We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Members' Business. - Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 1973: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 186–368 of 368. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment)(No. 2) Bill, 1973
Enacted

No. 3 of 1973 ›

Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us not forget the dignity and decorum of this House.

Comment on this

This is a warning to Deputy Coughlan.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is no help to the Chair with these interruptions.

Comment on this

I am sorry that as a result of our asking for a quorum we get those interruptions. I am trying to get across the real reason why on this side of the House we are being so difficult about section 2. At present there are 106 Deputies in this House representing the territory of 25 counties.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I seem to recollect having heard that before. Repetition is not in order.

Comment on this

I have not expressed how worried the Government were.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is the Deputy making a speech?

Comment on this

He has plenty of time to make it.

Comment on this

On the one hand, you are telling me that I am repeating myself and on the other hand Deputy Harte, who has been here all the time and is a Pioneer, does not seem to have got the message.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy not resort to that tactic. If the Deputy does not want to put up his Pioneer pin in his coat and marshal before the people of Ireland——

Comment on this

The Deputy should say that to the Minister. He is the one who does that more often than anybody else.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Molloy objecting to the fact that I wear a Pioneer pin?

Comment on this

No, I am objecting to the objection which Deputy Coughlan has against the Minister.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Lalor on section 2.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy Lalor is making his continued, rather boring argument on the fact that the territory of 25 counties is losing one seat.

Comment on this

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

It is a point of order. The Deputy said that Dublin is being increased by five seats. On a point of order, does the Constitution not state that Deputies represent people and not geographical locations?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not a point of order.

Comment on this

The Constitution says that this House decides within constitutional limits. We do not agree with the way the Government are doing it. We do not think it is fair.

Comment on this

I think I have endeavoured to make my point in this regard by indicating that we can have two different points of view. We are anxious to have the maximum number of Deputies but only provided they represent the proper distribution of people. I do not know if anybody has read section 2. It states:

Dáil Éireann shall, after the dissolution thereof which next occurs after the passing of this Act, consist of one hundred and forty-eight members.

The most extraordinary thing can happen here. It is quite possible by a great stretch of the imagination to visualise a situation whereby the National Coalition Government, of which the Minister for Local Government is a member, may continue in office for a period of five years. This would mean their term of office would last to March, 1978. A census is due in 1976 and if the Government survive till then it is likely they could mess about a lot with the count— they have done so already—and might deliberately hold back having the census. I wonder if it would be possible for the Minister to alter this section to read:

After the dissolution thereof which next occurs after the passing of this Act or after the next census, whichever comes first

because it is quite probable that the population may have exceeded the number which would justify having 149 or 150 Deputies. I know that constitutionally it has worked out that 148 is the absolute maximum number of Deputies we can have in the House arising from the 1971 census. It might be no harm if the Minister amended section 2 in some way to take into consideration the possibility of increasing the representation of the country arising out of the 1976 census. That is likely to take place before the present Dáil dissolves. Tolerances have been stretched to the limit in some constituencies and those could be out of order following the next census. If the Minister was not so anxious to get this Bill and to do the gerrymandering which is so blatant and if he waited until after the 1976 census he would be in a position to see to it that the people would be more adequately represented.

Comment on this

The Deputy has said that so often that he is beginning to believe it.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is entitled to a good hearing.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring to make an argument against this section.

Comment on this

That is very difficult. The sad thing about the Deputy is that he has said that so often that he believes it.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputy Harte please cease interrupting and allow Deputy Lalor to continue?

Comment on this

I believe anything I say in this House. I am not masquerading like Deputy Harte, keeping up a front. I stand over everything I say in this House. I have said that I am fully in agreement with and fully support a section of this Bill which says that we should have the maximum number of Deputies because I realise that the maximum number of Deputies are necessary. If the Minister intends to misuse the power to increase the number by four, as he appears to intend to misuse it, by taking away from the representation of the people in 25 counties in order to give increased representation to the other——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for the Deputy to refer to 25 counties when the Constitution states that it is 20,000 people we represent?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

The Bill relates to counties.

Comment on this

I presume I am in order talking about 25 counties apart from Dublin. It makes sense to me.

Comment on this

He wants to recognise the 26 counties.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Lalor has made a long speech. He has been substantially in order but I am concerned that he may feel inclined to dwell on the distribution of the seats and this is not in order on this section.

Comment on this

I appreciate that.

Comment on this

We want to know what he wants the four seats for.

Comment on this

Any old straw to a drowning man.

Comment on this

We will not swallow gerrymanders. That is what this is.

Comment on this

I do not want to talk about the matters covered in the Schedule.

Comment on this

If you had got your way proportional representation would have gone and gone forever.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Coughlan, please.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

You had to fight for your own corner.

Comment on this

What did you tell Liam Cosgrave? You told him to go and "get stuffed" and fair play to you. Deputy Cosgrave went down on his knees and pleaded with Stevie Coughlan for three seats in East Limerick. "Get stuffed" said Steve.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Coughlan and Deputy Molloy will please cease interrupting.

Comment on this

With all due respect and obedience, but I hate hypocrisy from the Fianna Fáil benches. You are a sad sight over there.

Comment on this

We will fight gerrymanders anyway.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us have some order, please.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputies please desist from interrupting? I ask Deputy Coughlan to desist.

Comment on this

Put him out.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Interrupting is responsible for gross disorder in the House.

Comment on this

I agree with the Ceann Comhairle. It should not be allowed.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputy Ahern please resume his seat? He is being disorderly.

Comment on this

In this debate we are having a number of interjections. As I see it, an extremely useful interjection at this stage——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Can we keep off personalities, Deputy, please, and get back to the Bill?

Comment on this

It is not personal. I am seeking an interjection from the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought not to invite interjections.

Comment on this

He has already indicated that he has no intention of accepting Deputy Molloy's amendments.

Comment on this

Deputy Lalor is making a Second Reading speech and in the middle of it asks me to answer a question which he knows but I do not. This is asking a little too much. Second Reading speeches would not be in order here. I am amazed at what is happening over there.

Comment on this

I am surprised that the Minister is amazed in view of the fact that he has said, and I presume he believes what he said, that we are all sorts of duffers over here, that all the genius is over there.

Comment on this

We accept that we should have 148 Deputies in this House and more if the Constitution would allow it, more if we had an up-to-date census. I suggest that the Minister would do more justice to the voters of this country in its entirety if he would withdraw this Bill at this stage.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise on this section.

Comment on this

It arises on every section.

Comment on this

It arises on the basis of 148 Members.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Bill as introduced passed its Second Stage and is now in Committee.

Comment on this

The Minister should indicate now that he is willing to consider or introduce amendments. The Minister today on the Motorways Bill saw reason in a certain number of the amendments put forward by this party. While he resisted them originally he saw the justice of a number of them today and——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy appreciates that the amendments will come up on the Schedule.

Comment on this

With all due respect, there would not be an amendment on the Schedule. The Minister should consider an amendment so that he could increase, if the Dáil has not dissolved before the next census which is due in 1976, the representation in this House. I think that is very much on the section and is something that probably the Minister himself would welcome the opportunity of doing, because it is very much accepted, in the House, that the House could well do with the maximum amount of representation. Despite the fact that we regularly read letters in the papers, referring to how adequate it would be to have 40, or 50, or 60 working Deputies to have a proper Parliament here, we—who are engaged in parliamentary work—are extremely conscious of the pressures on our time in order to give legitimate representation.

I object to the Minister describing this as a Second Reading speech because I have indicated on two or three occasions in the course of my contribution the fact that I would welcome an indication from the Minister of an intention to intervene in order to clarify any of the points. As a matter of fact, I know there is nothing to stop me sitting down, letting the Minister reply and speaking again on Committee Stage. I am all for 148 Deputies but I object——

Comment on this

Watch it!

Comment on this

——to 25 counties of this Republic of ours being reduced by one Deputy and having the balance go to build up the representation from Dublin. I suggest the Minister seriously consider building into section 2 an amendment to provide that the numbers can be, or may be, increased following the dissolution of this Parliament, of this Dáil, if it exists beyond 1976 on the basis of the new census.

Comment on this

In relation to section 2, I should like to say that representation is the keynote. It refers to the number of Members of Dáil Éireann and an increase of four Deputies. Again, this is related to the population of the country. If we take the 148 Members, we find that that is broken down into a number of constituencies and counties. Nowhere else in the Bill is there a reference to numbers except in section 2. Therefore, I take it I am in order in referring to the breakdown of the numbers of population in relation to the 148 seats that the Minister proposes in the Bill. We see that the Carlow/Kilkenny area, in the 1971 census, had a population of 100,001 persons.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has said on a number of occasions that the Deputy may not discuss the distribution of seats at this juncture. The Carlow/Kilkenny constituency and all other constituencies can be discussed in detail, to the fullest extent, on the appropriate Schedule.

Comment on this

I am not discussing seats. I am discussing population in relation to seats and that is what this section is all about because, nowhere else in the Bill, is there any indication of where the population can be discussed in relation to seats. In the Schedule, there is no reference whatever——

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, is there a quorum in the House?

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

As I was saying, in relation to section 2, I was going to discuss this matter in relation to the 148 seats. I think this is in order. I am going to discuss the ratio of Members——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will decide what is in order.

Comment on this

Nevertheless, the ratio of population to the seats is very important. You cannot discuss this section without discussing the population on which these 148 seats will be based. It is fragmented into 42 different constituencies, this 148 Member Dáil which is proposed. This fragmentation is done in the following manner: in the Carlow/Kilkenny area—as indicated in the Bill—there are 100,001 persons. This is based on the census of population 1971. The second one is the Cavan/ Monaghan——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The constituencies to which the Deputy refers are contained in the appropriate Schedule and can be, and will no doubt be, discussed in detail at that point. They may not, and shall not, be discussed at this juncture.

Comment on this

I am not, a Cheann Comhairle, discussing——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not seek to circumvent the ruling of the Chair. He will abide by my ruling in the matter. He must not discuss constituencies, on a constituency basis, at this time.

Comment on this

The fragmentation of the 42——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The distribution of the seats does not arise on section 2.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with the distribution of seats; I merely wish to discuss the population in relation to——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I wonder would it be possible to reduce the number of the quorum to ten on this occasion?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Now, Deputy, please. Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this

I wish to discuss the breakdown of population on which the 148 Members is based.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That would be more appropriate on another section, Deputy.

Comment on this

There is no other section in the Bill where population is mentioned or where there is any reference to population——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is full and ample scope for that, Deputy.

Comment on this

There is no other section, I submit, a Cheann Comhairle, on which one can discuss population in relation to the 148 Members. I wish to discuss the 148 Members in relation to the population. This is a reasonable approach. We were told earlier that this must be discussed in relation to population and it is on that basis that I wish to discuss it.

The population of the nation is fragmented into 42 different sections. The first section which is fragmented is in Carlow/Kilkenny where there are 100,001 people. The second area— and I am not referring to seats but to the breakdown in population in relation to the 148 Members which the Minister has indicated in the Bill——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy may not move to separate constituencies.

Comment on this

I am at a loss to know how I can relate the population of the nation to the 148 Members proposed in the Bill without discussing the matter on that basis. I have no desire to move into the field of discussing the number of seats or, in a broad way, the constituencies.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Information was given in a statement regarding the total number of population and the number of seats.

Comment on this

There is a table in the explanatory memorandum which breaks down the population of the nation into 42 different sectors. I submit that it is reasonable and in order to relate the 148 Members to the population. There is no other way in which this particular section can be discussed unless on a population basis.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That will be dealt with in the Schedule.

Comment on this

In the Schedule there is no reference to population or numbers. The only place there can be reference is in section 2 which relates the number of Deputies to the population.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is trying to deal with individual places.

Comment on this

It is impossible to discuss section 2 without relating to the 148 Members. This is referred to in the table in the explanatory memorandum. Surely it is reasonable that one may comment on the fragmentation of the population in relation to the numbers in the Bill.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

When the Deputy comes to the Schedule he can deal with fragmentation.

Comment on this

There is no reference in the Schedule to population. There is a reference to the name of the constituency, to the area and the number of Members. I do not want to discuss in a general way the areas in the constituencies or the breakdown of Members in the constituencies. Nowhere else in this Bill can there be a comparison between the 148 Members and the population except in section 2.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

148 Deputies cover the country at large.

Comment on this

I want to relate that to the breakdown given in the explanatory memorandum.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

In any explanatory memorandum the breakdown is given in the Schedule.

Comment on this

There is reference to——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is concerned with keeping order.

Comment on this

I can find no other basis for discussing the population of the country as against the 148 Members. There is a breakdown one will agree. It is fragmented into 42 different areas.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that that is in the Schedule.

Comment on this

There is no reference to population in the Schedule.

Comment on this

It is in the explanatory memorandum only.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy Lalor had us bored stiff for 30 minutes——

Comment on this

That is not a point of order. Are we going to hear a speech from the Government side at last? Is there any Deputy on the Government side who will argue in favour of this Bill?

Comment on this

Is it in order for Deputy Dowling to make an argument which is contrary to that of his Chief Whip?

Comment on this

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

I spoke last night for 45 minutes giving good reasons why we could accept this. If Deputy Harte was not here I can cover that ground again——

Comment on this

I was here. When I went back to my hotel I had a nightmare.

Comment on this

I want to deal with this section in depth. There is no other section in the Bill where population can be related to Members. I submit, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that I am in order in discussing the——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will decide what is in order. I am telling the Deputy for the last time that he must keep within——

Comment on this

Can the Leas-Cheann Comhairle tell me where there is a reference in this Bill to population or where population can be discussed on the broad basis of the breakdown into 42 different sectors. The total membership of the House relates to the population. Therefore, one must be able to discuss population in relation to Membership and the breakdown thereof.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy can deal with the breakdown of the constituencies later.

Comment on this

Maybe Deputy Dowling is beginning to break down.

Comment on this

This is the section on which discussion must take place in regard to the 148 Members. Elsewhere we will see breakdowns in different ways in relation to seats, areas but not population. This is the basis on which this particular section of the Bill stands. It is related to the total number of population as in the 1971 census. The fragmentation of this 148 is broken into 42 different sectors.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has already given his ruling. The Deputy will have to accept it. Individual constituencies including their populations can be dealt with on the Schedule.

Comment on this

When discussing this section I do not wish to deal with the number of Members because that is clearly defined in the Schedule as, indeed, are the areas. I submit that if the 148——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is telling the Chair what order should be. Each time the Chair tries to advise the Deputy——

Comment on this

Where else in the Bill is there reference to population or where population can be related to 148 Members?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is no reference in section 2 to population.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowling is breaking down.

Comment on this

On a point of order, surely when discussing 148 Deputies, one cannot divorce population from the number of Deputies?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is no divorcing in that sense.

Comment on this

Who is talking about divorce?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy anticipate a Bill of that nature?

Comment on this

While Deputy Dowling is arguing about the number of Deputies that should be in this House one of his backbenchers is talking about divorce.

Comment on this

In my view I am being deprived of certain rights in this House. For that reason I do not propose to participate further other than to say that this most blatant type of gerrymandering which I was not permitted to discuss in full is a disgrace. It is useless to proceed on this because the Minister has already indicated that he is going to jackboot this Bill through the House. It is possibly the worst type of gerrymandering that has occurred in this country north or south.

Comment on this

In the five hours of debate which has taken place on sections 1 and 2 of this Bill there has been only one contribution from the Government side.

Comment on this

How could there have been any more with you fellows over there yapping all the time? No chance was given to Members on this side to speak.

Comment on this

I drew attention on a number of occasions to this extraordinary silence on the part of Deputies on the Government side. We consider this Bill a most disgraceful measure. It brings disgrace on the Government, the members of which should hang their heads in shame for attempting to succeed with a gerrymander of this type. We are all political animals in this House and we realise——

Comment on this

Talk about yourself.

Comment on this

——that within the law and the Constitution there are very few restrictions on a Minister in preparing a Bill dealing with the revision of electoral areas. The few restrictions that exist allow great discretion to a Minister who is charged with carrying out the revision.

The Minister, and the Government because there is collective responsibility involved in all measures brought before this House, the Fine Gael and Labour Parties must be tarred with the brush of shame arising out of the measure they have brought before Dáil Éireann in this instance.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot talk about shame.

Comment on this

I want to warn the Government, and the Deputies on that side of the House, that if they persist in bringing legislation similar to this before Dáil Éireann they have commenced on the slide down which will result in their being put out of Government. They are bringing great discredit on themselves from the community.

There will be reaction to this gerrymandering. At the outset, when the debate opened on section 2 of the Bill, we announced that we did not have any objection, in principle, to the proposal to increase the number of Deputies by four. Our objections and arguments up to now have been that the extra seats, which are at the discretion of the Minister, should have been allocated in a manner that could be seen to be fair and just to the whole community. This House should not be asked to pass legislation which is discriminatory in its very structure. This legislation discriminates against the rural areas.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should keep to the section which deals with the number of Deputies.

Comment on this

We will have ample opportunity when dealing with the other sections, and in particular with the Schedule and the amendments we have tabled or others we may choose to bring forward on Report Stage, to register again our strongest protest against the deliberate gerrymandering and political manipulation being carried out by the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

The Deputy could cut a long playing record.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 69
·
Níl 63
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I understand we have agreement that sections 3, 4 and 5 be postponed.

Comment on this

We are agreeable to that. When is it proposed to take sections 3, 4 and 5?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Immediately after the Schedule is decided. Is that satisfactory?

SECTION 6.

Comment on this

This section is purely administrative. It is similar to the corresponding provision made in the 1969 and the earlier revisions of Constituencies Acts.

Under the revision some polling districts or parts of polling districts will be in a constituency different in area from the constituency in which they are situated at present. The names of electors in the register of electors are arranged under polling districts and the name of the constituency is shown in respect of each polling district. The register which will be in force following enactment of this Bill will have been prepared on the basis of the existing constituencies. It is essential that arrangements be made to have the name of the appropriate new constituency entered clearly for each such polling district or such part of a polling district affected in the register to be used at the general election first held following the enactment of the Bill.

It is not possible to specify at this stage which register will be affected or whether the direction will be given in respect of the draft or final register. This will depend on the date of dissolution of the Dáil following enactment of the Bill and the date of the subsequent general election. For this reason, subsection (1) proposes that the Minister may by direction provide for the entry of the name of the appropriate new constituency, in respect of each such polling district or part of a polling district, in every draft register, list of claimants, register of electors and list of corrections published before the dissolution of the Dáil following the passing of this Bill. It is intended that the Minister's direction would be issued on the dissolution of the Dáil and would specify precisely which draft or register et cetera should be amended.

Subsection (2) provides for the preparation of a new postal voters list or lists where a new constituency is not identical in area with the present constituency. Corresponding provision was made in the 1947, 1959, 1961 and 1969 Acts.

Comment on this

Did the Minister say that this direction would be issued at the dissolution of the Dáil? One could foresee a situation in which the Dáil would be dissolved on 16th April and the register that is prepared would come into operation on 15th April. In such circumstances it would be necessary for the Minister to issue such an instruction on the day of dissolution. If by some mischance a general election did not take place until, we will say, next September, would it not be prudent for the registration authorities, without having to wait on a direction from the Minister, to have this tidying up job done before the dissolution of the Dáil? Why would it be necessary for them to wait for a dissolution and await a direction from the Minister?

Comment on this

In the normal way it would be done, but it can be done up to the dissolution of the Dáil. This is the very same provision as was made in all previous constituency changes. There is no alteration whatever in the arrangements.

Comment on this

Having a section like this in the Bill and justifying it on the basis that it is a replica of similar sections in previous Bills does not appeal to me, quite frankly. Later on, on the Schedule we will be talking about the creation of new constituencies, of new locations. There is nothing in the Bill which provides that the Minister may by direction make an order to delineate the particular constituency. That is inbuilt in the Bill. Somewhere in the Schedule a line is drawn down through the middle of a street. Is that not a straightforward indication to the returning officer for the area that he is expected to make the proper arrangements for the publication of the draft register to suit that area without any direction from the Minister? I cannot see that there is any necessity for the Minister to make an order which is obviously directed at the returning officer or the registrar for the area telling him that he is to put the constituency of Kildare on a register already marked Kildare.

The Dublin constituencies have been so messed about that I can visualise many registers having to be prepared. The titles of all the Dublin constituencies will have to be changed. Does the passing of the Bill not automatically mean that the registrar has to prepare the registers for the new constituencies in each location?

Comment on this

On a point of order, I understand that it is the county secretary who prepares the registers, not the county registrars.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is a point of information, not a point of order.

Comment on this

The registrar deals with claims. That comes under this section as well.

Comment on this

The Deputy's intervention raises another interesting point. In section 6 I see no reference to whom the Minister is to give his direction. I thought it was the county registrar. Deputy Harte understands it is the county secretary. I wonder is it the returning officer in the Custom House a couple of corridors down the way.

Comment on this

This can become terribly complicated if we proceed on the wrong assumption. To clear up the point raised by Deputy Lalor it is the registration authority and that is the county council or the corporation as the case may be. The direction will be given to them. The reason the direction is given on the dissolution of the Dáil is that the existing registers must remain for by-elections. The work will be done on preparing the new registers immediately this Bill becomes an Act. Legally they cannot be changed until such time as the Dáil is dissolved. That is why it is stated in this way. It is quite a simple matter. I know it can appear to be confusing. No. 1, the reason it is not changed is that the old registers will be used for by-elections and No. 2, the new register can only be declared on the dissolution of the Dáil but the work will be started as soon as the Bill becomes law. Does that explain Deputy Lalor's question?

Comment on this

I read here:

... the Minister may by direction provide for the entry of the name of that constituency in respect of the polling district or part of the polling district, in every draft register, list of claimants, register of electors and list of corrections prepared under Part II of the Electoral Act, 1963, and published by a registration authority before the dissolution of Dáil Éireann which next occurs after the passing of this Act.

Does this mean that, following the passing of this Bill, Dublin Corporation will have the responsibility continuously of having two sets of registers in preparation, one in the event of a by-election and the other in the event of the Dáil dissolving?

Comment on this

That has always been the case. It is the existing law.

Comment on this

I have not had the experience. My constituency has never been changed. I have never heard any Deputy say that at the time of issuing an approved register he gets two copies, one covering, say, a section of Ballyfermot for a by-election and the other covering a section of Ballyfermot for a general election. Is the Minister saying there will be two registers issued?

Comment on this

There will be two names on the same page. It is not actually as Deputy Lalor suggests. The register of electors is drawn up and when this Bill becomes law it will be necessary for the registration authority, the local authority, to prepare the new arrangement. This preparation will be done by the local authority even before the direction is issued by the Minister but on the dissolution of the Dáil the Minister will issue the direction. Meantime, the local authority will prepare the register to cover both eventualities if the constituency is changed. This has been the position, I understand, since the passing of the 1947 Act.

Comment on this

An interesting point arises from the comments of Deputy Lalor. For the sake of argument we must assume that by some mischance the present Government stays in office for longer than most people expect, say, for another two years. The registration authority is obliged to publish a final register on 15th April each year. It has been customary for each sitting Member of the House to be circulated with a copy of that register each year, the up-to-date register for the constituency he represents. If a general election did not take place for two years from 20th April this year we would have a situation where the registration authority would forward a copy of a completed register to a Deputy which in the case of a general election would be absolutely no use to him. I do not know if this point was ever raised before but, unfortunately, when the Electoral (Amendment) Bill was before the House in 1969 the then Opposition allowed all of the sections in that Bill to pass without comment. There were no queries on the Bill up to section 7, which we come to next.

We should like clarification on this point from the Minister. Does he foresee that following the passing of a Bill similar to this the registration authorities will be issuing registers to Deputies for areas they will not be able to represent in the succeeding general election, if they stand? That seems rather anomalous. Could the Minister say if it is intended to distribute these registers which must cost the State and local authority quite an amount of money to circulate?

Comment on this

Deputy Molloy has made a very good point. It is something on which I am not too clear. Deputy Molloy says there was no debate on the last occasion when this type of Bill was passed but in the Official Report we see that sections 1 and 2 were passed without discussion. Sections 3, 4 and 5 were postponed and there was a discussion from then onwards. I understand it was accepted that this was how it was done. Deputy Molloy said the Opposition did not make this point. While it is being made now by the Opposition, in a sense it was the Government's job if there was something wrong to see that it was dealt with. My information is that—and this has been the case since 1947—when a constituency is changed the local authorities draw up two registers and publish the register with two headings. This has not happened in my constituency because I got the County Meath end of it, even though portion of it was in County Monaghan and portion in County Cavan. I also got the Kildare end of it when portion of Meath was in Kildare. It never struck me that there was any particular significance in the fact that it was marked "Kildare". The reason was that if a by-election occurred the old register would operate. That is what has been done and that procedure will be adopted in this case.

I have been making some inquiries about how the mechanics of it work. I am as anxious as anybody to ensure there is no unnecessary duplication. I am assured it is necessary and that although inquiries were made earlier it was not found possible to find a simpler way of doing this. I intend to pursue this matter and see if there is some simpler way. All I can say is that I shall have further inquiries made and ensure that there is no avoidable duplication. I understand we are following exactly the procedure which was followed up to now. It appears the previous Government found it was all right and there must not have been much wrong with it or somebody would have noticed it.

Comment on this

A general election took place very shortly after the passing of the previous Electoral Bill and this situation may not have arisen before. Perhaps a general election will come very soon after the passing of this Bill, if it is ever passed——

Comment on this

About four years.

Comment on this

——and that would mean that the problem we are discussing would never arise.

Comment on this

The Minister said that when this Bill was before the House previously section 6 which was dealing with a similar provision in the 1969 Electoral (Amendment) Bill was, in fact, discussed. I should like to read out what was stated at that time in connection with section 6. The question was proposed that section 6 stand part of the Bill. Deputy James Tully of the Labour Party asked if the Minister could do anything about this problem possibly in this Bill or if not in some future Bill, where there are polling districts crossing. "The result of these proposals before the House" he said "is that people living in certain areas could be voting several miles away in the heart of another constituency. This is a peculiar situation and has arisen because of the way in which the boundary map is drawn up. Could the Minister try to have constituencies or electoral areas straightened out in some way so that this will not keep on recurring." The Minister replied: "It is provided for in section 7."

In other words, the question put by Deputy Tully on section 6 should, in fact, have been asked on section 7 and really there was no question asked on section 6 when the Bill was before the House then. The Minister may have inadvertently misled the House on that matter. There never has been any proper discussion on section 6 and on what happens and on the matter of whether two registers will be published and circulated which could involve substantial waste of the taxpayers' money. I am satisfied that the Minister is not too clear on what the procedure is.

Comment on this

The very same situation has arisen now. Section 7 is the section on which we should be discussing this.

Comment on this

Section 7 is the section where reference is made to polling booths. Section 6 deals with the register of electors. The Minister's question about areas crossing dealt with polling booths. So, they did not discuss the question of the register of electors and its publication and the position arising following the passing of such a Bill and also the position arising in the interim period between the passing of the Bill and the holding of the next general election and the obligation of the registering authority to forward copies of the completed register to each sitting Member in his constituency, to give him a register of the total number of persons entitled to vote in that constituency. It will, of course, be pointless because that constituency, in the case of quite a number as proposed by the Minister, and even as proposed by us in our amendments, would not exist after the passing of this Bill and the dissolution of the House. I am satisfied that the Minister is not clear how this will operate. He is not clear whether money will be wasted in distributing such registers to Deputies who will have no interest in them and he cannot clarify the point we raised. We could come back again on Report Stage and the Minister might at that stage be able to inform us exactly what the arrangements will be, how this problem will be dealt with and he may be able to give us an assurance that there will not be any undue wasting of the ratepayers' money.

Comment on this

The only mistake I seem to have made so far is that I have taken a section of the Bill out of a previous Act. I suppose I should have more sense and found out if what Fianna Fáil have been doing over the years was right or wrong. Deputy Molloy seems to be casting very grave doubts on what was done by the Fianna Fáil Government over the years and he has made me believe there must be something wrong with it, although I am not quite convinced.

He referred to sections 6 and 7. In fact, the former Deputy Boland, the then Minister for Local Government, referred to the fact that it was section 7 that dealt with it. We are not talking about the same thing. We are talking about a polling district split up and we are talking about the question of the register of electors. The whole point in talking about the register of electors is because the names of the people on that register of electors are in a split polling district. There is no point in talking about one unless we are prepared to relate it to the other. The former Deputy Boland whom many people considered to be an unreasonable man pointed out that it could be discussed under section 7 and I, being a reasonable man, agreed to that and we discussed it under section 7.

Apparently that does not hold any longer. As a matter of fact, one of the comments of the then Deputy Boland was that it was handed down over the years. I used almost the same expression earlier when I said that it was the way in which it was being done. He also said his carving was done to suit the Constitution. I quite agree with Deputy Molloy that, as it stands, it could appear that maybe there is too much printing being done and, perhaps, there is an easier way to do it. The best thing I can do is to have another look at this, see if it can be dealt with in another way and have an amendment on the Report Stage if this is necessary. It appeared down the years that it was not considered necessary but I am always open to suggestions if they are good ones.

Comment on this

I am grateful to the Minister for agreeing to come back and give us a full explanation of the exact procedure to be followed when we come to Report Stage. However, I would like to take him up on one point where he stated that because a similar clause was contained in the 1969 Act it should be good enough for Fianna Fáil today. We do not accept that argument. If the Opposition at that time did not decide that it was necessary to query these things and to establish what the facts were, then on their heads be it but we are not satisfied in Opposition that just because some similar section appeared in some Bill while we were in office we will not query it, that we will not see if it can be improved.

We believe in progressive legislation, in improving the system in this country and in making a positive and worthwhile contribution to the debates here. If we find that some measure that we brought before this House in the past comes before us again by way of a section in a Bill we will not concede our right to see if that can be improved. It is a nebulous argument on the Minister's part. I draw attention to it because it is about the fifth time he has used it. He seems to be satisfied that if we accepted it four or five years ago in a previous Bill it must be all right. It is a great compliment to the Fianna Fáil Government at that time that the Minister should think in this way and should put that forward as his only argument in favour of retaining such a section.

I would like to make it quite clear to the Minister that as long as we are in Opposition we will examine every single line of every Bill that comes before this House. If we can find ways of improving them we will do so. We appreciate that the Minister has already recognised that we have been able to make a valuable contribution to Bills already. He has accepted some of our proposals and the Bills have been substantially improved because of that. We would like to see that continuing and we would like to give the assurance to the Minister that quoting that argument again will hold no water with us.

Comment on this

The only thing I would like to say about this particular Bill is that Deputy Molloy seems to consider that he, in Opposition, is entitled to query things—rightly so— which neither he nor any member of his Government were prepared to do when in office. It appears that this is the fifth or sixth time, or maybe more, in which Deputy Molloy particularly has been prepared to throw overboard everything that Fianna Fáil did. It explains to me a lot of things because, unfortunately, I was under the impression that a Government who were in office for a good while would at least know the whole position. However, it appears to me that they did not bother to query anything at all. As long as they were in office it was all right. Deputy Molloy is saying that while that might be all right while they were on this side of the House when they are in Opposition it is an entirely different matter and they are then able to look for the mistakes they made.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. R.P. Burke Fianna Fáil

The Minister is in Government and not in Opposition.

Comment on this

I was pretty good at it over there. The man who was in my position at that time was not prepared to do what I am doing now.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. R.P. Burke Fianna Fáil

At least he used to give an explanation.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister without interruption.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will look at the debates he will find that I did query this particular matter.

Comment on this

Not about the publication of the register.

Comment on this

I queried whether or not the crossing of polling stations could be dealt with. The whole point in talking about the splitting of polling stations was that they would appear on different registers.

Comment on this

That would be a very expensive way.

Comment on this

Of course, but apparently Fianna Fáil did not mind what expense there was as long as they were in power. No expense mattered as long as they were over here.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The Minister should thank Deputy Molloy for bringing this to his notice.

Comment on this

We will make sure the Minister does his job.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister without interruption.

Comment on this

Let me point out for about the sixth time to Deputy Molloy that not alone will I do my job but where he failed to do his job—I have a lot of things to do which he did not do—while he was over here I will do it. He would probably still be over here if he was a little more meticulous. He is pretty good in Opposition. It is rather a pity he was not as good when he was over here.

As far as this matter is concerned it appears that the proposal I am introducing, is a repetition of five different Fianna Fáil Bills which were passed in this House silently. If it is possible to improve it I will do so. Maybe Fianna Fáil are right and it is not possible to do so. Perhaps this is the best way it could be done. I will have a look at it.

Comment on this

We will wait until Report Stage.

Comment on this

The difference between Deputy Molloy and me is that when I say I am going to look at something and do something I look at it and I do something. I do not come in afterwards and say that I did this or I did that when I have forgotten all about it.

Comment on this

I do not want to start talking about building societies. The Deputies will be talking about them in the morning.

Comment on this