We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 118–236 of 236. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972
Enacted

No. 30 of 1972 ›

Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not need any lecture from the Deputy about calling Deputies. He is not even listening to what I say; he just wants to speak. Deputy Foley knows that a member of his group was called this morning.

Comment on this

I understand that the Minister for Labour was called out of turn this morning——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The position is that when a Minister offers, he is called.

Comment on this

It seems to be preferential treatment when——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no preferential treatment. As a matter of fact, the time taken by Government speakers is very small compared with the time taken up by various other parties.

Comment on this

Is the reason for that that they have damn little to say?

Comment on this

I accept your ruling, Sir, and ask if we will be next?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think so but we will call the Deputy when the time arises.

Comment on this

The situation we face at present is a complex one, it is complicated by the fact that over the past fortnight we have faced not only the issue of this Bill but also the issue posed by the arrest and conviction of Mac Stiofáin and also the issue posed by the Government action with regard to RTE. Each of these has provoked its own reactions amongst different members of the community. This is not, therefore, a clear-cut issue. Secondly, on the Bill itself, the whole problem posed by this Bill is that perennial problem, the issue of liberty and freedom and how they are best safeguarded. Clearly a balance has to be maintained between the libertarian view expressed by Deputy Thornley which is entitled to respect and the view that the interests of the democratic system must be safeguarded and that any democracy which leaves itself with one hand tied behind its back is liable to founder. Our job in this House is to find the right balance between the two. It is not an easy task. The issue is not a clear-cut one and all of us who faced the problem on this Bill have had to face it with seriousness, to apply our minds to the question as to which parts of the Bill are, perhaps, desirable and acceptable and which parts are totally unacceptable and, in our view, unnecessary. It has not been easy for any of us to reach a conclusion on this.

In speaking on this matter I shall be bearing in mind both the desirability of giving to a government of a democratic State the powers that are necessary to defend the democratic system and the undesirability of giving to a government powers that go beyond what is necessary and which are a danger to the democratic system we are seeking to defend. That is the dilemma this Bill poses for us and it is no good pretending it does not exist.

With respect to Deputy Thornley, it is easy to make a speech purely in terms of individual liberty and protection against encroachment by the Executive. It is easy to make a speech on the need to safeguard the State against the IRA and to state that all measures are legitimate for this purpose. In fact, the truth lies between the two statements. These extreme viewpoints on the issue of liberty and order do not do justice to the subject. It is all too easy to oversimplify it and in a debate which the Government have contrived, apparently as a prelude to a general election campaign, they will seek to oversimplify these issues. They will seek to elevate the law and order issue and to pay scant regard to the issue of individual liberty with which we must be concerned.

The Opposition could fall into the trap set by the Government. By contesting the right of the Government to introduce inherently objectionable legislation there is a danger they might find themselves facing a general election campaign in which the Government would fight this law and order issue. However, I do not share the confidence of some members of the Government in the ability of Fianna Fáil to pull the wool over the eyes of the people.

The people in the last four years have watched the party opposite; they have watched the action and inaction of that party. Four years ago the people saw men firing guns over a grave in Mullingar and they saw that nothing happened in that case. From statements made in this House they know why nothing happened—because the Garda were not permitted to act. Since then they have seen a succession of actions in public defiance of the law, tolerated by a government not willing or powerless to act because there were in the ranks of that party and in the Government people who were sympathetic to the men of violence in a campaign against democracy in this State.

The people repeatedly have heard this party demand action, demand application of the existing law, but they have also seen that little use was made of the existing law. On this issue, our party have been consistent. There has been a succession of public actions in defiance of the law, followed by Government inaction. Nobody is in any doubt why action is not taken; we know of the internal difficulties the Government faced.

Yesterday I heard Deputy Sherwin make a speech that certainly gave aid and comfort to people threatening democracy in this State. Where did Deputy Sherwin emigrate from to the upper benches? He came from Fianna Fáil and the same is true of Deputies Foley, Brennan and Blaney. These are the people whose views, as expressed in this House, come nearest to sympathising with the illegal organisations and who at times seek to defend or explain the actions of these organisations. These people have never been willing to condemn murders committed by these bodies, they have never been willing to defend the right of the people to life when attacked by these organisations.

We have seen that when Ministers, in particular the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste, spoke on these matters there were silent gentlemen behind them unwilling to applaud them on the occasions when they chose to speak out against the IRA and even before they were willing to take action against the IRA. Members of this House saw the glum faces behind the Taoiseach, the failure to applaud the speeches, while from this side of the House there was applause for the sentiments expressed but not for the lack of action by the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and other Ministers.

Because of that problem in Fianna Fáil, we know the Government were inactive for a long period. We know that two years ago Ministers were engaged directly in activities, or knew or suspected of activities involving the security of the State which they did not bring to the knowledge of the Taoiseach. We know that with certainty because we have the report of the Public Accounts Committee on this matter and I will quote a statement from that report:

Had the then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Neil T. Blaney, the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Charles J. Haughey, and the then Minister for Defence, Deputy James Gibbons, passed on to the Taoiseach their suspicion or knowledge of the proposed arms importation, the misappropriation of part of the money which is now known to have been spent on arms might have been avoided.

The committee were concerned only with the technical issue of the money spent but, of course, this also involved knowledge of the arms importation and on this matter we have evidence from the trial as well as the evidence before the Public Accounts Committee.

A government in which Ministers knew of these activities and sympathised with them to such an extent that they would not tell the Taoiseach what was going on were a government that clearly could not act against the IRA. The accusations that have been made of direct stimulus to the creation of the Provisional IRA by Ministers, that they aided and financed this establishment, have not been properly refuted and are consonant with the findings of the Public Accounts Committee, although they go beyond what the Public Accounts Committee were able to find on the evidence before them.

Comment on this

On a point of order, when Deputy FitzGerald speaks of what the Taoiseach did or did not do, surely the decision of the arms trial clearly indicated that the Government knew precisely what was happening in the contingency plans in relation to the oppressed nationalist population in the North? It is wrong for Deputy FitzGerald to suggest the Taoiseach did not know this.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is scarcely a point of order.

Comment on this

I read every word of the evidence in the arms trial and I was involved in the Public Accounts Committee. I must say that the evidence before us was of the existence of contingency plans for certain action to be taken in certain circumstances. That in itself is not conclusive evidence that the Taoiseach knew of particular activities of certain Ministers. However, the leader of Deputy Sherwin's party speaking in 1970, about two months after these events, stated that these matters did come to the knowledge of the Taoiseach and the Cabinet and, knowing what had happened, the Taoiseach and the Cabinet decided to take no action against these criminal illegal activities. As Mr. Boland said at the time, the decision was taken to take no action but that decision was reversed only when Deputy Cosgrave went to the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach knew he would be exposed next morning for not having acted. That is the record of this Government.

Comment on this

Where did Deputy Cosgrave get the information?

Comment on this

That is a fair question which the Deputy can put to Deputy Cosgrave as I do not know the answer. Thank God he got the information and exposed the conspiracy. It was accurate information and he forced the Taoiseach to reverse the decision Mr. Boland told us the Taoiseach had taken, to push this matter under the carpet because he was afraid of these powerful Ministers and their involvement with the IRA——

Comment on this

Rubbish.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Minister for Transport and Power (Mr. B. Lenihan)

Is this relevant to the Bill?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to refer to the matter but to have a full discussion on the arms trial again is taking up the time of the House.

Comment on this

I merely want to recite the reasons this party find it difficult to take from the Government a Bill of this kind at this time, a Government which not only did not act against the IRA but whose members knew of its activities and had knowledge of its financing and whose leader was prepared to sweep this matter under the carpet. For such a Government to come here with this legislation naturally arouses suspicion on this side. That is the position so far as we are concerned——

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

That is the most convoluted argument I have ever heard.

Comment on this

The people can decide if it is convoluted. The people know the record of this Government. Yesterday the Taoiseach attempted to pretend the Government could not use the powers they have, but let us examine his argument in detail. Deputy Cooney mentioned a number of sections in the Offences Against the State Act which could and should have been used but which were not used. The Taoiseach replied selectively.

Of the various sections mentioned by Deputy Cooney, the Taoiseach replied to certain ones but not to others. From his silence I argue he could not reply to the others. Making that speech—perhaps his last speech in this House before a general election —he would have disproved any point he could have refuted. He remained silent on all but two points which I shall deal with.

With regard to section 6, he argued it would not have been possible to prosecute people under that section because until Dáil Mhumhan, Dáil Uladh or Dáil Connacht purported to legislate it would not be possible to find the people concerned guilty. I do not know enough about the law to state if this is so, but I know that when people set up bodies and call them a Dáil they are purporting to set up a legislature. There is a good prima facie case in such an instance. I agree the court might decide that the people concerned had not committed an offence but it is not the job of the Executive to pick and choose in that way. Where there is a prima facie case of a crime being committed by people seeking to destroy this State they should prosecute. The possibility is there that some prosecutions may fail but where people set up a body and call it Dáil Connacht. Dáil Uladh or Dáil Mhumhan and where they purport to set up a legislature, there is a prima facie case against them. The court may decide that unless there is actual legislation the charge will not stand but that is not the point I am making. The possibility was there of getting a large number of people involved in an illegal organisation and of putting them where they should be but the Government did not take that chance. The Taoiseach's defence on this point is inadequate. If he had told us that they prosecuted but that the prosecution had failed I would accept that, but when he did not attempt to prosecute he has no defence.

The Taoiseach referred to section 52, dealing with the question of requiring people to account for their movements. He told us this could not be used any longer because of the Commission on Human Rights. I do not know enough about the law to say that as things stand at the moment the Council of Europe would override that. If the Council of Europe override that provision I do not see how they can permit section 2 of this Bill but I reserve judgment until I hear more of the details. This Government have the power which they used before to derogate from our obligations under the Commission on Human Rights where there is a state of emergency sufficient to require it. The Government gave notice of their intention to derogate a year ago and they claimed there was a plot of some kind against the State by a small group. They gave notice of their intention to derogate when they had a rumour or a report that some action would be taken to kidnap or assassinate people which, in fact, never came to anything.

If they were prepared to derogate in that case and in the earlier case back in 1960—and derogate successfully because, in fact, the Gerry Lawless case was taken and we won that case—I should like to know why have the Government kept one hand tied behind their back in the face of what they describe as a national emergency. Why have they not derogated from the Convention at this point to enable them to introduce section 52?

Perhaps there is an answer to that, some technical answer which I do not know, but certainly for a Minister to introduce a Bill as this Minister introduced it and for the Taoiseach to intervene in the debate in the way he intervened and for neither of them to give us any explanation of this and leave the House in ignorance of the position is not to tackle this problem seriously, as they have failed throughout to tackle the problem of the IRA seriously.

Those were the two sections of the Bill which the Taoiseach chose to comment on: those were his defences and in both cases the defences are inadequate. Under section 6 they did not try to prosecute; they cannot tell this House that they failed; they can only say they thought they might fail, but that is not a defence. In the second case, they did not derogate and have not told us why they could not derogate from the Convention of Human Rights on that particular issue. On those two issues the Taoiseach had no defence and the grounds he gave for the inaction of the Government under those two sections were grounds that do not stand up on the evidence before us.

But the Taoiseach did not mention the other sections to which Deputy Cooney referred or others to which he might have referred. Why have the Government taken no action against military exercises, evolutions and manoeuvres, to use the words of a section of the Bill. I wonder why that was not mentioned because every week in this country now we have these parades of men with their berets and para-military uniforms marching in military formation, certainly engaged in military exercises, evolutions or manoeuvres, and doing it—and this is indeed a double event—within a half-mile of the Dáil last night. What action has been taken against that? None. The Government have permitted and are still permitting a para-military group, or several para-military groups, to parade in a manner prohibited in the Offences against the State Act and have failed to take action against them. Many hundreds of these people could have been arrested and charged under that section had the Government acted. Why they have not acted, we do not know because the Government have failed to tell us. The Minister in his opening speech failed to refer to it. The Taoiseach, despite Deputy Cooney's challenge, failed to take up the challenge and answer it. Is there a reason? Perhaps there is, but we do not know: the country is not to be told, apparently, why this section is not being used. I suspect the reason why we were not told is because there is no reason and the Taoiseach was silent because he was not able to answer Deputy Cooney.

There are other sections of this Act which could have been used and have not been used. What about the section on seditious documents, section 10, in which seditious documents are defined in a manner which covers quite a number of publications on behalf of these bodies? Section 10 (1) makes provision enabling a prosecution to take place of those who publish documents which allege, imply or suggest that the Government are not the lawful Government or that any other body is entitled to be recognised as the Government, or document which imply or suggest that the military forces of the State are not the lawful military forces of the State under the Constitution or that some other body is entitled to be recognised as a military force. We know perfectly well that there are publications of several illegal organisations appearing regularly which imply or suggest these things. When have they been prosecuted for section? Never, under this Government. The Government have never had the courage to prosecute them; they still have not; they are still permitting these seditious documents to circulate and have taken no action against their authors or those who publish or print them.

Again, there is provision under the Offences against the State Act with regard to public meetings of a seditious character. Section 27 (1) says that in the case of a public meeting held or purporting to be held by or on behalf of, or by arrangement with, or in concert with an unlawful organisation, or held or purporting to be held for the purpose of supporting, aiding, abetting or encouraging an unlawful organisation or advocating support for an unlawful organisation, those who organise it commit an offence and are liable to three months sentence and a fine of £50.

How many people have been prosecuted for holding such meetings? I cannot recall a prosecution; perhaps there have been some cases and that I am in error. Perhaps the Minister in replying can mention them in his opening speech he did not mention them and I am not aware of such prosecutions taking place. I am aware of a couple of prosecutions under the heading of incitement but very few indeed. The fact is that day after day and week after week in this State meetings are held—one was held within hearing distance of this House last night at which people were advocating support for unlawful organisations—but no prosecutions have taken place against those who organise these meetings. Why? We are entitled to be told—before anybody comes to this House—especially a Government with the tarnished record of this one of involvement in IRA activities—looking for legislation, why they have not used the existing legislation fully. We have not been told that.

Why is there silence in the Government about section 19, the section that enables organisations to be declared illegal? Why has Saor Éire not been declared illegal? Here is a body posing such a threat to the State we are told, on this occasion when internment was threatened that it was necessary to notify an intention to derogate from the Human Rights Convention of the Council of Europe in order to deal with this dangerous body. But it has not been declared illegal and whatever Saor Éire is, it is not a branch of the IRA. I suppose one or other parts of the IRA can claim to be descended in some kind of apostolic succession from the original body—although from what I have read of the IRA in that excellent textbook on the subject by Professor Bowyer Bell, that apostolic succession was broken once or twice and I am afraid that if it had to be ruled on by the Vatican it would not stand up. Nonetheless, I suppose one or other body might claim to be lineal descendant of the original IRA and to be entitled to the name but they cannot both be entitled to it. Indeed, there is a very curious position in the courts at the moment because neither body is prepared to contest this particular issue. If you do not recognise the courts you cannot, of course, claim before the courts to be one of these bodies or not to be one of them.

Saor Éire is not the IRA, yet it is a body which according to the Government threatened the security of this State more seriously apparently than the IRA and yet they are not an illegal organisation under section 19. Why have they not been declared an illegal organisation? Surely we are entitled to be told that before legislation of this kind is brought into this House. These are the kinds of cases and inaction which make us properly suspicious. Clearly, a Government who could have acted in so many ways against illegal organisations and who have failed to do so and are still failing to do so are a Government whose motives in bringing in further repressive legislation must be suspect. The motive which seems most evident in the circumstances is that the Government have now decided to take action and in order to justify past inaction they are suggesting to the country that they did not have sufficient power before and that was why they did nothing. They are suggesting that if they are given the powers now they can act. In that way they hope to secure an alibi for past inaction.

The Government will not get that alibi from this side of the House. We are not going to concede powers which are of themselves undesirable in order to cover up the failure of Fianna Fáil to act against the IRA. We will not do that and if we were to do so we would be failing in our duty to the country. That is why we are opposing this legislation. Were we to accept it as necessary when it is not necessary and to go along in conspiracy with the Government suggesting to the country that this legislation is necessary when present powers have not been used, we would be giving the Government an alibi for past inaction and we would also be conspiring with them to hide the truth of their past failure and the fact that some of this legislation is not necessary and is inherently objectionable.

The Taoiseach tried to bolster up his weak case by selected quotations. He chose to quote me. I would like to read the whole of the quotation and not just the last sentence which he read. I would like to quote from column 3458, volume 255, of the Official Report for 5th August, 1971. The Taoiseach quoted the last sentence and purported to quote it with a view to suggesting that I advocated internment and other changes in the law and was, therefore, being inconsistent in now opposing this Bill. The House will have no difficulty in seeing how selective the Taoiseach was. I said:

Internment can only arise if the problem is on such a scale that civil war is threatened and society as a whole is threatened and when all other methods have failed. This Government have discredited themselves by threatening to resort to internment at a stage when they have not begun to use the normal processes of law and they perhaps have made it more difficult for them to proceed according to the proper process. Let us not hear any more of internment until and unless other methods have failed and this Government can come to this House and say: "We went through trial by jury; witnesses were intimidated; juries were intimidated and we had to introduce special criminal courts. We did that; we charged people, but the scale of the problem is such that we are now threatened with civil war and the only solution is internment", the Government will get from this party support in that action—then and only then;

The Taoiseach had started his quotation just above that point. He left out what went before. He was seeking to suggest that what I said was the opposite to what I had said. I went on to say:

...but it will get that support when necessary because this party has always stood by any Government, no matter how much it is opposed to it, which, acting properly and with due process seeks to protect the liberties and lives of our people and the society in which we live.

And that all stands, but this Government are not acting properly and with due process. The due process in matters of this kind is to enforce the existing law to the hilt and to use every section of the existing Act and then, if that fails and if convictions are not being secured under section 6 about Dáil Uladh and the like, and under section 10 about seditious documents and under section 19 about military exercises and manoeuvres, and under another section about public meetings, when they have done these things and failed, then they can look for what additional powers are necessary and we will give them the necessary powers, no more than the necessary powers but all the powers that are shown to be necessary. I went on to say that we would not rule out and I certainly do not rule out that in a situation where we faced a civil war internment might be necessary. That is the ultimate resort. Internment can only be justified in the last resort when we face that kind of situation. This party would support the Government in that type of situation. We will only support the Government when they have used the existing processes fully and when they show that they have failed and when we face a situation which can be mastered by no other means than those extreme means. In those circumstances the Opposition, which is a loyal Opposition, would support the Government.

If the Government try to cover up their own mistakes and inaction and complicity in so much that went on in the past years we should expose them. If they try to bring in legislation of this kind without prior consultation with us involving measures of a character going beyond what is necessary and do it as a political manoeuvre, or as it now seems, a pre-election manoeuvre, they will not get our support. We would be failing in our duty if we gave them our support. That is our position. Let it be clear to the country and to the Government where we stand in this matter.

I would like to raise the question of why this legislation is being brought in at this stage. How many months have elapsed since the Minister first noticed these lacunae in our legislation? It is many months now since he told the House that the existing legislation was inadequate and that he was looking into the question of improving it. This is not a long or complex Bill. It is a very bad Bill but it is a Bill which cannot have taken all that long to draft. Even allowing for the due process in some of our Government Departments, which is remarkably slow, it could not have taken more than a couple of weeks to draft it in its present form.

The Taoiseach tried to explain this and then he suddenly backtracked. He tried to tell the House that the situation had suddenly become very serious with the bomb in the cinema and the guns in the Mater. Then the Taoiseach realised that there had been even more serious developments in other parts of the country, and said that 600 lives had been lost in Northern Ireland. He was trying to suggest that there was a new situation now and that we needed a new Bill to deal with it. The Taoiseach suddenly realised that the situation is not new to Ireland and the Irish people, although it may be new to Dublin. The people in the North have suffered intensely from the consequences of the Provisional IRA campaign in Northern Ireland and the counter-reaction to that by the British Army and more recently by the UDA. As a result of that guns were bought with money which came out of public funds, through the complicity of Ministers, and with the knowledge of Ministers, Ministers who did not tell the Taoiseach anything about it, as the Public Accounts Committee have said. As a result of that guns were bought in the winter of 1969-70 which were capable of being used and were used in Northern Ireland.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Minister for Transport and Power (Mr. B. Lenihan)

Is this relevant to the terms of this Bill?

Comment on this

I am surprised at Deputy FitzGerald. He reminds me of——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Deputy FitzGerald.

Comment on this

He has not the guts to rule this country——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. The Deputy will cease interrupting.

Comment on this

The country should be ruled from here, not from outside, but Deputy FitzGerald wants to rule the country from the streets of Dublin and I am really shocked at him.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order. Deputy FitzGerald.

Comment on this

That is what Deputy FitzGerald wants and I am shocked.

Comment on this

This is not worthy of Deputy Burke and I know Deputy Burke well enough to know he does not mean it. He knows my position.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy FitzGerald now, on the Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy stands for the homes of Deputies to be picketed and their wives and families questioned and intimidated. I do not stand for that. That is what Fine Gael stand for.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is just in time for the Evening Herald.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy remain quiet and allow me to continue? May I speak?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy FitzGerald, on the Bill.

Comment on this

My apologies, Sir, but that is what we are up against.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is well aware of where we stand on the question as to whether this House is to be ruled from here or from the streets and, if he had been here earlier and heard my opening remarks, he would know that. We were told that this legislation was necessary months ago, but it did not come before us. Why did it not come before us? It cannot be said that it is because the situation has suddenly become serious because the Taoiseach himself was forced to admit, when he thought about it for a minute, that, of course, the situation has been tragically serious in a certain part of this country for a long time past and the mere fact that some activities are spreading down here now does not change that. It aggravates the situation, but it does not change the fact that we had a duty to take action to save lives in Ireland and we did not take it. The Government did not introduce this legislation at the time it announced the need for it. It kept putting it off. Why? Why did they postpone it until now?

Comment on this

They did say it was a difficult Bill to draft, but I am blowed if I can understand why it was difficult.

Comment on this

And that is my feeling, too, having read the Bill. The amount of drafting that went into it was not very much considering there are so many inadequacies in it, but obviously it is the kind of thing one would have to sit down and think about for a couple of weeks before putting it into final shape. A couple of weeks should have sufficed and not the very many months that have elapsed since we were first told that the law needed to be changed. I cannot envisage what kind of legal research or drastic legal mechanism could take so many months. Quite clearly, the decision to postpone the introduction of the Bill until now was a political decision of this Government for political reasons and to shuffle the blame off on to their Civil Service advisers, suggesting that they were so incompetent they could not do the job unless they were given a year or so in which to do it. That, of course, is both dishonest and disreputable of the Government.

This Bill could have been introduced, had the Government wished to introduce it, many months ago, if, in fact, they felt, as the Minister stated, the law was inadequate. But they did not introduce it until now. Why? My belief, and I have some grounds for this as a result of what I have read and heard of published Government statements and what I know of things said less publicly, that what, in fact, has happened is that this Government have adopted a policy over the past year totally contrary to the policy advocated by this party—a wrong policy, I think—of postponing action on the IRA and action on constitutional reform right up to the brink of what they hope may be, and we all hope will be, a conclusive and favourable negotiation leading to a peaceful settlement of the problem in Northern Ireland. Our belief, on this side of the House, was that the way to approach this matter was for this part of this country to take its courage in its hands at the earliest possible moment and tackle the IRA in the course of 1971— it should actually have been done long before that—and introduce the necessary constitutional changes so that we could move towards this negotiation in a strong moral position, able to say to the British Government, the British people and the Protestant population in the North, that we have done our part; we have dealt with the IRA in good conscience; we have done all that we can, and effectively, and we have made various changes in our constitutional laws to show that we are anxious only to work towards the kind of Ireland in which all could share equally and we ask you now to sit down and talk over these problems with us. That is the approach we advocated. It was the right approach and the only approach that one lot of Irishmen could honestly adopt towards another lot of Irishmen. But that is not what this Government did. They saw themselves in a grand diplomatic battle with the British Government, culminating in some great negotiation from which the Taoiseach would come triumphantly back, doing a 1938, only twice as good, and, for that purpose, they wanted therefore not to build up good will so that there would be a possibility of agreement between North and South, but to hold back from dealing with the IRA and constitutional reform so that they could use these as a bargaining weapon in the final negotiation, not with the other people in Northern Ireland but with the British Government.

That is not, in our view, the way this matter should be handled. The Government have postponed legislation until now so that they could produce a good bargaining card in the negotiations with the British Prime Minister. If there is another explanation for this delay, let us hear it because, in the absence of it, and in the presence of a good deal of evidence to support my conclusion, I believe that is what lies behind the timing of this legislation now.

There may also be electoral considerations. The Government may have decided for their own reasons to go to the country on an issue on which it is thought they might do well. That may be present also but, so far as the Northern Ireland situation is concerned, their thinking was, I am sure, along the lines I suggest and I regard that as criminally irresponsible and as showing a total disregard of the interests of Irish people working together, a megalomaniac power politics orientation which will do nothing to resolve these problems peacefully.

In the course of his speech the Taoiseach said that Mr. Mac Stiofáin was convicted only because of the tape. He was trying to suggest—Deputy Cooney adduced the conviction of Mr. Mac Stiofáin as evidence that the law worked—that this was pure chance in this case. It is an interesting point. When he said it I reflected on the curious irony of the situation, a situation in which the Government are apparently so inept in dealing with this body and the leaders of it that they could not get any evidence until Radio Telefís Éireann conveniently obliged and produced a tape that enabled the court to convict. In the ordinary way, when one gets a help like that in convicting a criminal, one gets a handshake and, if he is a big criminal, one may even get a reward. What reward did Radio Telefís Éireann get? Dismissal was the result. The curious irony of this! If, in fact, the only way in which Mr. Mac Stiofáin could be convicted was a Radio Éreann interview, why did the Government dismiss the authority for having such an interview? I find this very hard indeed to understand and, if I were a member of the Radio Telefís Éireann Authority, I would feel there was a certain ingratitude on the part of the Government in the circumstances. I mention that by way of an aside because I was struck forcibly by the oddity of the Taoiseach's comments and the fact that he himself failed to appreciate the irony of it. His unconsciousness of that told us, I think, a good deal about the Taoiseach.

If the Government really thought this legislation was necessary, if they were seeking the national interest and not party political advantage, they would, of course, have come to the Opposition about this legislation. National security is at stake and there is a need to modify the law. I accept that certain parts of this Bill may be useful amendments to the present law. Certainly we are not opposed to every aspect of the Bill. There are some parts of it which could be quite useful. Unfortunately, together with those, totally objectionable sections have been put in. Had the Government come to the Opposition, as any Government concerned with the national interest would have done, and said: "Look, we have got problems here. There are certain cases where the law is not working and we would like to sit down with you—we will bring our legal advisers along to explain the points so you will see we are not just making a political advantage— and consult with you as to how we can best deal with this", does the Taoiseach think he would not have got the co-operation of the Opposition? Does he think we are so lacking in patriotism that we would not co-operate? Of course, if he had come to us along those lines, we would have discussed the matter with him. We would have pointed out that some of the provisions were unacceptable to us and we would have suggested amendments and changes and, if the Government were reasonable and seeking to govern the country properly, if they had the national interest at stake, they would have listened to and accepted our amendments and agreed legislation could have been introduced; but they brought in a Bill containing provisions so designed as to be certain to evoke the opposition of any Opposition party concerned to do their duty by the people.

Comment on this

You could put down amendments.

Comment on this

And we shall put down amendments if we fail to defeat the Second Reading. The fact that the Government chose not to seek our co-operation, and to bring in a Bill with unnecessary objectionable features, and with co-operation beforehand, makes it quite clear that this Bill is a party action for partisan reasons——

Comment on this

Do not back down.

Comment on this

The Government are disgracefully——

Comment on this

You are weakening now.

Comment on this

——pretending to use issues of national security for this purpose. We will not accept that. There are aspects of this Bill which are totally objectionable to this party and which we will not accept. Unless the Government back down we will be voting against them.

Comment on this

Let the people decide.

Comment on this

The people will decide in due course, but let us make it clear what the issues are that we are deciding.

Comment on this

We will put them very surely.

Comment on this

Let us stick to the subject. The Taoiseach went on to say, in defending his case, that they went through everything, meaning every part of the existing law, with a view to using it. I pointed out that there are half a dozen sections of the Offences against the State Act which have not been used, or which have been used on only one or two occasions. For him to say they went through everything was simply not true. He went on to say that the courts are not effective. He even went on to say that the special criminal courts are not effective. These are direct quotations from the speech of the Taoiseach. I wrote them down as he said them.

I do not understand what the Government mean by effective courts. The figures issued by the Government recently show that in 75 per cent of the cases the special criminal courts have convicted. What kind of conviction rate is necessary to show that the courts are effective? Must it be 100 per cent? Are the courts to become the creatures of the Executive, convicting every man before them regardless of his innocence or his guilt? Indeed, that is the purpose of section 3 (2) of the Bill.

Apparently the Government's attitude now is that, having failed to deal with the IRA until now, and having allowed this menace to grow, some of their supporters and members having helped to finance and assist it, the courts must become totally subservient and, unless they convict in 100 per cent of cases, the law will be changed and bent to achieve that result. We do not accept that. The courts are independent. We support and, indeed, called for the setting up of the special criminal courts. I called for that in a speech in August, 1971. We felt they were necessary because of intimidation. A frequent feature in this country has been the intimidation of witnesses and jurors. We have suffered from this for a very long time because of this organisation and the way they attempted to corrupt the body politic by violence and intimidation.

We called for them and those courts were set up. They have been effective. I regard a 75 per cent conviction rate as about as high as you will get without instances of injustice. It is inevitable that in any system of law some cases brought forward are defective as regards evidence. In some cases the accused is either innocent or there is some technicality on which he can get off. You are bound to get a certain failure rate. A 75 per cent success rate is very high. For the Taoiseach to insult the members of the special criminal courts by suggesting that they are not effective, because they are not being subservient to the Executive in convicting in every case, is something no Prime Minister has the right to do with respect to the judiciary.

This party are willing at any time to give all necessary assistance to the Government in dealing with the menace of the IRA. An attempt by the Government to suggest that that is not our position, an attempt to suggest that Fine Gael are soft on the IRA, will not arouse much reaction amongst the public. It will arouse the amused contempt of the public. The public know that we have been consistent. They know how over the past four years people like Deputy Cosgrave, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Cooney, Senator John Kelly and others, myself amongst them, have consistently called for action against the IRA and condemned Government inaction.

The public also know the people who are in the Government, and they know their involvement. They are aware of the Report of the Public Accounts Committee. They know where the people on those benches up there came from. They know in which party are the people who were not prepared to clap their leader when he was making strong speeches against the IRA.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

The Deputy said that ten times already.

Comment on this

The public will not be confused by people on the opposite side of the House, by Deputy Dowling or Deputy Moore or anybody else, into thinking that Fine Gael are, ever have been, or ever will be soft on the IRA.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Convoluted behaviour.

Comment on this

Let us look at the Bill itself. Let us try to look at it rationally from the point of view that we are seeking to do two things. We are seeking to strengthen the law where it is inadequate and is shown to be inadequate, and we are seeking to secure the innocent against the danger of being convicted. Above all, that is the job of the Opposition. We are trying to secure a system of legislation which will give the Government the powers necessary to deal with the IRA, and which will be seen not to be repressive in the sense of going beyond what is necessary.

When the Government introduce legislation which goes beyond what is necessary, there are many people of liberal disposition who will be taken aback, and who will be put off, and whose support for the Government in dealing with the IRA may be weakened. Not all the people who have been demonstrating and protesting have sympathy with the IRA. What the IRA want is an issue on which they can arouse sympathy from outside their own ranks. We know how these revolutionaries work. They try to broaden the area of their support by confusing the issue. Where you get an Executive which is foolish and repressive in its attitudes then you get danger to the State. Where you get an Executive which is prepared to confuse the issue of dealing with the IRA by sacking the RTE Authority, then you get danger because an extra issue is brought in to confuse the whole situation.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question? Over the past couple of days a number of statements have been issued from Catholic priests associations and last night there were many industrial workers from my constituency and other parts of Dublin parading in protest against this legislation. Surely the Deputy is not suggesting that they are all members of the illegal organisation he referred to?

Comment on this

If the Deputy heard what I said, he would know I said the exact opposite. Many protests have been aroused by this legislation and many by the sacking of the RTE Authority. This is creating a situation in which the clear-cut issue of facing the IRA is being confused. This is always the danger of repressive legislation. It gives a handle to the revolutionaries to excite sympathy and support. There is bound to be something of that in the present situation. There are bound to be some people with soft hearts and soft heads.

Comment on this

Have the priests soft hearts or soft heads?

Comment on this

Allow me to conclude my sentence before you interrupt. People with soft hearts and soft heads will go around demanding that Mr. Mac Stiofáin be released. There are bound to be such people. Indeed, this country has suffered for a long time from the menace of local authorities passing resolutions on such matters which are not within their competence and which can confuse the whole situation. On that issue the Taoiseach spoke for the vast majority in the House and in the country when two days ago he explained why it was not possible to release such a man without undermining the whole system of law and that, if any man could get himself released by going on hunger strike, law and order would break down completely. Those of us on this side of the House are totally in agreement with the Taoiseach's statement on that. Nothing that may be said from outside will shake that view.

Of course, there are people who allow their human sympathy to overrun their judgment in such a matter. We can understand that, but it is our job in this House to withstand such pressures, to stand by the Government on an issue of that kind, and we do so. Unfortunately, the Government have confused the issue by sacking the RTE Authority and by the consequent effects of that in regard to Mr. Kevin O'Kelly. They have confused the issue by introducing a Bill with repressive elements against which we have to protest and which we must seek to erode and eliminate. It is unwise and dangerous to confuse this issue. The Government have failed in their responsibilities by so doing.

We have a complicated problem, and it is not easy for us to try to tread our way through this impasse. We have to make it clear that we stand against the dismissal of the RTE Authority because they were put into an impossible position by the refusal of the Minister to clarify his directive. We have to make it clear that we stand by the action of the courts in enforcing the law in the case of Kevin O'Kelly, although many of us may feel individually that the sentence was too harsh and hope that on appeal it will be reduced. By the way, if I expressed that sentiment elsewhere than in this House after this Bill is passed, it would render me liable to a jail sentence, which is one reason for amending section 4.

There are aspects of this Bill which are dangerous and which should be eliminated. We feel the Government were quite right in their decision not to release Mr. Mac Stiofáin and that they are quite right to enforce the law that exists at the moment against the IRA, as they are now beginning to do, though still in a half-hearted manner. We have to get across that complicated position because so many issues have been raised and it is not in the interests of the country that the matter should have been complicated. It would have been far better if the Government had sought the co-operation of the Opposition and enabled us to stand firm on this issue and if the Government had not confused the issue by dismissing the RTE Authority and if the Government had brought in legislation to which this House could have agreed. The Government have chosen not to do it that way. They have chosen to divide the country at a time when the country should have been united on these issues and that is something that will be held against them in the years ahead.

Looking now directly at the Bill, let us be clear about it, as all speakers have said, parts of the Bill are totally objectionable, parts of the Bill need amendment, parts of the Bill are acceptable. Each of us can make his own judgment on that. There may be minor variations on that in regard to particular points. There are certain features of the Bill which to us are totally objectionable. Let me spell them out. It is important I should. There should be no confusion about this. We are opposing this Bill on Second Stage because it contains some things so objectionable that to leave them to Committee Stage and approve the Bill in principle would be open to the misconstruction that we are willing to concede matters which involve infringement of the liberties of the individual which are unnecessary and dangerous. We want to make that clear. We do not want to be put in the position of having it suggested that we are opposed totally to some sections of the Bill which seem to be useful amendments of the law or do not recognise the need for certain other changes although we may disagree with the wording. Let us, therefore, isolate those problems which to us are crucial.

Comment on this

That is not what the amendment says.

Comment on this

The amendment refers to certain parts of the Bill. I am glad Deputy Dowling and Deputy Moore reminded me to say that the wording of the amendment was dictated in that form by the rules of procedure of the House and that although the amendment as originally drafted referred specifically to sections 3 and 4, on the advice given to us by the officials of the House we had to change that because otherwise we would have been precluded from putting down amendments on Committee Stage to those sections.

Comment on this

It is a very good try but not quite right.

Comment on this

You, Sir, know that that is true.

Comment on this

You are having second thoughts and trying to wriggle out of it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy FitzGerald.

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, you know that that is true and that the amendment originally referred to sections 3 and 4. That was changed because that would have prevented us from having Committee Stage amendments. You know also, Sir, that the amendment, as originally drafted, included as a final clause a statement requiring a time limit to be put on the Bill and that once again the inclusion of that, had we left it there, would have precluded a Committee Stage debate. It had to be deleted before the Bill came to the House, on the advice given to us by the officials of the House. These are the facts. You know them. The officials know them. We know them. Those people over there will not confuse the issue by suggesting that that is not true.

Comment on this

We will not let you confuse them.

Comment on this

These are the issues for us: there is a problem in section 3 subsection (2), a problem in section 4 and the problem of absence of a time limit. These are the three points we put down in our amendment and the three points that we want to put to the House at this stage.

First, subsection (2) of section 3, in its present form, for reasons stated and which I cannot repeat because I do not want to delay the House, is objectionable. It is objectionable because, in fact, it puts the onus of proof—contrary to what the Taoiseach said—here he is wrong—he did not develop his suggestion that the onus of proof was not shifted because he could not develop it—the onus of proof is shifted to the individual concerned. He is put in the position where, unless he can persuade the court of the negative proposition that he is not a member of an illegal organisation he can on the word of the chief superintendent be sent to prison. We cannot accept that. The individual concerned must as a minimum be given an absolute right to rebut the view of the chief superintendent.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

He is.

Comment on this

This is a provision which is already in the Offences against the State Act. In section 26 of that Act that is precisely what is done. What we require is that the wording of section 26 be applied here in this section. Section 26 reads:

Where in any criminal proceedings the question whether a particular treasonable document, seditious document, or incriminating document was or was not published by the accused (whether by himself or in concert with other persons or by arrangement between himself and other persons) is in issue and an officer of the Garda Síochána not below the rank of chief superintendent——

That is where it came from

——states on oath that he believes that such document was published (as the case may be) by the accused or by the accused in concert with other persons or by arrangement between the accused and other persons, such statement shall be evidence (until the accused denies on oath that he published such document either himself or in concert or by arrangement as aforesaid) that the accused published such document as alleged in the said statement on oath of such officer.

These words are in section 26. I noted with interest when the Taoiseach was speaking that he gave as precedent for section 3 (2) this section 26 and said that the words were identical but the words are not identical.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

The Deputy is a very bad lawyer.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Write it into the Bill.

Comment on this

The words are not identical because in this section 26 there is an absolute right of rebuttal. If the accused does give evidence, then the chief superintendent's evidence is null and void; it ceases to exist. That is the position. That was omitted in this legislation in section 3 (2) and in omitting it the Government have turned something that in extreme circumstances could be accepted to defend the State into something totally unacceptable. We are not prepared to accept that.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

This is stronger in the interest of the accused.

Comment on this

As far as we are concerned, the failure to include these words or similar words to similar effect giving the accused person absolute right to rebut on oath such accusations, and by so doing to eliminate the evidence of the chief superintendent, makes this totally objectionable to us on this side of the House. I want to make that perfectly clear. Let there be no doubt about it.

We note with interest, first that the Government in presenting this legislation deliberately omitted these protecting words and, secondly, the Taoiseach tried to mislead the House into believing that, in fact, this section was based on and similar to section 26, when, in fact, he knew it had been changed in this manner in this Bill to the disadvantage and prejudice of the accused person. That is the first point, which is one which is totally unacceptable.

The second point is: in section 4 there are provisions which prejudice innocent people. Section 4 is drafted in an extraordinarily wide way. The suggestion in the Minister's opening statement that it did no more than turn into statutory form the law of contempt was, to say the least, contemptible. Let us pick out the relevant words and see what is meant. The section says:

A statement, meeting, procession or demonstration shall be deemed to constitute an interference with the course of justice if it is intended, or is of such a character as to be likely, directly or indirectly to influence any court, person or authority concerned with the institution, conduct or defence of any civil or criminal proceedings (including a party or witness) as to whether or how the proceedings should be instituted, conducted, continued or defended, or as to what should be their outcome.

(2) A person who makes any statement, or who organises, holds or takes part in any meeting, procession or demonstration, that is unlawful under this section shall be guilty of an offence.

The Minister tried to pretend, of course, that there is no problem there because, unless the person was guilty of an offence and intended to be guilty of an offence he could not be caught under that. We are not going to be taken in by that argument. The provision here is one where people who take part in a meeting put themselves at risk because if at that meeting anybody makes a statement, makes any reference to illegal proceedings, the person by attending that meeting is at risk and the onus of proof is then on him that he did not, in fact, intend by participating to support that attempt to interfere with justice.

Let us see how far this can go. There are advice columns in newspapers. There are even TDs who give advice occasionally. Occasionally, there may be programmes on television when people are asked their opinion and where people, lawyers or otherwise, say: "I think you have a case" in relation to a particular matter. That statement: "I think you have a case" could come under this section here. This is, as it stands, dangerous to freedom of speech for that reason and dangerous to any individual who attends a meeting where such matters are discussed or where anybody is likely to make any comment on any public case. That is obviously too wide. No Opposition anywhere in the world could accept legislation of that kind unless it were to fail totally in its duty. As far as we are concerned that must be cut down to size. If there is a reason, which we have not heard, why it is necessary to turn the law of contempt into statutory form, then let us do it in a manner which confines this to cases where there is genuine contempt.

If there is to be an area of discretion and if it is necessary to make provision for borderline cases, let us leave that to the court and to the law of contempt and let us confine the statute law to those things that are intended clearly to be interference with the course of justice. So far as we are concerned, unless there is a willingness to narrow that down so that the innocent are protected and so that only those who are clearly guilty of trying to interfere with the course of justice are contemplated by it, we have no alternative but to reject the Bill.

The third point that is crucial as far as we are concerned is the question of a time limit. After all, the Offences Against the State Act has been on the Statute Book for the past 33 years. A state of emergency was declared during the war and it is still in existence. There has been too much legislation that has been expressed to be needed for a temporary situation but which became permanent and remains a permanent threat to the lives and liberties of the people. We cannot accept that the Bill, even modified in the way we suggest, as it would need to be before this side of the House would have anything to do with it, should be brought in in permanent form. We know there is a crisis now and we wish to help the Government by all reasonable means to deal with it. We will not be found wanting in that regard if the Government meet us but we are not prepared to give powers to the Government that would continue long after the crisis ended. A time limit on this Bill of a period of one year is essential. Those, then, are the essential elements. They are the points that we wish to get at and which were in our original amendment before it had to be modified to comply with the rules of order of this House. Unless the Government meet us in regard to section 3, subsection (2), section 4 and the time limit, we shall vote against them, both in relation to our amendment and to the substance of the motion.

Comment on this

Make sure they are all here to vote.

Comment on this

If the Government are concerned to have the co-operation of the Opposition regarding the threat to the security of the State it is up to them to draft legislation and to accept changes from the House that will result in legislation that we can accept in these special circumstances prevailing but if the Government insist on putting innocent people at risk whereby any chief superintendent can swear a man into jail, if they insist on legislation which involves anybody attending a meeting being put at risk because somebody says something out of turn and if they insist on having permanent legislation to deal with a crisis that is temporary, they will get the negative vote they deserve from this party.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Minister for Transport and Power (Mr. B. Lenihan)

First, I shall deal with the points made last by Deputy FitzGerald because it is in this area that the greatest amount of misconception has arisen. The Deputy, quite dishonestly in my view, and not in proper legal fashion has added fuel to these misconceptions regarding interpretation of the Bill. Sections 1 and 2 and subsection (1) of section 3 are merely extensions, amendments or improvements of the existing Offences Against the State Act. The first point on which Deputy FitzGerald made a dishonest legal argument relates to subsection (2) of section 3. This is a subsection that has given rise to very great misconceptions. Let me make it clear that under this subsection there is no question of a chief superintendent swearing a man into jail, to use Deputy Fitz-Gerald's emotive phrase and there is no question of the onus of proof being shifted.

Comment on this

Come off it.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Every person who is charged with a criminal offence is innocent until he is proved guilty. That fundamental principle remains and before a verdict can be reached either by a court or by a jury, the judge or the jury must be satisfied that the prosecution has been proved beyond all reasonable doubt. That essential principle still remains.

Comment on this

What chance would a man have if the only evidence was that of the chief superintendent?

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Perhaps the Deputy, who knows very little about law, would allow me to continue. The procedure in our country under the common law system has always been that the evaluation of the weight to be attached to any evidence in proceedings before the court is a matter for the court. To suggest that evidence is always proof or that the existence of admissible evidence shifts the onus of proof is an astonishing proposition but under this subsection the basic common law procedure with regard to evidence and the evaluation of evidence remains. An officer of the Garda Síochána who is not below the rank of chief superintendent can give evidence stating that he believes that the accused was, at a material time, a member of an unlawful organisation and this statement shall be evidence that he was then such a member. It can be admitted as evidence but there is no question of that evidence in itself putting a man into jail or of shifting the onus of proof——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Of course, it does. It is prima facie evidence.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

——unless there is counter-evidence. Of course, the chief superintendent is liable to cross-examination either by the court, by the accused or by the accused's legal representatives.

Comment on this

That is not counter-evidence.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Under that subsection the accused is free to go into court and give evidence.

Comment on this

The onus is shifted to him to provide counter-evidence.

Comment on this

The Minister has conceded that.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Our courts operate under the principle that before an accused person can be found guilty he must be proved guilty of the offence beyond all reasonable doubt. There is nothing of a conclusive nature as has been suggested here and elsewhere in regard to the subsection. If the accused goes into the witness box and says he is not a member of an illegal organisation, the onus is on the chief superintendent, there and then, to prove his case.

Under that system of the administration of law it is clear that once an accused man goes into the witness box and says he is not a member of an illegal organisation, the onus of proof shifts to the chief superintendent.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Write that into the section.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

If you start writing in matters of that kind, the rights of the accused are weakened. His rights are strongest under our system of courts. If we have confidence and faith in our courts——

Comment on this

Which the Taoiseach did not have.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister must be allowed make his case.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Deputy FitzGerald made much play of this; in the event of the accused giving evidence to the effect that he was not a member of an illegal organisation, the onus would be shifted totally to the chief superintendent.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is written into section 26 of the Offences against the State Act.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Any other reading of the subsection is dishonest. There has been enough erroneous talk about the meaning of the subsection without Deputy FitzGerald adding to it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): State that clearly in the Bill so as to put it beyond doubt.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

Regarding section 4, the misconception in so far as Deputy FitzGerald is concerned, would seem to be that he is reading subsection (2) and taking from it matters relating to statements and to the organisation of and taking part in meetings and alleging that in some way this is so wide as to include many such meetings or demonstrations within a wider net. The Deputy did not refer to the basic fact that subsection (2) is subject to the section as a whole which deals with meetings, processions or demonstrations which interfere with the course of justice and which may directly or indirectly influence any court. That section read as a whole and without taking any excerpts from it is a statutory duplication of the existing law of contempt of court that we have had for hundreds of years——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Nonsense.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

——which is not being used by our judges and which we propose to ensure will be used by incorporating it in statutory form.

Comment on this

Would the Minister take a question from me? No.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

They were the two main points raised by Deputy FitzGerald on the legal aspect apart from the aspect relating to the time limit. There are arguments for and against here but the real heart of the matter is the criticism of those two sections—in particular the criticism of subsection (2) of section 3—which in my view is largely dishonest and erroneous in law. The very fact of criticising that subsection as it stands is a direct reflection on the courts here which will always operate the laws of evidence, operate the common law procedures in regard to the onus of proof, in regard to proof beyond all reasonable doubt, in regard to assessing evidence and only convicting a person when the court is satisfied beyond all reasonable doubt. These are the basic matters in our system of criminal law. They are not affected whatever by that subsection.

I should like to deal now with some of the wider aspects, on the political level, raised by Deputy FitzGerald. I thought candidly that his speech was hysterical, convoluted and dishonest. Hysterical, probably by reason of affairs within his own party at present, that is understandable, but there is no point in standing up in this House and debating this matter as if it were a Fianna Fáil matter. It is not a Fianna Fáil matter. Much of the content of his speech was devoted to an attack on the Fianna Fáil Party and on various things that have happened in the Fianna Fáil Party. Those matters are irrelevant today. In the context of debating this Bill the issue is one of Government and of parliament and representative democracy.

Comment on this

And freedom.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

This sort of anti-Fianna Fáil speech does not help. I will go through to the heart of the principle that is involved in both what Deputy Cooney said yesterday and what Deputy FitzGerald said today in regard to the alleged inoperation of various sections of the Offences against the State Act. There were various allegations that the Government did not pursue this or that aspect of illegal organisations' activities in a proper way.

Fundamentally what Deputy FitzGerald and Deputy Cooney are doing is attacking the independent law officers and the senior officers of the Garda Síochána. They are not attacking Fianna Fáil; they are attacking the permanent law officers of this State and the permanent senior officers of the Garda Síochána and accusing them of not administering the law in certain circumstances.

Comment on this

They are not being let. They asked for permission and you would not let them do it.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, I want your protection for this—their problem has been——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What about the camp in County Wicklow? It was there for weeks and the superintendent got orders not to arrest them when they knew they were there.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

The problem of the police authority of this State, the Garda Síochána, has been that sections of the existing Offences Against the State Act and the general law of this land in their view have not been effective enough in regard to the apprehension of the people whom Deputy FitzGerald hypocritically deplores should continue to be here. Deputy FitzGerald cannot have it both ways and Deputy Cooney cannot have it both ways. It is a fact that we have brought in this legislation on the advice of the senior police officers of the State and on the advice of the law officers of the State who have advised us that some of the existing sections of the Offences Against the State Act and some aspects of the general law of this land are not effective enough to enable us to deal properly with unlawful organisations as it is suggested we should deal with them and has been suggested we should deal with them by Deputy FitzGerald, by Deputy Cooney and by Deputy O'Brien for the past year.

Comment on this

What about the chief superintendent in Mullingar who sent up the names of four men who took out rifles and fired shots? He never was answered yet. The chief superintendent did his duty but the Government let him down. It was a political decision and you are afraid to act. Their photographs appeared on the paper. The chief superintendent sent up the names and said: "Here they are. When will we arrest them?" It is still on the files and you never answered him.

Comment on this

Answer him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is most disorderly. Will Deputy L'Estrange have some order?

Comment on this

They have stopped the Garda from doing their duty in the last three years. He said at meetings in Roscommon that it was all right for the IRA to continue as they were two years ago.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

That is not true.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

This particular amendment of the Offences Against the State Act has been introduced by the Government in order to deal with a situation where we were advised by our law officers and by the senior officers of the national police authority that the law as it stood was not effective enough in certain areas to deal with a problem with which Deputies opposite have been asking us to deal for the last two years.

Comment on this

What about the four men who fired shots over the graves? They appeared on television and a superintendent sent up the names and you never answered him.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

The suggestion made by Deputy FitzGerald and by Deputy Cooney that in some way we should explain the specific deficiencies in regard to sections of the Offences against the State Act and explain the deficiencies in the general law which led us to the introduction of this Bill is a highly irresponsible suggestion. We have no intention of telling the enemies of this State where our existing law is deficient in dealing with them.

Comment on this

You have given them succour for the last three years.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

But our law officers have examined these deficiencies, have taken the advice of the police officers of this State in regard to these deficiencies, in regard to the apprehension of the enemies of this State, and as a result of that advice this Bill emerges. That is the reason and the purpose of this Bill and that is the matter that really counts in this debate. Are the people opposite in the Labour Party and in Fine Gael willing to face up to the responsibility of dealing with this, willing to face up to the logical consequence of what many of them have been saying? There is no point in indulging in cant or hypocrisy and trying to run away from the situation which Deputies in the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party know well exist. We in Fianna Fáil are not going to——

Comment on this

For three years——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy L'Estrange refuses to obey the Chair I will ask him to leave the House.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Mr. B. Lenihan

The Government will not run away from this situation. The Government are facing up to the situation on the advice of their own law officers, on the advice of the national police authority, through the senior officers of the Garda Síochána. We are taking the necessary statutory action to remedy deficiencies that exist in regard to the apprehension of what people opposite have called the enemies of this State. When we seek to do something about it we meet hypocritical opposition, we meet double-talk and convoluted reasoning. We intend to go ahead and make this law.

Comment on this