Committee on Finance. - Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971: Report Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 405–598 of 805. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 30 of 1971 ›
First of all, the Minister is perfectly right in saying my amendment is defective. In drafting 33 amendments my eyes slipped and I deleted more than I intended to delete. I should have left in the last three lines of the original section and, if the Minister were prepared to consider the amendment, I would, of course, amend it to correct the defect in the drafting. The Minister asks how can this be done. In the British Act, as regards repairing and servicing ships and aircraft, ships and aircraft are defined according to their size by a rough and ready rule which more or less differentiates between foreign-going ships and aircraft. If a ship is over 1500 tons it is capable of going abroad and, if it is under 1500, it is not. In the case of aircraft differentiation is based on a weight of 18,000 lbs. If the aircraft is over 18,000 lbs it is treated as an aircraft likely to go abroad and, if it is not over that figure, it is treated as less likely to go abroad. A ship or aircraft designed or adapted for recreation or pleasure, such as a steam or motor yacht, is not covered. It is done on the basis of size. What has the Minister against that? He challenges us to produce a solution. I ask him what is wrong with the British Act and he will not answer me. I put it to the Minister there is an answer there. I am not saying it is the best answer, but it is an answer.
Comment on this
If the Deputy really wanted a dialogue he would not carry on as he has been carrying on here all day. Indeed, he will find a much greater dialogue going on between me and the Labour Benches. It is not any personal animosity now, but it must have sunk into him by now that Deputies on all sides are getting tired of Deputy FitzGerald's purely debating points.
Comment on this
I have had some comments from the Minister and from one or two Deputies on the Labour Benches who seem to have some feelings in my regard.
Comment on this
I take it that my job is to oppose constructively, to explore the difficulties in legislation and to put constructive suggestions as to how these difficulties may be overcome. I will not be put off by any Minister trying to tell me that I am taking too long to do that job.
Comment on this
If the Minister is not capable of restraining himself and wishes to become cross, I cannot prevent him from doing so.
Comment on this
The Minister issued a challenge. He asked: "How can this be done" and I suggested helpfully——
Comment on this
I recall an important occasion in this House when I had been on my feet for only a minute or two to oppose a Bill that was found subsequently to be unconstitutional, and Deputy FitzGerald accused me of wasting time.
Comment on this
It is absolutely possible that that happened. I am not objecting to either the Minister or any Deputy saying that I am wasting time. They are entitled to say so if they wish but I am impervious to the suggestion that because I pursue a legitimate point beyond the point that the Minister finds acceptable, I should then sit down. This is not my idea of opposition and never will be. I try to be courteous and I try also not to press an issue beyond the point of no return and where discussion will not lead any further I try not to be repetitious. Perhaps I fail on all these counts but I continue trying and I am sorry if the Minister finds me so trying.
On the particular point I will ask the Minister to consider the simple solution to the problem of the latter part which has been found in the British Act on the basis of the size of the vehicle. This is an obvious solution and one that has been used for other purposes in other Acts. On the first question of goods delivered on board a ship or aircraft, I think I can take it that what the Minister is saying is that if the ship or aircraft is going to a place outside the State even if it is to stop en route, he will interpret it in that way. It seems a fair interpretation and I am prepared to accept it. It could be turned over in court but I do not think it likely that that would happen. However, in the latter part, in respect of aircraft or ships engaged in international commercial transport of passengers and goods, the definition is vague and impracticable. The Minister's hesitant reply indicates that is his opinion also. He has admitted that he has sought a solution but failed to find one. Therefore, I ask him simply to do what was done in the British Act which in this case seems sensible.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 40 and 41 are related and may be taken simultaneously.
Comment on this
I would like to point out to the Chair that we had a discussion with the Ceann Comhairle this morning in respect of these amendments and it is our wish that they be taken separately.
Comment on this
I am being guided on this by instructions which I took from the Leas-Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
All the Leas-Cheann Comhairle could have told the Chair was that if agreed by the proposers, the amendments could be taken together. We do not agree to that. Therefore, they must be taken separately.
Comment on this
Would it meet the requirements of the Labour Deputies if the amendments were discussed together and the proposers had a right of reply?
Comment on this
The Minister has got the point but the question is whether it is in order to deal with them in that way. If they are taken together the first one is moved by the proposer who has the right of reply but if it is defeated, the other falls. For that reason we wish our amendment to be taken separately. I am prepared to accept the Minister's suggestion if that procedure is in order.
Comment on this
If they are taken together there will be an opportunity given to the Labour Deputies and to Deputy FitzGerald to reply separately.
Comment on this
I understand this is not a precedent that can be guaranteed to be granted at any future time.
Comment on this
The reason for tabling our amendment was brought out clearly at the special committee. It is an amendment which will be met by the increase of £3.7 million that the Minister mentioned. We took these foods out deliberately to meet that view because we knew that the Minister could not afford to lose £15 million in revenue.
Comment on this
I propose that we get on with the amendments.
Comment on this
The Chair said that two Labour Deputies and Deputy FitzGerald would have the right of reply. I take it that he meant a Labour Deputy or, alternatively, that Deputy FitzGerald and others would have the right of reply. I am sure that no distinction of that kind was intended.
Comment on this
It is strange that the Deputy should raise this sort of issue. There are two names here.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wishes to make an issue of this, we can go on talking on it for the next half hour.
Comment on this
The trouble with Deputy FitzGerald is that he is always trying to clarify matters unnecessarily.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:
In page 42, after line 24, to add a new paragraph as follows: "() food of a kind used for human consumption and non-alcoholic drink."
If the Chairman decides to permit two speakers from Labour and one from Fine Gael, we can be tolerant about such matters. The question of food here is a major issue. It is our belief that social justice requires that food should not be taxed. This is a point which can be argued best by reference to the facts of the situation. When one examines such evidence as we have, which is fairly extensive and, with some limitations is valid information on household budgets, one finds that food as a proportion of household budgets varies greatly according to the incomes of the families concerned. It would be difficult, perhaps impossible to find any other range of articles which looms so much larger proportionately in the budgets of poor and large families than food. Therefore, in specifying food for zero-rating we are picking on something that would have the maximum social impact. It might be thought that at this stage in the history of the country with its relative affluence, this would not be true to such an extent but it is true and the large variation in respect of foods generally in the household budget inquiry of 1965-66 was that from about 43 per cent of the family budgets of the poorer families were constituted by food down to 21 per cent in the case of the better-off families. In other words the proportion was twice as large in respect of the poorer families.
If one takes a narrower range of food—the range discussed at the special committee which I shall not go into because there seems to be some doubts as to whether we are entitled to refer to it because of the failure to have the report published, that is, that range of foods which constitutes 75 per cent of total food consumption—the difference in ratio was more marked. These foods are described commonly as necessary foods. The range of foods left for consideration by the special committee, representing three-quarters of all foods, are even more skewed in this way than the total food consumption. So much so that for these foods which one can describe loosely as necessities, the proportion of the budget was 31 per cent in respect of poor families and 10 per cent in respect of better-off families. As the foods mentioned in the Labour Party amendment are drawn from this list I suspect that these foods are ones on which the expenditure is very much larger in the poorer families than in the richer families. To that extent the Labour amendment is well judged in terms of seeking to achieve the maximum benefit possible for the poorer families within certain limits of cost to the Exchequer of about £4 million. I was not of the opinion that one should limit oneself to such a figure but in imposing such limits one would choose foods that would be on the lines of those mentioned in the Labour amendment. To that extent I support the amendment but I would like to press my own amendment first before adverting to the Labour amendment.
All food should be exempt because if we take the range of goods which were not covered by the suggestions made in the special committee there is one-quarter of foods which are regarded as less necessary. Even in that range of foods which represented 14 per cent of the budgets of poorer families and 10 per cent of the budgets of richer families, although the disparity there is much less than in the case of necessities it is still marked. In other words, by including the whole range of foods rather than the conventional necessities one increases the social impact by benefiting poorer families more at the expense of richer families. Given that and given the technical complications for retailers of distinguishing different foods it seems to me better that the whole of foods should be zero rated and that the necessary arrangements should be made to find the tax revenue from other sources and it is on that basis that this proposal is put forward.
If the amendment were accepted there would be a loss of revenue estimated at about £15 million. I think that estimate is common ground. In preparing any estimates which I shall be submitting I had the opportunity, through the courtesy of the Minister, of consultation with the Revenue Commissioners who were immensely helpful in checking out my calculations and in bringing me through many complications in the calculations which I would not have got through successfully myself, although this particular figure is one which I calculated myself and which I validated by reference to them. The money would have to be found from another source. In fact, in formal discusions proposals were put forward by this party which we have since published indicating how that money might be found. The total sum we would be seeking would be somewhat larger because we were also including some other articles which, as they are not referred to in this amendment, I shall not mention. That led to a need to find, not £15 million but over £17 million and any figures I give about finding money are related to that slightly larger figure going beyond the amount required to compensate for the zero rating of food.
The proposals which we put forward after considerable thought for finding the money were, first, that the present turnover tax—we can talk for the moment in these terms although that tax is, of course, being absorbed in the value-added system— should be increased by 1 per cent from 5 per cent to 6 per cent. In other words, you would have a value-added tax of about 6.4 per cent which we rounded up for the Minister's benefit to 6.5 per cent in lieu of the 5.26 per cent which is proposed in the Bill. Such a change would mean an additional £8.5 million, only half of the sum required. Therefore, it was also proposed that the present 10 per cent wholesale tax rate applying to about one-seventh of consumer expenditure should be increased to 15 per cent. This would be achieved by having for the goods in question a VAT rating of about 24 per cent in lieu of the proposed 16.37 per cent. The effect of such a change in VAT would be the equivalent within the present system of having a 5 per cent turnover tax and a 15 per cent wholesale tax instead of the present 10 per cent. This would yield a further £8.05 million.
Another feature of our proposal, which I shall not dwell on because we have dealt with it, was that this higher rate of wholesale tax turned into VAT at a rate of 24 per cent, would be trapped at the wholesale level and would not pass on to the retail level. As a result, through this scheme we achieve a single rate of tax at the retail level. I mention that merely to link these together.
The effect of these proposals, therefore, would be to yield an extra £16.5 million replacing the £17 million lost through zero rating of food and certain other commodities we shall discuss later. In other words, we replaced virtually all that money. It was also proposed, although this is not an integral part of the proposal here, that the proposed 30.26 per cent rate on cars, radio sets, records and record-players should be brought down to the 24 per cent rate and so have a single rate of wholesale tax. This would mean a certain cost to the Exchequer which would be more than met, we felt, by the extra revenue which the Minister proposes to get by his proposal to have the 16.37 per cent rate bringing in an extra £3.5 million.
If these tax changes were to be effective and satisfactory it would be necessary that the benefits of the tax reductions on food and the proposed other items should be passed on to the consumer. It would be necessary to ensure that where taxes are reduced as proposed in our amendment, and over a narrow range of goods proposed in the Labour amendment, that the retailers would pass this on to the consumer. One might think forces of competition would achieve this and very generally I think this would be the case but some doubt has been cast on the local effectiveness of the forces of competition by some recent figures and there are local problems in this respect. We recognise that it would be necessary for the National Prices Commission to keep an eye on this situation but we cannot accept the Minister's suggestion, repeatedly made in the special committee and I think earlier today here in another context, that we may no longer reduce taxes because in his view any tax reduction will not be passed on to the consumer. He went so far in the special committee as to suggest that a marginal reduction in tax from 5.26 per cent to 5 per cent would, by virtue of being a change in tax, so confuse people that retailers would put up prices. The proposition that we cannot reduce taxes without people putting up prices in response to it is one which I found curious and very unconvincing.
Neither am I convinced that we are in a position, where the mismanagement of the country's affairs and the failure to control cartel monopolies has been so total that the Government are now impotent to reduce taxes on expenditure lest these not be passed on to the public. To suggest that is to condemn the policy of the Government, and particularly of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in regard to prices so utterly that such a suggestion would come better, though not very convincingly, from the Opposition than from the Minister for Finance. That he should have so little confidence in his Government's prices policy as to believe that he dare not reduce taxes because the benefits would not be passed on because the cartel-monopoly situation and the failure of price surveillance is such that he could not guarantee the benefits would be passed on, is an utter condemnation of the Government's prices policy which I was surprised to hear from the Minister. Even a member of the Opposition might be slow to make such an accusation.
I am not convinced; I do not think he really believes his Government are as inept and as incompetent as that. I believe he is making an excuse not to do what in our view should be done. The price surveillance machinery is, or can be made sufficiently effective to secure this result.
There is another aspect of this which is another complication that must be dealt with. If our proposal for the trapping of the new rate of VAT of 24 per cent at the wholesale stage were to be accepted to achieve a single tax at the retail stage one consequence would be that the base for the calculation of the tax would be increased and as a result retail margins, if calculated on a percentage basis on a wholesale tax base, would rise in absolute terms. The Minister made this point in the special committee; he suggested this was a difficulty to be faced and that there was a danger that because retailers' margins are calculated in percentage terms in many instances and because he felt they would not agree to modify these, the effect of a proposal involving the trapping of more tax than is now trapped—at present only the tax at the higher rate of wholesale tax is trapped—the trapping of all wholesale tax, if that were done, would create a problem by increasing the absolute amount of retailers' margin by their applying the same percentages as at present to a larger wholesale tax base.
Recognising this as a point I took the opportunity of consulting with various retail groups. I sought public assurances from them which they would have to stand over and on which they could be policed—if that is the right word—by the National Prices Commission, should the occasion arise, that they would reduce their percentage margins by the appropriate amounts which would be a reduction of about one-eighteenth in the present percentage margin.
I received such assurances willingly from the RGDATA Group representing the VG, Spar and Mace groups as well as supermarket chains like Williams, Liptons and Five Star, and also from the Association of Voluntary Groups representing the MNC and the Londis organisations. Since these groups did not cover two major supermarket groups, Dunnes' Stores and Quinnsworth. I approached them and sought and got similar assurances from them. These were assurances given in public and they would, therefore, be open to supervision by an adequate prices surveillance mechanism if we had one, and I hope we have or can have one. Therefore, the only objection put forward by the Minister was overcome. On that basis we put forward our proposal at an informal meeting of members of the special committee.
Comment on this
Indeed, a private meeting, at the end of which there was some discussion as to what might be said about it. Agreement was reached that each Party present could state what they had said or done at the meeting but should not speak for others.
Comment on this
The statement issued by Fine Gael dealt only with our own position. We left it to the Minister to clarify his position which he did about 24 hours later. There was a certain informal briefing that night of the Press through the Government Information Bureau.
Comment on this
Acting as a responsible Opposition we devised a proposal which would meet the problem of maintaining the revenue. We went laboriously into the calculations. We checked them out with the Revenue Commissioners to make sure that we had not gone wrong, and that we would not be misleading the special committee or the House. We satisfied ourselves that our proposal was realistic in terms of replacement of revenue that might be lost if this amendment were accepted.
We also sought to ensure that the difficulty put forward by the Minister would be fully met by the necessary assurances from these organisations. We did everything we could to ensure that the zero-rating of food could be undertaken and that no valid excuse could be put forward to prevent this being done in the interests of the lower income group whose consumption of food represents such a high proportion of their budget, and whose living standards would be improved if this proposal went through.
The effect of this proposal would be roughly as follows on the price of the various goods: On food and other goods which we propose to zero-rate, a reduction of 5 per cent; on other goods, which we also proposed should be zero-rated, a reduction of about 7 per cent—certain goods which are sold by grocers which are not actually foodstuffs. The effect of our proposal to standardise the rate of value-added tax, other than the 5.26 per cent rate, at 24 per cent would be to reduce the price of cars and other goods like TV and radio sets by 5 per cent. Increases in prices would occur also; for the great majority of goods now liable to turnover tax only, representing a high proportion, something like two-fifths of total consumption, A 1 per cent increase in price; and for goods which at present involve one-seventh of household consumption an increase of 7 per cent in price.
The effect would be to switch the burden of taxation to a significant and perceptible degree from the lower income group to the higher income group which can afford, on a large scale, the kind of goods on which wholesale tax is paid. Virtually all groups in the community must buy some goods on which wholesale tax is payable but, when you come to the kind of goods which represent only one-seventh of total consumption, and which are in the upper bracket, and which together with cars and TV and radio sets represent one-fifth of consumption, obviously poor families can buy very little and richer families buy more. The shifting of the burden is quite perceptible.
We examined a great number of alternatives. We considered one proposal which was the doubling of the turnover tax on goods not zero-rated but, having examined its social consequences, we found they were not as beneficial as the proposal we put forward and accordingly we did not put it forward. In a statement to the papers, which I found disturbing in its degree of dishonesty, the Minister said that we have not referred to our proposal for the doubling of turnover tax which we intended to put into effect if our first scheme was found to be defective or inoperable. It was not our proposal at any stage. I do not know whether I am now entitled to disclose what the Minister said. I think I am.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donovan is so sensitive that I do not want to hurt his feelings any more. They were very hurt during the course of the day.
Comment on this
I do not think that any little difference between Deputy O'Donovan and myself should be taken too seriously.
Comment on this
I am interested in the amendment. We have an amendment down too and we are finishing at 12 o'clock.
Comment on this
I am sorry that I was deflected from my purpose. I am coming to the end of what I want to say on this point. At the committee, after I put forward our proposal which does not involve the doubling of turnover tax, the Minister put forward a number of what he described as possible solutions including the doubling of turnover tax or, to be more precise, the raising of the value-added tax rate from 5.26 per cent to 11½ per cent which he described as equivalent to doubling turnover tax.
None of us commented on this proposal at the time. The discussion was deflected into a different area, the area which lies between the Fine Gael and Labour amendments as to whether we should zero-rate all food or some food. The chairman, Deputy Healy, will confirm this because he was interested in that part of the discussion. The Minister then said he would like to revert—and the word used was "revert"—to the suggestion he put forward, or the point he made, or the proposal he put forward, in relation to increasing the turnover tax rate to 11½ per cent. I cannot quote verbatim. He said he would like to have Deputy FitzGerald's views on it.
Again I cannot quote verbatim but I said something to the effect that we thought our proposal was better from the point of view of social justice and that, while the debate had been going on, I had been doing some calculations because it seemed to me that the Minister had not done any calculations on the question of the social impact on different social groups. My calculations showed that the Minister's suggestion of doubling turnover tax would have some socially beneficial effects but nothing like as many as ours and therefore we rejected it. To find that after that history in the committee the Minister could be so lacking in regard for the truth as to say that this was our proposal was below the standards which we have generally expected from the Minister in question. If he were here I would suggest politely that he might like to withdraw it. He is not here at the moment and I cannot blame him because it has been a long day.
To sum up, the net effect of our proposal would be gains for the lower income group and, roughly speaking, families with less than about £1,250 would benefit from these proposals and only families with about £2,000 a year or more would lose perceptibly. This seems to me to be a good proposal from the social point of view. The Minister tried to suggest to the committee that the problem could be met by provisions in the social welfare code and children's allowances. That seemed an extraordinary suggestion because the kind of people this is designed to help would include, for example, unmarried women living alone—a group, as I have said before in this House, we pay too little attention to—and such unmarried women living alone in Dublin, anyway, have no chance whatever of getting a house in the foreseeable future.
They would have to acquire a husband and two children before they would get a house. Not being able to get a house from the corporation, they must pay private rents. If they want to live anywhere but in a tenement, this involves at least £5 or £6 a week, in many cases much more. The typical pay of such a woman is about £12 a week. We take £1 a week in income tax from her. We refuse to provide her with public accommodation and force her into private accommodation which will be at least £5 or £6 a week. We provide no social benefits. Unless she is an unmarried mother she gets no children's allowances. The Minister says that people like that who would benefit significantly by our proposals, because a very high percentage of their budget is on food, would be benefited by increased social welfare benefits which do not apply to them, or by children's allowances, which do not apply to them. The Minister has no understanding of the problem if he thinks in these terms and it is unfortunate that he holds the purse strings, if that is the level of his interest and concern.
One of the biggest groups in need of assistance here, more than any other single group, are the pensioners whose expenditure on food is an exceptionally high proportion of their total expenditure. One thing about old age pensioners is that they rarely have children. To talk about increasing the children's allowance to help old age pensioners is an absurd proposal. The Minister attempts to get out of his obligation to deal with this problem by trying to suggest that he is going to deal with it, perhaps, in the next budget by increasing social welfare benefits and the spending of the EEC money. We all know what they will try to do with that and how they will try to fob off the elections until then in order to get maximum electoral benefit from it. His suggestion that that will solve the problem of the social groups I have mentioned is nonsensical because, of its nature, in regard to some of these groups, it cannot do that. The Minister knows that and he is misleading the House and the country in putting forward that suggestion. The only way that people like the unmarried women can be helped is, in fact, to accept a proposal of this kind. The Minister knows that and should have regard to that when he comes to reply to this debate. I shall not speak any longer because there are other Deputies who wish to speak.
Comment on this
Thanks to Deputy FitzGerald for being so brief. We have a number of amendments which must be discussed and we have only up to 12 midnight. Deputy FitzGerald has made a case for his amendment and he stated what he considered preferable to ours. If you go back to the special committee on which this matter was discussed, the first item under consideration was selected foods and Deputy E. Collins, who so far has got no credit from anybody, is the person who named the foods which he asked to be costed. It is only fair to say that. The special committee consisted of more than Deputy FitzGerald and the Minister for Finance. There were a number of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Deputies on it and there were Deputy O'Donovan and myself. Everybody took part in the debate and there were some very constructive comments made by members of the three parties. Everybody was anxious to provide some kind of solution and to tease it out so that in this House we would not have lengthy speeches on matters already explained to us. I understood that that was the whole idea. I am rather disappointed that that has not been the end product.
Having discussed the question of selected foods, the Minister then said that if we were able to list what we wanted and Deputy Collins gave a list which was costed and also a list of items where we thought the increases should come from, he would consider it. The foods were to be listed and costed. The Minister said we should do it. My suggestion, which was accepted by the special committee, was that since the Minister had the Civil Service at his disposal he was in a better position to get both sides of the story than we were. The Minister produced certain figures to us and we discussed them. The Minister's argument was that the main reason why he did not want to exempt selected foods— what we call essential foods—the essential foods listed in our amendment— bread, tea, sugar, butter, milk, margarine and oranges—was that the cost to the Exchequer of exempting these would be £4.11 million. In view of the fact that the Minister admitted that the excess of revenue to the State as a result of the changeover would be £3.70 million, we felt that these items could, in fact, be covered easily without any upset.
The Minister made the argument that the retailers would not take kindly to those foods being exempted, that, if they were zero-rated, it would be a third rate of tax and that they would object to this. We could not see that point. We told him that we thought that to call a zero-rating a separate tax was ridiculous. The Minister eventually persuaded Deputy FitzGerald that it was so. He also stated that it would be better to try to cost the exemption of all foods, and this also Deputy FitzGerald accepted. Hence the amendment here this evening. The Minister having succeeded at the special committee in persuading Deputy FitzGerald that it was better to discuss the zero-rating of all foods, he then, in answer to a question from me, said he had no intention of zero-rating any foods. In fact, he had taken the ball completely out of our court simply by giving the impression that he proposed to consider zero-rating of foods and then saying that it would cost too much, that it would mean doubling turnover tax and it would mean paying double tax—10.5 per cent it was eventually—on essential items other than foods. Having reached that stage, it was agreed that nothing further could be done about the matter and so we come here today.
We have suggested again that essential foods should be exempted. We do so because we are concerned for the old age pensioner living alone, the widow living alone, the man and wife with a young family on a small wage, persons living on small fixed incomes.
So many people talk about the affluent society and about how people live. The people I have mentioned live mainly on bread and spread—tea, bread and margarine. They use some milk. When I go into houses in country districts where the occupants have not got a very high standard of living, I am appalled to find so many people who would laugh at the mention of the price of meat. They do not buy meat because they cannot afford it. If value-added tax is added on to essential foods they will have to reduce still further the food they eat and the food they give their children.
We talk a great deal about the great Christian country this is, how different we are from pagan England. In England they have excluded all foods from the value-added tax and have been able to do it. Here we are simply asking that essential foods be left out and we are pointing out that the amount of money involved, £4.11 million on the Minister's own figures, is almost counterbalanced by the amount which the Minister says the Revenue Commissioners say will be collected in excess, £3.70 million. The Minister today admitted that he himself felt there would be very much more than that collected but that he was not prepared to put an exact figure on it. He agreed that because of a new system of taxation which it is proposed to introduce and the double or treble check which can be carried out it would be almost impossible for those who should pay value-added tax to avoid it. The result will be that there will be additional revenue. Various figures have been bandied around the country and one can choose any figure one likes from £20 million down to £9 million or £10 million extra, but it is pretty clear that there will be a substantial amount of extra revenue coming in from value-added tax. We are merely asking that the small sum of £410,000 should be used for the purpose of subsidising, if necessary, even if no extra revenue comes in, the food which is used admittedly by almost everybody but is absolutely essential for people who have not enough of this world's goods.
For this reason we did not go for all foods. We know quite well the Minister will prove conclusively, if not to us on this side of the House, to his own Government and his own backbenchers that it should not be done, and he will get their voting strength behind him in the lobby, and therefore we cannot carry it. Nevertheless we feel that, in fairness, the Minister should accept the second alternative.
Briefly to deal with the suggestion that zero taxation is an additional tax, I should like to know how the Minister makes this out. Our biggest problem in regard to taxation is that when the person buys an article in a shop or supermarket—and we have been giving the example of the supermarket, which perhaps is not typical of the country district but it is the simplest way of giving the example—and then goes to the check-out system, the girl on the check-out system has to take two things into account at the present time, the price of the article and, if tax has to be added, what it is. Under the new system, she will have to take into account whether the commodity is taxed at the lower rate of 5.26 or the higher rate of 16.37. If there are certain items of essential food that are not taxed, surely it is unreasonable to suggest that it is an extra burden for anybody to say: "There is no tax on this, how much is that?" They do not have to add it on; they simply take the price as it is.
I dealt earlier with the Minister's suggestion that this question of the two rates of tax could be got over by putting on the 5.26 at shelf level. I disagree entirely with this suggestion because it means that lower-priced articles will be heavily over-taxed if that happens. However, no matter what is done I suggest there are only two rates of tax involved, not three. If the zero-rate is put on the essential foods, then there should be no difficulty. I do not think any trader would object to extra work being put on him because there is no question of having to estimate the tax; there is no tax. Therefore I suggest to the Minister that he should accept the amendment which Deputy O'Donovan and myself have put down on behalf of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
May I be allowed to speak on this occasion before the next member of the Fine Gael Party; it is not because my name is to the amendment but because I have to go away. It was Deputy Tully who first drew up this subject of bread and butter, tea and sugar at the Special Committee and Deputy Eddie Collins added red meats to it. It is all a matter of opinion. I think there should be no tax on any food, but I had to take what I thought we might get, and of course that was destroyed by the very bad behaviour of Deputy FitzGerald. I wrote to the Minister about this matter. I notice Deputy FitzGerald pretended it did not happen at all. He is quite entitled to behave like that if he likes. I wrote long before the private meeting; as a matter of fact the Minister's reply to me was sent to the various Deputies and rightly so. I have not disclosed what I said to the Minister or what the Minister said to me, and I have no intention of disclosing it. That is my standard.
When we came to deal with the matter I understood from what the Minister had said when he asked for the private meeting of the committee that he really wanted to do something, but naturally enough when the thing was blown out in the open by one Deputy running off to the newspapers he dug his heels in. He did not lose his temper; others have not been so kind but perhaps we have more reason because we are more concerned about it. The Minister and the Government have already taxed food, so they are not so concerned about it. I agree with Deputy Tully, and this is why I support him so roundly. I put in only one item, oranges. It is not worth talking about; it would cost only £80,000. The reason I put it in is that there is a serious deficiency of vitamin C in this country, the medicos will talk ad lib about that. Oranges are important. I remember when the war was ending, the first cargo of oranges that came in here were regarded as gold. But the other commodities that are even more important are bread, butter, margarine, tea, sugar and milk. We put down this amendment in this way not because, unlike the Fine Gael Party, we are in favour of taxation on food. Not at all, but because we knew the Minister would not take the tax off anything except these items. He had told us quite significantly at the last public meeting of the committee that he had £3.7 million. We proceeded to see what we could get for the £3.7 million, and this is what we proposed. Like Deputy Tully I heard Deputy Garret FitzGerald talking about figures and how he consulted traders, supermarkets, and so on. He should have been around the slums of Dublin consulting the ordinary residents there.
Comment on this
I will make a bet with the Deputy, that I did more for the St. Vincent de Paul Society than he did. This is one thing I do know something about.
Comment on this
He pretends that he did. He put down the big amendment. We put down the small one. We do not wear our hearts on our sleeves. He is trying to ride two horses at the same time. This was something which we felt the Minister might agree to but when the matter was blown out into the open the Minister came into the private meeting of the committee and, although, as I say, he was quite polite, he dug his heels in and did not move an iota during all that discussion. There was a complete change of atmosphere, and this is why I object so strongly about the matter this evening.
Let nobody suggest that I am not in favour of taking taxation completely off food. I am, because I have always spoken against the taxation of food, but on this occasion we wanted to get something from the Minister if we could, and we knew what we were up against and so Deputy Tully and I assessed the position. Deputy Tully prepared the amendment and I signed it with him. This is why we did it, not because it represents our real views but because it represents what we thought was practicable. Politics is the art of the possible. One tries to achieve what one can. We are all here to do the best we can for the people and there is no use in pretending that in what we call our affluent society, the great bulk of the population do not have as their basic foods bread, butter margarine, tea, sugar and milk. Nobody need tell me that. The suggestion was made that baby foods might be relieved of tax but most small children are fed on milk and I suggest that 90 per cent of babies are fed on milk.
Comment on this
It is regrettable that this squabble had to take place on this matter. For once, let me be fair to the Fianna Fáil Party. They had seven members on the committee and not one of them opened his mouth in public, but a real effort was made to make political mileage out of something in respect of which no such attempt should have been made, and it was made in the most objectionable way. In a democracy if the democrats, the people in this House, subvert democracy, we have all had it and above all else, the people who talk most about democracy and do this kind of thing deserve the most blame. I hope that Fine Gael Deputies are going to talk on this, but I am personally not prepared to vote for the Fine Gael amendment but I propose to vote for the Labour Party amendment because I think it the practical thing to do.
Comment on this
I thought I made it plain enough but if the Deputy could not take it in, perhaps he could not hear me, although Deputy Cooney understood me all right.
Comment on this
Is this the way this House is being run? Deputy O'Donovan had not sat down when this Deputy jumped up, not allowing any other Deputy to get in. It is nothing but a positive disgrace. However, I hope I will get the next chance.
Comment on this
I could not make any worse contribution than you.
Comment on this
I will vote whatever way I like but not for your gang anyway.
Comment on this
I was somewhat surprised by Deputy O'Donovan's attitude in relation to this amendment because we did discuss this fully at a number of meetings of the special committee and I think it was agreed by the members at these meetings that partial zero rating would not be the best way of approaching this problem——
Comment on this
——and that the simplest way of approaching this problem would be a global one of zero rating of foodstuffs and partial zero-rating would not be the best approach. The proposals put forward by Deputy FitzGerald are comprehensive in nature and deserving of credit, and I wish to place on record that in his comprehensive approach in relation to proposals to zero-rate food, he has done a very good service. Allied with this zero-rating of foods would be a simplification of the value-added tax charged at the retail level. He intended to trap the equivalent of a wholesale tax at the manufacturing and wholesale level and at retail level there would be two basic taxes, the zero-rate and 6 per cent VAT. This I think is acceptable to the retailers especially and it has the excellent effect of zero-rating all foodstuffs. This is a principle so far as the Fine Gael Party are concerned which has prevailed down the years. It is a good social principle and one in which I concur fully.
There should be an attempt to zero-rate foods for one major reason, that we are going into the EEC on January 1st. This will bring benefits in relation to some of our food exports, particularly meat, and the cost of living will increase and this increase in the cost of living will bear most heavily on people with smaller incomes, such as old age pensioners and people on fixed incomes who have not the bargaining position of trade unions. There are many in our society who live on the poverty line and the aim of the amendment is to go some way towards protecting their real income. The effect of it would be to decrease the price of foodstuffs by the equivalent of 5 per cent and this would hold back inflation on these people, especially those in the poorer classes who are suffering from a very high level of inflation in the past few years. It is a socially desirable amendment and I approve of it.
I proposed a list of foodstuffs at a meeting of the special committee somewhat more comprehensive than that proposed today by Deputies O'Donovan and Tully. I proposed bread, butter, magarine, tea, sugar, red meats, white meats, fish, potatoes, household vegetables and liquid milk and Deputy O'Donovan added oranges. I feel that the items produced by these Deputies are lacking in protein and not a really well-balanced list of items. Surely it should be the aim to improve if possible, the diet available to everybody. Deputy O'Donovan's item of oranges is a very valid item on medical grounds. I was surprised to find that the Labour amendment excluded fish, potatoes and household vegetables. Surely they should be included. The Minister, in principle, should have made some effort to zero-rate foodstuffs. This would require a marginal recording of the value-added tax rates and we would, of course, support any marginal change in the value-added tax rates provided such a change would benefit the lower income groups. Faced with the EEC, with inflation, with higher prices we must take a positive stand here to protect the less well-off sections of our community. It is for that reason I am more in favour of Deputy FitzGerald's amendment than I am of the Labour Party amendment. I do not think the latter goes far enough. I would like to see the Minister taking positive action to zero-rate foodstuffs. We have put forward a sound financial remodelling of the value-added tax rates. It would be generous of the Minister to acknowledge that this is possible. It would be even more generous of him to accept the amendment in principle and come forward himself with his own zero-rate on foodstuffs and a reorientation of the other value-added tax rates.
Comment on this
I am in some difficulty here in dealing with this because I was refused an answer on two occasions this evening to a very simple question. The answer should have been a simple "Yes" or "No". I am now in the unenviable position that I am not sure which way I shall vote. It would have been as easy for the Minister to answer my question and let me know what exactly the position will be as for someone else to shoot me down. If there is a vote, I am not sure how I shall vote.
Comment on this
The Deputy can do what he likes, but he knows very well that I was forbidden by the Chair to answer the question, which was ruled out of order.
Comment on this
It was a very simple question. If I ask it again——
Comment on this
If I get the answer it will enable me to sit down sooner than I will sit down if the Minister does not answer it.
Comment on this
If the Minister answers the question it will put me on my backside in half the time it would take me normally. The question is a simple one. I admit it was ruled out of order. It is not a hypothetical or a theoretical question. As the Ceann Comhairle probably knows, people do not register for turnover tax unless it can be proved against them that they sell more than £1,100 worth. The answer I want is a simple one. Will this same rule apply in the case of this new tax or am I to take it that an unfortunate publican who sells only £700 worth a month, or less, will have to keep accounts just for the sake of keeping up with this VAT '72 tax? If I get an answer to that question, it will solve a great many problems.
Comment on this
I hope we will. I was just about to point out to the Deputy that we are on amendment No. 40.
Comment on this
I have asked the Minister to answer the question.
Comment on this
The Minister did not answer. This places me in an invidious position. Am I to take it now that these people, who are not now subject to registering for TOT, under which I have suffered a helluva lot, will not be in trouble having to keep accounts under this new regulation?
Comment on this
I am telling the Deputy now that he should have raised this on section 8. We are now discussing amendment No. 40.
Comment on this
It places us all in an invidious position. I think it is time this nonsense stopped and I think it is time that the Deputy realised that he cannot come in here any time he likes and go on with a lot of nonsense.
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with that, sir. Listening to a man a few minutes ago, if you would not mind he was a financial adviser to a Government for seven years and obviously he made it bankrupt. It was not the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
If the Deputy has nothing to say on the amendment, will he please sit down, and allow the Dáil to deal with the amendment.
Comment on this
It is not so much that I have nothing to say, but I just want a "Yes" or "No" answer.
Comment on this
The Deputy got the answer. What is he going on about? He got the answer. He should stop trying to "cod" the House and the constituents.
Comment on this
I have ruled. It does not arise on the amendment. It arose on section 8. We are now dealing with the Schedule.
Comment on this
I cannot agree to debate the section until I get an answer.
Comment on this
All right but somebody will suffer before I leave this House tonight.
Comment on this
There seems to be something callous and oppressive about attacks on something as basic as food. I would like to support the pleas that have been made to the Minister to remove food from the value-added tax net. There are two amendments before the Minister by which he can do this. One of these has been tabled by Deputy FitzGerald and seeks total exemption in respect of food and non-alcoholic drinks. The other is an amendment from Deputies Tully and O'Donovan asking that certain specified foods be exempt. Obviously amendments of this nature must be of considerable magnitude in fiscal terms so far as revenue is concerned and the Minister would be entitled to object to them if they were presented to him without being costed fully. The Minister must admit, however, that it is unusual to have two such amendments presented to him and to have them presented with the costings involved.
Deputy FitzGerald's amendment involves a total figure of approximately £17,500,000 and in considerable detail he has spelled out to the Minister how this sum might be recouped. He has spelled out also how this recoupment would have less adverse social effects than would the taxing of food. Deputy O'Donovan was inclined to disagree with the omnibus exclusion on the grounds that politics is the art of the possible and that what was being sought in Deputy FitzGerald's amendment was, by implication, impracticable or impossible. I suggest that Deputy FitzGerald has indicated that far from being impractical or impossible, his amendment is entirely feasible because it has been costed accurately. Consequently Deputy O'Donovan's preference for his own limited amendment falls on that ground.
When supporting his limited amendment, Deputy Tully made the point that the items of food which he seeks to have exempted—bread, tea, sugar, butter, milk, margarine and oranges— represents the basic diet of a large section of our community. It is a sad reflection on our society if this should be the case but is it not an argument in favour of exempting food totally to bring down the cost of all foods in the hope that even that reduction might have the effect of broadening the diet of this unfortunate section of our community? Again, that is an argument in favour of Deputy FitzGerald's amendment. Not only would it result in a reduction in the cost of all foods but if we wish to improve the standard in our society generally we should endeavour to make available at the lowest prices possible, the widest range of foods possible and to as many people as possible.
Our perennial problem is inflation. Inflation is something that is triggered-off very often by non-economic factors. Very often it is triggered-off because of a feeling about prices, and the two areas in which this feeling can be most emotive are in relation to housing costs but above all in relation to food prices. A tremendous psychological blow in the battle against inflation could be struck if food were to be seen to be reduced in price and if it were known to the community generally that this basic commodity was free of taxation. That would ease considerably the perpetual cycle of wages chasing prices and prices increasing consequent on increases in wages. This is a very strong argument for consideration by the Minister in deciding whether to accept the amendments.
If an amendment which is desirable socially—no one can deny that to bring down the cost of food is not desirable socially and at the same time practicable economically—is presented to the Minister. I find it extremely difficult to understand why it is not accepted. Deputy FitzGerald's amendment has been costed and the balance is in favour of accepting it. Deputy Tully's amendment has been costed at £4.11 million and the Minister has admitted that revenue buoyancy following the introduction of value-added tax will give him a figure of £3.70 million. I would suggest to the Minister that he had his tongue in his cheek when he suggested that this would be the extent of the buoyancy to result from the change of taxation. It is my belief that it will be much more than that because, apart from the slight increases involved in certain rates, the accounting procedures will, of necessity, be much tighter and there will be a much better skim-off by the Revenue Commissioners than what they are achieving now. Instead of having a deficit when he puts this buoyancy against the cost of Deputy Tully's proposed exemption, the Minister will have a surplus. Even for this limited range of foodstuffs there is no argument against rejecting that particular amendment. I gather that the argument was put forward that the acceptance of the amendment would lead to complications in accountancy but as Deputy Tully pointed out, the very spot at which this complication would be expected to arise—the check-out in a shop—there are already two items to be dealt with and this is a third item not involving any calculation. By no stretch of the imagination could it be suggested, therefore, that this would lead to complications.
These are the reasons why I am disappointed and puzzled at the Minister's failure to exempt food. Even if there were economic difficulties I would expect the Minister to do everything possible to overcome them or to put up with them in view of the social desirability of exempting food. It has been pointed out clearly to the Minister that under both amendments there would not be any economic difficulties. This must be the case when Great Britain, with a much more complicated economy than ours, complicated apart from its size by its essential complexity, have found it possible to zero-rate food. I am sure that the revenue adjustments that have to be made in that country are on a vast scale. Yet, a Tory Government have found it possible to do so. I suggest to the Minister that when it was found feasible economically and desirable socially to do that in Britain, it defies imagination why it cannot be done here.
I suggest also to the Minister that to accept these amendments and thereby put food in a special position in the social structure of the nation would result in a tremendous blow being struck against inflation. Also, the Minister would be setting a climate in which it would be much more difficult to justify the demands that lead to inflation. There is a great opportunity in this Bill to achieve a result of that size and importance. For these reasons I urge the Minister to accept the amendments.
Comment on this
As has been pointed out already there are at the moment a significant number of Irish families living in poverty. It has been said that one family in seven has a household income of under £7 per week. Bearing that in mind when one considers, as one does in this amendment, that we are discussing a proposal to tax the food which people eat it certainly amazes me that every Deputy in the House should not be concerned to see in what way this can be avoided. We have one family in seven with a household income of under £7 per week, with these families spending 43 to 44 per cent of their income on food, and this House is now solemnly considering a proposal by the Minister for Finance to tax the food that we eat. That is what is involved.
Deputy Lenehan has his qualms of conscience; he had them nine years ago. But he got over them and his little peregrination from that seat over there down to the Minister to exchange a note, deceived nobody, least of all the Minister. Apparently he has gone away satisfied as to what the answer he sought to the question he asked ought to have been. The fact is that when the House last considered a matter as grave as this eight or nine years ago we were told by the then Minister for Finance that it was impossible to exempt food from turnover tax. This was asserted here. There were Deputies in the Labour and Fine Gael Benches who did not accept that but the assertion so clearly made by the then Minister for Finance convinced a number of Deputies, including the then Deputy Lenehan who, as a result, sojourned or hibernated a while in another place before he came back here.
This is now so much water under the bridge and we are again discussing whether food should be subject in this Bill to VAT and in effect whether it should ever have been taxed under turnover taxation. Deputy Dr. FitzGerald has clearly shown, decisively in my view, that there is no need to tax food in this country, that we can get almost every penny of revenue this Bill seeks to get, by altering in no unduly hard way rates of taxation. We can get the same amount without taxing food and if we adopt his proposal the result will be that every single article of food will be reduced by 5 per cent. What are we talking about? In these circumstances, which Deputy will vote against a proposal to reduce articles of food by 5 per cent? What can be the reason for refusing to bring in a piece of social legislation which will have a dramatic effect on the living conditions of at least one family in seven throughout the country?
The Minister has made it clear in the press before Dáil Éireann met that he is not going to budge on this. Why? Who advises him? We can talk about listening to the voice of the people; I regret to say that in my view the Minister is clearly the captive of his advisers in the Revenue Commissioners. They tell him what ought to be done and he is doing what he is told he should do. Of course, it is clear that the VAT rates of taxation in the Minister's proposal are convenient for accountancy and for recording; they are the system the Revenue Commissioners have decided on and I assert that they have already printed the necessary forms. It would be much too difficult to change all these and, therefore, the Minister will stand firm and will refuse to accept this amendment.
Let it be clearly known that that refusal with the present disposition of the House means, in effect, that Dáil Éireann tonight is reimposing taxation on food which it has been clearly demonstrated from these benches has been unnecessarily imposed for the past eight or nine years. As a result of action taken by the Fine Gael Party today the people in at least one constituency in the next three weeks will have an opportunity of saying whether they agree or not. When the people elect a new Government this kind of taxation on food will be removed and those who advise the Minister had better here and now take note of that fact. We cannot afford by our taxation to be boosting an inflation which is at present menacing the way of life and the sources of employment of many of our workers. We are now experiencing the results of rising living costs continued over the last three or four years and growing apace as a result of indiscreet, ill-advised administrative and legislative interventions by the Government. There is no housewife who does not look back with misgiving and some bitterness on the assurances, given prior to February of last year, that decimalisation would not make the slightest difference in living costs. Everybody knows it did and everybody knows that each week now anyone going into a shop faces enormous price increases, many of them stemming from decimalisation.
We were told that VAT would make no difference to the cost of living and that it was merely new taxation to supplant what was already there. This time the people do not accept that. They fear its effects particularly on food. If it were necessary for us to introduce it, if it were part of what we had to do by reason of our entry into Europe, and to achieve a position in the newly arrived European Community, that would be a price we would have to pay, but this is not so.
It is clear now that while VAT as a system of taxation will be obligatory on members of the Community, this proposal is not necessary. This is a Fianna Fáil proposal to tax the food of the Irish people. The British have not done it. The arguments advanced in support of the Fine Gael amendment demonstrate that it is not necessary to achieve the revenue required. Why then is the Minister refusing to accept this amendment?
Let there be no doubt about it, Deputy FitzGerald has demonstrated that, by a slight alteration in the rate of taxation, the same revenue could be achieved. VAT as a system of taxation could go into operation and all food could be excluded with a resultant bonus of a reduction of 5 per cent in the expenditure of the ordinary people of the country. When we are battling inflation, when we are fighting to sell our goods abroad, surely only a madman would assert that this should not be done.
When we vote, as Deputies point their shoes towards the division lobbies they should realise that they are voting to tax the food of the people and that there is no fiscal or financial reason for doing it. It is merely being done because the Minister and the Government have not got the imagination or the sense to realise that this Fine Gael proposal is sound and should be accepted.
Comment on this
I rise to support the Fine Gael amendment the purpose of which is to exempt all food from VAT. This is consistent with the attitude which this party have adopted down through the years. This was our attitude when turnover tax was originally introduced. At that time we felt that food should be exempted because it constitutes such a major proportion of the expenditure of less well-off families in the community.
Indeed, I should like to pay tribute to the work done by the Opposition members of the special committee which dealt with this matter. They went into detail and they elicited the facts which enabled us to debate this matter here today. I am surprised that no member of the Minister's party has yet risen to defend the declared attitude of the Minister. We have had six Opposition speakers on this amendment. The Minister's party had ample opportunity to offer to speak in support of the Minister's attitude. They have not done so. They will support him silently and with guilt.
We seek to exempt food from VAT because food constitutes a relatively higher proportion of the expenditure of low income families than of higher income families. The household budget inquiry estimate shows that in the poorest one-seventh of the community, approximately 43 per cent of their total expenditure is on food. The better-off section of the community spend only about 20 per cent of their total income on food. Therefore, a concession given to make foods cheaper benefits the poorer section of the community much more than the better-off sections of the community.
This proposal by our party is a practical expression of our basic philosophy which is that we need to redistribute income to help those who are earning less than others. It has been alleged by the Minister that this is an impracticable proposal. If it is, how is it that the British can exempt food from VAT? We are not putting forward a proposal which we are not prepared to stand over and for which we are not prepared to face the consequences. We have estimated how much it will cost and we have stated quite clearly where the revenue can be made up to ensure that there is no net loss to the Exchequer if our amendment is accepted. Naturally, there will be higher taxation on certain commodities because you cannot exempt food and not expect to have to raise the money elsewhere.
It has been estimated by Deputy FitzGerald that there will be a net increase in the total VAT load for people with an income in excess of £2,000 but the reason we have put down this amendment is that there will be a substantial decrease in the VAT load for families with an income of less than £1,250. In other words, our proposal would redistribute purchasing power in favour of the less well-off section of the community and to the disfavour of the better-off section. We would prefer if there were no disfavour involved but, when it comes down to hard practicalities, we realise that if the poorer section is to pay less the better-off section has to pay more if we are to raise the same amount of money.
There are additional side effects to this proposal. It will make a substantial contribution towards reducing the rate of inflation. Wage demands in excess of what the community can bear generally arise from the fact that people are afraid that their pay packets will be eroded by inflation in the prices they have to pay. The type of inflation to which most people are sensitive, and to which the housewife is most sensitive, is inflation in the price of foodstuffs. That is the type of inflation that results in the push for higher wage demands which are sometimes in excess of what the community can afford. If we introduce a measure which will reduce the tax load on food, and which will contribute to reducing the rate of increase in food prices, we are making a direct contribution towards a stable incomes policy situation by reducing the necessity for wage demands in excess of what the community can afford.
We also recognise that this is a food-producing country and a food-exporting country. Any tax change which gives a relative advantage to the consumer of food is in the interests of our balance of payments because it means that there is a net incentive to people to consume more food. We produce the vast bulk of the food we eat at home. Therefore, we are helping home industry by helping the food industry. We are also helping those who produce the food, the farming community. We in Fine Gael have always admitted that one of the disadvantages of EEC entry is that it will lead to certain increases in the price of food. Our proposal would also have the effect of reducing the impact of whatever increases in the price of food may result from the EEC entry.
Our primary reason for putting forward this proposal is that we believe food is a basic necessity of life and that it is the largest single item in the expenditure of the vast bulk of our families. It is a relatively larger item in the expenditure of poorer families than it is in the expenditure of better off families. Therefore, we in Fine Gael uphold the amendment to exempt food from value-added tax.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): First, I should like to reply to Deputy O'Higgins' remark that the Minister had already gone to press about this matter. The Minister was forced to go to press and was forced to explain his position because of the attitude of Deputy FitzGerald. Deputy FitzGerald, before the private meeting, made his intentions known. Naturally, it was the duty of the Minister to state his situation. It is unfair of Deputy O'Higgins to say that the Minister had gone to press already to explain the situation.
Comment on this
I do not quarrel with that particularly but the Deputy will accept that at the private session it was agreed that each of us could publicly state our position immediately afterwards, but not the position of anybody else.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I am explaining the Minister's position. Logically, he had to do it.
We can all welcome an amendment such as the one before the House. Any method of reducing the cost of living, especially for the weaker section of the community, is highly desirable. There are probably several ways in which this can be done. If it were practicable to accept the amendment I have no doubt that the Minister would accept it. We must consider who would benefit from this proposal put forward by Fine Gael and Labour. If this were to go entirely back to the weaker section of the community——
Comment on this
Presumably, if the Labour Party have a resolution down which is on quite a different basis, that is their approach.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I can sympathise with this amendment. It is a popular type of amendment to propose in this House, especially if it results in the alleviation of the distress of the poorer section of the community. As the Minister has already said, there are other ways of benefiting the poorer section of the community. There are many other sections of the community, the well-off section, people dining in big hotels tonight. As Deputy Bruton said, there are 20 per cent of the people in the well-off sector of society who would also benefit from the amendment. I do not believe anyone in this House has great sympathy for this section. If we can provide assistance in a different form, the benefits would then go to those who deserve them.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I am not sure that the purchasing of food by hoteliers would not be exempt. Food bought in a shop would have to be exempt. The benefit could be passed on to those dining and wining in expensive restaurants. If food is exempted, it will benefit the section of the community for whom none of us in this House has any great sympathy.
I should like to see the benefits going to that section of the community that deserve them. The best way to help the weaker section of the community is to give it in the form of children's allowance and social welfare. In this way it is given to that section who are entitled to it and to nobody else. If it were given on a broad basis, the benefits would be spread too thinly. I am convinced that the best way to help the weaker section of the community is in the form of children's allowance and widows' and orphans' allowance.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): This also should be considered. Let us hope that as time goes on and new legislation is introduced a closer look will be taken at who should benefit from children's allowances.
If we try to operate the system suggested in the amendment a third level will be introduced. There is the wholesale level, the 5.26, and the zero rating. This would present problems of accountancy for retail outlets.
I have certain sympathy with the amendment but I want to be practical about it. I know what the Minister has in mind as regards the distribution of wealth. It would be better to have it accrue to those really deserving. If increased taxation is to be imposed at wholesale level, we must ensure that the rate is not so high as to put manufacturing firms out of business. These are sensitive points which we should keep in mind.
In Deputy FitzGerald's proposals it was intended to increase certain taxation. I am not sure—I did not see it defined specifically enough—what industries this would affect. I have no doubt that it would affect some industries, and that sales of companies would be diminished.
The policy that I should like to see pursued is one whereby whatever resources we have would be distributed in a more confined sphere so that it would benefit the section of the community that are badly in need of help. I would hope that the benefits would accrue to the poorer section and that the benefits would exceed the 5.26 which they have to pay in respect of their food today. I am quite convinced that this is the mind of the Minister also.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins said a little while ago that anybody who voted against the Fine Gael proposal would be a mad man and certainly he would be if the position were as outlined by the Fine Gael speakers. We heard all about the benefits of taking tax off food. Nobody in this House has to have that idea sold to him. We heard very little about the consequences of the Fine Gael proposals.
Comment on this
Wait for it. I am going to take some little time on this, I am afraid, but it is worth doing because it is important that people should know and that Fine Gael members should know what they are committing themselves to, because I do not think they realise it. Under the proposals in this Bill, food will be liable to tax at exactly the same rate, the effective 5.26 per cent rate under value-added tax, as it is at present. Consequently, there will be no reason whatever for food prices to be disturbed on the changeover to value-added tax because it will be precisely the same rate of tax that is charged, and the same situation will apply as far as possible to most other consumer goods and services. The avoidance of de-stabilising price changes was one of the main reasons for making the changeover to value-added tax at the existing rates of sales taxation. As I said earlier today, this is the main reason that we have these rates of 5.26, 16.37 and so on. The Fine Gael proposals for the removal of tax from foods and certain other goods would, on the other hand, have repercussions which in some cases could be quite serious, in the form of compensating tax increases in almost the whole field of industry, commerce and agriculture. We reject the massive levying of extra taxation touching on almost every non-food item involved in the Fine Gael proposals. Almost every non-food purchase made by the consumer would cost from 1¼ per cent to 7½ per cent more, and even then there would be an unfilled revenue gap of over £4 million for which no provision is made in the Fine Gael proposals. Items which would be effected at the lower range would include new houses, electricity, coal, gas, clothing, beer, tobacco and cigarettes.
Comment on this
One and a quarter per cent, and at the upper range 7½ per cent, the price of household goods such as delph, cutlery, furniture, beds and bedding, stationery, hardware and household appliances could rise by up to 7½ per cent.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt Deputies. I listened to a lot of contributions and I would ask Deputies to bear with me.
Comment on this
I wonder if it would be expecting too much of Independent Newspapers Limited, who gave such space and prominence to Deputy FitzGerald's proposals, to allow their readers to judge the issue for themselves by letting them know about the wide range of goods which would go up in price under the Fine Gael proposals. They have failed to do that up to now. Apart from any effects on the industries concerned—and Deputy Fitzpatrick touched on this and its quite serious implications—the increases which are proposed by Fine Gael would be a great hardship to young married couples setting up a new home. Over 20,000 couples will marry in the next year. The extra taxation proposed by Fine Gael would add considerably to the cost of trying to furnish a home. There is not one household item from a door mat to a piece of curtain material that would not be substantially dearer, and this extra taxation which Fine Gael want to levy would hit everything, proverbially, from a needle to an anchor. Even then one could not guarantee that the hoped for reductions in food would reach the consumer. Under the Fine Gael proposals you are not even robbing Peter to pay Paul; you are robbing them both.
Price increases would also extend to a variety of farmers' requisites from spades and shovels right up to tractors and other farm machinery, machine parts, seeds, equipment and machinery repairs. The provision in the Fine Gael scheme that part of the increased tax would be built in to the wholesale price is simply not acceptable and not workable, and I shall deal with that later on in more detail.
Apart from the various technical objections that arise in this regard, there is a very real danger that the retailers would apply their normal profit margin to the higher wholesale price with the consequence that prices would rise by more than the increased tax. The most serious objection to the proposal, however, is that there is no in-built guarantee that food prices would fall by the required 5 per cent so as to bring about the relief to the poorer families which we are all seeking. I will not be a party to what amounts to a confidence trick of the housewives of this country. To pretend that the exemption proposed by Deputy FitzGerald would bring about a worthwhile reduction to the housewife is just naive.
Despite the assurances by RGDATA and other trade organisations that they would not increase their margins, there is no certainty that these organisations could ensure compliance in full by their memberships. Disparity in the price of groceries throughout the country revealed in a recent survey will make any housewife, if not Deputy FitzGerald or other Deputies opposite, doubt the capacity of the trade associations to enforce real reductions in any item. In addition, as Deputies know, there are certain large supermarket chains at present who claim that they do not charge turnover tax. Whether this claim be true or not, there is the distinct possibility that some of them might not feel obliged to reduce food prices if the tax were removed, because if there is any validity in their present claims then they should not reduce their present prices.
Comment on this
I wonder do the Fine Gael Party believe that Deputy FitzGerald can achieve price control by making half a dozen phone calls to trade associations. I wonder do the Labour Party believe it. The price surveillance machinery of the Department of Industry and Commerce is geared primarily to the control of price increases by the manufacturers, and there is little or no experience of enforcing general price reductions especially at the retail level.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to grow up. Has he listened to what has been said in this House time after time, that, with one or two exceptions, there is no control of prices at the retail level? If the Deputy does not know that, he should know it.
Comment on this
It has been said on numerous occasions in this House. The Deputy should not talk about alleging it. Where would he find an allegation that it exists? Where in the law does it say that it exists, apart from bread, milk and one or two other items? I do not want to embarrass Deputy FitzGerald and his colleagues, but there are a number of his colleagues who could explain to him why price control at the retail level is next to impossible. Take a very simple example, the price of a sandwich in a pub or in a café, you fix the price and the next day the size and the content of the sandwich are changed, and there is no control on the article that is produced. You could go on doing this for ever, and as regards other articles, regular purchases, experience shows that the maximum controlled price, which is the only way you can control at retail level, in most cases becomes the standard price. In practice it means that you are eliminating competition over a very wide range of goods. This is known or should be known to the Fine Gael Party, and if it is, they ought not pretend to the public that it is possible to ensure that there would be fully compensating reductions in the price of food if the 5 per cent value-added tax were removed from food items.
Comment on this
Despite his statements at the week-end, if not since, Deputy FitzGerald could not himself guarantee that there would be food price reductions, and in the special committee discussions, he limited himself to an assertion that food prices would at some time in the future settle at a level 5 per cent lower than they would otherwise be. Even granting him this very doubtful point, the retail and wholesale trades would in the meantime be the beneficiaries of the tax reduction at the rate of £17 million a year and the Exchequer and the housewife would be the losers. If even a significant part of the tax reductions is not passed on to the consumer, then the Fine Gael proposals could result in a greater tax burden on the poorer people with the larger families.
Comment on this
This is why I am convinced that the problem of helping the less well-off sections can best be handled within a redesigned social welfare system, including a more selective children's allowances scheme, which will channel the increased flow of help to the truly needy. One of the first things I did when I became Minister for Finance was to examine very thoroughly the possibility of taking tax off food, especially in the case of basic foodstuffs.
Comment on this
(Cavan): You put it on a few years ago when one of your predecessors removed the subsidies.
Comment on this
I found when I went into it that in our circumstances it would be impracticable to do so and apart from that I had no means of ensuring that by doing it, I would be helping in any worthwhile way those whom I most wanted to help. On Committee Stage of this Bill, I invited Opposition suggestions because, despite what may be said on occasions about Fianna Fáil Ministers, we do not think that all wisdom resides in us, and it was possible that some member of the Opposition could devise a scheme which would be feasible and which had eluded me and my officers in the past.
Comment on this
I said that I could not find the way to do it but if the Opposition could do it, I would adopt it. As it turned out, the Opposition were not able to produce a feasible scheme. Of course, it is possible to do it, but what really arises here is if you do it, what are the consequences, and weighing that up against the alleged benefits is it feasible? That is what we mean by: is it feasible?
I think the Labour Party has very clearly indicated their very obvious reservations about this Fine Gael scheme, if only from the limited scope of the amendments which they propose. It may well be that they realise the consequences of the compensatory taxation which Fine Gael would levy on everything except food and it may be that the Labour Party shy away, as I do, from the very dubious social achievement of taking caviare, imported snails, smoked salmon and lobster and grouse in port wine sauce out of the tax net. Maybe they do not like it but that is what Fine Gael are proposing to do.
Comment on this
(Cavan): What about the loaf of bread? You are bankrupt of an argument when you say that.
Comment on this
I repeat that the Fine Gael proposals involve taking all these luxury items out of the tax net.
Comment on this
The Deputy can try anything he likes but nothing is going to get him out of this. Six Fine Gael speakers got up to support this and that is what they are supporting. We will hang it around your neck in the next three weeks. Deputy O'Higgins thought he was going to hang something else around our neck but we will hang it around your neck as what you are supporting.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Would the Minister tell us the percentage of population who indulge in caviare?
Comment on this
The Deputy does not want to listen, but if he cannot listen, if he cannot bear any more maybe he would like to go out but would he allow me to make my speech? The fact of the matter is that Deputy FitzGerald is right in saying—and we discussed this in the Special Committee and I will come to it on the Labour Party amendment—that if you want to zero-rate food, you have, when you examine the whole problem, to do it across the board. He is perfectly right in that and one of the consequences of that is that you do start zero-rating these kinds of luxury items.
Comment on this
The point is that is what you are doing. It is one of the factors and you have to weigh up all the factors involved in this and Fine Gael should not try to run away from it. They may be learning now that if you have to put forward a proposal, it has its disadvantages as well as its advantages. They are finding this out, and this is one of the disadvantages you are faced with, if you put forward a proposal of any practical value, trying to eliminate tax on food, you are taking the tax off caviare, smoked salmon and lobster. You may not like it but that is what you are proposing and supporting.
Comment on this
There are people who have to depend on the pint of milk, on fish and chips and on bangers and mash, and these are the people we are worried about. We are not worried about caviare or pheasants.
Comment on this
Deputy Coughlan might allow the Chair. For the information of Deputies and the House generally, I would like it to be appreciated that all Stages of this Bill have to be through by midnight and there are other amendments to be dealt with. If Deputies continue to interrupt the Minister, they cannot complain later if the Stages of the Bill are compacted.
Comment on this
Because of the very few luxury items quoted by the Minister, he is prepared to let poor people suffer.
Comment on this
I can see that I am getting under the skin of Fine Gael even more than I thought I was. I have listened to a lot from that side but I am going to make my speech in spite of interruptions. I do not care how many interruptions I get. They will only delay the proceedings but I am going to make my speech. Now, in his weekend statement, Deputy FitzGerald did his best to twist his way out of the consequences of his clearly expressed opinion in the select committee, and I understand that, during my absence this evening, he had the nerve in this connection to say that he expected an apology from me in this regard.
Comment on this
Every member of the committee who happens to be in this House tonight can verify what I am now about to say. In that committee I asked whether, accepting for the purpose of argument that Deputy FitzGerald's proposal was not feasible, would any member of the committee favour the consequential alternative if one were to zero-rate food, which would be the doubling of the turnover tax on items such as electricity, clothes, gas, footwear, alcohol, tobacco and petrol? Frankly I was trying to eliminate the areas of disagreement and I was sure that every member of the committee would say: "No. We could not contemplate that." To my amazement, Deputy FitzGerald said, and he is the spokesman for Fine Gael and I want those who were not there to listen carefully now, that he did not accept that his original proposal was not feasible but that, if that were so, if it were not feasible, he would favour doubling the turnover tax on those items I have mentioned rather than the present system.