Committee on Finance. - Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 1973: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 396–597 of 597. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 3 of 1973 ›
I would ask the Deputies to refrain from interrupting.
Comment on this
I have the greatest respect for Deputy Desmond and sympathy for him. I have respect for him in every sense. I do not agree with his political philosophy, and I will fight him on those grounds only and reasonably so. I just want to give this Bill my "amen" with one more reference to the main charges which we have been making consistently against it during our contributions and which we will continue to make against it during the course of its journey through this House. We will continue to fight it to the very last and we know we cannot win. We are going in on a losing wicket. The whole Government apparatus is loaded against the Opposition.
The weakness of the Opposition case is only that it lacks a certain number of Deputies to defeat the Government in bringing about their wishes. It is probably one of the most dangerous Bills ever, it is dangerous to democracy. It is the most dangerous type of Bill to come before this House. It is an undemocratic Bill and a Bill of a highly gerrymandering nature. We will continue to expose it for what it is as long as the opportunity presents itself.
Comment on this
I would like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that apart from a very brief intervention by Deputy Luke Belton no effort was made by any Deputy on the Government side to defend this Bill. I suppose it is true to say that it is understandable that they should not attempt to defend a Bill of this type, or at least that it might take a certain amount of courage on the part of Deputies opposite to defend it. They are quite obviously lacking in that courage.
The Bill is an effort by the Minister for Local Government to copperfasten the Coalition in office for as long as possible. There is very little more to be said in relation to this aspect of the Bill. When the Bill was clearly published this aspect was identified by the media. Later on when neutral observers had time to consider the Bill properly they also recognised it for what it is. Today it is recognised by the public at large as an attempt to copperfasten the Government in office for as long as possible. I have no doubt that the Deputies on the Government side also recognise this Bill for what it is. In fact, the Minister himself recognises it. It would be too much to expect that the Minister concerned would express this view in public. While the Minister may be successful in his quite obvious aim, time will tell whether or not he will be successful. However, it is of little use that the Minister should pretend that this is not his aim.
I can understand why the Minister has taken up this stance and why he is not willing to admit publicly that his objective is, as I said earlier, as best he can to ensure continuance of this Government in office and to stifle as far as he can the democratic will of the people. It is, of course, because he himself—and this was quoted on many occasions so I am not going to bother quoting it again— while in opposition was one of the severest critics of the system which he is now operating. He it was who condemned the system under which the Minister for Local Government decided on the constituency boundaries. He vehemently advocated that this method should be abolished and that quite a different procedure should be adopted.
I have no doubt that the public, reading the then Labour Deputy's statements felt assured that should his party, whether as a single party Government or in coalition, be returned to office, when the opportunity would arise his party would press for change and that he himself would be foremost among those who would endeavour to change the system which he regarded as despicable when he was in opposition.
The same arguments were reiterated by the Fine Gael Deputies during the previous debates on constituency Bills in this House, and not only were those arguments put forward by the Fine Gael Party but they tried to introduce a Bill which would change the system. Again, I must underline that the public could be forgiven if they were to feel that a change in Government, where again the Fine Gael Party would come to power either as a coalition or as a single party Government, would ensure that the methods by which the constituency revisions were made during the Fianna Fáil Administration would be changed and that we would have instead the new methods which were so strongly advocated by the Fine Gael Party when they were in opposition.
There is no point in alleging, as has been done by some of the speakers on the opposite side in the earlier part of the debate, that the Fianna Fáil Party when in office, when they decided on constituency boundaries, decided on them to suit their own purposes. Even if this were true, there is no point in the Government alleging that Fianna Fáil did this. I am not accepting that it is true, but all one has to do is to look at the result of the general elections in 1969 and 1973 in the same constituencies, and it will be seen that it would be very hard to argue that Fianna Fáil did, in fact, change the constituencies to suit themselves. So vehemently was the case for change and for neutral involvement in constituency changes pressed by the Fine Gael and Labour Parties then in opposition, that one could be forgiven if one felt that this was not simply an argument being put forward by the Opposition Deputies against proposals by the Minister for Local Government in relation to the changing of constituency boundaries, but rather that it was a matter of principle with them and that the first thing they would do if they assumed office would be to make the changes that they were so strongly advocating. I do not know what one can think of Coalition promises and arguments when in opposition, when not only have the Coalition Government continued the system in operation whereby constituency boundary changes are decided by the Minister for Local Government, but have put in charge of it a Minister who himself was one of the strongest opponents of the system which was then in operation. This is too much altogether.
It would appear, in so far as the Coalition parties are concerned, that principles and promises are forgotten when they come to power. Of course, I have had my own experience of this, particularly in relation to the Arts Council Bill, when certain sections were introduced by the present Government into that Bill which during my time in office in a similar type of Bill were opposed to the extent not only of arguments against them but of calling for votes in the House to oppose them. Therefore, I am not particularly concerned about this situation, because it is something I have come to expect.
There is a further aspect to this matter to which I would like to refer. The Parliamentary Secretary referred to political commentators who stated that under the revised constituencies the Coalition would gain 83 seats and Fianna Fáil 63 seats. He went on to say that this was nonsense and that the argument was simply put forward for the purpose of frightening people. I would say he had a very good reason to worry about this, because his own party did a very good job of frightening the people at the time of the referendum on proportional representation, when they said that Fianna Fáil would get 90 seats under the proposed changes. I have little doubt that this was one of the arguments used by the opponents of the straight vote system which most affected the result of the referendum. The Parliamentary Secretary may very well worry that a similar fate awaits the Coalition because of the case now being made not simply by the Opposition here in this House but, as I mentioned a moment ago, by the media as well.
There is another factor here which was referred to by Deputy Andrews in the course of his speech. One of the most objectionable features of Unionist rule in the north of Ireland was the fact that they gerrymandered constituencies in order to ensure their continuance in power at all levels of government. During the campaign on the two referenda on the PR system, the Fine Gael and Labour Parties campaigned against the abolition of proportional representation on the basis that this system was a fair system, that it was not possible to gerrymander under the system, and that its retention was a worthwhile incentive to encourage unity in this country.
The forecasts of the media regarding the number of seats that will go to the Coalition and to Fianna Fáil respectively in the next election related to the total Fine Gael and Labour vote, as compared with the total Fianna Fáil first preference vote, shows, I am afraid, that it is possible to gerrymander under the proportional representation system. It will hardly be the incentive that the Coalition partners suggested it would be. One would think that in present day circumstances the Government would concern themselves with the overall national situation rather than with narrow political advantage. I was intrigued by the statement of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach that he was unaware of the constituency changes until they were published. From the Parliamentary Secretary who attends Government meetings this is a peculiar statement though perhaps he recognised that he did not have to bother very much about it because the matter could be safely left in the hands of the master.
One matter which particularly concerns me is the fact that in many of the city constituencies the average population per Deputy is below the national average. For example, in Dublin South-East it is 831 below the national average and in Dublin (Rathmines West) it is 771 below the national average. On the other hand, the population per Deputy in many of the rural constituencies is well above the national average. In Donegal, for example, it is 971 above the national average while in Mid-Cork it is 812 above it. I have always felt that the population per rural Deputy should be lower than the population per city Deputy. We must take into account the fact that some rural constituencies are territorially very large and that this presents a considerable difficulty for constituents when they wish to see their Deputy. Constituents do not always feel that a letter to a Deputy is sufficient, they often wish to see him personally and distance is very often a deterrent. We should try, in so far as it is possible, to treat all our citizens as fairly as possible in this respect. This can be done by reducing the population per Deputy in rural constituencies and particularly in rural constituencies of very large areas. If one looks at the proposed new constituency of Donegal, the distances to be travelled by constituents and by Deputies in the course of their duties are exceptional, and I have no doubt that were it not for the political implications in relation to this particular constituency nobody would dream of creating one constituency in such a large county.
Comment on this
I have always been consistent in my argument in favouring a smaller population per Deputy in the sparsely populated areas in rural Ireland as, indeed, I have been in relation to the retention of county boundaries which the Minister for Local Government supports in theory but deviates from quite considerably in practice when the political exigencies of the Coalition Parties call for it.
Comment on this
I shall deal with that later. I recall the case in the High Court brought by the former Labour Deputy and former Fine Gael Deputy and Senator and Parliamentary Secretary, Dr. John O'Donovan, in relation to the population per Deputy and the national average. I was a witness in that case. At that time the whole county of Louth was a three-seat constituency. The population per Deputy was well above the national average, if my memory serves me about 3,000 per Deputy. I pointed out in my evidence that while the population per Deputy was high nevertheless because the county was small constituents had no difficulty in getting in touch personally with a Deputy. But in West Cork the population per Deputy at that time was considerably below the national average, although it was territorially already very large, and if the Fine Gael Senator won his case further areas would have to be added to that constituency to retain it as a three-seat constituency and this would make it almost impossible for a very large section of the community in that constituency to get in touch personally with one of the Deputies representing them. I pointed out that County Louth was a unit for many different purposes and that the people there were, as were the people in Monaghan where the population per Deputy was much below the national average, anxious to retain County Louth as a unit just as the people in Monaghan were anxious to retain County Monaghan as a three-seat constituency. However, as it happened the Fine Gael Senator won his case and a large part of County Louth had to be transferred to the Monaghan constituency to bring the population per Deputy in each of the constituencies into line with the court decision.
The county of Louth is now to be a four-seat constituency with a part of Monaghan added to it. I welcome this because it is generally accepted that the people in an area which is cut off from the main stream of the population in that county, particularly in a county the size of Louth, Monaghan or Kildare, have not got the same interest in political life as if they were integrated in the county as a political unit. My whole attitude, as far back as the time of the court case I have mentioned, was that County Louth should be a unit in the political sense.
Fine Gael speakers during the course of the recent by-election spoke of the return of West Louth to the constituency of Louth and they inferred that this could have been done equally easily in 1961 when this part of Louth was transferred to the Monaghan constituency. This is simply not true. The population of Louth increased by 5,000 between 1966 and 1971. As far as I can remember it increased by 2,500 from 1961 to 1966 as a result, I might add, of the good government of Fianna Fáil. It will be obvious that if in 1961 the then Minister for Local Government decided on a four-seat constituency for Louth it would have meant that a very large part of County Monaghan would have had to be incorporated with County Louth. The Minister had to decide at that time whether he should add the part of Louth, which subsequently he did add, to Monaghan thereby leaving two three-seat constituencies as had been the position, or to add a large part of Monaghan to Louth and make it a four-seater while adding the other part of Monaghan to another county, perhaps Cavan, in which case Monaghan as a political entity would have ceased to exist. The reason why the Minister is now able to make the change he proposes is because of the very exceptional increase in the population of County Louth.
Comment on this
If that is so it must have been the very bad Government of Fianna Fáil that was responsible for the neglect of Donegal.
Comment on this
Might I add that had it not been for the case brought before the courts by the then Fine Gael Senator, Dr. O'Donovan, it would never have been necessary to breach the boundaries in any county.
Comment on this
I can understand why I am annoying the Deputies opposite but perhaps they would allow me to make my speech and then they will have ample opportunity of contributing to the debate.
Comment on this
Equal time is allowed in the House but Deputies opposite are prevented from speaking.
Comment on this
Will Deputies please refrain from indulging in crosstalk? Each Deputy who wishes may contribute to the debate, so perhaps the Deputy might be allowed to continue without interruption. In this way the debate might be concluded more expeditiously.
Comment on this
I thank you, a Chathaoirleach, for your protection and would point out that I interrupt Deputies very rarely in the course of their contributions. While I have no objections to interruptions I think I should be allowed continue my speech.
Comment on this
The second point I wish to make is that the people of the part of Louth that is being transferred back to Louth are under no illusions as to why once again they are to become part of the constituency of Louth which in future is to be a four-seater. These people know that they are being brought back by the Coalition——
Comment on this
——in the hope that they may win two seats in the constituency as against two for Fianna Fáil. The present situation is that Fianna Fáil have two seats and the Coalition have one. The Coalition parties have long ago given up any hope of ever shaking the Fianna Fáil vote in the present constituency of Louth and, judging from the 1973 General Election result and the result of the Presidential Election, they have every good reason for recognising that the intelligent people of Louth vote for the party they know from experience have done such exceptional work to develop the economy of the county and to put it, as it is now, in the forefront of both agricultural and industrial development.
Comment on this
Might I refer the Minister for Lands to the returns from Louth for the last general election? There is hardly any need for me to say any more.
Comment on this
(Cavan): That was the trap that Fianna Fáil fell into on Tuesday last: they were looking for a repeat.
Comment on this
A part of Monaghan will be included in the new Louth constituency. I note that the Fine Gael Senator, in his speech regarding the new Louth four-seat constituency, pointed out that the people of west Louth were anxious to return to the Louth constituency and he said that the people in that part of Monaghan that is being transferred to Louth would understand and accept the situation.
Comment on this
I cannot follow the logic of this argument. If the people of west Louth resented being put into the Monaghan constituency, and this resentment was understandable since nobody wishes that county boundaries be breached, why should the Monaghan people not resent being put into the Louth constituency?
Comment on this
(Cavan): Surely the Deputy cannot contend seriously that the people of Inniskeen do not regard the town of Dundalk as their shopping centre. That is the town with which they have all their affiliations.
Comment on this
We shall wait and see. I am glad to have the people of Inniskeen coming into my constituency but I do not think that Fine Gael will be very pleased with this arrangement.
Comment on this
I have a strong inkling that the Minister for Lands is not very happy with the transferring of Inniskeen and the surrounding district to the constituency of Louth. The Minister for Local Government has decided also on a four-seat constituency for Meath. I have never indulged in personalities and do not propose to do so now except to say that the Minister, like all of us, is human. However, I would hope that we shall not be given any philosophical reasons for the change. Part of Kildare is included in the Meath constituency and I note that when it suits the Minister's purpose he has no scruples regarding the breaching of county boundaries. I understand that there is very little change in regard to the part of Kildare now being added to the Meath constituency from the position which obtained before.
I can understand the people in that section of Kildare not having any great objection, such as other people might have, to continuing as part of the Meath constituency because I have no doubt that they would like to retain their connection with Deputy Crinion, who is well known to be a very active and hard-working Deputy. Nevertheless, we find that the County of Kildare is to be not in two but in three parts. I expect that the people of Kildare will endeavour to detect the logic whereby the Minister, on the one hand, can talk of his efforts to retain county boundaries while breaking them in a number of cases in their county.
I was interested in the comments of Deputy Malone in relation to the Kildare situation. It would appear that the Deputy will have some difficulty in extricating himself from the rather awkward position in which he may find himself at the time of the next revision should that part of Kildare that is now being transferred to Meath or Dublin be returned to the Kildare constituency, because I have no doubt that he will be reminded of the arguments he made here in favour of the division of his county and of his pointing out all the reasons why he believes that parts of Kildare which were to be attached to the Dublin constituency are rightly being removed from Kildare. He said they had to sacrifice a large part of Kildare to Meath and Dublin. I agree. This is in direct contradiction of what the Minister for Local Government said at an earlier stage in this debate. He stated that a very small slice would be taken from Kildare and joined to other constituencies. I expected Deputy Malone to argue for a four-seater for Kildare rather than attempt to justify the taking away of a large part of his county. I agree with him when he says that there will be additional seats in the next Dáil as a result of the increase in population. This increase reflects our growing prosperity. When one remembers that the figures he refers to are the 1971 census figures, nobody from this side of the House could have paid as worthwhile a tribute to the Fianna Fáil Party and Government as Deputy Malone.
Comment on this
When discussing constituency changes, Leitrim is one of the most interesting. No county had so many crocodile tears shed over it by the Fine Gael and Labour Deputies when they were in opposition than Leitrim. They wept copiously over what they called its dismemberment. They vowed that, if they were ever returned to power, collectively or individually, they would ensure that what they called "this grave injustice" would be removed and Leitrim would become a political unit once again. I have no doubt they cashed in on votes on that issue.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has not been in political life very long. He does not know——
Comment on this
I can assure the Parliamentary Secretary that there is no question but that the Fine Gael Party cashed in on votes in Leitrim on the understanding that, should they be returned to power, they would ensure that Leitrim became a political unit.
Comment on this
Now that the Coalition have been returned to power, and the Fine Gael Party is part of the power structure in the present Government, the unity of Leitrim has been forgotten and it is again partitioned.
Comment on this
I sincerely hope that the people of Leitrim in the next election will not forget what has happened to them.
Comment on this
It is no comfort to those people who have been told on numerous occasions that they would be returned as a unit——
Comment on this
If anybody wants to know more about the attitude of the Fine Gael and Labour Parties to this matter, they should read the debate on the last Constituency Bill.
As I have said, it is no consolation to the people of Leitrim, who were promised that should the Coalition come to power that they would be returned as a political unit, to be told now that they are two instead of three pieces. They wanted to be one unit. They were promised that they would be one unit. Votes were got because of this promise and, like other Coalition promises, it has been broken.
Comment on this
On a point of order, a Cheann Comhairle. I have heard Deputy Faulkner say three times that members of this party promised that Leitrim would be brought back as a unit. I ask him to quote who said it.
Comment on this
Are we to take it that Deputy Faulkner has no intention of replying to Deputy Reynolds?
Comment on this
The west of Ireland has been forgotten by the Coalition. Deputy Molloy clearly indicated the manner in which it would be possible to retain 30 seats in the west. If he was concerned with Ireland as a whole, the Minister would have approached the position in the west of Ireland in this way. This was not to be. Apart from reducing the number of seats in the west by two, the Coalition's only concern was to make adjustments to suit their own ends. These went against the stated principles of the Minister in relation to county boundaries. He created the monstrosity which will be known in future as West Galway, and includes a large slice of Clare. I do not mean to go into detail about what could have been done in relation to the Galway-Clare situation. It is patently obvious what the proper and fair distribution of seats should have been.
Comment on this
We had a considerable amount of peace when the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach was out of the House. Unfortunately, now that he is back, we have more than our quota of interruptions.
The two extra seats should have been given to the west. We are in danger of being dominated by Dublin's need and outlook, because of the large share of Deputies which Dublin is getting. If the population of Dublin continues to increase, then the number of Deputies will increase also. This should concern us all because of the needs of rural Ireland, especially along the west coast. We must always keep in mind the need to develop properly as a nation, not only economically—and our economy is still largely dependent on agriculture —but culturally as well. It is well to remember that one of our greatest cultural assets, the Irish language, is spoken in the west as the vernacular, and real concern should have been shown here rather than political expediency.
Reference was made on a number of occasions during this debate to the fact that Dublin has got three-seat constituencies, except in one notable case, while at present it has four-seat constituencies. In Cork where there are two three-seat constituencies at present they will be replaced by a five-seat constituency. If three-seat constituencies are deemed to be best for Dublin, why are three-seat constituencies not suitable for Cork? I cannot see the logic behind this decision and I do not think anybody else can.
The Minister said that one of his main objectives was to preserve county boundaries. We recognise, of course, that he is not in the least concerned with county boundaries except where it suits him. If he is not also concerned with city boundaries, how can he justify cutting off a large part of the city of Cork and joining it to a rural Cork constituency which is exceptionally large at present? I do not suppose that at this stage of the Bill it is necessary for me to continue to show up the many anomalies and contradictions in the Bill. As was said by Deputy Andrews and as I have already said myself, this Bill is quite obviously an attempt by the Minister and the Government to copperfasten the Government in office. Like many other speakers I should like to say that the people will have last say. I have no doubt that the people will recognise what is being done here and will deal with the Government accordingly when the next general election is declared.
Comment on this
I can truthfully say in relation to this discussion that I am in the peculiar position—I will not say the unique position because there are a couple of other constituencies like mine—in the light of this Bill and the damage it is endeavouring to do, that I can speak objectively about the Bill because it does not interfere with the possibility of my re-election or otherwise. The Laois-Offaly constituency is not being changed and it has not been changed down through the years. My observations can be made objectively because of the fact that I have no personal axe to grind. Opposition Deputies have spoken about changes which affect their own constituencies and they have dealt with the overall picture. They have been able to show up this Bill for what it is. Instead of being called the Electoral (Amendment) Bill it should be called the National Coalition Consolidation Bill. The Bill is likely to backfire. Deputy Andrews said that there seems to be unholy haste about the manner in which the Government are anxious to rush this Bill through the House.
Comment on this
In view of that interruption I think I should draw attention to the fact that while we had an Acting Chairman the Parliamentary Secretary and Government Whip left the House and there were no interruptions. For some peculiar reason the Parliamentary Secretary and Government Whip comes back into the House to give bad example when the Ceann Comhairle returns to the Chair.
Comment on this
Cavan): On a point of order, that is obviously a reflection on the Chair and should be withdrawn.
Comment on this
If it turns out to be a reflection on the Chair I withdraw it. I do not intend to reflect on the Chair. I intended it deliberately to reflect on the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
On me. One of the most disagreeable dog fights this evening was with Deputy Andrews and was conducted in the presence of the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
The Chair is anxious to maintain strict order in the House and to apportion fair play to all Deputies. Deputy Lalor may be assured of that also.
Comment on this
I got a lesson from the Parliamentary Secretary about three weeks ago. I want to show up some of his figures for what they are.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
In the course of my observations I propose to draw attention to a number of observations made by the Minister for Local Government.
Comment on this
During the course of this discussion so far a number of points have been made, 90 per cent of the time from this side of the House. A big number of contributions brought observations from the Minister who, naturally enough, cannot be here today. We should not allow this debate to be completed until the Minister comes back. I was given to understand today that his Parliamentary Secretary was standing by waiting to reply to the debate. In view of the very valuable contributions made from this side of the House it would be improper for us to complete the debate without giving the Minister ample opportunity to reply to the very many justifiable criticisms of the Bill and the very many justifiable criticisms that will still arise.
I do not want to leave myself open to any criticism indicating that I have no alternatives to suggest to the Minister for Local Government. I sat in this House during the debate on the 1968 Bill. I was Parliamentary Secretary at the time. I listened to the various contributions. I witnessed the crocodile tears shed in connection with Leitrim. I am glad Deputy Reynolds has come in to hear my reference to the Leitrim situation. A few moments ago he had some questions for my colleague, Deputy Faulkner. He did not himself contribute to the debate so far. If he did he would, of course, have to say in justification of what his own Minister is doing that he is quite happy with the carve-up of Leitrim, but it would be rather difficult for him to come in here and say that.
Comment on this
My colleague, Deputy Molloy, dealt very comprehensively with this Bill. He drew attention to the fact that on a population basis the province of Connacht, with the inclusion of Donegal and Clare, was entitled to 30 seats in this House but the Minister was making provision for only 28 seats. I have been listening to this debate and to a considerable amount of heckling from the Government benches. I now want to put on record that on 15th November, the day on which this Bill was introduced, there were 128 interruptions in the debate from the Minister for Local Government. I have counted them.
Comment on this
On Tuesday, 27th November, the day on which the debate resumed, there were 56 interruptions by the Minister for Local Government.
Comment on this
On Wednesday, 28th November, there were 76 interruptions by the Minister for Local Government making since the debate started—thank God, he is not here today—a grand total of 260 interruptions by the Minister for Local Government.
Comment on this
There is a reason for these interruptions. The Fianna Fáil Deputies were going off the rails. They were de-railing themselves and the Minister had to intervene.
Comment on this
The Deputy in possession is entitled to be heard without interruption or interjection.
Comment on this
I insist the Deputy be allowed to make his contribution. These interruptions must cease.
Comment on this
As I said, there have so far been 260 interruptions by the Minister for Local Government in the debate on this Bill. This is the self-same man who, in the debate on the Electoral (Amendment) Bill in 1968, said to the then Minister for Local Government at column 1816 of volume 237 of the Official Report of 4th December:
The Minister should leave me alone without interrupting and, when he comes to reply, he can speak for as long as he wants.
It is amazing how things change.
Comment on this
Interruptions can sometimes be a help, but I am not encouraging them. Deputy Harte said: "Not interruptions—corrections".
Comment on this
I would like now to draw the attention of the House to the first day of the debate, Thursday, 15th November. When Deputy Molloy was speaking he quoted the average population per seat in Dublin and he gave a figure of 20,142. The Minister for Local Government interrupted and said:
To help Deputy Molloy, may I say the average in the West is 20,509 and in the Dublin area it is 20,840. So would the Deputy please correct his figures?
This was said with the usual sneering smile. Later on the same day, immediately after Questions, at column 2092 of volume 268 of the Official Report the Minister said:
With the permission of the Chair, I should like to make a statement. This morning in the course of Deputy Molloy's speech there was an interruption by me on the average population for Deputies in certain areas. I stated in good faith from information I got that the average population for Deputies in Dublin was 20,840. I should like to correct that: I am now informed that the correct figure is 20,142. It is only fair to put that on the record.
This was exactly the figure Deputy Molloy had quoted earlier that morning and was corrected by the Minister.
Comment on this
There is a gentleman, says the Minister for Lands. Deputy Colley at this stage came in to say:
We appreciate what the Minister has said.
Deputy Colley was giving him full credit for being a gentleman, as he thought:
I heard of the incident but I did not have the precise figures. Could the Minister indicate whether what he has said means that Deputy Molloy's figure was correct?
To which Deputy Tully, the Minister for Local Government, the gentleman, replied:
No, not quite accurate.
Mr. Colley: But it was more correct than the other one.
To which the Minister, being a gentleman, responded: "Yes". Later that day Deputy Molloy, having heard what the Minister for Local Government had said and having heard——
Comment on this
Deputy Molloy, according to column 2104 of the Official Report of 15th November, on a point of information, asked the Leas-Cheann Comhairle for permission to ask the Minister for Local Government a question. Deputy Molloy was duly given this permission and he said he understood that after Question Time the Minister referred to a figure which he, Deputy Molloy, had quoted and which the Minister had said earlier was wrong. The Minister subsequently gave another figure and Deputy Molloy asked for an explanation from the Minister on that.
On that occasion the Minister said he had already given the figure and he was sorry that Deputy Molloy could not find time to be in the House. That was one of those sniggering remarks we have come to expect from the Minister, Deputy Tully. It would be very easy for me tonight to say that, as this business has been ordered, it was a pity that the Minister could not be here. I appreciate why the Minister is not here tonight because he is on far more important business. Deputy Molloy pointed out to the Minister that, as he was aware, he was not present at the time. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach will appreciate that it is not very easy for the Opposition spokesman on Local Government to be in the House at all times.
Later Deputy Tully told Deputy Molloy:
"You were right and I was wrong."
The Official Report goes on:
Mr. Molloy: I was correct?
Mr. Tully: The Deputy's figure was as nearly correct as makes no matter.
Mr. Molloy: The figure I gave was 20,142. That was correct? I understood that the Minister said my figure was still not correct.
Mr. Tully: It is slightly off.
Therefore, according to Mr. Tully, the figure of 20,142 was slightly off the figure of 20,142. Are the interjections by the Minister by way of correction rather than interruptions?
Comment on this
That is a brilliant intervention. On a point of order, I ask for a ruling from the Chair. I know that the Minister for Local Government is to be referred to as the Minister for Local Government but I am quoting from the Official Report and that report describes the Minister as "Mr. Tully". What description am I to give?
Comment on this
The Standing Orders of this House ordain that Members shall be referred to as Deputies and office holders shall be referred to as Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries as the case may be. If the Deputy is quoting from the Official Report and Mr. Tully is referred to as such in that report I feel that he is quite in order to say so.
Comment on this
That word "encouragement" is an awful word to use. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Cruise-O'Brien used it for four hours one day. It is a bad word and I do not think it should be used in this House.
Comment on this
I should now like to continue with observations on other remarks made by the Minister for Local Government in this House. In introducing this Bill the Minister drew attention to the fact that the population of the State had increased by 3.3 per cent since the census in 1966. Apparently this does not seem to have sunk in with the Deputies on the Government side who are still talking about an emigration problem that was overcome by the previous Administration. We have had this increase in population and there is no doubt but that in at least two of the counties west of the Shannon there has been a sizeable increase in population. The trend in the other counties shows that the exodus is drying up.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy taking credit for the increase in the population? Are the Fianna Fáil Party taking credit for this increase in population?
Comment on this
We are taking credit for the fact that we stemmed the emigration flow. The 1971 census to which we are referring established the fact that the population has increased. Everybody is aware of this fact.
Comment on this
It is a shame for a Deputy from the west of Ireland not to support Deputy Lalor in his remarks. The Deputy is quoting figures from Donegal to Clare and the population there justifies 30 seats.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Lalor taking credit, on behalf of his party, for the increase in population and, if so, is he accepting responsibility for the decline in population up to now?
Comment on this
The details I have referred to are on the records of this House but it is obvious that Deputy Harte has not taken time to investigate them. He has not done so because the Whip on the Government side has given instruction to the Government backbenchers not to make any contribution to this debate. We had one contribution which Deputy Dowling goaded Deputy Belton into making tonight but the assistant Government Whip was sent into the House, just as he was dragged in by the dog collar yesterday, to put a note in front of Deputy Belton telling him to shut up.
Comment on this
I have such respect for Deputy Luke Belton that if he says that what the assistant Government Whip put in front of him was not an instruction to him to shut up I accept his word.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This is only helping Deputy Lalor to kill time. He has no valid contribution to make.
Comment on this
I have a contribution to make and I intend to show the Minister for Local Government up. I am going to show the Minister how he could do something concrete about the west instead of slicing it up.
Comment on this
I cannot tolerate any further interruptions in this debate, I must ask Deputies to desist from interrupting and allow the Deputy in possession to continue. This applies to every Deputy.
Comment on this
The present population of the area west of the Shannon, which includes the Connacht counties, Donegal and Clare, is 574,254. That fully justifies 30 seats. The people on the Government side may say that there has been a fall in population in the west and I accept the fact that, taking those counties together, there has been a 1.6 per cent drop in population.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not said anything about Mayo and we are waiting to hear something from him about that county. However, I will give him some information about Mayo.
Comment on this
The Whip is allowing his backbenchers to speak. I cannot understand why the National Coalition have decided that because there was a decrease in population in those counties of 1.6 per cent they should deprive that area of one-fifteenth of its representation. We accept that some county boundaries must be breached but any unnecessary breaching should not be indulged in.
Comment on this
The Minister for Local Government could, if he was interested in endeavouring to do as little border-crossing or county boundary-breaching as possible—I do not accept that 28 seats are enough for the west, but assuming 28 seats were sufficient—he could have approached the matter in a different manner, giving five seats to Donegal, four seats to Sligo-Leitrim—a full and complete Leitrim and a complete Sligo, maintaining his new position——
Comment on this
I am talking of the situation as the Minister for Local Government finds it in relation to all of the squawking we heard from this side of the House in 1968 in reference to Leitrim.
Comment on this
Times have changed. The population has increased, thank God, as a result of Fianna Fáil policy. We heard the principles of the people opposite before but they are changing them now because they do not suit. We had a lot of lip service from the Minister for Local Government about sparing county boundaries. I can show him that, with the breaching as already introduced in Donegal——
Comment on this
I am trying to get a constructive suggestion on record in relation to the 28 seats in the west of Ireland.
Comment on this
If I am allowed to complete my speech I shall show how they can have 28 Deputies in the west of Ireland and leave Sligo-Leitrim as an intact constituency without boundary-breaching. The population has changed.
Comment on this
Agreed, and so has the principle and the projected honesty of the former Opposition. Deputy Reynolds, sitting up in the back was squawking a few minutes ago. I am telling Deputy Reynolds——
Comment on this
Deputy Reynolds is reneging on the people of Leitrim because he snatched a seat and he is afraid of losing it back to Deputy Joe MacLaughlin. That is why he does not want Leitrim and Sligo——
Comment on this
If there are Deputies in the House who find it difficult to listen to what another Deputy has to say they have a remedy.
Comment on this
If the truth is going to provoke any Government Deputy I am sorry if they cannot accept it. The position improved from 1971. It is disimproving now, of course, because there is no money and shortly there will be no people left. County Sligo has a population of 50,275.
Comment on this
The constant barracking of a Deputy in possession from any side of the House is not only unfair and unjust but is disorderly in the extreme.
Comment on this
I needed that protection, thank you. I have been endeavouring to do a sum for the back benchers with a view to their conveying the information to the Minister for Local Government when he returns. The population of Sligo in 1961—it is higher now since we opened Snia (Ireland) Ltd. which gives valuable employment—was 50,275. The population of Leitrim— I know Manorhamilton and surrounding districts and Carrick-on-Shannon are also improving—was 28,360, making a total population in the area of 78,635. Add to that the slice which the Minister for Local Government has stolen from Donegal in order to make sure that it will not be two three-seaters, a total of 2,835 votes, making in all 81,470. Sligo-Leitrim can be a distinct four-seat constituency with no border breaching as far as it is concerned. You have the complete county of Sligo and the complete county of Leitrim making a four-seat constituency which no Deputy on the Government side likes. The logical thing to say is: "That is grand if you can continue it." I move on then to the situation in Roscommon-Mayo. We have already five seats in Donegal and four in Sligo-Leitrim making nine. I am sorry to have to count it out——
Comment on this
We had somebody here from Mayo but he has gone. In Mayo we have 109,525 people and in Roscommon 53,519 which means that in the area it is possible to have eight seats giving five to Mayo and three to Roscommon with a very small incursion across the Mayo border. Deputy Mrs. Burke was rather worried about Roscommon having lost some land back to Athlone. That brings us to the third part of that area. We already have nine seats and eight seats making 17. We have another 11 seats to distribute and we have two counties.
Comment on this
We have another 11 seats to distribute and we have two counties, Galway and Clare. I know this is annoying the Government because they are putting it up to the Minister for Local Government——
Comment on this
The Chair is appealing to Deputies' sense of fair play to allow the Deputy in possession to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
The population of Galway is 149,223 and the population of Clare is 75,008, making a total population of 224,231. This entitles that two-county area to 11 seats. Clare is only 2,000 votes short to make it eligible for a four-seater. It should be possible to have four seats in East Galway, three in West Galway and four in Clare. In that context it would be necessary to borrow a small piece of Galway to make up the four-seater in Clare.
Comment on this
It does not really matter because the same man will get that seat, whether it is in Galway or Clare.
Comment on this
I doubt if Deputy Loughnane is helping the Deputy in possession. He is certainly not helping the Chair.
Comment on this
I want to show that even though the Government filched two seats from the west, if they wished they could have arranged for the minimum breach of county boundaries. The suggestion I have made would cover that area with only three minor breaches. I agree that 2,000 people were dislocated in South Donegal, as were people in South East Mayo and South Galway but it was much less than the total dislocation that is taking place now. Despite the protestations, the crocodile tears and the abuse the former Minister for Local Government received——
Comment on this
He received dog's abuse from the other side of the House. Last night the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs told us to forget the past.
Comment on this
If Deputy Harte continued to rise on points of information from now until doomsday we would not be able to penetrate the thickness with the information.
Comment on this
It would be a challenge for the Deputy but perhaps if he tried hard enough it could be done.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy is a better authority on six inch nails than he is on making speeches.
Comment on this
I have outlined the situation as objectively as I can. There is one intellegent man on the other side—I do business with him every day.
Comment on this
I would appeal to Deputies to allow the speaker in possession to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
Apart from the attack on the western areas by the Government and the loss of two seats because of the continued support of the people for Fianna Fáil——
Comment on this
The Government are robbing them of their birthright. It is obvious that the Dublin-dominated Cabinet have had their way. The Government have shown their animosity not only towards the west of Ireland but towards rural Ireland. Kildare, which has a population of 71,977 with three seats, is also being robbed. The population of Meath is 71,729 but because the Minister for Local Government had his seat almost snatched from him on the last occasion, he robs Kildare, which is entitled to greater representation, slips it into Meath and gives the rest of Kildare to Dublin. Deputy Andrews quoted this evening the speech of the Minister for Local Government when he was in Opposition when he challenged the then Minister to add to County Meath a bit of County Dublin. Instead of taking from Dublin, the Minister now robs Kildare and Wicklow. In fact, a great slice is taken from North Kildare to ensure that the former Deputy, Terry Boylan, will not be sent back to this House by the people of Kildare. As proof of that we had Deputy Malone coming into the House, saying he was very sorry for the people in Kildare.