Prohibition of Forcible Entry and Occupation Bill, 1970: Report Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 716–958 of 958. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 16 of 1970 ›
Would Deputy Dowling allow me to say that amendment No. 9 refers to reasonable comment on a matter of public interest in any newspaper, magazine, periodical or book, and I take it that Deputy Dowling is referring to——
Comment on this
If it is in order for him to refer to this, I presume it will be in order for us to do so.
Comment on this
May I point out that on a previous occasion when Deputy Fitzpatrick made references to the Press's treatment of the withdrawal of the dole he was not permitted by the Chair to pursue that? Is Deputy Dowling to be permitted to raise a similar matter without being ruled out of order?
Comment on this
Does the Chair wish that some time be given to consider the handling of the Order of Business?
Comment on this
I want to draw your attention, Sir, to the comments of Deputy Fitzpatrick in relation to this subsection.
Comment on this
I am not questioning whether you made such a ruling, but are you making a distinction between your rulings and those of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle?
Comment on this
I am not making any such distinction. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle ruled as he heard the remarks.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I should like to put on the records of this House that I spoke under difficult circumstances for an hour after the closure motion. The Minister for Transport and Power was in the Minister's seat and I tried to refer to the fact that the Press had intervened in the dole dispute. The Minister rose on about 35 points of order. It is difficult to follow what is in order and out of order on this debate.
Comment on this
We are aware that an effort was made some time ago to stifle the Press in relation to certain activities in this city. Trade unionists like Deputy Michael O'Leary and his colleagues, Deputies Cruise-O'Brien and Noel Browne, wanted to ensure that the Press would be handcuffed by methods other than what they suggest here. They wanted to ensure that visitors who came to the country were subjected to pressures to ensure that they would not be served meals, and that the Press would not publish reports about it. They wanted to ensure when they endeavoured to see that facilities would be withdrawn from the tourists that that would not be reported in the Press. The same thing applies in relation to hotel accommodation. They attempted to cover up. They used all sorts of pressures to ensure that visitors to this country could not get the facilities to which they were entitled. They endeavoured to intimidate the Press. That is the only occasion I can remember of anyone trying to handcuff the Press in any way or to ensure that the filthy action of the Labour Party would not get to the public.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Deputy referred to "the filthy action of the Labour Party." We did not use that kind of language.
Comment on this
This was the filthy action of the Labour Party to try to starve tourists and intimidate the Press. They tried to ensure that their dirty action would be covered up but the Press on that occasion, as on this occasion, reported honourably and correctly. They have that freedom now and they had it then and they did not bow to the pressures of the Labour Party, of Deputy Cruise-O'Brien and Deputy M. O'Leary who tried to intimidate them on that occasion. The Press was free then and responded in a correct manner.
Comment on this
The Labour Party wanted to ensure that their crimes on that occasion would not reach the ears of the public. The Press were correct in rebutting men like Deputy Michael O'Leary. I understand many of the Springboks whom they endeavoured to starve out and to deprive of facilities were trade unionists. They are now trying to ensure that protection of the bullyboys. When we see what happened last night with the Labour Party, the Communist Party of Ireland, the socialists and a variety of other groups——
Comment on this
I do not believe he has. That is not the way it was reported in this morning's papers. Who produced that? Was it the Fianna Fáil Party?
Comment on this
You were in very good company last night with the Communist Party of Ireland, the Connolly Youth Movement and other subversive groups.
Comment on this
This is an effort to ensure that these people will be protected in any type of activity that they care to embark on even if it is to deprive people of accommodation they are duly entitled to.
Comment on this
The Labour Party are endeavouring to protect the bullyboys, the queers and the birds. They want to ensure that——
Comment on this
This is amendment No. 9 and the Chair suggests that Deputy Dowling is entitled to make his case in regard to it.
Comment on this
The idea of the Labour Party amendment to subsection (1) is to ensure that these particular groups who want to deprive people of accommodation will be protected.
Comment on this
In relation to amendment No. 9 which relates to subsection (1) of section 4 we are aware of the activities of the members of the Labour Party who are now hiding behind the Fine Gael amendment and who I am quite sure will support the Fine Gael amendment. This is done for the purpose of ensuring that people will be deprived of accommodation when these groups say so just as they have been in the past. Deputy O'Leary encouraged people to squat in the city and so deprive workers and trade unionists who were legitimately on the waiting list from getting a home of their own.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary has deprived people entitled to accommodation of accommodation by having people squat in their homes.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Since it is not unlikely that the closure may be applied again on this amendment I would respectfully point out to the House that it is essential speakers should be relevant to the amendment. This particular amendment deals with an amendment to subsection (1) of section 4 which proposes to exclude the Press and certain books and periodicals from that section. I was not permitted to make more than a passing reference to newspaper comment on the dole et cetera and yet this Deputy is being allowed to roam over the entire area.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy not read out the leading articles from the papers four times? Surely I should have an opportunity to discuss subsection (1)? I am in favour of subsection (1) as it stands and I am against amendment No. 9.
Comment on this
We are not on the section yet. Deputy Dowling has said he wants to talk about subsection (1).
Comment on this
I should like the Chair's advice. What does amendment No. 9 refer to, is it subsection (1)?
Comment on this
The Deputy should know by now that the Chair leaves it to individual Deputies to think what they like in regard to individual sections; the Chair guides them as best it can afterwards.
Comment on this
I am in favour of retaining subsection (1) in its present form. My reason is to ensure that groups of people will not be able to dictate to this city who will live in certain houses. This is what has been happening in the city. Efforts are now being made to cover up and support the action of the groups who have been responsible for depriving people on the waiting list for homes.
Comment on this
Subsection (1) as it stands gives adequate protection to people who are allocated homes. Whatever groups may be encouraged by members of the Labour Party or the other subversive organisations I have mentioned will be subject to the law. The law will be applied to them to ensure that they will not carry on a campaign as they have done of putting people in houses to which they were not entitled and thereby depriving women and children of a home to which they were entitled.
Comment on this
It is quite obvious that both the Labour and the Fine Gael Parties do not want to hear the truth in relation to the protection of people who are entitled to services in this city.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy must speak to the amendment on the Forcible Entry Bill and not on the Housing Act?
Comment on this
The Chair has directed Deputy Dowling's attention to the fact that it is amendment No. 9 to section 4 which is being discussed and not housing or other matters like that.
Comment on this
It is a silly question and I suppose I should not be bothering my head with his type during the course of this important debate.
Comment on this
As I said before, I am against this amendment to subsection (1) of section 4. I prefer subsection (1) as it stands. I can see no reference in the section to the Press. The Press are able to deal with the situation as it affects them in a very effective way. Nobody has endeavoured to tie the Press in any way but there is an effort from this back-up service of the Labour Party to ensure that certain groups of people will be protected from legislation of any kind so that they can, when they desire, decide who will occupy either corporation or private dwellings. For some time past we have seen people being deprived of their accommodation. To my way of thinking any legislation that protects the rights of people to accommodation is worthwhile.
Comment on this
The Chair has allowed the Deputy a certain amount of latitude but would now ask him to come to the amendment before the House.
Comment on this
The only other occasion on which the Press were denied facilities was when they were locked out from the Labour Party Conference because they could not be trusted.
Comment on this
If Fianna Fáil had known in advance what was to happen at their Ard-Fheis, the Press would have been locked out too.
Comment on this
The Press have adequate safeguards. These people are more courageous than the Labour Party and they will endeavour to do what they believe to be right and, if they do that, there is no problem.
Comment on this
When efforts were made not so long ago to handcuff the Press, they were not intimidated by Deputy Cruise-O'Brien.
Comment on this
When we read this particular amendment in relation to subsection (1), it seems to me that it does arise.
Comment on this
The Chair will not allow its ruling to be questioned and, if Deputies will not keep to the amendment, the Chair will ask them to resume their seats.
Comment on this
The Deputy who is trying to make his case is entitled to do so without interruption. We would be much better off if everybody co-operated in this matter.
Comment on this
We have seen here tonight how the Opposition Parties have endeavoured to deprive those of us on this side of the House the opportunity of free speech and an opportunity of upholding their amendment. They have endeavoured to monopolise the speaking time of the House backed by their usual 13 volumes of the Oxford Dictionary. The pressures that have been applied tonight by them might be applied also by them in relation to the Press irrespective of whether there is a section such as this in legislation.
Comment on this
The Chair is not interested in what happened here earlier tonight. At present the Chair is interested only in amendment No. 9.
Comment on this
I can see no reference here to the Press and it is my belief that the Press, as a responsible body, will report the situation as they see it at any given time. They will not be intimidated either by legislation or by individuals. There is no effort being made in this Bill to stifle the Press in any way. This amendment is a tactic of the Labour and Fine Gael Parties in their efforts to bolster up and protect subversive groups who wish to operate freely throughout the country, to disrupt the affairs of local authorities and to take over houses, both local authority and private. Although the Press publish what they believe to be right, erroneous reports appear occasionally such as the report in today's Irish Independent concerning the affairs of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
While we accept that inaccuracies can occur, the right to make reasonable comment has never been questioned. We know also that offences such as encouraging persons to take over a plane at Shannon, or occupying buildings in the city and disrupting the day to day affairs of people and endeavouring to put people out of employment by taking over——
Comment on this
It may be wide of the amendment but surely I am entitled to say why I believe the amendment is not necessary?
Comment on this
It is difficult to understand the references that have been made during the debate and which have confused the issue. Some of the references made during the six-hour marathon of Deputy Cruise-O'Brien——
Comment on this
I am not sure whether the reference made by Deputy Cruise-O'Brien relates to the Press but they certainly did not relate to the particular aspect that he was discussing at the time.
Comment on this
I am not in favour of this amendment but surely I can speak in favour of the subsection as it is as against the amendment.
Comment on this
——who told us all about the birds and the bees. A person who encourages or advocates the commission of an offence——
Comment on this
This amendment seeks to enlarge the subsection by an addition after "offence". This amendment is not at all necessary. It is designed not for the purpose of protecting the Press, but for the purpose of protecting the groups I mentioned earlier who have other ideas about the breakdown of the democratic system, about the occupation of buildings, of houses, of factories, of workshops, of planes, and so on, in some cases depriving workers of their employment. The subsection as it stands will ensure that people who advocate the commission of an offence will be adequately dealt with. If the Labour Party or the Fine Gael Party feel that they want to protect people who are entitled to accommodation, to protect the jobs and homes of Irish workers then they will be in favour of this subsection as it stands. There is no need to bring in the red herring of the Press. The Press have not been mentioned in this section.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the amendment in which the Press is mentioned—newspapers, magazines, periodicals and books.
Comment on this
This amendment is not necessary at all. I do not know what magazines they want to protect or what periodicals or books. I do not know what they are seeking to protect. The Press can adequately handle their own situation. They do not need the support of the Labour Party or the Fine Gael Party. It may be that they are trying to rally support but I am sure that when the Press report tomorrow the affairs of this House today——
Comment on this
When the Press reports tomorrow on the affairs of the House today I am certain they will report in a very factual way.
Comment on this
——of Deputy Cruise-O'Brien will be reported and the people will then have an opportunity of judging who tries to deprive others of certain freedoms. The effort was made here tonight to deprive me and to deprive other Members of this party of an opportunity of speaking on the amendment.
Comment on this
There was not a mention of anything that was contained in the amendment. We had all sorts of points of order, points of information, rude interruptions, and when one wants to quote the leaflet that was handed round yesterday——
Comment on this
This is a publication. Is this the type of nonsense they want to protect? It is erroneous in every way.
Comment on this
Is this the type of document the Fine Gael Party want to ensure is circulated, giving erroneous information? Maybe it is. Maybe they do not want the facts of the situation to be known. That could be one of the reasons why they tried to deprive the people on this side of the House of an opportunity of speaking.
Comment on this
Where did the Deputy get this document? I never saw it and I am a Member of the House. Will the Deputy give me this document?
Comment on this
Oh, sure. At the next election if you can, but you cannot pull the same trick twice.
Comment on this
For the information of the Chair, will the Deputy let the Chair know what document he is referring to?
Comment on this
"Kill the Bill" is the heading and "Dev Don't Sign" and it is issued by the Committee to Oppose Repressive Legislation, 50 Oak House, Sussex Road, Dublin 4.
Comment on this
Regretfully the Chair will have to ask the Deputy to either stay with the amendment or to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I am sure no honourable journalist would produce a document of this type. Therefore, one has no need to fear but if documents of this type are being produced——
Comment on this
On a point of order, the amendment relates to any reasonable comment on a matter of public interest in any newspaper, magazine, periodical or book. What is this document Deputy Dowling is talking about?
Comment on this
We do not often have a Bill of this sort before the House. Kill the Bill. Is that the periodical? I did not get this document.
Comment on this
Deputy Dowling on the amendment. It is not in order to quote from this document. The Chair has already ruled that this matter is irrelevant.
Comment on this
It is important that one should make the facts of the situation known, that there are documents, that there are periodicals, that are conveying a completely erroneous impression to the public.
Comment on this
This is one of them and I want to find out whether this is the type of document Deputies Fitzpatrick and Cooney want to protect.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not be allowed to proceed like that. The amendment deals quite plainly with newspapers, magazines, periodicals or books. It does not deal with documents. This has already been ruled on.
Comment on this
If a periodical indicates that a Bill has already gone through the House, as this one does, it is giving a completely erroneous impression to the public. I should like to know what kind of documents they have in mind. Will they produce documents in the future that will convey an erroneous impression to the public? I am certain Fine Gael have something in mind they might wish to produce in the future and they seek to protect themselves before they embark on this.
Comment on this
It appears the Deputy has transferred his attention from the Labour Party for the moment.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not be here for very long. Reasonable comment on a matter of public interest does not constitute an offence. I cannot understand why Deputies are trying to read an offence into the section when this is not the case.
Comment on this
The only people endeavouring to read offences into the Bill are members of Fine Gael and Labour. Reasonable comment does not, and could not, constitute an offence.
Comment on this
Deputy Dowling should be allowed to make his case. The Chair is prepared to listen and Deputies should allow him to speak.
Comment on this
Nobody need fear that reasonable comment, either in the House or outside, constitutes an offence. There is no need for the inclusion of this amendment.
Comment on this
The Press could not be deprived at any time of expressing reasonable comment. An effort has been made to read something into the Bill that is not there and the people responsible have gone to the extent of putting down this amendment in order to confuse people. However, they have not fooled the Press, this House, or the public because the House and the Press are aware they have all the facilities available to ensure that reasonable comment is possible. As I have pointed out, the only occasion when an effort was made to intimidate people was when Members of this House——
Comment on this
The Deputy is departing from the amendment. The Deputy knows this has been ruled out of order previously.
Comment on this
I do not wish to detain the House much longer but I wish to express my views in relation to this amendment which I consider is unnecessary.
Comment on this
The Deputy's views could be written on the back of a postage stamp. He is repeating the same thing since he started his speech.
Comment on this
It has been alleged by Deputy Tully that I have been repeating myself. I would point out that if repetition is necessary in order to get a point across——
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy Cooney tried to indicate there were dangers to journalists in this section but this is not so. The free Press will always be able to comment freely on matters of public interest.
Comment on this
The Labour Party were the only people who endeavoured to handcuff the Press in any way. The Labour Party will not let them into conventions——
Comment on this
We saw what happened to the man with the camera at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis—you did not get the coat over him in time.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy means. That is not in the amendment we are discussing. Deputy Tully is now reading into the section something about a man with a camera. A person can print offensive pictures, and I mentioned that point to the House when I spoke recently about the dog that enticed Deputy Keating into the Labour Party. Having expressed my opposition to this amendment, I shall give other Deputies an opportunity to speak.
Comment on this
On behalf of the Labour Party I should like to support this amendment which provides for the insertion of the following words:
provided always and it is hereby declared that reasonable comment on a matter of public interest in any newspaper, magazine, periodical or book shall not constitute an offence under this subsection.
All we are asking is to allow "reasonable comment" on a matter of public interest. If there is a housing problem, if houses fall down and people are homeless and an editor is prompted to write about their plight and to ask that some provision be made for them, or if some people find themselves in difficulty, out on the street or seeking shelter in some little hovel and an editor supports them and says they are morally justified in doing that he should not go to jail. This is a safeguard we would like to see written into this Bill. It is one of the last attempts we will make to ensure that freedom of the Press is assured.
The Minister has said that freedom of the Press has been guaranteed all along and all he wants to do is to spell out the law as it is for them. The Minister said: "I want it to be clear to people" but there is no need for it to be clear because anyone who edits a newspaper knows about limitations, knows about reasonable comment, knows that he can speak about social matters; but the Minister by section 4 has made things completely different for him. An editor, by the fear that it could be applied, could be prevented from commenting on matters of public importance.
This amendment is not one that Fianna Fáil could reasonably object to. If Fianna Fáil object to this amendment we are on our way to a fascist State. This is an opportunity being granted to them to ensure that the Press remain free. It is an opportunity for them to say: "We have no bad intentions towards the Press; we have no intention of stifling public opinion as expressed in newspapers; we have no intention of curbing them in their criticism or comment."
Comment on this
We seek to have this amendment included in the Bill so that when the present Minister for Justice and the present Government are gone and when the interpretation of the courts is sought they may read this reasonable amendment included in the Bill. The last Deputy put forward no reasonable argument against the amendment. All he said was that it would not be accepted. If the editor of a newspaper wishes to comment on any social problem in this city he should be able to do so without fear of being brought to court.
It is not inciting people to do wrong by asking that the words "reasonable comment" be inserted. It is not encouraging people, as the Minister says, to break the law. The words "reasonable comment" leave it to the interpretation of the courts to say what they mean. Since the 18th century, when a newspaper is brought before the courts on libellous matters it can plead before a jury that it was reasonable comment. We believe that this freedom is being taken from them in this Bill. The Minister has not convinced us otherwise.
There would have been no need for section 4 of this Bill if freedom of the Press was guaranteed. The danger to the freedom of the Press is there in that section. It is not the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party who say this. It is the newspapers of the country who say it. They have been alert to the dangers of this section and have condemned the present Government. The Cork Examiner said in an editorial: “It is not often that this newspaper takes a stand on an issue to criticise the Government.” They had their fears about section 4 of the Forcible Entry Bill. They knew that the freedom of the Press was in danger. The Irish Times said that this section was so dangerous that they could be stifled altogether and that it was obvious that the Bill would have to be challenged in the courts because the Government had gone so far in section 4.
Deputy Dowling thought it was wrong to put in this amendment. If a Deputy of this House outside this House condemns a situation, condemns the pollution in Dublin Bay, and if he suggests that the people take action about it and the Press comment on that or support him and say, perhaps, he is right, unless this amendment is accepted the Press will find themselves in trouble.
If the Minister and Government are so confident that the freedom of the Press is not at stake, why will they not accept this amendment? This is the test, this is their opportunity to prove that this is not a fascist Bill. This is their opportunity to demonstrate that it is not their intention to muzzle the Press. I do not believe for a moment that they will take it because in the past year the Press have found it necessary to criticise the Government. Even the Irish Press, a servile organ of the Government Party—as a matter of fact the circulation of that newspaper depended on cumann subscriptions——
Comment on this
I have to talk about the Press. We had no freedom of the Press in this country except in a few cases. The Irish Press is the organ of Fianna Fáil and its circulation depended on the subscriptions of cumann members. A transformation took place in that newspaper. A new editor was appointed——
Comment on this
I certainly will. I am not disagreeing with you but I was trying to point out that more and more we are getting a free Press. This is becoming evident to Fianna Fáil: they have begun to realise that the Press are free, untrammelled, unfettered, and this could be a bad thing——
Comment on this
It is not. There was a libel action taken against the Press and court fines were imposed.
Comment on this
The Deputy was talking about a free Press. I am sorry for interrupting the Deputy. I do not wish to hold him up.
Comment on this
On a point of order, before the House adjourns I should like to find out what is the position about those massive tomes which are being displayed here long after the user had finished.
Comment on this
Could I have a ruling? Are we to have those things here tomorrow morning when the House resumes?
Comment on this
Surely it is the Parliamentary Secretary who is unruly in interrupting a speaker to make a personal criticism against a member of this party.
Comment on this
Give him one with pictures. The point I was trying to make is that in a democratic country there is no such thing as a completely free Press. Newspapers know that more than anybody—they know the law of libel. What we are trying to ensure here is that the freedom they have will be maintained and not contracted in any way. I do not think that is too much to ask. On the previous amendment the Minister made it clear that the word "encourage"——
Comment on this
This amendment is a double safeguard. It is a much more reasoned one and it is quite innocuous. It states:
In page 3, line 35, after "offence" where it secondly appears to add "provided always and it is hereby declared that reasonable comment on a matter of public interest in any newspaper, magazine, periodical or book shall not constitute an offence under this subsection.
We would include in that the United Irishman. It is because that would be included that the Minister rejects the amendment. I know in my heart and soul he is determined to get at that newspaper because it criticises the Government on many issues. That paper is allowed even into the north. The intention of this subsection is to get at that newspaper. I should like to see that newspaper continue as an organ of opinion. I should not like to see an end put to it. I have read it often and I have found nothing in it that would undermine public order or morality or undermine the safety of the State. I have written in medical newspapers.