Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 3: General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–181 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
There are three further matters that I wish to speak on concerning the financial statement. I expect to conclude by 4.45 p.m. Those three matters are taxation on imported books; the financial needs of blind persons in the Republic; the housing needs and Government policy with particular reference to speculation.
I have received a number of representations in regard to taxation on imported books. I am sure many other Deputies have received similar representations. There is an anomaly in the current position. We submit to the Government that it is unfair in the case of many books that there should be an import duty on them. For example, author's copies that are presented free of charge to persons in this country are subject to tax. In our submission these at least could be exempt from the tax imposed on their arrival in this country. We submit that there should be no tax in the case of review copies sent here, especially when they are published in Britain.
The practice is growing of the free exchange of books of a technical and academic nature. The tax on such books represents a heavy liability on universities, research institutions, learned societies. We submit that there should not be a tax in the case of the free exchange of printed literature.
It has been put to the Labour Party that it is ludicrous that when valuable literature, particularly where it has antiquarian interest, is purchased abroad from booksellers it should be subject to tax when it is brought into this country. We consider that it is wrong to impose tax in such circumstances.
We would ask the Minister to have a further review of this matter. The liability to tax in such cases as I have mentioned represents a heavy burden on students, research workers, teachers, universities and research organisations. For example, a constituent of mine, who is a sixth form teacher, told me that a continental friend had sent him three very small books, one of prose and two of poems, in French. In order to receive them he had to pay 22p in collection charges. The books in question are not normally sold in this country. They did not even have a price mark; they were merely, in the case of the poems, two poems in French. This is a rather antediluvian type of tax on knowledge. The law in this respect should be amended. Also, in regard to the decision of the Government to introduce a value-added tax, I submit that a zero rate of levy should be imposed on such literature as I have mentioned. This would remove the anomaly which exists at present. I would ask the Minister to comment on this matter.
Now I come to the second point— the need for more extensive and more effective budgetary relief for blind persons. Successive Governments have been all too complacent, all too smug and have been stingy in regard to the provision of financial and other help for blind persons to enable them to have a fuller and more effective life. The budget is an obvious means of making suitable provision. At least there is now a recognition of the position of blind persons in that an extra £100 personal allowance has been given to blind persons under the income tax code and there is another £100 concession for their wives. In my view that does not go far enough. The cost of living for a blind person is much higher than in the case of a person with eyesight and, indeed, in the case of persons suffering from other types of handicap. It is now generally accepted in Northern Ireland, in Britain and on the Continent, that a greater range of general benefits should be provided for blind persons over and above the handicap allowance. In this country there is a blind pension. Whoever devised that type of allowance did not show humanity or sensitivity. There should not be a pension for being blind. A blind person should get a handicap allowance. Further provision should be made having regard to the peculiar expenses incurred in the case of blind persons.
The public assume that a blind person is automatically in receipt of a blind pension. It may come as a surprise to people that there is a means test in relation to the blind pension. It is not granted automatically. I was shocked to find out that in the past three years 26 blind people have been disallowed the blind pension. The irony is that it has cost £12,000 to adjudicate the means test in relation to the blind pension. In the past three years we have spent approximately £30,000 to administer the means scheme with the result that 26 people have been disallowed. This is a ridiculous situation and we should do something to change it.
I do not think members of the public appreciate that blind people will receive the magnificent amount of £5.50 per week. I know blind people in my constituency who will have to live on 74p per day as from next August. The current level of pensions, particularly for blind people, is utterly inadequate. Blind people face special problems. Their expenditure on shoe leather is considerably more than that of other citizens; because of their disability they may brush against wet paint, they may sit on dirty seats, and in consequence their clothes must be cleaned frequently. Blind people may be obliged to have special electrical equipment installed in their houses and frequently the cost of repairs in their houses is more expensive. We should bear in mind the extra expenditure the blind must bear each week, not the least of which is the additional cost facing a blind housewife who, inevitably, has a restricted choice when she shops.
I submit that concessions other than the £100 tax concession should have been given to the blind people. The blind must pay for many services which other members of the community can do for themselves; they must pay for house repairs and for gardening costs. Frequently they are obliged to pay the cost of a reader service because this is not always borne by the voluntary organisations; they may need special typewriters, Braille writing machines and many such items. They may have to pay for a guide dog. These are some additional items of expenditure which the blind must pay although we know that their earnings are limited and their capacity to earn additional money is restricted.
I would point out to the Minister that most of the western European countries have introduced special allowances, free of means test, for blind people. For example, these allowances are available in Sweden, Denmark, the Federal Republic of Germany, France, Australia and New Zealand, to name but a few countries. These allowances are given in addition to the income tax allowances. The Minister should remember that in many countries a blind person is exempt totally from income tax and this is a concession that should be granted here. In 1962 the British Chancellor of the Exchequer introduced income tax concessions for the blind; yet it took us until 1971 to do this.
We may claim to be especially sensitive to the care of the disadvantaged in our community. This is a Christian concept which we profess but when it comes to putting our hands into our pockets we tend to adopt a different attitude. The so-called concessions I have mentioned should be dealt with by the Minister. I do not think that it would cost a tremendous amount to give those additional helps.
For example, the net cost of increasing the blind pension to £7 maximum, with a corresponding increase in the other rates, would cost approximately £750,000 per year. This is not too expensive when one considers total budgetary expenditure. The Minister should consider the provision of free travel for blind people—it would not cost very much. Many able-bodied and active pensioners can travel around the country but how much more would it mean to a blind person to be able to travel on public transport where he would have valuable human contact. In addition, we should provide free radio and TV licences. We provided free radio and TV licences and I think the matter is now being reviewed. I am not sure of the present position but I hope that the blind may be provided with a combined licence and that they might also get free electricity.
We have been appallingly complacent with regard to housing. The Government or the community do not appear to have put a great deal of effort into this important matter. It is the old story of Fianna Fáil—doing a little and doing it far too late. Deputy FitzGerald made a pertinent comment on this matter in his article on the budget in The Irish Times of 25th April. When commenting on the public capital programme he said:
It seems fair to say that the proportion allocated to housing is now very low—only 16½ per cent as compared with 23 per cent six years ago. This relative erosion of the housing programme is a feature of our capital programme which is difficult to understand in the light of the growing backlog of housing in Dublin.
Deputy FitzGerald pinpointed the fact that while our budget has grown very considerably, like Alice in Wonderland, we are running fast but staying in the same place. In the urban areas the situation is growing more critical and I wish to comment on a number of factors with regard to the housing position. I do not propose to comment on rates reform, differential rent schemes or on tenant purchase schemes as I do not wish to delay the House unduly.
In this country we state adamantly in our various housing programmes that the family is the basis of society. We neglect fundamental areas of family life such as making reasonable provision for houses for all families in the community and putting houses within the normal reach of these families. For many families at present this is a rather pious aspiration, a piece of political theory, because there are many thousands of families who have no prospects of a home. There are at least 4,000 families in my constituency who have no prospect of a home until the mid-1970s at the earliest.
We cannot be unduly critical of the situation which we now see emerging in the Irish urban areas in particular, and more particularly in certain parts of Dublin, patterns of crime, delinquency, juvenile alcoholism and patterns of family desertion which I have found in my short experience of public life can be in many respects traceable to and can be and are derived from lack of adequate housing for the families involved. Where families are forced to live in less than adequate conditions for human beings inevitably the defects I have mentioned come to the surface. The appalling thing is that those who have houses, generally speaking, do not give a damn about those in most not. Very frequently those who have need of houses when they get a house are not very preoccupied about the remaining persons in the community who have no homes. In this respect our community conscience deserves to be severely criticised.
One must say without being unduly critical of the Government—Governments come and go, as political parties and politicians come and go— that in the Irish community in the Republic the existing situation is a glaring scandal. The never-ending rise in the cost of houses and in particular in the cost of developed sites is equally scandalous. I suggest very strongly to the Government and to the Minister for Health, who is present now, that the past policy of the Government of doing far too little far too late and of keeping serviced building land in relatively short supply and at relatively exorbitant prices has ensured that in the mid-1970s relatively artificial, inflated prices are being paid for building sites. The result is grossly exorbitant and scandalous profit for land speculators over the mid-sixties and now in the seventies.
It is illuminating to point out—we had a little of this last week—the number of Deputies who cash in on it. It is very interesting to go through the past occupations of a number of Deputies and see the number who, since their election, have become auctioneers, a very interesting indication of where the profits and the motives lie. There is money to be made out of property and nobody knows this better than many Members of the Dáil and they have made, and are making their money out of it. The exorbitant profits being made out of land at present and the exceptionally high mortgage rates being paid by struggling young couples and the profits being pocketed by private speculators constitute a scandal which must be thoroughly and repeatedly exposed. A house is not a luxury like a racing stable or a yacht or an expensive motor car; it is an elementary necessity of life for a wife and family and young children. It is extraordinary in our community, which professes to be overwhelmingly Christian, that we should tolerate such exploitation of human needs because that is what is happening in the current land situation particularly in the greater Dublin area. Pious political platitudes from various Government Ministers on this question will not remedy the position. Young couples, at a time when they can least afford it, are being financially crippled because of the growth of speculation in land prices and the exceptionally high rates of interest on mortgages. We used talk of the rack rents charged by British landlords but there are quite a few native Irish speculators in land at present who are getting far more profit from the rack rents they are charging for the land they are retaining.
The situation has become more critical because about 20,000 new marriages take place annually at present. This is a record figure for the past 100 years. This is all to the good for the future development of the country. But it means that about 40,000 persons begin family life and want houses. Many of them must find a house but the prospects are growing dimmer each day in the 1970s in the urban areas in respect of costs and repayments.
The Government's decision last year to increase interest rates on loans to local authorities to 9½ per cent meant that at that time many persons buying their own homes found they had to pay 10 per cent on their loans. Many of them could not meet the cost of these mortgages. There is no dearth of information available to the Government right on from the publication in 1964 of the first White Paper, Housing Progress and Prospects, to 1969 when we had another White Paper published by the Government, Housing in the Seventies, as it was then called. There was no shortage of statistics to forewarn the Government and indicate the crisis now facing us in many urban areas.
We could not allow a budget debate to pass without pointing out that much of the land speculation which is taking place in the urban areas and much of the profit accumulated by the speculators in those areas has produced a great deal of marital stress through gross overcrowding in housing. It has resulted in the psychiatric health of the community suffering because there is nothing worse than an overcrowded family in a sub-tenancy living on top of another overcrowded family. The effect on the health, the education and the development of young children can be quite dramatic. A great many of their deficiencies can be traced back to the lack of adequate housing.
I shall give an instance that has recently come to light from An Foras Forbartha of the escalation of land prices and the Government's failure to come to grips with it. In 1960, it has been authoritatively estimated in a study made by An Foras Forbartha, the cost of an acre of potential building land was £301 and an acre of developed land cost £1,000. In 1971 the same land cost £2,500 and £7,000 per acre respectively. One can safely say that the cost of developing the land did not increase from £800 to £4,500 per acre since 1960. Therefore, the profit is roughly £3,000. That is straight profit for developed land in urban areas. That is a rate of profit which must be almost unique in Western Europe.
In the early 1960s the price of land was relatively unimportant to the house price. At that time one had eight or ten houses to an acre and the cost of developed land was £1,100 per acre. At present the same number of houses must be squeezed into an acre of land costing about £7,000. Therefore, the cost of land per house is now very substantial and making the price of houses for many young people completely exorbitant.
This, I would strongly submit to An Tánaiste, has been an area of price inflation in which, with all the NIEC Reports and all the work of the Prices Commission, effective Government control could and should have been introduced a half decade ago. We have had comprehensive information available to us. Three years ago the NIEC, in Report No. 26, recommended to the Government that they should make an effort to assemble the facts about increased site values so as to identify what precisely was occurring in terms of land exploitation. Again nothing very much was done.
The magnitude of price increases can be measured on a simple basis. Retail prices have gone up by about three-fourths since 1950 but site values have been multiplied by eight over the same period. The lesson was strikingly obvious to anybody. The neglect of the Government and their failure to come to grips with land speculation, particularly in the Dublin area, is something which will not rebound to their credit in the years ahead. The situation is scandalous.
We in the Labour Party have raised this question time and again in this House. We raised the intrinsic inequity of the situation right through the 1960s and pointed out the moral injustice of allowing escalation in land values to take place. The Government permitted that escalation to take place, thus permitting a blatant exploitation of pressing community needs. This has been one of the greatest factors in the increased cost of housing in Dublin and other urban areas. Anybody looking for a site for a house will pay at least £1,000 for it and the person who bought that land perhaps in 1960 will make at least £700 or £800 clear profit.
The irony of it is that this is a tax-free profit. Not only have the Government allowed exploitation to take place but they have allowed it at the expense of taxpayers' money pumped into these particular sectors of land to develop them for the community. The speculator got the benefit of roads, of a water supply, of ESB cables, the whole infrastructure provided in the peripheral areas of our towns, and overnight capitalised on that investment in those areas of land. At the same time he gets special, privileged tax treatment. The situation would be beyond belief in any normal democracy. The tax treatment of capital gains made out of land transactions is a great social problem. It is true that since 1969 income tax is levied on profits arising from the sale of land but only in the case of persons engaged in the buying and selling of land as an actual business and how many people formally register them-buying and selling of land? Any auctioneer will tell you—friends of mine are auctioneers and they do not make any bones about telling me—what to do if you want to make money out of land. The current practice is, with entry to the EEC allegedly imminent, to buy up as much rural land surrounding the urban areas as possible. It can be bought relatively cheaply and one will cash in on this in the mid-1970s——
Comment on this
——without any tax being paid on it. Without dwelling unduly on this matter, I submit that the absence of any kind of capital gains tax compounds the present exploitation and the present injustice inherent in a system which permits massive profits to be made on land transactions. There is added a third dimension because you have a situation in which farmland is derated and this encourages speculators to invest in land in the rural areas in the knowledge that it will be free virtually from local rates and this will mean a fine capital gains killing in a few years.
Comment on this
I will give the view of a man whom all of us respect, Mr. Macken, the Dublin city and county manager.
Comment on this
Mr. Macken spoke on this to the Dublin County Council in January, 1971, and he is reported briefly as follows:
One of the corporation's greatest problems was that when they went to buy land they were pursued by all kinds of agents who wanted to find out what they were doing with the result that speculators got in at a much higher price for land which they then sold back to the corporation at an inflated price.
Who wants more evidence than the authoritative view of the Dublin city and county manager?
Comment on this
The Deputy is talking about derated farmland being bought by speculators. That is completely untrue.
Comment on this
I would recommend the auctioneering pages of The Irish Independent, The Irish Press, The Irish Times and particularly The Cork Examiner.
Comment on this
I undertook to conclude at 4.45 p.m. I agree that the remedy in the Republic is a difficult one. The Government will have to move in and even if constitutional amendment is necessary, we are in the position here that we have a written Constitution. It has been pointed out in successive Government White Papers that there might be constitutional difficulties in respect of legislative amendments but it has been pointed out——
Comment on this
I have three minutes to go. I suggest that the Government ensure that the necessary constitutional amendments be made so that they can have capital gains legislation. We are different from Britain in this matter and I strongly suggest that the Government come to grips with it. Otherwise, inevitably, there will be widespread public reaction to the situation in which such practices are allowed by the Government to be continued without any effort being made to remedy the position which has now gone on since the late 1950s. From 1959 until 1971 we have seen an appallingly unjust and unfair system of land gains, of capital gains speculation in land, throughout the Republic and we have seen the Government point blank refusing to take any action. I suppose it is difficult for them because I remember a Deputy elected in a by-election and within a matter of a few years he was a prosperous auctioneer and estate agent. I am sure that there is not a great deal to encourage a backbencher in Fianna Fáil not to press the Government to take action, particularly if he is on a good thing. However, this is not good for the country, it is not good for democracy, it is not good for the taxpayers and certainly it is not good for young married couples who are paying from £10 to £14 per week out of an income of £28 or £30 to own their own houses, living on sausages and mash simply because Fianna Fáil will not take action that is long overdue.
Comment on this
Deputy Desmond has been speaking for four hours, 25 minutes. This is not democracy in action.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not shown charity towards his fellow Deputies. Like an egotistical demagogue, he made up his mind that nobody was to be heard only himself. If every Deputy decided to speak for four hours, 25 minutes, the voices of only a couple of constituencies would be heard. I never transgress the laws of procedure as far as speaking is concerned.
Comment on this
May I remind Deputy Burke that we had three hours, 40 minutes of unadulterated rubbish from Deputy Dowling?
Comment on this
Most of the stuff I have been listening to from Deputy Desmond could not be described in any other way. He is entitled to his opinion but we have democratic procedure in this House and he transgressed it. As a member of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges I should not like to interfere with the rights of any Deputy to speak for as long as he likes but neither would I protect from criticism any Deputy who did so. The Deputy stayed there and kept everybody else out. From the way he spoke about the price of land one would think he is the only saviour in the country.
I would remind him that in 1955 and 1956 you could not give away land. There were 500 houses in this city with the crows nesting in them because people were not able to put roofs on them. Land could be bought for £50 an acre. Now, because of better times and a buoyant economy there is keen demand for land and for new houses. It is a sign of the times. We do not want the communist type procedure whereby if Paddy Burke or John Murphy has a house to sell he will have to wait to be dictated to by the Government. That is what Deputy Desmond has been advocating. He wants Government control so that houses will be sold at less than value. If we are to say that a person must sell land at the agricultural rates, at no more than £200 an acre, how many people would speak out against Government interference? The gentleman who has just spoken speaks about the right of the individual only when it suits him. However, I will move on to more important matters.
The members of the Labour Party and the Trade Union Congress and the ITGWU, as far as I am concerned, will go down in history as sabotaging the welfare of this nation. They are entitled to take that stand, but is there anybody who can tell us that we can cut ourselves away from every other country in the world and still be as we are? Those people tell us that if we go into the Common Market we will lose our independence, that we will have unemployment. Do they realise that almost every factory in this country is in the export market? Where will they export their goods to if England and Northern Ireland go into the Common Market and we remain outside? Will we have to ask them if they will take some of our goods from us? Do we want our standard of living to be half what it is today?
I have travelled to most of the European countries who are members of the Six and I did not see them losing their nationality or economic freedom. They were as independent as ever they were. The egotistical demi-gods of the Labour Party and the trade union movement tell us that we are not to go into the Common Market, that we are to build a wall around ourselves. I knew of people who built hedges around their homes but the day came when they were delighted to have a neighbour when they were in trouble, when their house was on fire or something else happened. Those egotistical demi-gods criticise the parties in this House and the people of the country who see that, when other countries who are trading with us go into the Common Market, we must do the same.
The organisations which are against our entry into the Common Market are writing "EEC, No" on public buildings, bus shelters and pillar boxes in this city and throughout the country. Some of those people could not get into this House and now they are trying to tell us what we should do. Some of them take down posters which the Fianna Fáil Party and the Fine Gael Party put up urging the people to go into the Common Market. I do not know what they want. I think they want an associate membership.
Comment on this
I did not anticipate that. If the Deputies in this House do not speak up those people who do not want us to go into the Common Market will try to put us behind railings and they might introduce some type of Siberia here. The people of Ireland have an opportunity of answering those people. All the manufacturers in this country are clamouring to sell their surplus goods to those countries in the Common Market.
Comment on this
In many factories in my constituency which employ from 300 to 700 people at least 70 per cent of their production is for export. They need the Common Market. I met two of the people who are going around with "No" badges on their lapels and I said to them: "I often heard of a man cutting another man's throat but I very seldom saw a man trying to cut his own throat as you people are." When I spoke to them and reasoned with them they saw what I meant and they took down their badges.
We are not anxious to sell our economic freedom or our political freedom but we are intelligent people. This national issue is completely above politics and therefore the great majority of the Deputies in this House are with us. Would France, West Germany and Italy stay in the Common Market if they thought it was not to their benefit? Although each of those countries are able to stand on their own they are delighted to be associated with one another in the Common Market. The standard of living in each of these countries has improved very much during the last ten years. Some of the people who are against the EEC even went out to Howth and wrote on the wall "No EEC. If you were in Germany you would be working for nothing." I have been in Germany and I did not see anybody there working for nothing. The standard of living in Germany is the highest of any country in Europe. Nobody could say that any worker in Germany has to work for nothing. Those demi-gods I referred to think that we are ignorant in this House, that we know nothing. They want an associated membership.
When Deputy Keating spoke he said that everything, including horticulture, would go when we enter the Common Market. I do not know why he changed his mind so quickly because before he joined the Labour Party he was one of the people who felt that we should go into the EEC.
It is surprising when one changes political allegiance how one can change one's views so quickly. This is not anything new. I remember that in 1946 and 1947 the members of the Labour Party in this House were talking about our international airlines. The shortsightedness of the Labour Party has been shown repeatedly. They sold the aeroplanes in the period I have mentioned. The late Mr. Norton was Minister then. His colleagues were preaching about the tourist industry being bad. We were accused of bringing in foreigners to eat our food. The Labour Party, however, changed their ideas and said later that the tourist industry was worth so much money. Their economic outlook was always bad. No wonder they have so few Members in the House.
Comment on this
They never had any economic policy. They are now saying "Do not join the EEC" and "Say `No"'. They are talking about what they would do if they were in office and about associate membership of the Common Market. If one wishes to join a group or a committee one must take part fully in that committee and be able to sit around a table and discuss matters. An associate member would not have the right to sit with the committee. An associate member could only write a letter to the secretary, but could not be present at meetings to follow it up. The Labour Party are trying to fool the people. I never knew of such philosophies as they have. They say that we are a little country which could stand alone.
Comment on this
The Deputy was economic adviser to the inter-Party Government. That is why they failed.
Comment on this
I am discussing the Common Market and I know I have the Deputy's heartiest cooperation. No matter what statements Deputy O'Donovan is making outside, in his heart he is hoping that we will go into the EEC.
Comment on this
Never, I believe we should stand on our own feet. I did not talk against this in 1961 for nothing.
Comment on this
The Deputy's party have no economic outlook. I pointed out to Deputy Crowley and Deputy Malone what happened in 1947. It was a retrograde step.
Comment on this
I have a good mind to call for a House in view of that last statement, but I will not.
Comment on this
I cannot repeat a good thing too often. Every industrialist in this country is anxious to sell his surplus on some foreign market. At one time the tourist industry was minus £1 million. That was 28 years ago. Our industrial exports were minus £2 million.
Comment on this
The Irish people, led by a sensible Government, did all this. At one stage we were solely dependent on our cattle trade. The Argentinians sent in shiploads of frozen meat to England and the balance of payments here went wrong.
Comment on this
No Fianna Fáil man ever said it before. That is the first time I heard you saying the reason the balance of payments went wrong was because the Argentinians dumped meat on the English market.
Comment on this
Although the Deputy is very helpful I want to say a few words. I could talk for four hours and 25 minutes. Our industrial and agricultural exports are up. That is a big change and a change for the better. Why should we throw it away by telling the people to vote "No" in the referendum. I have a great regard for the Trade Union Congress, as an old trade unionist. Some of the unions think they have the cure for all ills. They are telling the people that so many thousands will be unemployed.
Comment on this
They are right. Look at the thousands who are unemployed under the free trade agreement with Britain.
Comment on this
We must have an outlet for our export trade. If not, where will we be? In nine or ten years the standard of living of our people will be reduced to such a low level that the Deputies who are left in the Dáil will be back where I was when I came here: £1 a day. That is what we had when I came in here 28 years ago.
Comment on this
We are living in an affluent society. I have confidence in the people. The farmers and the workers were able to compete against anybody, when they had to. As a nation we survived under the vilest conditions in the 16th, 17th and 18th centuries. We will now have a voice in Europe. Are we to say that we do not belong to Europe?
Comment on this
I am one of a few people in Dublin who were against this in 1961 and I was proved right. How have things changed since 1961?
Comment on this
Can the Deputy and his friends tell me that if we follow their advice we will be able to export more and more every year, and that our standard of living will not go down, that we will not be an isolated little country with a population of 3,000,000? I have heard characters saying, at about 3 o'clock in the morning at a party when they were inebriated, that they were bigger than the President of the United States, but the following morning they were completely——
Comment on this
This is a serious national problem. Every one of our people should seriously consider how he will vote in the referendum on 10th May.
Comment on this
There are some people whose only interest in this nation is to destroy our democratic institutions which were built up by various Governments since 1922. They do not represent the people. During a by-election in South County Dublin they did not even want us to speak.
Comment on this
If these people had their way they would not allow us to speak at all. Deputy Desmond spoke for four hours and 25 minutes.
Comment on this
On another occasion Deputy Desmond spoke for five hours. The same mentality is to be found outside the House. During the last election I was in Dundrum at a Fianna Fáil meeting and a person with a grey beard kept shouting.
Comment on this
He came up to the platform. These are the type of people who are causing all the destruction they can. If they had their way, we could not speak in here and we could hardly leave our own homes.
These are the freedom fighters who tell us they have cures for all our ills. Why do they not put forward some economic and political policy on the basis of which they could offer themselves for election? They would prefer to do their destructive work outside. I do not know of any industry in this country worthy of the title that is not in the export business. The Transport Union states that the people should vote against EEC membership. I have great admiration for this union but I cannot admire them when they are doing something that is anti-national.
Comment on this
Not at all. The Citizen Army never believed in isolation: they were always outward looking.
Comment on this
I have been a paid-up member for many years of the Transport Union but I must criticise them now for their anti-national outlook. Even if it were my brother who was president of the union I would have no option but to criticise him because of the attitude of the union towards the EEC.
Comment on this
No country today can stand alone. An American President, Mr. Wilson, died in his efforts to persuade the American people to join the League of Nations. He went from coast to coast telling the people that the League of Nations was the only salvation for all nations.
Comment on this
I am dealing now with the EEC and with what is contained in page 7 of this document.
Comment on this
I am talking about countries that wanted to stand alone. Those who succeeded President Wilson followed the isolationist policy but when Pearl Harbour was attacked, the Americans were glad of the help of other nations in beating the Japanese. If the United States, of which one State alone, New York, is as big as England, Ireland and Scotland together, were not able to stand alone, what chance have we of standing in isolation? I ask our people to consider this question of the EEC from a national and economic viewpoint.
As a member of the Council of Europe in the past I visited countries which are members of the Common Market and from my observations I can say that the peoples of these countries were as national as were their hills. They would not have remained members of the Community if there were not benefits to be gained from membership. The Six have been able to reach agreement on various differences. On one occasion when there was a meeting of the Six in Strasbourg we were invited to go along and listen and we found that none of those present had surrendered any thread of their nationality or of their language. There is much cod regarding the future of the Irish language in the context of the EEC. The French, the Germans and the Italians have retained their respective native languages and none of these people has lost one iota of their nationality or of their economic freedom. Agreement was reached among the Six on what was best economically for each member.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton is being very helpful. Let me tell him that it was only in 1960 we applied for membership of the Common Market.
Comment on this
There are too many interruptions. Deputy Burke must be allowed to make his contribution.
Comment on this
It was not until after the second world war that the Europeans got together. The Council of Europe was formed in 1946 or 1947. A short while later the idea of a Common Market was mooted. The people who tried to rebuild Europe from the ashes of the second world war were those who had these ideas and they developed them for the good of Europe and for humanity as a whole. There was no crime in so doing. The only crime being committed today is by the people who are telling the voters to vote "No" in the referendum. The socialists in Europe were the people who favoured the Common Market.
Comment on this
Yes, all of the other socialists are for it. Why are the Irish socialists against it?
Comment on this
Herr Brandt of West Germany who is a socialist is very much in favour of the EEC as are the socialists of the other countries of the Council of Europe. However, our socialists tell us to remain in isolation.
Comment on this
Self-sufficiency— the ancient doctrine of Fianna Fáil. They cannot get away fast enough from it now.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding the prophecy of the then British Prime Minister that, economically, the south would not survive we have overcome the difficulties. Successive Governments have contributed to our standard of living. We have come a long way in those 50 years. These people—the Labour Party—who had no economic policy whatsoever are now trying to destroy what it has taken 50 years to build up. They want our people to tolerate a standard of living which, if we stay outside the EEC, will be as bad as it was 50 years ago. This is a serious national and economic matter for our country.
Comment on this
James Connolly was the only economic thinker of the whole bunch, and he was for a workers' republic.
Comment on this
I am very sorry if I am offending Deputy O'Donovan, because it is not my wish to do so.
Comment on this
I would not offend the Chair, but I could not speak too long or too often on the blind policy of the people who are opposing our entry into the EEC. They do not mind what injury they do to the country or what lies they state as to what will happen us if we go in. Why do they not make comparisons with the other countries that are members? Why do they not travel and ask their socialist friends in Germany, Holland, France and Italy what their conditions are?
Comment on this
I have been in all these countries and have seen the conditions in every one of them.
Comment on this
These egotistical demagogues want to convey the impression that they have the right to do these things. We have given this matter very serious consideration. For the few years that I was a member of the Council of Europe I tried to get all the information I could from the leaders of the various countries about their views on the EEC: Did they sacrifice their economic freedom? Did their standard of living go down? Did they sacrifice their language or their freedom in any way? The answer in all cases was "No". I would not take it upon myself to ask our people to do anything unless I were sure that what we were doing was right.
I am not saying that every industry will be able to compete, but the late Seán Lemass, when he was in Government, asked the various industries to adapt themselves to changed conditions. The Government at that time introduced grants for the purchase of more up-to-date machinery and the modernisation of factories. These industries got protection for many years from Fianna Fáil and other Governments. Now they are being asked to compete with other countries.
Comment on this
Therefore whatever Fianna Fáil does is right, whether it is in favour of protection or free trade.
Comment on this
Deputies ought to appreciate that the speaker in possession has difficulty in speaking if he is constantly being interrupted.
Comment on this
The individual changes with the times. There is no such thing as anybody standing still. There is an old proverb that times change and you must change with the times. Our farmers have changed with the times. Our workers and industrialists have changed. That is a world trend. The day has gone when you could say: "What your grandfather did is good enough for me." Between now and 10th May I would like some of those people who oppose our entry to the EEC to visit the socialists in the various countries to which I have referred.
Comment on this
They have too much money. They are able to get plenty of money easily. I do not believe that the majority of Deputies in this Dáil, with the exception of the Labour Party——
Comment on this
Yes, some members. I thank the Deputy for his timely interruption. I do not believe any of them would advocate entry into the EEC unless they had made a study of the whole subject. Notwithstanding that, the Labour Party and other people outside are saying: "They are wrong. Vote `No'."
Comment on this
They would not make a trade agreement with anybody. If they had their way wages would be down 50 per cent and people would be lucky to get any job at all. They say they are concerned about the workers. The standard of living of our agricultural workers will have improved considerably under EEC conditions. More power to them, because they are a section of the people who deserve it.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donovan ought to know there is a body set up to deal with agricultural workers' wages.
Comment on this
The Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy Brennan, devoted the whole of his speech to what he intends to do for children next year when the election is on.
Comment on this
Anyway, I hope that common sense will prevail and that the Labour Party and their friends outside will see the light.
Comment on this
They have one week in which to make up for their lack of faith in everybody. An intelligent Deputy wants to ensure that we do not trade with anyone, that we do not make any trade agreement, that we will become completely isolated and will withdraw from contact with countries in which we have diplomatic missions; that we will stand alone; that we will not progress. What a wonderful country we would have in those circumstances. Tourists would be prevented from coming into the country. We would have plenty of food to eat because we would have to eat it all ourselves. Factories would be covered with cobwebs instead of being in production and providing a livelihood for workers.
Comment on this
I never thought I would live to see the day that I would hear so many anti-national statements made in this House by intelligent men, statements to the effect that we can live alone without contact with any other country. The men who make these statements may have some contact with the fairies in the forts. There may be a magic wand which will enable them to solve our problems.
Deputy Desmond referred to industrial areas, areas in which explorations were being carried out for oil, ores, copper, silver and gold. Deputy Desmond wants the Government to take over everything. He wants a geological survey. The money spent by those who have undertaken explorations has eased the burden on the taxpayer. We wanted all available money to provide means of improving the standard of living of our people.
I like statements to be factual. This is not a matter to be dealt with lightly. It is a serious national problem. Either we progress or we regress. May the Lord look down on those who mislead the Irish people. I want to see the standard of living of the people improved. In my young days the standard of living was low. I remember many unpleasant features of life. We do not want a recurrence of those bad old days. The outlook of those who are agitating is not democratic. They want to muzzle everyone and to destroy everything. I saw this type of agitation carried on on numerous occasions in the city of Dublin and in the country. Responsible leaders of public opinion in this House who claim to be friends of the workers misrepresent the facts without any examination. We on this side of the House and the majority in the other parties were never afraid to put national considerations before the interests of our party. If the decision that has been made by my party proves to be wrong, a league of nations will not prove them right. But, as a result of the research that I have carried out, I am convinced that the decision has been made with due regard to the well-being of the country. If that decision proves to have been wrong, then the members of the Six must be wrong. In my view they are not wrong. In my view the Six are right and have done a very good job. I have had the pleasure of speaking to representatives of the Six and of asking them questions.
I have spoken for almost an hour on economic matters—the longest time I have ever spoken in this House on any subject. I feel very strongly about this matter. I cannot understand why we should be asked to stand alone. It could happen that the six north eastern counties would be in the EEC and we would be out. May God forgive those who are trying to inspire people to do wrong to the country and to the economy. I can only leave them to God and hope that they may be converted before the 10th.
Comment on this
This is the best budget ever introduced in this House. This is the first time in 13 years that there was no division on the budget.
Comment on this
These are the people who were brought back last year. They are sent out again. They were relieved the year before last and then brought back last year. They are out again now.
Comment on this
A number of them are workers with families. We have come a long way in a very short time.
Comment on this
The retirement pension at age 65 has been increased by £1.25. In the case of the old age contributory pension the personal rate has been increased by £0.70. At age 80 and over the personal rate is increased by £1.20. I should like to see old age pensioners getting three times as much if the economy could afford it. Year after year any surplus available has been given to help the weaker sections.
Comment on this
So did I, for quite a long time. In the case of a person with an adult dependant the old age contributory pension is being increased to £10.35 and in the case of a person aged 80 or over with adult dependant the rate will be £10.85. The widows' contributory pensions have increased as have the disability and unemployment benefits. There has been an increase in the maternity allowance and in the orphans' contributory allowance. There have been increases for child dependants——
Comment on this
There have been increases for everyone except for the children of the workers with large families. Why were they left out? It would only cost a bagatelle in this budget.
Comment on this
According to Deputy O'Donovan, the widows and all those whose allowances have been increased are not workers. The blind pension has been increased; there has been an increase in the widows' non-contributory pensions and in the deserted wives' allowance. The Government are anxious to improve the lot of the less well-off in our community. The unemployment assistance has been increased——
Comment on this
The orphans' non-contributory pension has been increased. The disabled persons' maintenance allowance and the infectious diseases maintenance allowance have been increased. There has also been an increase for child dependants.
Many other social welfare concessions have been made. This has been a wonderful budget and I hope the Minister will continue with his good work which benefits the weaker section of our people. I was glad to see that old IRA and public service pensions have been increased and that veterans of the War of Independence have been given concessions. The farmers have also benefited.
There are other matters that I should like to deal with but I have been speaking for one hour, ten minutes and I will leave those matters until another time. I criticised a Deputy who spoke for four hours, 25 minutes and, therefore, I shall wait until another occasion when I will deal with housing and other matters. I wish to compliment the Minister for Finance for this budget and to thank him for his effort in helping the weaker section.
Comment on this
I should like to endorse wholeheartedly the remark of Deputy Burke in connection with the way public and private property has been defaced by a group who are trying to do their utmost to keep us out of the EEC. I am quite certain the Labour Party had nothing to do with it, but there is a group which is using this means. The paint they are using will be there long after we enter the EEC.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. I am not accusing the Labour Party. However, some group is doing it and it is to be deplored by every right-thinking person.
Comment on this
The Labour Party are covering posters with their own posters.
Comment on this
Posters can be taken down but paint remains. The budget is notable more for what it omits than what it contains. We listened with interest to the remarks about the EEC and the benefits that will come from membership but it is deplorable that at a time when we are on the threshold of Europe the Minister could find only £1.8 million for agriculture. With time running out, when we should be pouring money into agriculture, this is all we could find for the industry.
I know that fairly generous incentives are given towards increasing the cattle population and keeping up stocks and I am sure the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the Minister for Finance are worried about cattle losses as a result of brucellosis. Another sector which could bring great benefits to our economy are the sheep producers. The Chair will recall that this is one of my favourite hobby-horses; I have mentioned it previously on the Estimates for Defence and Agriculture.
Although an increase of £1 per head has been granted to mountain sheep breeders for wether lambs delivered to factories or exported between October and March, the sheep producers on the lowlands get nothing. The lambs which are slaughtered or exported live will be fattened on the lowlands. The benefit given in the budget is a benefit to the producers; it is not an incentive to increase the stock.
A place where a tremendous advance could be made is in my own constituency, on the plains of Kildare at the Curragh. The Sheep Grazers' Association some time ago requested a deputation to be received by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries but he refused to meet them because he stated it was a matter for Defence. Of course, Defence will pass the buck back to the Department of Finance or somebody else and one is caught in a vicious circle.
The Sheep Grazers' Association at the Curragh were not looking for this lamb subsidy for themselves; they were prepared to pool the subsidy and use it towards improving the Curragh and making it capable—as we know it is—of a greater stock-carrying capacity. In March, or thereabouts, when lamb exports may be getting into French markets, we should be giving more to the farmers to encourage them to keep sheep because while they are certainly more trouble than cattle there is also a much lower capital outlay and greater numbers can be carried on improved farms.
While the amount granted in the budget to agriculture is so small as to be quite unnoticeable, I certainly welcome the increases granted to Public Service pensioners but there is one section omitted. Certain widows of State servants are not included in any pension scheme. There are widows of State solicitors who do not appear to qualify. Widows of soldiers are often in a very bad way. Some qualify for pensions because of a special allowance or a military service pension or some other reason but a large number of them are left in very poor circumstances. There is no mention of their plight which is a sad one, very often, when the husband has died after having given his life in the service of the State. I am most disappointed that nothing has been done to remedy that situation.
The Minister was certainly not giving anything away in regard to death duties. We welcome the increase from £5,000 to £7,500 but the Minister must be living on the moon if he thinks this is any great relief there because with the value of property increasing every day the amount of death duties which people must pay is frightening. I found one man last year who had to pay as much as £40,000 on a farm. No later than yesterday I met a man, a smallholder with, I think, 25 acres, who wanted to buy five acres of land for sale near him so as to increase his holding. The price asked for this five acres was £3,500. One would not take long to reach the £7,500 at that rate. While the Minister tried to undo some of the harm he did last year the result is still very far from being realistic.
Efforts have been made in the past, through legislation and otherwise, to avoid fragmentation of holdings but unfortunately the death duty code, especially as amended last year and only slightly relieved this year, will, I think, increase fragmentation rather than relieve it. I hope the Minister will see his way to improve the position.
Some years ago the then Minister for Finance took a swipe at the Road Fund. Road tax went up by 25 per cent in what was considered at the time to be a temporary expedient but which has become a sort of permanent feature of budgetary policy since. The time is long past when this money should be restored to the Road Fund because the amount required for road making and road improvements far exceeds what is available to the Minister for Local Government. Every bank holiday weekend the Minister for Local Government rightly appeals for care on the roads but road deaths are going up daily. Each month we find the new figures higher. The increase, I think, is not all due to bad or careless driving or to drink but is very largely due to the deplorable state of many of our roads due to the huge volume of traffic they now carry and which is growing daily. Unless the Minister is given money to improve the situation, deaths on the road will continue to increase. I hope the Minister for Finance will take another look at that situation and see if he could improve it.
Finally, nothing has been done in the budget to help the housewife.
Comment on this
Food continues to be taxed. I do not know what it would cost to relieve food of taxation; I am sure the cost would be considerable but I am equally sure that smokers, pint-drinkers, workers or motorists would willingly contribute to whatever would be the cost of relieving food of taxation. In a matter of months value added tax will be introduced and the Minister will have a tremendous opportunity to announce then that he will set a common figure rather than have a three-tier tax which seems to be the pattern now. He should make a bold stroke and do as they are doing in England and have a 10 per cent tax with food exempt. I think this would be the greatest thing since the sliced pan. While a sizeable sum, I am sure, would have to be collected to meet the cost of relieving food from taxation it is deplorable to think that in this day and age the food we eat is taxed and there is a great opportunity to end that situation with the introduction of value added tax. I hope the Minister when he is replying or when he is introducing the Finance Bill will keep these points in mind and meet them as best he can.
Comment on this
I shall not attempt to rival Deputy P. J. Burke. I shall finish by 7 o'clock at the latest. I should like to see Deputy Crowley get-thing in. He has been very patient.
If one examines this budget seriously the real thing in it is the message of inflation. It is written high, wide and handsome right through it. The Minister talked about inflation, though he has created more inflation than any Minister ever did in this country. The Taoiseach, with his kindly, nice face, appeared on television on Friday night and had the cheek to devote his speech to inflation. How he had the cheek to do that I do not know, having regard to what has happened. Last year, the Minister by comparing one set of figures with another set with which they were not comparable, was able to pretend that he had made a cut in expenditure. Of course, as has every year been the case, we ended the year spending 20 per cent more than we had spent the year before. That was true even with the supplementary estimates. I thought the supplementary estimates would be much the same as the year before but they were up from £40 million to £50 million, that is 25 per cent. This year's budget is king of them all. It is a budget for £800 million. We will be told at the end of the year—when we have borrowed money at home, printed money, borrowed money in Germany, got part of the profits of the Central Bank, got by the manner in which this Government have allowed the commercial banks to charge the kind of interest rates that have been allowed—that the GNP is up by 5 per cent. Of course it will be up by 5 per cent. All this expenditure is part of the GNP. Of course GNP is neither gross, national nor product. It is wrong all the way, and I have said so frequently.
There are three things about the budget about which I want to talk. The first is the point at which income tax is levied. The second is the fact that there was no increase in children's allowances for the workers. These are the people in whom I am interested, the people who work and get very poor remuneration, like the agricultural workers. The third is turnover tax on food. The last speaker made the point very succinctly that the British have announced that when they bring in added value tax next year they will not have a tax on food. Of course they are perfectly right. One must be either a savage conservative or a super hypocrite to put a tax on food.
There is one matter that seems to occupy the minds of most politicians. The first time I came across it was about a year ago when I went to the annual general meeting of the professional and service organisation. It was a very long time since I had been there and I was delighted to be there. There was a Fine Gael backbencher and a Fianna Fáil backbencher there. When they stood up what did they speak about? The EEC, When it came to my turn I said: "I must be the greatest damn fool politician ever because it never occurred to me that anybody would talk about the EEC tonight." Of course there is such a thing in these matters as overskill. You can so thoroughly sicken the people with the subject that they do not pay the slightest attention to what is said, especially since so many errors and blunders were made. Let me mention the major blunder. Whenever one mentions this it is suppressed in the national newspapers. In the first White Paper, which was produced by the Department of Foreign Affairs, it was expressly stated that we would not be accepted for association with the Common Market. That was either a lie or it arose from ignorance. Either way that sort of thing did not happen in White Papers. No White Paper I ever heard of made that kind of blunder. Personally I believe it was due to ignorance, but if this was so these people should not have been preparing the White Paper —competent people should have been put in charge of its preparation. I shall come back to the EEC. Everybody talks about the EEC. Deputy Dowling spoke about it for hours. Deputy Desmond made several references to it. Deputy P. J. Burke spoke for about a half hour about it. He talked about various other things too, most of which had very little to do with the actual budget.
I want now to talk about income tax. A former leader of Fianna Fáil, our President, some time in the early fifties said: "We will be back again where we were in 1939 and things will be much better." I was very amused by that because I did not think that things were so hot in 1939. However, at the moment the rate of tax is up 50 per cent compared with 1939 and it is levied in real terms at a point which is only half way to the level at which it was levied in 1939. In 1939 a single man did not pay income tax until he had an earned income of £150 a year and on the first £100 after that he only paid half the rate. Until he had £250 a year a single man paid only about £10. Today the equivalent of £250 would be £1,250 and the exemption level, even with the £50 added allowance, is £290. Admittedly tax is not paid on about £7.5 a week because a large part of the social welfare stamp is taken off. That would be between £350 and £400 a year.
That is only half of the £750 and it would be equivalent to £150 in 1939. Yet we are supposed to have made progress. One of the results is that unfortunate young people with relatively small incomes trying to save to get married are instead paying their money over to the State. If they try to buy a house they have to be prepared to pay ten times what they would have paid pre-war.