Control of Importation, Sale and Manufacture of Contraceptives Bill, 1974: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–104 of 240. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 1974 ›
One of the arguments put forward for the implementation of the Bill is the fact that we have so many ills in our society that it would be a panacea for all these ills. We have at present a rash of people who go into various parts of the city, and particularly where the lower-paid workers live, and come back with horrifying tales of what they saw there. They then use this as an argument for supporting this measure. I want to point out that in the areas where lower-paid workers live, you may certainly have more children, but you have much less emotional disturbance, a much happier community and therefore the argument used by these people who have appointed themselves to work for this legislation does not hold water. Having said that and being aware of all the injustices in our society and the handicaps of young married people, I do not want to suggest that they are not suffering in lots of ways, but it is our duty to try to remove these injustices by a proper code of development to ensure that every young couple will be properly housed and have such means as will ensure a good standard of living.
On the other hand, it is always hinted that the manufacturers of these articles are some benevolent society whose only aim in life is to ensure that these are made available freely and cheaply. We have to face the fact that the name of the manufacturers game is profit. The people peddling these things at the moment, the vast majority of them, are doing it for profit and the advertising in some of the glossy magazines, which is contrary to the law and about which the Government have done nothing, is also being done for profit. Let us get away from the idea that there is any benign design behind the campaign to have these made freely available, from the manufacturers' point of view. I emphasise that I am referring to manufacturers with their outlook of the profit motive.
We have to recognise this fact and the fact that in our society there are many injustices. We have also to recognise that it is being suggested that young married couples and unmarried people also in the use of these devices will find a kind of panacea or solace for all their troubles. The atmosphere has been created in the past three or four years. The decision of the Supreme Court brought the matter to a head. In fairness to the Government, they did have to make some move, the Supreme Court having ruled in the McGee case, towards making certain changes and they introduced this Bill. The people who examined it, even its technicalities, tell us that it is imperfect and will not serve any useful purpose whatever, but what we have to examine is what legislation would bring about such a situation as would go towards making a different society. In my view, this Bill will make no contribution whatever towards achieving the common good. Therefore, it must be rejected by us because it is the job of legislators everywhere in the world to ensure the happiness of their people. They must ensure that every act must lead towards a better society.
If we look at other countries we will see that though they may have progressed as regards transport, housing and general wealth, the sum of their happiness has not been increased. Therefore, we must look further afield if we are to find a solution to the problems which this Bill is supposed to remedy. It has been suggested that unless this Bill is enacted and there is general availability of contraceptives here, our population problem will become frightful and that there will not be sufficient space to live in. This was said many years ago by Malthus. Few people listened to him. Of course, the population has increased since then to a great degree but there are still many uninhabited parts of the world. As well, the techniques of producing more food are being perfected all the time. So the Malthusian argument will not stand examination.
It has also been claimed that this Bill is affording civil rights, but even humanists would question this because nobody has the right to do something or to propagate a cause which might eventually bring unhappiness. I know it is held sincerely by many people in this country that they have a right to use contraceptives. I recognise their right to think in that way but how often do we hear things which are not right, and is it not just as well at times that we are restrained by the laws of the country? I have often had beliefs on different subjects which I felt were for the good of society but as one becomes a little more experienced one sees that these beliefs do not stand up to examination.
It has been suggested that a referendum should be held on this question. One has noticed the great number of opinion polls that have been held, some of which, to my mind, were suspect. I have not sought to hold an opinion poll but I have kept every letter and message I got for and against this legislation. I represent a sophisticated, cosmopolitan area, Dublin South-East, which has a large section of the affluent society and a large section of not so affluent people. Of the letters and messages I got, 160 were against and five were for this legislation. I have the file upstairs and if I can be guaranteed anonymity anybody can see that file.
I am highly suspicious of the manufacturers outside this country who are propagating the need for contraception and of any advertisements I see. Believing as I do that this Bill will not contribute to the common good, and because it is, as members on the Government side have said, a faulty Bill which is not workable, I must give due notice that I will vote against it.
Comment on this
I will only say of Deputy Moore's speech that I share his admirable desire to extend the sum of human happiness. I only regret that his party having spent almost 42 years unbrokenly in power did not succeed in doing so. Unlike Deputy Flanagan, I have not been 32 years in this House—I have only been five years here—but I agree this is a vital debate, so vital that I returned from Strasbourg for the special purpose of speaking in it. I can only say of the two speakers who preceded Deputy Moore—the short and explosive speech of Deputy Kitt and the long and explosive speech of Deputy Flanagan— that they filled me with a mounting sadness about the manner in which this debate was being conducted. I felt somehow that time had stood still in Ireland.
I will make only one point on Deputy Kitt's speech. I, too, was brought up on the speech he referred to when he invoked the former President as a reason for voting against this Bill—a form of logic which rather escaped me. I can almost recite that speech by heart about strapping youths and comely maidens living in frugality. Once upon a time I actually believed this until I found that under the regime of Fianna Fáil the strapping youths wound up digging the roads for the English and drowning their sorrows in Finchley Road.
As to the speech of Deputy Flanagan, I should like to make two points, one very simple and the other more complex. The simple one is that he made reference to the intake in mental hospitals in this country being very high. Anyone who knows anything about socio-medical practice knows that the statistics for intake in mental hospitals in this country are distorted by the fact that we do not have adequate home geriatric treatment and we have to put our old people into mental homes.
The other point is more complex. I do not want to criticise Deputy Flanagan who I assume spoke sincerely, but the constant linking of abortion and contraception by him is something which I found rather revolting. Speaking as a Catholic, no matter what the Bishops may have said, I see no connection between the two concepts. There are absolutely no circumstances in which I would vote for abortion. I regard it as murder and I consider it completely unrelated to this Bill. Indeed, a section of this Bill prohibits the importation of abortifacients which gives some indication of the Minister's intentions in this respect. They are the same as mine.
I should like to say with reference to Deputy Flanagan's speech that since I totally disagree with everything he said, I hope that if I can assume his sincerity he will do the same for me as a Catholic with two children. By way of preliminary. I shall make a couple of other brief points. If at times I appear to be flippant in this debate I hope, Sir, you will not take exception to it— my flippancy does not derive from the position that I do not regard this subject as serious but rather from a feeling, as I listened to some of the speeches in this debate, which is best reflected in a line from one of Byron's more famous poems:
And if I laugh at any mortal thing
'Tis that I may not weep.
Also I apologise to you if I introduce an element of realism into this debate by occasionally referring to rather unpleasant specific and anatomical details, although Deputy Flanagan was not exactly reticent in doing precisely the same thing.
I think this debate and all debates on this subject are surrounded by an element of hypocrisy, which I find distasteful. Everybody knows, of course, that contraceptives have been available for years in this country particularly to the affluent middle classes. Anybody who could afford the price of a return ticket to London, or who had a friend in England, was easily able to import these things. We are putting our collective national fingers in our collective national eyes when we pretend anything else.
Sometimes, listening with sadness to Deputy Flanagan, I felt there was no point in speaking in this debate at all, that everything that needs to be said about it has been said. It has been said in particular by two people, one a gentleman with whom I do not normally get on very well, "Back-bencher" in The Irish Times who, in his articles swiftly and brilliantly destroys the framework of hypocrisy which surrounds this controversy and the other, my good friend, Dr. Patrick Leahy of Ballyfermot in a letter to The Irish Times for which he was disgracefully criticised, in my view, by Deputy Lemass. I should like to add in this slightly cynical vein that as a European Parliamentarian and also as someone who is something of a linguist I can tell the House to rest assured that the protraction of this discussion over the last few years in Ireland has rendered us the laughing-stock of western Europe.
Deputy Moore and others referred to receiving letters from large numbers of people telling us not to vote for this Bill. I received those letters also; they were quite blatantly and patently part of an organised campaign, all verbally almost identical. In some cases they were even photocopies. Some of the admirable gentlemen or ladies who sent these letters descended to what I regard as the slightly unChristian omission of not stamping them so that in order to find out about them not wanting us to vote for the Bill one has to pay a surcharge to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. This is slightly unfair. All these letters began with the proposition that they had voted for me in the last election, a proposition which I found implausible in my case since my views on contraception are pretty well notorious, and went on to say: "You have no mandate to vote for this Bill, so do not vote for it." I am happy to tell the authors of these millions of letters that at the next general election they can have the pleasure of not voting for me because I intend to vote for this Bill.
With due respect to Deputy Flanagan who said that no matter what damage was done to his electoral chances by his voting against this Bill he intended to do so, let me suggest that, particularly in the case of rural Deputies, they are far more likely to do themselves electoral damage by voting for the Bill than by voting against it.
Since I take such a depressed and slightly cynical view of this Bill and this controversy or non-controversy, it may well be asked: why do I bother to speak on it at all. The answer is a slightly conceited one: I shall not allow myself to go into the record as having voted for what I regard as an insufficiently liberal Bill without having explained the reasons while I shall take an apparently logically contradictory attitude. I confess that the Fianna Fáil speakers who have called this a badly drafted Bill have a point. I can see Deputy Andrews, a lawyer, waiting to get in and I am sure he will say that this is a badly drafted Bill. I am inclined to agree with this. I confess a little disappointment with my colleague the Minister for Justice in his drafting of this Bill particularly since I played a humble role in elevating him to the office he now holds by, as Labour's director of elections, transferring the Labour second preferences in Longford-Westmeath ruthlessly to him in the 1970 by-election, a process for which I was duly censured by my own Labour organisation. That was, of course, in the halcyon days of "going-it-alone", before the Labour Party leaders put wet towels around their heads and by the application of simple logic and mathematics arrived at the startling conclusion, only equalled by that vouchsafed to St. Paul on the road to Damascus, that under PR you could not turn 18 seats into 72 in one election.
May I now make a few criticisms of the Bill for which I intend to vote? The Bill defines a contraceptive as "any appliance, instrument, drug, preparation or thing designed, prepared or intended to prevent pregnancy..." As Dr. Leahy pointed out—what is a "thing"? Could I draw the attention of the House at the risk of embarrassing it mortally to some of the facts of life? Suppose, as Dr. Leahy pointed out, a young lady having failed to menstruate decided to terminate a suspected pregnancy by the time-honoured method immortalised in literature by Alan Sillitoe in the novel Saturday Night and Sunday Morning, to wit, taking a steaming hot bath and consuming a bottle of gin. Does that constitute a bottle of gin a “thing”? If an unmarried girl goes to a supermarket and seeks to purchase a bottle of gin, is she to be eyed suspiciously by her neighbours who may wonder whether she is buying the bottle of gin for the laudable and time-honoured purpose of becoming inebriated or whether she intends to use it as a “thing” to procure the termination of pregnancy?
May I also draw some further facts of life to the attention of the House and particularly to Deputy Flanagan who appears to think that in this island, which Karl Marx once called this sacra insula, sin, fornication, abortion, contraception and things like that never happened until recently? As Dr. Leahy also pointed out, many an Irish unwanted pregnancy, and the life of many an Irish mother, has been terminated by the use of a knitting needle. Does that constitute a knitting needle “a thing”? If an unmarried mother goes into Woolworths to buy a pair of knitting needles, is she to be asked whether she intends to knit with them or to use them in a manner defined as illegal under this Bill?
There are sections of the Bill that I must in all conscience criticise even though I shall vote for it. Section 1 (2) for example says:
For the purposes of this Act a person who has no living spouse shall be taken to be unmarried.
So, the young woman married at 20 and widowed at 25, who purchases things between the age of 20 and 25 is acting perfectly legally but at the age of 25 such purchases ceases to be legal and become illegal. This is a concept which I find it rather difficult to comprehend in terms of abstract logic. I also have a criticism of this Bill which is at the same time a criticism of the Fianna Fáil Party for their persistence in opposition to it. If the Minister feels I am criticising him it is because this controversy has placed him in an utterly impossible position and the compromise he has endeavoured to produce is probably as good as he could produce in the circumstances. I hope he will accept my criticism in that spirit and that it can be seen in that light.
In a sense, this Bill can be seen as a class Bill—that is one of my objections to it. Because of its very complexity the people most likely to avail of it, if enacted, are precisely the people who are least in need of it because they are already provided for.
Let us again cut through some of the hypocrisy which has surrounded this discussion—and I do not mean that to apply only today but to the discussion over the past ten years. Everybody knows that anyone who belongs to the class of myself or anybody else in the House can contact a sympathetic Dominican who will tell him or her that Humanae Vitae can be liberally interpreted—pace, Deputy Flanagan, I have read Humanae Vitae—and that, therefore, the use of the pill is all right. Anybody who belongs to the affluent middle classes can find a sympathetic doctor who will indulge in the fiction that the pill is a menstrual regulator and not a contraceptive with the result that the middle classes can live happily ever after.
Deputy Moore spoke as if he was oblivious of the fact of a housing shortage in Dublin. I want to make a couple of points which are directly related to the class nature of our present contraceptive system which would not be ended in my view adequately by the passage of this Bill. As I said, I have not been 32 years in this House but in the five I have been here I have experienced a pattern which is very common in a working class area which principally concerns me. The young pair get married: everything is blissful. They move into the front room of a small house in the working class area. They have a child. They go to the corporation requesting that they be given a house but they are told that this is not possible since they have only one child. The principle of the corporation in this context seems to be the ancient injuction to increase and multiply. So the couple go back and have a second child. Then, they go again to the corporation or they come to me or to Deputy Moore or to some other Deputy and, consequently, we write letters to the housing manager of the corporation but we are informed that Mrs. X has only two children and so her name is down on the waiting list but that she will be notified when her turn is reached and that there are many cases worse than hers. The family return to living in their in-laws front room.
The in-laws are sick at the sight of them. The husband is sick at the sight of the wife and she is sick at the sight of the husband. The husband is on the booze while the wife is on librium and valium in vast quantities and the ultimate conclusion of this cycle, which is far more common than most Deputies will have the honesty to admit, is that the husband perpetrates what Dr. Noel Browne has described as the Irish form of divorce. There is no legal divorce here but there is a form of divorce in that a husband simply buys a one-way ticket to London or some other place where he disappears into a limbo from which he is not rescued. Luckily, progressive legislation in respect of deserted wives has brought this hideous problem to light in recent years. If I may, I shall borrow an expression used by Deputy O'Connell at the last Labour Party conference when he said that in the case of housing applicants he never knows whether it is best to prescribe the contraceptive pill so that the couple might be happier or to prescribe the fertility pill so that they might qualify for a house. Any Dublin Deputy who is not aware of that situation is talking through his hat.
The Bill makes reference in section 1 to authorised persons. I should like to refer here to statements made by Deputies O'Kennedy and Flanagan which I found profoundly distasteful. If this Bill is passed, which I hope it will be, will the millions of people who have been writing to Deputy Moore or to myself or to any other Deputy on this subject desist from their efforts? I do not think so. This Bill places chemists in a most unpleasant position. Deputy O'Kennedy suggested that the issue should be left to medical prescriptions but that would place doctors in an equally embarrassing position.
Deputy O'Kennedy referred to good, sound commercial practice perhaps dictating that a chemist would not apply to become a legitimate conveyor of "things". That reminds me of the nice ladies in the League of Decency and in the Family Protection Association going along to the chemist in, let us say, Ballygobackwards, that village immortalised by the late Jimmy O'Dea and saying: "I trust we can rely on you not to buy ‘things' because if you import things we will take our business in cosmetics and toothpaste ten miles down the road to somebody else because, great though that sacrifice will be, no sacrifice is too great to keep Ireland in a chaste and holy situation"—that situation in which Deputy Kitt thinks it continues to be.
Furthermore, I can envisage the local chemist playing 18 holes of golf on a Sunday afternoon and the local parish priest saying to him: "I know you are a good Catholic. I trust we can rely on you not to pollute our community with ‘things'." I can see the chemist succumbing to these pressures. This takes me back to my class point. If one lives as I live—in relative affluence in Ballsbridge or Sandymount one can get hold of "things" just as at the moment one can get hold of pills but what about the people who really need these things, those people who are living in overcrowded circumstances? What about the people who are not dependent on my intellectual confessor who tells me that I am so valuable to the community that I can do almost anything that remains within the purview of the Catholic Church? What about the people who are dependent totally on the tender mercies of less liberal and older doctors and priests?
One of the weaknesses of the Bill is in section 5 which provides for the restriction of sale of contraceptives to married people. That is not necessarily wrong but I would like to ask how it is to be enforced. My criticisms need not be taken as too stringent but if Fianna Fáil had the courage and honesty to allow the measure go to Committee there are details of the kind I have been discussing which could at that stage be tidied up by the introduction of amendments. I am sure that I speak for all of us over here when I say that we would be delighted to give every co-operation to the people opposite if they were prepared to do as I suggest.
Let me get back to the question as to how the restriction on the sale of contraceptives to married people would be enforced. If, say, I had a young brother who was not married and this young brother was fornicating—to use a term employed by Deputy O'Malley with that wonderful Old Testament ring which he gave to the debate—I can assure Deputy Flanagan and also the Hierarchy and the plain people of Ireland that the first thing I would do would be to try to dissuade my younger brother from fornicating with his girl friend but if he had lost his religion or had become converted to, say, Judaism or Protestantism I would say to him to take precautions because it would be highly unfair to impregnate a single girl and consequently, to expose her to the consequences either of the production of an illegitimate child or to the horrific consequences, which are mentally unending, of an abortion.
So, I go to the chemist and I buy my things—in fact, I do not buy things, but that is my business and nobody else's—and my mythical young brother buys his things. We are known to everybody in Sandymount so when we emerge from the chemist's shop the people say of me: "He is a public sinner, you know." They look at me with scorn and the worst thing they could do to me would be to write to the Administrator at St. Andrew's Church, Westland Row, and propose that no longer should I be allowed sing in the choir. However, they take me away from my younger brother and they rush him down to the corner where there is standing the local garda, with thumbs in his pockets, like Jack Cruise in pantomime, wondering quietly whether he should move in and enforce "holy hour" in the local pub. The people say to the garda: "Arrest that young man: he is carrying ‘things' which he has purchased and to which he is not entitled."
As a second proposition, suppose, because I feel so strongly about the horrors of impregnating unmarried women, that I swallow my principles and buy things and give them to my young brother, what would be the position? My young brother might say: "I appreciate, David, what you are doing but you are putting yourself to untold expense and, therefore, I must pay you for these ‘things'." At this point I become an unlawful purveyor of things and, either I am fined £100 or am sent to jail for six months for my crime while my young brother is also fined £100.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I appear to be funny in dealing with this matter. But I am not being funny because the subject is a very serious one. All I can say is that this Bill will provide the gardaí with a very interesting time. Already they are busy dealing with the problems of arson, theft, vandalism and wandering horses. The Bill, too, would provide the legal profession with a varied and interesting addition to their already substantial income.
Having said all that let me say now why I defend the Bill. I shall attempt to do this as tactfully and as politely as I can but I must say that the Fianna Fáil legalistic arguments against this Bill, strong as they may seem, are not put forward sincerely. The spectacle of a man of Deputy O'Malley's age thundering about fornication, like an Old Testament prophet, from the benches of this House, reduces me to a state where I do not know whether to laugh or cry. It reminds me of the equally nauseous spectacle which I had to endure about three years ago in this House when ex-Deputy Lenihan threw out the Browne-O'Connell Bill on contraception thereby earning himself the prestigious reward of a handshake from Deputy Flanagan.
What is wrong with this proposal? No one is being forced to use "things". These things are simply being made available for those whose consciences entitle them to use them. Am I to say I am my brother's keeper as Deputy Flanagan says to the extent that even if my brother is a Protestant or a Jew, does not share my religious belief, I have got the right to say to him he cannot have these things?
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has been derided for bringing the issue of Northern Ireland into this debate. Nobody suggests that the importation of contraceptives is ultimately and determinately fundamental to the partition issue. Nobody suggests that the ordinary Northern Protestant is some sort of raving sex maniac who will join up with the Republic of Ireland if he can have contraceptives available but not otherwise. Nobody suggests anything of the kind. But, there is a principle involved here. Articles 2 and 3 of the Constitution speak of this as one nation. If it is one nation it contains at least 25 per cent of the population—at least 25 per cent— whose consciences, unlike Deputy Flanagan's—I suppose he would regard them as uninformed consciences as they are Protestant consciences and not Catholic consciences—enable them to have contraceptives. Am I to say to that 25 per cent that they cannot have contraceptives? I admit as some speakers say, that it is not fundamental but there is a principle at stake here. Are the proponents, like Deputy Flanagan, on the retaining of Ireland as Catholic and subject to the teachings of the Pope, using a sort of paraphrase of Pádraig Pearse's fammatel ous remark, and I yield to no one in my admiration of Pádraig Pearse? What was it he said? —Ireland not free merely but Gaelic also. Are the Fianna Fáil Party saying, Ireland not free merely but Catholic also? Is this the message of peace we are taking to our friends in the North? It is absolutely farcical.
I once had the experience of being very close to and friendly with a distinguished Protestant rector who went on to become very high in his Church who believed that his young parishioners were entitled to instruction in the use of contraceptives and used regularly to have to go to England and, like a thief in the night, smuggle them in. Is this the way to treat the 5 per cent of our minority in the South and the potential 25 per cent of our minority when we have reunited the country as the Fianna Fáil Party are so adamantly determined to do?
Deputy Flanagan made a reference to the fact that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs—he said something patronisingly like "an admirable and gifted man in every other respect"— had not enjoyed the benefits of a Catholic primary education. This is the kind of remark which induces nausea in me and it compels me to indulge in a little sort of breast beating because while it may be true of the Minister for Post and Telegraphs that he did not have a Catholic upbringing, in my case, while I did not have a primary Catholic upbringing, later in life I did become probably the only convert in the House. I am not giving that lecture so as to beat my breast because I dislike breast beating but I think my Catholicity is pretty well known. In fact, it caused me to be insulted at a Labour Party conference on one occasion.
Deputy Flanagan invoked the name of the Pope a great deal. May I say that I had the privilege of an audience with the Pope the other day? I did not bring this issue up at the time. Also, I have read my encyclicals. I have read my Humanae Vitae, Populorum Progressio, Mater et Magistra, Rerum Novarum, Quadragessimo Anno and Mit brennender Sorge, one of the less attractive encyclicals. I have also read the Bull of Hadrian which brought the English in here in 1169. I cannot quite see how this is particularly relevant to the way in which we should treat those whose religious beliefs are different from our own.
If Deputy Flanagan wishes further instruction in encyclicals I can come to his help because I have copies of every encyclical of Pope Paul, Pope John, Pius IX, Leo XIII, Pius XII, Pius XI and I have selected editions of every previous encyclical from the beginning of the time when encylicals were issued. I can give these to Deputy Flanagan if he wants to improve his Catholicity still further.
As I have said, the North is not the issue really, although it is terribly relevant. To me as a Catholic the point of view is whether the Catholic Church is a voluntary organisation of which one may or may not be a member and the State is something different or whether the two are coterminous.
Comment on this
We are discussing a very important principle which affects our relations with the North. I think I am entitled to develop it very briefly. Deputy Flanagan was permitted to speak for three hours on almost nothing else but Catholic teaching. It may interest Deputy Flanagan and others to know that the Church has abandoned the thesis antithesis concept, as it used to be called, and has moved over, under the influence of great theologians like the late Courtney Murray and our own Enda McDonagh, to the belief that the two are separate entities. While I accept the right of the Pope to tell me what to do as a Catholic, I do not accept the right of the Pope to tell somebody who does not believe in the Pope what he should do. This is very good straightforward Catholic teaching to be found in Courtney Murray. I found all this out, by the way, it might interest Deputy Flanagan to know, in a period when I was lecturing in Catholic social teaching in St. Patrick's College, Maynooth as a substitute for the then Monsignor Jeremiah Newman, then President of the college, who has since been elevated to the Hierarchy. So my credentials here are impeccable.
I would appeal to the Fianna Fáil Party not to treat this matter as one of purely politics. I would appeal to them to recognise—and I know this is a high-sounding cliché—that the eyes of (a) the North and (b) the world are on us when we consider this issue today. If the Fianna Fáil Party had come up with a single constructive amendment to this Bill or were prepared to permit it to go to Committee Stage as it stands and bring up amendments to it then, I could understand their attitude but as far as I am concerned they are treating one of the most fundamental areas of private human conscience that it is possible to consider simply as a political football in the hope of embarrassing this side of the House. This is behaviour which is not worthy of them, particularly the younger members of their party. I respect the feelings of older people, just as I would allow a free vote on this Bill. I respect the feelings of those who disagree with me on this though I know and we all know that there are men on the Fianna Fáil side of the House, particularly, as I say, the younger men, who in their heart of hearts believe that the importation of contraceptives is a perfectly legitimate natural right for those who do not share the acceptance of the teaching of Humanae Vitae. As I say, the eyes of the world and the eyes of the North are upon us in this.
I want to conclude by saying this: I very seldom agree with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs on anything. I am, therefore, in a very particularly strong position to say what I am now going to say, a very strong position because my respectability as a Catholic has never been called in question, and a very strong position because my arguments with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs over the issue of republicanism are also notorious, and it is notorious that we disagree profoundly on that issue. In many ways I am closer to the people on the Fianna Fáil side of the House than I am to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs on the issue of republicanism. So I say, with all the force at my disposal: if this House renders itself ludicrous by throwing out this Bill I will not be able to find an argument which will enable me to differ from the view of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that Articles 2 and 3 of the Constitution should be repealed and the reality of the position accepted.
Deputy Dr. Gibbons rose.
Comment on this
For the benefit of those who may go to the trouble of reading it must be stated again that due to the decision of the Supreme Court contraceptives are freely available to married people in this country if they wish to import them. This Bill proposes to limit the importation of those to a certain extent by establishing distribution points and by emphasing that they will only be available to married people.
On the question of distribution, a number of ways were open to the Minister to do this. The Minister has chosen the chemist shop and no doubt this is one that offered itself to him being the vehicle for the distribution of medicines throughout the community. It would strike one that if this Bill is passed the nice man in the paint shop will have arrived in the town and he will have to look to his laurels. However, I do not think this is the best way. It was suggested that this could be done by the health boards. It was also suggested that it could be done by the family planning units or organisations.
The Bill suggests that under certain circumstances it can be done by people other than chemists or directly through the Minister's office. Of all those the one that appeals most to me is distribution through the health boards, and that they form family planning units for this purpose. It may be said that we have family planning units at present but, as far as I am concerned, those people have opted out. They are only using the name family planning to distribute contraceptives amongst unmarried people. In this way they have done a grave disservice to married people who wish this service. They have antagonised some people who would be anxious to help those married people.
Distribution through health boards would mean that they would only be available to married people. When we think of family planning in the context of this Bill we seem to be thinking only of artificial contraception but if the health boards established family planning units they would make natural methods of family planning available to the people who would approach them. In this way they would be satisfying everybody, whatever his outlook on this matter is.
The fact that the Bill has limited its benefits, such as they are, to married people is the nub of this legislation. This is where the searchings of conscience are arising. Anybody who, like me, happens to be a family doctor in a rural area cannot escape the fact that family planning is essential for a number of families. On my experience I would be prepared to place this as one in six. They require this for various reasons. To classify those, there are the persons who, for purely social reasons, wish to plan their family by virtue of the fact that their family, if it enlarges, will place certain restrictions on them and they will have to stay at home if they cannot get a baby sitter. Therefore, it is irksome for them to have more children. To my mind this is not a medical problem and, as such, should not be handed over to the doctor. This is probably more in line for social workers.
There are also families who, for financial reasons, may wish to plan their families or those who for illness may wish to do so. There are also families who, through lack of accommodation, may wish to plan their families. In my view all those should get some consideration and the people to give them this consideration are those on the health boards. The fact that they need this consideration does not, of itself, mean that this help should be confined solely to artificial methods of family planning.
On this matter one wonders how much at fault we have been, the Department of Health, the doctors and the various people concerned with the medical services, in not making those benefits available to people on a wider scale. Perhaps we were afraid to do so in the past and the fact that this debate has taken place may be a good thing because it will act as a contribution in urging health boards to do this.
It is the unmarried people who are creating most difficulty. Some people have stated in the House that this Bill is illiberal, is not acceptable, or a complete answer to the problem unless those devices are made available to those people. I do not go along with this and that is one of the reasons why I am voting against the Bill. I believe that the suggested method of distribution will give rise exactly to the situation envisaged by the previous speaker: that those "things" will become easily available to unmarried people.
It has been stated that contraception will lead to increased permissiveness and all that goes with it. This is a very wide and difficult field to discuss and debate. There is no doubt whatsoever but that permissiveness has been increasing. The figures for illegitimate births, abortions and early marriages that have had first births inside the nine months, all point to the fact that there is increased permissiveness in the country. It is arguable and has been argued, whether this is due to increased contraception or not. I believe it is. There is an old phrase which says that a taste of the grass makes a rogue of the cow and with sex experience, being such as it is, having being experienced once, the tendency is to wish to experience more of it, particularly where there is no fear attached. The big fear that was attached to it in the past was the fear of being found out due to the fact that the female party became pregnant.
It is my view that when this fear is removed there will be continued and increased permissiveness and all the difficulties that go with it. I have no doubt that it must be creating an increase in the incidence of venereal disease. I have no doubt that there has been an increase in the number of illegitimate children born. The number of abortions, in spite of the fact that those contraceptives are available in other countries, has increased. This has been investigated and reasons have been advanced for this situation. The latest that has come to my notice, and something which is more or less new to me in the context in which it was presented, was contained in the correspondence column of The Lancet of 6th July, 1974. A worthy contributor pointed out that already there is appearing an increase in cancer of the neck of the womb. This he attributes to sexual relations at an early age. He seems to be on such firm ground that he argues that it is not the number of acts that have taken place or the number of partners: at this point in time he is offering the opinion that it is due to early intercourse. We as a Government and State have been trying to eradicate disease and there is something contradictory in turning round to provide conditions for the increase in disease. There is an obligation on us to try to reduce disease and the State has gone out of its way to reduce it by various vaccinations, anti-natal services and preventive services that are in existence throughout the country. Like all things the State proposes to do it will not be able to do this as well as it would like and this brings me back to the health board and the family planning clinic because, as a number of Deputies must be aware the health boards use clinics for the prevention of cancer of the womb already. They carry out what is popularly called the smear test. To my mind those two clinics could be linked together. That would have the advantage that the person attending would not be labelled as going for contraceptives. In fact she might be going for the smear test. This letter in The Lancet to which I refer points out that now there must be renewed thinking about the use of the smear test. In the past it was suggested that those over 35 were the people the medical profession should recommend to have the smear test done but this correspondent suggests that it is the under 35 group who now must have it done and that is the group to watch particularly. If this is eventually proven to be true it will be a sad comment on the type of society we are trying to develop.
At times listening to this debate it struck me that we are a very presumptuous lot. I suppose we are. The mere fact that we offered ourselves for election and presumed the people would elect us indicates that. However, I say this in another context now. We are trying here to control what is probably the strongest instinct in man, probably the one that gives most pleasure, the one that is absolutely essential for the survival of mankind. We are trying to control this when we have failed to control the other instincts and inclinations of man—our selfishness, our progressive outlook and other attitudes of the human being. At times one wonders how worthy we are to be discussing this. The thought ran through my mind from time to time whether, if Our Lord came amongst us again and started to write on the sand, we would be able to hold a quorum in the House. Are we as qualified as we would like to be to discuss this problem? The more one thinks about it the more one is inclined to feel that we have been let down by the theologians. They are not able to give us unified advice on this matter. We have been let down by statisticians because no matter what statistics are offered to us on the one side somebody is able to come along subsequently and draw a different conclusion from those statistics. We have probably been let down by the doctors because if we had taken more interest in this problem we would have provided some of the answers by now and would not have left the House and perhaps the country in the situation which exists at present.
Another aspect of this problem strikes me. By and large the difficulties that are arising for Deputies are ones of conscience, ones of facing moral problems which are based on our religion. We as Catholics have been told that if some definite way could be established of scientifically diagnosing the fertile period this would be a solution to all the problems facing us. I am not prepared to agree with this because, assuming we could have this scientific test which would pinpoint exactly this time for the woman concerned, what guarantee have we that single people or teenagers would not do exactly as they are doing now, in other words, be promiscuous, make use of this information? This may not provide the answer to this promiscuity and excessive sexual relations that we can anticipate with the coming of contraceptives to the country. Nobody has made any reference to that to date and I think it is as well that I should mention it. We must ask ourselves what is the answer to that problem. To my mind if we feel strongly enough about it it is one of education, education all along the line, at home by the parents, at school, outside school, to create the atmosphere, which would be very difficult. If this time comes the problem will be with us just as much as we are told it will be if we accept this Bill or any Bill like it.
Unfortunately we have been pressured by various groups on this question. I have made reference to some of them who I felt overplayed their hand and certainly did not impress me. Those pressures come from the other side too. As has been pointed out by the Minister and others, the biggest mistake that has been made has been assuming that this Bill is allowing contraceptives legally into the country for the first time.
Reading the reports of the Supreme Court case it struck me that the plaintiff went to American law to get the precedents to establish her case before the court. In view of the history of the United States, in view of what goes on there and the fact that they have so many social problems they are unable to solve and that many of their social problems are a disgrace to them considering their wealth, I thought it was sad that this should have been done. Reading the report of the decisions of the judges I was disturbed to a certain extent too by their references to American law and their drawing conclusions from it. I hope that if at any time in the future they have to decide such difficult problems in the area of sex or any thing relating to any social field they will be able to get better precedents than going to the United States. As far as we see their life at the present time they have not much to offer us.
We may not be the best people and we may not have the knowledge to decide this problem but, unfortunately, that is what we are here for. We represent a cross section of the country. There are people of various callings in the House and we have got to make a decision on this. I am satisfied with my approach to the Bill. I do not agree with making contraceptives easily available to unmarried people. I believe there are married people who need those devices, contraceptives or other help, that they should get them and that they should be provided by law. Pressure has been put on us to make those contraceptives available to single people on the basis that this is private morality and that we have no right to interfere in private morality. One must ask oneself how many cases of private morality must there be before they become public morality or is that like asking how many angels could dance on the head of a pin? I do not know. I do not think there is any obligation on me to support positive law in this House to enable a person who is an alcoholic or who wishes to damage his health by alcohol to help him to do this. If a person has an interest in drugs and wishes to continue taking them, I do not think there is any obligation on me to help to bring in a positive law to aid him to do this. Both those things are wrong. I also think that the provision of contraceptives for unmarried people is wrong and I think it is wrong that they should be easily available to them. This is my main reason for voting against this Bill. Had some other type of Bill been offered which would cover the points I have raised, I would have been inclined to support it.
Comment on this
We have before this House a Bill to restrict. It is nothing more and nothing less. "Restriction" is the key word. We should not lose sight of that for one moment. Some of the confusion in this House has been spread throughout the country by Members of the Opposition party for certain reasons. We had people sending circulars to everybody adding more confusion. If you ask anybody in the street what this is all about he will not know whether it is the Bill or the pill we are talking about.
Certain Deputies in this House hold themselves out today to be paragons of virtue. You would not know whether they were praying or speaking. I could start praying, too, and say "Lead us not into temptation but deliver us from evil". If I have nothing else to bequeath to my child but a freely available flow of contraceptives, then I have failed in this House to do my duty as a parent. Some people made craw-thumping, holier-than-thou speeches. You could nearly see the haloes around their heads. They should be around the necks of some of them.
Every Deputy got circulars about this Bill even before it was published. A circular came to me which was signed by quite a number of people. When I approached one or two of those who had signed and asked them what they were against, they could not tell me. The Bill was not even published at the time but my colleague Deputy Molloy had signed saying he was going to oppose the Bill.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy confine himself to the Bill now that he has got it.
Comment on this
I am pointing out the confusion there was even among Deputies in this House at that time. I think I am within my rights, with respect to the Chair, in referring to this. The Fianna Fáil Party helped to spread that confusion abroad and this is what they want to cash in on today. I compliment the Minister on taking action to stop the floodgates we have today due to the failure of a Fianna Fáil framed Constitution. This is the reason something has to be done.
Reference has been made to under-age drinking and there is a lot of truth in it. It is the greatest danger to our youth at the present time. One man stated that in such circumstances they can get "sex-sighted". There is another form of contraception and I think many of those who oppose this Bill practise it. It is known as the rhythm method which is a form of contraception and the holier-than-thou think they did not fail in that respect either.
Deputy Gibbons, who spoke before me, opened up well. He pointed out the reasons why something should be done. Of course, the Fianna Fáil Whip has forced that decent man to toe the line. The fact that Fianna Fáil will use this House to take advantage of such a situation shows how low they will go to try to cash in on the present situation.
We had a piece of medical advice from Deputy Dr. Gibbons. I have heard medical advice from other people. A woman in our town had six or seven children and she was warned by a doctor not to have any more. He told her about rhythm and other forms of avoiding pregnancy. She was warned that if she had another child her life would be in danger. She had six healthy children since. I asked her would she give back one of them and she said "No. I would risk my life for everyone of them." At times medical advice can lead people astray.
What is before the House this evening? Are we to stand idly by and do nothing? We have had too much of that in other forms. I was a member of as many Catholic organisations as anyone else. No priest approached me. Maybe in some cases a priest had to sign the circular sent out by certain groups. I have discussed this matter with Catholic priests and they understand the Minister's position. They appreciate that something must be done and that the Minister wants to do something.
It is sad that Fianna Fáil will take advantage of this position. It is a damned disgrace to say the least of it for them, for political expediency only, to create the confusion they have created. I say to the Minister: "Do something. As a parent I ask you to do something to block the floodgates." I am for the Bill and I am not ashamed to say that. I can face my wife and children and I can hold my head high in that respect.
Comment on this
I should like to pay tribute to the contribution made by Deputy Dr. Gibbons. He is a rural doctor in general practice and he has told the House what he knows to be the true situation arising from his own experience. Having heard all the arguments, having read the plethora of literature on the subject of contraception, having discussed the matter with many people and many groups, I must arrive at a decision on my own account. Many people may disagree with that decision, and quite a number of other people may agree with it. This is a time for decision and for a rational discussion within the competence of one's knowledge of the subject on which one speaks.
We are discussing the Control of Importation, Sale and Manufacture of Contraceptives Bill, 1974. This proposal has been put before the House by the Coalition Government. I hope to put to the House my intrinsic objections to the basic provisions in the Bill. As I understand it the Bill stands or falls on section 5. The rest of the Bill cocoons that section. That is my interpretation. Of course, it is open to disagreement. As reported at column 286 of the Official Report of 4th July, 1974, the Minister said:
The legal position at the moment, therefore, is that importation without restriction as to quantity or type and by any person is quite legal; that the ban on sale which continues to subsist would appear to be liable to be challenged successfully.
I agree with what the Minister said in the first part of the statement. The latter part would be a matter for constitutional test. I believe that if it were put to a constitutional test it would be found to be unconstitutional. I agree with the Minister in the totality of his statement. The Minister said:
I considered that this anomalous position had to be rectified because an anomaly itself is unsatisfactory but, in addition, I have had clear evidence that as a result of it a black market exists and is growing in the illegal sale of contraceptives in this country.
If, as proposed in the Bill before us, contraceptives are to be made available to married couples only, I can see a very serious situation arising which will not be the fault of the pharmaceutical chemists who will distribute these contraceptives under the terms of the Bill. It is a matter of fact that, if an outlet is available to married people for the purchase of contraceptives, they will become available to single people. I do not think there is any gainsaying that.
For the Minister to come in here and give as a reason, in my opinion a spurious reason, for the introduction of this Bill that a black market in contraceptives exists and that, in some way, he proposes to cure that situation by the introduction of this Bill, is a fallacy. I agree with the Minister that there is a black market in contraceptives. The Minister has available to him knowledge which I have not got. He knows the extent of that black market and the size of it. Do Members of this House really think that, by limiting the sale of contraceptives to married people, they will instantly become unavailable to single people? Is the Minister offering this as one reason, among a number of reasons, why he wishes to enact the legislation we are now discussing.
Having outlined the reasons for the legal position post-McGee, I should like to pick out a number of quotations from what I would consider to be the liberal judgement of one of the members of the Supreme Court sitting in judgment on the constitutionality of the McGee case. The document I have in my hand is actually a transcript of the judgement of the learned and respected Judge Walsh. At page 3 of the transcript of his reasoned judgement he said:
There is no law in force in the State which prohibits the use of contraceptives either in or outside of marriage or the manufacture or distribution of contraceptives within the State. It appears to be the accepted fact that at present there are no contraceptives manufactured within the State and therefore any contraceptives presently available within the State must necessarily have been imported in breach of the statutory provision and although innocently imported would not attract a penalty to the importer. Such importation would, however, leave the goods liable to seizure.
That would appear to be the position. I am sure that, if the judge reads the Official Report of this debate, he will forgive me for skipping from page to page, but I consider the extracts I will quote from his judgement to be the most helpful for the argument I hope to pursue during the course of my short contribution on this important subject. At page 7 of the transcript Judge Walsh continued:
To control the sale of contraceptives is not necessarily per se unconstitutional nor is a control on the importation of contraceptives necessarily unconstitutional. There may be many reasons grounded in considerations of public health or public morality or even fiscal or protectionist reasons why there should be a control on the importation of such articles. There may also be many good reasons grounded in public morality or public health why their sale should be controlled. I use the term “control” to include the total prohibition. What is challenged here is the constitutionality of making these articles unavailable. The decision of this appeal must therefore rest upon the present state of the law and the present state of the facts relating to the issues in dispute.
At page 16 of the judge's transcripts he goes on to say:
The sexual life of a husband and wife is of necessity and by its nature an area of particular privacy. If the husband and wife decide to limit their family or avoid having children by the use of contraceptives it is a matter peculiarly within the joint decision of the husband and wife and one into which the State cannot intrude unless its intrusion can be justified by the exigencies of the common good.
I was very pleased to see that the judge went on to develop that point, because I had grave doubts on reading the matter whether the State could intrude into the privacy of a marriage between a husband and wife. The judge continues:
The question of whether the use of contraceptives by married couples within their marriage is or is not contrary to the moral code or codes to which they profess to subscribe or is or is not regarded by them as being against their conscience could not justify State intervention.
That places the matter in the proper perspective. The situation is articulated clearly by the judge and he expresses my point of view far clearer than probably I could express it myself, and that is the reason why I use the quotation, to support the judge and to use his judgment in support of myself. I do not think the State or anyone else has any right to interfere in or to intrude into the married life of a couple, least of all into the area in which they might use contraceptives. On page 22 the judge says in relation to the McGee case:
As this particular case arose primarily out of the ban on importation, I think in so far as Article 41——
of the Constitution——
is concerned, the declaration sought should only go in respect of subsections (3) of section 17 of the 1935 Act. That does not necessarily mean that the provisions as to sale in subsection (1) cannot be impugned. If in the result, notwithstanding the deletion of subsection (3), the prohibition on sale had the effect of leaving a position where contraceptives were not reasonably available for use within marriage, then that particular prohibition must fall.
At the moment I do not think it necessary to make any declaration in respect of that and that brings me back to my agreement with the Minister where he states that the ban on sale which continues to exist would appear to be liable to be challenged successfully, and I think that is probably where the information came from arising out of the judge's comments in that respect.
Another facet of the general argument and discussion is the matter of the enforceability of the Bill. I make no apologies for being a politician. I am proud to be such. There is a suggestion that we are using this subject as a political football. I would like to help in disabusing minds of that suggestion. What I say must be taken as the utterances of a politician. It has been suggested that there is something dirty about politics. I do not want it to be considered in a "dirty" sense. I personally do not understand the suggestion but it has been thrown out so often in the course of this debate that it is as well to get hold of it at the beginning. Article 15.4 of the Constitution states:
1º The Oireachtas shall not enact any law which is in any respect repugnant to the Constitution or any provision thereof.
2º Every law enacted by the Oireachtas which is in any respect repugnant to this Constitution or to any provision thereof, shall, but to the extent only of such repugnancy, be invalid.
This raises again the matter of the availability of contraceptives to single persons. My information from one of the highest authorities in this land of ours is that when this Bill becomes law its constitutionality could be challenged by a single person, who may be a widow, a widower, people living in a common law situation, a common law marriage as it is usually called, or it may be just a normal person, not by the standards of some of the contributions here. We do not know until we put it to the test whether the Bill is unconstitutional, but it is reasonable to accept the probability of it as suggested by this person of legal eminence. Assuming he is correct, what we are doing then is enacting an unconstitutional provision, section 5 of the Bill:
A person who is unmarried and not the holder of a licence granted under section 2 shall not purchase a contraceptive.
The second part of section 5 states:
A person who contravenes subsection (1) shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding £100.
I am putting forward my views to put the House on notice. We all of us come in here and give our reasons for or against the proposals before us. believe that the views expressed here are views honestly held by those who express them. I also believe that those who express views believe that their views are genuine. Section 5 is the nub of the Bill. Making contraceptives available to married people only is just not enforceable and my argument is underlined by the Minister's own statement. The Minister is in a very difficult situation and I really do not believe that he believes half of what he said in his introductory speech. At column 287 of Volume 274 of the Official Report of 4th July he said:
It has been asked if purchasers will be obliged to produce marriage certificates or other proof of marital status. The answer is no.
Leaving politics aside and, in all right reason, surely there you have the kernel of the matter in regard to the unenforceability of the Bill. A single person can go into a chemist's shop and purchase contraceptives without having to produce a marriage certificate or other proof of marital status. There will be no obligation on the chemist to inquire as to the marital status of the purchaser.
The Minister may say, as he said on the Prosecution of Offences Bill, that the section is there in terrorum; so long as people know it is there they will not do something which will bring them within the scope of the section. Section 5 provides:
A person who is unmarried and who is not the holder of a licence granted under section 2 shall not purchase a contraceptive.
Clearly, there is no obligation on the chemist to inquire about, or on the purchaser to declare, his or her marital status. Surely, straightaway the Bill is brought into disrepute. That alone is a good enough reason for not voting for the Bill. No doubt I will be asked what my alternative is. I will produce my alternative. I believe we are obliged to produce something other than what the Minister has produced.
Comment on this
My views are personal. I should like to make that clear. The views I expressed here are consistent with the views I have expressed elsewhere.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy agree to voting for the Bill and having it amended on the Committee Stage?
Comment on this
On the matter of the free vote, it has always been the function of a Government to stand over their own legislation. Here you have a situation in which the Government are positively not doing their duty. In the post-McGee situation the importation of contraceptives, without restriction, is quite legal. The Government apparently wanted in some way to curtail the importation of contraceptives and to confine their sale to married people. The Minister said that this Bill is designed to regulate their availability having regard to the constitutional decision in the McGee case. If that is the intention of the Government then they should discharge that function. This free vote is a funk vote in an effort to justify their inability to prevail on their own Deputies democratically to accept legislation which, according to the Government's interpretation, is necessary. They are funking the issue by having a free vote and I maintain they are not doing their duty. It is unfortunate that intelligent people like Dr. Thornley, to be followed, I assume, by Dr. O'Connell——
Comment on this
I am sorry. If that is the Ceann Comhairle's contribution to the debate, God help us. Deputy Dr. Thornley is, in my view, an intelligent man as, indeed is Deputy Dr. O'Connell.
Comment on this
I do not wish to attract interruptions. I think people should be allowed to speak on this without interruption from anybody. To come back to my position, Dr. David Thornley——
Comment on this
Deputy Dr. David Thornley has given his views and in some ways justified his reason for voting with the Government on this Bill. It is a sad occasion. He gave a number of reasons why he could see himself voting against the Bill. If, in those circumstances, he votes for the Bill, it would be very sad for him.
Comment on this
Deputy Thornley said it could be amended. Assuming that, we have not heard from the amendeors within the Government parties what the amendments will be and if they will then be taken on a free vote. That is another proposition which reduces Deputy Thornley's arguments.
Comment on this
If the Deputy has the courage to put his name to an amendment to the section in question I will put my name to it also.
Comment on this
This Deputy has already said the reason he will be voting against the Minister's proposals is that they are unenforceable and unconstitutional. Now I am being asked to put my name to amendments of which I have no knowledge and the content of which are not known to anybody. The word "amendments" has been glibly thrown about inside and outside the House. Nobody knows what they are.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy accept that he has the right to put down amendments? It is normal for the Opposition to do so. They have a better chance of getting them through with a free vote on this side of the House than they normally have.
Comment on this
The Minister for Foreign Affairs is being party to a funk vote. He is not doing his duty. The Government are not doing their duty.
Comment on this
The Minister is being selective, as he usually is, in his interruptions and remarks. I appeal to him to try to keep the discussion on a reasonable plane, which is what I have been trying to do.
Comment on this
Apart from considerations propounded by the learned Supreme Court judges as to the unconstitutionality of the decision in the McGee case, there are many other remarks in the Minister's opening statement which would be helpful to the House if he could clarify them.
If the Bill is as imperfect as those who talked about amending it say it is, why did they not perfect it before bringing it into this House? That would be the answer to the amendment question. The Minister brought in a Bill full of humbug. Opposition Deputies are being asked now to lend their names to amendments. That is another reason why I think the Government are not doing their duty. It is a well known fact that the Government parties met in their committee rooms to discuss this matter. Why did they not amend the Bill to the satisfaction of the Deputies who want to put down amendments now? It is humbug and cant. I would like to discuss section 5. As reported at column 287 of Volume 274 of the Official Report the Minister said:
It has been asked if purchasers will be obliged to produce marriage certificates or other proof of marital status. The answer is no. Likewise there will be no requirement or obligation whatever on the vendor to inquire as to the marital status of the purchaser.
Can the Minister honestly admit that the sale of contraceptives to unmarried people is unenforceable and that section 5 is not enforceable? He will deal with that matter at considerable length, if he has any respect for the institution and the intelligence of this House.
It was not my intention to deal with the proposed legislation in too much depth. The Bill and the Minister's statement are so riddled with anomalies and inconsistencies that if a person was to sit down and look at them he would have to admit that they exist. The two threads of my argument have been on the enforceability of the Bill and the probable unconstitutionality of the actual legislation when it becomes law.
I do not think there is anybody in this House who could disagree with me about abortifacient. Nobody in this House could support or argue for abortion. Having read a number of medical journals on the interpretation of the meaning of an abortifacient, I am still in some doubt as to exactly what it means. I am not competent to give a dissertation on matters pertaining to the medical profession nor is it my intention to give such a dissertation here.
Under this Bill:
"Abortifacient" means any appliance, instrument, drug, preparation or thing designed, prepared or intended to terminate pregnancy which has resulted from sexual intercourse between human beings;
That interpretation will stand in law if and when this Bill is passed.
Our present population is three million. The estimated population in 1980 will be somewhere in the region of 3.3 million. The most fertile period for the female population is between 15 and 44 years of age. Of the present 3 million population, 1½ million are females. Of those, over half a million are between 15 and 44 years of age. I got these figures from the latest available data. The marriage rate is 7.3 per 1,000, which would be equal to 22,000 per annum. The birth rate is 22.8 per 1,000, which would be equal to 68,000. The death rate is 10.6 per 1,000, which would be equal to 31,000 per annum.
From the latest figures available to me, an estimated 400 Irish girls went to the United Kingdom for abortions in a recent year. My information is that the figure for the North of Ireland was considerably higher. As I understand it, the figure quoted for that year is a reduction in the figure for earlier years. The figures on abortion must shock all of us who utterly abhor and deplore that insidious and unnatural practice.
At columns 289 and 290 of the Official Report dated 4th July, the Minister for Justice in his introductory speech on Second Stage said:
Those who oppose the Bill because it is too illiberal do so mainly on the ground that it seeks to restrict sales of contraceptives to married couples. They seek to argue that it is impractical to do so and any attempt to do so will bring the law into disrepute. I have already dealt with this argument when speaking of this restriction on sales to married persons only and the enforcing of it. They also argue, however, that there is a right, a natural right in favour of single people to have access to contraceptives. I do not accept that there is any such right because that implies a right to fornicate and in my opinion there is no such natural right.
I agree with the Minister in this matter. Has a pregnant woman a natural right to have the child, born as a result of illicit love-making, aborted? She has no such natural right. If people intend to fornicate and if we cannot prevent that, would it not be better to provide them with the means to prevent pregnancy rather than forcing them out of the country to seek abortion abroad? This is an extremely important question——
Comment on this
It is estimated that some 40,000 persons are taking what is commonly called the pill and my information is that this is the equivalent of 500,000 prescriptions per year. Some people may be taking the pill on the grounds of health but if we are to be honest we must admit that the majority are taking it for contraceptive purposes. All the figures I have given are open to correction if they are not correct.
There are 1,180 pharmacies in this country. It is estimated that 400 or 500 family pharmacy outlets would give the professional service required in the regulation of the sale of contraceptives. There must be control in the sale and distribution of contraceptives. Many people are genuinely concerned about their free availability as it exists at the moment having regard to the lack of restriction in the importation for personal use.
The matter of contraceptives has been of concern to the people for years. There are genuinely held views but there is one view I deplore, that which tries to confuse the issue in some way, which tries to introduce the element of abortion. I deplore the view that tries to suggest that we are discussing abortion in this debate, that the Government Bill provides for abortion or that the next obvious step will be the introduction of a Bill to allow abortion. That is a spurious argument——
Comment on this
I do not mean to interrupt the Deputy but I heard from his party's benches this morning what he has just condemned. I am delighted he has repudiated it.
Comment on this
There is a genuine anti-contraceptive lobby that we cannot dismiss but there is a dishonest lobby and I find the latter abhorrent. These are the people who send us colour slides of aborted children being disposed of in buckets. I do not think it is necessary for me to continue on these lines but it is this sort of argument that we, as Dáil Deputies, must react against. I do not know whether or not we should condemn these people; they may be intelligent people but they are not necessarily honest people.
It is interesting to note that Ireland, as a member of the United Nations— and I am sure the Minister for Foreign Affairs will agree with me here—is committed to (a) family planning in principle; (b) Ireland has also subscribed, as I understand it, to the Teheran Conference which regards family planning as a social right; (c) our own National Health Council—the supreme advisory body on all health matters—has recommended a change in the law here to allow family planning.
On the matter of an alternative to the Government proposal, I do not think we as an Opposition are specifically obliged to introduce a Private Member's Bill. If the Government had been doing their duty we would not find ourselves in the sorry impasse in which we now find ourselves. If the Government had perfected the instrument which they now purport to be a perfection, then I do not think we would have the spurious argument about introducing amendments and people adding their names, in all-party sense, to these amendments. However I shall not pursue that argument. My alternative to the Bill—and again it is a personal alternative—and indeed any other suggested Bill on contraception is the amendment of section 17, subsection (3) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1935, by deletion and the substitution of a new subsection setting out the pharmaceutical outlets as outlets for the sale and dispensing of contraceptives on prescription and, of course, the amendments consequential on such a proposal. Again, one might find one's self in trouble elsewhere but, at the expense of finding ones self in difficulties in respect of my suggestion, very little divides my personal views from those expressed already by Senator Mary Robinson on the subject in the legislative sense.
There is one other matter with which I might deal before concluding: the suggestion that in some way I refused to deal with this Bill as spokesman on Justice for Fianna Fáil. Nothing could be farther from the truth. At no time did I refuse to take the Bill, at a party meeting or elsewhere; at no time did I refuse to deal with the Bill or with its subject matter. At no time did I refuse to deal with the Bill on radio or television; at no time did I articulate my refusal to take the Bill in committee of the party, front bench or elsewhere. I would hope that the record will now be corrected in equally as strong language as that record was so unfairly misrepresented.
Comment on this
In this debate it is up to us, as legislators, to ignore the pressures on us from diverse sources. There are liberal pressures, sometimes based on principles with which many of us—most of us perhaps—do not agree. There are conservative pressures, highly organised, dishonest in some respects—that is in the organisation of the campaign—and often, in fact mainly, ignoring completely the realities of the situation. All the organised letters I have received have been ones which, even since the Supreme Court decision, have totally ignored its existence. They have virtually all used the same form of words. I have replied to every one; only in one instance out of scores has anybody written back. What this signifies I do not know; whether I convinced them all by the logic of my argument; whether they did not feel they wanted to take the matter further; whether they had written a letter to me in the first instance and somebody else put their names to it— there are a variety of possible explanations.
Our job here is to make up our own minds. Although one would not have known it from what was said earlier today by Deputy O.J. Flanagan, that is something which has been put firmly and squarely to us—those of us who are Roman Catholics—by the Hierarchy of our Church who said, having made some preliminary remarks in their statement:
It does not follow, of course, that the State is bound to prohibit the importation and sale of contraceptives. There are many things which the Catholic Church holds to be morally wrong and no one has ever suggested, least of all the Church herself, that they should be prohibited by the State. Those who insist on seeing the issue purely in terms of the State enforcing, or not enforcing, Catholic moral teaching are, therefore, missing the point.
Deputy O.J. Flanagan managed to miss the point for two hours this morning because he would not listen to what his Bishops said to him despite that he seemed to be talking as if he were a Bishop himself.
The real question——
The Bishops said——
facing the legislators is: What effect would the increased availability of contraceptives have on the quality of life in the Republic of Ireland? That is a question of public, not private, morality. What the legislators have to decide is whether a change in the law would, on balance, do more harm than good, by damaging the character of the society for which they are responsible.
They went on to suggest then—having put the responsibility for the decision fairly and squarely where it belongs in this House, and indeed in the other House—to make a case that there was evidence that the quality of life would be affected, a case which they are fully entitled to put, a case which some of us would feel was selective in the presentation of the figures, but which certainly needs to be considered seriously by anybody dealing with this matter.
However I feel it was perhaps a mistake to confine the issue put to us to the question of public morality. I will come in a moment to deal with the question of public morality, and I reject completely the idea of some liberals that there is no such thing as public morality or that we should not concern ourselves with it. But I think there are other matters as well as public morality to be considered. There is the question of human rights, which was not adverted to in the Bishop's statement. There is the question of the wishes of the people, which also must have some consideration. There are other related political issues with which we are entitled to concern ourselves and have regard to unless there are compelling arguments under the headings of public morality or human rights, such as, for example, the impact of what we do or do not do upon opinion in Northern Ireland; upon the tensions that exist between the communities there and, therefore, upon the lives and prospects of life of the people there. Therefore I should like to deal with this general question, because I will deal first with the general question of the rights and wrongs of controlling, not controlling, or having limited control of contraception. I should like to deal with it from the point of view of these different principles— the question of human rights, public morality, the wishes of the people and impact on opinion in Northern Ireland.
I am starting with this general issue. I am doing so because, although in fact what is before us today is not the principle of whether or not to control the availability of contraceptives, or whether or not to prevent them being available—because that issue has been determined by the Supreme Court; they must be available on some terms—nevertheless, so much of the debate outside and, to some extent, here has been on the general principles involved rather than on the practical problem of dealing with the Supreme Court decision, I feel it is right that somebody addressing himself to this subject should speak briefly on these general principles.
First, the question of human rights. The various judgments of the Supreme Court on this are interesting and I do not think they have been sufficiently appreciated. I think that something of the quality of the thought in those statements needs more publicity than it has had. It seems to me that some of those statements derive from a strong sentiment—one might almost say a passion—for human rights which some of the judges felt were being ignored. I want to quote from some of the judgments to illustrate what I mean by that. Judge Walsh said that:
the rights of a married couple to decide how many children, if any they will have, are matters outside the reach of positive law where the means employed to implement such decisions do not impinge upon the common good or destroy or endanger human life. It is undoubtedly true that among those persons who are subject to a particular moral code no one has a right to be in breach of that moral code. But when this is a code governing private morality and where the breach of it is not one which injures the common good——
which comes into public morality——
then it is not the State's business to intervene. It is outside the authority of the State to intrude into the privacy of the husband and wife relationship for the sake of imposing a code of private morality upon that husband and wife which they do not desire. In my view Article 41 of the Constitution guarantees the husband and wife against any such invasion of their privacy by the State. It follows that the use of contraceptives by them within that marital privacy is equally guaranteed against such invasion and as such assumes the status of a right so guaranteed by the Constitution. If this right cannot be directly invaded by the State, it follows that it cannot be frustrated by the State taking measures to ensure that the exercise of this right is rendered impossible.
Towards the end of his judgment, Judge Walsh concluded:
I am of opinion that not only has the State the right to do so but by virtue of the provisions of the proviso to section 1 and the provisions of section 3 of Article 40, the State has the positive obligation to ensure by its laws as far as is possible (and in the use of the word "possible" I am relying on the Irish text of the Constitution) that there would be made available to married women in the condition of health of Mrs. McGee the means whereby a conception which was likely to put her life in jeopardy might be avoided when it is a risk over and above the ordinary risks inherent in pregnancy.
Mr. Justice Walsh not only asserted that the State had not the right to interfere to prevent the availability of contraceptives but in cases like that of Mrs. McGee, have a positive duty to ensure that they were available.
Mr. Justice Griffin said:
The present case concerns a relationship lying within the zone of the privacy created by several fundamental constitutional guarantees.
He went on to ask some rhetorical questions:
Would we allow the police to search the sacred precincts of marital bedrooms for telltale signs of the use of contraceptives? The very idea is repulsive to the notions of privacy surrounding the marriage relationship. We deal with a right of privacy older than the Bill of Rights, older than our political parties, older than our school system. Marriage is a coming-together for better or for worse, hopefully enduring, and intimate to the degree of being sacred.
Judge Griffin concluded:
In my judgment, this subsection violates the personal rights of the plaintiff, in this case her right of privacy in her marital relations with her husband under Article 40, section 3, subsection (1).
Mr. Justice Budd came to a similar conclusion, concluding that the Act with which he was dealing:
is in particular in conflict with the personal rights of the citizen as to the guarantee of Article 40.3.1 to respect, defend and vindicate the personal rights of the citizen as far as practicable.
Mr. Justice Henchy said that the section, section 17 had the effect:
of condemning Mrs. McGee and her husband to a way of life which at best will be fraught with worry, tension and uncertainty that cannot but adversely affect their lives and, at worst, will result in an unwanted pregnancy causing death or serious illness, with the obvious tragic consequences to the lives of her husband and young children. And this in a Constitution which in its preamble proclaims as one of its aims the dignity and freedom of the individual; which in Article 40, section 3, subsection (2) casts on the State a duty to protect as best it may from unjust attack and, in the case of injustice done, to vindicate the life and person of every citizen; which in Article 41 after recognising the family as the natural primary and fundamental unit group of Society, and as a moral institution possessing inalienable and imprescriptible rights, antecedent and superior to all positive law, guarantees to protect it in its Constitution and authority, as the necessary basis of social order and as indispensable to the welfare of the nation and the State; and which, also in Article 41, pledges the State to guard with special care the institution of marriage, on which the family is founded, and to protect it from attack.
Section 17 in my judgment so far from respecting Mrs. McGee's personal rights, violates them. If she observes this prohibition (which in practice she can scarcely avoid doing and which in law she is bound under penalty of fine or imprisonment to do) she will endanger the the security and the happiness of her marriage, she will imperil her health to the point of hazarding her life, and she will subject her family to the risk of distress and disruption. These are the intrusions which she is entitled to say are incompatible with the safety of her life, the preservation of her health her responsibility to her conscience, and the security and wellbeing of her marriage and family.
He therefore concluded that:
Section 17 violates the guarantee by the State to Article 40 section 3 subsection (1) by its laws to protect her personal rights not only by violating her personal rights to privacy in regard to her marital relations but in a wider way by frustrating and making criminal any efforts by her to effectuate the decision of her husband and herself, made responsibly, conscientiously and on medical advice, to avail themselves of a particular contraceptive method so as to ensure her life and health as well as the integrity, security and wellbeing of her marriage and her family.
It is well that we should in this debate understand something of what lies behind the decision of the Supreme Court. These are the views of four judges, asserting the people's marital rights vis-à-vis the State, and if at any time the State sought, as it did in 1935, or by constitutional change to interfere with these rights, this would be a very serious matter indeed. Once the principle is established and is allowed to endure and is upheld that the State has the right to interfere in the private married lives of people in that way, then it would be difficult to sustain the proposition at some future time that the State would not have the right to interfere to enforce contraception on the people and force sterilisation on people. The family has rights antecedent to the State and no State has the right to interfere with the inherent rights of the family or with the institution of marriage, and it is on those grounds which seem to me to be fundamental to the whole thoughtbasis of our community, fundamental to our Christian heritage, might I say, that these judgments of the Supreme Court are of vital importance. They have upheld a principle which had been ignored for far too long, the principle of the basic rights of people in marriage and of the fact that the State has no right or power to interfere with them in their private married lives. That is a principle which it is very dangerous to seek to undermine.
There are people at the moment who have put forward the proposal that we should go to the country in a referendum to take away this right of the family, to go to the country and put to the people the proposition that this right, proclaimed in words of some nobility by the Supreme Court should be taken from them, that a campaign should be waged to give the State powers it has not now got to interfere with the family. I do not think that if such a foolish proposition were contemplated by any political party the people would entertain it. The dangers are much too great. There are rights antecedent to law and above all those rights concern marriage and the family.
I turn now to the question of public morality, the second consideration which we have to bear in mind. At the outset I should like to reject the liberal view that there is no such thing as public morality. The fact is that all States, I think, without exception—certainly I know of no exception—have such legislation. They have legislation on marriage, legislation laying down conditions and limitations on divorce and abortion, legislation controlling pornography and blasphemy. Even the most liberal States today have some legislation along these lines. Public morality is the concern of the community and of the State and we have the right and the duty to protect public morality by legislating against public acts that may interfere with it, so long as in so doing we do not interfere with basic human rights.
I also reject the liberal view that public morality is concerned only with public acts. It is so concerned but not only with them, such as for example acts of public indecency. Private acts, if tolerated or encouraged by State action, can have cumulative effects on the public mind and the social consequences of an aggregation of private acts must be considered. Thus the mere fact that a brothel is discreet, not advertised or clearly indicated on the exterior, does not mean that the law may not regulate or forbid brothels. The suggestion to the contrary is the individual heresy of the liberal west in the 20th century expressed in the phrase so often used "So long as I do not directly harm another person, I do what I like" and indeed the adverb "directly" is often omitted from this proposition. The fact is that indirect damage must be considered too.
For example, if we are considering the question of divorce, we cannot simply consider, as liberal thinkers do, the desire of the two parents to free themselves from entanglement and to enter into some other relationship. We must consider the indirect effects on the children and also the indirect effects if the availability of divorce should change the quality of marriage. I do not wish to enter into a debate on this, nor do I want to express a view one way or the other on whether there should or should not be divorce. I only want to reject the concept that in considering matters like divorce one can only consider the immediate effects on the people immediately affected and one has to rule out the impact on what has been called—though the phrase is so constantly used nowadays as to have become virtually derisory—the quality of life.
Having said that, and having rebutted as far as I am concerned those liberal individualistic heresies so characteristic of much of western culture at the present time, the fact remains that when we come to regulate public morality we may not do so by infringing on basic human rights and certainly not by infringing on them in ways that cannot be shown conclusively to be required by the needs of public morality. In any event, in this particular instance we are dealing with how strong is the public morality argument? It has been put in this House by Deputies. We are told that in other countries where there is contraception the quality of life has deteriorated and that immorality is prevalent. But how many of those countries are ones that we can compare with our country and its particular culture? How many of them are characterised by the strong Christian faith of the vast majority in this country? How many of those countries have 85 per cent of their population practising Catholics? It is not clear to me that what has applied in other countries with their cultural traditions has relevance here.
In any event, it is not clear from anything that has been said, or any statistics or any assertions from whichever source and with whatever authority, that the availability of contraceptives has itself been the cause of immorality. That proposition has been put but certainly has not been proven. There is, however, one relevant example we can look to for an indication of the consequences of the free availability of contraceptives in an environment and cultural situation similar to our own. That is, of course, Northern Ireland and particularly the parts of Northern Ireland which have an overwhelming Catholic population and are similar in their religious composition to much of the Republic.
If we look to Northern Ireland and particularly to the Catholic areas there do we see a long history of pastoral letters directed against contraception as dangerous? I have never seen one or heard of one. The first reference I have seen to anything of the kind has only come in this debate during the last couple of months when suddenly some people have woken up to the fact that their case is weak on this account and have started to worry now, rather belatedly, about the quality of life in Northern Ireland. The fact is that in Northern Ireland in general, and above all in those parts of Northern Ireland whose population have a similar religious composition to our own, there does not exist a situation comparable with that in Britain or America or the other countries we have been told to compare ourselves with.
There is a situation in Northern Ireland in which people who want contraceptives can get them but they are not flaunted, there is no effort to affront public morality, there has been no visible significant large scale change in the pattern of human relationships or in the way people behave. There have, of course, been changes similar to those that have occurred here, just as in this part of the country there is a much wider acceptance today of contraception than a couple of years ago. That is also true of those parts in Northern Ireland, but there is no evidence that if in areas similar to our own in cultural composition and similar to our own in the attitudes of the people, if you abolish controls you will get any significant perceptible change caused by that.
We are fortunate, indeed we are unique virtually, in being the only country which in legislating is able to look to somewhere and be confident that the example is one that is relevant because there is nothing inherently different between us and our fellow people in Northern Ireland in this respect. It has been alleged that there are certain differences. I do not accept their relevance.
Two arguments were put forward. The first is that the repression which Catholics have suffered in Northern Ireland for so long has made them staunch in their faith and that we, not having had the benefit of such repression, having been completely free and having been strengthened in our faith, therefore are liable to fall into evil ways which the fortunate Northerners are free from, after 50 years of one-party Protestant Government until a couple of years ago. I find that curious argument—an argument no doubt in favour of having one-party Protestant Government in Catholic areas—one I do not take to and I am not convinced by it. Neither am I convinced by the reverse argument. I simply do not believe that this has fundamentally altered the attitude of Catholics in Northern Ireland or that we are such weak brethren here that we would necessarily react totally differently from the way they do.
It has also been suggested from authoritative sources that the Northerners are more puritanical than we are. I am half Northern and half Southern; I have been accused at times of being puritanical; I am never quite sure whether it is the Southern Catholic or the Northern Presbyterian in me, but I am not sure there is such an enormous difference in attitudes as has been suggested here. I simply do not accept that the people of the Republic are such weaker brethren that they cannot be trusted with the liberties which can easily be given to people in Northern Ireland without dangerous effects.
This argument is one which I reject for a number of reasons. It would seem to argue in favour of Protestant repression, that we are a different kind of people, that Partition runs very deep, indeed, that there are two nations in this country so different that they require totally different legislation to keep them in their place. I reject that. I reject the divisive attitude involved here. We might even say that Partition is the attitude involved. I believe there is one people in this country, though with different subcultures, but I do not see that we ought to legislate in two totally different ways as if we were dealing with two peoples, one African and one Asian or something like that. Whatever differentiation there is between North and South, it does not seem to me to mean that what is tolerable in the North and does no harm will destroy the quality of life down here. The contrast is simply not credible and I do not accept it.
Another argument is put forward and with respect, because I am quoting from it. I must quote my source. I recall several years ago his Eminence, Cardinal Conway, in a radio programme putting forward—I am not quoting verbatim and I hope his Eminence will forgive me if I do not give the full statement—in a few sentences two statements which could broadly be summarised as that there is no need to change the law here because in any event it imposes no hardship because if you want contraceptives you can get them easily; and that a change in our law would be disastrous. I find it hard to accept the logic of those two statements in such juxtaposition. I do not think that the situation is such that a change would be disastrous in that way. I do not think one can argue on both these bases at once.
Let us summarise the facts of our situation. The pill is freely available. It has been said that 40,000 couples need it—Deputy Andrews mentioned that. I made a quick calculation after he said it. I checked the figure out and it seems to me to be roughly correct from information available from other sources, in this instance the evidence of surveys carried out which is in accord with evidence from medical or pharmaceutical sources. Another form of contraception has been freely available to all since time began, that is, coitus interruptus. Nothing we could do or say would change that. Contraceptives can be freely imported as set down in the Supreme Court decision and are being widely pushed.
These are the facts that we have to consider. Yet we are told that a change we make in the law will radically change the whole way of life in this country. If that is to be argued it would have to be shown that at the moment there are restrictions and that the change would involve such a degree of liberalisation that it could have such a big effect. Given the facts I have mentioned and given the controls to be imposed by this legislation, it does not seem to me credible that it would have any really significant effect on our way of life.
We must also consider the fact that the vast majority of our people are practising Roman Catholics—about 85 per cent of them—that we are a people who have traditionally a high standard of sexual morality and that, therefore, we are unlikely suddenly to change our way of life simply because one particular form of contraception became available at points of sale inside the country rather than freely importable. A change involving the legal availability of contraceptives within the State to married people will not change the quality of our life. The quality of life here will change anyway.
I, therefore, am simply unconvinced with the arguments on public morality. They seem to me to have been expressed unconvincingly and at times even hysterically. I do not see enough in the arguments here to justify even contemplating intruding on the basic human rights which have been put forward so effectively in the Supreme Court judgment.
There is another consideration which a democratic Legislature must consider. It is not the only consideration. Human rights and public morality are important considerations —most important—but we must also consider the wishes of the people. It is relevant in legislation to consider them. We are not bound by them; I do not feel as a legislator that I must always look at the latest public opinion poll to see what percentage voted what way. On the other hand, it would be wrong not to have some regard to the wishes of the people, not to try to establish what they want and take it into account unless there are strong contrary indications in such areas as human rights and public morality. It happens that we know a lot about the wishes of our people in this matter. Three surveys of public opinion have been carried out in the course of the present year. These surveys provide cross-checks on each other and all the cross-checks that one can make show a high degree of internal consistency between them. What they indicate is that there is a majority in favour of the availability of contraceptives—the questions put are slightly different in different cases —and that feeling is very strong among married women of the age at which they could have children and is overwhelming among younger married women.
I should like to illustrate that with some actual figures. As regards the population as a whole we have two surveys, the Market Research Bureau survey carried out earlier this year, in the spring, with a random sample of 571. We have the Irish Marketing Survey carried out around the same time with a quota sample of 1,600. The MRB sample excludes people aged under 18 or over 60—it does not cover the whole range of age in the population. For the range it covered it showed 58 per cent in favour of the availability of contraceptives. The question as to whom they should be available is one I shall return to because they went on to ask that question and a very clear picture emerged. The range of variation was from 73 per cent in the 20-24 age group down to 38 per cent in the 55-60 age group. The IMS survey, covering the whole population, showed a figure of 70 per cent for the age group 15-24—very close to the 73 per cent figure for the 20-24 age group in the MRB survey—declining to 30 per cent for the 55-upwards age group, the whole group above that, that is, 30 per cent of everybody over 55 as compared with 38 per cent for the 55-60 age group. The older you get the less the support, but the two sets of figures are very closely comparable.
In regard to married women we have three surveys giving different figures. Taking the MRB and the IMS surveys they show, overall, 54 per cent of married women in the MRB case, in favour of availability of contraceptives and 51 per cent in the IMS survey in favour of availability of contraceptives through chemists—the question was put in more precise terms. Taking individual age ranges for married women of an age likely to have children, up to 44, the MRB service shows 72 per cent in favour and the IMS 68 per cent—again closely comparable. If you take the sub-groups of age you get similar figures. Incidentally I should correct this: when I said MRB I should have referred to the other survey of married women carried out by Mr. Wilson-Davis. The two I am comparing are the Wilson-Davis survey with a random sample of 754 and the IMS survey. If you go through the different age groups you get the same compatibility of figures. It is therefore clear, given the size of samples, the three different surveys and the gross compatibility between the figures that whatever some people may think, or like to think, the facts are that our population as a whole have come to the view that on some basis or another contraceptives should be available: that view is held by the great majority of married women, women of marriageable age, the people most directly affected.
The surveys also tell us something about those to whom contraceptives should be available and on that, from the Wilson-Davis survey there is a very strong view that they should be available only to married people. I do not suggest that view should be compelling with legislators but it is a very strongly held view and legislators should have regard to it in legislating. I want to put the point that the Dáil, subject to other considerations, should have some regard to the wishes of the people and the wishes of the people, so far as they can be established, have been established with more clarity and certainty and consistency than usual and we have information which can guide us in our decision— not the determining factor, but one to take into account, when one has had regard to human rights and public morality.
What about the Churches? All the Protestant Churches have specifically asked the Government to have legislation to make contraception available. The Catholic Church, through their authoritative spokesmen, have opposed this or, to put it more accurately, indicated in their statement last November that their inclination would be towards not making contraception freely available and that they feel the balance of argument on public morality grounds lies in that direction. Our Catholics themselves are divided on the issue. The Wilson-Davis survey of married women showed, in relation to the attitude of Catholic married women to Humanae Vitae that 23 per cent either did not understand it or had no opinion, about 33 per cent agreed with it and 45 per cent disagreed. So, although the authorities of the Roman Catholic Church have a clear preference in the matter of legislation as they have indicated, while leaving the decision entirely to the legislators, the views of the Church in terms of the members of the Church on this issue, at least as far as married women are concerned, are not even on the moral issue—never mind the legal issue— consistent with the views expressed by the leaders of the Church. I do not think that should compel us one way or the other, but it is a point worth noting.
The final consideration which we should take into account in deciding our attitude on this general question before I come to the legislation itself, is the impact of what we do or say, or do not do or say, on the situation in Northern Ireland. It would be wrong to say that this is a major issue in the minds of people there; wrong to say that if we take a particular decision on this Bill or on the broad issue of contraception, that even if we remove all constraint on contraception it would have a significant effect on people's attitude in Northern Ireland or would bring peace there perceptibly nearer. To assert that would be to assert an extravagance. What is, however, clear is that the rejection of access to contraception would tend to confirm hostile views and would have an adverse affect on opinion there. In so far, therefore, as this issue is one that is significant the balance clearly lies with taking action to make contraception available in the Republic in view of opinion in Northern Ireland, although this is a very minor element by comparison with the three other considerations I have put.
To sum up—the Supreme Court has asserted very clearly that the availability of contraceptives for married people, at any rate, is a human right : the public morality argument is a valid one in principle but on the practical facts it does not seem to me to stand up and carry the weight and the burden that is being put on it by those who are pressing it. The people seek a change in the law regarding availability of contraceptives for married people because, as I said, the figures are very compelling. In the Wilson-Davis survey something like 63½ per cent favoured them for married people only, rather more than half wanted them on prescription only while 21½ per cent would be in favour of them only in cases of medical need and only 8 per cent of all the married women concerned thought they should be available to everybody. Admittedly these were the views of married women. The views of single women might be different but it is the one indication we have of the views on the particular point of legislation regarding confining contraceptives to married people. It seems a strong view and had we an indication of opinion over a wider range of women in the child-bearing age groups, it is unlikely that we would have a reversal of that view. It seems fairly clear that there is a strong opinion in favour of the limitation of contraceptives to married people. Whether that is practicable is another question. I am dealing with the question of what people want.
With regard to my fourth point, it is my belief that the rejection of the availability of contraceptives would do damage in so far as Northern Ireland is concerned. Therefore, had there not been the Supreme Court decision and if we were now deciding whether to leave the law as it is or whether to change it, I think the balance of argument would be strongly in favour of change.
I have gone on at some length on that because so many people are still arguing that issue. Although it is not an immediate issue, the counter-argument needed to be put clearly and, I hope, with some cogency. The Supreme Court has taken a decision and we must ask ourselves whether we leave the situation as it is or whether we legislate and, if we legislate, how? It would be undesirable to leave a situation where instead of the availability of contraceptives to married people who consider it necessary to have access to them there would be every incentive for people outside the country, perhaps, in conjunction with people inside the country, to promote contraceptives by way of a direct mail campaign of a kind the Minister for Justice has outlined in this House. That is an undersirable situation. I do not consider it desirable that young people, old people, or unmarried people should be subjected to literature through the post urging them to make use of contraceptives. This is a source of scandal to people and they should be protected from it but legislation is required to afford them that protection. The question is : What kind of legislation?
First, the legislation has to determine through what outlets contraceptives should be made available. It is my opinion that even if the outlets were not restricted the evidence of Northern Ireland suggests the high improbability of serious abuse or public scandal within the country. Nonetheless, there is the evidence of this campaign from outside. Perhaps there would be unscrupulous people here, too. who would seek to publicise contraceptives domestically. Therefore, there is a case for a restriction of outlets and the principle restriction seems to be to chemists' shops. These premises are to be found throughout the country, they are easily accessible and people turn easily to them for other requirements of a medical or cosmetic character.
It has been suggested from the other side of the House that contraceptives should be made available through health clinics. If I understand the suggestion correctly it advocated the setting up of health clinics for this purpose. It would seem an unnecessary complication to begin establishing special clinics for this purpose. The existing availability of clinics is not anything like the availability of chemists' shops so that from the point of view of carrying out the spirit, the intention and the letter of the Supreme Court decision, access through chemists' shops seems to be the more sensible course to adopt. A point one could consider is whether contraceptives might be available also through health clinics. However, to confine them to health clinics would be unduly restrictive and could make it more likely that even the restrictions on sale that we would have then could be overruled by the Supreme Court. However, these are Committee Stage points and I hope this Bill reaches Committee Stage.
The other point is to whom contraceptives should be available. It is argued from the other side of the House that it would be unenforceable to restrict them to married people. I accept that and on the whole I would prefer to have legislation which could be enforceable but there is evidence that our people have a strong preference for confining them to married people. Perhaps our people may not understand fully the difficulty involved in doing this but when we come to legislate in this way we are entitled to take into account what is public opinion. If contraceptives are confined to married people, even if this is not enforceable, the Bill will go some distance towards meeting what appears to be a strongly held view of our people. I do not hold a strong view on this but it is possible to defend the inclusion of this limitation on democratic grounds. May I say that in this controversy a number of people on the liberal side as well as people on the other side have at different points shown not very much regard for the question of democracy. Some of the criticisms of the Bill from the liberal side have suggested that we should have no regard for what people want but that we should give them what liberal opinion thinks they should have. On the conservative side the view seems to be that no matter what people want they should not have it. Our task here, unlike that of the liberal or conservative people, is to try in some way to respond to public opinion. I am not enthusiastic about an unenforceable ban on the sale of contraceptives to other than married people but that reflects public opinion. However, I would not be unduly upset if that particular element of the Bill were to disappear. I would appeal to the other side of the House who are not strongly represented at this moment—I mean in number rather than on the question of calibre——
Comment on this
——to think again about what they propose to do because a decision to reject the Bill and to Whip people to do so is clearly a political act. The arguments put forward from the other side of the House are unconvinving to the point of being ridiculous. The Bill may contain elements which some people have found humorous in some respects. This is because of the difficulty of trying to enact legislation in this area while responding to the needs of the situation, meeting human rights and providing for the genuine requirements of public morality and of public opinion, but the argument from the other side of the House is a lot more ridiculous than anything that is contained in the Bill. Their attitude of voting down a Bill because it contains some elements which they do not like is a negation of parliamentary democracy. The whole way in which we legislate here is that when a Bill is brought in, either it is something that is trying basically to do the right thing but may not in detail be well expressed, in which case the Opposition agree to its Second Reading but fight it on Committee Stage, or it is a Bill which is so objectionable in principle to the Opposition and which goes so much against their whole philosophy, that they vote it down on Second Stage. Nothing said on the other side of the House suggests that this Bill falls into that category. The criticisms of the Bill have been Committee Stage points and could not warrant honestly a rejection on Second Stage, particularly since this is the one Bill that the Opposition have such a good opportunity of amending.
In the ordinary way on Second Stage when there are strong differences of opinion, when the Whip would be applied on both sides, the Opposition might say that they would vote against the Bill concerned on Second Stage since they probably would not get very far on Committee Stage. I hope this Government have shown their willingness, as did a number of Ministers in the previous Government, but not all, to accept amendments from the Opposition. In this instance this eminently amendable Bill is the one Bill that the Opposition have every chance to amend because of the fact that there is a free vote on this side of the House. Any Opposition amendment put down to achieve the results proposed there would surely find some like-minded Deputies on this side to support it. It would be difficult to resist Opposition amendments in such circumstances. If the matter is left open there is every chance of the Bill being modified if a majority in this House wish it to be modified. Therefore, there are no grounds whatever for rejecting this Bill on Second Stage. It would be a dishonest political act to do so and would be playing games with a matter of serious public policy involving human rights and public morality. It would not be an honourable act by the Opposition to play politics so far as this Bill is concerned and it would not be sensible politically for them to do so. Their argument is one that will not be accepted easily on this side of the House. Their argument that we should not have allowed a free vote is disgraceful. It turns democracy on its head.
I have some difficulty in accepting the conventions of the democratic parliamentary system under which one is Whipped to vote, regardless of whether one is in favour of the issue involved, but to turn that on its head and to say that one must always do so and that it is wrong morally to allow a free vote, that it is wrong to allow people to vote according to their consciences, is a proposition which should not come from the other side of the House.
We at times in the past have accused Fianna Fáil of being authoritarian. I frankly never thought they would be as authoritarian as that and I do not think they are, either. I do not think it is because of a genuine authoritarian view that free votes are immoral that this line is being taken. It is being taken because of a curious and rather childish belief that if they can defeat the Bill it will in some way damage the Government. The one thing you cannot do is bring down a Government by defeating a Bill on a free vote. The Constitution does not provide for that. Any embarrassment in the defeat of the Bill will rest on the other side of the House. We will have done our best to bring in legislation. It may have defects but defects easily remediable, readily remediable on Committee Stage.
We have done our best to bring in a Bill. We have allowed our people to vote in accordance with their consciences. It seems to me to be a minimum right of a Deputy in a matter which pre-eminently involves moral issues. Moral issues may not bother people so much on the other side. I do not know. It may be that they have a different approach. As far as we are concerned, we have tried to bring in a Bill which reflects the needs of the situation, which guarantees the human right involved, which protects public morality, which reflects public opinion. Whatever defects the Bill has, they arise because of trying to do these three things at once. Perhaps we are trying to do too much. It is an honest attempt.
We have allowed a free vote on our side of the House to allow for people's consciences. That has not met with a response on the other side of the House. I hope it may yet. I hope that before the Bill concludes the Opposition may reconsider their position because I would look forward to a Committee Stage debate on this Bill in which there would be free votes and in which the Bill might in some respects be amended. I would listen to everything that was said on the different issues with an open mind and would be willing to join with others in amending the Bill if a good case was made for it. Therefore, I appeal at this late stage to the Opposition to reconsider their position. It does them no credit. It does Parliament no credit. It is not going to do the country any good.
Comment on this
Acting Chairman, your presence in the Chair prompts me to repeat a remark made to me upstairs in one of the offices by a lady. She said that if instead of having 141 men and three women in this House, there were 141 married women —and the word "married" was stressed—and three men this thing could be dealt with very quickly and logically and there would be no problems.
This is a political assembly and we represent political parties. I want first of all to put a political question to the Government. Why did the Government suddenly change their minds two days after the debate on Northern Ireland and introduce this Bill to be taken last week after agreement had been reached for the Order of Business for last week and bearing in mind that the Government had not included this Bill as part of the Order of Business? Because, at that time— last Friday week—the Government must have known that if the Bill passed the Second Stage which is now being debated it could not possibly get through Committee Stage. I would think this would be so because if the Bill did reach Committee Stage there would be bound to be a lot of amendments from all sides of the House since it is a Bill that not only has a party political aspect to it but has an individual aspect and amendments would reflect individual views.
As I see it, this could only mean that the Government anticipated that the Committee Stage could not come up sooner than the next session which, although it is not yet fixed, would be in or around mid or late October. I am rather puzzled to know what the Government have in mind because as a member of the Opposition front bench I have been very much aware in the past couple of weeks of efforts on the Government side to get agreement for an adjournment on the 19th, that is tomorrow week. So, it does not seem to me that it would have been possible to get this Bill through all its Stages in this session.
This means that if, as I anticipate, the Bill is defeated on this Stage it would make little or no difference to the present position regarding the contraceptive issue since no legislation could be put through the House before possibly November-December of this year.
On that question which has been mentioned by a number of speakers on the Government side, I do not see a great problem on the Government side if the Bill is defeated. The Government's function is to secure the passage of necessary legislation through this House and if it emerges that there is not support for this particular piece of legislation then the Government's responsibility still remains to bring in a Bill that will get the necessary support. It may be felt that for the Opposition to defeat this Bill would be in some way wrong, as implied by the Minister for Foreign Affairs, but I would say, looking at the thing from a practical point of view, that this debate itself, including the Minister's contribution that he has just made, is a part of the beginning of a process of education in regard to this problem which is badly needed in this country. I say that having in mind the numerous letters that I along with other Deputies have received in which there seems to be a complete misunderstanding of at any rate the legal situation in relation to the contraceptive issue.
This morning some speakers on the Government side seemed to think that speakers on this side of the House were misleading them by appearing to support the Bill and winding up their contributions by saying that they were going to oppose it. So, I will begin by saying that my party have decided not to support this Bill because we believe and are advised that it is unworkable and will not fulfil the necessary purpose and the purpose, as we understand it, is not control and importation, sale and manufacture, but rather is the control of distribution of contraceptives.
I see it as the function and responsibility of the Government to introduce necessary legislation and it is the function of the Opposition to support and/or amend or oppose legislation. The reasons for opposition might be opposition in principle or opposition to a Bill because we believe it to be unworkable and not capable of amendment so as to make it what we would support.
Personally I do not approach this Bill from the point of view of opposition in principle but I believe that we as an Opposition are entitled to treat this Bill as we would treat any other. Referring back to speeches made this morning I would say that the motives attributed to us by members of the Government, and particularly by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs as expressed earlier today, are their conclusions only and are as likely to be wrong as right. They are expressions of political opinions and conclusions and no more than that.
For example, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said this morning that we can let this Bill survive and amend it in Committee. I understood him to ask the Opposition spokesman on Foreign Affairs to deal with that side of it and I am not sure that he did. We have been advised that the Bill as presented, if it were allowed through to the Committee Stage, would not be capable of amendment because what has been put forward by our spokesman on Health involves a radical change in the Bill itself. Consequently, if it reaches Committee Stage, I am advised it cannot be amended. I am not a lawyer and I am merely giving an opinion passed on to me.
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said we should consider the effect defeat of this Bill may have on relations between Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach said we will never hear the end of it if this Bill is defeated. These are merely speculations. It may be that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach have been talking to different people than I or that the nature of the questions put by either of us was different. This is merely legislation which is necessary and is being introduced following the Supreme Court decision. I do not believe it can become law before the end of the year nor do I believe it can be an issue in Northern Ireland. As a result of my frequent visits to Northern Ireland over the past ten years I have come to the conclusion that many of the people there are inclined to be a lot more rigid in these matters than we are.
If this Bill is rejected, and my party have decided to oppose it as it is presented, it will be because we see it as bad legislation, however well intentioned, and not adequate to fulfil its purpose. I acknowledge that the Government have at least made an effort to fulfil their responsibility by introducing the Bill although this Bill is unworkable. I also believe that the Government are weak in allowing a free vote. The Minister for Foreign Affairs referred to this but in my view it is the Government's responsibility to put forward legislation and have it passed. I see a considerable difference between a free vote and a recognition that there may be some Deputies who consider it a matter of conscience not to support a Bill of this kind although I find it difficult, as I am sure the Minister does, to understand how conscience comes into this question because the purpose of the Bill is to impose restrictions where there are none. I am satisfied that legislation is necessary to control the distribution of contraceptives. Here I echo what the Minister said last week that the Supreme Court decision means that there is now no effective control over the distribution of contraceptives. Certainly up to the week before last I had the feeling that the great majority of people did not understand this. The people who wrote to me did not know it.
In connection with the general principles of controls in a question of this nature the majority of people in the Republic, and in the North, expect the civil authority to set a good public moral standard or example. They expect the legislators to be seen to be discouraging rather than encouraging permissiveness. They expect the State to carry some of the responsibility for the protection of young people from commercial exploitation in this area. In my view this is the feeling of the majority of people here. From the questions I have posed I am satisfied that this is certainly the view of all parents. All parents agree that there should be some form of control over distribution so far as young people are concerned during their formative years of adolescence and until they reach maturity when discipline and self-restraint have developed.
I believe the State is obliged in the public area to provide some means to ensure that contraceptives are not freely available to be commercially exploited to the detriment of young people. It is my opinion as a citizen that neither the State nor any Church has the right to make matters of private conscience such as relations between married couples the subject of legislation, particularly criminal legislation. A marriage contract is between a man and a woman and the Churches and the State are merely assistants or witnesses to that contract. In effect marriage is the oldest institution in the world which existed before any State or Church was heard of.
I do not believe there can be any question that the State can, in any circumstances, have the right to legislate for or against sin. It is a matter for the individual and primarily between him and his God. It is a matter for the individual, if he or she is a member of a Church, to accept the guidance and advice that may be given. The State has no function here and should not have. It is worth repeating that no legislation in the moral area should be criminal legislation directed against the individual in his or her private life. There may be a good case for legislation to deter anyone from engaging in commercial exploitation in the distribution of the means of corruption. That type of legislation could be criminal legislation.
Deputy Thornley referred to the existing social situation and to the undesirable side of it. In the public area the civil authority are bound to have regard to the danger by omission of encouraging permissiveness. I do not like referring to statistics but it is significant that the statistics for illegitimate births in this State are in the region of 2,000 per annum for many years past. The figure has been in this region for many years. Statistics recorded in London, I do not know if they are correct, show that many hundreds of women giving their names and addresses as being from this country seek abortions in clinics in that city. From the point of view of the public authority I do not think that we can afford to close our eyes to the existence of that sort of thing.
The public authority seem to me to have a responsibility in regard to what happens to the individual particularly if one takes the example of 2,000 illegitimate births in this country, and considers the consequences to the individual concerned particularly in situations where an unfortunate girl who has not meant any harm may be disowned by her parents and thrown out. One does not wish to visualise the subsequent consequences to that unfortunate individual for the remainder of her life.
It is for reasons such as this that I believe the public authority have a right to try to legislate in an intelligent and practical way. One of the suggestions made on this side of the House as a practical alternative was that the problem could best be solved by the health boards or by committees set up under them. It seems to me that such committees would be well suited to fulfil the very good objectives that are behind the Bill put forward by the Minister and also to do something that is not included in the Bill—whether it is the function of the State or not is another question— that is to provide education on natural as well as artificial means of contraception. I believe, and I am speaking now as a politician who has been talking to people, that something of that kind would find ready acceptance on the part of many people.
Finally I should like to refer to a question which has been mentioned in letters to the Press and was mentioned by the Minister for Foreign Affairs today, the question of a referendum. I have not heard any arguments in relation to the idea of a referendum in connection with this which would convince me that any majority has the right to impose religious or moral beliefs on any minority. Consequently I, and I am speaking personally, would be opposed to any idea of either the Government or the Opposition trying to evade their responsibilities by putting a referendum to the electorate on this question.
Comment on this
I heard a portion of Deputy Flanagan's speech and I appreciate that he solemnly believes what he said. If people feel that way about a Bill which does not deal with economic matters I do not see why we should not have a free vote. I think we are correct in having a free vote. I do not agree with Deputy Flanagan's point of view. The arguments he used while I was listening to him could have been used for voting for the Bill. At the moment we have no Bill to allow contraception but since the Supreme Court decision one can import contraceptives but cannot sell them. Deputy Flanagan mentioned alcoholism.
Alcoholism is reckoned to be caused by people having too much time on their hands or by worry. One often sees businessmen becoming alcoholics because of worry. How many women become alcholics because they have too many children and cannot cope? How many people are admitted to mental hospitals for the same reason? How many broken homes are there because of too many children? That is not always the reason. There are various other reasons. Child neglect is another aspect. I would have used all those arguments of Deputy Flanagan's in support of the Bill.
I know of one area in my constituency where there are a number of women with six or seven children whose husbands are in jail. We have the problem of bad housing. In many cases these women can hardly read a document which would tell them where they can get help. They go to their local Deputy, the parish priest or the social worker. They themselves come from big families in the same circumstances. It is not so much the large family that is the problem as the large family in which the children are like steps of stairs. This is why women become alcoholics and husbands leave or go into jail.
Deputy Flanagan also mentioned the huge increase in venereal disease where contraceptives are used. The fact is that where the pill is used venereal disease has increased but where the the condom is used it has decreased because it is a safeguard to an extent against VD. According to certain people the whole moral fibre of this country will be upset because we are legislating in regard to where contraceptives should be sold. We are coming back to the old idea. There is only one sin in Ireland, sin against the sixth commandment. There is no other sin according to the Irish. Honesty? Forget it. Charity? Forget it. We are not interested. There are many other commandments more important than the sixth.
The position is that prior to the case in the courts the pill was available and was used by a tremendous number of married and single women. Nobody knows the exact percentage, whether it was one in two or one in three, but it was used by a tremendous number. Condoms came in from the North of Ireland and from England. There was no trouble. Some were brought in for personal use and some for sale. In fact it is well known in Dublin that the "Enterprise" was known as the "Durex Express". It is a question of getting them across the Border rather than having them under control here. It is well known that a woman can have a contraceptive coil fitted by going to England. If one crosses over the Border one will get it on the national health. In this country many doctors will operate on a woman to make sure she will have no more children. If she has a number of children already he can use it as an excuse and say that she has got to the stage where it would be dangerous to have any more.
People and pressure groups wrote to me for and against this Bill. I answered each one and I told them that I would answer finally when the Bill was introduced. I told them I would vote for it. I knew some of the people. Two single women, aged about 55, wrote to me and said that contraception was wrong. They have voiced their opinion but I do not think they should become part of a pressure group to dictate to people what way to vote when they have not got the experience married women have. I also feel that people of a generation ago had to face a different way of life from that which young people have to face today. It may be better today but there is more pressure.
There have been arguments by Deputy O'Malley and Deputy Colley and by the Minister and other Deputies on this side of the House in relation to the McGee case. They took different meanings out of what the judges said. We all know that if you can import contraceptives the day must come when they must be sold here. All that has to happen is for somebody to take an action and he will get permission to buy them. I do not think anybody can disagree with that. It is imperative for the Government to legislate where they are sold, how they are advertised and where they are advertised. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said last week that contraceptives should be sold by chemist shops to everybody. He also pointed out the case of people who live together for six or seven years and believe in their own minds they are married. As far as I can remember, when I was at school I was taught that the priest is only a witness at the marriage ceremony, that if a couple were on a desert island and lived together all they needed to say was they wished to get married and they were married. The priest just solemnises the marriage. It is very wrong if two people think they are married and want contraceptives but are not allowed have them.
I would like this Bill to go a little further. I would like it to control advertising. I would like contraceptives to be obtained in chemist shops only. I would not like to see them going through the post where there is a chance of their getting into the hands of young people. I am for the Bill. I would like married couples to be able to buy contraceptives and I would also like anybody over 21, whether married or unmarried, to be able to buy them. They have then come to an age where they can make up their own minds what they want to do. We should also keep them from the young. Is it not stupid for a Government or the Church to make a law saying that a man 50 or 60 years of age cannot get contraceptives if he wants them? We are treating him like a child if, for instance, he is a divorced man. You cannot control a man, after he reaches a certain age, for the rest of his life. The State should not have a right to say you must be a Catholic or a Protestant or that you cannot have contraceptives. There should certainly be an age limit and we should not allow them to be given to people under that age.
I do not think we are a contraceptive nation. While we are thinking of selling contraceptives to married couples only I have a feeling we might be selling them to a married man for extra-marital reasons. We should certainly control where contraceptives are sold. We do not want to end up with the position like it is in other countries where you can get contraceptives out of a slot machine the same as you can get a packet of Smarties or a bar of chocolate. They are wrong to have this in those countries and it would be very wrong to have them sold in that way here.
I am a father of six children and I can say that no parent wants his children in their teens to be able to get contraceptives freely. We should be honest about this. Which would parents prefer to find out, that their children had used contraceptives, that their daughter was pregnant or their son had made a girl pregnant? In some countries people boast about having illegitimate children but in this country a girl who has an illegitimate child is an outcast. People point the finger at her. That is the reason why many girls who become pregnant have abortions. There is no charity in this country at all. Some people even laugh at girls who have had illegitimate children and boast how they got away with it themselves.
I have heard the speeches of most Fianna Fáil Deputies. They are not prepared to agree with this Bill. They want contraceptives provided through the health authorities. If that was to be done some people in those health authorities would know who had got them. Deputy O'Malley said that if they were made available through chemist shops only the gombeen man in the different towns would know the number of times a particular man had intercourse. In health authorities the whole office would know who had received them. I prefer contraceptives to be given out by chemist shops or doctors rather than having the health authorities knowing who got them.
Comment on this
The Deputy should bear in mind there are only two or three people employed in a chemist shop. Deputy O'Malley knows nothing at all about the working of the Mid-Western Health Board. I have been a member of it since it was formed and before that when it was a health authority. We employ between 200 and 300 people and a chemist shop only employs about three people.
Comment on this
When the President was Minister for Health he said he had everything worked out and that he would set up family clinics and contraceptives could be got there. Deputy O'Malley said that a chemist shop in the West of Ireland may not have contraceptives. What about the health authority in the west? They come in from Westport and Ballina to Galway to collect them. It has been said that chemists will not sell them. At the moment chemists are selling the pill and there is no bother about it.
With a free vote on the Government side, Fianna Fáil should have a free vote. I believe that 90 per cent of all parties are for the Bill. On Committee Stage they can put down whatever amendment they like and they could be voted on again on a free vote. They want to play politics and defeat this Bill and perhaps bring in their own Bill and try to get something out of it. I do not believe there are any votes in this. You might lose a few votes for talking about it or you might gain a few if you kept your mouth shut. The parties should get together and get this Bill through. Perhaps this subject has been discussed too much over the past couple of years but perhaps no Bill would have been brought in without a little pressure.
Men have been discussing a problem which is 90 per cent a woman's problem. Men have a part in it but a woman lives with it. It is a part of her nature. She has to bear the children. She has a monthly period. She becomes pregnant. She has morning sickness for three months. She carries the child for nine months with all the risk of a miscarriage. She is thinking of the child all the time. The child may be born dead. Consider the sorrow and depression that go with that. She has the pain of childbirth. She has to build up her health before and afterwards. The husband who causes the pregnancy visits her in the nursing home and goes out and gets drunk. He celebrates for a week when a child is born. Women are involved, not men, and men are laying down the law for women.
To me contraceptives are a method of spacing families. Within a couple of months after a child is born very often the woman is pregnant again. I heard a story the other day. If a Catholic has nine children people say: "That is a big family", but if a Protestant has nine children people say: "My God, he is a sex maniac". Catholics are expected to have large families, particularly those in the poorer class. I know parents who had eight or nine children in the same number of years. Must we not be worried about their health? Are we just to play politics? I believe that in the case of a fairly large family there should be a reasonable spacing to allow the mother to build up her health.
Some people intend to vote against contraception but we have contraception at the moment. I believe the pills should be available for people who want them. I suppose that one in three women are on the pill and we are talking about contraception. We are afraid to admit that doctors are prescribing the pill. We are afraid to legalise what is already happening. The question now is will they allow in condoms and other contraceptives. I see nothing wrong in making them available to people over 21 whether they are married or not. I go a little further than the Bill goes. I object to having contraceptives going through the post or having them on display in slot machines or advertised in the papers or on television.
If you have a party of several people a large number of women in that group are on sedatives, usually librium. They are suffering from their nerves because they have too many children and they are not able to control them because they are all more or less the same age and one cannot mind the other. Would it not be better for those women to have spaced their children better? How many women have nervous break-downs? After two or three births, with the pace of modern life, many women have a nervous breakdown and have to go into hospital and get electric treatment. I believe that is appalling, but it has to be done. They are sedated and their brain is shocked. This is happening because of the pace of life and because they have too many children. They are frightened because they cannot control their children.
This Bill should be accepted. It could be amended and made harder or more liberal. There should be an age limit for married or unmarried men and women who can buy contraceptives. I back this Bill so far as it goes. There is also the question of the number of wage earners compared to non-wage earners. In England it is something like 2:4 or 2:3; in Germany it is 2:5; and in Ireland it is 1:7. These are approximate figures. That is an economic factor. I am not putting it forward as an argument.
I would not in any way be for abortion. I am completely against it. People have sent literature to me and I have sent back letters asking them how they connect contraception with abortion. I am all for spacing children. As regards pornography, there is nothing wrong with it provided it does not get into the wrong hands. I will conclude by asking the Fianna Fáil Party to vote for the good of this country and not for party politics.
Comment on this
Seeing that there is such fire and brimstone around this House today, I would suggest that we would have an investigation by architects and engineers to find out if the building is structurally sound, because there is a likelihood that the place will go up in flames. I would make that suggestion to you, Sir, that you order this investigation bearing in mind——
Comment on this
There is another Deputy to contribute to the discussion.
Comment on this
At this stage of the debate the arguments for and against the acceptance of this Bill have well and truly been made and it will be difficult to avoid repetition. The subject we are debating is a very emotional one, but it is also a very serious one. It is one which poses great difficulty and much uncertainty for many men and women and, I expect, for many Deputies.
As the debate proceeds there is evidence of very real objection in principle to the fact that a Bill of this nature is before the House. By and large, Deputies have a reasoned approach to this and recognise that, following the Supreme Court judgment, such legislation is necessary. They realise that the law in relation to contraceptives has been changed anyway in spite of anything this House might or might not do. The net result of the Supreme Court findings is that all laws prohibiting the sale of contraceptives, including their importation for sale, remain in force, but now there is nothing in the law which bans the importation of contraceptives for any other reason than for sale. This has been said in the Minister's speech and no doubt it has been repeated during the day. Certain Members of this House, and maybe people outside it, wax very emotional on this and tend to disregard that fact.
Contraceptives are available on mail order, a black market is building up, and some of us Deputies are aware from evidence which relates to us personally that children in the 12 and 13 age group are capable of obtaining contraceptives by mail order. I have heard some cases where this has been done with the consent of the parents just to ascertain that such was possible. We have no guarantee that it is not being done without the consent of the parents as well. That should carry great weight with those who are putting forward the case that no Bill of this kind is necessary.
This Bill is a sincere effort to control the situation I spoke about. It also takes cognisance of the fact that the court ruling declared unconstitutional that married couples, in the present situation, have not access to contraceptive devices. I do not think there is anybody in this House, even the Minister himself, who does not realise that the Bill has shortcomings. It is open to criticism, but surely the logical consequence of any criticism should be amendments on Committee Stage.
I have heard very good speeches from the opposite side of the House —in fact, an excellent speech from Deputy Brugha a few moments ago— in favour of this Bill. The only argument he advanced on behalf of his party against it was the fact that, though he thought it was necessary and met his requirements in all respects, they were advised legally that it was not capable of amendment. I am not a lawyer; I am certainly not very well briefed on what is capable or what is not capable of amendment. Provided the Bill is agreed in principle, even if it means deleting whole sections and substituting other sections, it is desirable to implement it.
Allegations have been made here that the Bill is impractical and not capable of being enforced. Some people maintain it is too restrictive. Others that it is not restrictive enough. Many of these arguments are made seriously, and I would suggest that this is a situation in which we should get together and enact the best legislation and not play party politics. No Bill on such an emotive topic could meet every Deputy's viewpoint. I do not think this Bill aspires to that, but it is an honest attempt to put forward a consensus of the views of this House.
What this measure purports to do is to regulate the importation, the sale and the manfacture of contraceptives, as its title indicates. It endeavours to do this in a way that will give reasonable access to contraceptives to married couples while safeguarding public morality, and it does its best to interpret the will of the majority of the people as well. What this Bill does is to give access to contraceptives to married couples who have no conscientious objection to their use. It will not oblige anybody to use them. This matter is of great importance to women. Any woman who, because of her religious beliefs or who for any reason whatsoever does not want to avail of what this Bill makes accessible, is not obliged to avail of them. That is as simple as could be.
It is conceded by all, Church and State, that family planning is the sole right of the husband and wife. The Protestant religions in this country have made their point of view known. The Catholic Church condemns the use of artificial methods, officially anyway. Any Church is entitled to declare its viewpoint on this subject and to lay down norms of conduct for the people who subscribe to the beliefs of that Church. However, the method employed in relation to family planning is a matter of private morality, and while the Church may advise, I take the point completely that the State has no function in that regard and has no right to interfere in the private morality of a married couple. In fact, Article 41 of our Constitution, which was quoted freely here today, guarantees the husband and wife against invasion of their privacy by the State.
All that has been decided for us by the McGee case. All that is at issue for us here in this House today is the form of the Bill, the extent of the availability of contraceptives, their sale and so on. On that, by and large, we agree in principle. We can debate the form of the Bill and discuss the various sections in Committee. I endorse some of the points raised today. I endorse the suggestion that some advisory and educational service should be provided, that it should be a feature of this Bill. I agree that some provision might be made for that on Committee Stage, and that is the place to do it.
I see the difficulty the Minister has, I see the difficulty many Deputies have in relation to, for instance, the outlet selected for the provision of contraceptives to married couples and in relation to defining what is an abortifacient. This is an extremely difficult area. It is an area with which this Bill is making a serious effort to grapple and, from that point of view, the Bill deserves the full consideration of every Deputy to ensure that the best possible legislation is passed.
Everyone respects the conscientious objector but there is no place for playing politics with a measure like this. Opposition Deputies professed themselves in favour of the Bill and, at the same time, advanced as the only reason for their opposition to the present measure their assertion that the Bill was incapable of amendment. When one hears an argument like that advanced one immediately becomes suspicious. The Minister will probably be in a better position to challenge the Opposition on that argument than I am, but I cannot, quite honestly, accept that this Bill is a Bill incapable of amendment and I cannot accept the advice given to us by the Opposition on that score.
There is no place for emotionalism on this issue and a good deal of emotionalism has, unfortunately, been generated both inside and outside the House. For instance, today I heard an Opposition Deputy speak about the preservation of the quality of Irish life. A very worthy object and one about which we are all concerned, but he went on to wax eloquent about our athletic boys and comely maidens and one could not help thinking of the cruel treatment meted out by Irish society to those comely maidens who have the bad luck or are unfortunate enough to become unmarried mothers. That situation obtains in many parts of this country up to this very day. There is a great deal of hypocrisy in this area. The hypocrisy is not confined just to this Bill. It exists in all too many spheres of life in this country. We close our eyes to the facts which we do not want to admit. That can be said about those people who, wittingly or unwittingly, refuse to appreciate in the absence of a Bill of this kind a situation would obtain, and grow, in this country, a situation which they would be the last people who would wish to see it preserved.
I think everybody is convinced, as I am convinced, that there must be a Bill of this nature. I am convinced this Bill was brought in because it was clearly seen that the majority of the people want such a Bill. They want married people to have access to contraceptives. The Bill obliges no one to use contraceptives. The outlet,the restriction, and so on are matters that can be negotiated on Committee Stage. The Bill deserves mature consideration and that is something the public expect from us here in this House. Certainly married women of child bearing age expect that from us. Figures have been quoted and I want to remind Deputies that it is well to remember that 68 per cent of women in the child bearing age group wanted this law repealed. It has been repealed but, even had there been no High Court action, there would still be an onus on us to remember that 68 per cent of the women of this country want the legislation now before the House. I am not going into the reasons why 68 per cent of the women of child bearing age wanted the law repealed; suffice to say these are the people most directly concerned and these are the people to whom we should give prior considertion.
This House has a duty to debate this measure constructively. It affects intimately the lives of many of our people. He have a duty, whichever side we sit, to be constructive, to share views and not simply try to score debating points. There have been several appeals already made and I am now adding my voice to those appeals. I know the Opposition are not totally opposed in principle to this Bill and I appeal to them now to let this Bill go through to the Committee Stage, a Stage on which I hope many Members of the Opposition will have constructive criticisms and suggestions to make in a combined effort to improve the Bill. Only in doing that will we be sincere in discharging our duty to the people and, particularly, our duty to Irish women.
Comment on this
One of the difficulties in discussing this particular measure is the fact that Dáil Éireann, as currently constituted, is an almost totally male dominated Assembly. Added to that is the fact that the wives of most Members are beyond the child bearing age. This constitutes a difficulty in trying to assess objectively the views of Members on this matter. It is ironic that we have had only one woman Member contributing to the debate. I find that situation very, very sad. We have a male dominated Assembly deciding whether or not 41,000 women currently "on the pill" are acting criminally or otherwise. It is a unique experience for our Parliament to find itself in that kind of analytical situation. There are all the elements of a rather sick debate because of the peculiar structure of the House. Thus the attitudes reflected on this particullar issue.
I do not propose to refute the views of my fellow-backbencher, Deputy Oliver J. Flanagan. I listened painfully for almost three hours to Deputy Flanagan and I found myself in total disagreement with him. The innuendoes and the sweeping assertions made by him were certainly not the result of an objective analysis. One simply could not find oneself sympathetic towards his views and I doubt very much if the views of Deputy Flanagan are shared by very many people. They are certainly not shared by the bulk of the constituents I represent. They are certainly not shared by the very many people to whom I have spoken throughout the country.
I am not a medical doctor. I am not a social worker. I have no professional experience in advising people on the very fundamental issue of family planning. As a Member of Dáil Éireann, I have tried to assess as best I can the various arguments put forward over the years, and in particular over the past six months, about family planning, particularly in the context of the use of contraceptives. I have not come to my views lightly because of my upbringing and education. I do not accept the view put forward by the Hierarchy of the Catholic Church that contraception is intrinsically wrong and morally evil, even when it comes from so articulate a spokesman as Bishop John McCormack. He said that the Hierarchy regarded the use of contraceptives as morally unlawful. When he expresses these views this is where we part company. As a politician, I have tried to read as much as I can about this subject. I have discussed it with professional individuals who should know something about the subject and I consider I am as well equipped as the Bishop or anybody else to reach an informed judgment in conscience.
I have listened to the Fianna Fáil aberrations and consider them to be a kind of political idiocy. Deputy O'Malley suggested that the only alternative to the Government Bill was that the medical doctors, such as the district doctors under the various health boards, should issue prescriptions on so-called medical grounds. When he was caught on that point he immediately reverted to saying that prescriptions could be issued for contraceptives by health boards for social reasons. That kind of argument, even on the most superficial examination, does not hold water. It has been rejected by speakers on both sides of this House.
Deputy O'Kennedy followed suit by saying that contraceptives could be issued through the agency of the regional health boards but it would not be necessary to have prescriptions. I would like Fianna Fáil to make up their minds on their so-called alternatives because they have no alternatives. They have an "against" political strategy.
Deputy Andrews, my constituency colleague, can come in here and say he is perturbed that——
Comment on this
I have no need to misrepresent Deputy Andrews. I am fully aware of his views from Fianna Fáil ard-fheiseanna and constituency meetings.
Comment on this
If I wanted to berate Fianna Fáil I could say that their gyrations in Opposition to this Bill, to the role of Dáil Éireann and to the parliamentary institutions which they profess to respect, are dishonest. I have rarely met an Opposition which have so abdicated their responsibilities in relation to Government legislation.
Comment on this
It is not the function of the Government alone to put through legislation. It is the function of Dáil Éireann itself. This is a very important point. Otherwise, why have a deliberative assembly? Have Fianna Fáil nothing to offer except alternatives which the House will never discuss because they will vote against the Bill? Do not let anybody tell me that Deputy S. Flanagan, whose views in favour of contraceptives are well know, will vote according to his conscience this evening. Let nobody suggest that that sophisticated politician, Deputy Haughey, does not appreciate the dilemma of the Government. Who are we trying to cod? I do not want to name any more names.
In the past six months I personally interviewed a large number of Deputies from both sides of the House. I will not read out the list but there are at least 20 Fianna Fáil Deputies who have made it quite clear in the precincts of this House and in various symposia, debates and discussions in which I participated that they favour a change in the law.
Comment on this
I want to expose what I regard as arrant hypocrisy on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party who want to have a political strategy wherby they can console some Deputies by saying the Bill was a bit peculiar. With due respect to the Minister, I must say that I am not sure if this Bill is in all areas constitutional.
Comment on this
I regard Deputy Dowling as one of the 20 Deputies in favour. I challenge him to go out——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Deputy Desmond said I mentioned to him that I was in favour of the Bill. I did not. He is misleading the House. This is a deliberate lie.
Comment on this
I will make even more sweeping assertions. The President, Mr. Erskine B. Childers, when Minister for Health, favoured a change in this particular legislation.
Comment on this
He made it perfectly clear to the parliamentary party of which Deputy Dowling is a member that he was in favour of a change in the law. I have no desire to quote former Minister for Health although I know their views.
Comment on this
Before this debate gets heated in my opinion it would not be desirable or seemly to read out the 20 names.
Comment on this
Deputy B. Desmond is bluffing. He is the greatest bluffer in the House as everyone knows.
Comment on this
If Deputy B. Desmond in the course of his speech refers by name to Deputies who have not spoken and have not made their views known in the debate in this chamber, I will ask him to desist.
Comment on this
Deputy B. Desmond has a perfect right to give the number of Deputies who in his opinion will vote for or against the Bill. He has not mentioned, and I would not allow him to mention the names of Deputies who in his opinion would vote in favour of the Bill if they were allowed to do so. Will the Deputy please continue but with no names?
Comment on this
We will not ring the bell until the debate is over. Deputy B. Desmond is in the course of making a very interesting speech. There is no man better able to make an interesting and unprovocative speech than the Deputy. I would ask him not to provoke Deputy Dowling who is sensitive and has his rights.
Comment on this
I accept the views of the Chair. I will summarise the Fianna Fáil position as I see it. There are 22 Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party who would like to see appropriate amending legislation. There are about 46 Deputies on the Opposition side who would be opposed to any change. For example, I refer to Deputy Kitt who, this morning, assured us that the vote in favour of contraception was a vote against Eamonn de Valera. That Deputy would be included among the 46——
Comment on this
I presume the Deputy is referring to Deputy Flanagan who has already made his views very clear.
Comment on this
Having disposed of the views of the Fianna Fáil Party and, without commenting further on the sexual hang-ups of some of the Opposition speakers, such as Deputy O'Malley's preoccupation with fornication in the Republic of Ireland——
Comment on this
I wish to discuss the more serious issues in this debate. The first and the simplest reason why the House should legislate for public availability and sale of contraceptives is that the use of contraceptives—and the more broad question of family planning—is a fundamental human right. While this has been repeated by many Government spokesmen, it cannot be stressed too often. No legislator or group, whether in the majority or in the minority within the Republic, has the slightest right to deprive others of a fundamental human right——
Comment on this
That is nonsense. The world has existed for 1974 years without the Deputy telling it what to do.
Comment on this
Legislation is secondary to the fundamental human rights of people in this country. Dáil Éireann is secondary to the fundamental rights of the citizens, as enshrined in the Constitution. I found it appalling and somewhat frightening to find nuances within the Fianna Fáil opposition to the Bill, which suggest that the judgment of the Supreme Court should be set aside. When it comes to the fundamental issue of human rights in our society, any suggestion or implication that the judgment issued in the Supreme Court by Justice Walsh, Justice Henchy, Justice Budd and Justice Griffin, should not be implemented is frightening. This attitude can only lead in the long term——
Comment on this
The Deputy is only blustering. He wants to be interrupted so that there will be disruption in the House.