European Communities Bill, 1972: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 134–304 of 304. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 21 of 1972 ›
What is the position in the Six member states of the Common Market? What way do they work it? Do they do it in the same way as the Minister wants us to do it, or do they have prior discussions?
Comment on this
Seeking power to do it through ministerial regulation does not prevent a decision being made to have many of the directives of the Community implemented here by legislation in the first instance. It is left to each country to do it in its own way and all the countries do it in a different way.
Comment on this
I understand that in two countries the matter is referred to the national parliament before it is subsequently ratified. They are Holland and the Federal Republic of Germany.
Comment on this
In dealing with the directives of the Community each country is left to do it in its own way. The regulations of the Community are directly applicable. Each country can select its own method of doing it.
Comment on this
Is that not a very cogent argument in favour of the Minister doing what we suggest? We are still a free nation.
Comment on this
I am not looking for extra powers for Europe. I am looking for powers for Ministers to act in a way that makes it possible to fulfil the obligations we have undertaken and powers for the Dáil to control that by confirmation afterwards.
Comment on this
The Minister cannot indicate what the six countries within the EEC are doing. Does not that bear out what I quoted last night? Dr. Mansholt said that the EEC is a monster with many heads and that it is very difficult to explain clearly to people what it is intended to achieve. Dr. Mansholt was quite right. We now hear the reply given to Deputy Esmonde by the Minister who has been negotiating on behalf of this country for a considerable length of time.
Comment on this
I am not saying the Minister should know everything but it would be reasonable to expect that he would inquire what the position was in other countries and whether the legislation they passed was exactly similar to ours. The Minister has stated that each individual country brings in its own legislation. If he had seen their legislation would it not have been a guideline for him, and we could then base our legislation on the most liberal points in that legislation. To me this would have been a commonsense procedure. If I had been more intimately acquainted with the Minister I would have whispered that advice into his ear before tonight so that he could have had the information readily available in the event of questions being put by Deputy Esmonde and other Deputies who are entitled to query the Minister about the legislation prevailing in other countries, and how it is working. The point raised by Deputy Esmonde should have been answered more clearly. It is difficult for the Minister to be able to answer Deputy Esmonde when Dr. Mansholt himself tells us that the EEC is a monster with many heads.
Comment on this
Our amendment was defeated. We are now discussing amendments Nos. 8, 9 and 12 which have nothing to do with prior notice. Amendments Nos. 8 and 9 deal with the type of legislation which it is considered should be excluded from directions or regulations made.
The Minister, subsequent to amendment No. 7 being defeated, made a concession which, while it does not go the whole way, is one which is appreciated; but if we are to have any decision on the Bill, if we are to make any progress on it, with all due respect, we should stick exactly to what we are supposed to be talking about. What we want to do by our amendment No. 8, which sets out that the power conferred in the foregoing subsection shall not include power to repeal or amend any part of the domestic law of the State, is to ensure that the domestic law may not be interfered with by a direction which the Minister may say he has got from the EEC. That is what we are discussing. The Fine Gael amendment No. 9 is more specific. Amendment No. 12 is ours again but it is in fact on the lines of amendment No. 8.
In an effort to bring the debate back on the rails, I should like to know if the Minister has any further comment to make on the suggestion with regard particularly to amendment No. 8 and amendment No. 9. Can he say if he is prepared to concede that certain types of regulations which will be an effort to change the domestic law of this State should not be dealt with in the same way as other regulations? Amendment No. 8 has been defeated and I cannot ask him to go back and shorten the time for discussion on this amendment, but perhaps as I had to be out of the House for a while, the Minister might let me know if he is sticking to his guns and is not prepared to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Esmonde asked a question as to what is done in other countries and the Minister made a statement on what he thought was done. I would like to read two sentences which tell us what is done and they are relevant to what Deputy Tully has said. They are from "The EEC: National Parliaments in Community Decision-Making" by Michael Niblock:
In West Germany, however, Directives are given effect by laws, statutory orders, and administrative decrees, depending on the extent of the changes required to be made to German laws and regulations; if applying a Directives involves amending a Federal Law then the Bundestag has to be brought in. The Dutch arrangements tend to follow the German pattern.
Would the Minister explain to us, if the Germans and Dutch can deal with their problems like that, why he has to have power to amend laws by regulation?
Comment on this
That does not answer the point.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 3, between lines 17 and 18, to insert a new subsection as follows:—
"( ) The power conferred in the foregoing subsection shall not include power—
(i) to impose or increase taxation; or
(ii) to administer justice; or
(iii) to declare acts to be infringements of the law which were not so at the date of their commission; or
(iv) to make any provision taking effect from a date earlier than that of the making of the instrument containing the provision; or
(v) to create any new criminal offence; or
(vi) to confer any power to limit the personal rights guaranteed by Articles 40, 41, 42, 43 & 44 of the Constitution of Ireland and the European Convention of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms."
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 11:
In subsection (2), page 3, line 20, to delete "proper" and substitute "necessary".
The purpose of this amendment is to tighten up the Bill in the same way as Fine Gael's proposal tidied up the Third Amendment to the Constitution Bill which was voted on by the people. The Third Amendment to the Constitution Bill as introduced provided that no provision of the Constitution could invalidate laws enacted, acts done or measures adopted by the State consequent on membership of the Communities. In the Dáil the Fine Gael Party amended that Bill by providing that the words "consequent on" should be omitted and should be replaced by the words "necessitated by the obligations of". The purpose of our amendment, which the Government accepted, was to ensure that nothing would be done as a consequence of the extra power given in the amendment which would not be necessitated by the obligations of the European Communities.
In this Bill the Government are asking the House to give to the Minister power to make regulations which may contain such incidental, supplementary and consequential provisions as appear to the Minister making the regulations to be proper for the purposes of the regulations. We do not think the word "proper" is sufficiently tight to ensure that the Minister does not use the power now given to him to make regulations which are beyond what is required by the obligations of the European Communities. What may appear proper to the Minister may not be necessary and I think the Minister would agree with me on that point. The Minister might have a different measure of propriety to what might be absolutely required by the European Communities. The whole purpose of the power being given here is to enable this State to implement the obligations of the Communities and no more. We should not give in section 3 any power to a Minister to exceed the purpose of this legislation. The sole purpose of the legislation is to enable the State to comply with the obligations of the Communities—that and no more.
The draft regulations might be convenient from the administrative point of view but this House and the people are not concerned with administrative convenience. We are concerned with what power we give to Ministers and the purposes for which they are given that power and the way they use it. Our amendment complies with our obligations and does not in any way inhibit a Minister from discharging his obligations to the Dáil, to the people and to the Community. I hope the Minister will accept this reasonable amendment.
Comment on this
The difference in the words may not be very great but I should like the Minister to explain why the word "proper" was used instead of "necessary". It is possible the Minister might consider something was proper but might not be necessary. Before we debate the amendment, I should like to hear the Minister's explanation why this word was used.
Comment on this
It is the draftsman's phraseology for what the Minister would consider proper to do to implement our obligations under the Act of Accession. Perhaps the House would prefer that it should read "as it appears to the Minister to be necessary" instead of using the word "proper"? So long as the Minister maintains the power that is all right.
Comment on this
It seems the House will accept the word "necessary" but will not accept the word "proper".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
To add to the section new subsections as follows:—
"( ) Every regulation made under this section shall be laid before Dáil Éireann as soon as may be after it is made and Dáil Éireann may, within the next twenty-one days on which it has sat after the regulation is laid before it, amend the regulation in a way which, in the opinion of any Committee which Dáil Éireann may set up for this purpose, is consistent with the provision of the original Community directive which the regulation seeks to implement.
( ) Any Committee referred to in the foregoing subsection shall have power
(a) to examine and advise a Minister of State and Irish Members of the European Parliament on all EEC Commission proposals prior to decisions thereon being taken by the Council of Ministers, and
(b) to decide whether any EEC directive (i.e. proposal which is not directly applicable) should be implemented by regulation under this Act or by new legislation.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
All I want to say in relation to section 3, as it now stands, is that I think it is absolutely pitiful and disgraceful that Dáil Éireann has not got the guts to do what the German Bundestag, the Dutch Parliament and the British Parliament have done and that is to put some curb upon ministerial power to make regulations to comply with European Communities obligations. Why should we, with the aid of the Fianna Fáil Party, have belittled ourselves as a Parliament? It is thoroughly disgraceful and is clearly indicative of the contempt that Fianna Fáil have for the wishes of the people and for the wishes of the people's representatives. They want to rule absolutely, to be absolute rulers without any review, not even the benefit of comment by the elected representatives of the people. It is thoroughly contemptible and Dáil Éireann, I believe, will live to regret this day.
Comment on this
On a point of correction, the Deputy said that Fianna Fáil want to rule without any review. The review is in section 4.
Comment on this
The Dáil will have to confirm regulations and that is a review and the regulations will lapse if the Dáil does not confirm them. The Deputy should be aware also that it is to Ministers and the Dáil that power is given and not to any political party. His own thinking on the future of the country is obvious.
Comment on this
With respect to what the Minister has said he is wrong. The decision tonight was taken with the votes of the Fianna Fáil Party and nobody else. It is they who believe that the Government have an absolute right to rule without regard to the wishes of anybody else in the community. The German Bundestag, the Dutch Parliament and the British Parliament have decided that the powers now conferred on Ministers here by the Fianna Fáil majority should not be given to any Government but should lie with Parliament. That is the difference and the Minister cannot escape from that. He has shown Fianna Fáil's contempt for the whole parliamentary and democratic process. It is no use to say that six months after the event we can come along and try to change taxation, criminal law and other fundamental matters. That is no remedy. The damage is then done. What we sought was a right of trying to colour, influence, advise, beforehand. You have denied us that. You have now rendered Dáil Éireann impotent and sterile. That was your wish and you now have your wish. I hope you are thoroughly ashamed of yourselves.
Comment on this
Any regulation made by a Minister will lapse if not confirmed by Dáil Éireann. Even after the whole day the Deputy does not seem to know what we are doing. It is not fair of him to say what he has said about the Dáil. He must accept majority rule.
Comment on this
No. The Deputy may not have been here. We have decided to provide for six months confirmation and they will lapse if they are not confirmed by the Dáil.
Comment on this
I heard what the Minister is hoping to do between now and the Report Stage but even six months criminal law, six months taxation will operate. Why, if the Minister says it is valid to do it after the event, will he not allow the Dáil to be consulted beforehand? He has shown he does not want to consult the Dáil.
Comment on this
If a majority of the Dáil, which is what counts, want to, they can, immediately a regulation is made, introduce private legislation to overthrow it, at once. What we have done here is bring in effective law that makes it possible for us to take on our obligations satisfactorily and quickly and at the same time give the Dáil its right to confirm if such regulations are to be continued.
Comment on this
I asked a question before and I got no answer. If three other Parliaments, the Dutch Parliament, the German Parliament, and now the British Parliament, are legislating to do it, can allow the matter to be discussed before it is made a regulation or an act in the EEC, why can we not do the same?
Comment on this
We have not excluded that. It still remains a power to have any of the directives of the institution made into our domestic law through direct legislation if this decision is made by the Government.
Comment on this
Surely we have discussed this all night, the amendments have been defeated and I think we are just wasting time.
Comment on this
We are not wasting time, we are pinning responsibility. The Minister has no problem. He is off to Brussels. We have to live with it.
Comment on this
We understand from the Minister that he proposes between now and Report Stage to prepare an amendment to insert the period of six months as the period within which we could review the Government's misconduct, so I am prepared on that account not to move the amendment No. 14.
Comment on this
I think it is a sensible idea because we do not want to delay on this matter any longer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In subsection (2), page 3, line 36, to delete "a majority" and substitute "one-third".
I must frankly admit that there is some confusion about the import of section 4. On first reading it would appear that the purpose of recalling the Dáil would be to review what the Government have already done but on a closer reading it would appear that, in fact, if the Dáil is not recalled, what the Government have done would collapse if they did not get the benediction of the authority of the Dáil to continue what they had done. I would like the Minister to clarify any confusion which might exist before we press the amendment.
Comment on this
I think perhaps we were too solicitious for the Government's welfare in putting down this amendment. To me it reads if the section as it stands is allowed to stand it will require a majority of the Dáil to recall it. I do not know why it was put down in this way. I have been reading it the same way as Deputy Ryan has. If the regulation lapses, not being moved within the statutory period, then it is the Government's responsibility to see it does not lapse if they want to continue it. If there is another interpretation of it as Deputy Ryan says, perhaps the Minister might explain it to us as otherwise we will leave them to look after that part of the business themselves and withdraw our amendment.
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, a regulation made by a Minister will lapse if not confirmed at a time fixed by the Oireachtas. We have in mind here the other procedures which Deputies would like to avail of when a regulation is first published.
Comment on this
Such as parliamentary questions, motions, private motions, motions on the Adjournment, or legislation, as I mentioned. If the Dáil is adjourned these would not be available to Deputies. I do not think they would lapse in the ten days mentioned. They would not lapse until the failure to confirm by legislation six months afterwards.
Comment on this
I am more confused than ever because if it had been as originally intended, in operation up to two years, surely ample opportunity should have been given to ask the questions, put down the motions or use whatever facilities were available. Again, I think that possibly we have misinterpreted but the Minister's explanation has not made it any clearer to me.
Comment on this
The Deputy thought that at the end of the period if the Dáil were not in session it would lapse. It was not the intention. The intention was that if Deputies wanted to use the normal process available to talk on the matter, to oppose it by motion, private motion, motions on the Adjournment or by legislation if the Dáil were not in session this would not be open to them.
Comment on this
I can see the point. The Deputy makes the point that it is up to the Government to ensure that these matters can be discussed.
Comment on this
Yes. Is this not a good example where, if we wrote our laws in plain English, we could understand them. The draftsman does not understand it. The Minister does not understand it either. This is another example of this sort of gobbledegook.
Comment on this
This is a double negative and that is where the confusion arose. As the Fine Gael Party have seen through the gobbledegook of the double negative we do not propose to press our amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
Before section 5 to insert a new section as follows:—
"The enactments mentioned in the Schedule to this Act (being enactments that are superseded or to be superseded by reason of the European Communities' obligations and of the provision made by this Act in relation thereto or which are not compatible with the European Communities' obligations) are hereby repealed or amended, as the case may be, to the extent specified in the said Schedule with effect from the 1st day of January, 1973".
This Bill is evidence of a thoroughly disgraceful situation. On the 10th May last the people very emphatically authorised this country to join the European Community. One would have thought that even before then the Government and the Government's legal advisers would have had available to them and be able to present to the people a clear statement of the domestic laws of this country which would be qualified or affected by Acts of the European Community. If they did not have it on the 10th May last it was perfectly reasonable to assume that between 10th May and the 8th November following there would have been prepared a comprehensive list of the laws of this State which would stand amended, qualified or abrograted by European Community legislation.
We find, to our absolute horror, this Bill does not contain any schedule of legislation to be amended. There is in the explanatory memorandum an appendix which is described as: "A list of existing Irish legislation which will be affected by Community law". This spells out 100, and possibly more, Acts because some of the Acts are described under inclusive and omnibus clauses like the Enforcement of Court Orders Acts 1926 and 1940 and other Acts like the Courts of Justice Acts 1924 to 1961 which, to my knowledge, include no less than five Acts, so the number of Acts which will be specifically, directly and immediately qualified on the 1st January, 1973, exceeds 100. Even this appendix to the explanatory memorandum does not state in any respect to what extent the Acts in question stand repealed or amended.
This is a disgraceful situation and one to which the Incorporated Law Society have had to draw attention. Everybody is, under our legal system, presumed to know the law. Now we have for the first time on the statutes of this country legislative proof that the Government of the day do not know the law. The Government cannot even produce evidence of the law in an explanatory memorandum to a Bill. They do not know and are not capable of stating or setting out even in the explanatory memorandum the extent to which the existing domestic law of this State is being qualified by Community legislation. They have a caviat in the appendix which reads:
This list sets out the principle enactments which will be affected. The list is comprehensive but does not purport to be exhaustive.
On a personal level the Minister has become immunised against criticism. He is off to Brussels next year and good luck to him but I have worries regarding the part that he will play for this country there since we find that he is leaving behind this nebulous piece of legislation which cannot even set out in Schedules to the Act the laws of this country that are to be amended. I would ask Members to cast their minds back to other pieces of legislation during the years and they will recall Schedules to many Acts which contain the Titles of Acts to be amended. Not only that but the amending Acts specified precisely, line by line, what parts of the former Acts were to be amended or repealed, but here we are with the most far-reaching piece of legislation in our history and we have not got in it a Schedule with a guideline as to what pieces of legislation being amended.
I abhor that any Minister would think so little of the whole parliamentary process as to produce such a careless piece of legislation. Even a first year law student would know enough about the legislative process not to produce anything so ridiculous as this Bill. What is the Minister doing? He is bringing in this piece of legislation to make sweeping amendments to the whole law of Ireland and his attitude is "to hell with you if you do not know the consequences of the legislation. It is your business to find out". The Department of Foreign Affairs do not know the consequences, neither do the Department of Justice nor the office of the Attorney General.
Comment on this
The Department cannot produce a guide as to the precise consequences of the legislation. In relation to Deputy Corish's intervention, it is one matter to know the general consequences of a decision but—I speak now with my legal hat on—it is another to know what advice one can give to a client when consulted on a particular matter when there is no piece of legislative evidence in existence having the extent of repeals of former legislation. This is an atrocious position. Already the Incorporated Law Society have made the most urgent representations possible to the Government but despite that we get nothing but this clumsy, careless and infantile piece of legislation. Earlier when I suggested that the Government were being contemptuous of Parliament, the Minister took umbrage at my remark. He can carry that umbrage or shrug it off as he wishes but it is absolute proof of their contempt and of their unfitness to govern that they will not tell the people what they are trying to do to them. This is because they do not care about the whole legal and legislative process. They do not care what consequences or penalties may fall on people or what confusion may be caused. So far as the Government are concerned that is somebody else's problem and so the Attorney General, the Minister for Justice, the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Minister for Finance say: "we will not tell you the law; you can find out for yourselves".
It may well be that there will be a very lucrative world ahead for the legal profession. I do not think that is the intention of the Government but it is the situation they are creating today. While they are creating a whirlwind of profit for the legal profession they will impose on Irish people and Irish business an immense burden of trying to ascertain what is the law. This results from the Government being too lazy and too indifferent to spell it out in the Bill. It is because we are anxious that even at this 11th hour the Government will write into the Bill the extent to which our law is being amended, that we have put down this amendment. For the third time today I find myself saying to the Minister that I am no apologist for the British legislature or for any other legislature but the British Parliament found it possible to spell out the extent to which their laws, which are more ancient than ours, are being amended by the European Communities. They are spelled out in Schedules and appendices to the Bill. We have a legislative history of only 51 years and we have been too lazy and too indifferent to do the same.
I am appalled at the Minister, and my respect for him evaporates when I see him producing such a contemptible Bill, a Bill that is so unhelpful to the people he will leave behind when he goes to Brussels.
Comment on this
It would be very unfair to lay this burden completely on the shoulders of the Minister. The Government are responsible for certain matters and it is they, as a whole, who must carry responsibility for this proposed legislation. Each Minister in his own Department should have been responsible for preparing the necessary documentation. Deputy Ryan said that the Minister was contemptuous of the House in producing the Bill. The Minister knew what he was doing. In a short while the Committee Stage will have been completed.
Deputy Ryan referred also to the question of what advice could be given to clients in respect of amended legislation. Let me remind the House that before the referendum all politicians were advising the electorate but we in the Labour Party were the only people who gave the correct advice. There were a couple of exceptions in other parties but they merely whispered the correct advice. The proof of the pudding is in the eating and we are now saddled with something which, apparently, we must accept. It may be said that there was not time to compile the comprehensive information to which the Deputy has referred. I shudder to think of what will happen on the 1st January next when there will be a whole new set of laws and, I assume, a whole new set of offences. If we do not know what is the law, how is it to be administered?
It may be said also that there were no facilities available to have certain things done. I do not wish to repeat this too often but I would remind the House that an English translation of documentation from the EEC up to the 1st January last is in the Library and up to the present it is available in French. It has not been found possible to translate the latter yet. Yet it is found possible to delegate at least one civil servant to the task of translating the English text into Irish. This has been done. I do not know who will study it. Earlier Deputy Flanagan was defending the rights of Irish speakers to have this documentation and the rights of Irish speakers in this House to know what was going on, but we have not been able to get documentation to show what will be the effect of the legislation we are passing through the House. This is disgraceful. I will not blame the Minister although he must share some of the responsibility since he has had to pilot this Bill through the House. Neither will I blame the parliamentary draftsmen because they work only on what they are given from the Government. Therefore, the entire Government must carry the responsibility for what has been done here.
It appears that what has happened is that the Government, having got the referendum through with such a huge majority, were so tickled that they consider it hardly necessary to do anything more. Maybe they prayed to St. Anthony but, in any case, I do not know how they hope to get out of this mess. The amendments suggested here by Fine Gael would, perhaps bring matters up to date even at this late hour. Will the Minister tell us if it is possible to have the information before the 31st December? The Minister may say that a number of us might not understand the legislation.
I have got Consolidation Bills in this House with tabulated amendments to various legislation, dating away back over 150 years, all listed neatly. They might not mean very much to me unless I was interested in one particular section and went to the trouble of researching on it, but to the legal people who will have to administer this after 1st January it must mean something.
The attempt to put this sort of thing through the House without going to the trouble of showing what is being changed and how it is being changed is nothing short of disgraceful. It is a typical example of what this Government have been doing with practically everything they have handled over the past few years. They may have had, like the rest of us, their little internal squabbles but, over the last 12 months, they should have been in a position to find out what was being done. Surely since last May they should have been able to tabulate the changes which have to be made in legislation in order to comply with EEC conditions.
I am certainly not blaming the Minister for this. I wish him very well in his new office. I do not agree with what the Minister has been doing but I know he has been doing a tremendous amount of work in the EEC and has gone to a lot of trouble. However, those who with him have the responsibility of governing this country must accept the blame for not doing their homework and for not having ready for the House, before this Bill came in, the necessary tabulation.
Comment on this
Where a provision of existing domestic law is in conflict with a provision of directly applicable Community law, the domestic law will be automatically amended or repealed to the extent to which the conflict exists. That is in accordance with the rules of our domestic law on conflicting legislative provisions. It is, therefore, not necessary to amend or repeal individual provisions specifically. The Deputy knows the principle of implied repeal. If you wanted to do it it would require a call on our manpower at this time that we should not devote to that work because they are at much more important work on membership.
Comment on this
That is one. The point remains that the law is, by the principle we practice of implied repeal, amended or repealed to the extent of the conflict. We have published here a list for the guidance of the public to make them aware what provisions in our domestic law are likely to be affected, as being in conflict with the Community law. That is a guideline for them or their lawyers when they are dealing with something affected by the law, to know that there is a Community regulation which repeals this.
Comment on this
The list we published. It is not exhaustive, but it is a guideline. It indicates to the public and to the lawyers what laws are affected.
Comment on this
The Minister says "affected" but it does not say whether it is the whole of the Bill or the whole of the law or part of the law.
Comment on this
Many areas will not be clear, could not be clear. If there is a conflict the extent of it would have to be confirmed by our own courts, and some by the European courts.
Deputy Ryan mentioned that the British made a list. It is not exhaustive. If we took the list and repealed it or amended it as necessary it would not be exhaustive and it would lead to confusion, because there is an area then not indicated to the public. It is not just for now; as we go on into the future new regulations applied here by the Community will have this effect. The only way we can really catch up with it is to give guidelines to lawyers to watch out for it and read the law, get interpretations from the courts and, as the Taoiseach said when introducing this Bill, to have frequent revision Acts for the specific purpose of dealing with points to be amended or repealed, and this will be done.
Comment on this
When the original Act was going through the House I protested strongly at the terms in which it was drafted. As legislators we do not have to put up with this kind of thing. We do not have to put up with the Government standing on the right foot yesterday in relation to the Marriages Bill and on the left foot today. Yesterday they were going to itemise everything in detail. They were going to repeal a simple provision that marriages could be conducted in a registry office only between the hours of 8 a.m. and 3 p.m. so that the hours would be between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. That was repeated over and over again to the extent of a full page in the Marriages Bill yesterday. No Government can do that kind of thing to me anyway. If I am sufficiently concerned I will tackle them. My own attitude towards this Bill is quite simple. I believe that the original Bill that was produced in relation to our going into the Common Market was wrongly drafted and I said so.
Comment on this
This is an extremely serious matter. I have not taken up much of the time of the House. We have been here all day.
Comment on this
The Minister deserves to be here not for one day but for several weeks, on this thing, because this House should be protecting the rights of the people from this kind of business. Even at this eleventh hour let us bring home to the Minister that the Government cannot treat the House on separate days to completely different methods of legislation. Even the Parliamentary Secretary agrees with me.
Comment on this
In this House there is the tenth hour and the eleventh hour. There is this kind of suggestion that where there is a conflict, and I took down the Minister's actual words, the domestic law will be automatically repealed. All that was required yesterday in the Marriage Bill was that this matter should have been referred to once, that the words 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. were to be replaced by the words 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. — period. That was sufficient. But it was repeated over and over again in section 16 of the Marriage Bill. Now, we cannot have this global kind of legislation because the Department of Foreign Affairs is such a big place and so important that they can do what they bloody well like and the rest of us are to say nothing. We are not fit. I remember when the Minister would not answer me when I asked a most straightforward question about the extent to which the Germans had broken our bilateral trade agreement. I remember when it was rigged around the bloody House, "goodo," that these questions would not be answered on the grounds, from the Ceann Comhairle, and he had it all prepared when I raised it with him—
Comment on this
No. Let me say what I have to say first. Let me make my point first. The Minister does not know what I am going to say so let him wait until I finish. It was fixed up. Eventually I went into the public office and said: "Look, do you know what I want to ask? You fix the questions." And they fixed the questions. But were they allowed then? They were not and I will tell you why: it was because the Minister's dirty Department was interfering with the workings of this House in the filthiest fashion.
Comment on this
It is a reflection on the Ceann Comhairle to infer that people could successfully interfere with questions.
Comment on this
I know what happened and, with respect, it is a reflection on the way the business of this House is conducted. And I stand over it.
Comment on this
I certainly will. I have made my point. It is quite clear what I was talking about and the Minister knows it quite as well as I do. The Minister talks about implied repeal. Did Deputy de Valera say he does now know what I am talking about? Did he? I will tell Deputy de Valera what I am talking about if he wants to know. It is quite a simple thing. I asked a simple question in the House as to whether——
Comment on this
Was Deputy de Valera thinking out loud? Is this his trouble? He cannot think for himself. The Minister said there is a principle of implied repeal. I have never heard of this bloody principle in all my life and I have had as much to do with legislation as the Minister. I have had a damn sight more to do with legislation——
Comment on this
On the contrary. I am not prepared to swallow rubbish, not even from "Mr. Europe" himself. I am not built that way. I am not prepared to swallow rubbish from anybody.
Comment on this
The Minister is assured it by his men in the Department of Foreign Affairs. Is that it?
Comment on this
I did not know the Minister had any lawyers in Foreign Affairs. All I can say is you have a great many lazy people in Foreign Affairs.
Comment on this
I have every right to say this is one of the laziest Bills I have ever seen in this House, one of the laziest that ever came before the House.
Comment on this
Look, this is the end of the hunt in relation to this Bill and I have not taken up much time in the House, but other people have talked for 12 hours.
Comment on this
All right. On the Final Stage I will have a few words to say about it and I will say them with emphasis. I am now dealing with the Minister's reply. He said: "We have published a list." What was in this list? What was in this list was just the minimum of words. There was no worthwhile information at all, but there were 1,300 amendments of law, or something like that, amendments of directives, or whatever they are, or Acts. There were 1,300 of them and the Minister said: "We have published a list." What use is this list to anybody? Here it is. It is a massive document. This is the list in my hand.
Comment on this
I will read out just one: Regulation 2504/71 of 22nd November amending regulation No. 24 and regulation EEC No. 816/70 relating to common organisation of the markets in wine products. How much information does that give us?
Comment on this
These are our Acts which are affected. It is all very well to be smart about this kind of thing.
Comment on this
What the Deputy read out was some of the secondary legislation of the Community and what we are talking about is our Acts affected by secondary legislation. What the Deputy should read out is our Acts.
Comment on this
I know, but why should they be affected by secondary legislation. Under what obligation am I to read out our Acts?
Comment on this
None whatever. I can read out a secondary piece of legislation and ask what is the meaning of this legislation in relation to our Acts. I will go back to it again. Here it is. They are here by the thousand. What does it mean—relating to the common organisation of the market in wine products? I do not know how this affects our legislation and I suspect nobody else does either. It is all right to provide a list of this kind to the House, but what value is it to the Members of the House? What value is it in helping them to understand what we are legislating on? I do not think it is of any value whatever. The Minister says: "We have published a list." This is the kind of list he has published, himself and his Department— a kind of shorthand.
Comment on this
I am not aware of any Parliament which legislates on the basis of an index. I have read Acts of different Parliaments and I am not aware of any Parliament that legislates on the basis of an index. I am taking Deputy de Valera as being correct. I hope he is.
Comment on this
It explains nothing. It does not explain the Bill. It says nothing whatever about the Acts. All it does is give us a list in shorthand. Of what? Of what the Community has already——
Comment on this
The memorandum is just a few generalisations and the list goes on for page after page, hundreds and hundreds of items, and I do not believe that any one of them is explained properly. I do not approve of this method of legislating. I should like to know does Deputy de Valera approve of it either. Does Deputy de Valera approve of this kind of thing? Does he stand over what he said yesterday—that we are giving away none of our sovereignty in this whole situation?
Comment on this
The Deputy will remember what I said when he made that remark yesterday. We will leave it at that. The Minister then said in his reply that the lawyers are put on their track. What use is that to the ordinary citizens, that the lawyers are put on their track? As Deputy Ryan said, it will create a bonanza for the lawyers. He is right, of course. This section will create a superbonanza for the lawyers.
Finally, the Minister said that, if we did it in the same way as the British Parliament had done it, it would lead to confusion. This is what the Minister said as I took it down. I hope I did not misinterpret it. In fact, if we approached this matter as the British did it might have created a lot more work, but a custom has gradually grown into our legislation of doing things in a slick manner and you provide that the Minister may by order do this, that and the other thing. There is no detail of what he may do. It amounts to saying that the Minister may do anything he likes to ensure that an Act is operated as he wants to operate it. I am talking of ordinary legislation. This has led gradually to this situation where we are presented, in probably the most important piece of legislation we ever had in this House since the legislation bringing the treaty between Great Britain and Ireland into operation, with generalised statements which, as law, are worthless. No lawyer will accept them. Therefore, I think Deputy Ryan is quite right to put down this amendment.
Comment on this
——about the Department of Foreign Affairs. He called it a dirty Department and suggested it engaged in filthy activities. I know he probably allows himself a certain licence but anything the Department does is my responsibility. I think the country is well served by the people in the Department. Under the method we have of running this country the civil servants do not defend themselves and for that reason they attract attack.
Comment on this
The Deputy is entitled to say anything he likes about me. I am responsible for the behaviour of that Department and for the standards in it and I repeat that it is because they do not defend themselves—and that is our system—that they are subject to these attacks. I should far prefer the Deputy to say the same thing about me.
Comment on this
I would hope so. My contribution, I trust, will be brief and to the point. The blame here lies on the Minister and on the Government fairly and squarely. It is up to them to get from the civil servants the work they require and by now they should have required a detailed, comprehensive, exhaustive list of our own legislation which is being amended by the obligations of the European Communities. That is the absolute truth. I think the reality is that the Minister for Foreign Affairs, off to Brussels, could not care less what is left behind. The Government could not care less. Fianna Fáil have never shown much respect for legal obligations. It has often been said that there are Members of the Opposition here who have made immense profits out of legal cases. Shame on the Government that have made this possible. It was not possible when Governments were concerned about legal obligations. Now they are not. I believe profit will be made by the legal profession because of the mess and uncertainly left behind but losses will be caused to insurance companies which insure lawyers against what is called negligence, that is, failure to give clients correct advice.
I do not believe there is in Dublin today a lawyer who could give to his client correct advice on what Ireland's domestic law will be from 1st January 1973. There is no one library in Dublin—in fact, not all the libraries in Dublin—which can provide the total law of the European Community. The Incorporated Law Society have pointed out to the Government that the initial cost of providing in Dublin one reference library for the European Community would be £13,000 and that the cost of providing the annual increase in documentation would be £1,800. The legal profession have not at present available the income to provide for that. They have asked the Government to provide that library for the public. I quote from the annual report of the Incorporated Law Society published yesterday. They have made urgent representations to the Department of Justice and the Attorney General's Department that the Government should publish a guide to legislation which will become spent or obsolete following accession to the European Community because they regard that as the minimum essential to giving clients adequate legal advice.
They have not got this from the Government. It is not in the Bill and is nowhere available. It is a thorough and complete disgrace. Deputy Dr. O'Donovan is perfectly correct in saying that yesterday we had one process of legislation which spelled out in detail down to the hours at which you could get married, precisely the way the marriage laws were being amended. Here, according to the Government's own memorandum, we have legislation extending from agricultural produce, cereals, to the production of cement, to industrial relations, to dangerous substances, to weights and measures, to the enforcement of court orders. Yet there is no indication in this mass of domestic legislation of the extent of repeal, and that is an essential guide to the law.
I am appalled that the Government should do this. I suppose we cannot do anything at this hour of the day. Members have been treating contributions on this section with far too much levity, but be sure that you are putting the country and the whole legal system into a thorough and complete mess. All we can do at this stage is to protest and to vote emphatically against it. That is why we put down this amendment and why we insist the amendment should be carried to oblige the Government to set out in the Schedule to this Act an adequate guide to what is being repealed. It is not sufficient to say, as the Minister said, that there is a doctrine of implied repeal. There is, but that is no use to anybody who wants to confirm with the law. There is no reference available to them to show such people what the law is.
Comment on this
May I just say that we have been here from 10.30 this morning until almost 10.30 tonight. As the Minister is aware—I cannot repeat this often enough—I was opposed to EEC entry; I think it was a mistake, but the country decided in its favour. None of us will get any thanks if we impede the passing of this measure. It appears that the Government have made a bad mistake; they have not produced the necessary documentation, but there is nothing we can do here tonight if we talk until 12 o'clock. I think we should have this matter decided now if we are serious about it, and I suggest we do that. I am well aware that there are people here who have very valid points to make and they are entitled to make those points, but this will not alter the fact that the legislation must go through. Unless we are prepared to spend another day on it I suggest we should bring it to a close now.
Comment on this
With due respect to my senior colleague in the Labour Party, the Minister made some dirty references to me in his reply. He spoke about "wild remarks". I do not make wild statements in this House. It is the Minister who, when I asked reasonable questions in this House, said it was argument. I was treated with all kinds of nonsense and it was the Minister who was responsible for that. The Minister can interpret the word "Minister" any way he likes.
Coming back to the amendment, we have mentioned in the explanatory memorandum under "community provisions affecting Acts" the Companies Act, 1963, with a note "Provisions regarding the disclosure of accounts, etc. in certain cases." What does this mean? I do not know. Neither, I suspect, does the Minister. The Minister might explain that, for example. To take another, The Motor Vehicles (Registration of Importers) Act, 1968. The explanation is "The requirement in the Accession Treaty that provision be made for the introduction of a global quota in respect of vehicles other than those covered by the existing scheme." What does that mean? Has it any meaning? The fact is that it has no meaning. Taken by itself it has no meaning whatever. It is all very fine for the Minister to suggest that I cannot say things about Government Departments. I can and will say things about Government Departments any time I like. I want to put my interpretation of this rule about not mentioning the Civil Service. It refers to not mentioning individual civil servants. Everybody has the right to attack Government Departments, if they feel like it, in this House, and I stand over that. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle may rule me out of order if he likes but he is quite wrong in doing that. Every Member of this House has the right to say that a Government Department is doing wrong. When I say the Minister's civil servants are doing it, the Minister knows what the rules of debate are, that we are supposed to refer to the Minister. What is the difference? We all know the meaning of it. We are not idiots.
Comment on this
Having made the point. I will come back. Let me say that I have not delayed the House about this Bill. There will be no Division tonight because I will talk until 10.30 about this amendment.
Comment on this
I would not have done it but for the Minister's dirty remarks about me. If the Minister will withdraw his reference to my "wild remarks", I will allow him the Bill.
Comment on this
Will the Minister withdraw his remarks that I made wild statements? I made no wild statements. If the Minister says they are wild let him prove they are wild. He did not prove any one of them wild. He makes global statements, as this blooming Bill makes the most global provisions ever put into any Act—next to the one already passed in relation to the Community. It is all very fine to talk but if we are here as legislators we should legislate properly and we should not go in for this kind of thing of giving a clean state to the Minister and allowing the to do what he likes and allowing the Communities to do anything they like to us. This is not done. This was not done across the water. The Minister can say what he likes about my remarks but unless he withdraws his statement that I made wild remarks he is not going to get this Stage of the Bill tonight. He has a few minutes still to withdraw the remark but if he is not going to withdraw it I will not withdraw what I am saying. This will not end tonight.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Donovan would allow me for a minute, could both the comment Deputy O'Donovan made about the officials and what the Minister said be taken as not having been said and let us get on with the job?
Comment on this
I am getting on with the business of the House. We had statements repeated over and over again.
Comment on this
I will come back to the amendment straightaway. The amendment is intended to provide that there are some powers left to this House to deal with matters which are essentially the prerogative of this House. Of course, Deputy de Valera, having said yesterday that we gave away none of our sovereignty, is dead keen that we proceed to give away more of it today. Let me put it this way—I could not care tuppence whether we get through this Stage of the Bill tonight or not because there will be other Stages and there will be plenty of opportunity for me to talk on them but I will be back on the Minister's reference to my wild remarks and I will deal with the Minister's wild remarks as I have already dealt with them.
Let me repeat one of them: "There is a principle of implied repeal". This is a principle that I never heard of before and neither did anybody else. There is no such principle and, I do not care tuppence from whom he got that advice, it is wrong. It is completely and absolutely wrong. The Minister can come into the House and make this kind of statement if he likes but the House does not have to accept it. "There is a principle of implied repeal." Yesterday things were spelled out again and again and again on the Marriages Bill, and repeated over and over again—the same old form of words, for a whole page, and then the Minister comes in today, on a much more important Bill, and says there is a principle of implied repeal.
We have had altogether too much of this business of a gradual attrition of the powers of Parliament here and the more we give way the more it continues and the worse it gets. I have given the Minister an opportunity to withdraw his nasty remark about me. If he will not withdraw it I shall talk this out tonight. He can withdraw the remark or he can come in again tomorrow morning. He can have it whichever way he likes.
Comment on this
I can be here too. I do not see any problem in it. I am glad to see the Minister picking up his papers. That is a sign. I have said, and I am entitled to say it, that if the Minister talks about "wild remarks" when in fact what I was saying was the literal truth, the Minister will have to put up with a great deal more of this from now on. He had to put up with some of it today. He did not get any of it from me today but he will have a lot more of it before this Bill goes through the House. I am not going to put up with this from anybody.