We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Adjournment of Dáil: Motion.

Contributions 138–259 of 259. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Did the Deputy look at the situation of the footwear industry in countries other than Ireland and Britain which are not affected by the Free Trade Area Agreement? Let us keep it in perspective. There has, of course, been another factor in this which has been our own sluggish domestic demand. As Deputies know, demand rose by only 1½ per cent in 1970 and in the early part of this year it continued sluggish. This undoubtedly has had an adverse effect on some firms. Furthermore, we have had a situation of deteriorating competitiveness. The excessive wage increase of the last few years have caused unit wage costs to grow at a faster rate than those of our competitors and as a result some firms may not have been able to compete successfully and may have had to go out of business.

Comment on this

I have never seen a firm go out of business because of wage increases.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy please allow the debate to continue?

Comment on this

The Deputy might pay particular attention to what I am about to say. It should be noted that the industrial sectors which are most severely affected by higher labour costs are the labour intensive ones, namely, textiles, clothing, footwear, wood and furniture, paper and printing and part of the clay and concrete product industries. These are the industries that Deputy Corish referred to as the ones with high rates of redundancies. The Deputy might think about that.

Comment on this

It is just a make-up.

Comment on this

It is no use dismissing it in that way. There is a significance in it and the Deputy should not try to avoid it.

Comment on this

I have never seen a firm having to close down because of a wage increase. I challenge the Minister to quote an example of that.

Comment on this

Another factor which has been contributing to unemployment is, of course, bad management. A substantial proportion of the firms which have encountered difficulties in recent times have been private, family owned, family controlled companies and in many of these cases their management has often been inadequate to the task of coping with increased competition from imports. Another factor has been the substitution of new products which were being produced here. These are the main factors which have been responsible for the increase in unemployment in 1971. As I said, fortunately the indications are that their influence is waning somewhat. Over the last few months domestic demand has started to revive and this hopeful trend will continue.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement will not wane.

Comment on this

Prospects on the foreign markets are also more propitious than they were. The reflationary steps taken in Britain last July are now beginning to take effect and they should stimulate demand for our exports. Moreover, there are hopeful signs of an improvement on the rest of the international scene, particularly in relation to the action taken by the United States administration in recent months in connection with the international problem. There are hopeful signs that that situation is improving.

Comment on this

Where has it got?

Comment on this

I did not say it has got anywhere. I said there are hopeful signs. If the Deputy wants to interrupt me at least let him pay attention to what I am saying.

Comment on this

I asked where has it got? It is relevant.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy analyse that?

Comment on this

I think the Deputy understands the meaning of it all right.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, please.

Comment on this

One other quite heartening development is that there are indications that the rise in our unit wage costs in relation to those of our competitors is moderating. This is a vitally important factor.

Given the emergence of all these favourable circumstances it is reasonable to believe that our unemployment situation will improve. It should not be necessary, of course, but I should, perhaps, remind the House of it, that it is Government policy actively to promote the growth of employment by encouraging the expansion of existing industries and the establishment of new industries and this policy has been vigorously pursued since the introduction of the First Programme for Economic Expansion. As a result of that the number employed in the nonagricultural sector has been, with only slight interruptions, growing continuously over the last decade. The measures I announced in this House in October last were specifically designed as far as possible to provide results in this financial year by way of increased employment.

Deputy Corish quoted from the ESRI Economic Commentary to the effect that it appears likely that a continuation of present policies, even taking account of the most recent measures, is unlikely to reduce substantially the present level of employment in the course of 1972. This was the view of the authors of that commentary. He did not go on to quote further and, since he quoted that extract, I think I should quote what follows. He might, indeed, have continued to the next part, which is to the effect that, if a new wage agreement, which is significantly less inflationary than the current agreement, can be concluded then the expansion in real incomes and employment in 1972 will be much greater than foreseen in the projection set out in that commentary.

Comment on this

So the workers should not be compensated for the inflation.

Comment on this

What I am saying is that Deputy Corish did quote one bit but he did not quote another bit. What value does he attach to each quotation or does he attach equal value to both?

Comment on this

Are the Government the only people who may be selective in their quotations?

Comment on this

No. I am simply saying there are other quotations which can be cited and we can judge the value of each.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I do not care what the Minister says, the unemployment position is chaotic.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not here when I was dealing with that. I have given the reasons. I said, and I say it again, the unemployment situation is certainly not one that can give anybody any cause for joy, but it does not help us to have wild statements made about it. Let us find out the facts and the contributory causes.

Comment on this

I have them here.

Comment on this

If we want to improve the situation we must know these things.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

May I point out that the time for speakers is limited and Deputies are wasting the time of the House with these interruptions.

Comment on this

I do not think we have wasted a lot of time.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish referred to the EEC and I did intend to deal with the EEC but I shall not do so, not because I cannot — I should like to — but because, as the Ceann Comhairle has pointed out, the time is limited and I do not wish to prevent other speakers from getting in. There are, however, a few things I want to say. Deputy Cosgrave made reference yesterday to the Wilson proposals and he suggested it was a disgrace to have an initiative come from an Englishman—I hope I am not misquoting him — in order to get the parties here to band together. That was certainly my understanding of the general sense of what Deputy Cosgrave said. First of all, it is our contention and, I think, the contention of every Member of this House that to have a real political initiative in relation to the problem of Northern Ireland, that initiative must come from Britain. Britain set up the Six Counties and Britain maintains them. The initiative, therefore, must come from Britain. Secondly, is it not clear that an initiative from here would not of itself be successful? The real importance, therefore, of Mr. Wilson's proposals lies in the fact that this was an initiative from Britain. There are, of course, a number of points in Mr. Wilson's proposals which can only be described as unreal but, while I regard these as unreal, basically I regard his proposal, by and large, as an important contribution to the development of a political initiative. I think there was a great deal more in his proposals than many people may realise. Of necessity they had to be couched in somewhat vague terms but, as I say, I think there was more in them and is more in them than many people realise.

Comment on this

Is not the Minister's judgment completely subjective on the one he regards as unimportant?

Comment on this

I would, of course, agree with the Deputy and I think the proposals were so designed as to enable me to be exactly that and to enable Mr. Brian Faulkner to say something similar about other proposals. I think the proposals were specifically designed for that purpose.

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

And it is a matter now of one's subjective judgment, as Deputy Dr. Browne says, as to which are important and which are not. The real importance that emerged was the fact that this was a proposal from the Leader of the Opposition in Britain, proposals which were not rejected by the British Government, proposals which envisaged the re-unification of this country. That was the central and important part. Some of the details contained, perhaps, something that was not so obvious on the surface. I think Mr. Wilson went to considerable pains to try to devise a formula which took account of the reality of the difficulties we are facing, the reality on the ground, as it were. Whether or not he has the right formula, he has at least devised a formula designed to overcome the roadblock standing in the way of negotiations. For that reason I welcome his initiative and I welcome the fact that that initiative has not been rejected by the British Government. Everybody can read the significance of that. I had a number of other things I wanted to say and I am sure Deputy FitzGerald will be glad to hear I am not going to say them.

Comment on this

Delighted.

Comment on this

They would have been rather controversial from the point of view of his party and from the point of view of the Labour Party. For various reasons I am not feeling like being controversial at the moment.

Comment on this

The Christmas spirit.

Comment on this

It may be that or it may be something else. The last comment I have to make is that, when we are talking about the economic situation, we can disagree about causes but let us, at least, try to agree on the facts and then make our deductions from them.

Comment on this

In the 25 minutes left to me I shall endeavour to do my best. I thank the Minister for his having eschewed controversy to the extent of giving me at least that length of time. I want to say at the outset how disappointing was the Taoiseach's speech yesterday. It is, however, in the pattern of the system that Fianna Fáil have built up for Ministerial speeches. The whole purpose of a Ministerial opening speech is to set out the whole perspective before the House for the following debate and to state the issues so that they can be fully debated. Yet, traditionally, consistently, Fianna Fáil Ministers, and the Taoiseach himself, have adopted the practice of saying as little as possible in their opening speeches and keeping all the meat— sometimes rather stale meat — until their closing speeches to ensure that the debate will be as poor as possible and in that way they seek, as in other ways, to subvert the purpose of Parliament. The Taoiseach's speech was in that respect a disgrace. It was a disgrace in particular because he avoided any reference to the whole question of Northern Ireland and left the debate to that extent rudderless, hoping perhaps to capture more publicity for himself in his closing speech. That must be said in this House; it has already been stated in todays newspapers.

I want to deal with the economy while the Minister is still here. I accept what the Taoiseach said that there are likely to be significant improvements in the British economy next year which will help us. The latest forecast by the National Institute of Economic and Social Research in Britain is of a growth rate of just over 4 per cent accompanied, astonishingly, by a current external surplus of almost £1,000 million. That is going to help us but I do not think we should play down, as the Taoiseach and the Minister have played down the problems we face of inflation and the effects of the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement. I am sorry the Minister has to leave at this point because I want to answer some of the specific points he made in his speech.

Two dangers lie ahead of us as regards the growth of our economy in the next three years. It is helpful, as we approach a period when the worst effects of inflation and the worst effects of the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement are likely to hit us, that the British economy looks as though it is going to go into a period of boom but it may not be sufficient to insulate us from the effects of these two phenomena.

On inflation I challenge as untrue the Minister's statement that there is a tapering off of some kind in the rate of increase in the cost of living. No matter how one looks at this it is not happening. While the Minister was speaking I went to the Library and got the exact figures. They are given in three ways not one of which shows any sign of this tapering off. The figures show — we now have the November figures, the complete figures, therefore, for 1971 — that the increase in the consumer price index this year was 8.9 per cent, as against 8.2 per cent the previous year — that is not tapering off, that is creeping up — and the year before it was 7½ per cent. There is a consistent pattern of further acceleration. If we take the last nine months, which was a more recent period, the increase was 7 per cent. That is not an annual rate of 7 per cent but 7 per cent in nine months compared with 5½ per cent in the preceding nine-month period, running from the second quarter of 1970 to the first quarter of the current year. Even if we take the nine-month period the same process of acceleration appears. The latest increase shows a 2.4 point increase in the index and that is precisely the same increase as the previous quarter and precisely the same as the average for the last five preceding quarters. There is no sign of tapering off there, either. There is no way one can manipulate these figures, however selective one may be, to produce the result which the Minister claimed mendaciously in this House is the position at the moment.

Prices are not tapering off. We hoped they would. I thought they might. I am deeply disappointed this has not happened. I do not think we should discount, as the Minister and the Taoiseach seem to be discounting, the dangers of the situation, first, because of its impact on the second phase of the current wage round which is geared to increases in the cost of living. Faced with that situation the Government should have done everything to keep prices down. They should have tried to control increases in prices under their control and yet, as we know from the figures which the Leader of the Opposition read out yesterday, in every one of the cases in which a State body or the Government themselves are concerned increases in consumer prices in the past year have been far higher, in some cases four or five times higher, than increases in the private sector, ranging as they have from 12½ per cent to 50 per cent for a whole range of products and services. By permitting and encouraging this escalation of prices under their control the Government have seriously threatened the stability of the economy at this time. This is going to have a drastic effect upon the operation of the escalation clause for the second phase of the current round. There is a clear danger, which the Government ought to have realised, that this will also affect the negotiations which must take place during the next six months for the next wage round which for some workers will take effect from next July. The increase in the cost of living is something which workers rightly and understandably take into account in any claims they put forward. The way the cost of living has been permitted to rise faster and faster, despite what the Minister has said, constitutes a threat to the economy of a kind we may not be able to survive.

The only thing which has saved us to-date in this process of inflation is that other countries have inflated also. As it happens wage costs in other countries, with which we compete, have risen sharply in the past three years. They rose by 20 per cent in Germany, France and Japan and 25 per cent in Britain, not as high as here, but by amounts which at least come close to our inflation and have therefore helped to narrow the gap which otherwise would have existed between our wage costs and those of other countries and our competitiveness and those of other countries. Despite what has been happening elsewhere we still hold the record for inflation in Europe. This gap has to be closed, not widened. How is it to be closed with this continuing increase in prices generating pressure for a further wage round? If we get one more excessive wage round that gap could widen fatally to the point at which the parity of our currency will be threatened. The Government know this; they are trying to hide it, they are doing nothing to stop it, they have totally failed to tackle the problem of prices and incomes.

They sabotaged an incomes policy in 1969 when it would have been possible, if they had set their minds to it, to get agreement on an incomes policy in the wake of the maintenance workers' strike. They failed to do so. The proposals which came forward from the Government to employers and workers were so hostile and so unsympathetic to an incomes policy that they offered no encouragement and every discouragement to those concerned and contributed to the unwillingness of both sides to make the necessary sacrifices. Far from giving a lead in the matter the Government sabotaged it. One document put forward by the Government to these bodies was so bad that I suggested at at the time it should be withdrawn from circulation because of the damage it could do. The Government have failed to put across an incomes policy because they have no confidence in themselves and because they know the country has no confidence in them, the confidence a Government needs to get agreement on an incomes policy.

Not only have the Government sabotaged an incomes policy they have also sabotaged the National Economic Council, which was to replace the NIEC. This has been under negotiation for the whole of this year. The outcome has been that the Government, in their vindictive attempt to ensure that no trade unionist associated with the Labour Party and involved in membership of the Oireachtas should in any way feature on this council, have sabotaged the council; they have tried to dictate to the trade union movement that they shall not have members on the National Economic Council if these members happen to be members, in practice normally, of the Upper House. It is all right if they happen to be members of the Northern Ireland Senate but if they happen to be Members of the Seanad they are damned. Because of their determination to keep these people out, and because of their political bitterness and hostility to people who happen to be members of the Oireachtas, they have made it impossible for the council to be set up. This is one of the more disgraceful acts of this Government, an act for which they will not easily be forgiven because the national interest was at stake and they were prepared to set the national interest to one side for their own narrow, party political purposes.

The second problem we face in the period immediately ahead is the effect of the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement. We should guard ourselves here against confusion on this issue. Because of the interests some people have in trying to paint a picture of disaster in the Common Market there has been a tendency to play down the effects of the free trade area. The fact is that the free trade area has so far had a fairly limited effect, as was predicted. I originally did a calculation to try to show what the effect of this agreement would be. The conclusion I came to, which was published in The Irish Times and never challenged by anybody, was that the effect would be a diversion of something just under £50 million worth of trade from Irish manufacturers to British firms by 1975. That sum was expressed in 1965 money terms. I also came to the conclusion that this would happen by a gradual process which would not be linear at all but would involve very small effects at first, gradually gathering momentum and reaching a critical rate of impact in the years 1971 to 1974. Such an assessment as I have been able to make suggests that up to this point something like £10 million of this £45 million or £50 million of effects have been felt, which is exactly as I expected, and as anyone knowing how high Irish tariffs were, and knowing how they could be virtually halved without having much impact on the freeing of trade, would have expected. When they have been halved and when they reduce further below that to or near the point of free trade, the critical period arises. We now face that critical period. If we put a figure of £45 million on the damage that this agreement, which had so little to offer us in return, will do, of that amount £10 million perhaps has already been suffered. Another £35 million, perhaps, has to come in the next three years and it needs only simple division to show that the impact of the Agreement will accelerate enormously. From having affected our economy by something like £2 million a year, it will now affect it by about £12 million a year. There will be something like a fivefold or sixfold intensification of the adverse effects of this Agreement within the next three years. Already it has done some damage in the clothing and footwear industries. Those effects will become far more intense and those who have attempted to attribute the redundancy that has occurred to date exclusively to the Free Trade Area Agreement are in danger of missing the point, which is that we face very considerable redundancy before this Agreement even really hits us and we must not underestimate the damage it may yet do. We also face the underlying problem of technological unemployment which is causing a good deal of redundancy at present and the effects of the slump in tourism with its reaction on spending power in the economy which has slowed down our economic growth significantly in the past two years, one of the side effects of events in Northern Ireland.

Unfortunately for us, the compensating effects of EEC membership will not accrue immediately. None will accrue next year because we shall not be members and although in 1973 there will be the immediate bonus of £30 million agricultural subsidy transfer which will enable whatever Government is in power to make drastic improvements in our social services and compensate for some of the price effects of membership — more than compensate — the direct effect economically of membership will only occur gradually and cumulatively over a five-year period. It will not be until we have reached the stage when about 40 per cent of these effects are being felt, in mid-1975, that the impact on the economy will begin to become really striking.

We, therefore, face a period ahead in which the effect of inflation, the damage it may do our competitiveness and the damage that will be done to us by the Free Trade Area Agreement will hit us before we get significant benefit from EEC membership which will accrue really in the second half of the decade. The Government should not play down these dangers. I am not sure whether they are so stupid they cannot see them or whether they are dishonest and keeping quiet about them. Either way, it is our job to expose these dangers and try to ensure that the Government prepares for them, something they show very little sign of doing.

Finally on the economic side, on the question of unemployment and emigration, I have been depressed by the laborious way in which the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance have been dragging out these emigration figures. They know perfectly well that emigration figures derived from passenger movement statistics tell us something about the short-term movements in the British economy. The fact that the figure is down to 2,000 tells us that there is massive unemployment in Britain. It tells us nothing about our economy. Studies which I have carried out in the fifties and published then and since have shown conclusively that short term fluctuations in the level of this figure are totally dominated by the British situation. I can only recall one period of ten months in the last 20 years in which the movement of emigration in the short term, as indicated by these figures, bore any relationship to economic conditions in Ireland. What they do tell us about Irish economic conditions derives not from whether they are moving upwards or downwards but from the height of the peaks and the depth of the valleys. It is true that emigration in the 1960's has been very much lower than in the 1950's, perhaps no more than 40 per cent or even down to 25 or 30 per cent of the level of that period. I think I have never attempted to diminish that fact but have tried to expose its significance and get the Government to face the problems of economic growth arising from the fact that emigration has fallen, something they have been unwilling to face. That this figure is now fluctuating downwards tells us nothing about our economy; it tells us only that there is a big slump in Britain and high unemployment there. Trying to use these figures in the other way is spurious.

What the Government are entitled to say is that the very high level of unemployment at present is partly accounted for by the fact that there are no emigration opportunities in Britain and people are staying at home. This is true but only part of the truth. The real test of our economic growth is not in short term movements in emigration and unemployment but in the level of employment: how many jobs are there? What has been striking about the past two years is the very slow growth of employment and that in sectors where normally it increases it has not been increasing or not significantly. Those are the figures we should like to hear about from the Taoiseach. Lest there be any doubt about what these unemployment figures show and mean let me say that the only valid comparison we can make with past periods is in respect of figures for unemployment benefit. What they show, and it is an ominous fact, is that at the latest date for which comparable figures are available, the last week in November, the number receiving unemployment benefit was fractionally higher than the number at the end of November, 1956. As seasonal pressures mount and as these figures increase it seems we can expect a rise to a level even higher than the peak reached in the spring of 1957 which was the highest level reached for several decades past.

That is our position. It is not solely due to the mismanagement of the economy by the Government but is also due to the position in Britain, but when you take it in conjunction with the failure of employment to grow it is evident that there is something much more radically wrong here than the economic situation in Britain.

I want to say a word about EEC, mainly on one point, before moving on to Northern Ireland. Deputy Corish made some sort of distinction between people concerned with figures and people concerned with people and jobs. This is an utterly false distinction. The only figures that interest us as politicians on all sides of the House are figures that tell us something about people's welfare. There is no distinction between figures and people. Figures are the sum total, the aggregate of human problems and successes as a result of our efforts here. When we on this side of the House talk about EEC and say that it is a good thing that we should join we say so because we believe, and can show conclusively, that its effect on employment here will be radically favourable, just as staying out would have disastrous effects on employment. It is because of its effect on employment that we want to join, because the spending of the vast sums of additional foreign income accruing to Irish agriculture will generate enormous sums in wages, and incomes, partly in the form of additional jobs and partly in higher incomes. For that reason alone those of us concerned for the future economic and social welfare of the country favour membership. That needs to be plainly said.

In the White Paper due to come out next month let me urge the Government seriously to put forward the best estimate they can of these effects because if they fail to estimate the employment effects of membership in full and show what these are likely to be and if we are not given, for the purpose of this referendum, the facts to put before the people, distorted facts will be put forward by those who have an interest in keeping us out. It is up to the Government to produce a White Paper that gives the facts and does not dodge the issue. Every document they have so far produced on the Common Market has been useless, without a single hard fact or figure, nothing but talk in language which means nothing to the man in the street. If that is how they will tackle the referendum, if that is all the ammunition they give us and if that is all they give the Irish people by way of hard facts, the referendum may well be lost and, if it is, it will be the fault of the incompetent Government that will have caused it to be lost. Let me insist that the Government in that White Paper do their job if they want to win the referendum and sometimes one wonders if they are serious about it, they have handled it so ineptly.

Turning now to the North, I suppose that realistically it is better to start with the catalogue of mistakes that have been made. All of us have made mistakes and the tragic situation in the North is the result. Perhaps one of the first mistakes made, if I may say so, was made by the Northern Opposition. I am speaking from hindsight and I do not claim that at that time I saw the significance of this or that, if I had been in their shoes, I should have done otherwise because they were facing a situation without precedent. They made the mistake of having a reform programme which when conceded in principle and largely in fact, though not completely, of course, after August, 1969, left them in the position that they were not clear where they wanted to go. In retrospect we can see that it was essential they should have had a clear programme of drastic political change to put forward so that in that brief honeymoon period before the IRA could mobilise their forces to provoke the British Army and to cause the conflict and bloodshed in the North the real fundamental political reforms could have been pushed through. Unfortunately, disconcerted, perhaps, by the ease with which the reforms were granted after the tragic events of August, 1969, they did not have concrete proposals to put forward.

The Northern Government made their mistakes also. They were offered a chance by the Civil Rights movement to make a fresh start, to undo all the injustices they had committed and to join with the minority in Northern Ireland in trying to create within that community a society that would work on the basis that having built up a genuine and just society, in time the whole question of the Border could be considered in a dispassionate way.

There was a willingness on the part of those engaged in the Civil Rights movement and in the Northern Opposition to put Partition on one side for a period, to say: "Let us first create a just society here and then let us discuss Partition." There was a willingness on their part to take the issue of Partition out of politics, perhaps, to make it a matter for referenda at regular intervals so that party politics in the North could adopt a different approach.

The Northern Government could have grasped that opportunity. Had they done so, the North today would be peaceful, governed jointly by Unionist and Nationalists in a single administration, working together with an agreement to disagree for the time being about Partition, which could be left to the people of Northern Ireland to decide for themselves in referenda. However, with a lack of imagination characteristic of the Unionist Party and their history, they failed to accept the opportunity.

The British Government also failed to grasp the opportunity provided by this honeymoon period. They failed to grasp the duty they owed to their own army. They put their army into the North as a peace-keeping force but every sensible person knew this could not last indefinitely. It was the right answer at that time, it was rightly demanded by the Catholics for their protection—whatever shock this may have been to the sensibilities of some so-called Republicans down here.

However, the situation was bound to deteriorate. Always there are evilly-disposed people who want to cause trouble, people who cannot tolerate the idea of fraternisation between the Catholics in Belfast and the British Army. These people were prepared to start a campaign of murder in order to bring that honeymoon period to an end. During this period a solution could have been found but the British Government, with their customary lack of imagination, breathed a sigh of relief when peace appeared, turned their minds elsewhere, and allowed the opportunity to pass. They made a second appalling blunder—the blunder of introducing one-sided internment, accompanied by what they so euphemistically call "ill treatment" but what we, more realistically, call "brutality".

It is extremely difficult for the British Government to extricate themselves from that appalling blunder. They have locked up in Long Kesh hundreds of people, a fair proportion of whom are IRA men, although not all because of the ineptitude with which they chose the people whom they interned. They can say that they cannot let these people out to make the situation worse on the streets but, at the same time, they know that if they do not find a solution to internment, if they cannot find a way of charging these people before some kind of tribunal acceptable to the minority in the North, there cannot be any negotiations, never mind peace. By their mistake the British Government have made it almost impossible to find such a solution but they must find a way out.

Our Government have made their mistakes too. We all have but I think the Government have made more than their share. Anyone who reads the Fine Gael document of September, 1969, with its proposals for re-union by consent and for a joint Government of the minority and the majority in Northern Ireland, will find in it something generous and far-sighted. I think this puts us in a more favourable position than the Government to claim some credit.

Our Government have failed to carry conviction with the British Government on the question of tactics and the solution in Northern Ireland because of their refusal to tackle the IRA down here. This was a most unfortunate blunder. There are various possible reasons for it: fear of repercussions among their own supporters; fear of public unpopularity; the politician's desire to put off the evil day and hope that something will turn up, that some lunatic IRA men would start a campaign of murder down here and make it easier for the Government. There may even have been some kind of half-baked Machiavellian calculation of the kind this Government are capable of that they had better keep this kind of threat alive so that they would have some bargaining power with the British when they come to the conference table.

Any of these reasons may have contributed to this unfortunate decision but the failure of the Government to act in good time against the IRA has meant they have lost their position as second guarantor they so proudly claimed. They have lost credibility and influence with the British Government. If I were a member of the British Government at this time I could not take seriously the views put forward by a Government in Ireland that have failed completely to make a minimum contribution to peace and the avoidance of murder in this island. All the advantages the Government had built up by some intelligent and astute policies in the past have been dissipated by this unfortunate blunder and now they are not in a position to influence events.

There must be two elements to any solution in Northern Ireland. First, any solution must be such as to end the alienation of the minority from authority, to bring them back into the position where they can accept the authority of those who rule them. This must be done without alienating the majority. There is nothing to be gained by exchanging a one-third alienated section for a two-thirds alienated section of the population. The necessary changes must be made skilfully and subtly, in a manner acceptable to majority opinion and in which the majority can acquiesce.

Secondly, any solution must create conditions likely to favour reunion of this island by consent. Those are the two aims we should have, that everyone should have who is concerned to achieve peace in this island. The achievement of such a solution must be preceded by whatever steps are necessary to make negotiations possible. Given those two elements, the need to achieve negotiations first, Britain at this point must take the initiative, as the Minister for Finance pointed out.

The British Government must charge before some legal tribunal those people whom they have interned and transfer security to Westminister so that the SDLP and the Nationalist Party can enter into discussions that will lead to a solution. There can be no solution until they talk; they cannot talk without losing all credibility with the minority unless the British take this course of action.

The British Government must accept the principle of participation of the Opposition in government in Northern Ireland. This was done implicitly by the Home Secretary in his speech in the House of Commons in September but, as it was repudiated immediately in three speeches within five days by the Northern Ireland Prime Minister, that particular statement seems to have been left in abeyance.

Since then, the Northern Government in their Green Paper have gone on record as rejecting absolutely the possibility of participation by the minority in government. With regard to the Green Paper, I am indebted— as we all are—to Captain Brooke who has sent us today a number of basic documents about Northern Ireland which will help us to understand the problems there. We should all be grateful to him and be glad to have even this minimal communication from Northern Ireland.

In the Green Paper it states:

On three points however they are unable to admit of any compromise whatever...

Here a genuine Northern "no surrender" spirit comes through. I shall quote only the first point listed:

The maintenance of Northern Ireland as an integral part of the United Kingdom in accordance with the statutory guarantee of the Ireland Act, 1949.

The paper also states:

It is clear that no person who would not also accept these over-riding principles could join with Ministers of the present Government in the exercise of collective responsibility, nor could any "broadly-based administration" so constituted survive for long the inevitable and intolerable strains upon it.

When those words were penned and, indeed, when before they were penned, as far as we know, the Northern Premier three times reiterated that there could be no compromise on this, he signed his own political death warrant. Once he said there could be no participation in Government, his chance of continuing in Government disappeared. I cannot understand why he does not see that. It is his inability to see that, it is his dedication to the short term, to surviving until next week instead of looking ahead to next year and the next decade, which will destroy him and destroy the Unionist regime. They should have had the wit to see that, only if they accepted that, could they remain in power, sharing power, and with 65 per cent of the power in Northern Ireland.

Thirdly, as well as taking these steps to make negotiations possible, and as well as accepting and implementing the principle of Opposition participation in Government, Britain must also state her desire for a united Ireland and willingness to assist towards that aim, and set up some mechanism that will lead in this direction at the kind of pace that can offer people sufficient hope to end their present frustration.

Mr. Wilson has made a noble attempt to find a way out along these lines. Of course, any such movement towards reunion must be with the consent or acquiescence of the majority in Northern Ireland. We do not seek on this side of the House—and I believe this is true of the other side of the House also—to impose, or to have imposed by British arms, reunion without the consent of a majority. We want Britain to say she looks forward to such reunion. We would like said, at least at the minimum, what was said in the 1920 Act by people like Lloyd George and Churchill—and if they could say it surely Ted Heath can say it now 50 years later.

The Northern Government must accept this package or get out. They seem to be committed to getting out. That is their tragedy, not ours. The Northern Opposition must try to make this package work when it has been agreed. They must use their influence, which they have retained through their participation in the civil disobedience campaign, with the minority to get this package accepted and to get law and order restored in Northern Ireland.

What must we do? I must now turn to our responsibility. Our responsibility is to get rid of the partitionist and sectarian features introduced mainly by Fianna Fáil, and perpetuated solely by Fianna Fáil, in this part of the country. We must show that we believe in a pluralist society. I know it is argued that Protestants do not really want contraception or divorce and that most of them would never dream of getting divorced and many of them, perhaps most, would not dream of using contraceptives. That is not the point. Those who argue like that fail to understand the Protestant mind. They cannot get inside it. They are so governed by the authoritarian Catholic traditon that they cannot see how the Protestant mind works. It is not that Protestants want to do these things necessarily; it is that they do not want to be prevented from doing them by law. They believe in individual freedom and that belief is the great heritage of the Williamite revolution from which we all benefit and which we all share. Indeed, if we were transferred back to 1689, with our present mentalities and outlooks. I suspect that we would probably all be Williamites because of that very fact.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has one minute left.

Comment on this

We must try to understand their motivations. We must try to get rid of those features in our system which are alien to them. It must be said that some of these were brought in by the first Government, in good faith, and failing to understand precisely what was involved: the requirement of a knowledge of Irish for State employment; and of Irish in the Intermediate Certificate ante-dated the coming of Fianna Fáil to power. For all the rest Fianna Fáil are responsible. They are responsible for the encouragement and tolerance of the IRA in the 1930s, and all the damage that did to good relations between North and South, and all the damage it has done by keeping the IRA alive since then.

They are responsible in 1934 for introducing compulsory Irish in the Leaving Certificate, even when 95 per cent of the people were already taking Irish. In 1935 they brought in the law against contraception. In 1937 they brought in the provision against divorce in the Constitution and the special position of the Catholic Church. This was the hey-day of Fianna Fáil clericalism and partitionism. Throughout that period they brought in, and have since maintained, a system of jobbery which would mean that the Unionists would certainly get jobs down here if they were Protestant Fianna Fáil-ers, they would be excluded from employment as so many other people are from so many jobs today.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Order now provides for a speaker from the Labour Party.

Comment on this

Could I have two minutes?

Comment on this

Certainly. There is no difference between us.

Comment on this

What have they done now? At this very moment in time they have done two things to copperfasten Partition because they cannot get away from the partition-mindedness that is such a feature of that party. First they rejected in the Seanad the Bill to deal with contraception, showing how little they care for our relationship with Northern Ireland and the Protestants of Northern Ireland. Secondly, they introduced this abortion of a community schools proposal which is designed to abolish our multi-denominational vocational schools in favour of Catholic schools, at the very time when we should be turning our minds in the opposite direction. This is Fianna Fáil's contribution.

What I want to ask the Taoiseach when he is replying—and I would ask Deputies opposite to write down these points and ensure that the Taoiseach replies to them—is: is the Taoiseach prepared to make the necessary changes? Is he prepared now? Can we trust this Government to make the necessary changes? Can we trust them to drop the Irish language policy? Can we expect them to change the law on contraceptives? Will he say here and now that he will do that? Is he prepared to drop the community schools proposal, or will he persist in it regardless of its effects on our relationship with the North? Is he prepared to drop the whole divisive doctrine of a Gaelic Catholic state which Fianna Fáil invented, and Fianna Fáil fostered, and Fianna Fáil are now attempting to perpetuate? If he answers those questions in one way, we will know where we stand. If he answers them in another way, in a Fianna Fáil way, we and the Unionists in Northern Ireland will know how much he and his party care for the reunification of this country.

Comment on this

I should like to recommend to the House the Christmas Covenant message published in all the principal newspapers today.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Some Members of this House have already signed it and I hope other Members of the House and many ordinary people will also sign it. I hope that the majority of Irish people, North and South, will sign it. I should like for the record to quote one portion of this Covenant:

...Certain that the majority, North and South, are ordinary people who realise that peace will only come to our island through understanding, love, confidence and courage; aware that in some areas, each section of the community is genuinely afraid of the others, or, at least, of some of the others; mindful that the thing we most have to fear is fear itself, recognising that in this situation it takes greater courage to make concessions and be friends with the people we are expected to hate, than to put up the traditional barricades in our streets or in our minds, each one of us, Protestant and Catholic alike, do now solemnly promise in the Name of the Lord Jesus Christ Who binds us together in love— that never, under any circumstances, will we take up arms to attack our fellow-countrymen, that we will not use, threaten or countenance the use of violence to achieve political ends, or to coerce any section of the community into conformity with beliefs which they do not share—that at Christmastide and throughout 1972 we will try to make personal contact with people from whom we are at present divided, and that we will fight fear with friendship...

I commend that Covenant to the House. I am opening my remarks by referring to that Covenant because it is a real initiative by ordinary people and the problem before the whole country calls for this type of real initiative. I especially underline the words:

...in this situation it takes greater courage to make concessions and be friends with the people we are expected to hate, than to put up the traditional barricades in our streets or in our minds....

We have a situation of real tragedy before us. The question I should like to ask is: what can we covenant to do here in this House? We recognise that there are difficulties in the whole situation for politicians and for ordinary people North and South. There are those who talk about nothing more explicit than an eventual unity, avoiding the very difficult political terrain of the means to achieve that unity. If we simply confine our remarks on the North to a reiteration of our desire for territorial unity, while we will lose no friends on this side of the Border, we will make no appreciable advance on the other side.

The difficulty arises when we talk about the means. If one speaks about the means of ending the violence that is rending the Northern community and, in my view, postponing eventual unity, one is accused of abandoning the objective of unity. I still believe in the achievement of the unity of this country by consent and agreement. Over the year I have done my best to acquaint myself with the main elements which constitute the Northern question so far as anybody who has not lived under that sectarian regime can understand those elements.

The first elected position I held in any national organisation was when in Belfast in 1960 I was elected deputy president of the Union of Students in Ireland. In that organisation I learned at first hand how difficult it is to keep a group of people working across Border and to retain in a divided country a national organisation operating in the entire Thirty-two Counties. Later, I worked with the Irish Congress of Trade Unions as their education officer and learned again, at first hand, from 1963 to 1965 of the stresses and difficulties that lie in the path of even a labour organisation, a trade union organisation which seeks to preserve worker solidarity and co-operation across religious and political barriers. In 1966 I was a founder member of the Irish Council of Labour and I would say that in the period 1965-66, in the course of preparation for the establishment of the council which at that period included the NILP and what was then the Republican Labour Party and also ourselves, I made as many visits to Northern Ireland as others either in this House or outside it are likely to make in their entire lifetime. I have reached my own conclusion on the Northern problem and this conclusion is based on my experience of working there. I am my own man on the North of Ireland.

For those who wish to check on my interest in Northern Ireland since entering public life they may check the records of the Eighteenth Dáil. No Deputy in this House during that Dáil asked more questions than I on the actual growing development of the Northern area and I include among those better-advertised republicans since who were Members of that Dáil but who did not appear as concerned then with the problem. Therefore, I will take second place to no one in the extent of my commitment to the ideal of seeking the unity of my country. During the years in Opposition I have spared no personal efforts, even when many older heads told me that I should mind my own Twenty-six County business, to try to learn at first hand the elements of the Northern situation. I am a republican and a socialist but my republicanism belongs to an older tradition than that invoked presently in many parts of the country. I follow a republican who was called Tone who spent his life striving to cross the religious and political divides in an efforts to create a State that would have the possibility of independence within it. I do not follow that republicanism which relies on a 30-second period before the bomb goes off to convince people of the righteousness of their cause.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I do not want to be known as the native of a country, the citizen of a State or a member of a movement that, for one moment, would permit the condonation of such methods. All of us know what is happening in Northern Ireland or if there is anybody who does not know, there is no excuse for him. Civil society has broken down there. Armed soldiers roam the streets, search houses and shoot recklessly. The internment camps operate and the IRA practise counter-violence. A question I would like to ask the House is this: do we think that the destruction of civilised standards of behaviour is confined to Northern Ireland? I recall during previous debates that from listening to Members of this House one would imagine that the problem of Northern Ireland was practically at the North Pole. Are there not signs that the rest of Ireland at the moment, that part of the country that is operating under a democratic State—there never was democracy in Northern Ireland—is now being infected by the pus from the running sore that is now Northern society? Is it not true that people are becoming less shocked by the brutalities and killings which only 12 months ago would have provoked horror? Over a short time we have travelled a terrible road of horror, from the explosion in the offices of the Northern Ireland Electricity Board, which resulted in the maiming and killing of several persons, the explosion at McGurks Bar and at Moffets furniture store. How much further must we travel this dark road of horror to the next atrocity?

This coarsening of moral response to Northern atrocities is occurring throughout the rest of Ireland. Even if I cannot condone the feelings of revenge, in the heart of a member of the minority in Northern Ireland when he considers his lot at the hands of the Unionist regime during many years, the selective justice, the sectarianism practice by the Unionist regime, I can understand them. His memory of such things must go a long way towards explaining his attitude. However, there is no excuse in this part of the country for the coarsening of responsibility to the horrible events in Northern Ireland. For 40 or 50 years we neglected Northern Ireland and had no interest in what went on there.

Comment on this

Absolutely none.

Comment on this

It was a tricolour slogan at election time and the fate of all people of Northern Ireland was a familiar come-all used here at election time. The troubles of the Northern people were milked for vote yield at elections for purely Twenty-six County political considerations. Therefore, I cannot forgive or justify such rapid coarsening of moral response of many people in this part of the country, a part of the country which, through its political institutions and media, ignored the real North for so long.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not wish us to help them now?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy O'Leary.

Comment on this

That coarsening of response has now reached the stage that one's sincerity on the unity question is queried on the basis of the sympathy one extends, whether that sympathy is expressed at a Unionist or a non-Unionist death. Death notices are acquiring a political complexion. I mourn the victims of all the Northern killings. The Northern problem, essentially, cannot be solved by violence. Violence cannot contribute at all in settling the Northern question. I accept that the Stormont structure was an instrument of violence and coercion down through the years, I accept that the conduct of the Army now seems to be a continuation of that same violence but I cannot forget either that illegal organisations set out deliberately to push the Army in the direction of their present tactics. I will not accept any sophisticated argument or alibi for a continuation of the violence or any argument to the effect that we should accept this continuation and learn to live with it.

People condemn violence but they are afraid to name it. I will name the authors of violence. There is Stormont violence, there is British Army violence, and there is IRA violence. This was put well by Dr. Daly, Bishop of Ardagh and Clonmacnoise, when he said that the evidence mounts, as news bulletin follows bulletin, that the tree of violence is evil and that its fruits become more ruthlessly evil with every bomb and every cold blooded murder. He went on to say that the bishops have no less courageously condemned the brutalities and inhumanities of the other violence which is military repression and that the bishops have not ceased to declare that the basic injustice which the long standing denial of political and social equality in the North represents must be tackled boldly at its roots. In that the bishop names the agents of violence and that is a practice I would commend to every Member of this House. On this side of the Border it is easy to name British Army violence. We will lose no friends by doing so but we must have the political courage to name the other kind of violence that might lose us friends on this side of the Border. It is my conviction that this violence cannot contribute to a settlement.

Nobody who knows the Northern community now denies the horrible, undeniable fact that the component parts of that Northern Community have never been so distant from one another. Does any Member of this assembly here think that we are advancing on the high road to a united Ireland when every bomb, blast and bullet fired divides further that suffering Northern community? One would need to be totally, abysmally ignorant of Northern affairs to think that unity is advanced by these violent methods.

The British Government have made high-sounding noises about political talks. Maudling, their Home Secretary, spoke of a permanent, active and guaranteed role for the minority in the North. He has done very little to amplify that particular statement. It has just been left in the air and it is now acquiring all the connotations of a cliché. This whole Northern situation is full of clichés from both sides. Probably the most hopeless cliché of that situation is that so much depends on a new enlightened approach on the part of the British Government. The problem cannot be settled without that Deus ex machina, that change, that disposition on the part of the British Government to create the conditions that will permit political talks to take place. Unless they work to create those conditions our common country goes further down the road to ever renewed. ever increasing violence and no end can be seen to the nights and days of terror. As long as the British fail, and they have persistently failed, to take the initiative to set up the conditions for these talks, we cannot be faulted for concluding that the main objective of the Westminister Government is in reality the maintenance of a sectarian Unionist regime at all costs and at the expense of the political, legal, civil and economic rights of the minority.

We must not give way to despair but it would be foolish to deny that there are elements of despair in this horrible situation. How interested are the British people in reaching a settlement of this problem? How important is it to their politicians that it should be settled? Where would the Irish question come in the priorities of British politicians at present? We must not give way to despair, but the thought often occurs to me that probably Britain would not greatly care about the fate of democracy, North or South of the Border, as long as no trouble accrued to them.

Anyone with the slightest knowledge of the Northern problems knows that the participation of the SDLP in talks is essential if we are to get any significant political initiative and they cannot take part in talks because of the existence of internment without trial. Of course, it is a vicious circle. Internment without trial was introduced by the British Government probably on the advice of Brian Faulkner. It represented a terrible, a major error on the part of the Heath administration because it signified to the minority in Northern Ireland that nothing had really changed despite all the high talk about reform, it signified that the coercive core of the regime was still maintained intact. When Heath agreed to the introduction of that interment without trial the Downing Street declaration was dead on that day.

The SDLP have taken this stand that they cannot take part in talks as long as the situation persists where people are interned without trial. Surely it is not beyond the power of the British Government to use their full authority to exert the necessary influence on the Stormont security authorities to bring internment without trial to an end as this is a precondition to talks which the SDLP could attend. Could the British Government look into the possibility of taking security totally out of the hands of the Stormont authorities? Admittedly we will not take security out of the hands of the Stormont authorities without the resignation of Brian Faulkner. I do not know whether that is a great loss to Irish political life. He has said that he will resign if security is taken out of their hands. I think the resignation of Brian Faulkner is a small price to pay. I think security should be taken out of the hands of the Stormont authorities. Their handling of security over the years leaves a great deal to be desired and accounts for a great deal of the present trouble in that area, the one-sided way in which they have applied justice over the years. The British Government must create the conditions where political talks can take place. This would be a major contribution towards the achievement of peace.

When one makes suggestions in the area of achieving political settlement, one at all times encounters risks. You encounter risks because you must talk about the situation as it now is and you cannot simply pin all your statements to a future united Ireland. So I recognise the risks in making any suggestion, any statement on the situation as it now is. I think it would be a major contribution to peace if the British Government, within the next two weeks, were to take over total control of security and reduce the British military presence in those areas of Northern Ireland where it is at present no more than a provocation.

It is true that when the British troops first came in in August, 1969, they were welcomed by the minority as their protectors. This is true. It is on record. This happened in Belfast. At that stage we were seeing the beginnings of a civil war there and the army came in to protect the minority. It is no less true today that that army has justifiably secured the enmity and hostility of the minority there. It would be a signal improvement in the situation if the British Government could recognise this changed approach to the British Army on the part of the minority.

Earlier this week when Mr. Maudling went home from his press conference I made the point in a statement I put out that I believed Mr. Maudling did not yet appreciate this changed attitude towards the British Army in Northern Ireland. I have mentioned the organisations that had a hand in this changed disposition of the majority towards the army, but I also noted that a contributory factor of the changed approach of the British Army was undoubtedly the change of Government in Westminster. While I may make a criticism that, on the overall sweep of British politics, Irish affairs may have little interest, little significance, for the great majority of that population, it is a fact that the Labour Government that went out at the last election at least attempted to learn the elements of the Northern problem. They showed a capacity to learn which Mr. Heath's administration does not share, even if they had the interest, which I doubt. Their handling of the problem has been inept. They have shown too much reliance on army force alone, they have relied totally on the advice of Brian Faulkner. Evidently they have relied on his advice in relation to the introduction of internment without trial. They should abandon reliance on the political advice of Mr. Brian Faulkner.

What is the role of Mr. Brian Faulkner at present in Northern politics? Fighting for his own personal political survival. That is his role. Has Mr. Faulkner shown any development in his thinking as he looks at his community in ruins around him? Is there any sign of recognition that the old days of Stormont are over over for ever; any sign of recognition on his part that he is titular head of a community that is totally divided now; any evidence of a recognition on his part that he may look towards Dungannon, where portion of the people supposedly under his control, run their own Assembly? Is there any recognition on the part of Mr. Faulkner about this situation? Is there any evidence of it in his political approach? The answer is in the negative. He has shown no development in his response to the gathering crisis. He has rejected proportional government. He has rejected the possible presence of anti-partitionists in any future cabinet of a restructured administration of the area and he rejects the idea, as I said previously, that security should be transferred to Westminster.

So, we have to use our pressure here from Dublin on the British Government to attempt to force that Government to create the political conditions that will allow the talks to take place, that will allow the possibility of the violence ending, that will allow the possibility of the establishment of a new form of administration in Northern Ireland which would see a true sharing of power between both elements in the community there. That seems to me the necessary evolutionary step to the united Ireland that all of us in this House seek. If the talks which I suggest are essential do not take place, there will be no elected leaders to talk to eventually. Do the British Government want that situation? Do our own Government here want that situation where there are no elected leaders to speak to finally? I do not know. I hope our own Government see the necessity of preserving the possibility of the SDLP taking part in talks, accept the necessity for this, accept that those elected leaders are essential in any talks on the matter, but the hopeless feeling I have is whether this concern is shared by the British authorities. I do not know whether that goodwill exists in the present Tory Government, that commitment to settle the problem exists there. Does it exist? Events seem to belie that it does.

I often ask myself whether any British Government would be unduly perturbed to see this whole island drift away into a kind of Haiti, a place run by Dr. Duvaliers, on both sides of the Border, a kind of Fascist morass. I remember that in the Adjournment Debate at Christmas, 1967, I said, in respect of cross-Border talks which were then taking place, that if we did not get results from the so-called liberal ways that were supposed to be swamping the Unionist Party, then we had our remedy in going to the British Government and looking for change. And I remember at that stage asking that the price of our participation in cross-Border talks should be the achievement of a real democracy in the Six Counties.

As I said, there is no difficulty when talking on this question if you restrict your comments and your remarks to the wide sphere of eventual unity. You encounter difficulty in this part of the country only when you talk about the difficult political terrain of the means to achieve that unity, especially when you are talking about the complex matter of achieving that unity by democratic agreement and consent. It is a simple matter if you are talking about a unity by force, a unity that depends on shooting other people. There is no complexity about that. You simply get the statistics of the number of people to be shot and set about it. But that is not my way. If we are out to get that unity by consent, then we are involved in the business of seeing an end to the violence that exists at present in Northern Ireland, in bringing about the basis on which political talks can take place and this, as I say, involves us in risks, because we will have to talk about the actual steps that are necessary to be taken. I believe there is that duty on politicians here at the present time, that they must be prepared to take these risks. If we are in any way sincere about our common country, we must be prepared to take these risks and must resist the temptation to appeal solely to Twenty-six County prejudices.

But, if the people who seek unity by violent means are inexact or vague about the kind of Ireland they seek, there is a very clear duty on the part of democratic politicians to spell out clearly the kind of united country they eventually seek. Quite honestly, in this assembly here, we have not done our duty in that respect. This assembly has not spelled out the shape, composition, the kind of united Ireland we all seek on the basis of agreement and consent. That is why—there was nothing original in the suggestion which had been made previously by other parties in this House—when I asked the Taoiseach to set up an inter-party committee, I suggested as a necessary task of that inter-party committee here that we should have attached to it a full secretariat which would work out the constitutional implications of the united Ireland but which would not overlook the economic implications of that united Ireland.

How many of the people who are around our country at the moment declaring passionately their interest in a united Ireland realise or care for the kind of economic lives they may lead in the united Ireland? Do they know whether redundancies would or would not occur in a particular industry, where jobs would grow? Have we thought of these questions? If we are talking about a united Ireland it is essential also to consider the economic dimensions of that idea. It is important to bring the question down from the present state of abstraction in which it now is. Let us fill out the concept of the united Ireland with economic bones and flesh. Let us state what should be the fundamental guiding principles of that Constitution and let us not postpone necessary changes in the area of our own jurisdiction now that would anticipate those future changes in a united Ireland. We need not stand idly by in the context of our own Constitution. here is something we may change now. We need not stand idly by in the context of economic arrangements in this part of the country.

Here are things, in fact, that we may do. If sectarianism was elevated into a State principle in Northern Ireland, if they are now suffering for that elevation of that unholy principle, let us admit also that, not to the same degree, there are aspects in our own conduct of civil affairs here that smack also of sectarianism and let us as a testimony to the sincerity of our opposition to that State sectarian murder machine in Northern Ireland, erase, eradicate and eliminate those features from our own civil life down here. Such a determination on our part would be a genuine register of our sincerity.

It would be of no assistance whatever to the achievement of that united Ireland that we should allow democratic institutions in the rest of Ireland to languish. Politicians must ask themselves what is the significance of legislatures that have been set up in this part of the country, and politicians in this House who might be prepared to take the ordinary counsel of caution and walk on the other side of the road must ask themselves are these so-called legislatures which have been set up aimed at democratic institutions such as this which have been set up by the people. That is the question they must ask. They cannot avoid answering this question.

The Minister for Justice, Deputy O'Malley announced last night that he was thinking of changing the ordinary law of this land into some new form which he described as an inquisitorial form. From my reading of the papers today, it would seem that this would change the ordinary rule that a man is innocent until declared guilty. I am not in favour of any changes in the law of the land. I am simply issuing this warning in this House: "Let us ensure that democracy prevails in this part of the country. Let us see that democratic institutions are not undermined in this part of the country. Let not our emotions at events in Northern Ireland blind us into letting liberty slip from the people's control on this side of the Border." I see no need for any twist of the legal rules to ensure that democratic institutions survive in this part of the country. I do not want that Government, or any Government, to allow events so to slip that they come here to us during a recess or at any other time and announce the introduction down here of internment without trial. We are implacably opposed to such a step. We believe it would be the end for democracy on this side of the Border if internment were introduced. We do ask that democratic institutions be protected under the ordinary laws of the land as they exist.

Last week I was visited by representatives of the dependants of internees in Northern Ireland. A representative of the Taoiseach's party was visited also. Financial aid was sought for the relations of people who are now interned. We ought not to forget that the sacrifice is not confined to those who are interned. There are their dependants who are deprived of the earnings of the people who are locked up. They told me that the Taoiseach had expressed his willingness to help financially in order to give assistance to the internees committee which has been set up. Canon Murphy of St. Peter's in the Falls is on this committee. They are a reliable committee of honest people. The Taoiseach has expressed his willingness to offer financial aid. I would endorse that call for financial aid. We have, in this assembly over the years, given donations and cash to necessary causes around the world. I do not know how the rules would permit it, but I suggest it would be a more real mark of the concern of the people of this part of the country, to give some financial assistance before Christmas on a subvention basis to the internees' dependants. There would be no inter-party bickering on the matter. This is something we could all agree on. There is not a person in this assembly who is not in favour of the unity of this country. We should not indulge in any childish rivalry about it, saying: "So-and-so is more for it than somebody else". We are all at one in this matter of the achievement of unity, and, I would hope, the democratic means.

The Northern question is probably the biggest issue before the country. I know from my own contacts in Northern Ireland that over the years people there have desired, in so far as it is possible, a united voice from a free Ireland on the Northern question. Would the Taoiseach look again at the idea of expanding the all-party committee that has been suggested into one that would devise a joint approach on the part of all parties attached to this assembly on the Northern question, so that all of us could subscribe to it and do what Northern people have over the years requested—attempt to lift the Northern question out of the arena of 26-county constituency politics? Surely we should attempt that task because the problem is grave enough to risk the trouble involved in creating this kind of joint party approach.

The Taoiseach appears to think that we need simply restrict ourselves to Constitutional matters. I do not think this is good enough. The people, North and South, require a united approach on the part of the elected representatives. We could do this if we worked together and provided the committee with a full-time secretariat. We could in a relatively short time, have in outline the blueprint for a united Ireland, economically and constitutionally. How can we say we are sincere about a policy of achieving unity of this country by agreement and consent if, in fact, we do not do any homework on the economic and constitutional implications of that united Ireland. We must fill in the conception of this idea of unity with more facts and introduce a note of realism rescuing this ideal of a united Ireland from abstraction. If we seek to persuade people in Northern Ireland about the validity of that united Ireland proposition, then we must give them the blueprint of the model. We have not yet started on that work.

For many years CIO committees roamed this country in preparation for our entry into Europe. We should make some investigation of the potentiality of industry in a united Ireland situation and Constitution. In ending my speech I would simply say that the times we live in mean that all politicians in this assembly know that democracy no longer exists in Northern Ireland. Civil administration has broken down. Some people may still look comfortably at that situation and say that it does not touch us.

I am saying, in closing this Adjournment Debate for the Labour Party, that democracy on this side of the Border is also on trial. Let no member of this assembly forget that. In 1967, also in the Christmas debate, I said that it should be our function to attempt to get a real democracy functioning in the Six Counties. We must still attempt that task in far more difficult conditions now. We must use our influence to whatever extent it exists with the British Government, to ensure that we bring about the political condition for those talks. We must ensure that the SDLP can go to those talks. We must change those features in our own way of life and in our own Constitution that need to be changed. We must fill out a blueprint of a united Ireland to be devised by all three parties in this House. Again, we must reassert the authority of this lawful, democratically elected assembly. We must not, whatever our politics are, and whatever travail we go through, subscribe to any undermining of this democratic institution. This is a democratic institution. We do not assist towards the establishment of a united Ireland by consent or agreement if democracy should fail on this side of the Border.

Comment on this

First of all, I would like very sincerely to congratulate Deputy Michael O'Leary on the speech he has just made. If we heard more of those sentiments expressed as well as Deputy O'Leary expressed them many of the difficulties and confusions which exist in certain quarters might disappear.

This debate is a yearly review of the state of the nation. In opening the debate yesterday the Taoiseach chose to confine himself to an assessment of the economic situation. Listening to his speech one would wonder whether there was any problem in this country except the undoubted economic problems which exist. One would also wonder whether the events that are taking place in the North of Ireland were to be isolated and separated from the general health of this nation, which, of course, they cannot be. In concluding the debate on behalf of my party, I want, first of all, to deal with the economic review which the Taoiseach gave yesterday, and then to say something about the other issues before the country at the moment.

The Taoiseach reviewed the economy yesterday with such an uninspiring complacency that one must very seriously question whether there are now any economic plans or policies being pursued by the Government. He claimed that 1971 was a better year than 1970. He claimed that 1971 has shown some important improvements over the past year, and he instanced a 3 per cent growth rate in place of a 1 per cent growth rate. He appears to be utterly oblivious of the fact that a 1 per cent or a 2 per cent or a 3 per cent growth rate in modern times is indicative of an almost stagnant economy.

In referring to the 3 per cent growth rate the Taoiseach claimed credit for the Government for having forecast correctly that this rate would be achieved this year, as if they ought to be praised for recognising their inability to achieve anything better. We did not hear anything from him about the breakdown, utter and complete now, of economic programming. We did not hear anything from him about the vast increase in economic potential which under the Second and Third Programmes was promised by Fianna Fáil for this decade. These promises are now so much of the past that very few Deputies in this House have the heart even to refer to them.

The Taoiseach also referred to what he called the difficulties and the restrictions facing the economy, one of these which he mentioned being the 1969 balance of payments deficit of £69 million. He appears prepared to forget that that balance of payments deficit of £69 million in 1969 was the cost this country had to pay to enable the Fianna Fáil Party to win the 1969 election. Today he thinks the balance of payments deficit of £75 million for 1971 is quite satisfactory because it covers the purchase of Jumbo jets and because as he says, of the substantial inflow of foreign capital. I wonder at the vision and the imagination of the man who is now in charge of our destiny and who is satisfied with a balance of payments deficit of £75 million because, among other reasons, there is a satisfactory inflow of foreign capital. I would have thought that this represented a real danger to this country because it indicates that we are continuing to borrow lavishly from abroad and that our present level of economic activity depends on foreign financing—and this in a country which is ravaged by civil war; this in a country in which the threat of anarchy is beginning to loom larger and larger each week and each month. Should, for any reason, this flow of foreign capital cease to come in here, what then would happen to our present level of economic activity? If we are to continue to drift along, assuming everything will be all right, just because a satisfactory inflow of capital enables us to live beyond our means, to incur the many liabilities that we otherwise could not afford, then I suggest we are heading for economic disaster.

The Taoiseach went on to say that he regarded the rise in prices as a less satisfactory area of economic activity. So well he might when the cost of living in the last three years has increased by 30 per cent and is still rising. One only has to have regard to the fact that in this country today the women, the housewives, various organisations, are not only angry but are driven to action by the apparent, inevitable climb in prices one week after another. It is clear there is no control. It is clear there is no policy. It is clear there is no thinking now in the Government to find means by which some stability can be brought to prices. Everywhere, unfortunately, there is abundant evidence of continued inflation.

The Taoiseach went on to make a passing reference to what he calls "increasing redundancies", and he proceeded to attribute this to the advances in technology, to increasing mechanisation, to the trend whereby machines were doing the work of ordinary manual labour. However, he held out no hope, no plan, no policy to deal with this problem. What are the facts? We now have 70,000 unemployed people. We have 8 per cent of our insured working population out of work and our unemployment problem, comparatively speaking, is now twice as serious as that of Great Britain.

The Taoiseach offered no solution to this problem. He says: "There it is", and then, impliedly: "I am not to blame for it. It is the trend of the times." God be with the days when we used to hear from the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party these trenchant words, that the test of the worth of any government was the number of men they were able to put to work. Applying that test to the present Fianna Fáil Government what worth can be attributed to their policy, to their efficiency or their ability to govern?

On the entire economic front we have just completed another bad year. We have drifted throughout the year just ending in the same way as we drifted for the years before. We might as well have no Government at all. Here we are, a small country, supposed to be waiting on the threshold of Europe, in point of time on the very eve of that happening. Instead of being in the process of completing the entire overhaul and reconstruction of our economy we have to report that we are very much worse off now than we were a decade ago and very much less prepared than many other countries about to enter Europe.

Had we a Government with a policy, had we a Government able to give proper leadership to the country, we should be engaged now in mobilising our economic resources so that the challenges which face us in the next few years could be met and the opportunities which will undoubtedly be presented seized. Unfortunately that is not so. The best we can hope in 1972, the year of challenge, the year of opportunity, is a slight increase on a 3 per cent growth rate and we will go limping into Europe.

That is a sorry position to be in but we are in this position because there has been a complete breakdown in economic policy and economic thinking on the part of this Government over recent years. We can do little about it except, even at this stage, hope by speaking along these lines to force some action, even belated, from the Government.

I should like to make some general remarks about the course which this debate has taken. Quite properly and quite understandably, despite the Taoiseach's introduction, this debate has dealt with the darkening tragedy of the North. I would like to say straight away that everybody in this country must have watched with concern and apprehension the different things which have happened, the different things which were done in the North of Ireland over recent months. Unfortunately, these happenings at times have led to the expression of intemperate views and unfortunately also there are those who by their failure to condemn or at times their implied approval would at this juncture encourage young men from the Republic to cross the Border to attack Unionist installations and persons.

What kind of thinking is this? What kind of doctrine is this that is being preached? Do the people who speak in that way know or realise the evil they may reap? Under our Constitution and under our democracy there is only one Army and it is subject to this Parliament. Under our Constitution and under our democracy there is only one body that may direct that Army and declare war and it is this Parliament and no other body or person. Anyone who suggests otherwise or who acts otherwise treads a very dangerous path indeed, a path which may lead to the very destruction of our democracy and to the establishment, on its rules, of a military dictatorship.

May I say that those who speak like that, should such a dictatorship come about, would get no thanks from the dictator and would be swept away with all their other remnants of democracy. I hope that at this stage in this Parliament we, on all sides of this House, can be resolute and clear in our principles. We can afford no fifth column inside this Parliament or inside this democracy seeking to bring about its destruction. No such fifth column should be tolerated. Those who speak in that way and who advocate these kind of views act, in my view, utterly irresponsibly but there are others who by indolence, vacillation or fear tend to lead to the same bad results.

What of our internal security in this State today? Just as responsibility for the economic situation rests with the Leader of the House, so also is the trust imposed on him to see to the security of the nation. Today we have a depleted Garda force, an under-strength Army and we have to listen to the impudent assertion on the part of one group of the IRA that they have reached such a stage that they cannot be touched by the Government authorities of this State.

Who dares to speak in this way and to challenge the right of the people of this country to rule this country? How is it that members of an illegal organisation, an organisation outside the law engaged in an armed conspiracy against this State, can meet? How is it that they are permitted to hold a press conference and to challenge this State? What are the Government doing about it? What have they been doing about it? They have been whistling, hoping, waiting for the problem to pass by. What has the Minister for Justice, this young man in a hurry, whose duty it is under the Taoiseach to see that the law is enforced in this country, been doing? He has been picking a row with the Bar Council about two senior counsel in the Circuit Court instead of seeing that the law of this country is enforced and that the security situation is put right. I mention these things, perhaps with some emphasis, perhaps with some heat but I do so because I detect a feeling in this country of widespread apprehension.

Deputy Cooney said during the debate yesterday that there is civil war in the North and that there is danger that that civil war could overspill into the Republic. Of course, there is. Guns pointed in one direction today can be pointed in another tomorrow. Unless we who have enjoyed and helped to mould the democracy we have here in the South are prepared to speak up and be heard, irresponsible counsel and unwise words will fall on fertile ground. I ask the Government to do their duty and I hope we will never have to hear again, as we heard in this House yesterday, a Minister for Justice standing up and saying: "Ah, it did not matter. The training is all indoors and there are never more than five or six involved". That kind of silly assertion does little for the credibility of this Government.

We are here at the end of this Dáil session in the month of December, 1971; there are Deputies in this House who marked last Monday week, the 6th December, as the 50th anniversary of the Treaty and, as they marked the occasion, the 50th anniversary of the founding of this State, how sad it was to see not a flag flying from any public building in this city or in the country, to hear not a commemorative word from any member of the Government, not a word to mark the passing of 50 years on from the foundation of this State. It is a sad commentary on how we have learned our citizenship.

It is a sad commentary that five decades of Irish freedom should go unnoticed by those in charge of this nation today. Perhaps there may have been a reason unthought of because these have been 50 years of division, of disillusionment, 50 years in which the nation's efforts were diverted in various ways, 50 years in which the great prize of freedom could never be used properly to build this State. We can look back now and realise what harm was done to the Irish nation in the past 50 years. Is this division, this concern with past dissensions, this determination to score a point, or make a case, is it always to befog and confuse our thinking?

There are dangers inside this State today. There are changes facing us. This surely is a time when Irishmen should be moving closer together, closer together to build and strengthen this country. It has often been said by speakers in different countries, in order to emphasise a point or make a case, that a nation is at the crossroads. I believe we are at the crossroads today. I believe there is a testing time coming for every single person engaged in public affairs. It is a time in which we will have to think deeply about what is going to be involved in the immediate future. We will have to think deeply about the present problems of our land. We will have to have the courage to realise—not merely to say it, but to realise it fully—that the Unionist Senator who was shot dead in the North last week, that Brian Faulkner, Ian Paisley and Boal, and every one of them up there, are just as much entitled to the name of Irishman as anyone here in this House. They were born on the soil of Ireland. They breathe Irish air. They are entitled to be regarded as full citizens of this country.

We will have to have the courage, too, to realise that the traditions and the memories they honour and the people they respect are just as much Irish memories and Irish personalities as are the memories and the people we here respect. We have got to appreciate and understand—and, appreciating and understanding, we must be prepared to act in the light of that—that their views and their ideas and their beliefs must be fully and generously respected in any new Ireland.

I hope that these ideas are present to the Taoiseach's mind when he suggests that there should be an all-party committee. I did not want to score any debating point but I should like to express regret that this gesture should have come so late. It might have been that on the outbreak of the incidents in the Bogside in August, 1969, and since, mistakes might have been avoided and greater confidence given had the suggestion then made of an all-party committee been then acted upon. It is sad to think that this suggestion should now become politically possible simply because it comes from Westminister and not from the Deputies on the right of the Ceann Comhairle in this House. I hope good will come of it and I hope that we can by pooling our views and expressing them courageously and sincerely help to have a new approach to the division of our country.

I do not want to say very much more, but I do want to repeat that there is a very real fear in this country today. I mentioned the economic situation. It has tended to become pushed into the background over the last 18 months because of the events in the North but, in that area, there is certainly ground for disquiet, ground for the feeling that there is no sure hand on the tiller and no sound course being pursued. The problems are left unattended and we are drifting from crisis to crisis.

At the same time, there is the other fear, the other apprehension, that the law of this country is being flouted at will and that the security of the Republic itself may be in danger. I am going to ask the question which is on everybody's lips: is this Government strong enough to act decisively on the part of this nation? Has it the personnel capable of doing what needs to be done in the present crisis of our affairs? If it is not strong enough, if it has not the men of ability to act, then in what direction does this nation turn? Will it be towards anarchy? Will we, by indolence, vacillation, inefficiency or inability to act permit those who by their violent methods have become the new partitionists of our age to destroy our democracy? I do not believe we will turn towards anarchy. I hope that in the ultimate analysis, if it has to be that, that new leadership and new initiative can come from the Dáil itself.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

When I opened the debate here yesterday morning I indicated to the House that I was going to concentrate that part of my speech on the economic position. I did not avoid, and I do not think I have been accused of trying to avoid, a debate on the political situation which now obtains. I expected the debate would develop along these lines. It is right and useful that we should have a fairly deep debate on the situation which now exists in the North of Ireland and on developments which have taken place even since the 20th and 21st October when we debated that subject here.

The situation has certainly not improved in the meantime. It has, on the contrary, deteriorated along predictable and, in fact, along predicted lines since that debate took place. The number of people killed since August, 1969, is now touching on 200 and most of these have died since the 9th August this year. Far from this impressing on the Northern regime the need for different policies it seems to bring forth and induce a frenzy of demands for even greater oppression and also demands for greater power to carry out this oppression.

We have a stream of propaganda from the same source that Britain should extend the area of conflict in the North to the Border area. The greatest possible propaganda use has been made of the admittedly horrible killings near the Border. There have been too many deaths everywhere in the North but we must not let the repetition of accusations about a particular horror conceal that, whereas fewer than ten people have lost their lives along the Border over the past three years, 20 people were killed in one week in Belfast alone between McGuirk's pub, the Shankill Road and the Ardoyne and all of these innocent people.

The attempt is made to suggest that we here are responsible for this unfortunate situation. I have repudiated these charges and I will continue to repudiate them. We have been accused of insufficiently controlling the Border and, by implication, of being responsible for the deaths in the Border area. This is a fraudulent claim as everyone who makes it knows well. I and members of the Government have replied to it on a number of occasions recently and we fully stand over these rejections.

I should like to reply to it now by adding that a regime, whose continuance involves the destruction of the lives of 20 people in one week in its capital city as well as the continued discontent and unhappiness of its entire population more or less indefinitely, has no right to the support it expects and even demands from the British Government and the British people. It has even less right to point an accusing finger at anybody else.

I have said these things before but they bear repetition. The deterioration of the situation in the North of Ireland is due to the pursuance of wrong policies there by the British Government at the instance of a local regime which for the moment has trapped the British Government into a line of conduct which, if unchanged and successful—both of these are highly unlikely eventualities—can only restore the monopoly of Unionist power which is at the root of the instability in that State.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The causes of violence in the North lie in the refusal of civil and human rights to 40 per cent of its population. No community divided as the North is can expect to maintain a one-sided monopoly of power and have peace as well. In this respect I want to touch briefly on a number of things which have been recently said by spokesmen of the Unionist idea of government.

One is that those people who advocate the unity of Ireland—the Fitts, the Humes and so on—shall never participate in Government in the North. This, of course, is an assertion worthy only of ridicule. Furthermore, it is obviously one not shared by either Mr. Heath or Mr. Maudling. The sooner this idea disappears from political currency the better. It is also asserted in the same quarter that control of security must remain in the hands of Stormont. As the function of security so far as the Northern Establishment is concerned is simply to use armed forces, whether British or Northern, to preserve Unionist monopoly power, then equally clearly that assertion must also disappear from the currency of politics.

The third assertion made is that Irish unity is unthinkable. No one but Stormont now says so and the fact that Irish unity is now essential must honestly be faced by politicians in Stormont and elsewhere. The fourth and most recent assertion is that violence must be stamped out completely in the North before political progress can be made. This assertion completes the circle and the case defended by Unionism becomes clear. It is this: although everybody else knows that the political condition of the North breeds permanent violence, the Unionists say that violence must disappear before the political condition can be changed. The result of such an attitude is obviously no progress whatever, no peace and no real politics. Worse still, in the absence of peaceful progress, in the absence of political progress towards a real solution the opportunity for the Unionist establishment to create bad blood between Ireland and England increases.

It appalls me that in recent times the British Government, which has been drawn into a financial, military and moral morass in the North, in support of what is plainly insupportable, should allow their judgment to be so influenced as to attempt to find a fault on this side of the Border as they have in the past week or so. Mr. Heath knows my views very well on a number of subjects, including the effects of cratering roads and so on. He knows my views on the effects of one-sided administration of repressive measures. The consequences that I forecast to him on two occasions have, unfortunately, resulted and that to my deep regret. I hope the British Government will take time to stand back from the present entanglement which they have created for themselves with the Stormont regime and formulate policies more appropriate to British as well as Irish interests.

Having said this, I should also say that while the situation in the North has deteriorated seriously the situation about the North shows some important signs of change. Mr. Wilson and the British Labour Party have developed their views substantially in recent weeks. I discussed this before and I do not wish to take up the time of the House on it now but suffice it for me to say that two of the three political parties in the British House of Commons now espouse the idea of Irish unity. Furthermore, while it would be unwise to read too much into an informal statement—that recently made by Mr. Maudling—it now appears that he agrees that a solution in the North cannot be achieved by military means alone. He is also conscious that defeating the present campaign of violence is not, by itself at any rate, a policy at all and can lead to no lasting solution.

I would advise him and his colleagues to extend their thinking further to the point where they will see, as the majority of both the Irish and British people already see, that the only lasting solution is to be found in Irish unity. Neither we nor the British can go on allowing Anglo-Irish relations and the future of Ireland to be determined by an intransigent and very small minority in these islands. It is a pathetic use of words to say that Northern Ireland is a democratic State: It is a falsehood to claim that Northern Ireland is governed by democratic principles. I think it is the simple truth to assert that while every reasonable demand of the Unionist population should be accommodated in a united Ireland, their future is in a united Ireland and not in the perpetuation of the present division of our country.

Deputy O'Leary referred to the need for talks. I agree fully with him. He mentioned talks involving the SDLP and, I presume, he also includes the Nationalist Members of Parliament. Whatever one thinks of the decision of the SDLP, and subsequently of the Nationalists, to withdraw from Stormont— they had good reason for it— one must certainly sympathise in the frustration they felt as members of that regime. My efforts since they did withdraw were, so far as I could—and I have been criticized by Northern Unionists for what they described as openly consorting with these people who withdrew from Parliament— designed to maintain the influence of these minority-elected representatives with the minority population. I believe it is highly important that we try as far as we can to maintain that influence and maintain their position as leaders of the Northern minority community.

When I first met Mr. Heath at Chequers the principal message I had for him on that occasion was to get the SDLP and the Nationalists into talks and it was for that reason that I proposed quadrupartite talks. I impressed on him as strongly as I could the need for political initiative. Unfortunately, at the time of the second meeting, Mr. Faulkner had already made a preliminary announcement of his Green Paper and it seemed to me that the British Government were prepared to rest, first, on the so-called reforms that were being effected and, secondly, on this Green Paper as representing what they regarded as satisfactory political initiative. It must be clear to them now that the reform programme has been regarded as not in that category and the Green Paper of Parliamentary reform is totally unacceptable to the Nationalist population. They continue to withdraw their consent notwithstanding whatever carrots are held out to them in the Green Paper proposals for participation. And they are quite right in that Mr. Faulkner has said again and again that anybody who espouses a united Ireland has no place in a Northern Ireland Cabinet.

I have said that a political initiative must be taken, that violent activities will continue and that even if put down now they will break out again within a short period. What I have said in that respect does not in any way condone these acts of violence no matter by whom committed. It does not condone the actions of anybody responsible on either side for violence in any shape or form. I should like to say to those who try to suggest—as Deputy O'Higgins said, who arrogantly suggested here— that the majority of the people in this part of the country support the IRA, that I reject that totally.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It is an arrogant, unsustainable and impudent suggestion and I want to assure the gentlemen who made that assertion—one of them publicly here—that this Government do not stand in fear of him, his brand of IRA men or any other brand of IRA men. On this I want to give an assurance about the security of the State, to which one or two Deputies have referred. If I have time I shall deal with it in more detail later.

Nobody need fear about the security of our State. Above all, I wish to assure the IRA that if they think they can take advantage of allegations that there is any degree of insecurity they should have another think. So far as this Government are concerned, the IRA will not be let usurp the functions of this Government or of this Parliament. They have no mandate from anyone and that has been said to them many times, no matter what kind of moral support or otherwise they claim from the people.

The Minister for Finance recently told them to get out of the way and give us a chance to negotiate a United Ireland. So long as they are there, that prospect will not exist. Every bomb exploded, every bullet fired, not only by an IRA gun but by a British gun, and especially every innocent person, no matter on what side, who loses his or her life, puts the day of reconciliation further away. In Cork last week I said that they are almost pushing that day out of sight. Perhaps someone within their organisation would bring home to them the fact that the united Ireland they seek will be a united Ireland of shambles. By bombing factories, office blocks and electricity installations they will leave the country like a desert of rubble, North and South. Even if they succeed in uniting Ireland in that fashion, how do they propose to proceed from there? How do they propose to establish the kind of economic growth that successive Governments on this side of the Border have been striving to achieve for the past 50 years?

I want to repeat my statement that violence cannot be condoned. Violence is the one factor in the situation at the present time that is making worthwhile progress and initiative more difficult. Notwithstanding that, I still say that the initiative is with the British Government. I do not care if Mr. Wilson is given the credit for the current initiative. The initiative he took was bold and imaginative; even though he knows, as we know, that some of the proposals and suggestions are not acceptable, at least there is a working basis there that will try to get all the parties and groups that have a responsibility talking towards a solution.

I wish to deal especially with the allegations that were made that law and order were not being maintained in this part of the country. First, I should like to say to the Opposition that when we bring in measures here designed to ensure the security of property, to ensure the right of the Garda and the Army to effect law and to maintain order, we are met with ceaseless opposition within this House.

Because the Criminal Justice Bill contained one or two features they regarded as objectionable, the Bill was made impossible of passage in the last Dáil. There are sections in that Bill which, if in force, would ensure that there would be far less reason for the apprehension some of the Opposition Deputies have been expressing. The Forcible Entry Bill was opposed tooth and nail, although its purpose was to ensure the right of ownership, the right of access to and residence in one's own property. All these measures as we bring them forward are criticised by the Opposition. They are filibustered in this House because they do not suit perhaps some of the more liberal lights on the Opposition benches. I wish to state that within the existing law this Government intend to use whatever measures we can to maintain order and to establish and uphold the law.

There are defects, and the Minister for Justice has pointed out some of the defects in our laws of evidence, that make it more difficult for us to bring home certain offences, particularly subversive offences, in this country. We have tried to remedy these defects whenever they appear. I can assure the House that if further defects reveal themselves not only in the law but in the administration of the law we will bring forward measures here. We will ask the co-operation of the Opposition to cure these defects and to make the administration of law and the maintenance of order more effective in this part of the country.

Recently I gave an indication of the increase in Garda strength. Some minutes ago Deputy O'Higgins gave the impression that it was at an all-time low level. Since 1968 the strength of the Force has been increased steadily. This year 200 gardaí were recruited over and above normal recruitment and it is proposed to recruit 200 next year in addition to normal recruitment. The Minister for Defence told the Dáil recently that morale in the Army is very high and that the numbers were the highest for more than a decade. I think this gives an indication that this Government are not being complacent about the present situation.

At the same time, I should like to dispel any apprehension that the ordinary citizen might have as a result of statements made in this House by some Opposition Members and by Opposition speakers outside this House. Not only are the garda and Army at considerable strength at the present but that strength of numbers and equipment is being increased all the time and this will continue. The Minister for Defence said that in certain circumstances if it were justified we could bring our troops home from Cyprus within 48 hours. I hope it will not be necessary to do this at any time, but we have instructed our Ambassador to the United Nations to inform the United Nations authority of this possibility.

Deputy O'Higgins opened his speech and occupied about half of it with the economic situation as he saw it. He seemed to criticise capital inflow from abroad as something not good for us, something that was bolstering up our standard of living and which was not justified by our performance. I do not believe Deputy O'Higgins thinks inflow of capital from outside is a bad thing in a developing country. Inflow of capital from Europe originally built up the economic strength of the United States of America, and capital inflow in the opposite direction from the United States of America strengthened considerably the economies of most European countries since the war.

He also suggested that we are less prepared now for entry into the European Economic Community than we were ten years ago. Deputy O'Higgins knows that to be completely untrue and unfounded. He completely forgets the ten years of adaptation programmes which have been going on in the industrial economy. He forgets the new industrial development that has been taking place, development of the types of industries we know can survive and prosper in the Common Market. He knows, too, that our services generally have become more developed in order to enable us to maintain our economic momentum.

He criticised the rate of economic growth, and rightly so, but he misrepresented me as saying that the best we could hope for next year was a slight improvement on the 3 per cent growth in 1971. That growth rate was quite satisfactory having regard to international conditions. He seemed to imply—as many of his colleagues have implied from time to time when it suited them—that we as a nation can insulate and isolate ourselves from world economic conditions. He knows well that that is not true. He knows well that economic depression can be international and usually is international, and particularly inflation. Far from suggesting that I hoped for a slightly better than 3 per cent improvement on the record for next year, my speech made it quite clear that the opportunities for a much faster rate of growth existed and that the Government were, in fact, pursuing policies that would bring these opportunities to fruition.

Yesterday morning Deputy Cosgrave spoke in what I thought was almost an arrogant way. We are used to being charged with being arrogant from the opposite benches but, if ever there was a display of arrogance I think I saw it from Deputy Cosgrave yesterday. He began by accusing me of using phrases which were carefully selected to confuse and conceal. Those were his words. This is a typical example of the way in which the Opposition seek to smear this party and this Government, and to undermine the prestige and the authority of the Dáil. They shed crocodile tears in this respect while, at the same time, by engaging in these charges they themselves undermine respect for Parliament and Government.

Having made that statement he produced no evidence to support it. Indeed, in his subsequent remarks he showed that he was the one who was confused and not I. He showed his confusion is the very first point he mentioned, unemployment. In my speech I said, and I quote what I said: "The figures for unemployment show a rise of approximately 8,000 on those for December last year." Deputy Cosgrave contended that the figure for this year could not be compared with those for last year because of the impact of the Employment Period order and that my statement, therefore, to use his own words again, concealed the true facts.

My statement was based on the number of persons on the Live Register on 3rd December, 1971, compared with the same period in 1970. The increase in the number for this year is 7,668 so that, by rounding up the figure to 8,000. I was erring on the side against myself, far from trying to understate the change.

Comment on this

Not too much.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

There are a good many people between 7,668 and 8,000.

Comment on this

Are there? Not that many.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I will give Deputy O'Donovan a present of that point. Deputy Cosgrave accused me of being confused but it is he who is confused because he knows that the Employment Period Order had not been in operation since 18th November and therefore the figures I quoted were in no way affected by it.

He went on to deal with inflation and accused the Government of being the major cause of it. Here he displayed his capacity to use carefully selected phrases to conceal the facts. Having read out the list of price increases for items such as postal charges and bus fares, he deplored the increases in the rates and turnover tax, and then went on to lament the inadequate increases in social welfare, the high rate of company tax and the inadequate spending on the Army and the Garda. This is a classical example of the way the Opposition try to have it both ways. There was a clear inference from his remarks that there should be no tax increases and no price increases, but that we should be expending more and more money on social welfare. We have heard this so often that it is hardly necessary to reply to it in this House.

What does it mean? To take the steps he suggested yesterday, on a very rough and conservative estimate, would cost about £40 million. I would ask him, where is that kind of money to be found if taxes are to be ruled out? The obvious answer, and the one which comes from the Opposition frequently, is that we should cut down spending in other areas. This point was made during the last major economic debate we had and, when pressed further on that point, the Fine Gael spokesman on finance said that we should cut entertainment expenses, which would save about £35,000—not a very substantial contribution to the kind of expenditure Deputy Cosgrave had in mind.

Deputy Tully took a different view of my speech. He said it was nothing more than a collection of a few handy statistics which any old dog in the street could have strung together. The Deputy has different views on other things as well, of course. He seemed to be somewhat better informed than Deputy Cosgrave on the attitude of Fine Gael Deputies towards the EEC issue.

He criticised my figure of 2,000 for net outward movement of people from this country in the current year. He, and I think Deputy Corish as well, said there should be a "1" before it, making it 12,000. The fact is that it is 2,000. As I indicated, I do not depend on these figures as being absolutely reliable, but they indicate the falling trend, I have mentioned, from 21,000 four years ago to 2,000 now.

Comment on this

Great things have happened in our time.

Comment on this

Wait until next year.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Of course, as Deputy O'Donovan might have interjected at the time, this was contributed to by the lack of employment opportunities in the United Kingdom. That is true. However, the figures quoted by Deputy Tully are totally irrelevant. He said he was more accurate because he was more factual. In that, I think the Deputy was only indicating his own confusion. For example, in dealing with unemployment he said that I quoted a figure of more than 60,000 whereas in his opinion I should have said that the figure was more than 70,000. The fact is that I did not quote any figure in my opening speech yesterday. What I did say was that "the figures for unemployment show a rise of approximately 8,000 on those for December last year" and I added that, "however, it would appear that part of the rise in unemployment reflects a drop in emigration". The figure of 8,000 was a rounded off figure.

Comment on this

Would the Taoiseach add 8,000 to the figure for last year and tell us what is the answer?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I want only to clarify some points and to rectify some suggestions made by the Deputy.

Comment on this

If the Taoiseach adds both figures together, he will get a total of more than 70,000.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy said I used a figure of 60,000 but the only figure I used was that of 8,000. I did not add or subtract any figures. However, the next point raised by Deputy Tully was that I had given incorrect figures for the employment created by IDA projects. He thought the figures I gave were too high as he imagined that what I had done was to quote the expected figures when these industries referred to were in full production. I was quoting the actual figures of initial employment in the projects completed and the further projects which are now in the course of construction for which the initial employment was 3,500 in one case and 4,000 in the other.

Comment on this

How could the Taoiseach know what would be the figures in the course of production?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I said "in the course of construction". Again, regarding imports and exports, Deputy Tully suggested that I was trying to manipulate the data because I referred to the fact that the five months from June to October had shown better results than the months from January to May. The Deputy asked why I picked that five-month period. The period from January to October is a ten month one and October was the last period for which I had figures then. In the first five-month period there was an increase and in the next five-month period there was a continuous reduction. At all events in order not to spoil Christmas for Deputy Tully I have a little present for him. Since speaking yesterday, the November figures have become available and these show a decline, although small, over the import figures for 1970 so that there is a continuing pattern of decline as in the case of emigration. There were other references made by Deputy Tully with which I need not deal now.

Yesterday, while speaking of the 1922 Constitution, Deputy Cosgrave said that that Constitution should never have been abandoned.

Comment on this

I said Article 8 of that Constitution should not have been abandoned.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He referred specifically to Article 8 of that Constitution.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Subsequently, he referred to Article 8. If the Deputy reads the Press as they heard him, and probably the official records as the Official Reporters heard him, he will realise that Deputy Cosgrave said that the 1922 Constitution should never have been abandoned.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I suggest that the Taoiseach reads the Official Report.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I was here at the time and I heard Deputy Cosgrave. I take it that the Fine Gael Deputies want to have that Constitution back. If such a proposition were ever to be put before the Irish people. I have no doubt as to the answer that Deputy Cosgrave and his colleagues would get. Whatever deficiency the passing years may have shown in the present Constitution, at least we can claim it was enacted by the Irish people as a whole and not imposed on them either under threat of a terrible war or an act of the British Government.

Comment on this

Who told the Taoiseach to say that? I suppose that is the old Park line.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

A myth.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy went on to add that the offensive Articles of the present Constitution came from the warped mentality of Fianna Fáil politicians at the time.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Was it a warped mentality that got rid of Article 12 of the 1922 Constitution which describes our legislature as consisting of the King and two Houses, the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate? Was it these same warped minds that got rid of an oath we would have to take to be faithful to H.M. King George V, his heirs and successors?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It was not I who introduced warped minds into the debate.

Comment on this

We thought we were bad.

Comment on this

The Deputy thought right.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Tell us about Article 44.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Is it not extraordinary that when I am speaking on economic matters, nobody says a word——

Comment on this

We are living in 1971.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach will have to do better than that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Interruptions must cease.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It took far too much sacrifice and toil to remove the offending and humilitating Articles of the 1922 Constitution ever to have them back again.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It was not necessary to fire a shot in order to have it changed.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I did not introduce this subject. I did not talk about the warped minds that brought in the offending Articles and I did not advocate bringing back the 1922 Constitution.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is ashamed now of the 1937 Constitution.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I said that the passage of time in any event would call for a review of the Constitution and let me come to this point at this stage. When I suggested that an inter-party committee be set up to review the Consituation. I made a suggestion also that there should be a requirement that the parties would be bound by their recommendations. I did not envisage representatives of parties going into this committee without reference back in full consultation with their parties but I did not want a situation arising as arose from the informal committee which was set up by Mr. Lemass in which, first, nobody was bound by the recommendations even where they were unanimous and, secondly, nobody outside the committee knew what was going on because the committee were bound to confidentiality. We did not know what had been recommended until, ultimately, the report became available. Indeed each member of the committee and each party in the House were responsible equally for these recommendations. But now I can see the reason for the Fine Gael sham participation in that particular committee. First of all, they would have repudiated their members in any respect they wanted to. Deputy Cosgrave said then that because we find ourselves in difficulty about the 1937 Constitution we want to get in under the Fine Gael umbrella. I do not know to what extent we could fit under it but I suggest that Deputies of the Labour Party could fit under it better. Even then I suggest they would get soaked to the skin.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It ought to be a golf umbrella because there would be a lot of shades of green to be accommodated under it and there would be other shades as well. I shall not refer to them here.

Comment on this

Is the Taoiseach serious about this all-party committee?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am, yes.

Comment on this

Then I suggest that the Taoiseach should desist from this kind of speech.

Comment on this

Conduct yourself.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I wanted this committee to consider the Constitution and to consider the possibility of progress being made on the Wilson proposals. As I said, Mr. Wilson proposed inter-party talks in Westminster and then in Stormont. He did not mention this country but I am sure he hoped that such an initiative would be followed here. That was my purpose. As it happens, both party leaders have indicated their agreement to come and talk to me. I intended originally that the three of us would talk together in a very informal way but now it appears that Deputy Cosgrave would like to come with some of his colleagues to discuss the matter with me and not until after Christmas. Deputy Corish will come next week with his colleagues. I will be glad to discuss in a general way how a committee of this nature can be set up.

I agree with the Deputies around the House here that there is no point in going back. If things were done in a way before that did not produce the results that we desire by all means let us abandon these methods. When I suggested that the parties opposite might consult with us about any changes needed in the Constitution I did so in good faith because I realise, and everybody does, that the Constitution is not the property of any single party or any individual. I thought it was right and reasonable that I should ask representative people, churches and especially political parties, to discuss among ourselves to find the widest possible area of agreement on any changes that would come forward and if there was not agreement on particular things then the Government of the day would have to make up their own minds. I thought it was better first to get that area of agreement so that we could be sure that we could satisfy most of our people and especially that we would be sure we could take into account the views of the Northern Ireland people, that we could satisfy them as well in a Constitution covering the whole of Ireland.

I did not suggest this for the sake of protecting ourselves against anybody. The Constitution is not a party political matter and if we put forward a Constitution tomorrow and if it was defeated I do not think we in Fianna Fáil would regard it as a defeat for our party. Therefore, I still hope that it will be possible to get the views of all the people, all the organised people particularly, in the country in this respect.

Deputy Cosgrave started making threats, as far as I could see, about the referendum on the EEC. He has done it twice in this House already. He ought to know that it is not his choice but the choice of the people whether or not we will go into Europe. He seems to suggest that if he snaps his fingers it will be defeated. I suppose it is true that if he advises his party and his party supporters not to vote for the amendment then it could be in danger of being lost but I think Deputy Cosgrave is as convinced as I am that our place is in Europe, that our economic progress is bound up with the progress of the EEC. This seems to me to be a typical example of cutting off your nose to spite your face. I said in my winding-up speech on the Second Stage of the Referendum Bill that I was prepared to listen to objective criticism and to be reasonable about amendments. I still am prepared to do that. I do not think Deputy Cosgrave should try to threaten me in any way or threaten the people that he might withhold his agreement for the referendum.

I think, of course, that Deputy Cosgrave and the Fine Gael Party generally are like the fellow in the swimming pool with one leg on the ground. I think they feel that there is likelihood of a general election before the referendum. I want to assure the Deputies opposite that they can take that leg off the ground, that they can swim under their own strength, under their own steam.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Sure the Taoiseach does not know.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

What happens if Blaney votes with us?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

As far as we are concerned, we are going to get this country safely into the EEC and——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): As far as the Taoiseach knows.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

——Fine Gael can come out openly and honestly and express their views and their support for the referendum.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I do not think there are many points left for me to cover. There is no time left, anyway.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has said enough.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I want to sum up by assuring this House of a number of things. This Government are going to pursue their aims to unite this country——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

——in a peaceful way, by negotiation and in co-operation, in so far as we can get it, from the parties opposite.

Comment on this

And open internment camps.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Nobody is talking about internment camps. Secondly, there will be no pulling back as far as this Government are concerned in relation to pursuing IRA activities or other subversive action. Thirdly, I can assure the people who might be apprehensive as a result of speeches from the Opposition that our security position is sound. That may not please the Opposition; it may not please the IRA, but as far as we are concerned we shall maintain our position; we shall not flinch in the face of any IRA threats, any claims that they have support throughout the country, and I know I have the support of the Opposition in this.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

What about Aontacht?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy step out for a while and he might cool off?

Comment on this
A Deputy

That shook you.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am not a bit shook.

Comment on this

What is the Taoiseach going to do about internment camps?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I thought that by ending up in the middle of the day we would have a chance of being heard but apparently it does not work. However, we are ending up for a special reason and I should like to take the opportunity of extending our sympathy in the House to the relatives of General Mulcahy. I know the Deputies opposite want to go to the funeral. On that note I should like to wish all the Members of the House and the staff the traditional message of a Happy Christmas

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 69
·
Níl 59
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?