Prohibition of Forcible Entry and Occupation Bill, 1970: Report Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 470–715 of 958. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 16 of 1970 ›
I want to know whether the mover of amendment No. 10 will get an opportunity before the closure motion.
Comment on this
Has the mover of amendment No. 10 got the right to speak before the closure motion is moved?
Comment on this
Can we have a guarantee that the mover of amendment No. 10 will be allowed to speak before the closure motion? Could the Minister for Justice tell us whether there will be a closure motion?
Comment on this
This afternoon I think we got a particularly good illustration of the kind of attitude——
Comment on this
Two Opposition Deputies having spoken, I then turned to the other side of the House for a speaker.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Clerk should be quite fair. I distinctly heard you say to the Ceann Comhairle that the amendment before the House——
Comment on this
There are two amendments which are apparently being discussed together. It would appear that an amendment cannot be discussed until it is moved and seconded.
Comment on this
Nonsense. When two amendments are discussed together the procedure is that the first is moved and seconded, the two are discussed together and the Deputy moving the second amendment, if he wishes, may put it to a division when the debate has concluded.
Comment on this
The agreement is that both be discussed together. They cannot be taken together until both have been moved and seconded.
Comment on this
Standing Order No. 40 states:
A motion or amendment shall not be debated until it has been seconded, but a seconder may reserve his speech till a later stage of the debate.
This amendment has not been proposed or seconded.
Comment on this
In order to avoid further confusion, you asked if the Labour Party would agree to amendment No. 10 being discussed, and on the presumption that the normal procedure would be adopted, we agreed to that. You may not be aware of this, but we agreed on the understanding that we would not be dealt with unfairly and I would suggest——
Comment on this
We cannot have two motions before the House and two amendments are being discussed together. That has happened down through the years.
Comment on this
No case has been made for amendment No. 10 and it is unfair to members of the Labour Party that they have not been allowed to make a case for their amendment.
Comment on this
The reality of the situation is that both amendments are taken together but both must be moved and seconded.
Comment on this
Can a case be made for amendment No. 10? I offered before the Minister. I am the obvious person to speak on it. We are debating amendment No. 9 on its own, and then we will discuss amendment No. 10 separately. We are not party to that agreement.
Comment on this
When the Chair asked if amendments Nos. 9 and 10 should be taken together the Labour Party agreed. Deputies do not listen to the Chair. I specifically asked the Labour Party if they were agreeable to both being discussed together and they agreed.
Comment on this
Were the Labour Party aware that you would not proceed in accordance with the Standing Orders of the House?
Comment on this
This has been the ruling of the House down the years and Deputy Tully is aware of it.
Comment on this
I am aware of it, as you know, but an impartial Chair will always allow the second motion to be discussed before it is put to the House.
Comment on this
They want to change the Standing Orders when they do not suit them, just as they want to change their agreement when it does not suit them.
Comment on this
On a point of order, does the Chair have any conception of the damage he is doing to parliamentary practice and procedure by two rulings in an hour and a half——
Comment on this
Does the Minister know what he is doing? He is selling himself to a pack that he does not believe in. I am surprised at him above all. Where are his low standards in high places now?
Comment on this
Might I suggest a compromise would be to meet the very reasonable request of the Labour Party that there be no guillotine until they fully debate their motion?
Comment on this
Sir, you were not in the Chair when the second Fine Gael speaker was called. Possibly if you had been in the Chair you would have called a Labour Party speaker.
Comment on this
Does that mean that you do not believe the Labour Party have any right even to refer to their amendment before the Minister replies? He does not know what to reply to since the case has not been made.
Comment on this
Maybe the Chair would like some private discussion with the Minister first. That is what he is waiting on, advice from the Government.
Comment on this
Let me make it perfectly clear that we are not going to allow a situation to arise in which our amendment is not allowed to be discussed. We have no intention of allowing a Labour Party amendment to go without debate.
Comment on this
You will get your Bill soon enough and you will be able to silence not only us but everyone else as well.
Comment on this
Ministers should keep their mouths shut and should not come in here and disgrace themselves.
Comment on this
You are not entitled not to hear me. I want you to rule on whether Standing Order No. 40 is valid or not.
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy O'Malley, presented himself. How can he reply to a debate in which the case has not been made for the Labour Party amendment? Is he not replying?
Comment on this
The Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party are endeavouring to impede freedom of speech.
Comment on this
He was called and got up to reply before ever the Minister for Finance came in and then he beckoned to Deputy Dowling to stand up.
Comment on this
The Chair called on the Minister and the Minister should have spoken when the Chair called on him.
Comment on this
There is no wish on the part of this party to wreck this Parliament any more than you have wrecked it today but we stand on our right to defend our amendment and we insist on that right.
Comment on this
The Minister has no right to nominate another speaker if he does not want to speak himself.
Comment on this
How can the Ceann Comhairle call somebody else when he has already called the Minister?
Comment on this
The Minister was called by the Chair. Will the Minister deny that he was called by the Chair? Were you called by the Chair?
Comment on this
You had no right to call Deputy Dowling. He is your puppet, is he? You are not the Chair. Do you designate the next speaker?
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister has now stated that he gave way to another Deputy, although Deputy Dr. Browne had offered and the Chair called the Minister. Is the Chair stating now that this is proper procedure? Will the Chair state if this is proper procedure? Has the Minister the right to nominate a speaker after he himself has been called?
Comment on this
Deputies will not listen to the Chair. They do not want to listen. They ask questions. Deputy Dowling was entitled to be called because two Opposition speakers had already intervened.
Comment on this
On behalf of the Labour Party, I propose to move amendment No. 10 in the name of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
No one has the right to move our amendment and the Minister cannot reply to it until we have made our case for it. This afternoon in this House we were subjected to the spectacle of the Minister for Justice, Deputy O'Malley, applying the guillotine.
Comment on this
There is no question of a point of order. Will the Deputy resume his seat? If the Deputy does not resume his seat I will ask Deputy FitzGerald to leave the House.
Comment on this
On behalf of the Labour Party, I will not give way to Deputy Dowling unless we are either allowed to move the amendment now, or speak on it, or allowed to discuss it independently of amendment No. 9.
Comment on this
It was agreed before you did the confidence trick and only on the assumption that we would be allowed to speak on amendment No. 10 in accordance with Standing Orders.
Comment on this
We have been threatened again with another guillotine by the man sitting in front of you.
Comment on this
Deputy Dowling is not a member of the Labour Party and, as far as we are concerned, Deputy Dr. Browne is speaking to this amendment.
Comment on this
If the Chair allows Deputy Dr. Browne to speak on the Labour Party amendment, there will be no problem.
Comment on this
Up to this afternoon we might have accepted your assurance. We can no longer accept your assurance that we will be allowed to put our views in this House, as a result of the guillotine motion introduced by the Minister for Justice.
Comment on this
Either we shall speak on this amendment now or the amendment will be taken separately after amendment No. 9 is disposed of.
Comment on this
We will undertake not to move the closure if the Labour Party are allowed to discuss the amendment.
Comment on this
The Chair should be allowed to be heard on this matter.
Comment on this
Am I right in holding that under Standing Order No. 40 Deputy Dowling may not debate amendment No. 10 because it has not been seconded?
Comment on this
We are not discussing Standing Order No. 40 because having disposed of Standing Order No. 40 the Deputy will come up with another Standing Order.
Comment on this
Is it not clear that Deputy Dowling may not speak on amendment No. 10 which has not been moved or seconded?
Comment on this
Standing Order No. 40 says that a motion or amendment shall not be debated until it has been seconded. Amendment No. 10 has not been either moved or seconded. Therefore, in accordance with Standing Order No. 40——
Comment on this
I have already told the Deputy that we cannot have two motions before the House. Only one amendment can be——
Comment on this
The wording of the Standing Order is that a motion or amendment shall not be debated until it has been seconded.
Comment on this
On a point of information, will the Chair permit the Labour Party, after amendment No. 9 has been discussed and voted on, to move amendment No. 10 and have a debate on amendment No. 10?
Comment on this
Surely the Chair will appreciate that speakers on the Government side will be commenting on what they think is before the House. How can they do that if we are not allowed to put our point of view on amendment No. 10? The Chair cannot have it both ways and should either allow the amendment to be discussed and voted on separately—it will be voted on separately—or alternatively, let us speak to it now and allow others to come in afterwards.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 10 separately. It is now agreed that amendment No. 10 will be discussed separately.
Comment on this
In relation to this very important Bill I may say at the outset that it is understandable that the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party, particularly the latter, chose to interrupt as they have done because in this section they choose to protect subversive groups and elements; they choose to protect the bullyboys, the thugs and others who want to deprive the people who are rightfully entitled to accommodation of their just rights.
Comment on this
On a point of order, at considerable length and with much repetition the Minister for Transport and Power earlier indicated to the Chair that Deputy Fitzpatrick was out of order when he was merely developing a point. I want to suggest that Deputy Dowling is very much out of order; he has not come near the amendment at all.
Comment on this
I want to speak about the amendment section and the section as it is. It is easy to understand why the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party——
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Deputy has expressed the intention not only of speaking on the amendment but also on the section as it is. I was ruled out of order, and immediately accepted the ruling, when I tried to discuss the wording of the section as it is. I was told—very properly, I am sure—to discuss the amendment and I complied with that order. This Deputy now proposes to discuss the section and the Chair sits there and lets it go.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy please sit down? He has said all this before. The position is that amendment No. 9 is before the House.
Comment on this
The answer is: "Sit down; a Fianna Fáil speaker is speaking and he can say anything he likes."
Comment on this
Before I was so rudely interrupted by a Deputy who spoke today for six hours on one word——
Comment on this
In the course of Deputy Cruise-O'Brien's speech he referred to a number of people and a number of words far outside the scope of the particular amendment on which he was speaking. One of the references he made was in relation to Lady Montague, Oxford English Dictionary, volume 3. In his reference to subsection (1) of the Bill he referred to this honourable lady in the following terms: Lady M. W. Montague stated that no woman dares encourage two lovers at a time. How that refers to this Bill beats me. He went further to quote Rogers in relation to this section and this is what Rogers had to say, as he was quoted: “The famous were allowed to encourage venturous boys in bringing in young birds for the purpose of training.” How these particular quotations apply to the Bill I do not know.
Comment on this
Yes, they are on record. The first one was in relation to Lady M.W. Montague: "No woman dares encourage two lovers at a time." I do not know to whom he was referring. I cannot see any reference to that in the Bill.
Comment on this
The other one is more important, and I hope the Labour Party will clarify the situation when they are speaking on the rest of the Bill so that other Fianna Fáil speakers will be able to understand the intellectuals of the Labour Party. Rogers, as he said, was around to encourage venturous boys in bringing in young birds for the purpose of training. How they refer to this Prohibition of Forcible Entry and Occupation Bill I cannot say. Does he mean that the birds were brought in to squat? Does he mean that the young men who encouraged these venturous boys to bring in the birds for the purpose of training——
Comment on this
I would hate to prevent Deputy Dowling being picked up by an agent who might be in the Gallery listening to his comic turn, but I would point out that a closure was moved on the amendment on which Deputy Dowling is speaking; that was the one dealing with encouragement. If we are to continue with that, then surely the closure motion which has been moved and carried has been wasted?
Comment on this
This is just to give some idea of how far removed from the Bill the Labour speaker was in his six-hour marathon speech with 13 volumes in front of him.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the amendment to the subsection and it must be taken as a whole. It is difficult to divide the provision in two. I want to deal with it line by line——
Comment on this
——just as he dealt with it bird by bird. The Members of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party were loud in their criticism of this party not so very long ago saying that not a single Deputy from this side spoke today. It was difficult for a speaker to stand up here when Deputy Conor Cruise-O'Brien, the bird fancier, spent so much time dealing with matters which were completely removed from the Bill. He certainly confused me to some degree.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell, in common with other Members of the Labour Party, is endeavouring to ensure that the bullyboys that I mentioned early on, the queers and other groups, are protected. This is an effort to protect them from the law.
Comment on this
This must be taken in conjunction with the subsection. So far as I have found, there is no reference in the Bill to the Press or the freedom of the Press.
Comment on this
I have not seen any effort in this legislation to stifle the Press or to create a provision that would interfere with the freedom of the Press.
Comment on this
The only occasion on which an effort was made by politicians to muzzle the Press was not so long ago when members of the Labour Party applied pressure on the journalists to ensure that they would not report the activities of the Springboks.
Comment on this
This was specifically ruled out of order when I endeavoured to reply to charges of this nature. Why is it in order on this amendment when it was not in order on the last amendment!
Comment on this
Section 7 gives three years in jail to a journalist if he commits an offence under this Bill.
Comment on this
The only effort I can remember being made to silence the Press was that made by Members of the Labour Party when the Springboks were here some time ago and when pressure was applied to try to ensure that no report would be made of the Springboks' activities.