Committee on Finance. - Adjournment Motion: Northern Ireland Situation.
Contributions 1–109 of 226. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move: That the Dáil do now adjourn.
On Monday night on television and again on Tuesday in the Dáil I expressed the nation's grief at the happenings in Derry last Sunday. I expressed sympathy with those who were bereaved, those who were injured and with the people of Derry generally. I think it is true to say that grief and sympathy were hardly ever more sincerely felt, nor more widespread in this country, certainly not in my lifetime. I also announced on Monday night that the Government had called for a special day of mourning and I appealed to everybody who could in any way contribute to, or facilitate, that mourning to do so. I should like to express my appreciation of the manner in which those in positions of authority facilitated the day of mourning.
I appeal to everybody to respond to these tragic events with dignity and with discipline. There were demonstrations of sympathy in every part of the country. People in their tens of thousands responded magnificently and they attended church services. Indeed, it is true to say that the entire nation mourned. What was important too, was that the vast majority marked yesterday in peaceful demonstration, a demonstration of their grief, of their sympathy and of their solidarity with the people who were bereaved and with their friends and, in general, demonstrated their sympathy and solidarity with the deprived minority in the North of Ireland. In this way they showed that in these difficult days there is a degree of unanimity and solidarity that was an example to the entire world and which gave encouragement and strength to the people in the North. For all this I commend all our people and congratulate them on the magnificent way they responded. I thank them for their wonderful gesture of solidarity and unanimity.
Regrettably, the situation had its dark spots. In Dublin yesterday many thousands of our people representing the different organisations, the trade unions, State bodies, students and, indeed people from every walk of life showed their sorrow in a most disciplined way. However, a small minority—men who, under the cloak of patriotism, seek to overthrow the institutions of this State—infiltrated what was necessarily a peaceful demonstration, infiltrated essentially peaceful groups and fomented violence. As we know the British Embassy has been destroyed but I want to say that the nation gains no credit from such an action. It was the action of people who are dangerous, who, above all, are a danger to our freedom, our democracy and to our institutions of freedom and democracy.
Unfortunately that incident was not the end of the matter and since then other danger signals have manifested themselves. Groups proclaiming to be members of illegal organisations have gone around intimidating people and seeking to give the impression that these organisations are now to have a free hand here to do what they like by way of intimidation or destruction. At the outset of what I intend saying, I wish to reassure those of our people who, understandably, may be apprehensive or who may have become concerned at some of yesterday's events, that the institutions of this State will be upheld without fear or favour. The laws will continue to be enforced and those who seek to usurp the functions of the Government will meet with no toleration. I reaffirm those fundamental principles here today and I ask every member of the community and every Member of the Dáil to support the Government stand on this. The Government stand is the stand of the elected representatives of our people regardless of on which side of the House they sit and regardless of whether they are in this House or the other. In the days immediately ahead there is no doubt that those to whom I have referred will seek to play on the sympathies and on the emotions of ordinary decent people so as to secure support for their own actions and objectives. Many people in other countries—indeed throughout the world—are watching our reaction to the recent tragic events. The present situation is a test of our maturity as a nation. We must show the world that, with dignity and restraint, we can express our grief and our support for the minority in the North without, at the same time, playing into the hands of those who would destroy our own fundamental institutions. Therefore, I ask all men and women of goodwill and of responsibility and especially those in positions of influence and, perhaps, those who are engaged in the communications media, to be on their guard against the kind of danger to which I have referred.
This debate, perhaps, has been precipitated by the tragic events of last Sunday. Before the Government took action on Monday, we had received reports from sources that we believe to be absolutely reliable and since then we have been able to check these reports against more reports and especially against reports made by people who were eye-witnesses of these events, people who were actually on the spot. In this respect I would like to refer to the claim by the commanding officer of the British Forces in Derry last Sunday that 200 rounds were fired at his troops as well as nail bombs and other missiles. So far as I know and so far has been stated publicly, not one of these troops was injured either by bullets or nail bombs. They may have sustained minor injuries in scuffles but there were no casualties as a result of these alleged shootings and the throwing of bombs. The same officer claimed that shots had come from flats, that there were snipers on the roofs of these flats which, I understand, were high rise flats in the immediate vicinity, but the stark fact remains that all those who were killed or injured were people on the ground and people who were about to attend, and some of whom had already attended, a public meeting which had begun already. Therefore, to that extent, what these people were doing then was not illegal according to the decrees of the Stormont Government. The march was banned. Therefore, one presumes that under their laws it was illegal to take part in the march but it had concluded at the time the paratroopers fired on these people attending the meeting who, at that stage, were about their lawful business and demonstrating in a lawful way even by Stormont's standards.
As I have said, reports that we received were confirmed by other independent sources and I would direct the attention of Members to the statement of an Italian journalist who must be regarded as being completely impartial and who, so far as I know, said that no shot was fired from the crowds that were demonstrating before the British paratroopers opened fire. I would direct the attention of the House also to a statement made by a very prominent journalist of a very prominent British newspaper who said that he was there all the time, that he thought he heard one shot that might have come from the direction of where the meeting was being convened. He wrote in his notebook "sniper" after which he put a question mark. This gentleman has said that that was the only shot he heard before the paratroopers fired and, obviously, by his own admission and by the record in his notebook, he was not convinced that the shot had come from the direction of the demonstration. It was on these facts that the Government took their decision on Monday to withdraw the Ambassador from London, to instruct our diplomats abroad to inform the Governments to which they were accredited of the facts of the situation as we had got them.
I also put forward the three proposals with which the House is familiar. I should like to repeat them because I believe they are essential if any move forward is to be made. First, the immediate withdrawal of British troops from Derry and other areas in the North of Ireland where there is a high concentration of Catholic homes and the cessation of the harassment of the minority population. I believe that it was because of raids and repressive measures by the British troops in these areas that much of the violence that since has come about in the North of Ireland was caused. In speaking about harassment, I intended to cover the cratering of Border roads, which, I am convinced now more than ever I was, have no military effect or benefit whatever. It was done, as a result of repeated statements by a junior Minister in Stormont, to appease him, in the first instance, and to embarrass us in the second. Not only has it done both—it obviously has appeased the one and embarrassed the other—but it has incensed decent people on both sides of the Border against this type of activity, and has not prevented one person who had evil intent from crossing the Border. Therefore, not only was that kind of action undertaken for the reasons I said but it is militarily futile. The other two proposals I made were the end of internment without trial and a declaration of Britain's intention to achieve the final settlement of the Irish question and the convocation of a conference for this purpose.
I recognise that some of these proposals may not be immediately possible. I am certain that the withdrawal of the troops from the areas I mentioned is immediately possible and would be a first step towards the restoration of peace and the elimination of violence in the North. The second, too, the end of internment without trial, obviously will take some time because if those who are interned are brought to trial a suitable tribunal will have to be established. When I mentioned, having spoken to Mr. Harold Wilson on last Monday week, that I thought it might be possible to find a formula to induce the Nationalists and the SDLP Members of Stormont into talks, and that this might be one of the ways. I want to say clearly that I was in no way dictating to these minority leaders as to what their attitude should be.
However, since the events which gave rise to these proposals resulted from a demonstration to establish civil rights, I would add one other proposal which I think would also be very quickly implemented. As Deputies are aware, especially Deputies who are delegates to the Council of Europe, some time ago the Council of Europe Assembly made a recommendation to the Committee of Ministers:
(1) To instruct the Committee of Experts on Human Rights to draft an additional protocol to the European Convention on Human Rights which would secure the equal treatment of persons in the enforcement of the law and prohibit discrimination in the exercise of the following rights:
(i) the right to participate with equal voting rights in national and local elections based on the fair delineation of electoral boundaries;
(ii) the right of access to employment, particularly in central and local government services, in State and semi-State companies and public bodies financed wholly or partly out of central or local government funds and in private industries partly financed or sub-sidised by State or local bodies;
(iii) the right to the equitable allocation of dwellings and of resources required to provide dwellings wholly or partly financed out of public funds;
(iv) the right of access to the public service.
The Assembly in their wisdom thought it necessary to add these to the Convention on Human Rights. I would now suggest to the British Government that they could amend their Northern Ireland legislation, which they have authority and power to amend, that is, the Government of Ireland Act, 1920 or the 1949 Act, to include these specific principles, so that, instead of depending on the goodwill, the declaration, or whims, as the case may be of an administration in which people have lost all confidence, these people would legally enjoy those rights, and enforce such rights if they were not accorded to them. This, I suggest, could be done by simple amendment and done very quickly.
May I say in reference to demonstrations that I hope it will be possible to hold next Sunday's demonstration in a way that will not provoke the kind of action that we saw last Sunday in Derry, that it will not provoke the deliberate shooting down of innocent people by paratroopers. It may be that such a demonstration could be held within the law and equally effectively. That is not a matter for me to decide, but it is a consideration I would urge on those who are responsible and who rightly want to demonstrate to achieve those rights. It is known by now that I had a visit from the British Ambassador and this is one of the questions we discussed. It is not for me to say what passed between us. We also discussed the burning of the Embassy and I reiterated the Government's regret and our intention, as is the practice, to provide full compensation. He did not indicate to me whether there was any response so far to the proposals that I put to the British Government last Monday.
I want to refer to the suggestion that the Leaders of the three parties should go to London, which Deputy Cosgrave raised in the House here on Tuesday. I had intended to discuss this matter with Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Corish, but unfortunately the changed Order of Business and the visit of the British Ambassador precluded me from doing so. However, I hope to discuss it with them later. We, as political parties representing the people here, have publicly stated our unanimity and our solidarity and I would say we have the support of the vast majority of the people in our approach to this question. It may be that such a visit would endorse this solidarity, that as Deputy Cosgrave said, the meeting may do good but not do harm. I should like to consider this very carefully before I would make any comment on such a visit.
Comment on this
Not before I discuss the matter with Deputy Corish and Deputy Cosgrave. There is more we can do in this present situation. As I said, we are all solid and united in our approach to this problem. We are committed to a peaceful solution of the Northern Ireland situation. In talking of the future of Ireland, it is impossible not to reflect also on present policies being pursued in the North. Those lie at the heart of any discussions that we may have here amongst ourselves or otherwise.
The attempt to reimpose traditional Unionism, whose vision is narrow and self-defeating, will certainly end in total failure. I have no doubt about this. The political leadership of the non-Unionist community in the North have no doubt about it. Indeed, no objective observer—even though he might be British—European, American, or otherwise, doubts that this cannot happen either. It would be fair to say, in fact, that the published comments of most journalists, and the private views expressed to me and to the Minister for Foreign Affairs by most political leaders in other countries, are insistent that the policy of return to monopoly Unionist Government is now impossible.
The State itself was founded for the purpose of ensuring the ascendancy of one community there at the expense of another. I do not know of any other State—until the Eastern European countries were established after the last war—which was deliberately founded on the basis of keeping in power permanently one section of the population. I do not know either of any State which is less representative of the true meaning of Protestantism than the Northern State. The right to freedom of conscience was a fundamental of the Reformation. The practices of Government in Northern Ireland are certainly not in accord with these principles of Protestantism.
I know from many contacts I have that a great many Protestants in Northern Ireland seek peace and justice as much as their Catholic neighbours do. I also know that many of them have come to the belief that, within the limits of the Northern State, it is not possible to find peace with justice and that their minds, therefore, are turning in the direction of Irish unity. I should like to assure these people publicly, as I have done privately, that the unity which we seek is one which will be determined to find room for their talents as well as their sensibilities.
They owe it to themselves as much as they owe it to their neighbours to state how they would wish the institutions of Ireland to be formed. They will be their institutions as much as anyone else's. It is right that they should have a say in how they should be formed. If we are expecting moves or sacrifices from the Unionist majority in the North we, too, will have to face up to some change from our present stance and policy. In turning away from a failed system of government which was unworthy of them, if they do so, they will free themselves to undertake a task which is worthy of them, that of discovering out of the chaos of the present time the way forward to an Ireland which has been theirs for centuries and will be theirs again, as well as ours.
In addressing them publicly in this manner I am asking them to share in and to play an essential part in determining what Ireland should be. I have said harsh things about Unionism in so far as it has manifested itself in misgovernment in the North. It has never been my purpose to show hostility to Unionists, nor have I ever had any such feelings. To me the distinction is a vital one. Unionists are Irishmen who, to my mind, took the wrong course when the Irish nation insisted that Ireland should take charge of her own affairs. A moment of choice has come around again and Unionists can recapture their place in Ireland or continue down a road which will leave them without identity, without influence, and without happiness.
There are movements in Unionist circles which encourage me to believe that the right choice is on the brink of actuality. Certainly many Unionists —perhaps most Unionists—are prepared to support a non-sectarian State in the North. Many have the courage to advocate this despite the pressures exercised on them within their own society. In doing this they represent and speak for people Ireland needs in order to set in train Ireland's fulfilment. I would put a question to them: If the North should become a State capable of embracing the two communities there, in what essential manner could this context not properly be applied to the whole of Ireland?
It may be said in reply that the whole country is incapable of the resolution of problems in a manner satisfactory to the Northern majority for economic, social and other reasons. Laying aside the selfishness involved in a decision to keep a country divided for economic reasons, I consider that it can be truly argued that a united Ireland would not adversely affect the economic well-being of the North. In recent decades our economic development has been substantial, so much so, that far from being afraid of entering into the European Community—which among other things is a vast free trade area—we look forward to it confident of the acceleration of our economic expansion.
So far as social reasons go, Irish unity implies and, indeed, insists on a state of affairs equally satisfactory to the basic beliefs of all sections of the whole community. The North has nothing to lose from that. Therefore I would urge those thinking in the terms I have outlined to take the further step towards agreeing that their intention should be enlarged from trying to find a solution within Northern Ireland to one in which they will acknowledge that the proper goal is to find a solution for Ireland as a whole, agreeable to the Irish people as a whole.
I realise that I am limited to half an hour so I will just conclude. I want to refer again to the march next Sunday in Newry. I said that I hoped it would not provoke the same kind of reaction as the Derry march did. I also want to say that I hope it will not provide any cloak or alleged excuse for the British Army to behave again as they did in Derry last Sunday.
Finally, I want to say again to our own people: let not present emotion, absolutely justified and justifiable, turn them away from what the overwhelming majority of the people know to be the only way towards unity. Above all, let not people who wish to exploit that emotion turn them away from what the great majority of our people seek, that is, the peaceful reunification of our country, the maintenance of our institutions, and the maintenance of our democratic institutions above all, so that all Irishmen, North and South, can enjoy living in economic well-being and happiness in a united Ireland.
Comment on this
Those of us who still enjoy the gift of life carry a very heavy responsibility to ensure that the deaths of 13 Irishmen in Derry last Sunday and the grief of their relatives are not in vain. Those of us who still live must also, as we endeavour to recover from the shock of last Sunday's cruel events, recall that more than 260 people have died as a result of the insane use of force by man against man to achieve political objectives in the North of Ireland in the last three years. Those of us who come from the same national strain, who share the same views as those of the victims of Derry, must not in our sense of anger and frustration forget that there are on this island people who do not share, for the time being, totally in our outlook and we must have some thought for those who live in fear and dread of the threats of revenge and reprisal that were uttered by Irishmen in the last week.
It is difficult to categorise the happenings in Derry as anything but vindictive force criminally and selectively directed against a harassed and infuriated minority. When to that terrible injury which was inflicted you have the appalling and disgraceful untruths, to which the Taoiseach has referred, we feel thoroughly sick that there exists in this island such a deplorable situation. As people understandably vent their anger on the instruments of the wrong decisions which have been taken over the last few years, let us realise that the decisions to have the troops where they are, acting in the way that they are behaving, are the decisions of political persons like ourselves. Let us realise that if we make decisions and if we make literal utterances they may have consequences. Quite clearly, accepting the terrible realisation that all that involves, we must now bend all our energies on the political front so as to bring about a political transformation in the North of Ireland.
As we know the first step towards that political transformation is the next to impossible need to convert Mr. Edward Heath and his Government from the suicidal policies which they are pursuing. At best it can be said in defence of the present British Government that they do not know what they are doing, that they are incapable of understanding the problem, that they are no better and no worse than other British leaders that have gone before them. One would have thought that after centuries of oppression and coercion in Ireland, oppression and coercion which failed, a British Government in the latter half of the 20th century would realise that coercion would not succeed now any more than it did in the past.
Some people are saying that after Derry things can never be the same again. I do not think that is entirely right. Certainly many things will not be the same again. After the terrible events of last week we see no change in the attitude of the British Government, no change in the utterances and attitudes of the British Army who are executing the policy for the British Government, no change in the hearts, minds and dispositions of the die-hard Unionists, who do a gross disservice to the Protestant majority in the North of Ireland because they alone are responsible for the misery which is shared by both communities in the North of Ireland.
We must all have recoiled at the utterances of one Unionist MP whose only remark after Sunday was to utter congratulations to the British Army on their marksmanship. That indicated a dreadful state of mind; that the only good Catholic was a dead one. Nobody who is a Catholic in this country would consider for a moment or lead anybody else to believe that a good Unionist or a good Protestant is a dead one. If the dreadful happenings of last Sunday shatter some of the evil mythology under which our people have lived for so long then some good will come out of the evil.
We agree with the Government that in the face of the seeming intransigence of the present British Government we must resort to international action to win the support of friends of justice everywhere to the need to move in a correct direction to achieve peace and justice in the North of Ireland. We note that the Minister for Foreign Affairs is at present in America, having visited the United Nations. We consider that it is proper that he should make these visits but we should also like to see, as a matter of urgency on the Government side, moves to advise our European neighbours of the position in the North of Ireland. It is quite clear that Britain now would dread any worsening of her reputation in Europe. She is most anxious to get into the European Community. She is anxious to maintain friendships there.
Those of us who have had the privilege of recently being representatives of Ireland in the Council of Europe are aware of the immense concern which exists in Europe about the situation in the North of Ireland and we are also deeply conscious of the fact that most Europeans are not at all happy about the manner in which the British Government are dealing with the situation. We need now to bring more pressure to bear on our friends in Europe so that they will take the necessary initiatives to win the British Government away from the course of action which they are pursuing.
We accept and understand that the EEC is primarily a commercial and economic organisation but it is one that has serious and sound legitimate political objectives. It is not an organisation which can accept readily into its midst a country which is pursuing the repressive and deadly actions which the British Government are pursuing in the North of Ireland. Within the European Community you have for instance France, which is well aware of the inevitable evil consequences flowing from repressive measures and from depending on military solutions to achieve very difficult political ends. France has had her Algeria; Belgium has had her Congo. Most of the European nations are former colonial nations who are aware of all the difficulties which face big powers in endeavouring to deal with local difficulties. There is in Europe an immense fund of goodwill and we should certainly endeavour to harness that goodwill in Ireland's interest as quickly as possible.
We are conscious of the fact that both the SDLP and the Nationalists have expressed their unwillingness to accept the proposed judicial inquiry to be established under Lord Chief Justice Widgery. It is not for us to comment on the wisdom or otherwise of their actions, but we must accept that it is quite understandable in these difficult days that a purely British commission of inquiry will not be acceptable to the overwhelming majority of all Irish people. The world has moved forward in the last half century from the time when national governments were presumed to have complete control over affairs within their own borders.
We are fortunate enough to live in a world that accepts that human rights and individual freedoms transcend all domestic sovereignty, all individual loyalties. This being so, we should forthwith bring international machinery to bear to ensure that we have an international inquiry into the occurrences in Derry. What happened in Derry is in clear breach of Article 2 of the European Convention of Human Rights which guarantees the right to life. That right is admittedly qualified within the Article by entitling a Government under law to punish certain offences by depriving a person of life and also entitling a Government to use violence, even though it may cause death, in case of riots or armed rebellions.
These conditions did not exist in Derry last Sunday nor can even the paratroopers succeed in convincing their own Government that they existed in Derry last Sunday. We should not hesitate therefore forthwith to make this plain to the Secretary General of the Council of Europe for consideration by the European Commission of Human Rights. It is regrettable that it took the Government from August until November to decide to take a complaint to the European Commission about the undisputed cases of brutality and ill-treatment of prisoners in detention centres in the course of interrogation.
Do not let the same occur again. It is quite clear on the facts, and the Taoiseach accepted this, that there was a clear breach of the European Convention of Human Rights in Derry last Sunday, and the way to get an international inquiry, without further hesitation, into the matter is to make a form of complaint in Strasbourg which will set the necessary machinery in motion.
Speaking on Tuesday, Deputy Cosgrave on behalf of Fine Gael expressed our anxiety to present a united front in the face of this terrible national disaster. He promised the cooperation of Fine Gael in the belief that the best interests of Ireland will be served by showing to the British Government and to the world that we are united in our sense of shock and horror at what occurred, and also in our resolution to ensure that as far as it lies within our power it will not occur again. It would, however, be wrong for the Government to assume that Fine Gael can be depended on not to criticise the Government's actions. Certainly the Government should not assume that we would be satisfied with any gimmicky contrivance at consultation or participation unless we are given some opportunity to influence the decisions which the Government want to make.
As we say these things we do not for one moment detract from the right and authority, and indeed the duty, of the Government to make the necessary decisions and to have the necessary control over our affairs as far as lies in their power, but if there is to be a united front, then there ought to be effective, worthwhile, genuine and sincere consultation. This has not taken place to date, notwithstanding our repeated appeals in the past for consultation. We acknowledge that the Taoiseach spoke to Deputies Cosgrave and Corish this week. In the past two or three years there may have been a measure of consultation immediately following some extraordinarily new development, some new emergency, but that is not adequate in this great national crisis in which the full cooperation of everybody is required.
May I instance two examples of inadequate consultation in the face of serious developments? I believe the Taoiseach saw Deputy Cosgrave and, I think, Deputy Corish on the eve of the day on which he sent off a telegram to Mr. Heath, that rather disastrous telegram which had farreaching consequences because it was a major change of attitude on the part of the Government. When the Taoiseach had some difficulty in accepting that he should support the civil disobedience campaign, he suddenly changed his attitude and, without adequate consultation with the Opposition leaders, he sent off a telegram. Again this week we had the Taoiseach going on radio and again in the House making an announcement of serious import without any consultation with the Opposition as to whether it was the advisable course to adopt and, if it was being adopted, how the nation should go about doing it. I refer to the announcement by the Taoiseach to seek in the near future Dáil approval to provide money for political and peaceful purposes to enable the minority in the North of Ireland to secure freedom from Unionist domination.
That is a proposal which is certainly deserving of serious consideration, but it quite clearly would have been more helpful had such a matter been discussed with the Opposition parties before it was announced publicly. We have had rather unfortunate consequences from the last time that this House voted money. On that occasion it was for the relief of distress in Northern Ireland and the consequences, we know, were unfortunate. The matter is at present being examined by a Committee of this House and therefore I do not want to say anything which might in any way presume to anticipate the report of that inquiry. Suffice it to say that certain things happened which apparently should not have happened, giving cause for grave disquiet.
Similarly, if money is now to be voted for the purpose which the Taoiseach mentioned, which is a deserving cause, it is essential that the necessary machinery to ensure the proper application of that money is agreed on and, to get the necessary agreement, there should be sincere and genuine consultation before any decisions are taken which cannot later be reversed. Particularly the Opposition would want to ensure that there would be effective control over any money voted by this House for use outside its jurisdiction. That control would necessarily have to involve representation on a committee for representatives of all parties in this House as well as representatives of all opinions and interests being assisted outside. It is important that the credibility of recipients of money from this House should not be in question and unless there is that kind of consultation, which we hope the Taoiseach will now give, there is a real danger that greater difficulties may arise in the future.
There is also quite clearly a need to have continuing consultation on the question of internal security. When I speak of internal security I do not wish that any words of mine would be used mischievously by British or Unionist spokesmen to suggest that the cause of the violence and unrest in the North of Ireland is an attack on the North of Ireland based south of the Border. They know that is not so but, as the Taoiseach quite correctly has said, mischievously there have been certain people in the governing Unionist Party and indeed in the British Conservative Party who want to suggest it. It may be of interest to some Members here to know that so poisoned are the minds of some British Conservative MPs that one of them accused the Irish people of being responsible for the throwing of ink at Mr. Heath at the EEC signing ceremony in Brussels. Those words were uttered not in jest but in the serious belief by the man who uttered them that a Swedish girl living in Germany who had some opinion about some property movement in London was inspired by all the rebels in the South of Ireland. It is an interesting incident because it reflects the state of mind of so many members of the British Conservative Party on whom Mr. Heath relies for support.
I saw today a statement by Mr. John Taylor, one of the junior Ministers in the Unionist administration and one of the greatest mischief makers there, that he hoped the South of Ireland would take all security measures necessary to ensure that there would be no movement of the IRA from the South into Newry next Saturday. That sounds rather extraordinary when within the last 24 hours I was in Derry and we found that there were virtually no security measures taken by the British Government, by the armed forces, who could be present in mighty numbers to slaughter people who were unarmed. Even the most rudimentary precautions were not taken by them yesterday and, indeed, as anybody in this House who crosses the Border regularly knows, more often than not they are not taken at all. At the very time when those people who pretend to want to maintain control over security are not taking the steps necessary to secure their own territory they have the audacity to suggest that repressive measures should be taken in the South so that we could have in the South the evil that they, with their own criminal policies, have created in the North.
Let there be no doubt in anybody's mind but that the maintenance of peace and the rule of law in the Republic of Ireland is the greatest single contribution which can be made to the return of peace in the North of Ireland and to the creation of a just solution to the divisions which at present beset our people. Here, Sir, we are unhappy about the Government's action in this field. We feel that the Government have at last woken up to the terrible pit into which they have let the nation slip because of their lack of real discipline in the matter of internal security.
The events of the last 48 hours, where a building of the British Embassy was destroyed, may perhaps have satisfied many of the feelings of frustration and anger and bitterness which were in the hearts of many of our people but we must look at what the lesson really is. The lesson is that anarchists in our midst, those who in their own words are out to destroy the institutions of this State and of all Ireland, those who want to thrive on chaos, now know that if they get a sufficient number of unarmed civilians behind them, physically present, whether they agree with them or not, they can do untold damage. I think it would have been perfectly reasonable for the Government to have anticipated what might have occurred, to have anticipated it by having the necessary physical barricades there to ensure that these anarchists and evil-doers would not have got within striking distance of the Embassy. That simple precaution was not taken. There was a clear obligation on the Government to take it not only to protect the building but also to protect our gardaí from the kind of attacks to which they were subjected.
Comment on this
Those of us who first observed this incident on the earlier television broadcast yesterday were rather distressed that the building could be approached by people apparently in the presence of gardaí who did nothing to stop them but we saw later, of course, that the reason was that the gardaí were hopelessly outnumbered and that indeed had they endeavoured personally to intervene at the point at which developments had reached crisis proportions then there would possibly have been more serious injury to property and certainly most grievous injury, if not death, to persons.
This must not be allowed happen again. The Government, if they want to remain in government, must show they are a Government and they must govern in accordance with the wish of the people and that is that persons and property in this State be protected effectively. That requires sensible anticipation on the part of the Government. If they have not got the funds necessary or the personnel necessary to do it let them come into this House and they will get it from the representatives of the people because the greatest contribution we can make to the return of sanity to this island is to keep this part over which we have control peaceful. It is only by showing an example to the rest of Ireland, to Britain and to the world, that we can get the necessary support here and abroad for the sensible policy which we would want to see this country pursue. I did say in the natural reaction to the appalling tragedies of last week we have perhaps given insufficient thought to the views of 1,000,000 people in the North of Ireland who until now have been labelled as being opposed to Irish unity or not wishing to work with us. I agree with the Taoiseach when he says that there are now larger numbers than ever in the North of Ireland who want to see an end to the system which brings this evil upon them time and time again and which they realise will inevitably bring similar tragedies upon them unless something is done to change the system. This is not an occasion to propose anything in any specific detail because ultimately the mode of the Government of the North of Ireland, or of all Ireland, will have to be decided with the voice of the people of the North of Ireland clearly heard and clearly understood. I have suggested on other occasions and I again repeat —I think the events of last weekend underline the common sense of what I am saying—that the tragedies in the North arise out of the fact that you have there nearly 60 per cent of the people who profess loyalty to Britain although the loyalty of some of them is indeed very shallow because they have indicated from time to time that they are prepared to kick the British Crown into the Boyne rather than submit to direct rule from the sovereignty which they profess to respect. Nearly 40 per cent of the people, however, feel no attachment to the British sovereignty but do to the sovereignty of a Republic of Ireland. Are these two desires incompatible? I think they are not. A way out can only be found in a solution which recognises the two loyalties, the two outlooks of these two communities, and such could be found in a condominium in which the sovereignty over the North of Ireland would be shared by both Britain and the Republic of Ireland. Such would be an interim step which might restore peace then and at least would allow our people to begin to think about how they could live with one another.
That, Sir, is what we must do and our emphasis now must be on the way to live with our fellow Irish men and women. We must, as we have already in this House, say that arms are no answer and the message from the tragedy of last weekend is that the moral force of the unarmed mass is greater and more enduring than death inflicted by man upon man.
Comment on this
I should like to join in offering sympathy to the relatives of not alone the 13 who were killed in Derry last Sunday but the 260 odd who have lost their lives since this tragic affair started at Burntollet over two years ago. The tragedy is a great one. When we remember that already this year 28 people have lost their lives needlessly in Northern Ireland it brings the matter home to us how desperately important it is to get a solution to the whole matter.
One of the things which has rather surprised me in the two speeches we have heard this afternoon is that there did not seem to be that sense of urgency which I feel should be in what they were saying. While I could not disagree with what they did say unfortunately I felt that it was just as if the matter has to be dealt with some time. I believe it has got to be done now. I believe the initiative must be taken and that tomorrow is too late. Right from the time the tragedy was brought to a head on Sunday afternoon it became obvious to everybody that we could never go back, that we would never again have the situation which we had at that time. While I agree that the Government have taken certain steps. I believe they are not doing enough. Having said that, let me point out that, as far as we, in the Labour Party, are concerned, we are giving one hundred per cent support to anything the Government do. There are three major parties here who differ in certain matters of policy, but in this there is no difference. This is the old battle of Ireland v. England and we will give every support we can to the Government, to Fine Gael and to anybody else inside or outside this House who wants to bring a peaceful solution to this problem.
The unfortunate part of it all is that up until this week the Government were doing a "soft line" act with Britain. I sometimes feel a little bit ashamed when I hear some of the comments made by Government spokesmen and learn of some of the approaches made to Britain. Britain reciprocates as she always did with the old cliché of "Croppy, lie down"; this country, the poor relation, does not count; we are small people and we should not have the temerity to stand up, look Britain in the eye and tell her what we want. Britain forgets, apparently, and will continue to forget until we bring it home to her, that this is our country, all 32 counties of it. This is not some place out in Africa or in South America where there is a difference over borders. This is an island, 32 counties of Irish soil, and we are entitled to every square inch of it.
When the Treaty was signed, nobody, not even those in favour of it, suggested for one moment that it was a final solution. In fact, the British admitted it was a temporary solution, a stage, and from thence onwards we were eventually to have a 32-county country. But Britain took every opportunity to get out of that subsequently and it is now our job to see to it that she is brought back to square one. In my opinion we are not alone back to the 1921 situation but to the 1916 situation and, whether we like it or not, Britain considers herself at war with this country. I do not think we are exactly prepared to accept that situation or to allow it to continue any longer.
It is only right at this stage that some fairly well-known facts, though they are not repeated often enough, should be put on the record. The tragedy in Derry last Sunday was caused by a promise given by Mr. Faulkner, the Prime Minister of the puppet Six County State, to the Orange Order that, under no circumstances, would the march be allowed. Following on that, instructions were given to the Army that, under no circumstances, was the parade to be allowed. The difficulty appears to have arisen because when the parade was stopped, as it was stopped, and the marchers succeeded in persuading the 20,000 odd who were on this march that they should go back to Free Derry corner and have a meeting, as they were entitled to have a meeting even under the law in Northern Ireland, nobody told the British Army that it was not a parade and the gentlemen who were waiting in the background and who were to fire on the parade were apparently brought along and fired on the meeting. It is as simple as that. These facts cannot be stated too often and Mr. Faulkner, who likes to smile on the television screen and tell the people how serious the situation is, should never be let forget that responsibility for the deaths of the 13 people in Derry and the injuries to the others rests on his shoulders first, last and all the time; he was responsible and he must carry the responsibility.
Comment on this
We did not have to get into the Cabinet and spend other people's money to become rebels. We were always rebels. My people before me suffered for Ireland and I do not want any snide remarks now from anybody on the Fianna Fáil benches or anywhere else.
The position about the shooting in Derry last Sunday is that there is incontrovertible evidence that that shooting not alone took place by the hired assassins who went in there to fire at a peaceful meeting but it took place, in fact, at short range and people were fired at not just once but several times. Even children were picked out and shot. If what occurred in Derry last Sunday occurred in any English city, in Glasgow, or Liverpool, or London, or Swansea, what would have been the result? We know quite well that Mr. Heath would be on his way to the Palace to hand in his resignation within two hours of the facts becoming known. Not alone did this carnage happen in Derry but they are now, in fact, prepared to say that it was done in the interest of peace-keeping. The peace-keeping these people were there to do was not in fact carried out and those who committed these murders must be brought to justice. There is no point in saying they were acting under orders. These assassins are in the very same position as the Black-and-Tans were because they were selected and brought to the Six Counties from Britain to commit this act. In the last day or so I have seen a report that more of their kind will be coming in. If they do then the situation will be very, very bad indeed.
The Taoiseach referred to the day of mourning yesterday. It was indeed heartening to see the way people all over the country went to church services and paraded to show their solidarity with the people in the beleaguered North. It was heartening to see the thousands who marched and did exactly what they were supposed to do, demonstrate their solidarity with dignity. It is regrettable, very regrettable, that a small section, a section who will march at any time and for anything and who are, apparently, well used to this sort of thing, should have taken it on themselves to blacken the good name of this country by their actions. I am not talking about the destruction of the British Embassy. As far as that is concerned it may not do Mr. Heath one bit of harm to give him a kick in the pants and show him we do not have that much respect for his Government here. But it was unpardonable that public and private property should be damaged. Worst of all, was the attacking of the gardaí, whose job it is to protect people and property, and that applies even to those guilty of this blackguardism. I would like to pay a tribute to the gardaí. They do an excellent job. It is too bad they should have been subjected to all the abuse they got over the last few nights. I would appeal to the hundreds of thousands who went out to protest peacefully to show that they were not involved and do not want to be involved in this sort of thing. It is too bad that the "odd-bod" should spoil the dignity of the silent parades. I hope that, so long as there is need to parade over injustices, there will never again be a repetition of this sort of thing by people who are in the parades but are never of them.
With regard to the leaders of the three major parties here travelling to the United Nations, to the Council of Europe or to visit Mr. Heath—whether or not that would be any use I do not know—it is a good thing to have discussions. As a trade union official it has been my experience that, no matter how bitter the dispute, it is eventually settled sitting around a table. Even when it appeared two sides would not meet eventually they did meet and reached agreement no matter how bitter the discussion was beforehand. Nothing can be lost by having the facts put to all the important people to whom they can be put inside and outside the country. It is important to remember that if the Taoiseach takes a leaf out of Mr. Mintoff's book he might possibly wake up Britain to the fact that she is not the only pebble on the beach. I am sick and tired of people preaching, particularly in regard to the Common Market, that we must do what Britain does because she is our best customer. This morning one of the British newspapers suggested Britain should take the strong action open to her to deal with Ireland. Is it not fair to point out that we are Britain's best customer also and that we buy much more from her than she buys from us? So, two can play at that game. If Britain realised that there was somebody to replace her if she wished to try out an isolationist policy on this country she would perhaps be much easier to talk to. I am glad of the sterner line the Taoiseach and the Minister for Foreign Affairs are taking with Britain. This is the only way in which Ireland will get justice from Britain.
The Newry march question has been mentioned. I wonder if the incident we are now discussing will not be repeated again. I am aware that Mr. Heath has appealed to Cardinal Conway and Cardinal Heenan to use their influence to have the march called off. He says it would be an excuse for hooligans and would damage relations. The Stormont Security Office says the march will be stopped and the Northern Civil Rights Association say the march will go on. The one person who can stop the march is Mr. Heath.
Comment on this
All he has to do is to say that he is prepared to give concessions, that he is prepared to talk at top level and in a meaningful way about the problem. If he does, the march will not be necessary; but I believe the citizens of Northern Ireland have the right to march or demonstrate and if the death sentence is to be imposed on them again then I think the world will show Britain that she cannot carry on in this way. After all it is 1972 and not the time when Britain with her big empire was able to slaughter what she called the natives in other countries to prove she was the strongest power and that what she said had to be obeyed.
The Taoiseach mentioned the Italian journalist or photographer who gave evidence about what happened in Derry on Sunday. I suppose all of us have met people who were in Derry on Sunday and had their own version of what happened. It is extraordinary that with the exception of the British Army representatives all the stories seem to be the same. It is extraordinary that hundreds of people who have never met could have the same story of how it happened and that a small number of the British Army have a different story. A few questions asked particularly of the major of the paratroops showed that the man was feebly lying. The story he told was not acceptable even to a BBC interviewer who spoke to him on Sunday evening after the tragedy, when he said that in fact only three shots had been fired.
In the old time movies there was a character called Gabby Hayes who was always able to talk of all the Indians he killed with one arrow. The paratroopers apparently with three shots killed 13 and injured 16 or 17 more. Even more extraordinary, they were firing up at the flats where the snipers were alleged to be but shot people on the ground. They should be taken back to Britain and given a course on the range. If they are such bad shots I do not know what they will do if they ever come up against the real thing. They were shooting, and they knew it, at unarmed people. When I hear some people talk about defending the Nationalist minority in the North with arms I feel it was rather a pity that a few of those defenders did not happen to be around at that time and perhaps the paratroopers would not have found such easy meat.
There has been a suggestion that there should be an inquiry and Britain has again produced the rabbit out of the hat. Last year at the Inter-Parliamentary Union Conference in Paris I made a speech, which was not very popular with some people and I believe with some members of the Government party, in which I said that the Commission then being set up consisting of three Englishmen would not be accepted by anybody in Ireland. It has never been accepted that we can take from Britain evidence collected by three Englishmen as being the truth. When the report was made it turned out that we were right and that the British report was, as usual, a concocted affair. At that time there were three men involved; we now have one and, as was pointed out by John Hume early this morning, surely they do not expect us to believe that that one man who was a former high officer in the British Army will bring in a report saying the British Army were in the wrong.
There should be an international commission set up to find out, as the Taoiseach said, whether human rights have been violated and if so the British Government and particularly Mr. Heath should stand trial. He is responsible for anything that has been done in the Six Counties.
There has been talk about the necessity to prove to our Protestant neighbours in the North that they will be safe and will get the freedom they require in the Republic when a united Ireland comes, and I say when it comes deliberately because it must come. We must all admit that there are some matters in our Constitution which need changing and arrangements must be made to have them changed but they are not so vital that they can hold up unification. The story that all the Northern Protestants are afraid to come into the Republic in case they would not get fair play is a lot of hooey. The Protestants who are living in the Republic are living evidence that it is hooey.
Many of these people say, and I think Mr. Paisley is the one who repeats it most often, that it is because of their loyalty to the Crown that they do not want to come in with us. The only Crown to which these people had any loyalty is one which has now gone out of existence, the one they jingled in their pockets. The only reason they want Britain to remain is that they want British money. They have absolutely no loyalty to anybody except LSD. Now that that has changed perhaps they could also change. The time has come when we must attempt to get the Protestants in the North to realise that we have given them living proof in the Republic that there is equal freedom there for Protestants. The Tánaiste now sitting in the Front Bench is one man who can give living proof of this as also can the Fine Gael Deputy from his constituency. In a constituency like Monaghan we have two Protestant representatives out of three. Yet they tell us: "We would not get fair play if we went into the Republic."
No greater evidence can be produced to prove to them that the freedom which they say they want is here already. It is my belief that we are getting quite close to a solution to this problem. I do not say that because of reaction to what has happened in Derry but during the past six months in particular there has been an expression on the part of ordinary British people that the time has come for a change. They are sick and tired of what is going on. I think that if the matter were put to the British public now, there would be a very substantial majority in favour of freedom for all of Ireland. This is the basis on which we must work. It is very wrong for certain people to vent their spleen about events in Northern Ireland, against individual British people either here or elsewhere. They must remember that the majority of the ordinary British people are in favour of the reunification of our country. Those who take action against British people or British interests here who have been carrying on a fair trading relationship with this country for many years seem to forget the hundreds of thousands of Irish people who are working in Britain. If they could encourage the Irish people working in Britain to use their not inconsiderable influence in persuading everybody they can contact in Britain of the justice of our case for a united Ireland, they would be doing a lot towards solving the problem. This petty hooliganism that has been carried out by a small number of people should be and must be stopped. If we set ourselves towards doing that, there is a hope that we will reach a peaceful solution to the problem.
I should like to refer, too, to something that has happened during the past few days. The events of Derry seem to have wiped away everything else from the minds of the people and, in particular, from the minds of those in this House. I refer to the incident which occurred at Narrow Water outside Dundalk when the British troops shelled a house in the Republic. This was sheer audacity. Imagine the British Army having the temerity to shell a house in what they call "another country". Imagine them being allowed by their officers to attack and burn property on this side of the Border. The British Government were not so quick to notify the Irish Government that they would accept responsibility for the damage done as were our Government who did not wait until this morning but who last night assured the British Government that they were prepared to pay for any damage done to the British Embassy. I suppose the niceties of inter-Government play ensure that the Government had to make that assurance but they could have waited until today to do so. Indeed, as they were doing so, they should have pointed out that property on this side of the Border was damaged by British mortar fire and that regardless of whether the condition of the house concerned was good or bad, our Government should have demanded compensation for it.
Concerning the events in Derry, many of us are inclined to believe that the incident there was something that just happened because somebody became excited. I believe that the British paratroopers who are trained for such work and who have many people in their particular trade who are paid to kill thirsted after blood and that once they started shooting they could not be stopped. There was a report that before they opened fire, 200 rounds had been fired but it is evident now that no shots were fired at them until after they had killed the 13 people. For some peculiar reason all arms in the area that were held by the other people seem to have been withdrawn for the purpose of allowing a peaceful parade to go through. With that in mind we must remember that if the British Army had not intervened at all and had stayed out of sight as they did on previous occasions, the Derry march and meeting could have passed without incident. Remembering this, we must make an appeal that the British Army be kept out of Newry on Sunday. Unless Mr. Heath can offer something that will solve the problem and unless he will say that he is prepared for talks in settling the problem, the march will take place. Like the portion of Derry where the event occurred last Sunday, the town of Newry is, in the main, a nationalist or, if you like, Catholic area and any effort made there by the British troops to inflict the same sort of punishment on people who believe they have a God-given right to protest may not be dealt with in the same way as it was on the previous Sunday by the recipients of their missiles. Therefore, I would conclude by saying that no matter what happens, people in this part of the country must keep their heads. We are all grateful for the combined efforts in making a dignified protest yesterday. We are glad that steps are now being taken by the Government to ensure that a stronger line will be taken with Britain rather than the one we had been taking so far of asking them whether they would consider this, that or the other.
Although we are a small nation, our country is respected throughout the world and we should be able to enlist the help of those people who are important in world affairs. We should prove to Britain that they cannot over-ride us simply because of the fact that they are Britain and that in the past they were great. The British Empire is almost gone. Britain has given freedom to areas all over the world which were held in thrall for centuries. It is about time that she granted the same freedom to the portion of Northern Ireland that she holds still. The British Army is welcome no longer in this country and they should get out. Their going would bring a certain amount of peace in the area. In addition. Britain must make available the money that will be necessary to repair the damage she has done to this country during the past number of years. That, also, is her moral responsibility. When Deputy Corish is replying to the debate he will cover a number of other items with which I did not have time to deal.
Comment on this
The sympathy of the entire country has gone out to the people of Derry who suffered such grievous injustice on Sunday last and the sympathy of the Government and of the other parties in the House has been conveyed personally to these people. However, sympathy in itself is not enough. The relatives of those who were murdered need our help and we have a duty to help them in every way possible. I refer to the help that we can give very effectively by ensuring that no person in Derry who is in need of help will be refused that help.
There are many ways in which we can help. First of all, the people of Derry need money, because in the much-vaunted British welfare State there are families in Derry who, as a result of the punitive action taken against them by the Six County regime, are living on as little as £3 a week because they will not bend to the whims of the Unionists and be good little citizens according to the Unionist rules.
The people who protest here in the streets have a right to protest, but the protest should take the form of some definite help for the people in Derry, Belfast and the rest of the Six County area. It is all very well to demonstrate in Merrion Square or to shout in other parts of the city, but the most effective protest against British injustice is to give help to the victims of that injustice until such time as we can end that injustice effectively.
The Taoiseach and Deputy Tully referred to acts of blackguardism in the city last night. I support their condemnation of the small minority who smashed windows not of British firms but of an Irish firm a quarter of a mile from this House whose founder played a big part in the fight for freedom. That was the thanks he got from some of these people last night.
Comment on this
I am taking the example of one firm. Let the Deputy make his own speech. He is confused as usual.
Comment on this
I am not in the least confused. What I am saying is that the windows of one Irish firm were smashed last night for no apparent reason. We remember that in the 1916 Proclamation Pearse, Clarke, Connolly and the rest appealed to people not to besmirch the cause of Irish freedom by looting and rapine. In this House today we have to make the same appeal to the small minority who burned a motor car, smashed windows and so on. I do not know how they think they are helping people in the North who are oppressed. We saw enough burned motor cars in Derry yesterday, broken houses and, indeed, broken lives. If we want to help in the North, our greatest need is for a disciplined approach to the problems which are caused by Partition, always remembering that it is not the British firms who are operating here who are our enemy. As Deputy Tully said, many of these firms carry on a good business here and have been good employers. The enemy and the cause of Partition is the British Government. The Tory Government today is as much to blame as were those who first formulated Partition. Therefore let us direct all our efforts against Britain and its Government and try to bring some sense into their activities in 1972.
The people of all classes and all creeds in this country are starting to question whether their approach to this problem has been right. I speak as a moderate, as a person who does not like violence, but we have seen the violence in Derry yesterday and last Sunday. There is continuing violence, and it may not always be shooting; there is the violence of denying basic rights to the minority in the North. We have tried to impress on the people of the world the terrible injustice. People may say that very little progress has been made in achieving peace and that things are getting worse.
When one sees that 13 people were shot in Derry last Sunday for holding a march, that there are two or three concentration camps full of men, all because they exercise the right of free men to choose the form of democratic government they desire, one almost despairs of the British Government ever listening to reason, and one asks what can we do here in this House to end this state of affairs. We cannot go to war. The use of force is so futile eventually, having regard to the fact that for the past 300 years, since the Plantation of Ulster, force has been used against the people in that part of the country and, indeed, in the whole country. Yet the people of Derry or Belfast or any other part of the country are not beaten. If the British Government have done one thing it is to show that force is not a solution to this problem. We have impressed on the British Government again and again the need for some political initiative, and at times one sees a hope that in Britain they are thinking along these lines. But the British Premier seems to be in the hands of the old die-hard Tories who will not give one inch to this country. I suppose we are very lucky that we have not got dark skins or they would really go to town altogether. In the eyes of Britain it is wrong that the people in the North, who like ourselves, have not got dark skins, should have the hope of establishing a nation and a society to conform with their beliefs and their ideals, and in the eyes of Britain this is wrong and must be smashed.
I have never accepted the suggestion that the situation in the North of Ireland was a matter of Catholic versus Protestant. I have always seen it as a battle of the haves and the have nots. We see the Unionist junta in the North wanting to hold on to the spoils of office. They want to give out the jobs and the rewards to their camp followers. It must be remembered that the Protestant worker in the Shankill Road or Ballymacarrat or Fountain Street in Derry has no place in the Unionist aristocratic scheme of things, but they use them in a very cunning way in order to bolster up their own regime. The Protestant worker in the North has been so brainwashed by the Unionist that he has gone on supporting and voting for Unionist candidates. However, the Protestant worker is starting to think more for himself and I believe that soon we shall see the Protestant backlash, not the one to which Northern speakers refer but one that will come against the Unionist regime in the North who for many, many years have used these men in the Queen's Island Shipyard and the linen mills and told them that should they ever dare to vote against a Unionist candidate or to enter a united Ireland, they would pay for it by being denied basic rights in the South, or in a united Ireland.
I wonder what rights have the Stormont Government ever given to the unemployed in the Six Counties or to the workers in general. They have always had an unemployment rate of almost 7 per cent. Some time ago the Rev. Paisley spoke about housing in the North and showed us how bad matters are there. Of course the Faulkners and people like that do not live in these houses. They are reserved for the people in the working areas, in the Shankill and other areas in Belfast and in areas in Derry. It may be said that we are also short of houses, which is very true, and that we have got unemployment here, which is very true.
On those very points we have an affinity with the Protestant workers in the North and a basis for building a society in which there will be no place for the Faulkners or the Unionist regime, a society in which each man, irrespective of his religion or his political beliefs, will have a place in the scheme of things. We should direct our efforts not to speaking to Mr. Heath or Mr. Faulkner but to the ordinary people in the North. We should show them what we have in common with them and we should assure them that, when they come in here, they will be treated as equals, not because they are Protestants or Catholics or anything else, but because they are Irishmen and this nation is for the Irish.
When one goes to the North one feels very resentful at being stopped and searched in one's own country by British soldiers. Of course the British soldiers are merely cogs in the British machine. I am convinced that those soldiers who murdered 13 people last Sunday did not do so by accident. I watched these men in the Bogside before. When a march or a meeting took place the British Army came as far as Rossville Street or William Street and stayed there. The people went into the Bogside. There might have been cheering and shouting and perhaps some stones thrown, but there were no killings. Why was the pattern changed last Sunday? On whose instructions was the order given to fire on these people? The British Army said they were fired on first but that has been denied by many impartial people.
On a BBC programme last Sunday an interviewer questioned the officer in command. It was plain that the interviewer was a man with some human feelings. He asked the officer how many shots the Army had fired and, when the officer said three, the interviewer said: "I saw at least three bodies". The point I am making is that I believe there are still millions of decent people in Britain who feel like the rest of us that each man should have his rights and should be guaranteed his rights. Our task is to try to get the British people to bring some sanity into the actions of their own Government.
We must get help for the people in the North. Our people down here who are living in comparative comfort do not appreciate what the people of Derry are suffering. You may think that the barricades across the streets are ugly. You may think that the barricades are made up of somebody's property. Then you speak to the people and you realise that, if the barricades were not there, nobody would live in the Bogside or Creggan because the British soldiers, acting on the instructions of the British Government, would be in there night, noon and morning to persecute and, indeed, to kill the people living there.
I know there are differences of opinion in this House on our approach to the North, but we all share the basic belief that something very definite must be done. The Minister for Foreign Affairs has gone to the United States to enlist whatever support he can get there. Let me state this. We expect something from the Americans, and especially the Irish Americans, in this dire hour in our history. I want the most powerful nation in the world, the United States, to be our guarantor until democracy is restored in the Six Counties, until each man, irrespective of his beliefs or his creed, is as free as any American, and until a Bill of Rights like the American Bill of Rights applies in the Six Counties.
While this festering sore continues in existence we cannot start to build a new Europe. We cannot start to build a new Europe until justice and freedom are available to all people in the older Europe. I heard Deputy Ryan, Deputy Aiken and the Minister for Justice speaking in Strasbourg last week. They pointed out to the Council of Europe a few salient points about the situation here and in the North, particularly in the North. I am glad to say that, when the three speakers had finished, we found that 90 per cent of the Council of Europe were very appreciative of the points made, and had a better understanding of the whole question.
In the attacks made on us both publicly and privately by the British Tories we were made aware of their hatred of this country. This was a revelation to me because never before had I seen a British Tory in such a state of anger. It did not frighten me but I had hoped that that type of thing had disappeared with the old British Tory Party. That feeling is still there against this country. It reminded me of a very old bully who is dying. In his death throes he can be vicious and cause damage. I hope that I am witnessing the end of British imperialism. We have often been given the credit for having started the fight against British imperialism. It may be that we will have to wait for a few months or a year until we see the end of British imperialism. Then the people in the North, Protestant and Catholic, will be able to unite and build the new Ireland which we seek.
I want to stress that in the meantime the people of Derry are suffering grievously. To anyone who did not appreciate that, yesterday showed how deeply they are suffering. Our freely elected Government must be in the vanguard in creating the new order in the North. In the country there are many divisions on what we should do. In this very grievous hour for the country, North and South, we must look for and expect the support of all our people. Pearse, Connolly, Clarke and MacDiarmada called for the support of all our people, which they eventually received, when they set out in 1916 to throw off the British yoke. We have a duty to the people in the North both Catholic and Protestant. Our duty to the Catholic is to provide immediate help so that they will suffer less the torment and the persecution of the British. Our second duty is to the Protestant from the Lagan to the Bann, to set out on a crusade to show these people that the Faulkner regime is just as much their enemy as it is ours, that Stormont must go before we can go on the onward march.
We must convince the less well-off people of the Protestant community in the North that our only desire for a united Ireland is so that we can guarantee to each citizen of that new Ireland full rights and no persecution, that we will create a society in which we can guarantee employment, housing and an opportunity to the boys and girls who come from Protestant schools or Catholic schools the same opportunities here to better the society they live in and that they will have their rights guaranteed to them.
Deputy Tully mentioned that there is a demand for changes in the Constitution. Perhaps there are changes needed but I do not think that they are at the moment any barrier to unity. I believe that things are so dire in the Six Counties at the moment that even a Protestant in Belfast or Ballymena is not worried about our Constitution. He may be worried about getting a job or a house or he may wonder what future there is for his children in a country like ours at the moment. It may well be that he would point to us and say that we have made mistakes. I am sure we have but they were only mistakes. We did not set up any deliberate policy to persecute anybody. We did not try to set the Protestants against the Protestants. The mistake which we very often make is that we equate Protestantism with Unionism but there is little affinity between them. There is only the fact that the Unionist leaders who have had the benefits of wealth can get the message across much better than the lower-paid workers can.
When we go to the North and talk to those people, although they are not madly rushing into a united Ireland, we find that the business element and the middle-class people are those who are beginning to realise that the British promises may help them for a while, may ensure that the higher rank Unionist has a good job and a fair share of wealth but there is no guarantee for the future. The Protestant workingman in the North who up to recently would never think of a united Ireland is beginning to think that way. I suppose this is quite natural because I am sure there are many of them in the Shankill and other such places who are asking themselves what could be worse than what they have at the moment.
When Britain accuse this Government of not controlling the Border, which they put there, we realise how ineffective their Army in the North is. It can be very effective if it is attacking unarmed people. However, Derry last Sunday has shaken quite a number of people who up to this could see no good coming out of the Bogside. I feel we should make more demands on Britain. They cannot give back life to the people who were murdered last Sunday or to over 200 people who were previously murdered. Surely Britain with their huge army and police force could have prevented a public-house being blown up and killing over a dozen people in the heart of Belfast. The British are in no position to point to the shortcomings of the Government or of the people here.
I hope we may get a leader in Britain of the same calibre as the late General de Gaulle who may see the wisdom of effecting a settlement with this country as de Gaulle did in relation to the settlement between Algeria and France. There is a very broad analogy there and we should begin our preparation for the new Ireland. One of the first things we should do is to total the amount of compensation which Britain must in all fairness pay us for both North and South. Let Britain pay compensation and we can guarantee that the Northern people will enjoy, if that is the word, the same social services as they do at the moment until such time as we have a united 32-county Ireland and then we will draft our own social order in a democratic way which will provide employment, housing and the right to pursue their own happiness for all our people.
Comment on this
It has been said earlier today that this debate has been precipitated by Sunday's happenings. Perhaps to a degree this is so but I would remind the House—I do not do so merely to say that I was right—that I sought and asked for a debate here on the first day the House resumed after the Christmas recess. The reason I did this was not to sound off but rather to warn the Government and through them we hoped to warn Britain that her new initiative in opening a further internment camp, a further concentration camp, which it properly should be described, at Magilligan in sight of County Donegal was not only wrong but was provocative. This plea was not only not heard but was totally and completely ignored.
Perhaps had we had such a discussion, perhaps had we taken some action as a result of such discussion we might not have had the Derry episode, the massacre and the murders that we have experienced only last week. I say to the Government and I say to every Member of each of the parties in this House that if they think by what they have been saying in this House in the last few days about their new-found unity they are representing this House, then they can count me out and they can count hundreds of thousands of the people of this country out as well, because this new-found unity of purpose, this getting together of the three party hacks to do nothing about the situation, except by mutual consent to protect themselves in their own inactivity, is not representative of the people of this country.
I will not let them get away from this. I will express exactly what I feel on this occasion in the very short time available to me. I will not be overcritical but I cannot help but say that there is no unity of minds in this House as expressed by the Leaders of the three parties here last Tuesday when we adjourned the House as a mark of respect for the deaths in Derry. When I say that, I am saying it on behalf of the people throughout this land who are not represented by those views no matter how well held and how well believed they are by the Leaders of the three parties.
At this late stage can I appeal to the Leaders in this House to come alive and to come awake to the real situation that has been so evident to some of us for so long and about which I have given warnings time and time again since 1968, before there were any heads cracked, before there were any people shot and killed. I want to remind the House of the facts now. Instead of cognisance being taken of what I was then reading into the situation, I was misrepresented to say the least of it; I was condemned and I was branded as a violent man because I was trying as best I could to read the circumstances, to read what was coming, to warn this House and our people of what was coming in order that we might take action to prevent it.
In 1968 I indicated that the civil rights movement then emerging strongly, seeking reforms of the laws and the institutions of the Six Counties, was not enough, that the true civil rights was unity of this country and nothing short of it. I was blackguarded in the House for saying it. Twice in 1969 I was condemned roundly in this House; I was rapped over the knuckles time and again by my own Leader and the Leaders of the other parties, merely because I was reading the signs and conveying to this House what those signs indicated. All my predictions have, unfortunately, come true.
We have heard about the reforms. We have been given a list of the reforms. We had the B Specials stood down shortly to be replaced by the UDR which is the same wolf in another sheep's clothing. The UDR were formed to take up the slack when the B Specials left off. We had the British Army being welcomed in place of the B Specials and today we have them abhorred, properly so, by the whole minority population of the Six Counties.
We have the IRA being condemned by many of the people who wished them into existence when there was nothing to stand between the minority and the hordes of the B Specials and the Orange mobs who were backing them up except the IRA. The IRA have gained in numbers as the British Army have lost the respect they had when they arrived there first. They have lost respect not because of anything that we do not know about but because of the fact that they became a partisan force very shortly after arriving, as any such force of the British Army must do because the brass who came in with them have Unionists as their associates and Orangemen of the junta that is acting as the Government in Stormont. Therefore they must become flavoured, they must become coloured. This is the only contract they have. They did become coloured; they became the tools and the weapons of Mr. Brian Faulkner and his regime in the Six Counties.
Where are the searches that were to be carried out to uproot and to weed out the arms that are held in their hundreds of thousands in the Six Counties by the Orangemen and by the extreme Unionists? Where is Mr. Taylor, this warmonger if there ever was one? I seldom criticise individuals in the Six Counties, whether in the Government or in Opposition, but this supreme warmonger of the Six County Government, where is he and what is he doing in his new-found office, with his 102,000 licensed arms in the Six Counties held mainly by his own supporters, by the so-called gun clubs which have sprung up like mushrooms in the past two years? Where was Mr. Taylor when among those 102,000 licensed arms we know there are at least two and half score of heavy calibre machineguns which Mr. Taylor has licensed to civilians? The reasons given for those licences is to protect the salmon fisheries by shooting otters. Are the otters all Catholics, are they all Nationalists? Is this the purpose of these heavy calibre machineguns? Let Mr. Taylor go and clean up his own nest before he starts telling us here what to do. Mr. Taylor is a warmonger of the first order.
There are those who condemn Paisley and Craig and such people. Those men are men of conviction, whether you agree with them or not, and one of these days they are the people, and those whom they represent, whom we will have to deal with, but at least when dealing with men of conviction you know where you start and where you finish and you know that if you reach agreement you have an agreement. But if you are dealing with fiddlers on the roof, such as Faulkner, Taylor and others, politicians in the lowest sense, merely holding on to the graft, holding on to the influence, holding on to the jobbery in order to perpetuate themselves, they are not people you can deal with because even having done a deal, as somebody said, having done a deal an honest man is alone, when he is bought he stays bought, but those boys do not stay bought. They would have the same respect for us as they would for the British Government, and the same loyalty too. Their loyalty is worth as much as the money they are getting from the British taxpayers, worth as much as the protection they get for their own nefarious deeds from the British Army. They are the people we must beware of. They are the people we should tell to clean up their own nest before they start talking about what we are doing or not doing. Let Taylor call in his 102,000 licensed arms, his heavy calibre machineguns for shooting otter, and then let him come back and start talking about what is being done here.
Let us leave that for the moment and go back to some of the other warnings I gave to the House and to the country. Let us recall the efforts I made by public speeches to try to get the three Governments of the Six Counties, Dublin and Westminister to sit down as far back as 1969 in order that the holocaust now being visited on the Six Counties could be avoided and that we would begin to find a way towards a solution and towards the unity of the country and ultimately of our people. Let us recall those. I will not do so because they are there on record and the comments on them are on record and I hope those who are now convinced of the truth of what I then said will at least continue to recognise that truth and to do something about it, to get down to the brass tacks of the situation today and not to confuse themselves and the country further by talking about a peaceful solution when the violence is being prepetrated by the British Army on behalf of the British Government and the Six County Government here and now.
How can we have peaceful solutions unless we are advocating the complete clearance of every Nationalist and every Catholic from the Six Counties? Is that what we mean by peaceful means in these dire circumstances of extreme violence being perpetrated upon us? Or are we to do what any red-blooded people would do, stand up and tell Mr. Heath and his Government that we seriously represent the voice of our people and that we are getting our Army put on full stand-to? We want our entire reserves to be called and we want the FCA, all 20,000 of them, called into full service. We want the Army on the Border and we want Mr. Heath to be told by this House without question that we are not having any more of the Derry episodes of last Sunday.
Surely to God it must come into the minds of the people here that we are only fiddling at the whole problem, that we are only trying to get ourselves out of our dilemma by talking about it and not acting seriously? People will throw their hands up and say "This would be war". There is war in the Six Counties. Mr. Maudling said it last August. We who are associated closely with it know that there has been war there for the past two years, that there is war today and there will be war tomorrow and there will be more marchers and there will be more deaths. That is why this debate was urgently needed today, not next week, in order that there might still be the opportunity of bringing home to the British Government, to Mr. Maudling, to Mr. Heath, that there will be more marches, that so long as there are nationalist-minded people in the Six Counties who have seen what has gone on over these last generations, who have tolerated and suffered under what they have endured in these past few years, that they will march while there are any of them left to stand and that their laws prohibiting those marches are not going to be allowed to stick, that protest is not going to be allowed to be wiped out even by the bullet shooting down innocent people.
Premeditated murder was the action of the British Army last Sunday and let there be no doubt about it. Let them have their inquiry, let them have it international or all British, whatever way they like. It does not matter a damn. It was murder, murder in the first degree, premeditated, arranged, with their troops deployed, these boyos with the wine-coloured berets, these trained killers, these shock troops were brought in and deployed around the city from as early as 11 o'clock. They took over parts of the city, parts they were never in before. They departed at half past three, did their dirty work and returned to the same points of deployment and stayed for a further two hours, from half past five to half past seven. What doing? Playing record players, playing their radios and singing bawdy songs. They are the boyos who went out and butchered the people of Derry last Sunday. We are asked then to have dignity, to have discipline, to have no emotions. We have got to be emotional certainly if there is any feeling in us. There is nothing wrong with being emotional. Without emotion in a time like this we cannot reach the proper conclusions because these conclusions may be too terrifying for us to take in cold logic as we are advised to do. Emotion plays a big part in matters such as these. I am sorry, indeed, that all the Members of this House and many thousands more should not have been in Derry yesterday or the day before during their days of grief and mourning, to go and see and witness for themselves on the spot. It is all very well from down here to talk about what should be done logically, what should be done unemotionally, what should be done disregarding what has already happened. When you see those coffins laid out side by side, when you see the very men who have fought with bare hands carrying their own comrades out, to see those men yesterday with tears streaming down their cheeks, to see the bereaved widow, to hear her, to find her trying to get into the grave beside her dead husband, to see the young widow following, hanging on to the coffin of her dead husband, and to hear above all the six year old in the church as the coffin of his father was being removed, calling for his daddy, and then we talk about no emotions.
Surely we here as an Irish Government, not that long established, but with the proud tradition of being established on the memories and the blood of our dead patriots, surely we in this House after 50 years of control of our own destiny on this side of the Border, are not going to stand by and see more of the butchery and the murder done by these troops or any other troops to our people while we have any means at our disposal to deter such continuance and such happenings. This is what you are being asked for today. This is what your people whom you represent want you to do. They want you to stand now, even if you did not stand before, to do what we said we would do in 1969, not to stand idly by. Let us remember 1969, at the beginning of this terrible time our people have gone through. Let us recall it. Let us recall how our Taoiseach then truly was representing the vast majority of the people of this country when he made his now famous speech in those dark days of August, 1969 and if we have strayed since then from that declared intention which I have no doubt was right then, has been right since and is truly right now, surely even though we have strayed we must at least learn from our experience, from our mistakes and have some regard for the real dilemma in which the British Government must find itself. There is Mr. Brian Faulkner and, despite what I have said of him before, I will say this for him: he is playing the Unionist game as well and as good and as truly as ever a Unionist in the Six Counties did in his position.
Comment on this
We are not countering the game he is playing and he is being heard in London. He is being believed. They are acting in London on his advice because we seem to have been agreeing with him instead of countering him in every item and every iota everything he has been carrying to them. If the British Government are to blame, as I believe they are to blame, completely for Sunday's massacre because that was what it was, murder premeditated by the forces of the Crown, then that Government can point a finger at this Government and say we are to blame considerably because we did not make them aware or combat Brian Faulkner's propaganda to the degree that we should in order to give them an opportunity of realising that there were two sides to this story and not just one. Let us consider that not in any vindictiveness or spitefulness but rather as a hard reality.
Time and again I have said it outside—I am saying it again today—will we be at least fair to those people in Britain who do not know and do not care what happens to us here, who never have cared unless when they could use us to their own advantage? Let us at least try to get through to them by acting as any people should and would act in our circumstances by putting all we have got on the slate in the morning and saying, as I have said to Mr. Heath: "You cannot do it again, you must not do it again and you must take your army out of this land of ours once and for all." That we owe to the people of the Six Counties; that we owe to those who have died that we might freely talk here today. Let us consider that and try to act on it even yet. It is not too late despite the fact that the number is now creeping towards 300 dead since this whole business started three years ago. Let us also ask that the paratroops should be taken out now and that the appalling information that has been circulating last night that instead of this battalion going there is a hold-up in Hollywood Barracks and they are being joined by a second battalion of these Red Caps. Let us try to get to Mr. Heath before this madness is further perpetrated and he doubles the number of these murdering blackguards that have come in his name to this land of ours before it is too late. Let us ask that they be taken out even as a token immediately, before the week-end, before the next Civil Rights march that is going to take place without any doubt and that is going to have among its numbers as many from the South as from the North.
Comment on this
Do not forget that our veneer has now been broken and if the British Embassy has been burned let me say that I shed no tears for it. Let me say this, and I do not say it in viciousness or bitterness to the British people or their Government, the Gardaí or the forces of peace in this country behaved in a manner that was exemplary in the circumstances when these places were being burned. Because, what the hell could we do with 25,000 of our people screaming for some manner of ventilating their own frustration that we have been the cause of building up for the past two years? Would it not have been madness, would not our hospitals be full today, not only of our people but of our fine Garda force as well? I do not know what was the motivation. They are being accused of doing nothing. By their action or inaction, I regard their behaviour the other night as the best example of wisdom that any Garda force has ever displayed in this or any other country in the circumstances that were facing them. The cost of the embassy building being destroyed is a small price to pay as against what might have happened if there had been madness enough at the top of our police force to say, "Go in and wall up those people". It just cannot be done.
The people in this country have, as I say, broken through the veneer, prompted by the murder and the bloodshed in Derry and there is no force in this land that could have stopped them. Let there be no doubt about that. Let us not run off conveying our sympathy to the British, although we may express our diplomatic regret. Let us be realists in this matter, if on no other. This is something that, in fact, ended cheaply for us in the burning of the British Embassy.
Let me say also that in so far as our Government's action is concerned in the past few days, it is a beginning but it is a very puny, insignificant beginning. Withdraw our Ambassador; take him home. What do they care whether we take him home or not? What difference does it make? We still continue to operate over there and I am not advocating that we should not. What is a gesture? Whom are we trying to impress? Certainly, if it is the British Government, who are the people in the key role here and the only people who can begin to bring an end to the trouble in this country, then, withdrawing our Ambassador for some weeks or some months will not make the slightest difference to them. They only understand the obvious and that is what we have got to put on the line. We should say to them that we are having no more of this and at the same time we should ask every person in the service of the Crown in the Six Counties who has any Irish blood in him to resign, and withdraw in protest immediately. We should ask them to get out of the RUC, the UDR, the British Army, we should ask the titled people not only in the Six Counties but particularly in the South to renounce their titles. Let us have away with their titles, decorations and medals much though they may be prized and much though they may have been merited by those who now wear them. I say, "If you are Irish, let it be seen at this time that you are Irish and do not wear the regalia of the Crown or of the Queen whose forces are butchering your own people in your own land at a time such as this in 1972." Let us have from those people on this side of the Border a renunciation of their titles, a returning of their decorations and medals. If they do not want to send them back, I would be quite happy to receive them and to do with them what should be done. The same as the flag was symbolically burned the other night, we can burn those too.
Let us get after the EEC countries whom we are about to join. Do they mean anything? Does that association mean anything? Will it mean anything in the future? Now is an excellent time to find out. Now that we are on the threshold of opting to go in, by the wishes of our own people, let us ask the help of the Six—and there are friends there; remember their protest yesterday as far away as Germany. One of their citizens was killed when they were demonstrating against what is being done in Derry. Then we down here are cavilling and half-crawling and apologising because of the fact that our people are beginning to show the spirit that left us the freedom we are enjoying here at this very moment. Let us ask the people on the Continent to use their very decided influence on Britain today. Britain is also going into the Common Market. She believes she must get in in order to survive. Let the Six tell her that she has got to settle up and get out and take her baggage with her out of the Six Counties now. If they do that, it will be more effective than all the other spiels we may give, no matter from what corner of the globe.
We have sent our Minister for Foreign Affairs abroad to seek, as he said last night, help from anywhere he can get it. That is a very laudable thing to do and a proper thing to do. We did it in 1969 but got very little return and will get less return now unless we are prepared to help ourselves. We must help ourselves by displaying to the world that we are prepared to risk what we have got here for the sake of our people in the Six Counties and that we are not afraid to risk it and that we are not concerning ourselves with holding on, to our own benefit and to the exclusion of the other citizens of this land who are divided from us by an unnatural boundary. Let us put it on the line. Let the world see that we are serious. Let Mr. Heath see that we are serious. It is my firm belief that we will then get action to begin to dismantle this Border that is the problem and the trouble and will continue to be so long as there are people up there and down here with any red Irish blood flowing in their veins.
Negotiations are now being called for. I have been calling for them for years. I am glad that there is the suggestion that negotiations should be set on foot immediately. I am also glad that the amendment of the Ireland Act is being mentioned in this House because this Act is not relevant. It is not relevant in my book because we are not going back in this country, either North or South, to where we have been for the last 50 years. There is no going back. Let us be quite clear about that and let us be clear that if our House here does not give the leadership the people are now demanding, then, unfortunately, there will be twenties of thousands in many parts of the country who, instead of being led by this House, will lead the House or change it to their way of thinking. Do not let us think that we have any particular right to be here other than to represent the people from whom we come. We are not representing them and have not been representing them up to now. Despite any manner in which we have tried to prevent them from seeing what is going on in this land, they are now seeing for themselves, thinking for themselves, and we had better get out in front and lead them instead of being pushed from behind and finally overwhelmed. That is the one danger that is now evident to me on this side of the Border, that because of our own reluctance as a Government to lead, we will be led and we may be led in directions that none of us wants to go. Let us remember that and try to do something about it.
Above all, may I make a final plea, release the Republican prisoners on this side of the Border as a gesture to their dead comrades in the Six Counties. Let us have no more collaboration —and I say no more collaboration— with the police forces of the Six Counties or M15 or the legal system in London or elsewhere when any of these people are being charged. We have no obligation in any way to collaborate with those people in these matters at this time. Let us ask again immediately for the withdrawal of the paratroops as a gesture, as a beginning. Let us ask our own Army to go to the Border, to be there in time of need and tell Mr. Heath why they are there. Let there be no equivocation about it. Let us call for the end of internment as a further gesture. Let us, above all, make up our minds that we cannot wish this sad, unfortunate thing away, as we have been trying to do. Much as we may try for, and much as we would all like a peaceful solution—much as I am non-violent, despite what I say— I ask this House in their wisdom to realise and recognise what is in front of them, that they must lead or be overwhelmed. If they give the right leadership, the Six Counties is ours now for the taking and the bringing back into the fold of all Irishmen, whether Protestant, Dissenter or Catholic does not matter to me. As I have said elsewhere, I have more regard for my Protestant neighbours in the North than I have for many of my Catholic friends in the South.
Comment on this
This debate has been precipitated by the tragedy in Derry last Sunday. The whole nation was rightly shocked and deeply grieved by the enormity of that tragedy and by the savagery displayed by the British Army and the purpose of this debate now must be to examine what this nation can do towards ensuring that what led to that tragedy and to those savage incidents will never again recur in any part of Ireland.
I listened with attention, indeed, rapt attention, to Deputy Blaney. His speech, because of its emotionalism, its conviction and its fire, deserves earnest and careful attention. I listened to him, knowing that he represents a point of view which he claims himself has been badly misrepresented in the past. I listened carefully to find out what his answer is to the problem of Northern Ireland and to the tragedy that occurred last Sunday.
He commenced his speech by criticising and denigrating the new-found unity between the three parties here and by saying that "Do nothing" is the policy of these parties. He went on then to indicate that he was speaking on behalf of those people who are not represented in this House. I waited anxiously for him to spell out with conviction who those people are.
Comment on this
So far as I know, the entire Irish nation is represented in this Parliament.
Comment on this
He painted a sad and moving picture of the scene in Derry and of the tragedy inherent in the funerals there. As he described it, it was a highly charged scene, and he gave indications of the high degree of emotionalism that prevailed. In particular, he painted for us the harrowing loneliness of a six-year-old, not understanding what had happened, calling for his dead father. What is Deputy Blaney's answer to the problem that confronts this country? It is to call up our Army.
Comment on this
It is to send them across the Border to slaughter how many more fathers of how many more lonely children.
Comment on this
A warmonger he called a politician from Northern Ireland. I was appalled that the earlier part of his speech should be directed to inciting this country to a state of war, a war in which fellow-Irishmen will be killed, a civil war. That solution by Deputy Blaney deserves to be condemned and condemned roundly. The only problem that faces us, north and south, and faces Britain is how to effect a reconciliation between different types of Irishmen.
Comment on this
This is the kernel of the problem. One will not effect reconciliation by sending an army to the Border and making threatening noises. Surely Deputy Blaney is sufficiently realistic as a politician to know that we have not got the armed might to do the things he implies our Army should do. Reconciliation is what we must aim at and I deprecate speeches that put the day of reconciliation further away.
We have then to consider how reconciliation can be effected. While many of us have feelings of anger and frustration against Britain, and never so much as in the past few days, we have, nevertheless, in accordance with the tradition on which we pride ourselves and which is so often trotted out of being a Christian people, to ensure that the philosophy we practise as a nation will not be a pagan philosophy of an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth, a death for a death, a father for a father and a brother for a brother. We must use moral persuasion. The strength of our moral case at the moment is immense. We must use it as a united nation to impress on the rulers of Britain that their policies up to now have failed and, if they are pursued, they will continue to fail and will lead only to a greater bitterness and more deaths.
It is disappointing, when considering the history of the troubles in the North, to think that the representations of this nation have carried so little weight in Westminister. It is disappointing but it is not surprising because the status of the man making the representations has been diminished by the actions of erstwhile members of his Government, who have destroyed his strength as Taoiseach and who have left to represent us a man known in Britain to be the Leader of a party full of dissidents and to be hanging on to office in contravention of every code of constitutional conduct. It is no wonder that the response from Westminister has been negative. We can only hope that the welcome development in the past few days of a united Dáil sending the leaders of the Opposition and of the Government to London to impress on this intransigent Tory who heads the Westminister Government the urgent need for a change of direction in his policies will bear fruit, to impress on him that we here are willing to be reconciled with our brothers in the North, to impress on him that, in order to effect that reconciliation, he must, and he has the power to do it, indicate to the Unionist regime in Stormont that the policy of internment and repression must end and end instantly. Above all, he must cease the deliberately provocative policy of cratering Border roads. The British Army cannot be such fools as to imagine that that policy will be effective in stopping terrorists crossing, if they have a mind to do so; neither can one imagine that the wishes of John Taylor carry such influence in Westminister as to enable such a crazy policy to be continued. I see that policy as deliberately implemented in order to provoke confrontations between the British Army on one side and the illegal armies on the other in such a glare of publicity and with such frequency that the Government here will be forced to take certain actions, actions they have been loath to take. I believe this is the real and dangerous reason underlying the British policy of cratering Border roads. I would hope that the message will get across to the corridors of power in Westminister that that policy is both crazy and dangerous.
There is one other way in which we can put pressure on Westminister and, to my mind, Westminister is the key to the solution. It is one of the parts of Deputy Blaney's speech with which I agree. We should use all avenues open to us through our impending membership of the European Economic Community. It is ironic to think that the British Prime Minister only last week received a prize for his European statesmanship, a man who has two European nations at loggerheads with each other, a man who can send armed soldiers of his army to fire on citizens of his country. If this ridiculous situation were highlighted in the European capitals and if Europeans were made fully and urgently aware of the danger to Europe of a continuance of the situation in Ireland, they would be able to exert pressure successfully which when added to pressure from a united Ireland, might achieve results. I have no doubt it would hit at the vanity of that man, the Prime Minister of Britain, if he had to go to Europe as the man who led Britain into Europe and find himself taxed on all sides with his conduct of affairs in Ireland. That would be effective. Such a policy should be pursued urgently through all channels available to us in Europe. At last I think the message is getting out from this country of the intense anger and frustration which is growing among the people here at British policy in the North and that on the other hand there is a danger that if the anger and frustration are not relieved by a solution to the Northern problem they may grow to a dangerous extent.
It is our duty in this House not to say or do anything which might fan those flames of anger and frustration. My experience, moving among the ordinary people as Deputy Blaney has moved, is that there is no wish for physical revenge. The Taoiseach's statement that while we cannot forget what happened in Derry we will, out of charity forgive it, is a statement that has impressed many people and I think represents the feeling of the vast majority of the Irish people.
To achieve reconciliation there must be some positive signs and gestures by the parties to that reconciliation. What signs and gestures we can seek or expect from Belfast are a matter for the regime there to show us. It was disheartening, and there is no point in not mentioning it, that in Stormont, following the massacre in Derry, even liberal Unionists displayed a regrettable intransigence. That was a regrettable development. It should highlight for us the fact that those people are afraid and were frightened by the massive reaction to the Derry tragedy. It should highlight the need for us to do something to reassure them so as to diminish or remove their fears. From my contact with what I may call Protestant people though non-Unionists up there, I am satisfied that while the idea of unity is not altogether anathema it is some distance from being accepted by them.
They have lived as a separate community for 50 years and in this age of fast development and rapid evolution half a century is the equivalent of, perhaps, a couple of centuries some hundreds of years ago. One cannot dismantle overnight the sense of community, the sense of separateness they have gained for themselves over 50 years and which has been compounded by the attitude down here in that we have failed to engage in cross-Border activities with these people. We have allowed the two parts of the country to drift apart and it should be no surprise to us to have to acknowledge that there is another community up there and one to which I hope we could say: "You may continue to be a distinct community but please no longer be a separate community as we all live in one small island."
In opening the debate the Taoiseach briefly adverted to the question of change down here so as to assist reconciliation. If we have virtue on our side to the extent we claim we should have a surplus and should be able to give some of our virtue and make a magnanimous gesture to the other side. I do not know what it could be but it is the duty of the Taoiseach as Leader of the nation in consultation with his experts to devise some magnanimous gesture of reconciliation. I have no doubt the House, and through it, the people, would accept that. It is the duty of leadership not just to indicate, as he said, that there should be a change of stance and policy down here, but that is not enough. He must spell out the details of the change.
One small example which came to my notice very forcibly in the last few days of how our stance down here is wrong if we want to achieve unity is this: a townsman of mine who served for over 30 years in the Army was born in Omagh, received primary and some technical education there but never learned Irish. On retiring from the Army he was invited to apply for a Civil Service post. He was found suitable but because he did not know Irish he has been informed that he cannot be recruited as an established officer. Yet, we are saying to the people in the North: "Come in; things will be just as good here as they are with yourselves."
That may be only a small matter but it is one of those things that can lead to powerful propaganda to influence doubting Thomases in the North who are afraid of the Republic. It is one area in which a gesture of reconciliation could be made. It will call for courage on the part of the Taoiseach to make this gesture because he will have at the back of his mind the so-called Republican backlash. But if Republicanism means, as those who profess to practise it so unctuously tell us, uniting all religions under one flag and if his motive is to achieve that end he need not fear the speeches of demagogues.
I look to the Taoiseach as the nation's Leader to make such a gesture or series of gestures as a matter of urgency to show the Northern community that there is a place for them in a united Ireland. It would ease his position in making representations to the British Government to do their part and would ease their task also.
It is tragic that we had to have this debate following such horrifying events in Derry last Sunday. It was proper and right to have a day of mourning yesterday throughout the land. It is proper and right that we should lobby throughout the nations of the world to bring home to them the injustice perpetrated in this country, but above all, we must not take it on ourselves to take revenge. We must be extremely careful not to indulge in a philosophy or a course of action which will put back further the day of reconciliation because the day of reconciliation is the day of real unity. I disagree totally with Deputy Blaney when he says that the task is that of uniting our country and, ultimately, our people.
Comment on this
It could not be done in that order. The ideal is to do it simultaneously but I do not think that is possible. Consequently, the aim must be to unite first our people and, then, a united country will follow. We cannot achieve a united people if, in this part of Ireland, the doctrine being preached is one of revenge and reprisal. We may sorrow and we are entitled to a justifiable anger but we must never allow our emotions to spill over into physical revenge.
It is important that this House should not give way to an emotionalism or to any philosophy that could lead to such a course of action and one would hope that the incidents of the past couple of days which are understandable and explicable will not be repeated. The message must go clearly from this House, as enunciated by Deputy Ryan, that the preservation of the rule of law and the preservation of public order in this part of the country are an essential precondition towards unity. It is important that this House should reject absolutely and unequivocally the use of force. Deputy Blaney, in the course of winding-up his speech, made a further reference to our armed forces along the Border. His words were "to be there in time of need and let there be no equivocation about it". These were equivocable words——
Comment on this
——in a statement that pleaded for plain speaking. There is no half-way house between peace and war. There is no half-way house between a peaceful settlement and an imposed settlement of the Northern situation. It cannot be said too often that an imposed settlement is no settlement. I am glad that this debate, although emotional at times, is being held because I have no doubt that the message which will go out from the House loud and clear is that in so far as the people of the Republic of Ireland are concerned they only want the unity of Ireland that can be achieved through reconciliation of all Irishmen.
Comment on this
I was very upset and disturbed by Deputy Blaney's speech. If what he advocated were to be adopted by our people, I would be very much afraid for our country. I hate to have to say this about a colleague in this House but the impression I got was that Deputy Blaney was a warmonger, that he is spreading the seeds of discontent and war. He was preaching the same form of bigotry and hatred that he was condemning in the Northern part of the country. If his policy were to be adopted, it could lead only to total bloodshed and to the slaughter of our people. I was astonished that he should have been applauded for his speech because if this insanity were to spread through the country, the consequences would be very serious.
I would hate to think that last Sunday's happenings would be exploited but Deputy Blaney's display was scandalous. It was a scandalous exploitation of the sad emotions of our people. The real tragedy for the relatives of the victims will manifest itself today when they find themselves alone. We know that the victims were innocent people who were protesting against tyranny. We know of the intransigence of the Westminster Government and of their attempts to bolster up Mr. Faulkner and his regime and it is this that is responsible for the problem. The British Government stand indicted for what they did. It was a cold, calculated act. I would say that the paratroopers had their orders and all the evidence suggests that their action was not defensive. It stands to reason that it could not have been defensive.
I am sad that no political moves have been made. We all talk about the problem and offer various suggestions but nothing concrete is being done. Unfortunately, and regretfully, Britain is determined to proceed with her military solution to the problems of the North. I had discussions on the problem while I was in Britain and I was appalled at the intransigence on the part of the British and of their determination not to have political moves or initiatives under any circumstances that would bring about a solution to the problem. I was upset, too, that they should abide religiously by what Mr. Faulkner says and that they would not look beyond Mr. Faulkner and beyond what he and his crumbling regime offer for Northern Ireland. I am disturbed when they say they cannot be under threat. They cannot afford to talk like this especially when people are being killed. It is up to us to arouse British public opinion as to what is happening and to make them aware of how the problem can be solved.
I said yesterday that reunification was on the horizon. We have reached this irreversible stage; but I would say that if reunification were to be effective tomorrow it would be a disaster for our country. I say this because the Governments of this country during the past 50 years have not prepared for reunification. Not an attempt was made by any of them to prepare for reunification.
Comment on this
Perhaps when Deputy Carter is making his contribution he will let us know of the steps that have been taken.
Comment on this
We have confined everything within the Twenty-six County boundary, all our legislation and our social codes; we have not looked at the problem from a practical point of view. When I was in Northern Ireland last week I spoke to Unionists and to people from all walks of life and I realised that they have objections to a united Ireland. Their objections are practical ones. They talk in terms of our social welfare code being far below what is normal. They talk of our health services and of our underdeveloped economy. I know they are being subsidised by Britain—and, perhaps, taking into account the small country that ours is, we may have done a lot—but we have not looked further than the Twenty-six Counties. We have not considered how we might develop our services so as to put them on a par with services in the North of Ireland.
I talked in terms of 5 per cent of our people owning 71 per cent of the wealth of the country. Are these 5 per cent prepared to redistribute the wealth of this country so that we can have a proper social welfare code? I am asking our Government what we can do to ensure a more equal distribution. Are we prepared to make the sacrifices or are we going to continue to pay lip service to reunification? Are we, as TDs, going to continue to talk in rural areas and lead public opinion on changes in the Constitution, which might be unpleasant at first sight but which are vitally necessary for the people in the North of Ireland? We much change every aspect of the Constitution that is offensive to them and we must be prepared to grasp the nettle. When Deputy Dr. Noel Browne and I introduced a Bill on contraception the Government did not take the initiative but were prepared to relegate it to Private Members' Time where it would fade into oblivion. They are afraid to grasp the nettle. If they are sincere about reunification, if they want to bring about the changes that will reorientate the people of the North towards the people of the South, they have got to bring about the necessary changes in the Constitution so that this will not be called a theocratic State. We must have a separation of Church and State in this country. We must be prepared to stand up and talk about this even if we incur unpopularity and the displeasure of our own constituents.
Comment on this
I will speak about contraception because it is a private, moral matter, and the Deputy should be prepared to respect the view of people who consider it a matter of individual conscience. If backwoods men refuse to accept this and still talk about reunification I say they are hypocrites. If we are sincere about this we should be prepared to stand up and be counted among those who want the changes that are vital in the interests of our country. We should scrap the Constitution and prepare a new one.
Comment on this
I am talking about extending the hand of friendship to Unionists in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
I say that Mr. Faulkner's days in Northern Ireland are numbered and that he must come to the conference table and talk. If he is not prepared to listen we should talk to Mr. Desmond Boal and Dr. Paisley who are realists and who are orientating their minds towards the South and towards reunification. However, they have fears, and I say this despite the ridicule and the amusement of Deputy Aiken. They have fears that this is a Popish State, that this is a Roman Catholic State. They are entitled to have fears, but we must allay those fears. We must be prepared to tell them: "You have a rightful and meaningful place in this country." These are the talks I have had with people in the North. But they say: "How many of your colleagues really believe this or are prepared to do this?" We should be discussing with them how we might bring about reunification, and I would suggest that in a new Parliament for the first number of years we should give them equal representation to prove to them that we are sincere in our attempts to give them a meaningful say in this country. That is how far I would go in setting up a new Parliament.
The IRA have carried on a campaign in Northern Ireland, some of them against the British Army, some of them against innocent civilians. I do not think that their way is a democratic one. They could have a democratic role to play. Their aim is a united Ireland, and I agree with them in that, but I think they should pursue their aim along political lines. Their members could be elected to Dáil Éireann or to a new Parliament. I would sincerely ask them to think along those lines and to talk about changing, from within a Constitutional Parliament, our country and the defects they see in it. I do not think they will achieve their objects by an abstentionist policy.
The IRA propose regional parliaments, and I say, yes, regional parliaments by all means if we have a central parliament overriding them. The regional parliaments to which they refer will perhaps solve many of our problems, but they must come as a mandate from the people. The IRA would be well advised to consider this as the only possible and proper way to bring about the changes they want effected. It must be along democratic lines. I would see Dr. Paisley having a lot in common with the IRA, strange as it seems. They both would think in terms of a proper country for the people. I know this, and therefore I would appeal to them to do as I have suggested.
I was appalled, as I said, at Deputy Blaney's speech, especially when I think that he was one of the architects of the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement, when he sought closer and closer union with Britain. I do not think he made a constructive speech. I listened to every word he said. He denounced the three parties here; still the only constructive suggestions he put forward were ones which had been outlined here by the Taoiseach, the leader of the Fine Gael Party, and Deputy Corish of our own party. When Deputy Blaney was in a position of power to bring about the changes he talks about, to bring about reunification, what did he do about it? I do not know of anything positive he did, or perhaps I am too naïve and I do not know what really constructive work was done towards reunification.
As I said, Deputy Blaney is breeding the same bigotry and hatred which he condemns in Northern Ireland. When he talks about the call-up of the Army and the FCA I would say maybe we should give him a gun, because that is exactly the line he is pursuing at the moment. Perhaps I am a little harsh on him. Perhaps he is over-emotional and that because of where he lives it is understandable. However, I would appeal to him not to let emotional nationalism destroy him and destroy the rest of the country. He talked about the days of grief and mourning, but his answers would extend those days of grief and mourning much more. I would appeal to him to exercise restraint because, unfortunately, his voice still carries a lot of weight in this country.
He denounces the Protestants in the North; then he talks in terms of our sitting down and talking with them. How can this be brought about as long as we denounce them as we do? How do we get them to talk if we instil fears in them? We should be allaying their fears. A constructive suggestion was made by Deputy Corish when he said that we should go to Mr. Heath. I would hope that through his speech Deputy Blaney suffered an emotional catharsis. I would hope that this would save the country. He said we should not be afraid to risk what we have here to save the people of Northern Ireland. To me that would spell bloodshed. It would be a tremendous gamble that could only harm the country.
At this moment moral courage is much more important than courage in battle. Moral courage is a rare commodity, a rare quality. It is the courage that may incur the displeasure of your colleagues. It may have you denounced as a radical. It may make you very unpopular because you may be endeavouring to lead public opinion rather than follow it. Unfortunately in this House we have been content too often to follow public opinion. I ask those people with moral courage to stand up and be counted and to see what we can do to bring about the changes that are necessary.
It is not enough just to talk here for the sake of talking. The Taoiseach made a very good speech today. I hope he will keep his word. I hope he will bring about the changes which he said are necessary—the social, the economic, the political and the constitutional changes that are necessary before we can talk about a united Ireland. I hope he will not put them on the long finger and say they will come after the unification. That would be disastrous. It would be a retrograde step. I hope he will have the courage of his convictions.
I saw an advertisement in The Irish Times this morning from Mayo saying that 10,000 people will be marching and that it is expected that 250,000 people will be converging on Newry next Sunday. I would ask the British Government to make a declaration that political initiatives are on the way so that this march may be postponed. This is the only thing that will bring about a postponement of that march: a declaration by Britain today—and I have told them already that this is vital if we are to avoid further bloodshed next Sunday. I fear that the tragedy in Derry will pale into insignificance compared with what may happen next Sunday if 250,000 people march on Newry—that political initiatives are on the way which will bring about talks. It is up to the British to do this. It is necessary for Britain to make that statement if we are to avoid a further tragedy.
There is a danger in what happened yesterday that the dogs of war have been let loose. I was frightened at what happened yesterday. I should hate to see a day of national mourning exploited by elements in our society who are interested only in disorder.
Comment on this
I hope the Taoiseach has not done this. He has been vacillating between internment on the one hand and advocating action which is not good for our society.
Comment on this
He has been a vacillating Taoiseach. I am talking now as a citizen, as an ordinary person who fears for the future. I hope he will realise his responsibility as Taoiseach for what he has done.
Comment on this
It is excellent that Dáil Éireann has been given a full opportunity in this two-day debate to get down to the fundamental issues involved in the basic national problem that has been with us for 50 years now, wrongly imposed on us, and artificially created in the form of the partition of this natural island of 32 counties, with a population that can work with each other, as we have proved very well over the past 50 years in the type of society which we have evolved here in this part of Ireland, which is almost totally nonsectarian, classless and devoted to the common good and the achievement of justice.
It is my fundamental belief that this can be done equally in a 32-county Ireland. We have built in the proper protective measures both in the statue law and in the Constitution to protect the lives and liberties of people, to ensure their rights before the courts and to ensure that these rights are fully protected by law and by the Constitution. This type of society which we have evolved is one of which we should be proud and one we can certainly evolve in a 32-county Ireland if we are allowed to work out our own salvation. We have not been allowed to work out our own salvation in this respect and our persistent claim to a 32-county Ireland, which has been ignored over these 50 years by the British Government, has now been shown by recent tragic events to be fully justified. It has been shown, thanks to modern communications, to be a right and proper claim before the nations of the world.
The fact is that the unnatural division of our country in recent times begat violence and will beget more violence. This is the lesson of the present situation. This is the lesson of the tragic events that occurred in Derry last Sunday and the other tragic events that have developed and worsened since August, 1969. Any action done to protect and further perpetuate an unnatural division among people is bound to create the type of situation which we have seen developing in the six North-Eastern counties since August, 1969.
Added to that, over the 50 years of Stormont administration there have been the constant injustices, the denial of human rights, the denial of civil rights, the denial of everything that is proper in a fair and open society, to a substantial section of the people in the Six Counties, 40 per cent of the population there. There has been the entrenchment of an establishment in the interests of the members of that establishment and the people who support it, and support it at the polls. That is not a democratic society. Sixty per cent may vote for a Unionist establishment at election time but it cannot be called a democratic society in any sense of the world. It is merely the power of one group over another entrenched through the polls and buttoned down, and pinned down, and fastened down, by injustice and patronage and jobbery of every kind.
This is now out in the open. It is out from under the carpet where successive British Governments swept it conveniently. It is out now fully and openly before the eyes of the world and exposed for all the injustices it contains. The moral and administrative violence, which can be worse than physical violence, of making a people less than they should be, which has been the essence of the Stormont administration over 50 years, has now resulted in the present confrontation situation, a situation in which the British Army has had to be hired, in effect, by the Stormont administration and paid for by the British administration to copperfasten a people to whom basic civil rights were denied.
This is the situation now, starting from the moral and administrative violence of a people exercising their majority control in a wrong way over another community which has now escalated into physical violence of the very worst kind. This is what we have here now, what we must look at and assess in a sane way although it is very hard, as any of us who were in Derry yesterday can aver, to be sane and sensible in view of the horror we saw in the minds, the eyes and the very gestures of the people. We have to assess it as the elected representatives of this part of Ireland and decide what we can do about it in a sane and sensible way and what contribution we can make towards this endeavour.
There are certain basic truths in this matter that we must acknowledge in honesty here ourselves. Because of the size of our population, the facts in regard to what we believe in anyway in the ultimate, we cannot meet the type of violence exercised on us by Britain and the Stormont Administration. We cannot employ violence against that sort of violence. Apart from the morality of the matter, these are the facts of life. Morally it is wrong to escalate a potentially dangerous situation into a civil war situation and actually we do not have the fire power to do it. Let us be honest with ourselves about this. We are not in a position here from any point of view, either moral or practical, to meet violence with greater violence.
This is the situation we are faced with. To be honest, it would be a totally counter-productive attitude on our part here to suggest that in any way we could meet British Army violence with greater violence. Effectively, what can we do? I would suggest—and modern communications, television and radio are a help to a great extent—that we can exercise enormous moral power and pressure in regard to our just case. We cannot be seen to have a just case if we meet injustice with injustice. We can be seen to have a just case if we meet injustice with justice. This is the Government attitude and I think it is the attitude of every right-thinking person in this House and outside it. I believe we should fully exercise every possible pressure short of violence and we must fully back it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not think that after 14 years in Government this is a strange statement to make?
Comment on this
Remarks of that kind do not help. The Government have already taken steps in this respect. The Minister for Foreign Affairs has already gone to North America. He has taken the necessary steps there with the United Nations and with the United States Secretary of State and will be seeing the Canadian Foreign Minister. From there he proposes to go early next week to meet the various European Heads of State and make known the horror of what happened last Sunday, the whole basis of justice behind our case for a Thirty-two County Ireland and all the injustices perpetrated by the Stormont administration. In particular, he will make known the fact that the British Government through its agency, the British Army, so far from helping the case in any way has completely exacerbated the situation to such an extent that the British Government, the British Army, the British administration and the British people, who are not responsible at all, were brought into total disgrace through the events of last Sunday.
Comment on this
I wish the Minister well but, having signed us into the EEC, what arguments will the Government be able to make?
Comment on this
In my view what the Deputy said and what Deputy Harte said is irrelevant because this is not a debate for that type of interruption.
Comment on this
I suggest they are particularly disorderly in this debate.
Comment on this
The further violence that has taken place has been the result of massive internment without trial introduced in an arbitrary way by the Stormont administration last August and supported by the British administration. This total violence, worked in a discriminate way on people without any justification whatsoever and in every section of the community representative only of the minority section of the community, I might say, has merely triggered off a worse situation since last August.
On top of the continuing 50 years of violence against the minority population in the Six Counties by both Westminister and Stormont, we had in recent months internment by the Stormont administration and now the total excesses on the part of the British Army which have brought shame on Britain. We must use every pressure to shame them into doing something about this problem which is their problem. This is the type of moral pressure short of violence which we must exercise now. I would suggest to Deputy Harte that we now have a situation which did not exist to anything like the same extent in the past 50 years where we can, by reason of their actions of violence and their acts of injustice, shame them into doing something about it. This is what the Government propose to do.
Comment on this
There can be no questions. The Minister has only 30 minutes the same as any other Deputy and, consequently, there can be no interruptions. The Minister has only the same rights as any other Deputy. He only has 30 minutes and all interruptions should cease.
Comment on this
This responsibility lies, as always, but has never so far been so evidently lying at the door of the British Government, who created this monstrosity in the first instance and who for most of 50 years swept it under the carpet. The dirt is now out in the open in full view of the media forces of the world, in full view of everyone who is concerned with justice. It is now clear for every nation to see that this injustice has resulted finally in total excesses and total violence in a society which was artificially created in the first instance.
Comment on this
I am trying to make a serious speech and the Deputy might listen.
Comment on this
Thank you, Deputy. I appreciate your courtesy. This situation now quite clearly out in the open is a situation we must meet not with violence, not in any counter-productive manner of that kind. This is a situation where injustice has been clearly seen not just in Ireland, not just in Britain, but throughout the world; not just glaringly seen but so obvious that we must proceed straight away to work on this situation as an independent Government, and remember that where the injustice is out in the open, where the excesses on the part of the British and Stormont Governments are out in the open, where the excesses on the part of the British Army are out in the open, it is now a situation in which we should not meet injustice with injustice. It is precisely a situation where if we are to sustain the justice of our case we must meet violence not with violence, injustice not with injustice, but we must meet the whole case with the justice of our case.
This is where I suggest every pressure short of violence must be fully exercised and tapped. It can be done externally by the Government and through the various Government agencies which we propose to utilise to do this. At the moment the Minister for Foreign Affairs is engaged in this matter. We will shortly be taking further steps to intensify this publicity abroad so as to ensure that the justice of our case is seen. It is pretty well acknowledged both in North America and in Europe to a far greater extent than we imagine. We tend sometimes to think that the only foreign Press is the British Press. This is not true. The British Press has been for centuries the arm of the establishment in Britain and the British Press at all levels has been under the thumb of the establishment in Britain and has consistently given us here in Ireland a bad press, with certain honourable exceptions, such as The Sunday Times in recent times.
Beyond and apart from that, in Europe, all parts of it, East and West, in North America, throughout the various emerging countries in Africa and Asia, the justice of our case is recognised. It is up to us as a Government to use every means and every agency to make sure that the facts which we can place on record, the results of British injustice and British violence, are fully put on record by us as a sovereign independent Government. We can thereby meet injustice with justice, with the justice of our case, and have this case fully displayed and put on record before the countries of the world. This is a task in which we must engage and we have now for the first time the brutal, the horrible facts to place before the world of this injustice and we propose to make the fullest use of the facilities which we have as a sovereign independent nation to make sure that these brutal and horrible facts being wrought by British injustice and by Stormont injustice will be brought to the notice of the Governments of the world on the basis of justice on our side meeting injustice on their side.
The only way we can harm that case is by in any way using violence to meet violence, or injustice to meet injustice. I am certain that in this manner we can do the best justice to our case abroad with the governments of the world who are now coming round to our point of view. We can use all the aids of modern telecommunication, telenised vision and radio, to help us in this endeavour.
Comment on this
I had the great pleasure yesterday to meet Fr. Edward Daly who was associated in their last moments with the unfortunate people who died in Derry last Sunday. He has gone to America. He is going on the various American media tonight and tomorrow to tell the story which he told very fully, very clearly and without emotion but with total truth, to the Irish people on the "7 Days" programme last Monday night. We hope to have him relating that factual story of what happened in Derry on all the major American media today and tomorrow. That is a practical example of one of the many steps we can take at all levels of Government activity to ensure that the justice of our case and the injustice of the British case are brought fully to the notice of every country in the world.
The other way in which we can help practically is internally to support those forces in the Six Counties who are concerned about establishing a true and a just Thirty-two County Ireland and who at the same time have repudiated violence. I refer in particular here to the political representatives of the non-Unionist minority, the SDLP and the Nationalist Party and indeed any other party or individuals who are opposed to Unionist violence and Unionist injustice. We propose to devise ways and means to help these people financially.
Comment on this
My colleague, the Minister for Finance, will be talking tomorrow and spelling out more details in respect of this aspect of the matter. We propose to back those people who are exercising their form of moral pressure in the six North-Eastern counties, an exercise of moral pressure in the face of violence on all sides, violence from Stormont, violence from Britain and encouragement to violence on the part of the small minority of people who oppose Unionism.
Comment on this
This is part of the operation—the alternative Assembly and the parties opposed to Unionism— in some way to devise some means of channelling financial help to these organs who represent democratic opinion, who are opposed to Unionism and are trying to maintain a responsible stand in the face of the tremendous pressures they are subjected to from time to time—the people who are trying to uphold a situation which we want to see being upheld in a Thirty-two County Ireland.
Comment on this
The Minister seems to make politics of all this. Has he informed the members of the Opposition? He never tells them a thing about it but he looks for their support.
Comment on this
The Minister must be allowed to make his speech. Deputy L'Estrange will get an opportunity to make his speech later.
Comment on this
I was going to refer further to the co-operation that is required between all parties in this House.
Comment on this
Deputies will appreciate that speeches are limited and that there must therefore not be any interruptions from any side. If Deputies Harte and L'Estrange want to make their speeches later they can do so.
Comment on this
It is the function of the Government to take the immediate steps that are required to be taken to meet the situation at any given time. It is only with governments that the power and the facilities lie to take immediate steps and immediate action. Where I would see inter-party co-operation having a more fundamental meaning in furthering the talks that have taken place between the Government and the Fine Gael and Labour Parties is, in the long term, to work out the sort of society which we propose to have in a Thirty-two County Ireland, the sort of practical amendments to our Constitution, the sort of social and economic steps that are required to be taken now to ensure that the transition into a Thirty-two County Ireland can be eased, the sort of steps that we have to take in regard to many of our laws. All of these are matters in which I could see a great field of opportunity not just in the immediate future, now or next week, but in the long term, looking ahead to the sort of society in which we want to live as a Thirty-two County Ireland.
It must be emphasised that that type of society must be an open, nonsectarian society and I should like to say categorically that however we deplore the acts of both the British and the Stormont administrations in recent times—we deplore them vehemently for the injustice that has been inherent in their policies in recent years —we must remember one thing here: it is that we have built in this State during the past number of years a society in which there has been no sectarian tinge, in which all classes and creeds have had an equal right to make progress. This can be improved to contain a Thirty-two County Ireland. It can be improved in many ways, by amending our Constitution, our laws, our attitudes and policies.
Fundamentally, we have evolved here a fairly open, a fairly clear nonsectarian society. We have evolved here a society in which we are seeking, even if we have not always achieved it, to have justice written into every aspect of our administration, our laws and our Constitution. This is in direct contrast to the type of situation where injustice has been heaped upon injustice in the six North-Eastern counties. There is that clear distinction between the attitude of minds of the people in the Twenty-six Counties compared to the people of one party who have governed for 50 years in the six North-Eastern counties.
We will have to do more in this direction, and this is where the three parties meeting together can propose practical ways and means of how we can make our society more open, more acceptable in every sense of the word, so that nobody in the six North-Eastern counties can say this is not a society into which we can go.
This, in my view, is a practical, fruitful area of co-operation in which we should engage immediately between the three parties represented here in this Parliament. That is the longer-term aspect. The shorter-term aspect is to take the immediate steps which only a Government can take and which we are taking, both externally, as I spelled out, through the Minister for Foreign Affairs, and other governmental agencies and internally through our own co-operation with and leadership of the responsible people who are opposed to Unionists in the six North-Eastern counties. It is on these two fronts that we can work and work in the recognition that this is not an easy task. The people who say that we can just drive the British Army and the British administration out of the six North-Eastern counties and can drive one million Unionists into the sea at the drop of the hat are people who are talking dishonestly. Let us have some honest talk here.
The honesty, I believe, lies in working along the immediate lines on which the Government are working and along the more long-term lines in regard to which I believe the three political parties can closely co-operate. We must recognise that ultimately we must get the British Government to a firm declaration—Mr. Harold Wilson has proposed 15 years, but I believe that is too long in the context of what has developed—that in five years or ten years time we will have a definite date by which Partition goes, by which a Thirty-two County Ireland must come about. We must direct the energies of all responsible people in the two islands who believe in democracy, who believe in political parties, in parliament and in laws to protect the individual. All of us in these two islands who believe in these fundamental matters which make for what is called a democratic society must set a timetable, set down an agenda and set down a period of years—five years or ten years—within which period there must be a united Ireland and we must now sit down and devise the ways and means of achieving that. It is only in that way that we will achieve a united Ireland and in the meantime we must exercise every moral pressure, every pressure of every kind short of actual violence, to ensure that the British injustice is brought fully home to every country and every nation and to the peoples of every country and every nation—not just the governments and the administrations but to the peoples—through the media now there. We must exercise all the pressure at our disposal in the meantime and on that level pursue that way of activity externally and at another level pursue a way of activity in regard to helping the responsible people opposed to Unionism in the six North-Eastern counties. On the final level we must sit down in co-operation with other responsible and democratic parties and people in the other island and in the six North-Eastern counties, and start to work out ways and means for creating the fabric for the united 32-county Ireland we want to see operating in five or ten years time.
Comment on this
The situation in our country which has existed for many years and which has been highlighted by events—and, we must admit, inevitable events—since 1969 is very much in my mind and indeed in the minds of many others who bear the title of Irishmen. Just in case anyone might make the error of thinking that my speech here is an echo of someone else's words, I would like to make it quite clear, especially to correspondents who might think otherwise, that I am expressing my view and opinion on this and other matters.
I would like to indicate to the House that when I stood as a candidate in the by-election for what I thought then was the republican party I was elected by the people of Dublin South-West as a republican member of this House. I remained in Fianna Fáil to the point when I was absolutely convinced that they no longer held the republican traditions on which they were founded. I think that indications that this is so must be taken to be represented by the actions of Kevin Boland and Deputy Neil Blaney and others who dispute what Fianna Fáil are as against what they were.
What we witnessed in part of our country last Sunday is nothing short of a national tragedy. It is a national tragedy that Irishmen should continue to be killed by Her Majesty's forces, but it is equally tragic that we have a so-called republican Government who are only prepared to talk, to act inadequately, to act late and slowly, and, above all, to be seen, or seem to be collaborating with British interests. Last Sunday brought home to every Irishman the realisation that there is a war being waged, and when Mr. Maudling announced that war was in fact being waged in Ireland he was not joking. The logical conclusion, the logical consequence, of that war is that people undoubtedly will be killed. It must be admitted by us that a great number of people in this part of Ireland really felt as if the Six Counties were a thousand miles away, but I think that since last Sunday many of these people who might have made the mistake of believing that they were detached, uninvolved and with no capacity to be involved in that struggle have changed their minds. We have certainly seen evidence of the people's reaction on our streets in Dublin and in different parts of the country.
We must all sincerely sympathise with the relatives and friends of those who were killed in Derry, but what do we do as a Government and as a people? Deputy Blaney spoke here earlier today and asked that we should not be over-confused by the events of last Sunday, and I would like to say that lost in the tragic events of the bloody Sunday of our time is an interview between John Taylor and Bill Craig on our Irish radio on last Sunday between 1 and 2 o'clock. During that interview, compliments and criticism crossed the floor. Bill Craig and John Taylor complimented our Government and our Taoiseach for having done what they asked him to do, that is, he arrested seven men who were found to be in possession of arms on the Twenty-six County side, and although they remarked that this was late and inadequate, because there were so many people they knew to be on the loose or on the run in the South from the North, they still thanked our Government for this co-operation. Just as Deputy Blaney called on the Government for a fundamentally sincere and unequivocal gesture to the people's struggle in the North, I call on the Government to release these men who were arrested, on very technical grounds, by our Government and who are being held back from the defence of their friends and fellow-citizens within the Six-County area.
We must very clearly consider the consequences of our actions here and the logical conclusion which the British and Stormont authorities will take from our actions down here. It is not so long ago since another person was arrested by our Government in the South. That man was John Kelly. He was then the chairman of the Belfast Citizens' Defence Committee. His arrest, not on the streets of Belfast by the Stormont regime but by our Government here, gave the Stormont regime and the British a clear indication of what they could expect in the crunch from the Irish Government. The Irish Government despite what the Taoiseach had said the previous August dismissed members of the Government and arrested John Kelly. Up to that time the British soldier was acting in an impartial manner, he was acting in a peaceful role keeping two sides apart, but the consequences of what happened were seen in the actions of the Army. They became very partial to the authorities in the North and loyal to the British Government's policy in the North.
We must consider then what would be the consequences of the arrest in recent times of seven men who, let us be quite honest, were technically arrested. These men were not fighting against the Government here or the people of Ireland. If they were guilty of anything it was of being overenthusiastic in relation to their activities in the North.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I do not wish to interrupt Deputy Sherwin, nor did I say anything when he made this reference, but I think he is going into a lot of detail in respect of a case which is at present sub judice.
Comment on this
I think the Minister will have to allow the Chair to be the judge of what is relevant.
Comment on this
I have been trying to indicate the possible consequences within the Six-County area to our fellow citizens of actions by the Government down here. I believe that what happened last Sunday was, to some extent, the result of the clear indication that the Government down South were not going to assist the people's struggle in the North. Even if we do not admit that it was a consequence of the arrest of these men, we can surely say that that did not help the situation.
Comment on this
I call on the Government to release these men so that they can go back and be in the ranks of their own citizens——
Comment on this
Deputy Loughnane is not entitled to interrupt. Deputy Sherwin.
Comment on this
Amnesties have been granted for perhaps a lesser reason than sending these men back to where they belong to defend their people in the North.
Comment on this
May I point out that it is the present dispute that is under discussion? Perhaps the Deputy would now come to the matter.
Comment on this
In his broadcast on last Monday night the Taoiseach did not go far enough to express the feelings and the mood of the people of Ireland. He spoke of a final solution to the Irish question. I wonder and I question what is his final solution because if he is thinking of one which does not accept a firm commitment by the British to the reunification of the country he is wasting his time and indeed deceiving the people once again. He spoke also of an all-party conference. I wonder who would take part in this conference. I should like the House to look at the reason why we are talking here today, why any protest from the people of Ireland against British authorities in Dublin should take place, why we as Members of this House attended a funeral in the North. It would be futile to think of a conference without recognising the right to participate in that conference of the people who are responsible for bringing this situation to a stage where a conference can even be considered. Those men and women who are fully involved and active in this regard are legitimately entitled to be at that conference table and if it should be drawn up without the participation of these people this will be yet another nonevent.
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald is not entitled to interrupt.
Comment on this
——I want to make it quite clear to Deputy FitzGerald and others that these men are acting on behalf of the people in a damn sight better way than many of us are acting on behalf of our people in here.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach mentioned that internment should go. It has taken him six months to say unequivocally that it should go. We have read his description of internment as a terrible thing but it has taken him until now to say that it must go. I wonder did it take 13 deaths to make him make this demand. The Taoiseach spoke of the need to get the British soldiers out of the Catholic ghettos of the Six-County area. Why did he stop there? Why did our Taoiseach, the leader of the supposed Republican Party, not go so far as to say that the British soldiers should be removed completely from the Six Counties of Ireland? I cannot see how he can be excused for confining his remarks to the ghetto areas of Belfast. Does the same thing not apply to areas which have a mixed population? What about the Catholic or the Nationalist Republican on a street in Belfast where his neighbours are Protestants? Is he not perhaps more likely to experience the brutality the soldiers have inflicted on the people in the Catholic areas? I would suggest that these people are more in danger of the discriminatory powers of the British and Stormont regimes.
It is not right or proper that the Taoiseach should be talking about asking the British troops merely to get out of the Catholic areas. Anyone who has travelled up to the Bogside and Creggan knows that Creggan is not a ghetto area. Other parts of the Six Counties where the Catholic population live can be so described. The Creggan estate, to which we went yesterday, is a fine housing estate, very similar to any part of my constituency. In referring to Catholic areas as ghettos the Taoiseach should bear in mind that he is perhaps insulting communities. The people of Ballyfermot, where I live, are very proud of their community. That area got a bad Press heretofore. It is not a nice gesture for our Government to describe the Creggan area as a ghetto but that is a very minor point to make when we are talking about the absolute horror of the situation as it has escalated in the North.
In reference to the Taoiseach's speech on Monday night, when he mentioned the need to get the British soldiers out of areas where Catholics or Nationalists are in the majority, it is fair to say that even Deputy O'Brien, of the Labour Party, demanded, as we have demanded, that the soldiers be completely withdrawn from the Six Counties. Our Republican Government, through their Leader, have not gone as far as that.
Comment on this
When did Deputy O'Brien say that? Only last week he asked that they should remain. Last week he asked that the British Army be left in the North, in case of a backlash.
Comment on this
The Minister for Foreign Affairs said yesterday that if the British soldiers' tactics did not change then his Government would dedicate themselves to getting the British out. I should like to refer to the question that I had on the Order Paper today asking the Government to give the people of Ireland information as to the number of statements, tape recordings and other information in the possession of the Government since internment was introduced. There was implicit in that question the question as to how these statements indict the British authorities and the Stormont regime in the North. We are talking here after the event. Thirteen have been killed. It is suggested that this is justification for being tough. Many months ago the Government had even more gruesome details of the tortures the British authorities inflicted on the community in the Six Counties but the Government did not see fit to take action. I wonder why. I suggest again, as I did this morning and on Tuesday, that the Government are proving themselves to be three steps behind the people. But for the fact that the people of Ireland reacted in the way they did and protested as they did sincerely and with true feeling, the Government would not have made the statements they have made over the last couple of days. Of course, the people had not got the information that was entrusted to the Government by persons who were tortured and brutally treated by soldiers in the Six Counties. I put down the question to which I have referred so that some indication would be given of the volume of information that was given to the Government and some explanation as to why they took so long before making any comment or taking any action in regard to it.
In his statement last Monday the Taoiseach referred to the minority and to the need to rid them of Unionist misrule. Surely the Taoiseach appreciates that the minority in this country are the 25 per cent of the total population that Stormont was established to look after and that the minority that he refers to are, in fact, part of the majority of the people? Are the Taoiseach and the Government slightly confused on that matter? They continually refer to the Nationalist population of the Six Counties as the minority or part of the minority. It must be very clear that they are part of the majority of the 32 counties and that the minority in this country are the 25 per cent of the population in the various religious groupings.
I agree with all those who suggested that we should have a Constitution that would protect everybody's interest. It is worthless and a waste of time for Ministers, like the Minister for Transport and Power, Deputy Lenihan, to speak of amending our Constitution so that it would incorporate the wishes of the people of the Six Counties. In this very advanced stage towards reunification it is trite to talk about anything less than a completely new Constitution.
We have tried over the years to establish the claim to jurisdiction over 32 counties, that our jurisdiction is not confined to 26 counties. It is weakening that claim to talk about the right to exercise jurisdiction over what is commonly and continually referred to as the minority of the Six Counties. They certainly are a minority in the Six Counties but we must remember that when nine counties were offered to the British they realised that the Nationalists and Republicans in those nine counties would very quickly out-number the Protestant or Unionist vote and that therefore the Stormont regime, which is guilty of so many of the atrocities that we have seen over the past number of years, would falter and, consequently, that British influence in Ireland would falter. It is not altogether right to single out the Stormont regime and to blame only them; the British put the Stormont regime there and it is the British who can take them out.
We shall learn later in the debate from the Minister for Finance about the allocation of money which the Taoiseach mentioned was to be made towards the peaceful activities of political groups in the North. It is fair to ask: will there be another inquisition as to the use to which the money will be put, such as we have proceeding at the moment? When the current inquiry is over the cost of the inquiry will probably be in excess of the original allocation. Will the new allocation have the effect of buying over support and of buying off the criticism that has been recently levelled by members of the SDLP?
Through this House I would appeal to the SDLP under no circumstances to allow themselves to be bought over with this money. When we talk about the struggle of the people in the Six Counties against British occupation of their territory we cannot, if we are honest with ourselves, separate the IRA from the rest of the community. If anyone here who visited Derry yesterday took the time to speak to some of the locals instead of getting into their State cars and returning to Dublin they would know, since they would be told very clearly, that every man, youth and boy throughout the length and breadth of the Six Counties is now a member of the IRA. When we talk about the IRA leaving it to the politicians to take over we are talking about a whole community because the IRA are now firmly implanted in the community and firmly established as the defenders of that community and in no circumstances, therefore, is it justifiable to refer to them in a separate way.
I regret, as others have regretted, the violence that took place in Dublin yesterday. I believe, however, that it was necessary that this violence should take place in order that the people could show their real feelings to the British Government. Our Government have never so far done that adequately. It was noted that the greater proportion of the men and women were young people of my own generation and it is, I think, relevant to point out that when people get aged they become very conservative and they slowly but surely miss out on representing the younger generation's point of view.