Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill, 1972: Committee and Final Stages.
Contributions 247–500 of 500. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1972 ›
The proposed section merely extends that section and there is nothing more or less than that involved. In other words that is bringing up to date what was relevant for definition purposes in regard to "document" in 1939. Anybody who endeavours to import anything else into section 5 is talking through his hat. This proposed section is being added to include matters that were not related in 1939 and in particular this relates to subsections (c) and (d) which have come in for criticism and which relate to discs, tapes, sound-tracks, film, micro-film and tapes. Such matters would not have been in the minds of the draftsmen in 1939.
Comment on this
The Minister has been speaking for about ten minutes but has not yet answered one of the questions put to him.
Comment on this
May I repeat the question? I asked the Minister whether he anticipates that it will now be possible to introduce in evidence, having regard to the provisions of the Act of 1939 in relation to incriminating documents, recordings of conversations obtained at a distance by means of electronic-listening devices. I asked him also whether it will be possible to introduce as evidence as incriminating documents, recordings of telephone conversations.
Comment on this
If the Deputy reads it he can understand why I said no.
Comment on this
The Fine Gael Party know that you cannot either. The Deputy might check it out with his leader.
Comment on this
As I read it, recordings of telephone conversations would be included. I would ask the Minister to treat this matter seriously. He is well known as a buffoon but I would suggest that he stop playing the part.
Comment on this
I withdraw it but that does not alter the Minister's status.
Comment on this
If the Minister reads paragraph (c) he will see that a recording of a telephone conversation or of any conversation is a document within the meaning of the 1939 Act and that a document within that Act can be incriminating so as to convict a person. Is that not a correct interpretation?
Comment on this
If that is the attitude, the answer is regrettably clear.
Deputy Sherwin rose.
Comment on this
I will talk to Deputy Sherwin who is an intelligent Deputy.
Comment on this
Would a tape-recording of a conversation which took place within a room that was bugged by the Forces of this State come within the meaning of this paragraph?
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that it would not. This is intended to deal with ordinary discs, tapes and sound-tracks which are available in the course of the ordinary media and of ordinary distribution but there is no question of bugging or private investigation on the part of police authorities being involved.
Comment on this
Might I refer to a recent recording of a BBC television performance—I can only call it "performance"—by the Minister for Justice——
Comment on this
Any disc or tape, according to this definition, becomes a document. It does not say whether it is public or private.
Comment on this
The Deputy is operating on the presumption that the police authorities are engaging in private bugging activities.
Comment on this
I am not. I am merely asking if they did what would the result be?
Comment on this
I am not going to answer hypothetical questions. I will just say that they do not engage in such activity.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy understand that a speech would be more appropriate on the Fifth Stage?
Comment on this
Am I right in assuming that speeches are appropriate on both the Report and Final Stages?
Comment on this
Earlier yesterday evening I indicated on behalf of my party that we were prepared to withdraw our reasoned amendment. I indicated at that time and subsequently why we were prepared to do that. We were prepared to do that as a loyal Opposition, intent on assisting the Government and the Parliament to do their duty if the Government decided it had to be done in the exigencies of the present situation, a situation which was tragically heightened for us yesterday evening. We offered that co-operation as a loyal Opposition in a democratic Parliament. We offered it in the hope, now proved groundless— if we had considered the record of the party opposite a vain hope abenissio— that some of the matters in this Bill, which were patently objectionable, would be amended in such a way as not to deprive the Bill of any of its power or efficacy.
Our hopes in that regard were vain hopes because the party opposite are not yet a fully Constitutional party. They have no conception of the role of Parliament or any conception of what the duties of a Parliamentary Opposition are. With every duty goes a right.
Comment on this
The Chair does not wish to interrupt but to point out to Deputies that what must now be spoken to is what is in the Bill.
Comment on this
With every duty there goes a right and the right of an Opposition is a right to be treated with courtesy, a right to be treated with respect. Those rights were contemptuously breached today. The attitude of the Minister presently sitting in, the attitude of the Ministers there before him, has shown quite clearly that any efforts made by us on this side to improve or help legislation will be thrown back in our faces contemptuously. As far as I am concerned I learned a bitter political lesson.
Comment on this
The sneerers and the jeerers over there may regret the teaching of that lesson.
Comment on this
We are here allegedly debating a matter which goes to the very root of our democracy which the Government allegedly brought forward to try to safeguard this nation. The Government are only able to show themselves as a party of jeerers. The Minister for Transport and Power five minutes ago took pride in the idea of collective responsibility. It took 600 bleeding corpses to stir that party into the courage to bring forward this Bill.
Comment on this
It took the blood of those corpses on that party to stir them up. It was that party which provided the money, the assistance and the weapons which led to the deaths of those people.
Comment on this
I made it quite clear, when speaking in this House that the reason for my opposition to this type of legislation was that the Government had adequate legislation to deal with the particular type of situation that we are allegedly approaching. I regret the particular incident which happened in this city last night. I express my sincere sympathy with the people involved.
Comment on this
The Chair does not want to interrupt the Deputy but we must keep to what is in the Bill.
Comment on this
I know that has nothing to do with what is in the Bill but I hope the people who committed this felonious act will be apprehended. I want to say to Deputy Cooney, who, in his excuse for the Fine Gael Party——
Comment on this
This Bill has been allowed to go through this House in a contemptuous manner by the Opposition Party.
Comment on this
I do not wish to intrude on your courtesy but I say that there was an allegation made here against other Deputies as well as myself. I want to clear the air about it. I made it quite clear to Deputy Cooney and Deputy Corish that my opposition to this Bill was not because I was a member of or associated with any illegal organisation. Most of the Deputies know me well enough to know that is not true. These allegations have nothing to do with the way the Fine Gael Party slithered away from this Bill.
Comment on this
It is imperative that I make my position clear in view of the statements made by Deputy Cooney and Deputy Corish.
Comment on this
It is difficult at this early hour of the morning to realise that we had a tremendous tragedy in this city last night, and it is made all the more difficult by the behaviour of some members of the Fianna Fáil Party——
Comment on this
——who regard apparently a political victory, if they describe the passing of this thing as such, and obviously they do, as more important than a little—just a little— regard and respect for the people who have been killed and maimed in our streets.
Comment on this
I would never compete with the Deputies in hypocrisy— they have had too much experience, far too much of a start on me. When this Bill was opposed by us, we knew exactly the interpretation Fianna Fáil would try to put on our opposition. The provisions in this Bill are completely and entirely unnecessary to deal with what we were told by the Government they were to deal with, illegal organisations, because there is no doubt that there is, in effect, at this time and has been for some considerable number of years past enough legislation of a similar nature to this Bill to deal more than adequately with what we are faced with, and if we have sufficient legislation, why this? The only reason we are at this stage today is that the Government, for their own political purposes, would not implement the legislation they had in hands. One of the people who tonight are going to feel the brunt of that behaviour——
Comment on this
I might inform Deputy Cluskey that on Fifth Stage only matters contained in the Bill may be discussed.
Comment on this
At this very moment when that jovial group of lads over there are enjoying themselves apparently, out on our streets are the Garda Síochána and they are the people who are going to stand in the vanguard in defence of our democracy but for the past three years particularly they have been obstructed in implementing the law that existed.
Comment on this
A policy of stop-go has been carried out by that Government for purely party political purposes and that cannot be denied. When, because the pendulum may have swung that way, it was good Fianna Fáil politics to harass the IRA, to bring the IRA in, to charge them, to release them—anything went when it suited them——
Comment on this
When it does not suit, it is hands off the IRA and when it is not to Fianna Fáil political advantage to do anything, it is hands off, and we are going to make sure that the country knows that.
Deputy O.J. Flanagan rose.
Comment on this
We have been described by members of that party, both at Cabinet and backbench level, as West Britons, as Redmondites, as pro-British, as traitors over the past three years. What is the story tonight? We have now switched and we are supposed to be Provos. Why? Because that at the moment suits Fianna Fáil policy.
Comment on this
——and if the Deputy is hoping that I will put him out at this hour of the morning, he is mistaken.
Comment on this
The Deputy is disregarding the Chair completely. We will have to order this in some way.
Comment on this
I do not mind that but there is a Chair here in charge of our Parliament.
Comment on this
The only reason this is going on here is that for Fianna Fáil political purposes, another little move is needed.
Comment on this
He is indicating why Fianna Fáil are here in Government.
Comment on this
It is not for the purpose of dealing with subversive organisations or gunmen or bombers but because the introduction of the Bill is suitable to Fianna Fáil at this moment.
Comment on this
The Deputy and people like him are major assets to the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
That is the only reason the Bill was introduced because it has been clearly demonstrated, over recent days, that they did not use the legislation they already had, and the reason they did not use it——
Comment on this
I will tell you where he is: he is in company with his integrity which none of you fellows could be in company with. We know the power and the strength of that machine, particularly when it goes out to misrepresent, to blackguard and to slander any member of the Opposition.
Comment on this
This has nothing to do with the Fifth Stage of the Bill. The Deputy is being grossly disorderly. It has nothing to do with the Bill at this stage.
Comment on this
——opposes this Bill for one reason only—that is what this Bill does is to put in jeopardy the rights of ordinary law-abiding citizens who may irritate——
Comment on this
Deputy Loughnane was going to retire two years ago because he did not like what the Government were doing.
Comment on this
——or be a cause of embarrassment to that party. Though we have been saying over the last three years: "For God's sake do something about the IRA; for God's sake try to stop these subversives" nothing was done because it did not suit. The reason it did not suit politically was because the first illegal army in this country was that party over there.
Comment on this
The first group who ever refused to accept a democratic vote in the Dáil was that group over there.
Comment on this
There are still Members sitting on those benches who were in that first illegal army and who led that first illegal army.
Comment on this
Even though it is 2.45 a.m. Deputies should give this measure very serious consideration. Yesterday I spoke on this Bill. I was very critical of it. I was worried about the provisions of this Bill as a restriction on rights and liberties. I was worried about this Bill as a serious threat to democracy. I spoke strongly against it yesterday and I wanted to carry my conviction into the division lobby. I want it to go on record that my opposition to this Bill is because its provisions are unnecessary. The Government have sufficient law to carry them through any possible emergency. I voted in accordance with the dictates of my conscience. I could not allow this Bill to pass without voting against it. I voted against it because of the provisions in regard to the change in the giving of evidence. I object seriously to the conviction of Irish citizens on hearsay which I think is wrong, on the statement of the belief of another individual. I was impressed by the Association of Irish Priests——
Comment on this
——who publicly expressed their concern about the change in the law in relation to the giving of evidence. Under this Bill the dice is loaded against the defendant and for the first time the defendant must now prove himself innocent. I do not think that is good law. The Minister has not been reasonable in this matter. The Opposition spoke loudly against the Bill and asked the Minister to amend it. If this Bill was wrong yesterday and the day before it was certainly wrong when the Minister was finished with it because he did not amend it in any way. For that reason I want it to go on record that the Government have treated serious views expressed by the Opposition with contempt and arrogance. They have turned the blind eye and the deaf ear to the reasonable pleas to safeguard democracy, to safeguard the rights and liberties of citizens and not to pass a Bill under which Irish citizens can be convicted on hearsay, can be convicted on supposed evidence, can be convicted on information got through a secret service, can be convicted on the anonymous letter, on the anonymous phone call, can be convicted on a tape recording of a telephone conversation. All of this is contrary to democracy and all of this is being enacted without any real need for it.
I warned the House yesterday and the day before that this type of legislation can lead to violence. I want it to go on record that a Bill of this kind can breed violence, unrest, suspicion, the extension of secret service, underhand methods, grudges against neighbour. Is it possible that every single chief superintendent in this country— all men of stature—but is it possible that every one of them is a man who cannot make a mistake? We are all human. We all make mistakes. It is by mistakes we learn.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is Deputy Flanagan not making a Second Reading speech?
Comment on this
It would be unnatural and inhuman if chief superintendents could not make mistakes. I do not want to see citizens being convicted on the statement of one who believes he is telling the truth. At the same time he is guilty of a grave injustice against the citizen and that is the serious objection I have to this Bill.
The provisions of this Bill strike at the heart of democracy and it is the first step in the establishment of a police state here. This will not be helpful in our efforts to have good relations between the forces of law and order and the community. The best way to achieve peace is co-operation between the people who administer the law and the public. Where that co-operation exists there will be very little crime but where it ceases because of injustice or suspicion the result can be disastrous. I am sorry the House has not given more serious thought to the extraordinary powers given under this Bill to the Garda Síochána. They have never asked for or wanted these powers. There will be many miscarriages of justice because of the provisions contained in this Bill.
I do not like this Bill and I will oppose it. I am afraid the dice is loaded against the ordinary citizen and I would be failing in my duty if I did not point out this fact. I believe in co-operation between the public and the Garda Síochána but where there is a wedge driven between both sides and when the people begin to think that the police are their enemy then we will have trouble. The purpose for which the Garda Síochána were founded——
Comment on this
The Garda Síochána were founded to safeguard the lives and property of people but if it happens that the public lose confidence in the Garda Síochána because of this Bill there could be serious consequences. I hope the consequences I fear will not materialise. This Bill will lead to many breaches of the peace and I am sorry this legislation will be put on our Statute Book. I am obliged to oppose it because I do not believe in this kind of legislation. This is an effort by the Government to deprive people of their liberty. To demonstrate, speak or to march in procession will be the prerogative of Fianna Fáil only and that is one of the reasons I am opposed to the Bill.
Comment on this
It is my opinion that the provisions contained in this Bill will have serious consequences. There was no need for the Government to look for these powers because the existing law is quite adequate. The provisions of this Bill are undemocratic and dictatorial in a democracy and on principle I oppose the Bill.
Comment on this
If I were Johann Strauss I would ask Deputy Flanagan to continue like this at 3 o'clock in the morning but at this late hour I think perhaps we should pull ourselves together. For the past three years I have heard Deputy L'Estrange, Deputy FitzGerald and others criticise the Government for not taking more action. Now when the Government take further action they criticise them. It has been extraordinary that nobody has mentioned our defence forces——
Comment on this
This does not arise on the Fifth Stage of the Bill. We can discuss only what is contained in the Bill——
Comment on this
It cannot be done on the Fifth Stage of the Bill. The Deputy will have another opportunity to do it.
Comment on this
I despise this kind of legislation because it is the other end of the trick the Government constantly pull on us. One day we have the European Communities Bill which is so generalised as to be worthless. Now we have a Bill that is spelled out in detail. Section 3 (1) (b) states:
..."conduct" includes omission by the accused person to deny published reports that he was a member of an unlawful organisation, but the fact of such denial shall not by itself be conclusive.
He will be convicted if he does not deny them but if he does deny them it is not regarded as conclusive——
Comment on this
Is the Deputy entitled to go back on Committee Stage?
Comment on this
The Deputy may not go back on Committee Stage but he is entitled to refer to what is in the Bill.
Comment on this
As the Minister did not make any speech concluding the debate on Second Reading, I have to depend on what he said in his introduction. The Minister said that these points were matters of common sense. You cannot decide whether any conduct implying or leading to a reasonable inference is a matter of common sense. The other part is subsection (2) of that section. The Minister said that the purpose of that was to amend and strengthen the law, that is to say, to depend on the word of a chief superintendent and that this was to be the guide—"shall be evidence"—and it does not matter where the word of this chief superintendent came from. Then what did the Minister say? That the majority of the people were in favour of this. I do not believe for one moment that our people are in favour of that kind of thing. He went on to talk about persons who attempted to arrogate to themselves rights.
Comment on this
This is not in order. I am not concerned with what the Minister said in introducing this Bill. All I am concerned with is what is contained in this Bill.
Comment on this
I am about to finish. In regard to persons who attempt to arrogate to themselves rights, is there not in this Bill an attempt by the Government to get rights to which they are not entitled, rights that the ordinary citizen has under the civil law? I shall not say any more except that, as Deputy Oliver Flanagan says, this kind of legislation gets under my skin.
Comment on this
Our morning newspapers have a leading statement that the UVF have claimed responsibility for the happenings last night.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. I think it has to do with this Bill in so far as this Bill would not——
Comment on this
We are discussing what is in the Bill and the Deputy may not discuss the morning newspapers.
Comment on this
If the dastardly act that happened last night had not occurred we would not be here now discussing the Bill, and we would not have this Bill passed, as it is likely to be, because Fine Gael would not have the way out they have got so conveniently through the UVF bombs.
Comment on this
If this Bill becomes law it will have the same effect as internment. It will go even further than that. It proposes to give a fair trial which under this Bill cannot be achieved. The Government are dishonest in not introducing internment clearly. They are using this Bill as a camouflage but it will have the same effect. When the Minister spoke of difficulties in framing this Bill and of difficulties in achieving convictions, he was referring to our rights.
Comment on this
This Bill is removing my constitutional rights and those of the people of Ireland. Under this Bill a conviction can be secured by the forces without any redress. Under section 3 (2), any member of the community irrespective of whether he be an ordinary citizen or a member of the gardaí, no matter what rank below chief superintendent, can, in producing evidence, point the finger at any other member of the community and even effect death. This can be clearly shown in the case of Mac Stiofáin or any other person who may conscientiously object to being treated in the manner in which this man was treated, who may take the same action as Seán Mac Stiofáin took and die from hunger and thirst strike. This Bill is wrong from that point of view and if it is made law it will be bad law. Under section 3 (1) (b) if a person is named in public in a published report on RTE as being a member of an illegal organisation, and if that person is brought on RTE, because he demands to be brought on RTE, to deny that this published report is correct, the possibility is that under this subsection we may see the removal of another Authority because such action is interpreted as not being in accordance with section 31. I have no intention of delaying the House any longer except to suggest to Fianna Fáil that they can fool some of the people some of the time but they cannot fool all of the people all of the time.
Comment on this
It has been suggested by some of the political pundits on the radio this evening that I and some of the other people who occupy these benches have been responsible for keeping the debate going on so long. On the Second Reading I expressed my point of view and indicated that I intended to oppose the Bill. I did not take up much of the time doing that. I got in as early as I possibly could yesterday morning. We have now reached the Fifth Stage and the Bill has not changed basically as far as I am concerned. It was not acceptable to me yesterday morning and it is not acceptable to me now. What does concern me is that at the time I was speaking I believed the Bill would be defeated, but I see now it will not be defeated and, because it will not be defeated, I am concerned about some statements made here this evening by Deputy Corish and by Deputy Cooney.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot do this at this stage. This is the Fifth Stage. The Deputy must discuss what is in the Bill.
Comment on this
Let us be fair about it. The Bill, as it is, and all the arguments that have gone on here for and against the Bill and the statements made here will appear in the papers and I do not know what is going to be said in the papers tomorrow in relation to me.
Comment on this
I am not concerned about what is said in the papers. We are on the Fifth Stage of the Bill.
Comment on this
I asked Deputy Corish to "shut up" and I do not know if that was a very parliamentary way of making my request at the time.
Comment on this
I am concerned, Deputy, only with what is in the Bill and the Deputy should relate his remarks now to the Bill. The Deputy can take the other matter up with Deputy Corish.
Comment on this
If this was the way Deputy Corish could explain away his embarrassment at having to walk into the Division Lobby with me this evening, then I say it was damn bad form and I expected better from him, as far as I personally am concerned. We have been in this House for a long time——
Comment on this
I am sorry, a Cheann Comhairle, but this is the only opportunity I will get on this Bill.
Comment on this
It is not the proper opportunity. The Deputy may get a relevant opportunity another time.
Comment on this
As I said, we were expected to hold up the debate here and yet we find, when it closes, it closes because the Fine Gael Party decided they would not walk into the Division Lobby with me.
Comment on this
This is totally out of order and I must ask the Deputy to resume his seat. I have given every opportunity to the Deputy of explaining his position, but I cannot allow him to continue in his present vein.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I have been out of order. It is not so easy to make the one or two points I wanted to make in relation to this Bill at this particular stage. Suffice it to say that I now find myself in the extraordinary position in this House of being the saviour of the Fianna Fáil Government tonight because the Fine Gael Deputies would not walk into the Division Lobby with me.
Comment on this
He said that he was the saviour of the Fianna Fáil Government tonight because Fine Gael have advanced, as their reason for not voting against the Bill, the fact that they would not go into the Division Lobby with him.
Comment on this
That is what he did say and I think he got that from Deputy Cooney's pronouncements as to why they had changed their minds now as against the earlier stages of the Bill. So far as this Bill is concerned, it is as nasty a piece of legislation tonight as it was last night and the night before and I have no doubt that tomorrow night and every night thereafter it will be seen to be, as it is now, as nasty a piece of legislation as ever came before this House. Its nastiness may be seen more clearly as time goes on and the Bill begins to take effect, the effect being that, under the various provisions in it, we will find a situation arising in which a member of the Garda Síochána, having a reasonable ground for believing—that is the phraseology used a couple of times here—that an offence, which is, for the time being, a scheduled offence, et cetera, was or is about to be committed and, coming across a person in the vicinity at the particular time, that member of the Garda Síochána may then demand full details from the person in question as to who and what he is, where he has been, and where he is going, and ask him to account for his movements; and, if the questions asked by that member of the Garda Síochána are not answered, that will be an offence in itself.
I believe this provision to be totally unnecessary. But, worse than all that, the penalties that are laid down for not conforming with the demands of the member of the Garda Síochána for information are severe penalties, severe to the point that the person in question cannot win and must lose, irrespective of whether or not he gives the information requested. Likewise, we find even more unacceptable perhaps in another part of the Bill a provision under which a chief superintendent, or higher officer, is empowered to go into the witness box and say that he believes that a particular person is a member of an illegal organisation. This is a provision for which there is no justification. No evidence has been adduced to support such a provision. No demand was made for such a provision, particularly in the circumstances in which we find ourselves at the moment. The organisations that are threatening the security of this State have not been proscribed. They have not been declared illegal. Those who perpetrated the outrages in this city last night are still not, so far as we here are concerned, declared illegal and this Bill, therefore, does not apply to them. Neither does it apply to a number of other kindred organisations which have been making quite a lot of threats lately.
Comment on this
I want to know are we now going to get from the Minister a declaration that this legislation, which is on the verge of being enacted, will apply to the UDA, the UVF and the other organisations which are threatening our institutions here? Will they be declared illegal? Will this Bill apply to them?
Comment on this
Yes. I give that categorical assurance. This Bill will apply to all illegal organisations and that includes the UVF and the UDA as far as we are concerned.
Comment on this
When were these organisations proscribed? When were they made illegal organisations?
Comment on this
Just a moment. The provisions of this Bill apply to illegal organisations, and illegal organisations, as I understand, are organisations so declared under our existing law, under the Offences Against the State Act, and if those that have been mentioned have not yet been proscribed, then they are not, for the purposes of this Bill, yet illegal organisations. I am asking will they be so proscribed?
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows well, they can be proscribed at the drop of a hat under the Offences Against the State Act.
Comment on this
We have not got the hat. I pointed this out on an earlier stage of this Bill: the organisations that are threatening the security of this State are not declared illegal under our law and this Bill, therefore, does not apply to them.
Comment on this
Of course, it does. If an Order is made, then this Bill applies. The Deputy is well aware of that.
Comment on this
If! I am not here to bandy words about the Bill. As I said last night, once the dealing and the wheeling had been completed between Fianna Fáil and some persons in Fine Gael, there was no point——
Comment on this
That does not arise. What happened last night does not arise on the Fifth Stage of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not give any such reasons. It would be totally out of order. We are discussing what is contained in the Bill.
Comment on this
If you would wait to hear the end of the sentence before interrupting me you would see that I was refraining from attempting to amend this Bill once the wheeling and dealing had been done between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I made no contribution towards amending the Bill because there was no point in trying to do so since there was a deal and a wheel done between the two major parties.
Comment on this
We are discussing what is now contained in the Bill, and that is the only thing that is relevant.
Comment on this
I agree fully and entirely that what is in the Bill is relevant to the wheeling and dealing that has been done because, if there had been none, the Bill would be different.
Comment on this
I am talking about what the Bill would have contained if it had not been treated in a cynical manner by the two major parties. I suppose you cannot blame the Government for doing the wheeling, if other people were prepared to do the dealing. They obviously were and now give these phoney reasons why they will not oppose it, despite all their talk against it.
Comment on this
Could I turn to the Bill and its application, and to what it is intended or proposed to do with it, that is, better to secure the establishments and institutions of this State. Are we having an absolute declaration here tonight from the Minister on behalf of the Government that the hat he talks about is about to be dropped, and that the UDA and UVF who did your bombing down here in this city tonight, are going to be proscribed——
Comment on this
——and that this law you are enacting will be applied to them? If not, for what purpose is it being enacted? To whom is it to be applied? If those who threaten our institutions are not included in our laws and in the proscribing of them in such a way that it can be applied to them——
Comment on this
I answered the Deputy and he is well aware of that.
Comment on this
I am well aware, with no disrespect to the Minister, that I would need to see this in writing before there is any purpose in saying that it applies to this Bill. We have got to have the proclamation and proscription of this organisation if we are to have any security on this side of the Border. I would also remark that the haste and the panic with which this Bill has been put through here tonight, in fact the grasping of tragic opportunity, is not the manner in which a Bill of this weight, this type of measure, should be rushed through. Rather should we have had more time to look at it, not to panic and be hasty and jump in and get it through on a wave of emotion.
Comment on this
I am sorry about that and I feel it should, because it is the finished article of what we started out with that we still have before us, just as ugly, just as repulsive and repugnant as it was then, and it is a pity that this should be so. It is also unfortunate that the cynicism and the hypocrisy and the dishonesty that has gone into the passage of this Bill, enacting it in the form that it is, by the Fine Gael Party, who condemned it so roundly, and bored so many holes in it——
Comment on this
If it had not been for that party we would not have it in its present form. Surely I am entitled——
Comment on this
The Deputy is not entitled to be disorderly any more than any other Deputy in the House. The Deputy should know better.
Comment on this
I would certainly hope that after the years I have been in this House I do know better and I think the Ceann Comhairle, in all his experience in the Chair, knows that I have taken full note of what I know is order and disorder and I have sat here tonight looking at disorder.
Comment on this
I understand that on the motion that the Bill do now pass, I am entitled to discuss in full the implications and the ramifications and the contents of the Bill.
Comment on this
Not the implications but only what is in the Bill. The same rules apply to Deputy Blaney as apply to any other Deputy in the House.
Comment on this
The Chair is not being sarcastic but the Deputy evidently imagines that there should be different rules for Deputy Blaney.
Comment on this
No, he does not. All he would want from the Chair in other matters as well as tonight, would be the same application of the rules as other people have got. In so far as this Bill is concerned, the sordid provisions we find here being put into the hands of the head of the Special Branch in order to pursue the vendetta he was set upon, no doubt by his masters in the political world two and a half years ago, will now no doubt be continued and intensified with all the vigour and the dishonesty that man has displayed he is capable of. This is part of the Bill. This is, in my estimation, the real reason why chief superintendents should be sorted out and mentioned particularly so that this gentleman should, in fact, be given this sort of authority, this sort of law, that he can do his depredations on ordinary innocent and decent people, as he has displayed himself capable of doing, but the law did not stand for it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is again being disorderly. He is making an attack on an individual who has no opportunity of replying to him.
Comment on this
Who has attacked this individual when he had no opportunity on more than one occasion—and dishonestly and untruthfully——
Comment on this
I want to know, in regard to this Bill, and in regard to the provisions in the various sections, without enumerating them in detail, whether there is retrospection included in them. I would ask the Minister to nod his head, or wink his eye, or give some indication——
Comment on this
——or otherwise, as to whether the various provisions in this Bill are retrospective in the sense of statements made, gatherings attended, meetings, processions, et cetera, that may have taken place and been attended, or infringed in some way. When it becomes law, will the provisions of the Bill apply retrospectively to any and all of these things and, if so, how far back does retrospection go? This is an important matter that should be answered, if possible, by the Minister, if not immediately, then some time before we conclude.
Comment on this
I would particularly wish that that would be enumerated and explained as far as possible. I would also ask the Minister and, indeed, the Minister who will be charged with the responsibility of the administration of this document, this Bill, when it becomes an Act, whether, in fact, he will, or his Government, through the Attorney General, be able to call the tune in regard to the application of these various provisions or will the Attorney General and the law officers——
Comment on this
We are not discussing what will happen in the future. We can only discuss what is in the Bill now.
Comment on this
Sorry. Could I just put it this way, that I am not discussing what will happen in future? I am asking will the administration of this Bill, when it is enacted, be in the hands and under the jurisdiction and be the sole responsibility of the permanent law officers or officer or will that mean in the hands of the Attorney General in turn directed by the Government if political aspects emerge, which undoubtedly must emerge in almost anything in this context? In other words, will the Government be the directors of the Attorney General in regard to the administration of the Bill when it becomes an Act?
Comment on this
If it is not relevant now, there is not much we can find out about it in the future. Perhaps I am putting the question rather vaguely. I am trying to find out whether the Government or an independent law officer will, in fact, be the administrator.
Comment on this
The Deputy is well aware that on the Final Stage what may be discussed is what is in the Bill, not any suppositions about
Comment on this
I am making it a question. Perhaps I should have made that clear—a question rather than a supposition or suggestion or allegation. The question is, who will administer this? Who will take the decisions in regard to it?
Comment on this
No problem whatever I hope. Could we also get the further assurance which I have already heard the Minister give by way of a very short reply, a rejoinder, to questions asked, in regard to the next section, that is, the section covering discs, tapes, sound tracks and so on? The Minister did indicate, as far as I know, that these items and films and microfilms and negatives and all the modern paraphernalia of communication or recording will not, cannot be used as evidence or as a means of convicting a defendant unless those tapes, recordings, films, negatives, or whatever, arise from something that was produced as a public statement or effort indicative of some particular line of thought that would be said to be subversive or in support of subversion or an illegal organisation? In other words, can we have an elaboration, if possible, from the Minister that unless these items arise from public utterances and were intended to be public they cannot be included as evidence that would go towards the conviction of a defendant under this section?
Comment on this
I can give that assurance and will elaborate on that.
Comment on this
Fair enough. Thank you very much. Having said those few things in regard to the Bill, some of which would appear to have been on the outer cover rather than the inside, as I have been informed by the Ceann Comhairle, whose indulgence I have perhaps overstrained, I want to say that the Bill was, is and will continue to be a repugnant, nasty, cynical piece of legislation, that it is dangerous and will be damaging in its administration and cannot do any good and will in my estimation undoubtedly do an immense amount of harm, with perhaps disastrous effects, before it has been very long in existence. This is not, I am sure, the intention of the Government but, on the other hand, the Bill is there, the dangers are there and nothing that has been said here, or that could be said, can take from that. That is my opinion, was my opinion and nothing I have heard here has done other than confirm the opinion that it is a wrong piece of legislation, one which is unworthy of this House and which strikes at the roots and foundations of the rights of our people, which are restricted enough at the moment. It will be regretted. The only thing I hope is that I will be around long enough to see it wiped off the books together with its parents, the 1939 and 1940 Acts, in toto.
Comment on this
A lot of rather hysterical debate has been induced over the past few days on this measure. At this Stage we should bring the matter down to earth and discuss in a few minutes what exactly is involved.
This Bill is an amendment of the Offences against the State Act, 1939, designed to ensure as far as this State is concerned the men of violence and the people of violence, no matter where they come from, no matter what label they have on them—by that I include IRA, UVF, UDA or any other label that people of violence want to attach to themselves—can be dealt with appropriately by the Government in the interests of the preservation of the lives and the property of the citizens of this State. That is what this Bill is about.
Comment on this
This can be done by way of proclamation under the Offences against the State Act, 1939 and this Bill is designed to improve that Act so as to ensure that any deficiencies that have existed under that Act and under the criminal code generally are rectified so as to ensure the apprehension of people who are enemies of this State, enemies of this Parliament. We are all in this, as I said when making my contribution on the Second Stage. This is not a question of political parties. This is a question of all of us who go before the people and seek democratic election to this Parliament.
There is one important aspect that I feel should be mentioned and it meets a lot of the points made just recently by Deputy Blaney, that is, that whatever additions we have made here to the powers in the Offences against the State Act as they exist now are all matters that will arise for consideration by independent courts and this also meets the point that has been consistently made by Fine Gael spokesmen here. We will have courts deciding these issues. It meets the major point that was made in regard to subsection (2) of section 3. It means that whatever the chief superintendent may produce in regard to a particular citizen can be rebutted by that citizen in court and that citizen can give his evidence in full and can be legally represented and the chief superintendent can be cross-examined. If people in this House want to smear our independent courts and our independent judiciary, then they are in fact——
Comment on this
——going into a very dangerous area where the courts are under attack. We have and the Government have sufficient confidence in the independent courts established under our Constitution and under our laws. They are there to ensure that justice is meted out and that the laws of evidence enshrined in the Common Law and the Statute Law of this State over many centuries is properly administered and properly dealt with. The fundamental assurance is there under our laws of evidence and of procedure that a person charged in an independent court in this land with any offence must be found by that judge or jury to be guilty beyond all reasonable doubt before he can be convicted. There is nothing in this Bill or in the Offences against the State Act and neither is there anything in our criminal law that takes one iota from that fundamental right of anyone charged before a court. I emphasise that point because it is the basic point that arises here. Once a defendant goes into a witness box and is accused of being a member of an illegal organisation, the onus of proof does not shift and the accused has the right to rebut the charge, there is an independent judge who decides where lies the onus of guilt and if guilt is not proved beyond all reasonable doubt, there will be an automatic acquittal. This aspect should be given much more publicity than is given to the nonsense talked here in regard to this matter.
Comment on this
Deputy Blaney raised the question of the application of the provisions of the Bill and asked whether the Government or the permanent law courts of the State direct whether a prosecution takes place. Indeed, this applies in respect of the provisions under the Offences against the State Act and to our criminal code generally. Deputy Blaney was in Government long enough to know the position which is that the permanent law officers of the State, from the Chief State Solicitor down through the various State solicitors are employed and appointed permanently. They are there irrespective of government and they are the people who decide, on foot of information furnished to them by the police officers, whether a prosecution should be initiated. That has always been the position and will continue to be so.
It was precisely because of the advice given to this Government by the permanent law officers of the State to the effect that there were basic deficiencies under the existing State criminal code and under the Offences against the State Act that we introduced this measure. They advised the Government that these deficiencies prevented us from acting effectively in regard to the apprehension of enemies of the State. These enemies of the State, regardless of what label is applied to them, be it IRA, UDA, UVF or any other could not be apprehended effectively because of these deficiencies. After seeking to invoke and make effective the existing measures we decided on the advice of the permanent law officers to make the provisions more effective and that is why this measure is before us. The House is now well aware of the very real need for provisions of this kind and Fine Gael are well aware of the mistake they have made in seeking to ignore the advice of their leader.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?