposition, have asked him to do and, that is, to dissolve this Dáil.

Surely to God the Taoiseach will not continue to sit over in that seat having heard, as I am sure he has heard, the statement made just now in this Parliament by Deputy Boland and having seen the statements made in Press comments by commentators and others within recent months. Surely the people are entitled to act as the jury in this trial because I say Fianna Fáil are on trial? I do not think it is fair to the Government—and I want to see everything fair and above board; I want to see everybody getting a fair crack of the whip—that Labour Members or Fine Gael Members should be asked to judge this matter.

Our judgment is clear but we could be charged with bias. Fianna Fáil members have expressed their opinions of the Government and surely the Irish people from Cork to Donegal are entitled to express their opinions and to say whether they want a continuance of this Government which, according to a recent statement of an ex-senior Minister, Deputy Blaney, is composed of boys.

The main question, so far as I am concerned, is of a much more serious nature. Fianna Fáil have had it. If Fianna Fáil, as a party, have had it the question to which the Irish people are addressing themselves is what is the alternative. Everybody in the country knows enough about what has happened within the Fianna Fáil Party. Their fighting, their abuse has been well publicised and there is no need for any Deputy to take up the time of this House reiterating it. What I want to get at is the position when they are gone. I cannot see how Deputy Jack Lynch, no matter how much he likes the glint of power, can stay away from the Park beyond 11 o'clock tomorrow night, no matter how many vote for him.

Comment on this

I wonder what the people of Cork would think about a socialist republic.

Comment on this

I will tell you about your socialist republic.

Comment on this

You are a socialist. It is part of your philosophy.

Comment on this

Before I do that I wonder what kind of eye specialist the Minister for Transport and Power, Deputy Lenihan, attends. Here is how he sees this. I quote from column 210, volume 249, No. 2, of the official report:

One thing which Fianna Fáil have shown over the past six months is their capacity to act in a disciplined way, to act collectively, to act with integrity and above all to govern.

I wonder what kind of spectacles the Minister wears. That was as nonsensical a statement as could be made by any man in the street, never mind a Minister of State. There is no need to comment on it further.

Subsequent to making that statement he made a statement which was quite the opposite in that every word of it was correct, in my view. He said:

The main reason we were entrusted with the responsibility of governing during the past twelve months was the recognition by the people of the disarray in which the opposing political parties found themselves during the last general election.

The first day I came into the Dáil after the election I said Fianna Fáil was over there because of the disarray within the two Opposition Parties in the 1969 general election. I believe in forthright speaking and in calling a spade a spade. Fianna Fáil were elected with 75 seats and a minority vote of 113,000 but it was not the votes that elected them. It was, as the Minister pointed out, the disarray that existed within the Fine Gael and Labour Parties.

In that election the Opposition parties adopted the foolish idea that both parties could get into government on their own. We had Deputy Cosgrave expressing the view that the Irish people had sufficient confidence in Fine Gael to elect them independently as the Government. We had attached to every telegraph pole in the country the slogan: "Fine Gael will win." People did not accept that. People did not accept that Fine Gael had sufficient strength to win the election on their own. On the other side of the road we had posters which said: "Win with Labour." I have no doubt, and I had no hesitation in saying it then as I have said it now, that the Irish people did not accept that Labour would get sufficient votes to become the Government of this country. Deputy Lenihan was quite correct in asserting that disarray existed among the Opposition parties in the last election. I accept Deputy Lenihan's words as an apt description of what happened in the 1969 election.

Dáil Éireann will possibly be dissolved tomorrow night. Are we to have this disarray again within the Opposition parties?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I say "No".

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Dr. Thornley——

Comment on this

The central council of the Labour Party does not agree with coalition.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy.

Comment on this

That is the only hope Fianna Fáil have.

Comment on this

Deputy Murphy asked me a question and I gave him an answer.

Comment on this

Yes. Fianna Fáil succeeded in getting that across prior to the 1969 election. They drove a wedge and were helped by some of their Taca friends, in the guise of Fine Gael or Labour supporters, to drive that wedge and ensure that there was no unity among the Opposition parties. I am satisfied that on the 18th June, 1969, the one thing that elected Fianna Fáil was the fact that there was no co-operation good, bad or indifferent between Fine Gael and Labour and the fact that the people accepted Fianna Fáil as the strongest party numerically and as the only party likely to form a government on their own. That was how the Irish people viewed the situation.

Comment on this

But they were not that right, you know.

Comment on this

How about policies?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy is entitled to make his own speech.

Comment on this

I know there are pressures from other Deputies who want to make speeches.

Comment on this

Keep going. We like to listen to you.

Comment on this

When I got up I did not intend staying too long but I intend staying a little longer now than I anticipated.

My statements are based on the assumption that we are having an immediate election and that the Irish people will pass a certain verdict on Fianna Fáil. Before I was interrupted I was coming to another qualification which Fianna Fáil claimed to have during the 1969 election campaign— that is the qualification of solidarity, of unity. They were one in belief, one in achievement, one in everything.

That unity and solidarity is now burst and burst badly and I think "burst" is the word. The Irish people will not swallow that carrot if the election is held next month. The Taoiseach cannot go down to Cork; he cannot go to Donegal, neither can he go to the midlands nor to any other part of this country and say: "Vote for Fianna Fáil. We are a united party. We are the only party capable of giving good government in this country". That was accepted, even though luck was on your side in the 1969 election. You have a voting strength here at the moment of 75 votes to 67—a majority of eight, an exceptionally high majority for this Parliament. What is happening? You are breaking up and it is about time you did. I do not want my last remark to be misinterpreted. I remember saying in May, 1969, that I regretted, as I am sure Members of this House regretted, what was happening within Government circles. We are all anxious to see Ireland advance. Despite any political differences we may have, we are all anxious to see the Government of the day doing a good job for the people. My remark can be interpreted as meaning that Fianna Fáil had power long enough in this country. They had power too long. They have grown stale, dictatorial and arrogant and it is time to replace them. During the past 38 years they have been in power for 32 years. They feel that there is no other group or combination of parties fit to govern Ireland save themselves. It is time to get rid of that idea. It is no harm that some of their Taca associates and some of our senior civil servants in particular got it into their heads that there is a possibility that Fianna Fáil will go and that the protection which some of them enjoy at the present time will go with them.

Comment on this

Who will replace them?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy, without interruption.

Comment on this

I am open for questions. I have been asked by my good friend, Deputy Moore, who will replace them. Who replaced them in 1948?

Comment on this

For how long?

Comment on this

Who replaced them in 1954? My view is that there is an alternative Government. I am a Labour man but I am satisfied that in the ensuing election Labour cannot, even though they will get a much increased vote on the 1969 figure, get sufficient seats to become the Government of this country. I am a member of a Party who have opposed the policy of Fianna Fáil violently, forcibly and vehemently down through the years. I am satisfied, taking a look at the Irish position as it is, that the same applies to the Fine Gael Party. They cannot of their own, because of insufficiency of votes and insufficiency of seats, form a Government.

What then do you find? You find, as has been found in a number of other countries, a combination of parties and in this context it only means two parties. That is my own view. It is a matter for Fine Gael to say whether they agree or disagree with that. I know the members of the parties here and I am sufficiently confident that an alternative Government much more capable and with greater integrity, can be formed after the next election from the Fine Gael and Labour benches if both parties do the sensible thing. The alternative is chaos.

Comment on this

Why does the Deputy not join Fine Gael?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy agree with Deputy Dr. Browne's views which are being dealt with in the party tomorrow morning?

Comment on this