Adjournment of Dáil: Motion.
Contributions 1–137 of 259. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When speaking last evening I dealt with the peculiar 18 months or two years through which we have lived in this parliamentary assembly, culminating now in a form of parliamentary apartheid in the Fianna Fáil Party. Foremost in everybody's mind at present are the unfortunate circumstances prevailing in Northern Ireland and the vexed question of Partition.
Partition was imposed on this country by an Act of Parliament of the British House of Commons. There was a time when the people were almost persuaded that it was Fine Gael or Cumann na nGaedheal who did it. Certainly there were followers of the Fianna Fáil Party up and down the country who shouted this from every platform. Partition is not the work of Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael. It is the work of the British House of Commons. I suppose it all began many years earlier when the first movements were made in Northern Ireland to prevent this country securing Home Rule. Although both parties can be absolved of responsibility in respect of its perpetuone party cannot be absolved of responsibility in respect of its perpetuation, and that is the Fianna Fáil Party.
Our particular history has made it difficult to secure the necessary psychological background towards the abolition of Partition. Down through our history the attitude of the dominant regime in the South here towards political movements has varied. Sometimes they favoured them; sometimes they did not. I believe that the Fenians in their time were not favoured. After their failure to secure Home Rule and after the Deferment Bill was passed in the House of Commons on the same day as the Home Rule Bill was passed, the Sinn Féin movement still did not secure a foothold in this country. Even after the 1916 Rebellion Sinn Féin were still not a strong political force. Following this Deferment Bill in the House of Commons Britain made a second error in their judgment of this country. They seem prone to make errors in respect of the Irish situation. They made this second error by a measure not often mentioned nowadays and that was by introducing conscription here in 1918. Conscription culminated in every altar being a political platform and in every political platform being manned by politicians of all grades and by churchmen.
There was born the concept of faith and fatherland. It was that particular philosophy which has permeated political thinking and attitudes since then. It is that approach which has buried Wolfe Tone in our society. The Connolly concept of humanity and social thinking was equally buried. In our own time the spirit of Pope John has been buried by this sectarian approach. This has been accentuated under Fianna Fáil. Shortly after getting into power they tinkered immediately with the Constitution. The 1922 Constitution which could be regarded as non-sectarian was replaced by a 1937 Constitution which had strong sectarian overtones.
Powerful interests combined to perpetuate Partition. Perhaps I should not use the word "combined". Perhaps I should use the word "compounded". Perhaps I should use the word "conspired". There were commercial interests north and south of the Border. There were commercial interests where substantial subventions were coming to the North from the British Government. There was better money for farmers. The commercial interests south of the Border were affected by the policy of self-sufficiency and associated protectionism which began under Cumann na nGaedheal and was accentuated later under Fianna Fáil. The sectarian interests are obvious, but I do not want to dwell on these. There were political interests. The political interests of the Unionists in the North and of Fianna Fáil down here were to remain in power. The only difference between the Unionists and Fianna Fáil was that the Unionists were honest about Partition and Fianna Fáil were not.
Most people in the South can recall the years after Fianna Fáil came to power, when at every Fianna Fáil meeting they had the catchcry of the two long-standing problems: the restoration of the Irish language and the abolition of Partition. Their approach to the abolition of Partition was ingenious. I believe there were many rank and file Fianna Fáil members who believed it was an honest approach, but if you take an animal to the fair and you do not want to sell it, what do you do? You ask an impossible price. The impossible price demanded by Fianna Fáil for the ending of Partition was that it should be ended on their terms, on the southern terms, namely, that a Gaelic culture should be accepted, that the Irish language should be accepted and, perhaps, that the Northern Protestants should sing "Faith of our Fathers" instead of "The Sash".
It is clear that that aggressive, militant and sectarian approach could not bring us one step towards the solving of the question of Partition. It was diabolically calculated to perpetuate it and, thereby, perpetuate Fianna Fáil who, until the last election, when they began to fight among themselves as to who would be Leader, looked as if they would remain in power to the end of the century. Does anybody believe that a party who are prepared to commit political hara-kiri in order to remain in power, a party who are prepared to indulge in the greatest "gut job"in Irish history, wished to bring into our society, to have represented in a national assembly, a million Protestants who, by their arrival, might put the little boat in difficulty? "Why rock the boat? We were doing nicely. Why bring these boys in? Let us keep on talking about it, and talking about it in an aggressive fashion. Let us keep on hurling insults across the Border to make very sure the Border will remain, because that is our lifeline; it is our insurance policy; that is the thing that will keep us in power."
This is my interpretation of Fianna Fáil philosophy. I could not be convinced otherwise. In my lifetime I have never seen a single reasonable effort made by this political party now in power honestly to approach this question of Partition. The late Mr. Lemass did make one venture across the Border and had a cup of tea. However, efforts were made by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in a more practical way long before that, to which no recognition has been given.
Comment on this
Yes. Essentially the blame must lie fairly and squarely on the shoulders of the party who should have taken the initiative, the party who were in power almost continuously since 1930 and did nothing whatsoever about it except to use "Up the Republic" as a catchcry at every street corner. These shibboleths were trotted out at every Fianna Fáil gathering once a year and the faithful went back home spiritually reassured that Fianna Fáil were still on the right lines. Remember, this was not a party. Fianna Fáil did not regard themselves, in their early days particularly, as a party. They regarded themselves as a movement.
Comment on this
The Deputy would not know anything about republicanism, being a member of the party of the sell-out.
Comment on this
Partition was a fact when Collins and Griffith went over to London to negotiate the Treaty
Comment on this
The same Act of Parliament exists today, and what have Fianna Fáil done about it? Have they done any more than Collins, with his small guerrilla force behind him, did? He did come back with a Thirty-two County administration with the proviso, in accordance with the British 1920 Act, that the Northern Ireland Parliament could opt out within one month, and, in effect, they opted out within three days. The Treaty was established following the arrival in Belfast of King George V. In the course of his speech he expressed concern at the deplorable circumstances and conditions in which his southern subjects were living, and on the morrow of that Treaty the truce was established and in the autumn of that year negotiations began. The Stormont Parliament was then an entity, not where the present building is but in another part of Belfast, but it was still a parliament already opened by the king. At that time Lloyd George was head of the Liberal Party, a member of an inter-party Government, a party who were no longer the dominant party in Britain. Even if Lloyd George so wished he could not have secured repeal of the 1920 Act in the British House of Commons. Does history not tell us that twice or three times Home Rule was thrown out of the British House of Lords? It was only when Gladstone modified the powers of the Lords that eventually, around 1914, the Home Rule Bill was passed.
This is the sell-out the Parliamentary Secretary is talking about, the sell-out by a leader of Collins and Griffith and the signing of the Treaty at a stage when, as I said, Partition was a fact and an Act of the British House of Commons, and nothing has been done since to alter that. The difficulty is now that, for the first time, this Fianna Fáil Party have been shown up as being completely ineffectual. On the doctrine of force they have had to swallow their words.
They have persistently pursued a dishonest policy in that regard. They speak with divers tongues. Some speak out in forceful tones and yet other sections of them are quietly behind the scenes speaking in an opposite fashion in the hope of collecting a few votes from certain sections of our socitey. This is what I adverted to last night. This is what I meant when I said that one did not know nowadays how much one could trust the Fianna Fáil Party. I have nothing against Fianna Fáil members individually. It is the collective performance, as a political entity, which I find degarding and dishonest. Everybody who pauses to think for one second must accept that, even if we had the power of Hitler in his time and we were in a position to resolve the northern problem by force, we would still not have solved it, because one million captive people would be simply a gross embarrassment to us and not what we want, a people co-operating with us.
I would like to see here the evolution of a pluralist society. In every white race in the world, we have a liberalist pluralist society. This is the last bastion of narrow sectarian thinking, North and South. It is not for me to criticise other sections of our community as well as the political one but perhaps other sections of our community are open to criticism to a pose we are all open to criticism to a greater or lesser extent, but it is my duty here to place the criticism mainly where I think it should be placed.
In the past, criticism has been made about this question of the Boundary. I presume Deputy Andrews would say that Cumann na nGaedheal did another sell out there. I think I heard Deputy Blaney bleating in that fashion on one occasion. I did not live through the days of the Boundary Commission. Only the very senior Members of the House would be conversant with these particular circumstances. As I understand it, the delineation of the Boundary was something to be dealt with after the Treaty was signed, just as some of the bits and pieces will have to be filled in with regard to our entry to the Common Market.
The northern community retained to itself sufficient territory to perpetuate a one-sided system, to perpetuate Unionist domination in the northern Administration. Six counties were allocated to the northern Administration. It left in its wake an imbalanced society, a society in which, with a tendency to religious polarisation, there was a two-to-one ratio. That is an unhealthy situation in the type of environment which has traditionally prevailed there.
The problem which faces everybody who has an interest, direct or indirect, in this problem is how to undo this type of population imbalance. If one could work it out like something on a map one could do a population shift and introduce a balanced society but in the realms of practical politics these things cannot be done. The general approach in the South for many years has been to suggest acquiring more and more territory and to add to the Twenty-six Counties. It is questionable whether that would not aggravate the situation. There was a notion that if the northern territory was very small it would not be a viable entity. Even at six counties some of the northern Ministers in the early stages, Craig and others, believed that as an entity it would not exist. Of course, such an entity would exist if it was only four counties, two counties or only Belfast so long as it was subsidised from an outside source. After all Gibraltar exists as an independent entity due to subsidisation from Britain. The argument that the North will not survive as a unit falls down as long as the parent body, the British House of Commons, is prepared to pay sufficient money to keep it going.
Other people have taken the view that the six counties should have been seven counties or larger in order to provide a balanced population. If that suggestion is promulgated you will meet with objections in the south. This would be regarded as a sell-out on the part of the south. There is no simple answer to this. It is completely childish thinking to say that there was a sell-out on the question of the boundary because I do not think, even now, there would be unanimity as to whether the Border should be pushed up or down. If anybody here suggested that it should be pushed downwards, that the northern community should be enlarged and thereby provide a balanced society and fifty-fifty population which could give you change of Governments in the context of a united Ireland and which would, maybe, one day vote itself into a united Ireland you would be immediately confronted with the argument that you were selling out on the south.
I have been told that at the time these negotiations were going on the suggestion was that part of Donegal should be handed over to Northern Ireland but the northern community rejected it perhaps on the basis that it was too poor, perhaps on the basis that it was too Catholic and that the two-to-one ratio, which they had secured under the present delineation of the Boundary, would be upset. I have never been able to understand the half-baked accusations which sometimes emanate from the far side of the House, and this morning from Deputy Andrews, accusing this side of the House of a sell-out. There was no sell-out as far as I can judge from my reading of history in respect of the Treaty negotiations, in respect of the establishment of this State or subsequently in respect of the delineation of the Boundary. If I was there tomorrow morning and I had absolute power as to where to draw that Boundary I would have much thinking to know whether I should move the Boundary up or down.
Comment on this
You would be blamed whatever you did, and with the best intentions, and even if your purpose was to provide a balanced society and you told the world that, could you tell the southern Irishman that?
Comment on this
An original suggestion, indeed. That is what we would all like to do, but we will argue about the ways to do it. I do not object to honest dialogue as to how we will do it, but I certainly object to the attitude adopted by the Fianna Fáil Party down through the years, the Green Tory party which tried to persuade the people, and succeeded to some extent unfortunately, that they had the solution to partition and that they were the sole custodians of Irish nationalism. No matter how big an impostor one is, if one keeps on telling lies long enough, one eventually comes to believe in one's own imposture.
Comment on this
What is the sum total of our efforts here? We have buried in the one forgotten grave three great men, Wolfe Tone, Connolly and Pope John. They are merely names in our society. They represent nothing in our society today. Because of the distorted development Fianna Fáil have imposed on our historical evolution over the past 30 or 40 years the noble concepts behind the thinking of these three great men has been cast into oblivion.
Comment on this
They would not want the Border anyhow. They would not be sitting down wondering would they move it up or down.
Comment on this
They would not want the Border. Connolly and Wolfe Tone never wanted a Border. It is Fianna Fáil who want the Border. Fianna Fáil have survived on the Border and it is Fianna Fáil who want to keep the Border. Fianna Fáil are the custodians of partition. They are the real partitionists; they will stand to be condemned by posterity and, when history comes to be written, Fianna Fáil will be written down, analysed and dissected out as exactly that. To be sure, there is now some rethinking in the Fianna Fáil Party. The "standing idly by" proclamation turned out to be a damp squib. It was followed immediately by a conciliatory speech in Tralee and, since then, face to face with the factual situation, Fianna Fáil, as a party, have had to climb down on this question of taking over the fourth green field by force. We are now at the stage at which they are prepared to sit back and review the situation. But that is a welcome change. Nobody was more pleased than I was personally when this House passed a unanimous vote here—perhaps not unanimous in the heart—agreeing that we would put aside the question of force as a solution to our national problems.
I think every right-minded Deputy welcomed that. Surely every right-minded Deputy must deplore the fact that 200 lives have been lost in the last couple of years in the North. I spend my time trying to save life. You can appreciate how bitterly disappointing it is to me and how I turn away in revulsion from the idea of any man taking upon himself the right to take another man's life.
We, on this side of the House, have always held to the simple concept that in any organised society there must be only one parliament, one government, one army and one judiciary. If anything else is countenanced then society is moving down the road to anarchy. I assume that the majority of the Fianna Fáil Party accept that. Certainly every member of this party accepts it. I presume the members of the Labour Party accept it. But is there a minority in Fianna Fáil which does not accept it and, if there is, even if there is a minority which has reservations on that unanimous vote here, then that party over there continues to govern with that minority in its midst and dependent on the votes of that minority, a minority with mental reservations, and the question immediately arises as to whether that Government is morally entitled to go on governing? Should it not seek a new mandate from the people? Do Fianna Fáil Deputies not feel that they are now governing under false pretences?
Comment on this
There is a mental cleavage certainly in the Fianna Fáil Party. They are in the position now in which some members of the party— may be they are ex-members, but they assert they are still members—are looking for special quarters. They cannot bear the sight, the smell, the proximity of the other members of the Fianna Fáil Party and they are looking for special accommodation, a specially fumigated chamber for themselves.
Comment on this
Indeed I believe they are quite prepared to go to the basement to relieve themselves of the noxious circumstances of having to see their fellow-members every so often in the corridors. The only difficulty now is arranging the Members' bar. Will we have some kind of——
Comment on this
The Deputy has been drawing lines here all the morning so he will probably draw a few more.
Comment on this
That particular accommodation was designed for one Independent and we now have six. I think we should consult the Corporation. There would appear to be overcrowding.
Comment on this
I have dealt with the political situation. I want to keep the Government Deputies in good humour and, if I went any further, I might subject them to some strain. I want now to say a few words about the economic situation. Unemployment was mentioned. It is difficult nowadays to know exactly the number of unemployed and to make a comparison with the number ten or 12 years ago when one could compare like with like. I think it was in 1968 there was some kind of rearrangement, or fiddle, with regard to unemployment figures and over 10,000 or 12,000 were taken off the register and put into some other catalogue. At the moment the official figures are 70,000. If one adds on the redundants, and redundancy is another form of unemployment; as far as I know, these people are not working— one gets a figure of 76,000. When one takes into account the fiddle which was done in 1968 to make the figures comparable with pre-1968 figures there are approaching 100,000 unemployed, which is a staggering figure.
Comment on this
The Deputy is open to give his figure when he stands up and I am sure it will be different from mine—it will be deflated.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not agree that the redundancy figure has to be added to the numbers unemployed?
Comment on this
Emigration has stopped. Did the Taoiseach not say yesterday that emigration was finished. People cannot emigrate to Britain because there are already one million unemployed there. They have to stay at home.
Comment on this
Is there any truth in the suggestion that the Government are going to introduce assisted passages to Australia?
Comment on this
What about the 100,000 new jobs without any increase in taxation? I am pleased to hear the Government are going to introduce a malicious injuries Bill. I hope it will take some of the burden off county councils in regard to the destruction of property which has arisen from the Government's neglecting to do their duty. In north Tipperary we had the Silvermines incident and claims of up to £5 million have been mentioned by the mining company. Rates in north Tipperary are already about £5 in the £ and if this claim is levied on the country council the rates will have to be doubled. This will be a very serious matter for the ratepayers concerned. I do not know what award will be given in respect of the Silvermines incident but clearly this is a matter where the Government should be held responsible because county councils do not provide a police force as they do in Britain. If the Government allow law and order to break down and serious accidents of that nature occur it is the Government's responsibility to come to the aid of the local authority. When Nelson Pillar was blown up and property was damaged Dublin Corportation did not have to face the compensation which had to be paid.
The increase in the cost of living, which in any society is a fundamental cause of social unrest, is continuing unabated here. There has been an 8 per cent increase in the cost of living each year for the past three years. This means that anything one buys will cost about 25 per cent more now than it did three years ago. That is an average figure. Deputy Cosgrave recently asked a question about the items which formed the cost of living index and in the reply the movement in price of these items was given in the form of a tabular statement. As far as I can recall the most outstanding increases—I am probably forgetting some of them— were in the postal charges, CIE fares and motor taxation. The biggest culprit was not the ordinary trader but the Government. Increased charges by State and semi-State bodies had the greatest impact on the cost-of-living index. To this can be added increases in general taxation, the introduction of decimalisation. I am sure that could be called an inflationary move, increase in corporation profits tax and the impending imposition of value-added tax. These are all Government measures. We also had the Minister for Health, who is a quiet, inoffensive, little man, introducing a Bill by means of which he put his hand into people's pockets and took out £7 million. I do not know what the public are going to get for the £7 million. I do not know of any new service being provided. I asked the Minister and he gave me a two or three page reply and even though I have read it two or three times I still cannot analyse it. All I was able to gather was that the Minister for Health was doing the gathering and the man in the street was not going to get anything extra for his £7 million. The Taoiseach spoke of a growth rate of 3 per cent. I do not think the fellow down the country knows what a growth rate of 3 per cent means.
Comment on this
To tell the truth, I do not think anybody understands what it means. I doubt if it has any meaning.
Comment on this
I do not know. I have often wondered. I have no doubt the Deputy on my left will contradict me on that.
Comment on this
There are some figures which even Fianna Fáil Deputies can understand. These are the ordinary trade figures, which show the gap between what we export and what we import. That gap is getting bigger and bigger and bigger, even allowing for Fianna Fáil inflation of 8 per cent.
The trade gap is increasing at a higher rate than inflation which, rapid as it is, cannot keep up with the trade deficit. It is all right to talk about our money abroad or to give it the new name, external reserves. It is very nice to have sterling reserves but how much are of them are ours and how much are hot money we have in this country at present?
Comment on this
At the same time we have 90 hotels for auction at present. How many Dublin hotels are now in the hands of Irish nationals? When I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce the other day about how much property and share capital was in the hands of Irish people I was told there was no record kept and he is now inquiring about what type of records are kept by other countries as to how much control of the country's affairs remains in the hands of its nationals. This is a serious matter for us. A Governor of the Bank of Canada, Mr. Kyne, spent his life fighting against the power of American money taking control of Canadian affairs. We, as a small island on the verge of Europe, must be eternally vigilant to see that our resources are not undetermined and that the cheque book conquest does not become a reality in our time. This is real patriotism; shouting "Up the Republic" is not patriotism. To conserve our resources for our people is true patriotism and here Fianna Fáil have failed significantly.
Before I sit down I want to deal with one point which I already mentioned in relation to a debate last week. It is important and it does not seem to concern any particular Department and so it is not inappropriate to mention it in what may be termed a general discussion. This is the matter of regional development. The debate on entry to the Common Market is associated in most people's minds particularly in the case of the farming and rural community, with the improved prices we may get or anticipate for agricultural produce. Prices can vary and what may appear attractive now may not be so attractive in two or three years. It may be that further price increases for food products in the Common Market may be slowed down and that the trend may be towards using the Social Fund and towards regional development.
This is one field where I believe we have not done our homework. The importance of regional development to us may well exceed the importance of the price increases which may obtain in the Common Market. Every other country in Europe has a regional policy pretty well formulated and very substantial amounts of money have been spent on Southern Italy to improve backward areas. Most European countries have backward areas. The regional policy will be controlled by regional commissioners whose object is to prevent money being spent in already developed areas and, in the concept of Europe, not only the West of Ireland but the whole of this island, could be regarded as a peripheral undeveloped area in respect of the high proportion of population engaged in agriculture, the thinness of the population and per capita income. We qualify under every heading.
We have in operation for some time, since 1965, a Land Commission policy which bears some resemblance to the Mansholt Plan; though not as generous perhaps, the basis is somewhat the same. It has not worked for the simple reason that there has been no alternative place for displaced persons to go, no alternative employment for them. Small farmers with unprofitable farms all over the country, and particularly in the West have not availed themselves of our Land Commission plan nor, perhaps, will they avail themselves of the Mansholt Plan until a regional development plan is co-ordinated with it. It is regional development associated with the Mansholt Plan that will make this concept viable. At present nearly every Department is interesting itself in regional development and at local level we have regional teams. The Industrial Development Authority is interested in this. The other day I listed all the bodies and Departments that I knew had in one way or another interested themselves in regional development. This is like pollution; when you have too many different groups and organisations feeling that this is the "in" thing for them and trying to make it their own particular interest the result is the problem is not tackled comprehensively.
Regional development in the context of our society may even merit a new Ministry. It certainly merits a degree of centralisation, attention and control which it has not so far received. It is not a matter in which you can speak in a very rousing manner: it is very much a drab, bread-and-butter concept; you cannot very easily get it across to the public but those who sit back and reflect in the context of our type of society and particularly the rural parts and the less well-off parts, will realise that it is of extreme importance. The Mansholt Plan to my mind, no more than our own Land Commission Plan, will not work unless it is integrated with an active regional development plan. It should be centralised and proceeded with now. We cannot expect, and it is pointless to do so, that the Common Market will prepare a regional plan for us. They do it for no country; each country is responsible for its own development and planning on these lines. It may provide technical aid and it will provide the funds.
The plan has to meet with their approval and in that respect we have not done our homework. I know the Government have been too absorbed with more difficult problems. Their internal problems have been tremendous in the last year and a half. Now, in 1972 when they make up their mandate from the people—which they will not get—they might have more time to address themselves to the ordinary bread and butter issues they have neglected in the last 18 months.
Deputy Corish rose.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Corish speaks, may I make an inquiry regarding the length of speeches? Is it correct that at 2 p.m. a Labour speaker will make the concluding speech? With respect to the Chair, might I point out that the speeches are far too long. Everyone should get a chance of making some contribution; it is unfair that there should be a monopoly by some speakers here. They are trying to corner all the time. This is not with reference to Deputy Corish in any way.
Comment on this
It has been agreed that a Member nominated by the Labour Party will speak at 1.45 p.m.
Comment on this
I take Deputy Carter's point. Of course, the solution was with the Government. They could have given three days for this debate because it would take at least that time to talk about the many problems that exist. However, in deference to Deputy Carter I shall do my best.
Comment on this
I should like to draw attention to the fact that there is only one Member present on the Fianna Fáil benches. Could we have a House please?
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
In his review of 1971 and in describing the prospects for 1972, with the best will in the world the Taoiseach could not conceal what we must all regard as a depressing situation and according to his own speech, the outlook for 1972 is even more depressing. This depression is reflected in the attitude of the people when one considers the three important topics that have been mentioned by practically every Deputy in this debate —the North, the economy and the EEC. Apart from that and the low morale of the people, there is a decided change in the attitude of the people towards the Government, the Dáil, and public representatives generally. This is a dangerous situation, for which Fianna Fáil are entirely responsible.
One of the reasons for this is the isolation of the Government from the people. They are unaware of their day-to-day problems; they have been taking the people for granted, and I must confess have been doing so successfully for a long time. The time has come for the Government to change their attitude and policy if they wish to preserve the credibility of this House and of government. Perhaps some Deputies in Fianna Fáil may answer that they do not hear any criticism but it is dangerous when they do not hear such criticisms. I can tell them that we hear much criticism with regard to the three matters I mentioned. There is a feeling of hopelessness, of drifting, among the people. This attitude of drifting has come from the Government; with regard to prices, employment, the EEC and the North their attitude is, "What is the use?" This situation must be checked and it is up to the Government to do it.
The Government should not think that because of the natural focus of attention on the North the state of the economy can be ignored. I should not like to say they have taken refuge in the northern situation to ignore other matters in this country but it appears that this is what has happened. All the signs are there, and they were verified in an unenthusiastic speech by the Taoiseach yesterday that there is a severe deterioration in the economy and that 1971 has proved to be a disastrous year.
The key economic failure of the Government is with regard to employment. No more do we hear references to the First, Second or Third Programmes for Economic Expansion because the targets of these programmes were not reached and in the three cases the margins were very wide. I have heard taunts in this House about the unemployment figures for 1957—incidentally, three-quarters of which Fianna Fáil were responsible for—but if things go on as they are at the moment, no longer will members of the Government party be able to throw that taunt across the House. Once again, we are dangerously near the period when we will have 100,000 unemployed. I do not believe that the injection of £20 million some time ago by the Minister for Finance will change the situation in any way. With increasing redundancies and the closure of factories, unfortunately we will get to the stage where we will reach the 100,000 unemployment mark. This is by far the highest rate of unemployment of the six EEC countries and the applicant countries. None of them has an unemployment rate of 8 per cent. I would go so far as to say that I do not think any of these ten countries has an unemployment rate of 4 per cent. Yet we appear to be enthusiastic —perhaps we are whistling going past the graveyard—about entering the EEC.
According to the forecast of the Economic and Social Research Institute, the unemployment situation is not likely to improve in 1972. The tragic thing for those who are now unemployed, and for those who may become unemployed in 1972, is that there appears to be no real concern on the part of the Government and no initiative to correct that situation. As far as the availability of jobs is concerned there is nothing in that field to make us feel enthusiastic or optimistic. In 1964 there were 1,071,000 jobs available. In 1970 the figure was 1,066,000, a decrease of 5,000 jobs.
When questioned in this House about unemployment, the policy of the Government has been to be very, very vague, to say the least of it. We all recognise this when a question is put down about the numbers unemployed and asking the Taoiseach what will be done about it. Nothing has been done about it and nothing will be done about it. Unfortunately, 1972 will be worse than 1971 unless there is a change of direction and a change of policy by the Government.
Therefore, judging the Government's economic record in that field we must say very emphatically that they have failed dismally.
We must also condemn the Government for their failure to develop adequate tools for preparing Irish industry for free trade. It has shown itself in many areas to be totally unprepared for the competition that now faces us from abroad, and the competition which has faced us and is becoming increasingly intensified under the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement now in its fifth or sixth year. This is one of the key factors causing the record rate of redundancies over the past two or three years, to which most Deputies have referred. May I repeat the figure that has often been mentioned in this debate? This year alone, 7,500 people will become redundant.
I do not know what sort of thinking there is in the Fianna Fáil Party or in the Fine Gael Party when they talk about the EEC, having regard to the massive redundancy figures. I have a list here, a dismal litany, of people who have been made redundant in 15 to 20 areas of Irish industry: food, tobacco and drink, 751 redundancies; textiles, 961; clothing and footwear, 349; personal services, 355; motor repairs, 208; distributive trades, 578; building and construction, 347. Is there any glimmer of hope that the Government will do anything to curtail that trend? No amount of airy-fairy talk by the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance or any other Minister will suggest to me that they are serious about finding a real remedy.
The picture is not any brighter when one considers the annual growth. We must revert back to the three programmes for economic expansion, the three blueprints which were supposed to provide so many jobs, bring industries to this country and do such wonderful things for the economy. Under the First Programme for Economic Expansion from 1959 to 1963 the annual growth was 4 per cent. Under the Second Programme it was 3.3 per cent and under the third, between 1969 and 1971, it is estimated at 2.8 per cent. Therefore, our economy suffered under those three programmes rather than achieving what they were supposed to achieve according to those who promoted them, the Fianna Fáil Party. This slow growth makes it virtually impossible to create employment opportunities or to get the full employment we were promised.
I would say that we are further away from full employment than we were in 1965, and further away from full employment than we were on the introduction of the First Programme for Economic Expansion. The short-term economic policy of the Government must be blamed. There has been no attempt at a long-term policy to provide industries and employment. They are still using the same old policies—or can one even describe them as policies? They are stop-gap policies as, indeed, was the introduction by the Minister for Finance of his proposal to inject £20 million into the economy. All of these things should have been provided for in the last Budget and the Budget before that. We should not do this thing in a piecemeal way. Because it is now too late I do not believe that the Minister's injection of £20 million will correct this awful siuation in which we have an unemployment rate of 8 per cent. These policies have failed. They have proved to be failures over the past 15 years. We wonder when will the Government learn that these old conservative policies which are attuned to a capitalist society have failed and that new ones must be adopted.
I am sure that inside his own family every member of the Fianna Fáil Party recognises the anger that is felt about increases in prices. I want to say to the Minister for Finance, who is present in the House, that the value-added tax will not contribute to the stabilisation of prices or the reduction of prices. As far as the administration of that tax is concerned, according to the retailers, if it is administered as the Minister wants to administer it, it will cause a further increase in prices to the extent of 3 or 4 per cent.
Certainly 1971 was a depressing year for the housewife. The anticipated rise by the end of this year will be in the region of 9 per cent. Of course the price of some very important industrial items has increased at a faster rate than 9 per cent. In relation to houses the increase was 15 per cent. All of us must appreciate what that means to the young married couples who are faced with colossal bills for houses they need so badly, and to others who need houses so badly too. I said that the overall increase is estimated to be 9 per cent. For the people in the city of Dublin the increase over the past 12 months was 13.8 per cent. The increase in relation to fuel and light, which are so necessary for old people and particularly those down the country, was 12 per cent. This is, indeed, a period of very high inflation. Judging by the tone and the brevity of the Taoiseach's speech yesterday there seems to be no concern whatsoever about that depressing situation. There is no visible attempt—no attempt that I know of— to control prices. The Government have the legislation; they may not have the machinery. No attempt whatsoever has been made to curb the ever-increasing prices of foodstuffs and all the other necessaries of life.
So far as the EEC is concerned we have stated our position during the debate on the Referendum Bill. I was somewhat amused at some of the speeches from Fine Gael on the EEC. I do not know what is to the future policy of Fine Gael but they have been critical of the Government's approach during the negotiations for entry to the Community. Despite what the Minister for Foreign Affairs said yesterday and on other occasion, I do not believe that the alternatives of a relationship with the Community have been investigated in any depth. Other countries have availed themselves of the alternatives, and, when one has regard to the depressed state of our economy, we wonder why, as the Minister for Foreign Affairs said, we should throw out our chests for full membership. In that speech he undermined his own bargaining position by declaring that he accepted completely the Treaty of Rome.
He has said, and repeated time and again, that the Irish economy is prepared for entry and he said, as the Minister for Transport and Power would say, there are no great problems. Are we ready for Europe with 70,000 people unemployed, with the smallness of our growth and with agriculture in its present condition as described by the NFA and other farmers' organisations? In view of the fulsome way in which the Minister for Foreign Affairs accepted completely the Treaty of Rome, is it any wonder that the concessions to us were so meagre and so inadequate? We wonder if there was any real negotiation at all or have we been as we always have been, stringing along after the British negotiators or somebody else and taking part of what they negotiate for?
We should have outlined the state of our economy; we should have been honest enough to say that we were not fully developed but the Minister gave the impression that Ireland was willing and ready to join with the industrial giants of Germany, with the agricultural industry of France and with all those other nations whose economies are much stronger than ours. The Minister should have been big enough to say that, by the standards of other countries, we were an underdeveloped country. I have given some examples of the state of the economy and I do not think the figures can be denied. We have an unemployment rate of 8 per cent, 30 per cent of our work force is in agriculture, and 12,000 of our people emigrated last year. That figure is relatively low by comparison with other years. I hope the Taoiseach will correct what appears to us to be an error when he says that the number of people who emigrated during the year was 2,000.
Comment on this
I would be interested to know where the Taoiseach got the figure. I do not blame him if he made a mistake.
Comment on this
Then the reason for the lower rate must be, as Deputy Hogan said, that there are no jobs in England.
Comment on this
This is the sort of information that should have been given in relation to our application and on that basis we should have negotiated as strongly as possible for the concessions that are vitally necessary, in particular, for Irish industry. If we enter the EEC on the terms negotiated, we would be confronted with very many difficulties. It is not for me to tell Fine Gael what is their business, but, last week, they endorsed the Government's application for membership when the terms were not yet described in a White Paper, but it is clear as to what has been negotiated. I was interested to hear Deputy Cosgrave saying that the Government should spell out what will happen in the various industries. All the Deputy had to do was to turn to his right hand side and ask the Fine Gael "Mr. Europe", Deputy FitzGerald, what would happen because Deputy FitzGerald appears to know all the answers and he is the one man in Fine Gael who seems to have no reservations.
I am not being critical of Fine Gael per se but what I am trying to say is that we should not put up our hands as Fianna Fáil have done and say that we will go in on any terms. Deputy Begley is concerned about fisheries, and Deputies in the urban areas are concerned about industry. The advantages that will accrue to agriculture can be enumerated, but is the Minister for Foreign Affairs or the Minister for Industry and Commerce prepared to tell us what will happen to Irish industry? It is true that they negotiated certain terms for the car assembly industry, although these were not as good as the terms for that industry under the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement. However, in respect of all industries including the car assembly industry ten or 15 years is a very short time. Ten years is a very short time in respect of fisheries and we should not take consolation in saying that after the transitional period of five years in respect of certain matters, and ten years in respect of others that everything will be all right. In fact it is ten years since we applied first for membership.
Industrial employment will be threatened by membership and there is evidence to indicate that full membership of the EEC will put about 70,000 Irish jobs in jeopardy. Let me not exaggerate and say that 70,000 jobs would be lost immediately but they are vulnerable and under the limited free trade we have with Great Britain, we have examples of layoffs and there are redundancies under our present trading conditions. So far as I can see, nothing has been negotiated that would stop such trends. At a seminar held recently under the auspices of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions it was said in a report presented by the General Secretary, Mr. Ruadhrí Roberts, that present Irish industry is suffering from severe redundancy, that it is affected by world trends and also by a substantial reduction in protection against imports of industrial goods from Britain under the Free Trade Area Agreement; that redundancies had doubled last year by comparison with the previous year; and that, in addition, a large number of workers are now on short time. Listed in a table which followed that statement were the industries which, in the opinion of the ICTU, are vulnerable so far as some jobs are concerned. I would say that in respect of the 200,000 jobs in various industries, 70,000 or 71,000 are vulnerable. For the benefit of the Minister for Finance, I will name the industries that are listed as being vulnerable in respect of jobs. These industries are food, drink and tobacco, textiles and clothing, footwear, wood and furniture, paper and printing, chemicals, clay products and metal and engineering. Those members of Congress are representative of the trade unions of this country and are representative of the ordinary workers and I would venture to say that they know more about the situation in these various industries than is known to any member of the Government front bench.
It is all very well to list the advantages that would accrue to agriculture and to say that industry generally will be all right. We should be told why it will be all right. If special terms could be negotiated for a limited period for the motor assembly industry, why could they not be negotiated, in view of the state of our economy and if we want full membership, in respect of the textile industry, footwear, paper and printing, and wood and furniture? I do not believe there was any negotiation. I do not believe there was any hard bargaining.
Deputy Hogan and others referred to the lack of regional policy. God help the people of the West of Ireland for whom the members of the Fianna Fáil Government and their backbenchers express so much concern. There is no regional policy in operation in the EEC and there certainiy is no internal regional policy in this country to deal with places west of the Shannon.
It is not clear either in these vague negotiations what will be the position of the export tax relief. We are assured by the Minister for Foreign Affairs that it will continue. He says that these people will be compensated, in any case, from some source over the remaining period of this tax holiday.
The advantages to agriculture have been described, but will somebody spell out for me the advantages for industry? I would invite Deputy Garret FitzGerald to do that if the Minister for Finance is not able to do it, if the Taoiseach will not do it or if the Minister for Foreign Affairs is reluctant to do it. It is obvious, from what we have heard of the Mansholt plan and of agricultural policy in the EEC, that there will be fewer people on the land, that the objective of the Mansholt plan is to make farms bigger and to draw people off the land. Where will they get employment? That is a very simple question and it should be answered now because we are on the threshold of having this agreement signed, even though we have not seen the terms of it and have not seen what has been negotiated in detail.
I think it was Deputy L'Estrange who said yesterday that it is inevitable, that we must go in. Have we come to the stage in this country—we talk about our proud history—where we throw up our hands and say: "We have to go in because John Bull is going in"? Is that the attitude of members of the Fianna Fáil Party? Is it a question of our having Hobson's choice? It will be no consolation for me or for anybody else to tell our constituents in five or ten years time that we had to go in when they are out of work and when many of them are not in Britain but in places like Germany, Brussels or Holland. My experience of the Germans—I visited Germany recently—is that they are not too keen to establish industries in places like Ireland. What they want is to get Irish people to work over there.
We have been accused of being parochial, of being too national, but my concern is for Irish people. Let nobody say to me: "You are not a true socialist if you do not believe in a united states of Europe." I am interested in every single country in the world but I want to make sure there are at least four million or five million people in this country and that it will not be, as it was described on one occasion, Britain's cabbage patch. Our concern in this is for people but there does not seem to be concern on the other two sides of the House for anything except statistics There is no use in doing well in agriculture if it will mean more unemployment for us. For the benefit of Deputy FitzGerald, and I am not trying to provoke interruptions——
Comment on this
I know that. One can list the advantages for agriculture. I have simply asked the Government or anybody else to list the advantages for industry.
What was negotiated for fisheries has been condemned by the fishermen. Again, we had the blasé approach of Deputy Dr. Hillery. He believes he got a good bargain, or should I say a damn good bargain. Who better to know whether or not it is a good agreement than the fishermen of Ireland? I believe we should have held out for a 12-mile all round limit. We have the six-mile limit from Carnsore Point to Cork. In case the Minister for Foreign Affairs does not know it, these fishing grounds on the South Wexford coast, the Waterford coast and the Cork coast are nearly outfished already. What will be the situation if all the fishermen in the other member countries—I do not say Luxembourg wants to fish—after the period of negotiation are allowed in there with their expensive trawlers? It will be the end for the Irish fishermen. Some people may say there are 5,000 fishermen. There are many more concerned with this industry—those who build boats, those who are in the fish business generally, those who tin fish. I would reckon that there will be 50,000 people affected.
People may say it will not happen for a long time, for ten years, and that after ten years there will be a review. That clause in the agreement is very vague indeed and I think it was designed merely to conclude the negotiations before Christmas. It is obvious from the comments of at least one of the commissioners that if there is to be a review it is only a matter of going through the form and that in fact after the stipulated period of ten years the other members of the Community will be able to fish right up to the Irish coastline. Ten years is a short time. One must consider, for example, the young skipper of 25 years. What will be his attitude? Will he be bursting to invest, even with State aid, £100,000 in a trawler realising the competition he will face in ten years time? I do not believe he will. This could mean the virtual disappearance of Irish fishermen.
I do not believe the Government negotiated properly at all. The Minister for Foreign Affairs took me to task yesterday because he said I made a comment on a speech he was going to make next week. Typical of the Minister for Foreign Affairs. I am concerned about the beet industry for the farmers not alone in my own constituency, where they are pretty strong, but all over the country, whether it is in the western region near the Tuam factory, in the Tipperary region near Thurles or in the Munster area near Mallow. If the Minister for Foreign Affairs says I was wrong, we should be told now what is to be the future of the beet industry. As far as I am aware the quota fixed for the Irish sugar industry by the EEC for two years is 137,000 tons. This in my view will lead to a loss of about £2 million to £3 million for Irish farmers. If the quota is going to be substantially smaller than what it has been last year or the projections for next year it will do a lot of damage to the Irish farmer and to Irish workers. As far as I am aware, the quota of sugar to be produced is fixed in accordance with the average production between 1964 and 1967 or 1968. That is where I got my figure of 135,000 or 137,000 tons. Here we have jobs in jeopardy. The tragic thing here is that the jobs are directly related to agriculture and we are told we will do well in agriculture. The 1,000 jobs that will be lost if this happens are confined to the sugar factories. I believe they employ in the region of 5,000 people. The Irish Transport and General Workers' Union said that if this is the case it will influence their thinking when they come to make a decision on our application for membership of the EEC. There are others who would be involved: Nítrigin Éireann, the factories manufacturing agricultural implements and CIE. These are the offshoots, so to speak, but this is a very big one, of full membership of the EEC. This matter must be cleared up as quickly as possible.
The Taoiseach, in his urbane way, as did his predecessors, will wish the Members of the House and the country a happy Christmas and will assure us that the State is in good hands. We have heard that before. It has not been in good hands in 1971. It has not been in good hands for quite a long time and it does not appear that it will be in good hands in 1972 or, if there is not an election, until 1973.
This will be a very bad Christmas for many hundreds of thousands of Irish people. I am not talking only about people in the Twenty-six Counties. I am referring to people in the Thirty-two Counties. Does the Minister for Finance realise—if he has not got the figures we will make them available to him before he makes his speech— that there are over half a million people who are at a level where they could be described as being impoverished? Many of them are poverty-stricken. This will not be a very happy Christmas for them. This poverty is not confined to those who are in receipt of social welfare benefits. There are thousands of farmers who are below subsistence level. It will ring hollow in the ears of Deputies and of all these people when the Taoiseach wishes them a happy Christmas and assures the people that the country is in good hands.
The main theme of the debate has been Northern Ireland. May I preface my remarks on this subject by saying what I have said before, that we are all trying to blame somebody else? We heard it this morning across the House. We went back to 1922 and even to 1916 and to 1925. We should concentrate what we have to say on the situation existing in the Christmas of 1971. There is no point in going back. There is no point in saying that what was done was wrong or that what was done was good or that there was a difference of opinion between the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and the Fianna Fáil Party. The existing situation should be the concern of all of us.
For that reason I will accept the invitation given to me by the Taoiseach to sit down and talk about this awful problem. If I believed that by taking to somebody or having discussions or making suggestions we could bring an end to this problem and work towards a Thirty-two County united Ireland, I would make a lot of sacrifices. I would not refer to the Constitution of 1922 or to things like the Boundary Commission Report of 1925, because there are young people in the North who know nothing about 1922 apart from what they read in history books or about the niceties of the situation vis-à-vis the Border in 1925 but who want peace with justice and who, like the majority of us, want a united Ireland.
That does not mean to say that I am going to commit myself at this stage as to what my view would be or as to what the party's view would be because it is not quite clear yet—and I do not say this in criticism of the Taoiseach— what the function will be of the committee which it is proposed to set up, representative of the parties in this House. It is not clear what the terms of reference will be, whether we will debate only, for example, the Constitution or social and economic matters related to the division of our country or whether the committee will be charged with the task of suggesting political action.
As I have said, I will participate in preliminary talks with the Taoiseach. I will listen to what he has to say and report back to my party and then we will make our decision. Let me again say that if there are sacrifices to be made by me or by the members of my party, in order to ease the situation and to provide eventually for a united Ireland, we will make those sacrifices and will not invoke past history or past events as an excuse not to participate.
I hope this discussion will be held before Christmas. I think the Taoiseach did indicate that it would. There are still seven days before Christmas. The matter is so urgent, the situation demands that there be immediate discussion so that we might listen to what proposals the Taoiseach has to make.
All of us are appalled by the events in the North, one could say the terror in the North, particularly in recent times, where it certainly has intensified. This must be ended, whether it is the terror in the Falls or in the Border areas, Ballymurphy, Ardoyne, the Creggan Estate or Bogside. There will be an end sometime. There will be an end to this conflict as there has to be an end to all conflicts, but the question is, what sort of end? Will it be an end with hundreds dead and widespread destruction or an end that is the product of civilised men using their reason and composing their differences? There must be now an end to the terror and that must be brought about by a political solution and not by the bomb, the bullet, gelignite, brutality or internment. It cannot be and must not be an end that merely leads to a return of Unionist domination through discrimination and naked sectarianism. It must be an end marked by a new beginning of justice. It cannot be an end where the negotiators are self-elected or self-appointed from amongst those who believe in a solution by violent means or chosen because they are safe men. The negotiators must be democratically elected representatives of the two communities and, as far as the minority is concerned, that means that the Social Democratic and Labour Party must be at the conference table.
There must be a political initiative immediately to get talks going. How many lives must be lost before the British Government decide it is time to talk rather than to terrorise? How many more lives, both Catholic and Protestant, will be lost before the British Prime Minister decides that his present policies of suppression must be replaced by policies of concession and conciliation?
The British Government are salving their conscience by saying that they favour a "permanent, active and guaranteed role" for the minority and by claiming that the Social Democratic and Labour Party have refused to discuss the proposition.
I would like to ask Mr. Heath, what does he mean by this phrase "permanent, active and guaranteed role for the minority". When has he ever spelled it out? What has he said that is in the least bit worthwhile on the Northern situation—other than that violence must be brought to an end? Deputy Tully said yesterday, we are all against sin. We all believe violence should be brought to an end. When has he ever given a definite invitation directly to the Social Democratic and Labour Party and not through the safety of TV interviews or press releases?
I say to him now: "You have little time left to take a real political initiative to which the Social Democratic and Labour Party can respond by participating in talks. Every day the division in the North grows wider and wider. Your Government are seen to be favouring one side and one side only through the introduction of internment, the resort to military suppression, selective arms searches and brutality, especially during the interrogation of detainees. Make public what you have in your mind when you talk of a permanent, active and guaranteed role for the minority. If you do not, no political solution is possible. Take responsibility for your actions."
I said during the special debate on the North, in October, I think, that the one act of introducing internment had changed the Northern situation drastically. It had caused the complete alienation of the two communities, as demonstrated by the withdrawal of the SDLP from all levels of public administration. That feeling of alienation must be brought to an end, and the quicker the better. It cannot be done if the British Government appear to give licence to the Unionist Government to do as they wish in the security field. Will there be reconciliation in a situation where police and military interrogators brutalise detainees? On the contray, there will be hatred and distrust and a solution will be postponed.
I have no hesitation in condemning the many sordid examples of police and military brutality that have been brought to light since the introduction of internment. They can neither be hidden nor denied. My party demand that they cease immediately and that the respect for law and order which is preached by the British and Unionist Governments should be practised by them. They not only offend against all principles of justice but they damage the few remaining possibilities for peace, and they may do irreparable damage if allowed to continue.
In addressing these remarks to Mr. Heath I have no intention of shying away from my responsibility as a public representative or, as the leader of a national party with organisations north and south of the Border, of condemning those on the other side who attempt to secure their political ends by violent means. All such acts of violence breed further acts of violence, deepen divisions and push back the cause of Irish unity, the very cause they seek to serve. It does not matter which brand of so-called Republicanism one puts on their acts: they offend against all the principles of the founder of Republicanism, Wolfe Tone. His aim was to heal divisions, not to open them. He did not fear to denounce those of his own community who behaved contrary to his beliefs. We should not be afraid to imitate him.
We, the Labour Party, have been denounced as anti-national because we are true to our principles of fighting against appeals to sectarian passion and because we say that the national unity we seek is a unity by the consent of all of the people of Ireland. Our aim is a 32-county socialist republic. The achievement of a socialist united Ireland is the objective of the Labour Party. To that end we all subscribe.
The Minister for Finance, Deputy Colley, described us the other night as being anti-national. What can we expect from a man in a party that regard Connolly as anti-national? What can we expect from a so-called republican who has sold every resource we possess to the foreign speculator and the money-grabber?
At our annual conference in Galway this year I called for sweeping changes in the Republic as a genuine step towards unity. All of the measures I propose are within the control of the Government of which Deputy Colley is a senior member. Nothing has been done about my suggestions, which have the support of every person who thinks rationally about the political problems. In particular, I called for a new Constitution. I demanded a truly republican Constitution based firmly on the non-sectarian principles of Tone. I accept the suggestion that this would demand courageous and honest political change from the Taoiseach and his Government, committed, as they undoubtedly are, to narrow, bigoted concepts of society, as has become apparent on the community schools issue.
Who is anti-national? Is it those who propose that we eliminate within the Republic those barriers to unity with our Protestant fellow-countrymen in the North or those who when they have the power do nothing except to mouth clichés and cant?
Comment on this
It takes courage to stand against the sectarian side. Mr. Gerry Fitt, the leader of the SDLP, has shown that courage over and over again.
Comment on this
Mr. Fitt is a Connolly socialist and he agrees with us. I would prefer to have Gerry Fitt agreeing with me any day than Deputy Colley. I refer, of course, to the belief that the unity of Ireland is not around the corner. As a Connolly socialist Mr. Fitt accepts that what the immediate future requires is universal acceptance of the principle that power must be shared between the majority and the minority community.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Corish turned to the problems of the North of this country he dealt at some length with the economic situation. I felt he might very appropriately, when finishing that portion of his speech, have added the quotation: "We'll all be dead, says Hanrahan, before the year is out". I have heard him on many occasions recently making bewailing speeches but never have I heard worse than I heard from him today.
According to him, if we enter the EEC the fishing industry will disappear, the beet industry will disappear and, indeed, the manufacturing industry is unlikely to survive. Whatever view he may take of entering the EEC, surely it is not very helpful to our people to make up their minds if we have these kinds of exaggerated statements from the leader of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I took a note of one statement by Deputy Corish. He said the Government appear to be taking refuge in the Northern problem to evade economic issues.
Comment on this
I did not accuse the Government of taking refuge in the Northern problem. I described the seriousness of the Northern situation and I said that this should not excuse the Government from taking the interest they should in the economic problems. I did not say they were taking refuge in the northern problem.
Comment on this
What the Deputy said is: "The Government appears to be taking refuge in the Northern problem to avoid economic problems here". He then went on to talk about the Taoiseach's speech opening this debate. The Deputy will be aware that the Taoiseach's speech has been criticised on the grounds that it dealt almost exclusively with economic problems. Now, one cannot be accused of dealing with economic problems and at the same time of avoiding the main problem, which is the Northern problem. If the Taoiseach had dealt with the Northern problem exclusively, I have no doubt Deputy Corish would have accused him of evading the economic problem. However, the Taoiseach will be replying to this debate and will, no doubt, have something to say——
Comment on this
I do not wish to go back over the ground covered by the Taoiseach. He painted a clear picture of current economic trends in the country. Instead, I should like to turn to one or two points in respect of which there appear to be misconceptions about our economic situation. These misconceptions appear to be quite prevalent today, even among some of our more informed economic commentators. One of the most common is that Ireland is alone among developed countries in experiencing low growth with high price increases.
This is clearly not the case and even the most fleeting refernces to developments elsewhere will show this. It appears that after a decade of continuous rapid growth with relatively stable prices the phenomenon which we have now encountered has had such a traumatic effect on us that we tend to think of our position as unique. The fact is that in recent times most countries have encountered the twin problems of low growth and rising prices. The new word "stagflation" has been coined to describe this situation. Stagflation is what has been besetting the international economy in the last few years. In 1970 the average increase in prices in OECD countries was almost 6 per cent as compared with an annual average increase of 3 per cent in the previous decade. At the same time real growth in the OECD area in 1970 was only 2½ per cent as compared with an annual average growth rate of over 5 per cent in the previous decade.
If we bring matters closer to home, Britain, our main trading partner, achieved a growth rate of less than 2 per cent in 1970 but at the same time suffered a price increase rate of 6½ per cent. In the first half of this year in Britain they actually experienced a fall in the volume of national production with prices rising at an annual rate of 9 per cent.
Much play has been made here of the situation over the last few years. The international background to which I have just referred helps us to have a better understanding of our position. We are a small economy and are more dependent than most on international trade. Consequently, developments in this country are determined to a large extent by conditions prevailing on the international economic scene. Indeed, we can go so far as to say that adverse developments abroad tend to be magnified in this country. This is particularly true in relation to prices because of the high import content of many of the commodities that are used to make up the consumer price index.
Let us consider now those aspects of our domestic crisis which are largely influenced by developments abroad. The most obvious one has been the rise in domestic meat prices which generated quite an amount of argument here. This rise in meat prices was a direct reflection of the greatly improved prices obtained for our cattle and beef this year in exports to the UK. These higher prices, of course, affected our domestic prices. They also resulted in increased export earnings and in a significant improvement in incomes in the agricultural sector. Whatever view one may take of price increases of that kind, no one can deny that they have had some beneficial effects on our economy. I am speaking now of price increases of that type. The other kind of international price increases which effect us are those demanded by countries from whom we import goods. Inflation in other countries is pushing up prices of goods which they export to us. This is an unpleasant and unpalatable fact, but we must accept it. It has the unfortunate effect of inflating our domestic prices here. The influence of this factor can be gauged by the fact that higher import prices accounted for about 20 per cent of the average increase in our consumer prices in the first three-quarters of this year. I would like to remind Deputy Corish and members of his party that the influence of the external situation applies to our economy whether we operate a capitalist, a socialist or a mixed economy. It does not matter what system we operate. There factors apply and nothing can take them away.
The high income increases in this country in recent years have also contributed greatly to our inflation problems. This aspect of our economic situation has been dealt with fairly fully by the Taoiseach. I do not propose to go back over it here. I am glad to say that there are signs that the world economy is now emerging from its period of stagflation but the progress in some countries is slower than in others. For our part, I am glad to say that the concerted action taken by the Government has begun to bear fruit. The growth process has again been set in motion and, more importantly, because rapid inflation can undermine this process, the acceleration in the rate of price increase has been reversed.
Prices here are now rising at the rate of 8½ per cent as compared with a rate of 10 per cent in the earlier part of the year. This shows that we are breaking the back of the problem. We cannot afford to lull ourselves into any false sense of security. A rate of price increase of 8½ per cent is still excessive and we will have to be vigilant if we are to succeed in bringing it down to a more reasonable level. We must bear in mind that the excessive increases which led to the current rate of inflation have been building up in the economic system for a number of years. Consequently, they cannot be purged overnight. It will require a long period of hard struggle to bring the annual rate of price increase here back to the more moderate levels which we experienced in the early 1960s. I am confident that we will be able to do it. It was this confidence, together with the more optimistic outlook on the international front, which induced the Government recently to introduce measures to stimulate what I might call the nascent growth evident in the economy towards the middle and end of the year.
In this connection I would like to point out that we do not seek growth just for the sake of growth. I said this before but it bears repetition. We pursue growth because it is the only means by which we can attain our national objective of a rising population enjoying a high and increasing standard of living. I know there are some economists, perhaps not in this country, who have a nice, esoteric theory that the pursuit of growth is bad. These gentlemen normally come from economies who have had long and sustained periods of growth. They are suffering problems of the affluent society. We in this country can afford to worry about those problems when we reach that stage of affluence. For us growth is essential. Our objective in trying to achieve growth, which, as I have said, is the achievement of a rising population enjoying an improved standard of living, tends to be forgotten sometimes when some parts of the community, pursuing their own sectional interests, frustrate the smooth advance of the economy. With reasonable co-operation between the different sectors of our community we can go a long way towards enabling our economy to attain its full growth potential in 1972.
Comment on this
I do not think one has to go that far. One does not have to assume that human nature has been damned by original sin and can never recover from it.
Comment on this
Without being damned by original sin at all, any man is entitled to do the best he can for himself.
Comment on this
But even in his own interest he is better off — and this is the point I am making — by co-operating than by striking out for himself. In recent years our economic history has demonstrated that.
Comment on this
It depends. If he thinks he is strong enough and can get away with it, maybe he will try it on, but nobody is strong enough to survive this kind of jungle law in our economy.
Comment on this
There has been a number of comments in this debate on the topic of emigration. There appears to be some misunderstanding about the position. First of all, the annual average net emigration in the last few intercensal periods has been as follows: between 1956 and 1961, it was 42,400; between 1961-66, 16,100; and between 1966-71, 12,200. The average for the period 1966-71 conceals a marked variation between the levels of emigration at the beginning and at the end of that period. In the calender year 1966 net emigration amounted to over 19,000 persons, but this had declined to 5,000 in 1970. Low as the figure was for 1970, the latest figures for emigration, that is, for the 12 months ended October last, calculated by reference to the net outward passenger movemnet by sea and air, is below 2,000.
Comment on this
We know from past experience that the net passenger movement figures tend to overstate the level of emigration on the basis of the census figures. Each time the census is taken it is shown that the estimates based on the net passenger movement are too high and have to be adjusted downwards, so that the figure is actually lower than that. One can argue what are the causes for this and so on, but let us get the facts right anyway.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donovan may argue about figures derived from the net passenger movement; he may argue about figures derived from the census, but they are the only instruments we have got to measure emigration. They are the instruments by which it has been measured over the years.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach stated the cause of it yesterday, so the Minister is wasting his time.
Comment on this
For the period 1966-1971, the annual net average was 12,200, but, as I pointed out, there was a very substantial change, so the figure for 1970 was 5,000, and this year the figure for the 12 months ending October last was below 2,000. Deputy FitzGerald did try yesterday, in interrupting the Taoiseach, to suggest that this change was due solely to the employment or unemployment situation in Britain.
Comment on this
It certainly was not due to the employment situation here. Even the Minister would hardly have the effrontery to suggest that.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach pointed out to him that the downward trend in emigration in this country has been going on since long before the current economic difficulties in Britain came to a head.
Comment on this
I am not trying to argue at the moment about causes or effects. What I am trying to do is to discuss this matter on the basis of what the problem is. At least we have to know what the problem is and what are the facts if we are to do anything worthwhile about it.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy saying that now and at any time in the past we never knew what emigration was?
Comment on this
The figures derived in the normal way, as they have been derived over the years, are as I have given them.
Comment on this
I have never suggested they are not. What I am saying is that "in the normal way", "facts" and all these other words are just nonsense in this context.
Comment on this
From the point of view of a comparison of our situation now with our situation last year or 20 or 30 years ago, this is the only basis on which we can make a comparison. Deputy Tully suggested yesterday, as did Deputy Corish this morning that, perhaps, the Taoiseach had made a mistake, that there should have been another nought added, in other words, that emigration this year might have been 20,000 and not 2,000.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish quoted him as saying there should be another nought on it and said maybe the Taoiseach made a mistake. I said he did not, and Deputy Tully intervened and said: "Not at all. We have the figures". Therefore, the suggestion was that, perhaps, the emigration this year was 20,000. What appals me about this is that the Leader of the Labour Party should pontificate on our economic situation, including our emigration, and that he should not know whether emigration this year was 2,000 or 20,000. That is a very revealing statement by Deputy Corish.
Comment on this
Order. Will Deputy O'Donovan please cease interrupting? Remember the time is limited for this debate.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but it is much more relevant to the situation of the economy for the Minister to tell us about the unemployment figures.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would stop interrupting me I might get on to that. I will say, much as the Deputy may not like it, that the rate of emigration is quite relevant to the question of employment and unemployment and that is why I was dealing with that point first. On the question of unemployment, there are a number of reasons why the live register figures are not a very reliable guide to the actual level of genuine unemployment. It is true also that they do not provide a reliable estimate of the change in the unemployment situation between 1970 and 1971 because of distortions in the statistics caused by some important changes in the coverage of the register and the effects of the cement strike in the first half of 1970.
However, making the best allowance we can for these various distortions, the position appears to be that the underlying increase in the number of unemployed in recent weeks as compared with the same time last year was about 9,000. As best as it can be calculated it appears to be about that figure. That is not a happy situation for anybody but, as I said earlier, I would prefer that as far as we can get the facts and know what we are talking about. As far as it can be ascertained that is the fact about unemployment this year as compared with last year.
There are a number of reasons for this and I would like to comment for a moment on the main reasons for it. First of all, there is the point made by Deputy FitzGerald — almost as though it were a new discovery on his part, but it is, of course, almost a cliché in economic and, indeed, in political circles — and that is conditions obtaining on the British Labour market. Unemployment started to rise significantly in Britain around early 1970 and thereafter it gradually worsened. A sharper and a more progressive determination set in in the beginning of 1971 when the ratio of unemployment to the total labour force reached 3 per cent for the first time for many years. The latest unemployment figures in Britain are the highest monthly total since the war and they represent almost 4 per cent of the labour force.
Comment on this
Of course, as a result of this situation potential Irish emigrants to Britain have been deterred from going there and they have been deflected to our labour market. We have not been able to absorb them all and consequently our unemployment rate has increased. That is one of the factors which affects our unemployment situation.
Another of the major factors is the generalised world recession in certain industries. In certain industries, notably textiles and footwear, there is on a worldwide scale, over-production, and under-consumption, or a combination of both. This has adversely affected employment and production in Irish firms in these industries.
Thirdly, there have been, of course, depressed demand conditions in foreign markets and this factor has affected many firms who are engaged in exporting but it has borne most heavily on firms producing capital goods or goods of a luxury nature. In this respect subsidiary firms of foreign-owned industry have been particularly badly hit by cut-backs in production made by their parent companies.
Comment on this
Of course the Minister has omitted the most important factor of all, the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement.
Comment on this
I have not finished yet, although if the Deputy examines it he will find that that is one of the minor factors.
Comment on this
There was talk yesterday about the footwear industry. Imports of footwear from the United Kingdom in 1965 were £300,000. They were £1½ million last year. Is that a minor factor?
Comment on this
Did the Deputy look at the situation in the footwear industry in this country before there was free trade, when there was only a quota? Did he look at the number of factories which closed down at that time?