Control of Importation, Sale and Manufacture of Contraceptives Bill, 1974: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 105–240 of 240. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 1974 ›
It is disorderly to refer to a Member of the House in that fashion. If the Deputy finds it difficult to listen to what is being said by another Member, he has a way out. He may take that way out.
Comment on this
I apologise to the Chair if I have said anything about the Deputy. He is a man for whom I have great regard.
Comment on this
Any action by Dáil Éireann that would seek to circumscribe or refuse to implement the judgment of the Supreme Court is, in my opinion, incipient fascism. We are not the supreme authority in this country. In terms of legislative acceptance by the nation we must bow to the views of the Supreme Court. In all my life I have never heard or read such mealy-mouthed hypocritical reaction on the part of an Opposition towards the genuine efforts of the Minister for Justice to put into effect the situation as advised by the Supreme Court.
First, I would comment on some of the statements made by the Minister on Second Reading. The House should also take particular cognisance of the viewpoint given by the Minister for Justice which was obviously written with great care. At column 286 of the Official Report dated 4th July, he said:
The rationale of the Supreme Court judgment was to the effect that married couples are entitled not to have reasonable access to contraceptives denied to them and that the ban on importation was such a denial. The court did not go on to decide whether the ban on sale constituted such a denial but, having regard to what was said in some of the judgments, I would have little doubt that if a case were shown to the court that the total ban on sale meant that reasonable availability was not possible then that ban too would be found unconstitutional.
I think that this House must, therefore, not only take into account the actual findings of the Supreme Court but we must also, if we are to retain our credibility as a legislative institution, anticipate what we would regard as further constitutional blowing of holes in the existing legislation, as would undoubtedly develop if we refuse to anticipate the likely outcome of further constitutional action. On that basis, most certainly I think the Minister has an obligation, in his reply, to develop that point. But certainly Dáil Éireann has an obligation, as a minimum requirement, at least to pass this Bill in toto on Second Stage and amend it in Committee if necessary. In relation to several provisions of the Bill I am perturbed; I am not very convinced about the practicality of several sections and I am not very convinced about the constitutionality of several sections.
Certainly I would wish to retain these views and put them forward in the form of amendments because, although I hold the position of Government assistant Whip, and the Whip of the Labour Party, in a free vote situation I would regard myself as being entirely entitled to put down amendments to the Bill and to debate them with the Minister from a purely political point of view—in view of the fact that I am not an expert in this field—and to endeavour to tease out, as carefully as I could, the best course of action for amendment of the Bill. Therefore, I think the House has a fundamental obligation at least to ensure that we get that normal opportunity here to elaborate on the desirable amendments to the Bill itself.
In relation to the whole of the Bill, Deputy O.J. Flanagan suggested very strongly that all the indications were that this country would go to the dogs morally if we decided to pass this legislation. He suggested that the youth would suffer from an outbreak of permissiveness, the likes of which we have never seen in western Europe. Quite frankly, I think we should dismiss these thoughts from our heads in relation to this Bill because there is no objective evidence whatsoever available to any member of Dáil Éireann which would suggest that the inevitable outcome of this Bill would be a rampant outbreak of fornication in the country, a growing and rocketing incidence of V.D., for example, that there would be a major breakdown of marital relations, or that the youth would become, with the availability of contraceptives, sexually promiscuous and permissive to an abnormal degree. I think we in Dáil Éireann—so many of us ageing; many of us perhaps in a very perverse way rather jealous of youth—insult the common sense and intelligence of young people and particularly young married people, by implying that the change of legislation we are now advocating will turn them into some kind of raving sex maniacs. I use that kind of strong language because I had to suffer three hours of it from Deputy O.J. Flanagan when he berated us with that kind of extreme language.
In my experience—and I have had only one marriage; we have three children and I am most intimately involved with my family—Irish people are not like that. People do not live like that. People have not lived like that and are not likely to live like that. I hold the view sincerely that some of the very peculiar, traditionally ultra-puritanical, very puritanical throw-back sexual attitudes of many Irish people have been reflected in some of the contributions we have had in this debate. In many respects I think we are at a turning point in our history. I do not think we will have a debate like this ever again in the history of Dáil Éireann; I hope to God we will not, although I can assure the Opposition that if this Bill is thrown out there will be another Bill. That is my personal interpretation of what the Government may well have to do. The Government probably would have no option but to bring in further legislation. By then, of course, Deputy Jack Lynch may "grasp the nettle" and he may indeed decide to support the particular piece of legislation, having failed to get some common sense out of his Parliamentary Party on this issue.
I suggest sincerely, to those who have been so perverse in their opposition to this essential legislation, that they are reflecting social attitudes which are of the days gone by and which most certainly, by and large, we have put past us in attitudes to marriage, attitudes to young people and their sexual lives, attitudes to children within marriage and attitudes, in particular, to family planning. I must confess that I find it revolting and rather horrifying that the Deputies who come in here and wax so eloquently, so vehemently and emotionally about the dangers of contraception—when we have Estimates speeches on the Department of Local Government—do not say one word about the horror of alcohol in its effect on social attitudes. I would hazard a guess—and I am talking subjectively now; I have no evidence because I do not put forward any objective evidence—if I may indulge in some subjective speculation on human and social attitudes, that perhaps alcohol has contributed more to whatever degree of sexual promiscuity there may be, or to whatever degree of youthful permissiveness there may be in this country. I would suggest that the considerably high incidence of alcoholic consumption in this country probably influences social behaviour in relation to sexual attitudes far more than the availability of contraceptives. Certainly I hold the view, purely as a public representative, and meeting many married couples in regard to housing and social problems that the abuse of alcohol in marriage has created far more marital tension, far more human and family distress and has destroyed more children than the overwhelming assertion on the part of some Deputies that if we had contraceptives available the outcome would be far worse.
Many of those who turn the searchlight on the question of contraception should take into account these kinds of problems, for example, the availability of alcohol to young people and, I would say, the extremely permissive attitude in many families and many social gatherings towards alcohol and the outcome of excesses of alcohol on our community. And I do not suffer from any hang-up in relation to alcohol itself. I simply counter-pose that point as one which should indeed be considered because it can be held—and I can share the view of Senator John Horgan who put it, I think, appropriately in the Seanad debate on the Family Planning Bill—that it may well indeed be that alcohol could be a far greater stimulus, for example, to extra-marital sexual intercourse in our community than the availability of contraceptives. It is a view but I should like the House to consider it objectively. Of course, nobody in this House would dare to suggest that we should ban the importation of alcohol, the production of alcohol, the consumption of alcohol or, indeed, that we should prohibit the consumption of alcohol, for example, by single persons in our community. We would, of course, make a laughing-stock of ourselves in Europe on that basis and we have come perilously close in this debate to making ourselves the laughing-stock of Europe in relation to this issue.
I have found another social attitude very disturbing in this debate and particularly disturbing coming from the Fianna Fáil side. I have noticed an obsessional preoccupation with contraceptive devices, with contraceptive methods and the very word "contraception" itself, while I notice very little stress given to, and very little concern with or attempt at, an analysis of what would constitute a happy family, what could constitute a normal, stable and happy relationship between a man and a woman. There are of course some people who are not married and who live together. Such people do exist. Fianna Fáil may not be aware of it but it does happen in our society. Such people do live together and some live together happily.
It is one of the facts of life which we find it terribly difficult to legislate for because we choose to ignore the realities of life in many areas of our social living. This is the point that we have completely lost sight of in this debate, that in relation to family life, in relation to the advice we give to young people and the advice available within our educational institutions, there is the absence of family planning. It is not, therefore, just a question of definitions relating to abortifacients, to contraceptive devices; it is the wider absence within our community of sane, sound, professionally competent and trained advice to people on how to plan their families, how to space their families if they wish, and indeed, if necessary, advice to young persons before marriage and whether they marry or not. That is their privilege, and we as a Legislature have failed miserably in the context of our health services, our educational services, our social welfare services, to make provision for that fundamental necessity, that fundamental prerequisite to people living normal, happy, stable, democratic and secure lives in the community. There are very many people in our mental hospitals suffering from serious psychiatric side-effects because of the failure of our society to come to grips with this pressing need in our community and it is from that broader point of view that I certainly feel that the passing of this legislation is needed.
I detest and find sexually perverse the obsession within the Fianna Fáil Party with the intricacies of sexual activity. These, as we know, are but a very tiny part of what constitutes a human relationship, and a human relationship even in the Christian sense. I most certainly reject that kind of searchlight which has been so particularly directed in relation to Dáil Éireann and the feelings of many Deputies on this matter.
There have been suggestions that there are no pressures on Deputies to change their votes on this issue. It has been suggested that we have been entitled to make up our minds within the general views expressed by the Hierarchies of the different churches and within the viewpoints expressed in newspaper articles, and so on. Yet I find it strange that in the post this morning, I should receive—I do not normally buy the paper—The Irish Catholic of Thursday, 4th July, 1974, with the heading “Dáil Deputies on Trial”. Of course it contains the loaded comment in the editorial. I do not know who the editor is but he has my sympathy when he writes this kind of stuff. This is what he has to say in relation to those such as myself who would vote in favour of the Bill:
The Deputy who takes it upon himself to decide that he will vote in favour of the Bill even in the absence of a mandate to do so, cannot expect to win favour in the eyes of those whose support he will be seeking when election time comes around again.
I suppose The Irish Catholic next week will publish the names of all the Deputies who voted for and against and those mandated to abstain.
There is a new word in Dáil Éireann in relation to this Bill: people do not abstain, they fade, and we may see on the Fianna Fáil side a few faders by the end of the debate. That is the kind of stuff to which we have been subjected. I have received, through the post, material which I have had to ensure my children did not see. I have received large lurid photographs of the remains of abortion and the outcome of therapeutic operations. I have received these through the post from as far away as Canada, sent specially to me since I made my views known on this matter. These are the kinds of pressures which I hope, quite frankly, many Deputies will not respond to but which I find most disturbing in terms of trying to arrive at one's views on this matter.
There is a more subtle pressure. There is the suggestion on the part of the largest single Hierarchy in this country that Deputies should follow their consciences in this matter, but in so doing, must bear in mind the view of the Catholic Hierarchy, and I quote here a particular view, that of the Bishop of Meath, the Most Reverend Dr. McCormack, secretary to the Catholic Hierarchy, in a personal statement, that the bishops stood by their statement of last November, that contraception was morally wrong. He says:
The Hierarchy would regard the use of contraceptives as morally unlawful.
Within that statement of last November, there was the attempt to suggest that of course while the Catholic Hierarchy were conveying their view that contraception was morally wrong, they were in no way suggesting to Deputies that they should be unduly influenced by that particular view. As far as I am concerned, a statement in relation to contraception by the Catholic Hierarchy of this country is a political judgment. It is a moral judgment in so far as Bishops pronounce on moral matters but it is also a political judgment and as such, does inevitably bear on the minds of Deputies. It is rather disingenuous, to say the least, that this statement came in this manner because, as far as I am concerned, inevitably a substantial block of Deputies will regard that statement as a directive, a quasi-directive, a quasi-suggestion, that "You are free to do something which is immoral and of course you are free to take that political decision. So be it on your conscience and, of course, as a Member of Dáil Éireann you will be contravening the moral law".
This is the implication. This is the view that has been conveyed to Deputies by the Catholic Hierarchy and I for one do not accept that statement just as I reject emphatically the overtones of many of the statements made, particularly by the senior member of the Hierarchy, Cardinal Conway, in relation to contraceptives. I have found them to be unacceptable, more particularly when I found the parallels drawn on this subject between Northern Ireland Protestants, the Republic, a united Ireland and the other connotations which his Eminence managed to bring into debate.
As a Member of Dáil Éireann I would be very lacking in comment if I were not to say that in the past two years in relation to the statements made, particularly by the said gentleman, I have been increasingly perturbed that this kind of simplistic evasion of the rights of the minority in the Republic and of the minority in Northern Ireland should have been bandied about. I am sure a growing proportion of the community in the Republic would not disagree with me. If I have been harsh in these comments I frankly feel it is time we were harsh on such comments. There is very substantial pressure in relation to the views put forward.
Yet another pressure group seem to have plenty of money, with due respect to Deputy Oliver Flanagan who ranted and raved this morning about a couple of thousand pounds which the International Family Planning Association gave to the Irish fertility clinics. I think that association are a hell of a sight more reputable in international standing and in medical standing than the particular organisation mentioned by the Deputy and who have sent in a great deal of stuff to Deputies in this House. We have been bombarded with it. I received 90 letters in the past few months on this subject and I can produce these letters if any Deputy does not believe me. Some of the stuff I have received, particularly in relation to the rights of the minority in the community, has been nothing short of inverted racism. I will quote one section of a document which is headed "Can Protestants Survive Contraception?" I quote:
The minority position of Protestants in our State should rather dispose them to welcome a prohibition on contraception in order to preserve their numerical strength. They are heard to protest loudly and frequently against the decline in their number which they allege to be due mainly to the bringing up in the Catholic faith of the children of mixed marriages. This, however, is to wilfully ignore the greater loss which may have been caused by the surreptitious use of contraceptives by Protestants in recent decades. Mixed marriages in those decades were comparatively infrequent. Moreover, all the children born of such marriages might not have been born if the Protestant partners had married other Protestants, because in the wholly Protestant marriage contraceptives might have been used. Everybody but Protestant friends and acquaintances is well aware of the high proportion of Protestant couples without children or with one or two children where it can be reasonably assumed and is also known to be admitted that contraceptives have been used. Protestants therefore cannot reasonably object to a prohibition on contraceptives if they are genuinely concerned to maintain their numbers.
This is the kind of quasi-racism which has flooded into Deputies here and which I think has had some impact on Deputies and which certainly has given rise to some of the rather sick debates we have had here from some members of the Opposition.
There is a medical point which should be made and in this connection I should like to quote one distinguished medical correspondent, Dr. David Nowlan. It has been suggested by Deputy Oliver Flanagan and by other Deputies, notably Deputy Kitt, that involved in this are abortion and euthanasia. I thought Deputy Kitt would finish up with divorce and the devil knows what else. There has been a very strong suggestion in the Fianna Fáil approach by several of their utterly irresponsible Deputies that the introduction of contraceptives in this community will inevitably lead to abortion. The reason why I raise this issue is that there was in the Catholic Hierarchy's statement last November an implicit follow-through in relation to abortion. That statement did not deal exclusively with contraception but went on to infer grave concern about the allegedly growing incidence of abortion within these islands. Here one must endorse the view of Dr. Nowlan, which I share, that contraception is a means to prevent abortion and can be, and I quote:
most certainly a particular method by which any incidence of abortion could be reduced.
I ask this House if it has the moral courage to face, or if it cares a damn about, the fact that last year, and I believe the year before, more than 2,000 Irish women went to Great Britain and had abortions there? Where is the concern of the Opposition to ensure that the appalling and tragic plight of a woman in the Republic who would decide to go to England to have an abortion—would it be fair to suggest that if contraception were available in the Republic she would not have to go——
Comment on this
I emphasise the point made by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Cruise-O'Brien, this morning when he said— I hope I am not misquoting him— that the use of contraceptives was an integral part of preventive medicine. I share that view. I hope that we will take cognisance of that fact when we come to deal with the points made by many of the speakers.
It would be remiss of me if I did not pay a well-deserved tribute to perhaps the most outstanding Irish woman in the attempt to convince this male-dominated Assembly and the other equally male-dominated Assembly, the Seanad, of the need for family planning legislation. I refer —and I gather I cannot refer any further after that—to Senator Mary Robinson. I have been aware of her efforts and it can be said fairly that she has spurred on the Government——
Comment on this
——and where faint hearts have tended to develop she, by pressing a particular view in the Seanad ensured that we in Dáil Éireann were not lax in our duty in this regard. She made a distinguished contribution. There are many other notable individuals in our community such as Rev. Doctor Good whose views as a fellow Corkman I share on many aspects of religion and family life. I think that he also took the brunt of the commencement of this debate in our community. These people deserve a measure of support and thanks from the whole community.
I do not, and it would be quite wrong for any Deputy to suggest that we should particularise in relation to the precise use and best form of contraception for any given family. I have sufficient confidence in the medical expertise of Irish doctors who provide such medical assistance to accept their views on what is the best form of contraception for married couples or particular persons who wish to avail of contraceptives. One argument is implicit in a great deal of the Fianna Fáil argument and in a great deal of the propoganda showered into this House by those who say this Bill must be rejected. I refer particularly to the material we received—I am sure all Members are aware of it—entitled Is Contraception The Answer?, by a team of Catholic parents which went on to suggest in the document itself that there were available to Irish families various methods of family planning which could be used without any need to change the law, the rhythm method, the temperature method and the ovulation method. I have also read carefully the Papal encyclical on these matters and a good deal of material issued officially by the Catholic Church. I have read with even greater care the views of a fellow Corkman, Bishop Lucey and of gentlemen such as Senator Quinlan on, for example, the Billings method. I find in regard to their particular proposition regarding the so-called natural family planning methods of contraception that it is incredible that they would suggest that by virtue of using these methods there is an entirely Catholic, natural and one might even say, aesthetically acceptable and open form of contraception while they would run miles from the pill itself or any other form of contraceptive recommended by some medical advisers.
Without going into details I would regard the Billings method from what I have read of it—and I have read some very odd versions of it—as unacceptable. I would not care to be married to somebody who would avail of a clatter of thermometers and sticky labels on calendars and so on and find that we would mark up our diaries with punctual regularity and then decide, perhaps, as husband and wife that we should have sexual intercourse. To me the particular methods that are advocated widely as being natural methods of contraception are distasteful, aesthetically unacceptable and puritanical. I would like to have an explanation some time from a columnist—if I may name a particular columnist—such as Angela McNamara. My interpretation of marriage and human sexual relations —perhaps I am all wrong and suffer from some particular hang-up—cannot be reconciled with such methods. That is not my understanding of what constitutes human love and mutual respect and regard as human decision in relation to contraception or family life or even human life itself. Many of these methods advocated by many members of religious orders—and I have been assured by several priests that these are the methods that are quite natural and in accordance with the natural law—stem from a very unique, spiritual, clinical, cold, efficient interpretation of what should be, I presume, spontaneity in the human relationship between husband and wife.
I find in the kind of material that has come through my letter box and which has received widespread publicity and is vigorously promoted by some Deputies and notably by some Senators, especially Senator Quinlan, that it is also a question of iron self-discipline in implementing the precise procedure imposed and I find it as repulsive as the very reading of the proposition contained therein. Therefore this artificial spiritual distinction, this unique, classical, puritanical extension of what constitutes contraception in the eyes of some legislators and some advisers and so-called advisers on contraception is something which is certainly not based in many areas on human experience and is certainly open to question on grounds of medical efficiency and is, to say the least of it, codding some of the people some of the time but codding many all of the time in terms of contraception.
I have ranged somewhat wide of this Bill and I return to the point I made at the beginning. It would be a disastrous day for Ireland and above all for family life in Ireland and disastrous as regards giving advice and guidance to the young people if we in Dáil Éireann abdicated all responsibility and left it to the courts to decide. I find it disingenuous, if not slightly ingenuous, on the part of Deputy Colley to suggest that on the grounds of public morality contraceptives should be distributed through the health boards. He says this while accepting fully that Dáil Éireann should not interfere in the area of private morality.
This is what one might call another magnificent interpretation of the principle of subsidiarity in moralistic thought and in theological exactitudes at which we have become brilliant in this country but we are so cold about it that one would wonder whether a child had ever been born to a married couple. What is the precise distinction between public and private morality? Deputy O'Malley says that it is not the function of Dáil Éireann to legislate for fornication and permissiveness while saying at the same time, that if people wish to fornicate privately or to be permissive Dáil Éireann has no function in the matter. Fianna Fáil have, for one set of circumstances, a pre-occupation with public morality which, in the most intimate sense becomes private morality so that we are left with a confusion of thought from them on this issue.
The gyrations of which Fianna Fáil have been guilty during this debate will bring Dáil Éireann into disrepute if we do not face up to our responsibilities. Therefore we must restore the balance by providing a properly planned State subvented, voluntarily assisted, professional family planning service in our community. We should do that within a broad social framework. We should amend substantially the existing legislation in this regard. By so doing Dáil Éireann will recover the self-respect and the regard which the people had for this House but which have been eroded during this debate.
I thank God for the Supreme Court without whose judgment this House would never make up their minds on the issue before us. I implore the Opposition to pay heed to that judgment and in particular to the summing up of Mr. Justice Walsh who said that the sexual life of a husband and wife is, of necessity and by its nature, an area of particular privacy, that if the husband and wife decide by the use of contraceptives to limit their family or to avoid having children, that is a matter peculiarly within the joint decision of the husband and wife and is one into which the State cannot intrude unless it is an intrusion which can be justified by the exigencies of the common good. In conclusion, Mr. Justice Walsh said that the question of whether the use of contraceptives by married couples within their marriage is contrary to the moral code or to codes to which a couple profess to subscribe could not justify State intervention. Similarly, he said, the fact that the use of contraceptives may offend against the moral code of the majority of our citizens would not, per se, justify an intervention by the State to prohibit their use within marriage and that the private morality of citizens would not justify intervention by the State unless and until the common good requires it.
I ask Fianna Fáil, in conscience, to accept the validity of the assertion made by Mr. Justice Walsh in his judgment. I ask them at this late stage to indicate to the Minister—they can do this either through their spokesman on Justice or their spokesman on Health—that they are willing to reconsider this critical area of social family life in our community. Let them not make of this issue a spurious political football. That is what they have done during the course of this debate. If there are defects in the Bill, we can meet on them. The Minister is anxious to ensure that a fair democratic and reasonable piece of legislation goes through this House.
I will conclude, not on any note of threat or of recrimination against Fianna Fáil, by saying that if, for narrow, party political advantage, they decide to oppose this legislation or if they do so solely for the transient benefit of saying: "We beat the Government; were we not great?", they must bear the consequences of their action. In the Seanad the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party there, Senator Lenihan, is on record as having said that Fianna Fáil would view any measures introduced by the Government in this regard in a constructive, sympathetic, sensitive and compassionate manner. At a Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis the Leader of the party, Deputy Lynch, said that contraception was a matter of personal private morality and that his party would not be found wanting on the matter.
Are the Opposition implementing the pledge given in the Seanad by the leader of their group there? Are they honouring the views of the Leader of their party on this matter? Are they prepared to honour the views of the last Minister for Health, who now holds an exalted position in this country and who favoured a change in the legislation when he was Minister for Health? Are they prepared to discuss these matters in an objective and calm way? Should they fail to do so they will ensure that this country will have a period of human distress and human frustration because of the lack of what might be called an essential piece of preventative medicine in our community. They will ensure also that the status of Dáil Éireann will be diminished forever in the eyes of the community in the Republic and will be diminished particularly in the eyes of those in Northern Ireland who are noting carefully the comments made during the course of this debate.
Comment on this
It is with a good deal of what I might call distress that I enter into this debate. I say this because there are so many aspects of this issue that I should like to put before the House and before the people. Yet I feel that I am a very inadequate vessel to put forward these views. I speak here as an Irishman, a Member of this House, as we all do. In a wider sense, outside the House, I speak as a member of a religious minority, as a Protestant.
I have no authority to speak as a Protestant, but I am one and my views are naturally coloured in that way. So I should like in the course of this speech to put forward some Protestant views. I am not authorised to do so. I do so only in a private way. If in the course of trying to interpret views which are held by all the Members of this House and views which are held by Protestants, I fail through lack of precise words, I hope the House will give me its forgiveness and sympathy. I want to put certain things in an entirely non-controversial way.
I will start by talking about the Bill. The Minister is to be congratulated on bringing such a Bill to the House. We often say that here but we do not always mean it precisely. I offer the Minister my very sincere congratulations for his courage in bringing in this Bill. I do not entirely agree with all of the Bill. Nobody does. Even the Minister himself does not agree with every aspect of the Bill. The fact that there are such divergent views held in the country, divergent views held in our party, divergent views held in this House is the reason why this Bill is difficult to speak on and why this subject is still more difficult to legislate on, but the Minister has courageously put his political future at risk in doing this and has put to some extent the party's political future at risk, because this is a great Catholic country. By that I mean that while Ireland is not a great power, nevertheless she is a great Catholic country. Many Catholic views have held, and do still hold, that this is a wrong thing that we are attempting to do in this House. There are other equally Catholic views which hold the exact opposite. I do not want to go into that.
I want to start off by saying that this is a brave effort by the Minister and a brave effort by the party. I am proud that they have taken their courage in both hands because although we could not in all conscience leave the position as it is at the moment, namely, with the position undecided with regard to the sale of contraceptives, nevertheless we could, as a Government and as a party have carried on as things are and could have hidden our heads in the sand. The Minister and the Cabinet did not do that and as a result they have left themselves open, and knowingly left themselves open, to what has happened from the other side. I am sincerely sorry that Fianna Fáil did not take their courage in their hands and say that this is something which is above politics.
This is a matter which is in that strange realm of part public and part private morality but one in which the Government would have to move to legalise and clear up the position which has arisen from the McGee case and the interpretation put on it by the Supreme Court. That is primarily why we are debating this subject here in Dáil Éireann. I heard, I think it was Deputy Flanagan, asking almost with a sense of horror, who would have thought five years ago that a Bill such as this could be introduced into this House.
One would think that the Bill was introduced because various Members of the House wished to legalise or render easy forms of sexual intercourse. That of course is not the reason at all. The Bill has arisen not because public or private morality in this country has altered in any way but because the interpretation of the Constitution has altered and because our laws must be altered to conform with that or we have to scrap our Constitution. God knows how that could be done. I am not a constitutional lawyer and I would hate to see it attempted especially now when in this world so much has been scrapped. That is part of the reason horror arises in the minds of certain sincere people on both sides of this House. They think of this wave of madness which has swept over the whole world, and not only in the forms of human behaviour, sexual behaviour. This madness is not sweeping over the world as a result of contraception. It is because human beings are challenging those views of the past, those actions of the past. Many of us stand aghast at that sort of thing.
This Bill is not something to bring about the permissive society in a more easy fashion. It is not to allow sexual behaviour to alter in any way. No evil magic wand will wave over this country as a result of there being free sale of contraceptives. None of us wants to see that being done but we do want to see family planning carried out in a way that it never has been carried out here.
This will happen in this country even if this Bill is not passed. Things will never be the same again as a result of the Bill the Minister for Justice has brought into this House. I do not see what this Bill has to do with abortion because in my view the availability of contraceptives will prevent the need for abortion. Abortion is a terrible and horrible thing but preventative measures do not constitute abortion. This is recognised by all churches as not being an abortive measure but the point at which preventativeness ends and abortion begins varies amongst theologians and this has led to terrible results and suffering among human beings.
We have been accused of not being sympathetic in this House in the earlier stages of this debate and of not having compassion. That was true enough of the earlier stages but the people outside who criticised the way the Opposition spoke and described them as being like school boys let out of school should realise that this was something which Dáil Éireann never talked about in this fashion before. They could quite realise the vast field of human agony, suffering and compassion which may be covered in this Bill. Some did and touched on it but as men they shied away from the profundities. Now they have begun to come out.
We often hear in this country of large families. A large family is a beautiful thing and it is wonderful to see a proud father and mother surrounded by healthy and happy children but that does not always happen. What we do not see and what we turn our faces away from is the mother who has too many children too fast and who has insufficient money and poor housing to rear these children. Successive political parties have striven manfully to alter the terrible poverty we have had in this country and they are still working towards the elimination of that poverty. Governments have built houses to help people with large families and they have also done their utmost to help itinerants by establishing settlements. However, we have all shied away from the need to provide our married people with the objects, be they pills or artificial methods, of contraception.
Because we have shied away from that into small council houses and itinerant settlements have come, almost yearly, a baby. Sometimes they were unwanted babies and very often the parents had insufficient money to pay for the food for their children. This Bill is a step towards helping certain people, especially certain women, to drag themselves out of the mire of too many children and not enough money with which to rear them. It is not always a question of money because, as other speakers have mentioned, it can be a question of mental health and nervous health.
I cannot understand how we with our great love of liberty and the liberty of the individual refuse to certain people the right to plan the size of their own family. I am aware that some Members on both sides of the House have spoken as if the one effect of this Bill will be to increase permissiveness. "Permissiveness" is a foolish word to use in this regard and I will substitute with the word "lasciviousness". They speak as if all our teenagers will quite suddenly lose all the natural instincts they have towards decent behaviour because of the Bill. As human beings, we have a lot of instincts but life would be impossible if in civilisation and in civilised communities we did not keep our cool. There are people who when they see something attractive in a shop and because they do not have sufficient money to buy it break the shop window and steal the article but there are others who can wait until they have saved up enough money to buy that article. Some people do the same in the realms of human behaviour and I do not think that the fact that individuals can obtain contraceptive devices will necessarily make them more inclined to misbehave themselves.
Some people are born optimists and some people are born pessimists. There are some individuals who will look at a cup and say it is half empty while others will look at it and say it is half full. I am an optimist. I like to look at the half full side of life. It is possible to look at aspects of this Bill and say: "You are trusting human beings to behave. You know statistically that all of them will not." I think more of them will behave themselves than the pessimists think. Certainly married people will be given what the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs referred to today as an arm of medicine. That is what contraceptives should be.
I have a great admiration and respect for the Family Planning Association, especially for the noble woman who brought the Bill into the House upstairs, Senator Mary Robinson. She is a woman we can be proud of, a happily married woman with children of her own. She brought in a Bill and we know what happened to it. The family planning people are of that calibre. I was sorry to read in one of the newspapers that the secretary of that association does not like this Bill. I do not like the Bill and I do not think the Minister is in love with it but it is a great step forward. I say from here to the Family Planning Association that they should throw their weight behind this Bill and let us try to amend the Bill to suit the various views which would emerge on Committee Stage. It is a beginning. I am a great believer in taking what you can get legislatively and working on from that. The Adoption Act started out as a much more restrictive measure than it is now. It has been widened down through the years. I believe this Bill, if it is passed, as I hope it will be passed, will be widened and strengthened, not only in Committee but in the years to come.
I am sorry that Fianna Fáil have taken up the attitude they have taken on this Bill. I think they, like ourselves, have some people in favour of it and some not in favour of it, which reflects the view of the country, but we are people here in this assembly who are not necessarily supposed slavishly to follow various views which are put to us by and through groups, sometimes referred to as pressure groups. It is our business as Deputies to filter those views which come from pressure groups and decide ourselves whether they are wise or foolish views and whether they are in the national interest or not. I am sorry Fianna Fáil did not give that chance. I do not like speaking narrow party politics but I do think that they have played party politics with this Bill. It is with the lives of women they have played it and I am sorry. I hope I am wrong in that and that the Bill will be passed.
One of the speakers from our own side, Deputy Flanagan, referred to this as being based on Mrs. McGee's health. It is not based on Mrs. McGee's health at all. It is based on the interpretation of the Constitution as laid down by the Supreme Court. It is based on a legal decision and what we believe to be human justice to our adult population. I think we are very wrong if we think we cannot trust our teenagers and their parents to use this newer power wisely and in the human interest and, indeed, in the national interest. This Bill should be passed on the basis of human justice or what used to be called the rights of man although, indeed, it is more the rights of woman. It has been too much of the rights of man in the past and not enough of the rights of woman, who had to find the food to cook, and look after the children. They should be the prime deciders on the spacing and the number of the family. This will give people that chance and it is not opening the door to any form of abortion or to any wider sexual permissiveness.
I hope the Deputies will pass the Bill. I am sorry I did not make a more moving, wider speech on this. I wanted to do it partly because I am one of the very few people who belong to the minority Protestant religion here. I do not think, as such, we are terribly interested in it in the sense that Catholics must be because we do not think it is any sin. We do not like it very much. Our church does not encourage it but it has not forbidden it and it thinks, on balance, that greater good would ensue to the Irish people as a whole. It is in that spirit that I support the Bill and I hope it will be in that spirit that it will be passed by this House.
Comment on this
It is not my intention to take up the time of the House on this issue. My views on the subject are well known to all. Since 1966 I have been a firm advocate of the right to family planning and I have been much maligned for it. In 1968, when I raised the matter in the Dáil by way of a parliamentary question, the Government thought I was guilty of a heinous crime in mentioning the matter. I was also associated with a Private Bill to have legalised family planning in Ireland. I did so originally as a doctor as I saw the medical need for this in so many cases. I have changed my views since as I now consider it a basic human right and for this reason I have grave reservations about the present Bill.
I am of the opinion that it will hold us up to ridicule and will not be workable. I firmly believe it will be challenged in the courts and we may find ourselves in a very short time confronted with the same problem in the House unless there are radical amendments to the Bill. That is why I have grave reservations about voting for the measure. I can understand people who in conscience are sincerely opposed to it because it will be unworkable. I have the greatest admiration and respect for the Minister for Justice. I think he is a very good and humane man and I think he means the best but the Bill, as drafted, holds us all up to ridicule and makes a mockery of the whole issue.
It is with these grave reservations that I support the Bill and then only if I am assured that the amendments which I and many others like me will propose are accepted to make this a workable Bill. I am mainly concerned about the basic human rights issue here.
In 1966 at the United Nations conference in Teheran the people of Ireland signed the document establishing the right to family planning and we, with the Vatican, subscribed our names to the document prepared by the United Nations. I cannot understand because of this the views of the Opposition who were in Government when this was declared. I can understand people who by virtue of their conscience are somewhat afraid of the issue. The biggest problem is that we have not had enough healthy discussion on the subject of contraception. The word has been taboo in this country for too long.
I understand the fears of the pressure groups who sent us voluminous letters and petitions. The other day I received a petition with 220 signatures on it. The people concerned were afraid that if contraception was legalised it would open the floodgates to permissiveness. We must understand this. I have to be tolerant and I must accept the other person's point of view. We should make clear that this is not a question of wanting everyone to practise contraception. The onus is on us as legislators to make this clear. We ought to have free and frank discussion on it and let the people know that it is only a human right, giving the right to people if they feel like it, to married couples, if they want to space their families, to obtain contraceptives.
I accept there are other methods of family planning and I do not decry them or the organisations who put forward these methods as possible alternatives. The Billings method has its advantages. I do not agree with people who ridicule these methods. They are aesthetic in their own way. They have their advantages. I say to the people who wish to follow those methods and to practise them "Yes" but there are people not educated enough to understand the ramifications and the complications of these methods. I believe we should have the normal contraceptive means available for these people. This should be available as of right and it should be made known that we are not asking everybody to practise contraception.
We all talk about human rights and decry the conditions in the North where people are denied their basic human rights. We have not the right to speak as we do because we are hypocrites if we start talking about denial of rights in Northern Ireland when we refuse to grant the right to people here to practise contraception if they wish. It is ironical that when this Bill was presented in the Dáil for a Second Reading in the Seanad they were discussing the Northern Ireland situation and the problems up there. I do not say that the passage of this Bill will bring about unity but we should say to the people in the North that we will ensure that the people in this country, minority and majority, have basic human rights such as contraception. We can say to them that they cannot point the accusing finger at us that we are Rome ridden, a Catholic Church ridden State. It is not the law of the Catholic Church that should predominate in this country and we should not be bound by the laws of one church. We have Protestant and other churches here and we should not ask that the law of one church be imposed on the entire people of this country.
We might just as readily say it is illegal not to attend Mass on Sunday. We cannot legislate on the rules of one church. It would be wrong to do so. Unfortunately, we have been doing this for too long in this country. It would be a major step forward if we were to have a Bill passed in this House on contraception to eliminate another area where there has been discrimination for too long. We cannot legislate on private morals and we should not try to. Those who have fears in this regard can only depend on the proper upbringing of their children to feel confident that they will do their best as they grow up. You cannot say you will stop alcoholism by closing down every public house. It would be ludicrous to talk like that. We must hope that we will rear our children properly and have a proper community.
We have not made any attempt to educate the people in regard to exactly what is required and what we are endeavouring to do as legislators. I like the idea in this House—it is very rare—of having a free vote. I hope it will be the forerunner of many more such votes where we will not be bound slavishly by party legislation and party rules. We have rarely had a free vote in this House and I welcome it in the present instance very much.
I would say to those who have fears that contraception will lead to abortion that there is no rationale behind that suggestion. If I could be persuaded as a medical doctor that it would, I would be prepared to listen. It is illogical to talk in terms of contraception leading to abortion. There is no logic behind that argument. Those who have propounded it have sought only to deceive and confuse the public. From all the experience, contraception cannot and does not lead to abortion.
It is being said that it will open the floodgates and that once contraception starts abortion begins. I am very opposed to abortion. It is anathema to me. I would not and could not support any legislation that would legalise abortion. Under no circumstances would I do so. I would walk out of the House before I would be persuaded to support abortion. Therefore I can speak with absolute conviction when I say that a Bill legalising contraception, and contraception per se, will not and cannot lead to abortion. That argument is completely illogical.
I have expressed reservations about this Bill because, in my opinion, it will be unworkable and hold the law up to ridicule. Unless it is amended very significantly, it will be challenged in the courts and we will find ourselves endeavouring to enact new legislation. I have made my views clear that a Bill dealing with contraception should be passed in this House. I cannot accept that the sale of contraceptives through chemists' shops or, where they are not available, through other means, is workable. A proper family planning service is needed here. It should be operated under the control and supervision of our health boards.
We should have family planning clinics under the control of the health boards as part of the national health service. This would ensure that family planning, and not just contraceptive devices, and education and instruction in all forms of family planning methods were available to all those who sought them. This could be done very readily by the health boards. We should make it a statutory obligation on the health boards to provide them.
In outlying areas as part of the normal preventive service operated by the health boards, we could have family planning services with mobile clinics in the same way as we provide clinics for child welfare and mother welfare. This could be part of the entire health service. This would be ideal. It would ensure that there would be no abuse because anyone seeking contraceptive devices would go into a clinic to discuss family planning methods, education in family planning, which I maintain is badly needed, and full information on the type of family planning service which would be available. I think that would be best suited to our country and, in this way, we could be guaranteed that there would be no abuse of the system. It would be under the control of specialised people, social workers, medical doctors, and others. This is the way in which we could organise a proper family planning service.
I do not accept all the provisions in the Bill. I was very disappointed when I saw the Bill and I still am. I will try as far as I can to have it amended. It will be a difficult task. I have grave reservations about it. The only thing in its favour is that it is an attempt in this country, which has been so reactionary and so conservative, to introduce family planning legislation. For that reason only I feel compelled to support it. I would not vote for the Bill on its merits; far from it.
I would not ridicule the Opposition for their stance. Some of them are very seriously and very sincerely opposed to contraceptive measures and methods. I would not for one minute attack them, because anyone who is conscientiously opposed to contraception is entitled to be opposed to it. I do not think this should be a party political issue. We should not discuss it as such. I would make this earnest appeal to them. It is not their own conscience which is at issue here. This might be borne in the mind by Members of the Opposition in considering this Bill. This is a question of rights for other people, and not for them, or how they feel about contraception. That is not the issue. I respect their right to oppose the Bill, those who are opposing it on genuine grounds. If I felt it was not for the good of the community I would oppose any legislation. Irrespective of how the party voted, I would judge it by how I felt the people would be affected.
What is happening here is being watched by the people in the North, in Britain and in other parts of Europe. This is a very serious matter. It is wonderful that we have had this debate and that we have had people's views on it. If the Bill is defeated it is not a calamity. It is not a disaster. It may have enlightened many people and I will not be pessimistic if it is defeated. If it is, we should try again. We should make a greater effort to enlighten the public on what is at stake and explain to them that we are not opening the floodgates to permissiveness, that we are granting people the right to family planning. I do not think we should discriminate between single and married people. It is a matter for their own conscience. It is their own decision. The law as it stands is wrong and I have thought that for a number of years.
I admire the Minister for Industry and Commerce who admitted openly in the Dáil that he was breaking the law. It is bad for the country and the people that they were breaking the law. Many obstacles were put in the way of members of family planning clinics who were seriously and sincerely trying to help people who had no other place to get help. They carried out a wonderful task. Every attempt was made to obstruct them in their work. I admire them for their efforts. They brought satisfaction and relief to families and to couples who had problems. They performed a wonderful duty. I hope that they will continue their two clinics in Dublin and I would like to see them extended throughout the country. I would like to think that no legislation passed here would make it difficult for them to continue doing this work.
I am sorry that there was not consultation with the members of the family planning clinics, the people who have been trying to ensure this basic human right, as to the best means of bringing in legislation which would be acceptable to all and which would ensure that this basic human right would be available. I am afraid the Bill was brought in without enough consultation. This was a great pity. I am sorry there was not consultation with the Opposition on the Bill. I think it would have been a good idea. The Leader of the Opposition wanted to see a Bill on contraception passed in this House, and a little consultation with him might have produced the required piece of legislation. It is to be deplored that this consultation did not take place, to my knowledge anyway. If I remember rightly, it was the Leader of the Opposition who realised the necessity to have contraception legislation brought in and I think he had it in mind to do this. A few years ago legislation of this kind could not be discussed. It is not normal, perhaps, to consult the Opposition in regard to legislation but this was a unique situation that demanded that consultation take place so that there could have been agreement on the introduction of an acceptable piece of legislation.
I would like to hear assurances from the Minister about accepting amendments that will ensure that this legislation will be workable and will not create problems for the future. I have great reservations about it at the present time, and, perhaps, the Minister in the short time remaining to him would give those assurances.
Comment on this
Could the Government give us any idea as to whether we are to complete this debate? Fianna Fáil has not had a speaker since 7 o'clock.
Comment on this
It is a free vote. Anybody who wants to speak on this side is welcome to do so. I would not like to interfere with his right to speak on this subject.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would take that matter up with the Whip if he does not want to make a contribution himself.
Comment on this
I merely want to make a short intervention to explain my vote, which is common practice in another forum in which I have the honour to sit. I cannot recall any piece of legislation that has evoked so much controversy and misunderstanding. Some people say: "You have no mandate from me to vote for this Bill which will allow the sale of contraceptives in our country." These good-intentioned people must surely realise that it is not in contravention of any of our laws to possess and distribute contraceptives in Ireland today.
I intend to support the Government to put through the strongest possible legislation to control the sale and distribution of family planning aids and devices, because to leave the matter as at present whereby anyone, young or old, married or single, can have whatever they desire in this line mailed to them from outside the Republic, is not in the best interest of the country, when seen from the point of view of those who cherish and wish to conserve all that is good in our country and wish to have our families reared and educated in the same healthy and Christian environment that we ourselves were born into.
This Bill is a step in the right direction. It does not seek to open any floodgates but merely to allow freedom of choice among married couples. Section 2 prohibits the importation and sale of contraceptives except under licence. Section 4 prohibits the manufacture of contraceptives, again except under licence. Section 5 prohibits the purchase of contraceptives by unmarried persons. Section 6 prohibits the display of contraceptives for sale, and so on right through the Bill. I believe this Bill is an honest attempt to control and improve the present situation.
To my mind the Bill does not go far enough, but I have the utmost faith in my fellow countrymen, and I do not think that the mere fact that contraceptives are on sale under strict control will turn the whole of our population into a licentious or permissive society. Irish youth today enjoy better educational opportunities than ever before in our history. Teachers, both clerical and lay attend and graduate from special courses in catechetics, and I believe that our young people are benefiting from the new and improved methods of teaching Christian doctrine in our schools. This must surely mean that our people can be relied upon to follow the dictates of their conscience—their better informed conscience, I would submit, from now on.
We must distinguish between the morality of contraception and legalising access to it. These are distinct questions, but it is naive to think that because they are distinct questions they are unrelated. I am supporting this Bill which seeks to control the sale of contraceptives, but I want to stress that I am not the keeper of my neighbour's conscience. I do not set myself up as a judge of my neighbour's actions. I have but my own soul to save and my trust is in the God of compassion and love.
Married people today live in a tense, pressurised, changing world. They live in a sexually seductive world in which the expression and experience of mutal love relieve the loneliness and the longing that characterise modern living. By their loving sexuality religion enters their shared lives, since love, to my mind, is the essence of Christianity. Just because from now on contraceptives will be on sale in some places under strict control does not mean, as has been suggested by some speakers, that anyone will be obliged to use or purchase them or have anything to do with them. If the Bill can be interpreted as liberalising the law, it should be seen primarily as a recognition of the dignity of the individual and a step towards a more open, honest and mature society.
I should like to take this opportunity of expressing my thanks to the very many people—most of them outside my constituency—who bothered to mail me their views either for or against this Bill. I hope to get around to acknowledging their efforts and I certainly appreciate their interest.
It is noteworthy that tonight there is an unusually large number of young people in the public gallery. Incidentally, when we were looking for pairs last night in the European Parliament—some very important controversial company law is before that Assembly at the moment—people did not take us seriously when we told them we were being recalled to vote on an issue relating to contraceptives. We should not bury our heads in the sand. We should be proud of the educational advances we have made. Our people are now much better equipped from the point of view of education and I have every confidence in their ability to make up their own minds. I also believe there are people who will benefit from and find solace in this legislation. I hope the Bill will get a speedy passage. We should not deny people who are competent to make up their own minds and satisfy their own consciences the use of contraceptives, particularly when their use in designed to ensure economic stability in the home and an enriched family life. I shall vote for the Bill. I hope the Bill will be passed and that many Irish mothers will, as a result of this legislation, be saved a great deal of worry and hardship.
Comment on this
A few moments ago I tried to question the Minister sponsoring this Bill. I asked him if it was his intention to endeavour to conclude the Second Stage tonight. He indicated that there was a free vote situation and he did not intend to speak if there were Deputies who wished to contribute to the debate. From behind the Minister Deputy Harte said the proper way to deal with the situation was to approach the Government Whip.
Comment on this
What relevance has this to the Bill? If that is all the Deputy can talk about, he should sit down.
Comment on this
Deputy Harte will leave matters of relevancy to the Chair.
Comment on this
No Deputy on this side of the House has spoken on this very controversial issue since 6.45 p.m. Deputy Ruairí Brugha was the last speaker on these benches. The object was to enable the Minister to have sufficient time to conclude the debate. If there are Deputies on the Government benches who had problems of conscience or who wanted to make explanations to their constituents, we were providing them with an opportunity to do this.
It is quite obvious now that the Government have no intention of concluding this debate tonight and facing the position debated ad nauseam in this Chamber. Great emphasis has been laid on the free vote. Deputies on the Government benches have been clapping their fellow-travellers on the back, congratulating them on this free vote and suggesting that legislation would be improved if the House had more free votes. In actual fact—we are all aware of the activity of the Whips during the day—the Government decided not to conclude the debate tonight because of the number of waverers in the Government back benches and because there is a prospect that they might succeed in the application of the Whip before the vote is finally taken.
Everybody knows from the public Press, which has gone out of its way to ridicule those who have expressed opposition of this Bill, with the willing assistance of both radio and television, that a great effort culminating in this Bill has been made over the last ten years to turn this country into a completely permissive State. I do not normally agree with Deputy O. J. Flanagan, my political colleague in Laois-Offaly; I do not see myself agreeing with him in the future and I certainly will not go so far as he did today in pontificating on certain aspects of the moral law, but I am aware of the fact as a result of Press reports of various Government-sponsored meetings over the last few months that there were at least ten Government Deputies who, in a free vote situation, and I stress the word "free"——
Comment on this
Order. Deputy Harte will get his opportunity later.
Comment on this
The Deputy will cease interrupting. He will have an opportunity of making his own contribution later.
Comment on this
I understand the function of a legislative assembly is to discuss the merits or demerits of legislation. The Chief Whip of the Fianna Fáil Party is making an excuse.
Comment on this
If Deputy Harte would sit down, it would help matters.
Comment on this
I am not making any excuse. In actual fact I got up before Deputy Harte but I was prepared to let him have the floor because he wanted to make his excuse to the people in his constituency as to why he was doing what he proposes to do on this Bill.
Comment on this
Except the Chief Whip of the Government Party who has inisted that there is a free vote.
Comment on this
I warned Deputy Lalor at the start that I had a list of Government speakers as long as my arm and I am not going to closure my speakers.
Comment on this
We discussed the very important Finance Bill over the past two days and the Government Whip shut off the speakers.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that Deputy Lalor left the Chamber because he could not get any speakers?
Comment on this
This Government are supported by two parties who are not ashamed of what we are trying to do. We are grasping the nettles which Deputy Lalor talked about but never grasped.
Comment on this
I could name the Deputies whom the Parliamentary Secretary has been Whipping over the past few days. The Fine Gael Party met last night in order to introduce the Whip into this debate.
Comment on this
The Chair asks Deputies on both sides of the House to refrain from——
Comment on this
——publicising their respective virtues. I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to be patient while Deputy Lalor makes his contribution.
Comment on this
Deputy Harte will have an opportunity of making his contribution presently.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that Deputy Harte says I have not spoken on the Bill, how can he now say I am a reactionary?
Comment on this
If Deputy Lalor would leave Deputy Harte to the Chair and proceed with his speech, it might help.
Comment on this
If I am permitted to continue I will speak on this totally inadequate Bill. One of the leading Government spokesmen for the Government side—I do not know if it is in order to speak of the Government side when there is a free vote——
Comment on this
The Deputy will be up there in a month's time on holidays looking for my hospitality.
Comment on this
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs gave us an object lesson today on the history of family control here. I do not know whether it was because of lack of education on the one hand or the availability of contraceptives on the other but in a certain situation he said that——
Comment on this
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said that there were 44 per cent more children in the families of unskilled workers than there were in the families of salaried workers. He did not explain his reasons for this. Was it because of his education, using the rhythm method, that the salaried worker was able to control the size of his family better than the unskilled worker or because the salaried worker had access to contraceptives. On the one hand, Deputy O'Connell stressed the advantages of legitimised family planning. On the other, he was complimenting the Minister for Industry and Commerce on his candour or ingenuity, I do not know which——
Comment on this
We had the most unusual situation here tonight when Deputy O'Connell complimented the Minister for Industry and Commerce for breaking the law. I did not hear the Minister's contribution in the House but I was told about it. My reaction to some of the extracts I heard about was that it was an abominable speech. For any Minister of Government to admit freely to breaking the law, under whatever heading, should call for his resignation.
Comment on this
I presume we are now thinking along the same lines as Deputy P. Belton when he says there is no law except the one which deals with the Sixth Commandment. This seems to be accepted by Deputy Coogan when he says there is no law now. People can come to this conclusion when a Minister of State stands up and publicly proclaims that he consciously broke the law. It would appear from the manner in which he was complimented that he took pride in it. I am not even talking about taking pleasure in it but he was proud of it.
Comment on this
I do not want to be knocked on the basis that I am making a joke of this issue. I listened to Press correspondents on the radio last week saying that a skit was made of this Bill in Parliament.
Comment on this
I am endeavouring to be serious but the Deputies will not let me. This is the second day's debate on the Second Stage of this Bill. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said that this discussion had been going on for the past ten years. This Bill is here today as a result of lobbying by liberals over the past ten years. There is no doubt that the Deputies today and on the previous occasion who made their honest and conscious contributions to this debate will be castigated in the Press tomorrow and on radio because they are the "not with it" people. If you want to be with it——
Comment on this
If one wants to be with it, one must be permissive. I do not think this is acceptable.
Our legislation was described by a number of speakers as leading to the situation where our country was a laughing-stock all over Europe. If that is so, behind that laughter, the impression that we are not "with it", that we are antiquated and ruled from Rome, is the castigation that the ordinary, God-fearing Irishman gets from the liberals and the scribes who are so fond of being up-to-date and permissive. They are endeavouring to introduce into this country the same type of permissiveness that even people on the Government side have condemned.
It is not my intention at this stage to contribute to the debate. By the time we get around to having a further discussion on this matter, I presume we will have had an opportunity of collecting our thoughts. The Government Whip told me he was very anxious to get this matter dealt with——
Comment on this
The matter could have been dealt with and concluded today if we had what is called an open, free vote.
Comment on this
I want the people to see that there are many Deputies on both sides who want to speak in favour of this Bill and who have volunteered to do so.
Comment on this
The Chair would like to say to the Parliamentary Secretary and Deputy Lalor that it is not interested in the duelling that seems to exist between them. The Chair is interested in hearing discussion on the Bill.
Comment on this
A number of Deputies, including myself, have referred to the fact that they received numerous letters from pressure groups and individuals. It was alleged that a number of the letters were the result of a kind of sponsorship and this I accept. These people wrote to us and said we had no mandate; they were the people who were against the Bill. Quite frankly, I rebelled against letters which stated I did not have a mandate. The speakers in favour of the Bill seem to spend most of their time talking about this inspired letterwriting, castigating and reflecting on those who wrote them. On the other hand, there are the insidious pressure groups, sponsored mainly by the Press, radio and television. I am convinced that the writing of the liberals in the past ten years has been directed towards achieving the permissiveness that I and many others are worried about.
One of the reasons we are opposing the Bill is because of its blatant inadequacies in dealing with the matter. The intention of the Bill is to make contraceptives available to married couples and make it illegal for others to obtain them, but everyone who has spoken in favour of the Bill has said that contraceptives have been freely available for years. The inadequacy of the legislation was admitted by a number of speakers on the Government side. Deputy Thornley said he could find many faults with the Bill but that he was willing to buy it for the moment. He admitted it lent itself to shocking abuse. In view of the fact that so many people on the Government side took time to quote the Leader of this party and the Leader of our party in the Seanad, to use their speeches——
Comment on this
The Deputy should talk on the Bill. He should get down from the fence. He is not fooling us.
Comment on this
The Chair is not interested in Deputy Harte's gullibility. If the Deputy is not prepared to listen he has a remedy. The Chair does not propose to accept any more interruptions.
Comment on this
The Chair will have to ask the Deputy to leave the House if he is not prepared to listen and behave in a manner befitting the House and the nature of the debate.
Comment on this
The Chair would welcome silence from the Deputy rather than an apology——
Comment on this
The Chair insists that the Deputy be silent.
Comment on this
It was obvious that my colleague from Laois-Offaly, Deputy McDonald, had just arrived back from Europe because he said this Bill sought strictly to control the sale of contraceptives. Had the Deputy been in this House he would have heard most of the supporters of the Bill admit that it would not strictly control their sale and that it was just a pious wish. While the law states that contraceptives may be sold only to married couples, it was admitted openly that it was a law which could not be strictly enforced. Then we had the unfortunate situation where, apparently, the Minister for Industry and Commerce took pride in breaking the law. Naturally, it would be understandable that the ordinary John Citizen would take his example from such a renowned Minister of State.
I found one thing most disgusting arising from the contribution made by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs who introduced a subject which apparently is not quite near and dear to his heart—the question of reunification—when he said that if this Bill was defeated the repercussions on the North would be tragic. I have my own ideas about the Loyalists and the opposition to reunification from the North of Ireland. But the one thing I do not accept, and the one thing that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will not sell to me, in any case, is that the Loyalist people of the North can be bought by contraceptives. I have more respect for them than that.
Comment on this
The difficulty with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is that he makes statements and then has to somersault backwards in 20 different ways in order to——
Comment on this
I was here today. There were no interruptions while the Minister was making his statement and I listened to him very carefully. Certainly that is the conclusion I came to.
Comment on this
I am sorry. As Whip for the Opposition I am deprived of the opportunity of contributing to a number of measures here on which I would otherwise contribute. It is usually about this hour of the evening that I seem to come in to make my contribution. I regret that the atmosphere in the House seems to be heated excessively when I come to make my contribution.
Comment on this
The Deputy has a great audience. I wish I had the same audience when I speak. There are about 60 Deputies listening to him and look at the crowded gallery.
Comment on this
Yes, it would be perfect if we got them to listen. The last man in the world who should be interrupting is the man who should be giving the example, the Government Whip. Nobody in the House gets as much opportunity of addressing himself to the Opposition Whip as does the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach. It was rather remarkable that, at a stage this morning when it was quite obvious, arising from the Fine Gael meeting last night, that this measure was going to be defeated, we had the despicable and deplorable situation in which a man—I cannot say we detest anybody but possibly the man whom we distrust most, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, comes into the House and appeals to the Fianna Fáil Party——
Comment on this
I had hoped that we would have reached a position tonight where we could have taken a decision on the Second Reading. But it became obvious during the course of the day, that the change over from the free vote to the Whip vote was in process. Apparently the final achievement of being able to swing over the second last Government Member from a vote against to a vote for just did not work. Therefore, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach had the job of going around asking even Deputy McDonald, who had only just arrived back from Europe, to go in, make up a few words——
Comment on this
Deputy McDonald warned me on the telephone from Strasbourg that he wanted to speak when he got home.
Comment on this
Here we have a situation where there is an effort at government by opinion poll. I am commenting on contributions made by distinguished Members of this House during the course of the day. Deputy E. Collins was here for quite a time and heard a lot of the contributions.
Comment on this
I heard the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and I heard the Deputy's scandalous and unfounded accusation.
Comment on this
I want to repeat that I listened to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs saying today that if this Bill was defeated the repercussions on the North would be tragic. I have been told that I have been misquoting. I am not in a position to produce the official record but certainly it can be checked before this debate is resumed, and maybe it will be doctored. But I want to get on the record that that is what I heard the learned Deputy Doctor say in this regard.
We have the situation also in which we have been advised by Deputy McDonald not to bury our heads in the sand. He expressed the hope that the Bill would get an early passage. The opportunity for giving the Bill an early passage was there this evening but the Government did not take it. I do not know when they propose to take the further opportunity. It is unfortunate that Members of this House, who have their views on this and have had an opportunity of discussing it over two long days, will again be open to further pressures from pressure groups or individuals in an effort to try to——
Comment on this
It is a shocking situation that we have Deputies talking in terms of a free vote, castigating pressure groups from outside the House, castigating the ordinary man in the street who writes a letter to his TD or Senator asking him to oppose or support, and, at the same time, here, in the middle of it all we have two pressure groups pressurising the minority within their own parties into toeing the line.
Comment on this
May I be permitted to direct the Chair's attention to what I consider to be gross inaccuracy. I am a Member of the Fine Gael Party. My views are well known on this and I was not——
Comment on this
Deputy, this is hardly a point of order; I thought the Deputy was raising a point of order.
Comment on this
Deputy O. J. Flanagan is not entitled to intervene in this fashion. Deputy Lalor is in possession and must be allowed to conclude his remarks. It is almost time-up anyway.
Comment on this
I accept the fact that the Whip was fully aware of the fact that he could not handle Deputy Harte but that does not get away from the fact that pressure was used on other Deputies in this House.