We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971: Report Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 201–404 of 805. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971
Enacted

No. 30 of 1971 ›

Deputy Tully said the report I had given to the press was slanted.

Comment on this

Why did the Deputy include me?

Comment on this

I understood you to charge me——

Comment on this

The Deputy heard what he wanted to hear.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Donovan says the report was not slanted that is all right; if that is his view and he disagrees with Deputy Tully——

Comment on this

The Deputy is not going to twist my words. I made no reference to the matter.

Comment on this

Either it is his view that it was slanted or it is his view that it was not slanted and I do not give a damn which but it must be one or the other.

Comment on this

This is the way the Deputy tumbles words around the place. He knows well what the allegation was.

Comment on this

I shall deal only with Deputy Tully's allegation, not made by Deputy O'Donovan who does not feel that the report was slanted. But Deputy Tully, unfortunately, did feel that the report was slanted and accused me of having slanted it. I assert that in anything I said to any Press men or to anybody else that in the two statements I made, I linked the Labour Party with this matter in every respect.

Comment on this

Deputy Tully was quite right. You have drawn it out of me now.

Comment on this

Let me conclude my remarks on this by pointing out that as evidence that what I said to the Press was not slanted, in all four newspapers there are reports and none of them mention my name on any occasion without mentioning Deputy Tully in the same passage. I challenge Deputy O'Donovan to show me anywhere in these four papers where as a result of a Press briefing by me or otherwise, publicity was given to me or to Fine Gael without referring to Labour. The references in The Irish Press are as follows:

Deputy Dr. Garret FitzGerald (FG) and Mr. James Tully (Labour) had amendments down to this effect....

Later on:

Deputy Dr. FitzGerald and Mr. James Tully argued at the Special Committee on the VAT Bill that with the increased food prices in EEC the tax on food would bear more heavily on poorer and larger families....

I never told anybody that but in so far as it is there the two names are linked. Similarly, in the Irish Independent. I am going to nail this misrepresentation—I cannot use the word untruth although Deputy O'Donovan has no qualms about it—once and for all. In the Irish Independent the only references are as follows—Deputy O'Donovan does not like the truth but he is going to hear it:

The Fine Gael and Labour spokesmen on Finance, Dr. Garret FitzGerald and Mr. James Tully both tabled amendments in the Dáil seeking the removal of food from the proposed Bill....

The next reference is:

Dr. FitzGerald, Mr. Tully and other members of the Committee are expected to submit to a Committee session next week detailed proposals....

Let us take The Irish Times:

Comment on this

How was Deputy Collins left out of that?

Comment on this

The only references are to people who put down the amendments and whose names were on these amendments: Deputy O'Donovan's name was not and Deputy Collins's name was not. In The Irish Times there is a reference to a special body set up by the Dáil to discuss a motion from Deputy James James Tully (Labour) and Dr. Garret FitzGerald (Fine Gael)—Deputy Tully is first on this occasion—that food should be made exempt from VAT. There is no further reference to me or anybody else in Fine Gael in that report. In the Cork Examiner we have the same situation:

Considerable time was devoted by the Committee under the Chairmanship of Mr. Gus Healy (FF) to discussing amendments by the Fine Gael and Labour spokesmen on Finance, Mr. Garret FitzGerald, TD, and Mr. Jimmy Tully, TD,

There is no other reference to me there. There is no evidence whatever that I slanted the report. I have never done so at any stage and, in any reference I have made, I have linked the Labour Party to it both publicly and privately. If I had any confidence in the decency of Deputy O'Donovan on this matter I would expect him to withdraw the remark he made a few minutes ago about supporting Deputy Tully on the suggestion that I slanted the report.

Comment on this

The Deputy will wait a long time.

Comment on this

I will wait a long time for the Deputy to withdraw something he said which has been proved wrong, I agree. In fairness to the Minister, he never made any such suggestion. He is quietly enjoying this, of course. I do not blame him. Why should he not?

Comment on this

It is not worth as much to him as he believes.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not know how much I believe it is worth.

Comment on this

I can guess.

Comment on this

There was no question of the proceedings being secret. The Minister knows that and therefore he did not join in the allegations made by Deputy O'Donovan.

Comment on this

There was another reason.

Comment on this

I have dealt with all the points made and I have refuted the allegation of dishonourable conduct and I am content to leave it at that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is amendment No. 16 withdrawn?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that decisions are not required on amendments Nos. 17, 18, 20 and 22.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I am prepared to have the amendments in my name. Nos. 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 28, 30, 31, 32, 48, 50 and 51 taken in conjunction with amendment No. 16. I think amendment No. 47 was also taken in conjunction with it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 64
·
Níl 58
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As amendments Nos. 25 and 26 are alternative amendments, perhaps they could be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:

In page 17, after line 19, to add a new paragraph as follows:

"(f) an amount equivalent to the amount by which the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that the accountable person's costs have been increased as a result of the application of this Act."

Amendments Nos. 25 and 26 suggest alternative ways of trying to achieve the objective of giving traders some compensation for the work of tax collection imposed on them by the Revenue Commissioners under the provisions of this Bill. The amendment in my name is one which, perhaps with more confidence than one sometimes feels, leaves it to the Revenue Commissioners to decide what compensation will be appropriate. The other amendment, No. 26, proposes an amount equivalent to 0.5 per cent of the net amount payable to the Revenue Commissioners in respect of the taxable period, with a maximum of £1,000 in a taxable period.

The Minister met the point that a straight percentage of the net amount of tax payable should be given by saying that he believed it would give a bigger benefit to the larger firm than to the smaller firm and that therefore scaling would be required. To meet this point Deputy Collins approached it by putting a maximum on the figure. I considered the maximum but wondered whether an alternative might not be to leave it to the Revenue Commissioners to satisfy themselves as to the amount. The Minister could accept either amendment. Deputy Collins and I would not fall out as to which is accepted.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I moved an amendment similar to amendment No. 26 in the special committee. This is an attempt to allow all traders a certain amount of money as an expense for collecting the tax for the Government. Since the introduction of PAYE and of the turnover and wholesale taxes the trader at various levels has become an unpaid tax gatherer. This should not be so. The cost to any one trader of administering PAYE and the turnover and wholesale taxes has become substantial, and the introduction of the value-added tax system will further increase his costs in this respect.

My amendment allows a trader to subtract 0.5 per cent of the net amount payable to the Revenue Commissioners in respect of the taxable period, provided that this amount does not exceed £1,000 in the taxable period, which is the equivalent of £6,000 per annum. The reason I have put down this amendment is the reply given to me in the special committee by the Minister who said that an open-ended figure of 0.5 per cent would, first, be in favour of the larger trader and, second, in favour of the trader who collects the higher percentages such as 16.37 and 30.26 per cent. This was a valid argument and I accept it. With a view to satisfying the Minister's argument on this point I introduced the maximum amount by which a trader could benefit under this amendment, that is, £6,000 in any one year.

Comment on this

I do not quite follow that. I have been trying to work out from the amendment what the Deputy had in mind. Did he say that the maximum benefit a taxpayer would get would be £6,000 in any one year?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

That is right. £1,000 in the taxable period. The taxable period is defined in the Bill as two months.

Comment on this

Does the £1,000 relate to the amount which would be refunded, the saving to the shopkeeper, or does it relate to the amount of tax to which he was liable?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

It would depend on the amount he was returning to the Revenue Commissioners. At no point would he be entitled to deduct more than £1,000 in a taxable period of two months——

Comment on this

I see. That is what I wanted to know.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

——which is equivalent to deducting a maximum of £6,000 per annum. This, of course, would not be allowed to all traders. Those at the maximum would only be the very large traders, wholesalers, most likely, and the large-scale retailers, who would be giving quite an amount to the Revenue Commissioners in the taxable period. There are costs which every trader would have to meet under this Bill, and the Revenue Commissioners ought to recognise that traders have to bear these costs of collection. Heretofore no recognition has been given to the trader in respect of collecting this tax for the Government. By accepting this amendment the Minister would be showing goodwill in respect of the introduction of a new and complicated system, and this would be welcomed by wholesalers, retailers and manufacturers in general.

Comment on this

I should like briefly to support the principle behind the amendments. It is quite true to say that traders have become accustomed to calling themselves unpaid tax collectors, and, perhaps, all of us are in a certain way unpaid tax collectors for the State. Would the Minister state, when he is replying, whether or not it is correct that under the present system there is a certain amount of compensation allowed in certain cases for the collection of taxes? Does he not agree that this new system should have built into it something which would compensate the person who has to employ additional help?

I had a discussion with a group of traders, and possibly the man who was giving me the particulars might not be the best example at all, but he told me he had under his control—not owned by him but under his control —100 retail outlets. He said that each of them would have to provide a new cash register. The average cash register of the type he required he estimated would cost around £300, buying them in bulk. That is 300 times 100. Add on to that the training of someone to handle it and the cost of working it right through because of the complicated system which the Minister insists on introducing, and you can see an additional argument in favour of some compensation.

The small traders, with whom we discussed this matter, seem to be scared to death of all the extra work they will have to do for nothing. Some of them said they would have to go out of business completely, particularly the older ones who felt they would have to depend on the State for subsistence, that it would not be possible to run their business with this extra impost on them. I do not know whether the figure suggested by Deputy Collins is correct or not. It might be a little high.

Comment on this

I would think so.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

It is a maximum figure.

Comment on this

Anyway I do not think we will get anything out of this by arguing about it here, but I think the amendments are worth while and I would suggest the Minister should have a look at it to see if something could be done. I do not believe anybody in the Civil Service or in any other business would do this sort of thing for nothing. Why should it be expected of the traders of this country?

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I have expressed a certain amount of sympathy for this type of amendment before but, as I have said in Committee, I do not think an amendment giving a percentage is suitable, even though Deputy Collins has amended it to some extent. As we know, already, there is this concession on the first £100 of 2.27 pence. This concession was given to traders to encourage them to submit their accounts. There is no doubt that, by and large, retailers have a considerable amount of work to do. First, they have to deduct PAYE from their employees. They are also responsible for national health insurance stamps and for the turnover tax which has to be submitted every two months to the Department of Industry and Commerce. Now they will have to deal with VAT. These things are the responsibility of the retail traders.

Comment on this

A costly responsibility.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Therefore, a case could be made that they are doing a considerable amount of work voluntarily, work that it would take many civil servants to account for. However, there is one snag here. Up to now this concesion was only allowed at retail level, but I am not altogether sure that wholesalers or manufacturers would not claim the same concession. Seeing that manufacturers and wholesalers will also be accountable persons and will keep accounts, they probably would be in the same position to claim it as retailers, so that how this would effect revenue might be a different question. That is a complication I see in it. I agree with the spirit of the amendment, but there is no doubt that retail outlets and owners of shops have a considerable amount of work to do, and I sympathise with them, and I know that a certain amount of additional work will be involved in this value-added tax system. There is this difficulty I see that probably the wholesaler and manufacturer could say that they are entitled to it now because they have to make out invoices at various percentages.

Comment on this

Taking amendment No. 25 first, this is designed to give some compensation to the taxpayer for the additional cost of operating value-added tax. It would impose on the Revenue Commissioners the obligation of ascertaining the additional cost, if any, to the taxpayer of operating value-added tax and allowing that cost as a deduction from the taxpayers' VAT liability. Of course, the taxpayer will already have got a deduction in computing his tax liability in respect of the tax on his purchases, but that is not what is in question here. What is in question, apparently, is to relieve the taxpayer of the balance of the cost of VAT to him. Deputy FitzGerald did say when moving the amendment, quite unusually for him, that he was proposing to leave the matter entirely in the hands of the Revenue Commisioners. He did hint, without actually saying it, that this was not because he had absolute faith in the Revenue Commissioners. The real reason is that it is a question of passing the buck. He knows that it is impossible to make this kind of calculation, that it would be quite unworkable, and for this reason I could not accept amendment No. 25 at all.

Deputy Collins's amendment No. 26 seems at least to be designed, if one accepts the concept of it, on a workable basis, because there are figures quoted and one can operate on that basis. However, there are a number of reasons why I do not think this is really an acceptable or feasible arrangement. I think the point raised by Deputy Tully has been answered by Deputy Fitzpatrick but, perhaps, I should say——

Comment on this

I would prefer to hear the Minister.

Comment on this

It is true that there is at the moment under the turnover tax system an allowance, as Deputy Fitzpatrick said, on the first £100.

Comment on this

The Minister will accept that I knew that, but what I asked was why this is being taken away.

Comment on this

I am coming to that. I can say that I did understand that the Deputy knew it. The first reason which I feel should be advanced against the amendment is that it would be inequitable as between different classes of traders. I know Deputy Collins endeavoured to cover the point but I do not think he has done so. It is true that in the setting up of the VAT system, there would, I suppose, be certain transitional expenditure arising out of the procedures being set up to deal with it, but once this has been done the continuing cost of the operation would probably not be appreciably higher for larger firms than for medium or even small firms. A continuing compensation which would be based on net liability is, therefore, likely to favour the bigger firms, and in addition, while the cost of operating the tax in relation to goods liable at the 16.37 per cent rate is not likely to be higher than the cost of operating the scheme in relation to goods at the 5.26 per cent rate, nevertheless, the net tax payable would be higher and, therefore, the suggested basis of compensation would be higher, and would, therefore, favour people dealing in goods at the higher rate. As a consequence of that, jewellers and furniture dealers would receive relatively more compensation than grocers or drapers, and, of course, those traders who are accountable at the 30.26 per cent rate would be the most favoured of all.

Another factor in this is that the method proposed would favour traders who imported their stock because, since no tax would be chargeable on imports, their net liability for each taxable period would be higher than the net liability of the corresponding traders who purchase their stock in this country from accountable persons. Another factor is that firms who are engaged solely in exporting would have no net liability and, therefore, would not get any relief at all under this provision. We did discuss the matter in the special committee and Deputy Collins, I think in an effort to meet some of the points I have been talking about, did include in this amendment a limitation—"not to exceed £1,000 in a taxable period." I have not got an exact calculation on this and I suppose it is not possible to have one, because it depends on the rates at which the goods being sold are liable, but it is certainly not unreasonable to assume that under the proposal, there would be relief available to firms having a turnover up to £500,000 a year. It could well be higher than that but it would seem that that is not an unreasonable figure.

Therefore, as far as the amendment on the face of it is concerned, it would seem to be designed to give relief to people in quite a big way of business. I would have thought that the main concern in this regard would be in respect of retail traders, and particularly smaller retail traders, and this is where Deputy Tully's point comes in, because at the moment they have this benefit under the turnover tax system. It is true that that benefit is disappearing under VAT, but, on the other hand, they are getting benefits which I believe will more than compensate them for any additional cost they will have in operating VAT. Those benefits are primarily the right to claim refunds of tax on their inputs which they cannot do at the moment. There is a form of double taxation at the moment under the present system. Everything they will purchase in the course of business, for their business, under VAT, including even building of premises, extensions, counters, cash registers, fitments of all kinds— all these contain an element of tax under the present system—under VAT they will be able to recover that amount of tax in full, which they cannot do at the moment. This is one benefit.

The other benefit they get is that, because of the taxable period now being made two months, retailers, many of them to a substantial extent, will benefit by improved liquidity. It is for this reason that I am satisfied that, for retailers, the benefits will more than compensate them for any additional costs they may have in operating the value-added tax system as compared with the present system. While I do not want to get involved in an argument as to what additional cost they will have—it is difficult to be precise since it depends to a great extent on the particular case—I do not believe the additional cost involved will be anything like what has been alleged by some people, both inside and outside the House. I think the difficulties encountered will be far less than has been thought. I might also mention that no other member or applicant member of the EEC gives compensation of the type referred to in this amendment and it is possible—I do not put it any stronger than that—that an amendment of this kind might not be acceptable to the EEC.

Comment on this

The case made on both these amendments is that the collection of this value-added tax will involve traders in the expenditure of money. The Minister has stated that there will be costs involved in equipment and in setting up a system of collection and he argues that there is no cause for complaint really because the traders can claim a tax rebate. That may be so, but they cannot claim back the actual cost of the equipment.

Comment on this

That was not quite my argument.

Comment on this

It was to be inferred. The Minister also accepts that there will be a continuing cost, and he makes the case that the continuing cost, when the system gets going, will be quite small. He does admit that there will be a continuing cost and he admits there will be an initial outlay. Accepting that, he should not criticise the people who put down these amendments for failing to meet the cost exactly in their proposals. It is the Minister's job to find the right way equitably to recoup people for losses sustained as a result of the collection of tax. All of us have some experience of PAYE and what is involved in that system. There is absolutely no compensation. There is the case where semi-State bodies involved in this type of collection are not allowed to employ extra staff, but they must collect the tax. The Minister should really consider this very seriously. There is no doubt in anyone's mind but that this will cost traders money. If the Minister accepts that—I think he must accept it—it is up to him to devise the means of compensating traders fairly and equitably, whether they be small traders or large traders, or whether they are involved in the sale of items in which there are many or merely a few transactions. It should be possible to find a way to compensate people.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I am disappointed that the Minister did not go even part of the way to meeting my amendment. It is a constructive amendment. I prefer my amendment to that of Deputy FitzGerald. His would involve the Revenue Commissioners in estimating expenses. Mine would not involve that. To get £1,000 deduction in a taxable period a trader will have to return £1,200,000 in tax to the Revenue Commissioners. That would mean £6,000 in a taxable year. I am satisfied that the work which would have to be put into returning £1,200,000 to the Revenue Commissioners would cost a trader more than £6,000 per annum. That is a valid point. I accept that exporters will not benefit under this scheme. This is unfortunate and I did not realise that would be the situation until the Minister explained it. Some positive effort, expressed in terms of money rather than in terms of allowances in relation to inputs and capital costs, should be made in favour of traders. I am open to reducing the £1,000 taxable period if this will mitigate the advantages in favour of a large trader. I am sorry the Minister is not in favour of this amendment.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 17, after line 9, to insert the following new paragraph:

"(f) an amount equivalent to 0.5 per cent of the net amount payable to the Revenue Commissioners in respect of the taxable period, provided that this amount does not exceed £1,000 in a taxable period. "

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 52
·
Níl 65
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 36:

In page 23, line 35, after "whatsoever" to insert "other than documents which relate exclusively to the affairs of clients or customers of the accountable person".

This amendment is designed to include patent and copyright agents with barristers from the point of view of exemption and in respect of this there has been representation on this point. I raised this matter in respect of patent agents in the special committee but since then it has been suggested to me that it should be widened to include patent and copyright agents. It had not struck me that copyright agents should be included but they are in a similar position. Both groups feel they could be in the position which the Minister feels certain professional people could be in, where it would be to their advantage to be exempted. It seems reasonable that they should be included in these circumstances.

Comment on this

The decision as to whether or not certain services should be exempted is governed by the budgetary considerations and partly by the requirements of the directive of the EEC. There would not be any significant loss of tax in an exemption for patent agents but the general requirement of the EEC directives is that those services ought not be exempted which enter directly into the cost of taxable goods or taxable services. Article 6 of the EEC second directive requires the transfer of patents, trade marks or other similar rights as well as the granting of licences in regard to these rights, to be brought within the scope of the tax. My recollection is that I read this out at the special committee. The point is that this is the provision in relation to the transfer of patents, trade marks and other similar rights as well as the granting of licences in regard to these rights. The services of copyright and patent agents are directly related to such activities which are required to be brought in. Consequently, it would seem contrary to the spirit of the directive to exempt them and, therefore, I do not find it possible to accept the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

As the only man who holds the pen used by Cassius Clay this evening, I want just one minute. In regard to this value-added tax nobody has clarified one point, I should like to know before next voting—I am not too sure of what I voted for on the last few occasions— if the Minister can give some assurance that people who sell, say, under £1,100 per month or something like that will be treated under VAT as they are being treated at present.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot deal with that on this amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I cannot make a statement or debate on this unless I get the Minister's point of view.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The amendment before the House is specific. The Deputy may make an inquiry on Fifth Stage.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I am not trying to hold up the debate for a moment but before I can say yea or nay to this I want to get an answer to a simple question.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will permit the Deputy to put a query on Fifth Stage but we cannot have it on this amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I cannot speak on the amendment unless I get an answer to the simple question I am asking——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Even the Minister would not be answering a question on this amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

He probably would not know the answer.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had been present not so long ago he would have heard this whole question discussed and I gave the answer.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Give the answer now; it will not take a minute.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are on an amendment now——

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I will vote against it this evening, so.

Comment on this

The Deputy must do as he wishes.

Comment on this

I can imagine more rational grounds for bringing down a Government.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I am not afraid to walk across the House and do not think I am.

Comment on this

The Deputy might walk back again some day. As I understand the Minister, he is referring me to article 6 of the second directive. I think he is referring to article 6.2. I want to tease this out and make sure I have understood it correctly. The directive says that the rules laid down with regard to the taxation of the provision of services shall be compulsorily applicable only to services listed in Annex B which refers in the first item to assignments of patents, trade marks and other similar rights, and the granting of licences in respect of such rights.

It is suggested that, as far as the EEC is concerned, those references bring compulsorily within the framework of the Bill copyright and patent agents as distinct from the activities of assigning patents and trade marks? I would have thought that they perform a function of an agency kind. I would not have thought that they assign patents or trade marks or other similar rights. Would I be permitted to ask the Minister whether it is his view that this provision in regard to assignments of patents, trade maks and other similar rights, necessarily brings copyright and patent agencies within the framework of the Bill?

Comment on this

What I said was that since these services and transfers in relation to such rights are specifically brought in, the services of patent and copyright agents are directly related to these activities which are clearly in, and consequently it would seem to be contrary to the spirit of the directive to exempt them.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister is referring to section 10 of Annex B: the services of forwarding agents, brokers, business agents and other independent intermediaries in so far as they relate to the supply or importation of goods or the provision of services included in the list. Is the Minister suggesting that a copyright or patent agent is a business agent whose work relates to the provision of the service of assignment of patents and trade marks and other similar rights? Is that the Minister's line of argument?

Comment on this

No. I am not saying other than what I have already said.

Comment on this

If the Minister is not accepting my line of argument I am in a bit of a difficulty. The mere fact that the assignment of patents is included in the directive does not of itself require that the activities of copyright and patent agents should be included. It is arguable that section 10 of Annex B brings them within it but, as against that, there is no mention whatever of copyright. In our law the assignment of patents, trade marks and other similar rights would not necessarily extend patents and trade marks to copyright. Could the Minister indicate where, if anywhere, the question of copyright agents is brought within the framework of the directive? I submit that it is not. For some reason the Minister does not wish to press his line of argument which could be quite convincing on the question of patent agents. He has not got a case on the question of copyright. For that reason there is a case for not feeling bound by the EEC directive because it does not seem that it directly involves copyright agents. I wonder if the Minister would be permitted to comment on that?

Comment on this

The only comment I can make is that I do not think the Deputy listened to what I said.

Comment on this

I listened very carefully. The Minister referred to the EEC directive in terms which do not very much resemble the wording of the directive. He talked of business activities.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

It is difficult for me to recollect his exact words. Will the Minister quote what he said?

Comment on this

I said that Article 6 of the second directive requires the transfer of patents, trade marks or other similar rights as well as the granting of licences with regard to these rights to be brought within the scope of the tax. I did not refer to business activities.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister referred to activities which in some way had a business orientation.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I cannot quote it accurately enough to identify it in the Minister's brief but there was some reference of that kind. The Minister has not answered the point about copyright agents at all. I am reinforced in my view that the copyright agency situation is not covered by the EEC directive. That is not a reason for not including them. As I have been specifically asked to raise this matter I feel the Minister should give some consideration to it.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I am sorry——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy may not intervene at this stage because Deputy FitzGerald has concluded on that amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

The Chair does not know what amendment I am going to talk on.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy may not speak at this stage. He has already spoken.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I am as much entitled to talk as any other Deputy. I asked the Minister as question and he did not think it worth while to give me an answer.

Comment on this

As the Minister has not dealt with the point I think I will press the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

The House will not get up this week if the Deputy goes on that way.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 37 and 46 formed a composite proposal and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 37:

In page 41, line 2, to delete all words after "baggage".

The point here relates to the question of car hire. Contrary to the Minister's indication earlier that he did not wish to vary the present rates of taxation, the effect of the Bill is to extend the value-added tax to car hire which at present is not taxed under turnover tax. I am hoisting the Minister with his own petard. I would press that he should not choose this moment, especially with the tourist industry in its present condition, to start taxing car hire. I urge on him to accept the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I will not be very long on this. The Minister refused to answer my very simple question.

Comment on this

We are on amendment No. 37.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I cannot speak on this amendment until I get an answer to a simple question.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is out of order unless he keeps to this amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Under TOT we got £1,100 a month where the wholesaler collected the tax. Does this also apply to the new tax? The Minister does not want to answer. He can keep his answer.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister would not be in order in dealing with a matter which is out of order.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

So far as the good jobs of most of the people in this House are concerned I am a key figure.

Comment on this

God help the Government who depend on that key figure.

Comment on this

I have already dealt with the concept behind this amendment in some detail at the special committee and I do not think there is any point in my doing so again.

Comment on this

Since the reports of the special committee are not published for some time afterwards they do not receive any press publicity. While I recognise the undesirability of extended repetition here on matters dealt with by the committee, in the public interest it is desirable that the case should be stated for the various points which, after the special committee, are still considered to be at issue, and that the Minister should reply briefly and indicate his reasons for rejecting them.

I say that in the interests of Parliament and, indeed, of the Minister. I do not lose anything by the Minister not answering a point I have made. While not wishing to extend the debate and understanding the Minister's desire not to do so, I think it might have been better for him to say a few words as to the reason for deciding to tax car hire. Not to give the House a reason for his decision is a bit unsatisfactory, all the more so, because, may I point out, despite the Minister having referred a few minutes ago to the fact that he said something in the special committee, I am unable to verify that fact because we have now reached the stage where the reports of the special committee have not yet been published. I raised this at the second session of the special committee with the Minister and I asked him to make sure, because this House has no power to make sure, that the reports would be published quickly and promptly.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot deal with that matter on this amendment.

Comment on this

May I suggest that whether Deputy FitzGerald's recollection is accurate or not is hardly relevant?

Comment on this

I am sorry. The Minister does not take my point.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy has made a point.

Comment on this

This matter was discussed in the special committee but nobody in this House who was not on the special committee——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We can only deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

——can know whether or how it was discussed or what points were made because the reports, although a fortnight old, have not yet been published.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are not dealing in general with the Bill. We are dealing with a specific amendment.

Comment on this

May I inform you, because you have no other means of knowing it, that there was a discussion in the special committee on this point and the Minister made a reply there, the details of which I cannot recollect and which he is not inclined to give the House, on this point? I submit that it is unsatisfactory procedure in this House that if we have special committees, which I think are desirable, the reports should be so delayed that we should then discuss the Report Stage without them.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot discuss the procedure.

Comment on this

May I put it to you that I understand—I hope I am correct in this—that there is a convention of the House that although the reports are not secret and although one may discuss freely what happened there, one may not mention in this House what happened at a special committee until the report is published? You can mention it outside.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are dealing with an amendment on Report Stage. We are not dealing with procedure on a special committee.

Comment on this

May I put a point of order? Am I correctly informed, because I have been so informed privately, that, in fact, although there is no bar to the publication outside the House of what happens at a special committee, one is not entitled to refer to it in the House? The Minister has referred to what happened at a special committee the report of which has not been published.

Comment on this

If that ruling was given by the Ceann Comhairle, it is unfair to ask the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to give a decision which may be contrary.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot discuss the propriety of things on a specific amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Am I not entitled on a point of order, to ask if the Minister was entitled to refer to what was discussed at a special committee?

Comment on this
An Leas-Ceann Comhairle

No. The position is that amendment No. 37 is before the House and that is what we are dealing with.

Comment on this

On this amendment, the Minister said he had dealt with this matter in a special committee. This is the first time the Minister has not answered a case here. What I am wondering is, then, whether his unwillingness to answer the case relates in some way to the fact that there is a convention of the House that you may not refer in the House to what happened at a special committee?

Comment on this

How can the Deputy make that point when he and I and other Deputies have regularly in the course of this debate referred to what happened in the special committee?

Comment on this

It has been published.

Comment on this

The Deputy is simply wasting the time of the House.

Comment on this

I have pointed out to the Minister that we have now reached the stage where volumes 6 and 7 of the report of the special committee become relevant. The report has been published only up to volume 5 to date. That brings you to one of the sections of the Bill towards the end. We are now dealing with the First Schedule. The proceedings of the special committee in respect of the First Schedule have not yet been published. I understand that one is not entitled to refer to the proceedings that have not been published. Are we at a stage in the Bill, therefore, where neither I nor the Minister can refer to what happened at the special committee? I am entitled outside the House to refer to it but not inside the House. Is that the ruling of the Chair?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is looking for a ruling which, as far as the Chair is concerned, there is no necessity to give because what is before the House is an amendment and the Chair is going to stick with that.

Comment on this

Am I entitled to refer to what happened at a special committee on this amendment?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy may refer to that in so far as this amendment is concerned. The Deputy is concluding.

Comment on this

I am glad of the ruling because I was otherwise informed a short while ago, that I was not entitled to refer in the House, but only in the House, to matters in the special committee the reports of which have not been published. It is that ruling which is bothering me at the moment but you have indicated that no such ruling exists and I am entitled to refer to it.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not told that from the Chair, of course.

Comment on this

By the Chair but not from the Chair. I simply wanted to be clear because there is confusion.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

To refer to it. The Deputy, I take it, is only referring to it.

Comment on this

Am I entitled to refer to what happened at the special committee?

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, may I make a point of order? Deputy FitzGerald knows, following the Minister's statement, that we have reached the stage where the Minister has decided to refuse to accept the amendment. There are a number of very important amendments which have to be debated here. We have only until midnight. I would suggest to Deputy FitzGerald that there is no point in attempting to get a ruling on whether or not the proceedings of the private session should be discussed in this House at this stage. I hate to say this, but I think we are wasting time on something that is not relevant. I am not trying to rush away, as was suggested in some of the newspapers. I stay here as long as anybody else. I do not mind how long it takes to finish this. We should be reasonable. Either we vote on it or not.

Comment on this

What is not evident to the Chair is that earlier on in the debate, on another section, it was suggested that in disclosing outside the House what happened at a special committee before the reports were published. I had acted dishonourably. I sought private guidance on this from the Chair and was informed that there was no ruling whatever on that particular point and I was entitled to do so but I was not entitled to refer to these points in the special committee in the House until the debates were published.

Comment on this

I am sorry that Deputy FitzGerald has raised that point again.

Comment on this

I want to clear the air, in view of the allegations made.

Comment on this

What was considered dishonourable was that the special committee meeting which was arranged was not alone reported in the Press but the matter to be discussed was reported in the Press.

Comment on this

These were matters referred to in the proceedings of the special committee when it met.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We must deal with the amendment. We cannot go back on procedure.

Comment on this

I understand that the Chair has now ruled that I am entitled to refer to the proceedings of the special committee even though they have not been published, in so far as they are relevant to the amendment under discussion. That is as far as I want to go. I do not want to press the matter any further.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:

In page 41, after line 18, to add "( ) second-hand movable goods".

The point here is that goods that have been taxed should not be taxed a second time, I understood it was a basic principle of value-added tax. Yet, if this amendment is rejected, we are in the position that goods will be taxed each time they are sold. This seems against the basic principle of the Bill.

Comment on this

The effect of this amendment would be that all sales and importations of secondhand goods would be exempt from tax. There are a number of reasons why I could not accept this amendment. First, it would be contrary to the principle that value-added tax is designed as a general tax on consumer expenditure. Secondly, it would be contrary to the basic purpose of this Bill which is a changeover from the present system to value-added tax. Under the present system, secondhand goods are charged at the effective rate of 5.26 per cent.

The acceptance of this amendment would weaken the control of the tax by opening areas up at the retail stage where no tax would be chargeable. In addition, it would affect the situation in regard to traders who deal partly in new and partly in second-hand goods because an apportionment of the tax between taxable and exempt transactions would be necessary. Finally, it would disturb the neutrality in that second-hand goods could be imported tax free from abroad and sold in competition with home goods which had at some stage borne tax.

Comment on this

The last point the Minister made is reasonable, but I would not agree the other points he made are reasonable. I think there could be an arrangement made whereby imported second-hand goods could be taxed. We would all accept that.

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this

If that is the only reason which the Minister has——

Comment on this

It is not the only reason.

Comment on this

It is the main reason, and the Minister should have another look at that.

Comment on this

The Minister did give other reasons but I doubt if he feels they were very compelling. It does seem wrong that second-hand goods should be taxed, but apart from that the Minister has not put forward very convincing reasons on this point.

Comment on this

We went into this in considerable detail in the special committee and I believe that the arguments I put forward, especially when amplified, are such that I cannot accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:

In page 41, line 40, to delete all words after "aircraft".

This involves the deletion of the following words: "going to places outside the State; and the repairing and servicing of ships and aircraft engaged in international commercial transport of passengers and goods". The reason for my amendment is not that it is particularly important to secure that this applies to ships and aircraft engaged in internal transport. In fact, the volume of transport in Ireland which is internal and carried out by ships and aircraft is fairly small. There is a certain amount of coastal shipping and, of course, air services between Dublin and Shannon and Cork. It must be remembered that planes going to Shannon and Cork from Dublin are also, with few exceptions, going outside the country. There is no such thing as aircraft of the Aer Lingus fleet which is confined to domestic air transport. There is possibly only a helicopter or light aircraft so engaged and light aircraft would probably also be engaged outside the country as well as on domestic work. Therefore, it does not seem to me to be feasible to have a provision of this kind, which would mean, for example, that, if Aer Lingus stocked their aircraft with food and drink at Dublin en route to Shannon and New York, because the goods are going to a place inside the State, in the first instance, these goods carry 5 per cent tax, but if the aircraft were stocked up at Shannon the goods would be zero rated.

Comment on this

Do not forget the 5.26.

Comment on this

I must not forget that. I cannot recall—it is some years since I was in Aer Lingus—what the practice was then in that respect, but in those days, in any event, they were hired aircraft and the whole position was different. However, it could well be that Aer Lingus at the moment or in the future would wish to be in a position to be able to victual its aircraft in Dublin and not have to make a prolonged stop at Shannon en route to New York, to the disadvantage of the passengers, during which it would load up food and drink in order to avoid the value-added tax.

I put it to the Minister that this is quite unsatisfactory. I do not know if he has received representations from Aer Lingus on this point. I have not myself, despite my former association with them, but I would be surprised if the company would be satisfied to be so constrained that they must either pay value-added tax in this particular instance on trans-atlantic travel, on all goods embarked, or, alternatively, have a prolonged turn around at Shannon to embark food and drink there at the expense of losing passenger traffic by extending the length of the journey from Dublin to New York. I do not see that this will help the competitiveness of Aer Lingus in its operations against American carriers with whom, I gather, the Government intend that we should be competing in the very near future when they have finally got around to admitting what they have settled in this particular matter.

Comment on this

What basis is there for that statement by the Deputy? Is he trying to mislead the House again?

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting no decision even behind the scenes has been taken in this matter?

Comment on this

Yes, and has the Deputy any basis for saying otherwise, and if he has why does he not say it? If he has let him tell us what the basis is.

Comment on this

I understood, possibly wrongly, that, in fact, some time ago a decision in principle was taken.

Comment on this

What did the Deputy mean by saying he understood?

Comment on this

I have possibly been unreliably informed.

Comment on this

The Deputy might preface his remarks by that instead of trying to pretend he knows what the situation is and that he is speaking with some authority.

Comment on this

I am only stating the position as I understand it. If the Minister assures me to the contrary I accept his assurance, and, indeed, it is useful to have that matter clarified even in such an improbable place as a debate on the value-added tax.

Comment on this

In other words, the Deputy tries to mislead the House and then tries to justify it by saying: "Well, I got that information." It is a technique with which we are not unfamiliar, but I think attention should be drawn to it.

Comment on this

I think it is appropriate that information of any kind that comes to one's ears which may or may not be correct——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would the Deputy come to the amendment?

Comment on this

One does not speak of a thing like that as being true if one does not know it to be true.

Comment on this

I understood it to be true. If my tone indicated more certitude than the quality of my information justified, then that is a defect of the way I speak. I know I speak more dogmatically than I should at times and I apologise to the Minister.

Comment on this

The national interest is concerned here, and it is unfortunate that the matter should be dealt with in this way.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 39.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister has clarified the position. I would have thought he would be glad to clarify it. I am sorry if I departed from the amendment. The fact that we are concerned with here is that we do not know whether from this moment onwards there is going to be competition. Nobody has any idea as to whether the Government are going to reach agreement on this matter and permit competition into Dublin, and this is still something the Government have yet to decide. We cannot, therefore, give any view on this, but the Minister will allow me to say that the fact that the negotiations are going on suggests this possibility. In the light of this possibility it would seem, even if it is only a possibility, undesirable to worsen the competitive position of Aer Lingus either by imposing a tax on the goods which it lifts at Dublin, if that is the significance of the section as at present drafted, as I believe it to be, or, alternatively, having to spend extra time uploading drink and food at Shannon, thereby prolonging the whole journey and making it less competitive. I shall not dwell on that, but it is an important point.

Even where this is not the case, even where it is not a question of aircraft carrying passengers through Shannon or, indeed, through Cork to the Continent or to Britain, even if it was only a question of an Aer Lingus aircraft undertaking domestic flights on the same day or other days as well as undertaking international flights, the problem arises: how is a clear distinction going to be made in this matter? As regards the repairing and servicing of ships and aircraft, how is the Minister to determine whether an aircraft of Aer Lingus which is being repaired is an aircraft engaged in international commercial transport?

Is it necessary for the company to state or to establish that on its first trip after the repair and maintenance activity, it went to Shannon or to Cork or did not go there but went abroad? Is that what is required, or is it the intention to look at the whole fleet of aircraft and say: "They spend so much of their time outside the country that we will regard them as engaged in international commercial transport of passengers and goods, even though occasionally they undertake domestic trips? Is that the way it is to be undertaken?

It may be that that is the answer on that point and I will be satisfied if the Minister gives that answer, but I am not satisfied and will not be satisfied until the Minister clarifies the issue on the question of aircraft travelling from a point in the State to another point in the State in transit for an international destination. It seems to me that the wording here is explicit —"goods delivered on board ships or aircraft going to places outside the State". This aircraft is not going to places outside the State; it is going to Shannon. It will later be continuing on beyond Shannon. That is another question. Its initial destination is inside the State. Is it that the Minister's interpretation of this is wide enough to allow that if the aircraft is intended to go ultimately outside the State and although it is going to stop inside the State in the first instance, the tax is not payable? Is it the intention of the Minister that if it is a BAC 111 or a Boeing 737, undertaking a purely domestic trip to Shannon the goods will have to pay the 5.26 per cent rate but if the aircraft operating to Shannon is going on across the Atlantic, the food will be at the zero rate? Is this not going to create very great complications for Aer Lingus? I wonder if the Minister has thought this out and whether, on reflection, he may not agree that he is attempting the impossible in this matter and that in the nature of things aircraft are so interchangeable and the work they do, domestically and internationally, so closely inter-related that to attempt to distinguish between them is not practicable.

In the case of shipping, it may be somewhat easier. There are probably vessels engaged more or less exclusively in coastal activities—there used to be a tanker which went from Dublin to Cork exclusively—but even many coasting vessels operate fairly freely either along the coast or, perhaps, to Britain and is it going to be the case that if a coastal vessel is moving goods to Belfast, it is in one position and to Cork, in another position? I wonder whether the Minister has thought out the implications of the section. I do not want to waste time and having developed the point to that stage, I will leave it to the Minister to reply. It may well be that he can satisfy us that he has given adequate thought to this and that the problems I am fearful of may not arise.

Comment on this

I was under the impression that even though the Minister at the special committee did not appear to be very receptive to our ideas on this but the points having been made. I felt possibly he would decide to have another look at it. Like Deputy FitzGerald, I feel that a mistake has been made here and while Deputy FitzGerald has been accused of being dogmatic, I would say that the Minister is being dogmatic about a matter which he should easily recognise as being something on which he should give way. I do not propose to follow the line followed by Deputy FitzGerald because he has fairly well explained it several times, except to say that a few years ago we had in this House numerous complaints about a certain shipbuilding company here that was supposed to have been stocking up with vegetables, fruit and so on from Holland. We all raised our hands in horror and said: "Surely this does not happen," but, in fact, this sort of thing would encourage them to do it because if they stock up from Ireland with the necessary goods, they will have to pay value-added tax. In addition to that, in the case of boats going from Drogheda to Whitehaven, Cork to Whitehaven, Dublin to Whitehaven, this sort of thing happens quite often. They would be outside this; they must pay VAT on stores because they are not exclusively within the waters. The same thing applies with regard to repairs. With regard to aircraft, I think it is ludicrous to suggest that an aircraft which is flying through Ireland should not pick up any food particularly here because if they do, they will have to pay tax on it, whereas if they are going outside, the matter can be dealt with in a different way. This applies also in the case of repairs.

The Minister is, perhaps, being very dogmatic about this and I think he should have another look at it. There is no point in trying to force it here because the Minister says "No" and his cohorts will come in and vote us down—that is a certainty—but I appeal to him to show a little commonsense. This is not a matter over which we should have a lot of disputes.

Comment on this

Of course not.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should, in fairness——

Comment on this

Probably the Deputy is being a little dogmatic now.

Comment on this

I would be dogmatic if I had the forces behind me which the Minister has and that is his only reason for being dogmatic, because he knows he can vote us down. He must realise that he is wrong in this and I suggest he should have another look at it.

Comment on this

I do not know where Deputy Tully dredged up this idea that I am being dogmatic about this. The situation is that we discussed this in the special committee and I agreed to have another look at it. What was involved was the choice of the best wording to achieve what we all agreed should be achieved. I find it difficult to understand how, in those circumstances, my attitude can be described as dogmatic. I have not even replied yet.

Comment on this

But you have not put in an amendment which would give anything like what we are suggesting.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not even heard what is the result of my having looked at it and yet he says my attitude is dogmatic. As it stands, this amendment would apply the zero rate to all goods delivered on board a ship or aircraft, irrespective of whether the ship was engaged in transport within the State or outside the State. It would also exclude from the zero rate the repairing and servicing of ships and aircraft engaged in international commercial transport. I do not know if that was what Deputy FitzGerald intended, but it is not a proposition I would accept.

Comment on this

It is a defect of the amendment and the Minister is quite right in drawing attention to it.

Comment on this

It may be that he put down the amendment in relation to the wrong part of the section. If that is the effect of it then for that reason it could not be accepted.

With regard to the fact that I said I would have a look at this position, I intended when replying to tell the House what the result of that looking at it was. The position is that the main purpose of this provision is to ensure that foreign ships and aircraft can be bunkered and serviced at Irish ports without any tax complications. If we do not do that——

Comment on this

Did the Minister say "foreign ships"?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The Minister, perhaps, meant foreign-going ships?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy let me develop this, please? If we failed to make this kind of provision, there would be a danger that shipping or air companies would take their business elsewhere. As I understood it, Deputy FitzGerald's objection was that the persons carrying out the servicing would not know whether or not the ship or aircraft was engaged in international commercial transport and, consequently, would not know whether or not tax should be charged. On full consideration of this position, the best advice I can get is that there is very little force in the objection. The kind of ship or aircraft which is designed for international transport is well known to the traders who engage in the bunkering or servicing of such vessels. Furthermore, the identity of the owners will also normally identify the kind of activity in which the ship or aircraft is engaged. A foreign ship or an air company is exempt from tax on any service rendered within the State under section 5 (4). Secondly, it may safely be assumed that paragraph V of the Second Schedule will be interpreted as authorising a zero rate on the servicing of all ships or aircraft on behalf of such companies. If that is so, then the only area of doubt which could arise would be in relation to Irish transport companies, such as Irish Shipping or Aer Lingus.

Comment on this

Could the Minister explain why the exemption of something under one section should ensure zero-rating under the Schedule? I do not follow the argument.

Comment on this

I could go back and explain it, but is it really relevant or is it just an interesting point that the Deputy has picked on?

Comment on this

I just want to understand the Minister. I am sorry.

Comment on this

The words "going to a place outside the State", are these cogged from some foreign Act passed in France, or Germany, or Holland, or somewhere like that?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy let me finish and then put his question and I shall try to answer it? On the basis of what I have said, the only real area of doubt would be in relation to an Irish transport company, like Irish Shipping or Aer Lingus. In fact, it makes relatively little difference whether or not they are charged the tax because, since most of their business is outside the State, they would in any event be entitled to be repaid practically the whole of the tax they have suffered.

We have looked at this matter to see if we could devise a better wording to meet the situation we are trying to meet. We have not been able to produce anything better. The present wording seems to be reasonably suitable. It is clear, of course, that the whole problem of the treatment of transport under the value-added tax system presents considerable difficulties. This is so particularly where a single consideration covers transport which is partly within the State and partly outside it. This is one of the problems which is being considered by a special study group of the EEC and it is likely that a uniform system for dealing with this problem will be suggested in the near future to the member States. In the meantime, the wording in the Bill is the best we have been able to produce, having given considerable thought to it, and that wording will be interpreted administratively as meaning that, in relation to a contract for passenger transport, excluding any idea of a tour, from a place within the State to a place outside the State and vice versa, the whole of the consideration will qualify for a zero rating. In the case of, say, Aer Lingus, on a flight from Dublin to New York, the hop to Shannon will be ignored.

Comment on this

It does not say that in the Bill.

Comment on this

No, but I have explained the situation.

Comment on this

The Minister is aware that the interpretation of Acts beforehand has resulted in people saying that they do not care what the particular Minister said: they will take what is in the Act. I know the Minister has the intention of doing it properly.

Comment on this

May I remind the Deputy again that we have tried to devise a better wording and we have failed. No better wording has come from the Opposition either and so we are stuck with what we have. But I have placed on the record of the House the intention as to how this will be administered.

Comment on this

I suggest that the intention of the Minister as to how something is to be administered has not been accepted on other occasions.

Comment on this

Subject to certain qualifications, I do not think that is true. I would ask the Deputy to consider in what circumstances would it arise that someone would apply to the courts to upset this administrative interpretation.

Comment on this

Someone prosecuted for not paying value-added tax on goods might take it to court and quote what the Minister said and the court would say: "Sorry, but we take what is in the Act."

Comment on this

Who would take it to court?

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

If the Revenue Commissioners took someone to court on the basis of what I have placed on the record of the House as the intention of the Administration, then the Revenue Commissioners should be sacked and, if I were Minister for Finance, they would be sacked.

Comment on this

Sacked if they obeyed the law? That is an interesting proposition.

Comment on this

I have explained to the House that no one has yet come up with a solution but Deputy FitzGerald, of course, knows the answer clearly.

Comment on this

I am just talking about the legal effect of this. I am not talking about what the study group in the EEC may be trying to do about the problem.

Comment on this

It is exactly the same problem. I wish we would not waste the time of this House with the kind of nonsense that Deputy FitzGerald goes on with.

Comment on this

In this case I think I can understand why Deputy FitzGerald is raising the matter.

Comment on this

Has anyone a better suggestion? We have discussed all this before and no one has come up with a better suggestion. It has been gone into as thoroughly as possible and we have not been able to do anything better.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not do what is done in the British Act?

Comment on this

No, I would not.

Comment on this