Private Members' Business. - Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 1973: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–185 of 368. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 3 of 1973 ›
We are dealing in this section with a proposal to increase the number of Deputies to be elected to this House from 144 to 148. I have already indicated that on this side of the House we do not in principle oppose increasing the number of Members by an additional four to 148 but that we object very seriously to the manner in which it is proposed to distribute these additional four seats among the various constituencies the Minister proposes in this Bill.
The Minister is aware that the Constitutional provisions allow for such an increase if he chooses to take the lower figures suggested in the Constitution of 20,000. This is what he has done. The House should be aware that the option open to the Minister ranges from 148 Deputies down to 99 Deputies if he chose the higher figure per Deputy of 30,000 mentioned in the Constitution. As it has been the practice over the years to decide on the number of Deputies by going to the lower limit mentioned in the Constitution, 20,000, one can in that way justify the creation of four new seats. We feel that the Minister is expecting a lot from us in seeking our ready agreement to this section in view of the manner in which those seats have been allocated.
Comment on this
This section is influenced by the use the Minister makes of the power he is seeking in this Bill which we claim is unjust and unfair. He is paying no heed to the practical situation which obtained in this country at the time he drew up the proposals which are contained in this Bill. One must consider that the population of the province of Munster in 1971 was 882,002 and that that, in fact, was an increase of 22,668 over the previous census figures published in 1966 but in this Bill the Minister does not propose increasing representation in any of the counties in the Munster region. Yet, when one looks at the census figures for Leinster and examines the increase in the population that has taken place in that province one sees that it has increased by 88,700.
Comment on this
The Chair must draw the attention of the Deputy to the fact that if he proceeds to discuss any particular province every other Deputy might do the same and there would be duplication of debate. This section is only concerned with the number of Members. The distribution or the placing of them elsewhere will fall to be discussed on the Schedule.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been drawing attention to the numbers in the province. On that basis we would have duplication of debate.
Comment on this
In deciding whether or not we support section 2 we must take into consideration the increase that has taken place in the population. One must take into consideration the fact that the Minister has an option of increasing the numbers but that it is not absolutely necessary that this section should be included in the Bill at all in so far as it relates to an increase of four seats. The whole basis on which this section stands is that there was an increase in population shown in the 1971 census. I submit that I am fully in order in examining the census figures.
Comment on this
Nobody is interested. Deputy Molloy is making a speech and there is nobody except the Minister on the Government benches to hear him.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
The basis on which the Minister seeks to increase the number of Deputies is the fact that there has been an increase in population. It is only on that basis that he can argue in favour of increasing the number of Deputies by four.
Comment on this
We submit that the only valid argument that can be advanced by the Minister in favour of increasing the number of seats by four is that there has been an increase in the population since the last revision was carried out. I submit that it is in order for me to refer to this population increase on this section and that it would stifle debate on this subject if I were to be debarred from referring to the very basis on which this section stands, that is, population increases.
Comment on this
This section deals with an increase in membership. The distribution of Members may be dealt with on the Schedule. It is not in order to deal with it at this stage.
Comment on this
Whether or not the Fianna Fáil Party will support this section depends on whether the Government will give an indication to the House that they will allocate the extra four seats they are seeking in a fair and just manner. If I am not to be allowed to show that they are not allocating these seats in a fair and just manner——
Comment on this
The allocation of the seats is dealt with in the Schedule. We have not yet reached the allocation of seats.
Comment on this
The Chair will appreciate that there is a vital principle involved here. The whole Bill stands or falls on section 2. If there are no additional seats to distribute, then the Schedule falls because the Schedule as drawn up is dependent on 148 seats being allocated. We are arguing the question of these additional seats. We feel we are fully entitled to go into this whole matter on this section in very great detail. If the Government are seeking the support of the Fianna Fáil Party for this Bill they must come clean and they must give us an indication as to whether they intend to make any amendments to the Schedule, whether they intend at any stage to consider the amendments proposed by this party or whether they are prepared to consider amendments on Report Stage which would effect a fairer distribution of the additional seats. Not alone is the Minister by this device in a position where he has the discretion to create four new seats but by the devious means employed by the Minister in this Bill he has taken unto himself the right to allocate six new seats by reducing that area of the country from Donegal to County Clare by two. The population, as given in the 1971 census, does, in fact, allow for the retention of 30 seats in that area, which is the existing number of Deputies elected from that area now and the Minister proposes to reduce that area by two. This means that, in dealing with the Schedule subsequently, the Minister has six seats to allocate; two which he stole from the west of Ireland and four which he is allowed to create under the Constitution if we accept this section.
What has happened? Five of those seats have been allocated to the Dublin area; one to the Minister's own constituency. Munster has received no increase and the west has been reduced by two.
We submit to the House that this is gross gerrymandering; that it is total dishonesty; that the Government should be completely ashamed even to come before the House with a measure such as this. If they sent in Deputy Tully to carry the brunt of this debate and bring this Bill through the Dáil; if they had said: "You do it, Jim; you stick it out there; you march it through; we will come in when you want us to vote"—that is a very poor way for the Government to treat this House. As is evident now, there are three Deputies sitting behind the Minister and they are there because we called for a quorum.
Comment on this
The Minister was sitting here alone until the quorum was called. The Government have paid scant heed to the authority of this House in bringing this Bill forward.
Comment on this
I am very much with the section because we are discussing whether or not there should be an increase in the number of Deputies.
Comment on this
We have the interesting spectacle of not one Deputy from the Government benches behind the Minister making any contribution to this debate which has now gone on for three and a half to four hours.
Comment on this
As I have explained, the Constitutional position does permit these four extra seats being created. But we put it to the House and to the Minister that, in the allocation, it would have been more correct for him—in coming back to the House here seeking approval for his actions —to have used some arguments to support increasing the number of Deputies by four. No argument has been used other than that the Government have decided; the Government have the votes and will march it through. We are not satisfied that the Government have been fair and honest with the community in the manner in which they have distributed the additional seats that are to be created and the two seats that have been stolen from the west of Ireland.
The whole of the Munster region— increasing by 22,000 persons—was not granted any of these six seats which the Minister had to give away.
Comment on this
Yes—which we believe is a matter of fundamental importance if we are to be asked to agree to this section.
Comment on this
What the Chair is trying to tell the Deputy is that the distribution of seats is part of the Schedule.
Comment on this
Deputy Coughlan, I am sure, would have some valuable contribution to make to this Bill. It is a well-known fact that——
Comment on this
I do not do any crooked things like the Deputy. The Deputy cannot point the finger at Coughlan.
Comment on this
There is the well-known fact that Deputy Coughlan was called into the office of the Taoiseach, Deputy Cosgrave, and pleaded with to agree to a three-seater in the Limerick East Constituency, and that Deputy Coughlan——
Comment on this
And Deputy Coughlan has repeated on numerous occasions, inside and outside this House, how he told Liam Cosgrave to go and get stuffed and that there would be four seats in East Limerick——
Comment on this
——and that Deputy Coughlan would maintain his rural base and would keep Mr. Lipper out of this House.
Comment on this
People outside the House, who have no opportunity of defending themselves, should not be referred to.
Comment on this
The boy is lost for an answer so he is like a drowning man dragging at every old straw that passes his way. He should go back to Oranmore.
Comment on this
I will not return again for quite a while to Mr. Lipper. But this interesting sidelight on the manner in which this Bill was drawn up is a reflection on the integrity of the Minister and of the Government who come before the House asking us to accept the Bill in all good faith, telling us, trying to convince the press so that they, in turn, would try to assure the people of this country that this was the only way this could have been done by the Minister; that this was the best way and that there was no other way out of it. I have seen, since this debate started—and in the speeches that were made here on Second Stage —Deputies from the west of Ireland totally indoctrinated by their leaders, coming in here—Deputies from Roscommon, from Sligo and from Leitrim —saying that the Minister has no choice, because of the population figures in the 1971 census, other than to reduce the number of seats in that western region by two.
Comment on this
I have shown, in the amendment that I have put down, that that is not true. Yet those untrue statements have been made in this House.
Comment on this
I live four miles from Derry city and all students of politics know that, in Derry city, we have the classic, international example of gerrymandering. I accuse the Minister for Local Government of bringing in here a gerrymandering proposal which is very little behind the Derry set-up.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to stay with section 2 which proposes to increase the number of seats by four.
Comment on this
The Minister had a choice. According to the Constitution, he could have ranged from 148 Deputies down to the number mentioned by Deputy Molloy, which was 99. This is a fairly wide choice. We do not mind his making the choice he did; that is, 148. It does mean that he is creating a situation—by having 148 Deputies—where, in the views of all sides of this House, the people of this country will be better represented. In other words, we could have had a situation where the Minister could decide, under the Constitution, that he would take 25,000 persons per Deputy and, in so doing, would divide the population by 25, thus arriving at a number of Deputies which would be much fewer than 148.
Section 2 provides for that kind of activity by the Minister under the Constitution. Although he would be legally and constitutionally entitled to do it I think it would be wrong for the Minister to say that a Deputy will represent not fewer than 25,000 persons. I am glad he did not do it. As a matter of fact, the better representation any group of persons has in this House and the lesser number of persons which a Deputy represents, all the better. In other words, he can do it more efficiently, provided the area he has to cover is fairly small. Therefore, we do not object to 148 in itself.
We now have a situation where some men are more equal than others. The people in the Minister's constituency, where he added another seat, are more equal than the people in the western constituencies where, instead of a Deputy representing 19,000, he will have to represent 21,000.
Comment on this
We on this side of the House are prepared to give the Minister section 2 of the Bill. We would not like to see him jackbooting it through the House.
Comment on this
The Minister said last night that this is what he would do. The Government had decided and they would not change their minds no matter what logic was used, no matter what part of the country was depopulated so far as Deputies were concerned. We do not mind so long as the people, through the voice of Fianna Fáil as an opposition, have it spelled out loud and clear——
Comment on this
——that they have been gerrymandered and that the Government and Minister will take away equal rights and the just society —and may call it the Justin Society if you like——
Comment on this
The Chair has already advised the Deputy that the distribution of seats is a matter for the Schedule. He will confine himself to the number of Deputies.
Comment on this
The distribution of Deputies is important. When the Minister was being chiselled by Deputy Coughlan——
Comment on this
Why not a carpenter? I cannot use a chisel. Any chiselling that was done was done by Deputy Molloy.
Comment on this
There is no truth whatsoever in the rumour that the Minister for Local Government had to lay a new piece of carpet at his door after the pilgrimage of Deputies from that side of the House.
Comment on this
The Minister must have had the distribution figures for the population of this country before him when he——
Comment on this
The Chair has already advised the Deputy that the distribution of seats is a matter for the Schedule.
Comment on this
I respect your ruling, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. Could I ask you to help me? I visualise a situation where the Minister sat down with the census figures in front of him and arrived at section 2 and 148 Deputies and the distribution of the population represented by those figures. Surely I can make a logical argument against what he has done. Am I allowed to refer to population distribution?
Comment on this
The Chair is not interfering with the Deputy's right to argue. The Chair is pointing out that the section of this Bill enables us to have 148 Deputies. The distribution is dealt with in the Schedule and there will be an opportunity for Deputies to discuss it on the Schedule.
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I respectfully suggest that some of the remarks by Deputy Cunningham are relevant. Suppose a manager came to his directors for £X,000 this year, the first thing he would be asked would be what did he want to do with it. We are not satisfied with what has been done and we want to find out exactly what the Minister proposes to do. Therefore, I hold that Deputy Cunningham's remarks on distribution are relevant.
Comment on this
The Chair has indicated that there will be an opportunity on another section of this Bill for me to discuss this subject. It could be that the Government might change their minds. A Deputy might vote according to his conscience and this section might be defeated. In that case I might never get a chance again to discuss it on another section. This is possible. The Government were defeated before.
Comment on this
Will the Deputies accept from the Chair that what we are concerned with is the number of Deputies? The Chair is aware that even nine-tenths of the Deputies could discuss——
Comment on this
On a point of order, last night we had the distribution of population in Dublin and how the Dublin seats were arrived at, from the Minister. You were in the Chair, Sir. With respect, I asked him for the figures on Munster. I congratulated him for having the Dublin figures. If I were in his shoes coming in here and fighting for Dublin city I would have that ammunition with me. The fact is that he produced these figures and gave us not alone the population figures for the 1971 census but also the projected figures for the following two years. On that basis, if Deputy Cunningham is ruled out of order, the Minister should have been ruled out of order last night.
Comment on this
I have the figures which were given to us last night by the Minister in respect of the Dublin area. He also gave us the population of the Dublin area and the figures are, as the Official Report will show, 41, 42, 43 or 44. He had a choice.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil should stop for a minute and look at themselves because they are being extremely childish. Nobody would believe that a group of grown men would come in here, argue in favour of 148 seats and then argue for hours and hours against it and in doing so make nonsensical arguments.
Comment on this
Every time the Minister rises he uses, in respect of the Deputies on this side, the words "stupid" and "ignorant", or says they do not know what they are talking about or that they have not a clue.
Comment on this
The Minister must think himself the repository of all the wisdom, learning, understanding and other virtues of this House. He is not any such thing.
If the Minister took some time to discuss what he could have done arising out of the figures of the 1971 census in Dublin and the choices which he had available to him he might have had a different view. He has shown us clearly when talking on section 2 of this Bill that he had a choice in respect of Dublin. He explained to us that he was toying with the idea of giving Dublin 41 seats, 42 seats, 43 seats or 44 seats. As Deputy Molloy has pointed out, the Minister had six seats to play around with, four of which became available due to the increase in the population, the other two pilfered from the west of the country. Instead of any of the numbers that he mentioned the Minister decided on 43. In other words, the Minister went the whole hog but, of course, he kept one for County Meath, his own constituency.
Comment on this
The Minister went further. He went outside the population of the 1971 census and asked Dublin Corporation Planning Section to give him the up-to-date figures in relation to the city. What he wanted them for is hard to understand because they were not relevant to anything he was legally or constitutionally entitled to do with the Bill. However, he did so many things with this Bill that I suppose he had reached the stage where he thought he was all powerful and all mighty. He thought there was no harm in seeing what the situation in the future could be.
I should like to tell the Minister that the future for him, and his Bill, so far as the country is concerned looks bleak. The Minister will go down as the architect of this blatant piece of gerrymandering. The people up and down the country are not yet aware what is happening to them. That is because very little publicity has been given to this matter and little discussion has taken place. Some counties are now objecting to this. They are, of course, also objecting to the Minister's high-handed circular to the local authorities asking them if they have any suggestion to make but when they made suggestions down went the jack-boot.
Comment on this
The way the present Government is carrying on it will not be long before we are all in our bare feet.
Comment on this
We are prepared to agree to this section but I should like to paint the picture of difference between the present Minister's proposals and those of his predecessor. Deputy Molloy would not have pinched seats from Ulster, from Connacht or from Munster. It used be "to hell or to Connacht", but nowadays it is "from Connacht to Dublin".
Comment on this
The Deputy is making an historical comparison between the Minister and Cromwell and there is very little difference between the two of them.
Comment on this
The difference that exists between what is proposed now and what would have been introduced by Deputy Molloy if he was Minister for Local Government is vast. We have nothing against Dublin.
Comment on this
Dublin does not want the unfair advantage being given it in this Bill by the Minister. It is being done for political reasons to suit the Minister's political philosophy.
Comment on this
At least we would have argued in favour of what we proposed doing but in this case we have nothing from the Minister to back up his proposals.
Comment on this
Deputy Molloy made a dog's breakfast of it when he was here and what is now proposed is entirely different.
Comment on this
We must get it across to the people of Ireland, to the people of Dublin who will be represented by some of the 148 and to the people of the west of Ireland that the principle of equal representation is gone. Worse than that, the principle has now been established that if there is a nice small compact highly populated area more Deputies will be given to it than to one which is scattered, far from this Parliament and handicapped in every way.
The Minister now adds another handicap to those which affect some of the constituencies of Munster. I notice that the Deputies from Munster on the Government side of the House are now as mute as mice.
Comment on this
The Chair is anxious to ensure that every Deputy gets a good hearing. The Chair will tolerate no further interruptions and the Deputy will speak through the Chair.
Comment on this
The Minister has only three Deputies behind him but they will not say anything on this section. It is logical that a Munster Deputy would give his opinion unless he is being muzzled. I am speaking as a Deputy from Ulster, whose province has been robbed of a seat——
Comment on this
The Deputy did not put down an amendment. He is quite satisfied. He knows he will get one out of the five anyway.
Comment on this
The Minister took a seat from us. I want to tell the people of Ulster that he stole a seat; I will do it in this House and eventually the message will get across. The people of Munster are in the same boat but the Deputies from that province sit like dummies behind the Minister. When he looks crossly at them they freeze but on the appointed day they will troop in behind him and say they are happy with what the Minister did and that he is entitled to a seat in Meath which he has taken from Ulster. The same applies to Connacht. There is an Ulster Deputy sitting behind the Minister but he will walk into the lobby behind the Minister and say Ulster is prepared to be gerrymandered. We are not prepared and I want to state that loudly and clearly. The Minister can have 148 Deputies if he is prepared to give a fair deal. He should show by his actions that all people are equal.
Comment on this
I do not know if Deputy Cunningham is sincere in what he says or if he is playing to the gallery. He talked about going to hell or to Connacht. Does he realise that Fianna Fáil took part of Leitrim and put it into Donegal, that they brought part of Connacht into Ulster to keep six Deputies in Donegal, four of whom were Fianna Fáil? It amazes me that Deputy Cunningham and others seem to forget that prior to 1937 there were eight Deputies in Donegal and Fianna Fáil had four of these——
Comment on this
The Chair hesitates to interrupt the Deputy but he must advise all Members that this section deals with the fixing of the total number of Members to be elected to this House. The debate should not attempt to cover distribution of the seats. Deputies should relate their remarks solely to whether the number should be 144 or 148 Members. That is the issue.
Comment on this
The section deals with an increase in the membership of the House. Last night Deputy Dowling entertained us in a pantomime effort on whether he should support the section and he ended up by telling us how he could oppose it. I do not know whether Deputy Cunningham supports or opposes the section. He seems to be objecting to the fact that out of 148 Deputies there would be one less Deputy in Donegal. It is on these lines I am making my case.
Comment on this
We shall be dealing with Donegal, as well as other counties, on the appropriate Schedule and that will be the time for Deputies to raise arguments in respect of Donegal, Dublin and elsewhere It is not in order on section 2 of the Bill.
Comment on this
I should like to raise a point of order. I put the matter to the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and I think he agreed with it. It is in reference to Deputy Harte's comments. If I were manager of a big business and wanted extra money this year, one of the first things a director would ask me would be what I wanted to do with the money. The Minister is asking for four more seats and, on a point of order, I claim it is relevant to ask him what he is going to do with them before we give them to him.
Comment on this
The Deputy's remarks are of interest to the Chair but they will not influence his decision on the matter. The Chair is quite satisfied that the distribution of seats must be left to the Schedule.
Comment on this
Deputies will be afforded every opportunity of expressing their views at that time. It is disorderly to raise the matter on section 2.
Comment on this
I submit to the ruling of the Chair but I fail to understand how Deputy Cunningham could make the points he raised. I am at a grave disadvantage because I am not in a position to answer him as I should like to do. Deputy Cunningham forgets that in 1961 it was the then Minister for Local Government, Deputy Blaney, who kept the Deputy in this House, as happened in 1969 when Mr. Boland was Minister. What the present Minister for Local Government did should have been done in 1961 or in 1969. I do not know what thanks Deputy Cunningham will give the present Minister, but we all know the thanks he gave his former colleagues, Deputy Blaney, and Mr. Boland.
Comment on this
I am not arguing but I am submitting to the Chair as a point of argument that Deputy Cunningham's submission has been——
Comment on this
Deputy Cunningham's objection to the 148 seats is that one of his colleagues will be dismissed from this House. He should not have been here for the last 20 years.
Comment on this
On section 2 it is difficult to discuss the question of agreeing that the new Dáil, following the dissolution of this Dáil, will consist of 148 members. We have had evidence from Deputy Harte of the difficulty there is for the House in discussing this on section 2.
Comment on this
I have no intention of doing that. Under the existing Act there are 144 Deputies in the House. The Minister proposes to raise that figure to 148 Deputies. I take it that is in order.
Comment on this
I agree. You have informed us that we cannot discuss individual cases and therein I have a problem.
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I ask you a question, a Cheann Comhairle? I submit to you, as was submitted last night, that we are talking about 148 or 144 Deputies. The figure of 148 did not drop from out of the sky. It was added up by a number of constituencies grouped all over the country. I agree that we cannot talk about individual constituencies but, in a general way, surely how this figure of 148 is made up is relevant to section 2. With respect, Sir, I say this to you.
Comment on this
The Deputy's remarks are of interest to the Chair but do not change the Chair's ruling.
Comment on this
Allow me, Deputy. The Chair is prepared to give reasonable latitude. I said last night that brief remarks on the constituencies or the variations would be allowed by the Chair, but Deputies are going into detail and we cannot have that.
Comment on this
May I ask you a question? Is there another section on which we can talk about the groupings as distinct from the individual constituencies?
Comment on this
I want to help the Deputy. I will be suggesting to the House that we engage in this grouping to which he refers. There will be ample opportunity to refer to constituencies on a regional basis.
Comment on this
I accept that. I am not asking you to allow us to deal with the constituencies on this section but surely the groupings are relevant to the figure of 148.
Comment on this
This is becoming a bad joke. The Deputy is arguing with the Chair while another Deputy from his own party is on his feet.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I appreciate what you have said, a Cheann Comhairle, but as a matter of guidance am I right in this? You could visualise a situation in which this section was defeated and there might not be an opportunity to deal with what you are suggesting could be dealt with.
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that the Chair is quite conversant with the procedure in this instance.
Comment on this
Deputy Lalor is on his feet. The Deputy raised a point of order. I replied to him. He should allow Deputy Lalor to proceed.
Comment on this
I asked a question which you did not answer. I fail to find a Schedule on which you can refer to the groupings.
Comment on this
Like other Fianna Fáil speakers I share the view that it is advisable to have the maximum numbers of Deputies in Dáil Éireann arising from—and I take it this is relevant —the necessity to be represented in Europe and the possibility of a Council of Ireland. There are various reasons why we should have the maximum amount of representation especially in view of the proposed new regulations under which we will have more meetings in Committee. Deputy Molloy is also convinced that we should have the maximum number of Deputies. While we fully support that, we have reservations in view of the fact that we have no indication as yet from the Minister as to whether he is willing to accept amendments to the Schedule which have been submitted by Deputy Molloy.
Comment on this
Therefore my view on the figure of 148 Deputies is totally changed. In the 144 Deputies at present there are representatives from all over the country. There are 38 Deputies from the Dublin city and county area. In the 148 Deputies it is proposed to have 43 Deputies from the Dublin city and county area and 105 Deputies from the rest of the country, whereas at present there are 106 Deputies from the rest of the country. That acts as an incentive to us to oppose this section. While the Minister proposes that the people of the Republic be represented in Dáil Éireann by four extra Deputies he is also proposing that 25 counties should be represented by one less. This Electoral (Amendment) Bill sounds to me in a peculiar sort of way—if I am not ruled out of order—very much like the Sunningdale Agreement.
Comment on this
We are talking in this instance about section 2 and when we talk in another instance about section 5 we are told we have to buy the whole package. We cannot have details.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is the Deputy trying to tell us that the similarity between Sunningdale and the Bill before the House is that both are wrong because Fianna Fáil did not draw them up?
Comment on this
It is sub judice.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
It is a poor effort when you have to come back to try to justify your claims in this way.
Comment on this
While I cannot make out what Deputy Coughlan is saying I am sure it is the most intelligent contribution from the Government side so far.
Comment on this
I suggest the Deputy should listen to me. We hear about this open Government but we do not seem to get any factual statements from them. I was pointing out that the 1971 census of population showed that there were roughly 94,000 extra people in the country as compared with the 1966 population. Arising from that, the Minister, following the pattern his predecessor would have adopted, proposes that the number of representatives to be elected to this House should be raised to 148. I was saying that I agreed with this proposal in section 2. That means an extra Deputy per 23,000 or 24,000 people and this is fully justified but the manner in which the Minister proposes to increase the representation in one area, the Dublin city and county area, by five Deputies and to reduce the other 25 counties by one Deputy has this side of the House worried. I think this view has been expressed by everybody speaking here. It is from this point of view that we are worried about sanctioning the increased number of Deputies.
We are justified in asking the Minister to give some indication that he is willing to review his decision to disenfranchise 25 counties which have earned increased representation in order to boost the representation in Dublin city and county by an extra five Deputies. I am talking not in terms of Ulster, Munster and Conacht but about Ulster, Munster, Connacht and the remainder of Leinster outside Dublin city and county. There has been an increase in population all over the country. The Munster area population increased considerably. So did the Leinster population. The population in the Connacht area dropped by little more than 10,000 people. From that point of view there seems to be every justification for querying the intention of the Minister and the Government as expressed in section 2 of the Bill.
There are two different matters involved: one, the Minister is seeking four extra seats in Leinster House with which we agree, and two, the manner in which he proposes to fill them, with which we positively disagree. I realise that we shall have an opportunity of discussing individual cases on the Schedule and later in the Bill but if the Minister is adamant on this we would be justified in opposing the increase in representation which will have an end result of reducing rural representation—by "rural" I mean outside Dublin city and county —from 106 to 105 Deputies. This is extremely important. At present, outside Dublin city and county 106 Deputies are returned to Dáil Éireann. As a result of this Bill, as it is apparently planned at present, we shall have four extra Deputies but on the other hand we shall end up with a situation in which there will be one fewer Deputy from the 25 counties outside Dublin city and county.
Comment on this
I am extremely anxious to make a positive and concrete contribution on section 2 and I am sorry that the ringing of the quorum bell brings in what it does bring in.
Comment on this
If reducing the representation of the 25 counties from 106 to 105 meant that Deputy Harte might be the 106th man, I should feel inclined to support the Bill and I have a funny notion that on that guarantee the Minister for Local Government would probably support me——
Comment on this
The Deputy has become very clever since he became chief whip of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I was even reasonably clever in keeping down the cost of living, something the Deputy's Minister has not been able to do.
Comment on this
What has that to do with section 2 of this Bill? It is utterly disorderly and the Deputy knows it.
Comment on this
I suggest if what Deputy Molloy says is true we will do what they did. We will give the people free beef.