We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 3: General (Resumed).

Contributions 182–335 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I will settle for ten times. They will have to pay ten times the amount for a house built in Mount Merrion for £850. Now they are paying full income tax. In 1939 they were paying only half the rate on the first £100. We are told that the GNP is up, that our growth rate is up, that we have made advances in many other ways, yet our young people are not able to make the deposit on a house.

Comment on this

How is it that more people are buying their houses than ever before in the history of the State?

Comment on this

That one is dead easy to answer. The Government have been systematically and deliberately destroying the value of money. The time will come when we will have to pay £100 for a box of matches.

Comment on this

Who believes that?

Comment on this

The Deputy need not start on that one. There were houses built on the Rathfarnham Road. I lived there, near Rathgar, and my wife and I used walk along that road. They were nice semi-detached houses, above the road level, and my wife used say they were very nice. They were built for £2,450 in the sixties, not 40 years ago. It was a nice development. One of them was sold the other day for £8,400. That is why everybody wants to buy a house.

This budget as a budget is the worst ever from the point of view of the degree of its destruction of money value. It is the worst that has ever hit the country. Deputy Burke boasted that 50,000 people have been taken out of the income tax net. Are they not the people who were put back into the net last year, having been taken out of it the previous year? In 1939 people's incomes were supposed to be lower but there were then infinitely fewer people in the income tax net.

Comment on this

What is that the sign of?

Comment on this

Simply that the Government are spending more and more money.

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this

It is the sign of inflation.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not doing too badly out of inflation.

Comment on this

No thanks to the Deputy or his party.

Comment on this

How can any Government have the neck to talk about inflation in such circumstances? If the fire of inflation be burning, what have the Government done about it? They have thrown a barrel of petrol on it. If one were slick and quick it could be argued, if one did not bother about logic, that there are increased children's allowances for large families. It could be argued that I am asking the Government to spend more money. In his spiel the other day the Minister for Social Welfare said that if the allowance in respect of every child, not just the children of large families, were increased by one shilling the cost would be £2 million. Of all the people in the community who are hardest hit those with large families are the worst. The hardest hit are the big families where the head of the house is working.

Comment on this

And underpaid.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton is quite right. Last year and the year before I produced figures of what it would cost if we doubled the allowance in respect of every child of three years of age and over in every family. The whole cost would be only a flea bite in this budget. The £2 million mentioned by the Minister for Social Welfare would cover the lot and would give an allowance of £2 in respect of each child per month. That might be of some use to big families. I call the present situation disgraceful because children's allowances were not increased during the whole of the Government's last period in office until the election was looming in 1969. Then they were doubled.

How do the Government expect parents whose children are underfed to rear those children to be citizens who can make a proper contribution to the success of the community? These children are left stunted in mind and body and with a grievance against society. I hope that in ten or 15 years time they will not get together and blow up the whole thing. It is what the Government deserve. Fianna Fáil say they are interested in the lower classes. They are not interested in those who work for their living. They may be interested in the unemployed and in the widows and orphans barely sufficiently to compensate them for increases in the cost of living.

I wish to mention a few details of the budget. One item in the estimate of receipts is a sum of £3.5 million which has been included for "sinking funds surrendered". That word "surrendered" intrigued me. If the word used had been "confiscated" it would have been apt. Surrendered by whom to whom?

I will answer it myself—surrendered by the accountant in the Department of Finance to the treasury, the super part of the Department of Finance. Who owned those sinking funds under the terms of the various loans? The owners were the owners of the stock whose money was confiscated. If they had even put in "sinking funds money sequestered". If somebody surrenders something you say "OK". Were the owners of these stocks ever consulted about this? I am absolutely certain they were not. It was a grab and the purpose of it was to enable the accounts to be balanced. In a budget of £300 million a sum of £3½ million does not matter very much but the Department of Finance should use the English language properly. I would agree with a phrase such as "sinking fund moneys taken over by the Minister for Finance".

The surplus income of the Central Bank as calculated was put into this Estimate of Receipts and Expenditure for the coming year at £8 million as compared with receipts last year from a surplus income of £9½ million. I do not know what was the purpose of this trick. I suggest it was to mislead the commentators on the budget. When we get the ultimate figures of the table of expansion of the budget there is £9 million extra from the Central Bank, profits which they made in the last year. Their rates of interest were related to those of the commercial banks and the Minister takes this in to help him balance up his budget.

The Minister can give me any explanation he likes but the correct figure to have put in for surplus income on the Central Bank would have been £17 million instead of £8 million but that would have given the kind of situation the Minister did not want. He made a provision of £17 million for additions to salaries of staff whereas in other years no such provision was made. Last year when the Budget came before the House the Minister was concentrating his mind on inflation. Although increases were agreed, provision was not made for them; but this year, when increases were not agreed, there is an item in the White Paper of £17 million. The purpose of this was to show that instead of there being a surplus there would be a deficit. When the budget was read out there was a stunned silence in the House in regard to the figures published beforehand.

The Fine Gael Party were always accused of raiding the Road Fund. When Deputy Malone spoke a few moments ago he quite rightly said that this game of increasing the road tax and then using it for ordinary expenditure not relating to roads should stop. This year the Minister is grabbing £4¼ million from the Road Fund. There used to be a great row here before the war if the Minister for Finance was looking for half a million pounds and he raided the Road Fund. This year he is raiding £4¼ million from the Road Fund.

Comment on this

What percentage of the Road Fund was a half a million pounds?

Comment on this

The Deputy will have to work that out for himself. I can tell him what percentage £4¼ million is on the total revenue of the Road Fund this year. It is one-fourth of it.

I now want to speak about something which has been touched on by many other Deputies who spoke, although strictly speaking I doubt if it relates to the budget. I refer to the question which comes up for decision next week. I was never as much a believer in self-sufficiency as Fianna Fáil but I believe in tariffs for the protection of small industries. There is no known example in history of the industries of any country being built up under free trade with the sole exception of Britain which was in first, but there was no competition. The United States and Germany when building up their industries in the last century did so under protection.

What is proposed in the suggestion that we become members of the EEC? It is that we depart from the system of protecting our industries and throw them to the wind of competition from all the countries of western Europe. In view of the example we had when we were a member of the finest economic community in the world at the time of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland from 1800 to 1920 what chance have our industries got? A very good summary of what was done was written by Professor George O'Brien as an introduction to Mr. E. J. Riordan's Modern Irish Trade and Industry. I am afraid that Mr. E. J. Riordan's book would appear to be very ancient stuff to some of the people I hear talking. Professor George O'Brien wrote about 40 pages on what happened to our industries in this country between 1800 and 1850. He summed up the situation very well.

Comment on this

A lot more happened than industrial trade during that time.

Comment on this

The late James Connolly said:

For me Ireland without its people is nothing. That combination of chemical and physical substances known as Ireland is of no significance to me without its people. The people are the only thing that counts.

The Irish song the Spailpín Fánach deals with this extremely well. "Ag seasamh ar mo shláinte", depending on my health, that is, he would die of starvation if he lost his health. Are we going into Europe for the purpose of creating another race of spailpíní fánacha? Is that what we are at? We had Deputy Paddy Burke speaking earlier tonight.

I do not believe that Deputy P. Burke believes one word of what he was saying. I am assuming that he was a genuine member of Fianna Fáil when they were in favour of self-sufficiency. Where did all this come from? There is a French phrase for it "la traison du clercs"—the treason of the clerks. That is what is happening in this country at the present time—the treason of the clerks and the intellectuals. It is no harm to know a few words of French.

Comment on this

Obviously getting ready for the Common Market.

Comment on this

I am glad to think that I will not have much to do with the Common Market. I hope that I will have very little to do with it, despite the fact that vast sums of our money have been spent on little pamphlets. Money has been spent on various documents issued by the Department of Foreign Affairs. These are the so-called White Papers, although they are not White Papers. A White Paper is one that is supposed to examine something impartially in a fair and above-board fashion. Not one of these pamphlets does that. Is this through deliberate intent or ignorance? It has been said that the EEC is not a political party matter at all. It should not be a political party matter.

I have noticed a decided change in emphasis on the part of some of the colleagues of Deputy P. Belton and of the Parliamentary Secretary. Deputy FitzGerald and Deputy Childers have both been accusing us of falsifying figures. Who has falsified figures? Look at the document which was produced about industry by the Department of Foreign Affairs, where the nitwit who wrote it within two pages argued that we are going to have a vast market open to our industries and then that our industries are not going to suffer at all from the competition with industries in the Common Market.

I would be baying to the winds in regard to our fragile industries except for one reason. We have had the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement. The Labour Party opposed it and voted against it. We have been vindicated to the hilt. I said before that the Government sold out the long-term interests of this country for short-term advantage. Conditions in the cattle trade improved for a couple of years, but that was a short-term advantage. In the last couple of years Britain gained more and more from us. The tariffs are only down halfway. We have massive redundancies. The members of the Government tell us that this is due to the decay in world trade and to the fact that certain textiles have gone out of fashion.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

They would never dream of saying that the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement had anything to do with it. This proves that they are avoiding reference to it. They know my statement is true.

The great defect in our position when we became a free country in this part of the island was that we had no trained economists or economic thinkers among the politicians. One man wrote a book which was called, I think, Politicians by Accident. None of the politicians in the early days of this country knew anything about administration or economics. Some of them may have been interested in poetry or mathematics but none of them had an interest in economic matters. This was one of the difficulties. There is a trend nowadays to thinking that economics is arithmetic.

Comment on this

I might have agreed with the Deputy a couple of years ago, but I do not think there is any defect as regards economists here now.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not think that the increase in the number of unemployed by tens of thousands in recent years, even excluding certain categories, shows a defect?

Comment on this

The unemployment of anyone is serious.

Comment on this

It is more serious to have 80,000 unemployed than to have 50,000 unemployed. The Government are right in doing what they can to improve the position as regards unemployment. That is the purpose of their budget. This has been done at immense cost. The figures of unemployed for the last week in April would not lead one to believe that there will be much improvement in that field shortly. What really appals me about the attitude of Fianna Fáil is that they do not care at all. It was pointed out over the last week that the price of food is a cost in industry and if food is low in price industrial costs are low. If food is high in price your industrial costs are high to that extent. We are told constantly, as we have been told by everyone in the Establishment, that wages are so high that our exports cannot compete. If we cannot compete while the price of food is at its present level, how will we compete when the price of our food starts to creep up to the level it is at in the European Economic Community? Would Deputy Crowley tell me the answer to that?

Comment on this

At least the Deputy is honest enough to say the price will creep up.

Comment on this

This arises from what the Government said. The Government said they would save £30 million on agricultural subsidies next year but, when the Treaty between Ireland and the Common Market was signed, it was found that we would gain only one-sixth a year for six years. The difference between our price for beef, to take an example, and the Common Market price for beef will be closed gradually over a six-year period, and not next year. The same applies in the case of butter. The £30 million agricultural subsidies will not be saved unless the gap is closed at once.

I will finish on this note. I will not break my word that I would speak for a relatively short time on this budget. The logically indefensible position of those who favour entry into the Common Market is this. How can you tell the farmers that there will be a bonanza and they will make plenty of money, and also tell the housewife in the cities and towns that the price of food will not go up? You cannot do that. You cannot get away with it. That is the difficulty facing the people in favour of going into the Common Market, and that is why the newspapers today and for the past few days were saying that the message has not got across and the people are befuddled. They are not befuddled. Any farmer spends a great deal of money on food. I would say that the average farmer has departed from self-sufficiency. I take it that even in that great home of self-sufficiency, west Cork, where I used spend my holidays, they are not nearly as self-sufficient as they used be. We used have brown and white cakes baked in the bastible pot, but that is gone by the board.

Comment on this

Not quite.

Comment on this

The brown cake and the white cake are not baked every day now by the woman of the house. If she wants to entertain her friends or relatives she will bake a cream cake, but that is a different matter. The price of the loaf is now a serious matter. It is 3s compared with 9d when Fianna Fáil got back into office. We do not hear about that. The price of the loaf is now four times as much as it was then.

It would have been a worthwhile action on the part of the Minister, if his mind and his eyes were not on other things, if he had taken the turnover tax off food. The Government may have all kinds of economists in various institutions telling them various things, but I know of no economist who would defend a tax on food. If the Government can produce one I would like to meet him. That tax is still with us. The difference between a value-added tax, a wholesale tax and a turnover tax is marginal. The logic of the whole thing was set out by the Revenue Commissioners. It carried conviction on paper but when I examined it afterwards, in the cold light of day, it did not carry nearly as much conviction. The argument was that a value-added tax is not a cumulative tax.

These are the major defects in the budget and nobody will persuade me that they are not major defects. The worst defect in the budget is that children's allowances were not increased for large families so that the less well remunerated workers could feed their families properly. With the present price of clothing I do not believe they will be able to clothe them properly, but at least if they could feed them properly that would be something. Ever since the PAYE system came into being in 1959 the Fianna Fáil Party have given no concessions whatever. They have increased the burden of income tax. The figures speak for themselves: £160 million from income tax alone this year. I suppose the only thing that can be said in favour of the Revenue Commissioners is that they exercise economy. Their rate of expenditure is as low as that of the St. Vincent de Paul Society. Most of the work for the St. Vincent de Paul Society is done free of charge so all they have is a small expenditure on letters and so on.

This budget is not nearly as good as has been suggested. From an economic point of view it is deplorable. From a social point of view it is not nearly as good as it has been alleged to be. I will admit that if these two matters had been attended to—that is to say, if there had been proper income tax concessions and an increase in childdren's allowances for large families only—from the social point of view everybody could say this was a first class budget, absolutely outstanding. Even as it is, it is not that bad a budget from the social point of view but from an economic point of view it is deplorable.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donovan had a very hard time trying to pick holes in the budget and trying to look for legitimate criticisms.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

In the end he admitted that this was a good social budget.

Comment on this

It is not even keeping up with inflation.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton will have plenty of time to talk about inflation and deflation later on.

Comment on this

Deputy Crowley did a fair amount of interrupting.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt destructively at any time. If I did, I will apologise immediately to Deputy O'Donovan. In actual fact, the Minister is to be congratulated on the budget. Naturally you will never get the ideal for every section, and everyone, and every expert. Anybody who tried to attain that sort of Utopia would have to pay a visit to the nearest mental hospital because attempting to attain it would lead him to that institution.

Before the Minister prepares any budget he gets plenty of advice from all the pundits in the Opposition parties, the press gallery and many organisations. I see nothing wrong with that. It is only as it should be. He is the man who has to introduce the budget. He is the man who has to stand over the items contained in the budget. He is the one who must raise the revenue in order to implement the social policies of the budget. This is where the real crunch occurs. Members of the Opposition can ask continuously for various concessions but they then decry the imposition of the extra taxation that is necessary to implement the benefits they have been seeking. The same happens at local authority level when the rate for the year is being struck.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I would not have expected anything but that rude interruption from Deputy Belton. He is now leaving the House with the same indecent haste with which he was removed recently from the front bench. Of course all the critics cannot be satisfied fully with any budget but it must be agreed that this budget has done more to meet the demand of the under-privileged than has any other budget for a long time.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We could see how bereft of policy and, indeed, of criticism, were the Labour Party when we had Deputy O'Donovan telling us that the budget could be criticised from an economic point of view. Undoubtedly the main factors of this budget have been the medium and long-term prospects for the economy. When we remember that we are on the threshold of entering the Common Market, we must also remember it is vital that we have in the economy an incentive to growth. I do not think anybody is in doubt as to our entering the Common Market despite the slogans and the shibboleths of the Labour Party and of the paid subversives who are going around the country trying to break up meetings and to interrupt symposia and conventions that have been arranged to make the people aware of the facts regarding the EEC.

The Minister was aware of what is needed to prepare this country for Common Market membership and, in my opinion, as an ordinary layman, he has gone a long way in this budget to prepare us for what is ahead. It is significant, also, that the Opposition did not divide on the budget. With the Labour Party's policy of being destructive at all times it must be regarded as a compliment to the budget provisions that they did not find any excuse for calling a division of the House. There have been specific criticisms of the budget. For instance, it has been said that not enough has been devoted to agriculture but can anybody say that at any given time there has been enough devoted to every section of the community? We must remember that the national cake is only so big and that each person must be satisfied with a fair slice. The agricultural community, especially the farmers in my constituency, would be the last people to complain about this budget. For the first time the farmers, especially the small ones, are getting their due recognition. One need only consider the price of agricultural land to realise that farming is becoming a very profitable business. Long may it remain so, because when our agricultural community are doing well it follows that the whole economy is doing well. Work generated as a result of wealth in the agricultural community has a spin-off effect on the rest of the country. That is why it is so important that the people be under no illusions about the consequences of entry into the EEC, that they be not misguided by the so-called intellectuals and economists who are distorting the facts. Let us equally be honest with the people and say that there will be increased prices, that food prices, in some cases, will go up, that clothing prices will go up. But have they not already gone up? Is this not a worldwide trend? Are not all budgets prepared with a certain inflationary content in them? However, I believe the benefits will be enormous as a result of going into the community. They have already been well stated on behalf of the agricultural community. The farmers, small, medium-sized and large, are well aware of the advantages that will accrue to them from membership.

It has been our fault to a certain degree that the industrial worker has not been made aware, to the same degree of the advantages of membership, but it can equally be said that he also will reap the benefits of our joining the EEC. For instance, in Bantry, in my constituency, there is a huge industry awaiting the result of the referendum on 10th May. Their decision will be made as a result of the decision taken by the people on that date. The workers in my constituency are alive to the advantages that will accrue to them. After all, where is the obvious place for anyone of the other nine member countries to establish a heavy industry but Ireland where we have a surplus male labour force with tremendous adaptability and some of them highly technically trained. The reason why we have people who are so adaptable and who have this bent towards technical positions is that we are basically a rural community. What young fellow off a farm or even a neighbour to a farm has not been fixing a tractor or plough or doing something mechanical as long as he can remember? Unlike the members of the Labour Party, I have complete confidence in the ability of the ordinary Irishman to rise to the occasion and produce a product that is as good as, if not better than, any produced in Europe and, at the same time, to lift his standard of living to the level in, say, Germany or France.

It is also very important that we be not misled emotionally by people talking about selling out our sovereignty, about selling out on the Six Counties, about selling out on the people who gave their lives to make it possible for us to congregate here today. This is a complete distortion of all the facts that are available to us, and I would go so far as to say that it is a deliberate distortion. There is no legitimate, honest argument for non-entry. Any argument that would be made for non-entry, in order to be effective, must inevitably be based on distortions. Maybe those of us now in favour of entry have been remiss in not going sooner to the meeting places and convincing the people of the rightness and the profitability of entry into Europe. The late Seán Lemass summed up free trade well when he said it did not automatically give you a profit but it gave you the opportunity of profit. The Irish people have this opportunity of profit on the 10th May.

It is disconcerting that there are people in this country who are claiming to be Irishmen and claiming to be, in some cases, more Irish than the greatest Irishman, who go round to political meetings and try to break them up lest views with which they do not agree be put forward. I had that experience last Sunday when some of these ultra-nationalistic organisations, which they claim to be, did not seem to like the arguments I was presenting in favour of entry. They decided that this was one way of silencing me, by constant heckling and bullying tactics. The people have never been cowed by these tactics and the perpetrators came very much the worst out of it, because, as they had to stoop to these tactics, the people saw they had no legitimate arguments to put up; if they had they would have put them up.

The only danger to our entry is complacency, but I do not think that danger is very great any longer, because people are becoming much more interested in the issues. As I said, maybe we were wrong in not informing them as soon as possible of all the issues that were involved, but we are getting around to doing it now, and I believe the people will recognise the validity of the arguments for entry.

There is one slight criticism I would make. It has to do with the Old IRA veterans. I recently had a question down to the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Defence about the possibility of exempting IRA veterans from income tax. Unfortunately my representations were not successful, but the Minister did give some concession to them. I would appeal to him, if at all possible, to ensure that these great men are exempted from paying income tax. Surely if we can do it for actors and artists we can do it for the people who fought to give us our freedom. It is a very small concession to give them at the end of their lives. I hope the Minister will pay some attention to my request on their behalf. I know he is concerned about them. He probably sees many difficulties in the way of implementing such a policy, but there is already a precedent in the exemption of artistes, writers and others.

In the budget the Minister faced up to his responsibilities and went for medium-term and long-term growth in the economy. He did this by putting additional spending power into the hands of those who spend it most quickly—pensioners and the less well-off members of the community. He gave men and women in employment an opportunity to safeguard their jobs. He gave the whole community the incentive that was needed to create more jobs and to increase the national income. He provided some very attractive incentives for industry and outlined the way to industrial expansion. Above all, he showed his complete confidence in the ability and character of our people. That attitude will be reflected in the future in the tangible assets of increased wealth, increased production and increased prosperity for all. The Minister took steps to ensure that this prosperity would be shared by all, including the poorer classes.

Of course, Deputy O'Donovan said that we would blame all sorts of depressions, the fall in the textile industry and various other factors in order to show that the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement was not the cause of any failure. I do not think that that agreement was the cause of any depression in the economy. There was a depression which hit the United Kingdom, for instance, which is our principal customer. The depression in the United States also had a minor effect on our economy. We suffered little through any fault of our own. Perhaps we can say that there were more strikes than there should have been although, quite honestly, I say last year was the year that showed the maturity of the Irish working people. The unions came of age in the ESB strike. Generally there is a very sound basis for optimism for the future as a result of what we have seen in the past 12 months. I am convinced that any depression that there was in the economy was due to the external factors I have mentioned.

If I were to try to describe the budget in one word I would say that it is an adventurous budget. Not alone is it adventurous but it is imaginative. It will have the effect of creating confidence in the minds of management and it will provide the necessary incentive to industrialists to expand, thus automatically increasing employment.

This budget will provide a healthy economic climate for us. Of course, the critics are less vociferous now than they were on former occasions. This is the greatest compliment that can be paid to the Minister. If the budget were not as good as it is Deputies would be coming in here to deride it. I am particularly pleased, as I am sure every Deputy is, that the poor have not been forgotten, that those who are unorganised, who do not represent a pressure group, who have nobody to speak for them except their public representatives as such, have not been forgotten and have been given fairly reasonable increases. I am also pleased that thousands have been removed from the income tax net. That is a source of satisfaction to all concerned with the welfare of the less well-off section of the community.

I only hope that we will be able to achieve a national wage agreement that will give the type of consolidation that is required on entry to Europe. The prospects of having a national wage agreement are very bright. I do not want to say any more on that subject for fear that anything I might say would affect the outcome. The prospect of negotiating a really worthwhile wage agreement is on the cards and I hope such an agreement will be forthcoming.

As I said at the outset, this budget is a challenge to us all. It is a challenge to prepare ourselves for membership of the European Economic Community. It is a challenge to grasp the opportunities now being presented to us and to show the self-control and dedication that will be necessary in order that we may be successful within the Community.

The Minister mentioned the prospect of a White Paper being issued in the summer in regard to a new type of company taxation, a corporation tax of some description. I assume that this will correspond roughly with the British tax with some modifications to suit Irish conditions. It is time that companies were assessed and charged on a different basis from that applicable in the case of ordinary individuals. Nevertheless I cannot help feeling that the whole system of taxation, which was devised to serve a great industrial and commercial nation, the UK, is unduly ponderous and complicated for a small nation such as ours. I would ask the Minister why cannot we have a system that would be more suitable for a small country and which would be comprehensible to the man-in-the-street. If companies and individuals are to be segregated—I agree with this type of segregation and I consider it is long overdue—is this not an opportunity to revise the tax code in relation to individuals? Perhaps the Minister has this in mind; if not, I would urge him to give careful consideration to the matter.

It is not too much to ask that tax legislation should be relatively easy to understand. There is no justification for making it so difficult and abstruse that the ordinary taxpayer has not a clear idea of the implications. Ignorance breeds fear. Rightly or wrongly taxpayers think that the system is geared to soak them and this fear should be allayed. Those people who can afford it can hire the services of a taxation expert and frequently the fees paid to these experts are returned a hundredfold in the form of reduced liability. However, the poor and the not so rich have to bear the full brunt of taxation and this breeds resentment. One should not have to rely on the services of experts; alternatively, the services of experts should be available to all. The lack of accumulated wealth should not militate against any taxpayer.

It is common knowledge that in the last five or ten years there has been a phenomenal growth in the formation of private investment companies. They have as their aim the avoidance of surtax and estate duty. I hope that corporation tax legislation will be so framed as to discourage such abuses and will ensure that those who enjoy large incomes will bear their proportionate share of taxation. Neither should it be permitted that those who earn large profits here should be able to escape payment of taxation because they channel their profits into foreign companies which are registered in such notorious havens as the Bahamas and Jersey.

In conjunction with the reform of company taxation, the Minister might consider, in consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, reform of the Companies Act, 1963. I refer in particular to the abuse of the provision in relation to the now permitted issue of redeemable preference shares. This permission has been of little or no value to the commercial and industrial interests and I urge that it be withdrawn. Nowadays one rarely sees the issue of such preference shares to the public. For practical and financial reasons they have gone out of fashion and this is even more justification for not allowing redeemable shares to be used for the avoidance of taxation. It was gratifying to find that the Minister took many people out of the income tax net. This is a welcome return to the position which obtained previously.

I listened to Deputy O'Donovan and Deputy Desmond speaking about the prices of houses and land and property generally and of the number of people who are seeking to buy their own homes. Nobody denies that the price of land and property has increased considerably. I agree that there should be some system of control whereby more building land could be put on the market by county councils or corporations. This is being done at the moment by local authorities but it should be done on a larger scale. If the colossal cost of a site were taken out of the price of the house it would make it much easier for married couples to buy their own houses. However, it is not an easy problem to solve. So long as we are committed to the free enterprise system of buying and selling it will be difficult to introduce any legislation that will not affect that system. In addition, there would be constitutional difficulties in this kind of operation.

It was gratifying that many social welfare benefits were given in the budget. In the retirement pension at the age of 65 the personal rate was increased by £1.25 bringing it to £6.20. For a person with an adult dependant the increase was £1.95 bringing it to a total of £10.35. It is only right that we should keep pace with the cost of living in our social welfare benefits. The old age contributory pension for those aged between 70 and 80 years was an innovation; the personal rate will be £6.20 and for a person with an adult dependant the amount will be £10.35. Disability and unemployment benefits have increased; the personal rate will be £5.55 and for a person with an adult dependant the amount will be £9.30. The widow's contributory pension and many other pensions have been increased. These increases were all welcomed by the recipients. In the preparation of our budgets we must remember that the less well-off section are the least vocal and they deserve all the help we can give them. I would be inclined to cut down on other groups who are much more vocal, more powerful and more vehement in their demands and to give to social welfare recipients.

I agree completely with the extension of the free travel scheme and the increased allowances of free electricity. I also agree, of course, with the new provisions for widows of War of Independence veterans. We had an anomaly there since the scheme was introduced. It was very hard to explain why a widow could not travel on her husband's card. That is rectified now and we hope there will be even further concessions to veterans of the War of Independence.

Deputy Malone expressed disappointment at the fact that only £1.8 million, as he said, was allocated to agriculture. He carefully ignored what had been allocated in the past 12 months which included over £10 million by way of increases in creamery milk prices, increases in export subsidies for beef and lamb and the special loans scheme for the meat industry. The gross cost of that was £2.65 million. Capital grants for farm improvement and disease eradication were increased by £4 million and— very important—the amount of credit was increased by £7 million last year and by a further £4.5 million this year. The small farm bonus scheme was increased from £375 to £500. Anybody being fair and objective in regard to the agricultural industry could not decry the amount of money put into agriculture and say it was minimal. It was a considerable amount of money, especially in view of the other forms of assistance provided in regard to the price of pigs and the mountain lamb subsidy and so on.

All in all, we can say it is a budget of which the Minister can be proud that he did a good job, that he looked after those who most needed to be looked after, and that he did all this without any extra taxation. He utilised the buoyancy of the economy. This must have been a source of grave dissatisfaction to the Labour Party who have been saying for so long that we are bankrupt and that we are gone forever financially and cannot recover but suddenly when we have decided to go into Europe they say we are such a great little country that we should stay on our own. It would be funny if it were not so serious. This budget is the farmers' incentive to prepare for the Common Market to ensure that they gear themselves to avail of the opportunities provided by membership. If they do this the benefits for them will be enormous.

In conclusion. I wish to emphasise to the Minister my request that he should take the Old IRA veterans out of the income tax net. I know he will give that suggestion his most sympathetic consideration.

Comment on this

I do not intend to delay the House very long but there are a few points I should make on this budget. I certainly welcome the Minister's decision to give those benefits to the lower income groups, particularly social welfare recipients, old age pensioners and so on. With the implementation of decimal currency taxation rose considerably without the people realising it. The increases that had been given have already been accounted for in increased prices and the people need whatever extra benefit is being allowed and far more in order to have any decent living. Across the Border we can see that social welfare benefits are vastly increased. How can we expect that our people there will join us and take our social welfare benefits?

I do not believe this is an election budget; I believe it is a budget for entry into the EEC. I welcome the increases but they will mean little or nothing at this stage to the people who are getting them because the little items they must buy to sustain life have increased in price by far more than can be met by the increased allowance.

I am sorry that there were some omissions among the social welfare recipients, particularly female relatives. There are hundreds of female relatives in the west of Ireland who must look after a father or mother. For instance, a young farmer's wife may have to take her mother-in-law out of bed ten or 12 times a day but, because her husband is out working, perhaps temporarily if the farm is a small one and he is trying to make a living there, this woman is denied an allowance because she is supposed to be maintained by her husband. There are hundreds of old people in institutions or hospitals when they should really be at home where they would be happy and where a daughter-in-law would love to have them and look after them if she could afford to do so, if an allowance were provided. If a small farmer in the west of Ireland goes out to work for ten or 15 weeks of the year and if he does not have 78 stamps in three years and the social welfare officer decides that he earns more than 10s. a day, he is automatically debarred from unemployment benefit. I think this is a very dishonest regulation which deprives a man living with his wife and family who earns more than 10s. a day of unemployment benefit. Surely there is something serious wrong if that type of regulation is not amended. I am delighted that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare is here. With the help of God he may increase this to at least £1 a day.

Much has been said of the great benefits the farmer has got. I, as a farmer from the West of Ireland, am fully aware of the reasons why the price of cattle has gone up and why our balance of payments has improved this year. The price of cattle has gone up because farmers are banking on entry to the EEC. If the people of this country say "No" on the 10th May I can tell the farmers they will be taking £25 a head less for their stock before the end of this year.

Comment on this

And perhaps, double that.

Comment on this

No, this is what I say. There is a surplus amount of money because of the increased price of stock on the export market and an increased price of agricultural produce this year. The Government know perfectly well that if we do not enter Europe this country is doomed, regardless of what the Labour Party may think. The Labour Party were directed by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions and it is impossible for any Labour Deputy to stand up here and support entry when the Irish Congress of Trade Unions have decided to vote against entry.

The Minister is supposed to have given an increased price for pigs but pigs are going for far more than that on the open market. This is never availed of but it has been raised. I welcome the increased price for mountain sheep but I think this should have been extended to lowland sheep.

That would have been an incentive to produce. The people in my part of County Mayo and in County Galway are deprived of that increase. People wonder why the mountain sheep breeders have been given this subsidy. Early last year it was almost impossible to sell lambs. Wool was sold at 2s a pound and if there was any chemical which would burn the wool off the sheep it would pay a farmer much better than shearing sheep and trying to sell the wool. I do not know what has gone wrong with wool prices. Ten or 15 years ago wool was 5s, 6s and 7s a pound. Last year it was sold for 2s a pound.

There was no provision made for one section of the community who are trying to survive on very meagre means. These are people with small businesses in small towns and villages, particularly in County Mayo where we have the highest rates in Ireland, £8.30 in the £. I am sorry the Minister has made no provision for them. In my county we pay £3.60 in the £ for health alone. We are at a serious disadvantage in that we have no specialised services within our county and all our patients must be transported at the expense, to a certain degree, of the ratepayers to Dublin hospitals or to extern institutions in Galway. This is a great drain on the rates. Unless some Minister of some government makes this a national charge I cannot see how poor people who live in small towns and villages with small businesses can survive.

I hope the referendum succeeds. My party have always believed in the advancement of this country. The Government of today had not a hope in hell of ever winning this referendum without the support of Fine Gael. We always believed in the betterment of this country. I lived, as a young boy, through an economic war. This economic war is never mentioned by anybody on the Government benches because they were the people who created it. I lived through that and I hope that I, or any member of my family, will never have to live through another and this is what it will mean if we do not enter the EEC. We will be isolated and Britain will become an agent to sell our produce and buy it at her own price. As well as that, we will be creating a permanent Border within our country if the people reject entry. There will be no use for that Border, no need for it to be there in five years if we go in. I can see that Border disappearing, economically anyway, easily within five years. Thank God it will stop a lot of this unnecessary trouble and murder across the Border.

I can understand why every subversive element in the country is completely opposed to EEC entry. Speaking as a Deputy from the north-west, I am convinced that it is not Northern Ireland but Southern Ireland they want to take over. Therefore, my advice to the people and to my constituents in particular will be to support our application for entry. It will be for the betterment of themselves, the betterment of our country and it will mean that as a nation we will have a better chance of survival. There is no solution for us without EEC membership, no matter what the proposed alternatives are.

A certain amount of money will be saved on subsidies to the farming community. It will be in the region of £30 million to £40 million. I hope that when that money becomes available to the Exchequer it will be spent wisely. I am not satisfied with the amount of money the Government have been putting into agriculture throughout the years. Agriculture has been our mainstay. In the next four years production can be increased by 100 per cent and the person who has land will be given the opportunity to make a decent living.

I do not like the proposal of the Government to introduce value added tax before Britain and I do not understand why they contemplated its introduction during the present year. Britain will not introduce it before next year and the same goes for the other applicant countries. Of course, it is a stratagem to collect extra revenue but it is dishonest to the people to implement it before Britain and ourselves are members, which will not be until March next.

I welcome certain provisions of the budget, particularly those which benefit the lower income groups and the social welfare beneficiaries. They are entitled to the little extra they get because we all know how prices are outpacing incomes. Something will have to be done about rates and particularly about the system of financing our health services. At the moment there are too many people who cannot afford even the necessaries of life and I, as a Deputy from Mayo, unfortunately know this only too well.

Comment on this

Anyone travelling in the countryside after a budget will hear reaction to it one way or the other. Sometimes there is violent reaction because somebody thinks he has been overtaxed and someone else thinks that the social welfare categories have not been treated properly. This is one budget which has been welcomed by all sections. It does not impose extra taxes and at the same time it provides relief for many people who are paying heavy taxes. There has also been a general handout to social welfare beneficiaries.

The budget makes us appreciate that the economy is very sound. Opposition speakers have said the country is going burst, that the country is on the rocks, that we are running up huge debts here, there and everywhere. However, when they size the budget up they must admit that the economy is sound. From time to time our balance of payments has run into difficulties but we have always been able to bring it back to a tolerable level because of action by the Government, unpopular, perhaps, but necessary for the betterment of the country. The people have appreciated this. Now, because of the campaign for entry to Europe, the whole world realises that the economy here is very sound.

The budget gave a special concession to the over 80s. This was only right because those old people spent their lives working hard and they deserve this special concession. They are not getting too much. It is very hard to give a person even enough when he depends solely on a non-contributory old age pension.

Every year we have been given more in social welfare benefits. I hope that in the near future there will be an added benefit, a comprehensive scheme to provide home care for the aged and invalided. Our aim is to keep our aged invalided people out of hospitals. At the moment hospital costs are rising and in most cases aged people would prefer to stay at home. I know such a scheme would be difficult to initiate because if the payments were made to the aged person the relative responsible for looking after him might complain and if the payments were made to the relative it might be said that the old person was not receiving adequate attention. It will be difficult to work out a scheme but it should be remembered that there are public health nurses and social workers who are only too willing to call to each home. I urge the Minister to consider introducing such a scheme in his next budget. It may cost a lot of money but it is costing a lot at the moment to maintain those people in hospitals.

This year the Minister for Finance gave other concessions in the budget. All of them were necessary because the people concerned could never be given too much, particularly with prices rising all over Europe. Deserted wives have been given an increase. They deserve everything we can do for them. Those people do not know whether they are here or there. A widow knows her husband is dead and she can plan for the future but in this case the woman never knows whether the man she married will show up again and she cannot plan for the future. The Minister should be more lenient with that category of people.

Deputy Crowley said he was not satisfied with the amount of money which went to help the veterans of the War of Independence. I agree with what he said. We are much too strict in our regulations in granting special allowances to the survivors of the War of Independence who are the holders of service medals. Those men were idealists and they fought for the love of their country. They are getting fewer every year and we should give them as much as we possibly can. When those people retire from business and live on a small farm with a son the investigation officer comes out to investigate their case and he has to put down whether it is a hardship on the son or daughter to look after them. If he puts down that it is well within the financial resources of the son or daughter to maintain the father and mother a very small allowance is given. The regulation in this case is much too stiff. I hope in a future budget the Minister will ensure that every person with a service medal is granted at least £1 a week.

In a previous budget the Minister granted an allowance of £1 a week or half her husband's pension at the time of his death to the widows of War of Independence veterans. I should like to see that extended to the holders of service medals. This will not make those people rich but it will show them some appreciation from us. I am sure all parties in this House would be behind that.

The Minister has increased the burial allowance of £25 to £50. This means that the person burying one of those War of Independence veterans can obtain £50 towards the cost of burial. This has now been extended to military service pensioners. I am glad there is no difference shown between the holders of military service pensions and the holders of service medals.

Many of us had urged the Minister to extend the free travel allowance to wives of the War of Independence veterans. However, I am a bit confused about one matter in connection with this. Will the wife of the veteran of the War of Independence get free travel when her husband is in hospital? As far as I know she must be accompanied by her husband. That man could be in hospital for quite a long time and his wife might wish to visit him.

Although I criticise the Government in regard to this matter I must point out that it is only the Fianna Fáil Government who have done anything for those people. The Opposition got their chance but they did very little for them. It was the Fianna Fáil Party who in the forties first gave help to those people.

Many people criticise the budget because enough was not given in it to agriculture. Farmers should get special allowances on 1st January or 1st February so that they can make their plans for the year ahead. The Minister is converted to this idea now. He has said that will be his policy in the future. A lot of money has been poured into agriculture over the years. It is the backbone of our nation and of our export market. When we go into the EEC we will have to do away with all the subsidies. We will then be able to give further help to the social welfare recipients.

We allocate large sums of money each year to the eradication of disease. That has been increased to £4 million this year. We are not strict enough in regard to eradication of disease in pigs, sheep and cattle. I should like to see better grants given. We see cattle in trucks being brought into marts every day. Some of those may have suffered from disease. In the evening we see cattle, which are free of disease, being brought away in those same trucks. The work on eradication is set at nought if healthy animals are carried home in the same trucks as diseased animals were brought in early in the day. They cannot mix. We will have to have a careful look at this.

The small farm bonus scheme was increased from £375 to £500 for new participants. That is a good idea. It is beneficial to the younger men. It should always be our aim to give incentives because they are vital for the survival of the small farmer who has a difficult life, because he has not enough land. Most of our young farmers do their best and make a good living.

The mountain lamb subsidy is to be increased by an average of £1 per head on fat wether lambs of mountain breeds. This is a welcome innovation. The hill sheep farmer has not been forgotten. Such farmers work very hard to eke out a living. It is not easy to mind the sheep, even though grants for fencing are paid. The Department have been strict in enforcing regulations concerning the breeds of sheep who qualify for the mountain lamb subsidy. They are not inclined to allow any crossing at all in breeding. The Minister should sanction the crossing of some of the mountain lambs with inland sheep. Scotch ewes and Suffolk rams should be crossed. This is worth a trial for one year. The lambs would probably be better.

Everyone thinks that those engaged in agriculture are millionaires. They think that there is no fear for the farmers if we do not join the EEC. I cannot understand the mentality of anyone, even remotely connected with agriculture, opposing entry to the EEC. Agriculture will suffer badly if we do not join.

The Minister referred to credit unions and the exemption from tax on their operating surpluses. There was a fear that they were to be subject to high taxation. These unions are doing a good job. They are operated by an excellent group of people and really try to help people who cannot get money elsewhere. Much money has been invested in the credit unions. People have small savings there and can get loans. In cities they help people who might otherwise go to moneylenders who would charge exorbitant rates of interest. These credit unions are a help in discouraging the use of moneylenders.

The general exemption limit of £5,000 for death duty purposes will be increased to £7,500 and there will be a reduction in the rates of estate duty on certain estates. That is only proper. The value of property and of land is rising each year. It seems to rise daily. Death duties should be kept in line with that. They are a heavy imposition on the families who have to pay them.

Money must be got somewhere. The Minister has acted wisely. I congratulate him also on the arrangement regarding death duty as it affects illegitimate children. It is proposed to provide that, for death duty purposes, illegitimate children inheriting property from their mother will be treated as if they were legitimate and that, where foreign adoption orders have substantially the same effect as orders made under our Adoption Act, children adopted under such orders will be treated as children adopted under our law. This is a change in the right direction and should have been brought in long ago. There is new thinking in this country in regard to these matters. It is only right that such children should be treated in a proper manner.

People are inclined to discuss entry to the EEC. It is the greatest decision this country has ever been asked to make. On the 10th May the people will be asked to decide whether they will join with the developed countries of Europe or stay out on our own on the periphery of Europe. I am not asking anyone to join a Europe where there is easy living or lazing around. That is not the idea of the EEC. The EEC is a community where people work hard and have a rationalised system under which they are paid well for their work and have guaranteed market for their products. Our people should think about this. In the past our farmers were often asked to produce certain goods and, having produced them, they found that Britain had her own financial difficulties affecting her balance of payments and that tariff barriers were imposed on our exports. That is how Britain got out of difficulties at times. The tariffs might be 10 or 15 per cent and they could be imposed overnight. We could do nothing about it. On the agricultural front we could find, when we produced milk or beef, that when we came to sell them in England the markets there were flooded. The export of meat from this country has been affected by price slumps following frozen meat importations from the Argentine and South America. There was no definite price for our produce. If we join the EEC there will be a stabilised market and a levelling off of prices. Each category of people will know what they are going to get for their produce. Many people are saying that we can have an associate membership, during the past week, with the EEC, and trade agreements. People must have read in the papers that countries which sought association with the EEC countries have been denied such association. We must become full members.

We should be at the negotiating table. We should be at the table where the decisions are made. We should have our representatives there to make our case as strongly as possible. We should not be in a position in which other people in the EEC having made their decisions would say to us if we sought associate membership: "Here are our conditions. You can like them or lump them." That is what is being said to the nations who are seeking associate membership at the moment.

There is a lot of murky thinking by some people. Many of those who are campaigning are throwing mud and hope that some of it will stick. They are telling us that we can have trade agreements with many other countries, and that we can have trade agreements with the eastern bloc. The eastern bloc countries will not be able to take our produce overnight. Surely the Irish people should not be told that Portugal and Spain will be able to purchase our agricultural or industrial goods. They have not got the purchasing power. I often feel like asking the people who say that, do they mean what they are saying. I think they are out to cod the people for their own gain.

Surely they are not asking us to sell our goods to the countries bordering on the Mediterranean. The African countries have no purchasing power either. An old man said to me the other day: "There are people talking about selling goods to Africa but if we only send out a missioner we must send out a ball of money after him to keep him alive." That is a sound remark because those countries are not in an economic position to purchase goods from us at reasonable prices. Therefore it is vital that the people should consider this question very seriously.

The object of the campaign at the moment seems to be to say to the housewife: "Look at what it will cost you in the EEC." We all know that what is important is not what something costs you but what you have in your pocket. I heard another person say: "I remember when a pint of porter cost 6d and I was not able to buy it because I had not got the money. Now it costs over 3s and all the lads are able to buy it because they have the money."

On radio and television and in pamphlets we are told what goods will cost in the EEC and what they are costing in Ireland today. Many of these figures are inaccurate. We are told that the price of sugar will go from 5d or 5½d to 10d per lb. The price of beet here is approximately the same at the moment as it is in European countries. The cost of processing it is about the same as well. The price of that commodity will be about the same. The price of bread will not increase very much.

It may go up from 7d to 7½d if we join the EEC. In those pamphlets it is stated that it will go up to 10d. They say that potatoes which cost 1½p at the moment will cost 5p if we join the EEC. That is completely untrue because it just cannot happen. They will cost about the same as they cost at the moment.

A subject which they are all talking about now is the price of steak. At chapel gates I hear people talking about sirloin steak and fillet steak. If you were a foreigner you would think that we throw the rest of the animal away and that there is no such thing as boiling beef and roasting beef. Sirloin steak and fillet steak are not the basic cuts we eat, or the basic cuts eaten by the people who are talking about them. We only have them now and again. Let us face up to the facts. They are saying we will not be able to have them every day because they will cost a ridiculous sum. They are saying they will cost 130p per lb. It is easy to go to any country and make out a price list. You could probably make out a price list in Dublin today higher than the price list they made out for the EEC countries.

I was in a hotel the other night and I saw fillet steak at 130p for 12 ounces. There was 5 per cent turnover tax and 12½ per cent service charge to be added to that. I could go to another country and say that is the price of meat in Ireland, but it would not be factual. Other hotels may not be as posh or may be catering for a different type of customer, and they would quote a different price. It is very dishonest of those people to say we should not join Europe and quote prices which are completely unrealistic.

In the budget each year provision is made for agricultural subsidies. Some of those subsidies should really come under industry. People are inclined to say—and many people are inclined to swallow it—that if we enter the EEC it will be to the advantage of agriculture alone. What does agriculture really mean? The dairy farmer is the man who works seven days a week and almost 24 hours a day. He is paid for the milk when he delivers it to the creamery. It then goes on to the processing plants and the industrial worker gains from it. Hundreds of industrial workers are engaged in the processing plants every year, and make a good living. Money is provided in the budget for farm improvements, for building farmhouses, lean-to's, milking parlours, and so on. The materials, the corrugated iron, the gravel, the sand, the cement, the masons and the carpenters should come under an industrial heading. When people say that the farmer is the only one who will gain by entering the EEC we should remember that, if he does not gain, other categories will be poorer and many of them will be unemployed.

The same people are saying that we will lose our sovereignty and that Ireland will not be able to decide for herself whether to remain neutral in the event of another clash between the great powers. I would say it is a great pity that the EEC or some such body was not in existence at the turn of the century so that we could have avoided the horrors of two world wars which took millions of lives and destroyed Europe economically and otherwise. I hope that will never again happen. There is no law which says that you must go to war. There is no law which says you cannot have another referendum if you want it. M. Pompidou in France has proved that. He has shown that he can have a referendum any time he likes, on any matter he likes, even though France is a member of the EEC. We should think about these matters. Everybody must come out and vote on 10th May. We are facing the most important issue that ever faced this country.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil must be in serious trouble if they are talking about another referendum.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donovan is a man of many parts. I think he started out in the Fianna Fáil Party, then joined the Fine Gael Party, and he is in the Labour Party now. If there were another referendum on the EEC he might be back supporting us.

Comment on this

I was never a member of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

The Deputy was a civil servant in the Taoiseach's office.

Comment on this

I was in Mr. de Valera's office. He taught me a few things about politics.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We are prepared to believe that.

Comment on this

We must join the EEC if we are to survive economically. So far as the South of Ireland is concerned there is much to be gained from membership. It is known that Dunlops of Cork are to have a £5 million extension if we join the Community. In the event of our not joining, that extension will go to England. This would result in a big loss for Irish Industry and for Irish workers. There is a £20 million plant for Cork Harbour but that will never materialise if we do not join the Community for the simple reason that Cork Harbour would not be used should we remain outside the EEC. I could mention firm after firm that will benefit from membership. Any man or woman who considers our position will have no option but to vote "yes" in the referendum.

We are allowed discuss many matters during this budget debate. Several speakers have referred to the question of rates. We all know that the rate struck by each county council is very high. I suppose the Health Act is responsible for that to a large extent but hospitalisation for patients and increased remuneration for hospital staffs and for the officials of county councils and of the health boards must be provided for. Those of us who are members of local authorities must be prepared to stand up and say that it was we, acting for the people, who were responsible for striking these high rates. If we were to provide accommodation for all those seeking it and to provide everything that is requested, the rates would be much higher. Requests are made from time to time that health charges be covered entirely from central funds. That would act against the lower and middle income groups because it would mean that they would be bearing the entire cost by way of taxation whereas under the present system people are assessed for rates on buildings and property, and usually those in the lower and middle income group do not own large amounts of property.

At the beginning of my speech I referred to the increases being given to social welfare recipients. I might mention too, that those people are entitled also to certain reliefs regarding the payment of rates. It was left to each county council as to what they should do in this regard. Cork County Council did not adopt the system because they thought it would not include the many hardship cases that would arise. That was the right approach because there will always be people who get into difficulties and who will be unable to pay their rates. Such people cannot be turned out on the road.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy anything to say about Mallow Hospital?

Comment on this

Let the Deputy not worry about that.

Comment on this

Many people are worrying about it.

Comment on this

I have played straight.

Comment on this

What is "straight"?

Comment on this

Once again there is provision in the budget for a large increase for housing. This is a matter which must concern each one of us. Many advances have been made during the year in this field. It was a good decision on the part of the Minister for Local Government to notify local authorities that, when seeking sanction for schemes of four houses or less, it would no longer be necessary to send the schemes to his Department. Many speakers have suggested that the price of land for development should be controlled. It is my contention that, human nature being what it is, it would not be possible to control the price of land. I understand that a commission are studying the matter at present and that they are expected to make certain recommendations. Any law enacted regarding the control of land prices would be bound to be broken. If, say, a maximum price of £800 per acre were to be fixed one could expect that offers in excess of that amount would be made and that it would be likely that the person who offered the £800 in the first instance would return later to make backhand offers greater than the highest offer at that time.

The £800 might be given for legal purposes but the owner of the land would have received much more. Instead of trying to control prices in this way it would be better to allow for free negotiation regarding the sale of private lands. One way of solving the problem would be to extend the areas in which planning permission is given. We all know that the demand for water and sewerage schemes is not keeping up with the demand for houses. The various county development plans limit the amount of land that can be developed in each county but if they were to double the amount, we would be going a long way towards solving our housing problems.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

That is the only method of dealing with the matter. The availability of much more land would result in the prices of sites being reduced and it is the price of land that is a major contributing factor to the overall cost of housing building.

Comment on this

That has been the case in recent years under this Government.

Comment on this

Why have they not stopped it?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney Acting Chairman (Mr. Tunney) Fianna Fáil

Perhaps Deputy FitzGerald and other Deputies would allow Deputy Meaney to make his contribution?

Comment on this

I cannot see how the price of land could be controlled.

Comment on this

By providing adequate serviced land and not creating an artificial shortage as has been done under this Government.

Comment on this

That is what I have suggested.

Comment on this

Yes, but Fianna Fáil have not done it. That is the difficulty.

Comment on this

What I am saying is that county development planning permission is very limited.

There was generous provision in the budget for education. There is much talk nowadays of schools and I can say that in my constituency everybody seems to be seeking a community school. Deputations have been made to the Minister in this regard. The Minister has sanctioned most of the money that is required and we are grateful for that. Our education system is changing very much but perhaps detailed discussion of the subject would not be appropriate in this debate.

The economy of this country is sound. There is no use anybody saying otherwise. We all look forward to a solid wage agreement. Deputy Crowley said that the unions have come of age. The ICTU are to be congratulated on their handling of the recent power crisis. Congress should be backed in their dealings with breakaway unions or any such groups. We must have a national pay agreement. Once it is processed we want the various groups to adhere to it. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions should get every possible support. They have shown themselves to be a responsible body. It is vital to this country that we have good, strong unions under strong leadership.

There has been little or no criticism of this budget throughout the country. There are people who will never be satisfied but, generally speaking, it was well received. Our next goal is entry into the EEC. It is everyone's duty to vote on Referendum Day, and the only sane way to vote, if we are to survive as a nation, is to vote "Yes" on 10th May.

Comment on this
David Andrews Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. Andrews) Fianna Fáil

I should like to take up on the subject which was dealt with by my colleague, Deputy Meaney, in the last part of his speech and which has been referred to at some considerable length in this budget debate, namely, our proposed entry into the EEC and the vote thereon on Wednesday week next. Like Deputy Meaney, I would urge the people to vote "Yes" on 10th May.

In this connection it is difficult for me to understand how people in a position of responsibility to the Irish nation can advise people to vote against going into the Common Market on economic grounds. The White Paper on the Common Market, which sets out fairly and objectively the advantages and disadvantages of entry, make it totally clear that the advantages are so great economically that it would be little less than economic suicide to ignore this magnificent challenge. Again I pose the question which I have been posing throughout the country on Common Market platforms: how can the leader of the Labour Party possibly take the responsibility of advising his followers to say "No"?

Comment on this

Is that why the Parliamentary Secretary was suggesting the executive should impress on their workers—or was it suppress their workers—to voting "Yes"? He was so reported in the papers.

Comment on this

No. I was reported in the papers correctly. I urged managements who believed in our entry into the EEC to ask their employees to vote "Yes" to ensure the continuation and the extension of their employment.

Comment on this

That idea has a bad reputation in this country.

Comment on this

I also urged trade union leaders to ask their members to vote "Yes".

Comment on this

Supposing some employee told the executive to go to hell?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney Acting Chairman (Mr. Tunney) Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Donovan might allow the Parliamentary Secretary to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

He has made a suggestion which has a very bad tradition in this country.

Comment on this

I am not part of a bad tradition. I am part of a very strong tradition and I am very proud of that tradition. The Deputy ought not to put words into my mouth. Let him get the record right.

Comment on this

I have the record right.

Comment on this

He has not the record right. He has it all wrong.

Comment on this

I read it in the newspapers.

Comment on this

The Deputy is interpreting what he read in the newspapers incorrectly.

Comment on this

I wonder am I?

Comment on this

He wonders is he. Therefore the Deputy has doubt as to the correctness of what he is saying.

Comment on this

No, I have no doubt about it.

Comment on this

Of course he has.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

We cannot tolerate this cross-talk.

Comment on this

I shall subside, having made the point.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not make the point.

Comment on this

Indeed I did.

Comment on this

Perhaps you will move on to the next point.

Comment on this

When I want advice as to how I should make my speech I shall ask for it. I stood up here in a reasonable fashion, and the moment I stand up in this House I seem to get flak.

Comment on this

No offence was meant. I was not directing my remarks at the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am sorry. I just want to clear up this point in case there is any misunderstanding about it. I felt that as we were living in a democracy I had a right as a public representative to ask various sections of the community to urge their people to vote "Yes" on May 10th.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

All men are equal but some are more equal than others.

Comment on this

I do not have the Deputy's complexes in this context.

Comment on this

I have no complex at all.

Comment on this

Of course he has. You appeal to the personalities and the decent-mindedness of people. You appeal in a civilised fashion. You do not go up to a person and say: "Vote `Yes' or take the consequences." That is not what I was suggesting.

Comment on this

It read a bit like that.

Comment on this

That is the interpretation the Deputy will put on it, and there is nothing I can do about the interpretation the Deputy will put on anything I say. The Deputy will put whatever interpretation suits his own prejudices. This is part of the two-truth syndrome.

Comment on this

To me all men are equal, really equal, and nobody needs any advice as to how he should vote from his employer.

Comment on this

I also asked trade unionists in positions of prominence to urge their members to vote "Yes". What is so wrong with that?

Comment on this

That is still wrong.

Comment on this

The Deputy has the same entitlement to do that in his capacity as a public representative or indeed, in his capacity as a citizen of this nation. I do not ask anything other than that.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has a peculiar concept of democracy.

Comment on this

I have a correct concept of democracy, and I am exercising my right within that concept of democracy.

Comment on this

I shall subside.

Comment on this

With great respect, I wish the Deputy would subside outside. I do not want to bore Deputy FitzGerald on that point. I accept that the Labour Party and their leadership are as interested in and as anxious about the future of our country as we are.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I also feel justified in criticising their judgment. I believe there has never been a more politically inept judgment made by the Labour leadership in opposing the Common Market. I mention the Labour Party leadership specifically because I do not really believe it represents the beliefs of many of the members of the party itself and indeed quite a number of the rank and file of the Parliamentary Party.

Comment on this

It represents my view anyway.

Comment on this

The Deputy is one of the exceptions. I believe it is a national issue and that the economic future and hope for Ireland as outlined in the White Paper shows that it is a national issue, economically and socially. I believe that Deputy Corish's fear of Europe is obsessional. He not only refuses to go into Europe but refused to go to Europe when the Treaty was being signed.

There is another aspect of our entry into Europe that is being discussed in the context of the phrase "Common Market" to describe the EEC. The European Economic Community is much more than a market. It is a community of the most highly civilised nations in the world living together in peace after centuries of conflict. It is the Europe from which we have for too long been excluded, and to return to it is to end hundreds of years of exile.

I believe, too, Sir, that we have by history and propinquity been solely involved in the affairs of England for hundreds of years and our national energies have been dissipated in trying to rid ourselves of this connection. We have up to now not succeeded psychologically in breaking this connection. Too many of our institutions, trade unions, Civil Service and professional bodies are imitations of English models and are not always suited to our particular needs. I would go further and say that one of our most successful enterprises had to seek their inspirations and models and techniques in Europe. This is witnessed in our electricity supply which found its inspiration in Germany, in our peat development which found its inspiration in Germany also and in Holland and Denmark, our sugar industry in Czechoslovakia and one of the great native industries which we have, the glass industry, found its inspiration in Belgium.

I believe our intimate contacts with Europe and the manners and customs of Europe will expand our horizon for living a fuller life. It will extend our experience in the theatre, in painting and literature as we learn, as we must, one or more Continental languages, as say, the Dutch learn. We will have wider contacts in television and radio. It will, of course, widen our experience in sport and it may be that we will be taking as much interest in Ajax, or Juventa or Muenchen-Gladback as in Manchester United or Liverpool or Glasgow Celtic. Not many of our voters will be misled by the poor net judgment of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

You are giving a lot of attention to it, are you not?

Comment on this

Because, apart from your strange-allies, you are the leaders of the van against entry into the Common Market and as we are the leaders of the van in the context of the "Yes" vote, I think I should concentrate on it. You are our opposition in this context.

Comment on this

We were opposed to the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement and we have been vindicated up to the hilt.

Comment on this

You have not been vindicated.

Comment on this

Yes we have.

Comment on this

You have been vindicating yourselves up to the hilt for so long that you do not know where it begins or ends.

Comment on this

Tens of hundreds of people becoming redundant.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us how many jobs we will lose if we do not get in? Is that what the Deputy is saying?

Comment on this

I cannot tell the Parliamentary Secretary anything except the history of this country in relation to this kind of free trade area business. The long history of the union of Great Britain and Ireland and again recently in the Free Trade Area Agreement indicates one thing only and the people can get the message.

Comment on this

The Deputy will get the message on May 10th or 11th.

Comment on this

Fan agus feicimid.

Comment on this

Feicimid ceart go leor gan dabht.

Comment on this

Feicimid go léir.

Comment on this

There is just one other aspect that I should like to deal with. It has been used by the allies of the strange coalition that the Labour Party are made up of in the context of their opposition to the Common Market and a lot has been made of it by them, namely, the question of our national sovereignty. Expressions have been used, such as, "sell-out"; emotional, baseless, expressions, used as a headline to frighten people, to panic people—the "sell-out of our national sovereignty". I accept that national sovereignty in this context has assumed a new significance and I believe that it is one of the most important of our national issues and touches on the fundamental dignity of our nation.

However, we in Ireland are bound in our foreign and domestic policies by very real limitations of size, location and of trading possibilities. These factors are highly relevant to any discussion of national sovereignty in the context of the EEC. The EEC as it is now involves the sharing of sovereignty between six independent, democratic states in the specific and economic spheres covered by the Treaty of Rome. These member states have suffered no diminution of their national identity through being members of the Community nor is any applicant state likely to suffer any such diminution. The Dutch have become no less Dutch; the Germans have become no less German and the French, certainly, no less French.

The question of our national sovereignty has been abused considerably by opponents of the Common Market and of our proposed entry to the Common Market. Who is to say of the Germans, a highly nationalistic people, or of the French, a highly nationalistic people, that their concept of their identity, of their national sovereignty, has been eroded in any fashion by virtue of their membership of the Six? I can see Ireland in the same position.

Comment on this

Highly imaginative.

Comment on this

Let me paint the picture as I see it. The Deputy has made his contribution and has painted it as he sees it. It is up to the people of the country, in the final analysis, to judge who is right and who is wrong on May 10th. Does the Deputy accept that?

Comment on this

I do, of course.

Comment on this

That is very kind of the Deputy.

Comment on this

But let me say the Government have spent a lot of money and even gave a present to the Fine Gael Party in connection with it. Who has to provide the resources for the campaign against?

Comment on this

What present?

Comment on this

Ten thousand pounds.

Comment on this

To the Fine Gael Party?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Tell us more.

Comment on this

Have a bit of sense.

Comment on this

That roused you all right.

Comment on this

Most interesting. I have not seen the colour of the money.

Comment on this

I am talking about the European Movement. Do you mean to tell me you do not compose the Council of the European Movement? Of course you do.

Comment on this

Labour were in it too until they left it for a short interval. They will be back again on May 10th and very welcome they will be.

Comment on this

That excited you. It did that much.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy O'Donovan cease interrupting and allow the Parliamentary Secretary to continue?

Comment on this

I certainly will. I have already promised him twice that I will but the dish is so tempting that I cannot help eating out of it.

Comment on this

I have been saying, Sir, that full participation in the work of the Community does not imply a wholesale abandonment or, indeed, any abandonment of our national sovereignty any more than it does in the case of small member countries or any more than it will in the case of Denmark or Norway. Such limitations as may be placed on our sovereignty through our membership of the Community must be related to the reality of our present position as a small country with Britain close by, an independent state but one with a very limited capacity to influence significantly external developments which can affect us in the more important aspects of our daily lives.

I also believe that in the enlarged EEC, which will include Britain, it is certain that policies will be pursued and decisions taken which will vitally affect our national interests. If we were to remain outside this enlarged Community we would find it extremely difficult, indeed impossible, to safeguard our interests when decisions having a bearing on those interests were being taken by the Community. This is borne out by our experience of relations with the Community over the past ten years in so far as our agricultural trade with the member states was concerned. In the situation of isolationism in which we would find ourselves if we remained outside the enlarged EEC our sovereignty would suffer and our nationalism might well turn inward upon itself and become increasingly insular.

In this particular context I can see a truncated, isolated Twenty-Six Counties sitting on the outskirts of western Europe, with no future, nowhere to go. That is the reality of the position if we do not get into the Common Market. As I see it, within the EEC Irish economic relations with other member states, including Britain, will be conducted within a framework of common rules and indeed many of these rules, as Deputies know, are there at the insistence—at the insistence—of smaller member nations. Is it any wonder that the smaller member countries are the most enthusiastic about membership and most conscious of the benefits it has brought them? I suggest this is because they recognise that in pooling part of their sovereignty they have achieved greater use of it overall. It is clear that membership of the Community will increase rather than diminish our real sovereignty. Membership will present significantly greater possibilities than at present for action in our own interests.

We shall participate in the formulation of proposals for the Community as a whole and influence decisions on matters affecting this country and all the member states. Sovereignty is closely allied to the concept of nationality. Some nationally-minded people seem to assume that by joining the EEC we will be accepting Partition. There is no question of our being required to acquiesce in the division of our country at the price of membership. Can anyone seriously contend that staying out of the EEC while the North joins the Community with Britain would help the reunification of our country? When Britain joins the EEC the North will develop as part of the Community, but if we stay out there will be a situation in which the economic and social differences between the two areas will be intensified. Trade in all products, especially in agricultural items, would be upset by trade barriers.

On the other hand, the most obvious impact of EEC membership on the Border would be the removal of tariffs and other restrictions. By 1978 all Irish farmers, North and South, will be working under the same conditions. It must be obvious that membership of the EEC will mean the gradual abolition of obstacles to unity.

I hope that social welfare services will be brought into line on the basis of common European standards. Freedom for people in both parts to seek employment anywhere throughout the country will be established in full by 1978 and regional policy will be one of the major questions for the enlarged Community. Both parts of Ireland will have a common interest in the development of this policy.

It would be wrong to assume that membership of the EEC without further effort on our part will solve all our regional problems. The higher prices for farmers, the increased rural prosperity and the new factories, undoubtedly will be of tremendous value but the Government must, and fully intend to, continue and intensify their efforts for the development of the West. Their ability to do so will be increased by membership of this common Community, this Common Market.

Here I would appeal to the membership of trade unions in this country and to outline very briefly—and speakers who follow me will have an obligation to do so—the role of Irish trade unions and the role they will play in the EEC. I can foresee a tremendous outlet for Irish trade unionists in association with their brethren in Europe. I can see a wonderful opportunity for the rank and file of Irish trade unions within the enlarged Community. Here I appeal to trade union leaders—as I have appealed to management—to ask their union members to take the view that it is in their interests, in the interests of their families, and in the interests of future generations, to say "Yes" on 10th May. I do no more than urge and ask them to do this. In a democratic society it is my entitlement to do this; indeed, if one believes in it it is an obligation on one to make this appeal.

Membership of the EEC will not affect the present role of Irish trade unions in industrial relations and this may be one of the great fears of the trade unions at the moment. The principle of free collective bargaining will remain undisturbed——

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not think so; I think so. The two truths.

Comment on this

I said I do not think that this may be one of their fears. I would remind the Parliamentary Secretary that I have closer contact with the trade unions.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was taking the other line. I apologise to the Deputy; I thought he was saying something else. European trade unionists will welcome their Irish counterparts as they favour the further integration of Europe and, in particular, the enlargement of the Community. The International Confederation of Free Trade Unions and the World Federation of Trade Unions—two of the largest trade union confederations in Europe—favour enlargement of the EEC. They believe that the influence of trade unionism in the future development of Europe will be strengthened by the addition of the trade union movement in countries like Ireland. Trade unionists in Ireland share the same interests in making European institutions more democratic, in attaining full and better employment and they share the same political attitudes towards development of the Community's policy in the social and international relations field.

To those in receipt of social welfare —I should like to call it social security —I would urge them to take it that by voting "Yes" on 10th May next they will be improving and ensuring the improvement of their living standards. I can appreciate their concern about the campaign of outright dishonesty which is being conducted about food prices. It is of vital concern to people in receipt of social security——

Comment on this

On which side is there dishonesty about prices?

Comment on this

Let me put it this way: it is not on our side. I have been canvassing very extensively for the past week——

Comment on this

I want a House to hear the Parliamentary Secretary. Up to now there has not been any reason to call for a House but if anyone is accused of dishonesty there is only one sanction and that is to call for a House.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

Before Deputy O'Donovan called for a quorum I was saying that the campaign in relation to prices is one of the most dishonest campaigns ever conducted by any organisation or group of organisations against the actual truth in regard to prices. Certainly, there are price increases but there is no mention of price reductions with the removal of tariff barriers and so on.

A leaflet was circulated by the Common Market Defence Campaign which makes comparisons between Irish prices and alleged EEC food prices. I strongly underline the word "alleged" because these are highly misleading and dishonest. I intend to go to some considerable length to set out the prices in regard to certain items and prices as they stand at the moment in the EEC and the actual prices to this country when we do enter the EEC on January 1st, 1973. I think it was Deputy O'Higgins who mentioned the figure of 120 new pence. People asking the voters to vote "No", such as the Common Market Defence Campaign and groups of that kind, say that tea will be 120 new pence. This is an absolutely top-of-the-head, outrageous figure.

Take, for instance, 1 lb of fillet steak of which the present Irish price is 60 new pence. The price alleged by the Common Market Defence Campaign leaflet is 130 new pence. The correct Irish price when we are in the EEC will show an increase. It will increase from 60 new pence to 85 new pence. There is the difference between 85 new pence which it will be and the figure of 130 new pence which is being projected by the people who are asking the country to vote "No" on May 10th. The present Irish price of 1 lb of plain cheese is 20 new pence. According to the Common Market Defence Campaign leaflet it will be 45 new pence. The correct Irish price in the EEC will be 28p. The present Irish price of one pint of milk is 4½p and the alleged EEC price 8p. The correct Irish price in the EEC will be 5½p.

Another outrageous price, so scandalous in its concept that possibly I should not mention it, is the price of 1 lb of cod fillet. The present Irish price is 18 new pence and the alleged EEC price, á la Common Market Defence Campaign leaflet is 56p. The actual price in the EEC will be a mere increase of 4p as against an alleged increase of 22p. This is the type of any-old-figure-will-do campaign being conducted in regard to the projection of alleged prices on our entry into the Common Market. This kind of campaign could make people who might not be in a position to weigh and judge the situation in the years ahead get a false picture. The type of prices suggested are calculated, as I see it, to cause panic and fear in people.

I began by appealing particularly to those in receipt of social benefits to realise that whatever government— I hope and, indeed, I know it will be a Fianna Fáil Government—will be in power here if we go into the EEC, these people will certainly not be let down by voting "Yes" on May 10th. Quite a number of social security recipients have an immediate fear in regard to prices. That is understandable but it is wrong that they should be stampeded into voting "No" because of this false campaign which is being conducted in regard to price increases when we accede to full membership of the Common Market.

It is a wrong campaign, it is a mean campaign and it is a dangerous campaign because the consequences of a defeat for this country on May 10th are too horrible to contemplate. The social security classes will be one of the most gravely hit sections by our non-entry to the Common Market. I say this purely on the basis of reality, the reality being that here we have a Twenty-Six County Ireland, truncated, on the periphery of Europe, isolated, introverted, call it what you will, and we are asked to make the best of our lot with the tariff barriers, cultural barriers, social barriers and all the other barriers placed against us. How can we hope to survive on our own in that context? It is too horrible to contemplate. It is these people, the people I personally would be most concerned about, the social security classes, the handicapped, the less well-off sections of our community, who will be most damaged by this campaign against entry to the EEC if it is successful. I would ask them to take the view that whatever Government is in power—and it will never be a Labour Government in the foreseeable future —but whatever Government is in power, they will not be let down by that Government when we do get into the Common Market but they will be let down by those opponents of our entry to the Common Market. Let there be no doubt about that. They have been let down in the past by them and they will be let down in the future.

This is a small open economy, in the nature of things, by comparison with the great powers of the world. It is vulnerable to economic trends. One can imagine our vulnerability if we do not get into the Common Market. Quite a number of our difficulties are brought about by world trade and world trends but here we are erecting this massive tariff wall, if we do not get in, against the very community which will die and wither, namely the farming community. Quite a lot of this nation depends on farming. Farming does not just begin and end with a man ploughing a field or with a man owning a farm. The whole hinterland of any part of the Irish countryside—shopkeepers, hauliers, suppliers of grain, merchants of all descriptions, depend on the economic welfare of our farming community. One can imagine the tariffs being put against this country, one can imagine the economic stress being created for this country, if we do not accede to membership, and the damage done to our farming community and all the areas which rely on the survival of our farming community.

This decision had not been taken lightly. It is a decision which has been contemplated since the formation of the Common Market itself but has been particularly pursued since 1960-61 when Seán Lemass, one of the great leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party, decided, having set us on the right road to industrial revolution, in the right sense of the word "revolution," to set us on the road to Europe. It was he who applied in the first instance for membership. Mr. Seán Lemass, former Taoiseach, said it was good for Ireland to expose herself to the Common Market. He said it was good for Ireland to lift her tariffs against outside competition and brought about—I know it has certain defects and so on—a fair state of economic well-being arising out of his industrial outlook. If he said the exposure of industry to outside influence was good enough for Ireland, surely when he said that entry to the Common Market was "on" for Ireland we should accept that as one of the great leads? We can accept it in all the sincerity which that man had available to him. He had the good of this country at heart as was shown. He did not talk about it. He did something about it.

This tradition is now being carried out by the present leadership of the Fianna Fáil Party under our Taoiseach, Mr. Lynch. It has been traditional Fianna Fáil policy in no way, as some people, one might describe them as the emotion mongers suggest, to sell out on our republicanism or our republican ideals. They use the good names of Pearse and Connolly to bolster up their false case. Pearse was no isolationist. Connolly was no isolationist. These were men who thought about Ireland, fought for Ireland and died for Ireland and they did not want Ireland to be an outpost on the coast of the main island of Europe. These men were part of the European ideal because, after all, republicanism did come from Europe and we are rededicating ourselves in that sense to the European ideal of overall republicanism, if one can describe it as such. People who say that we are selling out are misrepresenting the facts. It is a most unfair form of debate to use names that can bring up very serious and deep emotions in the Irish people, to use these great names, these good names, these honourable names, to bolster and strengthen a weakened case. Let us get down to the real issues and discuss them on a rational basis rather than on an emotional headlining basis. A newspaper headline lasts as long as that newspaper is read and the day that it is printed—24 hours at the most—and if a person sees his or her remarks in headlines it is only a piece of self-gratification indulged in against the best interests of this nation.

May I come back to the budget and deal specifically with some of the more important items therein? I would say the budget has been seen by most Members of the House as one which does a lot for all, not least the group of people I have been speaking about, the social security recipients. They have been the concern of this Government for many years and evidence of the Government's sincerity has been proved by the amounts they have received during the years in consecutive budgets. This is not to say we are always satisfied with the amounts we have been able to give to the social security recipients under the various schemes.

For instance, we would like to see old age pensioners getting £10 to £15 per week which should bring them into the comfort in which we should like to see them. However, our priorities and the Exchequer rely on the output of our people and the Exchequer has a lot of demands on it. Therefore, we may not be giving them as much as we should like to see them getting and I should like to assure them they are the first priority of this Government from the point of view of the availability of money. That is only right and proper. The Minister has dealt with them fairly as successive Fianna Fáil Ministers have done in the past. He has given them free travel, free electricity and television licences, an innovation by a Fianna Fáil Government and there have been extensions of the schemes this year.

For instance, the Minister has stated he is increasing the free electricity from 200 units to 300 units per two-month period from October to March and to 200 units from March to October, the off-light period. He has extended the scheme to persons over 80, whether they are social welfare beneficiaries or not. He is to be congratulated on this.

Another matter the Fianna Fáil Government must take credit for is the introduction of parity for public service pensioners. The history of this has been long and I am sure the people concerned were wondering whether they would ever be taken into account. They have been now and it is another indication that the Minister was aware of the hardship consequent of their not having been taken into account.

In this respect Fianna Fáil have a number of committees dealing with matters of this nature. These committees present the Minister with their case. Members of the committees met the State pensioners in their respective constituencies and they are to be congratulated for the work they did on behalf of those pensioners. The Fianna Fáil Party as a whole were very strong on this issue. We dealt with it by way of resolutions and motions at party meetings and it is as a result of this demand, this pressure, that we have now brought about a fair and equitable solution in regard to Civil Service pensioners.

Once more the Minister has dealt fairly with the veterans of the War of Independence. He has decided to increase and to extend funeral grants and to allow veterans' widows to benefit by the free travel scheme. They were people who in the dark days maintained our freedom fighters and comforted them and there is no reason why they should not now benefit. It is only right that the State should not forget them because they were the power behind a number of good men. A large number of those women in their own right were members of Cumann na mBan but those who were not were married to members of the Old IRA and when the going was hard and the times difficult they supported them and gave them comfort. The State is now realising its debt to them. The funeral grant has been doubled in respect of the holders of special allowances by £50 from 1st April, 1972.

One other item I should like to mention is the position in regard to credit unions in our society. The Minister has seen fit to give them a considerable benefit, realising the very important part they play in our social structure. In the constituency which I represent there are a number of excellent credit unions. There are the Dún Laoghaire union, the Glasthule union and the Sallynoggin union. They are doing excellent work on behalf of the community by ensuring that people among whom they work do not fall foul of others who would make a profit from their hardship. That is one of the great benefits of credit unions. Many of them are in their early stages of development and the Minister has been examining the position. He has recognised their economic state by providing that operating surpluses will be exempt from income tax and corporation profits tax. The exemption will apply to existing unions from the date of their registration as credit unions. Here again the Minister is to be congratulated.

This is all part of the social thinking of Fianna Fáil which a lot of people who do not support the party do not take into account when they sneer at us. We have a very strong and independent sense of social justice. This is evidence by the fact that within the party—I have mentioned this already—we have many committees dealing comprehensively and in a dedicated way with the works of the various Government Departments. We have committees on social welfare, health, foreign affairs, justice, education and others. The committees are manned and complemented by members of the parliamentary party. They do a magnificent job by bringing from their constituencies various points of view to be discussed at committee meetings. In that way they are brought to the attention of the Ministers concerned and there are full discussions at parliamentary level.

In the nature of things, I would say the credit union provision in this year's budget is a perfect example of that flow and ebb within the party—ebb in the sense that something was not accepted and flow in the sense that it was finally accepted. This is the great merit of a democratic party like the Fianna Fáil Party, despite as I say, what some pundits would write about it. It is what is there and we as members of the Parliamentary Party, know to be there and the people of Ireland know to be there. That is what matters in the final analysis. This is the structure which I have described, which is there, is existing, is viable and is full of good health, I am sure our opponents will be sorry to hear that. These committees meet on a once a week basis if there is an issue which concerns any or all of the Deputies who are members of the various committees I have described.

Equal pay for work of equal value to the women in our society is another matter which concerns the Fianna Fáil Party as it does the whole apparatus of the Fianna Fáil Party throughout the length and breadth of the country. There have been quite a number of forums within the structure of the Fianna Fáil Party relating to this question of equal pay. I believe the principle has been accepted. I would see the cost as being a factor in the actual implementation of equal pay for work of equal value. However, this again is part of the democratic process which takes place within the structure of one of the great political organisations in this country or, indeed, in Europe.

It does not remain for me to hold up Deputy FitzGerald much longer. I wish to thank him for bearing with me in my short contribution, as it is short by comparison to other Deputies contributions. I am not that particularly concerned about who contributes the greatest number of lines in the Dáil. I am sure Deputy FitzGerald will add to his rating in that particular respect by his contribution. I concede that the Deputy has been consistent on our entry into the EEC and I hope he will develop at some considerable length his views on the catastrophe which will fall on this country if the vote is "No" on Wednesday week and this country does not accede to membership of the Community.

Comment on this

I shall, in fact, be dealing with aspects of the EEC, as they seem appropriate to this debate, at a later stage. It seems to me that first I ought to discuss the budget itself in the context of the economic situation and of the economic policies that seem appropriate at this time. The economic situation that faces us is unsatisfactory. It is best described in the OECD Report published just before the budget. In that report there is reference to the disappointing nature of recent performances. The report goes on to say that the 3 per cent average annual growth rate of GNP compares unfavourably with the Third Programme projection of 4 per cent and even more so with the medium term trend rate of 4½ per cent to 5 per cent suggested as a possible target in last year's OECD Review, or indeed the 5 per cent growth rate needed to achieve full employment in the eighties as suggested in the full employment report of the NIEC Report of 1967.

The OECD goes on to say that the slower growth rate has retarded employment growth. It comments that while there has been slippage in performance, as they call it—the fact that we have fallen behind targets, growth has been slow and disappointing—it has not entirely been the result of domestic causes, because of disturbances in Northern Ireland and the consequent political strains which inhibit tourism and so on. Nevertheless, they say when all this is considered, when the whole question of external problems is considered, there is still little doubt that domestic forces stemming from the common cause, rising inflationary pressures, contribute significantly to the deceleration and slowing down of growth.

It is important to stress this because although undoubtedly the situation in Northern Ireland has had an impact on tourism and to some degree on exports, and perhaps also on foreign investment, while these things are already having an effect on our economic growth the effects lie really in the future more than in the past. There has been, of course, some impact on tourism in the past three years. Some estimates have suggested that our national growth rates has been slowed down by as much as a half per cent per annum by the slower growth of tourism, in fact to what has been in real terms a decline in tourism.

This has been, perhaps, the upper limit of the probable effects and it does not therefore account for the fact that the performance of our economy in the past two years has been as poor as it has been. You have to look beyond the effect of the northern situation on tourism in the past to explain why growth has been so slow. The OECD Report is correct here and it is important to stress this because there is a remarkable tendency on the Government benches persistently to seek an alibi in external causes for any failures at home.

Of course, with an open economy like ours we are vulnerable to external factors but this vulnerability is a two way vulnerability. At times rapid economic growth in Britain particularly, and perhaps in other countries, can help us to achieve faster growth but at other times we suffer. As an explanation of the generally poor performance of the Irish economy it is inadequate and it is right that the OECD should draw attention to this and should not allow the claim, sometimes made by the Government, that it is all the fault of other factors outside, to go uncontradicted.

The impact of the slower growth over the last three years on unemployment has been one of the things which has concerned people most of all. It has been a considerable impact but it is not, of course, the only factor contributing to higher unemployment. On this the OECD Report has some interesting things to say. It refers to the redundancy problem which hit us last year and looks like being the same problem this year. It says of this redundancy:

By and large, the shake-out was a forced response to competitive pressures and a sluggish market.

It goes on to say that productivity increases in 1969 and 1970 were extremely poor while employment had increased. The result was the creation of redundant labour which is now being released in the face of rapidly rising wages and salaries. It is important to be clear on this. There have, of course, been redundancies attributable directly to the freeing of trade. It is possible to make some assessment of these. I have no wish to diminish their importance although I have warned over the past year or two against exaggerating the importance of redundancies in this period lest this should in some way minimise the problems that lie ahead. If people believe that all the redundancies that occurred in 1970 and in 1971 were due to the freeing of trade then given the scale of these redundancies they might be misled into thinking that the problem of redundancies caused by freer trade was behind us.

In fact, as the OECD Report points out the factors which have contributed to redundancies are, first of all, the stagnation of the economy, itself the product of the deflationary measures required by the inflation of the previous years, and also the fact that employers faced with surplus labour, faced with an increase in their labour force, which was very sharply increased in 1969—I do not recall any year in which labour force increased so rapidly by 6 per cent in industry —over-expanded in the expectation of a continual growth and with a sluggish growth since then this surplus labour situation has created a problem which has been severely aggravated by the increase in wages and salaries.

I have not seen this point so well made before. It is not simply a question of slower growth and deflation due in turn to inflation. There is also the fact that employers who might have carried additional labour in other circumstances have been unable to do so in view of the very sharp increase in wages and salaries which has simply made it uneconomic to carry labour through a period of stagnation.

There is a double effect here of inflation, making deflation necessary and leading to prolonged stagnation and shaking-out of labour. This fact, and the expensiveness of labour, make it necessary for firms facing costs they cannot carry to reduce their labour force. There is a persistent tendency in this country to fail to grasp the relationship between excessive rises in income and unemployment. I do not think one can overstate this. It may appear to be a simplification to put it as I am about to put it, but it is not an oversimplification. In this country we have as a nation made the choice, in recent years in particular, to pay ourselves, those of us who have jobs, higher incomes, thereby making ourselves less competitive, slowing down the growth of employment and condemning our children to emigration on a scale that would not otherwise be indicated.

The resources of this country can be spread among the existing population or, should we wish it, a larger population. We could, through measures of restraint in the growth of income and redistributive measures, providing adequate social benefits that would not mean a sharp drop in income for people temporarily unemployed and keep a much larger population in this country if we were willing to make the sacrifice. But we are not. We have the practice of sharing out the loot among those who have jobs and expanding our incomes at such a rate that, in fact, we make emigration inevitable. This is, perhaps, an unpopular thing to say. It is not the job of a politician always to be popular. It is the job of a politician to stay sufficiently popular to be able to say unpopular things. It is sometimes necessary to pose the issue in unpopular terms. In the last couple of years this has been more acute than before.

Our selfishness as a people in paying ourselves in jobs the whole of what is available and thereby squeezing out people leaving the land or leaving school and forcing them to emigrate has mainly taken the form of preventing people from getting jobs. In the last couple of years this policy has actually shaken people out, to use the rather unattractive phrase of the OECD report. By increasing our incomes so rapidly we have disemployed people. This is a serious responsibility on all of us. It is primarily the responsibility of the trade union movement, but not solely. It will not help to put the blame on them. The trade union movement in their attitude reflect the attitude of the community. They give absolute priority to incomes rather than employment and to raising incomes, even at the cost of emigration. It does so because it reflects the attitude of the people. There is an easy tolerance of unemployment and emigration. There is a particular attitude of mind here which is relatively unusual. In other countries there is not quite the same pressure for incomes or tolerance of emigration as there is here. This is a feature which has become more acute in the last three years. People are actually being put out of work by the excessive increases in income. That is what the OECD report says in plain language.

It is right that the attention of the House should be drawn to these harsh remarks, which are salutary. This all goes back to the initial failure of the present Government to cope with the problems of growth. They came to power at a time when the Irish people were rejecting policies of the past which had led to stagnation in the 1950s. These were policies closely connected with Fianna Fáil. There was the policy of absolute protection and the rejection of any movement towards freer trade. There was a policy of emphasising tillage rather than grass land. The rejection of these policies was the main feature of the First Programme for Economic Expansion. The Fianna Fáil Party at that time were faced with the disastrous consequences of the policies they had pursued to such a degree. The policy of protection may have been necessary, but I have many criticisms of the way Fianna Fáil produced and administered it. The policy of protection was good in itself. The persistence of this policy beyond the 1950s and beyond the point where every industry has been established, and the failure to reorientate industry towards exports—which was eventually initiated by the inter-Party Government by the establishment of the IDA and the introduction of the tax relief in the late 1950s—and the reluctance to switch policies when the policies had achieved all they could have achieved, all contributed to the terrible stagnation, depression and massive emigration of those years.

Faced with the disastrous consequences of those policies in 1957 Fianna Fáil accepted the advice given to them to abandon these policies or to reverse them. They did so with courage at the time and did not claim all credit for reversing those policies. This spread the load a little. They published the advice given to them and made it clear that the new policy was one which did not come from the ranks of the party but from Dr. Whitaker. That change of policy, although it achieved economic growth because it provided a much more favourable basis for such growth, did not do everything. The Government in power at the time, although well attuned to the initiation of economic growth, failed to grasp the scale of the problem which economic growth created and the kind of inflationary situation which could be created if they drifted along and did not reorganise the whole structure of society to meet the situation. The absolute absence of planning for economic growth has been the outstanding feature of Ireland in the 1960s. The time-scale for adjusting to the problems of economic growth has been incredibly long. There is not a country in Europe in which the lack of adaptability to changing circumstances has been as great as here. Regional policy proposals were first initiated in January, 1963. In April, 1972, we are still waiting for the regional policy.

There are rumours that the Government are about to produce a regional policy within the next few days. I do not want to condemn it in advance but I am sceptical as to whether that regional policy will match the need of the situation and face up to the scale and magnitude of what is required in this country to bring us into line with the other countries of Europe within a reasonable time. I doubt if the regional policy will match the opportunities for regional policies in the EEC. Will it be adequate to command from the EEC the kind of resources which an adequate regional policy could command? We will have to wait and see. If a regional policy is published within a few days, it is nine years too late. It took nine years to move from the point where an outline for regional policy was put forward in the report unanimously adopted by civil servants, the trade unions and management. Nine years later we are told that we will have a regional policy adopted by the Government. This time-scale applies to everything.

While preparing notes for this speech I was looking at the Devlin Report. My eye was caught by the date on the top of the report. It is over two and a half years since the Devlin Report was produced. In this House we have still to bring in the Bill setting up the new Public Services Department, which is the first step towards the reform suggested in that report.

No country whose pace of adaptation to change at Government level is so desperately slow can hope to succeed in a modern competitive society. There is no doubt that the public service with its great merits has no concept of the pace of modern events, no concept of the speed which is necessary to adjust to events in the modern world. There is no doubt whatever that the Government have failed totally to give an impulse of dynamism to the public service, to give a lead, or even to grasp the scale of the problems and the need for action. Indeed, the Government's role has been a dilatory one: putting off decisions year after year lest they be politically unpopular.

It is almost as if the Government, at times, have been patiently waiting to be put out of office so that the next Government can do the unpopular things. They have been slightly surprised and a bit upset to find they are still there and have to kick to touch for another two, three or four years while the country waits for action in these spheres. This is the kind of situation we have been facing in the sixties.

That slow pace of change, that failure to adapt, that lack of leadership on the part of the Government, and the incredibly slow pace of administrative adjustment in the public service, have contributed to many of our problems. Above all, in the sixties these failures have contributed to the growth of an inflationary situation which has few parallels in Europe. Few countries in Europe were as well placed as we were in the early sixties, moving out of a period of stagnation and into a period of growth.

Had we had the imagination and the vigour to adapt to these problems, had we seen the kind of changes that were needed, had we seen that if economic growth were to be sustained there would be a massive rise in land values in the cities, if the Government had enough wit and imagination to see that, we would have taken steps to deal with this problem and to acquire the land when it was cheap, when it could be bought for a fraction of its present price, and enormous savings could have been secured. Savings at the expense of whom? At the expense of speculators who have made such massive killings of millions and millions of pounds at the expense of house owners through the dilatory failure of this Government to face the facts that their own policies, if they were to succeed, must inevitably create a vast accretion in land values. That is just one example of how we failed to adapt. Indeed, there is no difficulty in finding examples.

In particular the Government failed to grasp the fact that economic growth in a country with our experience of stagnation was likely to lead to inflationary problems in the incomes sphere. Here we had the growth of the pressure of the rise of incomes in 1964 and the crisis in 1965 which came upon the Government so unawares that they had to come into this House in July and rush through a series of measures, some very ill-conceived and quite unrelated to the problems facing us, others making some impact on the situation. We had the deflation of 1965, the prolonged deflation which, like almost every other deflation that any Government introduced in this country, was allowed to go on too long and then the slow recovery which suddenly took wings and led to the excessively rapid growth in the economy. Then, at the end of the sixties, we had a further bout of inflation because of the failure again to tackle the problems of an incomes policy, the maintenance workers strike and the consequent rapid inflation of incomes, the new deflation, again prolonged for two full years and, over two years later, we are still in a state of relative stagnation, not total stagnation but far too slow growth.

By their failure to command the situation, their failure of imagination in not understanding what they were achieving in the sphere of economic growth, and in not understanding the problems this would create, the Government have got us into a stop-go cycle which is not only as bad as but worse than the British stop-go cycle. Britain shows some signs of emerging from her problems. We show signs of getting more deeply stuck into ours. As a result the growth in our economy is perceptibly slow.

If in a five year interval you allow a situation to develop in which the Government have to take deflationary action, and if that deflationary action halves the growth rate for a period of two years, you lose roughly one year's growth in the five. That is what we have been doing. It means something. The loss of one year's growth in five means that after a decade all our people are something like 8 per cent less well off than they would have been. That makes quite a difference.

I know the figures do not very easily convey the realities. A figure like 8 per cent does not mean very much on the surface, perhaps, but it can mean quite a lot in living standards because that 8 per cent need not have been distributed equally amongst everybody. Had we had that extra growth and had we then applied it—as this Government, perhaps, would never have done—to those in need, the living standards of the poor could have been raised very much above their present level.

The poor are a minority and, as a minority, the application of the additional growth we could have had but lost because of defective Government policies, could have raised their living standards very much higher. If the poor are judged to be one-third of the community they could have been one-quarter better off if that money had been applied to their benefit. If they are judged to be one-quarter they could have been one-third better off. It is a matter of simple arithmetic to make that calculation.

It is a matter of much more than arithmetic for the people concerned living, as so many of them are today, in conditions of great poverty and distress, contributed to by the failure of the Government to avoid the stop-go cycle which was avoidable. I do not want to detain the House by going back over a full account of the disastrous failure of the Government to grapple with an incomes policy at any stage. I have been over that before. The Government cannot shake off the blame for this. It is not good enough to say that it is all the fault of the unions or all the fault of management.

The fact is that at several points the Government had a suitable opportunity to give a lead and did not do so. The reaction of the Government to an incomes policy in the years after 1965, after the headline was set by the NIEC Report, No. 11, and the attitude of the public service—I do not exempt them; the fiction is, of course, that the public service are merely the servants of the Minister but with this Government it has been more or less the other way around—was to avoid taking the responsibility of trying to give a lead. The contribution of the Government and the public service to an incomes policy in those years was negative. It was so negative that it proved to be a discouragement to labour and to management which needed to be given a bit of a push along the road. They found themselves encouraged to stop short and do nothing by the negative attitude displayed by the Government and the public service.

This is a sad background. Where has it left us? It has left us in a position where in the year ahead our growth prospects before this budget were miserable. The variety of opinion expressed by different bodies on what that growth would be is, I find, a little entertaining and a little inexplicable. None of them offered a very cheerful picture. I am a bit puzzled by the fact that they vary so much. The Economic and Social Research Institute, in a report written very much in the aftermath of Derry and, perhaps, over-reacting to the effect of the Derry killings and the situation that seemed to exist in the immediate aftermath—the massive reaction in Britain against Ireland—forecast a growth rate of 1½ per cent. That was on the low side. They somewhat over-estimated the effects on tourism. We can say that now in the light of hindsight. They were excessively pessimistic with regard to the effects on industry and investment. That was their figure at the time.

The Central Bank, in their bulletin published just after the budget but written before it and representing their views before the budget was introduced, as I understand it, mentioned a figure of 2 per cent. The Department of Finance, in their report published before the budget, mentioned a figure of 2 to 2½ per cent. The OECD mentioned a figure of 3 per cent. So you take your pick. The OECD figure is puzzling and I should like the Minister to enlighten me on this. In their report they referred to the growth in the economy in 1970 as having been between 1 and 2 per cent. The official figure is, and has been for some time past in the various publications, 3 per cent. I wonder why the OECD got this very low figure for 1970? Is it because of this error, if that is the word, and that they have compensated by giving a very high figure for 1972? Usually the OECD figures reflect very much the thinking of the public authorities here at a point in time. Naturally, they take the advice and the views of the public authorities and on matters such as the likely growth rate they are inclined to accept those views. Certainly they are not likely to put in their own figures for economic growth in the year past at variance with national accounts statisticians in the Central Statistics Office. I find it puzzling that they should have such a different figure for 1970 and I wonder whether there is any connection between that and the fact that their forecast, too, for 1970 was as high as 3 per cent.

However, one can play around with figures and leaving aside the OECD figure which does seem a little odd— there may be some explanation for it —the expectation for this economy's growth in 1972 was more or less half that which in a normal year one would expect. That, for the third year in succession, was a rather disastrous situation and one that calls for action. In a situation like that an Opposition party have to decide the line they will take. Facing that situation it was open to this party to hold their fire, to let the Government go ahead with a deficit budget and then to come back and attack them for having, for the first time in the history of the country, budgeted openly for a deficit.

No doubt that would have been a good political tactic. I suppose some people would have gone along with us on it and said that the Government were being irresponsible. However, that is not the line we have pursued. What we did was to make a statement before the budget stating that in our view the situation warranted a deficit budget. In a sense we protected the Government's flank. We made it possible for them to budget in this way without endangering their flank and without risking an attack from us on the basis that this deficit budget was in some way a dangerous thing. That was a responsible act on our part. We made it easier for the Government to do the right thing and, frankly, we have found during the years that, unless it is made easy for this Government to do the right thing, they are very slow to do it. They are not a Government who have the courage of their convictions. They need a push in the right direction On this occasion it was appropriate to give them this push and I am glad that they responded.

Of course a deficit budget is always one to be watched with care. There are dangers associated with it. However, in advocating it we believed we were justified not only by virtue of the fact that in the absence of action to reflate the economy we faced a growth of only half what this country is capable of but also because that particular situation owed something to special factors of an unusual character and, one would hope, of a non-recurrent type. We accept that had it not been for the situation that has arisen in Northern Ireland the growth of the economy would have been faster, that it would have been back on a 4 per cent to 4½ per cent growth path. Recognising, therefore, that to some degree the inadequate growth of the economy in 1972, as it seems likely to take place, was attributable in some degree to the situation in Northern Ireland, that this was of its nature a special situation, the kind of situation for which one builds up reserves, it was our opinion that the Government would be justified in these circumstances in introducing, for the first time, a deficit budget with an openly stated deficit, taking the risk of an increase in the external deficit above its present level of £70 million which, a few years ago, all of us would have thought to have been a very high figure. We recognise that the kind of budget which, under our prodding, the Government have introduced is one which could lead to an external deficit of £100 million or perhaps more. That is not something we would welcome. It is a matter which the Government must watch very closely; but it is a risk worth taking in the light of the special circumstances in which we find ourselves, in the light of the high level of the official external reserves and, above all, in the light of the high level of the unemployment figures. Given the high level of unemployment in this country today for which there are many reasons, the first priority of any Government must be to try to get as many as possible of these people back to work. If that involves taking a calculated risk within reasonable limits it is right to take that risk. We were right in encouraging the Government to do so and they were right to have taken advantage of our encouragement.

Of course the deficit poses some dangers. My concern regarding it is that the stimulation given to the economy by increased expenditure in this budget, unaccompanied by increased taxation, is starting from a very bad point. I would have been much happier if the Government had had in hand a reasonable surplus to start with and that, therefore, if they got into that position, then, in deciding to spend more money and not to raise taxes, they would not have been left with the kind of deficit which seems likely to occur. I shall come back to the question of how big will be the deficit. I do not think it will be as big as the Government say. If this Government can be faulted, they must be faulted for having mismanaged our affairs so badly in the 1960s that at the end of that decade we were not in a position of having an adequate surplus in the current budget to give us a good point from which to start to reflate the economy. I shall have a certain amount to say about this because I think not enough thought has been given to this question in this country. It is true that in 1962-63 the Government in their publication, Capital Budget, adverted to the need to do something about this, the need to finance more of our capital budget out of Government savings, but they never did this. What the Government should have done, given that they got themselves into a situation of having to deflate the economy twice in the 1960s, was to have used fiscal measures to a greater degree than they did in those deflations, substituting them in part for other measures. They should have sought to meet the situation by increasing taxation and achieving a budget surplus thereby getting into a better position from which to reflate the economy thereafter. Their failure to do so inhibited the reflation of the economy after both of these periods of deflation.

There are a number of figures in this connection which are worth referring to but first I must make one technical point. There is a difficulty in talking about budget surpluses and deficits and that is that the figures that are shown in the finance account bear no relationship to those in the national accounts. I know that I am liable to confuse the issue if I talk in national accounting terms but from an economic point of view one has to consider the budget in national accounting terms. Unfortunately our finance accounts are an extraordinary medley of the results of past actions. The actual deficit or surplus shown in the finance accounts has no particular significance. This is due to an odd treatment of items—for example, redemption of the national debt and road improvements are items which are treated as being current although, of course, they are capital items. There is also the treatment of national debt interest paid by the Government to themselves in respect of which a similar situation arises. As against this, items which are not genuinely capital—for instance, the TB and brucellosis eradication schemes—are treated as capital although they are current. All of this was done by the Government at different times in the past for different reasons but it produces a very muddled picture and the actual deficit that results from treating some capital items as current and some as capital bears very little relationship to any rational classification of items between these two categories.

In national accounting terms we have a surplus in our budget. Our method of accounting in the finance accounts makes our position seem usually to be about £25 million worse than what it is; but, even in national accounting terms and comparing with other countries, the surplus we have been able to secure has been quite inadequate. In 1970-71 only £15 million was available in national accounting terms to finance net investment by the central Government.

Comment on this