We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 1973: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–192 of 597. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment)(No. 2) Bill, 1973
Enacted

No. 3 of 1973 ›

When we were discussing this matter last week, as a result of some interruptions made by the Minister for Local Government the tone of the debate accelerated and, indeed, there were some sharp exchanges across the House. I am aware that the speed of the exchanges was such as to prevent any stenographer from getting everything that was said. I am aware also that Ministers and Deputies have the privilege to go into the office of the Editor of Debates and edit their own contributions, but I am not aware that at any time can one Deputy or, indeed, a Minister, alter the contributions of other Deputies. On looking at the Official Report of last Wednesday, Volume 269, No. 5, 28th November, it appeared to me in particular that the references or the exchanges I had with Deputy Coogan, where I had insisted on a withdrawal of an inference he had made—the Deputy had the courtesy to rephrase his earlier remarks to my satisfaction—have not, I regret, appeared in the Official Report.

You know, Sir, I think probably what nettled the Minister was that I questioned his competence and ability and I will do that again today. I treat everybody in this House with courtesy and respect and I expect to be treated back in the same way. But if any Minister, any arrogant Minister, wishes to treat me in a different way I will give him more than he can give out, as indeed the Minister withdrew from the exchange with a very insulting and personally insulting remark when he realised he was not getting the better of the argument. I was making my contribution practically without interruption when the Minister pointed out that in his view he had to spend six months cleaning up the mess left by his predecessor and that is why we had the delay in seeing this particular Bill. But the Minister knows as well as I know, as well as every Deputy in this House knows, that he produced a Bill which was unacceptable, in the first instance to some of his own colleagues and certainly to his own Executive and then unacceptable, indeed, to the Parliamentary Secretary, who is sitting across, if my reports are correct, in certain facets, and the Bill had to be drafted and redrafted.

If I thought this Bill was the complete work of the Minister for Local Government I would urge our party to support it. The Minister has made so many decisions that have proved incorrect, he has been so anxious to make decisions without being properly briefed or without fully considering the implications, that if this Bill were his work it must be wrong for the present Government. However, it is not his Bill. I am aware that the Taoiseach consulted with some of his "whizz kids" and, as a result, we have a Fine Gael Bill introduced by a Labour Minister.

I have gone through the Bill, constituency by constituency. With the sole exception of the amazing exercise of putting Ennis with Galway in the hope of electing Senator Higgins, there is not one prospect I can see of any extra Labour seats being acquired in the next general election, regardless of whatever way public opinion may swing at that time.

I admit the Minister has carefully put an extra seat in his own constituency to protect himself and also that he has put one in Waterford to protect the party chairman, Deputy Tom Kyne. If there are seats to be won by the Government in the next general election as a result of this Bill, working on the statistical facts available from the last and previous general elections, they will be won by Fine Gael not by Labour. The one exception is the extraordinary exercise of putting Ennis in with Galway, in the interest apparently of the Senator in that area.

Referring to the debate last week, I expressed the view that I had no objection whatever to the introduction of three-seat constituencies in Dublin. Indeed, I have expressed the view since the first referendum was defeated that we should maximise the three-seat constituency situation throughout the country. I believe in the system of single-seat constituencies. The next nearest thing to letting proportional representation work as it should, namely enabling a government to be elected, to be formed and to govern, is a three-seat constituency situation. Admittedly there may be some exceptions to that but we should maximise the three-seat constituency situation. In that event, depending on public opinion at the time, one side will get two seats and the other side will get one seat if the general trend throughout the country is the same. That means that a government will be elected with a reasonably comfortable majority and will be able to put their programme into effect without compromising, perhaps, with Independent support.

I do not know how Fianna Fáil got an overall majority in 1933 because at that time there were two nine-seaters. As I pointed out last week, in the townships in Dublin South there were seven seats, of which Fianna Fáil got five. I should like to quote the following because the Minister's interruption is very interesting. At the time Deputy Cluskey was sitting opposite me. At column 689 of the Official Report dated 28th November, 1973 I said:

As the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare will remember, there was a seven-seat constituency in his area and on one occasion Fianna Fáil elected five out of the seven Deputies and, indeed, it was on my late father's surplus that Jim Larkin was elected.

Mr. Tully: People became very intelligent since then.

I do not know if it was the Minister's intention to insult my late father or to insult Jim Larkin. Both these men are respected by the people in Dublin and I can assure the Minister if it was his intention to insult either of them it will not do him any good in the Dublin area. In the seven or nine-seat constituency situation it was an amazing achievement for any one party to get an overall majority. The smaller constituencies we have now are far more workable.

I should like to refer briefly to the exchange between Deputy Coogan and myself. When I named the Dublin-based Ministers in the present Government, as the Deputy always seems to object to anybody with what he calls "Jackeen" associations some names were left out such as the Minister for Education, Deputy Burke, and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Clinton. As Dublin is expanding at the moment, I suppose we can call the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Tully, a "Jackeen", if not now then in the very near future.

When Deputy Blaney was Minister for Local Government I asked him to do only one small thing. Some cumainn in my constituency bought a house; I told the Minister to do what he liked but I asked him to leave the house in the constituency. Of course he did not do that. Any Ministers with whom I have been associated in constituency revisions have said that what might suit me might not necessarily suit Deputy Briscoe, or Deputy Dowling as the case might be. Except in broad outline, the details of all Bills in connection with constituency revisions are largely the work of statisticians, mathematicians and officials in the Department of Local Government. With the exception of a few very obvious points, I find little objection to the Bill. However, there are some very obvious matters that stick out like a sore thumb and they make the Bill objectionable.

I should like to quote the Minister when he was in opposition. At column 1817 of the Official Report dated 4th December, 1968, he said:

I do not care what any Member of the House says, I have a personal view on this. I believe that county boundaries are important just as I believe that the national boundary is important and I would not agree that somebody who lives in County Meath would be happy being attached to another county... I do not agree, therefore, that county boundaries should be sundered. The Minister has a sin to answer for.

At column 1986 of the Official Report dated 15th November, 1973, the Minister said:

It is particularly desirable that the historic county boundaries should be preserved as far as possible and that natural communities should not be divided between different constituencies. In practice, these considerations may be incompatible with one another in certain cases and in such cases a choice must be made.

This brings me back to the Ennis-Galway position, the only effort I can see to bring in an extra Labour seat. What the Minister seems to forget is that in a three-seat situation in Dublin he is running a grave risk. Prior to the revision introduced by the then Minister, Mr. Boland, it was mostly a five-seat situation in the Dublin area. Not on the first occasion but in due course Fianna Fáil succeeded in electing three out of five and in one election when we dropped one of the three seats it was by a matter of four votes. I refer to the time Deputy Eugene Timmons was the victim of a long count.

Most of us were in Monaghan in the last four weeks. Most of us were probably in Mid-Cork and the extent of constituencies such as this was absolutely amazing to me, as a Dublin Deputy. I moved from one comhairle area to another. I had to drive 57 miles and I was not going from the extreme north to the extreme south. I am trying to figure out how a Deputy who is elected for a constituency—he is not elected only for a parish or a part of a constituency but he represents all the people in the constituency—can give service to these vast areas. Certainly the Minister has given no recognition to that problem. There has not been a by-election in County Meath that I can recollect. But how the Minister can put the county of Cavan and the county of Monaghan in together and make the constituency so much greater than the constituency we recently canvassed is something which I will never understand.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

That is very nice. I thought they had all gone home or that the celebration party was still continuing.

Many of us in recent times will have had experience of the by-election, in Monaghan and in Mid-Cork.

Comment on this

Is it not nice to be here to hear that?

Comment on this

I thought they were all on retreat.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Whatever about the retreat, could we have a little advance on the Bill?

Comment on this

As I was trying to explain. Monaghan was a three-seat constituency. On one Friday I was asked to move from Monaghan town down to Nobber. It was something over 50 miles, which means that the constituency was something like 60 miles long. This is a three-seat constituency. What is it going to be like as a five-seat constituency? How is the Deputy in Cavan going to make proper representations and keep proper contact with the people in north Monaghan?

Comment on this
Gerard Lynch Mr. G. Lynch Fine Gael

They can divide it between the three lads there.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not be too unhappy about this. Three of the seats will be Fianna Fáil seats.

Comment on this

There is no danger at all about that. For the Deputy's benefit, as you will recall, Sir, I was recommending that we should maximise on three-seat constituencies all over so that when the people were giving a decision they could give a clearcut, firm decision on whatever Government get in and they would get in with a clear majority and with a mandate and with sufficient strength to make sure they could be held responsible for all their policies and could implement them. This is what we do not get in very large constituency situations. As a Fianna Fáil Government on one occasion we were dependent on Independent support and we still lasted as long as two Coalitions. That day is still to come. We will have it in 1974-75. It is difficult for a Government to carry out a proper programme policy without a reasonable majority.

Comment on this
Gerard Lynch Mr. G. Lynch Fine Gael

No problem.

Comment on this

I have an answer but I will not give it because the Deputy might mix me up with a gentleman from the other House.

Again, like the Ennis-Galway thing, this is an extraordinary thing. I was down in Mid-Cork and working in Douglas where they are very nice people. It is a very nice place and I enjoyed myself there. Douglas is traditionally a Fine Gael area, but now it is voting sensibly Fianna Fáil and we won it for the first time in history. When I had to go to the count I had to drive nearly half way across the country. As a four-seat constituency that was obviously too big and unwieldy. Now it will be a five-seat constituency going right around Cork city and a bit of Cork city has gone into it.

Comment on this

That was Kevin Boland's decision. Kevin Boland made it when the Deputy was there. That was a 1969 decision.

Comment on this

Now it will be a five-seat constituency. Cork city has gone into it.

Comment on this
Gerard Lynch Mr. G. Lynch Fine Gael

Only for the by-elections Deputy Lemass would not know the country.

Comment on this

Deputy G. Lynch is always very quick with smart remarks. He fails to notice that I am wearing the badge of the Irish Commercial Travellers' Confederation and I was in every town in this country before the Deputy got out of his own native Kerry.

Comment on this

I was in Kerry before the Deputy saw a paved footpath.

Comment on this
Gerard Lynch Mr. G. Lynch Fine Gael

We did not wait in Kerry for Deputy Lemass to pave the footpaths of Kerry.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair is waiting for Deputy Lemass to speak on the Electoral Bill.

Comment on this

And to give us common sense. That is what we are waiting for.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Other Deputies will have an opportunity of making their contributions later on.

Comment on this

As I was saying, if I thought that this Bill was entirely the product of the Minister for Local Government I would vote for it because every decision that Minister has made since he has taken office was a mistake. It will be exposed as a mistake. I warned him about the mortgage rises last May and he bluffed it out and eventually he had to make a State subvention. I am still saying that the mortgage interest rates are pushing close to 14 per cent and they were only stalled because the Monaghan by-election was on. We will have the rise in January and the people who have SDA loans will know about it.

There is another peculiar thing which I came across, again relating back to Monaghan, where we have been quite recently. There are proposals by the Government to create three borders instead of the one we have now. This ten-mile joint policing zone—how will it fit into this Bill? Will the people on the north side of this "no-go" area vote on the south and will the people on the south vote in the north?

Comment on this
Fergus O'Brien Mr. F. O'Brien Fine Gael

The Deputy is being mischievous now. That is a lie and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

Not at all. This was published in the papers. I hope this is a Coalition kite, but it is certainly being flown.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Brien Mr. F. O'Brien Fine Gael

We did not fly it. Ask the Independent newspaper about it.

Comment on this

A good old Fine Gael newspaper. Anyway this is a matter the Minister should seriously consider. If this ten-mile no-man's-land situation comes about are these people to have no vote? Are they to elect their own government?

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

I am not quoting. I am paraphrasing.

Comment on this

Paraphrasing what?

Comment on this

I am paraphrasing a general report in the newspapers. This is what I have been led to believe is the kite that is being flown by the Coalition. I hope it is a kite, because people will shoot it down, and if it is shot down, then this problem to which I refer will not arise. In the event of the Government proceeding with these proposals, what I am curious to know is where these people will be, what their constituency will be; will they be self-governing or what will the position be?

I should like to get on to Dublin, if I may, because in Dublin I see all that is good in the Bill. If we can gain, as we have done on many occasions, three seats out of five, we can certainly gain two out of three, and it will take only a very small change of public opinion, which is already starting and is very obvious in city areas.

Comment on this

It started in Monaghan all right.

Comment on this

I do not know how the price of feedstuffs counts with people, but I certainly know how the price of foodstuffs counts with people in Dublin city. In regard to the constituency of Kildare the Minister says at column 1986, Volume 268 of the Official Report of 15th November last:

It is particularly desirable that the historic county boundaries should be preserved as far as possible.

I have already given the quotation from the Minister when he was in opposition. Bearing that in mind I cannot understand why a constituency called Mid-Dublin and another called West-Dublin will require any parliamentary party that gains two seats in these areas to select one from the city and one from County Kildare. Both of these constituencies are the same. I know Mid-County goes into Wicklow rather than Kildare, but West County goes into Kildare. The Minister, when in Opposition, said at column 1817, Volume 237, of the Official Report of 4th December, 1968:

I do not care what any Member of the House says, I have a personal view on this and I believe that county boundaries are important, just as I believe the national boundary is important...

He has the audacity to state that belief and then present us with this when introducing this Bill. The worst example is the Ennis-Galway one, but here we shall have to have rural and urban people selected if we aspire to two seats in these constituencies, as of course we will do; our city area will be our rural area and our rural area will be our city area. There are many unusual things about this. I talked about West Galway; indeed, East Mayo and West Mayo seem peculiar to me as well.

Comment on this

That is O'Brien's two Irelands; they got mixed up in them.

Comment on this

As far as Deputy Nolan and I are concerned, while it will not be possible to elect two Fianna Fáil Deputies in every constituency, even without any change in the figures available to us for the last couple of elections, there are certainly at this time 18 out of 43 seats. But what I can tell the Minister and the Government without any fear of contradiction is that if they continue as they are doing there will be two-thirds of those 43 seats which will come to the Fianna Fáil Party when the people once again ask us to clear up the mess.

Comment on this

Having studied this Bill and listened to and read some of the contributions on it, I am certain that no matter what decent motives the Minister credits to himself—and he must have had to search very hard for any decent motives for this type of Bill —it is an attempt to secure a proportion of the seats for the Labour and Fine Gael Parties that is much more than the votes of their supporters warrant.

When one looks at the map one sees the crooked, tortuous line, the butchering that went on, the unusual little snippets that were taken out here and there and the lack of any overall pattern in the framing of the constituencies. What I mean by an overall pattern is that there would appear to be a special policy for Dublin city and a different policy for Dublin city of Cork, and an extra special policy for the constituency of Meath; but the same policy was not applied to Wicklow. Any child could easily see through this and that it was political expediency and a desire to hold the reins of office that dictated these changes in the constituencies. There is no need for me to labour this fact when the Chief Whip of the Government Party has already admitted it.

When a previous Minister, the former Deputy Kevin Boland, was doing his job, the Opposition looked for an independent commission at that time. It is extraordinary that what they felt was so desirable then is not desirable now. Boland's so-called butchery would not hold a candle to Tully's trickery. The Tullymandering, the bisecting and the trisecting of my own constituency, beggars description.

Comment on this

Is it in order to refer to the Minister in such terms as "Tully's trickery"?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I think the Deputy should refer to the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister's trickery then. Would you think it in order for me to refer to it as "Tullymandering"?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Whether the Deputy should attribute trickery to the Minister or not, the Chair would prefer that he would not make such allegations.

Comment on this

The Minister's bisecting and trisecting—I shall leave it at that—beggars description. The biggest difference I have seen between the carving up of the constituencies on this occasion and the carving up on the previous occasion is that Kevin Boland was prepared to take a chance. He gave himself a three-seater in South County Dublin and he was elected to the third seat on the eighth count. Boland's bravery contrasts very forcibly with the timidity of the present occupant of that office. The Minister, Deputy Tully, was very much afraid to take a chance. He had a three-seater in Meath; he has now made it a four-seater. He was afraid he might not be in the first three. He was lucky to be in third in 1969 and 1973. In our part of the country, if we have an each-way bet, bookies will pay out only on the first three; in certain big handicaps where there are a lot of runners you might get odds on the first four. Apparently the Minister had not much faith in his own ability for the next election, and so he made a fourth place.

With regard to the independent tribunal I believe, and I am not a party spokesman, this is my personal opinion, that this is the proper way to have this matter decided. I think that we in Fianna Fáil should make this one of the planks of our future policy to be enacted when we resume Government. I would certainly welcome this and Deputy Molloy has also indicated that he would welcome it. It is important that the people of Ireland should know that this offer has been made to the Minister. I am making it to him again now and asking him whether he is turning it down. It is important that the voters should know that an offer of an independent tribunal or commission was made and that it has been turned down.

What was so desirable when Deputy Tully was on this side of the House is no longer palatable to him since he gained ministerial status on the other side of the House. Of course, we can look upon this as just another broken promise and when one is in the habit of breaking one's promises one may adopt the attitude that one may as well be hung for a sheep as a lamb. It is now evident to most clear-thinking people that these promises were merely political posturing, that they were motivated by greed and that the present Government were eaten up with the very vices they accused our Government of when we were in office. It is clear to me that these people, the people of all talents, are now shown up for what they are. They are just a sham as far as I am concerned and their short period in office has shown them up for what they are.

Deputy Lemass mentioned that the word "sacrosanct" was used in regard to county boundaries. That word should not be used because "sacrosanct" comes from the word "sacred" and it is clear from a cursory examination of these proposals that the word "sacred" does not enter into it because no county boundary is sacred. Look at Mid-Cork, a portion deep into the heart of Cork City now being added on to a very ungainly constituency. Look at Kildare, Wicklow and Clare. In fact, look anywhere on the map and you will see that boundaries have been breached. I do not think the Minister would fool anyone by the use of the word "sacrosanct". To me the use of that word is sacrilegious because no boundary is sacred.

The key to the Minister's attitude can be seen in his remarks during this Bill and in particular in his many interruptions. He was not content to tell us about the Bill and sit down and listen to our comments. He interrupted many times and he seemed to take delight in telling us all that no one personally dislikes the Bill. He seemed to lay great weight on the word "personally". I would ask the Minister why should personalities enter into this at all. Personalities should not enter into the carving up of constituencies. I know they did and very forcibly in the Minister's case but why should the Taoiseach's personal position be safeguarded in Dún Laoghaire/Rathdown? This attitude, to me, is political fawning at its worst, fawning on the boss. In the overall thinking on this Bill there must have been a thought in the Minister's mind as to what he could gain personally? That is political patronage at its worst and the fact that the Minister facilitated a Fine Gael Taoiseach indicates to me that he possibly would, as many people now think, feel much more at home with Fine Gael than he does with his former colleagues in Labour.

If the Minister wants to know about my personal feelings, I do not care what the Minister does about the constituency. I defy him to carve up Kildare and deprive me of my seat. I will get in in spite of him and Fine Gael and Labour and all the scalpels and long knives in the Custom House. I dislike the overall implications of the Minister's remarks, that he should be thinking personally at all. I notice that when the Minister interrupted Deputy Moore in the course of his contribution he said:

I am proud of my work. I think it is great. Fantastic.

Those were the words he used. One would expect that if the Minister got more opportunity from the Chair he possibly would have come up with that famous remark "I am the greatest" or, like the person to whom the phrase was first attributed, one could expect Minister Mohammed Tully to break into poetry. Perhaps this little piece of doggerel, with your indulgence, Sir, would be appropriate:

In '69 and '73

The last elected was Jimmy Tully And just in case he slips some more He gives Fianna Fáil two and he makes it four.

In Meath it is clear to me that party expediency played second fiddle to personal expediency. It is easy for anybody to see that we will get a second seat in Meath on the next occasion. It would appear that the Minister had no faith in his own ability and he is quite content to give us an extra seat there and let the rest of the country make up for his shortfall in County Meath.

When one examines this Bill I think the biggest single defect in it is that Dublin will decide in all future elections what the Government of the country will be. This, I suppose, is in keeping with a Coalition Government that is pickled with Dublin-based Minister, whether they are sweet pickles or sour pickles remains to be seen. From an industrtial viewpoint and from a population viewpoint Dublin is top heavy. The metropolitan area has far too big a population and it needs to be decentralised. I am told that one of the first signs of decay in a country is when the capital becomes too big. Dublin has at least two seats more than it should have. I would ask the Minister to explain why Celbridge, Maynooth and Leixlip were packed into Dublin and why two portions of Wicklow were clipped off and put into Dublin constituencies. I am confident that we, the rural people, deserve an extra seat in each and whatever constituency had the extra seat would not suffer thereby.

Why were 13 three-seaters established in the Dublin Metropolitan area? My belief is that that was done so that 47 per cent of the voters of the country in the Dublin area would, it is hoped, succeed in getting 33 per cent of the seats and that 25 per cent of the voters would get the same percentage of the seats, 33 per cent. However, as Deputy Lemass remarked, this might not work out as the mathematicians plan. Mathematicians' and Ministers' and mice's plans "gang aft agley" and even the best laid plans in this case will come unstuck, too, because Dublin voters are much more fiickle than their conservative rural brethren and the expected one Labour, one Fine Gael and one Fianna Fáil return in each of the three-seat constituencies in Dublin will not materialise.

Assuming that those people within the Minister's party who do not agree with him will decide to vote for this Bill, the Minister will find at the next election that the minds of the people cannot be manipulated as easily as can county boundaries. He will have no control over the votes of people when they go to the booths. In the tricky three-seater situation in Dublin many of the Minister's Labour, or should I say Coalition colleagues—although one wonders about the order of preference after the rather passive role of the Assistant Whip yesterday when Deputy Toal was introduced to the House—will rue the day that this Bill was passed.

One aspect of the Minister's proposals with which I agree is the decision to have 148 Deputies returned to this House. No doubt the four extra Deputies will warrant the small amount of extra expense involved. I am convinced that a Deputy from any party is a help to any constituency: if he were not, he would not be in office for very long.

From the point of view of Kildare the Minister's proposals are very disconcerting. The county of Kildare is a growing and developing area. Before the last change, with the aid of a portion of Meath and of Westmeath, ours was a four-seat constituency but after the last change it was reduced to a three-seater. The portion of a rural area near Carbury was transferred to Meath for election purposes. We find now that, despite the growth in our population, it is proposed to retain the constituency as a three-seater and that a built-up portion in the Kilcock area is being transferred to Meath while a small rural area is being given back to us from the former Meath constituency and also that a big chunk of north Kildare—Celbridge, Maynooth and Leixlip—is now being transferred to Dublin.

With the exception of the metropolitan area, Kildare has the highest growth rate in the country. Our population is greater than that of Meath, and for that reason alone we should have been one of the counties to receive an increase of one seat. At the time of the last revision the population of Meath was slightly more than that of Kildare. Possibly that would have swayed the issue in deciding to give three seats to Kildare and four to Meath before the 1969 election; but on this occasion we have the greater population and, consequently, should have had a claim to a fourth seat.

Kildare was tri-sected to make it a three-seater. One would wonder why that should have been done, but it is no more than an example of the personal tone that is evident in all the Minister's plans. The reason why Kildare is being divided in this way— portion of it being given to Meath and another portion to West County Dublin—is to ensure that Mr. Terry Boylan would no longer pose a threat so far as votes are concerned. In order to do this the portion of Kildare that must be cut off would possibly have given a Fianna Fáil nominee a secure base in any new constituency. Consequently, it was decided to give portion of the constituency to Meath and another portion to Dublin. Even in the case of Celbridge parish it was decided to divide that parish so that the Straffan portion would remain in Kildare and the Celbridge portion would go to West County Dublin. This was done with the intention of helping the Labour Party, or perhaps, a stag party might be more appropriate. My colleague, Deputy Bermingham on the opposite benches will know what I mean.

It is difficult to understand why a portion of Kildare that was necessary to give Meath four seats some years ago could now be given back to Kildare while Kilcock and another portion of Kildare is being given to Meath. The desired result of this effort is to ensure that Mr. Boylan's base will be such as not to have a significant bearing on his new Dublin constituency. Enough butchering has been done to deprive him of a seat in Kildare. I am amazed that the Minister should have considered the Labour Party to be so vulnerable. Indeed, the Minister's action is no compliment to Deputy Bermingham. He must not have much faith in the good work that Deputy Bermingham is doing in the constituency. The only difference I see between the Minister's actions regarding Leinster and Cromwell's action in relation to the whole country is that while Cromwell said "To hell or to Connacht", the Minister, to give him his due, gave Kildare people a choice in that they could go either to hell or to Meath or Dublin.

I have some interesting figures here regarding Kildare. Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary would convey them to the Minister. These figures show the decline in population which occurred in that county between the years 1841 and 1971. In 1841 Kildare county had a population of 114,488 persons. It is interesting to note that in the same year Dublin, which comprised the county and county borough, had only 372,733 persons. At that stage Dublin was hardly three times bigger than Kildare but in the meantime the population of Dublin has increased every year, or at least for every year in which a census was taken, and the figure for 1971 was 852,219. Kildare's population dwindled consistently every year from 1841 to 1936 when the population was 57,892. Perhaps it is significant that in 1936 the policies pursued by the then new Fianna Fáil Government who had only taken office a short time before began to have effect and on upward spiral began in Kildare at that time. There was a slight decrease from 1951 to 1961, the population being a little more than 66,000 in 1951 and a little more than 64,000 in 1961 but the figure has increased every year since and at the last census our population was 71,977 so that there were 5,500 more people in Kildare in 1971 than there were in 1966.

The Minister has decided to put into other constituencies the areas of our county in which there was the greatest growth rate. The people of Kildare will not be very happy about that. At the time of the Normans the Fitzgerald family established Kildare as their base, erecting a castle in Maynooth and another at Kilkea and they decided on the boundaries of Kildare. These boundaries remained unchanged from the time of the Great Earls and the time of the halycon days of the Geraldines but the Minister has changed that. He might as well go the whole hog and change the name of Leinster House, the town residence of the Fitzgeralds, and of Kildare Street to West Dublin House and West Dublin Street from now on. With very little help we would have had the population to warrant four seats. Our county boundaries demanded that. If the remarks which are credited to him when matters like this were being discussed mean anything, he should have given Kildare back to the Kildare people. We deserve another voice in the Dáil; we are entitled to that. I know the people in the Carbery and other areas would prefer to be in a Kildare constituency. The Minister should apply to Kildare the same guidelines he applied to his constituency.

When this Bill is discussed and analysed the people will not thank the Minister for giving Dublin a say out of all proportion to its size. That is the Bill's biggest defect. The Minister is denying rural areas the representation they deserve, not alone from a population point of view but also because of geographical factors. Rural constituencies are much more unwiedly than city constituencies. Local people must travel long distances in order to maintain contact with their Deputies. For that reason I feel Kildare deserves an extra seat. Dublin could easily have been restructured. The two seats which were given to the metropolitan area could have been given to Kildare and Wicklow. Regretfully, I am confident that the Kildare voters in the Meath and Dublin constituencies will not be of sufficient number to succeed in electing a Kildare man. Two divisions saw to that. As we know from experience, political loyalties do not pass over county boundaries. People now in Kildare will not feel properly represented in the metropolitan area.

A name will often succeed in electing a person to a Dublin constituency. I do not know what criteria the city voters use when electing representatives, but many people are elected who would not be in the first three in a rural constituency. If the Minister cannot change the Bill at this stage, and he must persist with three seats in Kildare, why does he not apply the same test to Meath? Why should he show the white feather with regard to Meath? He should take a chance on his re-election. He should be confident in the fact that he is a Minister and in the news every day. He is seen opening new housing estates and so on and taking credit for them. He directs operations from his lofty eyrie in the Customs House. He should not be afraid that the people of Meath will not think the world of him at the next election and return him to a three-seat constituency. If he wants to cover up the skullduggery he hopes to enact in this Bill he should show an overall pattern. Why should he have three-seaters in Dublin and a five-seater in Cork? Why take a chunk out of Cork City and put it into Mid-Cork? My only remark on the carving up of Mid-Cork is that after the next election the Minister will be wise after the event.

This Bill will have far-reaching effects on politics. It is sad to think that the Minister will be remembered for this Bill and this Bill alone; a Minister who kept his seat while everyone about him was losing his. The Minister should feel ashamed of himself, if he has any sense of shame. It is evident in every carve-up that it is political patronage at its most vile; it is party advantage carried to extremes that nobody could defend, and, worst of all, it is his personal salvation ensured to the extent of giving us a seat. It is no wonder it took the Minister so long to produce this shameful sham.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

This is the first time I have addressed the House on an Electoral (Amendment) Bill. With no disrespect to the Parliamentary Secretary, I am sorry the Minister is not here to hear my comments. We have all been waiting for this Bill which was promised and expected since the election last February. Any time the Minister was asked a question he smiled or laughed and said that the Bill was coming. One expected it to be a wonderful production for which the Minister would be remembered and that it would follow the lines he had preached for so long in Opposition while adopting a holier-than-thou attitude. In the early summer he promised to have the Bill ready in July. Of course, the Minister was not able to keep that promise, like many other promises. We are all aware of the reasons why he could not do so. There was in-fighting between the two parties forming the Coalition. Members of these parties, who had been so long in Opposition, were determined that they would introduce a Bill which would keep the Coalition Government in power for at least another term of office. Despite the Minister's confidence in his own ability, I do not think that even a man far superior in ability would have been able to introduce a Bill to achieve this because many mistakes have been made up to now. However, he has tried, and tried to the best of his ability.

One striking aspect of the Bill is its inconsistencies. The influence of the two parties is obvious from the document before us. It reminds me of a chunk of wood which was round at the beginning but when each member had finished chipping and adding, it had become a very peculiar shape. When the last Bill was introduced somebody described it as a "Bolander"; this could be described as a "Tullyar".

Comment on this

Tulyar was not much good. They sold him to America.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

He did well for a considerable period and then failed the acid test.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy speaking about the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Lynch?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

No. We are talking about the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Tully. Obviously this man let his imagination run away with him in very many areas.

Comment on this

What about the mongrel foxes?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I was coming to that point because there was a lot of biting done in Cork and I think the mongrel foxes played a big part. I offer my sincere sympathy to the Minister because, despite his faults and despite the complaints and criticisms we will voice of him, I accept that he is a hard-working Minister and that he is determined to do his job to the best of his ability. I am sorry that this production is so definitely designed to gerrymander the constituencies to give him the result he and his Government would like to see. The mistake they are all making is that they are forgetting that the people of Ireland are very sensible when it comes to voting, and they will give this Bill their answer at the first available opportunity.

The Minister will have many worries between now and the next general election. He will worry about the eventual result of the election. He will worry about how many seats his Government will get. He will also worry about how many seats his own party will get. Therein lies the crunch. This is where the Minister will be regarded as having failed the Labour Party throughout the length and breath of the country. This will be proved to him in the next general election. It will react on him and on his party in a very unfavourable way when the opportunity arises.

I suppose we are all parochial on a Bill such as this. There are areas with which we are familiar and there are areas we do not know so well. To those of us who do not know the area so well, it seems a bit peculiar to see a big chunk of Clare added to West Galway. I wonder did the Minister forget the promise he made to keep the county boundaries intact so far as possible. That one went a bit lobsided on him. We all know why that constituency is being so framed. Deputy Power has already mentioned his own constituency. A Minister who sat in Opposition for so long, and adopted a holier-than-thou attitude, and talked about how he would treat such a Bill if he were given the opportunity, should have set an example instead of entrenching his own position and perhaps upsetting the position of some of his colleagues.

This is typical of the Government. I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary is here because he is a Munster man. He is one of the few men from outside the Greater Dublin area in the Government. This Bill is giving more power to the metropolitan area and this gives people down the country reasonable grounds for criticism. It is worth looking at the situation in Cork. Cork City has six seats under the existing arrangement. The Minister has now seen fit to downgrade Cork City and to reduce its representation in the city, as such, by one seat. The people of Cork will remember that for the Minister. They will look at Dublin and see that he gave Dublin all three seat constituencies with the exception of the Taoiseach's constituency. That is an interesting one and I will come back to it later.

The Minister decided that he would reduce the representation in Cork, the second largest city in Ireland, by one seat. Naturally the first question everybody must ask is: why? Why should the Minister look at Cork and decide to reduce Cork City by one seat and give that seat to Mid-Cork? This is one of the jokes in this Bill. When the previous Electoral Amendment Bill was introduced the constituency of Mid-Cork got most of the criticism from the Opposition at that time. It was referred to as a monstrosity. It was referred to as a constituency that crawled almost from Cork City Hall out to the county boundaries of Kerry and Limerick. It was suggested that it was an impossible constituency to work.

While agreeing that it is a very big constituency, I think the four representatives from that area would not say that it is impossible to work, nor could the people say they did not work hard enough for them. The joke is that now, when these people who spoke so loudly, so strongly and so clearly about Mid-Cork are in office, approximately 15,000 voters from Cork City have been added on to make Mid-Cork a five-seater. If you look at this area which has been added on to Mid-Cork you will discover that included in it are some of the older parts of Cork City, traditional old areas. I refer specifically to Bandon Road and The Lough, to places like Gillabbey and Togher. I cannot say when University College, Cork, was built but it is no longer in the Cork City constituency.

The voters of these areas are included in Mid-Cork and we welcome them. We welcome working for them but I do not think it is sensible to think that the same type of representation can represent some of the older areas of Cork City and some of the outlying rural areas. Obviously this was done with a purpose and this is where I think the mongrel foxes bit the deepest. The people of Cork will not blame the Minister to the same extent as they will blame the Minister for Transport and Power for their own city. As a Government Minister from that city, he would have been expected to show a greater regard for the people of Cork and for the area of Cork generally. Obviously he used his influence and his powers of persuasion on the Minister to have this constituency divided in the way it has been divided. This is very interesting. I am sorry the Minister is not here so that I could tell him a few things.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

It is significant that the areas coming into Mid-Cork are the Labour areas of the city. They are traditionally Cork City, having long links with Cork City. As I said, we welcome these areas; we welcome the voters in them and we will certainly work in their interests. Nevertheless, this change is really a tragedy. It is something that will not be forgotten for the Minister when it comes to facing the people. The Minister for Transport and Power must share most of the blame because it is obvious his powers of persuasion on the Minister for Local Government exercised a strong influence on the Minister's final decision. It may interest the Minister to know that his own party members in the city are most disappointed because of the areas which have been taken out of Mid-Cork. Blackrock and Douglas were in Mid-Cork at one stage, but they were not moved out because that would not have suited the Minister for Transport and Power. This addition has a specific purpose behind it. The Minister has let down his own party in dividing Cork City. Again we have the inconstituency of a five-seat constituency in Cork City, a five-seat constituency in Mid-Cork and the city of Dublin carrying mainly three-seat constituencies.

In the debate on the last Electoral (Amendment) Bill in 1968, at column 1725 of Volume 238, Deputy Barrett, the predecessor of the present Minister for Transport and Power, referred to the unfairness of having residents in Blackrock and Douglas within a quarter and half mile of Cork City Hall having to depend for their representation on rural Deputies living throughout the county. What was true of Blackrock and Douglas then is equally true now of Ballyphehane, Gillabbey, Bandon Road and the Lough. The argument used then by Deputy Barrett applies with equal force today. It is, of course, a question of designing an area to try to help the present Government.

I have a message to give the Minister: the reconstructed Cork City and Mid-Cork will give us in Fianna Fáil the very same representation as we now hold in the next general election and the Minister's party in the city will not forgive him for the way in which he has treated them, considering he had an opportunity of winning a seat there.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Then the Deputy has nothing to complain about.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I do not look on this matter personally. I look at the overall situation. That is the way we should all look at it. It would be foolish of me to say I have a personal complaint because my personal complaint is not important in the long run. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach is in the House at the moment and he was one of the people that publicly stated on very many occasions that electroal amendments should not be made by a Minister for Local Government or by the Government but that a commission should be set up for this purpose. Now that he and the others with him have the opportunity of trying desperately to hold on to power against the will of the people——

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

What about Monaghan?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

That was a victory for the Opposition, not for the Government.

Comment on this

The Government parties were depending on Kevin Boland's votes to get them in.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. Kelly) Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil would have turned up their noses at Kevin Boland's votes, would they?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The holier-than-thou man is now in power and he is using that power to protect his own interests, to hold on to power, to keep his Government in power, but the people of Ireland——

Comment on this

Not only did Fianna Fáil have the chance but they failed to make the change when they had the chance.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Would you bring the Parliamentary Secretary to order, Sir? He has an unfortunate habit of interrupting. This is the first electoral Bill since I came into this House. It is a sore disappointment. I am disappointed that the Minister designed what he regards as a Bill to keep his Government in power. I am disappointed that he should have yielded to the pressure put on him by both parties and the in-fighting which was known all over this House, the in-fighting that went on for months and delayed the Bill for months, with Senator John Mannion and others putting in their spoke in regard to the townlands they wanted in their constituencies. When the parties opposite were in Opposition they stood in these benches and preached about what should be done and what they would do if given the opportunity but, when given the opportunity, this is what they produce. As I said, this is the "Tullyar" which fell at the final fence. In the next general election the Minister and the Government will have many worries about how many seats they will win. I have a message for the Minister: the people at the grassroots level of his own party are not happy and the Members opposite will be less happy when the general election is over.

Comment on this

One of the things that strikes me most in this debate is the failure of the Government parties to offer any speakers. I wonder why this should be.

Comment on this

They are completely disgusted with the Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy's party is losing power every minute.

Comment on this

I am surprised at this because this is the first piece of legislation the National Coalition Government have introduced since they came to power last March. I had hoped that, as it was one of the most important pieces of legislation this year, we would have had constructive contributions from the Government side of the House. Unfortunately, this has not been the case and, as we have seen this afternoon, all the speakers who have offered are from the Fianna Fáil side.

Comment on this

They are trying to waste time and hold up the business of this House.

Comment on this

Then maybe it is a waste of time for the Members on this side of the House to talk on this Bill.

Comment on this

Therefore, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach does not consider this to be important legislation.

Comment on this

It is the fifth day that we have had the Second Stage of this Bill.

Comment on this

That shows the importance of the Bill.

Comment on this

The only conclusion that I can come to is that the Minister for Local Government consulted with all of his Deputies before the introduced this Bill and that they are happy with what has been presented to this House. I am surprised at this and, in particular, I am surprised at the Deputies from the west of Ireland. Under this Bill the west of Ireland will lose two seats. I cannot understand why the Fine Gael Deputies from the west of Ireland accepted this. There is no point in them saying that they had not been consulted about it or that they did not know about it because everybody knows that for a few months previous to the introduction of this Bill they had the soles of their shoes worn going in and out to the Minister for Local Government in an effort to carve up their own constituencies to suit themselves.

This is a fact particularly in relation to County Galway which, under this Bill, will be divided into two four-seats constituencies. It is obvious that a seat will be lost in County Galway. This is unfortunate. I know we cannot blame the Minister for juggling the constituencies in an effort to get the most out of them for his own political end. This had been done before. However, it is unfortunate that the west of Ireland, over which so many crocodile tears have been shed, should be deprived of two voices in this House.

We know that when the Taoiseach was appointing his Ministers he almost forgot the west of Ireland. All he gave to the entire western region was one Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

The Leader of the Opposition dropped three western men from the front bench.

Comment on this

He is giving the other fellow a chance.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnellan need not talk because we know that when the Cabinet was being formed he took a train trip to Dublin.

Comment on this

I usually drive.

Comment on this

The news was that Deputy Donnellan travelled by train because he expected to have a car coming home. I am sorry for the Deputy that this did not happen.

Comment on this

The Deputy was on a one-way ticket.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach at that time forgot about the west of Ireland and now the Minister for Local Government sees fit to deprive us of two voices in the House.

Comment on this

And one of those voices will be that of the Deputy. Then the Deputy will be in possession of the one-way ticket.

Comment on this

That will be decided by the people of North-East Galway. As long as the people of that constituency want me I will represent them. I have no fear about this division because if I do my duty for my constituents they will return me along with Deputy Donnellan, I suppose. Deputy Donnellan has made sure of consolidating his position in Galway and he cannot be blamed for that, but every Deputy should be concerned about the fact that the west has lost two voices in this House.

Comment on this

What would the Deputy's plan be in relation to this?

Comment on this

I am not the Minister for Local Government and I have no intention of intimating what my plan would be.

Comment on this

The Deputy has criticised the proposals of the Minister without having any of his own.

Comment on this

If the Minister went according to the figures of the last census there was no reason for him to alter the position in the west.

Comment on this

The west lost 40,000 people under Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

There is no reason, according to the figures of the last census, why the west of Ireland should have lost two Deputies. That is my sole complaint. I am not speaking at all about the way the constituencies have been divided but about the loss of two seats to the west. This is something that should concern those representing that area of the country. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach has admitted that the population in the west was sufficient to elect 30 Deputies as has happened in the past. That cannot be denied. Of course, in order to copper-fasten the position of the National Coalition——

Comment on this

That is incorrect.

Comment on this

——and to keep them in power——

Comment on this

The National Coalition got into power on a Bill drawn up by a former Fianna Fáil Minister, ex-Deputy Boland.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy then explain to me why it was necessary to butcher the constituencies in such a fashion as the Minister for Local Government has done now?

Comment on this

And we were described as being the worst in the world for taking votes from Fianna Fáil in the last election.

Comment on this

I do not see why Deputy Hussey or other Deputies on the Fianna Fáil side are complaining because it is the first time that a Government other than a Fianna Fáil Government has had an opportunity to redraw the constituencies. Fianna Fáil are now shedding crocodile tears. They should take their medicine.

Comment on this

We are not shedding crocodile tears. If the Deputy refers to the statements made by Fine Gael and Labour Members when in Opposition he will see the extent of the crocodile tears they shed.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Donnellan wish to speak?

Comment on this

Deputy Donnellan is free to speak on this Bill and I will not interrupt him. I feel certain that he will speak in protest against this injustice. Making the Dublin constituencies three-seaters is an attempt to strengthen the Labour representation in Dublin. However, I do not believe this will happen because if the present swing against the Government continues it will lead to a change of Government.

In my view the most important thing is that in the west of Ireland it takes more people to elect a Deputy than it does in Dublin. This is a grave injustice against the west and it should not be allowed to happen. I should like to protest again against the Minister's action in reducing the representation of the west of Ireland by two Members. This is the greatest injustice that has been done to the west but the people there will remember it at election time.

Comment on this

If any Member on the Government backbenches wishes to speak I will give way.

Comment on this

Has Deputy Dowling spoken on this Bill already?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowling is playing such a "blinder" that the Government side think he is two men.

Comment on this

This is a very important piece of legislation although the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach feels that a limited amount of time should be devoted to it. This legislation can manipulate the affairs of the nation for the next eight or nine years. This Bill, in my view, is a device to maintain power.

The people of the six north-eastern counties of this country must be very depressed to think that there is a Government here that sets out to do the same thing that they have been fighting against for many years. This Bill is an effort to gerrymander this section of the country. We are aware of the difficulties that exist in the North; we know of the trouble that resulted there due to the gerrymandering that took place over the years. I shall just quote the Minister for Foreign Affairs when he said, in an article printed in the Sunday Independent on 12th November, 1972, that for 50 years Unionist control of government in Northern Ireland was extended far beyond the areas where the Unionists secured a majority of votes. This, he said, was done by gerrymandering, by rigging the constituency boundaries in such a way as to convert a minority of votes into a majority of seats. Of course, we now have the riggers in Government here who will ensure that the area is gerrymandered. We should know by now the terrible tragedies that resulted from consistent gerrymandering over the years in another part of this country. No doubt the Unionists in the North will read this discussion with interest and see how the Fine Gael and Labour Parties have endeavoured to gerrymander the situation here. I am certain that they will say that should they come in here they will be subjected to the same treatment which is regarded as so undesirable in that part of the country. I am certain that the Northern community will be watching the situation here and we want to tell them now that this is a Bill to gerrymander this part of the country. It is a type of treatment they would possibly get under a Government such as we have here at present.

There will not be two parties, Fine Gael and Labour, contesting the next election. There will be only one party and this Bill is so devised that it will be for one party and one party in Opposition. We welcome the day when we shall meet on equal terms one party comprised of Fine Gael and Labour. An effort was made in Monaghan to establish that party. So, some members of the Labour Party were distrubed by some of the meetings which took place in Monaghan between Members of the Government and numbers of people in corners in order to bring about a position in which they would form one party. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach may not have been aware of this development but some Labour Party Members feel that their Ministers in this Coalition are losing their identity and are being absorbed into this great gerrymander machine that we see in action.

Comment on this

If they had steered clear of the campaign the Deputy would have said they were not behind the Government.

Comment on this

They participated in the campaign and they set in train a situation in which the workers of this city who supported Labour in the last election will have completely lost their identity because I am sure very few of them would support Fine Gael. The only party we shall have in the next election will be a combination of Fine Gael and Labour.

So long as Labour Party supporters are aware of what is happening at this early stage, that some of their people are now betraying them in order to assure themselves of Ministerial posts in a future Government should the people be foolish enough to re-elect them, I am certain that the collective wisdom of our people will give an answer to the present Government when the time comes. We have relied on that wisdom through the years and the people have responded in a responsible way on every occasion. Only on two occasions since 1932, other than the last occasion, did we have a change but never did either Fine Gael or Labour get a clear mandate from the electorate. When on the next occasion we have only the one Party we shall see how the people will feel.

This type of gerrymander and constituency rigging which the Minister for Foreign Affairs spoke about in his article is exactly what is happening here now. The Parliamentary Secretary cannot deny this and that this is an attempt to rig the constituencies. This is a fact that cannot be denied and I want to say that here and now so that people north, south, east and west fully understand it.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think we should have kept Mr. Boland's pattern of constituencies? What would he have said had we done that? Would we not be the laughing stock of the country?

Comment on this

This is a deliberate attempt to gerrymander——

Comment on this

It is an attempt to undo Mr. Boland's gerrymander——

Comment on this

——and well the Parliamentary Secretary knows this. I am certain that the people in the North will be watching the situation here to see if a responsible Government will devise electoral areas to the satisfaction of the community as a whole. They now can see this Bill which is designed to do just the opposite. It is designed to do what a group of people were condemned for doing for so long and so violently in the six north-eastern counties.

I support the view of the Minister for Foreign Affairs when he spoke recently about the type of situation which evolved there. We do not want that here; we have no time for it and I am quite certain that in time the people here will give their answer. It is a question of how many seats that party will get. I do not know the names or even the form of the party. I am not sure if the Parliamentary Secretary will have a position in it but nevertheless there were Ministers who took part in discussions regarding the formation of a combined party of Fine Gael and Labour. Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary knows about it.

Comment on this

No, they left me out of that.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should direct his remarks to the Chair and not to the Parliamentary Secretary. In that way we might avoid interruptions.

Comment on this

Through the Chair, I want to say that I am quite positive he was. He was up there and so I am sure he was familiar with the set-up. As many speakers have pointed out, we have, first, the Minister for Local Government who has apportioned his constituency in such a way that he must retain his seat, or so he hopes. He has added a further seat so that this upholstered constituency which had three seats will now have four. This is to make sure that he as a Minister will be re-elected. Again, the people will have their say.

Many Deputies have made the important point regarding the western problem, which is a very serious one. In Opposition members of the present Government shed many tears for the people of the west but the amazing fact is that when they came to power, as Deputy Hussey and others pointed out, not one Minister was appointed from the west of Ireland, showing their complete disregard for the west. But for the fact that it was mentioned here, when the Taoiseach had his Cabinet lined up, that he completely forgot the west, I am quite certain the Taoiseach would not even have appointed a Parliamentary Secretary who comes from west of the Shannon. We have a situation of complete disregard for the people of the west of Ireland.

Comment on this

What about the three decent men from Mayo that Deputy Lynch dropped?

Comment on this

There has been a complete disregard for the west but the people will give the Government their answer when the time comes. At column 2012 of the Official Report dated 15th November the following is stated:

Examples of this manipulation can be found in what has been done in Dublin. The proposed revision is North County Dublin, three seats, population 59,514; Dublin/Cabra, three seats, population 59,314 Dublin/Clontarf, three seats, population 58,592; Dublin North-Central three seats, population 58,357; Dublin South-East, three seats, population 57,875, making a total of 15 seats for a population of 293,652 persons. Compare that with the following constituencies in the West; Sligo-Leitrim, three seats, population 63,030; Roscommon-Leitrim, three seats, population 63,358; East Galway, four seats, population 83,176; Donegal, five seats, population 105,509, making a total of 15 seats for a population of 315,073 persons. In the Dublin area mentioned there is a total of 15 seats for 293,652 persons; in the western area mentioned there is a total of 315,073 for 15 seats. There is a difference of 21,421 persons. To elect 15 TDs in the five constituencies in Dublin you need 21,421 fewer people than it takes to elect a similar number of TDs in the Western constituencies.

A complete disregard for the west was shown in this electoral Bill—it might be called the "anti-west device" because it is designed to ensure that the population of the west will not get the same kind of representation as the people in the capital. During the years we have heard from the people on the Government benches that the west needs assistance. However, the Taoiseach disregarded it in the composition of his Cabinet and the Government are gerrymandering the constituencies to deprive people in the west of representation. One might ask what will be the Government's attitude in relation to western development in the future? Will the west get the same kind of treatment that is evident in this anti-west device and in the Taoiseach's appointment of personnel?

I sympathise with Deputy Hussey and other speakers from the west who spoke about their concern because their people will be deprived of adequate representation. In these scattered constituencies it is necessary and desirable that the tolerance should act in favour of them but it is obvious the Government do not believe that. This Bill was designed by the Minister for Local Government, who upholstered a seat for himself in his own constituency, because of the pressures placed on him to deprive the west. A group of Ministers and pressure groups in the city insisted that the west be further denuded not only of people but of representation.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I wish to sympathise with Deputies who spoke here about giving greater representation to the west. As I pointed out already, to elect 15 Deputies in the five constituencies in Dublin requires 21,421 fewer people than it takes to elect a similar number in the west, notwithstanding the fact that during the years the emphasis has been on greater representation from the west.

As I pointed out earlier, the Taoiseach did not think it worthwhile to appoint a Minister from the west and it was not until he was so prompted that he decided to appoint a Parliamentary Secretary. There has been a complete disregard by the Taoiseach, the Government and members of Fine Gael and Labour for the western constituencies. However, Fine Gael and Labour will not be together for long; as we saw in Monaghan there is only one party but they will get their answer from the workers of this city.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy worried about the Labour Party?

Comment on this

There will be no Labour Party after the next election.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Deputy Dowling without interruption.

Comment on this

Senior Ministers participated in talks in Monaghan with a view to forming one party. Some of them will now desert the people who support them but will get their answer.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Monaghan by-election is hardly relevant to this debate.

Comment on this

Since this debate started there has been talk about every election, not just Monaghan, and also about future elections that will occur in the revised gerrymandered constituencies. The concern of Deputy Hussey and others from the western constituencies regarding the reduced representation is not shared by some Deputies. Some of those elected for constituencies in the west are deserting their supporters who sent them here time and again. Deputy Coogan and his friends will support this Bill to deprive their people of an additional voice in Dáil Éireann. We want to ensure that the people in that section of the country get the representation to which they are entitled. When the time comes no doubt Deputy Coogan will be forced into the lobby with other Members elected by the people in the west on the last occasion to deprive those people of this additional voice.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Does the Deputy think that Dublin is over-represented?

Comment on this

They will give to Dublin city——

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Is Dublin over-represented?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Good man, Joe.

Comment on this

I am aware of the in-fighting that went on in relation to the maintenance of seats by members of Fine Gael and the Labour Party and of the various pressure groups which are in existence and have been a prime pressure factor on the Minister for Local Government for the last six or 12 months. The Minister indicated on many occasions that the was ready to bring in the Bill the following week, but it went to the week after and the week after that again. It took a long period before he was allowed to bring the Bill to the House. We now have this long-awaited measure which will deprive the people in that section of the country of the representation to which they are entitled.

We know the in-fighting which took place at Government level in the Fine Gael Party rooms and in the Labour Party rooms in their efforts to gerrymander the nation just as it was gerrymandered in the six north-eastern counties over the years, as was commented on by the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Deputy FitzGerald. I agree with the statement made by the Minister for Foreign Affairs in relation to the corrupt practices and the rigging of constituency boundaries by a section of the people not so very far from here. They are looking down here tonight to see the same type of riggers—here in this House——

Comment on this

Rigor mortis.

Comment on this

The people will have the deciding voice. We are not afraid to face the people.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

What about the mongrel foxes?

Comment on this

There is only one Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Which one?

Comment on this

We know the type they are. We know what happened last Christmas when the mongrel foxes turned on their leader and he said he would flush them out and let the pack deal with them. The bloodthirsty Taoiseach said that. Some of them are sitting here tonight. You are the people who were going to turn on him on that occasion.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is drawing fire on himself and is getting away from the Bill. I am advising the Deputy that he must confine himself to the Electroal Bill.

Comment on this

Look at the felon setters.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

What about the Four Courts speech?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy G. Fitzgerald can leave the matter of procedure in the House to the Chair.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Provided they are kept in order.

Comment on this

As Deputy Belton was wondering about the Four Courts affair we will deal with that now.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must insist that interruptions cease and that the Deputy relate his remarks to the matter under debate. No interruptions please.

Comment on this

In relation to the Electoral (Amendment) Bill—I want to put my notes in chronological order——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair wants co-operation from Deputies.

Comment on this

I can understand the confusion in the minds of the people who framed this Bill. Deputy O'Brien has spoken on many occasions.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy referring to a Minister of this House?

Comment on this

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. This Minister has an influential voice in this House. He must have been instrumental in the formulation of this Bill. Naturally enough the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs must have confused the Minister for Local Government because when one reads through the various sections of this Bill one will notice how confused the Minister for Local Government was. Deputy O'Brien with his two Irelands——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister.

Comment on this

I am sorry. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs with his two Irelands——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is quite irrelevant to the matter under discussion.

Comment on this

He has confused everybody.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy please confine his remarks to the matter under discussion? I declare this matter out of order.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Brien did state about the two Irelands——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It has no relevance in this matter.

Comment on this

He confused the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy persists in going against the wishes of the Chair——

Comment on this

I would be the last one in the House to do that. The Minister for Local Government is a very confused man. It is obvious that he needs geography lessons because the type of constituencies that have been set out and have been commented on by many Members is puzzling. Dublin is given part of Kildare and Wicklow. In Monaghan one finds parts of Louth and Meath.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I insist on order.

Comment on this

There is no amount of trick-o'-the-loopery which would put me off.

Comment on this

You are too used to it.

Comment on this

You are "off" anyway.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach said on occasion that one must forget about trick-o'-the-loopery I can use that expression. He mentioned it in his famous television appearance. Present members of the Government were operating on a trick-o'-the-loopery basis with trick-o'-the-loopery legislation.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Moderation of language would be helpful.

Comment on this

They are the words of a famous man, Deputy John Kelly in his famous speech on television. I would not use bad language but I do not think that is bad language.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order.

Comment on this

I was here long before you knew where this place was.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Age is not on your side.

Comment on this

Vigour and tenacity are.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

I want to thank you, Sir, for your protection against these rude interruptions.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought not to invite them either.

Comment on this

The Bill refers to the constituency of Cavan/Monaghan as being "the administrative county of Cavan; and the administrative county of Monaghan, except the part thereof which is comprised in the constituency of Louth." We have heard much about the breaching of the boundaries, the desirability of maintaining communities within their existing boundaries, but when we go down through this gerrymandering document that has been presented to the House we find the provisions introduced by the Minister are completely inconsistent with the views expressed by him in the past in relation to the breaching of existing boundaries. Under this Bill many people will be deprived of true representation in their own areas. The people are being siphoned off, just as they were——

Comment on this

In Monaghan.

Comment on this

——just as they were in the North, as explained very fully in an article in the Sunday Independent of 12th November by the Minister for Foreign Affairs.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not quote that.

Comment on this

I will quote it all right.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We have already had the quotation.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants it quoted. Just for the record——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We have already had it. It is not necessary.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not hear it.

Comment on this

He might have read it.

Comment on this

But he might not have read it.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It may not be repeated.

Comment on this

The present gerrymandering is taking place on the very same basis: the rigging of the constituency boundaries, and the gerrymandering that has caused so much suffering and so many problems to so many people not far from here. We hope the Minister and the Government will see sense and ensure that representation will be extended to the areas where there is the greatest need and that tolerance will operate in favour of people in those areas.

It is obvious from the Bill that the Government have completely deserted the western seaboard and that they will get the unanimous support of their backbenchers in that desertion. It will be interesting to see how many of the Deputies who represent western constituencies will go into the lobby and vote against this Bill, because by voting for it they are voting to reduce the representation in the constituencies that most deserve additional representation. Some of the constituencies have been dealt with here in detail by other speakers. I do not intend to dwell too long on other constituencies; I have dealt with the west to some extent. Paragraph 12 of the Explanatory Memorandum says:

Maps will be deposited shortly in the Oireachtas Library indicating the proposed constituencies.

The Minister has completely misled the House by giving erroneous information in the Bill or on the map, because the Bill is different from the map, especially in my constituency. I have not studied the other constituencies, because I have the map of my own constituency only. A completely different area is indicated in the Dublin-Ballyfermot area in the Bill as distinct from the map. I wonder is this a deliberate error, an attempt to mislead the House. A person might look at the map or read the Bill, because at all times the map would not be side by side with the Bill. This may be an effort to mislead the Attorney General, who would seem to be the person most likely to fall.

As regards the registers that are outlined, if the map is correct, then the Bill is wrong, and if the map is wrong, then other constituencies are wrong. I do not know how the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary will explain this away. I do not know whether it is deliberate, but I would be inclined to think it was deliberate. Taking into consideration the pressures that were on the Minister, he may have been confused, or if he was not confused then it was a deliberate act to mislead some Deputies who he felt might just look at the map and be satisfied with the division of their constituencies. I hope that by the time this Bill reaches Committee Stage the Minister will have rectified this situation and that the Attorney General, Deputy Declan Costello, will then be in full possession of the facts, because I understand he was a very worried man.

Comment on this

It is not usual for Attorneys General to know all the facts.

Comment on this

You would imagine they would be the people who would know.

Comment on this

Not so long ago they did not know.

Comment on this

The constituency was revised to suit him, and he got a bit of paper which gave a different picture.

Comment on this

The register has not been compiled yet.

Comment on this

I want to protect the Attorney General from the vultures on that side of the House who are out to destroy him.

Comment on this

Protect the last Attorney General.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Could we come back to the Bill please? Deputy Andrews, I have asked for a good hearing for Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

It is obvious——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am trying to secure order for the Deputy who is in possession.

Comment on this

As I say, I want to protect the Attorney General. I understand he was a man who was bringing pressure to bear to maintain constituencies or areas where he might gain a seat. I want to inform him that if the Bill is correct he will lose his seat, and if the map is correct he will probably retain his seat. It is just to inform the gentleman that there is this knife brigade who are out to ensure that he is not re-elected, and they are doing it in this way. I want to draw it to his attention. I am sure that when he reads the Official Report and examines the map and the registers he will see how he was misled by Deputy Tully and Deputy Cosgrave and other people who told him they would give him a safe seat.

A great deal of in-fighting has gone on over the last six or eight months. There have been problems in the Labour Party and in Fine Gael over who would go, who would stay, who would be promoted, who would be demoted and who would be fixed up here and there should certain eventualities take place. No doubt they have made arrangements for every type of eventuality for some Deputies; other Deputies will be left to fend for themselves. It is common knowledge that certain Deputies will be facilitated by the Government before they go out of power because out of power they will go at the next election when the people get the opportunity to decide. However you endeavour to rig the constituencies, the people will become aware of this rigging in a short time. However you endeavour to deprive people of their just representation, the people will become aware of this and they will give their answer as they have done on so many occasions in the past. Deputy Coughlan is probably quite happy with the set up.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Malley is, anyway.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought not to invite interruptions.

Comment on this

The in-fighting has resulted in the gerrymandering. I hope that Deputy Coogan and others who represent the west will have the courage to ensure that the people of the west get adequate representation.

Comment on this

I have given it to them for 20 years.

Comment on this

We will know whether they are sincere or not when the division bell rings and they are corralled into voting for the Bill in its present form or with some minor amendments. Do not underestimate the people. The Irish people are a very intelligent people and down through the years they have spoken loud and clear.

Comment on this