We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Adjournment Motion: Northern Ireland Situation.

Contributions 110–226 of 226. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Conservatism is a failing of youth also.

Comment on this

I will confine myself to my speech. The Deputy can make his contribution later. He is a member of the generation to which I referred and, if he is not careful, the young people in his constituency will tell him exactly what they think ought to be done.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary is getting old like the rest of us.

Comment on this
Brigid Hogan-O'Higgins Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins Fine Gael

So is Deputy Sherwin.

Comment on this

This is not a time for light relief.

Comment on this

In relation to the wanton——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I must call the next speaker now.

Comment on this

I will be very brief.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not a question of being brief. The Deputy has had his opportunity.

Comment on this

With regard to the wanton destruction attributed to those who attended these protests in Dublin, it is not inconceivable that members of MI5 and the SAS and other paid British officials roaming the streets openly, collaborating with our intelligence forces, could be just as responsible for this wanton damage and it should be pointed out to the Government that they ought to be conscious of this. We want the Government to remove from our society these spies who are infiltrating our society.

Comment on this

Excuse my mirth a moment ago but the concept of MI5 having nothing better to do than break windows in Grafton Street was just too much for me.

Deputy Blaney's speech was a valuable speech because it showed us just precisely where the emotions of the last few days could lead if they are not channelled in the interests of the people. May I say to him, through you, Sir, that other people share his emotions? He has no particular monopoly of emotion where national issues are concerned. Others, as well as he, in this House have Ulster blood and, even those who have not, care for all our country. I, too, felt as he did yesterday at the funeral. My heart, too, was with the suppressed and sorrowing people. I saw the same coffin-bearing, weeping boys that he saw and I heard that child cry, a cry all the more heartrending because its tone clearly betokened that the child did not fully realise he would not see his father again.

What those scenes mean to me now is that this cannot go on. There must be an end to these deaths. This violence is leading us to a human disaster and we must forget our differences here, forget our fears of unpopularity, ignore the pressures of demagogy displayed in this House today, stand firm against the voice of unreason, prevent more families being destroyed and more desolation of human heart and mind. I wondered, listening to Deputy Blaney's speech, was it entirely sincere, despite the supercharging with emotion. He is a man we all know whose actions have always been over the years very calculated. He is a man who, in Government, would lock up the IRA, up to 1961, as a Government Minister, for four years, sharing responsibility for it and who has the nerve to come into this House and ask us to release the Republican prisoners. Is that honesty, sincerity or hypocrisy? I know what I think it is—hypocrisy, hypocrisy of a kind which does not come well from someone putting forward the sentiments he put forward here today. I saw him yesterday with his cohorts——

Comment on this

Stop slagging and get on——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

——and I wondered why he and his cohorts were so careful to occupy those front rows normally reserved for members of the Government party, why he was there with his Gerry Joneses and Mark Hylands and Padraic Haugheys and Louis Maguires blocking off those seats normally reserved for the Government party, blocking off those seats from Fianna Fáil. Was that because they were so concerned to show sympathy for the people in the Creggan or was it for political motives?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. The time is limited for each speaker.

Comment on this

Deputy Blaney left me in doubt yesterday as to his sincerity but, even if he is sincere, he is an evil influence. He opened his speech today by congratulating himself at some length on being right, as he thought, and yet, this morning, he told the House unctuously that he wanted a debate, but not in order to show that he was right; he changed his tune as soon as he got on his feet. He told us how right he has been. But how hard has he worked to make his prophecies come true?

Comment on this

Harder than the Deputy anyhow.

Comment on this

Indeed. It was predictable all along that if enough arms and enough explosives could be got into the hands of the IRA and enough British soldiers could be blown up there would be a reaction no matter how good the initial relations might be between the troops and the Catholics. The policy he propounded to this House today was a war policy. Blood he spoke of three times: once about a redblooded people, again about people with red blood coursing through their veins and, later, he told us we should not take cold-blooded decisions. Cold blood or hot blood, it is always blood. He wants the Army out and the FCA to be mobilised. He wants them sent to the Border "for a time of need" and there was to be no equivocation as to what this time of need is but, equivocally, he would not tell the House what the time of need was. He also mentioned the word "war". What he means is civil war. What he means is to send our soldiers so that there would be death and destruction in the North knowing, as he knows perfectly well, that our Army and our fully organised FCA could not reach Belfast and could not do anything to save the 120,000 Catholics in Belfast as a consequence of Deputy Blaney's war policy.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The Deputy had his opportunity. Let him take his medicine now.

Comment on this

Let us have a speech about what this is all about.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot have two speeches at the one time. Deputy FitzGerald.

Comment on this

I am speaking about what this is about; I am speaking about the Deputy's policy, the policy of civil war. In this House today he came clean. In this House today we saw what he wanted. We know what the result would be of the policies he advocates and I say the people are entitled to have this put to them plainly before this man leads them to destruction.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comharle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

He tells us that our decision in this matter must not be a one. He says the veneer is now broken and, indeed, broken it was in Merrion Square yesterday and he tells us, and I quote again, for I took down his words with care, "These conclusions are too terrifying to be taken in cold blood." So, let us close our eyes—this is what he wishes —to the consequences, to the death and destruction and plunge into this war with all the results it will have.

Comment on this

You are a liar, Deputy FitzGerald, and you know it.

Comment on this

On a point of order? Is it in order to call another Member a liar?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blaney may not call any Member of the House a liar.

Comment on this

Especially when the Deputy is quoting accurately.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy please allow the Chair to deal with Deputy Blaney? Deputy Blaney must withdraw the word "liar". It is not in order.

Comment on this

In deference to the ruling of the Chair, I withdraw that and I want to ask, on a point of order, whether it is right that this ranting half-wit down here should come in masquerading as——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not make another speech. I take it the Deputy has withdrawn the word "liar".

Comment on this

I am withdrawing the word "liar" and I am asking what the half-wit is doing——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not add insult to injury by calling a Deputy such a name.

Comment on this

I hope the Ceann Comhairle will add injury time to the insults.

Comment on this

Is it in order for a Deputy to cast reflections on another Deputy as Deputy Blaney has done in regard to Deputy FitzGerald?

Comment on this

What did I do?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has taken action on that point and the Deputy has withdrawn the appellation.

Comment on this

In all fairness to Deputy Blaney, I think Deputy FitzGerald did misrepresent what he said on that particular point.

Comment on this

I agree substantially with a great deal of what Deputy FitzGerald has said but I am concerned with accuracy.

Comment on this

The Minister should understand that raising a point of order means that he should keep quiet. Is it in order for the Chair to listen to the type of remark Deputy Blaney made in regard to Deputy FitzGerald?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blaney withdrew the remark and I am now calling on Deputy FitzGerald to continue.

Comment on this

Is the Chair tolerating a situation like that?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I want to make this very clear. I called on Deputy Blaney to withdraw the remark which he did.

Comment on this

I am not referring to that remark. I am referring to the second remark. If the Chair was minding what he did he would take a note of it.

Comment on this

That is a reflection on the Chair.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let us have a period of reflection now and allow Deputy FitzGerald to continue.

Comment on this

I can appreciate that Deputy Blaney does not like being reminded of the four years when he was the jailer of republican prisoners but he over-reached himself today. Many people in the last few days have been swept by momentary emotions and have cried for something positive to be done—have we not all felt the urge to do something?—but many of those people will be shocked into sober reality by the bitter, bloodthirsty speech here today. Deputy Blaney is right in one thing, in a sense of urgency. The pressures of emotion and unreason are now powerful, fomented by men like Deputy Blaney. Time is desperately short and another massacre like that in Derry on Sunday could bring us to the brink. This message must reach the British Government from this House and from us all, including Deputy Blaney.

Comment on this

Thanks very much, Deputy.

Comment on this

The message must reach the British people from whom the truth has been kept by the British Press and communications media who are ever fearful of criticising their own defence forces, a fear which I think the Press and media in every country feel. I am sure that if ever a similar occasion arose here—we know it would not—there would be the same inhibitions. But these inhibitions are dangerous. The British people do not know clearly what has happened in Derry. Even though some of their reporters did report plainly what they saw in honesty, at times the sub-editing left something to be desired and the editorials suggested that the men who wrote them never read the reports of their own journalists.

We must reach the British people in any way we can, through the media, through articles, letters, interviews on radio and television. They cannot suppress them all although they suppress some of them including one that I was in on this very subject. We must reach them also through friendly nations, through the countries with whom we and the British are about to ally ourselves in the EEC, countries which cannot be, and which we know are not happy with the situation created by British policy in Northern Ireland. To me, that seems the most hopeful channel of external pressure on the United Kingdom. I do not think this pressure will come from the United Nations. Britain is a blind spot where the UN is concerned and pressure from that source is likely to be counter-productive, but where Britain is sensitive is in relation at this moment to the European Economic Community. Pressure from France or Germany, Belgium, The Netherlands or Italy and countries like that could have its effect. That is where our Minister for Foreign Affairs should be today rather than performing on television in the United States to an audience friendly to us in any event in that country. I hope the Taoiseach will bring him back and send him with representatives of the Opposition to show a united front in the countries of Europe to persuade these countries to use their influence to bring peace to this country so that a peaceful Ireland may, with Britain, enter the EEC on 1st January next year.

Ultimately, it is to British politicians we must address ourselves. We must get them to see and admit what happened in Derry, to see the folly of their policies of turning a friendly neighbour into an enemy. To get them to see how we feel, we must bridge a gap in understanding. The great problem here is the gulf in understanding that has arisen partly because when emotions are aroused reason disappears and people see things only from their own point of view—I am sure we are guilty of this here today also—and partly because the media are not always good at ensuring that both sides of the case are heard in each country. Some of the media in Britain have been particularly unfortunate in this respect. For these reasons a gap in understanding has arisen. When you talk to fair-minded British people and politicians and to British politicians who are very well-disposed towards this country and towards ultimate Irish unity, one finds at times an inability to understand how we think and feel. At times I think we share this inability. Certainly, when I listen to men like Goodheart on television the other night I find it hard to understand how he thinks and feels, a man like that who in the face of the evidence before him blandly asserted as an absolute fact that the troops behaved perfectly in Derry on Sunday.

It is hard to understand people like that and they find us hard to understand. Anything that is done in this country or in this House that makes understanding more difficult makes it harder for us to understand them or for them to understand us, and any obstacles created to that understanding are obstacles to peace and unity. Does anybody think that burning down the British Embassy will make the ordinary Britisher more likely to see our point of view? Is it not obvious that it will merely hold up the evolution of understanding? They will come to see the truth: they are slow people to learn: they find it hard to understand other people's point of view. We know how long it took us in the years before independence and it is taking a hell of a long time now. But in time, as weeks and months pass, they are coming to see the truth. The tone of their politicians' comments is changing even visibly day by day. There was a different note sounded by Lord Carrington in the House of Lords than that sounded by Mr. Maudling in the House of Commons. Visibly they are coming to realise that within the Northern Ireland area, for the period that it remains separate from our administration, there must be community government, something which they did not see six months ago and which they are now beginning to see clearly.

But the pace of events so far as they are concerned is far too slow. Growth of understanding of our problem is far too slow and the pace of events here and the danger it creates for us here is far too great. It is the disparity between these two that threatens us at this time.

Therefore, we must do whatever we can together because we can work together on this if sufficient confidence can be created between the different sides and I think that can be done. We must make what dramatic gestures we can to get across to them. That is why the other day the Leader of Fine Gael, the Leader of the Opposition, proposed a joint visit to London by the Leaders of the three parties to see Mr. Heath. Of course, he recognised that there are dangers in this. The chances of Mr. Heath suddenly being enlightened by such a visit and changing his policy overnight are pretty slim, judging by his performance over the past 18 months. Yet, it would be an opportunity to make some progress, an opportunity of getting across to the British people through the publicity such a visit would arouse and the impression it must make on them that parties so divided as we are here can unite in putting to the British people the situation as we see it and pleading with them to have sense at last and realise what they are doing to this country, doing to themselves and to relations between the two countries. It is not in the interests of Britain to have an inimical Ireland on their flank. They can be brought to see this, this is where we must apply ourselves rather than in making the kind of gesture of moving troops up to the Border and threatening war.

We can do something at home also —something I have pressed in every speech on this matter that I have made here since 1969, but to no avail so far. There are things about the way we run our part of Ireland that are an obstacle to understanding with the North and which stand between us and the Protestant people of that part of the country. While there is a recognition of this, a recognition that extends to the other side of the House, it has not led yet to any kind of action. The Taoiseach told us today that we must face some change in stance and policy here if there is to be unity, but he said the same thing in much the same words each time he spoke on this subject. What action has there been? Is there any sign of a sense of urgency in this matter? I see none. Six weeks ago it was proposed and shortly afterwards agreed that a committee of the three parties be established for this purpose but nothing further has been heard about it either publicly or privately. No progress has been made but yet the situation worsens as each day passes. How, then, can the Government excuse inaction when, if that committee had been set up at the time it was proposed, it could be reaching the point already of agreeing on some kind of proposals that would show to the Protestant people of Northern Ireland that we are prepared to create in a United Ireland a society of which they would be proud to be members? It is open to us to do that. Nobody is stopping us. It does not need any action on the part of the British for us to sit down and do this job but we have not done it.

This does not suggest any great sense of urgency on the part of the Government and yet they claim that they recognise there is a sense of urgency. Could we have some genuine consultation? We have not had any so far. There is a whole range of issues which this committee will have to consider. Some of these issues were referred to by Deputy O'Connell but there are others and these include the whole Church-State relationship which, of course, is central to the fears of Northern Protestants. This must be on a basis that they find acceptable.

There is the problem of the Irish language which was adverted to by Deputy Cooney. We cannot impose this on Protestants of Northern Ireland and tell them that they can serve in the Civil Service of a federal Irish State only if they have learned Irish. They would regard that as discriminatory as the kind of tactics which they have wielded against the minority in Northern Ireland. When will this matter be tackled? Are we serious about unity or do we, in our hearts, go on believing that it will not happen and that we can continue with our policies down here which in their effects are often sectarian and divisive?

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy will agree that there are many Protestants who can speak Irish.

Comment on this

Would Deputy Tunney stand in the way of national unity?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Tunney please cease interrupting?

Comment on this

Of course there are such. My mother who was a Northern Protestant was the foundress of the Cumann Gaelach in Queen's University. But is anybody going to tell me that a million Protestants from the North of Ireland would look forward to coming into a country where they could not get their school-leaving examination without passing an examination in Irish? We all know that that cannot be imposed on them. Could we not make the gesture now of ceasing to impose this on people down here?

Comment on this

A little girl from Japan was awarded first prize in Irish a few months ago at Shannon Airport.

Comment on this

If that is the level on which this debate is to be conducted, God help Ireland. Protestants in the North are beginning to think again on this issue and if we could show them at this stage that we are genuine it could have an effect at this dramatic moment but they have had no evidence of this in anything that we have done or said during the past couple of years. It is possible now to see the way towards some kind of agreement which, over a period, would lead us to a united Ireland, a united Ireland achieved by consent. This will not be easy and neither will it be quick. Those politicians and those newspapers which suggest that unity can be achieved overnight are rendering no service to the Irish people. We could set ourselves in that direction with success and with a fair expectation of arriving there if we are prepared to make the changes here that would indicate to the people of Northern Ireland who are not of the same religious persuasion as the majority of the people here that they would be acceptable in this part of Ireland.

To sum up, Deputy Blaney during his contribution showed the utter bankruptcy of extremist policy and that such policy has nothing to offer but war. Thank God that that has been exposed clearly here today for the Irish people to see. We, who do not seek to kill other Irish people, must lead the Irish people in unity towards the radical changing of British opinions and decisions. We must help to do this by showing our sincerity in our actions at home, but time is desperately short. We must show that we measure up to this occasion. We must show this by our willingness to drop our differences and to have a genuine unity of approach between those who share the concern for peace.

We have not seen that yet. We have heard talk of consultation but it must be said that it will not be possible to have a united approach if consultation means that in a crisis or every few months the Taoiseach has a hurried consultation in the middle of a Government meeting with Deputy Cosgrave, promises to come back again but makes no further communication for days or maybe weeks. That is not consultation. If we are to act unitedly, the Taoiseach, in replying to this debate, must show that he is prepared to bring the Opposition into his Cabinet in matters of internal security and in matters that concern the development of our Northern policy so that we could all work together towards this end. If he does not measure up to that, if he wants to keep all the cards in his own hands for political reasons—that may be the case; I do not know, but there is no evidence to the contrary—let that be clear so that we will know where we stand. It should be clear to everybody that there is willingness on our part to work with the Government towards this national end if we can have the genuine consultation that will make that possible. That is the message that should go out from this party and from this House today. The message is one of urgency. Above all there is the urgency of getting through to the British, and that is a hard task; but if we cannot get through to them to change their policies quickly, this country faces a disaster towards which it will be led by men, one of whom we have heard speak in this House today.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

I presume we would not be having this debate at this time if it were not for the tragic events that occurred in Derry on Sunday last. To some extent this debate should be taking place, at least in spirit, at the gravesides of the young victims of those events. I would hope that the tribute which the elected representatives of this Assembly could bring to the graves of Derry would consist in an attempt to be constructive, to face up to the tragic, serious crisis before the whole country. The dead of Derry would be better honoured if the living, instead of giving way to emotion would attempt to avert greater tragedy and to protect by their statements and actions the lives of other young people throughout the country. I do not know whether all of us in this Dáil are aware of the serious situation facing us all, of the dread abyss in prospect for the whole country. It is a situation in which one might legitimately give way to despair. The elements are present that give honest reason for despair.

Can civil war be averted? That is the question before us. Earlier this century there was another debate in which another assembly gave way to the pressures of civil war and people left that assembly and took part in that civil war. The coming civil war, casting shadows before it in certain of the speeches heard here today, could be more calamitous both in its size and in its effects. That other civil war took place when the territorial outline of the State was known and concerned the prizes to be won within the confines of that State. The coming civil war is about an ideal on both sides, and nobody can tell how many lives it would claim. Therefore, the question before us is whether we are for or against civil war. Without calling it that name, some people have opted for civil war and they have lined up on that side. On this issue, I do not see it as an indictment of this House, but rather as the duty of Parliament to eschew party politics and unite to give the people a lead at this time of crisis.

Certain Deputies taking part in this debate have the idea that the old politics can continue, that we can continue to make party points on this occasion. I believe the situation is far too serious for that attitude. Emotions are high as a result of the Derry shooting and further events may result in galvanising this whole country in the direction of war. By establishing an all-party committee this Dáil can take a much more purposeful line in dealing with this problem. If it is considered that conditions are not yet perilous enough for the formation of a national Government, we can certainly have unity on this question between all the people elected to this House, because there is a great measure of agreement between us on the direction to be taken in seeking a solution. If the all-party committee suggested already is to be fruitful there must be a certain ceding of sovereignty on the part of the Government in the functions of this committee. The issues before us are larger and more important than the fate of any political party or Government.

Recommendations on unity should be advanced as soon as possible and this Dáil all-party committee should be the agency for contact with Britain and other foreign Governments on this issue and the immediate priorities of achieving political talks. I do not believe the Government can maintain any longer the sole responsibility for this question. There are divisions in their ranks and there are divisions in other parties. There is also a great deal of division of opinion in the country, and people are looking for a clear lead. Above all, we must set our faces against the emotion giving way to the forces that are looking for armed confrontation. We should leave no diplomatic stone unturned. We are very much alone in the world as a result of the foreign policies we have followed, and I would not hesitate to go to the East European camp, to the Soviet Union or any other country in an effort to get the right diplomatic pressure exerted on Britain to grant us the political conditions in which talks can take place, internment can be ended and some settlement achieved that will lead on towards a united country. Short of actual war I am for any initiative that puts pressure on Britain to come to the conference table to negotiate.

There is no use fooling ourselves that the British Government are in a co-operative mood. They are not. To believe that peace can be totally restored and that Irish unity will be on the agenda with the departure of British troops is to be deluded. From the little contact I have had with Northern problems over the years, I believe that the real crux in our struggle for unity is the division in political allegiance between the Unionist and Nationalist elements of the population of this island. There are Deputies here who can pretend that problem does not exist; I wish I could so pretend.

I would have hoped that people would not use this debate as a means to vindicate opinions which they allege they held previously. It requires no great crystal-ball-gazing talent to know that relations between the British Army and the minority have broken down. Any good relations that existed between them broke down more than a year ago, and it required no particular insight to foresee that the army without political initiative by their Government must end in disaster. Any illusions that anybody might have had that the British Army would act in a disciplined fashion at a time of public excitement were dispelled last Sunday by the conduct of the paratroopers in Derry, and we have made a call that those men should be court-martialled for the murders perpetrated.

This, of course, will not bring the dead back to life. The people killed in Derry were ordinary working-class people, and the count down of those killed in the North of Ireland indicates a preponderance of casualties on the civilian side. If this violence extends from Northern Ireland the same preponderance of civilian casualties will apply. I do not think any Deputy here should indulge in the traditional kind of politics that have been indulged in on the Northern issue over the years. I would hope that after Derry we could say goodbye to the practice of using that issue as electoral fodder in the Twenty-six Counties. I do not know one Deputy out of any party present in the House who is not for unity. I do not like the political or economic policies of the Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch, I am critical of his methods, his dilatory approach but I do not question his sincerity on the question of Irish unity, nor do I question the sincerity of any other Deputy on that issue. Therefore, I would hope that we could say goodbye to this super-patriot cult which would suggest that some people in this assembly think more deeply about and long more strongly for Irish unity than other Deputies.

The problem is how to achieve the unity we all desire. It must be admitted that it will require the British Government's co-operation. I think even Deputy Neil Blaney admitted that in the past few weeks. However, the present British administration appears to be locked in total collusion with the rump of the Unionist Party in Northern Ireland on security matters and all other vital matters affecting the area. We are up against the enormous problem of how to get through to Mr. Ted Heath. The all-party committee to which I have referred must be the agency for contact with the British Government and any other international institutions. The times are too dangerous for the Government to manage this on their own. All of us should say clearly to our constituents: "There is no division between any of the political parties in Leinster House on the Northern issue. Nobody claims to know all the answers. Nobody can claim to be more zealous than any other party." Quite frankly, not one amongst us knows all the answers.

Plainly, the British Army must go. What comes in its place? I have no clear answer. It is clear to me, however, that our problems do not disappear with the departure of the British Army. We must get some form of security force in the area. I believe that it will not be possible to avert civil war unless we can get some political shortterm settlement which, for a period, will create a sharing of power between Unionists and anti-Unionists in the North of Ireland on an equal basis, so that they may learn in a preparatory period what it would be like to live together in a united Ireland. We will not wake up one Monday morning and find ourselves in a united Ireland, which has happened without an intermediate stage of the most intense political effort. If a civil war takes place I do not believe that a united Ireland will be possible in this century or in the next. Not a great deal would be achieved by a civil war. We would have hundreds of dead and political boundaries altered minutely, perhaps, but substantially the problem of division would remain the same. But there would be many more Derry funerals.

I get the impression that many of our people are like children who are afraid of the dark, when looking at this problem: "We want our war with Britain but we want our totally dependent trading relationship with Britain to be retained intact. We want a war by resolution and manifesto, but not a war by bullet and bomb." Apparently the mental picture of some people is that the British Army departs, the subsidies are withdrawn, and unity is then ours—as Deputy Blaney said, we can take them over. I do not believe we can. I admit to the limitations of my view. I cannot fool myself. I cannot believe that this would be so. If ever we reach the stage where that happens and where those people come in with us without any trouble, I will have been totally wrong and I will admit it. I make the following admission: I am convinced of the present intransigence of the Unionists towards coming into a united Ireland. I do not believe they will be deserted by the British Tories in their intransigence and in their opposition to a united Ireland.

I agree with the Taoiseach that Border incidents can be very dangerous indeed. I believe we could find British tanks reach nearer to Lucan than we think if these Border incidents developed. I believe this about British Tory thinking. I do not think British Tories would greatly care about intervention and penetration deep into the territory of the Republic. The question I put to the House is: to whom would we appeal in that eventuality? Where are our friends in the world to whom we should appeal on the head of British invasion or British penetration of our territory? What would be our stance internationally if the British penetrated 50 miles into our territory and then withdrew, just to let us know exactly the kind of wogs they thought we were? What would be our reaction?

I get the impression that, in thinking about this situation, many of us have the idea that some miracle will take place, or that there will be some flash of recognition and all that was troublesome before will be rendered smooth. I do not believe that. I wish I could. I may be wrong, but I think the times are too serious for any of us to begin to criticise one another on the basis that some are less sincere than others about our desire for unity. We in this Assembly should come together and pool our resources, our contacts and our opinions. This all-party committee should be serviced by a full-time secretariat. It should not just be a casual weekly meeting of politicians of different parties smoking their pipes and talking about the weather. It should demonstrate to the people that it is the unified focal action of the Dáil parties on the whole issue of unity, the living expression of the agreement of Dáil Éireann on how the matter should be dealt with.

There is no doubt in my mind that there is this danger in the period immediately ahead of us, and I have referred to this danger before, the possible destruction of free institutions of democracy. So far we have shown a determination to resist any tendency in this direction. One consequence of the continuing impasse in the North, an impasse created by the British Tory Government with the continuation of internment without trial and the impossibility therefore of seeing the SDLP taking part in talks—a determination we support—one consequence of this continued confrontation between the streets and the British Army, must be a growing movement away from Parliament and free institutions in this part of the country. There is a very serious danger that this could happen down here.

In such a situation we will have to consider something like a national government. That time has not yet arrived, thank God, but it may not be very far away. I see no service to the cause of a united Ireland if democracy fails and free institutions wither away here. This could happen very rapidly. The people who would be responsible for the withering away of democracy on this side of the Border would be the elected representatives in this Assembly if they were unable to sink the party differences that belong to more peaceful, normal times. They would be responsible for burying democracy. They would be accessories to the burial of democracy. It would be no fitting tribute to the dead of Derry to see democracy fail in the rest of Ireland.

These are testing times for all of us. We must all do our best to avert what could be a disastrous turn of events in our history. We must bury party differences and come together to provide a unified approach to this whole question. There may be some unforeseen intervention which could avert what I fear; there may be a change of Government in Britain but that looks doubtful at present. The question remains whether the Taoiseach and the Government really appreciate the gravity of the situation we are now in, the furnace which the future may hold for us all. I wonder whether the journalists, the media generally, know what the future may hold for them and the freedom of expression which they have at present to comment on public affairs. Quite obviously if democracy goes, if there is an end to free institutions, the limitation on freedom will not simply apply to this assembly. It will apply to every institution, to newspapers and free expressions of opinion in the Twenty-six Counties.

My despair is this: I do not think the Tory Government give two hoots what happens to democracy in the rest of Ireland. We owe it to the Derry dead not to despair, to keep control of our emotions. What the people of Derry want from us is a constructive contribution. Our tribute to their sacrifice should be to discover how we construct the peace, how we get a unified people on the basis of that peace? If I am right in thinking that the crux of our problem is a division in political allegiance between Unionist and anti-Unionist on this island, who but a madman could suggest that war would settle our problems? Who but a madman would suggest that 3,000,000 people have the digestive tract to swallow 1,000,000 people? Because that is what we will be asked to do. Forged with blood what kind of unity would result? It would be the unity of the abbatoir.

The last funeral in Derry which evoked such interest was the funeral of Cusack and Beattie in the summer. Now we have had the funeral of 13 people. No man should be rash enough to say: "I have been proved right by this event or that event in the North." Let us grow accustomed to one thing. If the present course of violence continues, there will be many more deaths to mourn and many more gravesides to prove who was right and who was wrong. We are an emotional people. If the elected representatives at this time are not seen to have regard to the gravity of the situation, to the kind of sacrifice it demands, then other agents will act, other agents answerable to no creed or principle will take over. The legitimacy of democratic institutions will be overthrown here and any possibility of a peaceful solution will be totally eliminated. There is no doubt that these violent agents will not be so scrupulous, will not be too worried about means and will not be too worried about results, because finally I am not unconvinced that many of the people calling for change in the North are, in fact, even more interested in political change in the South. In many of the most revolutionary slogans we find lurking an ambition to run the old State, the Twenty-Six County State, rather than trying to do what others of us are trying to do: facing up to the problems that must be faced if we are to create a united Irish political state linking Unionist and anti-Unionist.

I did not intend to speak this long because there is nothing original in what I have to say except that I believe that this Dáil must have a far more purposeful role to play in giving leadership at this time. I believe we should sink political differences. If we cannot have a national Government, if conditions do not call for it at this time, I believe we can have a national Government in effect on the most important question before us, that of the North. I believe the minority in the North would welcome this. We would be giving an effective answer to the forces of anarchy and disorder, who in fact, if they win through, will bring no real unity to the Irish people, nothing but death, destruction and graveyard slogans.

I welcome the Taoiseach's decision to give financial aid to the alternative assembly in Dungiven. It is the very least we can do. It is a democratic forum in that area. It is a democratic assembly and, as far as I am concerned, I am prepared to stand or fall with the elected representatives of the minority of the Six County region, with the SDLP and the other elected representatives.

I began by saying I hoped, if our debate does not shine for oratory this time, that we will make up for it and we will be paying fitting tribute to all the young people, all the civilians, both Catholic and Protestant, who have died in this terrible conflict in the North over the last three years. We will be showing that our Parliament here is not worthless or a vain enterprise if we show our people that we are serious and ready to make any sacrifices necessary in defence of the future unity of our country.

Comment on this

I have listened to all the speeches so far, some of them highly intemperate and more of them cool, calm and collected. We on this side of the House have always expressed the view that war was not a solution to the reunification of our country. There is no doubt but that we have a ginger group and if this ginger group had its way it would land us in the position where we should find ourselves faced with solving this problem without weapons. It has long been held that force is not a solution for our difficulties but this does not deny the fact that we need a Defence Force here. We need to strengthen the arms of State and we need to recruit extra men for the Department of Defence. We need extra gardaí as well.

A good plea has been made by Deputy O'Leary on behalf of the institutions of State. Most Members of the House, no matter how they differ otherwise, will subscribe to this view. There has been a good deal of criticism in this debate today about lack of initiative on the part of the Government, not merely in this period but in the past. I would point out to those who make those assertions that many times during the last 30 years the Government made overtures to the North but regrettably the extreme left wing movement made up of the IRA and others stepped in to spoil any movement towards unity. All members of the House are well aware of this and it is, therefore, untrue to say that the various Governments here did not make the most of whatever opportunity presented itself to try to promote a better relationship with the North.

It is regrettable also that when the Labour Government in England left power and the Conservatives came into power the hardliners in the North seemed to sense that they had acquired a new lease of life. I went to the House of Commons to hear the former Home Secretary introduce the legislation necessary to send troops to Northern Ireland on 13th October, 1969. I cannot help but contrast the attitude of the present Home Secretary, Mr. Maudling, with that of the then Home Secretary, Mr. James Callaghan. In his speech he gave a summary of the fears of the Northern Protestants and he referred to the recommendations of the Cameron Report, which brought about the move at that time to police the North in a more favourable way, as it was then thought, by sending in the British Army. The British Army came and regrettably, when Mr. Maulding came in, the first night he appeared on TV he said that the British Army were sent in to defeat the IRA.

In our long history and in our dealings with various British Governments, we had a good deal of duplicity; we went through periods of high propaganda, periods when British politicians spoke in the House of Commons with one tongue and outside with another. This time we had the British Home Secretary suggesting that he was sending the British Army into Northern Ireland to defeat the IRA. It was the height of folly. He did it for one of two motives, either as a Conservative Home Secretary seeking justification for the presence of the British Army in Northern Ireland, or deliberately to strengthen the hands of the IRA so that the militants among us would be seen to react. It is not always possible in this House or elsewhere to profess peace, to profess unity through peaceful means, and I have my doubts of the genuineness of the British Home Secretary when he went deliberately before a large audience and stated that the British Army were being sent in to defeat the IRA. The IRA at that stage were a very small unit and I am charging the Home Secretary with malice aforethought. He said his purpose was to bring the IRA under control and I charge him with being an accessory to the addition of thousands of recruits to the IRA. This was often done in the past by British Prime Ministers and Home Secretaries. We should all regret that it should be repeated in 1971. I suppose it was to be expected from an introvert Englishman who had never looked outside his own shores except, possibly, to deal with some remote colony or another. He made a terrible mistake in that statement.

All of us regret the dreadful incidents of last week. In general, most people fear many more such incidents in the future but we cannot get away from the point that in a time of crisis we have to stand on our own as the people did in 1918 when another serious challenge faced the country. I am glad to see all Members of the House, with the exception of a tiny minority, subscribing to this point of view. We should not allow extreme militants to make the pace for us. In this context the Government have been criticised on the grounds of inactivity in so far as making representations on our position abroad is concerned. This is part of the usual desire to blame the Government for events over which we have very little control.

If a Government purport to be a Government they cannot delegate responsibility to any committee of the House. No doubt they may work in unison with the Leaders of the major parties in the House but I suggest to the House that it is not possible for any Government worthy of the name to divide responsibility for decision-making. If the country so wills, the Government can be put out of power. That is another story, but so long as the Government retain power they have to act accordingly. In this context a good number of people seem to think the Government are not in power and, perhaps, this was responsible for the enormous parade, the enormous show of strength through the streets of Dublin yesterday.

Be this as it may, I suggest we should not allow the extreme militants among us to make the pace at this stage. Therefore, I was pleased during the past fortnight when the announcement was made that the strength of the Garda was to be increased and that the Army also were to be strengthened, because in times of national stress one has to preserve the law. The institutions of State must be upheld at any cost and those who would try to pull them down must be put under.

On many occasions in the past, in 1798, 1801, 1916 and subsequently, we had those among us who could be termed splitters. We have them today. Splitters are splitters no matter how one looks at them. They split for a purpose. We have them in abundance today. This is why I was glad to see the Opposition in general coming to stand behind the Government at this time. I must pay a tribute to the senior members of the Opposition for their stand at this time. I also command all members of the Opposition as well as the actions of all others who have the real interests of the country at heart. One does not start off by knocking down the house one builds. There is no place at this stage for burners, looters or robbers. We will have to make this very clear in the coming period, that if we are to help the minority in Northern Ireland, we can only help them through the institutions of the State, not surreptitiously by unofficial means, not by violence and certainly not by acts of aggression as suggested by certain members of the community and a few Members of this House.

If I gathered right from my visits to the House of Commons at that stage, Mr. Callaghan felt, when he was sending in the troops, that he was sending them in to separate the communities in the no-go areas, as he called them, but he did not bargain for the fact that there would be a change of Government and that the hard-line Unionists would get the upper hand and regrettably we have hard-line Unionists. It is a regrettable fact that while we have intermingled and crossed the Border to and fro now and again even to various social functions, for upwards of 48 years, we had the people who purported to be the leaders in the North, people who were educated at public schools, some of them at Oxford and other higher centres of education——

Comment on this
Brigid Hogan-O'Higgins Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins Fine Gael

We have some of them here, unfortunately.

Comment on this

And we have some of them here, people who, at the same time, marched behind the big drum and gave the ordinary worker in Northern Ireland the impression that if the Catholic population outgrew the Protestants, that was the end for them.

Mr. Callaghan on that day summarised the position very well. He dealt with those fears but he dealt also with the fears of the minority and the fears of the minority far outpaced the fears of the majority. The general fear of the majority was, and is today, that if they lose power, if the Unionists lose power in Northern Ireland, that is the end. They should be aware of the fact —I presume they are and so are their leaders—that the minority here are treated in the same way as the majority. This is why I never cease to wonder—if Deputy Thornley wishes to comment on that, we have had a mandate for it time and again and he will get a chance of going before the electorate and putting his views; if he gets that mandate, all right——

Comment on this

I shall certainly comment upon it.

Comment on this

I hope so. It is these men who, as I said, acted up in a comic opera atmosphere—going out to celebrate the Battle of the Boyne, walking with the Apprentice Boys and so on—whom I blame for the debacle we are faced with at this stage after 50 years, and I also blame the ultra-patriots, who time and again when we tried to make overtures across the Border shot down our efforts. It is not today or yesterday that we had these extremists amongst us, these pseudo-patriots, these true-blue republicans, setting out to climb the heights and secure the ultimate freedom, but what have they done? They have provided a vehicle for the British Government to send their paratroopers into the no-go areas, as Mr. Callaghan said, and have provided a vehicle, in my opinion, for the murders which took place in Derry last week. We cannot have it both ways. We either subscribe to the democratic institutions of the State or we do not, and we cannot go about preaching pacificism with a book in one hand and a revolver in the other, and the sooner all of us get this clear the better. This should not prevent us from adopting what this House and the Government deem to be the proper measures to deal with the present menace, the present position in the North. This will not prevent us from helping our fellow-citizens there; this will not prevent us from sending all the aid we can to them; and this will not prevent us from providing shelter and refuge for them, if necessary.

At this point we cannot subscribe to the view that we can shoot our way into unity. The Taoiseach time and again, and especially since 1968, has made it crystal clear that Unionists or Protestants have nothing to fear from the Government here, or any Government established here. He made it quite clear that there were equal rights and equal opportunities, but despite that, the teachings of those, who, as I say, should know better, down the years apparently are going to prevail and this fear of the dominance of the Catholic population is the root cause of this whole matter. It is too bad then that the Unionists are going to insist that ultimately the whole of Northern Ireland will be a no-go area; it is too bad if the mounting deathroll is to go on; it is too bad if the British Government do not see the end of the road in regard to violence; it is too bad if the British Government do not see that they are feared and hated from the Continent of India, round about Africa and right down by the Bay of Biscay; and it is too bad that a dense Government in 1972 present that picture because I do not think this is the general aim of the ordinary British citizen. But at this time this is the image which is being presented by the British Government.

I remember 1940 when we were assembling an Army. We did not have much of an Army before that but it did not take us long to assemble a fairly good Army and to equip it. We also assembled a local defence force. I think we can do it again; I think we should do it, not with any ulterior motive but for the purpose of providing for law and order at home and ensuring that the elected Government, whatever Government that may be, carry the assent of the electorate, and will carry the assent of those who are violent among us and who believe that by bomb and bullet we can solve our difficulty. What we did before we can do again and we should do it as rapidly as we can.

We should not be too critical of a Government who have faced very difficult problems in the last three to four years, not merely problems abroad but problems at home. When we refer to the under-strength of the Army or Garda it is my submission that we had priorities and we could not divide the money we had in such a way as to build up the forces. If we did we would have neglected some other arm of our economy.

Comment on this

On the subject of the North of Ireland, the division of our country and the hope for unity of our country, there is no side in this House, no Deputy in this House and no party in this House who can with justification deal with the subject confident that he or they have always been right. The division of our country and the problems arising from it have, unfortunately, found nothing but a sort of studied interest in this House in years gone by. It has been an area of considerable neglect for many decades in relation to the functioning of this House and in relation to the administration of different Governments. In this debate when I hear any Deputy saying: "Our point of view has always been correct" or "I foretold this" or "I said something was going to happen and I am entitled to a pat on the back for that" I suspect such an approach because we have to bring to the problem of the division of our country a great deal of humility and I hope a great deal of dedication and sincerity. It is a problem which has grown by reason of neglect over many years past and it is a problem which is today much more acute and much more difficult of solution than it might have been some time in the recent past.

We have this debate today because of the shock everybody felt at the events that took place in Derry last Sunday where by reason of the inevitable logic of an unjust situation defenceless people were shot down, murdered—and I do not think we should be the slightest bit reluctant to use that word "murdered"—by British forces, by soldiers of the Queen, acting presumably on orders, firing directly at defenceless people and having done the damage, having killed 13 people, then proceeding, through their officer, to create a web of deceit, trying to suggest that events had occurred which had not occurred and trying to prevaricate and set up the usual kind of excuse for those who have done wrong, that it was not their fault.

We are having this debate because of that, because from the dreadful events of the last two years or three years, there is now a situation in part of our country where violence and killing are so common that people scarcely are concerned or surprised or shocked at events of this kind. This is dreadful. It has come about because in the last three years those who ought to have listened to the voice of reason did not pay heed in time. Many opportunities have been missed. Much could have been done in 1968, much could have been done in 1969, in 1970 and 1971, but what might have been is now just so much more added on to the problem that we have to face.

I suppose there is no point in this House in trying to get the ear of the British Government, or trying to speak out from here to those in charge in Westminster, but let us at least state here and have it to say that we were able to say it, the sands of time are running out very fast in so far as the North of Ireland is concerned. There has been lip-service to the desirability of a political initiative, of breaking the deadlock situation, of some new political intervention. People say that. When is it going to take place? The facts are known. Internment was wrong. It has been declared by the elected representatives of the minority that as long as internment is there they will not talk or meet or discuss the common problem with others. That is a fact and, if words mean anything, presumably that is a fact that everybody has to live with. It is no good wishing that their attitude might be otherwise. It is no good saying that perhaps if they put it in a different way a whole lot of other things might be possible. The plain fact is that they have put it on the line that as long as internment remains they will not be in a position to talk or to discuss what is a common problem facing all of us. Does that mean that things are to end in that situation and that with internment continuing there will be no talk but just a continuance of a deteriorating situation in which one incident follows another and there is the cumulative effect of a whole lot of incidents into a situation of almost complete civil war?

I do not want to make any suggestions from here but it appears to me that this is a situation in which farseeing and big-minded intervention is required from the British Government. I do not think anyone now regards the Stormont situation, the Stormont Government, as important. The tide has receded from that position. I do not think anyone could imagine the possibility of the restoration of the Stormont situation as it was three or four years ago. It just is not on; it cannot happen. Whatever is going to take place in the future, everybody realises that there is going to be a very drastic and profound change. In that situation, if we are not to foresee more bloodshed, more killings, more funerals, more distress, this is the time if ever there was one, when the Prime Minister of England should take this matter entirely into his own hand and initiate a new movement on the political stage which may bring some prospect of success.

The British troops are there. We will not go back over the circumstances in which they arrived in 1969 or the climate in which they arrived or the way in which they were greeted by the people at that time, but it is perfectly clear now that the British troops in the North of Ireland are regarded with hatred by the people in the minority there. It is clear that if there is to be any stage set for fruitful discussion, some decision must be taken to change the troop situation in the North. A phased withdrawal has been mentioned. Whatever it may be, they are now a source of provocation, of fear and a source of division and polarisation in the North.

I know there are difficulties about a United Nations force. It may be that it is possible for some other international police force to be made available in the North. I can appreciate that you could not, at least, in my view you should not, withdraw British troops without providing some other force in their place but, if confidence is to be restored in this part of our country, some form of police force or security force must be there to give a feeling of protection and security to both the majority and the minority. I should like to see some steps taken in that direction and I believe that can only be done by the personal intervention of the Prime Minister of England.

Many of us were there in Derry on Tuesday. As other Deputies have mentioned, I think anyone who was in Derry, in the church, at the funerals, will always carry with him the memory of the poignancy, the dreadful sorrow, the awful calamity and the tragedies that had afflicted the people of Derry and the unfortunate families concerned. As I was there, I could only wish that in that church on that occasion at that funeral there might have been some representative of the British Government or, indeed, of the Stormont Government, somebody there to see what had happened, this tragedy that had beset a community and 13 different families. Anyone who was there and saw it must feel a responsibility to do something to avert a repetition of a tragedy of that kind. Unfortunately, there was no one there to see from those Governments and one can only hope that public opinion can convey the message to the British Government and to the Government in Stormont of the immensity of that tragedy.

We declared a day of mourning. The purpose in doing that was to emphasise the shock felt by, it is fair to say, everybody on this island, in relation to what happened last Sunday. It was a national day of mourning on which our people mourned with the relatives of the 13 persons killed in Derry. That day of mourning and the fact that it was held and that these deaths were marked in that way must have some effect on public opinion outside this country, outside this island. Is it too much to hope that the message in some way may get home to the Government in Britain and to those who have present responsibility in relation to the North of Ireland? A nation does not go into mourning for nothing and this nation went into mourning because a tragedy had occurred, something dreadful had happened and we marked it in that way because that was the only way in which a small country can ask for justice from a more powerful neighbour.

The cry for justice that went out from the national day of mourning yesterday was a cry that can, I think, be fairly said to come from the 13 graves of these 13 victims. It was a cry for justice from the future government of this country, a cry which, I hope, will be listened to by those who have responsibility. That day of mourning was, of course, used by others here in this part of the country for their own fell purposes. They were not concerned with the division of our country, with Partition, or with the eventual reunification of our country, North and South, and they used this opportunity to turn an honourable, decent expression of sympathy and sorrow into an occasion for rioting and destruction. I should like to join the Taoiseach in condemning those who used the occasion for the purpose of destroying the building occupied by the British Embassy here.

In his speech today the Taoiseach recognised, belatedly perhaps, that this State is threatened by forces, groups and movements which operate under the cloak of patriotism but which are concerned only with the destruction of democracy. I share the views expressed by Deputy M. O'Leary who referred to this a short while ago. We have got to be very certain where we are going. The division of our country and the deprivation of citizens of Ireland of normal civil rights are things about which we know and things about which we feel. These are things with which we are concerned. We would like to be able to solve these problems. Unfortunately there are those who use the frustration we feel in order to try to destroy this institution of parliament and the democracy we have here in this part of our country. They are people willing to use the North as a sounding board for all sorts of destructive views and aims.

Do people, I wonder, realise the dangers involved in this? We had Deputy Blaney's speech here today. He came in to preach what? War. What kind of war? Civil war. What kind of gospel was he preaching? The gospel that Irishmen should get guns into their hands and shoot fellow-Irishmen. He stood up there and he said: "As I said before I say now. I was right then and I am right now." This is the Deputy who denied in this House time and time again that he ever advocated violence in relation to the North.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

But he does it now because he senses a widespread, euphoric feeling in favour of warlike stances and a warlike posture. How many heroes have we had who fought to the last drop of the other man's blood?

Comment on this

Especially when they live in Clontarf.

Comment on this

Those who hold that view may sincerely believe that they are right, but what they say will be used by those who are, in fact, sworn enemies of our democracy, of our state and of its future.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

They are those who want to establish here a kind of military dictatorship in which no view will obtain except that laid down by the small clique who will control the state. Deputies have a certain responsibility. I hope that we will hear from Deputy Haughey in this debate. I hope that we will find out exactly where every man stands. Deputy Blaney, Deputy Sherwin, Deputy Haughey, these are the Deputies who have talked about republicanism as if it were some special gift that descends on certain Deputies in this House.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon. I have not. Please be accurate.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that Deputy Haughey never made a virtue of republicanism?

Comment on this

Never.

Comment on this

Did he not stand up on a barrel in the Four Courts and talk about fellow-patriots?

Comment on this

Address fellow-patriots.

Comment on this

There will be an end some day to the cod and nonsense in the case of those Deputies who try to gain their own political advancement out of the troubles of this country.

Comment on this

I came in here to hear the Deputy. I paid him the courtesy of coming in to listen to what he has to say.

Comment on this

Then sit and listen.

Comment on this

I was sitting and listening.

Comment on this

Get up and speak.

Comment on this

There is talk about republicanism. We all have our differences but I hope that we can share one thing; each one of us, Deputy Haughey, myself——

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins has said that I have preached about republicanism. I have not.

Comment on this

Very well. I accept that and I apologise to the Deputy. May I say that there is talk about republicanism. We had it from Deputy Sherwin to day and we will probably have it from other Deputies. The implication seems to be that there is some benefit conferred if one can say: "I am a true republican." No matter what one's political affiliations may be, I think that on both sides of this House, in our own way, we all seek and strive for the betterment of our country.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

There is no particular virtue in anyone saying that he is a better republican than somebody else. If one works for Ireland, if one is concerned for Ireland, if one strikes sincerely for the betterment of the country, then, whether one is a good republican or a bad republican, one is certainly a good Irishman, and that is the important thing. I would urge those in the Fianna Fáil Party who have their own differences and troubles—Deputy Haughey, Deputy Blaney and others— I do not know whether or not Deputy Blaney is in or out of the party—not to make a fetish of republicanism because, once one does that, one is merely cheapening the possible work one can do for Ireland and Ireland at this time needs, I believe, the services of all parties and of all Deputies in this House if we are to achieve any solution to our problems.

Comment on this

This is a debate in which it is impossible to speak with any pleasure. I think we would all agree about that. I should start by congratulating Deputy Blaney on something and while I hold no brief for Deputy Blanev, I think Deputy FitzGerald and Deputy O'Higgins descended from their normal impeccable standards of Parliamentary debate by implying that Deputy Blaney was advocating war here. I do not think he was—as will be seen if his words are analysed when the Official Report comes out—nor do I think that Deputy Haughey, who as a very senior and important Member of this House waited here to listen to the debate, should promptly have been made a cockshot by Deputy O'Higgins. I think we should congratulate Deputy Blaney on one thing and that is that it would have been absolutely disgraceful on the part of the Government if this debate had not taken place. It must be recognised that we came in here to conclude the Defence Estimate and take up the Estimate for Fisheries. We owe it principally to Deputy Blaney and Deputy Sherwin, with all their faults—I am no particular ally of theirs—and to this party that this debate is taking place at all. But for them it would not be, and we would now be within some hours of concluding Fisheries, presumably. Let us at least put that on record.

Like everybody else, I feel this is no time for point-scoring or "I-told-you-so's," no time for hawkishness for the sake of hawkishness, no time—I agree with Deputy O'Higgins—for republican, holier-than-thou breast-beating. I promise the House I do not intend to indulge in that. At the same time, one must recognise the national mood at this moment and make allowance for it even if at times one thinks it is wrong. Deputy O'Higgins referred to a mood of euphoria; I do not think that is the right word. I think it is more a mood of horror and, above all else, frustration.

I was not in Derry on Wednesday; perhaps I should have been. I was one of those in the crowd outside the Embassy. I certainly was not a petrol-bomb thrower nor do I believe in petrol-bombing, either throwing petrol bombs at animate targets, which I regard as murder, or at inanimate targets, which I regard as rather pointless but, in the mood which prevailed in the city of Dublin that day, I could not find it in my heart to condemn those who threw bombs into the British Embassy. I am glad we did not apologise for that action. We had to accept the expense consequent upon it. I suppose this is a diplomatic necessity but I am sorry in a way that we did not say to the British Government that while we regret the destruction of their property, so long as they continue to send uniformed assassins to murder Irish people they must realise that by preserving an embassy in the city of Dublin they are running something of a risk. It is no more than a statement of fact to say that yesterday the temper of people was so great that it would have required more than the army of police possessed by Mayor Daly in Chicago to turn aside the sense of horror and outrage expressed by the people.

If anything sums up this debate for me and sums up yesterday's experiences it is that one word "frustration" rather than "euphoria". To me this is what the people were doing outside the British Embassy: expressing above all else the sentiment that there was nothing they could do, that they were irrelevant, that each of the parties here was, in a sense, irrelevant, that each of the parties here had failed in a sense to provide the leadership for them which they sought. They could not, even if they morally so willed, march upon the North and destroy 17,000 British soldiers and dragoon one million Protestants into the South. In effect, they could do nothing. That explains the petrol bombs, the bricks and the cheers and shouts of "More, more". Frustration explains that more than any sinister infiltration by armed groups. It was a natural, incoherent, spontaneous reaction.

Deputy FitzGerald said there must be an end to deaths. This is true but what power do we possess to end deaths? We cannot will an end to deaths by asserting in this House that we are opposed to them. I have made this point again and again and I have been accused of being sympathetic to violence by making it. Condemnations of violence in themselves do not stop violence; constructive solutions must be found. It is not sufficient for us in this House to say we are ready to help the Government to do precisely what I am not clear; that we are ready to form an all-party committee to do precisely what I am not clear either. We must recognise that to those tens of thousands who thronged the streets of Dublin yesterday we have become a largely irrelevant institution and expressions of solidarity among us— and I do not wish to rock the boat of amity as it swims around this semicircular Chamber—do very little to palliate or relieve either the grief of the people of Derry or the frustration of the people of Dublin. They serve only to remind us that perhaps the kindest thing that can be said of some of my colleagues is that the mahogany has entered into their souls.

This poses the frightful dilemma of the moderate at this time when the shots are being called literally by violent men. Does one accept this as a fact and embark on a process led by violent men with whose political, social and military principles most, indeed all of us, including myself, have nothing in common? Or, does one, on the other hand, ignore the outrage and frustration of the people and allow oneself to be washed away in the tide of history like Dillon and Redmond were in Ireland and Kerensky was in Russia? I am not saying these are the only two polarities but they are the two frightful polarities facing not merely us but also unfortunate people like Hume, Cooper, Devlin and others in the North. They have a similar problem. Do you join them or do you sit back and let them beat you?

In between there is constructive leadership, a demonstration to them of our total involvement in their problems. Where do we find this? Have we yet found it in this House? I am not sure we have. I assert again the pointlessness of simply condemning violence. When I said this before in this House in the context of the killing of an elderly man in the North I was accused of being a "Provisional" or an "Official" or something like that. Now the mood of the House has changed. Why? Basically, let us face it, because it is our lot who are getting it this time and not their lot.

Violence can always be condemned particularly when it is provocative. If evil men had shot from that crowd in Derry at the British Army I would have been the first to condemn them but in this instance no provocative violence was used. Calculated, mass-murder, naked and unashamed, was revealed on television films and in the reports of those present, not merely Irishmen and women who are suffering the violence of the British Army, but people as detached, objective and removed from this conflict as an Italian journalist with no axe to grind, whose reports are striking in their starkness and honesty. I suggest that a point which has not been made too often in this House is that we face a new and still more horrible situation because of the nakedness of the violence which took place on Sunday and because of the source from which it emanates, to wit, direct, as we can all accept it to be, and deliberate use of violence by the British military forces in that area. I shall return briefly to that point. I do not want to go into it at any greater length at this stage in case I appear to be in any way sustaining violence, which I do not.

What do we do? That is the constructive question. We take initiatives. Some of the initiatives taken by the Government have been good. It is good that we should demand direct rule. The Taoiseach is right to have sent the Minister for Foreign Affairs Deputy Hillery to New York and he is right to contemplate that Deputy Hillery should visit the EEC countries. It is also correct that the last remaining vestige of our forces in Cyprus should be withdrawn. No man of goodwill could fail to commend these exercises and hope that they worked but which, without wishing to make party political points which I am not doing, they must see in the present national atmosphere and in this crisis situation which we face to be both too little and too late. I called for the withdrawal of troops from Cyprus last August. I was not supported on this even in my own party. As far as I recall, Deputy Haughey also called for this withdrawal at that time. Done then, it might have been more effective as an international gesture rather than now.

I thought Deputy Sherwin made a very good point which I did not expect him to make and which I had down to make myself. That was when he deplored the Taoiseach's suggestion that the troops should be withdrawn from—I quote—"the predominantly Catholic areas". This is a line of argument which I find personally intensely distasteful. As far as I am concerned, the troops should be withdrawn. The public admission by our Prime Minister that there are things called predominantly Catholic areas, which should be treated in some way different from other unspoken things which presumably are predominantly Protestant areas, is not a chain of reasoning which is acceptable to me. The troops should be totally withdrawn, and not just the paratroops, and should be replaced by a United Nation peace-keeping force. I realise all the attendant difficulties of this and I cannot go into these difficulties in what remains of my half hour but I consider these exercises to be absolutely necessary.

I disagree totally with Deputy Blaney in one respect. I cannot quote him precisely, although I was listening intently to his words. He seemed to imply that this issue, this turmoil in our country was one which ultimately must be settled locally. I would put seriously to Deputies the complete opposite, that is, that the key to this whole question is on the level of international politics. The British are concerned deeply with their foreign image, but not where it affects us. It is no great secret that on the telephone on the night of the murders Mr. Heath told the Taoiseach more or less what he could do with himself with regard to the complaints about the horrific events of that day. When I say that the matter should be dealt with internationally I do not think it can be dealt with by negotiations with Britain. The time for cups of tea with British leaders, whether they be Tory or Labour, has passed. I am glad Deputy Dr. Hillery has gone to the United Nations. I would say that he should address the General Assembly and that he should do more than that. He should, with straightforward determination, demonstrate our independence of Britain—an independence which for a considerable time was demonstrated in the foreign policy of our former Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Aiken. He should reassert that independence by appearing suddenly in Moscow to proclaim that we might indeed have friends in parts of the world other than those that we would seem to have. In our home and foreign policy we have tied ourselves so closely to the British in respect of international and European affairs, with specific reference to the Common Market, that now when we find ourselves in conflict with the United Kingdom of which we have been, speaking effectively, a client State for so many years, we are at a loss to understand how to deal with the situation. I suggest that this is because we have never understood the role of British imperialism in this country. I suggest that the Minister should go to Moscow and elsewhere.

There are examples both of the effectiveness of such action and of precedents for it. As an example of the effectiveness of it one has only to think of what the Prime Minister of Malta, Mr. Mintoff, succeeded in securing from the British and the Americans by threatening them not merely with the mighty presence of the Russians but with the rather less significant presence of the Libyans. Also, there is an historical precedent for this. Almost 51 years ago, when our nation was suffering similar stresses, the bones of a treaty were laid down by our present President and Dr. McCartan on the one side and the representative of the Bolsheviks on the other, a treaty guaranteeing reciprocal assistance on the basis of Bolshevik support for the recognition of the Republic of Ireland as an independent State. Therefore, anyone who wishes to throw the accusation of Communism at me for making this suggestion had better check back on the history books and on the conduct in those days of our present President.

We should hammer at the doors of the headquarters of the European Economic Community, although I fear that this would be a fruitless exercise because we would be speaking as an insignificant nation, as a nation which has expressed so much enthusiasm for the EEC that now its detachment from Britain will not be effective. These things should be tried. Perhaps some of us do not realise how much the implications of this turmoil are being discussed around the world and to what extent they are being understood. One of my students, who is a German, was able to tell me this morning that she stayed up late to listen to German news bulletins last night in which the implications of Irish affairs were discussed. We are not utilising these measures sufficiently.

I know I may be accused of militism in what I say now. I agree with Deputy Blaney on one point. Not merely should we recall our troops from Cyprus but we should call up the reserve and put the FCA on a stand-by basis. I know that I will be told at once that the fighting strength of these forces is almost minimal. I will probably be asked: "Are you really urging that we should march on Newry? Are you suggesting that we could take on the might of the British Empire?" Of course I am not. At the same time, let me repeat the point that this battle is being fought on an international level and unless we can alert the attention not merely of the British, who are largely disinterested in our problems, but of the whole of international public opinion, we will not succeed because we are too small.

Furthermore, the situation has now been reached that before the demonstration in Newry takes place on Sunday—and I do not know whether it will—the Taoiseach should issue a solemn warning that, if Newry on Sunday produces another Derry or another Sharpeville, we will not treat this lightly, that we will regard it as the creation of a major international incident. I know this is dangerous. I know there are evil men in the illegal armies who could provoke an incident which, in turn, would bring about the doomsday situation that we all fear. If the Taoiseach is to stand over seriously his role as second guarantor of the rights of the beleaguered minority in the North, he must issue this stern warning. What faces us now is a situation none of us expected. Deputies on every side of the House fear the horrific prospect of a doomsday situation provoked by the IRA either sincerely or wilfully on their part, the hoisting of the tricolour in Newry. This is what we feared in 1970 and 1971.

We are faced now with a different situation. The history of the question "who provoked who first" is now academic. Was it the IRA or was it the British during the past two years? The excellent research carried out by The Sunday Times, of all people, would suggest it was the British Army which first changed from the role of impartial arbitrator to the role of aggressor. However, the historians can discuss that after the contemporary citizens are dead, but we are now in a situation where the British Army have not merely assumed the role of aggressor but where they may provoke a doomsday situation. This is a horrific thought and something we must consider.

It may sound strange but we know the British military mind. We know that professional soldiers, particularly of the type of commandos, marines and paratroopers, are taught and trained to kill and that no man who has acquired a skill likes to allow it become rusty but enjoys the opportunity to practise it. We saw that in Derry on Sunday last. We must accept the consequences of this. We must accept that one of the consequences of this is that the heroes in the Creggan, the Falls, Ballymurphy or Ardoyne are not us; by now they are not even the official IRA; they are the Provisionals. This is a horrific thought, a thought which leads me to the conclusion that these people, who in some cases are sincere and honest men but who in many cases are mindless exponents of fascist violence, enemies of democratic institutions both North and South, may yet some day so capture the public imagination in this island that all of us can carry our reverence for democracy into the dictating of our memoirs in the manner that Redmond and Dillon did in the early twenties of this century or that Kerensky did for 50 years in Russia. Let no one say I welcome that prospect. It is perhaps something that our own inertia here has brought about as much as anything else. I detest it but I am trying to bring home to the House that it is something we face.

I have spoken of the military mind of the British. What about the ordinary British people? These are the ones we must reach. This has been said by many people during this debate, including Deputy FitzGerald. I know the ordinary British people better perhaps than anyone else in this House. I was born in England. I was brought up amongst them for 15 years; individually they are a likeable, decent, rather humourless race; collectively they have the longest record of mindless imperialism of any country in the western world. Ireland, as far as they are concerned, is a remote, rather pleasant place of whose exact location they are not quite sure. Its troubles derive from the peculiar whimsicality of the Irish and it is in no sense the job of the English working-class man to try and penetrate what those troubles are.

However, this is changing and this is one of the few hopeful signs. That very British Press which all of us have correctly condemned for its biased reporting of the events in Ireland is slowly changing, and more important the British popular press. It is no good if we have The Sunday Times or The Guardian on our side, but today's Daily Mirror, a mass circulation newspaper, can bring out a five point plan calling for the withdrawal of British troops, a UN force, the end of internment, talks on the constitutional future of Northern Ireland and the appointment of a special Cabinet Minister to deal with the North. When you get that into a paper that is bought by virtually every man who follows horses and soccer—and these are the English we have to deal with —then you are making progress, and I hope that we in the Labour Party will contribute with our links with the unions in making progress here to make the British realise that what is happening in the North is not “our brave boys being shot down by masked murderers” which undoubtedly is the impression that they have largely been allowed to acquire over the last six months.

Let us finally be self-critical in the very few minutes remaining to me. I hope I have been reasonably constructive here, and I hope I have left no one with the impression that I in any way endorse or approve of violence. I simply perceive it as a phenomenon which is a hateful fact of life today in Ireland and which is daily winning more support. The most unpleasant thing you can say about the horror of Derry on Sunday is that it was the greatest recruiting episode in the history of the Provisional IRA.

Let us then be self-critical. What have we done to justify demanding that the Unionists come in? "British out" is an easy slogan. It sounds good chanted on a march. In some cases here today we have been as two-faced as we have been over the last 50 years. We live in a socially unjust and denominationally unitary State. The Protestants of the North have genuine fears of the constitutional and other biases we have here against them. Dr. Paisley, with whom somebody rightly said in this debate we shall have some day to deal, has expressed these fears repeatedly. Deputy Carter, in one of his lovely solecisms, said that in this House the minority was treated exactly as the majority. That is the point, they are; they are treated as if they were Catholics, expected in the main to have Catholic schools, Catholic hospitals, a Catholic Constitution, Catholic laws. What have we done about this?

Whenever we speak here of the repeal of Article 44 or the Article on divorce, or the laws on contraception and censorship then the other side of our sincerity is seen. Can we really be receptive towards Northern Protestants and still take this double-faced attitude? Much is made of the necessity for a declaration of intent by the British that they will do certain things —for example, get out of the North over a period of 15 years. How about a declaration of intent from the Taoiseach that he will set up a representative commission to remove all traces of discrimination in our laws and institutions? We talk here about an all-party committee. How about an all-party declaration of intent that we will do that? Let us open a book and see how many of the 144 Deputies here will sign to that. At least Griffith and Collins, to do them justice, faced with not a dissimilar situation, took into their closest and most intimate confidence the Protestant leaders of the day, the Glenavys, the Andrew Jamesons, before they set up the Constitution of their time, and not merely the Constitution but the whole complexion of the State.

Let us show our goodwill to the North by calling in to Dr. Buchanan and saying: "What do you think would be the correct way to run community schools?" Let us change the complexion of our State education. Let us cease to have a situation in which the hospitals are virtually in the hands, with a few exceptions, of a single group. Let us raise our social services to a level where we can look on our industrious Northern brethren and ask them to join us.

I have spoken very rapidly and intensely, not so much that I wanted to sound vehement but that I wanted to get a lot in in half an hour. In the main, my feeling would be two-fold: first, if this conflagration is to be averted, then all the issues leading up to it must be transferred to a massive campaign the like we have never seen before. We can no longer talk of civil rights simply. Many of us would wish for the situation of 1969 when civil rights were the issue, but you cannot propound the solutions of 1969, 1970 and 1971 in 1972. Even Harold Wilson has shown that the unity of our country is now on the agenda of one of the two great political parties, which it has not been since 1893.

We must face up to our obligations, and we shall not face up to them either, on the one hand, by the empty green republicanism of associating ourselves with the dead who cannot speak for themselves and claiming their virtues as our virtues, as some of us tend to do; nor, on the other hand, by asserting the historic unity of this island as if it was an absolute statement to be accepted by the Unionists on any terms. We must marry the two together and show that, while we cling to the historic determination that our island is one and indivisible, at the same time we accept that there are faults and flaws in our system, and we must make declarations of intent such as will allay the fears of the Unionists of the North, some of which are provoked artificially by British imperialism but some of which have been provoked by our own sloth and cowardice in this House.

Comment on this

There has been an appeal to the Members here to speak without emotion. Having been born in January, 1922, I am one of the first free-born generation of Irishmen. Conscious of the efforts that have been made down through the years and the lives that have been given in order to achieve freedom, many of us will have some ideas that are generally accepted but also other ideas which are broadly different. We were horrified to see this tragedy in Derry last Sunday. How different has the tragedy of Derry been from the previous tragedies in Irish history. The road to freedom and to basic human rights has been paved with the bodies of countless thousands of Irish men and women, added to by the 13 young men who died in Derry last Sunday. This road to freedom is a difficult one. We have not yet attained the ultimate freedom and nothing less than that will satisfy the great bulk of our people. We shall achieve that ultimate freedom. The methods that have been suggested are acceptable to me. I do not believe in mob-law. I believe that every effort should be made to ensure that there will be no further bloodshed, that Irishmen whether Catholic or Protestant, will not meet the end which those unfortunate people met in Derry last Sunday. This bloody massacre in Derry by the British soldiers in this never to be forgotten bloodbath will certainly inspire many people in future generations to be conscious of the efforts made by people in the past, and of the attitude of British soldiers and British politicians to Irish men and women.

These foul assassins have been applauded by the British Government and by the puppets in the North. They have been publicly applauded for their efforts in peacekeeping last Sunday. This solution was adopted by the British and put into operation 50 years ago and it now takes regiments of the British Army, regiments of paratroopers, to be pumped into the North to maintain peace. This shows clearly the failure of the settlement that was foisted upon us by Britain in the not-too-distant past.

There is nothing new in the type of brutality meted out by uniformed butchers last Sunday. It is difficult to speak with restraint on an occasion like this, particularly when one feels for the unfortunate, innocent people who were shot down in cold blood. This human suffering and human misery we witnessed in Derry yesterday is a repetition of the tragedies of the past. Deputy Sherwin said that every person up there is now a member of the IRA. The mothers and families of the young men who were brutally shot down last Sunday repudiated that and said their sons were not a party to gun fights in any shape or form. To suggest now that everyone there is a member of the IRA is to give licence to the British to shoot down innocent people at random. I hope Deputy Sherwin will correct this.

The relatives of the innocent people who were done to death last Sunday, and the people close to them, have repudiated that suggestion. The funerals yesterday were a clear indication that they took no part in gun battles and that they were not members of organ-isations. To suggest that everyone there is a member of the IRA is to give licence to the British Army to shoot again at unfortunate innocent people. There are many people there who believe in peaceful means and who believe that they have a right to make a peaceful protest in their own country, and this they have. They have a right to march in Newry next Sunday if they so desire. It is their country and our country and impostors from outside have no right to tell us when or where we can march.

We had the explanation given last Sunday by Major General "Three-Shot" Ford. After the event he indicated that his troops fired three rounds at snipers on the roofs but shot 13 unfortunate people and injured 16 others on the ground. This is the type of justification we get from British Army majors and this is the type of justification that has been given in the past. We are well aware of the type of individuals who have been sent to this country both now and in the past. We had Major "Pitchcap" Sirr, for example. Yesterday I was told in Derry that many people believe that these people who shot down in cold blood the unfortunate victims last Sunday were high on drugs at that time. It could be an explanation that these members of the British Army were high on drugs. Major Ford and Major Tugwell and thugs of this type who made erroneous statements which have been repudiated time and again since are the type of people who are sent in to do the dirty work of Health and his companions. I do not trust British politicians either in or out of office, no matter to which party they belong. In the past they have not shown any great consideration for us. I am quite certain they will not show any in the future.

We are aware of the atrocities that took place during the arrest of personnel and later on in the confines of the internment camps. We also know of the other types of individuals, the lords and the ladies, who have spoken out in the past few days. We in this country have had our quota of lords and ladies, like Lord "Cut-throat" Castlereagh who imposed the Act of Union on this country. It was said at that time that the Irish people had to pay for the very knife with which he cut his throat, just as they will have to pay for the burned out shell of the British Embassy. I hope he got a good one on that occasion. I have no regrets about any action taken by frustrated people if they take it in an orderly fashion. I can well understand the utter confusion in the minds of the people who attempted to protest in this way. I do not condone it but I can understand it.

We also remember another General, the "Butcher" Maxwell who in the not-too-distant past dug his limepits up at Arbour Hill and was fairly free with the distribution of ammunition, and the Black-and-Tans and other people who were sent here to crucify this nation over the years. Last Sunday was a repetition of this type of foul and dirty deed. On this occasion it was an unforgivable offence that unfortunate innocent children were gunned down at a range of one or two yards. The attitude of soldiers in gunning down people at a range which was indicated by priests and others whose word I accept was the attitude of a savage or a cannibal.

Those are the types of individuals who were sent here as a peacekeeping force. They are not a peacekeeping force; they are an occupation force, occupying this country and buttressing the wall of partition. I hope that the day is not too far distant when they will be gone completely from the country. We should tell Heath to get his murderers out of this country. It is our country and we do not want them. I am quite certain that in their own way the people in the North could do a far better job than the gang that was foisted upon us, the paratroopers and others.

To further indicate the attitude to these murders, Mr. Heath and his advisers have indicated that they have further plans to send in more paratroopers and to pump into this country a greater number of troops to proceed on this foul trail of destruction against innocent people. Too many people have lost their lives in this country down through the years by the assassin's bullet or in some cases at the hands of the British hangmen. The British were never any friends of ours. They are not concerned about us today.

I heard many stories yesterday. When the paratroopers entered the Bogside many people who were close to them believe that they were high on drugs. If people were playing "Mauser music" on the top of the flats, I am quite certain that a number of the paratroopers would not be around today. Heath should be told to get these people out. I am quite certain that the puppet Government in the North, bad as they are, could do a better job than the paratroopers and possibly do it in a more humane way.

I do not condone mob law. The institutions of this State should be upheld and we should do everything to ensure that they are upheld. The word has gone out and should go out from each and every politician here that we stand behind the lawfully elected Government, that we will ensure that the people will have the freedom and the protection necessary, that we will not tolerate other forces taking the law into their own hands, that we will suppress them in every way possible, and that we will do the job we were sent here to do in an effective way.

The brutality of last Sunday has meant that the true story of the occupation of this country has penetrated deep into the hearts of many people. Many men served this nation honourably in arms, Old IRA men and others, and played their part effectively down through the years to get for me and for many others the freedom we have today. We want to see the young men of Derry and Belfast and the young men of the occupied counties enjoying the same freedom as we have. They are entitled to that freedom. I want to say to the Taoiseach that I hope this Government will go forward now knowing that we are united here, except for one or two Members of the House. Unity of purpose is what we require. We must show the country, Britain and the world that we are united in this matter.

I was glad to hear some of the speeches from the Fine Gael and Labour Members today endorsing the actions of the Government and the speech of Dr. Hillery. His appearance on television cleared the way for many people who had doubts whether the action taken was decisive enough. We are well aware that decisive action will be taken in order to ensure so far as we can that we will work towards the unity of this nation. I hope this House will be completely united in their thinking. I hope some of the erroneous statements that have been made by some of the speakers will be erased from the record and that they will be repudiated so that no unfortunate innocent people will be the victims of further gunfire because they have been branded in the way they have been here today.

We require a strong and united effort because divided we are weak. We must show on this occasion that we are strong, that we are united and that we will follow the policy laid down here today. If this policy does not succeed then we must sit down and think out another one. This policy must be given a fair trial in order to ensure that the people in the six occupied counties will have the same freedom that we have. There may be some defects in the set-up here, as Deputy Thornley stated. I do not agree that contraceptives will entice people into this part of the country. I believe it is an insult to indicate that this is one of the factors. There are many other major factors but that is not one of them.

From this House a call should go to Irishmen serving in the British Army to throw off their uniforms and so show that they are not a party to this brutal murder which took place and that they will not endorse those tactics on fellow Irishmen. If there are people in the British Army who are prepared to do this and to protest against this type of brutality we should find a place for them here. We should ensure that they will be at no financial loss even if it means absorbing them into our own force here. There is a recruitment campaign going on at the moment and I am quite sure if men are honourable enough to throw off their British uniforms and say that they do not endorse the butchery which took place in Derry last Sunday then we must ensure that we will find a place for them in our Army here, that they will be at no financial loss and that their service will be properly compensated.

I would appeal to the House to be completely united in our approach to show the world at large that we are united in relation to this matter, that we will ensure if a tragedy such as Derry takes place again we will have to rethink the situation and think out another means of dealing with a desperate situation such as that we witnessed last Sunday.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I say in relation to what Deputy Dowling said, so that he will not go home tonight believing what he said was what I said, that in speaking to people from the Creggan they informed me that their menfolk were members of the IRA. It was not I who said it. It was the people from the Creggan.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This emergency debate is being held here today because 13 unarmed civilians were indiscriminately shot by members of the British forces in Derry city last Sunday while holding a protest meeting to protest against internment without trial in Northern Ireland. The slaughter of those 13 men has shocked the people of this country. Indeed, it has shocked the people of the world. The publicity which it has received over the world and the world reaction to it demonstrates forcibly the enormity of what happened.

One can understand the feeling of Deputy Dowling but I do not think that his contribution to this debate or the manner in which he delivered it can be calculated to bring the troubles in Ireland to an end, particularly when it came from a Member of the Government party. I want to say that in my opinion responsibility for the present state of affairs in Northern Ireland and the terrible happenings on last Sunday must rest fairly and squarely on the shoulders of the British Government and the British people because the British Government represent them. I say that because the evil of Partition was created by the British Government over 50 years ago and having created that evil they tolerated a system of Government in Northern Ireland for the last 50 years under which discrimination against the minority there was tolerated, under which the minority there were treated as second-class citizens.

It was inevitable that the Nationalist people of Northern Ireland would sooner or later rise up and refuse to continue to be treated as they have been treated. They did that in 1968 in a peaceful way through the Civil Rights Movement with John Hume, Ivan Cooper and the others. The violence in the North was not started in 1968 or 1969 by the minority. It was the people who had oppressed them for over 50 years who started the violence. One would have thought at that time that the British Government would have come in and seen the folly of their ways, have seen the evil of their own creation and that they would have brought about effective reforms at once which would have for the time being and as a temporary measure enabled the people residing in the Six County area to live in comparative harmony.

The British Army were invited in there because certain sections of the minority were in real danger of being annihilated and the British Army were welcomed when they came because, as I said, they were supposed to come to protect the minority who were living in real danger. I regret to have to say, and I think no reasonable person can contradict me, that when the British Government sent in their army, as a peace-keeping force supposedly, they bungled their way from one mistake to another. In the short time they have been there it cannot be denied that the British Army have rendered themselves totally unacceptable to the minority in Northern Ireland whom they came there to protect and that as from last Sunday never again will the British Army be acceptable in Northern Ireland, never again will there be any confidence in them. On the contrary, there will be hatred for them, and they have only themselves to blame.

The first major blunder that was made was internment without trial. I believe internment without trial was introduced as a package deal. It was introduced in order that the Apprentice Boys' march in Derry might be suppressed and with internment came allegations of brutality against the British forces and the police in Northern Ireland who enforced internment. I have heard people denounce the Compton Report as not being impartial. As far as I am concerned the British Forces stand condemned on the findings of that report and I do not mind whether the findings are related in terms of excessive force or excessive brutality. I do not mind what one calls it, but I believe the findings of the report, of men being made to stand against walls, of being subjected to excessive noise, amounts to brutality. I was shocked to look at a television programme in which responsible people in Britain seemed to stand over the findings of the Compton Report and to say that what was done was necessary.

The next stupid thing that was done —it was referred to by the Taoiseach —was the cratering of Border roads. That was a senseless operation calculated to do no good but every harm. It was a senseless operation that could not possibly prevent people passing from North to South. My native parish was divided by the cratering of roads: the road from one part of my parish to another was cratered. That started up a lot of anxiety on both sides of the Border. It was another example of British Government bungling. It is no use blaming the British Army. They are a body of paid men operating under the British Government and it is that Government which must take responsibility for these things. Many of the people in the British Army are young fellows earning their money in that way and following orders.

Finally, there was the catastrophe of Sunday last. I believe extreme force was used last Sunday as part and parcel of another deal. That package deal was that in the predominantly Catholic city of Derry there was to be this march and there were to be speeches against internment. Then militant Unionists decided they would have a march and that there would be a confrontation, and the Unionist march was held off by an undertaking that such force as was necessary would be used to put down the other demonstration. One might say that that force was used with a vengeance.

They are three examples of the complete mishandling of the Northern Ireland situation by the British Tory Government. I might be asked what solutions I have. Of course, the long term one is the reunification of the country. That will come, in my opinion, quicker than most of us think, notwithstanding recent happenings. I believe our entry to Europe will speed that up because once the economic border goes, as it will, the political border will be meaningless and will disappear. However, until that happy day comes about, when the country is united by the general consent of the people of the country, steps will have to be taken to create a state of affairs in which all the people of the North can live without fear of intimidation and in comparative harmony.

I believe the first thing that must be done is to withdraw the British forces. I have given the reasons why that must be done. The British forces have lost all respect and I am surely making an understatement when I say that. It is too much to expect that they could be accepted by any of the minority in the North. I do not say for a moment that the British forces can be withdrawn leaving the people of Northern Ireland to work out their own salvation because if that were done I believe there would be prolonged civil war in which this part of the country would be involved, but a case can be made for bringing in a United Nations peace-keeping force and I think that if a case were made properly to the UN they would send in such a force. I appreciate that an argument could be put up that the UN will not interfere in the domestic affairs of a country and that England is putting up that case within the UN. Northern Ireland never was a part of Great Britain, is not now a part of Great Britain and never will be.

An argument can be put forward that a peculiar and exceptional set of conditions exists here, in the sense that the Six Counties are not really a part of the United Kingdom, that there has been this resentment of 40 per cent of the people of that area at being treated as part of the United Kingdom, that none of the people of Ireland ever agreed by their votes to the establishment of the Six County area. Therefore I believe that immediately the British Army should be withdrawn and should be replaced by a United Nations peace-keeping force. Circumstances have changed since that proposal was made before, have changed substantially and in such a way as to make an unanswerable argument for bringing them in now. I believe, too, that the government of Northern Ireland should be shared on equitable terms between the majority and the minority there. Indeed, I believe that even the Northern Ireland Government, if one may call them such, accept that. The Prime Minister there is on record as having said not so very long ago that a Government in power for 50 years is bound to create problems. He is also on record as making statements which would suggest to me that he concedes that government and power in Northern Ireland must be shared and shared immediately.

Therefore my proposals are that a United Nations force should be brought in, and we should not accept that a case cannot be made for bringing them in, and that power should be shared and shared immediately. I also believe that the British Government should interfere immediately to have reforms on the question of housing and to put these reforms into operation; to have reforms on the question of jobs and employment and see that they are put into force immediately. We are living here and we are very concerned for the minority in Northern Ireland. We are very concerned to see that all the people in Northern Ireland should be able to live together. That was demonstrated this week by the spontaneous reaction of the people of Ireland to the happenings of Sunday last, the demonstrations we have had during the week, and I am very pleased to be able to say that in my own town of Cavan, there was a very gratifying demonstration from all sides and all creeds and all classes. There was a Requiem Mass in the Cathedral at 11 o'clock and there was a Service for peace in our country in the Church of Ireland church at 11.30. This is as it should be; this is the sort of relations we have between the different communities in this part of the country, and long may it remain.

As spokesman for the Fine Gael Party on Justice, I would be failing in my duty if I did not refer to one major incident and some smaller incidents in this city of Dublin which marred the generally peaceful protests which were conducted yesterday. I refer to the burning of the British Embassy, and I do not care whether it was the British Embassy or whether it was a factory, whether it was a private house or any other building that was burned. I say that I was absolutely appalled to see on the television screen that private individuals were acting as prosecutors, judge, jury and executioners, in complete and absolute defiance of the law. The Embassy was burned to the ground, but that is not the only case. We know that windows were broken in other houses and that people were threatened and we have to ask ourselves at this stage: Is democracy to prevail here? Is this country to be ruled from the streets of Dublin by people who represent nobody, people who have not gone through the ballot boxes and obtained authority to rule? It would be a sorry state of affairs if the Government of this country were to renounce and renege their rights in favour of mob law.

I do not accuse the Garda Síochána for standing by yesterday and the day before. As a matter of fact, they have my sympathy. They were left there without any protection, in the pouring rain, for 48 hours. There was nothing they could do, but I think that what happened—I have not spoken in a political fashion—and what we saw happening on the screens yesterday and the day before is the inevitable result of a drift in the Government of this country over the last two or three years. We have a weak Government, presided over by a weak Taoiseach. During the first few years of his office, he allowed things to drift within his own party and within the Cabinet, with the result we all know. He has been allowing things to drift within the country. I know that the position and the happenings in Northern Ireland have created a delicate situation, but delicate situation or no delicate situation, the events of the other day should have been anticipated. I know that the happenings in Northern Ireland and the injustices which have been perpetrated on the minority there make it difficult—more difficult than in normal circumstances—for the Government here to rule, but I say that the Government have to decide as of now, at this point in time, whether they are going to rule, whether they are going to rule this country pursuant to the mandate they received from the people on 18th June, 1969, or whether they are not.

I do not believe that the burning of the British Embassy or violence of that sort in this city is doing any good to our kith and kin in Northern Ireland. I believe, on the contrary, that it is doing a lot of harm. I believe that the burning of the British Embassy took the heat off the British Army in so far as public opinion was concerned in Northern Ireland. I looked at the BBC television news yesterday evening. First of all, we had the burning of the Embassy given a very considerable period of time. It was highlighted. The fact that the security forces stood by was flogged to death. And then came the funerals in Derry. If the foolish people who burned the Embassy had not done that the British public on their television screens would have got the funerals in Derry. As food for thought they would have had the 13 people who were done to death but instead of that their attention was distracted from the killings of last Sunday and the burials yesterday by the people who, even if they were well-intentioned, thought fit to burn the Embassy and distract British public opinion from the cause of the whole thing.

We have been talking about spending money here for the relief of the people of Northern Ireland. I believe that we have not yet got across to the British public or to the European public the causes of the troubles in Northern Ireland, the injustices that were there. I for one will stand over the spending of very considerable amounts of money on propaganda, on bringing before the people of England, the people of Europe and the people of the world, the injustices that have been inflicted on the minority in the North and which have brought about the calamities about which we have been speaking in this debate.

I wish to conclude by repeating that my solution is the withdrawal of British forces, their replacement by a United Nations force, the sharing of Government in Northern Ireland on an equitable basis between Protestants and Catholics and the immediate implementation of reforms there. I again appeal to the people in this part of the country, to this small minority who have no mandate, to refrain from these acts of violence here because they will do no good to the cause of the re-unification of this country; they will do no good to the minority in the North but, on the contrary, they will take the heat off Northern Ireland and will project us as a people who are not governed here, who are living in an unsettled society, people who, as the British love to say and used to say, are not fit to govern ourselves.

Comment on this

Coming in at this stage there is no need for me to dwell on the demonstration of unity yesterday, the demonstration of the feeling of grief and of outrage through a very large part of the country. There is one aspect I should like to mention, the fact that under trade union auspices —I am particularly proud of that—in Belfast, Catholics and Presbyterians prayed together, with each other, and not at each other as is so frequently the case.

The sense of shock and outrage has been amply described by speakers from all parties but we could usefully pause a little to look at the situation that is unfolding as a result of what happened on Sunday in Derry. We must ask ourselves whether it was a bunch of berserk soldiers getting out of hand or an act of deliberate policy. It is not possible at this time to be certain but I think the balance of evidence indicates that it was an act of deliberate policy, whether it emanated from a decision of Mr. Heath's or not. We cannot know whether he actually decided to let off a whiff of grapeshot, that to shoot down some of the natives was the way to carry out his policy, but the deaths of those 13 people at the hands of his paratroopers I think is an extension of British policy as expressed by Heath, the British Prime Minister.

One expects, if one has the sort of outlook about the British Army that I have, senior officers to lie about what happens. That is not new, it is not shocking. They have been lying solidly, in my view, since the British reinforcements went into Northern Ireland in August, 1969. But then they have been lying pretty solidly about what they were doing all over the remnants of the British colonial empire since the end of the second world war. It is not surprising or shocking, it is in character. It is a little more shocking to see the front page of Monday's Daily Telegraph where the situation, contrary to what journalists had to say, was presented as a confrontation between the IRA and the army, a battle with shots fired by both sides, started by the IRA. But again one expects the organs of British imperialism, if one has my outlook, not to tell lies every day, only to tell lies like that at moments of crisis, at moments of difficulty. One expects them to be completely loyal voices of the British Government at moments like that and the Daily Telegraph and some other British newspapers were that on Monday.

One expects commissions, not just in Britain but in Ireland and in other countries, particularly judicial commissions, to peddle whatever version of the truth their Government want. The mechanism of selection of judges in many countries is such that one does not expect them to take a position hostile to their Government. They would not have got there if they were the sort of people who could take that position anyway. You cannot try the devil if the court sits in hell so nothing that any British commission will say will carry any validity with any people anywhere in the world except for British home consumption where it will be very valuable.

All this indicates a tactic. The British Prime Minister has shown himself to be a 19th century Tory in many ways since he came to power in his economic policy, in his willingness to see, quite ruthlessly, quite calmly, a million people out of work and I think he has decided that it is possible to get back to the status quo as it was before 1968 when the civil rights campaign started and the way to do this is the same technique which consolidated the statelet in the early 1920s, which is to kill some hundreds of people and then the rest of them are frightened and they acquiesce for a while, maybe for ten or 20 years. If they start to raise their heads again kill a few more of them. This is not new. Hundreds of people were killed in the 'twenties, we were preoccupied and we have forgotten it, and not so many were killed in the 'thirties. I think that Heath and the Ministers around him, the 19th century Tories—I would not even blame that attitude on contemporary Toryism which has evolved a little—but, the Selsdon men feel that if you kill a few hundred the rest will be frightened and you can go back to the status quo and that you need not reform Stormont and you need not bring in any of these inadequate and tiny little reforms that started getting under way at the end of 1969. That is where we are at with Heath's policy. That is what is revealed.

Wednesday, indeed, Monday and Tuesday, but Wednesday particularly, in this part of the country, I thought was very revealing but I feel that, perhaps, I am reading the situation differently from any other people in the House because what came over to me talking to people, listening to people, going about, was the sense of impotence down here, the sense that we could do nothing, the sense of fury that we were powerless to do anything serious, apart from uttering angry words, to help or to defend the people of Derry. That was very widespread through the country. The burning of the British Embassy and the looting of some shops in Dublin and the rest of it is not an indication of strength but an indication of profound weakness and hopelessness.

Deputy Blaney used a phrase where he said people were searching for some manner of ventilating their frustration that had been building up for two years. Yes, they were but I think that Mr. Heath when he sees the sacking of the British Embassy in Dublin will laugh all the way to his yacht. I do not think it moves him a little bit. I think it does indicate to him that we will use lighting conductors for our emotions, that we will go through the forms of protest, even to burning a building and looting some shops, but that having done that we feel we have made our protest and can go back to the situation as it is. I think that it is an action of despair, an action of weakness.

The tragedy about despair and weakness is that then you get the glamour of the reality which says: "There is a gun. At least that is real". That is the equaliser, in the language of the detective stories. So, you take a gun in your hands and you feel strong and you feel big and you kill somebody and the only person you kill is either somebody like yourself in income and outlook, of a different religion, in your own country, or else he is a poor, half-educated, ignorant, unemployed young man, often a decent, lost young man, from another neighbouring country. That is who actually gets killed and, again, I think Mr. Heath is laughing all the way to his yacht because that solves nothing at all.

I think that often the people are ahead of the politicians in their understanding of a real situation. Perhaps, we understand the situation, too, and we do not dare to say it. There has been great posturing and threatening in this House and elsewhere in the recent past which to me is pretty hollow, pretty unconvincing. I do not think that within the present framework of policies that we possess, there is very much we can do because I think the British have the most ferocious leverage over us, that we have permitted them to have over the last half century. For example, our official external balances are held in London in sterling and the private balances, vastly greater—the total together of public and private is getting to the order of £1,000,000.000— are in Britain, in sterling, capable of being sequestered, of various things being done to them. That is a most enormous leverage that we have chosen to leave in British hands for the past half century. A great deal of the ownership of our industry, on which the jobs of the ordinary people of Ireland depend, is in British hands. Our banks are very largely British. Two-thirds of all our export trade is with Britain. So that the industries here that are not actually owned by the British are depending on British trade. We have left all these different national hands in the mouth of the British dog all these years. We have taken away these freedoms from ourselves. We have failed to establish these freedoms. So, indeed, we are very weak and the joke to me is this: I think the realist is the Taoiseach. I think that he has been taking what one might call a low profile over the last year or so, realistically. That has been the profile he could take.

I do not like being sharp about somebody in his absence so I am sorry that Deputy Blaney is not here but to me, today, the most ridiculous and most unreal speech was the speech of Deputy Blaney, well delivered, full of sincere passion but coming from a man who had been the organisational mainstay of a party that with two little breaks have been in power all my life and the party which had never asserted the economic or financial or commercial independence that would give us the right to take an independent posture, his position is a profoundly weak one. The weakness of it was indicated by the two things— when you boil it down—that his speech contained. I admire the passion and the rhetoric but when you boil it down he said two things: first, mobilise the Army and the Local Defence Force and send the Army to the Border. If you do that, you enter the possibility of having a war. That is the reality. If you want to put the Army on the border, then the reality is that there may be a war with Britain. We leave aside for the moment the question of who would win where the Irish and British armies met up with each other. We might have an opinion about who would win. That is to leave aside the question of what would happen to the Catholics in the ghettos of Belfast and other cities. O.K., you might just blow the bridge at Derry and capture Derry; with luck, you might get Newry at the same time, but there is not any realistic hope of getting anywhere near Belfast.

Deputy Blaney was eloquent about the number of arms there were in Unionist hands through gun clubs and other bogus methods of arming people and the number of heavy machine guns up there. Does he not know that he is delivering the Catholic population of the ghettos of Belfast and other cities into the hands of these people? If you want the Irish Army to fight the British Army at the Border, that is the formula for civil war.

Comment on this

Deputy Blaney did not say anything about crossing the Border.

Comment on this

Indeed, he did not. To be fair to him, of course he did not. But, there is no point in posturing unless you are prepared to follow the posture with reality. There is no point in putting the Army at the Border unless the sequel is that if you get an event like the mortaring of a house inside the Republic or an event like the events in Derry last Sunday, you are prepared to use the Army. If you are not prepared for the reality of confrontation, then you should not take the steps that lead to that confrontation.

Comment on this

What did you think of his suggestion of contacting the EEC?

Comment on this

We will come to those points in due course. The full weakness was then revealed by the suggestion that the other important thing to do was to burn the medals and to give up the titles. I despise titles of any description, in common with Bernard Shaw. I think they are rather silly. People merit respect through what they are and they have personal names and family names. That seems enough to me. I do not admire titles but I do not think it is a significant contribution on a dramatic day in an important speech on a profound problem to suggest that they should send the medals to him and that he will burn them, and that they should give up the titles. That is a measure, in fact, of the irrelevance and of the extent to which Deputy Blaney is a prisoner of the same problem.

The Taoiseach is a dove; Deputy Blaney is a hawk today, both of them from an equally impossible position, a position of weakness, because we do not have the economic independence that would give us the power to take significant action against Britain. We are in pawn to Britain in the ways I have mentioned and which I will not elaborate. Obviously, it would be easy to spend a lot of time elaborating.

On the question of the EEC, again one sees the anomaly of the position of the Minister for Labour. He could not say he is against it. Presumably he is not against it. Yet, joining the EEC will abolish any sort of sovereignty we possess at this moment. Any opposition to Britain in EEC circumstances is utterly impossible. There is a great deal of empty rhetoric.

Comment on this

The Deputy was talking about the impossibility of economic independence.

Comment on this

Yes, and I intend to return to it.

Comment on this

In the wider context of the EEC, could the Deputy not find something useful?

Comment on this

There will certainly not be any independence.

Comment on this

The EEC abolishes any possibility of it. What political independence we have now will be gone.

Comment on this

The Deputy referred to our complete dependence on Britain at the moment.

Comment on this

We do not have to have that and we should not have it after the 50 odd years of so-called independence. The question arises then as to whom our opponents are. I remember the Taoiseach saying this was a matter between the Irish and the Irish would settle it between themselves. I think the Taoiseach still adheres to that view. Certainly I do. We may mean slightly different things when we talk about imperialism.

I was pleased by the human, decent and civilised reference made by the Taoiseach today, at a time of great emotion, to the Orange, or the Protestant, or the Unionist groups—many different names for overlapping sections of this island. It took some political courage to do what he did and I welcome it. I would, however, make an addendum. Deputy Fitzpatrick said he thought Mr. Faulkner was willing to let the Catholics into government. Mr. Faulkner has said repeatedly that he will let in only those people who promise they will not try to change the constitution. The great impetus which is still giving a certain vitality to Orangeism is precisely the same impetus which achieved in the glorious revolution in England the greatest change in the constitution that Britain has ever known or, indeed, that the world has ever known, the overthrow of feudalism and the establishment of bourgeois monarchy. The heroes were the Orangemen who gave their lives then to change the constitution and they might now usefully look at their own past for valuable and real lessons. The enemy is not the British people. It is not the people of Northern Ireland— above all, not the working people— whatever their religious or political conception. We have some political independence, but the division of Ireland was designed the better to rule both parts from Britain in the name of British imperialism. This is the enemy. This is where one directs one's opposition. One does not have to degrade oneself by hating any person. Those who do that are desperately in need of pity. The British officers telling these thin lies are, in fact, pathetic and miserable people. We have a need to hate oppression and institutions and a need to be charitable towards persons in all circumstances.

Is there anything that we can do? We have heard a list of things from these benches. We have read the five points in today's Daily Mirror. Wholly admirable. No problem. But will it happen? Can we make it happen? Is there anything we can do to bring about the situation? I believe that the something real we can do is to structure the sustaining of civil disobedience. We must not be frightened off because certain people will use it to engender a different type of violence. For example, the people of Dublin were not deterred from demonstrating yesterday because certain people smashed a few windows. Valid protest must not be put off because a few undesirables abuse the protest.

We should use the resources of the State to sustain and help the civil disobedience campaign designed to make Stormont unworkable. At this moment, more than ever, we have to put out the hand of friendship and trust and, dare one use the word, love towards ordinary Unionists in Northern Ireland who hate us and despise us and who believe that we have nothing to give them except forcing them into a state in which the rule of the church, which they reject and fear, will prevail. There are two ways we can do this. One is by the constitutional changes mentioned by many speakers. Deputy Dowling in this regard said that contraception was not important. It may not be important to him. It is not important to a great many people, but it is important to others. We know it is important to many of the people with whom we want to talk. It is their belief in its importance that makes it a real issue and not our personal assessment. That applies also to divorce and to Article 44 and a great many other things. Because certain people believe these things are important they are important. I hope I have time to deliver myself of something that is to some extent a new thought.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has five minutes.

Comment on this

It may not be worthy of consideration, but I think it is. One of the reasons for the desperate sharpness of the situation in the North is the chronic unemployment, a situation which has been made worse by the actions of Mr. Heath. Industries based on the British economy fold up and people lose their employment. We have a policy of spending money on Irish firms. We have always understood that these firms were Twenty-six County firms. I think we could usefully put the revenues of this State towards increasing the level of employment and the economic viability of undertakings in Northern Ireland. It could be argued that many of these are British companies. So are the companies down here. There is precious little to choose from. We should at this moment be putting out the hand of friendship in the most practicable way to the workers in the North, using our resources and the economic power of the State, slender as it is, to protect and expand employment in Northern Ireland. This would be a gesture of goodwill of the most concrete kind. It is a gesture that is possible and it is more necessary now than it ever was. We spend hundreds of millions every year. If we want ships built, then go to Cork by all means first but, if Cork cannot cope, then go to Belfast; the people there are our people.

We make claims of sovereignty in regard to them which, personally, I think are ill-judged because I do not think it helps unity, but that will be debated another day. Those claims bring responsibility to help economically and this is a time of desperate need for that sort of help, gestures of friendship, of trust, of love. At the same time—and this is very difficult— we can use our economic power if we will it, to coerce Britain a little. In my view we can use it by systematically taking into public ownership British assets in Ireland. I am perfectly well aware of the threat of disruption of the jobs of Irish workers in doing that but nonetheless it is possible and from the taken-over British assets we could build a national development corporation like IRI in Italy. We would get the nucleus of a publicly-owned sector of the economy. I think Britain would heed that. I do not think she will heed burning Embassies or the three party Leaders going to Mr. Heath. I do not think Mr. Heath is amenable to that sort of reasoning but I think British business is amenable to coercion—and I use the word explicitly—by the planned taking into public ownership of British assets in Ireland in such a way that jobs will not be lost here.

If we go on and use our political sovereignty to get real sovereignty by taking over sections of the economy, and the sort of economic sovereignty I have indicated, we would have some power to improve our social services. We would have some power to help the Northern economy. We have always had power to change our Constitution so as to make it acceptable. We could therefore extend a hand of friendship, which is important, and we could therefore put real pressure on the British Government which we are not doing now. In that way we might conceivably build some unity here. At least we are united in wanting that. Having established political sovereignty, which we did nearly 50 years ago, we can go on from there to establish economic sovereignty with a considerable content of socialism. We need a strong public sector. We can either do that which would give us the power, the muscle and the genuine independence to take action vis-á-vis Britain that will influence the North, or else we can go back to an EEC, a common market and, indeed, to an old UK position in which we were originally part of the United Kingdom and we shall get into a bigger economic United Kingdom in which we shall have no power to influence anybody.

The dignified and impressive thing would be to stop whining, stop blustering, which does not impress anybody, and accept that we have no option but to be a tiny, non-sovereign, nonindependent cog in a much larger machine. It might conceivably make us better off economically and it would mean that we squarely face the abandonment of dearly held aspirations towards unity and sovereignty which lie at the root of the conflict in the North at the moment.

Comment on this

Tá sé deacair ar ócáid den saghas seo aon rud nua a rá nó aon rud a rá nach bhfuil ráite agus athráite míle uair b'fhéidir. Ag an am gcéanna, tá sé feiliúnach go mbeadh focal amháin Gaeilge ar a laghadh le cloisint sa dhíospóireacht seo. Luadh gur dochar a dhéanfadh sé. Táim cinnte go raibh dul amú ar an Teachta FitzGerald agus tá súil agam go gcuirfidh sé in iúl dúinn amach anseo nach é sin a bhí i gceist aige. Admhaím go mb'fhéidir go bhféadfaimis feabhas a chur ar an bpolasaí a bhí againn maidir le foghlaim na Gaeilge.

It is difficult on occasions like this to marshal and express one's thoughts so that they may be useful and it is very difficult to make them appear original. It is difficult to say anything that has not been said already in connection with the agonising and tragic farce that masquerades in an area of our country as democracy. However, I avail of the opportunity to re-state the position as I see it.

It is fundamental to any discussion of this matter that nobody here can accept—certainly I do not—that the terms and regulations which govern the freedom of any Irishman in this country should be found in the statute book of an alien power. That is fundamental in this discussion and bears repetition. When we discuss how the Army might have behaved better in this way or that way, the mistakes that have been made in the recent past, and the possibilities in regard to how the farce should be continued, we should be very careful not to depart from the fundamental principle that is shared by this country and every other country, that no power, however mighty, has the right, no matter what they claim, to decide where the destiny of any man born in another country lies. The sooner that the English Government—and here I distinguish between the English Government and the English people—recognise the fact that this is the problem here, the better. No solution, military or political, can be attained here so long as they hold that they have any right here. I am prepared to accept that we accord them certain tolerance until such time as the sins they have committed have been repented but what is fundamental here is that which is accepted as being fundamental by the British people. At mention of this question we are taken back invariably along the road of history and we are told how the problem came about. While that may be factual I am not bound to accept it.

I often wonder what the reaction of the British Government and people would be today if any of those groups of people, such as Germans, Scandinavians and French, who were planted in England in the past, set themselves up in different parts of England attempting to make the case that, notwithstanding that they and their forebears have lived for many years in England, they were entitled to reject English authority over them, if they attempted to establish that the terms and the conditions which govern their freedom were to be found in the statute books of France, Germany or any other country. I do not think the British people, in their sense of justice, could accept that what they would not tolerate at home from these other people is something which we here should tolerate from the erstwhile English or Scottish. As other speakers have said, it is easy to be critical of the situation but not easy to offer a solution. No human problems are amenable to easy solutions. I am prepared to accept as Irishmen and women those people who came to reside on our island but I will not accept those who, while wishing to claim any advantages there might be and claiming that they are Irishmen and women, criticise the shortcomings which, in their opinion, exist in this part of the country but who will not allow others the right to be critical of them. As I see it, much more of the blame and of the guilt lies with them than with us.

While I do not consider contraception to be a major issue I would endorse what Deputy Dowling said in this regard. If I could go from this House tonight in the knowledge that there was nothing between me and Irish unification except the matter of contraception, I would be very happy.

Comment on this

Has anybody suggested that?

Comment on this

Deputy FitzGerald has.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has pointed out repeatedly that each Deputy has only a limited time on which to speak.

Comment on this

It is a pity there was no contraception before Deputy FitzGerald was born.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

There were insults hurled here tonight at people who were not here to defend themselves. Deputy FitzGerald should apologise.

Comment on this

For what?

Comment on this

Deputy FitzGerald, the golliwog of the Fine Gael Party, should apologise to Mr. Gerry Jones and to the Belgian Consul.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Foley must not interrupt. Deputy Tunney's time is being taken from him.

Comment on this

Where there are two opposing sides and where the question is of finding a balance, it is naïve of people to make the case that what is happening in the North, the tyranny, the butchery and the misgovernment in that part of the country, is justified because the only impediment to a united Ireland, so far as Church of Ireland people are concerned, is that we state in our Constitution that contraceptives may not be imported and advertised publicly.

Comment on this

That is not in the Constitution.

Comment on this

We do not say they may not be used. To balance that impediment, if impediment it is, against everything which the minority in the North are suffering, is one of the weakest attempts at justifying what is happening there.

Comment on this

Who made that suggestion?

Comment on this