We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Confidence in Taoiseach and Government: Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 221–442 of 442. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Does the Parliamentary Secretary agree with Deputy Neil Blaney?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputies allow Deputy Murphy to make his speech?

Comment on this

I was going to refer to the Parliamentary Secretary as Dr. Andrews. He will lose his post tomorrow night possibly.

Comment on this

I would be very flattered.

Comment on this

In answer to the question asked by Deputy Dowling——

Comment on this

I cannot answer five or six questions together. Deputy Dowling asked me why I do not join Fine Gael. I am a Labour man. I have been a Labour man all my life and I hope I will continue to be one.

Comment on this

Not a socialist.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputies please allow Deputy Murphy to make his speech?

Comment on this

I am factual about those things. It is about time, the eleventh hour, that the people learned about the alternative Government. In my estimation we are moving very close to the twelfth hour. In 1948 Fianna Fáil were ousted from power by a combination of parties which made it much more difficult then than it would now to form a coalition because at that time we had four parties in the House and a number of Independents. Consequently, difficulties arose. I have asserted during my time in public life that that Government were responsible for legislation which was then, and still is, advantageous to the Irish people. They brought new life to the Irish people. Up to that unless you were a member of a Fianna Fáil cumann you would not even get a job on the roads. The Coalition Government changed that. They held office for three years.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I was outlining the advantages which accrued to the Irish people from the formation of the first inter-Party Government in 1948. Then there was a second inter-Party Government from 1954 until 1957 and it worked quite well. The only unfortunate happening was that there should have been an election in 1957. I sincerely hope we shall have an inter-Party Government in 1970.

I do not intend to go back to this waste of public money through the trial that was held in the Four Courts. Surely you need have no legal knowledge to know that so far as three of the accused were concerned they could not be found guilty of any charges. Having regard to the fact that they were working under the direction of the Government of the State, that trial was a waste of money. On Thursday last, Deputy Tully was interested in another question and we have to learn what is happening in regard to people in high places. Deputy Tully was inquiring about one of the defendants in this trial, Albert Luykx, and I quote from column 247, volume 249, of the Official Report of 29th October, 1970 where he says:

I would like to know what investigations were made in Belgium before he was granted citizenship. Also, I wish to know if any investigation has been carried out to ascertain if this man who, it has been stated, was responsible for contacting people——

Then the Leas-Cheann Comhairle intervenes. At column 248 Deputy Tully says:

...I shall not allow anybody to cover certain people because it may turn out to be embarrassing. I do not know who or what Mr. Luykx is but I would like to know if anybody knows. Do the Government know?

Later on he says:

The Chair has given a ruling which I accept.

That is, that there should be no discussion on Mr. Luykx, and continues:

I am making no charge against Mr. Luykx but if somebody has the ear of a Cabinet Minister or Ministers and that same person is one who is able to put people in contact with people from whom arms can be purchased on the Continent— this is public knowledge, it appeared in the newspapers—and who in addition to that appears now, as a result of the trial, to have been given as a person who was doing it for the Government, the House is entitled to know what that man's background is.

I am sure that Deputy Tully did not make that assertion without being sure of his facts, that Mr. Luykx was a man who had contact with the Government, that he was a man who was riding in Government Ministers' cars. I do not like making charges against any man who is not a Member of this House but I should like to quote from a Belgium paper which reported this trial. It is the Belgian Weekly Bulletin and the issue of 22nd October has this heading: “Belgian Nazi on trial” and goes on to say:

A former Belgian member of the SS, Antoine Luykx, who was condemned to death in Belgium after the war (the sentence was later commuted to 20 years in prison) is being tried in the Irish Republic in connection with arms smuggling into Northern Ireland. He is one of four on trial, including a former Irish Minister of Finance.

Luykx, born at Lommel in Limburg province, was arrested by the Belgian military authorities after the liberation and accused of denouncing Belgian resistance leaders, recruiting Belgian youths for the Nazi armed forces and making economic capital out of the war.

In 1946 he was tried and condemned to death. The sentence was commuted——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy—

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

This is absolutely political.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Lenehan keep quiet? Deputy Murphy is criticising the private affairs of an individual who has no way of replying to him in this House, and Deputy Tully was ruled out of order last Thursday on the same point. Deputy Tully was out of order and certainly Deputy Murphy is out of order.

Comment on this

I prefaced my remarks by saying that I disliked doing that but here is the position, if you will bear with me, Sir. This is a vote of confidence in the Government, and in the course of the discussion the trial has been mentioned by a number of members.

Comment on this

This is a vote of confidence in the present Government, not the past one.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Carter please cease interrupting?

Comment on this

This gentleman was riding around in Ministerial cars.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Mr. Luykx can be criticised for his part in the arms question but his private life is a matter for himself and not for this House.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

His private life cannot be any worse than that of some of the band over there.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Lenehan wishes to remain here he should desist.

Comment on this

Are you saying this is not a matter for public comment?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Any person's private life cannot be bandied around this House.

Comment on this

I shall accept your ruling. Let me refer now to the dismissal of the Ministers which took place at 2.55 in the morning. It is only ghosts that are around at that hour. I should like the Taoiseach, when replying, to tell the House why he selected this unearthly hour to dismiss his Ministers. I asked that question during the May debate but as the trial was on the matter was sub judice and the Taoiseach could not reply. I did not see anything on reading the trial indicating a degree of urgency which necessitated this happening at 2.55 a.m.

As I mentioned at the outset, it is unnecessary to recap on what happened. The public are well aware what happened. My reason for speaking in this debate is to bring home to this House and the people the necessity for providing an alternative Government. I am satisfied from my experience as a Member of this House and from my knowledge of the people that such an alternative exists without question.

In the constituency of Cork south west last Sunday week I was given an unanimous vote of approval for the formation of an inter-Party Government should an election arise. In by-elections in Kildare and Longford-Westmeath the people indicated what kind of Government they want by their votes. We shall not shed any tears now that Fianna Fáil are moving out but we must ensure, should the Dáil be dissolved tomorrow night, that an alternative Government exists to replace them which will give the people the type of Government they have not had for years but which I hope they will get in the future through the inter-Party system.

Comment on this
James M. Gibbons Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (Mr. J. Gibbons) Fianna Fáil

In my contribution to this debate I want principally to apply myself to the resolution in the name of Deputy Cosgrave naming me, and with typical Fine Gael ineptitude quoting a certain column of the Official Report and thereafter amending it——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is this resolution before the House?

Comment on this

I do not think this is in order.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Cosgrave's resolution before the House?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That particular motion is not before the House.

Comment on this

The Minister is out of order.

Comment on this

I shall amend what I have said by saying that I shall apply myself to the slanders upon my name and character and upon the names and characters of my family that have arisen from the tabling of this motion. It is unquestionable that the motivation, apart from the political motivation and apart from the attempt to divide the Fianna Fáil Government and Party, behind the tabling of this motion is a continuation of what has probably been the biggest attack on a single Member of this House since its establishment. This volume of the Official Report is probably bigger in size and weight than any other report of a single sitting of the Dáil. The greater proportion of it is devoted to speeches made by members of the Fine Gael Party, whose main stock in trade is the destruction of people's good names and the slandering of people whom they cannot injure in any other way, the contents of which are aimed at me and at some of my colleagues with particular reference to the Taoiseach.

The Fine Gael motion, superseded by the subsequent motion of the Taoiseach, originally referred to column 792 of volume 246 No. 7 of the Official Report. Deputy Cosgrave spoke in this House the other day like the Pharisee in the temple beating his breast and thanking God that he was not like the rest of men. I have never seen anything so disgusting in all my life. It was reminiscent of the Ard-Fheis which followed this particular debate last May when Deputy Cosgrave shouted in the squeaky voice which he adopts when he simulates anger, and I recall him saying that people have often asked what is the difference between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael and he shouted, "Now you know the difference". The clear inference is that all the saints, all the men of virtue and integrity belong to the Fine Gael Party and they give thanks that they are not like the other adulterers and perjurers which, as has been said during the course of this debate, exist only on this side of the House. This is the pharisaical attitude of the Fine Gael Party in general and of Deputy Cosgrave in particular.

I am prepared to concede, as Deputy Cosgrave conceded when he spoke earlier in this debate, that he and I have had cordial relations for many years. I am also prepared to concede that he is a quiet, inoffensive little man, but I would not make the same concession about some of the people who sit either beside or behind him. I have no doubt that as this debate proceeds the malicious slanders on me, my family, the Government which I serve and the party which I serve will continue and all the charges will be baseless.

The basis of the Fine Gael attack is that I, at some stage, attempted to deceive this House and, as has been said by Deputy Dr. FitzGerald, "told lies in this House". This volume of the Official Report is a compendium of Fine Gael lies of the most fantastic and outrageous kind. I would say to Fine Gael before they suggest that I, either on this occasion or on any other occasion, deliberately misled this House, find something to go on. If they think by a succession of months of malicious, spiteful slanders that they can make me retreat one inch I want to assure them very firmly that there will be no surrender from me. I will not be betrayed by my party. I am certain about that as well. If Fine Gael think they can destroy this party by isolating one member of it or by attacking either the Taoiseach or myself they do not understand the meaning of the words "Fianna Fáil".

Fianna Fáil does not draw its strength from the Deputies on these benches. It does not draw its strength from any elected Member. Journalists and others think of us as wheeler-dealers and ward-heelers. This is not what the Fianna Fáil machine is at all. An example of what the Fianna Fáil machine actually is occurred shortly after this affair broke last May when Fianna Fáil held its national collection. In every constituency in the country there was a spontaneous reaction from the ordinary people, who are our strength and have kept us as the major political Party since 1932.

By an instinctive reaction they increased their contributions to our national collection by anything from 30 to 50 per cent. That is what you are up against. Slanders on me, or on my leader, Deputy Jack Lynch, or on any colleagues of mine here will have no effect on us. If you think you can break our courage with words or in any other way you had better think again.

I shall now turn to the contribution that I made as reported in this volume of 8th and 9th May and the first assertion arose from a spiteful contribution made on the basis of an anonymous letter hawked about this House by Deputy Cosgrave. I shall quote a little bit, and a little bit will be sufficient, from the speech made by Deputy Ryan sitting opposite:

It is quite clear that evidence has been given to the Taoiseach which links certain names with such activities not related alone to the attempted importation of arms from Vienna but related also to training which was given in at least one Army camp to civilians in the use of arms.

There are two specific things there: one is the question of the importation of arms from Vienna and I want to say that the first intimation of this importation of arms from Vienna that I got, was from the Secretary of the Department of Defence, Mr. Stephen Hearney on Friday, 17th April. While I was speaking to him I ascertained that the Department of Justice were also aware of this circumstance. As I have already informed the House by way of interjection today, I was also aware for some time that the activities of certain Members of this House and Captain Kelly were under the surveillance of the Special Branch and I felt that from the security point of view this was sufficient and adequate. It saved me, as Minister for Defence, from the distasteful task of acting as a policeman on people who were my colleagues since the security of the State has been impugned.

As regard the second point in this reference, the training of civilians, no civilian was trained in any Army camp. I explained with some considerable detail in the court the circumstances surrounding the enlistment of certain people from outside the Twenty-Six County area into the FCA, their attestation into that force and their donning of the uniform of that force and their induction into that force and their subsequent training. I should point out to the House that this practice is by no means unique. The FCA, like any other military force, carries on a continuous process of recruitment and it is not at all unusual for young men from the cross-Border areas to join the FCA because this might be their inclination. My personal feeling especially at that time was that it would be impolite and imprudent to decline enlistment of these people whom I knew to be from the Six-County area but I ensured that they were informed of the regulations that governed such things. They were enlisted as people coming from Donegal. Those are the facts but Deputy Ryan is not correct in asserting that they were civilians but my interjection, and it is merely an interjection, "That is not true" is correct. I do not think it is necessary for me to say anything more on that particular point.

Fine Gael in their efforts to bolster up their slanderous attack on me changed their tactics in mid-stream. I think I will assist them myself because I think the contribution I made in this debate was quite brief and I shall refer them to my own statement which began in column 838 and the first relevant part to which I wish to refer is this. I quote:

...to refer to a statement that I have heard has been made by Mr. Patrick Kennedy, MP, in the course of a radio interview. I have been informed that Mr. Patrick Kennedy, MP, in the course of a Radio Éireann interview, suggested that any participation by Captain James Kelly in an attempt to smuggle arms could only have been made with my knowledge and consent.

For a very long period in the courts recently this particular matter was examined and I explained to the court the circumstances of my first meeting with Captain Kelly in what I believe to be mid-March. It was disclosed to the satisfaction of the court, as I remember it that a great deal had been done months before about the assembly of weapons in what afterwards proved to be Antwerp and for their eventual despatch to this country.

On the first occasion that Captain Kelly came to me he came to inform me that he had formed a moral obligation to the people in the north — and mark you there was no specific reference to defence committees as such, he merely told me that his allegiance had shifted from his Army duties to the beleaguered people in the Catholic ghettos in Belfast and elsewhere in the north — and that because he wanted to assist them he proposed to resign his commission in the Army. I told the court then and I tell the Dáil now that I looked upon this as an honest and honourable gesture from an Army officer. I should add also that Captain Kelly's coming to me was at the request of a senior colleague of mine at that time and that is why I saw this junior officer at all. I thought since his declaration of faith had been so forthright and honest that some effort should be made to provide an alternative living for him. I asked him about his family and his family circumstances and how he proposed to live.

I must interrupt myself at this juncture to say that I do not propose to go into any particular details of the trial because on that occasion I testified for, I think, a total of about 15 hours on oath. I do not propose to elaborate on that but it is necessary to clarify this short statement of mine. After that, either in the last days of March or the early days of April, Captain Kelly who before that quite evidently had been actively engaged in the procurement, purchase and assembly of arms in Antwerp, told me nothing about that, nor was I told about it by anybody else except for the vague allusion made by the Director of Intelligence, Colonel Heffron, at that time to a proposed visit in the month of February by Captain Kelly to Frankfurt to see his sister. I accepted this at its face value. I recall distinctly saying to the Director of Intelligence at that time; "Is it not the most reasonable thing in the world for a person who does happen to have a sister in Frankfurt to visit that sister?" I asked him: "Does he happen to have a sister in Frankfurt?" and the Director of Intelligence said: "He does". I said: "Is it not the most reasonable thing in the world for an officer, whom you tell me is an honourable and high-principled man, to make such a visit to this sister?" and he readily agreed it was.

We proceed then to the last period to which I have just alluded, the period I would place in the last days of March or early April. It is quite impossible to be precise about this. He mentioned that there had been an abortive attempt to smuggle in arms through the port of Dublin. I did not know whether this illegal importation of arms was a squalid suitcase operation concerning half-a-dozen revolvers or what kind of operation it was. I did not know who was involved. I did not know what part Captain Kelly played in it except, and this must be said, and I have already said it in the court, that it was quite clear he made no great effort to conceal the fact that he was involved in some way, but in what way I could not say and he did not tell me.

Comment on this

Did the Minister ask him?

Comment on this

Do not interrupt. When Deputy Garret FitzGerald was speaking he made a great deal of heavy weather about knowledge vestigial and knowledge simpliciter. I said that I had vestigial knowledge. What I meant by that was that I had this tiny intimation that in some obscure, quite undefined way this officer, who was as yet attached to the Army Intelligence Service was connected, as he told me himself he was, with this business of the importation of arms. Deputy Garret FitzGerald, with his Sherlock Holmes magnifying glass almost visible in his hand, asked: “Did you not have knowledge simpliciter?” He seems to misunderstand that expression or, possibly, I do. From my rather limited knowledge of the Latin language “simple knowledge” is the way I would translate it. But this is a very, very different thing from total knowledge or even substantial knowledge. I used the expression “vestigial knowledge” and Mr. Sorohan asked me to explain in more mundane language what I meant by “vestigial knowledge”. What I meant by by that was that I knew both from Captain Kelly himself and from Colonel Heffron, who was then the Director of Intelligence, that Captain Kelly was up to something in the matter of the importation of arms but, beyond that, I knew very little.

Now there is a hiatus here. Except for this vital thing I had a pretty good idea for some months that the Special Branch of the police was on to Captain Kelly and on to this arms conspiracy generally. I had confirmation of this from the then Minister for Justice about that time too and, as I have already said, I felt that since this was the case it relieved me of the distasteful task of acting as a policeman——

Comment on this

Of doing your job.

Comment on this

——to beset my colleagues. It did not deter me in any way from pursuing as actively as I could the removal of this officer in as quiet and unobtrusive a way as possible from the Army because I felt, as I said in this speech, I thought it was the most prudent and expedient thing that this Army officer be quietly got out of the Army because there was a very big security question involved in all this. If he had been courtmartialled there would have been a great deal of pother about it and there would have been a great deal of rejoicing in the Paisleyite camp and possibly in other camps as well. This was the way I, at that time, deemed to be the most prudent way of dealing with the situation, the more so as I had knowledge that this man's activities were, in fact, under surveillance.

With regard to the hiatus between then and 17th April, what happened in that period I was not informed about at all and I so testified in court. I will proceed further now with the analysis of this short statement of mine because I want to assist the House as best I can.

I was aware, through the Director of Intelligence that attempts to smuggle arms were a constant danger and these attempts were kept under surveillance at all times.

It is evident that, when I said that, I depended in toto on the good faith of the then Director of Intelligence. What has emerged subsequently would naturally change my view on this, but to assert that this particular statement at that particular time is in any way misleading is in itself a misleading assertion.

I wish to say I discharged my duty to the full extent of my knowledge of the situation.

This knowledge I have been at some pains to point out, was quite marginal. I think it worthwhile at this juncture to ask, since this operation had been going on for quite some time and since the Department of Defence was one of the only ways by which arms could be imported into this country at all, why was the subject broached and broached to me so gently? I think the answer to that also emerged in the court because on that day, or possibly the day following, on which I was informed of the abortive attempt to land weapons in the port of Dublin the question was put to me as to whether I would allow my Department to be used for the illegal importation of arms. It was put straight to me and I answered it straightly and the answer was "No." I want to say further that, if I had wished to co-operate or if I sympathised in any way with the illegal importation of arms, by virtue of my office I could have done it and there would have been no case and there would be nobody any the wiser. But that is what happened.

As I said, I do not propose to go back over the evidence I gave on oath in court except to say that it was evidence given on oath. Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien said in this House that I was a convicted liar. Upon what basis he makes that charge I do not know. I do not know what code of ethics Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien observes. I do not know whether or not he is a Christian at all, but I want to tell Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien that when I take the Book in my hands it means something to me although it may mean nothing to him——

Comment on this

Does this mean that without the Book you can lie like a trooper?

Comment on this

I am inviting the Deputy or any of his colleagues, whether they come from Accra, Moscow or Havana, to demonstrate here or elsewhere that the charge the Deputy has made against me has any substance. I am inviting the Deputy to substantiate the foul charge he made against me——

Comment on this

Deputy Boland has also made it.

Comment on this

The Minister's colleague has also made it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is getting angry now because he is ashamed of himself and he is very right to be ashamed of himself. I am a countryman——

Comment on this

and look like one——

Comment on this

The Minister is under severe mental strain——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Deputies must cease interrupting.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): All of this is only a smokescreen.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair wants to point out——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

You should all shut up.

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Deputy to tell the Chair to shut up?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has already pointed out this evening that in a debate such as this Members on both sides should refrain from interrupting the Member in possession. Everybody who wishes to speak will get the opportunity to do so. Personalities and casting aspersions ought to be avoided; aspersions are disorderly and that has already been said this evening.

Comment on this

I was dealing with the assertion that Deputy Cruise-O'Brien made in this House the other night that I was a convicted liar. I was going on from there to compare our different backgrounds and to compare the sources from which we draw our different ethics because obviously they are very different.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

I have said I am a countryman and I learned my first bit of ethics from the penny catechism——

Comment on this

The Minister should learn to tell the truth.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Karl Marx, Che Guevara or Kwame Nkrumah——

Comment on this

The Minister is indulging in personalities now.

Comment on this

The Minister is being abusive now.

Comment on this

He is putting up a very poor defence.

Comment on this

I am not nearly as abusive as the Deputy was the other night. Neither Deputy Cruise-O'Brien nor any other Deputy in the House has any grounds to call me a convicted liar.

Comment on this

The same grounds as every other Deputy — it is what you have put on the record.

Comment on this

I am on the records and I am inviting you today, as I invited you then, to destroy my credibility if you can.

Comment on this

It does not need to be destroyed; it is gone forever.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Is Deputy Cruise-O'Brien to be allowed to continue in this way?

Comment on this

Am I supposed to put up with all those attacks?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has already pointed out that interruptions from any side are disorderly. The Minister must be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

We will leave Dr. Cruise-O'Brien alone because the country in general understands by now where he stands——

Comment on this

If you want to know, why not go to the country?

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Any time you like.

Comment on this

All right, tonight then.

Comment on this

I was speaking earlier about the strength of the Fianna Fáil Party and the source from which it derives. We will give the Opposition a demonstration of that any time they like.

Comment on this

Do it tonight then.

Comment on this

I shall continue to quote from my previous statement:

I want to refer specially to the references that were made in this debate by Deputy Ryan, in which he sought by innuendo to suggest that in some way or other I was implicated in the business of running guns into this country for illegal organisations or for any other purpose. I can only say that if Deputy Ryan, or any other Deputy has any scintilla of evidence of any such activity on my part, he has an obligation to produce it and to produce it at once so that the necessary steps may be taken.

This invitation was issued on the 8th or 9th of May and not one scrap of evidence has come from Deputy Ryan or anybody else. I shall continue to quote from my statement:

I am happy in this knowledge and I give challenge in this knowledge that since there is no such evidence of any implication on my part there is nobody in this House or outside it who can produce any evidence of the kind suggested by Deputy Ryan.

I would add that Deputy Cosgrave who brandished his anonymous letter in this House a long time ago has not produced any evidence either. I further stated:

I am well aware that this suggestion of Deputy Ryan's, made originally the other night, has given rise to certain speculation in the Press and on the radio and television. I want, once and for all, to state my position and to state it as clearly as I can. I think I have done that. That was my principal intention in rising to speak on this debate.

I want to refer to other matters which were alluded to in this debate so far. There was a suggestion by Deputy Tully that weapons, presumably for illegal organisations, were collected in Army trucks at Dublin docks and presumably driven away to some unknown destination. Does Deputy Tully realise what a serious thing this is to say? Does he realise how fantastically and absurdly untrue it is? That is the least offensive part of it. The real danger lies in the fact when a person of Deputy Tully's standing makes such a suggestion, even though I think it was merely speculative in nature, it must be realised that, once made, one must always bargain for a residual of credence and for somebody getting a hold of the story and getting the idea that Army trucks were used for the carriage of illegal arms.

The Official Report of the 8th/9th May, 1970, possibly the largest single volume since the establishment of this House, is a plethora of the most foul Fine Gael and Labour allegations and attempts to destroy the reputation of people by slander of the vilest kind. I want to assure them they have been totally unsuccessful.

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Boland.

Comment on this

The Minister could not convince the jury.

Comment on this

It was not my business to convince the jury.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

That is a reflection on the jury.

Comment on this

The bright young men have been gymnastically somersaulted.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Again, I appeal to the House to allow the Minister to continue.

Comment on this

I want to assist the Fine Gael Party as much as I can. Evidently, they are unable to identify the parts of my speech upon which they have based their dastardly charge of misleading the Dáil. Therefore, I shall continue to quote from my previous speech:

There have been fantastic suggestions made by some Opposition speakers earlier today about ships lying in Dublin Bay and sailing away with murderers on board.

I think it was Deputy Ryan who made that suggestion. Is this misleading the Dáil? Have they any evidence of any such occurrence? Is this not part of the smear campaign they have carried on during these months? Do the Opposition not realise the drastic action the Taoiseach took when this affair blew up? May I suggest to Deputy Cosgrave that he might question Deputy Ryan's suitability for membership of this House? Perhaps he might also question his own suitability for membership in view of the treatment he gave to a malicious anonymous letter? I shall continue to quote from my speech in an effort to help Fine Gael:

By inference, at any rate, it is suggested that members of the Government are involved in this kind of thing. There is an obligation on me to point out that this kind of talk is very destructive to the country at a time like this. There was some reference to the training of civilians in Donegal. I want to point out the position of the Defence Forces in this regard. The Defence Forces train only members of their own ranks, whether they be FCA or Army or Naval personnel. That is the extent of their training. This story first got currency in the Protestant Telegraph. It is time that stories of this kind cease.

Effectively, that is the contribution about which there has been all this pother.

Comment on this

It is not the end. We asked you to clarify the position.

Comment on this

I concluded my statement by saying:

I have nothing further to say on this matter. There were certain matters which I wanted to clarify for the House at this stage and I have done so.

Comment on this

Why not clarify them?

Comment on this

I can clarify the story a great deal better than the Deputy. The only matter that Deputy Cruise-O'Brien might clarify at some time at his convenience is whether his allegiance lies with Kwame Nkrumah or with Che Guevara.

Comment on this

I think it was Deputy Keating who made some snide and dirty slanderous suggestions the other night regarding the funds from which these guns were allegedly paid. I want to say that during this process I knew nothing whatever about bank accounts in Baggot Street, Clones or anywhere else. After the affair had become public I discovered the actual source of some of the funds. However, during the whole process I knew nothing whatever about it. But it is plain to me there was some kind of an arrangement to import and a fall guy was necessary, and I was to be this fall guy. I do not think that the country will accept that the Minister for Defence would lend his own co-operation or the co-operation of his Department to this miserable and contemptible operation of latter-day patriots who would operate behind other people's innocent backs. If there is anybody who can accept that kind of thing and operate their superrepublicanism from behind the backs of innocent fall guys, I do not think the country will swallow that. No matter how much the Fine Gael Party work on the slander campaign — I am in this House 13 years and about every two years they mount a slander campaign; this is by no means their first corruption campaign but on this occasion their guns are turned on me — I want to tell you, and tell you very definitely that if you think you can frighten me with your shouts and insults and slanders of one kind or another you have another guess coming. If you think you can destroy the Fianna Fáil Party you have even a bigger guess coming to you. The strength of the Fianna Fáil Party does not lie on these benches. It is among the ordinary people of Ireland and I told you what their instinctive reaction was to the dangers in which they saw their party in May last. If you think, like Deputy M.P. Murphy, of making preparation for the next coalition — whatever way the Deputy Justin Keating attitude to the EEC and the Fine Gael attitude to it will be worked out, and I have no doubt it will be worked out — you have yet to deal with the Fianna Fáil Party machine and the Fianna Fáil Party machine is the people of Ireland and I have confidence in them. A Cheann Comhairle, I trust I have exploded the unwarranted and dastardly charge made against me by Deputy Liam Cosgrave. I acquit him personally. As I have said before, basically he is a decent little man but I would not so describe some of the people who are behind him. They have failed totally to demonstrate what they set out to demonstrate. So far as I am concerned and so far as their resolution is concerned, I am staying here.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The great tragedy of Deputy Gibbons is that every time he opens his unfortunate mouth he only makes a bad situation worse. The best thing that Deputy Gibbons can do to preserve his own honour and the standards that should be observed by all people in public life is to resign. Perhaps the only reason Deputy Gibbons has not resigned is because part of the sordid burden which led certain of his comrades to the dock was that, having turned informer, he would not be let down by the man to whom he informed.

Comment on this

We shall see in the next few weeks the terms of the conspiracy which is being conspired. Ever since the three Fianna Fáil dissidents left the Fianna Fáil Party meeting last week after midnight saying they would not vote for the Taoiseach and for his Ministers, we are just waiting for the moment when the inevitable happens, when Deputy Lynch, having a diplomatic illness or other ailment of that nature, hands over his seal of office and thereby Deputy Gibbons will lose his ministerial post without Deputy Jack Lynch sacking him. Then those who seek the Taoiseach's blood and Deputy Gibbons's blood will have it and some new person will be offered as the agreed candidate for these people within Fianna Fáil whose hatred for the Opposition is nothing to the depth and extent of the hatred which they bear for one another.

Exactly six months ago today, on 3rd May, when the Taoiseach came into the House and announced the resignation of the first of the names involved in the disarray of the Fianna Fáil Cabinet, Deputy Cosgrave asked: "Is this just the tip of the iceberg?" and the Taoiseach replied: "I do not know what the Deputy is talking about". Well, he knows now, the Fianna Fáil Party know now, the country knows now, that sailing on the sea of Ireland is an iceberg which can crush our people because crushed and depressed and frightened and bewildered they are today; and instead of destroying this iceberg of conspiracy, the Taoiseach is endeavouring still to keep it down in the water so that only the tip can be seen on the surface.

Therefore, it is not the passing fortune of any group of politicians which is at stake in Ireland. It is our whole system of democracy if by that we mean the right and the ability of the people to select the Government they want to carry out the policies they believe in. That is not what we have at the moment. Even the people who voted for Fianna Fáil have not got a Government which they trust, a Government united in their policies who will carry out the policies which they were elected to carry out. We have indeed a Government who announced a proposal last month as being their policy but which they changed three days later and which they changed again four days later.

We have a complete breakdown in the whole machinery, purpose and morality of the Government and it is therefore understandable that our people should have feelings of great frustration. But perhaps this terrible blight which our nation has will have been justified if it brings the awareness that it is only through the ballot box that an Irish Government can be elected, that it is only through the ballot box that standards of morality in Government can be dictated by the people.

Those who elected Fianna Fáil, or the vast majority of them, thought they were electing a Government which would be in keeping with the best traditions of what public life ought to be. They now know to the contrary, but they know also that through the ballot box they have the changing of that Government at any time the Taoiseach will unwillingly allow the people to exercise that opportunity which he knows they would certainly exercise against Fianna Fáil.

There are people asking what will replace the Fianna Fáil Government, whether it will be Fine Gael, an inter-Party Government or what Deputy Haughey, from his mansion in the wealthy suburbs of Dublin, described as chaos. One thing is certain: nothing will ever be the same again. Whenever the election comes, whether this week, next week, next year or in two years, nothing will ever be the same again in this country. The grip of Fianna Fáil has been broken. They have now come back to the roots, corrupt, detesting one another as they detested those who were against them 50 years ago. There is, however, total, absolute slavish agreement that even when they cannot agree among themselves they have the right to rule, going from one opportunity to another.

The contribution of Deputy Gibbons tonight was pitiful. He spent the first 8½ minutes of his speech in attack, in miserable, cheap, taunting, pointless, debasing attack. Let us be fair to him. He was following the one man who is keeping him where he is, the one man who has promised he will not let him go: he was following the example of the Taoiseach who, when there were fundamental matters in relation to how Government should be conducted, on the breakdown and the collapse of the Government's credibility, came into the House and spent practically the whole of his speech when opening this debate taunting, jeering, sneering and making snide remarks about the Opposition. What trust can the country put in a man who will not rise to the occasion, who will not deal with basic principles, who will not give the people the opportunity of selecting a Government in which they can trust? The Taoiseach began by boasting he would wipe the eye of Fine Gael and Labour by putting down a substantive motion which, because of his position, he has the right to move, a motion of confidence in himself and his nominees. He boasted that by doing that he had tricked the Opposition of their right to have the position——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Please be accurate.

Comment on this

How despicable can the Taoiseach become? At a time of crisis, when all organs of public opinion are taxing the Government for their behaviour, all he can do is boast. It is in keeping with what we have, a Government by trickery. The Taoiseach governs by trickery. He tries to rule this House by trickery and to rule his own party by the threat of a general election. That threat alone was able to change five men who were prepared to vote against him into three men at a meeting late at night. From that meeting came the three Fianna Fáil witches. I do not know what has happened to them since. In Macbeth, Act 1 Scene 1, the first witch speaks and says: “When shall we three meet again, in thunder, lightning or in rain.” The second witch: “When the hurly burly's done, when the battle's lost or won”; and the third witch: “That will be e'er the setting of the sun.”

Do we recall the three witches when we think of the three dissidents? Together they said: "Fair is foul and foul is fair, hover through fog and filthy air."

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Good theatre.

Comment on this

Exeunt the witches. "Fair is foul and foul is fair." People wondered at times what the Fs in Fianna Fáil stood for: fair is foul and foul is fair, hover through fog and filthy air, conspiracy with, for and against one another. This gives us no joy. It gives national regret because it is against the interests of the Irish people. Deputy Gibbons, one of the innocents——

Comment on this

Who is Duncan?

Comment on this

——swore on oath that a man who is supporting him, whom he seeks and whom the Taoiseach seeks to keep them in office was on 27th April last setting a trap to trap him. He said also, as he boasted tonight, that he still has the support of the man whom he said was doing something hooky. He spoke also in court on oath of Deputy Blaney behaving suspiciously. We all remember, in all its political and religious ramifications, the frightful evidence on oath of Deputy Gibbons when he sent 500 guns with ammunition to Dundalk. Why? In case Deputy Blaney might do something more rash. On his own admission he committed a rash, a reckless, a dangerous and an unpardonable act. He did it, he said, because he was afraid that one of his own colleagues would do something even more rash.

Is it possible to find in any part of the world, even in those countries referred to slightingly by Deputy Gibbons, any conduct on the part of any Government or member of any Government so despicable, so rash, so reckless, so opposed to the national interest and so much in conflict with the very needs of humanity itself? I do not believe there is. Neither do I believe that now or at at any time in the past has there been a Government that has acted so irresponsibly.

These, then, are the matters on which I wish to dwell, apart from the Government's mishandling of the whole northern situation and the arrangement to import arms. I shall come back to that later because some of the remarks made by Deputy Gibbons require specific reference which I will deal with by way of quotations from the Dáil debates and from the actual court reports.

The most important decision facing this nation at the present time is whether or not we become a member of the EEC. It seems to me that the Government's mishandling of one of the most vital aspects of this matter in relation to this country indicates that they are utterly unfit to lead our people to reach a right decision in this matter. When I say this I am not in any way criticising people who have expressed opposition to our entry into the EEC. We are, or should be, mature enough as a nation to consider all the facets of membership and, on weighing all the pros and cons, to make an appropriate decision. Our first discussions in relation to the EEC began with one of the most calamitous undertakings given unnecessarily, recklessly and foolishly by the then Fianna Fáil Taoiseach, Mr. Seán Lemass — an undertaking which has been given again by the present Taoiseach who now seeks our support to endorse him in his position as Taoiseach, an undertaking that was given as recently as June last by the Minister for External Affairs, speaking in Luxembourg. I speak, of course, of their declaration that Ireland was ready to abandon her traditional policy of neutrality. That was something which they did unnecessarily and without invitation because member states have never required from themselves or anybody else, as a condition of membership, that countries should abandon their neutral position, if they had such.

Neutrality is a positive virtue; war is a negative concept and a negative activity. Morality and prudence dictate that this country is neutral and should remain neutral. It was wrong and very foolish of the Taoiseach and his Minister for External Affairs to commit Ireland to abandoning a stand that is entirely justifiable and which is indeed the only appropriate one for this country to take at any time.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. Mr. de Valera did not do so.

Comment on this

Having made that mistake, they have belittled us before the member nations of the Council of Europe who accepted that Ireland was a neutral country but who then saw a grovelling, begging and slithering applicant who had not the guts to stand on its own dignity and strength and on its sense of propriety. That was fault number one, and as the weeks go on it becomes more clear that this was a crucial mistake to make in relation to Irish public opinion. The Irish public are not prepared to abandon the neutral stand which this country took as early as 1925 and which guided us in the international conflict of 1939-1945. It was General Richard Mulcahy, as Minister for Defence of the first Cosgrave Government and who later became leader of our party, who asserted Ireland's right to be neutral even if Britain or the other Commonwealth nations went to war. That has been a cardinal principle and one that has been agreed by all parties in this State. There may have been some individuals in the past who could not agree but they took the honourable course. There is no reason or justification for abandoning that policy now. It seems that the Government have mishandled the situation. They have misled the other applicant nations in the Council of Europe. Also, they have brought into the debate here something which is irrelevant, which is dangerous and which might lead the people into making a decision in the ultimate referendum which would be injurious to Ireland's interest.

The other matter to which I wish to refer is the recent statement of the Taoiseach at the United Nations when he declared our emphatic desire to use only peaceful means towards achieving the unity of Ireland. We welcome his endorsement of the stand which Fine Gael have taken always and we are glad that it should be on record in the international forum where all nations come, with the exception of China, that Ireland is committed— that all parties, or such of them as can still call themselves parties, are committed — to a policy of unity by peaceful means.

However, where we disagree with the Taoiseach is in his precipitous and presumptuous absolving of Britain from any continuing blame for the situation in the North of Ireland. The reality of the matter is that the much promised reforms, which are necessary if peace with justice is to be achieved, are not proceeding fast enough but to suggest and, in particular to suggest at an international forum, that the British are doing their best is likely only to relax the pressure which we would hope the Westminster Government would be bringing to bear on the powers that be in the north. It is necessary that these reforms be implemented without all the play acting and all the postponements that we have seen up to now. It was a mistake at the United Nations to appear to let Britain off the hook.

I do not speak with any feeling of ill-will towards Britain. Neither do I speak with any desire to rake up old disagreements with Britain, but it is necessary that we look at the situation in Ireland as we have inherited it and that we accept the problem as given to us. It is necessary that we face that problem without belittling ourselves in the process.

Of course, we appreciate that the Taoiseach was in a difficult position. He is, and still endeavours to be, head of a Government which has lost practically one-third of its membership because that one-third disagreed fundamentally with the Taoiseach in his endeavour to lead his party on a course of unity and reconciliation rather than on a course of destruction and subjugation. Therefore, he had to endeavour to make amends and to camouflage the gross errors of the people whom he had selected only 15 or 16 months earlier as Ministers in his own Government, knowing their attitudes, knowing their traditions and knowing their convictions. But why does Ireland have to be belittled and Britain absolved because the Taoiseach makes a wrong decision? That is what happened in the United Nations.

I would ask the Dáil to pause for a moment to consider how it is that the British Prime Minister, Mr. Health, the Leader of the Tory Party, prefaces every statement he ever makes on Northern Ireland with a renewed guarantee of British support for those Irishmen who refuse to work with their fellow countrymen irrespective of religious or political background? That is what Mr. Heath does. No matter what he or any other British politicians may profess about not standing in the way of Irish people if they agree to unite the reality is that as long as the British Prime Minister guarantees to support the Unionists in their intransigence they know they have no need to look to the south, they know that there will be no compulsion on them to endeavour to work out a formula, they know they can continue in their wrong doing because they will never be asked to survive on their own or to learn how to live with us.

God knows, one does not have to go to the sophisticated and difficult field of international politics to appreciate that, if there are two people involved in a row or if two people will not talk with one another, the sure way of keeping them apart is for a third party to come along and say: "Look, as long as you want to keep up that fight, as long as you want to stay apart, I will support you and maintain you". That is exactly what Britain is doing to the tune of £140 million a year. It is maintaining that separate entity. This is not at all to make little of the frightful problems which any peacekeeping force whether it be British, international or Irish, would have to face in the present highly dangerous and sad situation in the North of Ireland. As human beings we can certainly understand, particularly with the approach of winter, that standing all night in the streets being the target for petrol bombs, stones and so forth, is not a pleasant or enviable position to be in, but having said all that it is very necessary that we would say here, and that the Taoiseach would say direct to the British and in any international forum if he ever again addresses one, that Britain must realise that her interests, all Ireland's interests, dictate a unified Ireland and that the time has come for an end to the repeated declarations of the British Prime Minister to lend support to those Irish people who are not prepared to work with their fellow countrymen.

This, Sir, may have drifted somewhat from the general tenor of the debate but I felt it was necessary because to my mind these are very fundamental matters, (1) the unity of our country and (2) the question of whether or not our country will at least set out on a policy of neutrality for the future. It is because we in Fine Gael have no confidence in the Taoiseach that he has made the right declarations in these matters or is prepared to do so in the future, that we are unable to lend him support and that is why we must vote against this motion even if we had never seen the terrible scandals of the last six months.

I also want to draw the attention of the Dáil for a few moments to the pitiful plight of our forgotten people —the nearly 500,000 people who are living below the breadline, who have not got enough to provide themselves with a sufficient diet much less to put clothes on their backs and pay their rent, the aged, the poor and the unemployed who are increasing in numbers daily. Where are they while the giants fight out their battle? Where are they while the Fianna Fáil Party fight out their personal animosities and rivalries? They are forgotten. When taxation was increased last week by £21 million what was there for them? Nothing. They are forgotten and the dreadful thing is that this country is in danger once again of embarking upon decades of futile dialogue and animosity and bitterness such as accompanied the inauguration of this State. That was the case at that time due to the follies of those who now form the Fianna Fáil Party. We pray to God that now they are going to disintegrate we are not going to be set upon a course which again will leave the miserable, the poor, the little people who make up our country, forgotten, dejected and overlooked.

Last week the Minister for Finance told us that there was an increase of £3.6 million in the Budget for social welfare last year; it was to provide the standard of living of anybody on social welfare last year; it was to provide the pittance which is given to our unemployed who have increased in number since the Budget of last April. It is more than a coincidence that this increase in unemployment has gone hand in hand with the sordid conspiracies of the Government, with the lack of leadership on the part of the Government, with the confusion and disintegration of the Government and their policies. The Minister for Finance said last week that it was an illusion that rising money incomes give rising standards. That is something which we will quote to the Minister for Social Welfare whenever he introduces his Social Welfare Bill or any other proposals. We are forever having rammed down our throats a comparison in money incomes between now and 1956. But of course it is true that it is an illusion that rising money incomes give rising standards; it is a complete illusion and that is the illusion under which the Fianna Fáil Party endeavour to live and to mislead the people. We were told last week that in health there was an increase since April of this year of £3.8 million, not to provide better health services, but simply to provide for the increases in prices and costs. We think of the little people who are forgotten, the little people who have to travel on the buses. In Belfast they protest vigorously against increases but here we have the tragic situation, apparently, of many of our people now so subjected, now so demoralised that they can accept two increases in bus fares, amounting in many instances to 45 per cent or 50 per cent, since last June. Many people would call this petty and small but to my mind it is a barometer of the dejection, frustration and worry which pervades this land at present.

Of 12 European countries Ireland comes first with the greatest number of unemployed per head of the population. Our unemployment figure is 7.6 per cent. Next comes the colonels' country, Greece, the dictatorship of Greece, with 3.6 per cent and we, a free democracy, or an alleged democracy, have 7.6 per cent of our people unemployed. In social welfare, of 12 European nations we come last. We are the last in what we give. In 16 countries Ireland is the only one to have a drop in industrial production this year. Again, it is more than a coincidence, I venture to submit, that all this has happened while the Government are in a state of disarray. The country has not got a Government; it has a conspiracy occupying the seats of power. Production costs in Ireland for the third quarter of last year increased by 11.5 per cent. Our nearest rival in rising costs of production was Italy with an increase of 7.5 per cent. In strikes and industrial disputes Ireland comes pitifully at the top of the scale. In 1968, we lost 920 man days per 1,000 employed compared with 370 for Great Britain. In 1969, we lost 2,122 man days for every 1,000 people employed. We have not got the figures available yet but we know that this year the figure is infinitely worse.

So this is the scale of the Government's failure economically, socially, politically. Dare we mention the forgotten, if it was ever born, Third Programme for Economic Expansion and Social Development—the first time that they ever, in any of their programmes, mentioned social development. It has now been forgotten because the whole Third Programme is incapable of being implemented because the Government are incapable of agreeing among themselves what they want. When they agree within themselves they are denounced, contradicted and repudiated by their own party. How can the Civil Service, Government-sponsored bodies, private industry, the trade unions—anybody in the country —know what they are to do when the Government themselves are incapable, in economic, social and financial matters, of giving the kind of leadership it is essential this country should get if it is to make any progress whatsoever?

I should like to return briefly now to the matter which unfortunately has been capturing the greatest public attention—unfortunately, because it should never have arisen but, having arisen, it is proper that it should be aired. We can thank the statesmanship and patriotism of Deputy Liam Cosgrave, Leader of the Opposition, for having aired it and as a result of his action it was aired on 6th, 8th and 9th of May last in this House and it was aired in the courts and it is being aired here again. It is now clearer than ever that the Taoiseach would not have carried out his responsibility to the nation if he had not been embarrassed into doing so by the knowledge that the Leader of the Opposition knew that his Ministers were untrustworthy and that they were involved in some way or other against the safety of the State or that they were working against the Taoiseach and against Dáil Éíreann by opposing the policies which Dáil Éireann had enunciated.

I mentioned in May last, and it is with sorrow that I mention it again, that there stands undebated, unvoted upon, the motion on the Order Paper of Dáil Éireann asking that Dáil Éireann reaffirm its conviction that the unity of Ireland should be achieved only by peaceful methods. We endeavoured to have that motion debated last November—a year ago—when the northern situation was being debated but the Taoiseach would not have it. He was up to his little tricks then as now. He put down his own substantive motion. He would not allow the Dáil, he would not allow his own party, to vote. He would not give what might have been a very useful instrument in the hands of the peacemakers. He would not give them a unanimous vote from Dáil Éireann that everybody here, with the votes of the people, was committed only to a course of peace towards the solution of the division of our country. Why?

I accept the bona fides of the Taoiseach: I accept that he personally believes peace is the only course open to us and that, even if it was not, it is the only course proper for the Irish people to adopt. He is afraid of his own party. He was afraid last November. He has been living in fear of them. He was still afraid of them when he knew they were doing wrong, when, to use his own words, there were suspicions in relation to their conduct. He did nothing until he was forced into action by the Leader of the Opposition who reminded him that there was far more to the iceberg than the tip. Then he moved.

The Taoiseach now comes here and asks us once again to assert that we have confidence in him and in his Ministers when we know he has not got the unanimous support, I believe, of even his Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries in the policies which he personally enunciated—and he certainly has not got the support of the Fianna Fáil Party in these policies. On that account, how can Irishmen north of the Border, who have been unwilling to work with us in the past, trust a Government who are dependent on the support of people who would use guns to fight out issues between Irish people? That is the reality of the situation.

It may be that the Taoiseach will not long remain Taoiseach. Maybe he will dissolve the Dáil tomorrow: that may well be on the cards. We do not know. Tomorrow night, if the Dáil survives that long, we have to vote on whether the Taoiseach and his Ministers deserve our confidence. To that question we give an emphatic "No". Throughout the sorry disclosures of the past six months there has been evidence, which the Taoiseach's own view supports, that Ministers of his Government endeavoured to pervert, endeavoured to subvert, the Army, the Gardaí, the Civil Service and the Red Cross. Deputy James Gibbons, the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, repeated tonight a great deal of what he said on oath in the courts and some of which he inferred on 8th May last. I speak with charity of him and say, as Deputy Boland said earlier tonight: the jury did not believe him.

It is important that, as the Army, the Gardaí, the Civil Service and the Red Cross have been involved in the misconduct of members of the Government, we should pay tribute in this House to the manner in which the Army, and the Gardaí and the Civil Service refused to be subverted. We should applaud them for the manner in which they executed their duty impartially and in discharge of their clear obligations to the fundamental principles of democracy, namely, the rule of law as applied by the votes of the elected representatives of the people in this House. The public officials who were involved in this affair—not of their own volition but because of the efforts by their political heads to subvert them—performed their duty impeccably. They refused to turn the blind eye to wrong when personally it might have been the easier course for them to adopt. They refused to facilitate wrongdoing because they knew that what was being done or was attempted to be done was wrong. They refused to be intimidated by the majesty of ministerial office. We must recall as a vital principle of democracy and of our way of life that our Army, our Gardaí and our Civil Service are responsible to all the Irish people who express their voice through this House. It is not apparent that this fundamental principle is accepted by the Taoiseach and all members of his Government or all members of his party.

The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Gibbons, made heavy weather tonight. We wondered why he was so long in the witness box in the Four Courts: now we know. It takes him a long time to deal with simple matters and, because he takes so long, he endeavours to confuse them. He quoted from column 792 of the Official Report of 8th May, 1970. He gave what he earlier described, when another Deputy was speaking, as an edited version. I will read out the full paragraph. I will indicate when the Minister commenced his quotes. I said, as reported at column 792 of the Official Report of 8th May last:

The purpose of an army is to protect a people against external and internal violence and our Army is responsible to all our people through Dáil Éireann. What then must we think of anybody who has attempted to pervert Army officers in the execution of their duty, who has endeavoured to get or persuade members of the Army to act contrary to their oath to serve Oireachtas Éireann and no other group? We must condemn such people. Such people have committed criminal offences.

At this point the Minister commenced his quote:

It is quite clear that evidence has been given to the Taoiseach which links certain names with such activities not related alone to the attempted importation of arms from Vienna but relating also to training which was given in at least one Army camp to civilians in the use of arms.

The Minister then interjected: "That is not true." I take it he was referring to my statement that evidence was given to the Taoiseach that training was given in at least one Army camp to civilians in the use of arms.

Suggestions were made by the Minister that we were taking an unholy delight in raking up all this filth. Might I just quote the next sentence to show our concern for the welfare of the nation, our anxiety that what need not be disclosed, if it would be harmful to the national interest, should not be disclosed. After the Minister's contradiction and denial of what I said that apparently there was evidence in support of, I said:

It seems that this crisis is so grave that the Taoiseach—the present one or whoever shortly succeeds him— has a clear obligation to take the whole Dáil into his confidence. There is provision in the Constitution for the holding of a secret session of the Dáil in case of national emergency. I believe that we are in such a position at the present time— that we are in a state of national emergency and if there is information available which the Taoiseach believes it would not be in the public interest to reveal he can call that secret session.

I then went on to say that we were not particularly wishful that these issues should be resolved in secret but that it was a matter for the Taoiseach, as Taoiseach, if he felt that the issues justified it, to save the nation from any harm that might be brought about by disclosures. The Taoiseach decided otherwise. He referred the matter to the Attorney General with the consequences which we now know. It was not from these benches that this matter was revealed although, as I mentioned earlier, we have not any regrets that it has been revealed, terrible and all as those consequences have been.

The Minister then went on to quote from his own speech. It is a pity he did not quote from the radio and television appearances which he made that day. Unfortunately I have not got the scripts of them but, if I remember rightly, he accused me of making allegations against him. Here I would draw the attention of the House to the fact that I mentioned nobody. I said it appeared that evidence had been given to the Taoiseach relating to an attempt to illegally import arms from Vienna and that also there was evidence of training in at least one Army camp. I did not name the Minister but even before he spoke in this House to contradict what I said, Deputy Gibbons went on radio and television to denounce me and accuse me of uttering slanderous remarks concerning him. It was he, Sir, who put the cap on himself, not I. I may have tailored the cap but he put it on, believing that it was on his head alone that it should rest.

Later that day he said he wished to deny that there was any attempt to import arms or that he was implicated in such an attempt. Be that as it may, the court has heard and the court has given its verdict. As reported at column 841 of the Official Report of 8th May, 1970, the Minister said:

There was some reference to the training of civilians in Donegal. I want to point out the position of the Defence Forces in this regard. The Defence Forces train only members of their own ranks, whether they be FCA or Army or Naval personnel. This story first got currency in the Protestant Telegraph. It is time that stories of this kind ceased.

They did not cease. The Minister's own evidence on oath in court gave the specific details and these details indicate that the Minister was a party to limited truths, if not untruths, and that the Taoiseach, by reinstating him in ministerial office and by promoting him and by appointing Deputy Cronin to ministerial office, also has been and continues to be a party to the limited truths, to the untruths and to efforts to definitely and deliberately mislead the Dáil. I propose to quote chapter and verse to prove it.

Giving evidence in court on Friday, 9th October, as reported in the Irish Times of 10th October, page 8, column 8, the Minister said in reply to Mr. Finlay that he had heard of a demand by the representatives of the Citizens Defence Committees in Belfast and Derry for training by the Irish Army and this demand was met to some extent by the process of enrolling citizens of Derry in the FCA and giving them a week's training at a fort in Donegal. I want to repeat those words because it is necessary to underline them in view of what the Minister has been saying and what he said here again today, and what Deputy Cronin has said as Minister for Defence, when they endeavoured to give the impression that nothing unusual occurred, that this was a routine recruitment of people without any investigation as to whether their addresses within the Republic were genuine. The Minister said in court that he had heard of a demand by representatives of citizens defence committees for training by the Irish Army and this demand was met to some extent by the process of enrolling citizens of Derry in the FCA and giving them a week's training at a fort in Donegal.

These were Derry citizens, mark you, citizens, Bogsiders, and they understood it. They were certain selected people. Selected by whom I wonder? Certain selected people presented themselves and requested training. They were informed that they would have to enroll in the Defence Forces which they duly did and they received their training. So far as he could recall the number who received this training was nine. They were immediately enrolled in the FCA, received their training and then went back to Derry. Asked if this course of action was stopped because of newspaper publicity, the Minister replied that the Taoiseach was on leave and "I sanctioned that on my own initiative", indicating that he was consulted before these people were recruited and received into the FCA. The Minister was consulted about whether or not it should be done and on his own initiative he said: "Yes".

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Today once again he suggests that people who quote his own words and rely upon his own words, his own oath, are slandering him. It was said by a Deputy in the House who is medically qualified to speak that perhaps the Minister is not well. We would be prepared to accept that but we cannot accept that when we rely upon his own words we are slandering him unless it be that he knows his own words are perjury. Certainly we do not know. Whatever suspicions we may have we rely upon his own words where he states that on his own initiative he recruited people from Derry to get training in arms in Donegal for the purpose of going back to Derry and that that is exactly what happened. When the matter was put before him in the Dáil he denied it.

Let us be fair to him. I am prepared to quote his justification for his denial. As reported in the Irish Times of 10th October, the Minister asked if this course of action was stopped because of newspaper publicity, replied that the Taoiseach was on leave and “I sanctioned that on my own initiative”. I already quoted that. I want to go on to the next paragraph. The Minister explained to Mr. Finlay that the FCA was a local defence force and the intention behind it was to provide in each area of the country opportunities for persons to perfect themselves in the use of arms so that they might be available as a reserve force. It was a part-time organisation.

Mr. Finlay: It is not intended for the purpose of training people living outside the Republic?

Mr. Gibbons: Not strictly speaking.

Mr. Finlay: Do you agree that the enrolment of the people of Derry on your order into the FCA was an unorthodox method of achieving what you thought a proper objective?

Mr. Gibbons: Yes.

He did not deny, when the question was specifically put to him, that he recruited these people into the FCA on his own order, on his own initiative. He did it and is there to be no end to his denials, to his contradictions? Nobody has to suggest that he is a convicted liar. He convicts himself every time he opens his mouth and he is incapable of doing otherwise.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The poor, miserable fellow that the Taoiseach stands over.

Again I quote from the Irish Times of Saturday, 10th October, page 9, dealing with the evidence of the Minister in court the previous day. He was asked:

What was the point of training them in the use of guns if they were not going to get guns?

His reply was:

My chief motivation in this gesture would be to convey to them that their dire straits were perceived by us and were sympathised with by us.

He was asked:

May I take it that your purpose or idea, in permitting the enrolment of a number of citizens from Derry in the FCA, was simply to make a gesture of sympathy to the people of the Bogside?

He replied:

I think that would be accurate.

Again, no denial that it was his purpose, his idea, to permit the enrolment of people from the Bogside of Derry.

Again, he was put the question:

Did you think it was going to be of any practical assistance to the people of Derry?

The Minister replied:

My principal objective in ordering this action was to indicate to the people of Derry that they had our sympathy and the refusal of an action of this kind of ours could be misunderstood by them as a total rejection of their plight.

Again it was his order which caused these people to be trained there in arms.

This, then, is the Minister who spent the first eight and a half minutes of his speech today attacking the Opposition because they were criticising him and spent the last 18 minutes of his speech in like attacks upon the Opposition because he said they were defaming him and his family. I had not heard his family brought into this at all. It would be most unfair to criticise the family of any Member unless we knew that the family was in some way or other involved. His family have never been involved by us and if he puts that baby in his arms he can throw that baby out. We have not put it there and we will not have it suggested against us that we are unfairly criticising people who are not in this House. The Minister is here. He has answered in the House and, having answered in the House, he is accountable to the House and the House has a right to criticise him.

Before I go on to the general philosophy of Fianna Fáil, which apparently justifies this kind of misleading statement, I want to deal with two questions which were addressed to the present Minister for Defence, Deputy Cronin, in the House on the 21st May last. My esteemed colleague, Deputy P. Hogan, asked the Minister for Defence if citizens from Northern Ireland were brought into this State any time last year for special army training; on whose authority this was arranged; the extent of the operation; whether he was informed of it beforehand; whether he gave approval; and whether any financial commitments fell to be met by the State. Deputy P. Belton asked the Minister for Defence if civilians were afforded the training facilities of the FCA in Donegal recently; and, if so, what action he intends to have taken against the officers in charge of the units concerned. The Minister for Defence adopted the same line as Deputy Gibbons had attempted to justify on the 8th May last, that people were no longer civilians once they had the jacket of the FCA put on their shoulders. He said the position was explained by the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in the Dáil on the 8th instant. The Minister went on to say, and this is interesting:

While, under Defence Force Regulations, a person ordinarily resident outside the State is not, subject to certain exceptions, eligible for enlisting in the FCA, it has not been the practice of attesting officers to question the addresses within the State given by potential recruits as their place of ordinary residence.

Here, again, the great cover-up, the statement that it is not the practice to recruit people into the FCA outside the jurisdiction of this Dáil which our Constitution recognises for the time being as applying only to the Twenty-Six counties. It is not the practice and it is not the practice either to query their addresses. At column 2171 of the Official Report for the same date Deputy P. Hogan, as a supplementary, asked the Minister a perfectly straightforward question:

Is the Minister satisfied that citizens from Northern Ireland did not participate in any training activities under arms in the Republic?

The Minister replied:

I have no such information.

Deputy Gibbons acknowledged under oath in court that he ordered it, he initiated it, he directed it. He gave his motives for doing it. He then stated that the whole matter was called off when the Taoiseach got to know about it, that the Taoiseach considered it and the Taoiseach stopped it and that the nine people in question were sent back to Derry. On the 21st May with that information known to the senior officers in the Army, known to the officials of the Department of Defence, known to the Taoiseach, possibly known to senior officials of the Taoiseach's Department and known also to the man who was promoted to the position of Minister for Defence, they come out and blatantly say in the Dáil that they have no information relating to the training of citizens from Northern Ireland in arms in the Republic. They were not even asked whether they were citizens while they were training. They were not asked were they civilians while they were training. They were asked whether any citizens from the North of Ireland got training in arms in the Republic. The only honest answer to that was: "Yes". That was not the answer that was given but the Taoiseach remained silent. The Taoiseach has remained silent over all this, leaving the mugs to do the dirty work but he has appointed them, he promotes them, he keeps them in his Cabinet, he asks this Dáil and the Irish people to endorse his conduct, to say that it is all right to mislead because, according to the Fianna Fáil doctrine, you may lie if you are under attack in the Dáil.

On Saturday, 10th October the Irish Times reported the court case of the previous day and gave this evidence from Deputy Gibbons. When reference was being made to the quotation which I gave earlier of the 8th May when I said that the Taoiseach had evidence which suggested that people had been trained in arms in the north of Ireland I pointed out that Deputy Gibbons interjected: “That is not true”. He was questioned about that in court at considerable length. I do not want to go into it all. I have already indicated that the Taoiseach, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, the Minister for Defence, were all aware that this had occurred. It was misleading to the nth degree to suggest it was not so. Deputy Gibbons was asked:

Do you think that your reply to Deputy Ryan was not something of a half truth?

He said:

I am suggesting what Deputy Ryan said was inaccurate.

So be it. My conscience is clear and I have no doubt about the view of the 12 jurymen on that particular issue or what the verdict would be by the people of Ireland if they were asked who was telling the truth and who was being accurate. Deputy Gibbons was then asked:

Would you accept that in this instance you had told the truth but only half the truth?

His reply was:

This was a Dáil debate.

He was then asked:

Is that your answer Mr. Gibbons, that one is not bound to tell the truth in a Dáil debate?

He sharply replied:

This is a Dáil debate in which Deputy Ryan and his colleagues are seeking to demolish the Government and the Government Party.

Is that not extraordinary? This is the doctrine of governmental behaviour, the guideline for governmental behaviour, which the Taoiseach stands over, that when the Government are under attack in the Dáil they are entitled to lie, they are entitled to tell half truths, they are entitled to hold back, they are entitled to refuse to answer questions. God knows we have known here for years and years that we were not getting the truth in reply to Parliamentary questions.

What has happened? Unfortunately, this is the tragedy for this country, that instead of the people seeing where the blame lies they are inclined to repudiate all the institutions of this State and to have a desperate lack of faith in them. When that lack of faith becomes all pervading, as I fear it is becoming in this country, then democracy will be destroyed overnight. Anybody last week who had the privilege of hearing Madame Helen Vlachos, the newspaper owner from Athens who refused to continue to publish her newspaper under the censorship of the colonels, would have realised just how easy it is for democracy to be overthrown and dictatorship to be installed. It happened in Greece on a normal day, on a quiet day, when there were no rumours of conspiracy and when there were no known dangers threatening the State, when everybody was at ease. They woke up in the morning to find democracy had been overthrown because some people, apparently with their own standards as to what the country should do, decided to reject democracy and to impose their will. I fear for this country. This is the kind of concern which ought to be affecting our minds tonight, a concern for the institutions of this State, and for the survival of our little State here. We could be a great little State amongst the greatest in the world but we have belittled, cheapened and ridiculed ourselves. We have demeaned ourselves to ourselves and before the world. This is an appalling state of affairs and those primarily responsible are the Taoiseach, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and all the members of the Government.

There is one thing which makes me wonder. Have we heard everything yet? Deputy Haughey, and what he described as his fellow-patriots in court, gave evidence that, when the Taoiseach was out of town, relaxing in Cork or having his well-entitled rest, it was Deputy Haughey who was in charge. One wonders where the Tánaiste was. Why was he not consulted? Is he the boy who is left, as we suspect he is, or has been for years, the fellow who is never considered, whose views are never considered? It was not to Deputy Childers, the Tánaiste, the senior member of the Government, the man next to the Taoiseach, that Deputy Blaney, Deputy Haughey, Deputy Gibbons or anybody else went to when crisis, doomsday or some matter of dramatic importance arose. No, it was always, according to Deputy Haughey, and this was not contradicted by anybody else, to him.

We are asked to endorse as Tánaiste a man whom nobody in the Fianna Fáil Party will speak to. God knows apparently it is difficult enough for Ministers to communicate with the Taoiseach who apparently has his touchables and his untouchables. The untouchables cannot communicate with him except through one of the higher people like those who have now been dismissed. Apparently, the Tánaiste was never to be used either when he was still in town when the Taoiseach was away or even as a conduit pipe to get to the Taoiseach. Mark you, Deputy Erskine Childers, the Tánaiste, lives in my own constituency just down the road from me. If anybody is ever in any difficulty in contacting him and gets in touch with me I will be his messenger boy and drop down the road to see him. He is hardly ever out of town at weekends but apparently he was never consulted at all. His counsel was never sought. That is an extraordinary position. One wonders that the Taoiseach would have about him somebody who is apparently of such little consequence.

We come to another extraordinary episode in this sordid and frightening playacting. On the 2nd April, in common with all his ministerial colleagues who were not attending to their duties but were seeking to win a by-election to hold them in office and to help them keep their hands on the loot, Deputy Gibbons then Minister for Defence, was being transported to the constituency of Kildare in a State car when he was held up by a member of the Garda Síochána who handed him a piece of paper containing a number which he was to ring immediately. Apparently he did not know who he was to ring. He rang from the Fianna Fáil headquarters in Naas and he spoke to Deputy Blaney the then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, the man who was supposed to be concerned about protecting our fisheries but had not even got a rowing boat to protect them.

Deputy Blaney, since dismissed from the Government, but on whose support the Government still hope to rely, indicated to Deputy Gibbons he was going to do something rash. I wonder what rash thing Deputy Blaney had in mind to do that day. It must have been really dreadful because Deputy Gibbons, in order to stop Deputy Blaney doing something more rash, rang up the Chief-of-Staff of our armed forces and gave him a direction to move 500 guns from some safe secure place to Dundalk together with the appropriate ammunition.

This is one of the ironic twists of this situation. The Taoiseach quite recently, perhaps on his return from New York or some other place, said that the first two national priorities of Fianna Fáil were the restoration of national unity and the restoration of the Irish language. The ironic aspect of this sordid Naas episode is that the Minister for Defence decided to speak in Irish on the telephone to the Chief-of-Staff so that nobody would know what they were talking about. Here we have the Minister for Defence using the failure for Fianna Fáil's second national aim to make sure that the achievement of the first national aim is absolutely impossible in our time. Was there ever a greater condemnation of the Fianna Fáil Party, of its total failure in its two principal aims that they use Irish so that nobody will understand it in order that they can use arms against fellow-Irishmen so that they will hate the rest of the people and never unite with them?

This is just typical of the lack of thought, the stupidity, the hypocrisy of the Taoiseach and his Ministers in whom he now asks us to vote confidence. They continue to play down other opinions and attitudes suggesting that they alone are the great custodians of the Irish Celtic heritage and that without their remaining in office it would be utterly and completely destroyed.

We have not heard the end of this sorry story and we will not, I fear, hear the end of it as long as the Government remain in office. Surely it should be apparent that the Government must go. The national interest requires nothing else. There is unexplained still £99,999 9s of public money voted by this House for the relief of human distress and misery in the streets of Belfast and Derry. We do not know what, if anything, ever got it. Maybe it is as well that decimalisation has not come in for the nines might have gone on forever. All the Taoiseach would say up to now is that he was assured that none of the money voted by this House had been used for the attempted importation of arms. All we know now apparently, if we are to rely upon the testimony which Deputy Gibbons asks us to rely upon, is that some £20,000 or £30,000 of that money was certainly not used for the purpose for which it was voted by this House.

Therefore, the nation is entitled to an immediate and detailed account of all that money. We believe that all the forces of the Garda Síochána, the Army and the courts are not of themselves sufficient to get an appropriate account of this money. We voted that money on behalf of the Irish people. We voted it for the relief of human misery and distress so that people's wounds might be bound, so that the hungry might be fed, so that the unclothed might be clothed, so that those without bedding might get bedding, so that those without a roof might get a roof above them, without discrimination as to whether they were Protestant or Catholic. That was the will and the wish of our people, and I do not think there is .0001 per cent of our people south of the Border who would wish that money to be spent in any discriminatory way. We wished it to be spent for the relief of our kith and kin without regard to their religious or political convictions and that was the direction which was given.

What do we find? We find that the Irish section of the Red Cross was again subverted and perverted by the Government, by agents of the Government and Ministers of the Government, for the purpose of using that very money voted for humanitarian reasons in a way contrary to the interests of humanity and the interests of the Irish people in particular.

Our name in international circles, if it is not mud, is a laughing stock. In the United Nations, the Council of Europe, across the world, the banana republic in the Celtic mist and fog off the western shores of Europe is a laughing stock. I was in Strasbourg and in Berlin during the conspiracy trial. All the continental papers carried accounts of the evidence that was revealed one day after another. Ireland was the joke in Europe but it was a rather sick joke for the Irish people to have to hear the laughter and the statements made. You could not blame other people: "Oh, the Irish are as bad as ever they were. The stage Irishman is still alive. They are a gas lot, the Irish. How they ever survive one just does not know." This is the kind of remark that is being passed in the international corridors, and how could it be otherwise? Goodness knows we have already belittled ourselves with undertakings which were called for in relation to neutrality and by absolving the British from any continuing responsibility in regard to the northern situation. We are now in this appalling position of having destroyed practically the last vestige of our reputation and we are now on record as having used or misused the International Red Cross for the sordid purpose of buying guns to shoot people.

This is the negation of what the International Red Cross stands for. I heard the criticism offered last week of the International Red Cross that it was the great "cover-upper" because it would not condemn the Government when it saw the mistreatment of prisoners or when it saw the misuse of public funds. The only reason why the Red Cross does not do it is that the Red Cross in order to bring necessary relief to the sick, the anguished and the dying, must not involve itself in politics. It must not, even when it knows wrong to have been committed, condemn the wrongdoer, in the hope that by remaining silent it will be allowed in to relieve the victims of the wrongdoer. To use the Red Cross for this purpose is to my mind a dastardly and unforgivable act. We have shamed ourselves before the world in every activity over which this Government have any control or ought to have control.

This Government will dissolve sooner or later. Political parties, like all human societies, have their disagreements from time to time. There are the clashes of personalities from time to time. These do not matter a great deal. They may, in fact, be of benefit to the country, be of benefit to the party. But it does matter where the people who are having these disagreements happen to be at the time they are having them, and it does matter that they should not use the institutions of the State and that they should not subvert public officials for the purpose of carrying out their intrigue against one another or because they have a clash of policy even on fundamental matters.

What has happened here and what is doing most damage to the country is not that Fianna Fáil are having disagreements. I can even respect those who have opinions on this and other matters which are in total conflict with mine. One could not but have respect for Deputy Kevin Boland who took an honourable course. We have often criticised him for his intransigence, for his lack of understanding for the other person's point of view, but he at least has had the integrity, when he found himself in conflict on a matter of principle, on a matter of policy and on a matter of strategy, to leave the Government. However, because he did leave the Government and criticised the Government that he had left, he has been drummed out of the Fianna Fáil party.

This to my mind is not the worst part of it, because at least Deputy Boland is out of the Government. Even if they detest him they can proceed without him. They do not need his support— which is just as well because quite obviously they will not get it — but there are others supporting the Government; there are others still within the Government who, I believe, fundamentally disagree with the Taoiseach in his statement that force must not be used in any way in relation to the issues concerning the unification of our country or even when our people disagree.

The Opposition parties here have had their disagreements. They are well publicised. They have been thrashed out. Perhaps they are not all solved yet. This is the way in any democracy and it is a good process. But when it happens that a Government is torn by the intrigues of its members against one another, when they are perverting and subverting the institutions of the State and the people that are in them, in the Army and the Garda Síochána, then it is time to cry halt and say: "Look, boys, sort yourselves out. Come back to the Government again if the people give you the chance, but please," and this is the cry on the lips of all our people with the exception of the diehard Fianna Fáil supporters, even from the lukewarm Fianna Fáil supporters, "hand over office to somebody else while you sort yourselves out. When you have sorted yourselves out and found out who is going to win, whether it is Lynch with Gibbons, because Gibbons ratted on his colleagues, or whether it is Hillery without Gibbons, promoting the fellows on whom Gibbons ratted or whether it is somebody else it does not matter." Fianna Fáil cannot settle this dispute. It is too deep, and they know it. It is too extensive, and they know it. It has done the country immense harm, and they know it. It has done the Fianna Fáil Party a total disservice and because of that it has done the country a total disservice. Answer the pleas of our people to get out and let into office a Government which will be agreed on fundamentals, agreed in carrying out their policies and, when they have had a chance of doing so, then the people can decide whether a reformed and united Fianna Fáil Party can ever come into power again.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

Deputy Gibbons spoke before Deputy Ryan.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Since the debate began Fine Gael have taken four hours 45 minutes, Labour have taken one hour and 50 minutes and the Government party have taken one hour and 46 minutes.

Comment on this

Surely, we have been operating on the basis of a fair rotation throughout the House? This emerged in a recent discussion and it would appear on the rotation principle that a Labour Deputy is now entitled to speak.

Comment on this

Of course he is.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair will give the House that fair rotation and for that reason I am calling on Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

A Fianna Fáil Deputy spoke before Deputy Ryan and a Labour Deputy is now entitled to follow.

Comment on this

I do not quite understand the Chair's ruling on rotation. I think I rose before Deputy Dowling. If the Chair rules that Deputy Dowling holds the floor I have to respect the Chair's ruling but would ask that I be called after him.

Comment on this

The Deputy must not say that.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins has just said that Deputy Dr. Cruise-O'Brien must not say what?

Comment on this

Will Deputy Andrews take himself to a debating society in Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown.

Comment on this

The one, one, one principle has been enshrined in debates here.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The one, one, one principle has been enshrined in debates so far as Private Deputies' Motions are concerned and the Chair has always held to that.

Comment on this
Deputies

No.

Comment on this

I disagree with the Chair.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I appeal to the fairness of Deputies on all sides of the House. The position is, as I have pointed out, that since the debate began Fine Gael Deputies have spoken for four and three-quarter hours.

Comment on this

This has never arisen before.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil Deputies never offered to speak.

Comment on this

If Fianna Fáil are ashamed to defend themselves, what can we do about it?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The position is that the Opposition have monopolised seven hours of the time as against the Government's one and three-quarter hours.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): May I ask the Chair on which side Deputy Boland is put?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Boland has been put on the independent side.

Comment on this

This is a radical departure from the normal procedure of this House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

The usual procedure is party after party. Surely the Chair will agree it is not a matter of the duration of the speech? A Government spokesman is entitled to speak as long as he likes.

Comment on this

The Chair smiles. Is it the situation that the Government have a bad case and are ashamed?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has nothing to do with the merits or demerits of the case.

Comment on this

The Government have no credibility.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowling has been called upon by the Chair to speak. He is the Fianna Fáil Deputy who stands in the gap and is always seen by the Chair.

Comment on this

The Whips of the three parties came to an agreement which was registered by motion today and agreed to. If there had been any suspicion of a departure from the usual rotation I, for one, would not have made that arrangement.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is surprised that the Whips arrived at that decision because the Chair was not consulted.

Comment on this

That may be the case, but if this rotation is upset we shall have to look into this matter again.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has already heard a point of order on this matter. The Chair has explained fully to the Deputy and if he cannot understand that the Opposition have taken up six and a half hours as against one hour fifty minutes——

Comment on this

A Deputy is being denied his right to speak in proper rotation and this is unprecedented. The strongest possible protest was made about this before.

Comment on this

At the time I indicated my willingness to yield to Deputy Dowling I was not aware of the agreement reached between the Whips of which Deputy R. Burke has just spoken.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cruise-O'Brien should be allowed to finish making his point of order.

Comment on this

I do not want to upset that agreement, which would be in accordance with orderly proceedings here, but I should like to assert formally my claim to speak.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair would also like to point out that the debate is limited and it is the duty of the Chair, where the debate is limited, to give all points of view an opportunity.

Comment on this

May I respectfully ask on what precedent and on what Standing Order the Chair relies for this ruling? I am a new Deputy here. I have the rights which ordinary Deputies have and I think that these rights are being over-ridden by the Chair and, I may say so, not entirely for the first time.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has always been the position. The Chair has always held to the one, one, one principle on Private Deputies' Motions.

Comment on this

The Chair did not hold to that when Deputy Boland spoke for seven hours.

Comment on this

The Chair well knows that the strongest possible exception was taken to this departure in the past and it is very unusual that the Chair should adopt the same procedure here tonight.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am glad the Deputy agrees that there has been a departure in the past. I understood from some Deputies that it had never occurred before.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I understood the Chair to rule in the past that speeches rotated from one party to another and that the Chair was not going to depart from that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair agrees with the Deputy, but that was so far as Private Members' Motions were concerned.

Comment on this

We have not had Private Members' Business for the last one and a half years.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am calling on Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

I should like to speak to the motion:

That Dáil Éireann reaffirms its confidence in An Taoiseach and the other Members of the Government.

In doing so I want to say that I am not concerned with a rehash of what took place in court or what has taken place in the Press in relation to the recent trial. I am concerned, like most other realistic Deputies, with the bread and butter issues facing this country at present. I am concerned with providing jobs for workers and ensuring a better standard of living for all our people, because it is by these things that the Taoiseach and the Government are judged. We stand on the records produced during our years in office in relation to these matters. We are well aware that no policy is an excuse for talking. That is the reason why the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party have been so vocal on this Motion of No Confidence in the Government.

When the Taoiseach introduced his motion he indicated that he was well aware the debate here would follow the line it is now following. It is important to note that at the moment, there is not a single member of the Labour Party in the House. Evidently, they have no interest in the discussions which are taking place here. The political banshees of the Fine Gael Party have been crying here for the past two days or months. We heard Deputy Ryan tonight and others today. We shall probably hear Deputy Cruise-O'Brien, who left the Chamber sulking some time ago and again tonight. We shall hear in due course the type of trash that has already been dished out today and previously. They spoke about credible alternatives, a credible alternative that has now run away from a little problem as to who was to speak. We are left with three members of Fine Gael and no member of the Labour Party. This is the credible alternative to Fianna Fáil which runs away and sulks when the position is put to them regarding speakers.

The position is clear in regard to discussions that have taken place. There may be and there are differences of opinion within our party, but these can be solved by taking a lift to the fifth floor. We shall not have to travel to Peking or to Cuba or elsewhere to solve our problems. They can and will be solved here. In regard to the Taoiseach and the Government, the policy that has been presented and endorsed on numerous occasions by the people——

Comment on this

I think we should have a House for this oratory. Even his own Deputies will not listen to him. Bring them in.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I should like to thank Deputy O'Donovan. Since I came here his main function in the House appears to be calling for a quorum.

Comment on this

The bell man.

Comment on this

Bell man for the Labour Party. The Government's policy is one on which we can look back with credit as regards industrial and social development, health and housing and other features of that policy. If we were faced with an alternative we have two members of Fine Gael here now and no member of the Labour Party — and these people say they can present an alternative Government.

Fine Gael have a policy known as The Just Society as an alternative to the Fianna Fáil policy. Transport workers and others should know of what is meant by The Just Society which will be put forward by a Fine Gael Government. During the recent election campaign we saw a letter which appeared in the paper under the heading "The Just Society" in which it was said that a bus conductor in Dublin North-West was rejected because he could not raise £300 for the Fine Gael Party. The situation is that The Just Society demands from an ordinary worker £300. Was he deprived of an opportunity of standing for Dáil Éireann because he had not got £300 or because he was a bus conductor? This is the question Fine Gael must answer. The transport workers would be delighted to know that embodied in Fine Gael policy is a demand from workers in this city for £300 or else they cannot stand for election.

This is only a down payment on their seat in Dáil Éireann which they get on hire purchase, £300 down and the balance when elected. We would like to know — it has not yet been published— what is the deposit on a Seanad seat. A worker in this city was deprived of an opportunity of standing for election because he was a worker. The excuse was that he had not got £300 to pump into the Fine Gael funds. It is now clear that workers are not required in Fine Gael; it is a lawyers' party and the people with £300 to advance are the people who will be selected in the future. This is the alternative party with an alternative policy which would debar an important section of the community from standing for election to Dáil Éireann.

We are well aware of the manner in which this policy was rejected by the people not so long ago. We had the leader of the party for the time being— I shall deal in some detail with the attempts that have been made and that will be made to dislodge him — criticising the Taoiseach some time ago for not acting and when he acted in regard to the problem mentioned Deputy Cosgrave criticised the Taoiseach for acting. So you cannot win if you are a Taoiseach of a Fianna Fáil Government so far as Deputy Cosgrave is concerned.

There was one matter in relation to the statement made by Deputy Cosgrave which was referred to tonight by Deputy Ryan, the letter which he produced in this House. Rumour has it at the moment that the letter he produced and waved in this House was obtained on the basis of a promise of promotion if the Government were toppled. Is this correct? Rumour has it that there was a promise of promotion for this person if the Government fell as a result of the free supply of information. Is this information continuing to be supplied to Deputy Cosgrave or what price is he paying for it? If it was supplied by an Irishman in an Irish service it is understandable. However, it may have been supplied by the British secret service and, if so, was the same promise of promotion made to the person who supplied this information? Without doubt Deputy Cosgrave has so many friends, as the Fine Gael Party have, across the water that there would be no difficulty in influencing the promotion of such a person. Rumour has it that this is what has taken place and I should like to know if it is correct. It is not a very creditable way for a leader to act, to wave a letter and at no time give the source of his information. He did not give it in court, when he had an opportunity of presenting the information there, but he waved it here in this House. I should like to know if Deputy Cosgrave is at this moment prepared to give this House the name of the person who supplied this information, or is he going to continue to protect a traitor, a person who divulged information for a price. What price? Is it the price of promotion? Is that the price he promised for the information? This has been said and there may be something in it. We will get to the bottom of it in due course.

Comment on this

Why not get to the top of it?

Comment on this

Maybe, from time to time, we will get additional information. This is the alternative leader who is being presented to this House. Of course, we had Deputy Ryan letting us know some time ago what happened in Fine Gael. He went into the meeting as Richard the Lion Heart and he came out as Richard the Chicken Heart. This is the Sunday Independent of 7th December, 1969 — this is the alternative government presented to this House. We will see what Richard the Lion Heart had to say before he became Richard the Chicken Heart:

Last Wednesday night I was discharging my duties as Fine Gael shadow Minister for Health in the Dáil Chamber moving amendments to the Health Bill. I was necessarily excused from the Oireachtas Party meeting which was going on at the same time in Leinster House. Without any notice to me the business of my constituency was irregularly discussed... I could have been summoned from the Dáil Chamber within 30 seconds.

They did not think enough of him to send for him. Next day, December 8th, the front bench Fine Gael Deputy, Richard Ryan, was prepared to name those involved in the alleged plot to overthrow the party chief, if they did not stop their sabotage. This was Deputy Richie Ryan:

You can identify them by their failure to attack those who have been already attacking the party and by their readiness now to rush and criticise me.

Again: "Ryan tells of canvass for Higgins." Deputy O'Higgins, the man in the gap. "Mr. Ryan's statement, the second in 24 hours, was issued in reply to remarks by Tom O'Higgins. Mr. Ryan pledged to keep Mr. Cosgrave as party leader." However, Deputy Ryan was not sent for, but he gives some indications of the hatchets that were being sharpened and the attempts to overthrow the leader of Fine Gael in May, 1971, and that has yet to come. They talk about an alternative Government knowing there is disruption in their own party. They talk about confusion in our party while there is patent disruption in their, with the hatchet men out to get at the leader, and Deputy Ryan is the man who went into that meeting threatening to spill the beans and to confront the party with the names of those who wanted to put Deputy O'Higgins in place of Deputy Cosgrave. As he said tonight: "There are still problems in our party and we hope they will soon be solved." We have some indication now of the type of alternative government the Fine Gael Party could provide. We know the type of man the leader is, accepting information from a variety of sources without telling us those sources. One does not, of course, know what the terms were. After a course of corrective training lasting several days Deputy Ryan came back into the Dáil. The doctors advised he should return to normal duties for a prolonged period. He was demoted to the back bench and, after he had purged himself, he was promoted once more to the front bench. This is the alternative government with which we are presented.

We know that Deputy Ryan, who spoke at length here tonight, was the chief architect in the destruction of Dublin City Council. He had no regard whatsoever for the sick, the unemployed and those dependent on social welfare benefits, the benefits this Government provided and increased over the years. He and the members of the Labour Party destroyed the Dublin City Council by failing to measure up to their responsibilities and by trying to ensure that the unfortunate people would not get the benefits the Fianna Fáil Government had provided for them over the years.

Comment on this

Differential rents.

Comment on this

I will deal with differential rents and everything else. By our re-affirming our confidence in the members of the Government we know we will continue to ensure that the weaker sections of our community will be protected, protected from the political vultures representing Fine Gael and Labour on the Dublin City Council, vultures who have no regard for the weaker sections of our community. We will continue to build our industrial arm. We will continue our housing programme. We will continue our agricultural policy. We will not allow these to be sabotaged again as they were sabotaged by Fine Gael and Labour in the Coalition Governments. Deputy Ryan must bear a great burden of responsibility for the dissolution of Dublin City Council. He obviously disliked the unfortunate people who were getting social welfare benefits; all he succeeded in doing was putting himself and his colleagues on the scrap heap.

I have no doubt whatever that the day of reckoning has come for Deputy Ryan. In recent editions of certain papers we have seen a photograph of a Cabinet ready to govern, the alternative Fine Gael Government. There has has been a notable omission. Deputy Oliver J. Flanagan has not appeared in the photographs. We wonder why he is missing. Is it because he spoke his mind in relation to the Germans? Is it because of the Ryan affair? Is it because he wanted to see the leader of the party toppled? I have my own ideas. Others have theirs. But this is a notable omission. Perhaps he did not arrive in time or perhaps the photographer was told to leave, but Deputy Oliver J. Flanagan is missing. They probably will not be ready to govern until they have a cabinet with Deputy Oliver J. Flanagan in it.

With regard to Deputy Garret FitzGerald, he was described as a Sherlock Holmes going around with a magnifying glass in his hand. A very apt description. I can see him with his deerstalker hat, his pipe and his magnifying glass. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries made mince-meat of some of the statements made by him and his colleagues in the course of this debate. In regard to the Labour Party I wish to say that I agree fully with Deputy Cruise-O'Brien because I think he described the Labour Party very well. He has stated that the Labour Party has been dominated for years by dismal poltroons, by spineless and gutless individuals. This is Deputy Cruise-O'Brien's opinion of the Labour Party. This is the other half of the party that is going to present an alternative government for this country.

We saw these poltroons being pushed into the Labour Party lobby last Wednesday; a fight broke out among them in the Chamber when they were instructed to vote, I take it on the instructions of the Fine Gael Whip and the Fine Gael Leader. I understand a decision had already been reached by the Labour Party not to vote against the motion concerned but they were pushed into the division lobby. When they saw that there might be an opportunity of obtaining power they decided to vote against their principles.

Are we to accept their policy which is a sick policy? The left-wing radicals have spelled it out — divorce, abortion, pill-pushing and contraception. These people have preached here on these matters time and again and have explained their policy in detail——

Comment on this

What has this to do with Deputy Blaney?

Comment on this

I know that Deputy Coughlan has his own problems with Barry and some of the others. I know Deputy Coughlan probably would not push pills too hard——

Comment on this

I would be pushing the guns with Deputy Blaney, though.

Comment on this

Once the Deputy is under the influence of his colleagues he does not know what might happen. This is the alternative that is being presented here. There are two policies: one, the Just Society that debars workers from participating in the affairs of the State, and the other people who want a sick society. We know the kind of society that would be developed if the Labour policy was implemented. We would have sexy films, made and shown to suggest ideas and to titillate desires——

Comment on this

Would the Deputy mind repeating that? That should be gone out of the Deputy's head a long time ago. How old is the Deputy?

Comment on this

I am a normal individual. I am only repeating what the Labour policy would be.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making a joke of this House.

Comment on this

The people would be asked to decide if they wanted a combination of these two policies and, no doubt, both of the parties would have to come together and present their policies to the public as they did before. I am quite certain when they go before the people they will get their answer, as they did in the past.

The documentation of the Labour Party says that it is essential to open up the minds of the children. It is their aim to contaminate the minds of the children. One can see now the type of society that would be developed by the Labour Party if they had power. Apart from the confiscation of land, the nationalisation of the firm of Guinness and the various other schemes they indicated they were prepared to advance——

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, I am new to this House and would ask you to advise me. I was under the impression that when direct quotations were made from documents they were tabled in the House?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

If quotations are made from documents, that is so, but not if a Deputy is giving his own résumé.

Comment on this

If Deputy Thornley wants a copy of the Labour Party policy we will see that he gets one. It is obvious that the Deputy does not understand or know the contents of the Labour Party policies as outlined in their little blue book. We know that policy as stated in the policy document and if the Deputy wants direct quotations we will get them for him. We have had many interruptions here over the last few hours from Deputy Cruise-O'Brien, Deputy Murphy, Deputy Thornley and others. I want to look at the alternative for this country if the Labour Party got into office. The Labour Party have one great advantage over the Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil Parties and that is that they have a visiting psychiatrist to meet them every day and to see that they are in a fit condition to come into the House. I feel that one such psychiatrist is not enough. They should try to get another to correct the ailments which exist among them. At the moment they are not fit to be a government and they are fortunate in having a visiting psychiatrist available to them.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this

I remember the time when the Labour Party had two seats in my constituency. I am confident that they are a forgotten force there now and the activities here last Wednesday when they were put into the Lobby by the Fine Gael Party assured me and others that they had joined, behind the backs of their conference, with Fine Gael. They must do what the Fine Gael members tell them. Deputy Dr. FitzGerald spoke to the Labour Party members prior to the vote and to the Labour Party Whip who was one of the tellers on that occasion. It is quite evident that no longer can anyone have any confidence in the type of set-up which exists. They forsook their principles to ensure that they would vote with Fine Gael. We had that super-Socialist from Cork, Deputy M.P. Murphy, who projects in Cork the image of a super-Socialist who stands for everything that the Labour Party stand for — and he must accept the lot including divorce, abortion, contraception, et cetera— but he tells the people in Cork during his election campaign that those policies are only for the Dublin Labour Party and do not apply in Cork. We have the Labour Party Member of the House who subscribes in full to the Labour Party policy within the House but in Cork tells his constituents that the policy is only for the Dublin lads. That would indicate that Deputy Thornley, Deputy Cruise-O'Brien, Deputy Browne, Deputy Cluskey, Deputy O'Donovan and others accept this situation. I will not say the Deputy is two-faced but he surely speaks with divers tongues. I would protect the Labour Party people from Deputy M.P. Murphy. It is terrible that he should attack his Labour Party colleagues in this fashion.

There is one man at the moment who should have a word with Deputy M.P. Murphy who comes to Dublin to say one thing, while saying another to his constituents in Cork. At least the Fianna Fáil Deputies say the same things in Dublin, Cork, Galway and elsewhere. We have only one acceptable policy for the people and this has been endorsed on many occasions. We have been presented with a "credible alternative" and this is the credible alternative. Deputy M.P. Murphy tells us there will be one set of rules for the Cork people and another set for the Dublin people and the set for the Dublin people will not be too good at all. There is only one Labour policy and that is the policy which Deputy M.P. Murphy supports as do Deputy Tully and other Members here in this House.

Comment on this

What about Donegal?

Comment on this

I believe the Deputy may need protection in the future. He is giving a bad impression of Deputy Thornley, Deputy Cruise-O'Brien and Deputy O'Donovan. Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien spoke about the poltroons of the Labour Party, as he described them. I fully endorse what Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien has stated. I would not like to dwell at length on the super-Socialist from Cork. There are other members of the Labour Party who are entitled to corrective training as well. I listened with interest to Deputy Cruise-O'Brien and some of his interruptions of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and others. I would like to speak about some of his activities. There is a publication in the US called Human Events in which some time ago a person called Alice Winder said of a function which the Deputy attended that they were all “drunk with success” and could not care less about what the Kremlin said because “they figured they were destined to be world leaders”. This is the kind of company that Deputy Cruise-O'Brien keeps.

Comment on this

It is a type of McCarthy-like smear.

Comment on this

I do not question Deputy Cruise-O'Brien's right to mix with the type of people who were present at the Civil Liberties Committee last December but I say that I wonder if his activities here are just a front for this revolutionary body. The Deputy was the first speaker. He was referred to as a recently-elected Member of the Republic of Ireland Parliament and said that violence was the only way to ensure moderation.

Comment on this

On a point of fact I was quoting something said by the late Mr. William O'Brien, the former MP.

Comment on this

With this violent group in the US we have a Deputy who has been mixing with their pretty bad company. I would ask responsible men to exercise some authority over this man. I could imagine a person getting injured when mixing with that type of group. It could happen in Belfast. One never knows where there is violence——

Comment on this

Deputy Cruise-O'Brien's poetry on "7 Days" and his interruptions here give one a clear picture of the type of man he is and of the company he keeps. I would ask responsible men like Deputy Stephen Coughlan to ensure that Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien is kept on a tight leash in future. He will get into trouble otherwise. We are wondering whether his activities here are a front for this group of people who will take over the United States because there were some funny individuals at the function I spoke about and many funny things were said in relation to the US Army which I would not like to put on the record of this House. The language used at that particular function and recorded by this lady was something which would not be tolerated here. It is a type of language I would not use.

I wish to quote now from the Sunday Press of 11th October, 1970. There was a heading “Is Thornley afraid of Socialism?” The article went on to say that Deputy Dr. Browne said that he considered that his attitude was more honourable than that of Deputy Thornley who suggested that the Labour Party should oppose the vote against the Taoiseach but at the same time make sure that enough Labour Party Deputies absented themselves from the House lest the Government be defeated and there would be an early election.

Comment on this

I denied that statement, as the Deputy knows.

Comment on this

This is the type of individual Deputy Thornley is. I accept Deputy Dr. Browne as an honourable man who has been in this House for a number of years although I disagree with his policies from time to time. I disagree with some of the statements but I do not think anybody can point a finger at Deputy Browne and say he tells lies. He is not afraid to say what he thinks or to indicate events in the past. It is stated in this report that Deputy Thornley suggested we should oppose and vote against the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that before.

Comment on this

We know all about this type of nonsense that Labour have been throwing into debates. They have no policy whatever. Any opportunity that presents itself is good enough for them——

Comment on this

When will the Deputy finish?

Comment on this

Not for a long time. When an opportunity presents itself I will not be deprived of expressing myself in this House. I was saying that that is the type of member Labour have. Apart from Deputies Murphy and Cruise-O'Brien, there is another honourable man coming in now.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not go into the lobbies and vote for them. However, there is no honour among the others or in Fine Gael — there is the secret pact between closed doors.

Comment on this

On a point of nothing in particular — this is a very funny music hall term——

Comment on this
Deputies

Down, down.

Comment on this

I am leaving the House, which men died to establish, rather than listen to any more of this.

Comment on this
Deputies

He cannot take it.

Comment on this

This is the credible alternative to Fianna Fáil. They are the men who do not want divisions, who do not want to vote, who ask their colleagues to stay away, but who want to be recorded as opposing. This is the game with them. They can be assured that we will go into the lobbies tomorrow night and that there will be a substantial majority in favour of the Taoiseach, and Deputy Thornley may rest assured that it will not be necessary for him to ask any Labour Deputy to stay away.

Comment on this

What about your Deputy Blaney?

Comment on this

I come now to the Sunday Press of 4th October. There is a report which states: “Deputy Lynch has clearly emerged as a leader among leaders.”

Comment on this

Is that Gibbons?

Comment on this

This is Deputy Browne.

Comment on this

Boland said it.

Comment on this

The heading states: "Why Noël Browne is wrong." It is by Dr. David Thornley.

Comment on this

What did he say about us?

Comment on this

That is what Deputy Browne said.

Comment on this

It is selective quotations.

Comment on this

There is a meeting of your backbenchers outside. Everything will have changed by tomorrow night.

Comment on this

We know Deputy O'Leary has been sent in here to disrupt a very orderly discussion.

Comment on this
Deputies

What?

Comment on this

It has been orderly.

Comment on this

I often heard better at Puck Fair.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions must cease. Deputy Dowling to continue and to address the Chair.

Comment on this

They are upsetting me. I am sorry Deputy Thornley has left the House because there were references in this article of 4th October which I should like to remind him of. He stated this:

Early in 1969 I was asked by the Labour Party. I had been previously offered a Fine Gael nomination by Deputy Gerard Sweetman but, despite my admiration for Garret FitzGerald and other Deputies, I was unable to accept the invitation.

So he went from the Just Society to the sick society. Anything at all to get into Dáil Éireann. Anything at all was good enough so long as he could sit here. He is not concerned about policy. A substantial effort was made by Fine Gael to get him a place in Dublin South West but despite his admiration, not for Deputy Sweetman but for Deputy FitzGerald, another old Coalitioner like himself, he did not accept. Policies and principles were not important. I should like to say a number of things here to Deputy Thornley but it would not be fair because he has left the House.

Another man who disrupted proceedings today is Deputy Desmond. I do not know why he is not here. They have sent Deputy O'Leary here to heckle. Deputy Desmond is another of the heckling brigade who is probably listening in on the intercom. He is another who has presented himself as an alternative to Fianna Fáil. Of course, Deputy Desmond got his answer from Deputy Coughlan when the latter referred to him as a jumped up, political pipsqueak. Deputy Desmond tries to interfere in everybody's constituency. We can see here the difference between a down-to-earth man like Deputy Coughlan and a pipsqueak like Deputy Desmond whose heckling contributions in this House are such that no party could be proud of. Deputy Coughlan was right in keeping him out of his constituency. Otherwise he might have brought along some of his football friends with whom he marched some time ago.

Labour Party policy has been mentioned briefly here tonight. There are certain aspects of that policy other than those mentioned. We have had a motion put down by them in relation to the direction of labour — that is the sending of workers to any part of the country. In other words, Irish workers would be dictated to in the same way as are Russian workers and workers in other occupied countries. We have heard also from them about the confiscation of land, about the taking-over of Guinness and other firms but there is yet another aspect of their policy and that is that they would dictate the type of games we might attend, whether we might attend Croke Park, Lansdowne Road or Dalymount Park. This is the party that is offering itself as the credible alternative.

Comment on this

Which side is the Deputy on?

Comment on this

I am in favour of the Motion that Dáil Éireann reaffirms its confidence in the Taoiseach and the other Members of the Government. I have always stated openly where I stand. I take my stand according to my conscience and according to what is right.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy for Haughey or for Lynch?

Comment on this

I have already said that I am in favour of the Motion before the House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot continue on this question and answer basis.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not allow himself to be led astray. The Minister for Finance has done many things of which the Deputy has no knowledge.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has already pointed out that these interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this

If Lily the Pink has come in here in an effort to upset me, he will not succeed. This, then, is the credible alternative——

Comment on this

Will the Deputy be a Breslin man or a McGlinchey man?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Coughlan must cease interrupting and allow the debate to continue.

Comment on this

Apart from these aspects of the Labour Party's policy that I have mentioned — a policy that is a combination of the sick society and the just society — there are yet other aspects that most of us would find appalling. For instance, they would go so far as to dictate to Aer Lingus whom that company might or might not carry on their aeroplanes and if by any chance people whom the Party might not like managed to board a plane, they would direct that such person's baggage would not be handled. Of course there are different ideas in Limerick among the Labour Party from those there are in Dublin. However, Deputy Coughlan put the political pipsqueaks in their place and has ensured that democracy functions in Limerick with the result that the people of Limerick are free to attend whatever type of games they wish.

Comment on this

What will be the Deputy's stand in relation to the Donegal by-election?

Comment on this

May I again remind the Deputy that I support fully the Taoiseach and the Members of his Cabinet?

Comment on this

Is that what the Deputy thinks of Deputy Boland?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

These interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

This credible alternative, if elected to power, would also propagate filth. The question tonight is not whether they want the Taoiseach out of office but, rather, this gives them an opportunity to get rid of Deputy Corish and the same applies to Fine Gael who are anxious to be rid of Deputy Cosgrave. Deputy Ryan has already indicated, as reported in press statements, that there is a plot afoot to get rid of Deputy Cosgrave and that this plot, like an insurance policy, would mature in May of 1971. There are still differences within that party. Nobody has been expelled, which means that those who are hatching that plot are still active. They may be watched but, no doubt, they will succeed. Therefore, is it not time that Deputy Cosgrave packed his bags and got out? By availing of this opportunity now, these people would succeed without having to expose themselves to the public.

Deputy Corish is in a somewhat different position. He is there by toleration. He has already stated that he would be prepared to go to the backbench but he will go there anyway if some of the boys have their way. I was speaking some time ago to a member of the Labour Party, a "leftie," and he said in relation to Deputy Corish: "Well, he presents a nice, respectable front for the Labour Party and he will stay for as long as we want him."

Comment on this

What kind of "leftie" would talk to the Deputy?

Comment on this

Is not the Deputy speaking to me now? At any rate, it is apparent that both of those men will be got rid of. Is it not an insult to the people who supported Labour to hear that their leader is there simply because he presents a nice, respectable front for the party?

Comment on this