Committee on Finance. - Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971: Report Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–200 of 805. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 30 of 1971 ›
To amendment No. 16 there are a number of alternatives and consequential amendments. It has been suggested that we should take amendments Nos. 16 to 24, inclusive, 28, 30, 31, 32, 47, 48, 50 and 51 together.
Comment on this
Might it not be better to take amendments Nos. 16 and 17 together? Amendment No. 16 contains the principle of the single rate of tax at retail level and is really the crucial one, although I think amendment No. 47 is consequential on it. The others are concerned with a different matter, the matter of rounding. It is true that in amendment No. 16 there is provision also for rounding but the main feature is the single rate of tax at retail level.
Comment on this
I suggest that we discuss them as the Ceann Comhairle proposes. We can have separate votes if necessary.
Comment on this
Yes, separate divisions. It has been suggested that amendments Nos. 17, 18, 20 and 22 form an alternative proposal and might be taken together.
Comment on this
They form an alternative in so far as they involve a somewhat different system of rounding but do not deal at all with the question of the single rate of tax at retail level because some of the rounding refers to the very tax which we are trying to eliminate in amendment No. 16. We could discuss amendments Nos. 16 and 47 and confine ourselves to the single rate and discuss the question of rounding on the others.
Comment on this
I suggest that there would of necessity be a duplication of much of the discussion and I think the other way would be better, allowing separate decisions, if we want them at that stage.
Comment on this
I do not mind very much but the single rate of tax and rounding are totally different issues. However, we can take them together.
I move amendment No. 16:
In pages 14 and 15, to delete subsections (1) and (2) and to insert:
"(1) Tax shall, subject to subsection (2) be charged at whichever of the following rates is appropriate in any particular case—
(a) 11 per cent of the appropriate amount of any consideration which relates to the promotion of dances and the delivery (if any) of goods and the rendering (if any) of services other than those specified in the First, Second and Third Schedules, in connection with dances, where payment of the consideration for such delivery or rendering is included in the consideration in respect of admission to the dance or is a condition of admission.
(b) 30 per cent of the appropriate amount of any consideration which relates to the delivery of goods specified in the Third Schedule.
(c) 5 per cent on the appropriate amount of any consideration which relates to the delivery of goods or the rendering of services other than those specified in the First, Second and Third Schedules.
(d) zero per cent of the appropriate amount of any consideration which relates to the delivery of any goods in the circumstances specified in paragraph (i) or (c) of the Second Schedule or the delivery of goods of a kind specified in paragraphs (vi) to (viii) of that Schedule or the rendering of services of a kind specified in that Schedule.
(2) Where goods which are of a kind specified in the Third Schedule and which—
(a) were imported, or sold in the State, before the specified day in such circumstances that wholesale tax was chargeable or would have been chargeable if that tax had been in force on the date of the importation or sale, or
(b) were imported or delivered on any previous occasion on or after that date in such circumstances that tax at the rate of 30 per cent was chargeable in relation to such importation or delivery.
are delivered within the State on or after the specified day by a person other than a manufacturer of goods of the kind so delivered, tax shall be charged at the rate of 5 per cent of the appropriate amount of the consideration for such delivery."
As these amendments are being discussed together, I shall have to deal with both the single rate of tax and the rounding of the amounts. I shall not dwell on the latter because Deputy Collins will want to speak on that in relation to his amendment and discuss the issue and principle of rounding more fully than I would wish to do. I am concerned with the single rate of tax.
The effect of this amendment would be to eliminate the present wholesale tax rate of 10 per cent which, in conjunction with turnover tax, means a 16.37 per cent tax rate, although, as I pointed out earlier that, in fact, involves a higher figure and more money than is involved in the present wholesale tax. A system that imposes two separate rates of tax is, we believe, something to be avoided. We also believe—I shall not dwell on this— that products like food should be excluded or derated. As this would cause some difficulties for retailers—though, by no means, the same difficulties as having two tax rates—we feel this is an added reason for having a simpler tax rate. To achieve this in accordance with the amendment set down would involve a loss of revenue to the Exchequer because it would involve charging goods that are now charged at 10 per cent wholesale tax at the turnover tax rate only. That is a strong reason against the amendment, but I would point out that the reason why the amendment takes this form, and why it does not make any provision to cope with the problem which would undoubtedly be posed for the Exchequer in losing this tax revenue, is that the Rules of the House and, indeed, I believe the Constitution do not permit us to make proposals involving an increase in taxation and we would, therefore, be ruled out of order if we put down an amendment in that form. I am, I think, permitted to say however that, as far as we are concerned, we recognise the need to maintain revenue and, were the principle in this amendment to be accepted with a view to securing a single rate of tax at retail level, we would be sympathetic to an appropriate proposal to secure additional revenue by other means. This would clearly involve some adjustment in tax rates so I would like the House not to take this amendment too literally but to recognise that the rules have necessitated our putting down an amendment which is really not in the form in which we would like it to be, and which involves an adverse impact on the Exchequer, whereas we fully recognise, as a responsible Opposition, that if you are going to have a single rate of tax and if you are going to have also, as we will propose in a later amendment, a zero rate on food and other products, adjustments would need to be made in tax rates to obviate any loss. What I would like to discuss, therefore, on this amendment is the principle of the single rate of tax and not the literal wording of the amendment.
It is clear that, if retailers and wholesalers have two rates of tax proposals, very severe problems will be posed for them indeed, especially because the borderline between the two is by no means clear. We have had representations from one organisation, the Irish Drug Association, setting out some of the products in question. I think these came up at the special committee where the point was made by us that, on the basis of that list, it becomes extremely difficult for anyone running any kind of business to make the necessary distinction. The whole business would need to be organised in a different way to achieve this.
The products that were mentioned were baby cream, which would have a tax of 5.26 per cent, baby powder which would have a tax of 16.37 per cent, baby food which would have a tax of 5.26 per cent and baby bottles and teats would have a tax of 16.37 per cent, nappy-liners, 5.26 per cent, but nappy-pins 16.37 per cent, magnesia 5.26 per cent and baby toilet utensils, not unconnected, 16.37 per cent. A system which requires a chemist to segregate all these articles on the basis of distinctions which are certainly not clear to me and not, I think, to the chemist, never mind the baby, is one which introduces unnecessary complexity into the system and the desirability of having a single rate of tax is immediately evident. One can take that position and, at the same time, believing that food should be zero-rated, a clearcut division in regard to food and things like newspapers and books should be easy enough to operate. Even if our other proposal in relation to certain other goods other than food sold by grocers is accepted the purpose of that is, in fact, to make it simpler for the average grocer's shop which deals in other articles like soap and detergents to operate, drawing a line roughly where the grocer's shop ends and another type of shop begins. We could argue the merits of that and I can see a case being made against extending the zero rate on food to other products. However, we can discuss that later.
Any lines drawn must be clear and simple. Where it is between zero-rating and two rates of tax it must be clear and simple for the retailer and wholesaler to be able to operate it simply. The rationale of distinguishing baby food from baby powder, nappy-liners from nappy-pins and baby powder from baby bottles and teats is something which is lost on me and I defy the Minister to produce a rationale which would come readily to the mind of the retail chemist so that, as he deals with these goods, he instinctively knows which one falls into which category. No such clearcut distinctions exist at the present time.
For these reasons it seems to me vital that there should be a single rate of tax and the demand for this from both the retail and the wholesale trade is overwhelming. There are, of course, problems involved. Of course, our system at present, involved in both a wholesale and a retail tax, does not easily lend itself to this without loss of revenue but we have put forward proposals, which I shall dwell on at greater length later, designed to meet this particular point. It is our view that this could best be met by having a single rate of retail tax which would need to be marginally higher than the present rate to bring in additional revenue and to compensate for the loss of zero-rating food and the single rate of wholesale tax which would merge the present two rates of wholesale tax into something like an average of the two. Such an arrangement could then be operated on the basis of trapping that wholesale tax at the manufacturing level and this would then reduce the number of taxes at retail level to a single rate of tax, plus, if our proposal in relation to food and other products is accepted, the zero-rating of these articles. From the retailers' point of view and the wholesalers' point of view this would be very much simpler and it seems to us that, although this involves signiticant changes in the incidence of tax, as these charges can be secured in such a manner as to benefit the poorer consumer and place the burden on the better off, the only valid objection to the changes in the incidence of tax connected with the question of a single rate of tax disappears. For these reasons we would press the Minister to accept the principles of the amendment by recognising that the amendment itself would need to be varied somewhat to ensure that acceptance of this principle would not lead to a loss of revenue to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I agree in principle with what Deputy FitzGerald has said. I am, however, more interested in my own amendments, Nos. 17 to 24, 28, 30, 31, 32, 48, 50 and 51. These are concerned with the rounding of the rates of taxation under the value-added tax system. Under the latter system our tax system will become more complicated. I do not think this is fully appreciated in commercial and industrial circles. I have been considering the structure which will emerge. We will have a zero rate of tax for some goods, a 5.26 per cent rate of tax for other goods and services, an 11.11 per cent rate of tax for certain activities, a 16.37 per cent rate of tax on goods not classified as luxuries and a rate of 30.26 per cent on certain luxury goods? This will cause traders a great deal of trouble.
There is a very good case for rounding off all these figures. I refer the House to the proposals for a value-added tax system in a paper laid before this House in March, 1971. On the section dealing with the manner in which value-added tax works it was stated that each taxpayer arrives at his liability by taking first the full amount invoiced by him for a chargeable period for taxable goods sold or taxable services rendered and by applying the rate or rates of tax appropriate thereto. From the resulting sum he deducts the value-added tax invoiced to him on his purchases of goods or services or borne on goods imported by him in the same period. This will necessitate a tremendous amount of accounting and accountability right along the line from the point of manufacture through the wholesale and retail levels.
I am satisfied that each business unit will have to have an invoice for each distinct purchase, setting out the prices of the goods to which will be added the appropriate rate of taxes for the various commodities. In the case of some firms working on a two-monthly period, there would be thousands of transactions involved. On the sales side the trader would have to keep separate accounts of the selling prices and would have to show also the appropriate rate or rates of tax charged on the selling prices of the goods. These would all have to be compiled every two months and the tax paid would have to be substracted from the tax received.
Surely the figure should be rounded off if only for practical purposes. By rounding them off as I have suggested, that is, from 5.26 to 5 per cent, from 11.11 to 10 per cent, from 30.26 to 30 per cent and from 16.37 to 10 per cent, a certain amount of simplicity would be introduced into the system in relation to invoicing. This would help in no small way to alleviate the administrative difficulties which this system will involve for traders. It will be difficult for a clerk in an office to make out invoices which will have columns for the various tax rates. Looking at the suggested invoices published by the Department it will be seen that this will lead to an expensive set of documentation. I know that part of the exercise of this system is to make it unprofitable for people to evade taxation. Under the value-added tax system each trader will be forced to keep proper accounts if he is to get the full value for tax he has to pay. He can do this only by offsetting the tax he has paid against the tax he has collected. This will force a certain amount of proper accountability. We in this party would not favour the evasion of taxes by anyone as was suggested by the Minister this morning. Such evasion would be very unfair to those traders who account for tax under the present systems.
I do not wish to delay the House on this point but I wish to emphasise again the logic of rounding up the figures. Admittedly the adoption of the figures I have mentioned would result in a loss of revenue to the Revenue Commissioners. I am aware that a reduction in the rate from 16.37 to 10 per cent, for instance, would involve a substantial loss of revenue but I merely wish to make it clear to the House that the principle I am advocating is one of rounding off figures for the purpose of facilitating traders in compiling their daily invoices. I do not think anyone can argue against the validity of that principle. It is not a matter of a trader having to pay 5 per cent to the Revenue Commissioners and, therefore, having to charge 5.26 per cent on his turnover in order to bring in this amount. This is the system operating at present under the turnover tax system which is a sales tax, whereas value-added tax is not a sales tax. Under the value-added tax system there will be a deduction from a gross receipt of tax. I do not know why these fractional figures were suggested in the first place. At the special committee it was suggested that the reason for them was to maintain the present structure of taxation. I do not think that the present structure can be brought to the second decimal place. That is going beyond what is reasonable or necessary.
Perhaps I am speaking for every trader when I say that they would wish to have figures which could be ascertained easily at the point of making out invoices. Instead of a 30.26 per cent rate I would not be against having a 33? per cent rate but, of course, I could not suggest that by way of amendment because it would be ruled out of order. A figure of 33? per cent would be easy to calculate. Again, in relation to the 16.37 per cent rate I have suggested a rate of 10 per cent. Perhaps a more realistic figure in this instance would be 15 per cent which would not be difficult to calculate either. The point is that it should be possible to incorporate a system of simple figures which would reduce the task of calculation for the traders at all levels and in particular at retail level. I ask the Minister to reconsider this question. During the sittings of the special committee, he gave no indication of being sympathetic in relation to the practical administration of this new system at the commercial and industrial levels. I am asking him now to appreciate the obvious difficulties and unnecessary complications which these figures will involve for traders and to accept rounded off figures.
Comment on this
This group of amendments, I think, provides a suitable opportunity to say a few words I want to say about the conduct of one of the members of the special committee. The Minister, at the end of the last ordinary meeting suggested that we should have a private meeting. Next day there appeared in the newspapers, obviously from a particular Deputy whom the Minister identified for us at a subsequent meeting, a notice that this private meeting had been arranged, and not alone that, but a statement as to what was to be discussed at it. I consider that conduct contemptible. Democracy cannot work if people behave like that. Democracy is at present being subverted and here we have a Deputy who pretends to be a great upholder of democracy and he behaves like this. But there were much more serious results than that——
Comment on this
The meeting to which the Deputy is referring is one of which the full minutes are to be published in due course and there was nothing private about it at all.
Comment on this
On the contrary, the Deputy is entirely wrong: no minutes were taken of it. There was no reporter at it.
Comment on this
The meeting at which the decision was taken as a result of which the accusation is being levelled at me was a meeting the minutes of which were taken and they are to be published.
Comment on this
Let me deal with this matter once and for all. If we are to have special committees——
Comment on this
It is necessary to deal with this matter once and for all. If we are to have special committees——
Comment on this
The Deputy already spoke on it this morning. He defended himself by telling a lot of fibs and untruths in the House.
Comment on this
The Deputy pretended he had taken up the argument with the Minister but that is not the issue. The issue is the disclosure——
Comment on this
If the Deputy is imputing that an untruth was told by Deputy FitzGerald it would not be in order to do so.
Comment on this
I presume what Deputy O'Donovan meant was that Deputy FitzGerald's statements were inaccurate.
Comment on this
I am raising a point of order. Perhaps the Deputy would not shut up but stay quiet while the Leas-Cheann Comhairle rules.
Comment on this
Yes, I have ruled. I said that if the Deputy said Deputy FitzGerald was telling an untruth it would not be in order.
Comment on this
I think the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is aware that the Deputy did, in fact, say that fibs and untruths were told by me here this morning. Therefore, I take it he will ask the Deputy to withdraw.
Comment on this
I am not going back on that. I stand over what I said. This morning here the Deputy deliberately drew down this on an amendment to which it did not relate——
Comment on this
It is neither because the Deputy misbehaved himself in a most disgraceful fashion. You cannot have this kind of thing in a democratic institution——
Comment on this
What the Chair has already said in regard to the matter is that if a Member imputes to another that he told an untruth then normally the Deputy concerned, when it is brought to his attention, withdraws. In this case the Chair understands that Deputy O'Donovan used this phrase "fibs and untruths".
Comment on this
There will be no withdrawal because certainly the Deputy misled the House or attempted to mislead the House this morning.
Comment on this
He did attempt to mislead the House this morning. He pretended the issue was what happened last weekend. That was not the issue at all. The issue was, is, and will remain his conduct the day after the Minister——
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy O'Donovan would withdraw any imputation of untruth if he made such.
Comment on this
If the word is required to be withdrawn I withdraw the word but I want to keep on my point. This was a special committee set up for a very good reason which we all know. They worked quite well and when they were finishing their ordinary sittings where a report was being taken, the Minister said: "Let us have a special meeting about the taxation of food, a private meeting." That private meeting was held last Thursday and there were no reporters at it but before it was held, a member of the committee dashes off, gets in contact with the newspapers, saying the Minister made that suggestion and it all appeared the next day that the Fine Gael Party had proposed that taxation be taken off food.
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald keeps on interrupting but he will not get me off this. He is not getting off this hook so easily. It was dishonourable and discreditable conduct and the result was—and this is what I am concerned about; I do not give a fig about Deputy FitzGerald scoring petty points—that when we met the Minister last Thursday his whole attitude had changed, perfectly correctly because his confidence had been disclosed in public and violated. It was a most dishonourable and disgraceful business. I do not care who did it: the Minister knows well that if anybody in the Minister's party did it I would say the very same things about him. I am damned if I see why I should not say them about a Deputy on the other side of the House. It was quite wrong——
Comment on this
The Deputy may discuss them till he is blue in the face. It was a discreditable and dishonourable business.
Comment on this
If the Chair would prefer I can talk at length on this matter on amendment No. 40 or amendment No. 41.
Comment on this
You bet I am, much more interesting. This special committee and the whole democratic system of Parliament cannot work if Members are going to behave in that dishonourable fashion.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that he cannot deal with the procedures of Parliament on this Bill now.
Comment on this
I could put down a motion of repudiation of the activities of Deputy FitzGerald on the matter but to be quite honest I do not think he is worth it. I would certainly do it with the greatest pleasure but it is not worth it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, could I ask whether an allegation that a Deputy acts dishonourably by disclosing the proceedings of this committee, which are printed and published subsequently, and in respect of which there is no confidentiality, is in order?
Comment on this
Generally, in regard to matters like this political charges are made by Members of the House from time to time. Where there are personal imputations involved the Chair always protects the reputation where a Member is personally affected but political charges are very often made across the House.
Comment on this
This is a real example of these "instant politics" about which I have frequently protested, dashing round to the newspapers——
Comment on this
If the Chair would prefer I could keep my remarks until amendment No. 40 or No. 41 because they would certainly be relevant then. May I explain to the Chair? The whole atmosphere changed and rightly so; I think the Minister was quite right; if it had happened to me I should not have been as quiet about it as the Minister was. He did not lose his temper but he certainly dug in his heels and he was not even going to consider our amendment. I shall deal with that afterwards. I can give very cogent reasons as to why we put it down. I think the Minister appreciates those reasons. The behaviour of Deputy FitzGerald on that occasion was not in accordance with ordinary common decency in political life. Nobody does that kind of thing. When the Provisional IRA were to meet Mr. Whitelaw they did not announce it, and neither did he. It came out four or five days later.
Comment on this
I have allowed the Deputy to make his point and the Deputy should now deal with the amendments.
Comment on this
In deference to the Chair I will leave the matter for the present. It relates primarily to the food subsidies so on the amendment dealing with the food subsidies I will say more about it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is too skilled a parliamentarian not to know that repetition is out of order.
Comment on this
It is very good to hear Deputy FitzGerald talk about my being out of order for five minutes considering the hours we listen to him repeating things which he has been told were wrong over and over again. I would put up with anything, but I will not put up with dishonourable conduct. It was a discreditable business that he should rush around to the newspapers that evening and say: "We of the Fine Gael Party have got the Minister to agree to talk about abolishing tax on foods."
Comment on this
I am in favour of amendments to round these taxes to even figures. I am aware of the Minister's argument on the special committee that it would not make that much difference.
Comment on this
What about the Provos? I thought the Deputy was at variance with somebody not so long ago.
Comment on this
I regard this taxation as a very serious matter. If the special committee were to work properly the Minister was giving it a real opportunity to do so when he suggested a private meeting. I believe the Minister. I take people as I find them. I wrote to the Minister about it and got a most cordial reply from him. In the meantime, Deputy FitzGerald had committed this crazy coot action. It was the action of a crazy coot individual to dash around to the newspapers and tell them we were going to have a private meeting, and what it was about. It would be bad enough to tell them that there was to be a private meeting of the committee but to tell them what it was about was most discreditable and dishonourable.
Comment on this
Part of the proceedings of the committee which will be on public record in due course when the printers get around to printing it.
Comment on this
In due course. Mr. Whitelaw's meeting with the IRA came out in due course also. It did not come out beforehand.
Comment on this
It would have been preferable to have the press at all the meetings. Then they would not have to get unofficial reporters to tell them their version of what happened and give the impression that not merely were there only two parties on the committee, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, but only two people, the Minister and Deputy FitzGerald.
Comment on this
It would be no harm if we did, and if Deputy FitzGerald would subside for a few minutes. He has to listen now. He has no option. Normally he does not listen. He leaves the House the minute he has finished speaking. There was an occasion not so long ago when he was pulling his hair out by the roots because Deputy O. J. Flanagan was called before him. I got in after him and Deputy FitzGerald had to listen. He was like a jerking Jehovah.
Comment on this
In the proceedings of the committee which have already been published the Minister said that an evening-off of the tax would not achieve what we wanted. He also said that what appears to be the case on the surface very often is the case if sufficient people come to believe it. I discussed this matter with a professional accountant yesterday, a man of some standing in the city, and he told me there is no question but that the rounded figures are the ones. I am not a professional accountant but I know a good deal about figures.
The ordinary trader will be appalled by a figure like 16.37, for example. The Minister raised great objection to having more than two rates. He said it would make it very complicated for the traders. There are many people who go back like a snail into a shell at the sight of figures like these. If the figure is 5 or 10 or 20 per cent they feel they know what it is about but the bulk of the people are horrified at a figure like 16.37. Therefore I am strongly in favour of these amendments to get the system on an even keel. I appreciate that computers and machines can be set to tick this thing out but there are many traders who not only could not afford a computer but could not afford any machine. These unfortunate people, having started early in the morning and done their day's work, will have to spend at least one evening every week, probably until 2 o'clock in the morning, trying to make their returns to the Revenue Commissioners.
The Minister and his officials may be right. I want to make a comment. We did not see a Revenue Commissioner during all of these meetings. This is of some importance. It is on the same topic as what I said about Deputy FitzGerald. It does not do the standing of a special committee of this House any good if no Revenue Commissioner appears before it. When I was a member of the Civil Service, during the budget debate the chairman of the Revenue Commissioners was always here and so was the secretary of the Department of Finance. Nowadays I notice they are here on the day of the big show, the day the Minister reads his budget speech, and then they "vamoose" and some juniors are put in instead of them. I do not mean any disrespect to those men. I simply mean that the senior men disappear. I do not think they even wait for the motions to put the taxes into operation to be dealt with. They go immediately the Minister finishes speaking. What I am doing is trying to defend democracy.
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald was suspicious of the Prisons Bill and then he voted for it. I have no use for lip-service democracy. I believe in democracy and I have always believed in it. If the private proceedings of a special committee are to be reported in advance to the newspapers they cannot function. The special committee did not function that day. That may appear to be a reflection on the Minister but it is not intended that way. I do not blame the Minister for making up his mind that he had enough of that kind of thing and that he would not put up with it. You cannot have a discussion in private and in public at the same time.
These amendments are all being taken together, I am glad to say. There is a plethora of them. It seems to me that they are reasonable from the point of view of how they will appear to the public. You work this thing in fives: 5, 15, 30, something like that. I will leave what I was going to say in relation to the scheme which got so much publicity for Deputy FitzGerald and the Fine Gael Party to be dealt with on the amendment relating to tax on food. I have said what I want to say on these amendments and I am strongly in favour of them.
Comment on this
I should like to hear the Minister's comment, if he does not mind coming in before me. Deputy FitzGerald will be concluding.
Comment on this
In that case it is only fair to the Minister that I should make my comment, which will be brief. Like Deputy O'Donovan, I feel that there should be a rounded off figure. I have been looking through the report of the debate in an effort to find the relevant portion where the Minister referred to the countries which were already charging value-added tax. I am afraid there was a difference of opinion in the special committee about some of the rates of tax. Eventually we ironed out what exactly was happening in the countries referred to. I mentioned in the early part of the afternoon that while the Minister quoted The Netherlands as being the country on which we were basing our tax system——
Comment on this
"Basing" is the word I used — he seemed to think that in Sweden there was also something worth following. I found going through the report that somebody had done a pretty good job of selecting the tough systems and trying to incorporate them in ours. This was a wrong idea. As to the number of rates of taxes being used, the Minister said that in one country there were four rates being used. It turned out that only two were in operation, the other two did not count very much.
The Minister has been insisting that it is necessary to go to two places of decimals for the purpose of having an accurate tax here. Of the countries on which he has been basing his system none has done so. With one exception, all European countries have a rounded off system of tax. There is one country using one system only. That is, of course, a high rate. I do not think any of us would be satisfied if we chose that one, because the rate is too high.
I do not want to go over the ground so well covered by Deputy O'Donovan and I do not want to quarrel with Deputy FitzGerald in this House or any where else. Perhaps it does not do us any good. I also believed that a mistake was made. When the Minister asked for a private meeting to discuss a matter which was mentioned to members of the committee, it was a pity that meeting did not remain a private meeting until the matter was discussed. Afterwards the press and the general public would have had available to them what we had decided to do. In the early days I could see no reason why the press were not allowed to be present at our meetings. It was pointed out that we would have more freedom to express views. This was agreed. In those circumstances I do not think it is fair that a slanted version of what happened should have appeared. I have great respect for the gentlemen of the press. We have to when we are in public life. Perhaps if I had put in a version I would have slanted it towards myself although I do not think I would. A slanted version was given to the press. It appeared as if nobody took part in the discussions—there was one reference to the Labour Party—except Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil and Deputy FitzGerald.
One of the things that I had been referring to on a later amendment which Deputy Collins asked about was, perhaps, the most important matter raised at any of the meetings. I believe that he and a number of other Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil members, possibly because the press were not present, were prepared to express the view held by the Minister and the Revenue Commissioners at the committee meeting. This was done. I do fear for the future of special committees. If I take part in future committees either the press will be present or a statement will be issued. It is most unfair to those who work so hard to get things done to find that the general public were given the impression that nobody except the Minister and Deputy FitzGerald took part in the debate. We would not be raising the matter here but for the fact that it has been brought to our notice by the general public. In fact, I was given credit for a little point, that I was interested in taking the tax off school books, but he added "only". Having regard to the fact that Deputy O'Donovan's and my amendment dealt with the tax on food, that was a little bit thick, even for Deputy FitzGerald.
The Minister's argument, that it is necessary in order to have the amount of tax which is to be collected as even as possible to what is being collected at present under existing taxes, two decimal points must be used, is an argument that I am not prepared to accept. At a special committee meeting on 21st June the Minister said:
By taking 5 per cent. of 105.26, we collect precisely the same amount as is collected under turnover tax at the moment, which is 5 per cent on a tax inclusive basis. The VAT is on a tax exclusive basis. That means that if goods are sold at 105.26 and if you take 5 per cent as being the amount of the tax, that works out at 5.26, which is the amount of the tax.
What the Minister was saying is that 5 per cent is what is being collected under the turnover tax. Can the Minister find anything wrong with the system under which the turnover tax is being collected? If it is all right to collect it at the even 5 per cent now, why is it necessary to change to 5.26? The same applies to the other rates of tax. If the effect is the same, why not leave it as people understand it? There are persons in the Revenue Commissioners office and in this House who cannot visualise the position of a small shopkeeper trying to estimate what a 5.26 tax on 35p or 36p comes to. There are people, even in the House, who would have difficulty. I do not know how the customers will find out whether or not they are being treated fairly. In a craze to have things absolutely right and because the Revenue Commissioners want to prove that they are doing what they feel should be done, they have introduced these little refinements which have caused so much trouble.
I quite agree with Deputy FitzGerald that a single rate of tax would be ideal. The Minister said it could not be done. He also says that if we have zero tax rating this is, in fact, another tax. We disagreed on that before. We will disagree again. Would the Minister not agree that it will be extremely difficult for somebody going to the supermarket where there will be a little girl at the check-out point who must calculate the price of the commodities bought and decide whether the tax is at 5.26 per cent or 16.37 per cent, in addition to the price?
When I asked the Minister did he think this difficulty could be got over the Minister came back with the rather pat answer, which does not fit in, and his suggestion was that possibly something that had been suggested to the RGDATA earlier could be adopted, that the tax could be put on at shelf prices for the 5.26 and, therefore, there would be only one rate of tax to be watched by the girl at the check-out.
The Minister must know that if you attempt to put on tax at shelf prices— and I know it is done already by those who put up a sign in the window saying: "No turnover tax collected here," because they must get it in some way—the item which costs only a few pence will have added on to it the lowest amount of tax that can be put on, that is, the new half penny. If you put a new half penny on to something which costs two, three, four, five or six pennies, does the Minister not realise that that is far in excess of the amount of tax? Therefore, the obvious way to put on the tax is to do it at the check-out where the entire bill can be put together.
However, if that is done, how do you get over the two rates of tax? I am quite sure the Minister will, some time before the Bill finishes, come back with the story that he used when the decimal currency was being introduced: "It is all right. The traders can take the tax off one item and add it on to another and the average will work out all right." There are two things wrong with that: No. 1, it will not work on a small item being bought and on which a half new penny will be much higher than the proper rate of tax; and, secondly, what happened when decimal currency was being introduced and when there was talk of reducing the price of one item and increasing the price of the other? Our friends, the traders, in many cases reduced the price on the slow-selling item and increased the price on the fast-selling item, and we know who made the money then. This is a problem which I do not think it is easy to deal with, and I am not asking the Minister just to wave a wand and decide it.
Comment on this
The Deputy will accept, I presume, that it is not a new problem under VAT, that it will be precisely the same position as at present.
Comment on this
The Minister is wrong there, because, while I am prepared to agree it is a problem under VAT, the Minister is creating a bigger problem by making the tax 5.26 per cent instead of 5 per cent. I am sure he agrees this is a new problem of his creation.
Comment on this
It is not. If it is, why have the other European countries that are operating VAT gone for the rounded tax rather than for tax running to two decimal places? Or are we the smartest race? If so, we should have been in Europe long ago and taken over. There must have been some reason for it, and I believe the reason for it is that the Revenue Commissioners believe they are smarter than anyone else in Europe and are going to show the rest of Europe how things should be done. They may be very clever people but I think they are making a mistake.
I suggest to the Minister that the introduction of 5.26 is a mistake, and, as regards the introduction of a second rate of tax, 16.37, to suggest that anybody can easily work that out is a mistake for the Minister. I know quite well the Minister will say: "It is the same thing except that it is the difference between tax exclusive and tax inclusive," but you cannot tell that to the country grocer, because he is the man who will have to operate it. I believe that eventually it will show a higher rate of tax all round, that when the goods are being finally bought they will be bought at an excessive price, that there will be a small extra cost added on. In addition to that, the customer is the person who will have to pay the tax anyway, because all the people who have handled the goods before him will collect it from him. For that reason, if for no other, the arrangements should be as simple as possible. It should be a single rate of tax or, if that is not possible, it should be rounded off so that those who are handling it would be able to understand what exactly they are doing.
Comment on this
I have three main items to deal with arising out of the discussion on these amendments. First, on the remarks which have been made about the meeting of the special committee, that is, the unofficial meeting, if I may call it that, I do not wish to comment at all. I think the Labour Party Deputies have expressed their point of view and I assume that Deputy FitzGerald is about to express his when he gets in to reply.
Comment on this
I do not wish to comment on that except to say that I think Deputy O'Donovan and Deputy Tully are long enough in politics now not to be taken aback too much at what happened. Indeed, they are showing that if they were a little taken aback, they know very well how to deal with a situation like this. I do not want to comment any further except to say— and it is an obvious comment but one which it would be peculiar if I did not make—that the whole performance bodes very ill for the projected Coalition.
Comment on this
I am trying to restrain myself. The Deputy will appreciate that if I wished I could go to town on that point. I have no desire to do so. I do not think it needs to be underlined.
Comment on this
The Minister appreciates, just as Deputy Tully and myself do, that Deputy FitzGerald is a Johnny-Come-Lately in all this business.
Comment on this
Yes, I do. If I may get to the other main matters I have to deal with, the question of rounding, on the one hand, and, in effect, the concept of trapping tax at wholesale level which is inherent in the first amendment proposed by Deputy FitzGerald. On the question of rounding, there seems to me to be still a good deal of misconception. The first misconception is this: Deputy Tully still believes that in the other countries which apply value-added tax they do not have these odd rates, but he is not right in this. If I may burden the House for a moment with some examaples: France has rates of 7.5, 17.6, 23 and 33.3; Belgium has whole numbers; Germany has 5.5 and 12 per cent; The Netherlands has whole numbers, 4 and 14 per cent; Luxembourg has 5 and 10 per cent; Sweden has 17.65 per cent, which is to two decimal places.
Comment on this
One rate, but I am dealing only with the relatively minor point, at the moment, as to whether or not other countries have odd rates or rates to two decimal places.
Comment on this
The French rates are not nearly as awkward as the Minister is pretending. A rate of 33.3 is one-third.
Comment on this
I can see that. I am merely dealing with what I regard as a very minor point. What is a major point in all this is that Deputy Tully, despite all the discussion we have had on this—and they have been lengthy —does not seem yet to have grasped why we have these peculiar-looking rates here, because he asked whether the Revenue Commissioners think they are smarter than anybody else in Europe. The real point as to why we have these odd-looking rates is that they are as close as we can get to the existing rates. For instance, the 5 per cent turnover tax is exactly the same as the 5.26 value-added tax. Therefore, when Deputy Tully talks about the problem, and it is a problem, of applying tax to a small item and where the smallest amount you can add is half a new penny, he is talking about what is a genuine problem but he is not talking about a new problem or about a problem arising under VAT. This is a problem arising at the moment under turnover tax because it is precisely the same level of tax as will be charged under VAT.
Comment on this
I do not quite get the Minister's point on this. This whole thing is going to be submerged by inflation and the Minister knows that as well as I do.
Comment on this
That is another point. I am speaking from the point of view of the shopkeeper and the consumer.
Comment on this
——that what he said is not necessarily a good or valid case for a multi-fractional VAT system such as 5.26 per cent, which I think is one rate at the moment.
Comment on this
I had not completed my argument. The point I am making, and it is a very important point and relevant to this whole discussion, is that the rates which are proposed are arrived at on the basis of existing sales taxes. This means that, in the case of a customer going into a shop to purchase something which is subject to turnover tax at the moment, but not subject to wholesale tax, he should pay precisely the same price after VAT as before because the tax will be exactly the same. The amount of tax collected by the Revenue Commissioners on the particular item is exactly the same. Unless one grasps that basic fact, one can go completely wrong and can certainly say that having rates which go to two decimal points does not make sense. We would not have contemplated these very strange-looking rates but for the fact that I was determined that we were not, by introducing VAT, going to provide an excuse for increases in prices because, in so far as the consumer was concerned, the consumer who goes in, after VAT comes into force, to buy £1 worth of groceries should get, other things being equal, exactly the same as before because the tax will be exactly the same.
Comment on this
Let us say that we took 5 per cent instead of 5.26 per cent. What we would be doing then is, first of all, reducing the amount of tax collected on particular items and then finding ourselves faced with raising that amount somewhere else—that is problem No. 1, where do you raise it? —and secondly, from the point of view of the customer going into a shop, does Deputy O'Donovan or any other Deputy believe that by reducing the rate to 5 per cent the cost is going to go down? I do not believe it.
Comment on this
I will come to the shopkeeper in a moment. I am speaking now from the point of view of the customer, the man-in-the-street, going into a shop. If we reduce the rate from 5.26 to 5 per cent do you think he is going to pay a lower price? I do not. As it is, with 5.26 per cent he will pay exactly the same as under turnover tax now.
Comment on this
I do not know how much clearer I can make this point but I think it is essential to grasp it, that we are proposing 5.26 per cent VAT because it is the precise equivalent of 5 per cent turnover tax. To the man-in-the-street, the important thing is that he is paying exactly the same, not more or less tax nor more or less for the goods, so that there is no disturbance in the price of the goods.
Comment on this
He will pay more every day that passes owing to the huge inflation which is going to submerge the whole thing.
Comment on this
That is another point, but on the question of rounding, which is what we are discussing on these amendments the fact is that if the man-in-the-street finds that as a result of changing to VAT the price of the commodities he buys in a grocery shop are the same, that the tax is not changed even though it looks different, he is not concerned in working out 5 per cent or 5.26 per cent. If the price does not change, that is what he is concerned about. This is unanswerable from the point of view of the customer.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister ought to be so concerned with logic. It is not a matter of logic.
Comment on this
I think it is. I think that from the point of view of somebody paying in a shop, it is very real. If the price of his goods goes up or alternatively, there is a reduction in tax but the price does not go down, that is very real from the point of view of the man-in-the-street—the customer. I am quite convinced that from his point of view the case for having a 5.26 rate instead of 5 per cent as suggested is unanswerable but from the point of view of the shopkeeper the situation is different. The argument is made that this is going to present enormous problems from the shopkeeper's point of view because calculating on the basis of 5.26 per cent is very difficult, compared with 5 per cent.
Comment on this
This is a plausible argument. I am taking this 5.26 per cent rate because it illustrates it best but the arguments I am making apply in fact to the other rates too, with qualifications.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that so far as the shopkeeper is concerned, it may look as though the thing is going to be far more difficult for him, but let us examine what is involved. First of all, if you take 5 per cent instead of 5.26 per cent, this involves a more simple calculation but, conversely, it produces a figure for him in calculating his actual tax liability to the Revenue Commissioners of something like 4.762 per cent on a tax-exclusive base, so that whatever you do—if you round the rates in the Bill—you produce uneven rates for the shopkeeper in calculating his liability to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
Could I point out, on a point of clarification—in the circumstances here, I have no right to reply but I should have—under the system a manufacturer, retailer or wholesaler will deduct from the tax he collects the tax he pays and give the balance to the Revenue Commissioner? This does not involve him in any fractional computation.
Comment on this
How does he know? Surely he has to take it on the basis of his sales and purchases. There is no other way to do it. He subtracts the tax on one from the tax on another and the difference is the tax.
Comment on this
Wholesalers and manufacturers have endless multiplication sums to do to two decimal points.
Comment on this
I am coming to this, but the fact is that he does have to do this calculation with this odd figure but if you make the rates in the Bill even——
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Deputy and perhaps he would let me put my arguments. What I am trying to put across is not so complex but the Deputy seems to think it is and perhaps the Deputy might give me the opportunity to do it. He will have an opportunity to reply. It is very important that this should be understood by Deputies as to what this involves. So far as the shopkeeper is concerned —and as I said, this is the negative side of it—if he has an even figure of 5 per cent to charge, he has to do a calculation with a very odd number to calculate his tax, some figure running to three decimal points. That is the first point. The second point is that, when you analyse what is involved for the shopkeeper, you find, first of all, that he will be issued by the Revenue Commissioners with a ready reckoner which will show at a glance in regard to all the figures he will be dealing with what the tax is. He does not have to calculate. He just has to look up the ready reckoner.
Thirdly, any shopkeeper in the course of time becomes very used to the items he is selling. Even with a fairly wide range he knows what the goods cost him, what he sells them for and what his profit is. He knows this by force of habit. He is ordering the same goods month after month and, for the vast bulk of his range of goods, he is very familiar with all this. The result is that, in the course of time, for the vast bulk of his goods he will not even have to look at his ready reckoner. These arguments are equally true of the wholesaler and the manufacturer. I am just adding that in. I am describing it from the point of view of the retailer who seems to me to be the person most likely to have these problems of calculation.
For those who are in a bigger way of business and for whom the thing could be complex, most of them, if not all, will in fact use machines to do this calculation and there will virtually be no difference for them what ever rate you make or how many decimal points there are because the machine will be set to do the calculation. I do not think we need worry about these people. The people we need to think about are those who have no machines and who will have to make their own calculation. I suggest people will not have to calculate a rate of 5.26 per cent on something; they will just look at a ready reckoner. When you look at this, and when you analyse it, you realise that the suggestion of a shopkeeper sitting up until 2 o'clock in the morning doing all these calculations just does not stand up. The arguments for altering these odd figures—the 5.26, the 11.11, the 16.37 and so on—based on the difficulties involved for people in making calculations just do not stand up.
We come back then to the question: why have these rates? Why not have even numbers? I come back now to the first point I made. It is a point I should like everyone to understand. We have them because they are the closest mathematical equivalent we can get to the present taxes. I want to ensure that, when value-added tax comes in, there will not be a change in the rate of tax so that a person going into a shop will not be faced with the situation in which, if the price is increased, the shopkeeper can say the increase is due to value-added tax. I want customers to be in a position to know that, if anyone increases prices and says the increases are due to value-added tax, the customer can say that is not so and it can be investigated.
Comment on this
They will say it anyway. I have been told time and again in shops that this increase and that increase is due to the Government. I knew very well that it was not.
Comment on this
Would the Minister answer a question from me? The Minister has been asserting the extreme importance of keeping the tax rates the same.
Comment on this
The Minister can hardly say that a rate of 16.37 per cent is as near as is mathematically possible equivalent——
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain how he can justify his statement in the light of the 16.37 per cent tax rate?
Comment on this
I have already done so in the special committee and I shall not go into it again. It is on record and there is no point in wasting the time of the House.
Comment on this
There is no contradiction. If the Deputy looks up what I said the Deputy will find there is no contradiction whatever because I phrased my argument very carefully.
Comment on this
The Minister is in possession. He may speak only once. The same applies to Deputies except that the Deputy who moved the amendment has the right of reply.
Comment on this
I will just say about the £3½ million mentioned by Deputy FitzGerald that he knows this is going back to the taxpayer and not to the Revenue Commissioners. It is for these reasons that I am opposed to the amendments which suggest the rounding of the figures. I believe that the alleged advantages are illusory and the practical effect would be to provide an excuse for changes in prices, whether up or down, but mainly up, and the customer would not know what was right and what was wrong. Under this system the customer will know that the value-added tax system is not providing an excuse for increasing prices and it can, therefore, be much more easily checked on.
On the other main issue raised in Deputy FitzGerald's amendment, what is involved here is, of course, tied in with a later amendment and the proposals which got publicity in the newspapers, to which the Labour Deputies referred; the principle involved in this is involved in that too. This is the principle of trapping part of the tax at the wholesale level. There are a number of objections to this approach. It emerged this morning in discussion on another amendment that Deputy FitzGerald was under the impression that the value-added tax on building materials, and so forth, would, in fact, be paid back to the traders. It will not. I think that misconception of his is built in to this proposal also but, leaving that aside and accepting that the loss of £3 million revenue on motor cars, radios, televisions, et cetera, would not be made up within the value-added tax system and would have to be made up somewhere else, even allowing for all that, we find that the rates suggested by Deputy FitzGerald are not sufficient. I am in some difficulty here in that I am in danger of spilling over into a discussion on the other proposals.
Comment on this
I thought we were to deal with trapping when we came to the zero rating on food and other proposals.
Comment on this
No more than is trapped at present, but the basic idea of the single rate at retail level does involve trapping.
Comment on this
It is not possible to have a single rate at retail level without trapping. My difficulty is that, if I do not deal with it now, I will not, in fact, be dealing properly with Deputy FitzGerald's amendment. On the other hand, if I do deal with it, it will come up again later and I do not want to be repeating myself. Perhaps it would be better to say simply that there are a number of possible, cogent, detailed objections to this concept of trapping and that I will elaborate on them on a later amendment. Perhaps it would be better to say at this stage that that is so and, for that reason, I am opposed to this amendment which involves this concept.
Comment on this
We appreciate the thoroughness of the Minister's replies in many respects but he has not dealt with the basic question of the desirability of having a single rate of tax at retail level.
Comment on this
I think everybody will agree that one rate is desirable if that is attainable but the real argument is not whether it is desirable but whether it is feasible and that is the item that I did not go into again.
Comment on this
I accept that but I am afraid that we have reached the situation where, however we discuss this, we will divide the arguments in half so that the argument is bound to be incomplete. While the Minister has been inhibited, and rightly so, from dealing with that point I would have thought that he would have argued more on the issue of this desirability and how important it is to have a single rate. However cogent the Minister may believe the arguments to be regarding the difficulties of alternatives, this is of such importance that a solution to it must be found. Clearly the Minister must not attribute the same importance to it because he has not got the same determination to overcome the obstacles as we have on this side of the House. Therefore, there is a difference in attitude on this point of the importance of the single rate tax.
Although the Minister developed at great length his thoughts on rounding off figures the basic fact remains that so far as the retailer is concerned, it is only necessary to calculate once every two months and having arrived at his turnover he must calculate what tax he has to pay. That means that once every two months he must multiply his turnover by 5.26 per cent or, under the Minister's proposal of having two tax rates, he would have to segregate his sales and apply two percentages. On the Minister's proposal which involves rounding off from the point of view of the consumer, but not from the point of view of the wholesaler or manufacturer, every wholesaler and manufacturer would have to do this calculation on every invoice in order to establish how much tax is on the goods at that point so that tax can be recovered at the next stage. The enormous amount of work involved, which will require the installation of special machines which cost £1,600 each but which will not be available until next year, exceeds thousands of times over the work that retailers will have to do once every two months in their double calculations. This point does not seem to have got across to the Minister. It is obvious that the operation must be simplified for the wholesaler and the manufacturer.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot have it both ways. If the wholesaler must do all this work, the retailer will not have to do it.
Comment on this
I am always willing to be put right. I am aware that I have been wrong on several points but my understanding is that under the Minister's proposal, every time anything is sold to a retailer by a manufacturer or wholesaler, the invoice must show what tax is levied up to that point. That involves taking the values of the goods at that point and multiplying them by 5.26 per cent, by 16.37 or 30.26 per cent but always multiplying them to two decimal places. That having been done, the retailer has a series of invoices with the tax shown on each. He sends these in with a single calculation once every two months or, under the Minister's proposal, two calculations. I would much prefer the retailer to have to go two decimal places once or twice every two months than for every wholesaler and manufacturer to have to go to two decimal places on each invoice. All the Minister's arguments about not wishing to disturb by even .26 per cent the level of tax lest somebody should increase prices is unconvincing. On special committee the Minister went so far as to argue that if he reduced the 5.26 per cent rate to 5 per cent, it would be taken by people as an excuse to increase prices. I found that argument astonishing. The Minister may convince some people that if he did that the benefit might not always be passed on but I do not think that anybody will accept that a reduction in taxation would lead to an increase in prices. The Minister's emphasis on this question of the importance of maintaining the tax rate is not convincing in any case. When I raised the point by way of question he dodged away hastily and went on to repeat something that he had said earlier.
Comment on this
In all fairness to myself I must say I did not dodge away from the question. I referred to the fact that I had gone into the details on special committee. I have some concept of the mood of the House which I think would be that we ought not to go on repeating what we said on special committee. One must make certain cases but it is not necessary to repeat ad nauseum everything that was said before.
Comment on this
We are debating a very important principle and the Minister is asserting it is his determination that the tax rates will be as near as possible mathematically to the existing rates. However, I have pointed out that in respect of a range of goods representing 15 per cent of consumption—these are goods which at the moment bear 10 per cent wholesale tax as well as 5 per cent turnover tax — the Minister proposes to up the taxation by a number of full percentage points to vield £3,500,000 extra because he needs that money in order to pay money back. He cannot argue simultaneously that he needs the money and, consequently, must increase tax, and then go on to say that at all costs tax must not be increased even by the slightest degree and that throughout this Bill he has endeavoured to remain as near as possible mathematically to the present tax level. He has departed widely from the present level in the case of 15 per cent of goods. He said it is very important that the customer should know there was no increase in tax yet he is increasing tax on those goods. Therefore, he cannot claim that there will be no change in prices because he is raising the £3,500,000 in order to repay money to different people in different amounts.
There is no question of one offsetting the other for the same person. There is no question of a trader who is selling furniture now being taxed more heavily but getting back an equal amount through the repayments system. Anybody who is selling furniture or any of the goods that bear the 10 per cent wholesale tax will have the tax increased and must, consequently, increase prices. The position will be that the Minister is expecting the customer to know that the price of baby cream should not be affected while the price of baby powder will be increased, or that nappy liner prices will remain the same while nappy pin prices will be increased.
Therefore, for a range of goods that are in no way distinguishable from other goods, there is to be an increase in taxation. In that respect the Minister is, perhaps unintentionally, liable to mislead the House and that is why I am trying, in so far as I can, to inform the House on this point. The Minister departs from the principle of maintaining the present tax rate and for a heterogeneous group of goods indistinguishable from other goods by any principle known to man he intends increasing the price so that the customer cannot know whether the price ought to be going up. He must remember that in respect of nappy pins, for instance, prices will increase, whereas for nappy liners there will be no increase. Once that confusion has been introduced there is no point in us trying to hang on to the principle to the tune of 0.26 per cent in other cases. There is no point in the Minister trying to say that he cannot reduce the tax rate of 5.26 per cent to 5 per cent because in some way this would confuse the customer. On the one hand he cannot justify an increase of about three full percentage points in taxation on 15 per cent of consumption and then say that because he is tied so tightly he cannot vary tax rates at all and cannot agree to reduce the tax rate by 0.26 per cent in another case.
That case has no logic whatever and the Minister knows it, and he should not attempt to put across to the House something which is not, in fact, the case. From that point of view his argument on rounding is cockeyed and carries no conviction. It would have carried no conviction if he had held to this principle on the wholesale tax and if he had not decided to raise £3.5 million extra by increasing tax rates on this range of goods with a view to providing money to pay for these repayments of tax to different people in different circumstances. So much for that argument. I do not wish to be repetious although I am accused of it at times. I am not conscious of being repetitious and I try to minimise it as much as possible whether the Minister and Deputy O'Donovan believe me or not.
Comment on this
I am glad that in that respect at least my honesty of purpose is recognised. Let me come to the area where I am accused of being dishonourable. I should like to defend myself for a shorter time than that taken by Deputy O'Donovan to make these accusations. Deputy O'Donovan refers to the special committee which at its first meeting, in fact, set out the procedure to be followed.
Comment on this
I have not started yet. When this committee first met and the question of the admission of the public and the Press was discussed, there was never any discussion or mention of the proceedings of the committee being kept secret or not being published or not being communicable to anybody either then or later. The question of the admission of public and Press was raised by the Chairman and Deputy Tully said:
I would have no objection to either the public or the Press being present. I do not think they would be very interested in what we are trying to do here. They would be interested in the end result; I do not think they would want to sit here for hours.
The discussion went on; the Minister intervened and discussed the matter further and said it was a workmanlike session and that, perhaps, we might be tempted to be a little less workmanlike when we are in the presence of the Press and public. For that reason he said he would favour not having the Press or the public at sessions of the committee. There was no question there or anywhere else of the proceedings of the committee being secret. They are, of course, published. Not alone that, but I myself raised in the committee at the end of the second session the question of the delay in publication which was a problem causing great concern to all of us.
Comment on this
I have been accused of dishonourably disclosing the proceedings of this committee. Deputy O'Donovan took about 12 minutes to make the accusation and I propose to answer it in ten which I think is appropriate as my conduct has been called in question in this House——
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donovan did accuse me of untruth this morning. He withdrew that by saying he withdrew the word, with great emphasis on the "word", thereby not withdrawing the intent. He did not state what was the untruth I was supposed to have told. He knows perfectly well that I never made the slightest secret, in the committee when the members met informally, of the fact that I had communicated the decision to hold this meeting to the Press. It was not secret; the proceedings of the meeting were in no way secret. The purpose of having the discussion in committee out of the House was to enable us to have a more detailed, technical discussion as a result of which——
Comment on this
I do not like the Deputy still shaving the truth as he is now doing because there were no reporters at the private meeting.
Comment on this
It was agreed that there would not be reporters at the meeting but there was nothing whatever secret about the proceedings. In fact, the purpose of the committee was to discuss highly technical matters outside this House. There would be no value in this if, after the discussion we were, by virtue of the proceedings not being published for a fortnight or more—and there is a delay of over a fortnight in publication now—we were not able to go and consult various interests concerned with the Bill, tell them what happened at the committee and discuss with them what should be done on Report Stage. I have never heard it suggested in this House that if a matter is discussed in special committee we are precluded from having any consultations on the proceedings and that we must enter Report Stage without having discussed with anybody outside what has happened or what amendments are appropriate.
Comment on this
It has never been suggested that the proceedings should be secret and we are entirely free to state what has happened at a special committee to anybody one likes. I come now to the suggestion that I in some way gave a slanted report to the papers. The suggestion was made by Deputy O'Donovan and Deputy Tully that I, in some way, highlighted not only the Fine Gael role but my own and that I played down the role of the Labour Party. I have twice already asserted and I assert again, that in anything I have said in public or in private on this matter, I have in every instance linked the Labour Party and Deputy Tully with the amendment and I have never at any stage——
Comment on this
On a point of order, at no stage did I allege anything about what Deputy FitzGerald had said about the Labour Party. I made no reference to it.