We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971: Report Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 599–805 of 805. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971
Enacted

No. 30 of 1971 ›

That was not what I said.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy saying that he did not say that?

Comment on this

I will correct it in due course. I did not say that.

Comment on this

Let us be clear. Is it true or is it false?

Comment on this

It is not correct.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Deputy FitzGerald has the right to reply and the Fianna Fáil Party does not like that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy FitzGerald will get an opportunity to reply.

Comment on this

Sorry.

Comment on this

What Deputy FitzGerald is now saying is what he said in the newspapers and it is not true. He is trying to twist his way out.

Comment on this

The Minister knows I did not say that.

Comment on this

Every Deputy who was at the committee knows that what I state is true and that he did not talk in the context of the household budget inquiry. He said he did not accept that his proposal was not feasible but, if it turned out not to be feasible, he would favour an 11½ per cent rate, doubling the turnover tax on these items, rather than the present system. That is what he said.

Comment on this

The Minister has compounded his argument by saying I did not talk in the context of the household budget.

Comment on this

In that context.

Comment on this

My remarks were solely related to it and I worked that out——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will get an opportunity of making his speech.

Comment on this

No wonder the Minister is as he is. He has not a rib of hair on his forehead because he is taking it all too seriously. Sure nobody bothers his head about what he says and why is the Minister devoting all his time to what Deputy FitzGerald says. We do not listen to him and neither do we read him. We have other things to do.

Comment on this

Indeed, we have, but the point I am really at is that this was the attitude taken by Deputy FitzGerald. He is the spokesman for Fine Gael on these matters and, unless his colleagues are prepared to repudiate that view, they will have to accept responsibility for that approach. That will be hung around their necks too. They have their chance tonight. The Deputy can twist any way he likes but he said, in the circumstances I have described, that he would prefer to double the turnover tax on electricity, fuel, clothing, gas, footwear and other items rather than the present system. That is what the Deputy said. He may try to get out of it and, if he wants to get out of it and to get up now and say that he did not mean it, that he said it on the spur of the moment, I will accept that; but, if he is not going to say that, then he is stuck with it and his party is stuck with it too unless they are prepared to repudiate it.

I did say there were a number of reasons—they might be called technical reasons but, from another point of view, some of them could be described as anything but technical— why the Fine Gael proposal is not feasible. The proposal, apart from all the consequences I have mentioned, involves what we describe as trapping tax at the wholesale level. Without that device it does not work and I think Deputy FitzGerald will agree with me on that.

Comment on this

No. I will come back to it.

Comment on this

He disagrees with it?

Comment on this

This is an optional extra, but I think an important one from the point of view of the retailer. The scheme works perfectly, as the Minister knows.

Comment on this

All I can say is that the proposal put forward by Deputy FitzGerald——

Comment on this

I stand over the proposal. It is not an essential feature of it. It is something we have added. That is all.

Comment on this

We can only take the proposal that we discussed, the one that was in front of us today and again tonight on this amendment. I want to point out in regard to the Fine Gael proposal, first of all, that the calculations of the rates of tax which would be required to give effect to the Fine Gael proposals do not appear to take into account the fact that on the changeover to value-added tax the equivalent of wholesale tax will not be effectively paid on building materials, such as timber, glass, paint, et cetera, used by traders. Even accepting that the loss of £3 million on motor cars, radio and television sets, et cetera, would not be made up within the value-added tax system but in some other form of taxation, even if we accept that, the more realistic rates to give effect to the Fine Gael scheme would be food, et cetera, zero; all other taxable goods and services, 6.5 per cent and, at the wholesale level, 26 per cent in place of the 24 per cent that Deputy FitzGerald suggested. I want to get that straight first of all as regards the figures.

Much more important than that is what is involved in this proposal and how it would work. First, if we accepted this, there would be a tax increase of 24 per cent on certain of the more essential goods and services. As I mentioned, the tax element in those goods and services—Deputy FitzGerald said a 24 per cent rate would not apply, but it would, in fact, be a 26 per cent rate, that is, the ones to which it would not apply, would be fuel, clothing, footwear, electricity, petrol, hotel and other services. They would go up under his scheme by 24 per cent—that is, gas, electricity, clothing, footwear, all these basic essentials. There would be an indefinite tax increase in other goods and services. The tax element in goods and services to which the proposed 24 per cent rate would apply would increase by an indeterminate percentage which would depend on the level of the amount of the mark-up price at retail level. If anyone doubts this I can give him examples but I do not want to delay on examples if it is not necessary. Under the proposals in this Bill, on the other hand, the tax element in the final selling price is always a constant percentage. Under the Fine Gael proposal the lower retail mark-up the higher will be the percentage of tax in the selling price. It follows from this that, under the Fine Gael scheme, not only would there be confusion about what was the tax element in goods but also, even when a retailer cuts his profit, he would be unable to pass on to the consumer as great a tax reduction as he would be able to do under the proposals in this Bill.

As I have said, the lower the retail mark-up, the higher the percentage of tax and, therefore, when he cuts his price he cannot correspondingly cut the level of the tax element involved because the tax element increases, whereas, under the scheme in the Bill, if the retailer cuts his prices, the tax element will be reduced by a corresponding amount. The scheme proposed by Fine Gael would be biased very much in favour of the larger traders. It would benefit the big retailer who could obtain the best quantity discounts. If we assume that a trader who was a large retailer could buy a certain quantity of stock for a net price of £900 whereas a small trader would have to pay a £1,000 for the same quantity, the effect of the Fine Gael scheme would be that the price advantage to the large trader, that is the £100 which he has already, would be increased by 20.4 per cent on the deal. We all know what is the attitude of small traders and what is happening to them because of the competitive advantage of the large chains and supermarkets. This proposal involves a direct build-up of increased competitiveness by the large trader against the small shopkeeper. Furthermore the Fine Gael proposal would introduce a cascade effect or double taxation element within the tax system—something that the value-added tax system is designed to take out of the present system.

Any significant element of a cascade in the tax system would make Irish exports less competitive in foreign markets. Of course, this is a factor which must be considered. Deputy FitzGerald has suggested, as have a number of his colleagues, that the prices of zero-rated goods would fall by a full 5 per cent. Indeed it has been implied in what they have said that the prices of goods proposed to be taxed at 26 per cent, or at 24 per cent according to their figures, would be likely to rise by no more than the additional tax element. At present there are such variations in food prices that it would be virtually impossible to determine whether a particular trader had genuinely reduced his prices or whether he was operating merely some sales promotion gimmick.

There are large traders who claim not to charge turnover tax. What would they do in these circumstances? Would they reduce their prices by 5 per cent? If they do, their claims at present would be exposed as being false. The smaller traders would be inclined to say that because of the competition which they suffer from larger retailers by way of the operation of trading stamp schemes and so on, they held back legitimate price increases which they should have put on but which they could not afford to put on because of this competition. It is reasonable to expect that a number of them would not pass on the full 5 per cent reduction and this in particular, when they found that under the Fine Gael scheme the competition that they were suffering from big retailers was being stepped up remarkably because of a built-in feature in the Fine Gael scheme. That would be all the more reason why they would refuse to reduce their prices.

At present retailers are accustomed to take a mark-up on the cost of goods inclusive of any wholesale tax charged to them by their suppliers. This practice continues after the wholesale tax was increased from 5 to 10 per cent and despite any protestations to the contrary, it would be likely to continue in relation to the increased tax proposed under the Fine Gael scheme to be charged at the wholesale level.

In the grocery trade at least, it is accepted that it would be impracticable to operate two rates of tax at the check-out. In order to do this it would be necessary to segregate the goods in such a way as to be able to obtain a separate total of the goods chargeable at each rate. The adoption of a zero-rate would not in any way solve this problem. It would still be necessary to segregate the goods so as to obtain the total to which the zero-rate applied and the total chargeable at 6.5 per cent. The only saving would be that the assistant would have to calculate the tax for one total instead of two, but since the traders agree that it would be impracticable to arrive at separate totals at the check-out, this advantage can be described only as illusory.

All of the member and applicant countries of the EEC, with one exception, either tax food under their present system or propose to tax it on the changeover to VAT. The Commission of the EEC will have power to require new member states to harmonise their VAT system in accordance with the VAT directives which each member must accept. We are not quite sure as to what would be the Commission's attitude in regard to an application by a member State to continue the zero-rating for food after the end of the transition period, which in our case is 1st January, 1974. However, there is a very strong possibility that if food were zero-rated as from the commencement of value-added tax, the tax would have to be reimposed within about 14 months.

Britain is the only one of the ten countries which does not tax food or propose to tax it. I have gone into this before and I do not wish to go over it again except to say briefly that the British position is different from ours. They are changing from a system which is much further removed from VAT that is ours. The impact of entry into the EEC and of VAT on their cost of living will be substantially different and more adverse than it will be in our case. For these reasons and for the reason that they have never taxed food in the past, it is conceivable that they might get an additional transitional period for their system of non-taxation of food under VAT. Our situation is different and the odds are very heavy that if we were to adopt the Fine Gael proposal, in about 14 months time we might well have to reimpose tax on food.

Leaving all these matters aside, if anyone is to judge the merits or the demerits of the Fine Gael proposal he must know, broadly speaking, what are the other items that will be increased in price and how they affect the average person. He must know also what kind of people are affected.

Comment on this

That is very important.

Comment on this

I have pointed out that almost everything that would be purchased by newly-weds in setting up house would be increased in price under the Fine Gael proposal. Also most of the commodities used by farmers would be increased under that proposal.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): House prices have been decontrolled as a result of the Prices Bill passed last evening by the deletion of house control from the Prices Bill.

Comment on this

Do not blame us.

Comment on this

Is not the Deputy aware of the announcement made by the Minister for Local Government?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am aware of it.

Comment on this

Therefore, this is another Fine Gael gimmick to twist the facts, just like Deputy FitzGerald's effort to get out of what he said at the special committee.

Comment on this

I shall be dealing with that in a moment.

Comment on this

The Deputy may deal with it as he wishes but it is very significant, and every member of Fine Gael is stuck with it unless they repudiate it. They would prefer to double the turnover tax on the most essential elements rather than have the present system.

Comment on this

Less essential ones.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy saying that footwear, clothing and fuel are less essential?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Let him go out and sell that idea to the people.

Comment on this

The Minister knows the facts, too.

Comment on this

I know the facts and I know also exactly what Deputy FitzGerald said. I know the attitude he took and I know what the Fine Gael Party will have hung around their necks unless they repudiate him.

Any examination of this situation shows that the overall effect will be that the prices of virtually everything except food will go up, sometimes by quite substantial amounts. There will also be the effects of improving the competitiveness of large retailers against small retailers, the upsetting effect on the overall position in shops and the consequences that flow from that judging by past experience—I am throwing in for full weight the zero rating of the caviare, lobster and so on so beloved of Fine Gael——

Comment on this

It is Fine Gael who are proposing to take off the tax. Adding all these together I think it is quite clear where the interests of the consumers lie.

Comment on this

In taxing food?

Comment on this

Deputy FitzGerald— and more power to him politically— has tried to get the best mileage possible out of this but I fear the day of retribution is coming and his party did not know the full implications of his proposal to them. They have heard a little tonight; they will hear more later on and they will not be very happy or very thankful to Deputy FitzGerald. That is an internal party matter which no doubt, will be sorted out like some other little problems which blew up today in that party. However, that is not my business.

Comment on this

I want to deal as briefly as I can with the Labour Party amendment. I said this in the special committee: my first approach to this matter was something on the lines of the Labour Party approach which was to pick out the most clearly essential items and try to take the tax off them. This is probably the approach most reasonable people would take as a first approach. However, when you get down to it, you find in practice—and I conceded this already, that I believe Deputy FitzGerald is right and indeed I expressed the same view at the special committee—in what he says that when you get down to it you either have to zero-rate all food or none, because, some of the problems of zero-rating that arise are these: first, not everybody will agree as to what are the basic necessities——

Comment on this

Go on.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy think that eggs and vegetables should be exempt?

Comment on this

I have said what the basic diet of the poor people is in this country for generations, bread, butter, tea and sugar and milk.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy concede that there are many people who might take the view that if you are going to exempt you ought to exempt eggs and vegetables?

Comment on this

A man might take any view.

Comment on this

That is my point. Therefore, whatever you do when you begin selecting you reach a stage where, unless you are prepared to ride roughshod, you cannot get any agreement on what should be exempt. That is only a practical difficulty of application, not a fundamental objection. A fundamental objection—and I think Deputy Tully does not accept this— is that it would create a third rate at the retail level. All the arguments we have received from representatives of retailers and all the experience of the Revenue Commissioners in dealing with retailers confirm that they cannot operate more than two rates. Many of them argue they cannot operate even two rates. I do not think it can be disputed that they cannot operate three rates. It may be said that zero-rating is not another rate, but it is. From the shopkeepers' point of view he must segregate the items which are zero-rated and charge the appropriate tax on what is left. He might as well be charging a tax at 1 per cent. The only difference is that he does not have to do a sum.

Comment on this

That is right; that is the saving.

Comment on this

For his purposes he has three rates and that is his problem. The shopkeepers say, and we believe them, that it is not possible for them to operate three rates. For that reason any selective system brings you up against this problem.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Sir, before the Minister——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not rise to interrupt.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

In regard to the small shopkeeper and publican, is the Minister saying that they keep daily accounts or anything like that to meet his requirements or——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy allow the Minister to conclude? Time is running out for this debate.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

If the Minister wants to close down every small shopkeeper and publican he can do it as far as I am concerned.

Comment on this

I have already given Deputy Lenehan the answer on two occasions, once across the floor of the House and the Deputy did not like it because I was sitting down when I said it. I am standing up now and I shall say it once more but it is the last time I shall say it. There is an exemption contained in the value-added tax system which is virtually the same as the existing exemption under turnover tax.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Virtually the same means there is a change——

Comment on this

There has to be a change for reasons analogous to that whereby the 5 per cent turnover tax is the same as 5.26 per cent value-added tax. There is no other change involved. As far as the shopkeeper is concerned it is just the same. I was saying that the creation of a third rate makes it impossible for shopkeepers to operate. Further, where you have a selected number of items zero-rated and the other items in the shop subject to different rates of tax you will have a situation in which the housewife will be very confused because she will not know which items are subject to tax and which are not. She will, therefore, be confused as to what should be the price. Furthermore, by selecting certain items and omitting others you are affecting the existing trade pattern in regard to those things and the competition between them, for instance, as between tea and coffee and milk and cocoa. This may not seem a fundamental point but if it has the effect of, perhaps, putting a number of people out of work because of the switchover——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

It is quite clear that Deputies over there have not really thought about this because they do not know what is involved. Anybody who thinks you can switch rates of tax, and favour one thing against another, or step up the rates of tax on the more relatively luxurious items, without affecting employment does not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The Minister should go back to the one he was at.

Comment on this

I am not talking about Deputy Tully because I think he knows the score. If you alter the trading pattern, one of the possible consequences is that you affect employment. I am not saying this is a fundamental issue but it is another factor you have got to take into account. The main objection I have to the Labour Party proposal which is the one—or something very much on those lines—that I would favour if it could be done, is that it just will not work. The shopkeepers cannot work it. That is the simple explanation.

Comment on this

Give them a try.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean force them? They tell us they cannot do it and we believe them so what does the Deputy mean?

Comment on this

They say they cannot collect the VAT at all. They say it is impossible.

Comment on this

They say it will be very difficult and will cost them a lot of money but they do not say it is impossible.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

Does that remark by Deputy FitzGerald mean that he thinks they can work three rates? What did the Deputy say?

Comment on this

I said the Minister should continue to expound his incredible beliefs.

Comment on this

Therefore, we may take it that Deputy FitzGerald thinks shopkeepers can work three rates of tax. Right?

Comment on this

We sought to reduce it to one rate.

Comment on this

So he does not believe that they can work three rates of tax?

Comment on this

I tried to get it down to one and the Minister sabotaged my proposal.

Comment on this

The Deputy refers to what I was just saying about the impossibility of having three rates of tax as the Minister's incredible beliefs.

Comment on this

The Minister is proving to be a good pupil of Deputy FitzGerald's at the moment.

Comment on this

I do not regard that as a compliment.

Comment on this

It is not so intended.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Will the Minister allow Deputy FitzGerald to reply?

Comment on this

Deputy Bruton reminded us of the number of Fine Gael speakers we had. Does the Deputy want to add up the time spent by the Opposition on this as against the time spent by this side of the House? Let us have a little balance.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Let us spend tomorrow at it.

Comment on this

I know that the Fine Gael Party do not like the floor to be given to a Fianna Fáil speaker who exposes the nonsense they have been going on with—talking about taking the tax off food and increasing the tax on everything else, hammering the unfortunate newly marrieds, the farmers, anybody you can think of. They want to shove up prices on them, and they ask us to believe that, because Deputy FitzGerald made a few phone calls to a few trade organisations, they will all keep down prices; they will all be good boys. They told Deputy FitzGerald they would not take any advantage of the situation, although they admitted they could, and we in this Parliament are to accept that because they told Deputy FitzGerald this on the phone that is all right. Does Deputy FitzGerald think that there is any housewife outside this House who would accept that?

Comment on this

I did not say it, so I would not expect them to accept it.

Comment on this

Of course, they would not accept it. The Deputy did say it.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

Does he want me to quote him?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy care to remind me of what he did say while I am looking for it. If he really wants me to quote I will.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Will the Minister allow Deputy FitzGerald to reply?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is entitled to make his statement without interruption.

Comment on this

Has Deputy FitzGerald the quotation over there?

Comment on this

I will read it for the Minister.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy FitzGerald cannot intervene at this stage. He cannot drive a coach and four through Standing Orders.

Comment on this

I will bring it over to the Minister.

Comment on this

I am very grateful to the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Minister should read it all and not stop half way through by any unhappy Fianna Fáil chance.

Comment on this

I want to quote from the statements as I saw them in the newspaper. I presume this is what it was. I have not seen the document given to me by Deputy FitzGerald before. I now have my quotation. I am quoting from The Irish Times of 10th July, 1972.

Comment on this

Read the document I gave you.

Comment on this

I have never seen that before in my life. Is the Deputy afraid of the quotation?

Comment on this

Read the full text and not just what was published. We want no selective quotations.

Comment on this

How do I know what part of it was published? This is what I was referring to. Maybe Deputy FitzGerald wants to repudiate it. Was he misquoted in The Irish Times.

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

He seems to be building up an alibi before I quote him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister should be allowed to make his speech. The Deputy will get an opportunity of making his own speech.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this

I told the Fine Gael Deputies I would make my speech, and I am going to do so.

Comment on this

Could I have my document back? It may be necessary to counter the quotation.

Comment on this

With pleasure the Deputy may have it back. I will not be shouted down by Fine Gael. I told them that an hour ago.

Comment on this

Will the Minister quote the statement in full?

Comment on this

Let me quote from The Irish Times of 10th July, 1972? It reads:

Dr. FitzGerald said that Fine Gael has discussed its ideas with retailers and supermarkets. "From all these groups we sought and secured agreement not alone to the passing on of tax reductions in full to the consumer, but also to a reduction in percentage retail mark-ups, necessary to ensure that the operation of a single rate of tax at retail level— one of the attractive features of the Fine Gael scheme—would involve no increase in the size of retail margins in money terms. Finally, we produced a fully documented proposal complete with tabular statements showing the amount of tax involved in each aspect of our scheme, and the precise effects of each of our proposals on tax revenue.

Comment on this

It is not our proposal.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy saying he did not say this? This is the only knowledge I have. I never saw that document before.

Comment on this

The Minister is quoting from a different document altogether.

Comment on this

Let us be quite clear on this. Is Deputy FitzGerald saying he is misquoted here?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Is this correct?

Comment on this

It is incomplete. It does not represent fully what was said in our proposal. It is correct so far as it goes.

Comment on this

It is correct so far as it goes? Good. I said long before that barrage over there started that Deputy FitzGerald expected us to believe, and that no housewife would believe, that wholesalers and retailers would reduce prices by a full 5 per cent, and reduce their mark-ups to achieve the effect mentioned in this quotation, just because Deputy FitzGerald had been told by them, mostly on the telephone, that this was so. I said they would not accept this and Deputy FitzGerald said he never said that. We have had all this carry-on to produce this statement which verifies precisely what I said.

Comment on this

Read the reference to the National Prices Commission.

Comment on this

Stop bluffing. The Fine Gael Party bluff has been called. Let us face up to it.

Comment on this

We will call the Minister's bluff in Mid-Cork.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy recovering from his shock?

Comment on this

I was not shocked.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Taoiseach said last week that he did not want a by-election.

Comment on this

I have got to hand it to Deputy Fitzpatrick. He would try anything.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Would Deputies cease interrupting?

Comment on this

I would have finished quite a long time ago but for the various efforts to prevent me exposing just what has been involved in these Fine Gael proposals. We could not have had a better example of the carry-on of Fine Gael than we have had in the last few minutes with the denial by Deputy FitzGerald that he had said what I said he did, or the efforts to prevent me actually quoting and then when it was quoted saying, well, it was another document. This indicates very clearly the kind of situation we are dealing with, the kind of "con" job that Fine Gael are trying to do as far as the electorate and particularly the housewives are concerned. I have got news for them. They are not going to succeed.

Comment on this

I think it is time to conclude this interesting debate. I should like, first of all, because it is the matter freshest in our minds, to deal with the way the Minister handled the quotations.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Do I take it that the Deputy is concluding the debate?

Comment on this

I am concluding on this amendment. There are many more to come, if we have time to deal with them.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Are we going on until midnight?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy FitzGerald is concluding on his own amendment. Will the Deputy please sit down and allow him to do so?

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

I have to go back home. I do not believe in listening to this bunkum for the next three-quarters of an hour.

Comment on this

On the point the Minister raised, at the end of his suggested quotation, I handed over to him the statement issued by us. He refused to read it, for very good reasons, of course——

Comment on this

I had never seen it before in my life.

Comment on this

——because this is the statement issued to the Press which appeared in the newspapers. It contained a reference to the National Prices Commission. In fact, we said in this document—I will now read the text which the Minister tried to suppress.

Comment on this

The Deputy should know that I did not know anything of the document he handed to me and I did not have time to read it. I wanted to quote what I myself had read. The Deputy can twist as much as he likes, but that is the fact.

Comment on this

It was issued to the Press and appeared in the Press and it is as follows:

Dr. Garret FitzGerald, spokesman on Finance for Fine Gael, today received assurances from all these interests that the full benefit of tax reductions would be passed on to the consumer and that the percentage margins or mark-ups on wholesale prices would be adjusted by the amount necessary to maintain existing margins in money terms on any goods the tax rates on which have to be adjusted as part of an arrangement to secure a single tax rate at the retail stage. With these assurances, the implementation of which can be undertaken in consultation with the National Prices Commission, the way is cleared for the implementation of the Fine Gael proposals.

Comment on this

Even that is a very naïve statement.

Comment on this

In a further statement, I pointed out:

The Minister's statement that reduction in food prices "could not be guaranteed", following an elimination of the tax on food imposed by the present Government nine years ago which now stands at 5 per cent shows a total lack of confidence in the Government's price surveillance machinery, which is surely valueless if, as the Minister suggests, it is so ineffective as to be unable to secure that tax cuts are passed on to consumers.

If the Opposition, as distinct from the Minister for Finance, had accused the Government of giving such free rein to price fixing, and of such a failure to secure competition in the retail trade, as to make it impracticable any longer to give the public the benefit of tax reductions even when these are agreed to be desirable and financially possible, they would have been accused of factious opposition and political pointscoring! Yet this is what Mr. Colley has now said about the Government of which he is a member; he must not think much of his colleague in Industry and Commerce, Mr. Paddy Lalor!

Those quotations make it perfectly clear——

Comment on this

An interesting little debating point but disclosing the Deputy's ignorance of what the position is, not convincing the housewife.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

No interruptions.

Comment on this

Were there no interruptions when I was speaking?

Comment on this

These quotations make it perfectly clear that there was no naive assumption on our part that the mere receipt of assurances from any interests would necessarily secure this result. I made specific reference to the National Prices Commission to make it clear that these assurances, having been given, would need to be policed to make sure that they were carried into effect.

Comment on this

A nice word. How does the Deputy suggest it should be done? Come on. Stop trying to cod the people.

Comment on this

The price surveillance of this Government is so weak that it would be incapable in consultation with these interests of securing that they carried out these assurances. If the Minister believes that of Fianna Fáil's prices surveillance machinery at this point, first of all, it is no wonder they have no incomes policy and, secondly it is a wonder they have not the sense to get out and let a Government come in that can secure adequate price surveillance.

Comment on this

Now tell us how you would propose to do it. The public want to know. If you cannot tell us, do not go on trying to cod them.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring to make my speech. I will not be unduly diverted from this point. I am not going to be put off answering all the points because of shortage of time.

Comment on this

The Deputy will be diverted from answering that question. I will guarantee that.

Comment on this

The Labour Party also wishes to answer on their amendments. I an anxious to ensure that this is done. Once assurances are given by interests of this kind, it is a matter for the National Prices Commission, in consultation with them to secure—the Minister does not want to listen—that these assurances are carried out and that evidence is produced that margins have been reduced appropriately and that the absolute level of profits has not been increased. A Government incapable of securing that, when assurances have been given by people willing to co-operate with the system, are a Government that should not be here.

Comment on this

Tell that to the housewives.

Comment on this

I am telling it to the housewives through the medium of this House.

Comment on this

They will give you their answer.

Comment on this

Let this go out from this House to the housewives, that there can be no tax reductions any longer because Deputy Colley has told this House that as long as they are in office there cannot be a reduction because he cannot guarantee that they will be passed on and, like the decent man he is if he cannot guarantee that they will be passed on, if the Government are so imcompetent that he cannot pass them on, then he is not going to reduce taxes. The housewives can know that as long as Fianna Fáil are here there will be no tax reduction. That is the message from this House tonight from the Minister for Finance. If the housewives want taxes to be reduced, they will not get it from the Minister who has told us that he is not prepared to do that because he cannot secure that these will be passed on. This is the message from this debate, a very important one, and it will ring loud and clear in mid-Cork in the next few weeks.

To come back to the points made earlier and I will deal with them as briefly as possible, the Minister talked of a de-stabilisation danger, the importance of securing as far as possible that the same taxes are applied under the new system as under the old. He objected to the fact that we were proposing to increase the level of wholesale tax on certain goods. What he has not made clear to this House is that he in this Bill is increasing the present rate of wholesale tax on these goods substantially. The return in the current year from wholesale tax of 10 per cent is estimated at £10½ million. The Bill before the House is designed to secure £14 million on these goods, a £3½ million increase or an increase of one-third in the return from wholesale tax. That £3½ million is the Minister's own figure and the figure of £10½ million and £14 million are estimates I have made. I checked the £14 million with the Revenue Commissioners and arrived at the £10½ million by subtracting £3½ million.

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking about only one section, not giving the correct figures.

Comment on this

The Minister in this Bill is increasing the rate of wholesale tax.

Comment on this

I want to make sure that this message reaches the public: the Minister in this Bill is increasing the rate of wholesale tax from £10½ million to £14 million. He has the nerve to come into the House and complain that we in reducing the tax on food, are prepared to concede increases in this tax.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not telling the truth.

Comment on this

I resent that allegation.

Comment on this

I just want to put it on the record that he is not telling the truth.

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Minister to say I am not telling the truth?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is not in order.

Comment on this

I withdraw it and say the Deputy's statement is not accurate.

Comment on this

As regards the accuracy of the statement, the figures which I calculated and which are set out in the tabular with our statement here were checked out with the Revenue Commissioners. I have to say there was a difficulty in reconciling the final total for wholesale tax by a small margin, but as they said to me the difference was one that would not be significant, we did not pursue the matter to the last decimal point. Subject to the question of the final decimal point, the figure I have given of £14 million is accurate to within a few hundred thousand pounds, and that figure is the one after the Minister has added £3,500,000. The Minister is increasing this wholesale tax of 10 per cent by one-third and then he has the nerve to criticise us for imposing increases in taxation. That inaccuracy I have now, I think, nailed. The Minister used the following words in his speech: a "massive increase in taxation" and goods would be "substantially dearer". When he spoke about the figures he got muddled between 1¼ and 1½ per cent. He said, in fact, there was a 1¼ per cent increase. I think myself that if you have a 5 per cent turnover tax at the moment making the price of goods 105, that to me is an increase of less than 1 per cent. Our proposal envisages for the wide range of goods mentioned by the Minister which are not food and are not covered by wholesale tax just under 1 per cent.

Comment on this

The figure is going down by the minute.

Comment on this

If the Minister would explain to me how when you add one to 105 you get a 1¼ per cent increase I would be happy to hear it. What we propose is an increase fractionally of 1 per cent, .95 per cent.

Comment on this

That is not what he said publicly.

Comment on this

That is precisely what we have said throughout. That is not a massive increase in taxation. In relation to the other goods to which the Minister refers where the increase in price is of the order of 7 per cent —I do not know where he gets 7½ from, but it is not worth quarrelling about the half—the point here is that these are goods which are purchased in larger quantities by better off people than they are by less well-off people. Indeed this is true of the range of goods on which turnover tax has been increased. The Minister should know that, in respect of goods covered by turnover tax but not covered by wholesale tax and excluding food, at the moment in the lower income group 35 per cent of the budget is covered by these items; it is 53 per cent at the top. If you have a range of goods which feature much more largely in the budgets of rich people than poor and if you increase the tax there and if you reduce the tax on goods like food which feature very much more largely, twice as largely, in the budgets of the poor than the rich, then you are shifting the burden from the poor to the rich. That is what the Minister is trying to obscure in this debate by his curious talk of caviare and other products.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy accept that his proposal takes the tax off caviare?

Comment on this

Indeed, off all foodstuffs, and the net effect of this is that you are relieving the budgets of less well-off people to the tune of 45 per cent on food and of the better-off people to the tune of 20 per cent. That is the difference. If in fact you increase the price of goods that wealthy people buy, the range of goods the Minister has pointed out, and if you offset this with the price of caviare going down by 5 per cent and the net effect is that rich people pay £50 more on goods generally and £1 less on caviare, I am willing to give them the £1 to get the £50 from them. It seems a fair deal to me. As the Minister said, you cannot distinguish between one kind of food and another; you must either reduce tax on all food or no food, and lest somebody should get cheaper caviare the poor shall bloody-well starve and their budget will not be reduced. That is Fianna Fáil policy.

Children's allowances were described as a way of channelling aid to the truly needy. They certainly channel aid to some of the truly needy, but the Minister was very careful not to refer to the examples I gave. He did not tell us how children's allowances will cope with the problem of a single woman living alone and working and who now on her £12 a week has to pay £1 a week tax, who because she cannot get housing from the corporation has to pay a rent of £5 or £6 a week. Has she to have some illegitimate children to benefit from the Minister's proposal?

Comment on this

Is she therefore worse off than a mother of four children?

Comment on this

Under our proposals she would have an advantage. As our proposals do not involve any net change in the burden of taxation, they do not make any more difficult the improvement in children's allowances that is proposed. Therefore under our proposals the poor, including a woman in that position, including an old age pensioner, can benefit from the cheaper food prices, and the children's allowances can also be paid. As we are not imposing any net burden on the Exchequer the money is still there to pay any children's allowances this Government is willing to pay, which is damned little so far.

Comment on this

I am not going to be shouted down by a disorderly Minister.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): By an angry Minister.

Comment on this

He is not angry. He is very pleased indeed.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I wonder if the House is interested in the record being kept. The notetaker would have extreme difficulty in recording what is being said.

Comment on this

It might be just as well it would not be recorded.

Comment on this

He is exceeding the speed limit.

Comment on this

One would want to exceed the sound barrier to get through the barrage of the Minister. The Minister's reference to children's allowances does not offer much hope to the old age pensioner. Of course, children's allowances should be radically increased, and the Minister will recall, I trust, the Fine Gael proposals in the last election to increase them by two-thirds, which may put the skids under this Government before the next election. It seems to be doing so. We shall support any proposals to increase children's allowances which are 40 per cent lower than the British and Northern Ireland figure, the British figure being so much lower than anywhere else in Western Europe. As our proposals envisage no increase in the burden of taxation, can we not simultaneously help the poor whether they be the families of children, a single woman living on her own in private accommodation because this Government will not house her, or an old age pensioner? Can we not help them with cheaper food and increased social benefits, including children's allowances, in the next budget when the big EEC giveaway will be presided over by this or some other Minister?

Comment on this

Why is the Deputy ignoring my reference to improved social welfare benefits and children's allowances?

Comment on this

I am expounding that if the Minister proposes to do this we shall support it. Why can we not do that and also reduce the cost of food? Both can be done. Now I come to this question of the Minister's disreputable performance in this committee. The last time I had to deal with this the Minister was not present and I wish now to answer him directly. When the members of this committee met I was asked to present our proposals. I presented them and made it clear we had proposed a particular method of finding the alternative taxation. It did not involve doubling the turnover tax. I expounded, as I have done in this House this evening, the reason for this, and then I stopped and the Minister intervened. The Minister proceeded to say there were several ways this could be done. He said that my proposal was unworkable because it involved this problem of trapping the tax which, he said, was unworkable; and then he proceeded for the first time in this committee to put forward the proposal for doubling the turnover tax, or, to be more precise raising the level of the value-added tax on goods which involved turnover tax at present from 5.26 per cent to 11½ per cent.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean by "brought forward this proposal"?

Comment on this

The Minister brought forward this proposal, expounded it to the committee——

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean by "brought forward this proposal"?

Comment on this

——and expounded it to the committee.

Comment on this

I gave the precise words. Is the Deputy denying that the words I used here were precisely the words I used in the committee? He is now saying "brought forward the proposals". Will the Deputy say what he means?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy FitzGerald.

Comment on this

Who first mentioned the doubling of turnover tax in this committee? Who raised it? We did not. We had decided against it in the Fine Gael Party. We had our own proposals. Who brought this in? The Minister raised it in the committee. Who started all this? The Minister, in the committee.

Comment on this

I questioned whether any member of the committee would support it and Deputy FitzGerald said he would.

Comment on this

It was raised by the Minister and the discussion then reverted, as the members of the committee, if they are here will recall. I am sorry Deputy Tully is not here because I know he would not stand over a false account of what happened.

Comment on this

He certainly would not.

Comment on this

The Minister then turned to the question as to whether we should zero-rate all food or just some food. While that discussion was proceeding I did some calculations on the household budget inquiry to see what effect the Minister's proposal would have, to see whether I was wrong, whether the Fine Gael Party were, by any chance, wrong in having rejected the doubling of the turnover tax and I carried out these calculations, which the Minister did not seem capable of doing, and then, after an interval the Minister said: "I should like to revert to this question of this 11½ per cent value-added tax in the doubling of the turnover tax". The Minister wanted to revert to it and he asked me for my opinion on it. Why? Why was he so concerned about it.

Comment on this

I did not ask the Deputy. I asked every member of the committee.

Comment on this

He distinctly asked me specifically for Fine Gael's reaction to his proposals and every member of the committee present will confirm that.

Comment on this

I do not think they will.

Comment on this

I was somewhat puzzled—flattered, of course—but somewhat puzzled, too, by this concern of the Minister to have my opinion. I was very interested that the Minister should want my opinion, but a little suspicious, perhaps unworthily and therefore the opinion I gave was carefully worded in the circumstances, because it seemed rather an odd procedure for the Minister to ask my view; I said we had considered this proposal but we had rejected it because it was less satisfactory. Nevertheless, I had done some calculations for the Minister's benefit and, in fact, I said that, as compared with the present system, the incidence of tax under the Minister's proposal would be more favourable to the poor than the present system under which Fianna Fáil tax food. But we did not accept this system and we proposed our own system. Now for the Minister to have the effrontery in the papers and here to talk of this being our proposal, knowing we had rejected it when he brought it in, and when he sought our opinion on it, and when our opinion was given in terms of the household budget inquiry, for him now to come along and say it is our proposal carries things to a height of dishonesty which I had not expected from a member of the present Fianna Fáil Government though, indeed, one or two years ago there were people in Fianna Fáil Government——

Comment on this

The facts are now clear and Deputy FitzGerald has now out of his own mouth condemned himself in a way that could not be any worse than anything he said about any member of any Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

All right. As I have said to this House, the Minister's proposal, involving the doubling of turnover tax, is one which, although we do not favour it, although we rejected it in the Fine Gael Party, is better than the present Fianna Fáil system for the simple reason I have mentioned already: as far as food is concerned, in the poorest families in the household budget inquiry 45 per cent of the money was spent on food and 20 per cent in the richest families, whereas in the goods which are subject to turnover tax at present the percentage was 35 per cent in the poorest families and 53 per cent in the richest.

One does not need to be very good at arithmetic, and some members of the House perhaps are not, to see that, if the Minister's proposals were adopted and if you, in fact, relieved from tax 45 per cent of the budget of the poorest households but increased by 1 per cent taxation on 35 per cent of that budget you helped them; then, in rich households, you leave them perhaps 20 per cent of the budget but tax 1 per cent extra 53 per cent of the budget and they have to pay a bit more. You do not have to be brilliant to discover that. The Minister knows perfectly well that is the case and he knows that his proposal, unsatisfactory as it is, defective as it is, and one we would not accept because it is not the best answer, is a proposal which, in fact, would have some beneficial effects. But it is not the best proposal and we will not support it because we have a solution which is a far preferable one.

Those are the main points I want to make, except to comment on the fact that the Minister keeps referring to the EEC, but always in very cautious terms. He does not tell us the "EEC will not let us", because he cannot, because Britain is going ahead with zero-rating food. Is the Minister going to come into this House and say that the British have got away with something which his Government are unable to get for us? He cannot say that. He knows perfectly well that if Britain can zero-rate food then so can we. And so he has to talk, using Sibylline phrases like "If we did this we might well have to revert to the present situation." All kinds of things might well happen in the future but, as far as we are concerned on this side of the House, we are anxious to take the tax off food unless and until some time in the future we are required by the EEC to do otherwise. At the moment they do not require us. If they do require us we will face that day when it comes, but we will fight to prevent that day coming, which is something this Government will not do.

Comment on this

The case for the Fine Gael amendment has been put again by Deputy FitzGerald. I do not propose to comment on it except to say that we would naturally support the removal of tax from food. We believe it should be done and we will do everything we can to support any effort to have that done. But, if this cannot be done, then we accept that too. The Minister himself provided us with the figures on which we worked our amendment to the Bill and our amendment suggests the reduction or the removal of tax from certain essential foodstuffs. I have referred before to the fact that the Minister admitted himself that the new rate of tax, the value-added tax, would, according to the Revenue Commissioners, on existing taxation produce a surplus of £3.70 million. We suggest that essential foodstuffs exempt from taxation would cost the Exchequer a loss of £4.11 million. We feel that a figure of £.41 million is a small sum to charge for the reduction of the cost of living to the really needy.

The question of the assistance which might be given by way of social welfare benefits, if this could not be done, has been mentioned by the Minister. One of the things I have been noticing about Minister's particularly when there is a general election or a by-election around the corner, is their invariably hinting vaguely at some increase in social welfare benefits. Here, once again, we have the old chestnut being thrown out once more. There was no increase in children's allowances for a long time until just before the last election and then it was suddenly decided it was necessary to increase children's allowances. It has been suggested again now that children's allowances will be increased.

If the Chair will permit him, I would like the Minister to detail the proposed increases—the extent of the increases, when they will be paid and whether they will apply generally; also what other increases in social welfare are proposed for the purpose of compensating those who will have to bear additional taxation. I am glad that the Minister has returned. For his benefit I would repeat briefly that we have suggested to the House a way of having essential foodstuffs exempt at a cost of £41 million additional taxation, that is, in addition to the £3.70 which will be a surplus. We would support the exemption of all food from the additional net if that would be possible. If that cannot be done, we have suggested an alternative. The excuse the Minister has given is not that it cannot be done but that traders have told him that they could not operate what he calls a third level tax. The extraordinary thing is that we have talked to the traders and they have not made any such case to us. I presume these were the same people who talked to the Minister. What they wanted was one tax rate but they did not suggest that a zero-rate was a tax or that it would cause any difficulty for them. The Minister did not try to put forward a zero-rating as an insurmountable difficulty. He said that when pricing goods, traders will have to segregate zero-rated goods and that this would result in a difficulty although it would not involve any calculation of tax.

The alternative to this, according to the Minister, is an increase in childrens' allowances and other social welfare benefits. He may remember that at the last sitting of the special committee, when he said there were other ways of dealing with this, I asked him if he was talking of social welfare benefits and he replied "Yes", that they were his thoughts on it.

Comment on this

My recollection is that Deputy Tully brought up this suggestion as being, in his view, the right way to approach the matter.

Comment on this

The Minister told me that these were his thoughts on the matter. Since then he has had some time to consider it and I would ask him now on the eve of the by-election to let us know by how much he proposes to increase children's allowances, whether they will apply generally, when they will apply and also whether he proposes to grant increases in social welfare benefits to the people who will be hit badly by this taxation. From the discussions we had at the special committee I am aware that the Minister appreciates there are people living solely on the foods in respect of which we have asked for exemption.

When tabling this amendment we considered whether we should include red meat, white meat, fish, potatoes and household vegetables. The reason for not including these was that, according to the Revenue Commissioners, to exempt red meat would involve a cost to them of £5.10 million, white meat £.56 million, fish £.47 million, potatoes £.30 million and household vegetables £1.03 million. It is impossible for anyone to estimate what will be the price of meat and it is our opinion that even the relatively well-off will not be able to buy meat after a while. We will know who to blame for that. Nobody knows what is happening in regard to the price of potatoes. They are now so dear that people are being forced to go back to the bread-and-spread diet.

The debate to-day was on a good level. However, I have always opposed late night sittings because for some extraordinary reason even those who are sober, and that includes most Members of the House, begin saying things which they would not say normally. Of course we have the odd drunk who comes in and interrupts the proceedings and causes a certain amount of embarrassment because this House is embarrassed by such people who do not enhance the image of Parliament before the visitors in the gallery.

Comment on this
Mr. J. Lenehan

Because the Deputy nor no one belonging to him has ever taken a drink, it does not follow that no one else should either.

Comment on this

We will have these people for as long as the public are foolish enough to return them. Before concluding can the Minister let me have the answers to the questions I have asked?

Comment on this

I said that these things will have to be done in the context of the budget. At the special committee I told Deputy Tully what are the problems in relation to the children's allowances scheme as at present constituted. I told him that we are trying to amend it in a way that would direct it more to the people who need it. Knowing that, the Deputy will appreciate that I cannot answer his questions precisely, by-election or not.

Comment on this

The Minister is aware that I have been advocating legislation to deal with Lourdes marriages for the past 12 months but that the Taoiseach has told me now that we cannot have the Bill because it will be an intricate one. The problem of children's allowances has been with us for a long time. This must have been recognised earlier because, as the Minister knows, the Government discontinued giving increases in children's allowances except at election time. Surely it is not good enough to say now that the problem is very great.

Comment on this

What I have said now is exactly what I told the Deputy at the special committee.

Comment on this

That is true. Therefore, am I to assumt that nothing has been done in the matter although the people concerned will have to bear additional taxation? It is essential that these increases be granted quickly. We will support the amendment to remove taxation from all food but in the event of that not being possible we will press our own amendment. The Minister may hang whatever he wishes around the necks of Fine Gael but he will have difficulty explaining why the Government are not prepared to exclude from VAT such essential foods as bread, butter, margarine, tea, sugar, liquid milk and oranges.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 63
·
Níl 0
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?