Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972: Committee and Final Stages.
Contributions 1–246 of 500. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1972 ›
I am sorry if I appeared to infringe the rules of the House but I was under the impression that I was to be allowed to make a short statement and I should like to continue, if I may, that statement on section 1 which describes the Bill.
Fianna Fáil, as Deputy Blaney has admitted, created or helped to create the Provisional IRA and people concerned with that attempt are still prominent in the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
What we have been talking about over the last few days is free speech. That is all I look for.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach bears before history his share in that responsibility and I do not believe he can succeed in transferring that responsibility to any part of the Opposition or to any side in the Opposition.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the only point that is at issue in section 1 is whether or not it is proper to abbreviate, for the purposes of the Bill, the Offences against the State Act, 1939 to the Act of 1939. I respectfully submit to the Chair that the remarks so far made by Deputy Corish and likely to be continued to be made by him have no reference to this.
Comment on this
I must point out to Deputy Corish that we cannot have a general debate on section 1. The Deputy must relate his remarks to what is in the section.
Comment on this
I do not intend to talk at length. I merely want to make a statement on behalf of my party and this is the section on which I think I am entitled to do that.
Comment on this
On a point of order, section 1 clearly states:
In this Act "the Act of 1939" means the Offences against the State Act, 1939.
Deputy Corish is talking about the Offences against the State Act, 1939 in relation to this Act and nobody in this House can stop him from doing it.
Comment on this
We believe the Bill is unnecessary, unwarranted and unjustifiable. We will not be stampeded into voting for it because atrocities—we have deplored them and I still deplore them—are no excuse for bad law. We shall vote against it for the reasons that we have explained over the last three or four days. But we shall continue to support the application of the law against illegal organisations. I and my party have been consistent in that ever since the trouble started in the north of Ireland. We call on the Government to bring to justice the perpetrators of those atrocities and they could well do it under existing legislation if they had the will to do it.
Comment on this
They need no new drastic and excessive laws to do so. We found ourselves tonight, and knew we would find ourselves, in the lobbies with Deputies Blaney, Foley, Brennan and Sherwin. Our reasons for voting against this Bill and the reasons we adduced over the last three or four days are entirely different and opposite to the reasons why these four Deputies voted.
Comment on this
If the Deputy proceeds on these lines then I must allow every other Deputy to do the same.
Comment on this
If the last two sentences are also out of order I do not see how the Deputy can proceed.
Comment on this
You will not know until I say them, Sir. What we have consistently warned against now appears to be beginning in the southern part of this country and that is the backlash.
Comment on this
We cannot have a general debate on this section and that is what the Deputy is endeavouring to do.
Comment on this
Arising out of the preliminary part of Deputy Corish's statement I want to repudiate emphatically and utterly his allegations against this party, in trying to identify us with the Provisional IRA. The House, the Oireachtas and the country can weigh up Deputy Blaney's statements here this morning against his denials in this House in May, 1970 and can understand why I, the Government and the true and loyal members of the Fianna Fáil Party and organisation took certain decisions at that time.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 3, after subsection (2) to insert a new subsection as follows:—
"(3) Subsection (2) of this section shall be in force whenever and for so long only as Part V of the Act of 1939 is in force".
The purpose of this amendment is to apply the same limitation as exists in section 2 of this Bill to subsection (2) of section 3. Subsection (2) of section 3, under the amendment I propose, would be in force only while Part V of the 1939 Act was in force. This is a period following the making of a proclamation by the Government that a state of unrest exists in the country. The ordinary courts are not adequate in the circumstances. This will have the effect of allowing subsection (2) of section 3 to apply only in these times of serious unrest. I have considered that it is probably only fair to limit the periods of its application but I want to make it clear that this in no sense restricts it to any particular period of time in the calendar or chronological sense but it is restricting it to such period or periods of time in the future when this state of very serious unrest would exist.
Comment on this
In so far as the Minister's amendment seeks to limit the operation of this section it can be received without any great objection. However, in the opinion of this party it does not go far enough. When the House adjourned at 10 p.m. it was for the purpose of enabling discussions to take place between the Minister and spokesmen of the Labour Party and myself on the subjects of amendments. In the course of that discussion we indicated to him certain amendments which we regarded as important. I understood that adjournment took place in the spirit of the statement from this party with regard to our reasoned amendment on Second Stage.
We indicated the withdrawal of that reasoned amendment was being moved having regard to the terrible exigencies that now exist and in an effort to show our co-operation with the Government in the present national difficulty. It was in that spirit we withdrew our amendment. It was in that spirit of co-operation that we answered the Minister's invitation to discuss amendments to the Bill with him. Regrettably, the invitation was a hollow one because the Minister's attitude—if I might use a phrase from another part—was "not an inch".
We offered an amendment to section 3 (2). This is the subsection that has caused most controversy. I should like to remind the House that this is the subsection that permits an officer of the Garda Síochána not below the rank of chief superintendent to state his belief that an accused was at a material time a member of an unlawful organisation. It says that this statement shall be evidence that he was then such a member.
I can well conceive the motives which prompted the drafting of that section. I can well conceive the difficulties the gardaí might have in proving that fact. The type of person this section is aimed against is not the kind of person who will make evidence readily available, is not the type of person who will have incriminating documents in his possession, nor will he make voluntary admissions if he is in custody.
I concede that these difficulties inspired the drafting of this section but, even in a crisis situation, the section as drafted permits a person to be convicted of a serious criminal offence, and an even more serious political offence in this climate, on hearsay evidence of a garda officer. I do not impugn the integrity of the officer who will offer that evidence but I dispute the principle of introducing hearsay evidence without, in the same section, giving an accused a right to rebut it conclusively and absolutely.
The amendment which I had hoped the Minister would take from me read as follows:
On page 3, line 6, to add after the word "member"—
"provided however that the accused may on oath and without being liable to cross-examination deny the statement of the chief superintendent as aforesaid and such denial shall of itself be conclusive".
Bearing in mind that the evidence is hearsay and that the person giving it is a chief superintendent, should the defendant attempt to cross-examine the chief superintendent he will find himself met by the plea of privilege, a normal plea by a garda officer when he is asked for the sources of his information. In common justice the defendant should be put in the position where, if he makes a rebuttal on oath, that should be conclusive. If he is innocent he will not have any trouble in making the rebuttal on oath; if he is guilty he will fail to make this rebuttal and the evidence of the chief superintendent will be coercive.
The amendment was offered to the Minister in the spirit not in any way of damaging what he wanted to achieve but in the hope that it would restore some of the balance which should be in our legislation and in our courts but it was rejected. The amendment the Minister has offered —it is small but is acceptable—is to limit the time during which the section would operate. If the chief superintendent had other positive evidence other than his own hearsay, the rebuttal by the defendant would not be sufficient to excuse him from answering in cross-examination whatever facts might be adduced.
I should like to remind the House of the dangers of hearsay. Hearsay can come from fourth, fifth or sixth-hand and in its journey from the original source to the person giving the evidence it can become garbled. The status of the original information can become diminished in its progress through three or four persons. There is a lively possibility of mistake and equally there is the possibility of fraud if the originator of the information should be somebody wishing to work off a grudge. He might be a person of status using his status to work off a grudge and, when that grudge arrives on the desk of the chief superintendent, it becomes evidence that can come into a court of law.
In fairness this demands that the section should be softened by giving some rights to the accused. The minimum right he can and should have is the right to rebut on oath the hearsay evidence of the superintendent. In his opening statement the Minister alleged the courts would not necessarily take the evidence of the superintendent and that in any event it was not conclusive. The Minister knows as well as I do that if an officer of the status of chief superintendent is prepared to give evidence on oath of his belief and if that evidence is not controverted the court is coerced into accepting it. The Minister sought to suggest in his opening statement that this subsection merely extends the common law rules of evidence under which a witness's opinion as to a fact is admissible and he quotes the case of an expert witness.
Of course, that is a complete misstatement of the law. In that context a superintendent is not an expert witness. An expert witness is a doctor or engineer giving technical evidence in their particular field of work but a chief superintendent giving hearsay evidence of his belief that a person is guilty of a crime is not an expert witness in that sense. It is for these reasons and in the spirit in which we withdrew our amendment to the Second Stage that we put to the Minister that common justice demanded—and he could concede that demand without in any way taking from the efficiency of the Bill—that he accept our amendment.
Comment on this
It is not our intention to delay the House or go over what has been said previously in this debate. Very briefly, I would like to say that, as far as this party is concerned, with or without this amendment of the Minister's, we totally oppose this section. In particular, the acceptance of the evidence of the chief superintendent that "in his opinion" a person is a member of an illegal organisation is a total departure from the normal proceedings in any court held in a democratic country. We are greatly encouraged in our opposition to this section by the wide variety and numbers of people who have also indicated their objection to it, people who by no stretch of the imagination could be called Provisional or Official IRA or members of any illegal or subversive organisation or people who could be classified as those who would support or defend the aims of any illegal or subversive organisation.
We in this party are extremely conscious of the great difficulties this country is in, and we have deplored violence since it first became a reality in any part of the country in the campaign since 1969. We still deplore it and our opposition to this Bill is based on one thing and one thing only: we are perfectly satisfied that there is sufficient and adequate legislation already passed by this House.
Comment on this
That cannot be discussed on the amendment. We are discussing the amendment by the Minister.
Comment on this
I agree, but the amendment is to amend a section of the Bill to which we object. I cannot talk on the amendment without relating it to the section which it seeks to amend.
Comment on this
Surely under the Rules of the House I am entitled to do both, that when we come to the section I would also be entitled to make a speech referring to the section.
Comment on this
It is not my intention or desire to come into conflict with the Chair to delay the House. I just want to make it perfectly clear what our opposition to this Bill is based on. It is based on our firm belief that the Government already have adequate legislation if they only had the political will to use it consistently.
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy Cooney, this section permits evidence to be admitted only and does not in any way interfere with the accused's right to rebut that evidence. Deputy Cooney said specifically, if I heard him properly, that the accused did not have the right to go in and swear to the contrary. Of course he has that right.
Comment on this
He most certainly has that right. As well as that, he has the right to cross-examine the chief superintendent as to his information and as to the source or nature of his information. He further has the right to call other witnesses besides himself to rebut the evidence of the chief superintendent. What the chief superintendent has said is evidence only; the court is not in any sense compelled to accept it and the whole question of whether or not the accused is a member of an illegal organisation is to be decided by the court not simply on the basis of what the chief superintendent swears but on the basis of all the evidence and, in particular, on the basis of the cross-examination.
It may interest the House to know that since February this year there have been 30 prosecutions in our courts for membership of an unlawful organisation. In only three of those cases has a conviction been secured and I think at least one of those three is well known, and the rather laborious method by which the conviction was obtained is well known, and I think this is indicative of the difficulties which there are in proving an offence under section 21.
It should further be borne in mind that not alone must the court take all evidence put before it either by the prosecution or by the defence into account, but it must be satisfied beyond all reasonable doubt that the man was in fact a member. If the defendant can raise any sort of reasonable doubt at all, even quite a small degree of doubt, in the minds of the court, whether it is judge or jury, then that court must acquit him.
Comment on this
Is it a fact that only the Minister, the "Shadow Ministers" in Fine Gael and Labour can propose amendments to this Bill? I raise the matter on the basis that I assume that every Member of this House has an opportunity to propose any amendment to this legislation. It is indicative of the panic measures that the Government are trying——
Comment on this
How can you say, a Cheann Comhairle, we had an opportunity to propose amendments to this legislation—not, indeed, that any amendment could change its character——
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I want to ascertain what the Minister's intention is when he provides under section 4 (1) (a):
Any public statement made orally, in writing or otherwise, or any meeting...
What is meant by "otherwise"? As far as I can gather you can make a statement orally or in writing. I wonder what does "otherwise" mean? Can we take it that the Minister is trying to ensure that, if a dumb person happens to be involved in any incident and uses dumb language, his gestures in doing so can be classified as "otherwise" under this section? I should like the Minister to explain this to me because I fail to understand what "otherwise" means. Is Harvey Smith's famous gesture at a function not too long ago "otherwise"? Could he be convicted for making that gesture? If I had time, or if I were allowed, or if I were given some facility as a novice Member of the House, I should like to put down an amendment to section 4. I should like to add a paragraph (c) reading, "that this section is also binding on all persons, including Government Ministers". Section 4 (1) (a) reads:
Any public statement made orally, in writing or otherwise, or any meeting, procession or demonstration in public, that constitutes an interference with the course of justice shall be unlawful.
As I mentioned on Second Reading, the Tánaiste went on television in 1970 and was clearly in breach of this section. Indeed, he was in breach of the existing law. He used words which had the effect of accusing two ex-Ministers of the Government of being conspirators at a time before they were brought to trial. The Minister should add my proposed paragraph (c) to the section so that in the future the Tánaiste or any other Minister would not be permitted to go on television and do what he did in May, 1970.
Comment on this
I had an amendment drafted to substitute a new paragraph (b) in subsection (1). I will not bore the House by reading it because the Minister has made quite clear his attitude to amendments or to the spirit of co-operation offered by this party. We should not be surprised, although it is to be regretted in the circumstances of the present situation, that arrogant politics should be played with a loyal Opposition.
Subsection (b)—as the Minister well knows, is drafted to interfere with the institution of civil proceedings. It is puzzling to see the words "civil proceedings" mentioned in a Bill entitled an Act to amend and extend the Offences Against the State Acts. During the debate on our reasoned amendment I gave an example of how the Bill, as drafted, could inhibit proper agitation for the commencement of justifiable civil proceedings. The Minister knows well that that danger is there but, in his failure or refusal to co-operate, he is prepared to let a Bill go through which is patently bad and which contains law which he admits is bad. I look forward to the Supreme Court correcting it.
Comment on this
What I have to say has nothing to do with the Bill. When I came to the door it was opened and I was refused admittance.
Comment on this
Deputy Cooney's suggestion would seem to constrict the operation of the section very considerably indeed. It would fail to embrace people who would seek to pressurise an authority or person concerned with the institution of proceedings against instituting those proceedings. If the words suggested by Deputy Cooney to be omitted were omitted, it would mean that demonstrations, pickets and so, designed to compel either the Attorney General or the Garda Síochána from instituting proceedings would, in fact, be lawful or at least not unlawful under the section and, of course, such demonstrations at the moment are clearly contempt of court and that is why they are included in this section.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister why he insists on retaining the words "civil proceedings" in the section? This is a criminal statute, why make it a criminal offence to mount a campaign for the redress of a wrong that can be redressed by civil proceedings? Why make that a criminal offence? If the Minister has in mind picketing in pursuance of a dispute that is not a trade dispute within the strict meaning of the Trade Disputes Act, that is covered by the Conspiracy Act of 1875.
Comment on this
There are a great many quasi-criminal prosecutions, such as prosecutions under Fisheries Acts and other similar ones. These are regarded as civil proceedings. Any summary summons other than by the State or statutory authority is regarded as civil proceedings and, of course, there are several different types of purely civil proceedings in the institution of proceedings in which certain subversive groups would try to undermine or try to pressure to prevent proceedings and, of course, the most obvious type is an ejectment proceedings.
Comment on this
If the Minister has in mind summary proceedings of a quasi-criminal type, as he calls them, it would be a simple matter to amend the Bill by deleting the word "civil" and putting in "summary of criminal proceedings". Then we would be quite clear what he means.
Comment on this
If a man has a civil right to damages, in my opinion, it is the law, at the moment, in contempt of court that it is wrong that he should be pressured by some group of persons from exercising his right. It is public policy that people should be encouraged to exercise their rights in court so that disputes will be solved or agreed in court rather than in any other fashion.
Comment on this
Of course, it is proper public policy that people should be in that position but, does the Minister not realise that the section as drafted can cause these people to be prosecuted? It is becoming farcical.
Comment on this
It can cause people to be prosecuted who seek to restrain someone from exercising his lawful rights. I do not see anything wrong with that.
Comment on this
Or would seek to encourage someone. The section deals with any proceedings that can have any influence in any court. If somebody seeks to influence a person to commence very proper civil proceedings— I quote the example if a newspaper campaign were launched to encourage proceedings against the purveyors of dangerous drugs such as thalidomide —that person would be committing a criminal offence under this section.
Comment on this
I want to raise one point with the Minister for Justice on this. I cannot claim to have any legal knowledge but I have been listening to the legal men exchanging views on this Bill.
Comment on this
Especially in relation to this section. I want some form of undertaking from the Minister. I am afraid of every section of the Bill but I am particularly afraid of section 4.
Comment on this
Yes, Sir. Section 4 states:
Any public statement made orally, in writing or otherwise, or any meeting, procession or demonstration in public, that constitutes an interference with the course of justice shall be unlawful.
I want to have a guarantee from the Minister for Justice that in the case of a responsible group of landowners, farmers or town tenants who feel they have a serious problem in connection with the payment of what they consider to be an unjust tax or an unjust rate and if they are charged before the courts for it, they will be exempt from the provisions of this Bill if they demonstrate outside the courthouse, if they speak or if they picket a local authority office.
This section gives extraordinarily wide powers, not alone in relation to offences against the State; the Minister for Justice and the Government, if they so wish, could twist the terms of this Bill to suit any emergency that is likely to arise. I should like to hear from the Minister if he can give a guarantee that there will not be a state of affairs such as we had some years ago when a peaceful demonstration of farmers ended by the farmers finding themselves in jail. I want the Minister to give the House an assurance that the citizens will have the right to protest, to march and to demonstrate peacefully so as to expose possible injustice, that the public will be entitled to express an opinion and that that will apply also to speakers on their behalf, either Members of this House, local authorities or others who support the exposure of what are believed to be genuine grievances. I would not like to see, under this Bill, any restrictions on peaceful demonstrations by the public.
In relation to trade unions, in relation to organisations far removed from the illegal organisations the Bill is supposed to cover, the Bill could be used by the State in an effort to prevent the free expression of opinion, free speech and peaceful protest.
I want to make it quite clear that I have no respect for violence or violent men. I have condemned violence. I condemned it yesterday. I condemn it now. I want to maintain and I ask the House to cherish, the rights of citizens to protest loudly, clearly and determinedly without fear of being dragged into prison for doing so. If a citizen feels that he has been harshly treated by the courts, that penalties or fines have been too severe, or if it is proven beyond doubt that the law has been unjust in dealing with citizens, there must be some means whereby the citizen can be protected against the provisions laid down in a Bill of this kind.
I am concerned about any infringement of the right of peaceful protest and peaceful demonstration and the right of free speech, the right to make known a grievance and to solicit support in redressing grievance, in a peaceful and law abiding manner. The citizen cannot do it in a peaceful and law abiding manner if the terms of this Bill are implemented. That is why I am so terribly afraid of this Bill.
Comment on this
I am on section 4. Where we have had no cause to complain in relation to public statements, in writing or otherwise——
Comment on this
I am very sorry. I realise it is the early hours of the morning. It is of vital importance to safeguard the individual rights of citizens. This House should be very slow to allow those rights to be whittled away. I should like to have an assurance from the Minister, that this section will not diminish the right of peaceful protest far removed from offences against the State but which could be brought before the court, by order of the Minister, as an offence against the State. I want to preserve the right of free speech, free demonstration and peaceful protest whether it is a trade union or organised farmers or town tenants who are involved. If you like to include women's lib in that, they also should have the right. I would like to have greater assurances from the Minister on this section.
Comment on this
I am aware of that, Sir, but a good thing cannot be repeated often enough. I am worried about taking away the rights of citizens and that is why I have had such a dread of this Bill since reading it first, especially in relation to section 4 which, in my opinion, could be used by Members of this House, for instance, and could be used generally by the Government in muzzling those who might not agree with them. I wish to safeguard my rights——
Comment on this
——as a public representative so that I may be able to expose grievances on the part of my constituents.
Comment on this
No matter how often Deputy Flanagan has said it, it is still true that the manner in which section 4 of this Bill is worded means that it can be used against a large number of people or bodies who are not subversive and who never have been subversive but who are an irritation to the present Government.
Comment on this
Any answers or assurances that the Minister may give to Deputy Flanagan as to whom this Bill will or will not be used against are useless because, so far as the courts are concerned, all they will apply their minds to is what is contained in the Bill. In this instance any assurances from the Minister are of even less use than the normal assurances we get from Fianna Fáil Ministers. This Bill is worded deliberately so as to allow the Minister at some future date, if he so desires, to move against organisations that are in no way subversive but which are an embarrassment to the Government. For instance, in its present form, the Bill could be used against NATO, a body that is very much a source of embarrassment to Fianna Fáil. It could be used against such an association as ACRA if at any time they should decide they had enough in respect of the health charges being levied on the rates and if they should decide to hold meetings to discuss what action they might take.
It could be used against the NFA, for example. In fact such legislation was used against that body despite assurances by a Fianna Fáil Minister at the time of the introduction of the relevant Bill that it would not be used against any such body.
The Bill is drafted in a way that would give the most sweeping powers that any democratically elected Government have ever sought in a democratic Parliament. For those reasons we are opposed totally to it. The Bill is not necessary to deal with the IRA and other illegal organisations. There is already adequate legislation for that. The Bill can be used to give widespread powers to a Minister at his discretion, and is there any sane person who is not able to interpret what is meant by a Fianna Fáil Minister's discretion? It means nothing less than Fianna Fáil's political advantage at any particular time.
I know it is normal on Committee Stage for Deputies to question, to probe and to try to reach agreement; but in our case we are stating, that the Bill is totally unacceptable to us because it is not necessary for the purpose for which we are being told it is necessary.
We do not intend questioning and probing during this Committee Stage because we know that any such exercise would be useless in this instance. Fine Gael, too, should know it would be useless to do so at this stage. They have tried to co-operate with the Government, tried to do what in their conscience they thought they had to do, but we are opposing the Bill in the only effective way——
Comment on this
We are opposing this section of the Bill and opposing the Bill in general in the only effective way possible, that is, by going into the Lobbies to vote against it.
Comment on this
I am sorry that the Minister is not here to explain why the existing provisions of section 27 of the Offences Against the State Act are not sufficient to deal with the problem proposed to be dealt with in section 4 as proposed. Under section 27 of the Offences Against the State Act there is power to prohibit a public meeting on behalf of or by arrangement or in concert with any unlawful organisation or which is held or purports to be held for the purpose of supporting any unlawful organisation.
While section 4 refers to different aims and different purposes it seems to me that section 27 was adequate, particularly as section 7 of the Act of 1939 makes it an offence to intimidate or obstruct the judiciary or the courts. I do not understand why section 4 has been deemed necessary and I would like some explanation from the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister for Justice has asked me to explain to the House and to apologise for his not being able to be here. He has had to leave for the moment because he is joining the Taoiseach at a meeting with the Commissioner of the Garda Síochána and the Chief-of-Staff of the Army in connection with securty measures.
In regard to the arguments that have been made on this section, the short answer is that the section enacts in statutory form what is the present law under the common law in relation to contempt of court. That is what it is doing.
Comment on this
That is not so. This is putting into statutory form, for reasons which the Minister explained, on an earlier Stage, what the law is at present.
Comment on this
I am not concerned whether the Minister intends to argue but I assert that he cannot be serious. This is a section which, in effect, prohibits meetings or processions held for a specific purpose. Already in our legislation, combining sections 7 and 27 of the Offences Against the State Act, this prohibition appears to be there. I ask the Minister reasonably why this proposed section should be totally necessary. It has nothing to do with contempt of court or anything like that. Even at this late hour I suggest the Minister ought to get a grip of himself. Is it the position that nobody can reasonably explain to Dáil Éireann why section 4 is necessary?
Comment on this
The Minister is talking utter rubbish and it is perfectly clear that he has not even read the section much less understand it. It is a disgraceful way to treat Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
So far as section 4 re-enacts the law on contempt it is not clear why it is necessary if the law is there already. Some reason must be given why the law of contempt is inadequate in its present form and needs statutory enactment. That has not been explained, because by definition, that attempted explanation explains nothing.
Secondly, I would like the Minister, if he has recovered from his fit of pique to tell us under what circumstances at any time in the past a person has been found guilty of contempt for attending a meeting or procession. I have no recollection of any such thing happening at any stage. Perhaps that is my ignorance. If the Minister is prepared now to discuss the matter and has recovered from his momentary attack, or whatever it was, would he give us some example to validate his statement?
Comment on this
I regret that the Minister for Justice has left the Dáil Chamber because I wonder if he has forgotten what I said earlier. I asked what the meaning of "otherwise" was in section (1) (a) which says:
"any such statement made orally, in writing or otherwise,".
Can we find out from the Government what precisely "otherwise" means? So far as my understanding of making a statement goes you can make it either orally or in writing. Is the word "otherwise" included to get at a person who has not the power of speech but would speak in sign language? Will this language, to be interpreted as a statement to interfere with the course of justice, be under the heading of "otherwise"? Perhaps the chief superintendent, when he is trying to arrive at a conviction, is able to interpret a person's dreams. Has he the power of mental telepathy so that he can ascertain what a person is thinking? Is that what "otherwise" means?
Comment on this
If this Bill goes through surely there will be no danger of a further 77 executions.
Comment on this
Can we take it that the Minister cannot explain to me what "otherwise" means or is this only part of the arrogance of the Government that they are not prepared to give an explanation to the public? I speak on behalf of my constituents and I want to know what "otherwise" means.
Comment on this
How can the Minister answer my question by saying, in his opinion, the public have had enough? Is it enough of the arrogance of the Government? I must insist that the Minister explain in the context of section 4 (1) (a) what the word "otherwise" means.
Comment on this
Does this section imply that standing in a crowd at a meeting renders one culpable of guilt by association with the purposes for which this meeting is taking place? Next week Father Austin Flannery is taking part in a meeting protesting against this Bill, which, with a degree of collective hypocrisy, we are rushing through this House tonight. Will Father Flannery be accused of irritating the Government?
Comment on this
There is no charge provided in this Bill of irritating the Government. Maybe the Deputy does not know it but I will give him that information.
Comment on this
I can only interpret that the Minister for Finance, on behalf of the Minister for Justice, cannot explain to me what "otherwise" means.
Comment on this
I have asked the question but I have not got an answer to it. Can a statement made in the USA, the Six Counties, Britain, China or anywhere else be interpreted as interference with the course of justice under this subsection? Deputy Cooney earlier made a statement which, I feel, refers directly to section 4.
Comment on this
I want to show how this statement relates to section 4. I am not exactly quoting Deputy Cooney. He said that tragic events have overtaken Parliament and anxious that the Fine Gael amendment, if supported by those Members of the House known as the dissidents and now revealed——
Comment on this
On a point of order the debate has not concluded. We are waiting for a reply from a Minister. If this Minister is not competent to reply could some other Minister be sent in to reply?
Comment on this
The Chair is dealing with Deputy Sherwin who is irrelevant to the point in question. He has been told that.
Comment on this
It is not my business to rule whether or not a Deputy is out of order. I would suggest if he is that you deal with him but not curtail the discussion on this Bill.
Comment on this
I have tried to indicate, and I would like to continue indicating, how this statement is relevant to section 4.
Comment on this
On section 4, if I have not the opportunity, as a member of a constituted party in this House, to deny that I am in any way related to the IRA——
Comment on this
I would like to move to the point I made earlier on to the Minister for Justice. Will this subsection be binding on all persons, including Government Ministers? Are Ministers of the Cabinet and members of Fianna Fáil above the law? Will this section be applicable to Government Ministers who make statements to prejudice court cases?
Comment on this
I have already told the House that this is a statutory enactment of what is the existing law under common law in relation to contempt of court.
Comment on this
I am interjecting and I am doing as Deputy Tully does frequently. He sits in his seat when he is interjecting. The Minister for Justice explained all this and the reasons for it on the Second Stage. I have said all this before and I am not going to go back over all that ground, and Deputy FitzGerald can say as much as he likes about not being answered. That is what I said before and I am telling him again.
Comment on this
Could I ask the Minister if section 4 creates an absolute offence?
Comment on this
Where in it is the expression to give intent in regard to subsection (2)?
Comment on this
If a person takes part in a meeting, he is guilty of an offence, full stop.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This House has facilitated the Government tonight in relation to this Bill, and if I might say so, has rightly facilitated the Government, but, in those circumstances, the Minister and the Government should co-operate with the House. Normally there is a lapse of a week or more between the Second Stage of a Bill and the Committee Stage and it is possible for Members to put down amendments and have them discussed. I fully appreciate that the Minister for Justice is unavoidably out of the House and that the Minister for Finance is at somewhat of a disadvantage, but this is unusual legislation and legislation which should be explained when a reasonable request is made. It is not my purpose nor this party's purpose to stand up for members who are not in this party but I would like to stand up for the supremacy of Parliament we have been talking about over the past few days. A reasonable request has been made for an explanation of the meaning of “otherwise” in section 4 (1) (a) and it is not unreasonable that an explanation should be given or should be attempted to be given of what exactly is meant by it. I think I know, but the House may not know and it is the business of the Minister in charge of the Bill to explain it.
Comment on this
Could I ask a very simple question on section 4, Part 2? I cannot remember if the Minister for Finance is one of the many failed barristers on those benches but perhaps he would let us know what does "takes part in" mean in that section. It reads: "Any person who makes any statement or who organises, holds or takes part in any meeting...". Does "passing by", "standing", "listening", "clapping" mean that he takes part in? Would the Minister please tell us what "takes part in" means?
Comment on this
I wonder could the Minister get some advice on this because it is a quite serious point— the point raised by Deputy Thornley as to "takes part in any meeting". I can imagine a situation in which there is a procession or a meeting and any Deputy or any member of our families may find himself part of that meeting, accidentally or as a curious onlooker or as an observer. I have occasionally gone to Fianna Fáil meetings to see how many were there and I am sure the Minister has done the same. Do I take part in the meeting? The Minister says that mens rea is necessary, that is, guilty intention.
Comment on this
Of course it is not and the Deputy knows that it does not need to be. Unless it is written in to the contrary, it applies as part of the general law.
Comment on this
I am amazed and I am learning new law every day. That is a most extraordinary statement. I would have thought——
Comment on this
On a point of order, this is a most serious piece of legislation. It is most controversial and——
Comment on this
I have a certain amount of sympathy with the Minister. It is quite obvious that the Minister for Finance does not know the first thing about the Bill——
Comment on this
It is a point of order that the House cannot get the information on the Bill to which it is entitled because the Minister is not competent to give it. I suggest that the House should adjourn until the appropriate Minister is available.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins gets up here and says that because it is not written into this section mens rea must apply and then a person can be guilty under this, even though he has not a guilty intent. Why does he not say that about the other sections? I will tell you —because he knows as well as I do that it does not need to be written in, that it is there under the general law. We have all this nonsense going on here, with people trying to question what is the existing law. I told the House that was the position and Deputies want me to explain what the existing law is. I do not intend to go along with this kind of codology which is designed to retrieve to some extent the shattered political fortunes of the parties opposite.
Comment on this
May I make one comment, Sir? You and the Ceann Comhairle have been very quick to tell us that we were not on the Bill or on the section. This thing had better be applied a little more impartially. The point that is being made, and not being made in a political way but because we are in a very serious situation and this is a very serious matter we are discussing after one o'clock in the morning, is that through no fault of his, the Minister does not understand what this Bill is about. I suggest that, in the interests of whatever democracy we are going to have left when this is passed, this House should be adjourned until the Minister for Justice is available I am not criticising him for not being here; I realise that he is engaged on a most important job at the moment. I am only asking that, to ensure that this House and parliamentary democracy are left with some credibility, the House should adjourn until a Minister who is competent is able to answer the legitimate queries which Deputies raise.
Comment on this
I support Deputy Cluskey, and I am not going to make any comment on what the Minister for Finance has said because I think he must be tired like the rest of us, but we have a facility in the Opposition of retaining our common sense——
Comment on this
I support the proposition that the House adjourn until someone from the Government who knows something about the Bill can come along to assist us.
Comment on this
The Chair cannot accept a proposition like that. The question is that the section stand part.
Comment on this
I clearly understand that this is an amendment to the Offences against the State Act, 1939 but may I take it for an absolute fact that section 4 and any subsection of it only refers to statements et cetera made within the jurisdiction or could any such statement take place outside the jurisdiction and still be held to be interference with the course of justice?
Comment on this
Now that the Minister has returned, may I ask him what "or otherwise" means in this section?
Comment on this
We are concerned about the use of the words "orally, in writing or otherwise". Is that television, broadcasting or what?
Comment on this
I understand it is expressing assent with views, by nodding or some such other gesture showing that you agree with the views.
Comment on this
Deputy Thornley a few moments ago raised the possibility of a person who happened to be passing by, stood for a few moments and happened to clap at a meeting of an organisation or any public meeting. I now understand from the Minister that if an innocent bystander happened to clap he could be found guilty under this subsection.
Comment on this
I have told the Deputy that one must have guilty intent under this so why is he making that argument?
Comment on this
(Cavan): In the absence of the Minister for Justice the meaning of the words “or otherwise” was raised. On his return he has said, as I understand it, that this means nodding assent or something like that. If that is so it is going a very long way and it is creating an offence that might be very difficult to interpret, might be very easy to prove and might put an accused person in an extremely difficult position. I want to be more than reasonable with the Minister and I do not want to treat this lightly but this Bill must go to Seanad Éireann before it reaches the Statute Book and I invite the Minister for Justice to consider seriously the meaning of the words “or otherwise” and to explain them to the House and if they mean something so ingloriously vague, as the Minister's interjection would suggest, I appeal to him with all the sincerity at my command to have second thoughts about them.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister for Finance should keep out of this because he is in bad humour and I find the Minister for Justice sometimes reasonable enough.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I would ask the Minister for Justice to tell us clearly what “or otherwise” means. If it means something as vague as nodding assent I appeal to him to have second thoughts about it between now and this Bill going to the Seanad.
Comment on this
At the risk of interrupting the Minister for Finance who has now yielded place to the legal expert of the Fianna Fáil Party, the Minister for Justice, could I reinforce the point made by Deputy Sherwin and Deputy Fitzpatrick? What does "or otherwise" mean and what does "taking part in" mean? Is simply passing by enough? Does this infer guilt by association at a meeting? I must apologise to Deputy Fitzpatrick. I do not know what mens rea means.
Comment on this
It sounds like a football team to me. I have sat the last examination I ever intend to sit, I do not have to be a candidate for further examination and I do not intend ever to undertake the practice of law so I do not apologise for not knowing what mens rea means but I would like to know what “or otherwise” means and what “taking part in” means. I would like this explained to me in simple layman's terms by the Minister for Justice.
Comment on this
The section reads:
Any public statement made orally, in writing or otherwise.
The only word that is left out is "mentally". He will be committing an offence almost in thought. Would the Minister not be prepared to drop the words "or otherwise"? Are these words to capture say the tick tack man one sees at the races, somebody who communicates by sign? If dumb people start expressing views it will be taken by the gardaí that they are participating in an illegal act. It could also include a wink of the eye or a nod. I do not want to get involved in the exchanges between legal men here because I am neither capable nor competent but I Judge this Bill from the point of view of the ordinary Joe Soap down the country. I want to safeguard him.
If all the things I have mentioned are to be taken as offences I think this House, though it is in the early hours of the morning, is engaged in a worthwhile exercise. A wink of the eye, a nod of the head or a sign are all included under "or otherwise". Deputy Kitt is laughing. He is laughing because he has the State car for Christmas. He was not laughing earlier in the day. If this Bill was bad this morning it is bad tonight because it has not changed. I want to know in what circumstances the citizens of this country are to be hamstrung by this Bill, tied up and perhaps imprisoned under the heading of "or otherwise". If I can not get a satisfactory explanation, I would recommend to the Minister that he should drop the words "or otherwise".
Comment on this
I am puzzled about one point. How can one apply a guilty mental state to an action that is unspecified? Can the Minister explain how he can apply a mental attitude to something non-specified?
Comment on this
I understand Deputy Flanagan is an auctioneer. I do not know if Members are aware of the way bids are given at an auction. To me the word "otherwise" means just otherwise. This is only a gimmick to hold up the proceedings here.
Comment on this
I should like to emphasise this is not a frivolous matter despite all the laughs and smiles of the people on the other side. The Minister for Finance said that the question of intent to do something illegal is necessary in this context but I should like to read section 4 (1) (a) which states:
Any public statement made orally, in writing or otherwise, or any meeting, procession or demonstration in public, that constitutes an interference with the course of justice shall be unlawful.
Can the Minister explain how a person can show intent or how can it be shown by the chief superintendent that he showed intent by way of a gesture or otherwise, as is set out in this section?
Comment on this
What was the reason for including the words "or otherwise"? Surely the legal advisers to the Minister have given some reasons why they consider these words are necessary?
Comment on this
There are two types of offences known to the law. There is what is known as an absolute offence and that is usually stated in bald terms, namely, to do a certain thing shall be unlawful. There is the other type of offence and it is one for which a guilty intention is inspired. For example, the offence of larceny is committed only when a person has the intention of depriving permanently the owner of the object stolen. That is what the phrase "mens rea” means. The Minister for Finance has suggested that in this section in order to commit the offence it is necessary to have an intention but I dispute this. Section 4 (1) (a) states any public statement that constitutes an interference with the course of justice shall be unlawful. However, section 4 (1) (b) states:
A statement, meeting, procession or demonstration shall be deemed to constitute an interference with the course of justice if it is intended,
——that requires intent, but it goes further because it states:
or is of such a character as to be likely,
——there is no intent required there——
directly or indirectly to influence any court,.
section 4 (2) states that a person who makes any statement or who organises, holds or takes part in any meeting that is unlawful under the section shall be guilty of an offence. This very badly-drafted section provides that if this mythical "otherwise", whatever it might mean, which might directly or indirectly influence any court is carried out irrespective of the intent of the person who performs this "otherwise" he has committed an offence and that is the end of the matter. It is nonsense to say this section can come into operation only where there is guilty intent.
Comment on this
There are two separate issues here. First, there is the issue which has not been resolved to the satisfaction of this side of the House as to whether there is a legal principle applicable to a section like this which requires and implies that mens rea must be involved. The Minister has asserted this but he has not given us any legal authority for it and on this side of the House there are genuine doubts as to whether what he has said is correct, whether, in fact, mens rea applies——
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot make that argument here if he does not make it on other sections also. Why did he not make that point on the other sections?
Comment on this
In the other sections the matters raised are not ones which are capable of innocent or guilty interpretation depending upon mens rea. In this section there is the danger of someone doing something innocent, perhaps he takes part in a meeting——
Comment on this
Is the Deputy suggesting that in any section in any Bill dealing with a criminal offence in which it does not specify that mens rea is necessary, that in such a case mens rea is not necessary? Is that what the Deputy is saying?
Comment on this
The Minister knows that when mens rea is intended in a Bill, the Bill is so drafted as to provide for intent. This is drafted so that absolute offences can be committed under the section.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to explain the legal principle which involves mens rea in this instance of a statute dealing with something not inherently wrong, for instance, taking part in a meeting. If the Minister will tell me what is this principle and the authority for it and if he can reassure me that what he has said is not just an ex cathedra statement, and that there is genuine authority for it I am prepared to accept that.
Comment on this
In the English criminal law—and for better or worse our law is based on English criminal law—mens rea must always be proved. Unless it is specifically excluded, it is assumed.
Comment on this
If I forgot to pay my premium for my car insurance and if a garda stops me and I cannot produce an up-to-date certificate, will the Minister give me a guarantee that the district justice——
Comment on this
I will remind the Minister I could be sent to jail for six months. That seems to be somewhat criminal.
Comment on this
We have now reached the stage where a number of questions have been asked. The Ministers, knowing they cannot be beaten on a vote because of a guarantee given, are meeting this matter with a complete arrogance and could not care less——
Comment on this
I agree it is farcical because no matter how many questions are asked on legal matters or otherwise no reply will be given other than the replies which have been given. I think it is a waste of time——
Comment on this
I will ask the Minister one further question in regard to this section and I should be obliged if he would reply in some detail. Has the Minister considered the constitutional implications of this section?
Comment on this
The Minister's reply does not satisfy me because we have established that in respect of part of the criminal law—because if you are sent to gaol for something it is part of the criminal law, not the civil law—mens rea does not apply and is not required. There are some cases where it is required and others where it is not. What is the distinguishing legal principle? The Minister must answer the question and not try——
Comment on this
There are three lawyers beside the Deputy who told him I was wrong in each thing I said, so he would be more likely to get what he would consider the correct answer from one or other or all three beside him.
Comment on this
This is a serious matter. If there is something wrong about this matter we want to put it right. The Minister is not entitled to treat the House with levity, as he has done. It has been pointed out to him that there are statutes, for instance, the Road Traffic Acts, where mens rea is not required. It is excluded there but it is included here. The Minister is not entitled to treat my request for an answer with contempt.
Comment on this
That is a specific statutory offence. This is part of the criminal law; the other is not.
Comment on this
Is the Minister seriously suggesting that if I am sent to gaol under the Road Traffic Act, that is part of the civil law?
Comment on this
The Minister did not say that. Deputy FitzGerald should know by now that this is a very old, basic question for a student of law, and the Deputies beside him, who are lawyers, know exactly what the position is, and this carry-on is a facade and a farce.
Comment on this
It is because I have listened to them and think there is some reason in what they say that I am asking the question. The fact that the Minister for Justice is not answering is disturbing.
Comment on this
It is not my function to instruct Deputies in the law. If they want that they can go to a law school.
Comment on this
The Minister has made an assertion that mens rea is necessarily required as this is part of the criminal law. It has been pointed out that this is not the case in respect of another statute. If the Minister fails to answer the question, the only conclusion I can come to as an ordinary fair-minded person is that he is wrong and the Deputies on this side of the House are right.
Comment on this
Is there any control over the behaviour of Ministers in this House who have been treating us with contempt?
Comment on this
When we have completed the debate on it, Sir. It is quite clear mens rea does not apply here and, therefore, this section as drafted puts an innocent person in jeopardy; secondly, on the question of “or otherwise”, the Minister says “if somebody nodded”, that is what “or otherwise” is meant to cover. If somebody at a meeting says something which in some way could influence the course of justice and any member of the audience nods to that, he is, therefore, liable to be sent to gaol for a term of imprisonment of five years.
Comment on this
It seems to me we are doing something very strange here. If a person who nods to assent to a statement, and if it is mens rea because he intends to assent to a statement which can be shown in the court to be equivalent to contempt of court, he gets five years in gaol. That seems excessive treatment for a person at a public meeting who nods to assent to a proposition which he may not have the legal sense to realise is in contempt of court. Would the Minister not agree that is going too far and that it is possible to deal with the IRA and other illegal organisations effectively without giving five years to somebody who nods at a public meeting?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I know I will not get an answer but I want to go on record as saying that I do not accept the proposition that unless mens rea is written into a statutory offence it is not necessary. I want to take the Minister for Justice back for a moment to the Road Traffic Act, particularly to the section of it which deals with dangerous driving causing death. That section says that anybody who drives a car or motor vehicle in a dangerous manner thereby causing the death of another person shall be guilty of an indictable offence for which he can be tried before a judge and jury and for which he can be sentenced to a lengthy term of imprisonment. If what the Minister is saying is correct, the wording would be: “anybody who knowingly or with intent drives a vehicle dangerously”. There is nothing like that in the Act. Therefore, I say that anybody who innocently attends a meeting is guilty of an offence even if he only happened to be passing the meeting and decided to pull up to see what was going on. I think that calls for an explanation. I know it is not going to be given, but I want to go on record as saying it.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
Under paragraph (a) of section 5, would the Minister consider excluding the map of Ireland? It refers to any map, plan, graph or drawing. On Second Stage it was clearly indicated to the Minister that it is pretty normal for any person travelling throughout this State to have a map of Ireland in his possession or in his dashboard. It is not inconceivable that this person, no matter what organisation he belongs to, or otherwise, may have certain markings or pencillings on that map and, for the convenience of the chief superintendent, or whoever might be giving evidence, if he has failed to get anything else, he may use a map of Ireland in the possession of this man in his car as evidence to be brought before the court.
It is not inconceivable that the chief superintendent could construct some form of statement that this map was used by this person in his activities as alleged by the chief superintendent. I gather that when the Minister includes "any map" he means a detailed map of a section of the country, or a building, or otherwise. Would he consider excluding a map of Ireland so that every person travelling throughout Ireland who has a map will not be in fear or dread that he will be hauled in and brought before the special courts on the basis of having an ordinary map in his possession?
With regard to paragraphs (c) and (d) would the Minister withdraw the word "tape" as defined as a "document"? It is known to every member of this House that it is not unknown to suggest that tapes might be altered. Tapes can be tampered with and jockeyed around and can have voices added to them, to try to bring evidence before the court. With regard to bugging devices producing a sound track of events or happenings within a building which the Special Branch wish to take a sound track from, again it is not inconceivable that in wrong hands a tape or a sound track can be tampered with. Seán Mac Stiofáin objected recently in the courts as to the admissibility of a tape recording. He suggested very strongly that the tape should not be left in the hands of the Special Branch but should be handed over to the custody of the courts in case it might be interfered with. To my knowledge a tape recording has never been admissible evidence. We have seen what a tape recording can do. We have seen what the sacking of the RTE Authority can do.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to withdraw the word "tape" from the definition of "document". To refer back to the map, does the Minister not consider that any person who happens to have a map, costing 6d or 1s in his possession, might be in fear or dread of being apprehended by the forces of the State on the direction of a chief superintendent, and brought before the courts? In my contention he has no way of proving that he is not what the chief superintendent may allege him to be.
Comment on this
There are many serious difficulties in regard to section 5. No matter how highly qualified chief superintendents may be, and they are highly qualified, nevertheless there have been cases in which genuine mistakes have been made. If genuine mistakes have been made it is quite likely that, under this section, genuine mistakes may be made which may lead to the conviction of innocent persons.
Section 5 refers to "any map, plan, graph or drawing, any photograph". I would ask the Minister to tell us what is meant by "any map". Would it be a map of Ireland or of the United States or of Canada? The wording is very vague. It is usual for a motorist to have a map in his car. A member of the Automobile Association will have an AA map. Will it be an offence under this section to carry such a map? Will it be an offence to have a map on which certain areas are marked, areas in which in the opinion of the superintendent a breach of the peace is likely to arise, of which possibility the motorist is unaware? This is very serious.
Engineers and architects usually carry plans and drawings. If there is an engineer or architect who is politically active and who comes under the notice of the chief superintendent, probably on the basis of information given by a competitor who may want to damage his business, could he be charged with committing an offence under the provisions of this Bill?
The section does not define "photograph". Will it be an offence to have a photograph, say, of the men who died in 1916? Would that be sufficient to identify a patriotic citizen as being guilty of an offence against the State? The word "photograph" is too vague. If a photographer takes a picture of persons attending a meeting and if, in the opinion of the chief superintendent, those persons are associated with activities not in the interests of the State, that photographer, no matter how innocent he may be, will be unable to prove his innocence.
With regard to the use of the words "disc, tape, sound-track or other device", I want to say that persons engaged in television repair services and in dance bands and other activities use certain equipment of the type mentioned in the Bill. There is a link between the business of TV engineers and those employed in television in relation to tapes and discs. In that way a TV engineer may come under suspicion if he has these items in his possession.
What will happen to the innocent person who finds a photograph and has it in his possession, even though he may have no connection with what is depicted? What will happen in the case of the citizen if a map, plan, document or photograph is sent to him through the post which could come under this section? Will he be liable under this Bill?
The section is vague. It is dangerous. It loads the dice against the citizen. I consider it to be a most offensive section. The citizen can be adversely affected by the section and will have no means of proving his innocence. By being in possession of the items mentioned in the section the citizen is automatically guilty and is liable to the penalties prescribed. I strongly object to the section and view it with alarm. In existing circumstances there is no need for these provisions. The law as it stands is adequate to deal with any emergency likely to arise. The Act of 1939 does not require these additions in order to safeguard the State. I fail to understand why the section has been put into the Bill. The section having been inserted, safeguards should have been provided for innocent persons who might find themselves charged under the section.
Comment on this
It would seem to me that paragraphs (c) and (d) of section 5 were inserted for the benefit of the Special Branch and the Garda. The items mentioned in (a) and (b) are items which the gardaí might find on a person or in his car or in his house. It is clear that the provisions of paragraphs (c) and (d) will be used by the Garda in order to secure a conviction. Since I have referred already to the question of tapes I would like to refer specifically to the last part of paragraph (d) which reads:
...and a reproduction or still reproduction of the image or images embodied therein whether enlarged or not and whether with or without sounds or other data.
I can interpret this only as being a reference to photographs that may be in the possession of the Garda. Police forces in other places, especially in the North of Ireland, take photographs of protest marches and identify the participants from the photographs.
I hope the Minister will be able to tell me how the authorities, in using a section of an enlarged photograph, could establish a time element in court so as to use the photograph or portion of it as evidence. During my journeys to and from this House and to other places, many photographs could be taken, but how could the Garda establish later when any such photograph was taken?
Comment on this
Does the Minister anticipate that this section will permit the giving in evidence of conversations recorded by means of long-distance electronic devices or conversations recorded by way of intercepting telephone messages?
Comment on this
Certainly not. Basically section 5 is for the purpose of bringing up to date section 2 of the Offences against the State Act.
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister to do me the honour of not repeating the Minister for Justice's Second Stage speech.
Comment on this
I have not said anything yet. The Deputy might behave himself. Of course he has had troubles recently.
Comment on this
I happen to have here section 2 of the Offences against the State Act, 1939.
Comment on this
This is a joke. The Minister does not know the answers and the Minister responsible has not been available to the House for at least two-thirds of the Committee Stage.
Comment on this
As a Government we accept collective responsibility.
Comment on this
Section 5 relates directly to section 2 of the Offences against the State Act in which the word "document" is defined as including a book, a newspaper, magazine or other periodical or publication and also a pamphlet, leaflet, circular or advertisement.