We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 1973: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 193–395 of 597. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment)(No. 2) Bill, 1973
Enacted

No. 3 of 1973 ›

In Monaghan.

Comment on this

The Monaghan situation was not that bad. We gained votes in Monaghan.

Comment on this

What about the national loan?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please. Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

The confidence of the nation is shaken. The former Deputy Burke used to say that when they left office on one occasion there was not a bag of cement in the country. There will not be a pound in the country when you fellows get out. The national loan gave a fair indication——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not relevant to the Electoral Bill.

Comment on this

That is where the people have spoken, in the national loan.

Comment on this

The ballot box is where the people speak.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I would be grateful if Deputy Crowley would not inject something the Chair has ruled out of order. The national loan does not come into this debate. Please do not try to inject it into it.

Comment on this

Not very much came in in the national loan.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Crowley, please do not try to make a mockery of the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this

I did not, a Cheann Comhairle. I would be the last man to do that. I have too much respect for the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this

That is something strange.

Comment on this

Even as a Deputy I had the greatest respect for Deputy Treacy.

Comment on this

We look forward to the opportunity in the future of fighting an election and I have no doubt that whatever measures the Government take to manipulate the boundaries, to gerrymander or to rig, the people will give their answer in a very decisive way. As I said before——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought not to indulge in repetition. It is not in order.

Comment on this

Will he say whether he is a George Colley man or not?

Comment on this

I am taking the Bill section by section in order to deal with it in greater depth. I was going to conclude but seeing that there is a demand for further explanation and that it is desirable that the public should be fully aware of the type of gerrymander that has taken place I will go through the Bill in some detail.

The amazing thing about this debate is that we have not heard the voices of the Fine Gael or Labour backbenchers. A silent service has operated over there. They have been told to sit quietly and not to speak. Not alone is a section of the country being deprived of representation but Deputies are being deprived of the opportunity to express their opinions in the House. That is the type of future to which we can look forward. While Deputy Coogan and Deputy Belton can interrupt——

Comment on this

I spoke before the Deputy.

Comment on this

If Deputy Coogan, Deputy Belton or Deputy Reynolds wish to speak now, I am prepared to sit down and allow them to make their contributions, if they are prepared to do so. You are under instructions not to speak.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dowling, you are deliberately drawing interruptions by provocation and by addressing Members of the House rather than the Chair.

Comment on this

George Colley will chastise him.

Comment on this

I wish to refer to the explanatory memorandum.

Comment on this

Are you going to let us speak, Joe?

Comment on this

I will let you speak all right. If there is any Government backbencher who wants to speak, I will give way to him.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Right. Sit down.

Comment on this

If you are prepared to speak.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

If you are prepared to speak, I will give way to you.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy concluding his remarks then?

Deputy Andrews rose.

Comment on this

None of them is getting up.

Comment on this

You sit down. You have concluded your remarks.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I think, in fairness, there was an understanding in the matter.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

I was interested to hear Deputy Dowling state that Dublin is over-represented. I hope the people of Dublin will understand this when it comes to the next election. He talks about gerrymandering. This Bill would be completely lost in the gerrymander that was carried out on the last occasion. Of course, we know the fate that befell the Fianna Fáil Minister who carried out the gerrymander. I challenge Deputy Dowling to tell us any peculiarity in the Dublin area which would compare with Clondalkin being in North County Dublin. He has endeavoured to make much capital of the Minister's decision to have three-seater constituencies in Dublin, but I would like to remind Fianna Fáil that it is not so very long ago since they, even at the expense of a referendum, endeavoured to create single-seat constituencies in Dublin.

Comment on this

Supported by the Deputy's party leader.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Possibly, but opposed bitterly by many Members of Fianna Fáil. After the result of that referendum had been made known I heard the pro tem leader of the Opposition, Deputy Lynch, state that he was glad the people had spoken and had given their decision in no uncertain manner and that they had shown they wished for the retention of the PR system. It was not very long afterwards that Fianna Fáil proceeded to reduce practically every constituency in Ireland. As a result of the last gerrymander there were only two five-seaters in the country. If it is the position that larger constituencies are needed to ensure the most effective working of PR, one must congratulate the present Minister in that at least there are more five-seaters now than there were after the Fianna Fáil carve-up.

Comment on this

There are many more three-seaters.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil advocated the three-seater constituency in the west of Ireland when it suited them to do so. How many times have that party re-arranged constituencies? They say now that the Minister should have left the matter to a commission but despite all the opportunities they have had to do this they never before suggested a commission. Yet they tell us that we should take this step. I would remind them that in the past they despised every attempt by this party to have such a commission set up. Their change of heart stems from the answer they received in no uncertain terms in the recent by-election. They know that the people support fully the policy of the National Coalition and no amount of talk from the Opposition will succeed in disillusioning the people or in giving them the impression that this Minister has been less fair than was the Minister responsible for the last revision. The present Minister has been more fair than Mr. Boland was and has not breached as many county boundaries as were breached on the last occasion.

In the west of Ireland Fianna Fáil have a very slender majority over Fine Gael. So far as I am aware they have 11 seats in the entire west as against Fine Gael's ten. There is no point in Fianna Fáil shedding crocodile tears in regard to this Bill. Looking at the map of the proposed revision one can see that county boundaries look much more natural now than in the past. We will not have the ridiculous situation of Clondalkin and Newcastle being in North County Dublin with Balbriggan.

Comment on this

What about Maynooth?

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Maynooth is close to Dublin and, therefore, is being put into the West County Dublin constituency. Perhaps this might be a suitable constituency for Deputy Walsh at some stage.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not thinking of himself.

Comment on this

I shall answer for myself.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

The Deputy asked me a question.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Walsh will be afforded the opportunity of speaking if he so wishes.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil need have no worry about this Bill. It is a definite improvement on the last revision of constituencies Bill. People opposite can rest assured that the fate that befell Mr. Boland will never befall the present Minister.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The last speaker's contribution was a record in terms of the length of time he spent in making it, that was, some five or six minutes. However, that is an indication of the type of pressure that is being brought to bear on the Coalition cacophony, cackle, group or parties—call them what you will— by the Whip. Apparently they are not allowed even to interrupt Fianna Fáil speakers now. All this is indicative of the concern they have for this, probably one of the most infamous pieces of legislation ever proposed in this House. It is a gross piece of hypocrisy for the present group—the Government for the time being—to come here and produce this Bill having regard to what they said in relation to the revision of constituencies while they were in office.

Those of us who recall their opposition to the last electoral amendment Bill must be shocked to see them introduce the Bill now before us. The Dáil debates of that time are littered with statements about the propriety and probity of setting up independent commissions and about the matter of the breaching of county boundaries, which Deputy Belton spoke so glibly of, while in this instance county boundaries have been breached many times throughout the Bill.

It is my intention to refer to the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown to be known after the enacting of this Bill as the constituency of Dún Laoghaire. This constituency which happens to be the Taoiseach's, is being subjected to the most gross piece of gerrymandering ever to take place in the history of this State. This gerrymandering has been carried out to the extent that back gardens were syphoned off from the constituency to be put into the new constituency of South County Dublin. Indeed one might say that some garden sheds have not been missed in the proposed gerrymander. It is my intention, too, to place on the record of the House the piece of drafting which purports to bring about that gerrymandering. Apart from the drafting, the Bill is a lot of gobbledegook and is couched in complicated and confusing language. One can have nothing but the utmost contempt for the entire Bill.

The part of the Schedule which deals with the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown will be seen in its proper context when put on the record. I understand that, unless I place this Schedule on the records, it will not find its way into the report. I quote from page 6 of the Bill:

... commencing at the point where the centre line of Kilmacud Road Upper meets northern boundary of the district electoral division, then in a south-westerly direction along the centre of Kilmacud Road Upper to the point where is meets the imaginary north-westerly projection of the southern boundary of St. Joseph's Carmelite Monastery——

Comment on this

It sounds beautiful.

Comment on this

It does. The Deputy would know a little about this type of line drawing.

Comment on this

Look at Dublin South-Central after the 1969 Act. The constituency I represent was defined in exactly that way.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Andrews.

Comment on this

You are a party to that gerrymandering and I will prove——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Andrews, I have been striving earnestly to attract your attention. Please direct your remarks to the Chair and not to any other Member of this House. In this way you will avoid interruptions.

Comment on this

What about the Chief Whip?

Comment on this

I cannot tolerate this kind of foul charge against this side of the House by a man who might examine his own philosophy in the context of his own conscience.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should avoid indulging in personalities and stick to the Bill.

Comment on this

Would the Chair direct his remarks to Deputy Kelly also? I will have to go back over this particular quotation because I have been interrupted. I am quoting from the Schedule and I will get it on the record if I have to stay here until 10.30 tonight.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Deputy Andrews is threatening the Chair.

Comment on this

I am not threatening the Chair. I am pointing out that——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

With regard to quotation the Chair will tolerate a brief quotation but a very long one is not in order.

Comment on this

This is not a quotation as such. What does the Chair mean by "quotation"? I am quoting a part of the Schedule which refers to the constituency——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have advised the Deputy that I will accept a brief quotation but I will rule on a very long quotation.

Comment on this

I must be allowed to make my point——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will be allowed to make his speech——

Comment on this

——in regard to this constituency which I represent. I must be allowed to place on the record the part of the Schedule which refers to my constituency.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I want to help the Deputy but he should not place himself in conflict with the Chair.

Comment on this

With respect, it is a most unfair ruling. It shows the bias and prejudice of the Chair towards the Opposition.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Andrews has made accusations against the Chair which he must withdraw.

Comment on this

I must point out that Deputy Kelly came into the House a few moments ago and interrupted me.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must leave personalities out of the debate.

Comment on this

The Chair promptly turns on me and makes me the culprit. This shows bias and prejudice.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I shall have to ask the Deputy to resume his seat unless he withdraws his remarks unreservedly.

Comment on this

I am just making the point——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Does the Deputy withdraw his remarks?

Comment on this

——that I must be allowed to make my contribution on this Bill and on that basis I will withdraw my remarks about bias and prejudice. I should like to put the Chair on notice of my intention of dealing with it in a different fashion and on a different occasion.

Comment on this

There is some confusion here. We agree with the Chair when he says that he wants to get through the work as expeditiously as possible. In relation to a Bill such as this and especially in the Schedule that Deputy Andrews is quoting from——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy making a point of order?

Comment on this

——it is impossible for him to make his point unless he quotes fully the areas mentioned in the Schedule. If he goes through half of it it is meaningless.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has always shown the utmost discretion in matters of this kind and has conveyed to Deputy Andrews——

Comment on this

The Chair has never shown discretion. You have been most unfair to Deputy Andrews and to a number of Deputies in the Opposition.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a disgraceful accusation. I cannot allow the Chair to be challenged in this fashion. I must ask Deputy Andrews to withdraw these allegations.

Comment on this

I have withdrawn the remarks——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must ask the Deputy to withdraw the insinuation that the Chair has been unfair. The Chair strives to be strictly impartial to all Deputies and maintain the dignity and decorum of this House. He resents deeply the insinuations you have made against him. They must be withdrawn without qualification.

Comment on this

I am entitled to express my point of view. I have already unreservedly withdrawn my——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not seek to circumvent the ruling of the Chair in this matter.

Comment on this

I am doing that and I will deal with it on another occasion.

Comment on this

Withdraw the allegation.

Comment on this

I have already done so.

Comment on this

A troublemaker was sent into this House and he gets off scot free and I name the Chief Whip of the Coalition. He started the interruptions and the Chair has made no reference to him whatsoever.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have sought protection for every Deputy in this House, especially in the debate this evening. Would Deputy Andrews please resume on the Bill?

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, you can hardly blame Deputy Andrews for feeling aggrieved. He is making a fair and logical speech and this man comes into the House and starts interrupting him. It is natural that he should retaliate.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Can we please get back to the debate on the Bill?

Comment on this

I assume I have the Chair's protection in this matter?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy knows that full well.

Comment on this

Can a speaker quote from the Schedule to the Bill.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Of course he can.

Comment on this

To get back to this piece of gobbledegook to which I have referred, and which is contained in the Schedule to the Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 1973. Page 6 of the Schedule relates to the constituency of Dún Laoghaire as mentioned in the Bill but refers to the existing constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. It states in the most beautiful of bureaucratic language

In the administrative county of Dublin, the district electoral divisions of:

Stillorgan Number Two, Stillorgan Number Three, Stillorgan Number Four, Stillorgan Number Five;

and that part of the district electoral division of Stillorgan Number One situated within a line drawn as follows:

commencing at the point where the centre line of Kilmacud Road Upper meets the northern boundary of the district electoral division then in a south-westerly direction along the centre of Kilmacud Road Upper to the point where it meets the imaginary north-westerly projection of the southern boundary of St. Joseph's Carmelite Monastery, then continuing, initially in a south-easterly direction, along the aforesaid projection and boundary to the point where it meets the western boundary of No. 75 Merville Road, then continuing, initially in a south-easterly direction, along the western boundary of each of the following—No. 75 Merville Road, Merville Road and No. 78 Merville Road—to the point where the western boundary of No. 78 Merville Road meets the rear boundary of No. 1 Weirview Drive, then continuing, initially in a south-westerly direction, along the rear boundary of the houses on the western and southern sides of Weirview Drive to the point where the rear boundary of No. 131 Weirview Drive meets the southern boundary of the Electricity Supply Board property on Brewery Road, then continuing from that point, initially in an easterly direction, along the southern boundary of the said property and the imaginary easterly projection of that boundary to the point where that projection meets the district electoral division boundary, then continuing, initially in a northeasterly direction, along the district electoral division boundary to the point first mentioned;

and the borough of Dún Laoghaire.

What a piece of infamy? What a deliberate and calculated attempt to be carried in this House, unfortunately, by virtue of the number of Deputies in Government vis-à-vis the number of Deputies in Opposition. Back gardens and boundary walls were breached to ensure that known Fianna Fáil supporters in the constituency would be lopped off at the whim of the Government Deputies in the constituency. If you continue the gerrymandering line from Stillorgan to Shankill, you find that in parts of Rochestown Avenue, a road known to myself and Deputy Desmond, a very large group of his own supporters, in fairness to Deputy Desmond, and supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party have been gerrymandered out of the constituency to make things easier for the Coalition party.

I will be dealing with the map as it relates to the Bill shortly, but that part of the map of the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown has to be seen to be believed. It looks as if somebody put his hands into a jar of sweets and took a bundle of sweets from one place and put it in another. The same thing happened in relation to the map. They said: "We will take that part of Weirview Drive from here and put it into South County Dublin and so on up along the proposed new boundary of the constituency which will be known as Dún Laoghaire. Chunks were taken from here and there right along the line. It is an incredible performance. I can imagine the situation which confronted Deputy Tully——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government. There was a knock on the door and who presented themselves to the Minister led by the respected Taoiseach but Deputy Desmond with Deputy Percy Dockrell hovering in the background. This is pure speculation. I have no evidence that this happened. One can only speculate but this speculation is probably correct and proper. They would describe the Minister as Jim and say: "Here we are Jim, the three of us. We would like to discuss the legislation you intend to introduce in Dáil Éireann." Then they would produce their own views on what it was best to do from the point of view of the Coalition party to retain their three existing Deputies, Deputy Cosgrave, Deputy Dockrell and Deputy Desmond. They would then say: "Good bye Jim. Thanks Jim. That will be all right Jim." Of course they got their way.

I accept that Deputy Desmond is in a more difficult position. Of course, it is well known now that the Labour Party will be consumed by and become integrated into the Fine Gael Party, so Deputy Desmond will bear the tag of Fine Gael if not at the next election at the election after that. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

It is not long since you were calling them all Reds.

Comment on this

I never did that.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order please.

Comment on this

Now, Sir, I claim your protection. It has been suggested by Deputy Doctor Professor Kelly——

Comment on this

Do not be such a baby.

Comment on this

——that it is not long since I was calling certain individuals Reds. It has never been my practice as a public representative to make that sort of charge against anybody. I seek your protection. Will you ask him to withdraw?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Many charges have been made in the House and many of them are political charges. It is not as if the charge has been made against the Deputy personally.

Comment on this

That confirms my opinion.

Comment on this

On what?

Comment on this

On what I expressed before.

Comment on this

Did you hear that, a Cheann Comhairle?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

Is it in order for Deputy Crowley to call me a fascist?

Comment on this

Is it in order to say what you said to Deputy Andrews?

Comment on this

He called me a Red baiter.

Comment on this

I said your party called the Labour Party Reds four years ago and you are now talking about them being absorbed in Fine Gael.

Comment on this

You have brought me back to my line of thought.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Andrews without interruption.

Comment on this

Trick-o'-the-loopery on your own admission.

Comment on this

As I said, it will not matter to the Coalition party in three or four years time when the Labour Party have been consumed by the Professor Kellys of this world and his colleagues of the Fine Gael Party of the extreme right.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Standing Orders ordain that Members of the House shall be referred to as Deputies and office holders shall be referred to as Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries as the case may be.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach and the Minister for Defence, Professor John Kelly.

Comment on this

My experience as a teacher is that the pupils who sneer the loudest are the stupidest.

Comment on this

On a point of order, can Deputy Kelly come into the House and stand up and make a speech any time he likes and not be repremanded as we are on this side of the House?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is striving to maintain order.

Comment on this

I have never yet made a speech without being interrupted.

Comment on this

It is a reputation he will have forever. To come back to the matter of the constituency boundaries and the denials of the Labour Party, it was understandable that the Fine Gael juggernaut in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire would overcome the lesser weight of the so-called Labour left. I have already quoted from the schedule a lengthy piece of complicated drafting to ensure the continued welfare of the Coalition party in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown to be known as the constituency of Dún Laoghaire. Undoubtedly, the Taoiseach, Deputy Dockrell and Deputy Desmond conspired together to ensure that the Coalition party would be kept in office for a considerable time to come. They made one very serious mistake. The people in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown will realise the extent of the gerrymander hoodwink perpetrated on them and the deliberate and cold and mechanical fashion in which the gerrymander was brought about to the extent of actually breaching the borough boundary. That is how it was organised.

As we know in this constituency the Fine Gael Party have quite considerable support, and fair enough. Equally in a number of areas to my certain knowledge, they have a number of very good people who have decided themselves to the welfare of the party in which they have believed over the years. They are good people. I do not deny that. While I may not agree with a man's political views, it is good to see him with a commitment. I do not criticise people for their involvement in the Fine Gael Party, quite the contrary, but these individuals would know, properly so, where their vote is in their own locality and, of course, their messages were coming in from the various parts of the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown to the Taoiseach and to Deputy Dockrell and, I have no doubt, to their Coalition party colleague Deputy Desmond: if you keep that part of the constituency in you will be all right; if you keep that part of the constituency out it will be equally all right because that part of the constituency contains a greater number of Fianna Fáil supporters as against support for the Coalition parties. That is the way, as I understand it, and as I understand it, that this vile gerrymander was brought about in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown.

The job is well done. Make no mistake about that. It was done well and I accept that. When one talks about a gerrymander being done, one thinks of the same job being done in the Six Counties over the years by the Unionist Party. A job done well, certainly, but whether it is in the best interests of democracy is the question. I believe it is not. The mechanics, the deliberate working out, the mechanical calculated working out of a gerrymander of this nature to continue the best interests of one political party as against the other is politically and conceptually wrong. It is false. It is undemocratic. That is why I charge the present Coalition outfit—forgive me, Government—with hypocrisy. They must be complete hypocrites. If one looks at the record, at the whole history of the debate on the last Electoral (Amendment) Bill introduced by the Fianna Fáil Party the Opposition then were calling for independent commissions. I personally —I must have this on the record of the House—do not favour independent commissions. I believe we are elected here to do our own work and I do not think responsibility should be shrugged off lightly by this House. I would not accept the proposition for one moment that we should have independent commissions and let someone else do the work for us. We should stand on our own two feet. Whatever decisions we make here let us stand over them. We are sent here by the people for a term of years to represent them and if we make mistakes during the course of those years here we will have to answer for them in the next election, and so be it, but in the meantime let us do our duty according to what we consider our duty to be. I believe it is not proper that an independent commission should sit on a Bill of this nature or other related matters. This is a purely personal opinion but it is not in conflict with the policy of Fianna Fáil on this Bill in any respect.

I have dealt with the constituency which the respected Taoiseach and my colleagues, Deputy Desmond and Deputy Dockrell represent. Over the years we have enjoyed a rather friendly relationship and I would hope that nothing I said in relation to the constituency would in any way harm that relationship in the personal sense of that relationship. Of course, we are going to be forever in opposition in relation to the political philosophy, one party as against another and that is proper.

Comment on this

Deputy Andrews will be back. Room was left for him.

Comment on this

That is not the point. That is the sort of selfish thinking that, as I understand it, has brought about the gerrymander I have been pointing out. I must recognise and so must all Deputies, if they are honest with themselves, that they are trustees for the time being of their political party; it does not matter if the Fianna Fáil Party gets the seat or Deputy Larry McMahon gets the seat or the Labour Party gets the seat, the person holding the seat is a mere trustee for the time being and the name of the person does not matter so long as the party is represented. That is the important thing.

Comment on this

So long as the Deputy represents Dún Laoghaire.

Comment on this

That is not so. The Deputy has my concept of politics altogether wrong. I do not want my line perpetuated. The people who perpetuate me here are the people in the constituency.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy would address himself to the Chair and avoid taking up interruptions, we would make better progress.

Comment on this

It was a pleasant philosophical interlude, but we will leave it. Deputy Dowling mentioned a matter that must cause grave concern to the people of the west of Ireland. As we know the Coalition group, the National Coalition Government, came into being as a Government on foot of a number of promises they made, the now well-trodden and infamous 14-point programme. None of these promises has, of course, been honoured.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is hardly relevant to the Bill under discussion.

Comment on this

I am coming to it, with great respect. None of these promises has been honoured. It is consistent with their policy and, indeed, with their philosophy in relation to the west of Ireland that they did not appoint a Minister, but when they found the public outcry——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Again, this is not relevant to the Bill at all.

Comment on this

——they suddenly came along and appointed a very——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The matter of the appointment of Ministers is not relevant to the Bill.

Comment on this

——respected Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Kenny, and the matter——

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary ever run away? Deputy Kelly, Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach and to the Minister for Defence, really should not interrupt me. He has made his contribution to the Bill and I would appeal to the Chair for the third time for the protection of the Chair.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair supports the Deputy in his appeal for freedom from interruption from anyone.

Comment on this

Is it in order for a Deputy to refer to another Deputy as a fascist?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I did not hear the expression.

Comment on this

If the Chair did not hear it, there is nothing for me to withdraw. I must say the new candidate for Monaghan struck a very significant pose in the Irish Press and the Irish Independent today.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is straying now from the matter under debate.

Comment on this

The matter of the west of Ireland is totally consistent with the National Coalition Party policy and their philosophy in relation to the west and the way in which they have taken Deputies from the west and once more given the eastern part of the country more Deputies, increasing representation on the eastern seaboard. As I said, they appointed no Ministers from the west. They appointed a Parliamentary Secretary after much public outcry and now they are actually taking away seats from the west of Ireland. I am glad to see Deputy McDonald in the House.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not indulge in personalities. If he ceases to do so we will avoid the interruptions about which the Deputy complained so bitterly.

Comment on this

There is nothing wrong with the Deputy saying he is glad to see Deputy McDonald in the House. There are so few Fine Gael Deputies in the House it is no harm to draw attention to one of them.

Comment on this

I was not complaining, Sir. I was expressing pleasure at seeing Deputy McDonald in the House. Having said that, may I say their whole attitude in relation to regional policy vis-á-vis the west of Ireland is well known. It is consistent with the terms of this Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy's party depopulated the west.

Comment on this

They moved a number of Deputies from the west of Ireland and redistributed them elsewhere. In fact, they gave Dáil Éireann 147 seats, an increase of 3 seats.

Comment on this

The Bill proposes to increase the number of Deputies to 148.

Comment on this

Fair enough, we are all entitled to a Deputy one way or another.

Comment on this

Some of our memories are a bit faulty. Monaghan was not long ago.

Comment on this

This Bill sees fit to increase the overall representation in Dáil Éireann and to decrease the representation in the west of Ireland. I hope the people in the country will take note of the proposal in this regard. It is absolutely disgraceful. Unfortunately, this Bill will succeed in doing this because the Government have a majority of Deputies to go through the lobbies.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

For too long it was the other way.

Comment on this

I am certain that the people of the west of Ireland will take a clear note of what is happening. This is a continuation of a very serious and insidious process begun by the Government when they returned to office after 16 years. The Government is again consistent in depriving the west of Ireland of a Minister on the one hand, various industrial schemes on the other hand, and now depriving the west of Deputies. At the same time, they increased the number of Deputies in the Dáil. If that is not scandalous in the proper sense of that word I do not know what is.

I should like to refer again to the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown which will be known, when this Bill is passed, as the constituency of Dún Laoghaire. We have the situation daily where we are informed by the news media and some of the sophisticates therein that the Dáil will be overburdened with something like 82 or 83 seats on the Government side. This, in my opinion, is not giving credit to the people of this country who will decide on the issues and policies presented before an election whether the Government outgoing will be the Government incoming.

I do not want to put panic into the hearts of the Labour Deputies in the Dublin area but I can see the situation——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The panic is there already.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is striving to ensure that Deputy Andrews can speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Look how politely Deputy Andrews welcomes interruptions from his own side.

Comment on this

I do not count that an interruption; I call it an assist. From my own Deputies it is an assist but from people like Deputy Kelly it is base interruption.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will decide these matters in respect of interruption and will not make a distinction either.

Comment on this

The three-seaters in the Dublin area, and the Labour Party, would make a very good title for a play, "Three seaters in the Dublin area and the Labour Party". Here we have a situation where with prices, the non-fulfilment of national loans, the undermining of national confidence by this present grouping described as a government, and we must recognise them as such until such time as they cease to be a government——

Comment on this

And the Potez factory.

Comment on this

The Deputy is going back a long way.

Comment on this

We remember.

Comment on this

For these reasons the Labour Party in the Dublin area must be extremely concerned. I should have said the former Labour Party. They are going to be submerged into the Fine Gael Party in due time and there is nothing surer than that. In the meantime, because they describe themselves as the Labour Party, they must be given that proper description.

Comment on this

When will the Deputy merge the dissidents in his party.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

What about the mongrel foxes.

Comment on this

The next election will be fought on the non-discharge of promises and particularly on the prices front. The Labour Deputies will have to go back to their constituency organisations, those who have such organisations left, prior to the next election. I can understand the decent man who supported the labour philosophy as propounded by Labour Deputies in the past when he sees the situation of the Parliamentary Labour Party being taken over lock, stock and barrel by the Fine Gael Party, having difficulty in supporting the Labour Party organisations in his constituency.

I can see the Labour Party, under the three-seaters, being wiped out in the Dublin area. With all their smartness, all their glibness, their arrogance and other matters related to the type of mind which would introduce a Bill of this nature, I do not believe that the people will accept it. Unfortunately, democratically they must get away with it in the sense that it will pass through this House and will become the law of the land. I believe the people will reject it. The greatest point of rejection, as those who have spoken to wellknown Labour supporters were given to understand, is this question of the consumption of the Labour Party by the Fine Gael Party in the Dublin area. The people at the next election will wipe them out formally. Then they will go running to the clubs, the wigwams, the tents and the lodges of the Fine Gael Party seeking protection. They have the umbrella of the Fine Gael Party while they are described as the Labour Party, a description that does not properly fit them.

Maybe the next election is not that far off. Indeed, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach and the Minister for Defence was pressing to have this Bill dealt with expeditiously. He was pressing to have it dealt with as a matter of urgency before the Christmas recess. Naturally one's antennae are inclined to go up and one is inclined to question this rush and indecent haste. Why is this Bill wanted so quickly? Flushed with the limited success of the Monaghan by-election I believe the Taoiseach saw the opportunity and he sent his messenger boy, I beg your pardon, Deputy Professor Kelly, along to the Fianna Fáil Whip's office with the message to get the Bill through as a matter of urgency.

However, our antennae also went up. We want a general election as a matter of urgency, tomorrow, if possible. Nevertheless, we feel that we have an obligation to expose this vile and infamous document which has been given the title of the Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2 Bill), 1973. We have an obligation to the community and to democracy to expose this insidious Bill proposed by the Minister for Local Government.

On the Committee Stage more particularly I intend to challenge the legality of that part of the Bill which relates to the then constituency of Dún Laoghaire—the now constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. We are informed that the Minister for Local Government produced a map of the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown and that the statement in the Schedule relates to the map of the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown then and the new constituency of Dún Laoghaire. Nothing could be further from the truth. There is no such thing as a map of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. I defy any individual Deputy to go to the Library and have a look at the detailed map of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown as distinct from the map of Ireland where you will see Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown set out as a spot. In that sense there is a comprehensive set-out of the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown, in the map of Ireland, in the totality of the map, but not in the small map which is presented as the constituencies in the Dublin and county area.

The constituency of Dún Laoghaire does not exist in map form and I must challenge the Minister for Local Government to produce a proper, full map of the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown to let us know where we are. Certainly, as a Deputy for the area I know exactly what the gerrymander means. As somebody said, in fairness, as far as one's personal future is concerned, for an individual Fianna Fáil Deputy in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown there is clearly a Fianna Fáil seat there but the gerrymander is so organised as to ensure—and I am entitled to say this because it is a fact —that a second seat for the Fianna Fáil Party will never rear its head in Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown.

Comment on this

It did not on the last occasion.

Comment on this

No, but it did the time before that and the time before that and, I believe, the time before that. Deputy McMahon, who is a very fairminded Deputy, will agree with that assessment if he analyses what I have said, that it was a calculated gerrymander to ensure the survival of the National Coalition Party in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown being made up of the Taoiseach, Deputies P. Dockrell and B. Desmond. This map, as I have said, is not in existence. I would ask the Minister to ask the respected civil servants to go about getting the mapping section or whatever section they have, to produce a proper map of the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. As I understand it at the moment it is truncated to the extent that when you come to Loughlinstown Cross it ceases and you then have to go from Loughlinstown Cross by your imagination to the outskirts of Bray. A Deputy for the area should know—and does know in this case—exactly what this Schedule means in the context of the constituency of Dún Laoghaire. he knows it, indeed. He knows what has been done deliberately to continue, really, the existence of the National Coalition juggernaut in that constituency.

On the matter of the breaching of county boundaries the Minister for Local Government while in Opposition—he was spokesman for something or other; I cannot quite remember what it was—stated in Volume 237, column 1817, of the Official Report:

I do not care what any Member of the House says; I have a personal view on this. I believe that county boundaries are important just as I believe that the national boundary is important and I would not agree that somebody who lives in County Meath would be as happy being attached to another county.

Later in the same column he said:

I do not agree, therefore, that county boundaries should be sundered. The Minister has a sin to answer for.

The Minister at that time was the Minister for Local Government in the Fianna Fáil Administration, Mr. Boland.

Comment on this

The man whose votes were too dirty to handle according to——

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary got a fair slice of the same votes.

Comment on this

We were being sneered at from your side——

Comment on this
Frank Carter Acting Chairman (Mr. Carter) Fianna Fáil

Deputies may not carry on crosstalk. If a Deputy wants to interrupt he will please do it through the Chair.

Comment on this

I must thank you for your protection which is much appreciated. I have been vilified here and——

Comment on this

Sorely tried.

Comment on this

Sorely tried, to use the Deputy's expression, over the last hour and a half.

Comment on this

Like every other Deputy, except that Deputy Andrews cannot take it.

Comment on this

Professor Kelly is not dealing with one of his students now.

Comment on this

I know well I am not.

Comment on this

The Deputy should behave himself. He is in Leinster House now. We are dealing with the breaching of county boundaries by the present Minister for Local Government and I have just quoted two rather interesting passages from his contribution on the last Electoral Amendment Bill. He says he does not agree that county boundaries should be sundered and that the Minister has a sin to answer for. If the then Minister had a sin to answer for surely the present Minister who made this statement has some sins to answer for now.

Comment on this

Greater sin.

Comment on this

It is a greater sin because it was said, I am sure, with great sincerity at that time; and the person who alleged the then Minister was sinning is now committing the very same sins. In my view this could be described as hypocrisy. Those with a greater command of the English language might use less crude phraseology in charging the Minister with this but I must charge him with hypocrisy because that is what it is—humbug and hypocrisy. The whole tragic gerrymander Bill is littered with this: views expressed a number of years ago cease to have validity now. What was good four years ago appears to be bad now. They called for an independent commission and they have reneged on that. They suggested county boundaries should not be breached and they have reneged on that. They have reneged all along the line in the production of this mammoth gerrymander.

Let me make the point once more, and I shall go off it again, that I do not accept that the Bill itself will give the outgoing Government continuity in office as it is calculated to do. It is deliberately calculated to ensure the continuance in office of the outgoing Government for years to come. I do not think they will get away with it because the electorate are too sophisticated and will understand the intention behind a measure of this kind. The Government will not get 82 or 83 seats. I believe the next Government will be a Fianna Fáil Government. That is a personal belief but I am entitled to put it on the record.

With regard to the breaching of county boundaries, I should like to quote a letter from the corporation of Dún Laoghaire dated 4th December, 1973. I might put on record that the council is Fine Gael-dominated. Unfortunately it is over-burdened with Fine Gael councillors but at the next June elections that matter will be sorted out and I have no doubt that Fianna Fáil will have their fair share of seats there.

The Government talk glibly about power sharing but we know that they have appointed all their own pals to State boards. We know what they have done in other areas that I will not mention here. We know they have wiped out individuals who purported to support Fianna Fáil. It is a case of jobs for the boys, but the only problem they have is that they cannot decide which boy to give the job to because one person may be Labour and the other Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

The golden handshake.

Comment on this

Are you practising golden handshakes also? That does not surprise me. At the moment we are talking about power sharing; tripartite talks are being conducted and we wish them every success. Everyone knows Fianna Fáil's attitude in relation to those talks. The Minister for propaganda, Deputy O'Brien, through his propaganda machine—otherwise known as the Government Information Services— from time to time has produced the most beautiful litany in the newspapers of what the Government are doing or are not doing, and what they intend to do in the future. This is presented in such a way to suggest that the Government have cornered the market in political purity. We know they are not practising power sharing and that they never intended doing it. It is there for the grabs, and my goodness they are grabbing it. Since coming into office last March they have distinguished themselves in grabbing the loot, from the most minor appointment——

Comment on this

On a point of order, what has this got to do with the Bill?

Comment on this

It is totally consistent with grabbing the loot. That is what this Bill is designed to do. It is designed to screw down the country for the benefit of the Coalition Parties.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Obviously that is hurting.

Comment on this
Frank Carter Acting Chairman (Mr. Carter) Fianna Fáil

Deputies should refrain from interrupting. Cross-talk will serve no purpose and Deputies should allow the debate to proceed.

Comment on this

This gerrymander Bill is designed to preserve the continuance in office of the Government. It is well known that certain designs have become unstuck. We believe this design will become unstuck.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Is the Deputy referring to the Monaghan by-election?

Comment on this

I have outlined my own views. I have put on the record the fact that Deputy Kelly, Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach and to the Minister for Defence, rushed up to Deputy Lalor in a breathless state and said that they wanted the Second Stage, in fact the whole Bill, before Christmas. Deputy Lalor might confirm this when he is making his contribution to the debate. Fianna Fáil's antennae went up. Why do the Government want the Bill before Christmas? It cannot be for any altruistic motive. It cannot be that they want to streamline the business of the House because their reputation in relation to legislation is deplorable and disreputable. With the compliments of the Government propaganda services—otherwise known as the Government Information Services—we are provided with the daily lie that the Government are producing certain kinds of legislation. I suggest to them that they put up or shut up.

The Monaghan by-election has far greater significance for the Government than they realise and it is a lesson they might learn in the very near future in a general election. I am sure Deputies will agree with me when I say we do not like by-elections because it means that some of our colleagues retire or pass on.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

That is not what happened in Monaghan.

Comment on this

In that instance he retired. I was trying to get on the record of the House a letter I received from the corporation of Dún Laoghaire dated 4th December, 1973. It reads:

4th December, 1973.

Dear Deputy,

The following is the text of letter of this date which has been forwarded to the Department of Local Government with regard to proposals contained in the Electoral (Amendment) No. 2 Bill, 1973, affecting this constituency:—

"The Borough Council have considered the proposals in the Electoral Amendment (No. 2) Bill, 1973, so far as they affect the Borough and the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown Constituency area. On 3rd instant, they adopted the following resolution in this connection:—

`This Council recommends the transfer of Ballybrack No. 1 (8703) from the proposed South County Dublin to Dún Laoghaire, with Stillorgan No. 5 (4776) and Stillorgan No. 1 part of (2758) total (7534) being transferred from the proposed Dún Laoghaire to South County Dublin.'

The members have pointed out that the Corporation has provided a 100 acre housing site in the Ballybrack No. 1 Electoral Division and have rehoused or will rehouse there borough residents who could not be accommodated in the borough. They suggest that a very sizeable proportion of the electorate in the Ballybrack No. 1 Electoral Division consists of these former residents of the borough and that it would be contrary to the Minister's expressed intention of not splitting unnecessarily natural communities to cut them away from the borough electorate and attach them to the Dublin South County Constituency.

It has also pointed out that a constituency consisting of the borough with the Ballybrack No. 1 Electoral Division and Stillorgan 2, 3 and 4 Electoral Divisions would provide a constituency with natural physical boundary so far as possible, in that the Dublin-Stillorgan-Bray Road would be the boundary from Booterstown to Loughlinstown.

Based on the 1971 census figure, the deviation from the national average population per seat would only be 292 which is considered reasonable. I am to request that the Minister will give sympathetic consideration to the Council's resolution before the Committee Stage of the Bill."

Yours faithfully.

The letter is signed by the Town Clerk.

Comment on this

The Deputy had a busy time closing brackets.

Comment on this

I had to get the letter properly on the record. If one has to close brackets one has to close brackets. That is all about it. The Minister's expressed intention when he was spokesman for Local Government in Opposition on the matter of the breaching of constituency boundaries has been quoted by me at considerable length. Here we have a very reasonable request from the corporation of Dún Laoghaire, which is the borough council. They have properly considered the proposals in the Electoral (Amendment) Bill. I am sure other local authorities have also done so. I would like to take this opportunity of congratulating the Borough Council of Dún Laoghaire for going into this matter in such considerable depth. It is a matter which affects their own area and they have properly articulated a point of view to the Minister.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

It shows how fair Fine Gael are. They have the majority.

Comment on this

They have the majority in the constituency and in the borough unfortunately. When June, 1974, comes there may be a different story to tell. Fianna Fáil will get a proper and consistent representation on the Dún Laoghaire Borough Council. In the letter the council recommend the transfer of Ballybrack No. 1. One must imagine the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. It is a triangle with a broad base at the Booterstown end and it runs into a narrow apex at the top around the Killiney-Ballybrack area. In that apex is contained parts of the borough of Dún Laoghaire, and Ballybrack is prominent in that respect. Here it is being wiped out of the borough of Dún Laoghaire which itself is an autonomous borough in the sense that it is one unified whole. Why should we not keep Ballybrack? Why should not Ballybrack, a natural part of the borough of Dún Laoghaire, remain within Dún Laoghaire. It is just not being done by the Minister for Local Government who has decided that it does not suit the Coalition Party machine or juggernaut. The Minister is going to cut out that piece ruthlessly. He is going to snip it. He is going to snip that piece of Ballybrack which he considers to be most embarrassing to the Fine Gael Party. That is what he is doing.

The Minister has taken a natural piece of the Borough of Dún Laoghaire out of that borough for selfish, political, party reasons. I cannot speculate about any other reason. This was not done through any sense of altruism.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy alleging that they are all Fianna Fáil people who are being snipped out?

Comment on this

Almost. I cannot say emphatically that that is so. I would like to conclude. I can see that my colleagues wish to get in. I apologise for delaying the House but I felt it was important to speak. Deputy Desmond may have spoken on this. I have no doubt that when he spoke on the Bill he praised and congratulated the Minister, and went through all the old rigmarole and formula. Poor Deputy Desmond knows as well as I do that he is in a difficult situation. Not only did they not appoint him to some office but they did the dirt on him in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. That is understandable.

Comment on this

That is not fair. If Deputy Desmond were here he would tell Deputy Andrews that a similar situation arose before. When Deputy Jack Lynch was Taoiseach in 1969 Deputy Andrews was lined up for Parliamentary Secretary but the former Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries said "no" and Deputy Andrews was not appointed until that Minister left.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will Deputy Andrews resume his seat? Will the Deputies please have reference to the Chair? The Chair cannot tolerate this cross-talk.

Comment on this