Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–117 of 236. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1972 ›
In the few minutes at my disposal last night I adverted to certain elements here who would subvert the powers of the State and I also stated that I was behind any legislation designed to secure and defend our democratic institutions. I said I did not think that the Government were bringing in the Bill merely for the sake of an exercise in verbal gymnastics or for the purpose of having a bit of fun here. This is a serious Assembly and, over the last three years, we have all of us listened to demands from the Opposition side of the House that the Government should do something. We have had attempts to bring certain people under control, but none of these attempts were effective in achieving our aim. The accusation made yesterday by Deputy Ryan cannot, therefore, be said to hold much water. If the Minister and the Attorney General are unable under present legislation to find the law sufficient for their needs, then it is our duty here, the duty of the Government and of Parliament as a whole, to ensure that there is sufficient legislation in the hands of those responsible to protect and preserve our democracy.
I was surprised at many of the statements made, particularly the statements made by that well-known literary figure, Deputy Cruise-O'Brien. He used some nice literary phrases. He said this was an attempt to improve the image of Fianna Fáil and to justify our alleged inactivity over the last few years. He used the word "cosmetics". Whatever cosmetics may be necessary to improve the image of Fianna Fáil, I can assure the Deputy that it would take quite drastic plastic surgery to improve the image of the Labour Party. That goes for Fine Gael also.
Fianna Fáil do not have to introduce legislation to improve their appearance or to redeem their reputation. The referendum on entry into Europe gave the Taoiseach a vote of confidence and, if that were not sufficient, then the Cork by-election certainly strengthened his hand quite considerably. The Government stand as a stable party. I was surprised to read the headlines in last evening's papers. Whether they were inspired or otherwise, whether there was a leak or whether there was not, I do not know, but it is rather a pity that at times like these—they are nearly emergency conditions—there should be these divisions even considered, never mind being voiced as real.
The main Opposition speaker yesterday indicated a certain amount of dissatisfaction over supporting this Bill and over the attitude of his party. I support this Bill simply and solely because I want to secure democracy here. I want to ensure that it will endure. If we procrastinate here, either as a Government or as a Parliament, and deny the officers of the law sufficient legislation to preserve democracy we will lose it altogether.
It is fair comment to say that we never can and never will be able to enjoy complete freedom. At any stage we have only a limited freedom and, should the need arise, we must limit that freedom further in order to protect the sovereignty of the State and preserve democracy. There are forces at work today which do not recognise democracy, forces which will use democracy to destroy democracy. It is up to every Member of this House to ensure that that ambition is not attained, even if that means some slight curtailment of liberty and, perhaps, some legislation of a nature we might not really like.
It is alleged that there are ominous overtones. In the 11 years I have been a Member of this House most legislation has been attacked on the basis that it has ominous overtones. Yet, legislation goes through and there is no ominous effect. As a matter of fact, the complaint is very often made subsequently that the legislation is not strong enough. I am very pleased that the Opposition parties have decided to oppose this measure because I want this measure to be fully explained to the Irish public. I could not and would not support Deputy Donegan's argument that the leaders of the main Opposition parties could have formed a nice little circle and that this could be brought in in a nice palsy-walsy way. I want this Bill fully discussed. I want it discussed as between the Minister proposing it and the Opposition opposing it. Whether or not it has weaknesses, it is the type of legislation we need at this time. I would say to the Minister that, if there is any virtue in the arguments put forward by the Opposition he should accept them——
Comment on this
——if he sees that they can be accepted. I want to ensure that we have legislation to maintain law and order. It is utterly and absolutely disgraceful that the Judiciary should be intimidated whether they are presiding in court or in their own homes, or that their wives and families should be threatened with damage if the judges acted in a certain way. It is high time that an end was put to the intimidation of Ministers and Deputies. They have been intimidated in their homes. They have a job to do and they are doing the job they were elected to do.
When a small percentage of the population decide: "We do not like democracy; we do not like the way it works; it is too cumbersome; there is too much work and too much argument in it; let us have the good old Stalin system; let us have the good old Hitler system; let us issue orders, bring in the jackboot and silence opposition", we must guard against that. This would appear to be the new image of the new generation and the new political parties who are unable to make an impression on the population, and who would denigrate the population as being some form of stupid imbeciles who are not mature enough to make a decision as to what type of government they want.
The decision rests with all of this House. I am glad the Opposition are opposing the Bill and I hope their opposition will not be a denigration of past Acts and laws, but that we will have a constructive and helpful debate, and that they will seek whatever amendments may be necessary to round off this Bill into an effective measure. Far from being the tyrant some people would make him out to be, the Minister for Justice has considerable courage and integrity and intelligence. He will co-operate with them and ensure that democracy will prevail here.
I never thought that I would see as I went out through the Merrion Street gate last night such a mobilisation of troops with shields and other equipment to withstand a barrage. I never thought that any Irishman whatever his breed, colour, seed or generation would see a scene like the one we saw when the Mater Hospital, a place of refuge and healing, was assailed by hooligans——
Comment on this
Deputy Thornley says 450 patients. These patients are suffering from all kinds of diseases.
Comment on this
That is rather lopsided humanitarianism. He has the right to his opinions. I hope he will accept our right to our opinions. Deputy Ryan fulminated about there being sufficient legislation on the Statute Books to deal with these matters. It has been found that this is not the position. I have no doubt that the Department of Justice, the Minister and the Attorney-General's Office have at their disposal adequate legal advice. Yesterday evening Deputy Donegan quoted the Offences against the State Act, 1939. I know he is a businessman and he may well be a lawyer. I do not know. I am not denying him his right to interpret the law as he sees it. He said the Taoiseach stated that a section of that Act is not in accord with the Convention on Human Rights and that, in his view, that is not so. I have 25 years experience of lawyers of repute and I must confess that I never got a straightforward opinion from them yet. It was always laced with qualifications.
Comment on this
I never got a clear-cut decision from them. It was always qualified, even in relation to simple little Acts which one would imagine they would be able to interpret. I was always told: "It depends on the evidence. It depends on the particular case. It depends on the judge." There were so many qualifications that I decided that lawyers were not the best men to give advice. In any case, few lawyers give advice. They usually call in barristers, or senior or junior counsel, depending on the gravity of the case.
The Minister for Justice cannot act unless he is given a very strong opinion on how he should proceed. He would be holding the law up to odium and ridicule by bringing prosecutions on which convictions cannot be secured. I cannot see the Minister doing other than what he is now doing after receiving legal advice from all the resources available to him. Deputy Ryan is a young lawyer of some experience. For over three years he has been urging us to take certain action. It is rather strange that at this emergency hour he should now enlighten us all on the fact that the laws have been there all the time. I think he was speaking as a politician rather than as a lawyer. It would have suited him better if we were to suspend the rights of these people and intern them without trial. He would have liked that better. It would give Fianna Fáil a worse image than the image Deputy Cruise-O'Brien alleges we have. This would have suited him and many members of the Opposition.
I am glad the Minister is seeking to deal with them within the law. When this Bill goes through these men will be brought before a judge and, as the Minister said, the judge is bound by nobody and will depend on his own skill, competence and conscience in making his decision. It is, indeed, regrettable that we find it necessary to bring in this Bill and it is laudable that the Government have held out for so long against so much pressure before bringing in this type of legislation. Nobody can accuse them of acting in haste. They are acting in time, but no more than in time, to give themselves the tools to preserve democracy. I hope and pray that this will bring peace.
There are those who talk about Northern Ireland and about uniting the country. I am as certain as that I stand here that this country will be united, perhaps not in the next 10 or 20 years, but I can see the foundation stone of that colossus of sectarianism being removed. Indeed, Stormont has been prorogued. The Unionist Party is itself fragmented and in pieces. Whatever system will replace it, I do not see it ever being the same again.
The destruction of the Northern Ireland Government was built into it right from the start. The Roman Empire lasted for 400 years but it, too, collapsed with all its power and all its might. It collapsed because its collapse was built into it. The injustice perpetrated by Stormont over 50 years had to have its day of reckoning and that day of reckoning came when the civil rights marchers marched and the authorities tried to deny them the right to march and they had no other course but to rise up out of their chains to show some protest against the many, many disabilities and the many years of the jackboot pushing them into the ground. If it was not the jackboot, it was unemployment driving them out of the country or unemployment leaving the men on the dole and the women in the factories.
The whole system of society in the North is rotten and is seen to be rotten and is collapsing like the rotten edifice it is. It did not have a heart, it did not have a thought; it only had a belief in maintaining and retaining power for its own benefit, for just a few. The terrible calamity in the North of Ireland is the abysmal ignorance of the majority and the masses. They are foolish to be led along, by sectarianism and other means, to support and continue to support a party that should never exist in that form and which grew into the monster that it did. I hope we will long preserve democracy and freedom and that majorities and minorities, wherever they may be, will get equal and fair treatment and that we will see peace some day.
Believe me, it was peace that brought down the Roman Empire, peace expressed in Christian principles and Christianity. Christian principles and Christianity will destroy ultimately the Unionist Party and sectarianism in the North of Ireland, when people come to recognise that they cannot worship the golden calf and that Christianity is the only way by which peace and justice for all will be achieved.
I see no danger in the introduction of this Bill. There was a great bruahaha over the Forcible Entry Bill. I am pleased to note that since that Bill became law the illegal occupation of private property has ceased entirely. That Act, for all the opposition, seems to be working well and I have no doubt that the Bill before the House will work.
In conclusion I would ask the Minister to build into this Bill a limit of, say, two years or five years, so that it could be removed. The Bill gives certain powers in an emergency situation to superintendents of police. I will be supporting this Bill but I would ask that as soon as possible those special powers be taken away again from superintendents of police. I wish the Minister success and I hope there will be a long and good debate. In a democracy, there must be debate but I want responsible debate from the Opposition, not negative and destructive comment. This is a Bill that I would prefer not to see put on the Statute Book but, as it is so necessary to preserve democracy here, I will support it.
Comment on this
Like Deputy Gallagher, I hope time will be given for the House to discuss this Bill and that there will be no question of agreement being made for a closure. I want to make that statement, at the outset, arising out of Deputy Gallagher's remark.
When I received the Bill by post on Monday morning, I did something that I had never done before, I sat down immediately to read the Bill because there had been speculation in one of the Dublin Sunday papers as to the likely contents of the measure introduced last week.
I have not any legal experience or legal training but it was not very long until I realised that it was not necessary to have legal experience in order to appreciate what the Bill meant. The Minister yesterday said that he had circularised the Bill without any comment from him. How right he was, because there was no need; it was spelt out loud and clear to me as an ordinary lay person what the full contents of the Bill were. To be quite honest, I felt that the Fianna Fáil Government must have gone mad that they should think up such a Bill and think that they could bring it into this House and get away with it, or else, that they were legislating here for the big heads of the British Government.
As I read the Bill then and as my impressions of it are, the Bill is unacceptable and it will not be acceptable to me in any amended form. I want to make that perfectly clear. It stinks, in my opinion. It is not easy to describe the kind of State we will have here if this amendment of the Offences against the State Act is allowed to pass through this House. Deputy Carter yesterday mentioned something about a police State. I did not get the full statement. That is one way in which the State could be described if this Bill is allowed to pass.
I am not alone in that thinking because many people in my constituency have been in touch with me during the past couple of days requesting me to oppose the Bill. I have had representations from many more people than ever before in my 18 years experience in this House. However, it was not necessary for them to approach me because my mind had been made up already but their representations counteract the arguments being made here by the Minister and the Taoiseach to the effect that the campaign that was launched against these proposals by the Press and by those who are referred to as "leftists" is an indication of the type of people who oppose the Bill. The people who come to me are ordinary citizens and with one exception all of them were workers for Fianna Fáil up to the 1969 General Election and for all I know may very well work for the party again at the next election. These people are opposed to this measure because they have no wish to live in a police State. Yesterday I had a letter from an officer in the FCA asking me to oppose the Bill. Will anyone try to suggest that he is the type of person who would wish to bring down the institutions of the State? I had a phone call from a high ranking civil servant with a similar request. All of these representations bear out my own thinking on the matter.
Proposals of this nature should not be before us because they are seeking to give extraordinary powers to the Garda Síochána, powers which I do not believe the Garda wish to have. Our police force are highly respected. It has been my privilege to know many members of the Garda Síochána. I have been acquainted with them from my days in the Army through sporting activities and as a Member of this House. The integrity and sincerity of the vast majority of them cannot be questioned but, unfortunately, there is always the odd one who is unsuitable and this is the type of person who should not have the power that would enable him to point a finger at somebody and accuse him of being a member of an illegal organisation which accusation might result in that person being sentenced to six months imprisonment. The Taoiseach has said that a witness would be subject to deep cross-examination but from reading reports of court cases during the past two or three years I know that it is very easy for a policeman to claim privilege. It has not been beyond them to do that in the past and I have no doubt that they will do it in the future, too, so that the ordinary individual would not have a chance.
I shall not go into the details of the Bill section by section because that has been done already by Members who, by reason of their legal background, are well qualified to do that. We are living on an island which has a population a little more than four million people. The island comprises two States which, between them, have more suppressive legislation than have all the countries behind the Iron Curtain. Last week Mr. John Hume spoke at Oxford. I congratulate him on his speech which was in line with my own thinking and which, in my view, represented the views of the vast majority of the Irish people. During the debate Mr. Hume reminded us that the Prime Minister of South Africa would be glad to sacrifice all the repressive legislation on his statute books for one section of the Special Powers Act. That gentleman, no doubt, would be prepared to go to great lengths if he could have a section of this Bill as proposed.
We talk of the free world and when we do so we think in terms of our own country but there will be no freedom for our citizens if these proposals are accepted. There has been reference in the House to Fianna Fáil's association with the IRA. I am the son of an Old IRA man and I am very proud of that but I stand here today in my own right. I was brought up in the Republican tradition and I have no doubt that my late father would support me all the way in my opposition to this Bill because he would never have advocated repressive legislation.
I am convinced that these proposals were brought forward in an effort to appease Mr. Heath. It is more than coincidence that after every meeting with the British Premier, the Taoiseach took action of some kind on his return in an effort to suppress the people of this country. I happened to be in hospital about two years ago when I heard talk of internment. Was it coincidence that at that time the Taoiseach had returned from the UN where he had met Mr. Heath? Members of the Government appeared on television to tell the Irish people and the world generally that 80 per cent of our people were behind the Government's proposal to introduce internment but that did not come off, the reason being that the public would not accept it. I am convinced that the Taoiseach had given an undertaking to Mr. Heath that he would introduce internment. Another matter of note was that the Taoiseach decided to go alone to the Chequers meeting. He did not take his Minister for Foreign Affairs or any other colleague with him but Mr. Heath called in Sir Alec Douglas Home and other members of his Government who had responsibility for Northern Ireland affairs at the time. My view is that the Taoiseach did not wish any colleague of his to be present when he would be told by Mr. Heath that he had not lived up to his promise.
Comment on this
Only the week before last the Taoiseach went again to meet Mr. Heath and again I am convinced that he could not have gone to that meeting unless he was seen to be doing something regarding the IRA and what he decided on was the arrest of Seán Mac Stiofáin. This was done despite the fact that the Minister for Justice, only a couple of weeks previously, had indicated on television that they could not arrest Mac Stiofáin because they had nothing on him or words to that effect. We did not have to have this legislation. We were operating under the Offences against the State Act, 1939. Seán Mac Stiofáin was arrested, he was charged after something like 48 hours and he was sentenced to six months' imprisonment. That was done despite the fact that a fortnight previously the Minister for Justice did not think he had anything on him. What the hell more powers does he want? If he was able to get the big fish, as far as Mr. Heath was concerned, and succeeded in putting him in prison for six months under the existing law I do not know what he wants this legislation for.
It is all too much of a coincidence. Deputy Seán Sherwin reminded me of that when he was speaking yesterday. The archenemy in this country, as far as the British authorities were concerned, was Mac Stiofáin, because he was born in England. Members of the British Conservative Party have on more than one occasion said that the man who was leading activities here was not even an Irishman. The same was said about the late Erskine Childers. There was the very same type of carry-on 50 years ago in relation to Childers.
Comment on this
The Deputy is surely not insulting the memory of Erskine Childers by associating his name with that of Mac Stiofáin?
Comment on this
I am saying what was said about Childers in London and by the politicians in Dublin at the time. He was a murderous renegade, according to Churchill, he was a damn Englishman according to Griffith but in my book he was a very good Irishman. They succeeded, anyway, in liquidating him at the behest of the British Government. They were under pressure to do it and they succeeded in doing it.
It is too much of a coincidence that we now have this man in jail with people like Deputy Desmond and all the rest having their whack at him. I do not know the man good, bad or indifferent. I do not know that I will ever meet him but I know that he is in jail today because Mr. Heath decided it. There was adequate legislation here to do that and I am not prepared to give this Government or any other Government any more.
I have been 18 years in this House. For 17 years I answered the Whip of the Fianna Fáil Party loyally. I worked hard for them. I had my differences with them. There was an occasion here about 12 months ago when I was not prepared to walk into the division lobbies with them on a certain motion. The result of that is that I am out here now. I am not taking this stand today because I have a chip on my shoulder. I have fairly consistently supported the Government over the past 12 months. I am taking this stand today because in my opinion this piece of legislation strikes at the very roots of democracy and I am not prepared to stand over it.
I have a feeling—I hope I will be allowed to say this without interruption —that there are people in the Fianna Fáil Party who are opposed to this measure. I know that if it is pushed to the House, people will walk into the division lobby in support of it against their better judgment. I know that happened before. I am asking the Minister present, and through him the Minister for Justice and the Taoiseach, in God's name to withdraw this Bill. That is the only thing that can be done about it. There is every reason why they should withdraw it. They have all the powers they need to uphold law and order. They have the Offences against the State Act, 1939, which has served many Governments over the past 30 years and I do not see that the need is any greater now than it was any time in the past to strengthen the provisions of that Act particularly along the lines which are proposed here.
I am making an honest and sincere appeal to the Taoiseach and his Government to consider this Bill over the week-end and do the right thing. The right thing would be to withdraw it. It will not embarrass me but do not ask any more of your men to do something that in their hearts they do not want to do.
Comment on this
The Fine Gael Party have tabled an amendment to this Bill stating that they believe this Bill is repressive legislation. I believe it is. The Fine Gael Party since the foundation of the State have at all times upheld the security of this State. For many years there was a taunt thrown at the Fine Gael Party that they were the law and order party because on every occasion when it was necessary they voted for what they felt was right. This party at all times put country before party and that is the great test of any party. In any country it is the great test of a Government. We have at all times upheld the security of the State and the freedom of the individual. When one is faced with a Bill such as this, one must ask oneself whether it would cause more harm than good. At present there is sufficient legislation on the statute book to ensure the maintenance of law and order if the Garda and the Government carry out their duties.
I shall briefly recap on the situation in regard to the Offences against the State Act, 1939. In looking at the Bill before the House one must also look at the legislation already available to the Garda Síochána, to the Government and to the judiciary. To mention some of the offences at present, I refer to Part II, section 6 which deals with usurpation of functions of Government and which says:
Every person who usurps or unlawfully exercises any function of government, whether by setting up, maintaining, or taking part in any way in a body of persons purporting to be a government or a legislature but not authorised in that behalf by or under the Constitution, or by setting up, maintaining, or taking part in any way in a purported court or other tribunal not lawfully established,...
The net effect is that for such conduct the person is guilty of a felony and liable on conviction thereof to suffer penal servitude for a term not exceeding ten years or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years. For the usurpation of the functions of government at present a person may be sent to jail for a period not exceeding ten years.
As regards obstruction of government, section 7 provides:
Every person who prevents or obstructs, or attempts or is concerned in an attempt to prevent or obstruct, by force of arms or other violent means or by any form of intimidation the carrying on of the government of the State or any branch (whether legislative, judicial or executive) of the government of the State or the exercise or performance by any member of the legislature, the judiciary or the executive or by any officer or employee (whether civil (including police) or military) of the State of any of his functions, powers, or duties shall be guilty of felony and shall be liable on conviction thereof to suffer penal servitude for a term not exceeding seven years or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years.
Section 9 deals with interference with military or other employees of the State and it says that a person who engages in this shall be guilty of a misdemeanour and shall be liable on conviction thereof to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years.
In section 10 of the Act there is a prohibition against printing certain documents. It says:
It shall not be lawful to set up in type, print, publish, send through the post, distribute, sell, or offer for sale any document
(a) which is or contains or includes an incriminating document, or
(b) which is or contains or includes a treasonable document, or
(c) which is or contains or includes a seditious document.
Subsection (3) provides that every person who contravenes the foregoing subsections of this section shall be guilty of an offence under this subsection and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding £100 or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to both such fine and imprisonment.
Section 16 of the Offences against the State Act, 1939, deals with secret societies in army or police and a person who forms or organises or attempts to form such a society or takes part in forming it or organising it or induces or solicits or assists any member of a military or police force lawfully maintained by the government to join any secret society shall be guilty of a misdemeanour and shall be liable on conviction thereof to suffer penal servitude for any term not exceeding five years or imprisonment for any term not exceeding two years. The administering of unlawful oaths and so on is also dealt with.
I have just read some of the offences and the sentences for people found guilty of them—ten years, seven years, two years and heavy fines. Very drastic powers are given and I think these are sufficient, if properly implemented. If the State looked after these matters properly and if the police force ensured that these offences were properly investigated and if the cases were properly presented in court and if the Government permitted it, I believe there is sufficient power here and sufficient approval by the House for obtaining convictions for any of the aforementioned offences.
As regards the legislation which is now before the House, I believe that it provides powers that are excessive and dangerous and which at the present time may do a great deal of damage. In regard to section 3 (b) dealing with evidence of membership of an unlawful organisation it is stated:
...but the fact of such denial shall not by itself be conclusive
The full subsection reads:
In paragraph (a) of this subsection "conduct" includes omission by the accused person to deny published reports that he was a member of an unlawful organisation, but the fact of such denial shall not by itself be conclusive.
This is a sort of Hobson's choice in that if he omits to deny published reports that he is a member of an unlawful organisation, then he is guilty. If he then goes and denies it——
Comment on this
It is very difficult for the speaker when there is a conversation going on in part of the House.
Comment on this
If a person omits to deny it this will be regarded as "conduct" and if he then denies it the fact of such denial shall not by itself be conclusive. This is serious. Continuing with section 3 (2) we find that it reads:
Where an officer of the Garda Síochána, not below the rank of chief superintendent, in giving evidence in proceedings relating to an offence under the said section 21, states that he believes that the accused was at a material time a member of an unlawful organisation, the statement shall be evidence that he was then such a member.
A person stating that he believes a person was a member of an unlawful organisation—such a statement shall be evidence that he was then such a member. I refer to the Minister's brief in regard to this matter where he deals with this subsection and says that it extends the rule of common law evidence under which a witness's opinion as to a fact is admissible evidence to prove the fact only in certain circumstances, in particular in the case of an expert witness. This is without doubt hearsay. The evidence comes through to the chief superintendent from many people. The chief superintendent then gives this evidence and if the person accused asks him for proof there is a grave danger —and this is one of the most serious points about the Bill—that the chief superintendent may say he has conclusive evidence and when questioned further, may plead privilege. That requires some safeguard.
I do not intend to go back too far but I merely mention the Public Accounts Committee. There was a man, who may or may not vote with the Government tonight accused by a superintendent at that committee who pleaded privilege as to where he got his evidence. One of the persons mentioned was Deputy Haughey and the other person involved was Chief Superintendent Fleming who claimed privilege on this matter. It is not for me to argue the rights or wrongs of the matter at that time but Deputy Haughey later said he was very aggrieved. This can happen at some point in time in the case of a person who may be brought in and charged. The chief superintendent will have his evidence handed to him by different people and the accused person will have no opportunity of cross-examining the person who gave the evidence to the chief superintendent.
It is difficult to get this point across, but what I am saying is that the person who gives the evidence to the chief superintendent may not be in court to be cross-examined on the point. This is very important because somebody may have a grievance possibly against somebody in this House for political, religious or economic reasons, may have a very strong dislike of a particular person, and he goes to a memof the Special Branch or the Garda Síochána and says that this person has been away for long periods or may give some other reason. That member then goes to the chief superintendent and says that this is the position. I must say that I have at all times had the highest possible respect for the Garda Síochána of all ranks, from the Commissioner down to the ordinary guard, or from the ordinary guard up to the Commissioner, whichever way you wish to put it; but they are liable to err on occasions and a person in respect of whom wrong information has been given is not in a position to cross-examine. That is a very dangerous precedent.
The section sets out that if the chief superintendent believes that the accused was at the material time a member of an unlawful organisation, the statement shall be evidence that he was then such a member. I am a solicitor and I am not saying that what I am putting forward is 100 per cent right. I am endeavouring to give what views I have on the matter and I would hope that what I am saying is not prejudiced or political because I am endeavouring to be fair and not political. You have the situation in a district court, a circuit court or a high court in which a certain amount of evidence is tendered on behalf of the prosecution, and at this stage, once the evidence is given, it is up to the defendant to prove his innocence.
Reading the letters columns in the three papers today, I find one very interesting letter which endeavours to prove something of what I have been saying because I have been trying to put my point fairly from this side in pointing out the danger and the difficulty facing a person involved when such evidence is given in that the onus of proof then falls back on to him. The chief superintendent gives this evidence and it is then up to the defendant to prove himself innocent. The letter is from William Sweetman of Cranford, Taney Road, Dundrum, Dublin 14, in today's Irish Times on page 13. It is the first letter in the letters to the Editor section and the heading of the letter is “The Bill”. I have met this man and his honesty and integrity are beyond challenge. I have the highest opinion of him, as have certain members of the Government party. Watching him practising in court, I found him at all times fair and reasonable in all his decisions. He is a barrister and a former member of the editorial staff of The Irish Press and I believe him to be a justice of wide experience.
The second paragraph of his letter reads:
I do not believe that I, or indeed any of your readers, could possibly prove that we are not members of the Provisional IRA any more than we could prove that we are not members of the British Secret Service. Both are secret organisations believed to be active in this country, and it would be absurd to think that either of these organisations would be willing to disclose to a court a comprehensive list of their membership. Thus anyone is liable to conviction and punishment for not denying a "published report" or because a chief superintendent believes him to be an IRA man. This goes, of course, for women also.
The object of this strange legislation appears to be to give power of internment of suspected IRA men to the police, for whose actions the Minister is responsible, while making a clever and ruthless effort to pass the onus of making the order for imprisonment to a judge for whose actions the Minister is not responsible.
Every judge, before his appointment, makes a solemn declaration that he will, without fear or favour, administer justice in accordance with the law. But what can he do if faced with what many lawyers believe, and perhaps he himself believes, to be an unjust law? Each judge must handle that dilemma on his own.
I would ask you to publish this letter before the Bill is passed if it is to be passed in its present form. Otherwise, I would be risking imprisonment for myself and perhaps for you, too.
The second paragraph of that letter shows the difficulty of proving that you are not a member of the Provisional IRA. If a chief superintendent gives evidence that you are, the onus of proof falls back on you and you have a situation in which the evidence has been given against you and it is up to you to get yourself free. This man says he does not believe "that I or any of your readers could possibly prove that we are not members of the Provisional IRA any more than we could prove that we are not members of the British Secret Service". It is also pointed out that they are secret organisations. This is a very dangerous situation where one has to prove he is not a member. At any particular point one may find this absolutely impossible. The courts are being used to allow a person to be convicted on evidence that is very dangerous. There is a danger of interfering with our courts which have withstood the test of time. I ask the Minister to consider this particular section carefully.
Deputy Corish mentioned last night that this section smacks of internment. I myself also feel that that is so. It makes it impossible for a person to prove himself innocent. It is window-dressing and shadow-boxing to cover internment.
The situation in the North of Ireland really exploded once internment was introduced. This is window-dressing for internment. It brings the courts into disrepute.
Comment on this
That is what the Deputy is doing. He is shadow-boxing. Does the Deputy want this House to rule or other people?
Comment on this
I do not like to interrupt but it is very hard to swallow all this talk of shadow-boxing.
Comment on this
This section has all the appearance of internment. Would the Minister consider withdrawing this Bill? There is sufficient legislation on the statute books of the Dáil. The situation has been well-contained and legislation of this nature may just be the light to the fuse. I mention this as a warning. There is an inherent danger in all this.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy want intimidation of Deputies and of their wives and families in their own homes?
Comment on this
There is sufficient legislation on the statute books which, if properly implemented, would ensure that this does not happen. I ask the Minister and his Government to consider withdrawing this Bill.
Comment on this
We would be in a serious situation if this Bill is passed. I ask the Taoiseach and the Government to withdraw it. The Taoiseach made a request a year ago to withdraw something and his request was listened to. If the Garda force are not sufficiently strong in number I would ask the Minister to increase that force. People do not mind paying for protection and security. The increase in crime in this country is noticeable. It is in no way connected with offences against the State. The increase is frightening. If necessary the Garda force should be increased to ensure that the law is administered to its fullest extent.
Deputy Gallagher is not in the House at present. He mentioned that there was no time limit in this Bill. There should have been some time limit but even if there was I would not be in agreement with it. I could not see myself supporting this Bill for the reasons I have given.
Comment on this
This is a sufficiently important piece of legislation to warrant all of us saying something about it particularly when we listen to speaker after speaker referring to what the Taoiseach is doing and to what the Minister for Justice is doing. This legislation comes from the Government, unanimously supported by them and by the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputy P. Brennan said he knew there were Deputies who would be dragging their feet about this. No Deputy has any doubt about the need for this legislation and the support it must get.
Many red herrings are being dragged into the discussion by people who know well the sheer hypocrisy of what they are talking about. Is the legislation necessary or not? Are we to allow our institutions to be eroded by the type of thing which we are seeing on the streets in Dublin, by the people who would humiliate our police force and kick them around the streets? Are we going to take powers to ensure that we can deal with situations of that kind? That is the issue. If we do not pass this legislation we will leave ourselves stripped of any power to deal with any situation which may develop in the time to come. We were elected by the majority of the people to rule this country. We were given an explicit mandate to do that, to protect the institutions of the State and to see that the average citizen got what he is supposed to get in a democratic country— a right to live without interference from anarchists or others who may wish to interfere with his ordinary day-to-day life in this country.
Some people may say that we were given that mandate four years ago and that that mandate may not run today. Sometimes time makes changes but we have had a few opportunities in the interim to test the feelings of the people. We have had by-elections in Donegal and Dublin. We have had the referendum in which the attitude of the people was explicitly expressed. We have had in more recent times a by-election in mid-Cork where every facet of the speeches being made and every argument being expressed on the other side of the House was trotted out up and down the length and breadth of that constituency. We know the results in all these cases. To those people who might say that our mandate has perhaps weakened since the general election I want to remind them that we have had these opportunities to test it and the outcome was unmistakable.
We are asking for power to deal with an abnormal situation. We are not asking for it for the sake of "cussedness" or, indeed, to make ourselves unpopular. We know what our judiciary and our police force think about this. We know how our police force have been humiliated when they went into court and the rules of evidence made a mockery of them. We do not come in here lightly to do something unpopular and there is not one Member of this House who believes for one moment that this legislation will be used against any law-abiding citizen. No one believes that such a thing will happen.
Comment on this
Who wants to see this legislation stopped? The people who get out on the streets, the people who would ruin this country from the streets, the people who sling bottles at our police force and make a mockery of our police force, the people who, if a policeman puts a hand on a citizen, immediately shriek: "Police brutality". These are the tactics copied from other countries, countries in which attempts at mob law had to be stamped out. If this Parliament does not give us the right to enforce law and keep order, then the people will very quickly tell us in the next two weeks whether or not they want this Parliament. It is from the people that power comes. It is not from Fianna Fáil and it is not from Fine Gael. It is from the people who put us here to represent them and, if we are doing wrong now, then let us ask the people what they want. Do they want this Parliament to be upheld by legislation designed to deal with a dangerous and abnormal situation? Is it to be a case of wearing kid gloves and going around saying: "You are a nice fellow. You only robbed a bank. We have no proof and we cannot substantiate the fact that you did rob a bank". Is this situation to be allowed to continue? This Parliament must decide on this legislation or else the people must tell us what they want.
Comment on this
It is very easy to be smart. It is very easy to mock. We have here a clear-cut situation. There is no choice. One is either for law and order or against it. If one is for it, then it is the duty of this Parliament to declare war.
Comment on this
Yes. If people are against violence they must do everything possible to keep peace and order in the country. If people are in favour of violence, then the forces of order, who have an Army, have a duty to maintain that order. We cannot just sit back and allow violence to continue. The kind of character who goes into a hospital and protests, and subverts the course of justice, and comes out the next day and protests that he is completely opposed to that kind of thing shows the kind of ambivalence that those who support law and order just do not want. We have come to the crunch and the Members of this House will walk into the Division Lobbies this evening to vote and I hope, after that vote, the message will be loud and clear. Will we face the country, having left ourselves no opportunity to pass legislation here designed to deal with an extremely explosive and serious situation? Do we reject the opportunity to bring in such legislation in the pretence that it would interfere with the liberty of God-fearing citizens? Would it interfere with the liberty of God-fearing citizens? Of course, it would not. The only people with whose liberty it might interfere are the people who want to be out on the streets, throwing bottles at the police, and at the same time, talking about the freedom of the individual and the great virtues of democracy, the people who were outside this House last night, the people who have come in here in the last few years and openly stated that their objective was to overthrow the institutions of this State.
Comment on this
Why did the Government not deal with them? The Government are bringing in a Bill now to have a general election. This is a ploy to have a general election.
Comment on this
The Minister played Dumb-Joe for the last four years. He had it both ways in Donegal.
Comment on this
Interruptions must cease and, if Deputies continue interrupting, I will have to ask them to leave the House.
Comment on this
My attitude is and has been quite clear. My constituents know my attitude. It is unequivocal. Every single constituent who supports me—there are some 16,000 or 18,000 of them—knows what my attitude is. Deputy P. Brennan said that someone had told him to vote against this Bill. Not a single constituent of mine has asked me to take a stand against this measure.
We have been accused frequently of wanting to hang on to power here. That accusation has been made both inside and outside this House. Now we are accused of wanting to have a general election. I will give my seat to anyone rather than continue to sit in this House and see an attempt to introduce legislation to deal with a serious situation being held out as something designed simply to engineer a general election.
Comment on this
If I wanted advice on law and order the last person from whom I would seek such advice would be Deputy Coogan. One speaker talked about our trying to pass on to the courts a responsibility that should be ours. But surely it is the courts who interpret the law and surely it is the courts who decide. I would advise District Justice Sweetman, instead of writing long letters to the Press, to read the Bill. Nobody should know better than he does that it is the courts who interpret and decide on the law. All we are seeking to do here is to make it easier for the courts to deal with situations which they, more than anyone else, know must be dealt with; they also know that, in order that they may be able to deal with the situation, there must be a change in the rules of evidence.
Some speakers made the point that there is no terminal date. I am quite prepared to accept a terminal date of two years, or one year, or whenever this is not necessary, but let us leave ourselves free to bring in this type of legislation any time we think it is necessary. I would ask those people who pretend they fear what is contained in this legislation to look at who is opposed to it, who is genuinely opposed to it. There are different reasons. Some people are opposed to it merely for political reasons. Some are opposed to it because it is an instrument to defeat the Government. Some are opposed to it because they do not want law and order anyway.
Comment on this
Some are opposed to it because they want a low profile effort that will permit anarchy, without any serious effort to prevent it. Everybody is free to express himself in this House. The people who are interrupting me while I am making my views on the Bill known can make their own contribution. They are free to make it. I have just as much common sense as anybody else. I am capable of assessing motives as easily and as readily as anybody else I know when people have ulterior motives, and when they have genuine motives. I have heard very few expressions of genuine fear of this legislation which were not prompted by some ulterior motives. This is unpopular legislation. Nobody denies that. We are all agreed on it. Nobody wants to have it, least of all the Government who are bringing it in.
Comment on this
We must deal with this serious situation when it occurs. Those who think they can face the present situation, and the future, as they would face a normal situation, will find themselves in Queer Street one day. Let us suppose there is an election and that a coalition mixum-gatherum take over the situation. If the position deteriorates further, as it has all the signs of deteriorating, they will have burned their boats and they will not be able to look for legislation to deal with the situation.
Comment on this
These are the considerations that must be taken into account, and these are the things the people of Ireland are thinking today, not the nonsense that is being talked on the other side of the House. They know that we did not bring in a piece of unpopular legislation to cut our own throats. They know we brought it in because we have the advice of those who are responsible for administrating the law, and the advice of those who are capable of sustaining the law in the police and in the army. They know we have had the advice of the people who are sufficiently intimate with the situation to be certain that the legal position under the present legislation is not adequate to deal with the situation and as it is likely to develop.
It is all right to carry placards through the streets about "Jack the Rat", and what have you. They are not dignified to say the least of them. They may please people sitting over there but they will not please any decent citizen.
Comment on this
They may derive certain satisfaction out of them and the cameras will be sure to focus on them but, remember, we are at a serious crossroads. I do not claim to have all the wisdom of this House, but one does not need to have a lot to foresee that we are at the crossroads now. We are facing a situation, and let us not burn our hopes.
Comment on this
The discussion we are supposed to be taking part in is a discussion on the Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972. The shadow of a possible election seems to hang over virtually everybody who speaks in this debate.
Comment on this
On the contrary. It seems that the only thing we should consider in this discussion is the possible repercussions upon our first preferences and our transfers of votes.
Comment on this
In case I may not have got the message across I meant that what we should consider is whether or not the people want us to do this.
Comment on this
I recognise an election propaganda speech when I hear it. I have been called naive because I am not obsessed with the electoral consequences of what we say or do in this House. Have we sunk so low in this Parliament—and by God the 19th Dáil has sunk pretty low over the past three years—that all our actions are determined solely and exclusively by a head count of what will happen to us, whether we will be re-elected and whether we will get our pensions. I want to make a number of things quite clear. I deny flatly the charge of ambivalence made against me by the Minister. I regard this as a piece of disgraceful, fascist and totalitarian legislation which, if it were introduced by the Greek colonels, would be opposed by every delegate we sent to the Council of Europe. Since it is introduced close to home we all find that there are necessary and reasonable excuses for having it passed.
Let me make one thing absolutely clear. Irrespective of the electoral consequences to me or to anyone else, if no one else were to stand in his place and call for a vote on this Bill I would do so, and I hope I would find four others to stand with me, so that a division would be possible under Standing Orders. Happily that issue does not arise because the Labour Party are unanimous in their opposition to the Bill. Let me make that absolutely clear before the label of a so-called Provisional supporter is hung around my neck, or the neck of anybody else in this House.
No one is more conscious than I am of the importance of this debate. No one is more conscious than I am of the dilemma of a democracy, a so-called democracy if Ireland can be called a democracy—and I sometimes wonder—which is faced with the conduct of people who deny the rules of the game and who deny the proper sequence of legal action under a democracy. No one is more conscious than I am that some of the people at whom this extraordinary piece of legislation is allegedly aimed have said that they have no time for this House, and no time for the process we are now going through here. What is a democracy to do in these circumstances? Is it to arm itself with powers which are of their very nature in breach of democracy? Before it does this, it has to take a very long and searching look at its own conscience and its own conduct.
The Government party in this Republic, this 26-county State, have to do that. It is very easy to wheel 71 Deputies, all desperately concerned with their political, administrative and financial futures, through the Dáil lobbies. Would it not be more appropriate to debate whether the conduct of the party which, effectively speaking, have this country in a vice-like grip justifies adding to themselves the powers contained in this Bill? I contend that they have not got the right to do this and I will explain why in a second.
I want to make a very brief reference—I trust the Ceann Comhairle will bear with me while I do this since it has been referred to both by the Minister and by the Taoiseach—to an incident in which I was involved on Sunday. I went to the Mater Hospital on humanitarian grounds to seek to ameliorate the conditions of an individual whom I did not want to see die. I would do the same for anyone. It would be very easy, like the Pharisee and the Levite, to pass by on the other side. To take my phone off the hook would be the easy way out. I did not do that and I am not prepared to do that. I am not ashamed of my conduct. I know that by doing what I did I left myself open to the sneers which have come from the gentle, kindly, indolent Taoiseach that I am a Provo supporter. I know, and I knew before I took the action I took, that this would be the consequence and that if an election is fought on the polarities determined by those people over there—do you want the Oireachtas or do you want Seán Mac Stiofáin—at every chapel gate in Ireland I will be called a Provisional supporter. I know and I do not care and I did not care on Sunday because I am not prepared to stand idly by, to use a famous phrase, while a man's kidneys degenerate past the point of no return. I am not prepared to do it.
Comment on this
This does not mean that I am in any sense a supporter of the campaign of violence waged in the North, allegedly by the Provisional IRA. Like every other member of this party I am committed, as is every other Member of this House, to the view that the only possible solution to the division of what I regard as our integral national territory, the Thirty-two Counties—I am not quite sure the Fianna Fáil Party still regards it as our national territory; I regard it as such and the Labour Party constitution regards it as such—is by peaceful means and I will be found on Sunday equally ready to stand with the appeals for peace of the Protestant clergyman from Belfast who lost his son on Friday. I will be found equally ready to stand there. I detest and abominate death in all its forms. If I had the guts I would be a pacifist —I probably am a pacifist—let me make that quite clear.
It is the policy of this Labour Party to oppose this Bill and that policy is unanimous, whatever the correspondents in the Press may say. I am unlike the Minister who has talked about the way television cameras are used and placards about "Jack the Rat". It would be unparliamentary for me to call Jack "Jack the rat", so I will not do it. I simply ask his former colleagues what they think about him. Unlike the Minister I do not mind if political correspondents misinterpret my actions as being an expression of allegiance with the Provisional IRA. They have that right. It annoys me. I do not like it. It irritates me. It upsets me. But, unlike those people over there, I am not going to set out to muzzle them and stop them doing it. I hope I make my position clear on this.
This has been an appalling fortnight for Irish justice, culminating in this Bill. A man—we will call him X for the purpose of argument—has been mysteriously picked up in the early hours of the morning after he had made a tape. The entire authority of Telefís Éireann have been sacked for allowing the tape to be made. A distinguished journalist—one of the most distinguished journalists in the country—has been sentenced for contempt for refusing to talk about the tape that has been made and another man has been sent to his possible death on the basis of the contents of the tape appropriated by the Government. If that is not having it both ways, well then, I am even more politically immature than I am accused of being.
I want to make quite clear that I have no shame for what I did on Sunday. It does not make me an apostle of violence to lead a deputation—I do not speak of the demonstration—to see Mr. Mac Stiofáin. If it makes me an apostle of violence to do so, it makes the Archbishop of Dublin, Dr. Dermot Ryan, an apostle of violence; it makes the former Archbishop—more loved on those benches than on these—Dr. John Charles McQuaid, an apostle of violence. It makes the Limerick City Council apostles of violence; they passed without opposition a resolution calling for the release of Mr. Mac Stiofáin on humanitarian grounds, a resolution supported by Councillor P. J. Liddy of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
Are these all to be condemned as Provos at every chapel gate? Is Councillor Liddy to be condemned as a Provo for seeking to prevent a man's death? There are enough deaths in Ireland, Protestant and Catholic. Even if I did not think the Offences Against the State Act to be an abomination, which I do think and it is party policy to think it is an abomination—I am perfectly in accord with party policy in saying this and successive conferences have said we are opposed to the Offences Against the State Act—and if I did not think personally that Mr. Mac Stiofáin should not be let down—and I do not think he should be let down —even if I did not think this, are the Government so irresponsible that they want to provoke a situation where the corpse of Mr. Mac Stiofáin is pulled through O'Connell Street on a gun carriage and the memories of Thomas Ashe are evoked in this State, that they want the confrontation revived of the kind those associations, fostered more on those benches over the years than by any other group of people evoke? Do the Government want that? Are the Government so totally concerned with survival and power that they do not care if that is the kind of confrontation they foster?
If that makes the Government clever, if that makes the Government politically astute, if that makes the Government good at electioneering tactics, I am glad I am a fool because at least I am a fool with a clear conscience. What was it Pearse said?
The lawyers have sat in council
The men with the long, grey faces
And some have said and called him a fool
And others have said he blasphemeth.
Call me a fool but a fool who can look into the shaving mirror every morning for the rest of his life. I am not ashamed of what I did. I would do it again in the morning but I wonder how those people who sit on the back benches over there and who were preaching republicanism as recently as three years ago, feel when they look in their shaving mirrors.
Comment on this
I turn to the Bill with profound depression. It is almost unnecessary to talk about it. It is unamendable. Deputy Cooney's amendment is so directly a negative that it is tantamount to not being an amendment but I think the Deputy is correct in his amendment although I do not go all the way with everything he said in support of it.
It has been said both by the Taoiseach and the Minister that the Bill does not transfer the onus of proof of innocence to an accused person. I refute, deny and challenge this because it seems to me that it does that precisely. Let us look carefully at the Bill. Section 3 (1) (a) states:
Any statement made orally, in writing or otherwise, or any conduct, by an accused person implying or leading to a reasonable inference that he was at a material time a member of an unlawful organisation shall, in proceedings under section 21 of the Act of 1939, be evidence that he was then such a member.
First, may I ask what is the meaning of the word "reasonable"? I am not a lawyer but I have taken legal advice on this. The word "reasonable" is one that occurs here and there in this Bill. Who is to determine what is reasonable? Secondly, the previous common law practice has not been that a person is obliged by law to provide any information or even his name and address to a member of the Garda Síochána. This is a right to silence, as clerical people have said, the silence of St. Thomas More, a saint to whom, if I may be forgiven the crawthumping, I have a particular devotion. St. Thomas More's defence was silence until the point of his conviction and then he broke the silence. If this Bill becomes law silence will be culpable. This is a major change in the whole common law tradition which runs right through, by a golden thread as the textbook says, the laws of both Great Britain and Ireland. Furthermore, the Bill places the onus of belief on a member of the Garda Síochána who is not below the rank of chief superintendent where he states that he believes the accused was, at a material time, a member of an unlawful organisation. Such statement would be evidence that the accused was then such a member.
Deputy Enright made the point that for one to prove he is not what he is accused of being is almost impossible. For all I know, the Minister may be a member of the Provisional IRA. How would he prove he was not a member of that organisation? How would Deputy Haughey prove that he was not a member of the Provisional IRA? This Bill would create an entirely new situation in law and it is arguably in breach of the European Convention on Human Rights which was ratified by all the member states of the Council of Europe, including Ireland. Article 6 (2) of that convention states that everyone charged with a criminal offence shall be presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law.
This Bill places the onus on the accused rather than on the accusor. I would oppose the Bill equally if it applied as much to Billy Hull, William Craig, Adolf Hitler or members of the Provisional IRA. It is a matter of indifference to me because the Bill is something which is intolerable to me as one who has been brought up in the common law tradition of these islands. The Taoiseach, the Minister for Justice and the Minister for Social Welfare all made the point that the Bill was aimed specifically at special categories of people, to wit, members of the Provisional IRA. That is a reassuring statement, I do not think. As Deputy Cooney correctly pointed out, we were given a comparable assurance that the Forcible Entry Bill was aimed only at people who were squatting but we know that those measures were used subsequently against other categories of persons. In the same way, the Offences Against the State Act has been used in the past against the trade unions. Once that party are armed with these powers, are we simply to rest on their word, a word that they have broken so often since June 1969, that the Bill would be used only against the geligniter and the bomber? If I were to accept that assurance from those benches I would be guilty of a degree of gullibility even greater than that of which I have been accused.
The Minister referred to the fact that there are people who are members of what is described euphemistically as an unlawful organisation who refuse to recognise the courts, who would not plead, and he said that even in those cases these people's rights would be protected because the justice could cross-examine police witnesses. Let me make two points clear. Every tradition of common law asserts that even a person who refuses to plead in a court is innocent until proved guilty. The statement that he is not prepared to give evidence does not render him a non-person. In legal terms he is still a human being who has legal and civil rights although he denies the efficacy of the system which gives him those rights. Maybe democracy is over-lax or over-lenient here but every democracy behaves in this way. I am not prepared to say people who do not recognise the court are to be sent down on a systematic conveyor belt on the basis of the evidence adduced under this Bill to what is tantamount to internment. Their legal rights remain even if they deny the validity of the institution which provides those legal rights. This is not Deputy David Thornley making a statement. It is a fundamental principle of common law. In one of the classic textbooks on social democracy, that written by E.F.M. Durbin, the point is made that even those who refuse to play by the rules of the social democratic game are entitled to benefit by the application of those laws. This is something in which I firmly believe because, as I have said before, when democracy arms itself with powers which abrogate the rule of law in order to resist people who wish to overthrow the rule of law, then you are in a circular logical situation because in effect democracy has then committed suicide and that is what it is doing in this Bill.
I have no wish to make any criticism of our judiciary as a whole or of any individual judge. It would be wrong and invidious to do so in this House. The argument of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Justice that even where a prisoner refuses to plead or as, perhaps, in the case of Mr. Mac Stiofáin is arguably not in a physical or mental condition to conduct his own defence, his rights are adequately protected by the possibility of the presiding judge or judges acting in an inquisitorial capacity on his behalf, cross-questioning a superintendent of the Garda Síochána, does not carry conviction with me. I am choosing my words very carefully and very deliberately here. Reading the transcript of the Mac Stiofáin trial does not suggest to me that it is safe to leave the protection of accused people who refuse to plead solely in the inquisitorial hands of justices.
This Bill cannot be seen in isolation. It has been a bad fortnight for Irish democracy. I have mentioned four ways—the arrest of Mac Stiofáin, the dismissal of the authority, the arrest of O'Kelly and now the introduction of this Bill. We listen to the protestations of successive speakers from that side of the House that there is no pernicious purpose behind this Bill. In addition to taking this Bill in the context of the four events to which I have referred, one also has to bear in mind that The Sunday Independent of 19th November, 1972, carried an advertisement calling for the recruitment of 100 temporary male prison officers with, as it put it, good prospects of permanent employment. For what? For whom? For me? For you? The country is alive with rumours that Kilworth Camp, County Cork, is being prepared for the reception of large numbers of people of one category or another and The Irish Times this morning carries a story that Arbour Hill is being prepared similarly for the reception of prisoners. “Arbour Hill”—famous, evocative words—is being prepared with a rapidity which does credit to the Board of Works. If only they had applied the same expedition to the repairing of Mountjoy Jail we might not have had the Prisons Act passed through this House.
The Taoiseach, speaking last night, criticised my colleague, Deputy Cruise-O'Brien, and much as I may differ from him on points of detail, on this Bill we are at one. He criticised him for referring to the historical origins of the Irish Republican Army and tried to make a distinction between the IRA from which that party proudly take their origin and the IRA which functions at the moment. I will not follow the Taoiseach into historical exegesis. It is not my practice to take this House back to 1922, 1931 or 1932 but I would say this, without any expression of support for violence on my part—I have no support for violence—if people in this country have been taught that their heroes should be gunmen, should be Dan Breen, Seán Treacy, Séamus Robinson, Seán Hogan, Ernie O'Malley, Cathal Brugha, Erskine Childers, senior, and as late as the 1950's, Seán South, if they have been taught this rightly or wrongly— Deputy Cruise-O'Brien and I would differ on this—they have been taught this nowhere more clearly and more firmly than from those benches. Maybe the Fianna Fáil Party have experienced a late conversion, do not believe in violence any longer, do not believe in republicanism any longer, want to amputate their roots, want to amputate their historical past, want rapidly to turn themselves into a new kind of party—a smooth party, a party of Europe, of mohair suits, pâté de foie gras, eternal realism. Maybe that is what Fianna Fáil want to do but it is an expensive and rather rapid operation and unfortunate poor devils like Mac Stiofáin who were brought up on the mythology perpetrated from those benches are now starving so that the Government can rapidly bring this party of theirs into a different dimension and a different view of Irish history. May God help those who believed what they heard from those benches up until 1969. They are paying the price for it now.
The Taoiseach speaking last night in a speech of characteristic and to my mind disgraceful cunning which epitomises the Taoiseach, a very clever speech, a brilliant speech—I take my hat off to him—made reference in this House in an appeal for sympathy for this Bill to two things in particular —the bomb incident in a Dublin cinema recently and the conviction and release of, though he did not name her, I hope I am in order because it was obvious to whom he was referring, Mrs. Máire Drumm. The Taoiseach is a lawyer. I am not. Even if the Taoiseach did not practise for very long in the early years of his career as a barrister he was too busy making up his mind whether he would join Clann na Poblachta, Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil to have time to practice as a barrister——
Comment on this
I am not a barrister so I do not know, but is it proper for a Taoiseach to imply before any case is brought before a court that the Provisional IRA are responsible for the bomb incident which we all equally in this House deplore? Do we know who is responsible for that incident? I do not. Is the Taoiseach in possession of sources which I am not in possession of? Is it proper for the Taoiseach to try to hang around the necks of the opposition to this Bill the fact that Mrs. Máire Drumm only received a 22 day sentence? Surely if the Taoiseach is asking us to repose confidence in the Judiciary he should not get up in this House and, in effect, call in question a decision reached by the Judiciary.
This Bill, to me, is repulsive. Section 5 (d) says that:
any film, microfilm, negative, tape or other device in which one or more visual images are embodied (whether with or without sounds or other data) so as to be capable (as aforesaid) of being reproduced therefrom and a reproduction or still reproduction of the image or images embodied therein whether enlarged or not and whether with or without sounds or other data
shall be included as a document when this Bill becomes law. This is a novel proceeding which has largely escaped notice in this debate, not totally novel because under the ruling of the justice in the Mac Stiofáin case the famous tape was used—and I have my own views about the legitimacy of doing that—to convict Mr. Mac Stiofáin. Now if this Bill becomes law, video tapes are to be used for convictions. Personally, I find this abhorrent. It is not even done in America where political sophistication has reached a very high point, but leaving aside the major issues raised by the Bill, I wonder has the House considered the effect which section 5 (d) is likely to have upon an interviewer, a broadcaster, a producer of a programme in our radio and television. In future whenever it is put before him—should he make a particular programme or should he conduct a particular interview—hanging over him will be the shadow of 5 (d). If he does this, if he interviews Mac Stiofáin, if he interviews me, if he interviews the Minister for Transport and Power, there is always the possibility that someone is going to tap him on the shoulder and say: "Give me that cassette; it is material evidence in a prosecution I am about to take". As one who has some small experience of broadcasting, may I say that I am deeply conscious of the inhibitions which this will impose upon a disseminator of objective news in the public media.
Let me say that everything in the Taoiseach's speech shows that it was an election speech, a clever speech, a cunning speech, a speech designed to catch votes, a speech designed to frighten people, a speech designed to appeal to the small man, the man of property, small property, a speech designed to say: "Your car or your house is in danger from irresponsible subversive elements; therefore, accept this Bill". It was a very clever speech. The Government are setting the polarities of a future election and they are getting a certain amount of help from certain Press correspondents in doing this. The polarities they are choosing are between the Oireachtas on one side and the Provisional IRA on the other, a marvellous issue to fight an election on, and I take my hat off to the Taoiseach for the characteristic cunning with which he has chosen it. But there are times when moral and political issues transcend electoral considerations. The polarities are not as the Taoiseach states them; they are not between the Provisional IRA and democracy. They are between the Fianna Fáil Party and democracy and this Bill is designed to arm the Fianna Fáil Party with powers which I, for one, were I alone of the 144 Deputies in my protest, would under no circumstances concede to them.
Let me finally repeat that pace the sneers of the Minister for Social Welfare, I have no time for violence. I am a pacifist and a democrat, but I disapprove of allowing men to add to the catalogue of death in this country by dying of hunger and I disapprove of fascist oppressive totalitarian legislation, and no matter how my actions last Sunday, what I am saying here today or what I may reserve the right to do in the future are misinterpreted by members of that party, I shall remain obdurate in opposition to this disgraceful Bill.
Dr. FitzGerald rose.
Comment on this
On a point of information, could the Chair tell me by what procedure Members on these upper benches will be called?
Comment on this
The Chair is giving an opportunity to all parties for the expression of all points of view in the House and has continued that since the debate began. A member of the Deputy's party has already spoken this morning and five Government speakers and five Fine Gael speakers have intervened.
Comment on this
It would be my understanding of the position that, as you, Sir, have often explained to the House, there would be rotation. This means that a member of the Government party speaks and then a member of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party. Surely an Independent Member would then be entitled to speak? I am not challenging the ruling of the Chair but I asked for information.
Comment on this
That only applies in the case of a debate on a Private Members' motion. On a Government motion, the choosing of speakers is a matter for the Chair. It is different from the debate on a Private Members' motion.